grameenphone ltd. - bracu ir
TRANSCRIPT
Implementation of Short term loan for Mobile Financial Services 1
Internship report on
Implementation of Short term loan for Mobile Financial Services of
Grameenphone Ltd. Submitted to:
Ms. UmmulWaraAdrita
Lecturer
BRAC Business School
BRAC University
Submitted by:
Rafia Fardous
14104124
BRAC Business School
BRAC University
Course: BUS 400
Submission date:
29 November, 2018
Implementation of Short term loan for Mobile Financial Services 2
Letter of Transmittal
29 November, 2018
Ms. UmmulWaraAdrita
Lecturer, BRAC Business School
BRAC University
Subject: Submission of the Internship report
Dear Miss,
I am really very pleased that I am submitting my internship report on ‘Implementation of short
term loan for mobile financial services’. I had to go to many places to gather information related
to this topic. I have tried to portray the current market condition and potential future problem
related to this field. This is a very fresh experience for me to work with such a team who are
very much devoted towards their work. I tried to gather as much information as possible and
put those in my report. I hope this report will be informative and useful.
Finally, I am really very thankful to my team Business Innovation, Digital Department. Besides
that, I want to thank my honorable faculty member for being cooperative throughout the whole
semester.
Sincerely,
Rafia Fardous
14104124
Implementation of Short term loan for Mobile Financial Services 3
Letter of Endorsement
The internship report which is ‘Implementation of short term loan for mobile financial services
of Grameenphone Ltd’ is made to fulfill the course requirement of BRAC Business School. I am
confirming that all the information mentioned in this report is acquired by the company from
surveys.
(Any opinion or suggestions made in the report are entirely that of the author of the report. The
University does not condone nor reject any of these opinions or suggestions)
---------------------------------
Ms. UmmulWaraAdrita
Internship Supervisor Faculty
Lecturer
BRAC Business School
BRAC University
Implementation of Short term loan for Mobile Financial Services 4
Acknowledgement
First of all I would like to show my purest gratitude towards Allah for letting me finish my
internship without facing any problem. My topic sounds really interesting and very realistic in
terms of current market situation. The more I explored the market, the deeper I felt the
problem is. That’s why I was very devoted while creating the report.
Secondly, it would have been very difficult for me to write this report without the help of my
internship supervisor UmmulWaraAdrita. From believing me to choose this report to checking
whether it is right or not, she was always supportive. It wouldn’t be this smooth without her
help.
Besides that my supervisor of Grameenphone Salwa Bakht, Senior Executive of Financial
Services showed some real patience while making me understand the whole process. She was
supportive all along so much interested to show me the real scenario of the present condition of
the market. I would also like to thank Nur-E-Azam, Executive of Financial Services for helping
me during my tenure.
Lastly, I would like to thanks my parents for always believing in me and letting me chase my
dream.
Implementation of Short term loan for Mobile Financial Services 5
Executive Summary
Grameenphone Ltd is one of the leading and prominent Telco companies in Bangladesh.
Grameenphone is constantly innovating and providing world class services to satisfy their
consumers.
At the very beginning of the report I have given an overview of Grameenphone Ltd and its
history. It will give the readers a clear idea about GrameenphoneLtd’s activity and mission
vision.
In the next part I will be providing organizational structure of the company which will give the
readers a clear idea about the structure of the company as well as the management team.
Next part of the report contains an overview of all the functions of Grameenphone mobile
financial services. That will be the main focus of my report. Because I have seen the revenue
loss of GP due to stock out of the retailers.This is the point where I will be focusing on the
most. I have interviewed some retailers as well as the distributors of Grameenphone to define
the problem and find out the solutions to the problem.
In the following part I have given my day to day activities in Grameenphone. I have given a
detailed and comprehensive overview of my involvement with Grameenphone over the last
three months.
I have also mentioned the limitations and learning in the last part of the report. I have also
tried to come up with few suggestions from my observations which I believe can be helpful to
Grameenphone Ltd.
Implementation of Short term loan for Mobile Financial Services 6
Contents 1 Introduction ............................................................................................................................................... 8
1.1 Introduction of Grameenphone Ltd.............................................................................................. 8
1.2 Origin of the report .......................................................................................................................... 9
1.3 Objective of the report .................................................................................................................... 9
1.4 Methodology ...................................................................................................................................... 9
1.5 Limitations while preparing the report ...................................................................................... 10
2 Organizational Overview: ...................................................................................................................... 11
2.1 Industry overview ........................................................................................................................... 11
2.2 Share of Grameenphone ............................................................................................................... 12
2.3 Corporate Division and Departments of Grameenphone: ..................................................... 13
2.4 Mission, Vision and Values ........................................................................................................... 14
2.5 Grameenphone Organizational structure: ............................................................................... 16
2.6 Corporate Social Responsibility of Grameenphone ................................................................. 17
3 Concept Part: ........................................................................................................................................... 18
3.1 Defining the problem: ................................................................................................................... 18
3.2 Looking deep into the problem: .................................................................................................. 18
3.3 Interviews: ....................................................................................................................................... 19
3.4 Interview outcome ......................................................................................................................... 20
3.5 Market impact: ................................................................................................................................ 21
3.6 Solution to the problem ................................................................................................................ 21
3.7 Financial Analysis: .......................................................................................................................... 22
4 Activities undertaken .............................................................................................................................. 24
4.1 Job responsibilities: ........................................................................................................................ 24
5 Internship outcome ................................................................................................................................ 25
5.1 Learning outcome and experience: ............................................................................................ 25
5.2 Problems I faced during my internship ..................................................................................... 26
Implementation of Short term loan for Mobile Financial Services 7
5.3 Influence of this internship on my career plan ........................................................................ 27
6 Challenges and recommendation: ...................................................................................................... 27
6.1 Identified challenges in GP ........................................................................................................... 27
6.2 Recommendation ............................................................................................................................ 28
7 Conclusion ................................................................................................................................................ 29
8 References: .............................................................................................................................................. 30
Implementation of Short term loan for Mobile Financial Services 8
1 Introduction
1.1 Introduction of Grameenphone Ltd.
Company Registration No: C-31531 (652)/96
Grameenphone is the largest cellular operator and best telecom service in terms of network,
coverage and services. This is the biggest mobile telecom operator in Bangladesh in terms of
subscriber (65.3 Mn) and in terms of revenue (128.4 Bn). Grameenphone received its license
for cellular phone operations from Ministry of Post and telecommunication, Bangladesh back in
March 26, 1997. This company has more than 65.3 Million subscribers as of December 2017.
Grameenphone is a joint venture enterprise between Telenor and Grameen telecom.
Telenor is the largest Norwegian company in Norway which own 55.80% shares of
Grameenphone .Grameenphone has stepped into its 21th year of operation. This leading
company is known best for its brilliant network infrastructure. Besides that they are the trend
setter and most of the new innovations of telecom era are initiated by them. Now
Grameenphone has 71 million subscribers within Bangladesh who takes part in creating
revenue. Customers who are the main part for this organization are known to be very much
loyal toward the company and services.
Grameenphone has also contributed in direct and indirect employment for a large number of
people over the years in Bangladesh. As at 31st December 2017, Grameenphone had 2,397
permanent full time employees. There are many people in addition to the permanent employees
who are directly and indirectly dependent on Grameenphone for their livelihood, people who are
working for the distributors, retailers, suppliers, vendors, contractors and other business
partners.
Implementation of Short term loan for Mobile Financial Services 9
1.2 Origin of the report
This report shows a clear idea of my 3 month activity and work experiences after completing
Bachelor of Business Administration course program named internship. And I am very happy
because I got this opportunity to write my internship report on “Grameenphone Ltd.” Under
supervision of Salwa Bakht, Senior Executive, Financial Services.I completed my internship
period on the supervision of advisor UmmulwaraAdrita, Lecturer, BRAC University. I got full
support from my supervisors as well as respected faculty member while writing my report. I
tried to show my day to day activities in my report and what I have learnt. The topic of the
report is to show the market gap between the demand and supply of liquidity of the mobile
financial services of Grameenphone. This liquidity problem causes 40% revenue loss in the
remote areas.
1.3 Objective of the report
The primary objective of preparing this report is to fulfill the requirement of internship program
of BRAC University. But I had a great experience while collecting data and meeting new people.
Besides that I got know about different aspects of Grameenphone Ltd. Some of the other
important objectives of preparing this report on Grameenphone Ltd are given below:
To present an overview of Grameenphone Ltd.
To analyze the industry
To analyze the core functions of Grameenphone Ltd
To analyze the credit stock out problem in details
1.4 Methodology
Primary data: For primary data collection I mostly depended on interviews. I interviewed my
line manager and supervisors about my topics. Besides that I went to Gazipur remote area to
talk with the retailers who face huge stock out problem. I took in-depth interviews and got to
Implementation of Short term loan for Mobile Financial Services 10
know about the difficulties they face. Apart from Gazipur I went to Mirpur and Khilgaon to talk
to the balance distributors, sales executives and retailers.
Secondary data: For secondary data collection I went to different websites, annual reports and
journals.
1.5 Limitations while preparing the report
Time constraint:
Big companies like Grameenphone make the best use of their employees as well as the interns.
Though I learned a lot from them but it is undeniable that for the last three months I faced
huge workload with limited time frame. I worked for 3 projects at the same time. It was really
very hard for me to balance between completing my work and preparing this report. So to work
under huge pressure in the limited time frame was one of the major challenge I faced preparing
this report.
Confidentiality
Telecom industry is competitive than any other industries of Bangladesh. There is a huge
competition among the players. Grameenphonehas its code of conduct to maintain the
confidentiality among the employees. So being a part of organization like this is very
challenging for me to maintain that and prepare the report. So it was not possible for me to
mention everything in the report as it will breach the code of conduct and leakage of
information to the competitors. I only provided the data in the report which is publically
available.
Mismatch between Academic background and functional department:
Although I am a Marketing graduate student, here I had to work mostly with Engineers,
Finance, Financial services and other department employees as well. I had to do research about
their field of work to match their standard. My supervisors and co-workers were very
cooperative and they helped me a lot to overcome this barrier.
Implementation of Short term loan for Mobile Financial Services 11
2 Organizational Overview:
2.1 Industry overview
The telecom industry is one of the most flourished and prominent industries of Bangladesh. The
players of this industry are very competitive and aggressive. There is likely to be whole new
wave of innovations in value added services as well as data for telecom players. The telecom
brands are very proactive when it comes to digitalization. They have been actively participating
in every campaign and adding value in the project of ‘Digital Bangladesh’. Apart from this
digitalization these companies are even participating in creating employment. When this country
was lagging behind from new innovation and digitalization, Telecom industry helpsthem to keep
up the pace. Besides that this fastest growing industry has already attracted many marketing
geniuses, researchers, research companies to explore the opportunities. Researchers are trying
to investigate different markets and potentials of those markets. Even multinational giants are
taking tech solution from this industry. Now-a-days they are even thinking on going global.
Grameenphone is the market leader in telecommunication business of Bangladesh. The total
number of Grameenphone subscriber is 65.304,RobiAxiata Limited is 45.258, Banglalink Digital
Communications Limited is 33.403, Teletalk Bangladesh Ltd is 3.769 (in millions).
Implementation of Short term loan for Mobile Financial Services 12
2.2 Share of Grameenphone
Grameenphone is a concern of Telenor group which is one of the leading Norwegian telecom
companies. Telenor owns 55.8% ,Grameen Telecom owns 34.2% and 10% of the shares are
for general public & other institutions. Being the highest shareholder of Grameenphone, Telenor
dominates the most when it comes to dominate the decision making and managerial decision.
Now GP has introduces digital market service where different apps are used in one digital
basket. These apps are GP music, GP apps, MyGp app, Gpay, Wowbox, Bioscope, Shoparu, GP
online store. Most of the apps are made according to customer’s needs. These apps make
customer’s life easier and create a good brand image.
Grameenphone has so far invested more than BDT 278 Billion to build this strong network
infrastructure on a nationwide basis. In 2017, Grameenphone invested BDT 14.5 billion. The
majority of the investment was for the expansion of 2G and 3G
coverage along with capacity up-gradation to support higher data and voice traffic and improve
customer experience. Grameenphone rolled out 1,776 3G sites and 1,010 2G sites in 2017,
Implementation of Short term loan for Mobile Financial Services 13
increasing the 3G population coverage to 92.6%. With 12,994 sites across the country,
Grameenphone currently provides its telecommunication services covering 99.5% of the total
population of the country.
Grameenphone is one of the largest tax payers of Bangladesh. The total contribution to
government since its inception up until December 2017 was BDT 585.2 billion, of which BDT
61.8 billion was made in 2017. Out of total BDT 585.2 billion, BDT 527.9 billion was made on
account of direct tax, VAT and duties through National Board of Revenue (NBR) and Bangladesh
Telecommunication Regulatory Commission (BTRC). Grameenphone has been recognized by the
National Board of Revenue as the largest corporate taxpayer in the Telecommunication sector,
in 2015 and 2016.
With the payment of taxes and the investment in the network, Grameenphone is making a
significant contribution to the country’s growth and development.
2.3 Corporate Division and Departments of Grameenphone:
Grameenphone is the largest telecommunication operator in Bangladesh which has various
departments to operate on day to day basis. Apart from that Grameenphone follows the mixture
of centralized and decentralized decision making process. Here top management is responsible
for strategic decisions while functional management is responsible for day to day work. The
departments of Grameenphone are:
Commercial Division
Finance Division
Corporate Affairs Division
Managing Director Division
People and Organization Division
Technology Division
Customer experience
Service Transformation Division
Digital Division
Implementation of Short term loan for Mobile Financial Services 14
2.4 Mission, Vision and Values
Grameenphone always bring the best solution in communication and technology so that the
people of the country can go beyond.
Vision
“We exist to help our customers get the full benefit of communications services in their daily
lives. We’re here to help”
Mission
Grameenphone is the only reliable means of communication that brings the people of
Bangladesh close to their loved ones and important things in their lives through unparalleled of
network, relevant innovations and services.
Empower Societies
They provide the power of digital communication, enabling everyone to improve their lives,
build societies and secure a better future for all.
Core Values
Make It Easy: Everything that they make should be easy to use and understand. Besides
that they always try to make their customer’s lives easier.
Keep Promises: Everything they should work perfectly. If it doesn’t, they’re there to put
things right. They’re about delivery, not over-promising. They’re about action, not
words.
Be Inspiring: They are creative. They bring energy and imagination to their work.
Everything they produce should look fresh and modern.
Be Respectful: They acknowledge and respect local culture. They want to be a part of
local communities wherever they operate. They want to help customers with their
specific needs in a way that suits way of their life best.
Implementation of Short term loan for Mobile Financial Services 15
Brand promise:
Previous: “Stay Close”
At present: “Go Beyond”
GP WAY: Their Way of Work
It is how they do business
It's all about living their vision, values, codes, leadership, governing principles in our
daily life and deliver upon our brand promise – Stay Close and Go Beyond
Organizational Structure
Flatter organization
Two growth stream: Leadership & Specialist
Workplace Ethics
Fortified Codes of Conduct
Ensured compliance
Sustainability Consciousness
Paperless office
Reduce 15% carbon emission by 2012 & 40% by 2015
Corporate Transformation: 'Green Company'
Aware-Engage-Advocate GP employees
Implementation of Short term loan for Mobile Financial Services 16
2.5 Grameenphone Organizational structure:
Implementation of Short term loan for Mobile Financial Services 17
2.6 Corporate Social Responsibility of Grameenphone
Grameenphone has always been committed to empower the society with digital solutions. This
company always works for the betterment of the society. Right now they are doing these CSR
activities:
Online School-quality education for left out children: Grameenphone wanted to improve
the quality system of underprivileged children. That’s why they merged with Jaago
Foundation and Agni System Ltd. launched an online school in 2011. Their aim is to
provide quality education to rural underprivileged students.
Supporting during Natural Disaster: Grameenphone always plays dynamic role in playing
role during difficult moments like flood, storm, building collapse. They are always beside
the crisis moment of our country.
Climate change green endeavor for green business operation: Grameenphone is highly
focuses on the sustainable solutions and environment friendly networks. That’s why they
are concerned with low-carbon society policy. Basically they are prioritizing on low CO2
emission generated by their own operations.
Online Child Safety-an eye opening study on Bangladeshi children: Along with the
agenda of supporting under privileged children Grameenphone is working on safe
internet and online safety omission policy. This is one of the many problems that has
become a major concern for the parents. In this case Grameenphone can monitor
children behavior of children and limit some selected websites which can bring out the
negativity in them.
Safe Internet Workshop-Country wide awareness:Grameenphone has associated with
BRAC for countrywide safe internet.
Grameenphone has also done many CSR activities in early years like:
1. Sponsor of Bangladesh Special Olympics Team
2. Sponsor of Bangladesh National Cricket Team
3. Establishment of Blood Bank at Bogra for underprivileged patients
4. Blood donation camps for underprivileged Thalassemia patients
Implementation of Short term loan for Mobile Financial Services 18
3 Concept Part:
3.1 Defining the problem:
Mobile money is growing so fast around the world. Now consumers don’t want to wait in lines
to pay bills or recharge their phones. In simple form mobile money allows them to use their
mobile phones as virtual wallet. By using this virtual wallet they can pay bills to service
providers, transfer money through their phones, exchange physical cash with the help of
agents. This is an emerging market in Asia and some countries of Africa. Since this has a very
high demand, meeting supply is getting difficult.
Although the aim is to provide faster money solution, the back end value chain is complicated
and difficult to manage. There are many layers which makes the process difficult. First of all
there are distributors who spread the service across large geographic area. Those distributors
then hire sales executives/delivery guys to distribute float to those areas. These retailers are
the ultimate touch points for end customers. A customer can avail Mobile Financial Services
(MFS) through these retailers. They also get a commission from the parents company. The
problematic areas are:
1. Customers go back without taking the service because of stock out problem
2. Because of vast geographic area sales executives miss out some of the retailers
3. No existing loan service for retailers
4. Parent company is losing Return on Investment (ROI) because of stock out problem.
3.2 Looking deep into the problem:
On a rough cut survey done on Bangladeshi customers, it was found that retailers return 30%
of the customers on an average day, 33% of retailers in India said that they have to reject
customers due to lack of float and Kenyan retailers claim that they cannot serve customers 5%
of the time due to lack of float. In Pakistan, majority retailers claimed liquidity to be a major
barrier in MFS business.
Implementation of Short term loan for Mobile Financial Services 19
3.3 Interviews:
A thorough user research in the Bangladesh market resulted in interesting findings. I
interviewed 10 retailers, 3 sales executives, 2 distributors and 2 parent company executives to
validate the problem. Apart from interviewing the key value chain members, I also had focused
group discussions with sales managers, followed Sales Delivery Guys for an entire run to
understand the customer journey (participant observation), observed retailers during peak
hours and so on. Triangulating all the information from different sources brought us to the
following pain points of the value chain.
Implementation of Short term loan for Mobile Financial Services 20
3.4 Interview outcome
User group Characteristics Pain point
Retailers
-Bottom of the pyramid
-Usually happy with their
present condition
- 5-10 years in business
- Usually they have a very
loyal customer base
- Earns commission on
transaction
- Proud and reputed
-Losing out on customers and
profit
- No instant support for retailers
-Retailers can’t balance e-
money and hard cash
whenever they want
-Unpredictable customer
demand
-Limited power on upper
management
Sales executives -Distributor: Reseller who
hires delivery guys for stock
delivery
-1000 retailers under a
distributor
-30 retailer per delivery guy
-Delivery guys usually stay in
the morning
-Cover either large number or
geography of retail
-Runs cash handling security
risk
-Bounded by banking hours
-No real-time view of retailer
status
-Fails to manage delivery routes
efficiently
-High manpower cost
Parent Company -Licensed MFS provider
-Earns Service
charge/transaction
-Customer loyalty and brand
value
-Key decision makers and
initiative takers
-20% retailers contribute to
80% performance
-Diversification risk
-Remotest market coverage is
still low
-Poor customer experience
-Difficult to manager robust
distribution channel
-Gives upper hand to
competition
Implementation of Short term loan for Mobile Financial Services 21
3.5 Market impact:
MFS services are available in more than 92 countries with a huge customer base. This industry
processed 269 Billion USD in transaction being served by 4.3 million registered mobile money
agents. According to GSMA industry report, mobile money providers process an average of
30,000 transactions per minute. However the end retailers are not able to cater every customer,
this results in an industry loss of roughly 3 billion USD every year. This usually happens when
demand is higher than supply. This potential revenue loss creates dissatisfaction in that
particular industry.
Apart from revenue loss there are also some problems like customer dissatisfaction, loss of
reputation in the industry. The beauty of mobile financial service is the transaction speed. The
faster the money moves, the more money its players make. But insufficient liquidity
management increases the amount of idle money in the market.
If the demand increases dramatically, the problem will be more severe. Besides that the
solution will be difficult to execute.
3.6 Solution to the problem
Liquid Eye is a real time market monitoring and electronic balance optimization solution for
mobile money businesses. It is a complete digital liquidity management solution to cater to the
needs of all value chain members. Firstly, it will provide a smart algorithm which will
automatically predict the amount of electronic balance that retailers need to keep which will
help optimize their investment. Alongside that, real time interfaces like apps and dashboards
with features like real-time updates, remote transfer options will be given to delivery guys and
distributors to help them serve the market faster.
Liquid Eye will solve these particular problems:
1. Real time update
2. Remote transfer
3. Route suggestion
4. Retailer rating
Implementation of Short term loan for Mobile Financial Services 22
3.7 Financial Analysis:
I have made a Five year financial analysis where I have found that its impact is significant in
terms of the revenue. I have prepared the below financial analysis table where I have covered
the revenue, revenue associated cost, general cost and other cost. The revenue and cost of the
coming years are forecasted and in line with Grameenphone previous year performance.
Year 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022
Total Revenue
128,400
141,240
155,364
170,900
187,990
Revenue from retailers
109,140
120,054
132,059
145,265
159,792
Current Revenue loss
3,274
3,602
3,962
4,358
4,794
Expected Revenue Gain
2,619
2,881
3,169
3,486
3,835
Cost associated to the
retailer
131
144
158
174
192
Promotional Cost
210
231
254
279
307
Transportation Cost
13
14
16
17
19
Other Cost
183
202
222
244
268
Total Cost
537
591
650
715
786
Total Return
Contribution'
2,082
2,291
2,520
2,772
3,049
Table: Five year forecasted financial model for the project
Implementation of Short term loan for Mobile Financial Services 23
The initial return from this activity is 2Bn from first year and then it will improve gradually. I
have made a five year financial analysis and found it will contribute a significant contribution in
the coming years. After five year we need to revisit the model and then we can also look for the
profitability going forward. From the above financial model and analysis I can see the project is
profitable and business viable.
Challenges:
I have not considered the Capital expenditure part here as it is not fixed yet. But I have talked
with the finance colleague about this issue. If there is a part of Capital expenditure then there
will be two part involved, the Hardware and Soft-ware part. Then we have to reevaluate the
model including the CAPEX part. We also have to include the depreciation and amortization part
in the financial model. If the CAPEX part is not that significant then we can tell from the five
years financial model that this project will add significant value to Grameenphone in coming
years.
2,082 2,291
2,520 2,772
3,049
2018 2019 2020 2021 2022
Total Return From Contribution
Implementation of Short term loan for Mobile Financial Services 24
While we are doing the financial analysis we have faced some other challenges as well. But with
the help from the different teams it was resolved and taken care well in the end. The following
challenges were there while doing the financial analysis:
Availability of Data
Educate the Retailers
Time management
Fix the parameters
Ensure documentation
4 Activities undertaken
4.1 Job responsibilities:
It was a great opportunity to work as an intern in of Business Innovation team. This internship
was for a specific project named Liquid Eye. Project Liquid Eye and the team won the Local
championship in one of the biggest international platform, Ignite Incubator Program hosted by
Telenor. As we were working in digital solution for MFS providers, the Liquid Eye team was
placed in the Digital Service team for one year period. So, I have the knowledge of both the
departments. As being the Local winner, they are given funds to develop their products further
with Grameenphone. Ignite’s aim is to develop digital products and solutions that can positively
impact the societies in the country where Telenor operates in. The project was about
developing a solution for liquidity management, which would help the retailers; Sales
Executives(SE), distribution house and the parent company to earn more revenue as well as
customer can get better service. Liquid Eye Team consisted of 3 initial members later I was
appointed as an intern. The team was divided in two parts, one was User Research and another
was Technical Research. I was assisting on the user research part of the project.
In the initial days of my internship, my basic responsibilities were simple but it evolved as the
time passed:
- Documentation: Throughout my team’s training period of Ignite, they developed their idea
and gathered many information. Also after the competition has ended, they did 2 market visits.
Implementation of Short term loan for Mobile Financial Services 25
My job was to analyze those data and make forecast in excel from those data and upload those
file in the designated portal so that the SE can see the liquidity position of the retailers as well
as the distribution house can have a look through the whole process.
- Transcribe: Before I joined there were already many interviews taken from the stakeholders.
So my task was to organize those data and make presentation from the important findings.
-Prepare Questionnaires: My supervisor asked me to prepare questionnaires for other
stakeholders and conduct interviews
-Manage and Conduct Interviews: After few weeks, I had to manage some relevant
stakeholders of the project and conduct interviews with them like the SE and retailers of
different distribution house.
- Prepare Reports: I had to make reports based on my findings from the interview. Some based
on their previous collected data and sometimes on the current data, which we are still
collecting.
- Analysis: I also had to analyze all the information that were collected and write up summaries
give my unbiased opinion on the research findings and find out top retailers and top SE based
on their performance.
- Technical Research: As I was performing well, I was also given responsibility on technical
research part and create report from portals and various sources.
5 Internship outcome
5.1 Learning outcome and experience:
My internship period started from October 9th, 2018 in Grameenphone Ltd. It is a 3 month
period internship program. I have learned so many things from this whole thing. Besides this I
got to know my potentials and my strengths. I have done every possible thing to develop my
skills and make the best use of my time.
Implementation of Short term loan for Mobile Financial Services 26
Personal development:
Grameenphone conducts many seminars and workshops to make sure the employees
know about the new technologies and every details that can help them in various
aspects of life. My team members and supervisors gave me enough room to explore my
abilities. During this internship period, my leadership skills, decision making skills, critical
thinking skills have improved a lot. Besides I learnt to be patient, cautious and work
under pressure.
Skill development:
Before joining Grameenphone I used to be a very introvert person. But my skills in
terms of communication, technicality and adaptability have improved a lot. Since I had
to engage with almost everyone in my department, I got the chance to talk to them
about my improvement areas. I could know their expertise. Beside this I got the
opportunity to learn the usage of many hardware and software as well as Microsoft
Office/Excel extensively. This has helped me to be more efficient than I was before.
Building connection:
Connection building is one of the most important things to do during internship. I tried
maintaining positive relationship with people of different departments as well as my own
department. I tried to stay relevant while talking to them which eventually led me to be
a part of their team. This helped me in various ways like I got to know about their
upcoming project and how they are going to execute those projects.
5.2 Problems I faced during my internship
It was a fun experience for me to work for Grameenphone. But it was very challenging to avail
every opportunity to work. It might be a single organization but there are different departments
and different people working in there. Though my co-workers and supervisors were super
friendly, I still faced some minor difficulties. And they are:
1. As I had to work in a team, I had to report to other three seniors. It was a pressure for
me to work in three different projects. Moreover their way of work was different. So I
had to face difficulties in term of finding a common medium to explain things to them
Implementation of Short term loan for Mobile Financial Services 27
2. Grameenphone is a paperless office. Everything done here is digital. I had to face some
problem to adopt and get dependent on using laptop and various application
3. For research work I had to talk to other employees of Grameenphone. It was one of the
challenges I faced because it was really difficult to communicate with them and get the
required information. Moreover, I had to go to different locations to talk to the retailers
and sales executives. It was also a challenge for me to get the proper information from
them.
4. Another challenge I had to face is that I had to work mostly with engineers and financial
officers. I am mentioning it as a challenge because I am a marketing graduate. I had to
work very hard to match their standard.
5.3 Influence of this internship on my career plan
There are influences of my internship on my further career plan. From very young age I wanted
to work in MNCs. But I wasn’t sure from where I can start. Doing internship in telecom industry
enriched my knowledge as well as stirred my interest in this industry. I got to know so many
things specially the corporate culture. Through this internship I know what I want to do in
future and this boosted up my confidence that I will be able to adapt to different culture of
different companies.
6 Challenges and recommendation:
6.1 Identified challenges in GP
Turnover:
Grameenphone Ltd one of the most cherished work place for most of the people. This is the top
choice among the MNC’s where people want to work. From interesting work to salaries and
incentives of Grameenphone, everything seems so appealing. But there is always an other side
of the story. The competition in telecom industry is beyond imagination in Bangladesh. Meeting
Implementation of Short term loan for Mobile Financial Services 28
the demand of the customer used to be the biggest challenge for telecom companies. But now
it’s not just meeting demands. They need to come up with new innovations and new ways to
add value in the consumer’s life. It is very hard to brainstorm and come up with fresh ideas.
Failing to cope up with the pressure many people quit their jobs. This is a great pressure for the
companies. Because turnover and recruiting new people adds unexpected expense to
companies overall expense. Furthermore recruiting, training and finding suitable people is also
time consuming.
Limited Career Growth and Opportunities: Career growth is one of the most important things in people’s life. But keeping the job and
working for the company has become a challenging thing for Grameenphone employees
because of sudden lay off. This has also created a bad name for the company. This thing makes
the employees demotivated. They cannot think the company as theirs, so they don’t put 100%
effort while working.
6.2 Recommendation
Because of stock out problem 33% customers go empty handed. This is a potential revenue
loss for a big company like Grameenphone. There are some measures that can be taken to
solve this problem. However, other companies face this problem even more severely than
Grameenphone. GP can encourage the support department to work more effectively so that the
system problem can be solved. They can monitor the distributor, retailer, and sales executive’s
performance and motivate them to keep up the good thing. The other measures that can be
taken are:
1. Create more accurate forecast to determine which retailers face stock out problem more
frequently
2. Sales executives should have at least some idea about potential stock out area
3. Short term loan which have very less commission cut can be introduced. By this both
the retailers and parent company can be benefitted.
4. The layer between the parent company and retailer should be reduced
Implementation of Short term loan for Mobile Financial Services 29
5. Distributors should have more access to the retailer’s data. So that they can forecast
demands and future stock out.
7 Conclusion Getting an opportunity to work at Grameenphone was truly a privilege for me. I am really very
happy that I got the best supervisors one can hope for. They helped me a lot to collect as much
experience during my tenure. Throughout my internship period I have gone through immense
pressure for several times but every time I faced any problem they helped me to get through it.
I would say my existing skills enhanced and I learned many new things which will always help
me in my future. Now I know how to deal with different kind of people and my communication
skills got better by time. No matter where I will work next this 3 months experience will always
be my favorite. All this knowledge and skills will boost my confidence. Besides this it will help
me to become a better person in future. Finally I would like to say that this is a once in a life
time experience that I got from here and I will utilize every bit of it.
Implementation of Short term loan for Mobile Financial Services 30
8 References:
Grameenphone. 2018. GP. [ONLINE] Available at: https://www.grameenphone.com/. [Accessed 14 November 2018].
Investopedia. 2018. Financial model. [ONLINE] Available at: https://www.investopedia.com/search/?search-terms=FIve%20year%20analysis%20of%20%20project. [Accessed 20 November 2018].
Project management. 2018. Project Analysis. [ONLINE] Available at: https://www.pmi.org/learning/library/basic-process-project-management-2114. [Accessed 20 November 2018].
Grameenphone.2018. GP Investor site. [ONLINE] Available at: https://www.grameenphone.com/business/investor-relations/ir-annual-report/annual-report-2017. [Accessed 20 November 2018].
Whiteboard.(2017). Fund Starter. [online] Available at: http://www.white-board.co/ [Accessed 11 Dec. 2017]