the logical structure of offense-defense theories

8/10/2019 The Logical Structure of Offense-Defense Theories

1/56


2/56

T C

I ................................................................................................................................3

D O D ...................................................................................................6

O D A ...............................................................................................7

O D A ...........................................................................................8

A P S I N P ..............................................................................................9

D E OD B ...........................................................10

D OD B C ...................................................................11

D OD B G O .........................................12

FM A OD B ....................................................14

FM L S ...............................................................................................15

O OD B .........................................................................16

T, M, F T ......................................................................17

S D B? ..........................................................................................19

O L A M B ...................................................................20

S, MT D B ............................................22

T C OD T .......................................................23

T O CI ..........................................................................23

T O I E .......................................................................26

OD T MH .......................................................................28

T R P T ..............................................................................................33

T F N D ..........................................................................37

C ................................................................................................................................42

N .........................................................................................................................................44


3/56

T L S OD T:

B T L H

T , , .

O, . I

I

, . A

.1

D 1980 ,

. T , ,

,

.2

T

,

, ,

F . T

,

,

.3

T ,

, , ,

. B

. O

, ,


4/56

D, A 2000 G . A

,

.4

S . E

, ,

.5G K

, .6B

.7I , I

,

. M ,

, .

F , I

.

, :

; , ;

, ,

.

D ,

. T

. T .

. T .

, .

G P S 1, 1939 F M 10, 1940. B

, , ,

. T

, , , .


5/56

D, A 2000 G . A

M , ..

, , . B ,

,

. I ,

, .

.

I , . I

, ,

. U,

. T

.8B I

,

,

. T , ,

,

.

, , ,

. E

, . T

, . O

, , .

A , ,

, , ,

. T

.


6/56


7/56


8/56

D, A 2000 G . A

? , ,

?

OFFENSIE AND DEFENSIE ACTIONS

T

, .. . B

. F ,

,

. T . I ,

, , .. , ,

. O

: O

, . M

, ,

. ,

.14

T ,

. ,

, ,

. B

, . T

, ,

. H . H

, . H ,

. T , ,

.


9/56

D, A 2000 G . A

APURE STRATEG ISNOT POSSIBLE

O , ,

. N .

. , , ,

.

. A ,

, , .

T . T

,

. A

. C T

C15, ,

, .

, , ,

.

. T , , . B

, .

E . O

, . O

,

, . S

, ,

,

.

,


10/56

D, A 2000 G . A

, .16

O : .

B , ,

. T

.

B

T C: "...

". B C

: "I , ,

,

." T C

. D , ,

. B

; , .

C : "D

."17

T C : C

? C

?

I ,

, . , . A


11/56

D, A 2000 G . A

. T

. T

.

R . P

, ,

. F , ;

. B

,

. M

,

.

DEFINING THE OFFENSEDEFENSE BALANCE B COST

T , ,

. I ,

, , ,

.18G K , ,

. A

, : "

."19

T G K ,

. B . T

. ,

, , , ,

.


12/56

D, A 2000 G . A

, , . I

, C,

, .20

F , A S D I

S . B

? N , . I

, , A , ,

R . T , ,

A R .

E . I

, . B

,

GNP? T GNP ,

, GNP

. T

,

? T , , ,

.

T

:

. I . B, ,

. S , ,

? I

. T .

DEFINING THE OFFENSEDEFENSE BALANCE B GOALS AND OUTCOMES


13/56

D, A 2000 G . A

G K

: .21

:

. S

, ? I ,

, . B

? T , ,

.

LJ

.22I ,

, ,

. B

. F

, ,

F 1871 G 1945.

T , ,

, .23G,

, T O E, 14531606,

: , ,

.24

,

.

I ,

, . I

,


14/56

D, A 2000 G . A

. T, , ,

, . B G K

,

.

FIRSTMOE ADANTAGE AND THE OFFENSEDEFENSE BALANCE

G K "

",

! . T

,

. G K

"

' , ."25

I

,

. B I

. T

. T .26

A ,

. T ,

: O

. B

. B . T

, , , ,

. A 27,

. T

, '


15/56

D, A 2000 G . A

.28O , ,

. S ,

, .29T

G M, D,

, .30

G : I B

, ,

.31

T G K : I

, ? T

? ? T

,

, . I

,

,

.

FIRSTMOES AND LATER STAGES

I , , ,

, ,

'', . I

,

NATO ,

S . O

,

N . B

.


16/56

D, A 2000 G . A

A , S

G , G ,

. B ? O ,

? D ,

B , USA, S U,

N G?

T , , S

, . I

.

L ,

. T , ,

, .

OPTIMALIT OF THE OFFENSEDEFENSE BALANCE

T , ,

:

?

G K " ",

" ",

, , 32. I

,

. S , , . D

,

,

. D . E

, . T

"" . G K


17/56

D, A 2000 G . A

, ,

: T ,

.33I . U ,

. T

,

.

TECHNOLOG,MOBILIT,FIREPOER AND TERRAIN

S ? L

J

, ,

, ,

. B

.34G K ,

.35M

. T , ,

, ,

.

F ,

. A , : ,

,

. B ,

, , ,

. T , ,

. T, 1928

F , : M

, ,

, .36


18/56

D, A 2000 G . A

A ,

,

. U ,

.37T

. F

, S ,

, . R N

A C , G

F . B,

,

. T ,

,

.

A ,

, . G K "

... , , ."38B,

G M 1940, .

C

.

B

,

.39T

. I

,

L . B

,


19/56

D, A 2000 G . A

. T B

. T D A D R,

, T G, 20 L, J 14,

1667.40B B

. E N H E

, .

T , , ,

, , . T

, . E

,

. A . A

. A

. . E

. F

. A , ,

.41

STEMIDE OR DADIC BALANCE?

M

.42G K

" ,

". I . B

, , ,

. I "

:" .43B

. F ,


20/56

D, A 2000 G . A

: . E

,

. I

, , , .44B

, , . F

,

.

ON THE LIMITED ABILIT TO MEASURE THE BALANCE

G

K ,

,

. A ,

.

F , I

" ",

NATO C F.45P

,

, , .46

T ,

. B

. T

. I

, ,

.


21/56

D, A 2000 G . A

F , G H

SI , S I ,

, I , L.

A :

? NATO G,

S U P G,

S A, . T

, : H

? H ? T

"

" , ,

, .47

, ,

, . M ,

, ,

. B ,

. I S G

. B ,

, .

T G , ,

, .48

A , ,

H B USA

, G S

U. B NS ,

, H M

. T H


22/56

D, A 2000 G . A

. T

.

SUMMAR,AND A MILITARTECHNICAL DEFINITION OF THE BALANCE

I

. A

, . T

,

, .

R , , I

I .

,

. I

. T ,

. T

.

T

. M

, . B

,

.


23/56

D, A 2000 G . A

B

, .

;

, ;

, , .

THE OUTBREAK OF AR AND CRISISINSTABILIT

D ? B

,

. T, ,

A

S. A , :

T I A,

S; .49

G T . I

G P , E 1914,

. T

, , ,

.50

T . ,

,

. T

, , . ,

. E

,

. A


24/56

D, A 2000 G . A

, , ,

,

.51

, ?

P ,

. T , , ,

.52O

,

, . B ?

O

. T

,

. I

. P , ,

,

. E ,

?

. C USA,

C USA

.

I ,

,

. B

. T , , .

A T ;


25/56

D, A 2000 G . A

.53T

. T , ,

.54

E , ,

,

. T , S ,

.55

C , ,

,

, ? N

. B

. C

, .

T

, .

T , , ,

, .56F .

B

. , ,

,

T S U , T,

, .

T ,

. T , ,

, , .


26/56

D, A 2000 G . A

T : O .

B , ,

.

THE OUTBREAK OF AR AND AR IN ITS ENTIRET

B ,

:

? H ?

T

. S

. P , , ,

, . B

?

I

.57

. B

: P

.

I , , . B

, .

E "

."58I , ,

.59B

, ,

. I


27/56

D, A 2000 G . A

,

.

I , E , "

."60C . I

E' , :

,

.61

G K ,

.62B I

. A 1914 , ,

,

. A

. T ,

, E F G . H, E

,

, , F

.

T

: T

. I

, ,

. T E 1973 . I

, ,

, , ,


28/56

D, A 2000 G . A

. U ,

.

OFFENSEDEFENSE THEOR AND MACROHISTOR

E . I

I

, .

E : "

... E ". A 1954: "

,

...

..." I

, , A, I

.63

T M E, . T

P K F M

. I E

M . B M E,

G K . I .64

T C, ,

. C . B

C

, , .65

A ' '

: T ,

. A ,


29/56

D, A 2000 G . A

, , .

, .

O , .

"T O C

1453" , G, " . T ,

, ." B

, , C.66

T

, . T

. T , , ,

.

T ,

, . A

' ,

, ' F L I

.67P , ,

. T :

, F ?

T F ,

F , F

F .68T ,

,

. A A S : "I

. I


30/56

D, A 2000 G . A

."69

D

, I . L

,

. A . S

, . T

, . ( ,

.) T

. D , . S ,

. O .

C ...

T , . H

,

. I

? T

. C ,

, . B

. T ,

. E

, . E

:

.70

T E . T

E .


31/56

D, A 2000 G . A

E .71E

,

, . T

, , ,

. C

,

.

,

, . I

.

T M A . B, D ,

. S , ,

?72

O ,

. O . D

, : T

, .

B BP F

, . A , E

. P , ,

. S , D

,

.73

B D .74F

, , ,


32/56

D, A 2000 G . A

. D

. T ,

, .

O S

, 17631848. S ,

. S , , ,

. H

B R ,

. F ,

,

. O ?

?75

T

E .

F E

. O C

E.76

I S 77, I ?

H I I ? T :

T ,

? C

. I

; . I

. B ,


33/56

D, A 2000 G . A

, .78T

D S ,

?

L

: T , , ,

. T

. T

,

.

, ,

, , . T

, , .

A , ,

, , ,

. T

.

M

, .79

, , ,

: ?


34/56


35/56

D, A 2000 G . A

M

C. . T

. S ?

C . F, ,

. T

, ... T

, , , ,

. T

, .84

T ,

; .

H, ,

. , ,

, , ,

. , ,

;

,

.85

L . F E

. I,

.86 , I

, , . A ,

. I

:

. B

, ,

.87


36/56

D, A 2000 G . A

A , ,

. I , , .

, . B , ,

, . P , ,

, .88

, , ,

, ,

. S , ,

. B

, . T

,

. A

, , , . , ,

MM : T

;

( ) .89

I E ,

. I ,

. I

, , , .

T G

. , , ,

, . T , ,

.90O , H

. T , , ,

.91S , K O, H,


37/56

D, A 2000 G . A

T, C ,

.

T F ,

. T , ,

1914. H ,

S

. T ,

. T F

1980,

.

B E

1914.92I , : I

. I

F .

T . I

.93I , ,

,

. T . G K

.94T

.


38/56

D, A 2000 G . A

E

. B, F 1933,

.95

T ,

, , ,

. T

. N

, ,

.96

B I

F , . I ,

,

.

I , F , I .

F, ,

F . S,

, 1914

.

L . F ,

,

.

. O , ,

J M ,

. B .

T

, S J 1916. T

F . T , ,


39/56

D, A 2000 G . A

,

. ,

,

, .

I ,

.

S ( !),

,

.

L . T F ,

, . T

, . B F

. T A C

, S , , .97I 1914, S

D

. T . E

, , . T

. A H , B 1914

1918 ,

. I 1920,

, F

. T 1920 1930,

F ,

.98

C ,

F . A S,


40/56

D, A 2000 G . A

I? B ? I

; . T

.99P ,

. P . I

. I

. S

, .100

,

,

. T ,

. T , . A S ,

F R N

C E. I E , 1914 1945,

.

, R .

S :

.101

T 1914: I

, . B ,

, , . T

,

,

. T E

P A 1866 F 1870

, A C , B

B, . E RJ M

. T


41/56

D, A 2000 G . A

. B ,

, ,

, J M. T

. I 1914

,

.102

E I B,

, . H

.103

A F ,

. A S, 1916,

.104S

1916? T . I 1916, , G,

F B . T

,

. I , ,

.105

T F . E

, . T

F . I

. P

, . T ,

. T

. B


42/56

D, A 2000 G . A

,

, .106

R ,

, , , ;

, .

I ,

. I , , ,

,

. A ,

, , . B, ,

. T

, ,

.

A

, , .

, , ,

, . E

, ,

. S

, , , ,

. O


43/56

D, A 2000 G . A

, .

O , .

E , . B

,

,

. , , ,

,

.

I , : A

, ..

, . F

,

, ,

.

A

, . A ,

,

.

T , ,

. T , ,

.


44/56

D, A 2000 P

1 I 2:4, M B, "A D L 'A' A

D S," 16, . 1 (1941).

2 B R. P, : , B,

(I: C U P, 1984); S E, "C

" (P.D. D, U C, 1984).

3 J S, "CM R C O, 1914 1984,"

9, . 1 (S 1984); J S,

: 1914(I: C U

P, 1984); J S, "P S D 1914,"

, . R J, R N L, J G S (B:

J H U P, 1985); S E, "T C O

O F ," 9, . 1 (S 1984);

S E, " C F 1914," 38, . 1 (O

1985).

4 A J S. L, "T O/D B

M T: A T H A,"

28 (1984). F S

M. LJ, "OD T I C," 4, . 4

(S 1995).

5 S E, "O, D C ," 22,

. 4 (S 1998); S E, :

(C U P, 1999).

6 C L. G C K, " I OD B C

M I?" 22, . 4 (S 1998).


45/56

D, A 2000 P

7 J . D, B I. F, S E. G, S E, C L.

G, C K, "C: T O OD

T," 23, . 3 ( 1998/99).

8 T R J,

(P U P, 1976). (S R

J, "C S D," 30, . 2 (J

1978).) J , R.

H

. B

, . H "

", " ".

F " ... ...",

" , ...

." (J H,

(U C P, 1959), . 4; H B, "T T

E M I C," (L:

C, 1951), . 1920.) T 2400

. (, , . R .

G C. (P, 1972), . 123124.)

9 S A, ., : ,

(P U F, 1990).

10 J. A. S E. S. C. , , S . (O:

C, 1989).

11 P R, , . A R, S . (P:

L R, 1985); A R, , N .

(P: D L R, 1994).


46/56

D, A 2000 P

12 T () H

: T , (J

14:20), T ; ,

(J 15:24), A ,

: . (E 4:12). T G

, L

, . T

:

(E 6:10);

(E 9:29); A ( E 10:2);

(D 11:17), H

. M

, , , ,

T . I N

E ,

, ,

, , , .

(I E', "O M C A E E: A

R O," , : B

, . H. T M. (J: M, 1983), . 91

93.)

13 O R J,

: A(C U P, 1989), .

32. O

R K. B, "M F ?" 24, . 2 (F 1999),

. 169170, E. H. C, ' , S . (N :


47/56

D, A 2000 P

M, 1946), . 5355, 7984; C C, . E

M H & P P. (P U P, 1984), . 377.

14 C C, . . 357.

15 T J. C, "C, USJ A, S D E

A," 23, . 4 (S 1999), . 6466.

16 S, , E. A. K, "T C CO,"

, . R. K E. A. K (B: 1991).

17 C, , . 358, 361.

18 S E. G, "T O OD T," 23,

. 3 ( 1998/99), . 190191.

19 G K, " I OD B, . 50.

20 C, , . 149.

21 G K, " I OD B, . 53, 73.

22 LJ, "OD T I C, . 671.

23

I , "T R F D C S:

C C A," & 16 (S

1974), . 388, F B, "H S S,"

: A, . P B (L:

R & K P, 1972), . 3839. B,

,

.

24 J F G, "I C: T O E, 1453

1606," 18, . 4 (S 1988).

25 G K, " I OD B, . 7172.

26 S, , C, , . 357359, 363 2.


48/56

D, A 2000 P

27 T , , R' F ,

. (E R,A(, : A

P, 1979).)

28 S. L. A. M . "I

' ,

15 . I

, ,

25 ." (S.

L. A. M, : B . F

1947. (G, M.: P S, 1978), . 56.) M'

, .

(R . G, "M F ," (F L: US A CGSC,

1987); F S, "T S S D' S,"A ,

(M 1989); R J. S, "S. L. A. M R F,"

133, . 4 ( 1988).)

29 S. L. A. M, . T

ORO 1952 , E C. E. (L: G, 1988),

. 911.

30 H D, : ,

, ,

(U L P, 1913), . 2728.

31 P G, B: ,

R . (N, CA: P, 1991), . 29.

32 G K, " I OD B, . 5557.

33 I., . 72 87.

34 LJ, "OD T I C, . 668.

35 G K, " I OD B, . 6061.


49/56

D, A 2000 P

36 R E. S, B: B (L:

B', 1987), . 110,161. T

S . S C

B, : A (L: B', 1986).

F S

K. T, A(F C, 1994),

. 7384.

37 J J. M, (I: C U P, 1987), .

2526; G K, " I OD B, . 6263. B

,

. (A

.) M,

. (S D. B, "T D

O D C L " (P.D. D,

H U, 1992), . 195.)

38 G K, " I OD B, . 65.

39 C, , . 417422.

40 A T M, 16601783(N :

H & , 1957), . 116. T

L.

41 R J, : (P U

P, 1997); E N. L, : (C,

M: H U P, 1987).

42 LJ, "OD T I C, . 668.

43 G K, " I OD B, . 5758.


50/56

D, A 2000 P

44 LJ, "OD T I C, . 666.

45 G K, " I OD B, . 74.

46 P, , . 4446.

47 G K, " I OD B, . 7677.

48 F S P, R,

G G ,

G , T

, "T S P R," 6, . 3 (1999).

49 T, , . R L (O

U P, 1960), B I P 23.

50 R G, "T T H ," 18,

. 4 (S 1988), . 598, 611612.

51 LJ, "OD T I C, . 670.

52 I., . 689690.

53

P . S, , 17631848(O:

C, 1994), . 355.

54 B, "M F ? . 172.

55 S, , . 752.

56 M I, C 11.

57 T G K, " I OD B, .

48. S E, "O, D C , . 78.

58 E, "O, D C , . 7.

59 T E 1914

. (G . A, "D C D: C

F M T 1914 R A D P, F F,

L D G," (S U: C I S

A C, N 1993).) T


51/56

D, A 2000 P

,

. (R A R O. K, "A

C U: S I," 38, . 1

(O 1985), . 232.)

60 E, "O, D C , . 8.

61 M , P

L, ?

(P U P, 1993), . 146. T

N G . B

.

62 G K, " I OD B, . 49.

63 E, "O, D C , . 5; G H. Q,

(J , 1977); J, "C

S D; S A, , S

E . (B: U C P, 1968), . 76.

64 E , "T M O S E P, 12451255,"

B15 (1941).

65 L G, : A , . M R (U

C P, 1991).

66 J F G, :

(C U P,

1974), . 263.

67 A , ,

, , ,

R. B

, F

F . (M P, K A,


52/56

D, A 2000 P

: A , 17631815(P

U P, 1997), . 3134.)

68 R B, " B N S," 33, .

1 (M 1973); J A. L, "T T I G A: T F

C," 55 (J 1991).

69 A S, "O E D," A

(I: L C, 1981), . 708.

70 E', "O M C A E E: A R

O, . 99.

71 R. T, "T M S T A

E S," 10, . 1 (S 1999), . 152.

72 B M. D, :

A (P U P, 1992), . ,7. F

B M. D, "M O

C G ," & 18 (1989).

73 D, , . 14, 1617.

74 D B. R, "A R ,"

67, . 1 (1995).

75 S, , . 37, 244, 273.

76 I., . 117, 287, 580581. F , P . S, "T

N C S: B P P E?"

15, . 2 (1989); P . S, "'S' S T

I H," 15, . 1 (F 1993).

77 F , S , T. C. . B, C I, J

S. L, P . S, H. M. S, 16, . 4 (N

1994).

78 C, , . 171172.


53/56

D, A 2000 P

79 G K, " I OD B,

.

S . 61 53.

80 LJ, "OD T I C, . 664.

81 G K, " I OD B, . 4849.

82 T TA : H

; . (J D, , ,

: (N, 1997), . 157175.)

83 T B, "P, C E,"8 (1975), . 42.

84 C, , . 136, 139, 140141, 148, 168.

85 I., . 153, 156158.

86 B I. F, "T O OD T," 23,

. 3 ( 1998/99), . 187.

87 F

H B, "I T: T C C

A," 18, . 3 (1966); J. D S, "T I T:

I E," A , . K

K J N. R (P U P, 1969).

88 C , A D, "T D F L,"

B, 4 N 1999, . 35.

89 E MM, "T I E N S,"

9 (1984), . 215216. T ,

, , . S S J G, ' A, '

: (P, 1988).

90 E P, : A (N :

G H, 1983), . 710.


54/56

D, A 2000 P

91 B M. . K, : ' (

U P, 1998), . 120121.

92 B, "M F ? . 179.

93 , ,

MAD . (I., . 181.) F

, R N L J

G S, "B D," 43, . 4 (1987), . 610.

94 G K, " I OD B, . 53.

95 E, , . 118 2; J. F. C. F, "A A

: T A Q D,"A 14, . 79 (JA

1933), . 7, 9. S B, "M F ? . 183.

96 I , , ,

, . I

, US

,

S U . E

, . F,

E , R, ?

(Q R J, "T I M ,"

: A(C U P,

1989), . 45.)

97 F C , , J M. MP,

"F L T : 18611865," :

A (O U P, 1996); J M. MP, "L

S U S," , , . G S.

B, (O U P, 1992).


55/56

D, A 2000 P

98 N H, "R R," :

191418 R G, : A

G P, A B S S,

, 1622 S 1988. I H B B,

: (O U P,

1996), . 126 50.

99 P . S, " I G G: A R J R,"

44 (S 1972), . 322.

100 D K, (N :

D, 1995).

101 S P R, : (I,

N: C U P, 1991), . 20.

102 L. L. F, : , A

A 1914(S B O: ABCC, 1973); M H,

"M F: T D O 1914," :

A, . P P (P: P U

P, 1986); A, "D C D."

103 J B, ,

(B: G, 1899).

104 L : T

, ; G

. B

, .

105 D ,

. S E J. L, "B : O R

E A," 6, . 4 (S 1997).


56/56

D, A 2000 P

106 B , F

, , . F

A, "D C

D."

the logical structure of offense-defense theories

Documents