design and fabrication of hybrid silencer - new horizon
TRANSCRIPT
A PROJECT REPORT [10ME85L]
ON
DESIGN AND FABRICATION OF HYBRID SILENCER
Submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirement for award of degree in
Bachelor of Engineering
(Mechanical Engineering)
Of
VISVESVARAYA TECHNOLOGICAL UNIVERSITY, BELGAUM
By
JITENDRA SINGH (1NH11ME021)
NACHAPPA . K.S (1NH11ME030)
RAVI RANJAN KUMAR (1NH11ME042)
SYED ABDUL NADEEM (1NH11ME056)
Project work carried out at
NEW HORIZON COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING, Bangalore
Under the Guidance of
Mr. SUMANTH. H
Assistant Professor, Department of Mechanical Engineering, NHCE
Department of Mechanical Engineering
NEW HORIZON COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING (Accredited by NBA, Permanently Affiliated to VTU)
A Recipient of Prestigious Rajyotsava State Award 2012 by the
Government of Karnataka
Ring Road, Kadubisanahalli, Bellandur Post, Near Marathalli, Bangalore -560 103
Tel.: +91-80-6629 7777. Fax: +91-80- 28440770
Web: www.newhorizonindia.edu
2014-2015
NEW HORIZON COLLEGE OF ENGINEERING (Accredited by NBA, Permanently Affiliated to VTU)
A Recipient of Prestigious Rajyotsava State Award 2012 by the
Government of Karnataka
Ring Road, Kadubisanahalli, Bellandur Post, Near Marathalli, Bangalore -560103
Tel.: +91-80-6629 7777. Fax: +91-80- 28440770
Web: www.newhorizonindia.edu
Certificate This is to certify that the project Report
DESIGN AND FABRICATION OF HYBRID SILENCER
[10ME85L]
Is a bonafied work carried out by
Jitendra Singh (1NH11ME021)
Nachappa.K.S (1NH11ME030)
Ravi Ranjan Kumar (1NH11ME042)
Syed Abdul Nadeem (1NH11ME056)
In partial fulfillment for the award of degree of Bachelor of Engineering in Mechanical of
the Visvesvaraya Technological University, Belgaum during the year 2014 - 2015. It is certified
that all corrections/suggestions indicated for Internal Assessment have been incorporated in the
Report deposited in the departmental library. The project report has been approved as it is
satisfies the academic requirements in respect of Project Work prescribed for the Bachelor of
Engineering degree.
Signature of the Guide Signature of the HOD Signature of the Principal
External Viva.
Name of the examiners. Signature with date.
1.
2.
ABSTRACT
Air pollution is most important from the public health of view, because every individual person
breaths approximately 22000 time a day, inhaling about 15 to 22 kg of air daily. Polluted air
causes physical ill effect decides undesirable aesthetic and physiological effects. Air pollution
can be defined as addition to our atmosphere of any material, which will have a dexterous effect
on life upon our planet. The main pollutants contribute by automobile are carbon monoxide
(CO), unburned hydrocarbon (UBHC), oxides of nitrogen (NOx) and Lead. Automobiles are not
the only sources of air pollution, other sources such as electric power generating stations,
industrial and domestic fuel consumption, refuse burning, industrial processing etc. also
contribute heavily to contamination of our environment so it is imperative that serious attempts
should be made to conserve of our environment from degradation. A hybrid Silencer is an
attempt in this direction. It is mainly dealing with control of emission and noise. A hybrid
Silencer is fitted to the exhaust pipe of engine. Because we use activated charcoal in this silencer
and hence its name HYBRID SILENCER. The noise and smoke level is considerable less than
the conventional silencer, it is cheaper, no need of catalytic converter and easy to install.
(i)
ACKNOWLEDGEMENT
The satisfaction that accompanies the successful completion of any work would be incomplete
without the mention of the people who made it possible and whose constant encouragement
and guidance has been a source of inspiration throughout the course of completion of this
project work.
We express our heartfelt thanks to Dr. Mohan Manghnani, Chairman, N.H.E.I, for providing
all the facilities for carrying out the project work.
We express our heartfelt thanks to Dr. Manjunatha, Principal, N.H.C.E, for providing a
friendly atmosphere to work in.
Any amount of gratitude is incomplete without thanking Dr. M.S. Ganesha Prasad, H.O.D,
Department of Mechanical Engineering, N.H.C.E, for his constant support, motivation & co-
operation in carrying out our project work successfully.
We express our gratitude to Mr. Sumanth. H, Asst Professor, our guide, for his expert
guidance, encouragement and suggestion throughout the preparation of this work.
We sincerely thank our lecturers of the Mechanical Engineering Department whole heartedly,
for their guidance and encouragement.
We would also like to express our sincere gratitude towards my parents and my friends who
have been a source of constant encouragement and moral support. They have supported me
throughout the preparation of this seminar in some way or the other.
(ii)
Serial No Contents Page No
Abstract i
Acknowledgement ii
List of contents iii
List of figures v
List of graphs vi
List of tables vi
1. Introduction 1
1.1 Types of silencer 2
2. Literature survey 6
2.1 History of emission control system 6
2.2 vehicle emission control 7
2.3 Design criteria 8
2.4 Terminology of exhaust system 11
2.5 Exhaust system tuning 14
2.6 Exhaust system repair and maintenance 15
3. Emission testing and standard 17
3.1 Emission testing 17
3.2 Bharat Stage Emission standard 17
(iii)
3.3 Background information 20
3.4 Emission Standards 26
4. Construction and working 27
4.1 Construction of Hybrid Silencer 27
4.2 Working 29
4.3 Absorption process 29
5. Design and calculation 30
5.1 Design calculation of muffler 30
5.1.1 Design Data 30
5.1.2 Part Design 30
5.1.3 Calculated Wavelength from Frequency 31
6. Material used in fabrication 33
6.1 Carbon steel 33
6.2 Stainless steel 34
6.2.1 Maintenance 36
6.3 Galvanized steel 36
6.4 Charcoal 37
6.4.1 Types of Charcoal 38
7. Operational and physical parameters 41
8. Experimental analysis and result of hybrid silencer 45
(iv)
8.1 Experimental analysis 45
8.2 Result 48
9. Conclusion 49
10. Scope for future enhancement 50
List of figures
Figure no. Title page no.
1 Reflecting type 3
2 Reflection absorption type 3
3 Absorption type 4
4 Absorption type 5
5 Exhaust piping and silencer on Ducati
Monster motorcycle 9
6 After market exhaust manifold 11
7 Hybrid silencer CAD model 38
8 CAD 2D view 28
9 Stainless steel 35
10 Galvanized steel 37
11 Charcoal 38
12 Perforated tube 41
(v)
13 Activated carbon 43
14 Experimental setup 44
15 Emission test results 46
16 Emission Test Result 2 47
List of graphs
Graph no. Title Page no.
1 Compression between European, us and bharath stage
Emission standard for gasoline passenger car 19
2 Compression between European, us and bharath stage
Emission standard for diesel passenger car 19
3 Effect of change in porosity 41
4 Back pressure v/s hole diameter 42
List of table
Table no. Title Page no.
1 Indian emission standard for 4 wheel vehicle 20
2 Indian emission standard for 2 and 3 wheel vehicle 21
3 Emission standard for diesel truck and bus engine 21
4 Emission standard for light duty diesel vehicle 22
5 Emission standard for light duty diesel engine 22
6 Emission standard for 4 wheel gasoline vehicle 23
(vi)
7 Emission standard for 3 wheel gasoline vehicle 23
8 Emission standard for 2 wheel gasoline vehicle 24
9 Emission standard for 2-3 wheel diesel vehicle 24
10 Emission limits for diesel engine < 800 kW 24
11 Emission limits for diesel engine > 800 kW 25
12 Ambient air quality standard 25
13 Calculated wavelength 31
14 Co and Hc level at idling volume 48
15 Sound characteristics 48
(vii)
DESIGN AND FABRICATION OF HYBRID SILENCER 2014-2015
DEPARTMENT OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING,NHCE Page 1
Chapter 1
Introduction
The purpose of emission control is to reduce amount of pollutants and environmentally
damaging substances released by the vehicles. If not controlled the automobile can emit
pollutants from fuel tank, carburetor and crank case and exhaust system into the
atmosphere. The fuel tank and the carburetor emit gasoline vapor , crank case releases
partly burnt air – fuel mixture blown off by piston rings and pollutants from exhaust
system consists of partly burnt hydrocarbons, carbon monoxide, nitrogen oxide and
sulphur dioxide. The smoke may be formed due to incomplete burning of fuel. It took
many years for public and the automobile industry to address the problem of the
pollutants.
It is estimated that in USA alone, 200 million tons of man-made pollutants adds to the air.
Therefore, these pollutants, if not controlled, adversely affect our health. Automobile
manufacturers have been working towards reduction of automotive air pollutants when
auto emissions were fund to be a part of the cause of smog. The emission of pollutants
can be decreased by improving combustion efficiency which in turns needs redesigning of
fuel tank, carburetor, and combustion chamber, cooling system, ignition and exhaust
system. The other way of controlling atmospheric pollution is destroy the pollutants after
they have been formed.An exhaust system is usually piping used to guide
reaction exhaust gases away from a controlled combustion inside an engine or stove. The
entire system conveys burnt gases from the engine and includes one or more exhaust
pipes. Depending on the overall system design, the exhaust gas may flow through one or
more of:
Cylinder head and exhaust manifold
A turbocharger to increase engine power.
A catalytic converter to reduce air pollution.
A muffler (North America) / silencer (Europe/India), to reduce noise.
DESIGN AND FABRICATION OF HYBRID SILENCER 2014-2015
DEPARTMENT OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING,NHCE Page 2
1.1 Types of Silencer
Silencer or also known as muffler is device that reduces amount of noise that is produce
by a machine, in this case an engine. There are many types of silencer in the market, but
there are three basic types of silencer, diffusion, absorption and active. For this project,
we will only focus on experimenting absorption silencer.
Diffuser or Depressive Silencers
Diffuser type silencers have perforated pepper pots to slow down flow velocity and
prevent the generation of low frequency noise and are mainly used for applications
involving nozzles, control valves, jet engines etc.
The total pressure drop is divided in several stages across the nozzle, the valve and the
diffuser. This allows a better pressure ratio between upstream and downstream and
reduces the noise level.
Active Silencers
Active noise control is sound field modification, particularly sound field cancellation, by
electro-acoustical means. Active silencers use microphones and electronics to determine
and attenuate noise.
In its simplest form, a control system drives a speaker to produce a sound field that is an
exact mirror-image the offending sound (the "disturbance"). The speaker thus "cancels"
the disturbance, and the net result is no sound at all. Such silencers can be effective at low
frequencies under 300 Hz.
Active noise control is best suited for applications with relatively steady noise fields - like
fans, engines or similar. Active silencers are not suitable for broadband noise reduction.
DESIGN AND FABRICATION OF HYBRID SILENCER 2014-2015
DEPARTMENT OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING,NHCE Page 3
Reflection Type
The noise is reduced by creating a gas flow through separate chambers in the silencer.The
Reflection Type silencer is most effective in lower and middle frequency range
Figure1: Reflecting type
Reflection/Absorption Type
The Reflection/Absorption Type silencers are based on a combination of absorption and
reflection damping techniques in order to reduce the noise in the complete frequency
range.
Figure2: reflection-absorption type
DESIGN AND FABRICATION OF HYBRID SILENCER 2014-2015
DEPARTMENT OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING,NHCE Page 4
Absorption silencer
Absorption silencers use heat resistant sound absorbing materials which are held in
position by perforated tube(s).
Noise reduction is achieved by converting the energy in the sound pressure waves into
heat. This heat is the by-product of the friction generated between the exhaust gas
particles and the sound absorbing material.
Absorption silencers are manufactured in various designs to suit the required application,
straight through silencers where low backpressure is required to multi pass silencers
suited to LPG engines with high frequency noise due to higher gas velocities.
Figure3: absorption silencer
The hybrid silencer discussed in this project report works on the principle of absorption
silencer. A hybrid silencer System is designed to replace conventional single unit engine
silencers on board structures. With its light weight and slender design, it offers a minimal
'footprint' while optimizing the entire exhaust system for low noise and reduced
backpressure. It is used to control the noise and emission in IC engines. The reason why
we go for hybrid silencer is, in today life the air pollution causes physical ill effects to the
human beings and also the environment. The main contribution of the air pollution is
automobiles releasing the gas like carbon dioxide and unburnt Hydrocarbon.
DESIGN AND FABRICATION OF HYBRID SILENCER 2014-2015
DEPARTMENT OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING,NHCE Page 5
In order to avoid these type of gas by introducing this hybrid silencer. It is fitted to the
exhaust pipe of the engine. The emission can be controlled by using the activated
charcoal layer and it is highly porous and possesses extra free valences so it has high
absorption capacity. So absorb the gases from the engine and release much less position
to the environment. The noise and smoke level is considerable less than the conventional
silencer, no need of catalytic converter and easy to install.
In this silencer, the Charcoal and Water so it is called hybrid silencer, and it is useful in
automobile, industry, DG sets & DG machines, Marin and Boats also so, it is known as
hybrid universal silencer.
Figure4: Absorption type
DESIGN AND FABRICATION OF HYBRID SILENCER 2014-2015
DEPARTMENT OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING,NHCE Page 6
Chapter 2
Literature Survey
2.1 History of emission control system
Throughout the 1950s and 1960s, various federal, state and local governments in
the United States conducted studies into the numerous sources of air pollution. These
studies ultimately attributed a significant portion of air pollution to the automobile, and
concluded air pollution is not bounded by local political boundaries. At that time, such
minimal emission control regulations as existed in the U.S. were promulgated at the
municipal or, occasionally, the state level. The ineffective local regulations were
gradually supplanted by more comprehensive state and federal regulations. By 1967 the
State of California created the California Air Resources Board, and in 1970, the
federal United States Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) was established. Both
agencies, as well as other state agencies, now create and enforce emission regulations for
automobiles in the United States. Similar agencies and regulations were
contemporaneously developed and implemented in Canada, Western Europe, Australia,
and Japan.
The first effort at controlling pollution from automobiles was the PCV (positive crankcase
ventilation) system. This draws crankcase fumes heavy in unburned hydrocarbons — a
precursor to photochemical smog — into the engine's intake tract so they are burned
rather than released unburned from the crankcase into the atmosphere. Positive crankcase
ventilation was first installed on a widespread basis by law on all new 1961-model cars
first sold in California. The following year, New York required it. By 1964, most new
cars sold in the U.S. were so equipped, and PCV quickly became standard equipment on
all vehicles worldwide.
The first legislated exhaust (tailpipe) emission standards were promulgated by the State of
California for 1966 model year for cars sold in that state, followed by the United States as
a whole in model year 1968. The standards were progressively tightened year by year, as
mandated by the EPA.
DESIGN AND FABRICATION OF HYBRID SILENCER 2014-2015
DEPARTMENT OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING,NHCE Page 7
By the 1974 model year, the emission standards had tightened such that the de-tuning
techniques used to meet them were seriously reducing engine efficiency and thus
increasing fuel usage. The new emission standards for 1975 model year, as well as the
increase in fuel usage, forced the invention of the catalytic converter for after-treatment of
the exhaust gas. This was not possible with existing leaded gasoline, because the lead
residue contaminated the platinum catalyst. In 1972, General Motors proposed to the
American Petroleum Institute the elimination of leaded fuels for 1975 and later model
year cars. The production and distribution of unleaded fuel was a major challenge, but it
was completed successfully in time for the 1975 model year cars. All modern cars are
now equipped with catalytic converters and leaded fuel is nearly impossible to buy in
most First World countries.
2.2 Vehicle emissions control
Vehicle emissions control is the study of reducing the motor vehicle emissions. Emissions
produced by motor vehicles, especially internal combustion engines.
Emissions of many air pollutants have been shown to have variety of negative
effects on public health and the natural environment. Emissions that are principal
pollutants of concern include:
Hydrocarbons - A class of burned or partially burned fuel, hydrocarbons
are toxins. Hydrocarbons are a major contributor to smog, which can be a major
problem in urban areas. Prolonged exposure to hydrocarbons contributes
to asthma, liver disease, lung disease, and cancer. Regulations governing
hydrocarbons vary according to type of engine and jurisdiction; in some cases,
"non-methane hydrocarbons" are regulated, while in other cases, "total
hydrocarbons" are regulated. Technology for one application (to meet a non-
methane hydrocarbon standard) may not be suitable for use in an application that
has to meet a total hydrocarbon standard. Methane is not directly toxic, but is
more difficult to break down in a catalytic converter, so in effect a "non-methane
hydrocarbon" regulation can be considered easier to meet. Since methane is
a greenhouse gas, interest is rising in how to eliminate emissions of it.
DESIGN AND FABRICATION OF HYBRID SILENCER 2014-2015
DEPARTMENT OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING,NHCE Page 8
Carbon monoxide (CO) - A product of incomplete combustion, carbon monoxide
reduces the blood's ability to carry oxygen; overexposure (carbon monoxide
poisoning) may be fatal. Carbon Monoxide poisoning is a killer in high
concentrations.
Nitrogen oxides (NOx) - Generated when nitrogen in the air reacts with oxygen at
the high temperature and pressure inside the engine. NOx is a precursor to smog
and acid rain. NOx is a mixture of NO, N2O, and NO2. NO2 is extremely reactive.
It destroys resistance to respiratory infection. NOx production is increased when
an engine runs at its most efficient (i.e. hottest) part of the cycle.
Particulate matter – Soot or smoke made up of particles in the micrometre size
range: Particulate matter causes negative health effects, including but not limited
to respiratory disease and cancer.
Sulphur oxide (SOx) - A general term for oxides of sulphur, which are emitted
from motor vehicles burning fuel containing sulphur. Reducing the level of fuel
sulphur reduces the level of Sulphur oxide emitted from the tailpipe.
Volatile organic compounds (VOCs) - Organic compounds which typically have a
boiling Point less than or equal to 250 °C; for example chlorofluorocarbons
(CFCs) and formaldehyde. Volatile organic compounds are a subsection of
Hydrocarbons that are mentioned separately because of their dangers to public
health.
2.3 Design criteria
An exhaust pipe must be carefully designed to carry toxic and/or noxious gases away
from the users of the machine. Indoor generators and furnaces can quickly fill an enclosed
space with poisonous exhaust gases such as hydrocarbons, carbon monoxide and nitrogen
oxides, if they are not properly vented to the outdoors. Also, the gases from most types of
machine are very hot; the pipe must be heat-resistant, and it must not pass through or near
anything that can burn or can be damaged by heat. A chimney serves as an exhaust pipe
in a stationary structure. For the internal combustion engine it is important to have the
exhaust system "tuned" for optimal efficiency. Also this should meet the regulation norms
maintained in each country. In European countries, EURO 5, India BS-4 etc.
DESIGN AND FABRICATION OF HYBRID SILENCER 2014-2015
DEPARTMENT OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING,NHCE Page 9
Motorcycles
In most motorcycles all or most of the exhaust system is visible and may be chrome
plated as a display feature. Aftermarket exhausts may be made from steel, aluminium,
titanium, or carbon fibre.
Motorcycle exhausts come in many varieties depending on the type of engine and its
intended use. A twin cylinder may flow its exhaust into separate exhaust sections, such as
seen in the Kawasaki EX250 (also known as the Ninja 250 in the US, or the GPX 250).
Or, they may flow into a single exhaust section known as a two-into-one (2-1). Larger
engines that come with 4 cylinders, such as Japanese super sport or superbikes (such the
Kawasaki ZX series, Honda's CBR series, Yamaha's YZF series, also known as R6 and
R1, andSuzuki's GSX-R series) often come with a twin exhaust system. A "full system"
may be bought as an aftermarket accessory, also called a 4-2-1 or 4-1, depending on its
layout. In the past, these bikes would come standard with a single exhaust, as seen on the
Kawasaki ZX-6R 2000 and 2001 models. However, EU noise and pollution regulations
have generally stopped this practice, forcing companies to use other methods to increase
performance of the motorcycle.
Figure5 - Exhaust piping and silencer on a Ducati Monster motorcycle
Trucks
In many trucks / Lorries all or most of the exhaust system is visible. Often in such trucks
the silencer is surrounded by a perforated metal sheath to avoid people getting burnt
touching the hot silencer. This sheath may be chrome plated as a display feature. Part of
the pipe between the engine and the silencer is often flexible metal industrial ducting; this
helps to avoid vibration from the engine being transferred into the exhaust system.
DESIGN AND FABRICATION OF HYBRID SILENCER 2014-2015
DEPARTMENT OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING,NHCE Page 10
Sometimes a large diesel exhaust pipe is vertical, to blow the hot noxious gas well away
from people; in such cases the end of the exhaust pipe often has a hinged metal flap to
stop debris, birds and rainwater from falling inside.
Two-stroke engines
In a two-stroke engine, such as that used on dirt bikes, a bulge in the exhaust pipe known
as an expansion chamber uses the pressure of the exhaust to create a pump that squeezes
more air and fuel into the cylinder during the intake stroke. This provides greater power
and fuel efficiency.
Marine engines
With an on board diesel or petrol (gasoline) engine below-decks on marine vessels:-
Lagging the exhaust pipe stops it from overheating the engine room where people
must work to service the engine.
Feeding water into the exhaust pipe cools the exhaust gas and thus lessens the
back-pressure at the engine's cylinders. Often in marine service the exhaust
manifold is integral with a heat exchanger which allows sea water to cool a closed
system of fresh water circulating within the engine.
Outboard motors
In outboard motors the exhaust system is usually a vertical passage through the engine
structure and to reduce out-of-water noise blows out underwater, sometimes through the
middle of the propeller.
DESIGN AND FABRICATION OF HYBRID SILENCER 2014-2015
DEPARTMENT OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING,NHCE Page 11
2.4 Terminology of Exhaust System
Manifold or header
Figure6: Aftermarket exhaust manifold
In most production engines, the manifold is an assembly designed to collect the exhaust
gas from two or more cylinders into one pipe. Manifolds are often made of cast iron in
stock production cars, and may have material-saving design features such as to use the
least metal, to occupy the least space necessary, or have the lowest production cost. These
design restrictions often result in a design that is cost effective but that does not do the
most efficient job of venting the gases from the engine. Inefficiencies generally occur due
to the nature of the combustion engine and its cylinders. Since cylinders fire at different
times, exhaust leaves them at different times, and pressure waves from gas emerging from
one cylinder might not be completely vacated through the exhaust system when another
comes. This creates a back pressure and restriction in the engine's exhaust system that can
restrict the engine's true performance possibilities. In Australia, the pipe of the exhaust
system which attaches to the exhaust manifold is called the 'engine pipe' and the pipe
emitting gases to ambient air called the 'tail pipe'.
Regardless of the negative attributes focused upon by potential sellers of steel tube
exhaust outlet configurations, engineers who design engine components choose
conventional cast iron exhaust manifolds can similarly list positive attributes, such as an
array of heat management properties and superior longevity than any other type of
exhaust outlet design. For the average consumer, having trouble with an exhaust outlet
system may qualify as 'poorer performance'.
A header (sometimes called set of extractors in Australia) is a manifold specifically
designed for performance.During design, engineers create a manifold without regard to
weight or cost but instead for optimal flow of the exhaust gases. This design results in a
DESIGN AND FABRICATION OF HYBRID SILENCER 2014-2015
DEPARTMENT OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING,NHCE Page 12
header that is more efficient at scavenging the exhaust from the cylinders. Headers are
generally circular steel tubing with bends and folds calculated to make the paths from
each cylinder's exhaust port to the common outlet all equal length, and joined at narrow
angles to encourage pressure waves to flow through the outlet, and not back towards other
cylinders. In a set of tuned headers the pipe lengths are carefully calculated to enhance
exhaust flow in a particular engine revolution per minute range.
Headers are generally made by aftermarket automotive companies, but sometimes can be
bought from the high-performance parts department at car dealerships. Generally, most
car performance enthusiasts buy aftermarket headers made by companies solely focused
on producing reliable, cost-effective well-designed headers specifically for their car.
Headers can also be custom designed by a custom shop. Due to the advanced materials
that some aftermarket headers are made of, this can be expensive. Luckily, an exhaust
system can be custom built for any car, and generally is not specific to the car's motor or
design except for needing to properly connect solidly to the engine. This is usually
accomplished by correct sizing in the design stage, and selecting a proper gasket type and
size for the engine.
Header-back
The Header-back (or header back) is the part of the exhaust system from the outlet of the
header to the final vent to open air — everything from the header back. Header-back
systems are generally produced as aftermarket performance systems for cars
without turbochargers.
Turbo-back
The Turbo-back (or turbo back) is the part of the exhaust system from the outlet of a
turbocharger to the final vent to open air. Turbo-back systems are generally produced as
aftermarket performance systems for cars with turbochargers. Some turbo-back (and
header-back) systems replace stock catalytic converters with others having less flow
restriction.
DESIGN AND FABRICATION OF HYBRID SILENCER 2014-2015
DEPARTMENT OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING,NHCE Page 13
With or without catalytic converter
Some systems (including in former time all systems) (sometimes nowadays called cat
less or de-cat) eliminate the catalytic converter. It is illegal and is against Federal Law in
the United States and other countries to not have a catalytic converter if the vehicle is
driven on public roads. The main purpose of a catalytic converter on an automobile is to
reduce harmful emissions of hydrocarbons, carbon monoxide and nitrogen oxides into the
atmosphere.
Cat-back
Cat-back refers to the portion of the exhaust system from the outlet of the catalytic
converter to the final vent to open air. This generally includes the pipe from the converter
to the muffler, the muffler, and the final length of pipe to open air.
Cat-back exhaust systems generally use larger diameter pipe than the stock system. The
mufflers included in these kits are often glass packs, to reduce back pressure. If the
system is engineered more for show than functionality, it may be tuned to enhance the
lower sounds that are lacking from high-RPM low-displacement engines.
Tailpipe and exhaust
With trucks, sometimes the silencer is crossways under the front of the cab and its tailpipe
blows sideways to the offside (right side if driving on the left, left side if driving on the
right). The side of a passenger car on which the exhaust exits beneath the rear bumper
usually indicates the market for which the vehicle was designed, i.e. Japanese (and some
older British) vehicles have exhausts on the right so they are furthest from the curb in
countries which drive on the left, while European vehicles have exhausts on the left.
The end of the final length of exhaust pipe where it vents to open air, generally the only
visible part of the exhaust system part on a vehicle, often ends with just a straight or
angled cut, but may include a fancy tip. The tip is sometimes chromed. It is often of larger
pipe than the rest of the exhaust system. This produces a final reduction in pressure, and
sometimes used to enhance the appearance of the car.
In the late 1950s in the United States manufacturers had a fashion in car styling to form
the rear bumper with a hole at each end through which the exhaust would pass. Two
outlets symbolized V-8 power, and only the most expensive cars (Cadillac, Lincoln,
DESIGN AND FABRICATION OF HYBRID SILENCER 2014-2015
DEPARTMENT OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING,NHCE Page 14
Imperial, and Packard) were fitted with this design. One justification for this was that
luxury cars in those days had such a long rear overhang that the exhaust pipe scraped the
ground when the car traversed ramps. The fashion disappeared after customers noted that
the rear end of the car, being a low-pressure area, collected soot from the exhaust and its
acidic content ate into the chrome-plated rear bumper.
When a bus, truck or tractor or excavator has a vertical exhaust pipe (called stacks or
pipes behind the cab), sometimes the end is curved, or has a hinged cover flap which the
gas flow blows out of the way, to try to prevent foreign objects (including droppings from
a bird perching on the exhaust pipe when the vehicle is not being used) getting inside the
exhaust pipe.
In some trucks, when the silencer is front-to-back under the chassis, the end of the
tailpipe turns 90° and blows downwards. That protects anyone near a stationary truck
from getting a direct blast of the exhaust gas, but often raises dust when the truck is
driving on a dry dusty unmade surface such as on a building site.
Lake pipes
Lake pipes are a type of aftermarket performance exhaust added by performance
enthusiasts. The exhaust is routed from the exhaust manifold along or beside the bottom
of the car body beneath the doors. They were usually chrome plated. Usually they also
offered a performance boost as they had less back pressure than conventional exhaust,
along with less environmental control (no catalytic converter).
2.5 Exhaust System Tuning
Aftermarkets exhaust system including headers and a white plasma-sprayed ceramic
coating.
Many automotive companies offer aftermarket exhaust system upgrades as a subcategory
of engine tuning. This is often fairly expensive as it usually includes replacing the
entire exhaust manifold or other large components. These upgrades however can
significantly improve engine performance and do this through means of two main
principles:
By reducing the exhaust back pressure, engine power is increased in four-stroke
engines
DESIGN AND FABRICATION OF HYBRID SILENCER 2014-2015
DEPARTMENT OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING,NHCE Page 15
By reducing the amount of heat from the exhaust being lost into the under bonnet
area. This reduces the under bonnet temperature and consequently lowers the
intake manifold temperature, increasing power. This also has positive side effect
of preventing heat-sensitive components from being damaged. Furthermore,
keeping the heat in the exhaust gases speeds these up, therefore reducing back
pressure as well.
Back pressure is most commonly reduced by replacing exhaust manifolds with headers,
which have smoother bends and normally wider pipe diameters.
Exhaust Heat Management is the term that describes reducing the amount of exhaust heat
radiated out from the exhaust pipe and components. One dominant solution to aftermarket
upgraders is the use of a ceramic coating applied via thermal spraying. This not only
reduces heat loss and lessens back pressure, but provides an effective way to protect the
exhaust system from wear and tear, thermal degradation and corrosion.[1]
2.6 Exhaust System Repair & Maintenance
Your vehicles exhaust system not only makes for a quieter and more enjoyable ride it also
directs fumes away from the interior and processes the fumes into safer gases and water
vapour. It is mounted to the bottom of your car and is subject to abuse from road hazards,
water and dicing salt. The signs that your exhaust system may need repair are:
Excessively loud engine sounds during acceleration. This is caused by holes and
breaks in the exhaust system.
Rattling when you start your vehicle. This is caused by failing mounts.
Drowsiness while driving – especially while in traffic. This can be a sign of
exhaust fumes leaking into the vehicle cabin.
Springdale Automotive technicians are trained and certified in the inspection and repair of
the following:
Mufflers
Tail Pipes
Exhaust Manifolds
DESIGN AND FABRICATION OF HYBRID SILENCER 2014-2015
DEPARTMENT OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING,NHCE Page 16
Catalytic Converters
Exhaust Gaskets
Clamps and Hangers
Exhaust System Inspection & Replacement
Servicing and repair of your exhaust system not only makes for a quieter and more
enjoyable ride it protects you, your passengers, and the environment from harmful gases.
We have certified technicians and the highest quality equipment in the automotive
industry to help insure the safety and reliability of your vehicle and pride ourselves on
exceptional customer service and providing the best quality auto repair for your vehicle.
DESIGN AND FABRICATION OF HYBRID SILENCER 2014-2015
DEPARTMENT OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING,NHCE Page 17
Chapter 3
Emission Testing And Standards
3.1 Emission testing
In 1966, the first emission test cycle was enacted in the State of California measuring
tailpipe emissions in PPM (parts per million).
Some cities are also using a technology developed by Dr Donald Stedman of
the University of Denver, which uses lasers to detect emissions while vehicles pass by on
public roads, thus eliminating the need for owners to go to a test centre. Stedman's laser
detection of exhaust gases is commonly used in metropolitan areas.
Use of emission test data
Emission test results from individual vehicles are in many cases compiled to evaluate the
emissions performance of various classes of vehicles, the efficacy of the testing program
and of various other emission-related regulations (such as changes to fuel formulations)
and to model the effects of auto emissions on public health and the environment. For
example, the Environmental Working Group used California ASM emissions data to
create an "Auto Asthma Index" that rates vehicle models according to emissions of
hydrocarbons and nitrogen oxides, chemical precursors to photochemical smog.
3.2 Bharat stage emission standards
Bharat stage emission standards are emission standards instituted by the Government of
India to regulate the output of air pollutants from internal combustion engine equipment,
including motor vehicles. The standards and the timeline for implementation are set by
the Central Pollution Control Board under the Ministry of Environment & Forests and
climate change.
The standards, based on European regulations were first introduced in 2000.
Progressively stringent norms have been rolled out since then. All new vehicles
manufactured after the implementation of the norms have to be compliant with the
regulations. Since October 2010, Bharat stage III norms have been enforced across the
DESIGN AND FABRICATION OF HYBRID SILENCER 2014-2015
DEPARTMENT OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING,NHCE Page 18
country. In 13 major cities, Bharat stage IV emission norms have been in place since
April 2010.
The phasing out of 2 stroke engine for two wheelers, the stoppage of production of Maruti
800 & introduction of electronic controls have been due to the regulations related to
vehicular emissions.
While the norms help in bringing down pollution levels, it invariably results in increased
vehicle cost due to the improved technology & higher fuel prices. However, this increase
in private cost is offset by savings in health costs for the public, as there is lesser amount
of disease causing particulate matter and pollution in the air. Exposure to air pollution can
lead to respiratory and cardiovascular diseases, which is estimated to be the cause for
620,000 early deaths in 2010, and the health cost of air pollution in India has been
assessed at 3 per cent of its GDP.
History
The first emission norms were introduced in India in 1991 for petrol and 1992 for diesel
vehicles. These were followed by making the Catalytic converter mandatory for petrol
vehicles and the introduction of unleaded petrol in the market.
On 29 April 1999 the Supreme Court of India ruled that all vehicles in India have to meet
Euro I or India 2000 norms by 1 June 1999 and Euro II will be mandatory in the NCR by
April 2000. Car makers were not prepared for this transition and in a subsequent
judgment the implementation date for Euro II was not enforced. In 2002, the Indian
government accepted the report submitted by the Mashelkar committee. The committee
proposed a road map for the roll out of Euro based emission norms for India. It also
recommended a phased implementation of future norms with the regulations being
implemented in major cities first and extended to the rest of the country after a few years.
Based on the recommendations of the committee, the National Auto Fuel policy was
announced officially in 2003. The roadmap for implementation of the Bharat Stage norms
were laid out till 2010. The policy also created guidelines for auto fuels, reduction of
pollution from older vehicles and R&D for air quality data creation and health
administration
DESIGN AND FABRICATION OF HYBRID SILENCER 2014-2015
DEPARTMENT OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING,NHCE Page 19
Graph 1: Comparison between European, US, and Bharat Stage (Indian) emission standards for gasoline
passenger cars
Graph 2: Comparison between European, US, and Bharat Stage (Indian) emission standards for diesel
passenger cars.
DESIGN AND FABRICATION OF HYBRID SILENCER 2014-2015
DEPARTMENT OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING,NHCE Page 20
3.3 Background Information
Table 1: Indian Emission Standards (4-Wheel Vehicles)
Standard Reference Year Region
India 2000 Euro 1 2000 Nationwide
Bharat Stage II Euro 2 2001 NCR*, Mumbai, Kolkata,
Chennai
2003.04 NCR*, 13 Cities†
2005.04 Nationwide
Bharat Stage III Euro 3 2005.04 NCR*, 13 Cities†
2010.04 Nationwide
Bharat Stage IV Euro 4 2010.04 NCR*, 13 Cities†
Bharat Stage V Euro 5 2017.04 (proposed) Entire country
* National Capital Region (Delhi)
† Mumbai, Kolkata, Chennai, Bengaluru, Hyderabad, Ahmedabad, Pune, Surat, Kanpur,
Lucknow, Sholapur, Jamshedpur and Agra
The above standards apply to all new 4-wheel vehicles sold and registered in the
respective regions. In addition, the National Auto Fuel Policy introduces certain emission
requirements for interstate buses with routes originating or terminating in Delhi or the
other 10 cities.
DESIGN AND FABRICATION OF HYBRID SILENCER 2014-2015
DEPARTMENT OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING,NHCE Page 21
Table 2: Indian Emission Standards (2 and 3 wheelers)
Standard Reference Date
Bharat Stage II Euro 2 1 April 2005
Bharat Stage III Euro 3 1 April 2010
Bharat Stage IV Euro 4 1 April 2012
Bharat Stage V Euro 5 1 April 2017 (proposed)
In order to comply with the BSIV norms, 2 and 3 wheeler manufacturers will have to fit
an evaporative emission control unit, which should lower the amount of fuel that is
evaporated when the motorcycle is parked.
Trucks and buses
Emission standards for new heavy-duty diesel engines—applicable to vehicles of GVW >
3,500 kg are listed in Table 3
Table 3: Emission Standards for Diesel Truck and Bus Engines, g/kWh
Year Reference CO HC NOx PM
1992 – 17.3–32.6 2.7–3.7 – –
1996 – 11.20 2.40 14.4 –
2000 Euro I 4.5 1.1 8.0 0.36
2005 Euro II 4.0 1.1 7.0 0.15
2010 Euro III 2.1 0.66 5.0 0.10
5.45 0.78 5.0 0.16
2010 Euro IV 1.5 0.46 3.5 0.02
4.0 0.55 3.5 0.03
DESIGN AND FABRICATION OF HYBRID SILENCER 2014-2015
DEPARTMENT OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING,NHCE Page 22
Light duty diesel vehicles
Table 4: Emission Standards for Light-Duty Diesel Vehicles, g/km
Year Reference CO HC HC+NOx NOx PM
1992 – 17.3–32.6 2.7–3.7 – – –
1996 – 5.0–9.0 – 2.0–4.0 – –
2000 Euro 1 2.72–6.90 – 0.97–1.70 0.14–0.25 –
2005 Euro 2 1.0–1.5 – 0.7–1.2 0.08–0.17 –
2010 Euro III 0.64
0.80
0.95
– 0.56
0.72
0.86
0.50
0.65
0.78
0.05
0.07
0.10
2010 Euro 4 0.50
0.63
0.74
– 0.30
0.39
0.46
0.25
0.33
0.39
0.025
0.04
0.06
Table 5: Emission Standards for Light-Duty Diesel Engines, g/kWh
Year Reference CO HC NOx PM
1992 – 14.0 3.5 18.0 –
1996 – 11.20 2.40 14.4 –
2000 Euro I 4.5 1.1 8.0 0.36
2005 Euro II 4.0 1.1 7.0 0.15
DESIGN AND FABRICATION OF HYBRID SILENCER 2014-2015
DEPARTMENT OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING,NHCE Page 23
Light duty gasoline vehicles
4-wheel vehicles
Table 6: Emission Standards for Gasoline Vehicles (GVW ≤ 3,500 kg), g/km
Year Reference CO HC HC+NOx NOx
1991 – 14.3–27.1 2.0–2.9 –
1996 – 8.68–12.4 – 3.00–4.36
1998 – 4.34–6.20 – 1.50–2.18
2000 Euro 1 2.72–6.90 – 0.97–1.70
2005 Euro 2 2.2–5.0 – 0.5–0.7
2010 Euro 3 2.3
4.17
5.22
0.20
0.25
0.29
– 0.15
0.18
0.21
2010 Euro 4 1.0
1.81
2.27
0.1
0.13
0.16
– 0.08
0.10
0.11
3- and 2-wheel vehicles
Emission standards for 3- and 2-wheel gasoline vehicles are listed in the following tables.
Table 7: Emission Standards for 3-Wheel Gasoline Vehicles, g/km
Year CO HC HC+NOx
1991 12–30 8–12 –
1996 6.75 – 5.40
2000 4.00 – 2.00
2005 (BS II) 2.25 – 2.00
2010.04 (BS III) 1.25 – 1.25
DESIGN AND FABRICATION OF HYBRID SILENCER 2014-2015
DEPARTMENT OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING,NHCE Page 24
Table 8: Emission Standards for 2-wheel gasoline vehicles
Year CO HC HC+NOx
1991 12–30 8–12 –
1996 5.50 – 3.60
2000 2.00 – 2.00
2005 (BS II) 1.5 – 1.5
2010.04 (BS III) 1.0 – 1.0
Table 9: Emission Standards for 2-3 wheel diesel vehicles.
Year CO HC+NOx PM
2005.04 1.00 0.85 0.10
2010.04 0.50 0.50 0.05
Table 10: Emission Standards for Diesel Engines ≤ 800 kW for Generator Sets
Engine Power (P) Date C
O
H
C
N
Ox
P
M
Smoke
g/kWh 1/m
P ≤ 19 kW 2004.01 5
.0
1
.3
9
.2
0
.6
0.7
2005.07 3
.5
1
.3
9
.2
0
.3
0.7
19 kW < P ≤ 50 Kw
2004.01
5
.0
1
.3
9
.2
0
.5
0.7
2004.07 3
.5
1
.3
9
.2
0
.3
0.7
50 kW < P ≤ 176 kW 2004.01 3
.5
1
.3
9
.2
0
.3
0.7
176 kW < P ≤ 800 kW 2004.11 3
.5
1
.3
9
.2
0
.3
0.7
DESIGN AND FABRICATION OF HYBRID SILENCER 2014-2015
DEPARTMENT OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING,NHCE Page 25
Table 11: Emission Limits for Diesel Engines > 800 kW for Generator Set
In addition to the above emission standards, the selection of a site for a new power plant
has to maintain the local ambient air quality as given in Table 11.
Table 12: Ambient air quality standard
Category Conc. g/m3
SPM SOx CO NOx
Industrial and mixed-use 500 120 5000 120
Residential and rural 200 80 2000 80
Sensitive 100 30 1000 30
Date
CO
NMHC
NOx
PM
mg/Nm
3
mg/Nm
3
ppm(v)
mg/Nm3
Until 2003.06 150 150 1100 75
2003.07 –
2005.06
150 100 970 75
2005.07 150 100 710 75
DESIGN AND FABRICATION OF HYBRID SILENCER 2014-2015
DEPARTMENT OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING,NHCE Page 26
3.4 Emission Standards
The NOx and PM Law introduces emission standards for specified categories of in-use
highway vehicles including commercial goods (cargo) vehicles such as trucks and vans,
buses, and special purpose motor vehicles, irrespective of the fuel type. The regulation
also applies to diesel powered passenger cars (but not to gasoline cars).
In-use vehicles in the specified categories must meet 1997/98 emission standards for the
respective new vehicle type (in the case of heavy duty engines NOx = 4.5 g/kWh, PM =
0.25 g/kWh). In other words, the 1997/98 new vehicle standards are retroactively applied
to older vehicles already on the road. Vehicle owners have two methods to comply:
1. Replace old vehicles with newer, cleaner models
2. Retrofit old vehicles with approved NOx and PM control devices
Vehicles have a grace period, between 8 and 12 years from the initial registration, to
comply. The grace period depends on the vehicle type, as follows:
Light commercial vehicles (GVW ≤ 2500 kg): 8 years
Heavy commercial vehicles (GVW > 2500 kg): 9 years
Micro buses (11-29 seats): 10 years
Large buses (≥ 30 seats): 12 years
Special vehicles (based on a cargo truck or bus): 10 years
Diesel passenger cars: 9 years
Furthermore, the regulation allows fulfilment of its requirements to be postponed by an
additional 0.5-2.5 years, depending on the age of the vehicle. This delay was introduced
in part to harmonize the NOx and PM Law with the Tokyo diesel retrofit program.
The NOx and PM Law are enforced in connection with Japanese vehicle inspection
program, where non-complying vehicles cannot undergo the inspection in the designated
areas. This, in turn, may trigger an injunction on the vehicle operation under the Road
Transport Vehicle Law [8]
DESIGN AND FABRICATION OF HYBRID SILENCER 2014-2015
DEPARTMENT OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING,NHCE Page 27
Chapter 4
Construction And Working
4.1 Construction of hybrid silencer
Basically a hybrid silencer consists of a perforated tube which is installed at the end of the
exhaust pipe. The perforated tube may have holes of different diameters. The very
purpose of providing different diameter hole is to break up gas mass to form smaller gas
bubbles the perforated tube of different diameter .Generally 4 sets of holes are drilled on
the perforated tube.
Around the circumference of the perforated tube a layer of activated charcoal is
provided and further a metallic mesh covers it and further a galvanized steel sheet is used
to cover the charcoal layer and a drain plug is provided at the bottom of the container for
periodically cleaning of the container. At the inlet of the exhaust pipe a non-return valve
is provided which prevents the back flow of gases.
Figure7: hybrid silencer CAD model.
DESIGN AND FABRICATION OF HYBRID SILENCER 2014-2015
DEPARTMENT OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING,NHCE Page 28
Dimensions of hybrid silencer
Figure8: CAD 2D view
DESIGN AND FABRICATION OF HYBRID SILENCER 2014-2015
DEPARTMENT OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING,NHCE Page 29
4.2 Working
As the exhaust gases enter in to the hybrid silencer, the perforated tube converts high
mass bubbles into low mass bubbles after that they pass through charcoal layer which
again purify the gases. It is highly porous and possesses extra free valences so it has high
absorption capacity.
After passing over the charcoal the gases escapes through the opening in to the
atmosphere. The noise and smoke level is considerable less than the conventional
silencer, no need of catalytic converter and easy to install. Hence HYBRID silencer
reduces noise and pollution.
4.3 Absorption process
Activated charcoal is available in granular or powdered form. As it is highly porous and
possess free valences. So it posses high absorption capacity. Activated carbon is more
widely used for the removal of taste and odorous from the public water supplies because
it has excellent properties of attracting gases, finely divided solid particles and phenol
type impurities, The activated carbon, usually in the powdered form is added to the water
either before or after the coagulation with sedimentation. But it is always added before
filtration. Feeding devices are similar to those used in feeding the coagulants.
Advantages of absorption process
It increases the coagulation power of the process. Its use reduces the chlorine demand.
The excessive dose of activated carbon is not harmful. The treatment process is very
simple and it requires nearly no skill. The efficiency of removing colour, odour and taste
is quite high. It can be easily regenerated It has excellent properties of attracting gases.
DESIGN AND FABRICATION OF HYBRID SILENCER 2014-2015
DEPARTMENT OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING,NHCE Page 30
Chapter 5
Design And Calculation
5.1 Designing and calculation of muffler
A muffler have been designed which is of supercritical grade type and includes all the
three attenuation principles i.e., reactive, followed by absorptive type muffler, and a side
branch resonator. The interesting events of the design are continuous volume reduction of
chambers in the reactive part, the flow pipe cross-sectional area is maintained constant
throughout, a layer of insulation outside the reactive part, the placing of side branch
resonator compactly, option for tuning the resonator using a screw and cylinder.[6]
5.1.1. Design data
For the experiment, an existing petrol engine has been used. Calculations are done on the
basis of data collected from the engine; however, some data are applicable to all engines.
For designing, the following data are required.
1) Sound characteristics (without silencer)
Rpm of the engine= 5500
2) Diameter of exhaust pipe of engine/inlet pipe of muffler
The Exhaust Pipe diameter: 1.5 inch
3) The theoretical exhaust noise frequency range
From various experiments is has been found that the theoretical exhaust noise frequency
is 200-500Hz.
5.1.2. Part design
Exhaust pipe diameter = 1.5 inch
The dimensions to determine are that of the chamber length L and the body diameter.
To determine L, three methods have been used. They are as follows:
(1) First method used to determine L
Maximum attenuation occurs when
DESIGN AND FABRICATION OF HYBRID SILENCER 2014-2015
DEPARTMENT OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING,NHCE Page 31
L = nλ/4…………. (1.1)
Where, λ = wavelength of sound (m or ft)
n = 1, 3, 5, ……. (Odd integers)
Since λ is related to frequency by the speed of sound, one can say that the peak
attenuation occurs at frequencies which correspond to a chamber length.
The range of frequency is obtained from the design data in section. The following table of
L has been constructed with this data.
5.1.3. Calculated wavelength from frequencies
From Table, we can find that L has a range between 6.72
Table.13: Calculated Wavelength
Frequenc
y
λ = C/f
(m)
Λ
(inch)
n = odd
integer
L (inch)
L = nλ/4
N(min)
200 Hz
1.70
(λmax)
66.9
(λmax)
1
3
16.7
50.1
N(max)
500 Hz
0.68
(λmin)
26.77
(λmin)
1
3
6.69
20.07
From Table, we can find that L has a range between 6.69 and 50.1 inch. Due to space
limitation, the length of the small chamber has been chosen to be 6.69 inch and 20.07 or
20 inch for the whole of the chambers.
(2) In order to select a suitable muffler type, some basic information are necessary
regarding muffler as per the ASHRAE Technical Committee 2.6 :
Muffler grades:
Industrial/Commercial:
IL = 15 to 25 dB Body/Pipe = 2 to 2.5 Length/Pipe = 5 to 6.5
Residential Grade:
IL = 20 to 30 dB Body/Pipe = 2 to 2.5 Length/Pipe = 6 to 10
DESIGN AND FABRICATION OF HYBRID SILENCER 2014-2015
DEPARTMENT OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING,NHCE Page 32
Critical Grade:
IL = 25 to 35 dB Body/Pipe = 3 Length/Pipe = 8 to 10
Super Critical Grade:
IL = 35 to 45 dB Body/Pipe = 3 Length/Pipe = 10 to 16
IL= Insertion Loss, i.e., the level of sound reduction after attaching the muffler.
Muffler grades and their dimensions, the requirement matches with the critical grade.
IL = 25 to 35 dB
Body/Pipe = 3, Length/Pipe = 8 to 10
That is, 8 × pipe dia ≤ L ≤ 10 × pipe diameter
8 × 1.5” ≤ L ≤ 10 × 1.5”
12” ≤ L ≤ 15”
Again the chosen length L = 12 to 15 inch, satisfies the above condition.
DESIGN AND FABRICATION OF HYBRID SILENCER 2014-2015
DEPARTMENT OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING,NHCE Page 33
Chapter 6
Material Used In Fabrication
6.1 Carbon steel
Carbon steel, also called plain-carbon steel, is a metal alloy, a combination of two
elements, Carbon steel, also called plain-carbon steel, is a metal alloy, a combination of
two elements, iron and carbon, where other elements are present in quantities too small to
affect the properties. The only other alloying elements allowed in plain-carbon steel
are: manganese (1.65% max), silicon (0.60% max), and copper (0.60% max). Steel with
low carbon content has the same properties as iron, soft but easily formed. As carbon
content rises the metal becomes harder and stronger but less ductile and more difficult
to weld. Higher carbon content lowers steel's melting point and its temperature resistance
in general, and carbon, where other elements are present in quantities too small to affect
the properties. The only other alloying elements allowed in plain-carbon steel
are: manganese (1.65% max), silicon (0.60% max), and copper (0.60% max). Steel with
low carbon content has the same properties as iron, soft but easily formed. As carbon
content rises the metal becomes harder and stronger but less ductile and more difficult
to weld. Higher carbon content lowers steel's melting point and its temperature resistance
in general.
Types of carbon steel
Typical compositions of carbon are:
Mild (low carbon) steel: approximately 0.05% to 0.25% carbon content with up to
0.4% manganese content .Less strong but cheap and easy to shape; surface
hardness can be increased through carburizing.
Medium carbon steel: approximately 0.29% to 0.54% carbon content with 0.60 to
1.65% manganese content (e.g. AISI 1040 steel). Balances ductility and strength
and has good wear resistance; used for large parts, forging and car parts.
High carbon steel: approximately 0.55% to 0.95% carbon content with 0.90% to
0.30 manganese content. Very strong, used for springs and high-strength wires.
DESIGN AND FABRICATION OF HYBRID SILENCER 2014-2015
DEPARTMENT OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING,NHCE Page 34
Very high carbon steel: approximately 0.96% to 2.1% carbon content specially
processed to produce specific atomic and molecular microstructures.
6.2 Stainless steel
Stainless steel is a steel alloy with a minimum of 10.5% chromium content by
mass.Stainless steel does not readily corrode, rust or stain with water as ordinary steel
does. However, it is not fully stain-proof in low-oxygen, high-salinity, or poor air-
circulation environments. There are different grades and surface finishes of stainless steel
to suit the environment the alloy must endure. Stainless steel is used where both the
properties of steel and corrosion resistance are required.
Stainless steel differs from carbon steel by the amount of chromium present. Unprotected
carbon steel rusts readily when exposed to air and moisture. This iron oxide film (the rust)
is active and accelerates corrosion by forming more iron oxide; and, because of the
greater volume of the iron oxide, this tends to flake and fall away. Stainless steels contain
sufficient chromium to form a passive film of chromium oxide, which prevents further
surface corrosion by blocking oxygen diffusion to the steel surface and blocks corrosion
from spreading into the metal's internal structure, and, due to the similar size of the steel
and oxide ions, they bond very strongly and remain attached to the surface.
Applications
Stainless steel’s resistance to corrosion and staining, low maintenance and
familiar lustre make it an ideal material for many applications. There are over 150 grades
of stainless steel, of which fifteen are most commonly used. The alloy is milled into coils,
sheets, plates, bars, wire, and tubing to be used in cookware, cutlery, household
hardware, surgical instruments, major appliances, industrial equipment (for example,
in sugar refineries) and as an automotive and aerospace structural alloy and construction
material in large buildings. Storage tanks and tankers used to transport orange juice and
other food are often made of stainless steel, because of its corrosion resistance. This also
influences its use in commercial kitchens and food processing plants, as it can be steam-
cleaned and sterilized and does not need paint or other surface finishes.
DESIGN AND FABRICATION OF HYBRID SILENCER 2014-2015
DEPARTMENT OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING,NHCE Page 35
Stainless steel is used for jewellery and watches with 316L being the type commonly used
for such applications. It can be re-finished by any jeweller and will not oxidize or turn
black. Some firearms incorporate stainless steel components as an alternative
to blued or packetized steel. Some handgun models, such as the Smith & Wesson Model
60 and the Colt M1911 pistol, can be made entirely from stainless steel. This gives a
high-lustre finish similar in appearance to nickel plating. Unlike plating, the finish is not
subject to flaking, peeling, wear-off from rubbing (as when repeatedly removed from a
holster), or rust when scratched.
Some automotive manufacturers use stainless steel as decorative highlights in their
vehicles.
The Allegheny Ludlum Corporation worked with Ford on various concept cars with
stainless steel bodies from the 1930s through the 1970s, as demonstrations of the
material's potential. The 1957 and 1958 Cadillac Eldorado Brougham had a stainless steel
roof. In 1981 and 1982, the DeLorean DMC-12 production automobile used stainless
steel body panels over a glass-reinforced plastic monocoque. Intercity buses made
by Motor Coach Industries are partially made of stainless steel. The aft body panel of
the Porsche Cayman model (2-door coupe hatchback) is made of stainless steel. It was
discovered during early body prototyping that conventional steel could not be formed
without cracking (due to the many curves and angles in that automobile).
Thus, Porsche was forced to use stainless steel on the Cayman.
Figure 9: Stainless steel
DESIGN AND FABRICATION OF HYBRID SILENCER 2014-2015
DEPARTMENT OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING,NHCE Page 36
6.2.1 Maintenance of stainless steel
Maintenance during installation
The quality of installation affects the durability and lifespan of stainless steel.Therefore it
is important to make sure stainless steel is in good condition before installation.
Normally, giving it a quick clean is enough prior to installation. However, if surface
contamination is present, more attention is required. In fields such as aerospace,
pharmaceuticals and food handling, an extremely high standard of cleanliness may be
required so extra care should be taken.
Routine maintenance
Maintenance is required to maintain the quality and appearance of steel. Depending on
the environment, it is carried out between one and ten times per year. A proper
maintenance routine significantly prolongs the life of stainless steel.
Tools used for maintenance
Soft cloth and water: suitable for cosmetic issues and general cleaning
Mild detergent: needed if stains cannot be easily lifted with water
Glass cleaner: useful for removing fingerprints and similar stains
6.3 Galvanized steel
Galvanized steel is widely used in applications where corrosion resistance is needed
without the cost of stainless steel, and can be identified by the crystallization patterning
on the surface.
Galvanized steel can be welded; however, one must exercise caution around the resulting
toxic zinc fumes. Galvanized steel is suitable for high-temperature applications of up to
392 °F (200 °C). The use of galvanized steel at temperatures above this will result in
peeling of the zinc at the inter metallic layer. Electro galvanized sheet steel is often used
in automotive manufacturing to enhance the corrosion performance of exterior body
panels; this is, however, a completely different process which tends to achieve lower
coating thicknesses of zinc.
DESIGN AND FABRICATION OF HYBRID SILENCER 2014-2015
DEPARTMENT OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING,NHCE Page 37
Like all other corrosion protection systems, galvanizing protects steel by acting as a
barrier between steel and the atmosphere. However zinc is a more electronegative metal
in comparison to steel, this is a unique characteristic for galvanizing which means that
when a galvanized coating is damaged and steel is exposed to the atmosphere, zinc can
continue to protect steel through galvanic corrosion.
Figure10: Galvanized steel
6.4 Charcoal
Charcoal is a light, black residue, consisting of carbon and any remaining ash, obtained
by removing water and other volatile constituents from animal and vegetation substances.
Charcoal is usually produced by slow pyrolysis, the heating of wood or other substances
in the absence of oxygen. It is usually an impure form of carbon as it contains ash;
however, sugar charcoal is among the purest forms of carbon readily available,
particularly if it is not made by heating but by a dehydration reaction with sulphuric
acid to minimise the introduction of new impurities, as impurities can be removed from
the sugar in advance. The resulting soft, brittle, lightweight, black, porous material
resembles coal.
DESIGN AND FABRICATION OF HYBRID SILENCER 2014-2015
DEPARTMENT OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING,NHCE Page 38
Figure11: charcoal
6.4.1 Types of Charcoal
Commercial charcoal is found in either lump, briquette, or extruded forms:
Lump charcoal is made directly from hardwood material and usually produces far
less ash than briquettes.
Pillow shaped briquettes are made by compressing charcoal, typically made from
sawdust and other wood by-products, with a binder and other additives. The
binder is usually starch. Some briquettes may also include brown coal .
Hexagonal sawdust briquette charcoal is made by compressing sawdust without
binders or additives. Hexagonal Sawdust Briquette Charcoal is the preferred
charcoal in countries like Taiwan, Korea, and Middle East, Greece. It has a round
hole through the centre, with a hexagonal intersection. Mainly for barbeque uses
as it does not emit odour, no smoke, and little ash, high heat, and long burning
hours (exceeding 4 hours).
Extruded charcoal is made by extruding either raw ground wood or carbonized
wood into logs without the use of a binder. The heat and pressure of the extruding
process hold the charcoal together. If the extrusion is made from raw wood
material, the extruded logs are then subsequently carbonized.
DESIGN AND FABRICATION OF HYBRID SILENCER 2014-2015
DEPARTMENT OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING,NHCE Page 39
Japanese charcoal removes pyro ligneous acid during the charcoal making.
Therefore when burning, there are almost no stimulating smells or smoke. The
charcoal of Japan is classified into three kinds.
Application of charcoal
Charcoal has been used since earliest times for a large range of purposes including art and
medicine, but by far its most important use has been as a metallurgical fuel. Charcoal is
the traditional fuel of a blacksmith's forge and other applications where an intense heat is
required. Charcoal was also used historically as a source of carbon black by grinding it
up. In this form charcoal was important to early chemists and was a constituent of
formulas for mixtures such as black powder. Due to its high surface area charcoal can be
used as a filter, and as a catalyst or as an adsorbent.
Industrial fuel
Historically, charcoal was used in great quantities for smelting iron in bloomeries and
later blast furnaces and finery forges. This use was replaced by coke in the 19th Century
as part of the Industrial Revolution. For this purpose, charcoal in England was measured
in dozens (or loads) consisting of 12 sacks or seams, each of 8bushels.In 2010, Japan
Consulting Institute took an action in search of a better, 'greener', and even cheaper
alternative to replace fossil fuels like coke in steelmaking. The research revealed that
Palm Kernel Shell charcoal (PKS charcoal) is proven to be a better fuel in Electric arc
furnace (EAF) as coke replacement. As auxiliary energy in EAF, in many aspects, PKS
charcoal outperforms coke.
Cooking fuel
Prior to the industrial revolution charcoal was occasionally used as a cooking fuel.
Modern "charcoal briquettes" are widely used for outdoor Dutch ovens, grilling,
and barbecues in backyards and on camping trips, but the briquettes is not pure
charcoal. They are usually a compacted mixture of sawdust with additives
like coal or coke and various binders.
DESIGN AND FABRICATION OF HYBRID SILENCER 2014-2015
DEPARTMENT OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING,NHCE Page 40
Syngas production, automotive fuel
Like many other sources of carbon, charcoal can be used for the production of
various syngas compositions; i.e., various CO + H2 + CO2 + N2 mixtures. The syngas is
typically used as fuel, including automotive propulsion, or as a chemical feedstock.
In times of scarce petroleum, automobiles and even buses have been converted to
burn wood gas (a gas mixture consisting primarily of diluting atmospheric nitrogen, but
also containing combustible gasses, mostly carbon monoxide) released by burning
charcoal or wood in a wood gas generator. In 1931 Tang Zhongming developed an
automobile powered by charcoal, and these cars were popular in China until the 1950s.
In occupied France during World War II, wood and wood charcoal production for such
vehicles (called gazogènes) increased from pre-war approximately fifty thousand tons a
year to almost half a million tons in 1943.
DESIGN AND FABRICATION OF HYBRID SILENCER 2014-2015
DEPARTMENT OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING,NHCE Page 41
Chapter 7
Operational And Physical Parameters
A. Perforated tube
Perforated tube diameter is 1.5 inch because engine exhaust manifold dia. is same and
13.7 inch long as per design data and made from the stainless steel because it has a high
melting point 15100C
Figure12: Perforated tube
B.Effect of change in porosity and change in diameter of perforation hole on
backpressure
Graph 3: Effect of Change in Porosity
DESIGN AND FABRICATION OF HYBRID SILENCER 2014-2015
DEPARTMENT OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING,NHCE Page 42
From Figure- it is observed that for the smallest hole diameter of 5 mm the back Pressure
is as high as 13,837 Pa. If we increase the diameter of the hole Back Pressure rapidly falls
down and it is lowest i.e. 788 Pa for the hole diameter 12.5 mm. The pressure e drop is
very large which is 75% of highest backpressure for first two hole diameters viz. 5 mm
and 7.5 mm. For other hole diameters the pressure drop is small but significant.
Graph 4: Back Pressure vs. Hole Diameter
When the porosity is doubled than the conventional, backpressure drops by 75% for first
two hole diameters. While for other hole diameters it is fairly the same value with a
difference of 20 Pa to 75 Pa. Thus it can be seen that the backpressure value is high for
small diameters as compare to bigger diameter holes even if the porosity is doubled. But
for higher diameters the Backpressure value remains the same even when the porosity is
doubled.
DESIGN AND FABRICATION OF HYBRID SILENCER 2014-2015
DEPARTMENT OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING,NHCE Page 43
C. Activated carbon
(1) Size – 0.35 to 0.80 mm
(2) Shape – Cylindrical palates
Figure13: Activated Carbon
D. Engine specification
Engine Displacement : 98.2 CC
Engine Type : Air cooled, 2 stroke
Number of Cylinders : 1
Max Power : 7.9 PS @5500 rpm
Max Torque : 9.8 Nm @5000 rpm
Bore x Stroke : 50.0 x 50.0 mm
Fuel Type : Petrol
Starter : Kick
DESIGN AND FABRICATION OF HYBRID SILENCER 2014-2015
DEPARTMENT OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING,NHCE Page 44
F. Hybrid silencer setup
A hybrid silencer consists of a perforated tube which is installed at the end of the exhaust
pipe. The perforated tube has holes of different diameters.
Around the circumference of the perforated tube a layer of activated charcoal is provided
and further a galvanizing steel sheet covers it. This whole setup is enclosed in a mild steel
casing which forms the outer body of silencer. A drain plug is provided at the bottom of
the container for periodically cleaning of the container.
Figure14:Experiment set up
DESIGN AND FABRICATION OF HYBRID SILENCER 2014-2015
DEPARTMENT OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING,NHCE Page 45
Chapter 8
Experimental Analysis And Result Of Hybrid Silencer
8.1 Experimental analysis and result of hybrid silencer
Basically a perforated tube which is installed at the end of the exhaust pipe. The
perforated tube consists of number of holes of different diameters 8mm, 4mm, and 2mm.
It is used to convert high mass bubbles to low mass bubbles. It is made from the stainless
steel.
The charcoal layer is pasted over the perforated tube. Bead Activated carbon is used as a
charcoal layer. It is a process by which the carbonised product develops porous structure
of molecular dimensions and extended surface area on heat treatment in the temperature
range of 800 –10000C in presence of suitable oxidising gases such asCO2. Bead activated
carbon is made from petroleum pitch and supplied in diameters from approximately 0.35
to 0.80 mm. It is also noted for its low pressure drop, high mechanical strength and low
dust content, but with a smaller grain size. Its spherical shape makes it preferred for
fluidized applications.
Around the circumference of the perforated tube a layer of activated charcoal is provided
and further a metallic mesh covers it. Over the charcoal a layer of galvanized steel is
provided. The whole unit is enclosed in mild steel casing which forms the outer body of
the hybrid silencer.
DESIGN AND FABRICATION OF HYBRID SILENCER 2014-2015
DEPARTMENT OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING,NHCE Page 46
For testing of Ordinary silencer we used two stroke petrol engines of Suzuki samurai
Figure15: Emission Test Result
DESIGN AND FABRICATION OF HYBRID SILENCER 2014-2015
DEPARTMENT OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING,NHCE Page 47
For testing of hybrid silencer we used two stroke petrol engines of Suzuki samurai.
Figure 16: Emission Test Result 2
DESIGN AND FABRICATION OF HYBRID SILENCER 2014-2015
DEPARTMENT OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING,NHCE Page 48
8.2 Result
From the PUC testing of above two stroke petrol engine I find the following result about
Carbon dioxide and hydrocarbon.
Table.14: CO & HC Level at idling volume) (ppm) (%)
Prescribed STD
CO
Measured level
CO
Prescribed STD
HC
Measured Level
HC
Ordinary Silencer 3.50 1.210 6000 1031
Hybrid Silencer 3.50 0.627 6000 1143
SOUND CHARACTERISTICS
Table 15: Sound Characteristics
SOUND LEVEL
ORDINARY SILENCER
SOUND LEVEL WITH
HYBRID SILENCER
Without any load 102.5 dB 82dB
DESIGN AND FABRICATION OF HYBRID SILENCER 2014-2015
DEPARTMENT OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING,NHCE Page 49
Chapter 9
Conclusion
The hybrid silencer is more effective in the reduction of emission gases from the engine
exhaust using perforated tube and using activated charcoal we can control the exhaust
emission to a greater level. It is smokeless and pollution free emission and also it is very
cheap. It can be also used both for two wheelers and four wheelers and also can be used
in industries.
Silencers work in different ways depending on the way they are constructed, allowing
sound waves to lose some power before they are released, or through materials used to
absorb some of the sound waves. Some silencers use both of these methods to control
noise. Performance silencers amplify and tune certain types of engine noise, yielding a
deeper, more aggressive sound.
The noise and smoke level is considerable less than the conventional silencer, it is
cheaper, no need of catalytic converter and easy to install.
DESIGN AND FABRICATION OF HYBRID SILENCER 2014-2015
DEPARTMENT OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING,NHCE Page 50
Chapter 10
Scope For Future Enhancement
10.1 Future enhancement
Following are some of the improvements and enhancement that can be made:-
After passing over the charcoal layer some of the gases can be made to dissolve
into the water and finally the Exhaust gases escape through the opening in to the
atmosphere. Hence resulting in greater reduction in noise and pollution.
Effect of dissolved gases on water
The water is a good absorbing medium. In aqua silencer the gases are made to be
dissolved in water. When these gases dissolved in water they form acids,
carbonates, bicarbonates etc.
Action of dissolved SO2
When SOx is mixed in water, it form SO2, SO3, SO4, H2SO4, H2SO, i.e. sulphur
Acid (H2SO3), it forms Hydrogen Sulphide which causes foul rotten egg smell,
acidify and corrosion of metals.
Action of dissolved CO2
The dissolved carbon dioxide forms bicarbonate at lower PH and Carbonates at
higher PH. This levels 40-400 mg/litre. The form a scale in pipes and boilers. The
carbon dioxide mixes with water to form Carbonic acid. It is corrosive to metals
and causes greenhouse effect.
Effect of dissolved NOX
The Nitrogen in water under goes Oxidation to form ammonia, Nitrate, Nitrite,
Nitric acid. This synthesis of protein and amino acids is affected by Nitrogen.
Nitrate usually occurs in trace quantities in surface water. [5]
DESIGN AND FABRICATION OF HYBRID SILENCER 2014-2015
DEPARTMENT OF MECHANICAL ENGINEERING,NHCE Page 51
Reference
[1]Apparatus for purifying exhaust gases of an internal combustion engine by Keith, C.
[2] Rosen (Ed.), Erwin M. (1975). The Peterson automotive troubleshooting.
[3] Environmental Pollution Analysis- Khopkar
[4] Internal Combustion of Engines- M. L. Mathur, R. P. Sharma
[5] Engg. Chemistry - Jain & Jain
[6] The Design and Tuning of Competition Engines, Philip H. Smith, pp. 137–138
[7] IJIRST - Design and Development of Aqua Silencer
[8] Bansal, Gaurav; (2013). "Overview of India’s Vehicle emission