cycloheximide-induced amnesia for taste aversion memory in rats

4
Pharraacology Biochemistry & Behavior, Vol. 4, pp. I $1-184. Copyright © 1976 by AN KHO International Inc. All rights of reproduction in any form reserved. Printed in the U.S.A. Cycloheximide-Induced Amnesia for Taste Aversion Memory in Rats ALAN TUCKER 1 AND MARIE GIBBS Department of Psychology, La Trobe University, Bundoora, 3083, Australia (Received 18 June 1975) TUCKER, A. AND M. GIBBS. Cycloheximide-inducedamnesiafor taste aversion memory in rats. PHARMAC. BIOCHEM. BEHAV. 4(2) 181-184, 1976. - Male hooded rats were conditioned in one trial to avoid saccharin by pairing saccharin drinking with an intragastric injection of LiCl. A 24 hr water-saccharin preference test showed that conditioned rats exhibited a very low preference for saccharin whereas rats injected intraventricularly with cycloheximide (CXM, 400 ~g) 5, 7, or 9 hr before training exhibited a greatly increased saccharin preference which differed significantly from NaCl injected controls. This 24 hr amnesia was found to be dependent upon the time of administration of CXM, since injection at 1, 3 or 17 hr before training did not confer amnesia. The nature of the task, a control measure and a control experiment indicate that the CXM-induced change in saccharin preference at 24 hr is not due to a CXM-induced aversion, nor a loss in drinking ability nor an inability to retrieve information whilst under the influence of CXM. Saccharin aversion Cycloheximide Amnesia CXM injection-training interval WHEN a rat drinks a distinctive tasting fluid such as saccha- rin, and is subsequently made ill (e.g. with LiCI) then it exhibits a strong, long-lasting memory for that particular taste [ 10]. This taste aversion is well suited to analysis of memory mechanisms since one trial is sufficient to establish the memory and moreover this information may be tested for in a discrimination situation. Physiological investigations have shown that electrocon- vulsive shock (ECS), when interpolated between tasting and illness, has only a weak amnesic effect [141 unless fairly high current parameters are used [12]. A considerable problem with using ECS as a physiological treatment is that it is by no means clear which of the electrical and metabolic brain processes affected are crucial to the ensuing amnesia [ 11 ]. Cortical spreading depression has also been reported to produce amnesia for taste aversion memory when it is given between the taste and the illness experiences [7,8]. So far there is no information on the effects of metabolic inhibitors on the retention of such gustatory memories. Accumulated evidence suggests that the produc- tion of protein during or close to the time of learning is necessary for the encoding of memories in a number of species [5]. It follows then, that the cellular processes affected by protein synthesis inhibitors should be necessary for the establishment of taste aversion memories. The present study was designed, therefore, to investigate the effects of a protein synthesis inhibitor, cycloheximide (CXM), [1, 2, 4, 9, 13, 17, 18] on saccharin aversion memory in the rat. METHOD Animals Seventy-seven experimentally naive male hooded rats aged approximately 80 days at the start of the experiment 1 Reprint requests should be addressed to Dr. A. Tucker. were used. All animals were bred in the Psychology Depart- ment, LaTrobe University, and were housed individually in the laboratory on a 12/12 light cycle for at least one week prior to the start of the experiment. All animals were main- tained on ad lib food and water until 24 hr before the first training session when water was removed. Apparatus Training and testing was carried out in a 29 x 44 x 44 cm clear plastic box which had two 50 ml graduated cylinders fitted with copper drinking spouts attached to one wall. The spouts were accessible to a rat inside the box through 2 cm dia. holes set 13 cm apart at a height of 5 cm above the wixe gauze floor of the box. The floor and the copper spouts were connected to an electronic circuit which counted tongue contacts with the spouts. The clear plastic box was housed in a larger sound attenuating box fitted with a one-way mirror. Experimental Design Prior to the experiment animals were assigned, on a random basis, to one of 14 groups. In the 6 experimental groups rats received intraventricular CXM at 1, 3, 5, 7, 9 or 17 hr before the start of the training trial. Animals in the placebo control groups received identical treatment to those in the experimental groups except that these animals received physiological saline intraventricularly, instead of CXM. Animals in the final 2 groups, control groups CC2 and CC3, received no intraventricular treatment. Group CC2 animals received the standard taste aversion training in which saccharin was followed by LiC1 poisoning. Group CC3 animals were unconditioned controls which were given saccharin followed by NaCI. 181

Upload: alan-tucker

Post on 28-Aug-2016

214 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Cycloheximide-induced amnesia for taste aversion memory in rats

Pharraacology Biochemistry & Behavior, Vol. 4, pp. I $1-184. Copyright © 1976 by AN KHO International Inc. All rights of reproduction in any form reserved. Printed in the U.S.A.

Cycloheximide-Induced Amnesia for Taste Aversion Memory in Rats

A L A N T U C K E R 1 AND M A R I E GIBBS

Department o f Psychology, La Trobe University, Bundoora, 3083, Australia

(Received 18 June 1975)

TUCKER, A. AND M. GIBBS. Cycloheximide-induced amnesia for taste aversion memory in rats. PHARMAC. BIOCHEM. BEHAV. 4(2) 181-184, 1976. - Male hooded rats were conditioned in one trial to avoid saccharin by pairing saccharin drinking with an intragastric injection of LiCl. A 24 hr water-saccharin preference test showed that conditioned rats exhibited a very low preference for saccharin whereas rats injected intraventricularly with cycloheximide (CXM, 400 ~g) 5, 7, or 9 hr before training exhibited a greatly increased saccharin preference which differed significantly from NaCl injected controls. This 24 hr amnesia was found to be dependent upon the time of administration of CXM, since injection at 1, 3 or 17 hr before training did not confer amnesia. The nature of the task, a control measure and a control experiment indicate that the CXM-induced change in saccharin preference at 24 hr is not due to a CXM-induced aversion, nor a loss in drinking ability nor an inability to retrieve information whilst under the influence of CXM.

Saccharin aversion Cycloheximide Amnesia CXM injection-training interval

WHEN a ra t dr inks a d is t inc t ive t as t ing f luid such as saccha- r in, and is subseq uen t l y made ill (e.g. w i th LiCI) t hen it exh ib i t s a s t rong, long-last ing m e m o r y for t h a t par t i cu la r taste [ 10] . This tas te avers ion is well su i ted to analysis of m e m o r y m e c h a n i s m s since one trial is suf f ic ient to es tabl ish the m e m o r y and moreove r this i n f o r m a t i o n may be tes ted for in a d i sc r imina t ion s i tua t ion .

Physiological inves t iga t ions have shown t h a t e l ec t rocon- vulsive shock (ECS), when i n t e r p o l a t e d be t w een tas t ing and illness, has on ly a weak amnes ic e f fec t [141 unless fairly high cu r r en t pa rame te r s are used [ 1 2 ] . A cons iderab le p r o b l e m wi th using ECS as a physio logica l t r e a t m e n t is t ha t it is by no means clear which of the electr ical and m e t a b o l i c bra in processes a f fec ted are crucial to the ensuing amnes ia [ 11 ]. Cor t ica l spread ing depress ion has also been r e p o r t e d to p roduce amnes ia for tas te avers ion m e m o r y when it is given b e t w e e n the taste and the illness exper iences [ 7 , 8 ] .

So far there is no i n f o r m a t i o n on the ef fec ts of me tabo l i c i nh ib i to r s on the r e t e n t i o n of such gus t a to ry memories . A c c u m u l a t e d ev idence suggests t ha t the p roduc- t ion of p ro te in dur ing or close to the t ime of learn ing is necessary for the encod ing of memor i e s in a n u m b e r o f species [ 5 ] . It fo l lows t h e n , t ha t the cel lular processes a f fec ted by p ro te in syn thes i s i nh ib i to r s should be necessary for the e s t a b l i s h m e n t of tas te avers ion memor ies . The present s t udy was designed, t he re fo re , to inves t igate the effects of a p ro te in syn thes i s i nh ib i t o r , cyc lohex imide (CXM), [1, 2, 4, 9, 13, 17, 18] on sacchar in avers ion m e m o r y in the rat .

METHOD

Animals

Seventy-seven expe r i m en t a l l y naive male h o o d e d rats aged a p p r o x i m a t e l y 80 days at the s ta r t of the e x p e r i m e n t

1 Reprint requests should be addressed to Dr. A. Tucker.

were used. All an imals were bred in the Psychology Depar t - m e n t , LaTrobe Univers i ty , and were housed individual ly in the l abo ra to ry on a 12 /12 light cycle for at least one week pr ior to the s tar t of the e x p e r i m e n t . All animals were main- t a ined on ad lib food and water unt i l 24 hr before the first t r a in ing session when wate r was removed .

Apparatus

Tra in ing and tes t ing was carr ied ou t in a 29 x 44 x 44 cm clear plast ic box which had two 50 ml g radua ted cyl inders f i t ted wi th copper d r ink ing spou t s a t t a ched to one wall. The spou t s were accessible to a rat inside the box t h r o u g h 2 cm dia. holes set 13 cm apar t at a he ight of 5 cm above the wixe gauze f loor of the box. The f loor and the coppe r spouts were c o n n e c t e d to an e l ec t ron ic circuit which c o u n t e d tongue con tac t s wi th the spouts . The clear plast ic box was housed in a larger sound a t t e n u a t i n g box f i t ted wi th a one-way mirror .

Experimental Design

Prior to the e x p e r i m e n t an imals were assigned, on a r a n d o m basis, to one o f 14 groups. In the 6 e x p e r i m e n t a l groups rats received in t r aven t r i cu la r CXM at 1, 3, 5, 7, 9 or 17 hr before the s tar t of the t ra in ing trial. An imals in the p lacebo con t ro l groups received ident ica l t r e a t m e n t to those in the e x p e r i m e n t a l groups e x c e p t t ha t these an imals received physiological saline in t raven t r i cu la r ly , ins tead o f CXM. Animals in the f inal 2 groups , con t ro l g roups CC2 and CC3, received no in t r aven t r i cu l a r t r e a t m e n t . G r o u p CC2 animals received the s tandard taste aversion t ra in ing in which sacchar in was fo l lowed by LiC1 poisoning. G r o u p CC3 animals were u n c o n d i t i o n e d con t ro l s which were given sacchar in fol lowed by NaCI.

181

Page 2: Cycloheximide-induced amnesia for taste aversion memory in rats

182 TUCKER AND GIBBS

Procedure

Days 1-3 of the experiment were the pretraining phase in which rats were placed into the experimental box for daily 10 min sessions and trained to drink tap water from both bottles attached to the box. During these trials and all subsequent phases of the experiment each rat's total number of licks at each spout was recorded. Animals which did not register at least 100 licks at each spout on at least one of the 3 pretraining days were eliminated from the experiment. Throughout the experiment the only fluids received were those consumed in the training and testing trials and those fluids injected. On Day 4 at the appropriate time prior to training the CXM and NaCI groups received their intraventricular injections.

The freehand technique of injection used was a modified version of the one described by Noble and co-workers [ 161. Rats were anesthetised with ether and placed on a small animal rack. A midline incision was made, the skin reflected and the cranial bone was cleaned. A small hole was bored by hand at a position 1.5-2.0 mm lateral to the saggital suture and immediately posterior to the coronal suture over the left hemisphere. A Hamilton dispenser and 500 ul syringe fitted with a 26 ga needle was carefully lowered into the hole. The needle was fitted with a stop so that it penetrated 4.0 mm below the cranial surface. Thirty micro- liters of solution was then injected into the ventricle. The hole was filled immediately with bone wax and the incision closed with skin clips. The entire operation usually took 5 rain and animals were fully recovered from the anesthetic within 15 min. Experimental animals received 400 ug of

100

80 ¸

o "r

~ 6o- uJ

~.~

~ o -

~ '20-

0.J

?

I C X M GROUPS [ ] NaCI GROUPS A CC2

O CC3

CXM dissolved in 30 ul of 0.9% NaCI while the placebo controls received 30 ul of 0.9% NaCI.

In the training trial all rats were given a 0.1% sodium saccharin solution in place of the water in both cylinders. At the conclusion of this l 0 min saccharin drinking session animals in all groups except CC3 were given an intragastric injection of 0.6% (0.15 M) LiCI (10 ml/kg body weight). Group CC3 animals received an intragastric injection of 0.9% NaCI (10 ml/kg body weight). Data from rats which licked less than 25% of their last pretraining trial lick total were not included in results.

On Day 5 all rats were given a retention test 24 hr after their training trial. In this session one cylinder contained tap water, the other 0.1% saccharin. The positions of the water and saccharin cylinders were decided by a random process. At the conclusion of the retention trial a saccharin preference score (%P) was computed for each rat, according to the following formula:

%p = number of saccharin licks × 100 total number of licks

Data from rats which failed to lick 50% or more of, their final pretraining trial lick total were not included in the results.

RESULTS

Figure I summarizes the main finding of this experi- ment, namely that CXM will cause amnesia for the memory

l / /

INTERVAL BETWEEN INTRACEREBRAL INJECTION AND TRAINING (hours)

FIG. 1. Median saccharin preference scores 24 hr after training as a function of time of intraventricular treatment with CXM (400 #g) or isotonic saline (30 #1). Saccharin preferences at the level of untreated controls (CC2) indicate memory whilst saccharin preferences at the level of unconditioned controls (CC3) indicates complete amnesia. Vertical bars are half

of the interquartile range.

Page 3: Cycloheximide-induced amnesia for taste aversion memory in rats

CXM AMNESIA AND TASTE A V E R S I O N MEMORY

TABLE 1

TOTAL NUMBER OF LICKS DURING 24 HR RETENTION TEST

183

Group Median (Q, - Qs) / 2" Group Median (Q, - Qs) / 2* Pt

E1 2013 643 CI 2246 293 0.246

E3 2410 307 C3 2020 524 0.420

E5 2651 247 C5 1774 871 0.202

E7 2852 647 C7 2492 435 0.638

E9 2614 362 C9 2642 349 0.876

E17 3007 548 C17 2328 768 0.150

CC2 1734 378 CC3 2869 583 0.032

*Q~ = lower quartile; Q~ = upper quartile tMann-Whitney Test, 2 tailed

of the taste o f saccharin 24 hr af ter the learning trial when CXM is given intraventr icular ly from 5 to 9 hr prior to training. One-tailed Mann-Whitney U tests indicated that the CXM groups differed significantly on their %P score f rom the physiological saline controls at 5 hr (CXM median = 86, NaC1 median = 2, p = 0.003), 7 hr (CXM median = 83, NaC1 median = 5, p = 0.024) and 9 hr (CXM median = 51, NaCI median = 1,/9 = 0.001). Uncond i t ioned controls CC3, though appearing to be quite di f ferent f rom the unt rea ted condi t ioned controls CC2 were in fact not significantly different (CC3 median = 83, CC2 median = 2,/9 -- 0.075, Mann-Whitney test, l- tai led). However this nonsignif icance may well be due to low group sizes, since one rat out of the 5 in group CC3 preferred water over saccharin to such an ex ten t that he gave a %P score of zero. In spite of this it is wor th not ing that the median %P scores for the 5 and 7 hr CXM-treated animals are very close to that o f the uncon- di t ioned controls (CC3). Also Fig. 1 reveals that the NaCI controls prefer saccharin at about the same level as rats which had received only the basic taste aversion condi- t ioning.

The effects of the drug upon total number of licks during the re tent ion test is shown in Table 1. Tlie total number of licks recorded for each rat during its re ten t ion test may be taken as an index of general drinking behav- iour. Statistical analysis o f this data shows that on ly the controls CC2 and CC3 differ significantly from each o the r (Mann-Whitney test; p = 0.032, 2 tailed). None of the CXM groups differs f rom its appropr ia te NaC1 control .

In order to test the possibili ty that CXM causes blockade of in format ion retrieval during the re tent ion test, addit ional data was col lected. Four rats were injected with 400 ug of CXM 7 hr before the 24 hr re tent ion test and compared with the 24 hr saccharin preference of ano ther group of 4 rats injected with CXM 7 hr before training. Table 2 shows that the resulting saccharin preferences form nonover- lapping distr ibut ions (p = 0.014, Mann-Whitney test). F rom this it is clear that rats can retrieve previously stored informat ion when cerebral protein synthesis is inhibited by

TABLE 2

24 HR SACCHARIN PREFERENCE OF INDIVIDUAL RATS UNDER THE INFLUENCE OF CXM

Treatment % P

CXM 7 hr before retention test 1 0 1 1

CXM 7 hr before training trial 53 88 55 9

CXM. This result also suggests that the performance change 24 hr af ter learning is not due to state dependent learning.

DISCUSSION

Informat ion on the biochemical t ime-course of inhibi- t ion o f cerebral protein-synthesis , after intracerebral CXM inject ion, has been repor ted for mice but not , as yet , for rats. Barondes and Cohen [2] repor ted that the peak inhibi- t ion of cerebral protein synthesis ( 9 4 - 9 5 % ) in mice occurred 5 - 8 hr after inject ion. This biochemical t ime- course concurs with the t ime-course o f amnesia found in the present exper iment .

Al though there are numerous reports of amnesia after subcutaneously injected CXM, there is only one report o f intracerebral CXM t rea tment of mammals [2] . In this work no amnesia was found for mice trained in a mult iple trial discr iminat ion task after CXM injection. However there is evidence that this result may have been due to an excessive amount of training for the single-dose level of inhibi tor employed [31.

Two recent ly published articles have repor ted that CXM can induce aversions to odors [6] and to water [151 when

Page 4: Cycloheximide-induced amnesia for taste aversion memory in rats

184 T U C K E R AND GIBBS

admin i s t e r ed in t r ape r i tonea l ly or s u b c u t a n e o u s l y (respec- tively). This raises the possibi l i ty t ha t CXM-induced defici ts of pe r fo rmance in appet i t ive tasks may no t be due to amnesia bu t r a the r a CXM-induced c o n d i t i o n e d aversion. The resul t of the present e x p e r i m e n t does no t s uppo r t this n o n - m e m o r y in t e rp re t a t i on . In the taste aversion paradigm

a CXM-induced aversion to sacchar in would lead to a r educed sacchar in preference , no t the reverse as is d e m o n - s t ra ted . Also, CXM did no t p roduce aversion to water when admin i s t e red before the r e t e n t i o n trial. Hence, in t raven- t r icular CXM would seem to be exer t ing a t rue amnes ic in f luence on sacchar in aversion m e m o r y .

REFERENCES

1. Agranoff, B. W. Effects of antibiotics on long-term memory formation in the goldfish. In: Animal Memory, edited by W. K. Honig and P. H. R. James. New York: Academic Press, 1971, pp. 243-258.

2. Barondes, S. H. and H. D. Cohen. Comparative effects of cyclo- heximide and puromycin on cerebral protein synthesis and consolidation of memory in mice. Brain Res. 4: 44-51 , 1967.

3. Barondes, S. H. and H. D. Cohen. Delayed and sustained effect of acetoxycycloheximide on memory in mice. Proc. natn. Acad. Sci. U. S. A. 58: 157-164, 1967.

4. Barondes, S. H. and H. D. Cohen. Arousal and the conversion of "short-term" to "long-term" memory. Proc. hath. Acad. ScL U. S. A. 61: 923-929, 1968.

5. Booth, D. A. Protein synthesis and memory. In: The Physio- logical Basis o f Memory, edited by J. A. Deutsch. New York: Academic Press, 1973, pp. 27-58.

6. Booth, D. A. and P. C. Simson. Aversion to a cue acquired by its association with effects of an antibiotic in the rat. J. comp. physiol. Psychol. 84: 319-323, 1973.

7. Buresov~i, O. and J. Bures. Cortical and subcortical components of conditioned saccharin aversion in rats. Acta neurobiol, exp. 33: 689-698, 1973.

8. Davis, J. L. and J. Bures. Disruption of saccharin-aversion learning in rats by cortical spreading depression in the CS-US interval. J. comp. physiol. Psychol. 80: 398-402, 1972.

9. Flood, J. F., E. L. Bennett, M. R. Rosenzweig and A. E. Orme. Influence of training strength on amnesia induced by pre- training injections of cycloheximide. Physiol. Behav. 9: 589-600, 1972.

10. Garcia, J. and F. R. Ervin. Gustatory-visceral and telereceptor- cutaneous conditioning - adaptation in internal and external milieus. Communs behav. Biol. 1: 389-415, 1968.

11. Gibbs, M. E. and R. F. Mark. Inhibition o f Memory Formation. New York: Plenum Press, 1973.

12. Kral, P. A. ECS between tasting and illness: effects of current parameters on a taste aversion. Physiol. Behav. 7: 779-782, 1971.

13. Mark, R. F. and M. E. Watts. Drug inhibition of memory formation in chickens. 1. Long-term memory. Proc. R. Soc. 178: 439-454, 1971.

14. Nachman, M. Limited effects of electroconvulsive shock on memory of taste stimulation. J. comp. physiol. Psychol. 73: 31-37, 1970.

15. Nakajima, S. Conditioned aversion of water produced by cyclo- heximide injection. Physiol. Psychol. 2: 484-486, 1974.

16. Noble, E. P., R. J. Wurtman and J. Axelrod. A simple and rapid method for injecting H3-norepinephrine into the lateral ventricle of the rat brain. Life Sc£ 6 : 2 8 1 - 2 9 1 , 1967.

17. Quartermain, D. and B. S. McEwan. Temporal characteristics of amnesia induced by protein synthesis inhibitor: determina- tion by shock level. Nature 228: 677-678, 1970.

18. Schmaltz, G. and B. Delerm. Effects of cycloheximide on acquisition and retention of an avoidance learning in the rat: recovery of memory. Physiol. Behav. 13:211-220 , 1974.