assignment dr devi sem 2

Upload: amelia-ahzan

Post on 07-Apr-2018

218 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 8/3/2019 Assignment Dr Devi Sem 2

    1/26

    1Curriculum Development

    Part A : PHILOSOPHICAL FOUNDATIONS

    Philosophical Foundations

  • 8/3/2019 Assignment Dr Devi Sem 2

    2/26

    2Curriculum Development

    PART A

    I. IntroductionA curriculum is developed based on certain beliefs and orientations, conceptions of

    learning and the demands of society. Philosophy is the starting point in any curriculum decision

    making and is the basis for all subsequent decisions regarding curriculum. Through the centuries,

    many philosophies of education have emerged, each with their own beliefs about education.

    There are two sides of philosophical viewpoints that have emerged within the curriculum field

    traditional and conservative versus contemporary and liberal. The traditional and conservative

    philosophical viewpoints are perennialism and essentialism whereas the contemporary and

    liberal philosophical viewpoints are progressivism and reconstructionism.

    II. PerennialismIt is rooted from the philosophy of Plato and Aristotle. The modern perennialists are

    Robert Hutchins and Mortimer Adler. The philosophical base of perennialism is that they

    believed some ideas have lasted over centuries and are relevant today as when they were first

    conceived. The aim of the education in perennialism is to improve man as man (Hutchins,

    1953), to answer all educational questions derive from the answer to one question, to develop the

    rational person and to uncover universal truths by training the intellect. The ideas are a list of

    Great Books covering topics in Literature, Art, Psychology, Philosophy, Mathematics, Science,

    Economics, Politics and so forth. Examples of such books are Das Kapital written by Karl

    Marxs, Shakespeares complete works, War and Peace written by Leo Tolstoy and many others.

    Great Books are the source ofknowledge in perennialism. The role of education of

    perennialism is when students are immersed in the study of these great ideas from Great Books,

    they espouse ideas and issue that have been occupied the minds of the thinking individuals in the

    last 2000 years which make them want to read again and again and will get benefit from it

    because the ideas are profound and meaningful even today as when they were written. Hence,

    students will appreciate it and will then develop their intellectual powers and moral qualities.

    The focus of the perennialism curriculum is to have the Great Book program which

    will discipline the mind and cultivate the intellect. They want the study of philosophy as a crucial

    part because the wanted students to discover those ideas of insightful and timeless in

  • 8/3/2019 Assignment Dr Devi Sem 2

    3/26

    3Curriculum Development

    understanding the human condition. It recommended a single elementary and secondary

    curriculum, spends some time in pre-schools, and was not keen on allowing students to take

    electives because those subjects denied students the opportunity to fully develop their rational

    powers. They wanted educators to spend more time teaching concepts and explaining how these

    concepts are meaningful to students and teaching should focus on the processes. At the

    secondary and university level, emphasis should be on teacher-guided seminars and dialogue

    where students should learn to learn and not to be evaluated. This will prepare students for

    specific careers and pursue knowledge for its own sake. The perennialists wanted students to

    emphasis more on scientific reasoning, learn to recognize controversy and disagreement and

    lastly the curriculum should teach religious, values and ethics.

    III. EssentialismThe belief was popularized by educational philosopher William Bagley and later by

    Arthur Bestor and Admiral Rickover. The philosophy advocates in instilling students with the

    essentials or basics of academic knowledge and character development. This philosophy was

    based on argument that schools should not try to radically reshape society. Their aim is schools

    should transmit moral values and intellectual knowledge that students need to become model

    citizens. Teachers should instill traditional virtues such as respect for authority, fidelity to duty,

    consideration for others and practicality. Emphasize on the knowledge of science and

    understanding the world through scientific experimentation. Essentialist educators emphasize on

    the role of education which is to convey important knowledge about the world, acquisition of

    knowledge in natural science rather than non-specific disciplines such as philosophy or

    comparative religion.

    In its curriculum focus, the basics curriculum are Mathematics, natural science, History,

    foreign language and Literature. Elementary students receive instruction in skills such as writing,

    reading and measurement. Only by mastering the required material for their grade level arestudents promoted to the next higher grade. The essentialist programs are academically rigorous,

    for both slow and fast learners but are adjusted according to student ability. It advocates a longer

    school day, a longer academic year and more challenging textbooks but the classroom should be

    oriented around the teacher, who serves as the intellectual and moral role model for students. It is

    teacher-centered and teachers decide what is most important for students to learn with little

  • 8/3/2019 Assignment Dr Devi Sem 2

    4/26

    4Curriculum Development

    emphasize on student interests because it will divert time and attention from learning the

    academic subjects.

    Students are taught to be culturally literate, that is, to possess a working knowledge

    about the people, events, ideas and institutions. So that, when students leave school, they will

    possess not only basic skills and extensive knowledge, but also disciplined and practical minds,

    capable of applying their knowledge in real world settings. Discipline is necessary for systemic

    learning in a school situation. Students learn to respect authority in both school and society.

    Teachers need to be mature and well educated, who know their subjects well and can transmit

    their knowledge to students.

    IV. ProgressivismThe most responsible person for progressivism was John Dewey. The progressivism

    believed that education must be based on the fact that humans are by nature social and learn best

    in real-life activities with other people. Their aim is to make education more relevant to the

    needs and interests of students.

    In progressivism, the role of educationis to transmit societys identity by preparing young

    people for adult life. Hence, the aim of progressivism education is to allow learners to realize

    their interests and potential. Students should learn to work with others because learning in

    isolation, separates the mind from action and certain abilities and skills can only be learned in a

    group.

    Students should be constantly experimenting and solving problems; reconstructing their

    experiences and creating new knowledge. Teachers should not only emphasize drill and practice,

    but should expose learners to activities that relate to the real life situations of students,

    emphasizing learning by doing.

    The curriculum focuses on the study of natural and social Sciences as to expand personal

    experience of learners and from that it will developed students experiences, interests and

    abilities. Teachers should plan lessons that arouse curiosity and push students towards higher

    order thinking and knowledge construction. Students are encouraged to interact with one another

  • 8/3/2019 Assignment Dr Devi Sem 2

    5/26

    5Curriculum Development

    and develop social virtues such as cooperation and tolerance for different points of view.

    Teachers should not be confined to focusing on one discrete discipline at a time but should

    introduce lessons that combine several different subjects. Students are to be exposed to a more

    democratic curriculum that recognizes accomplishments of all citizens regardless of race,

    cultural background or gender.

    V. ReconstructionismFamous reconstructionists were Theodore Brameld and George Counts. Recontructionists

    philosophy basedon reform and argues that students must be taught how to bring about

    change. It is a philosophy that believes in the rebuilding of social and cultural infrastructures.

    Their role of education is to allow students to study social problems and think of ways to

    improve society. Students must be taught how to bring about change. They suggested that school

    has to be the agent of social change and social reform. The knowledge of this philosophy is from

    revolutionary literature such as Pedagogy of the Oppressed (1968) and also George Counts

    (1932) speech titled Dare the School Build a New Social Order

    The aimis liberation upon the use of revolutionary literature in classrooms. The

    recontructionists want people to become active participants in changing their own status through

    social action to change bring about social justice.

    The curriculum is focus on social sciences (such as History, Political Science,

    Economics, Sociology, religion, Ethics, Poetry and Philosophy), rather than the sciences. The

    curriculum should engage students in critical analysis of the local, national and international

    community. Examples are issues are poverty, environment degradation, unemployment, crime,

    war, political oppression, hunger and etc. Students are not just analyze, interpret and evaluate

    social problems, but they had to be committed to the issues discussed and encouraged to takeaction to bring about constructive change. Students should learn to come to a consensus on issues

    and so group work was encouraged. The curriculum should be constantly changing to meet the

    changes in society. Teachers are considered the prime agents of social change, cultural renewal

    and internationalism.

  • 8/3/2019 Assignment Dr Devi Sem 2

    6/26

    6Curriculum Development

    Part B : MALAYSIAN EDUCATION CURRICULUM

    Malaysian Education Curriculum

  • 8/3/2019 Assignment Dr Devi Sem 2

    7/26

    7Curriculum Development

    PART B

    I. Synopsis

    A uniform system of education in both primary and secondary schools has been

    established whereby a national curriculum is used in all schools. Common central assessment

    and examinations at the end of the respective periods of schooling are also being practiced. The

    national language, Malay, is the official language of instruction.

    The school curriculum is expected to contribute to the holistic development of the

    individual (mental, emotional, physical, spiritual) by imparting general knowledge and skills,

    fostering healthy attitudes and instilling accepted moral values. The aim is to produce

    Malaysians citizens who are balanced, trained, and skillful and cherish the national aspiration for

    unity.

    The general instruction for on-going curriculum reform is to improve the quality of

    education in order to achieve the aims of the National Education Philosophy (NEP). The NEP

    has been geared towards achieving the nations vision to prepare children to become

    knowledgeable, trained and skilled individuals to meet the growing needs of the millennium. It is

    envisaged that this can be achieved by emphasizing science and technology, use of information

    technology, and inculcating good moral and work ethics suitable for the Information Age. The

    school curriculum is designed to achieve the intended learning outcomes for different ability

    levels.

    The national curriculum promotes unity through the use of a single medium of instruction

    (the national language) and the provision of the same core subjects for all pupils in all schools

    with the National Education System. However, the cultural diversity of ethnic groups in

    Malaysia is preserved through the existence of National Type Schools, which are allowed to use

    other major ethnic languages as the medium of instruction.

    The underlying theoretical principle of national curriculum formulation is that of general

    education, using an integrated approach in curriculum planning. The curriculum comprises

    content and skills, with emphasis on the development of basic skills, the acquisition of

    knowledge and thinking skills. Each subject must also incorporate the inculcation of moral

  • 8/3/2019 Assignment Dr Devi Sem 2

    8/26

    8Curriculum Development

    values and attitudes and the correct use of Malay and other languages, such as English, Chinese

    and Tamil.

    The integrated approach is the main focus in the design of the Integrated Curriculum for

    Primary School and Integrated Curriculum for Secondary School. The elements of knowledge,

    skills and values are incorporated so as to bring the integrated development of the intellectual,

    spiritual, emotional and physical aspects of the individual.

    II. Analysis of the Malaysian Education Curriculum

    A. Curriculum during the colonial periodEducational Philosophy Malaysian Education Curriculum

    Perennialism The Fenn-Wu Report(1952)

    - Stresses more on continuing learning theirmother tongue as to keep their cultural identity.

    Essentialism The Cheesman Plan (1946)

    - Free primary education in all languages.

    - Teaching of English is compulsory in all vernacular

    schools and the teaching of mother tongue language

    also made available.

    Progressivism The Barnes Report(1951)

    - Recommended that education should be freeand using modern teaching method.

    - Emphasize on active learning, development ofthinking and active participation in school

    activities.

    Reconstructivism -

    During the colonial period, the policy of the British government is divide

    and rule. The policy was implemented through an education system designed to

    create a divided population. Before the independence of Malaysia, there were

    three education policy made by the British.

  • 8/3/2019 Assignment Dr Devi Sem 2

    9/26

    9Curriculum Development

    The Cheesman Plan (1946) was based on the essentialism philosophy as

    this plan introduced free primary education is all languages. It also made the

    teaching of mother tongue was to be made available in the English schools and

    at the same time the teaching of English was to be made compulsory in all

    vernacular schools.

    Whereas the Barnes Report (1951) was more on Progressivism philosophy

    in its planning. The report recommended that education would be free and modern

    teaching methods would be used with emphasis on active learning, development

    of thinking and active participation in school activities.

    The Fenn-Wu Report (1952) made a change in accepting another language

    as media of instruction but still hold the Perennialism philosophy. The Chinese

    still want to maintain the cultural identity by having textbooks and curriculum

    from China, to study the ideas and issues of the Chinese finest thinkers and

    writers.

    B. Curriculum initiatives after independenceEducational Philosophy Malaysian Education Curriculum

    Perennialism Razak Report(1956) and the Education Ordinance

    (1957)- All schools, irrespective of language medium

    should use common curriculum content

    Essentialism Rahman Talib ReportandEducation Act1961

    - The establishment of teacher-training programsto facilitate expansion of the school system.

    The Cabinet Committee on Education (1979)

    - Stress on 3R basic education reading, writingand arithmetic.

    - Stress on a strong spiritual education and thedesired elements of discipline.

    Progressivism The Cabinet Committee on Education (1979)

    - Upper secondary education of two streams,

  • 8/3/2019 Assignment Dr Devi Sem 2

    10/26

    10Curriculum Development

    academic and vocational

    Reconstructivism -

    After independence, there was growing realization that unifying the

    various ethnic groups was a priority. The Razak Report (1956) and the Education

    Ordinance (1957) recommended the use of common curriculum contents for all

    schools irrespective of medium of instruction. This idea comes from the

    perennialists which suggested a single curriculum for the primary and secondary

    schools.

    The Rahman Talib Report and Education Act (1961) recommended the

    establishment of teacher-training arrangements to facilitate expansion of school

    system. Teachers need to be mature and well-educated, who know their subjects

    well and can transmit their knowledge to students, as proposed by the

    essentialists.

    Students must gain skills such as writing, reading and measurement and

    also a strong spiritual education and desired elements of discipline. These were

    proposed by the Cabinet Committee on Education (1979) and the essentialists.

    The Cabinet Committee and the progressivists agree on having education

    in both streams, academic and vocational. This will make schooling bothinteresting and useful. So that students solve problems in the classroom similar to

    those they will encounter outside school.

    C. Curriculum ReformEducational Philosophy Malaysian Education Curriculum

    Perennialism Education Bill (1995)

    - Pre-school is part of the national educationsystem.

    Essentialism -

    Progressivism The Integrated Primary School Curriculum (ICPS)

    - Emphasizes the mastery, reinforcement andapplication of the 3Rs and the acquisition of

  • 8/3/2019 Assignment Dr Devi Sem 2

    11/26

    11Curriculum Development

    complex skills and knowledge.

    - Emphasizes the development of positiveattitudes and values.

    Teaching Methods

    - To enhance student interest and motivation,teachers are encouraged to use different

    teaching-learning strategies.

    - Encourage students to be independent learners.Recontructivism The Integrated Secondary School Curriculum (ICSS)

    - The inclusion of science social subjects likeHistory, Moral/Islamic education, humanities,

    applied arts and etc.

    The reformation of the curriculum is due to the demand from the society

    that existing curriculum was overloaded and the relatively disturbing number of

    students who could not read and write at the desired level.

    Emphasize is more on pre-school education (Education Bill, 1995) and

    was recommended previously by the perennialism.

    The Integrated Primary School Curriculum (ICPS) and the IntegratedSecondary School Curriculum (ICSS) were more on the modern education

    philosophythe progressivism and the reconstructivism. The ICPS having more

    of the progressivism philosophy like the emphasizing of 3Rs and the acquisition

    of complex skills and knowledge, the development of positive attitudes and

    values. Whereas the ICSS is having more of the reconstructivism philosophy in

    having the inclusion of science social subjects like History, Moral/Islamic

    education, humanities, applied arts and etc.

    Teaching methods were reformed as to enhance student interest and

    motivation. The teachers are encouraged to use different teaching-learning

    strategies. This is in conjunction with the progressivists who also wanted teachers

    to plan their lessons as to arouse students curiosity and push students towards

  • 8/3/2019 Assignment Dr Devi Sem 2

    12/26

    12Curriculum Development

    higher order thinking and knowledge construction. This will then encourage

    students to be independent learners.

  • 8/3/2019 Assignment Dr Devi Sem 2

    13/26

    13Curriculum Development

    Part C: CURRICULUM EVALUATION-CIPP MODEL OF EVALUATION

    Curriculum Evaluation CIPP Model of Evaluation

  • 8/3/2019 Assignment Dr Devi Sem 2

    14/26

    14Curriculum Development

    I. SummaryThe Context, Input, Process, Product Model (CIPP Model) was introduced by

    Daniel L. Stufflebeam (1971). The CIPP Model is a comprehensive framework

    for guiding formative and summative evaluations of projects, programs,

    personnel, products, institutions, and systems. The model is configured for use in

    internal evaluations conducted by an organizations evaluators; self-evaluations

    conducted by project teams or individual service providers, and contracted or

    mandated external evaluations.

    The models core concepts are denoted by the acronym CIPP, which

    stands for evaluation of an entitys context, inputs, processes, and products.

    Context evaluations assess needs, problems, assets, and opportunities to help

    decision makers define goals and priorities and help the broader group of users

    judge goals, priorities, and outcomes.Input evaluations assess alternative

    approaches, competing action plans, staffing plans, and budgets for their

    feasibility and potential cost-effectiveness to meet targeted needs and achieve

    goals. Decision makers use input evaluations in choosing among competing plans,

    writing funding proposals, allocating resources, assigning staff, scheduling work,

    and ultimately in helping others judge an efforts plans and budget. Process

    evaluations assess the implementation of plans to help staff carry out activities

    and later help the broad group of users judge program performance and interpret

    outcomes. Product evaluations identify and assess outcomesintended and

    unintended, short term and long termboth to help a staff keep an enterprise

    focused on achieving important outcomes and ultimately to help the broader

    group of users gauge the efforts success in meeting targeted needs.

    The CIPP Model emphasizes that evaluations most important purpose isnot to prove, but to improve. Evaluation is thus conceived primarily as a

    functional activity in the long run to stimulating, aiding, and abetting efforts to

    strengthen and improve enterprises. However, the model also posits that some

    programs or other services will prove unworthy of attempts to improve them and

    should be terminated. By helping stop unneeded, corrupt, or hopelessly flawed

  • 8/3/2019 Assignment Dr Devi Sem 2

    15/26

    15Curriculum Development

    efforts, evaluations serve an improvement function through assisting

    organizations to free resources and time for worthy enterprises.

    Consistent with its improvement focus, the CIPP Model places priority on

    guiding the planning and implementation of development efforts. The models

    intent is thus to supply evaluation userssuch as policy boards, government

    officials, foundation presidents and staff members, project staffs, school

    administrators, curriculum developers, city planners, military leaders, curriculum

    specialists, teachers and counselorswith timely, valid information of use in

    identifying an appropriate area for development; formulating sound goals, activity

    plans, and budgets; successfully carrying out work plans; periodically deciding

    whether and, if so, how to repeat or expand an effort; and meeting a funders

    accountability requirements.

    The CIPP Model also provides for conducting retrospective, summative

    evaluations to serve a broad range of stakeholders. Potential consumers need

    summative reports to help assess the quality, cost, utility, and competitiveness of

    products and services they might acquire and use. Other stakeholders might want

    evidence on what their tax dollars or other types of support yielded. If evaluators

    effectively conduct, document, and report formative evaluations, they will have

    much of the information needed to produce a defensible summative evaluation

    report. Such information will also provide invaluable to those outsiders engaged

    to conduct a summative evaluation of a given entity.

    Figure 1 summarizes the CIPP Models basic elements in three concentric

    circles and portrays the central importance of defined values. The inner circle

    denotes the core values that should be identified and used to ground a given

    evaluation. The wheel surrounding the values is divided into four evaluative fociassociated with any program or other endeavor: goals, plans, actions, and

    outcomes. The outer wheel indicates the type of evaluation that serves each of the

    four evaluative foci, i.e., context, input, process, and product evaluation. The

    goal-setting task raises questions for a context evaluation, which in turn provides

    information for validating or improving goals. Planning improvement efforts

  • 8/3/2019 Assignment Dr Devi Sem 2

    16/26

    16Curriculum Development

    generates questions for an input evaluation, which correspondingly provides

    judgments of plans and direction for strengthening plans. Program actions bring

    up questions for a process evaluation, which in turn provides judgments of

    activities plus feedback for strengthening staff performance. Accomplishments,

    lack of accomplishments, and side effects command the attention of product

    evaluations, which ultimately issue judgments of outcomes and identify needs for

    achieving better results.

    Figure 1. Key components of the CIPP Evaluation Model and Associated

    Relationship with Programs

  • 8/3/2019 Assignment Dr Devi Sem 2

    17/26

    17Curriculum Development

    These relationships are made functional by grounding evaluations in core

    values, referenced in the schemes inner circle. Evaluations root term value refers

    to any of a range of ideals held by a society, group, or individual. The CIPP

    Model calls for the evaluator and client to identify and clarify the values that will

    guide particular evaluations. Examples values are success in helping all students

    meet a states mandated academic standards, helping all children develop basic

    academic skills, helping each child fulfill her or his potential for educational

    development, assisting and reinforcing development of students special gifts and

    talents, upholding human rights, meeting the needs of disabled and

    underprivileged children, developing students as good citizens, assuring equality

    of opportunity, effectively engaging parents in the healthy development of their

    children, attaining excellence in all aspects of schooling, conserving and using

    resources efficiently, assuring safety of educational products and procedures,

    employing research and innovation to strengthen teaching and learning, and

    maintaining accountability. Essentially, evaluators should take into account a set

    of pertinent societal, institutional, program, and professional/technical values

    when assessing programs or other entities.

    According to the CIPP Model, an evaluation is a systematic investigation

    of the value of a program or other evaluand. Consistent with this values-oriented

    definition, the CIPP Model operationally defines evaluation as a process of

    delineating, obtaining, reporting, and applying descriptive and judgmental

    information about some objects merit, worth, probity, and significance in order

    to guide decision making, support accountability, disseminate effective practices,

    and increase understanding of the involved phenomena. The CIPP Model

    stipulates that evaluations should be rigorously evaluated, a process referred to as

    metaevaluation (evaluation of an evaluation). Internal and external evaluatorscannot maintain credibility for their evaluations if they do not subject to

    metaevaluations against appropriate standards.

  • 8/3/2019 Assignment Dr Devi Sem 2

    18/26

    18Curriculum Development

    II. EvaluationThe Malaysian Education Curriculum was evaluated by using the checklist

    provided by the CIPP Model. It was a summative evaluation where all the four

    types of evaluation (context, input, process, product) being done. The purpose of

    doing the four types of evaluation was to discover that the curriculum excels in

    meeting the National Philosophy of Education.

    Only a section of the Malaysian Education Curriculum being evaluated

    which is the English in Teaching and Learning in Secondary Schools. The

    revamp of the curriculum was based on the National Philosophy of Education. In

    this reformation, the introduction of the Integrated Secondary School Curriculum

    was the major change. The word integratedrefers to integrated approach for the

    infusion of moral values, patriotism, science and technology, proper use of

    language, environmental education, study skills, creative and critical thinking.

    Infusions of these ideas are to occur across subject areas.

    Case Study : Evaluation on English in Teaching and Learning in Secondary

    Schools.

    Stufflebeams (1971) CIPP Model provided a useful framework within

    which to evaluate Malaysian Education Curriculum i.e. evaluation on English in

    teaching and learning (English Form One) . The model involves attention to: (a)

    the Context evaluation examines the needs, goals and objectives of the

    curriculum and helps curriculum planning. The Input evaluation helps with

    curriculum structuring decisions by examining resources, alternative approaches,

    staffing and budgets to meet goals. The Process evaluation examines how the

    curriculum is implemented, therefore guiding implementation decisions. Lastly,

    the Product evaluation identifies and examines outcomes of the curriculum. This

    evaluation framework is helpful in determining the overall effectiveness of the

    curriculum. According to Stufflebeam (2003, pg. 4) the CIPP Model emphasizes

    that evaluations most important purpose is not to prove, but to improvea

    program.

  • 8/3/2019 Assignment Dr Devi Sem 2

    19/26

    19Curriculum Development

    Evaluation of the context of the educational reformation did had a clear

    set of goals and expectations to be used by students. The curriculum frameworks

    were used to guide the selection and development of unit and courses of study for

    secondary students (form one). The teachers also taught students consistently with

    the goals and the curriculum frameworks. Hence, the planning of the reformation

    of the curriculum consistent with the goals, objectives, students expectation and

    what the teachers practices. However, evaluation did come across problems such

    as the curriculum is too broad. If a teacher were to teach strictly the objectives

    then the most relevant and interesting parts of the content are left out. If the

    teacher includes the relevance then there is not enough time to cover all of the

    objectives. The teachers need a modified curriculum for special education classes

    and there were too many topics - not enough time to teach.

    Evaluation of the input of the English Form One focuses on the resources

    which are more on the facilities and technologies. The facilities here were the

    need for additional classroom like Language Laboratory together with the

    apparatus and gadgets for the subject to be taught to the students. The other part

    of the resources is the technology. Technology has become an integral part of our

    daily activities such as the need for computers i.e. computer laboratory in schools.

    In evaluating the English in teaching and learning, these resources had seriously

    considered by the government in conjunction with the new curriculum. A lot of

    computer laboratories and facilities were constructed and build. More teaching

    colleges were build, and upgrading the status of teaching colleges to institution

    and university were actually improving the staffing skills especially teaching

    skills of English teachers. More budgets were given by the government in order to

    improve all resources mentioned above. However there were claims about the

    following areas which need more research (especially for English subject): how

    learning progresses, how different instructional strategies link to student learning,

    how teachers develop expertise in teaching, current and developing instructional

    strategies, and especially how to support learners from a variety of cultural,

    linguistic, and socioeconomic backgrounds. In addition, it is recommended that

  • 8/3/2019 Assignment Dr Devi Sem 2

    20/26

    20Curriculum Development

    more research is needed to study the instructional methods of highly effective

    teachers.

    Evaluation of the process of the English form one is the implementation

    of the new curriculum i.e. the integrated curriculum. Given consensus on goals

    and adequate resources to carry out the goals, evaluation was more on the process

    of teaching-learning. In the reformation of teaching method where students were

    encourages having interest and motivation so that they can become independent

    learners. Students were exposed to different styles of learning such as small group

    techniques and the use of ICT in teaching and learning. These new modes of

    learning did effective where students were less dependent on the teachers in

    getting information. Less chalk and talk. However, there were weaknesses like

    inculcating creative and critical thinking in planned life-like situations through

    use of collaborative efforts at solving problems. Outdated computer software in

    the computer laboratory with a lot of viruses was another defect in stimulating

    learning independently.

    Evaluation of the product of the English form one was more on students

    attainments i.e. students abilities. Do they meet the goals and objectives of the

    curriculum? Students were evaluated through formative and summative

    evaluation. For examples, exercises, monthly tests, mid-year examinations and

    end of year examinations or examinations centralized by Lembaga Peperiksaan

    Malaysia likePenilaian Menengah Rendah, and later Sijil Pelajaran Malaysia

    and Sijil Tinggi Persekolahan. The new trend now was to have more

    assessments done in school levels. Assessments were done by teachers such as

    Oral English Assessment It is difficult to draw specific conclusions from the

    current data because the tests for each grade level are different (even different

    schools had different grading), have been changed from one year to the next, and

    consistent grading methods have not been established. Consistent curricula,

    assessments, and scoring guidelines need to be achieved before one can accurately

    analyze the data with regards to student achievement. Therefore it is advisable to

    develop model assessments for English subjects, for different level of students.

  • 8/3/2019 Assignment Dr Devi Sem 2

    21/26

    21Curriculum Development

    Finally, recommendations for the curriculum and future restructuring:

    Increase the time spend for students inquiry in teaching and learning process.

    Increase availability of technology to students.

    Recognizes that any professional development should focus on and consider the

    varying levels of teacher experience (e.g. beginning, intermediate, and veteranteacher).

    Encourage teachers participation in professional development activities whichpromote effective teaching and learning.

    The budget needs to support any special program related to the acquisition of the

    language.

    Equipment/materials need to be purchased for each school so that Englishcan be taught.

  • 8/3/2019 Assignment Dr Devi Sem 2

    22/26

    22Curriculum Development

    REFERENCES

    Stufflebeam, D. L. (2003). The CIPP model for evaluation. Western Michigan University, 2-9

    Nelson, E. A. (2007). Impact of an Integrated Arts Curriculum on Student Achievement in Writing.

    Retrieved November 23,2009, from http//:www.nelsonlessonplans.com/

    Torres, S. S. et al. (2007-2008). 6-8 Science Program Evaluation Report. Retrieved 23, 2009, from

    http//:www.columbia.k12.mo.us/

    Battle, M. V. Evaluation of Training Programs in Technical Communication. Retrieved 23,2009,from http//:www.stc.org/

    Phillips, J. A. (2009). Curriculum Development. Open University Malaysia. 22-36, 181-186,230-239.

  • 8/3/2019 Assignment Dr Devi Sem 2

    23/26

    23Curriculum Development

    APPENDIXES

    A.

    National Philosophy of Education

  • 8/3/2019 Assignment Dr Devi Sem 2

    24/26

    24Curriculum Development

    National Philosophy of Education

    Education in Malaysia is an on-going effort towards further developing the potential of

    individuals in a holistic and integrated manner, so as to produce individuals who are

    intellectually, spiritually, emotionally and physically balanced and harmonic, based on a firm

    belief in and devotion to God. Such an effort is designed to produce Malaysian Citizens who are

    knowledgeable and competent, who possess high moral standards and who are responsible and

    capable of achieving high level of personal well-being as well as being able to contribute to the

    harmony and betterment of the family, the society and the nation at large.

  • 8/3/2019 Assignment Dr Devi Sem 2

    25/26

    25Curriculum Development

    B. Curriculum in Malaysia

  • 8/3/2019 Assignment Dr Devi Sem 2

    26/26

    26Curriculum Development

    C. Curriculum for English Form One