assessment-driven instruction. models of reading assessment

143
Assessment- Driven Instruction

Upload: rosanna-doyle

Post on 26-Dec-2015

238 views

Category:

Documents


2 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

Assessment-DrivenInstruction

Page 2: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment
Page 3: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment
Page 4: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment
Page 5: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment
Page 6: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment
Page 7: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment
Page 8: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

Models of Reading Assessment

Page 9: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

Models of Reading Assessment

Deficit Model

Page 10: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

Models of Reading Assessment

Deficit Model

Contextual Model

Page 11: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

Models of Reading Assessment

Deficit Model

Contextual Model

Stage Models

Page 12: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

Models of Reading Assessment

Deficit Model

Contextual Model

Stage Models

Cognitive Model

Page 13: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

The Cognitive Model of

Reading Assessment

Page 14: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

PhonologicalAwareness

Decoding Sight Word Knowledge

Fluency& Context

AutomaticWord

Recognition

LanguageComprehension

StrategicKnowledge

PrintConcepts

GeneralPurposes

for Reading

SpecificPurposes

for Reading

Knowledge of Strategiesfor Reading

ReadingComprehension

Vocabulary

Knowledgeof Structure

BackgroundKnowledge

Page 15: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

PhonologicalAwareness

Decoding Sight Word Knowledge

Fluency& Context

AutomaticWord

Recognition

LanguageComprehension

StrategicKnowledge

PrintConcepts

GeneralPurposes

for Reading

SpecificPurposes

for Reading

Knowledge of Strategiesfor Reading

ReadingComprehension

Vocabulary

Knowledgeof Structure

BackgroundKnowledge

Page 16: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

PhonologicalAwareness

Decoding Sight Word Knowledge

Fluency& Context

AutomaticWord

Recognition

LanguageComprehension

StrategicKnowledge

PrintConcepts

GeneralPurposes

for Reading

SpecificPurposes

for Reading

Knowledge of Strategiesfor Reading

ReadingComprehension

Vocabulary

Knowledgeof Structure

BackgroundKnowledge

Page 17: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

Is the child able to read texts at his or her grade placement level with automatic word recognition and adequate expression?

Page 18: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

PhonologicalAwareness

Decoding Sight Word Knowledge

Fluency& Context

AutomaticWord

Recognition

LanguageComprehension

StrategicKnowledge

PrintConcepts

GeneralPurposes

for Reading

SpecificPurposes

for Reading

Knowledge of Strategiesfor Reading

ReadingComprehension

Vocabulary

Knowledgeof Structure

BackgroundKnowledge

Page 19: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

PhonologicalAwareness

Decoding Sight Word Knowledge

Fluency& Context

AutomaticWord

Recognition

LanguageComprehension

StrategicKnowledge

PrintConcepts

GeneralPurposes

for Reading

SpecificPurposes

for Reading

Knowledge of Strategiesfor Reading

ReadingComprehension

Vocabulary

Knowledgeof Structure

BackgroundKnowledge

Page 20: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

Does the child make use of context to monitor his or her reading?

Page 21: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

Before we go any further, let’s do a brief sidebar on context. The role of context in reading has long been a controversial topic. Two competing models of the reading process have described this role very differently. We will refer to these models as the Top-Down and Bottom-Up models. Lets’ take a quick look at each.

Page 22: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

Two Models of Reading

Page 23: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

She combed her hair.

Page 24: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

She combed her hair.

Page 25: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

She combed her hair.

Page 26: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

Top-Down Model of Reading

Brain cannot rapidly process print.

Reader predicts the next word.

Reader merely samples the print.

Reader slows down if prediction is wrong.

Page 27: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

She combed her

Page 28: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

She combed her b

Page 29: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

She combed her bangs.

Page 30: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

She combed her bangs.

Page 31: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

Bottom-Up Model of Reading

Brain processes almost every letter.

Most of this processing is automatic.

Reader does not need to predict words.

Reader uses context for multiple meanings.

Page 32: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

Conclusion:

Research has clearly supported the Bottom-Up Model.

Page 33: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

Is the child fluent?

Page 34: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

PhonologicalAwareness

Decoding Sight Word Knowledge

Fluency& Context

AutomaticWord

Recognition

LanguageComprehension

StrategicKnowledge

PrintConcepts

GeneralPurposes

for Reading

SpecificPurposes

for Reading

Knowledge of Strategiesfor Reading

ReadingComprehension

Vocabulary

Knowledgeof Structure

BackgroundKnowledge

Page 35: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

PhonologicalAwareness

Decoding Sight Word Knowledge

Fluency& Context

AutomaticWord

Recognition

LanguageComprehension

StrategicKnowledge

PrintConcepts

GeneralPurposes

for Reading

SpecificPurposes

for Reading

Knowledge of Strategiesfor Reading

ReadingComprehension

Vocabulary

Knowledgeof Structure

BackgroundKnowledge

Page 36: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

Does the child have adequate sight word knowledge?

theofgo

Page 37: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

PhonologicalAwareness

Decoding Sight Word Knowledge

Fluency& Context

AutomaticWord

Recognition

LanguageComprehension

StrategicKnowledge

PrintConcepts

GeneralPurposes

for Reading

SpecificPurposes

for Reading

Knowledge of Strategiesfor Reading

ReadingComprehension

Vocabulary

Knowledgeof Structure

BackgroundKnowledge

Page 38: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

PhonologicalAwareness

Decoding Sight Word Knowledge

Fluency& Context

AutomaticWord

Recognition

LanguageComprehension

StrategicKnowledge

PrintConcepts

GeneralPurposes

for Reading

SpecificPurposes

for Reading

Knowledge of Strategiesfor Reading

ReadingComprehension

Vocabulary

Knowledgeof Structure

BackgroundKnowledge

Page 39: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

Does the child have adequate knowledge of decoding strategies?

m ake

bl

t

Page 40: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

PhonologicalAwareness

Decoding Sight Word Knowledge

Fluency& Context

AutomaticWord

Recognition

LanguageComprehension

StrategicKnowledge

PrintConcepts

GeneralPurposes

for Reading

SpecificPurposes

for Reading

Knowledge of Strategiesfor Reading

ReadingComprehension

Vocabulary

Knowledgeof Structure

BackgroundKnowledge

Page 41: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

PhonologicalAwareness

Decoding Sight Word Knowledge

Fluency& Context

AutomaticWord

Recognition

LanguageComprehension

StrategicKnowledge

PrintConcepts

GeneralPurposes

for Reading

SpecificPurposes

for Reading

Knowledge of Strategiesfor Reading

ReadingComprehension

Vocabulary

Knowledgeof Structure

BackgroundKnowledge

Page 42: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

Does the child have adequate phonological awareness?

Page 43: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

PhonologicalAwareness

Decoding Sight Word Knowledge

Fluency& Context

AutomaticWord

Recognition

LanguageComprehension

StrategicKnowledge

PrintConcepts

GeneralPurposes

for Reading

SpecificPurposes

for Reading

Knowledge of Strategiesfor Reading

ReadingComprehension

Vocabulary

Knowledgeof Structure

BackgroundKnowledge

Page 44: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

PhonologicalAwareness

Decoding Sight Word Knowledge

Fluency& Context

AutomaticWord

Recognition

LanguageComprehension

StrategicKnowledge

PrintConcepts

GeneralPurposes

for Reading

SpecificPurposes

for Reading

Knowledge of Strategiesfor Reading

ReadingComprehension

Vocabulary

Knowledgeof Structure

BackgroundKnowledge

Page 45: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

Is the child able to comprehend the language of the text?

Page 46: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

PhonologicalAwareness

Decoding Sight Word Knowledge

Fluency& Context

AutomaticWord

Recognition

LanguageComprehension

StrategicKnowledge

PrintConcepts

GeneralPurposes

for Reading

SpecificPurposes

for Reading

Knowledge of Strategiesfor Reading

ReadingComprehension

Vocabulary

Knowledgeof Structure

BackgroundKnowledge

Page 47: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

PhonologicalAwareness

Decoding Sight Word Knowledge

Fluency& Context

AutomaticWord

Recognition

LanguageComprehension

StrategicKnowledge

PrintConcepts

GeneralPurposes

for Reading

SpecificPurposes

for Reading

Knowledge of Strategiesfor Reading

ReadingComprehension

Vocabulary

Knowledgeof Structure

BackgroundKnowledge

Page 48: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

Does the child have an adequate vocabulary for his or her age and grade?

blue weary

equatorwise

arrivePacific

Page 49: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

PhonologicalAwareness

Decoding Sight Word Knowledge

Fluency& Context

AutomaticWord

Recognition

LanguageComprehension

StrategicKnowledge

PrintConcepts

GeneralPurposes

for Reading

SpecificPurposes

for Reading

Knowledge of Strategiesfor Reading

ReadingComprehension

Vocabulary

Knowledgeof Structure

BackgroundKnowledge

Page 50: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

PhonologicalAwareness

Decoding Sight Word Knowledge

Fluency& Context

AutomaticWord

Recognition

LanguageComprehension

StrategicKnowledge

PrintConcepts

GeneralPurposes

for Reading

SpecificPurposes

for Reading

Knowledge of Strategiesfor Reading

ReadingComprehension

Vocabulary

Knowledgeof Structure

BackgroundKnowledge

Page 51: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

Does the child have the background knowledge necessary to understand the particular passage that he or she is reading?

Page 52: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

PhonologicalAwareness

Decoding Sight Word Knowledge

Fluency& Context

AutomaticWord

Recognition

LanguageComprehension

StrategicKnowledge

PrintConcepts

GeneralPurposes

for Reading

SpecificPurposes

for Reading

Knowledge of Strategiesfor Reading

ReadingComprehension

Vocabulary

Knowledgeof Structure

BackgroundKnowledge

Page 53: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

PhonologicalAwareness

Decoding Sight Word Knowledge

Fluency& Context

AutomaticWord

Recognition

LanguageComprehension

StrategicKnowledge

PrintConcepts

GeneralPurposes

for Reading

SpecificPurposes

for Reading

Knowledge of Strategiesfor Reading

ReadingComprehension

Vocabulary

Knowledgeof Structure

BackgroundKnowledge

Page 54: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

Is the child able to use common text structures to aid in comprehension?

Page 55: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

PhonologicalAwareness

Decoding Sight Word Knowledge

Fluency& Context

AutomaticWord

Recognition

LanguageComprehension

StrategicKnowledge

PrintConcepts

GeneralPurposes

for Reading

SpecificPurposes

for Reading

Knowledge of Strategiesfor Reading

ReadingComprehension

Vocabulary

Knowledgeof Structure

BackgroundKnowledge

Page 56: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

PhonologicalAwareness

Decoding Sight Word Knowledge

Fluency& Context

AutomaticWord

Recognition

LanguageComprehension

StrategicKnowledge

PrintConcepts

GeneralPurposes

for Reading

SpecificPurposes

for Reading

Knowledge of Strategiesfor Reading

ReadingComprehension

Vocabulary

Knowledgeof Structure

BackgroundKnowledge

Page 57: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

PhonologicalAwareness

Decoding Sight Word Knowledge

Fluency& Context

AutomaticWord

Recognition

LanguageComprehension

StrategicKnowledge

PrintConcepts

GeneralPurposes

for Reading

SpecificPurposes

for Reading

Knowledge of Strategiesfor Reading

ReadingComprehension

Vocabulary

Knowledgeof Structure

BackgroundKnowledge

Page 58: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

Does the child have adequate knowledge of the purposes for reading and possess strategies available to achieve those purposes?

Page 59: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

PhonologicalAwareness

Decoding Sight Word Knowledge

Fluency& Context

AutomaticWord

Recognition

LanguageComprehension

StrategicKnowledge

PrintConcepts

GeneralPurposes

for Reading

SpecificPurposes

for Reading

Knowledge of Strategiesfor Reading

ReadingComprehension

Vocabulary

Knowledgeof Structure

BackgroundKnowledge

Page 60: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

PhonologicalAwareness

Decoding Sight Word Knowledge

Fluency& Context

AutomaticWord

Recognition

LanguageComprehension

StrategicKnowledge

PrintConcepts

GeneralPurposes

for Reading

SpecificPurposes

for Reading

Knowledge of Strategiesfor Reading

ReadingComprehension

Vocabulary

Knowledgeof Structure

BackgroundKnowledge

Page 61: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

Does the child have a set of strategies that can be used to achieve different purposes in reading?

Page 62: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

PhonologicalAwareness

Decoding Sight Word Knowledge

Fluency& Context

AutomaticWord

Recognition

LanguageComprehension

StrategicKnowledge

PrintConcepts

GeneralPurposes

for Reading

SpecificPurposes

for Reading

Knowledge of Strategiesfor Reading

ReadingComprehension

Vocabulary

Knowledgeof Structure

BackgroundKnowledge

Page 63: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

PhonologicalAwareness

Decoding Sight Word Knowledge

Fluency& Context

AutomaticWord

Recognition

LanguageComprehension

StrategicKnowledge

PrintConcepts

GeneralPurposes

for Reading

SpecificPurposes

for Reading

Knowledge of Strategiesfor Reading

ReadingComprehension

Vocabulary

Knowledgeof Structure

BackgroundKnowledge

Page 64: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

What does the child view as the goal of reading in general?

Page 65: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

PhonologicalAwareness

Decoding Sight Word Knowledge

Fluency& Context

AutomaticWord

Recognition

LanguageComprehension

StrategicKnowledge

PrintConcepts

GeneralPurposes

for Reading

SpecificPurposes

for Reading

Knowledge of Strategiesfor Reading

ReadingComprehension

Vocabulary

Knowledgeof Structure

BackgroundKnowledge

Page 66: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

PhonologicalAwareness

Decoding Sight Word Knowledge

Fluency& Context

AutomaticWord

Recognition

LanguageComprehension

StrategicKnowledge

PrintConcepts

GeneralPurposes

for Reading

SpecificPurposes

for Reading

Knowledge of Strategiesfor Reading

ReadingComprehension

Vocabulary

Knowledgeof Structure

BackgroundKnowledge

Page 67: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

What concepts of print does the child have?

Page 68: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

What is the Literacy Coach’s role in reading assessment?

Page 69: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

An LC’s Many Assessment Caps

Tester Interpreter Profiler Cheerleader Booster

Page 70: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

LC as Tester

The LC will be part of the Assessment Team.

The LC may administer diagnostic tests.

Page 71: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

LC as Interpreter The LC may be asked to interpret schoolwide

achievement scores when they arrive.

The LC will need to be able to reach sound conclusions about trends.

These conclusions will need to communicated with honesty and tact.

Page 72: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

ITBS Percentile Ranks for Grade 3

School Last Year This Year Difference_______________________________________________________

Morristown 45 41 -4

Harmony 57 62 +5

District 49 51 +2

State 48 50 +2

Page 73: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

1. Misinterpreting of percentiles2. Assuming that different groups of

children are equivalent3. Confusing achievement with

norms

Three Common Problems of Interpreting Group Achievement Test

Scores

Page 74: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

ITBS Percentile Ranks for Grade 3

School Last Year This Year Difference_______________________________________________________

Morristown 45 41 -4

Harmony 57 62 +5

District 49 51 +2

State 48 50 +2

Page 75: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

Percentiles and Football

G 50 G

Avoid differences in percentile ranks.Use NCEs or stanines instead.

Page 76: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

How NCEs are made

NCEs “flatten” the normal curve so that differences are statistically equivalent.

Page 77: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

Interpreting Stanines

Above Average Stanines 7-9

Borderline Stanine 6Average Stanine 5Borderline Stanine 4

Below Average Stanines 1-3

9

8

7

6

5

4

3

2

1

{

{

Page 78: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

1. Misinterpreting of percentiles2. Assuming that different groups of

children are equivalent3. Confusing achievement with

norms

Three Common Problems of Interpreting Group Achievement Test

Scores

Page 79: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

Test Scores and Auto Racing

Page 80: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

LC as Profiler

The LC should present teachers with classroom profiles of test results.

Such profiles might use a spreadsheet format. The point is to influence instruction! This means:

Discussing options.Monitoring outcomes.

Page 81: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

Sample Excel File

A B C D E F G H

1 Student Teacher Grade Terra Nova Sep DIBELS Sep DIBELS

Comp NS ORF LevelWC/Minute

2 Doe, Jane Ellis 3 4 Low 52

3 Hall, Monte Ellis 3 5 Low 60

4 Perez, Juan Ellis 3 1 High 8

5 Rogers, Fred Ellis 3 5 Low 61

6 Ruth, Babe Ellis 3 7 Low 135

7 Yopp, Hallie Ellis 3 3 Some 39

Page 82: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

LC as Cheerleader Look for the silver lining. Interpret test results intelligently. Focus on what your teachers are doing right! Offer constructive suggestions. Don’t avoid unpleasant truths.

Page 83: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

LC as Booster

Understand AYP requirements. Do your best to make sure classroom

instruction is data-driven. This is the very best way to improve scores.

Cautiously consider additional steps in light of1. Ethical issues2. Likelihood of effectiveness3. Possible threat to professional climate.

Page 84: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

How Can DIBELSDrive Instruction?

Page 85: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment
Page 86: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

?

Page 87: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

How do we use DIBELS to drive instruction at a

grade level?

Page 88: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

Test K 1 2 3

A S L A S L A S L A S L

ISF 7 23 70

LNF 3 10 87 5 15 80

PSF 20 26 54

NWF 18 20 62

ORF 18 20 62 22 22 56

Sample Beginning-of-Year DIBELS Distribution

Page 89: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

Test K 1 2 3

A S L A S L A S L A S L

ISF 7 23 70

LNF 3 10 87 5 15 80

PSF 20 26 54

NWF 18 20 62

ORF 18 20 62 22 22 56

Sample Beginning-of-Year DIBELS Distribution

Page 90: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

Test K 1 2 3

A S L A S L A S L A S L

ISF 7 23 70

LNF 3 10 87 5 15 80

PSF 20 26 54

NWF 18 20 62

ORF 18 20 62 22 22 56

Sample Beginning-of-Year DIBELS Distribution

Page 91: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

Test K 1 2 3

A S L A S L A S L A S L

ISF 7 23 70

LNF 3 10 87 5 15 80

PSF 20 26 54

NWF 18 20 62

ORF 18 20 62 22 22 56

Sample Beginning-of-Year DIBELS Distribution

Page 92: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

Test K 1 2 3

A S L A S L A S L A S L

ISF 7 23 70

LNF 3 10 87 5 15 80

PSF 20 26 54

NWF 18 20 62

ORF 18 20 62 22 22 56

Sample Beginning-of-Year DIBELS Distribution

Page 93: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

Test K 1 2 3

A S L A S L A S L A S L

ISF 7 23 70

LNF 3 10 87 5 15 80

PSF 20 26 54

NWF 18 20 62

ORF 18 20 62 22 22 56

Sample Beginning-of-Year DIBELS Distribution

Page 94: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

Test K 1 2 3

A S L A S L A S L A S L

ISF 7 23 70

LNF 3 10 87 5 15 80

PSF 20 26 54

NWF 18 20 62

ORF 18 20 62 22 22 56

Sample Beginning-of-Year DIBELS Distribution

Page 95: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

Test K 1 2 3

A S L A S L A S L A S L

ISF 7 23 70

LNF 3 10 87 5 15 80

PSF 20 26 54

NWF 18 20 62

ORF 18 20 62 22 22 56

Sample Beginning-of-Year DIBELS Distribution

Page 96: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

Test K 1 2 3

A S L A S L A S L A S L

ISF 7 23 70

LNF 3 10 87 5 15 80

PSF 20 26 54

NWF 18 20 62

ORF 18 20 62 22 22 56

Sample Beginning-of-Year DIBELS Distribution

Page 97: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

Test K 1 2 3

A S L A S L A S L A S L

ISF 7 23 70

LNF 3 10 87 5 15 80

PSF 20 26 54

NWF 18 20 62

ORF 18 20 62 22 22 56

Sample Beginning-of-Year DIBELS Distribution

Page 98: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

An Action Plan for DIBELS1. Make a table for fall, including results at the three levels of risk,

for each grade and test.2. Identify points where large numbers of children are at high and

moderate risk.3. Discuss the “big picture” with teachers in grade groups.4. Make clear to everyone that a central goal is to move all children

into the low risk category.5. Meet with individual teachers to plan for intervention and

progress monitoring.

Page 99: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

Beware of comparing groups from two different years!

Page 100: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

Hamilton Elementary

PreK-5, 622 students 96.9% African American 89.2% Free or Reduced-Price Lunch 27th Percentile Rank in Reading, Grade 3 30th Percentile Rank in Reading, Grade 4 24th Percentile Rank in Reading, Grade 5 16% Annual Teacher Turnover Serves 3 Housing Projects Serves 2 Homeless Shelters

Page 101: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

Table 1. End-of-Year Kindergarten DIBELS Results over Two Years_______________________________________________________Subtest Year 1 Year 2

___________________ __________________At Some Low At Some Low

_______________________________________________________

LNF 6 11 83 6 17 77

PSF 11 45 45 8 48 44

NWF 7 12 82 5 12 84_______________________________________________________

Page 102: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

Table 2. End-of-Year Grade 1 DIBELS Results over Two Years_______________________________________________________Subtest Year 1 Year 2

___________________ __________________At Some Low At Some Low

_______________________________________________________

PSF 1 12 87 0 15 85

NWF 1 35 63 0 29 71

ORF 9 30 61 4 28 68_______________________________________________________

Page 103: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

Table 3. End-of-Year Grade 2 DIBELS Results over Two Years_______________________________________________________Subtest Year 1 Year 2

___________________ __________________At Some Low At Some Low

_______________________________________________________

ORF 19 24 57 24 34 41_______________________________________________________

Page 104: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

Table 4. End-of-Year Grade 3 DIBELS Results over Two Years_______________________________________________________Subtest Year 1 Year 2

___________________ __________________At Some Low At Some Low

_______________________________________________________

ORF 11 31 58 34 42 24_______________________________________________________

Page 105: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

Table 5. Changes in Percentage of Children at High or Moderate Risk________________________________________________________Grade Subtest Year 1 Year 2

___________ __________B E B E

_______________________________________________________

K LNF 7 17 27 23 PSF 71 56 64 56 NWF 10 19 20 17

1 PSF 54 13 61 15 NWF 18 36 15 29 ORF 21 39 18 32

2 ORF 33 43 62 58

3 ORF 21 42 67 76_______________________________________________________

Page 106: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

It’s better to track cohorts.

Page 107: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

It’s better to track cohorts.

B M E B M E

Year 1 Year 2

3

2

1

K

Page 108: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

It’s better to track cohorts.

B M E B M E

Year 1 Year 2

3

2

1

K

Page 109: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

It’s better to track cohorts.

B M E B M E

Year 1 Year 2

3

2

1

K

Page 110: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

It’s better to track cohorts.

B M E B M E

Year 1 Year 2

3

2

1

K

Page 111: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

It’s better to track cohorts.

B M E B M E

Year 1 Year 2

3

2

1

K

Page 112: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

It’s better to track cohorts.

B M E B M E

Year 1 Year 2

3

2

1

K

Page 113: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

It’s better to track cohorts.

B M E B M E

Year 1 Year 2

3

2

1

K

Page 114: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

K 1 2 3

Page 115: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

B M E B M E B M E B M E

K 1 2 3

Page 116: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

Table 6. Long-Term NWF DIBELS Cohort Results for Grades K-1________________________________________________________

Middle of End of Year 1 Year 2

________________________________________________________

Mean Number of Letter Sounds 29.1 66.8

Goal 13 50

Percentage at High or Moderate Risk 10 29

________________________________________________________

Page 117: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

B M E B M E B M E B M E

K 1 2 3

Page 118: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

Table 7. Long-Term ORF DIBELS Cohort Results for Grades 2-3________________________________________________________

Middle of End of Year 1 Year 2

________________________________________________________

Mean WPM Correctly Read 61.7 90.0

Goal 44 110

Percentage at High or Moderate Risk 33 76

________________________________________________________

Page 119: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

How do we use DIBELS to drive instruction in a

classroom?

Page 120: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

Start with theClass Profile!

Page 121: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

Class Summary

1st Grade: Beginning Benchmark

Name LNF PSF NWF

SCORE STATUS PCTILESCORE STATUS PCTILESCORE STATUS PCTILE

INTENSIVE

Poe, Edgar Allan 19 HIGH 5 40 ESTAB 65 8 HIGH 13

STRATEGIC

Blass, Bill 31 SOME 27 44 ESTAB 83 22 SOME 40

Borden, Liz 32 SOME 28 42 ESTAB 72 22 SOME 40

Tell, Wm. 40 LOW 48 27 EMERG 28 6 HIGH 9

Trump, Don 31 SOME 27 28 ESTAB 29 12 SOME 20

BENCHMARK

Doe, Jane 37 LOW 39 29 EMERG 30 36 LOW 72

Page 122: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

DIBELS Box-and-Whisker Plot

95th Percentile Rank

80th Percentile Rank

50th Percentile Rank

20th Percentile Rank (May need support)

5th Percentile Rank (May need intensive support)

Page 123: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

70

60

50

40

30

20

10

Mon 1 Mon 2 Mon 3 Mon 4 Mon 5 Mon 6 Mon 7 Mon 8 Mon 9 Mon 10

Sample Plot for Phoneme Segmentation Fluency

Page 124: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

70

60

50

40

30

20

10

Mon 1 Mon 2 Mon 3 Mon 4 Mon 5 Mon 6 Mon 7 Mon 8 Mon 9 Mon 10

Benchmark range for end of K

Benchmark range for middle of K

Sample Plot for Phoneme Segmentation Fluency

Page 125: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

70

60

50

40

30

20

10

Mon 1 Mon 2 Mon 3 Mon 4 Mon 5 Mon 6 Mon 7 Mon 8 Mon 9 Mon 10

Benchmark range for end of K

Benchmark range for middle of K

Sample Plot for Phoneme Segmentation Fluency

Page 126: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

A Data-Driven Model

Key Assumptions1. An SBRR core is in place.

2. The core offers additional materials for children who are slightly behind.

3. SBRR Intensive Intervention Programs (outside the core) are available for each of the 5 component areas.

Page 127: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

DIBELS Benchmark Test

Low Risk Some Risk At Risk

Core Core + Core + Small-Group Intensive Core Intervention Intervention

Core Intervention Intervention Assessments Assessments

DIBELS Progress Monitoring

Low Risk?Continue

InterventionDiscontinueIntervention

NoYes

CoreAssessments

Page 128: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

DIBELS Benchmark Test

Low Risk Some Risk At Risk

Core Core + Core + Small-Group Intensive Core Intervention Intervention

Core Intervention Intervention Assessments Assessments

DIBELS Progress Monitoring

Low Risk?Continue

InterventionDiscontinueIntervention

NoYes

CoreAssessments

Page 129: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

DIBELS Benchmark Test

Low Risk Some Risk At Risk

Core Core + Core + Small-Group Intensive Core Intervention Intervention

Core Intervention Intervention Assessments Assessments

DIBELS Progress Monitoring

Low Risk?Continue

InterventionDiscontinueIntervention

NoYes

CoreAssessments

Page 130: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

DIBELS Benchmark Test

Low Risk Some Risk At Risk

Core Core + Core + Small-Group Intensive Core Intervention Intervention

Core Intervention Intervention Assessments Assessments

DIBELS Progress Monitoring

Low Risk?Continue

InterventionDiscontinueIntervention

NoYes

CoreAssessments

Page 131: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

DIBELS Benchmark Test

Low Risk Some Risk At Risk

Core Core + Core + Small-Group Intensive Core Intervention Intervention

Core Intervention Intervention Assessments Assessments

DIBELS Progress Monitoring

Low Risk?Continue

InterventionDiscontinueIntervention

NoYes

CoreAssessments

Page 132: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

DIBELS Benchmark Test

Low Risk Some Risk At Risk

Core Core + Core + Small-Group Intensive Core Intervention Intervention

Core Intervention Intervention Assessments Assessments

DIBELS Progress Monitoring

Low Risk?Continue

InterventionDiscontinueIntervention

NoYes

CoreAssessments

Page 133: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

DIBELS Benchmark Test

Low Risk Some Risk At Risk

Core Core + Core + Small-Group Intensive Core Intervention Intervention

Core Intervention Intervention Assessments Assessments

DIBELS Progress Monitoring

Low Risk?Continue

InterventionDiscontinueIntervention

NoYes

CoreAssessments

Page 134: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

DIBELS Benchmark Test

Low Risk Some Risk At Risk

Core Core + Core + Small-Group Intensive Core Intervention Intervention

Core Intervention Intervention Assessments Assessments

DIBELS Progress Monitoring

Low Risk?Continue

InterventionDiscontinueIntervention

NoYes

CoreAssessments

Page 135: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

DIBELS Benchmark Test

Low Risk Some Risk At Risk

Core Core + Core + Small-Group Intensive Core Intervention Intervention

Core Intervention Intervention Assessments Assessments

DIBELS Progress Monitoring

Low Risk?Continue

InterventionDiscontinueIntervention

NoYes

CoreAssessments

Page 136: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

DIBELS Benchmark Test

Low Risk Some Risk At Risk

Core Core + Core + Small-Group Intensive Core Intervention Intervention

Core Intervention Intervention Assessments Assessments

DIBELS Progress Monitoring

Low Risk?Continue

InterventionDiscontinueIntervention

NoYes

CoreAssessments

Page 137: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

DIBELS Benchmark Test

Low Risk Some Risk At Risk

Core Core + Core + Small-Group Intensive Core Intervention Intervention

Core Intervention Intervention Assessments Assessments

DIBELS Progress Monitoring

Low Risk?Continue

InterventionDiscontinueIntervention

NoYes

CoreAssessments

Page 138: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

DIBELS Benchmark Test

Low Risk Some Risk At Risk

Core Core + Core + Small-Group Intensive Core Intervention Intervention

Core Intervention Intervention Assessments Assessments

DIBELS Progress Monitoring

Low Risk?Continue

InterventionDiscontinueIntervention

NoYes

CoreAssessments

Page 139: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

DIBELS Benchmark Test

Low Risk Some Risk At Risk

Core Core + Core + Small-Group Intensive Core Intervention Intervention

Core Intervention Intervention Assessments Assessments

DIBELS Progress Monitoring

Low Risk?Continue

InterventionDiscontinueIntervention

NoYes

CoreAssessments

Page 140: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

DIBELS Benchmark Test

Low Risk Some Risk At Risk

Core Core + Core + Small-Group Intensive Core Intervention Intervention

Core Intervention Intervention Assessments Assessments

DIBELS Progress Monitoring

Low Risk?Continue

InterventionDiscontinueIntervention

NoYes

CoreAssessments

Page 141: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

DIBELS Benchmark Test

Low Risk Some Risk At Risk

Core Core + Core + Small-Group Intensive Core Intervention Intervention

Core Intervention Intervention Assessments Assessments

DIBELS Progress Monitoring

Low Risk?Continue

InterventionDiscontinueIntervention

NoYes

CoreAssessments

Page 142: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment

DIBELS Benchmark Test

Low Risk Some Risk At Risk

Core Core + Core + Small-Group Intensive Core Intervention Intervention

Core Intervention Intervention Assessments Assessments

DIBELS Progress Monitoring

Low Risk?Continue

InterventionDiscontinueIntervention

NoYes

CoreAssessments

Page 143: Assessment-Driven Instruction. Models of Reading Assessment