tyndp 2018 improvements of tyndp 2018...we hope this guide is of benefit to all stakeholders....
TRANSCRIPT
TYNDP 2018
Improvements of TYNDP 2018
Communication
Final version after public consultation and ACER opinion - October 2019
1 SCENARIOS 1 1.1 ENTSO-E & ENTSOG Joint Scenarios 2 1.2 Scenarios & Time Horizons 2 1.3 Introduction of EUCO Scenario 3
2 Pan European Market Modelling Database (PEMMDB) 4
3 Pan European Climate Database (PECD) 5
4 Market & Network Studies 6
5 CostBenefitAssessment(CBA) 8
6 System Needs 10
7 Frequency Stability Studies 11
8 ProjectSheets 12
9 ProjectPlatform 13
Contents
Main Report Regional Reports– North-South
Interconnections East– North-South
Interconnections West– Northern Seas
Offshore Grid– Nordic & Baltics
Communication– Stakeholder
Engagement– Improvements
to TYNDP 2018
Technical– Data and Expertise– Technologies for– Transmission– Viability of the
Energy Mix– CBA Technical
Adequacy– Mid-Term Adequacy
Forecast
ENTSO-E Reports 2018As an improvement to the TYNDP 2018 package, the Insight Reports have beencategorised in order to help readers navigate through the document and focuson what readers might find of interest. The category of reports are:
— Executive Report – Contains the key insights of the whole TYNDP package through its two-year cycle.
— Regional Reports – Based on the four projects of common interest (PCI) regions, the reports focus on the regional challenges of the energy transition.
— Communication – These reports communicate how we have interacted with our stakeholders and improved the TYNDP package from 2016 to 2018.
— Technical – These reports give a deeper insight into the technical subjects, including how we use our data, and the technical challenges of energy transition.
We hope this guide is of benefit to all stakeholders.
Section 1
Scenarios
1.1 Joint Scenarios1.2 Scenarios & Time Horizons1.3 Introduction of EUCO Scenario
1
TY
ND
P 20
18 –
Impr
ovem
ents
of T
YN
DP
2018
2
TY
ND
P 20
18 –
Impr
ovem
ents
of T
YN
DP
2018
1.1Joint ScenariosTheENTSOsforgasandelectricityhavecombinedtheireffortsandexpertisetodevelopcommonscenariosforthefirsttime.Theseassistwithdecisionmaking,identifyingtheneedsandtheadequacyoffuture infrastructure investment.
ThescenariosformthebaseofallthestudiesundertakenintheTYNDP2018andthusareoneofthemostimportantfactorstotakeintoconsiderationinitsdevelopment.ThecoordinationofENTSO-E
andENTSOGinthedevelopmentofscenariosisanimportantsteptowardscreatingamorecomprehensiveviewoftherequirementsofthefutureenergysystem.WebelievethattheENTSOshavebeensuccessfulinidentifyingviablepathwaysfortheenergytransitionintheElectricityandGassectorsandwewillcontinuetoimproveourprocessesandmethodologies.Therefore,theinterdependenceofthetwosectorscouldbetakeninto account in future analysis.
1.2Scenarios & Time HorizonsIntheTYNDP2016,thescenariopackageconsistedofone2020scenarioandfour2030scenarios,whichwereallbrandedas‘visions’.InthemorerecentscenariopackageusedintheTYNDP2018, theENTSOshavecreatedamorewide-rangingset ofscenarios,followingtherecommendationsfromstakeholders.Thesehavebeendevelopedusingajointapproachbetweentheseparateorganization’sscenariobuildingmethodologies.
Theresultsareone scenario each inthe2020–2025timeframe,followedbyfourscenariosinthe2030–2040timeframe.Thenamingofthescenarioshasalso
becomemoreindicativeofthestorylineswhichtheyrepresent.Thenamesare;— 2020 Best Estimate — 2025 Best Estimate— 2030 – 2040 Sustainable Transition— 2030 – 2040 Distributed Generation— 2030 EUCO —2040GlobalClimateAction
MoreinformationcanbefoundonthescenariosectionoftheTYNDP2018website(https://tyndp.entsoe.eu/).
Figure1.1ThescenariobuildingframeworkforTYNDP2018.RenewableEnergySystems(RES)shareofdemandfor electricity and gas
2020 2025 2030
DistributedGeneration
BestEstimate
BestEstimate
The EUCOScenario
Global ClimateAction
SustainableTransition
SustainableTransition
DistributedGeneration
2035 2040 2045 2050
5%1.8%13% 6%
4%16% 8%
15%
0%
0%
5%18%
1%9%19% 25%
1%13%27%
21%3%9%
36%
12%0%5%
29%8%3%20%
External from European Commission
ENTSO-E/ENTSOGScenario
System share of wind
System shareof solar power
Biomethane productionshare of demand
Power-to-gasshare of demand
Merit orderswitch in 2025
3
TY
ND
P 20
18 –
Impr
ovem
ents
of T
YN
DP
2018
1.3Introduction of EUCO ScenarioAspartofthescenariobuildingprocess,theENTSOshaveintroducedascenariofromtheEuropeanCommission.ThisscenarioiscalledEUCO2030.The EUCO scenario shows the impact of EU policies at the time of its formulaton [2014] towards meeting the 2030 decarbonization targets. It is considered a good comparator with the other ENTSO scenarios developed with the industry, and thus the scenario has been implemented in the full range of studies undertaken by ENTSO-E.
Section 2
Pan European Market Modelling Database (PEMMDB)The PEMMDB forms the basis of all the information which is used to model the scenarios. Each scenario is based on a database for each country which outlines aspects such as installed capacity, hydro conditions, and demand.
InTYNDP2018theimprovementsmadewerequantitativeinputsforelectricvehicles,heatpumps,DemandSideResponsepricebands,amongothers.SomeoftheinformationforscenariosiscollectedbasedontheexpectationsofTSOsandnationaltrends,thisiscalledbottomupcollection.Thebottomupcollectionwasundertakenfor2020BestEstimate,2025 Best Estimate and 2030 Sustainable Transition.
TheotherscenarioPEMMDBsweredevelopedbyENTSO-Ebasedoncommonmethodologiesandusingthecollectedinformationinthebottomupscenariosasareferencepoint,ofthesocalled‘topdownscenarios’.Forexample,electricvehiclesandheatpumpswereforecastedbasedontheeconomicgrowthrelatedtothatscenariostoryline,andafactorfromtheWorldEnergyOutlookisusedtoforecasttheincrease.
4
TY
ND
P 20
18 –
Impr
ovem
ents
of T
YN
DP
2018
5
TY
ND
P 20
18 –
Impr
ovem
ents
of T
YN
DP
2018
Section 3
Pan European Climate Database (PECD)
The PECD provides an hourly timeseries for Wind and Solar load factors, based on historical data, for each scenario
5
TY
ND
P 20
18 –
Impr
ovem
ents
of T
YN
DP
2018
TherehavebeenmanyimprovementstothePECDincomparisontotheTYNDP2016.Thisincludestheintroductionof34climateyearswhiletheTYNDP2016consideredonly14.Theclimateyearwereclusteredinto9mainclimategroups,thenfurtherclusteredinto3whichformedthebasisofmostoftheTYNDP2018studies.ThisapproachallowedfortheassessmentoftheimpactofclimateyearswithinthetimeandresourceconstraintsoftheTYNDP2018timelines.
OtherfurtherimprovementsmadetothePECDincludedtheforecastoffuturetechnologiesused,whichincludedpredictedimprovementsinwindtechnologiessuchasincreasedshaftheightandsizeofturbineblades.Theexplicitmodellingofinnovativetechnologieshasbeenintroduced,likebatteriesanddemand-side-Response(DSR),allowingScenariostobeshapedaccordingtothenewdevelopmenttrendsintheenergysectorworldwide.
6
TY
ND
P 20
18 –
Impr
ovem
ents
of T
YN
DP
2018
Section 4
Market & Network Studies
The market modelling methodology has been improved in several ways compared to the TYNDP 2016 process.
6
TY
ND
P 20
18 –
Impr
ovem
ents
of T
YN
DP
2018
7
TY
ND
P 20
18 –
Impr
ovem
ents
of T
YN
DP
2018
NewmarketareashavebeenintroducedinTYNDP2018,likeGR03–Crete(Greece),TN00–Tunisia,FR15–Corsica(France)andIS00–Israel.ThisallowedENTSO-Etomodeltheinterconnection
projectsrelatedtothesepartsoftheeuropewithhigherprecision.ThedetailedoverviewisdepictedontheFigure 4.1 below.
Figure4.1MarketnodeconfigurationevolutionforTYNDP2018
IS00
NOm
NOs
NOn
SE1
SE2
SE3
SE4
FI
GB
NI
IE
FR
ESPT
DKw DKe
NL
BE
LU
DE
CH
AT
ITn
SI HR
BA
CZSK
HU
RS
ME
MK
GR
AL
BG
RO
PL
LT
LV
EE
TR
MT
ITsic
ITs
ITcs
ITcn
ITsar
FR15
CY
TN00IL00
GR03
Inherited from TYNDP 2016New in TYNDP 2018
MaintenanceprofilesforeachpieceofinfrastructurehavebeenintroducedfortheENTSO-Eareausedbyallmarketmodellingexperts,whichresultsinahighlevel of alignment between market modeling software tool results.
Acomprehensivecomparisonprocesshasbeenimplemented to ensure adequate accuracy and robustnessoftheresults,whereeachsimulationresulthasbeenvalidatedbetweenvariousmarketmodelingsoftware tools.
AnewcrossborderNetTransferCapability(NTC)calculationmethodologyhasbeenintroducedandused.Thisallowedlimitationstobeappliedtothecross-bordertransfercapacityforeachborderbeforetheNTCvariationhasbeencalculatedforeachprojectforTYNDP2018.Thisisimportanttoavoidnetworkconstraintsbeingneglectedwhilemodellingeachseparatetransmissionproject.
Thetestshaveshown,thatbasecasegridcontainsmanyoverloadswhichthe“NTCcalculationmethod”discardedsinceitaimedatmakingthegridcongestionfree during only 30% of time (stemming from caveat inCBAmethodologywheredeltaNTCparameterislinkedtosuch30%rule).
Following,intheTYNDP18welargelystucktotheNTCassumptionsusedinpreviousMAF/TYNDPproductsforthesakeofconsistency.
ForthelossesvariationCBAindicatorinTYNDP2018,monetizationhasbeenimplementedonanhourlybasisusingmarketresultswithandwithouttheprojectbeingassessed,whileTYNDP2016consideredonlyaveragevalues.Thishasimprovedthequalityoftheresultsandallowedhigherprecisionindefinitionoflossesvalueforeachseparatemarketarea.
8
TY
ND
P 20
18 –
Impr
ovem
ents
of T
YN
DP
2018
Section 5
Cost Benefit Assessment (CBA)
The overall Cost Benefit Assessment (CBA) process has been conducted in a centralized manner in TYNDP 2018. Two central teams dedicated to market studies (MST) and network studies (NST) have been organized to implement the necessary calculations in a harmonized way.
8
TY
ND
P 20
18 –
Impr
ovem
ents
of T
YN
DP
2018
9
TY
ND
P 20
18 –
Impr
ovem
ents
of T
YN
DP
2018
DuringtheCBAprocessatleastthreemarketmodelingsoftwaretoolshavebeenappointedtoassesseachoftheprojectssubmittedtotheTYNDP2018.ToavoiddistortionsintheaccuracyoftheresultstheoutlyingresultshavebeenexcludedfromthecomputationofthefinalCBAindicators.
Due to unique use of absolute and median average thresholdsfortheidentificationoftheoutlyingCBAmarketresults,thefinalresultswerefilteredconsideringthesensitivityofthealgorithmsofthemarketmodelingsoftwaretoolswhilekeepinginmindtheconsistencyofthemarketindicatordimension.Thisprocessallowedtherangesofuncertaintyintheresultstobereducedbyupto90%(whencomparedtoTYNDP2016marketCBAresultsasareference).
Furthermore,additionalindicatorshavebeenintroducedinTYNDP2018,whichallowedthebenefitsofprojectstobehighlightedinamoredetailedmanner.Asanexample,theSocio-economicwelfarecalculationhasbeenimprovedwiththecomputationoftwosub-indicators:RESfuelsavingsandemissioncostsavings(seeFigure5-1below).Theseprovideanindicationofthesourceofthesocio-economicbenefitforthattheprojectandconsequentlyanimprovedexplanationoftheoverallprojectbenefits.
Figure5.1Structureoftheprojectassessmentindicators
Benefits
B1Socio-economicwelfare
Costs Residual impacts
C1CAPEX S1 Environmental
C2OPEX S2 Social
S3Other
System adequacy
System security
B2 CO2 variation
B4Societalwell-being
B7 Flexibility
B3 RES integration
B6Adequacy
B5 Grid losses
B8Stability
RES fuel savings
Emission cost savings
10
TY
ND
P 20
18 –
Impr
ovem
ents
of T
YN
DP
2018
Section 6
System Needs
ForthefirsttimeENTSO-Ehasdoneananalysisonthesystemneedsforthe2040timehorizon.
Thereportaimstoaddressthequestions:— What should the electricity grid looklike in 2040 to
—CreatemaximumvalueforEuropeans,— Ensure continuous access to electricity
throughoutEurope,and —Deliverontheclimateagenda?—Whatwouldbethecostofnothavingtherightgrid
by2040?
Thereportisbasedonthethree2040scenarios.Inparticular,veryhighlevelsofrenewableenergysources (RES) of up to 75% of total demand could bereached.Inthissituation,Europeancountrieswill,morethanever,needtorelyoneachotherthroughcross-borderexchanges.Thisincreasestheneedforextendedcross-bordertransfercapacity,whichgoeshandinhandwithinternalreinforcementsofnationalgrids.ThisreportandthesixRegionalInvestmentPlansitaccompanies,presenthowtocomplementthepowersystemin2040inthemostefficientway.
ThereportscanbefoundontheTYNDP2018website(https://tyndp.entsoe.eu/)
10
TY
ND
P 20
18 –
Impr
ovem
ents
of T
YN
DP
2018
11
TY
ND
P 20
18 –
Impr
ovem
ents
of T
YN
DP
2018
Section 7
Frequency Stability Studies
11
TY
ND
P 20
18 –
Impr
ovem
ents
of T
YN
DP
2018
This year, to enhance our inertia studies, ENTSO-E has undertaken an inertia collection, which consisted of collecting the inertia constants and installed capacity of all generation units in Europe. This allowed us to give much more accurate results when looking at the inertia of various synchronous areas in Europe, based on the future energy scenarios. The results of the simulations can be seen in the European Power System 2040.
Duetotheadditionofextramarketnodes,ENTSO-E is able to run frequency stability studies for all of the synchronous areas as follows:– Nordics– Baltics– GB– Ireland– Cyprus– Sardinia– Crete– Central Europe.
ThestabilitystudiesincludecalculatingSystemsInertia,Energy,RoCoF,ResidualLoadRampsandWindandSolarcontributiontodemand.Thiswasdonefor all 2030 and 2040 scenarios and can be done for the2020and2025scenarios.
12
TY
ND
P 20
18 –
Impr
ovem
ents
of T
YN
DP
2018
Section 8
Project Sheets
12
TY
ND
P 20
18 –
Impr
ovem
ents
of T
YN
DP
2018
The format of the project sheets in light of stakeholder comments and suggestions has been professionally redesigned and improved and can now be viewed online. The project sheets now include extra information which wasn’t present/ relevant in the previous versions of the TYNDP. This includes the effect of climate years on a particular project, inclusion of the sequential and normal CBA results, and additional explanation for societal wellbeing.
Inadditiontothecontentslastyear,theprojectsheetsshowthefollowinginformation
– ProjectType(Internal,GenerationconnectionorInterconnection)
– Systemneedaddressedbytheproject– Explanation for clustering of investments– AdditionalCBAindicator– Comparison of results using different climate years.
Thisinformationshouldgivereadersdeeperinsightsintoeachproject.
Section 9
Project Platform
This year ENTSO-E developed a standalone project platform which has been used for the collection of project information.
Theplatformhasbeenusedtocollectalltheprojectdata,TechnicalData,ProjectNeedsandAdditionalInformation.Theplatformhasanintegratedmappingfunctionwhichallowspromotorstodrawtheirinvestmentsonthemap.ThesemapsubmissionsareusedforthefinalTYNDPmapaswellastheprojectsheets.
AllENTSO-Ecalculatedresults,includingtheCBAresults,areprovidedtoprojectpromotersviatheplatformasandwhentheyareready.Thishasaddressed any concerns about equitable treatment of internal ENTSO-E members and 3rd party promotors.Theplatformincludedachangerequestfunctionswhichallowedprojectpromoterstostatetheir opinionsontheresultsintheeventthattheyhave any reservations.
ThiswasarelevantimprovementfromtheTYNDP2016process.ThisisthefirsttimethatENTSO-Ehasreleasedthisprocessandwillendeavortoimproveandsmoothentheprocessinproceedingproceduralupdates.Theseupdateswillutilizefeedbackreceivedfromprojectpromoters.
13
TY
ND
P 20
18 –
Impr
ovem
ents
of T
YN
DP
2018
14
TY
ND
P 20
18 –
Impr
ovem
ents
of T
YN
DP
2018
ENTSO-E AISBL Avenuede Cortenbergh100,1000Brussels, Belgium
Tel (+32) 2 741 09 50
[email protected] www.entsoe.eu
©ENTSO-E2018