qualcomm equity research report kashif anwer...qualcomm incorporated archetypal graham/ buffett...

29
Qualcomm Incorporated Archetypal Graham/ Buffett Value Check for QCOM QCOM is the largest communication equipment company in the world with 3,000+ patents and a pioneer of 3G/4G/5G technologies. The company’s stock pays a dividend (4.31% yield) and is currently selling at an astonishingly cheap multiple of 10.8X (one year forward P/E). Street’s overreaction over multiple lawsuits filed by its biggest customer Apple and over some antitrust litigation has led to the recent decline in the price of QCOM shares. However, QCOM’s brand, product pipeline, market position and recent acquisition of NXP semiconductors equate to an unparalleled moat for the company. The firm’s balance sheet, with every information already sync’d in, is still very strong even in the midst of all the controversies over its Pandora’s box full of lawsuit’s. QCOM’s share value not only will see the light of the day but also will go only up from here with an anticipated explosive growth rate in smartphones and Internet-of-things (IoT) of CAGR 20% and 13.2% respectively. Growth Catalysts to “POWER-Up” Shares in 2017 “Hyper-trending” & “glaring” Valuation prospects: QCOM is cheaper than it has ever been on a Forward P/E basis of 10.8X Vs 10YR Average of 31X. It is cheaper than all of its major rivals. The stock’s forward P/E is also well below the industry average (26.9x for Semiconductor). It is currently selling at a discount of 9.4% per the DCF valuation and It is not possible to find a value like this in the technology sector that will also afford investors this much growth potential yet providing it with the margin of safety. Competitive Advantage - “Only Game in town”: QCOM benefits from their high revenue (relative to competitors), allowing them to out-spend every peer on R&D and once QCOM develops a new technology, they take action to develop multiple variances of this technology and provide additional functionality which allows their chipsets to be integrated with multiple types of technology. QCOM has 65-75% of market share in the smartphone chipset industry. They are protected by high switching costs, as developers creating newer models prefer to work with system architectures with which they are familiar and as discussed above, its technology integrates with many additional communications components; technologies which would have to be developed on a product-by-product basis depending on which components are used. Margin of Safety - “Murphy’s Law turned-up”: QCOM is a legend and a pioneer in the technology space of semiconductor-communication equipment space with $77.7B+ in market cap. It pays a dividend and also has an enormous amount of cash ($6B) and cash equivalents ($23B) on its balance sheet. The company’s fundamentals are superb (excellent track record, competent management, and the firm were debt free up until its decision to acquire NXP. QCOM is known for its dividend increment plan and for beating the street’s estimates on a regular basis. These attributes provide investors with plenty of safety, while also affording management the latitude necessary to maximize shareholder value. Recommendation - Field Research Confirms “BUY”: QCOM is rated as a strong buy by over 80% of Analysts covering for QCOM. Though the firm’s growth rate will take a hit in short term because of pending litigations and because of margins decline due to new players coming to take market share from QCOM, such as Intel. However, for Value Investors who buy the stock now will be awarded a premium on future prospects of the company deriving from QCOM’s vision for IoT and automotive space. A fair multiple on the stock based on a blended relative value, comparative value, PEG and DCF valuation is 18.95x one-year forward earnings, which equates to a dollar price of $76.03. Expected return on QCOM based on this forecast is 48.31% (including dividend yield). BUSINESS DESCRIPTION: “Qualcomm’s Business Overview,” Thinking Forward” QUALCOMM incorporated on August 15, 1991, is engaged in the development and commercialization of a digital communication technology called code division multiple access (CDMA). The Company is engaged in the development and commercialization of the orthogonal frequency division multiple access (OFDMA) family of technologies, including long-term evolution (LTE), which is an Orthogonal Frequency Division Multiplexing (OFDM)-based standard that uses OFDMA and single-carrier Frequency Division Multiple Access (FDMA), for cellular wireless communication applications. The Company's segments include QCT (Qualcomm CDMA Technologies), QTL (Qualcomm Technology Licensing) and QSI (Qualcomm Strategic Initiatives). The Company also develops and commercializes a range of other technologies used in handsets and tablets that contribute to end user demand, such as certain audio and video codecs, the wireless local area networks (WLAN) 802.11 functionality and volatile and non-volatile memory controllers. Other technologies used by wireless devices that it has developed include operating systems, user interfaces, graphics and camera processing functionality, integrated circuit packaging techniques, sensors and sensor fusion algorithms and application processor architectures. Qualcomm QCOM) U.S. Technology Communication Equipment Price: $52.78 Recommendation: 1/14/18 Target: $76.03 Discount [Price + 10YR QCOM Stock Performance

Upload: others

Post on 23-Mar-2020

13 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Qualcomm Equity Research Report Kashif Anwer...Qualcomm Incorporated Archetypal Graham/ Buffett Value Check for QCOM QCOM is the largest communication equipment company in the world

QualcommIncorporated

ArchetypalGraham/BuffettValueCheckforQCOMQCOM is the largest communication equipment company in the world with 3,000+patentsandapioneerof3G/4G/5Gtechnologies.Thecompany’sstockpaysadividend(4.31%yield)and iscurrentlysellingatanastonishinglycheapmultipleof10.8X(oneyear forward P/E). Street’s overreaction over multiple lawsuits filed by its biggestcustomerAppleandoversomeantitrustlitigation hasledtotherecentdeclineinthepriceofQCOMshares.However,QCOM’sbrand,productpipeline,marketpositionandrecent acquisition of NXP semiconductors equate to an unparalleled moat for thecompany.Thefirm’sbalancesheet,witheveryinformationalreadysync’din,isstillverystrongeveninthemidstofallthecontroversiesoveritsPandora’sboxfulloflawsuit’s.QCOM’ssharevaluenotonlywillseethelightofthedaybutalsowillgoonlyupfromherewithananticipatedexplosivegrowthrateinsmartphonesandInternet-of-things(IoT)ofCAGR20%and13.2%respectively.

GrowthCatalyststo“POWER-Up” Sharesin2017

♦ “Hyper-trending”&“glaring”Valuationprospects:QCOMischeaperthanithaseverbeenonaForwardP/Ebasisof10.8XVs10YRAverageof31X.Itischeaperthanallofitsmajorrivals.Thestock’sforwardP/Eisalsowellbelowtheindustryaverage(26.9xforSemiconductor).Itiscurrentlysellingatadiscountof9.4%pertheDCFvaluationandItisnotpossibletofindavaluelikethisinthetechnologysector thatwillalsoafford investors thismuchgrowthpotentialyetproviding itwiththemarginofsafety.

♦ CompetitiveAdvantage-“OnlyGameintown”:QCOMbenefitsfromtheirhighrevenue(relativetocompetitors),allowingthemtoout-spendeverypeeronR&DandonceQCOMdevelopsanewtechnology,theytakeactiontodevelopmultiplevariancesofthistechnologyandprovideadditionalfunctionalitywhichallowstheirchipsetstobeintegratedwithmultipletypesoftechnology.QCOMhas65-75%ofmarket share in the smartphone chipset industry. They are protected by highswitchingcosts,asdeveloperscreatingnewermodelsprefertoworkwithsystemarchitectureswithwhichtheyarefamiliarandasdiscussedabove,itstechnologyintegrateswithmanyadditionalcommunicationscomponents;technologieswhichwouldhavetobedevelopedonaproduct-by-productbasisdependingonwhichcomponentsareused.

♦ MarginofSafety-“Murphy’sLawturned-up”:QCOMisalegendandapioneerinthe technology space of semiconductor-communication equipment space with$77.7B+inmarketcap.Itpaysadividendandalsohasanenormousamountofcash($6B) and cash equivalents ($23B) on its balance sheet. The company’sfundamentalsaresuperb(excellenttrackrecord,competentmanagement,andthefirmweredebt freeupuntil itsdecision toacquireNXP.QCOMisknownfor itsdividendincrementplanandforbeatingthestreet’sestimatesonaregularbasis.Theseattributesprovideinvestorswithplentyofsafety,whilealsoaffordingmanagementthelatitudenecessarytomaximizeshareholdervalue.

♦ Recommendation-FieldResearchConfirms“BUY”:QCOMisratedasastrongbuybyover80%ofAnalystscoveringforQCOM.Thoughthefirm’sgrowthratewilltakeahitinshorttermbecauseofpendinglitigationsandbecauseofmarginsdeclineduetonewplayerscomingtotakemarketsharefromQCOM,suchasIntel.However,forValueInvestorswhobuythestocknowwillbeawardedapremiumonfutureprospectsofthecompanyderivingfromQCOM’svisionfor IoTandautomotivespace.Afairmultipleonthestockbasedonablendedrelativevalue,comparativevalue,PEGandDCFvaluationis18.95xone-yearforwardearnings,whichequatestoadollarpriceof$76.03.ExpectedreturnonQCOMbasedonthisforecastis48.31%(includingdividendyield).

BUSINESSDESCRIPTION:“Qualcomm’sBusinessOverview,”Thinking Forward”

QUALCOMMincorporatedonAugust15,1991,isengagedinthedevelopmentandcommercializationofadigitalcommunicationtechnologycalled code divisionmultiple access (CDMA). The Company is engaged in the development and commercialization of the orthogonalfrequencydivisionmultipleaccess(OFDMA)familyoftechnologies,includinglong-termevolution(LTE),whichisanOrthogonalFrequencyDivisionMultiplexing(OFDM)-basedstandardthatusesOFDMAandsingle-carrierFrequencyDivisionMultipleAccess(FDMA),forcellularwirelesscommunicationapplications.TheCompany'ssegmentsincludeQCT(QualcommCDMATechnologies),QTL(QualcommTechnologyLicensing)andQSI(QualcommStrategicInitiatives).TheCompanyalsodevelopsandcommercializesarangeofothertechnologiesusedinhandsetsandtabletsthatcontributetoenduserdemand,suchascertainaudioandvideocodecs,thewirelesslocalareanetworks(WLAN)802.11functionalityandvolatileandnon-volatilememorycontrollers.Othertechnologiesusedbywirelessdevicesthatithasdevelopedincludeoperatingsystems,userinterfaces,graphicsandcameraprocessingfunctionality,integratedcircuitpackagingtechniques,sensorsandsensorfusionalgorithmsandapplicationprocessorarchitectures.

Qualcomm QCOM) U.S.Technology Communication Equipment Price:$52.78 Recommendation:

1/14/18 Target:$76.03 Discount [Price+

10YR QCOM Stock Performance

Page 2: Qualcomm Equity Research Report Kashif Anwer...Qualcomm Incorporated Archetypal Graham/ Buffett Value Check for QCOM QCOM is the largest communication equipment company in the world

2

Long Equity Report- Applied Portfolio Management | Analyst: Kashif Anwer

DISSECTINGQUALCOMM’sBUSINESS:“Valuationpotential”

TheCompany'sproductsprincipallyconsistof integratedcircuits(chipsorchipsets)andsystemsoftwareusedinmobiledevicesandinwirelessnetworks.TheCompanyalsosellsotherproductsandservices,whichincludeintegratedcircuitsforuseinwireddevices,broadbandgateway equipment, desktop computers and streaming media players; software products and content and push-to-talk enablementservicesforwirelessoperators,andproductsdesignedfortheimplementationofsmallcells.PleaseseetheAppendixforalistofreferences.

NegativeHeadlinesinthePast(LossofiPhone7,NDRCAnti-MonopolyRuling,AppleDispute,Blackberryruling)PresentaStrongBuyingOpportunitywithsharepriceclosetoits52-weekLow.

♦ AsFigure1demonstrates,QCOMhasdropped27.3%inthepast3-yearperiodtoitscurrentpriceof$52.78,whiletheS&P500hasreturned13.60%inthesametimespan.

♦ QCOMralliedinJuly2016afterthemarketreactedpositivelytoitsacquisitiondecisionofNXP,butanumberofheadlineriskshavepushedthestocktosuchalowlevelthatitpresentsastrongbuyingopportunity.

♦ InQ22015,theChinaNationalDevelopmentReformCommission(NDRC)finedQCOM$975mmforviolatingChina’sAnti-MonopolyLawandstipulatedthatQCOMchargerunningroyaltyratesof5%for3GCDMA1orWCDMAdevicesand3.5%for4Gdeviceswhichledtomarketconcernsaboutroyaltyratesmovingforward,butQTLsegmentactuallybeatexpectationsinQ12016duetostrong3G/4GdevicevolumesandstrongASPs

♦ InQ12016,QCOMdeferred$100mm in revenuebecauseKoreansmartphonemakerLG tookQCOMtoarbitrationoverpreviousroyaltyoverpaymentsandfutureroyaltyrates.WhileQCOMPresidentDerekAberlesaidonaconferencecall,“IbelieveLG’sclaimsarewithoutmerit,”QCOM’sstockdropped8.3%thedayafter thenewsbroke. I thinkthat thiswasanoverreaction–however, IassumethatQCOMneverrecoversthelost$100mmfromLG,stillsubstantialupsidepotentialexists.

♦ Apple’slaunchoftheiPhone7inFall2016hasseenInteltakesharefromQualcomm.IfQualcommloses40%share,JPMorganpredicts$1.7bninlostrevenuein2017.Imodelinthis$1.7bnlossinCoreMobilerevenuesin2017,butEPSin2017stillgrowsyoyduetolowerrestructuringchargesfortheStrategicRealignmentPlaninadditionto$815mmlosstoblackberrythatpusheddownEPS.IbelievesharelosstoIntelcouldactuallybeanetpositiveinthelong-runasitpushesQCOMtodiversifyawayfromCoreMobileandtakeopportunitiesinAutomotiveandIoTspace,whichisevidencedfromitsrecentAcquisitionofNXP.

♦ InQ12017,QCOMreportedquarterlyrevenueandprofitthatbeatanalysts'estimates,howevertherewasmuchuncertaintiesoverapplelitigationofcloseto$1billionwithrespecttoQCOM’stieswithitsbiggestcustomer,Apple.

Page 3: Qualcomm Equity Research Report Kashif Anwer...Qualcomm Incorporated Archetypal Graham/ Buffett Value Check for QCOM QCOM is the largest communication equipment company in the world

3

Long Equity Report- Applied Portfolio Management | Analyst: Kashif Anwer

♦ InQ22017,QCOMreportedquarterly revenueandprofit thatbeat analysts' estimatesback toback for2quarters,helpingeaseconcernssurroundingthecompany'sdisputewithAppleInc.Inaddition,themostimportantinformationthatQCOMpresentedduringitsfiscal2017Q2earningsconferencecallthattheacquisitionofNXPSemiconductorshadpassedtheHSRreviewprocess.

BusinessSegmentsperformance:Qualcommoperateprincipallythroughtwosegmentsthatcontributetowardsitsrevenuestreamasdisplayedbelow.

Licensing i.e. Qualcomm Technology Licensing (QTL): QCOM’s licensing arm, which licenses their intellectual property to nearly everysmartphonemanufacturer.QTL’spatentportfolio includesmany“missioncritical”solutionswhicharerequiredforsmartphonestomeetinternational3G/4G/LTEstandards,sotheyearnlicensingrevenuefromeffectivelyeverysmartphonethatissold.

QCOMreceivesapproximately3%ofeachdevice’ssalesprice.Theselicensingrevenuesareafunctionofbothtotalsmartphonessoldandthedeviceprice;smartphonepurchasesareexpectedtoincreaseatover20%perannumthrough2018,however,muchofthisgrowthwillcome from emergingmarkets, which have lower device prices. QCOM’smanagement believes theywill continue net gains in licensingrevenue,astheincreaseinglobaldevicesaleswillcontinuetooutweighdecreasesinprice.Qualcomm’sreplacementvalueislessthan50%oftheirearningspowervalue,implyingtheyhaveasubstantialcompetitiveadvantagetoo.

QTListhe“crownjewel”whichdrivesthesignificantvalueforthefirmupuntilnow.Licensingrevenueisstableandgrowing.An18.5%CAGRovertheprior15years.Growneveryyear,withtheexceptionof2009.Duringtheworsteconomicrecession inmodernhistory,revenuedeclinedbyunder0.5%Overtheprior15years,EBTmarginshaveremainedremarkablyconsistentatanaverageof88%.Evenduringthegreatrecession,profitmarginsforthissegmentdroppedbyonly1.5%,reboundingtoaveragelevelswithintwoyears

Equipmentandservicesi.e.QualcommCDMATechnologies(QCL): A‘true’semiconductorfirm,largelycomparabletootherlargefablesssemiconductormanufacturers.Theymanufactureintegratedcircuitsandchipsetswithprincipalapplicationsinsmartphones,inwhichtheyhaveanimpliedmarketshareof~70%.QCOMreceivesapproximately$20perchipthattheysell.

Theoftenregarded“UglySister”whichprovidessomevaluetothefirm,butprincipallyexiststodrivelicensingrevenue:Muchlike“BestBuy”,whoseretailsalesdrivetheir trueprofitengine(warranties),QCT’sR&Dactivitiescreatetheopportunity forQLTtoexist.However,asastandaloneentity,QCT’sprofileislessthanideal.PriortoFY16,QCThadgrownnearlyeveryyear,ata21.4%CAGRHowever,marginsforthissegmenthavesteadilydeclinedoverthatperiod.Overall,EBThasgrown,astherateofgrowthexceededthedeclineinmargins.However,duetothelossofmajorcustomershare(ApplesinceiPhone7)andmid-termheadwindsintheChipsetbusiness(OEMspushingbackreleaseofnewproducts),managementhasreducedguidanceforthissegment.Theyarenowprojectinga6%YoYrevenuedeclineandadeclineinEBTmarginsto15.5%-TheFirstYoYdeclinesince2009,andthelowestEBTmarginofalltime.

SynergiesacrossQCTandQLTSegments:

♦ Development:QCT,whichdevelopsnewtechnologythroughR&Dactivities,concurrentlypatentingthisintellectualproperty,whichQLTthenlicensesouttocustomers.

♦ Integration: QCOM owns nearly the entire smartphone chipset platform, allowing them to integrate innovations into multiplevariantsacrossmarketsegments.

♦ Integration(again):QCOMowns(andhascreated)thefoundationaltechnologyforCDMAand3G/4Gtechnology.Thisfirst-moveradvantagehasblossomedintoabroadcompetitiveadvantage,andtheirtechnologyisgenerallysuperior,butalsosignificantlymoreversatile – for example, custom (or in-house) chipsets are generally produced with the intention of integrating with specifictechnologiesorcomponents–QCOM’stechnologiesareconsistentlyrefreshedtointegratewithmultipletypesofrelatedtechnology,makingthemmorecompetitiveandpreferabletocustomers–withtheaddedbenefitofcreatingadditionalIPtolicense.

0

10000

20000

9/1/06 9/1/07 9/1/08 9/1/09 9/1/10 9/1/11 9/1/12 9/1/13 9/1/14 9/1/15 9/1/16

RevenuebySegments(inmillions)

Equipmentandservices Licensing

Page 4: Qualcomm Equity Research Report Kashif Anwer...Qualcomm Incorporated Archetypal Graham/ Buffett Value Check for QCOM QCOM is the largest communication equipment company in the world

4

Long Equity Report- Applied Portfolio Management | Analyst: Kashif Anwer

♦ Collection:Qualcomm’sstatusasbothachipsetandIPvendorprovidesthemwithunparalleledleveragetocollectlicensingfeesatalowercost,simplybydenyingphysicaldeliveryofthechipsetsuntilallfeesarepaid.ThisallowstheirlicensingsegmenttooperateatmuchhighermarginsthancompanieswhichsolelylicenseIPorwhichprovideproductsun-relatedtotheirIP.

CORPORATEGOVERNANCE:“Unmatchedmanagementperformance”

QCOM'sshareownershipguidelinesforexecutivesduringtheirtenurehelptoalignshareholderandmanagementinterestbyrequiringtheexecutives toholdanumberof shareswhile activeat the firm. TheCompany’s stockownership guidelines for its executiveofficers aredeterminedasamultipleoftheexecutive’sbasesalary,withthesizeofthemultiplebasedontheindividual’sposition.TheguidelinefortheCompany’sChiefExecutiveOfficerissetatsixtimesannualbasesalary.TheguidelinefortheCompany’sPresidentissetatthreetimesannualbasesalary.TheguidelinefortheotherpersonswhoaredesignatedasexecutiveofficersforpurposesofSection16oftheSecuritiesExchangeActissetattwotimesannualbasesalary.Shareholderinterestisfurtheralignedwithmanagementthroughlong-termincentivesutilizingrestrictedstock,aswellasperformancegrantsderivedfromQCOM'stotalreturnvspeersandreturnoninvestedcapital(ROIC).Ifound2016ROICof12.3%,exceedingQCOM'scombinedfinancingcosts.ThemeanofQCOM'sROIC for thepast3years is13.1%. IbelieveQCOM'smanagementisactinginthebestinterestofshareholdersthroughitscapitalallocationanddividenddistributionmethods,whichhasahistoryofeverincreasingforshareholders.IbelieveanimportantmeasureofcapitalallocationformanagementistheimpactofretainedearningsonQCOM'stotalmarketcapitalization.Sinceinception,QCOMhasreturnedcumulativeof$55.3BilliontoStockholderstillDec25,2016almosttwo-thirdofitsmarketcapalready.ThisdividendpayouttestshowsthatQCOM'smanagementrationallydeployscapital.“IambullishonQCOM, mostly because of its sound management team, which has shown and continues to prove its ability to outperform domesticcompetitorsandbestpositionitselfforgrowthwithinthedynamicandvalue-addedsemiconductorindustry.AlsowithQCOM'sacquisitionofNXPat15xEV/EBITDAimpliedbytheQCOMofferislookingmightystingyconsideringInteliswillingtopayover100xEBITDAforanotherautomotiveADASleader–Mobileye,whichshowstheeffectivenessoftheQCOM’ssolidmanagement.Iwaspleasedtoseetheboard’sgoalextendedbeyondshareholdersbutalsoto“employees,customersandthecommunitiesinwhichQualcommoperates.”

INDUSTRYOVERVIEW&COMPETITIVEPOSITIONING:“WheretheIndustryderivesitsValue”

Porter5-ForcesThis is an analysis of the attractiveness of the semiconductor industry for QCOM based on Porter’s model of five forces of

competition.TheanalysisismainlybasedontheU.S.market.

♦ Suppliers’bargainingpower:betweenlowandmediumIntermsoflargesemiconductorcompanies,QCOMhasinherentadvantageswhenchoosingsuppliersfromthousandsofthem.DiversifiedcompaniessuchasQCOMusuallyuseenoughnumberofsupplierstominimizethepowerofeach.However,inthespecializedsemiconductorindustry,inwhichthe"fablessmanufacturing"modelisusedbymostofthecompanies.Asaresult,fablesscompaniesplayanimportantroleinthisspecializedsector.Besides,noteverysub-contractorhasthecapabilitytosatisfytheneedsofthespecializedcompanies,sosuppliersaremuchpowerfulthanthoseinthelargegenericsemiconductorsector.Thereareseveralsuppliergroupspresenttothesemiconductorindustry.Afewofthosegroupsare;capitalequipmentmakers,suppliersofsilicon,chemicals,gases,water,energy,metalsandothermaterialsareusedinmanufacturingsemiconductorproducts.

♦ Customers’bargainingpower:medium-highThebuyersofthesemiconductor industryareendless.There isabuyerat literallyeverycorner.Theswitchingcostsofthebuyers inthecommoditysemiconductormarketissmallastheycanpurchasefromanysemiconductorindustryplayerwhoisrepresentingthelowestcostavailableaslongasthetechnologyiscompatible.ThestrongroleoftheindustrygiantslikeIntelandQCOMlimitsthebargainingpowerofbuyers.Computers,smartphonesandelectricvehiclesaredefinitelythelargestpieceofdemandpresentedbythebuyersin2016,althoughitisdecliningduetotherisingsalesofsmartphonesandmediatablets.Buyersinthesemiconductortendtobeverypricesensitiveastheindustryisconstantlyproducingproductsatalowercosttopushthedemandoftheirproduct.Withinthebuyers,thereareseveralbuyergroupsthatshouldbementioned.Thecomputer industrytakesofthebulkofbuyerdemand,mobiledevicesandtabloids,andthemedicalindustrytomentionafew.Thesebuyersmakepurchasesfromthesemiconductorindustrytocontinueindailyoperationsastheyarealargepartofongoingbusiness.

♦ Threatofsubstitutes:LowTheindustryhastheabilitytochangeinaveryshorttime.Thistakesawayopportunitiesfromsubstitutestoenterthemarketsegment.Itwouldnottakethesemiconductorindustryverylongtorespondtoasuccessfulsubstituteastheywouldfindawaytoproducetheproductthemselves.Theproblemthatwouldbepresentisthemoneyconstraint.Itcanbedonebutatacost.Theindustryplayerscanfindthemselvesspendingalotofmoneytoresearchanddevelopnewproductsjusttofindthattheircompetitionbeatthemtoitbyafewmonths.Thiskeepsthebusinessenvironmentvolatileandcompetitive..

♦ Threatofnewentrants:betweenlowandmediumTraditionally,becauseofthehugecapitalexpendituresforstartup,itisverydifficultforthosenewentriestobesuccessfullyinvadingthesemiconductor industry.Obviously, it is great news for those large companieswho can control themarket in their favor by using theireconomiesofscale.Besides,thepointedendresearchanddevelopmentareothertwoindispensablebarriersfornewentries.

Page 5: Qualcomm Equity Research Report Kashif Anwer...Qualcomm Incorporated Archetypal Graham/ Buffett Value Check for QCOM QCOM is the largest communication equipment company in the world

5

Long Equity Report- Applied Portfolio Management | Analyst: Kashif Anwer

However, recently,withtheevolvementof the industry,smallerplayerscouldmovetheirattentionfrommanufacturingtoresearchanddevelopment.Benefitfromthesubcontractingofmanufacturing,smallercompanieshasmoreresourcesandcapitaltoinvestintoresearchofnewtechnologies.Thecooperationofsubcontractingeasedthefinancialburdenofthesmallerplayersandreducedthebarrierofsemiconductorindustrytothem.Thisisextremelysignificantforthosesmallerentrepreneurialcorporationsevenforthewholestructureofthe semiconductor industry.Moreover, except the high technology requirement for new entry, another significant barrier to entry thesemiconductormarket is the software compatibility. As a powerful semiconductor player, they are required to not only create physicaltechnology,butalsoneedtodesignconvenientandcompatiblesoftwarewhichcouldcollaboratewiththeirprocessorswellsocustomerscouldenjoytheirproduct.Anotherformidablebarriertoentryisthehugeinitialinvestmentrequiredtoenterthecarmarketsingeneral.LargeamountsofcapitalarerequiredtosetupmanufacturingfacilitiesandinvestinR&D,amongotherlargeexpenses.Thisalsogenerateslargesunkcostsandmakesithardtoachieveeconomiesofscaleforanewentrant.Apositivefactorfornewentrantsisthattheswitchingcostsofcustomersarenotprohibitivelyhigh.

♦ Competitionbetweenestablishedfirms:high

Thesemiconductorindustryisveryhighlycompetitive.Thefirmswithinthisindustrycompeteonadailybasistoproduceormanufactureaproductthatissmaller,fasterandcheaper.Theindustrychangesrapidlyastechnologychangesrapidly.Thiskeepsitcompetitiveaseachcompetitorcanseekandopportunitytocreatesomethinggreatbeforetheothersdo.Withinthiscompetitiveindustrythereisaconstantpressuretocomeupwithbetterproducts.Theproductsofthis industryaremuchundifferentiatedastheproductstheyaretryingtocreateareessentially improvementstosimilarproducts that already exist. The accomplishments of the products change very little. The methods of production is where can seedifferentiation.Theplayersaretryingtocomeupwithinnovativewaystodothesamethingsonlyinasmaller,faster,andcheapermanner(Investopedia,2010)..Forexample,ARMhasgainedverymuchcompetitiveadvantagewithismobilechiptechnology,similarlyIntelhasbeenthenumberoneinthelaptopmicroprocessorsbecauseofsuperiorproductperformanceTheresultofan industry that is thiscompetitive isemerging technology that iscutting-edge.The technology isconstantlychanging intosomethingbettersoforcompetitionitmakesithardtoremainatthetop.Whattendstohappeninthistypeofanindustryisthatthereareseveralindustryplayerswithsimilarsizeriseasthelargerplayers.Thisisbecausenooneplayercankeepexcellingwiththenewest,fastest,andcheapestproductavailable.Thefourmainproductsofthesemiconductorindustryarememorychips,microprocessors,commodityintegratedcircuit,andcomplexSOC(systemonachip)whichisacombinationofasystemofsemiconductorscompactedintoonesmallproduct.Thefollowingarethetoptenranked semiconductor industry leaders as of 2010: Intel, Samsung Electronics, Toshiba Semiconductors, Texas Instruments, RenesasElectronics,Hynix,STMicroelectronics,MicronTechnology,Qualcomm,andElpidaMemory(Ford,2010).Thegraphbelowshowshowthesecompetitorsaredoingagainsteachotherintermsofrevenue.Itgivesabasicunderstandinghowtheysitagainsteachotherandwhoarethemajorplayers.Overall,theindustryisnotveryattractivefornewentranttocomeinthisspace.OnsimilarnoteQCOMisexpectedtobenefitfromhavinggreatestmarketcapinitsindustryofcommunicationequipmentwhilehavingrelativelylesslikelihoodofbeingchallengedbythenewplayers.SWOTAnalysis

♦ StrengthFirstmoveradvantageenablesthecompanytosustainmarketpositionQualcommhavingpioneeredtheCDMAwirelesscommunicationstechnologyhasafirstmoveradvantageandisaleadingplayerinthemarket.ThecompanystartedpromotingCDMAtechnologyforwirelesscommunicationapplicationsin1989.ThecompanyisamajordeveloperandsupplierofCDMA-basedintegratedcircuits(ICs)andsystemsoftwareforwirelessvoiceanddatacommunications,multimediafunctionsandglobalpositioningsystem(GPS)products.Qualcomm's ICproductsandsystemsoftwareareused inwirelessdevices,particularlymobilephones,laptops,datamodules,handheldwirelesscomputers,datacards,andinfrastructureequipment.QualcommleadsthedevelopmentandcommercializationofallversionsofCDMAtechnology,andasaresult,ownsasignificantintellectualproperty,includingpatents,patentapplications,and trade secrets,portionsofwhich it licenses toother companiesbesides implementing them in itsownproducts. In thewirelesscommunicationsindustry,acompanygenerallyseekingtodevelop,manufactureandsellproductsthatuseCDMAtechnologywouldrequireapatentlicensefromQualcomm.CDMAplatformisoneofthemaintechnologiesfordigitalwirelesscommunicationsnetworks.Firstmoveradvantageinoneofthemostprominentwirelesstechnologiesenablesthecompanytosustainthemarketposition.Strongfocusonresearchanddevelopment(R&D)QualcommhasrobustR&Dcapabilities.ThecompanyhasR&Dcentersinvariouslocationsthroughouttheworld.Inaddition,Qualcommhassignificantengineeringresources,includingengineerswithsubstantialexpertiseinCDMA,OFDMAandabroadrangeofothertechnologies.

Page 6: Qualcomm Equity Research Report Kashif Anwer...Qualcomm Incorporated Archetypal Graham/ Buffett Value Check for QCOM QCOM is the largest communication equipment company in the world

6

Long Equity Report- Applied Portfolio Management | Analyst: Kashif Anwer

The company'sR&D focuseson innovation in voiceanddata communication technologiesandapplicationprocessor technology, amongothers.ThecompanyincurredR&Dexpendituresof$5.5billion,$5.5billionand$5billion,inFY2015,FY2014andFY2013,respectively.Thecompany'sR&Disprimarilyfocusedonextendingthedemandfor itsproductsandservices, includingdevelopingnewversionsofCDMA,OFDMA,andothertechnologies,anddevelopingalternativetechnologiesforcertainspecializedapplications.Further,thecompanycontinuestodevelop,commercializeandactivelysupportthirdgeneration(3G)CDMA-basedtechnologies,includingCDMA20001X,1xEV-DO,EV-DORevisionA,EV-DORevisionB,1xAdvanced,widebandCDMA(WCDMA),high-speeddownlinkpacketaccess (HSDPA),high-speeduplinkpacket access (HSUPA) andevolvedhigh-speedpacket access (HSPA+), aswell asOFDMA-based long termevolution (LTE) technologies,products and network operations. Moreover, the company has been investing significantly to enter new markets, including displaytechnologiesandtechnologiestoaddressthegrowthofmobiledatatrafficincludingproductsandsoftwaredesignedfortheimplementationofsmallcells,whichcanbeusedbycarrierstoextendthecapacityoflicensedandunlicensedwirelessspectrum;increasingdemandfordata;theconnectedhomeandtheInternetofEverything(IoE);datacenters;automotive;veryhighspeedconnectivity;mobilehealth;wirelesscharging;andmachinelearning,includingrobotics.Thecompany'sstrongR&Dhasenabledittowinanumberofpatents.Accordingtothecompany,ithasthemostwidelyandextensivelylicensedportfoliointheindustrywithover285licenseesofallcommerciallydeployedformsofCDMAandtheirderivativesrequiretheuseofQualcommpatents. The companyhas anextensiveportfolioof theUSand foreignpatents. TheMajorityof thesepatent andpatentapplicationsarerelatedtodigitalwirelesscommunicationstechnologies,includingpatentsessentialforthecommercialimplementationofCDMA2000,WCDMA(UMTS),TD-SCDMA,TD-CDMA(TimeDivisionCDMA)andOFDMAproducts.Inaddition,Qualcommhaspatentportfoliorelatedtokeytechnologiesusedincommunicationsandotherdevicesand/orrelatedservices,includingH.264videocodectechnology,thenextgenerationvideocodectechnology(H.265orhigh-efficiencyvideocodec),advancedWLAN(802.11ac),volatile(LP-DDR2,3,4)andnon-volatile(eMMC)memorycontrollers,operatingsystems,userinterfaces,graphicsandcameraprocessing,packagingtechniques,sensorandsensorfusionalgorithmsandapplicationprocessorarchitectures.Thecompany'srobustR&DcapabilitiesthatenabledittodevelopastrongpatentsportfoliooffertechnologicalleadershiptoQualcommoveritspeers.Itwillenableittointroducenewproductsinatimelymannerandenhanceitsexistingproducts.Thiswouldenhancetheappealofitsproductsthusenablingittoeffectivelyretainandgainnewcustomers.StrongmarketpositionThecompanyholdsstrongshareinanumberofmarketsinwhichitserves.Qualcommisoneoftheleadingprovidersofsmartphonechipsets.According to industry estimates, the company leads the smartphoneapplicationsprocessormarketwitha42%market shareand is thedominantplayerinthecellularbasebandchipmarketwithamarketshareof59%.Thecompany'sSnapdragon800seriesquad-corechipsetis extensively used in premium-tier smartphones and tablets with its superior processing and graphics performance and multimediaexperience.Inaddition,Qualcomm'sotherSnapdragonmodels,including200,400and600arewidelyusedinmid-rangesmartphones.Thestrongmarketpositionof thecompanyprovides it a competitiveedgeover itspeers. It alsoprovides strongbrand recognitionenablingQualcommtoaddnewclientsfromexistingandnewgeographies.

♦ WeaknessConcentratedcustomerbaseQualcommderives a significant portion of its total revenues froma limited number of customers and geographies. Revenues from fewcustomershavehistorically constituteda significantportionof the company's total revenues.QualcommCDMATechnologies (QCT) andQualcomm Technology Licensing (QTL) segment revenues related to the products of Samsung Electronics and Hon Hai PrecisionIndustry/Foxconn,itsaffiliatesandothersupplierstoApplecomprised45%,49%and43%inFY2015,FY2014andFY2013,respectively.Theloss of anyoneof its significant customersor thedelay, even if only temporary, or cancellationof significant orders fromanyof thesecustomersimpactsthecompany'srevenuesintheperiodofthedeferralorcancellationandwillharmitsabilitytoachieveorsustainexpectedlevelsofoperatingresults.Further,concentrationofdeviceshareamongafewcompanies,andthecorrespondingpurchasingpowerofthesecompanies,may result in lower prices for the company's productswhich, if not accompanied by a sufficient increase in the volume ofpurchasesofthecompany'sproducts,couldhaveanadverseeffectonQualcomm'srevenuesandmargins.HighdependenceonthirdpartysuppliersThe companydependson a limitednumberof third-party suppliers for theprocurement,manufacture, and testingof its products. Thecompany'sQCTsegmentpurchaseswafers,dieandfully-assembledandtestedICsfromthird-partysemiconductormanufacturingfoundries.Qualcommalso contractswith third-party suppliers for assembly, test andother services related to themanufactureof its products.Areduction,interruption,delayorlimitationinproductsupplysource,afailurebyitssupplierstoprocurerawmaterialsortoprovideorallocateadequatemanufacturingortestcapacityforitsproductscouldhaveanadverseeffectonthecompany'sabilitytomeetcustomerdemandsaffectingbusinessandprofitability.Moreover,thecompanyreliesonthesoleorlimited-sourcesuppliersforsomeproducts,subjectingittosignificantrisks,includingpossibleshortagesofrawmaterialsormanufacturingcapacity;poorproductperformance;andreducedcontroloverdeliveryschedules.

AlthoughQualcommhaslong-termcontractswithitssuppliers,manyofthesecontractsdonotprovideforlong-termcapacitycommitments.Qualcomm'ssuppliersmayallocateandinthepasthaveallocatedcapacitytotheproductionandtestingofproductsfortheirothercustomerswhilereducingor limitingcapacitytomanufactureortestthecompany'sproducts.Additionally,oneormoreof itssuppliersorpotentialalternatesuppliersmaymanufactureCDMA-orOFDMA-basedICsthatcompetewithQualcommproducts.Ifthecompanyfailstoexecutesupplystrategiesthatprovidesupplyassurance,technology,leadership,andlowcost,thenitsoperatingresultsandbusinessmaybeharmed.

Page 7: Qualcomm Equity Research Report Kashif Anwer...Qualcomm Incorporated Archetypal Graham/ Buffett Value Check for QCOM QCOM is the largest communication equipment company in the world

7

Long Equity Report- Applied Portfolio Management | Analyst: Kashif Anwer

♦ OpportunitiesStronggrowthinsmartphonesmarketTheworldwidesmartphonemarketisforecastedtorecordrobustgrowthinthecomingyearsduetostrongconsumerdemandandincreasedcommercialbuying.Accordingtoindustryestimates,globalsmartphoneshipmentsareexpectedtogrowfrom1.5billionunitshipmentsin2015toalmost2.1billionunitshipmentsin2020,growingataCAGRof6%during2016-20periods.

Qualcomm iswell positioned to drive growth from the increasing demand for smartphones. The company's Snapdragon processors areemployed inmanyof the smart devices, includingApple,HTC, LG, Samsung, Blackberry, and Sony, amongothers. Further, in 2015,QTIintroduced four new Qualcomm Snapdragon processors, including Snapdragon 620, and Snapdragon 618, the 600 tier processors andSnapdragon425andSnapdragon415,400tierprocessorsforhigh-performanceandhigh-volumemobiledevices.Theincreasingusageofsmartphonesandthechangingtechnologywoulddrivethedemandforthecompany'sproductsandenablestronggrowthinsales.ThiswouldenableQualcommtodrivestrongrevenuegrowthinthecomingperiods.

PoisedtobenefitfromthegrowingIoTmarketWith increasingadoptionofcloudservicesandthebigdataservices, the InternetofThings (IoT)market isgrowingrapidly.Accordingtoindustryestimates,theIoTmarketisexpectedtoreach$662billionin2021from$157billionin2016,growingataCAGRofover33%during2016-21periods.Further,itisestimatedthatover20.8milliondeviceswillbeconnectedby2020,comparedto6.4billiondevicesin2016.Accordingtothecompany,embeddedmarket,whichincludesIoT,providesamarketopportunityof$30billionby2020.

Thecompanyiswellpositionedtobenefitfromtherobustoutlookoftheendmarket.Thecompanyoffersaportfolioofintelligence-basedproductsfortheIoTmarket.Qualcomm’sMDM9207-1,aflexibleandscalablechipsetwithCat1LTEtechnologyiswasprimarilydesignedfortheIoT.ItskeyfeaturesincludesupportforCat1withpowersavemode(PSM)andupto10yearsofbatterylife;integratedARMCortexA7APandGNSSforlocationservices;supportforLinuxOS-basedplatforms;3G/4GLTEmultimode/multibandsupport;andflexibilitytoaddvoice.The company’s 2net platform is a cloud-based system that securely gathers health information fromvariousmedical devices andhealthapplications intooneeasilyaccessible spot.TheQualcommAllPlaysmartmediaplatformmakes itpossible formusicdevicesofdifferentbrandstoworktogetherforahigh-quality,whole-homeaudioexperience.

In addition, the company’s IoT Development Platform offers hardware and software for designing and building IoT/machine-to-machine(M2M)deviceswithbuilt-incellularconnectivity.TheplatformrunsJavaEmbeddedMESDKandincludescomponentsusedtobuild,testandprovecellular-enabledIoT/M2Mapplications.Withonboardsensors,indicators,andrelays,theIoTDevelopmentPlatformisextensivelyusedby developers to test a range of applications including automotive, transportation and logistics; smart energy and security; industrialautomationandenterprise;consumerandotherM2M;andthedigitalhome.

Thecompany'sgrowingpresenceintheIoTmarketwillenableittodrivestrongrevenuesandenhanceitsmarketshareinthefuture.

GrowingLTEadoptionTheoutlookfortheLTEadoptionisrobustprimarilyduetotheincreaseddemandforfasterdataratesandbetterspectralefficiencyinthewakeofheavydatausage,increasedpenetrationofsmartdevicesandthedemandforqualityservicesonthemove.Thegrowthinthemarketisfurtherenhancedbytheplannedlarge-scaleadoptionofLTEbyoperatorsintheAsiaPacificregions,primarilyChina.Accordingtoindustryestimates,theworldwideLTEsubscriberbasereachednearly1billioninthelastquarterof2015.Furthermore,theglobalmarketisexpectedtoreach3.8billionby2020.Moreover,LTEisexpectedtoaccountformorethan45%oftheglobalmobilesubscriptionmarketby2020.

Qualcommoffersarangeofcomponentsforthe4Gdevices,includingRFtransceivers,basebandprocessorsandpowermanagementchips.Thecompany'srobustLTEportfoliocoupledwithstronggrowthintheendmarketwouldprovideincrementalgrowthopportunitiestoenhanceitsrevenuesandmarketshareinthecomingyears.

♦ ThreatsIntensecompetitionThecompanyfacesintensecompetitioninthecommunicationsindustry.Thecompanyfacescompetitionacrossallitsbusinesssegments.The company's QCT segment competes worldwide with a number of the US and international designers and manufacturers ofsemiconductors.Italsocompetesinbothsingle-anddual-modeenvironmentsagainstalternativecommunicationstechnologiesincludingbut not limited to, global system formobile communications (GSM)/general packet radio service (GPRS)/ enhanceddata rates forGSMevolution(EDGE),timedivisionmultipleaccess(TDMA),timedivisionsynchronouscodedivisionmultipleaccess(TDSCDMA)andworldwideinteroperability formicrowave access (WiMAX). The company competes on the basis of performance, the level of integration, quality,compliancewith industrystandards,price,time-to-market,systemcost,designandengineeringcapabilities,newproduct innovationandcustomer support. QCT primarily competeswithmajor companies including Broadcom, Ericsson, HiSilicon Technologies (a subsidiary ofHuaweiTechnologies),Intel,Lantiq,MarvellTechnology,Maxim IntegratedProducts,MediaTek,Nvidia,RealtekSemiconductor,SamsungElectronicsandSpreadtrumCommunications.QCTalsofacescompetitionfrominternallydevelopedproductsbyitscustomersandfromsomeearly-stagecompanies.

Page 8: Qualcomm Equity Research Report Kashif Anwer...Qualcomm Incorporated Archetypal Graham/ Buffett Value Check for QCOM QCOM is the largest communication equipment company in the world

8

Long Equity Report- Applied Portfolio Management | Analyst: Kashif Anwer

TheQTLdivisionfacescompetition inthedevelopmentof intellectualpropertyfor futuregenerationsofdigitalwirelesscommunicationstechnologyand services. This segment competesprimarilywith theGSM/GPRS/EDGEdigitalwireless communications technologiesonaglobalbasis.

Intensecompetitionacrossthecompany'ssegmentsmayresultindecliningaveragesellingpricesforitsproductswhichmayaffectitstoplinegrowthandmargins.

RapidtechnologicalchangesQualcommoperatesinthetelecommunicationsindustrywhichischaracterizedbyrapidtechnologicalchanges.Thesechangeswillbroadentherangeandreducecostsoftelecomproductsandservices.Futurechangesinnetworktechnologywillcreateaneedforthecompanytoupgradeitsproductsandtechnologies.Theseup-gradationwillalsorequirethecompanytodedicatesignificantresources.Newproductsorservicesthatuseneworevolvingtechnologiesmayreducedemandforthecompany'sexistingofferingsorcausepricesforthoseservicestodecline.Inaddition,thecompanyneedstoupgradeitstechnologyinnovationstocompetebetterwiththeemergingtechnologies.Therecanbe no assurance that Qualcomm will succeed in developing, implementing and marketing new technologies, products, services orenhancementsinareasonabletime,orthattheywillgainmarketacceptance.Inabilitytoupgradetothenewtechnologiesmayaffectthecompany'scompetitivenessandtheresultsofoperations.Thecompanymayemployanumberofstrategiestoreducetechnologicalrisk,buttherapidrateatwhichnewtechnologiesareemerging,exposesthecompanytoinventoryobsolescencerisks.Investigationrelatedtoallegedanti-monopolypracticesThecompany issubjecttothe investigationrelatedtoallegedanti-monopolypractices. In2015,Qualcommagreedtopayafineof$975millionaspartofa14-monthgovernment investigation intoanti-competitivepractices.Asper thedeal, thecompanymayalso lower itsroyaltyratesbyaroundathirdonpatentsusedinChina.TheNationalDevelopmentandReformCommission(NDRC)probedisruptedthecompany'sbusinessinChinaandfostereddisputeswithexistinglicenseesandcausedotherfirmstodelaysigningnewlicenses.Similarly,in2015,Genitop,whichdevelopsChinesecharacterinformationprocessingsoftwareandsemiconductorchips,suedQualcommforinfringingitsChina-registeredtrademarks.Thecompanyisseekingapenaltyof$100billioninadministrativepenaltyand$16millionforusingGenitop'strademark.

The company's involvement inmonopoly offenses and other lawsuits would negatively impact the company's business and its growthprospectsinChina.ItwouldalsohaveanadverseeffectonthebrandimageofQualcomm.

Marginofsafety:“Whereisthevalue/Moat”-“Devilisinthedetails”

ThependulumalwaysswingsfromirrationalexuberancetounjustifiablepessimismandrightnowMr.marketisunjustifiablypessimisticabouttheQCOM’sprice.Grahamsuggests”TheIntelligentInvestordreadsabullmarketandwelcomesabearmarket”andhenceinmyopinionQCOMisattherightpurchasingpriceof$52.78sinceMr.Market’swildpricinginconsistencieshaswildlyundervaluedQCOMstock.AlsosinceGrahamshunsuponusingonlypastperformanceasamajordecision-makingtoolfortheInvestor,ItriedtolookattheprospectiveabilityofQCOMtowhetherpastthisstormsbeforechoosingitforvalueinvestments.Furthermore,GrahaminhisexampleofEmhartCorp.andELTRA’stalksaboutitsattractivelypricedstocksrelativetoP/EandbookvalueandbecauseofbothhavingstableearningsbringssimilaritytowhatQCOMisofferingtoitspotentialinvestorstoday.HistakeofbuyingrelativelylargecompaniesthatarecurrentlyunpopulartomakelargereturnsorbybuyingbargainissuestomakeoutsizedreturnsfitswellwithQCOMcurrentscenario.Henceinmyhumbleopinion,QCOMisdefinitelyaninvestmentbuyatthispointthatisitpresentsupsidethroughQuantitativeanalysisandpromisessafetyofprincipalwithanadequatereturn.AlsoasavalueInvestorInvestingonthebasisofprojectionisoftenconsideredasafool’serrand;Investingonthebasisofprotectionisthebestsolution”andthatbringstomynextthesisi.e.QCOM’sfutureprospectsanditseffectiveness.5GEconomy:“Ayetnewdiasporaforthecommunicationequipment’stechnologies”TherecentfocusforQualcommhasbeenin5GtechnologieswhichgiveitenoughadvantageoveranyplayerinthemarketthatarestilllackingthetechnicalskillstooutperformQCOMineven3Gand$Gspace.Itisestimatedthat%Geconomywillgrowthto$12trillionby2035andwithQCOMhavingthefirstmoveradvantagewithgrabthebiggestpiefromthistechnology.

Source:2017AnnualShareholderMeetingPresentation

Page 9: Qualcomm Equity Research Report Kashif Anwer...Qualcomm Incorporated Archetypal Graham/ Buffett Value Check for QCOM QCOM is the largest communication equipment company in the world

9

Long Equity Report- Applied Portfolio Management | Analyst: Kashif Anwer

Acquisition:“Amarriagemadeinheaven”PertherecentupdateinQ22017earningcall,itisalmostconfirmedthattheacquisitionwilltakeplaceasithaspassedtheHSRapprovalProcess.Withthis,theanticipatedsynergiesbetweenthetwocomeintoplay(oftheorderof835mllion)inadditiontotheextrarevenuegrowthpotentialfromtheNXPbusinessinautomotiveandIoTspace.

Source:2017AnnualShareholderMeetingPresentationSnapdragon&QualcommCentriq2400:“Futureisbright”Qualcommunveiledanew835Snapdragonprocessor,thefirsteverunder10-nanometers,earlierthisyear.TheSnapdragon820and821arefoundinhigh-endAndroidsmartphonesliketheGooglePixel,SamsungGalaxyS7Edge,LGV20,HTC10,andBlackBerry'sAndroiddevice.Executivestoldanalyststhatdemandfor10nanometerchipsisexceedingsupply.

Source:2017AnnualShareholderMeetingPresentationQCOM-“what’sthemanagementvision”Withthecleardirectionfromthemanagementastowherethecompanyisheadedintheyearstocomeconfirmsthemanagementexpertiseandvisionforthefuture.

Source:2017AnnualShareholderMeetingPresentation

Page 10: Qualcomm Equity Research Report Kashif Anwer...Qualcomm Incorporated Archetypal Graham/ Buffett Value Check for QCOM QCOM is the largest communication equipment company in the world

10

Long Equity Report- Applied Portfolio Management | Analyst: Kashif Anwer

InvestmentSummary

ForecastAssumptionsIestimategoingforwardandforF2017revenuewillgrowat11%eachyear(bybeingveryconservationonthesideofcaution).Thisincreaseinrevenueis justifiedbyQCOM’schipsetandlicensingbusiness,wherequalityassuranceisthethemeofthedayandQCOMhavinghadenoughcloutandinnovationgoinginfavorofitsproductslendssolidreasoningtoitsincreasedrevenuegrowth.Fordividends,Iassumedgrowthat8%,whichisakeymanagementgoalforQCOMandusuallyconferswiththetrend.Iamalsoexpecting,QCOMtoachieveitsgoalofspendinganaverageof$2.5-3.5billionayearongrowthCapExand$5.2–8BilliononR&D.

ValuationusingComparableMyP/EComparablemodel resulted ina targetpriceof$99.02per share.For thisestimate,weusedanestimated industryaverageP/Emultipleof26xandEarningsof$5,705forQCOMfordilutedsharesoutstandingof1.98billion,whichreturnedQCOM’sprojectedprice.ThepeergrouphasbeentakenfromMorningstarandthosethathavebeencitedbymanagementasusefulinperformancecomparisonssinceeachcompanyinthegroupoperatesinatechnologysectorweselectedtheP/Eforthesemiconductorindustry.IconductedaP/Esensitivityanalysiswhichshowsdiscountateventhecurrentlevel.

PEGValuationMyevaluationofQCOMonaPEGbasisrevealsanimplieddiscountof33%.Thisequatestoapotentialsharepriceof$69.93andamultipleof10.8Xoneyearforwardearnings.

QCOM PEG Ratio 1.53 10 Year Average Growth Rate (Model) 16.00%

1 Year Forward P/E (04/14/17) 10.8

PEG Calculation: 0.675

Implied Discount= 33%

Current Share Price (04/14/17) $52.78

PEG Implied Price $69.93

72% 74%69%

31%

64%68%

74% 70% 67%

45%47%

0%10%20%30%40%50%60%70%80%

DividenedPayoutRatio

AnalysisatVariousPrices-TradingComps-EarningP/E 16.00x 18.00x 20.00x 22.00x 24.00x 26.00x 28.00x 30.00x 32.00x 34.00x 36.00xQCOMLTMearnings $5,705 $5,705 $5,705 $5,705 $5,705 $5,705 $5,705 $5,705 $5,705 $5,705 $5,705EquityValue $91,280 $102,690 $114,100 $125,510 $136,920 $148,330 $159,740 $171,150 $182,560 $193,970 $205,380FDShsOut 1,498 1,498 1,498 1,498 1,498 1,498 1,498 1,498 1,498 1,498 1,498Valuepershare $60.93 $68.55 $76.17 $83.79 $91.40 $99.02 $106.64 $114.25 $121.87 $129.49 $137.10

Page 11: Qualcomm Equity Research Report Kashif Anwer...Qualcomm Incorporated Archetypal Graham/ Buffett Value Check for QCOM QCOM is the largest communication equipment company in the world

11

Long Equity Report- Applied Portfolio Management | Analyst: Kashif Anwer

UnleveredFreeCashFlow(UFCF)ModelTheUnleveredFreeCashFlow(UFCF)ModelresultedinatargetPriceof$58.34,whichsuggeststhatQCOMissellingatadiscountof9.4%withrespecttoitscurrentprice$52.78.Theanalysisisdonebyconsideringtheperpetualgrowthof1%pertheAswathDamodaransitewhiletherateofdebtat3%,calculatedassumproductofalltheavailabledebtsandrateofequitycalculatedusingamarketpremiumof3.74%andabetaof1.5.

CapEx&ResearchanddevelopmentCapExandresearch&developmenthasbecomeagreaterexpenseforQCOMsinceitsinceptionandcontinuestoincreaseatahighrate.However,withanincreaseinrevenueatamuchfasterratethecapitalintensityisstillreducedasanetresult.From2006–16,CapExintensityisreducedsignificantlybecauseofbetteroperationalefficienciesaswellaswithlowinvestmentinrequiredforoperationalbusiness.Ontheother hand, research & development spending increased at a rough rate of 10% p.a and is expected to increase even further withmanagement’svisiontopivotitsbusinesstobetterpositionitselfinIoTandAutomotivespace.Through2018,QCOMplanstospendonitslatest5Gtechnologyadvancementandhence,asaresult,IhaveassumedCapExtoincreaseonanaverageof9%ongoingforwardbasis.

FreeCashFlowAnalysisQCOM possessedpositiveFCFFalmostalltheyearssinceinceptionexcludingtheyears2008and2009andIexpectthesamein2017;However,theFCFFperthemodellingwilldeclineintheyearstocomeduetoitsrecentdebtfinancingforitsNXPacquisitionandsincetheoperatingworkingcapitalalmostunchangedforthenextfiveyearsandbusinessgeneratingenoughcashtomanageitsdebtloadandavailableanticipatedsynergiesintheNXPdeal.Thevaluationstandsbetterthanitisrightnow.OverthelastdecadethisishowtheirEV/FCFmultipleshavelookedattheendofthefinancialyear:

ΔinOthernon-currentliabilities 445 409 454 504 559

UnleveredFCFs $6,156 $3,503 $3,813 $4,172 $4,583

TerminalValueGrowthrate 1.00%

Discountrate(WACC) 6.05%

TerminalValue $91,654 TimingToday YearEnd Diff Year Factor

Discountingmodel 4/14/17 9/25/17 164 365.25 0.449Mid-yearconvention YESYearcount 0.225 1.225 2.225 3.225 4.225Discountdenominator 0.987 0.931 0.878 0.827 0.780PVofFreeCashFlow $6,076 $3,260 $3,346 $3,452 $3,576

PVofFCFs $19,708PVofTerminalValue 71,512TEV(TotalEnterpriseValue) $91,221

Short-termdebt $1,749

Long-termdebt 9,935

Totaldebt $11,684

RequiredCash $7,849

ExcessCash 0

TotalCash $7,849

Convertible/Preferred 0

MinorityInterests (10)

EquityValue $87,396DilutedSharesOutstanding 1,498

Valuepershare $58.34CurrentPrice(3/15/17) $52.78

Premium/(Discount)toIntrinsicValue (9.5%)Rating BUY

0.00%2.00%4.00%6.00%8.00%

10.00%12.00%

R&Dgrowth

-20.00%-15.00%-10.00%

-5.00%0.00%5.00%

10.00%15.00%

capexgrowth

Page 12: Qualcomm Equity Research Report Kashif Anwer...Qualcomm Incorporated Archetypal Graham/ Buffett Value Check for QCOM QCOM is the largest communication equipment company in the world

12

Long Equity Report- Applied Portfolio Management | Analyst: Kashif Anwer

Thebasicaveragesitsat18.8.However,againadjustingforoutliersoutfor2008and2009leavesuswithanadjustedaverageof18exactly.Usingthefinancialmodel,IemergewithFCFestimatesof$6.95billionand$6.15billionforthisyearandthenext.Averagingthese(giving$6.55billion),feedingthisbackintotheEV/FCFcalculation.TheFCFfairvalueresultsinthesharepriceof$79.1.Atthecurrentsharepriceof$52.78,QCOMcouldadvanceabout70%ormorebeforeevenhittingitsFCFfairvalue.InterestExpense,TaxesandInvestmentIncome:RecentLeverage,DeferredTaxAssets,andInvestmentPerformanceQCOM’semphasisonitsstrongbalancesheetandcommitmenttoaninvestmentgraderating

makeitunlikelythatthecompanywillissue

furtherdebtinthenextsixyears.Furthermore,thecompanyraised$10bnindebtin2015and$11bn2016andhasstatedgoalsofpreservingstrategicflexibilityandacommitmenttoreturnaminimumof75%ofFCFtostockholders,

makinganyearlydebtretirementsunlikely. I

appliedtheweightedaverageinterestrateof3%toQCOM’sremaininglong-termdebtbalancebasedonitsdebtscheduletoprojectinterest

expensethrough2021.

QCOMhad17%taxratein2016onits10-kannualreport/earningscall,andgiventhehistoricalreliabilityofitsprojections,Iprojecteda17%taxratefor2016,closetoitsfive-yearhistoricalaveragerateof17%.

QCOMhas federal net operating loss carry forwardsof $366mmasof September 27, 2015, expiring from2021-2033, unused state netoperatinglosscarryforwardsof$696mmexpiringfrom2016-2035,andunusedforeignnetoperatinglosscarryforwardsof$413mmexpiringfrom2019-2024.Inthecompany’s10-K,itstatesthatit“doesnotexpectitsfederalnetoperatinglosscarryforwardstoexpireunused,“whichIinterpretasthecompanyisonlyexpectingtoutilizeitsfederalNOLcarryforwardsintheforeseeablefuture.Therefore,IassumethatthefederalNOLswillbeutilizedevenlyineveryyearfrom2017-2033,whentheyexpire,amountingto$21.5mmannuallyintaxsavings.Iassumedthattaxprovisionsfrom2017-2021willequal17%*EBT.Iprojectedinvestmentincomeequalto3%ofrevenuesfrom2016-2021,slightlybelowthefive-yearhistoricalaverageof4.17%,asthecompanyexpectstogeneratelowerinterestanddividendincomeaswellasloweredrealizedgainsin2017duetorebalancing,atrendIconservativelyestimatewillpersist.IprojectdepreciationandamortizationwillremainatahistoricalaverageasapercentageofPPEandIntangiblesrespectivelybecauseIdonotforeseethecapitalintensityofthebusinessshiftingdramaticallyoverthenextfiveyears.

22.2x

32.1x

11.3x

19.3x 17.9x21.6x

13.9x 15.1x18.7x

15.6x

0.0x

5.0x

10.0x

15.0x

20.0x

25.0x

30.0x

35.0x

9/25/07 9/25/08 9/27/09 9/26/10 9/25/11 9/25/12 9/25/13 9/25/14 9/25/15 9/25/16

EV/FCFratio

1204 1399 1601 1816 2046

0

500

1000

1500

2000

2500

9/25/17 9/25/18 9/25/19 9/25/20 9/25/21

ProjectedIncomeTax(inmillions)

705 782 868 964 1070

0200400600800

10001200

9/25/17 9/25/18 9/25/19 9/25/20 9/25/21

ProjectedInvestmentIncome(inmillion)

Page 13: Qualcomm Equity Research Report Kashif Anwer...Qualcomm Incorporated Archetypal Graham/ Buffett Value Check for QCOM QCOM is the largest communication equipment company in the world

13

Long Equity Report- Applied Portfolio Management | Analyst: Kashif Anwer

BlendedWeightedValuationQCOM’sgrowthprofileisuniqueandwarrantedablendedapproachtoimpliedP/Eandforecastedprice.Weightingswereassignedtoeachvaluationmethodologyinordertoaverageouttheabnormalitiesintheimpliedresult.EqualweightswereassignedtoPEG,FCFvaluation,and Comparative P/E approaches. A lesser weight was assigned to the DCF valuation as themodel tends to underestimate estimatecompanieswithnegativerecentgrowth.Basedonthisanalysis,IbelieveafairmultipleforQCOMis18.95xoneyearforwardearnings.Thismultiplewouldresultinamarketpriceof$76.03,whichisa44%increasefromthecurrentsharepriceof$52.78.Atcurrentlevels,thestockissoattractive;BuffetandGraham,ifhewasalive,wouldbreakfromtheirstanceoninvestinginthetechnologysectoranddelveintoitforthisincrediblebuyingopportunity.

DuPontROEAssessmentROEisanextendedportionoftheROAratio.Theonlyadditiontothisratioistheleverage(debt).Leveragecanmagnifybothgainsandlosses.Toomuchleverageinpooreconomicenvironmentscanprovetobelethal.Similarly,itisimportanttonotethemediumofdebtfortheactualanalysisofmanagement’stakeonthefutureofthecompany.Ifthereistoomuchofshort-termdebtwrttolong-termdebtitagainsendsthewrongsignalaboutthefuturesustainabilityofthefirm.TheLeverageRatioofQCOMisveryconsistentupuntil2014andhasrecentlytakendebtinmyopiniontoleveragethealreadyconduciveenvironmentoflow-interestrate.OnecouldsuggestthatQCOM’smanagementknowsitsownbusinesscycleandassuchhastakenoutdebtsothatitcanmagnifythecurrenteconomicupwardtrendintoitsprofitabilityandalsoinvestinthefuturedirectionofIoTandAutomotivespace,whichisevidentfromitsacquisitionofNXP.PayoutRatioQCOM’spayoutratiodecreasedbetween2014and2016,duetoanincreaseinEPS,whilethedividendgrewatasecurerate.InQ22017,QCOM’spayoutratioof47%wasoneofthehighestamongitspeers.Overthenexttwelvemonths,IforecastthatQCOMwillpossessapayoutratioofroughly50-55%asapprovedbytheBoard.KeyRatiosInassessingprofitability,QCOMhasperformedverywellandisfirstinitspeergroupforgrossmargin,profitmargin,EBITmargin,andROE.Within our forecasts, I still expectQCOM to hold this lead among its competitors. SinceQCOM’s revenues have suffered fromnegativegrowth in the last twoyears, thesemeasures imply thatQCOMhasabove-averageproficiency incost-control.For long-termsolvency,QCOMstandssolidlywithcloseto$30billionincash,cashequivalents,andmarketablesecurities.QCOMhasbeguntotakedebttofinanceitsNXPacquisitionbuteventhenonlystandsat12%oftotalcapitalwhichisslightlyhigherforthetechnologyindustryonanaverageand itspeergroup ingeneral. IamoptimisticmanagementwilluseQCOMtostrategize itsbusiness fromsmartphonestoadditionalsegmentssuchasautomotiveandIoTandpivotitsvisiontogreaterprofitability.

9,4068,019 7,528 7,069 6,619

0

5,000

10,000

9/25/17 9/25/18 9/25/19 9/25/20 9/25/21

Projecteddebtcomponent(inmillion)

450 500 555 616 684

0

500

1000

9/25/17 9/25/18 9/25/19 9/25/20 9/25/21

ProjectedDefferedTaxassets(inmillion)

Valuationapproach ImpliedMultiple PriceForecast Weighings ComponentDCF 13 58.34 15% 8.75FCFF 18 79.1 21% 16.81P/ERelative 26 99.02 21% 21.04P/EComparative 18 68.55 21% 14.57PEG 18 69.93 21% 14.86Total 18.95x $76.03

Page 14: Qualcomm Equity Research Report Kashif Anwer...Qualcomm Incorporated Archetypal Graham/ Buffett Value Check for QCOM QCOM is the largest communication equipment company in the world

14

Long Equity Report- Applied Portfolio Management | Analyst: Kashif Anwer

KEYINVESTMENTRISKS

Firm-SpecificRisksQCOMisheavilyinvestedandcurrentlycommittingitselfintofuturetechnologies(5G,(IoT),connectedcars).Inasense,it’spositiveasitdiversifiestheproductlandscapeforQCOMhoweverifitdoesn’tbearfruititwillbeadownhillroadforQCOM.Inaddition,thecompetitionisgettingmoreintenseinQCTspacewithIntelandNVIDIAvyingformoremarketshareeverydayandupgradingtheirproductqualitytomatchQCOM’s.InarecenttestofprocessorperformanceofQCOMandIntelbasedIphone7revealsQCOMprocessorisstillfarbetterthantheintel’s.LegalRisks:QCOMfacesnumerouslawsuits,multiplelawsuitsfiledbyAppleandantitrustlitigation.BBRYannounceditwonanarbitrationoveranexistingcapclauseonroyalties.AsBBRYdoesnolongersellsmartphones,itwasintheirinteresttopursuetheargument.TheamountawardedtoBBRYisUSD815mln.Althoughtheheadlineslookscary,thisisactuallyaveryimmaterialeventforQCOM.TheUSD815mlnisactuallylessthan1%ofitsEVandreallyisaone-offeventrevolvingaroundasingleissueinaspecificcontractforsubscriberunitsbetween2010and2015.QCOMrestatedthateach licenseagreement isunique.ThisbringsustotheAAPL lawsuits, therealdangerof the lawsuits is theirpossibledisruptionoftheroyaltymodelforessentialpatentsbaseduponthevalueoftheentiredeviceratherthanaroyaltybasedupontheincrementalvalueoftheuseofthepatentsthatisbroughttothedevice.

ItismyopinionthatQCOMwilldefendthismodelatallcostsandratheragreeonaformulathatlowerstherateoftheroyalty.ThisiswhatQCOM did when the Chinese regulators challenged them. In a way, this adds to the price pressure and competitive dynamics of thefragmentedandhigh-techsmartphoneandsmartphonecomponentsmarketandhenceQCOMisdoingtheonethingthatreallyhelpsthem,i.e.diversifyingtowardsotherendmarkets(automotive)andpositioningforfuturetechnologies(5G,(IoT),connectedcars).

62.2% 61.7% 62.0% 62.0% 62.0% 62.0% 62.0% 62.0%

32.8% 27.6% 33.6% 31.4% 31.4% 31.4% 31.4% 31.4%

28.5%22.8%

27.6% 26.1% 27.2% 27.9% 28.3% 28.6%

10.8%11.4%

11.8% 10.2% 10.1% 10.3% 10.4% 10.5%

0.00%

20.00%

40.00%

60.00%

80.00%

100.00%

120.00%

140.00%

160.00%

KeyRatios

Grossmargin EBITDAmargin EBITmargin Profitmargin

5.9% 5.7% 5.3% 4.9% 5.1% 5.3% 5.5% 5.6%

10.6%11.7%11.5%14.2%12.8%11.6%10.6% 9.8%

16.1%10.8%12.3%12.6%13.8%14.6%15.1%15.5%

0%

10%

20%

30%

40%

50%

60%

70%

80%

90%

100%

Performanceratios

ROA ROE ROIC

Page 15: Qualcomm Equity Research Report Kashif Anwer...Qualcomm Incorporated Archetypal Graham/ Buffett Value Check for QCOM QCOM is the largest communication equipment company in the world

15

Long Equity Report- Applied Portfolio Management | Analyst: Kashif Anwer

RECOMMENDATIONSUMMARY

IbelieveofflatetechnologysectorisgoneoutoffavorfromtheInvestorspartlybecausethevaluationisnotthatwellunderstoodfortechnologystocksandpartlybecausetechnologyissoeverchangingthatyoucan’tinvestbasedonlyonthecurrentfundamentalsasitcanbemisleadingrepresentationforthefuture.However,inmyopinionasaninvestorthiscommonbeliefhaspresentedauniquescenariotoinvestinQCOM,avaluestockinthissectorwhileit isstillcheapandoutofsightfromthemajorinvestors.Alsoifhistoryisanyindicationoffuturethenwithreducedtaxandderegulation,theTechnologysectorisexpectedtodobetterthanthemostwhichcanbeseenfromtheindexforthismeasurethathasbeenbutincreasing,reflectingitsincreasinggrowthpotential.

ForQCOM,thecompanydoesnotneedtogrowearningsanywhereneartheestimated9-11%toprovideinvestorswithahealthytotalreturnoverthenextcoupleofyears.Shareholder’stotalreturnisdrivenbydividendyield+earningsgrowth+/-P/Emultiplecontractions.ForQCOM,thecurrentforwardyieldof3.7%andthesignificantsharebuybacks(assumingaconservative2.5%for2017)provideasolidbasereturnof6.2%p.a.,therapidlygrowingaddressablemarketshouldallowQCOMtogroweveninadversebusinessconditionsatleastatamodestrateof4%.ThetrailingP/Eof16.4(fwd.P/E10.8)isbelowthe10-yearmedianof19.0andfarbelowtheindustryaverage(27x)aswellastheS&P500(21.1x).WiththeP/Emultipleattheselevels,Idon'texpectacontraction,whichsetsupinvestorsforaveryhealthydouble-digitreturnorattheminimumatleastahighsingledigit.

TheequitycaseforQualcommoffersasymmetricrisk.Theveryattractivevaluationandstrongcashflowonthebackofitsstrongmarketpositioninastillexpanding3G/4Gmarket limitthedownsidewhilsttheupsidecanbehuge,propelledbytheNXPtakeoverandopportunitiesfromexponential growth technologies such as autonomous cars. Shareholderswilling to invest in a value stock and sit through the short-termuncertaintystandcanexpectadouble-digittotalreturnwhichisrareinthecurrentexpensivemarkets.AccordingtoGraham,“Sincetheprofitsthatacompanycanearnarefinite,thepricethatinvestorsshouldbewillingtopayforstocksmustalsobefinite”andhenceIrecommendanypricelessthan52.78isabuyopportunity.Also,QCOMfitstheGraham’scriteriaofa“large,prominent,andconservativelyfinanced”companywithamarketcapexceeding$77billion.AndashesaysNeverjust“Buywhatyouknow”,unlessyouhavedoneyourhomeworkandunderstandwhyitisworthowningthiscompanyandthereforeIbelievewithrespecttothehomeworkthatIhavedoneinthisreport“ItissafetosaygolongwithQCOMwithanupsidepotentialof48%.

Page 16: Qualcomm Equity Research Report Kashif Anwer...Qualcomm Incorporated Archetypal Graham/ Buffett Value Check for QCOM QCOM is the largest communication equipment company in the world

16

Long Equity Report- Applied Portfolio Management | Analyst: Kashif Anwer

Appendix:

1. “TheIntelligentInvestor,TheDefinitiveBookonValueInvesting”;BenjaminGraham;Harper;FirstCollinsBusinessEssentialsEdition,2006

2. https://www.qualcomm.com/info/investor-relations

3. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Qualcomm

4. http://www.researchnester.com/reports/internet-of-things-iot-market-global-demand-growth-analysis-opportunity-outlook-2023/216

5. https://www.statista.com/statistics/283333/compound-annual-growth-rate-smartphone-shipments/

6. http://www.reuters.com/finance/stocks/overview?symbol=QCOM.O

7. https://seekingalpha.com/article/4063786-qualcomm-beats-earnings-buy

8. https://finance.yahoo.com/quote/qcom?ltr=1

9. https://seekingalpha.com/news/3248327-apple-files-lawsuit-qualcomm-united-kingdom

10. http://www.morningstar.com/stocks/xnas/qcom/quote.html

11. HiSiliconandSpreadtrumareprivatecompanies.12. Factset.13. https://ycharts.com/companies/QCOM14. http://finviz.com/quote.ashx?t=QCOM&ty=c&p=d&b=115. AswathDamodaranatNYUStern.16. Bloomberg.17. QCOM10-K’s.18. CreditSuisseSemiconductorTeam–March10,2016.19. JPMorganEquityResearch–March14,2016.20. http://www.investopedia.com/features/industryhandbook/semiconductor.asp21. http://www.valueline.com/Stocks/Industry_Report.aspx?id=10175#.WPrm-FLMyCQ22. http://www.pwc.com/gx/en/industries/technology/publications/semiconductor-industry-analysis-and-projections.html23. https://www.zacks.com/commentary/100510/semiconductor-industry-outlook---january-201724. http://www.mckinsey.com/industries/semiconductors/our-insights25. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Telecommunications_equipment26. http://news.thomasnet.com/news/communication-systems-equipment27. http://www.nasdaq.com/symbol/qcom/news-headlines28. http://www.nasdaq.com/article/3-lowest-pe-stocks-today1-cm77712329. https://ub.rdinvesting.com/news/?ticker=QCOM30. http://www.cnbc.com/2017/04/19/qualcomm-earnings-q2-2017.html31. http://beta.fortune.com/fortune500/qualcomm-11032. https://www.bloomberg.com/quote/QCOM:US33. https://www.qualcomm.com/news/releases/2012/06/28/qualcomm-announces-plans-implement-new-corporate-structure34. https://blogs.wsj.com/cfo/2016/10/27/qualcomm-creating-subsidiary-to-avoid-nxp-tax-hit/35. https://www.qualcomm.com/products/snapdragon36. https://www.qualcomm.com/products/snapdragon/processors/comparison37. http://www.pcadvisor.co.uk/new-product/mobile-phone/snapdragon-835-specs-features-meet-chip-that-will-power-2017-

flagships-3649321/38. http://www.androidauthority.com/snapdragon-820-phones-683041/39. http://www.theinquirer.net/inquirer/news/2478197/galaxy-s8-tipped-to-pack-octa-core-qualcomm-snapdragon-835-processor40. http://www.pcworld.com/article/2990868/qualcomm-enters-server-cpu-market-with-24-core-arm-chip.html41. http://www.datacenterknowledge.com/archives/2016/12/07/intels-new-nemesis-qualcomm-shows-off-10-nm-server-processor/42. http://www.techradar.com/news/qualcomms-new-cpu-will-give-amd-and-intel-nightmares43. http://www.rcrwireless.com/20170106/chips/qualcomm-launches-mobile-processor-for-5g-tag444. http://www.tomshardware.com/news/qualcomm-debuts-10nm-processor-48-cores,33151.html45. https://www.forbes.com/sites/aarontilley/2016/12/07/microsoft-is-making-full-windows-10-run-on-mobile-processor-from-

qualcomm/#3833fe7c401946. https://www.quora.com/What-is-Qualcomm-Snapdragon-and-what-is-it-used-for47. http://www.foxbusiness.com/markets/2016/07/20/qualcomm-revenue-rises-from-snapdragon-processor-demand.html

Page 17: Qualcomm Equity Research Report Kashif Anwer...Qualcomm Incorporated Archetypal Graham/ Buffett Value Check for QCOM QCOM is the largest communication equipment company in the world

17

Long Equity Report- Applied Portfolio Management | Analyst: Kashif Anwer

Glossary

• RFFE–RadioFrequencyFrontEndProducts,whichconsistofallcomponentsinthereceiverofaradioreceivercircuitthatprocessthesignalattheoriginalincomingradiofrequencybeforeitisconvertedtoalowerintermediatefrequency

• IoT–InternetofThings,networkofphysicalobjectsembeddedwithelectronics,software,sensorsandnetworkconnectivitythatenablestheseobjectstocollectandexchangedata

• CDMA–CodeDivisionMultipleAccess,achannelaccessmethodusedbyvariousradiocommunicationtechniques

• WCDMA–WidebandCodeDivisionMultipleAccess,basedonCDMAtechnologybutisa3GtechnologythatincreasesdatatransmissionratesinGSMsystemsbyusingCDMAairinterfaceinsteadofTDMA

• QTL–QualcommTechnologyLicensing,referstoQualcomm’soperatingsegmentthatgrantslicensesorotherwiseprovidesrightstouseportionsofourintellectualpropertyportfolio

• QCT–QualcommCDMATechnologies,referstoQualcomm’soperatingsegmentthatisaleadingdeveloperandsupplierofintegratedcircuitsandsystemsoftwarebasedonCDMA,OFDMAandothertechnologiesforuseinvoiceanddatacommunications,networking,applicationprocessing,multimediaandglobalpositioningsystemproducts

• TDK–Japanesemultinationalelectronicscompanythatmanufactureselectronicmaterials,electroniccomponents,andrecordinganddata-storagemedia

• RF360Holdings–JointVentureintheRadioFrequencyFrontEndspacebetweenTDKCorp.andQualcomm

• SAM–ServiceableAddressableMarket,marketopportunitythatexistswithinafirm’sexistingcorecompetenciesand/orpastperformance

• ASP–AverageSellingPrice

Page 18: Qualcomm Equity Research Report Kashif Anwer...Qualcomm Incorporated Archetypal Graham/ Buffett Value Check for QCOM QCOM is the largest communication equipment company in the world

18

Long Equity Report- Applied Portfolio Management | Analyst: Kashif Anwer

FinancialModel:

QualcommIncomeStatement(USDinmillions,exceptpersharedata)

9/25/14 9/25/15 9/25/16 9/25/17 9/25/18 9/25/19 9/25/20 9/25/21

Revenues:Equipmentandservices 18625 17079 15467Licensing 7862 8202 8087

* TotalRevenues 26487 25281 23554 26145 29021 32213 35757 39690CleanCostofRevenues 10020 9686 8944 9945 11039 12253 13601 15097

* GrossProfit 16467 15595 14610 16200 17982 19960 22155 24593CleanResearchandDevelopment 5136 5124 4725 5205 5777 6413 7118 7901CleanSelling,generalandadministrative 2147 2188 2188 2270 2520 2797 3105 3446Otherexpenses 484 1293 (226) 521 579 642 713 791

* EBITDA 8700 6990 7923 8204 9106 10108 11220 12454Depreciation&Amortizatiion 1150 1214 1428 1367 1220 1132 1091 1086

* EBIT 7550 5776 6495 6836 7886 8975 10129 11367InterestExpense,net (5) (104) (297) (247) (193) (144) (93) (43)InvestmentIncome,net 1233 815 635 705 782 868 964 1070

* Incomefromcontinuingoperationsbeforeincometaxes 8778 6487 6833 7294 8475 9700 11000 12394Incometaxexpense 1244 1219 1131 1204 1399 1601 1816 2046

* Incomefromcontinuingoperations 7534 5268 5702 6090 7076 8099 9184 10349Discontinuedoperations,netofIncometax 430 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

* NetIncome 7964 5268 5702 6090 7076 8099 9184 10349NetLossattributabletononcontrollinginterests 3 3 3 3 3 4 4 5

* NetIncomeattributabletoQualcomm 7967 5271 5705 6093 7080 8103 9189 10353

BasicearningspershareattributabletoqualcommContinuingoperations 4.48 3.26 3.84DiscontinuedOperations 0.25 0 0NetIncome 4.73 3.26 3.84 4.11 4.77 5.46 6.19 6.98

DilutedearningspershareattributabletoqualcommContinuingoperations 4.4 3.22 3.81DiscontinuedOperations 0.25 0 0NetIncome 4.65 3.22 3.81 4.07 4.73 5.41 6.13 6.91

SharesusedinpersharecalculationsBasic 1683 1618 1484 1484 1484 1484 1484 1484Diluted 1714 1639 1498 1498 1498 1498 1498 1498

Dividendspershareannounced 1.54 1.8 2.02 1.94 2.26 2.58 2.93 3.30

ProjectedHistorical

Page 19: Qualcomm Equity Research Report Kashif Anwer...Qualcomm Incorporated Archetypal Graham/ Buffett Value Check for QCOM QCOM is the largest communication equipment company in the world

19

Long Equity Report- Applied Portfolio Management | Analyst: Kashif Anwer

QualcommBalanceSheet(USDinmillions,exceptpersharedata)

9/25/06 9/27/07 9/28/08 9/27/09 9/26/10 9/25/11 9/25/12 9/25/13 9/25/14 9/25/15 9/25/16Assets:Cashandcashequivalents 1607 2411 1840 2717 3547 5462 3807 6142 7907 7560 5946Marketablesecurities 4114 4170 4571 8352 6732 6190 8567 8824 9658 9761 12702Accountsreceivable,net 700 715 4187 700 730 993 1459 2142 2412 1964 2219Inventories 250 469 521 453 528 765 1030 1302 1458 1492 1556Defferedtaxassets 235 435 289 149 321 537 309 573 577 635 0Collateralheldundersecuritieslending 0 421 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Othercurrentassets 143 200 464 199 275 346 473 572 401 687 558Totalcurrentassets 7049 8821 11872 12570 12133 14293 15645 19555 22413 22099 22981Marketablesecurities 4228 5234 4858 6673 8123 9261 14463 14440 14457 13626 13702Defferedtaxassets 512 318 830 843 1922 1703 1412 1059 1174 1453 2030Assetsheldforsale 0 0 0 0 0 746 1109 72 0 0 0Property,Plantandequipment,net 1482 1788 2162 2387 2373 2414 2851 2995 2487 2534 2306Goodwill 1230 1325 1517 1492 1488 3432 3917 3976 4488 5479 5679Otherintangibleassets,net 0 664 3104 3065 3022 3099 2938 2553 2580 3742 3500Otherassets 707 345 369 415 1511 1474 677 866 975 1863 2161Totalassets 15208 18495 24712 27445 30572 36422 43012 45516 48574 50796 52359

Liabilities And Sharehlders' EquityTradeaccountspayable 420 635 570 636 764 969 1298 1554 2183 1300 1858Payrollandotherbenefitsrelatedliabilities 273 311 406 480 467 644 664 839 802 861 934Unearnedrevenues 197 218 394 441 623 610 545 501 785 583 509NEWREVOLVERShort-termdebt 0 0 0 0 1086 994 1072 0 0 1000 1749IncomeTaxesPayable 137 119 227 29 1443 0 0 0 0 0 0ObligationundersecuritiesLending 0 421 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Liabilitiesheldforsale 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Othercurrentliabilities 395 554 1070 1227 1085 2072 1723 2319 2243 2356 2261TotalcurrentLiabilities 1422 2258 2667 2813 5468 5289 5302 5213 6013 6100 7311Unearnedrevenues 141 142 3768 3464 3485 3541 3739 3666 2967 2496 2377Long-termdebt 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 9969 10008Otherliabilities 239 260 333 852 761 620 426 550 428 817 895TotalLiabilities 1802 2660 6768 7129 9714 9450 9467 9429 9408 19382 20591

Shareholers' EquityCommonStock 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 9874 7736 0 414PaidinCapital 7242 7057 7511 8493 6856 10394 11956 0 0 0 0Retainedearnings 6100 8541 10717 11235 13305 16204 20701 25461 30799 31226 30936Accumulatedothercomprehensiveincome 64 237 -284 588 697 353 866 753 634 195 428TotalQualcommstockholders'equity 13406 15835 17944 20316 20858 26951 33523 36088 39169 31421 31778Noncontrollinginterests 0 0 0 0 0 21 22 -1 -3 -7 -10Totalstockholders'equity 13406 15835 17944 20316 20858 26972 33545 36087 39166 31414 31768

Totalliabilitiesandstockholders'equity 15208 18495 24712 27445 30572 36422 43012 45516 48574 50796 52359Check 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

Page 20: Qualcomm Equity Research Report Kashif Anwer...Qualcomm Incorporated Archetypal Graham/ Buffett Value Check for QCOM QCOM is the largest communication equipment company in the world

20

Long Equity Report- Applied Portfolio Management | Analyst: Kashif Anwer

QualcommCalculations(USDinmillions,exceptpersharedata)

RetainedEarnings 9/25/14 9/25/15 9/25/16 9/25/17 9/25/18 9/25/19 9/25/20 9/25/21

Beginningbalance(previousending) 25461 30799 31226 30936 34288 38016 42283 47122

NetIncome 7967 5271 5705 6093 7080 8103 9189 10353

Dividends(fromCFS) 2629 2932 3046 2885 3351 3836 4350 4901

CumulativeeffectofadoptingFIN48 -143

ShareRepurchase 1912 2949

EndingBalance 30799 31226 30936 34288 38016 42283 47122 52574

Check 30799 31226 30936

0 0 0

IntangiblesBeginningIntangibles 2553 2580 3742 3500 2736 2138 1671 1307

NewPurchasesofIntangibles 568 1751 562 0 0 0 0 0

Amortization 541 589 804 764 597 467 365 285

EndingBalance(ActualfromStatement) 2580 3742 3500 2736 2138 1671 1307 1021

PP&EBeginningPP&E 2995 2487 2534 2449 2530 2702 2947 3253

CapitalExpenditures(ActualFromCFS) 1185 994 539 684 795 910 1032 1163

Depreciation(CalculatedBelow) 609 625 624 603 623 665 726 801

EndingBalance 2487 2534 2449 2530 2702 2947 3253 3615

2487 2534 2306

Check 0 0 143

Depreciation&Amortization(inCFS) 1150 1214 1428

Depreciation 609 625 624

Amortizationofdefinite-livedintangibleassets(D&A-D) 541 589 804

CostofProductsSold(ACTUALfromstatement) 10686 10378 9749

ResearchandDevelopment 5477 5490 5151

Selling,General&Adminsitrative(ACTUALfromstatement) 2290 2344 2385

Total 18453 18212 17285

%COGS 58% 57% 56%

%R&D 30% 30% 30%

%SG&A 12% 13% 14%

Depreciation&AmortizationinCOGS 666 692 805

Depreciation&AmortizationinR&D 341 366 426

Depreciation&AmortizationinSG&A 143 156 197

TotalDepreciation&Amortization 1150 1214 1428

CleanCOGS 10020 9686 8944

CleanR&D 5136 5124 4725

CleanSG&A 2147 2188 2188

Historical Projected

Page 21: Qualcomm Equity Research Report Kashif Anwer...Qualcomm Incorporated Archetypal Graham/ Buffett Value Check for QCOM QCOM is the largest communication equipment company in the world

21

Long Equity Report- Applied Portfolio Management | Analyst: Kashif Anwer

QualcommBalanceSheet(USDinmillions,exceptpersharedata)

9/25/14 9/25/15 9/25/16 9/25/17 9/25/18 9/25/19 9/25/20 9/25/21

Assets:Cashandcashequivalents(Required) 7907 7560 5946 7014 7786 8642 9593 10648ExcessCash 835 0 0 0 0Marketablesecurities 9658 9761 12702 11242 12479 13852 15375 17067Accountsreceivable,net 2412 1964 2219 2292 2544 2824 3134 3479Inventories 1458 1492 1556 1570 1742 1934 2147 2383Defferedtaxassets 577 635 0 450 500 555 616 684Collateralheldundersecuritieslending 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Othercurrentassets 401 687 558 575 639 709 787 873Totalcurrentassets 22413 22099 22981 23978 25689 28515 31652 35133Marketablesecurities 14457 13626 13702 15706 17434 19351 21480 23843Defferedtaxassets 1174 1453 2030 1638 1818 2019 2241 2487Assetsheldforsale 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Property,Plantandequipment,net 2487 2534 2306 2530 2702 2947 3253 3615Goodwill 4488 5479 5679 5679 5679 5679 5679 5679Otherintangibleassets,net 2580 3742 3500 2736 2138 1671 1307 1021Otherassets 975 1863 2161 1763 1956 2172 2411 2676Totalassets 48574 50796 52359 54030 57417 62354 68021 74454

Liabilities And Sharehlders' EquityTradeaccountspayable 2183 1300 1858 1856 2060 2287 2538 2817Payrollandotherbenefitsrelatedliabilities 802 861 934 902 1001 1111 1233 1369Unearnedrevenues 785 583 509 643 714 792 879 976

NEWREVOLVER 0 965 2826 4717 6619Short-termdebt 0 1000 1749 1399 1049 700 350 0IncomeTaxesPayable 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0ObligationundersecuritiesLending 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Liabilitiesheldforsale 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Othercurrentliabilities 2243 2356 2261 2387 2649 2941 3264 3623TotalcurrentLiabilities 6013 6100 7311 7186 8439 10656 12982 15405Unearnedrevenues 2967 2496 2377 2716 3015 3347 3715 4123Long-termdebt 0 9969 10008 8006 6005 4003 2002 0Otherliabilities 428 817 895 1001 1111 1233 1369 1519TotalLiabilities 9408 19382 20591 18910 18569 19239 20067 21048

Shareholers' EquityCommonStock 7736 0 414 414 414 414 414 414PaidinCapital 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Retainedearnings 30799 31226 30936 34288 38016 42283 47122 52574Accumulatedothercomprehensiveincome 634 195 428 428 428 428 428 428TotalQualcommstockholders'equity 39169 31421 31778 35130 38858 43125 47964 53416Noncontrollinginterests -3 -7 -10 -10 -10 -10 -10 -10Totalstockholders'equity 39166 31414 31768 35120 38848 43115 47954 53406

Totalliabilitiesandstockholders'equity 48574 50796 52359 54030 57417 62354 68021 74454Check 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

%ofdebt 0% 35% 37%24%

Historical Projected

Page 22: Qualcomm Equity Research Report Kashif Anwer...Qualcomm Incorporated Archetypal Graham/ Buffett Value Check for QCOM QCOM is the largest communication equipment company in the world

22

Long Equity Report- Applied Portfolio Management | Analyst: Kashif Anwer

Assumptions-Qualcomm(USDinmillions,exceptpersharedata)

9/25/14 9/25/15 9/25/16 Driver 9/25/17 9/25/18 9/25/19 9/25/20 9/25/21

IncomeStatement(nondebtitems)NetSales(growthinsales) 7% -5% -7% 11% 11% 11% 11% 11% 11%CostofRevenues(as%ofsales) 38% 38% 38% 38% 38% 38% 38% 38% 38%ResearchandDevelopment(as%ofsales) 19% 20% 20% 20% 20% 20% 20% 20% 20%CleanSelling,generalandadministrative(as%ofsales) 8% 9% 9% 9% 9% 9% 9% 9% 9%Otherexpenses(as%ofsales) 2% 5% -1% 2% 2% 2% 2% 2% 2%InvestmentIncome,net(as%ofsales) 5% 3% 3% 3% 3% 3% 3% 3% 3%Incometaxexpense(IT/PBT) 14% 19% 17% 17% 17% 17% 17% 17% 17%Discontinuedoperations,netofIncometax(as%ofsales) 2% 0% 0% 0%NetLossattributabletononcontrollinginterests(as%ofsales) 0% 0% 0% 0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0%

Gross profit margin 62% 62% 62%EBITDA margin 33% 28% 34%Income from operations (EBIT) margin 29% 23% 28%Net income margin 30% 21% 24%

Shareholder InfoBasic Shares Out 1683 1618 1484 1484 1484 1484 1484 1484 1484Diluted Shares Out 1714 1639 1498 1498 1498 1498 1498 1498 1498Dividend Payout Ratio (Dividends / Net Income) 33% 56% 53% 47% 47% 47% 47% 47% 47%

Balance Sheet (current assets):Cash and equivalents (REQUIRED) as a % of sales 30% 30% 25% 27% 27% 27% 27% 27% 27%Marketablesecurities(asa%ofsales) 36% 39% 54% 43% 43% 43% 43% 43% 43%Accountsreceivable,net(asa%ofsales) 9% 8% 9% 9% 9% 9% 9% 9% 9%Inventories(asa%ofCOGS) 15% 15% 17% 16% 16% 16% 16% 16% 16%Defferedtaxassets(asa%ofsales) 2% 3% 0% 2% 2% 2% 2% 2% 2%Collateralheldundersecuritieslending(asa%ofsales) 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0%Othercurrentassets(asa%ofsales) 2% 3% 2% 2% 2% 2% 2% 2% 2%

Balance Sheet (non-current assets):Ammortization(as % of Previous Intangibles) 21% 23% 21% 22% 22% 22% 22% 22% 22%Depreciation (as % of Previous PP&E) 20% 25% 25% 25% 25% 25% 25% 25% 25%Marketablesecurities(asa%ofsales) 55% 54% 58% 60% 60% 60% 60% 60% 60%Defferedtaxassets(asa%ofsales) 4% 6% 9% 6% 6.3% 6.3% 6.3% 6.3% 6.3%Assetsheldforsale(asa%ofsales) 0% 0% 0% 0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0% 0.0%Capital Expenditures (as a % of sales) 9% 10% 10% 11% 11.2% 11.2% 11.2% 11.2% 11.2%Goodwill (ACTUAL) 4488 5479 5679 5679 5679 5679 5679 5679 5679NewPurchasesofIntangibles 568 1751 562 0 0 0 0 0 0Otherassets(asa%ofsales) 4% 7% 9% 7% 6.7% 6.7% 6.7% 6.7% 6.7%

Balance Sheet (current liabilities):Tradeaccountspayable(asa%ofCOGS) 22% 13% 21% 19% 19% 19% 19% 19% 19%Payrollandotherbenefitsrelatedliabilities(asa%ofSales) 3% 3% 4% 3% 3% 3% 3% 3% 3%Unearnedrevenues(asa%ofSales) 3% 2% 2% 2% 2% 2% 2% 2% 2%Short-termdebt(asa%ofSales) 0% 4% 7% 7% 7% 7% 7% 7% 7%IncomeTaxesPayable(asa%ofSales) 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0%ObligationundersecuritiesLending(asa%ofSales) 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0%Liabilitiesheldforsale(asa%ofSales) 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0% 0%Othercurrentliabilities(asa%ofSales) 8% 9% 10% 9% 9% 9% 9% 9% 9%

Balance Sheet (non-current liabilities):Unearnedrevenues(asa%ofSales) 11% 10% 10% 10% 10% 10% 10% 10% 10%Long-termdebt(asa%ofSales) 0% 39% 42% 27% 27% 27% 27% 27% 27%Otherliabilities(asa%ofSales) 2% 3% 4% 4% 4% 4% 4% 4% 4%

Balance Sheet (equity):Common Stock (ACTUAL) 7736 0 414 414 414 414 414 414 414Additional paid-in capital (ACTUAL) 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0Retainedearnings 30799 31226 30936 30936Accumulated other comprehensive loss (ACTUAL) 634 195 428 428 428 428 428 428 428Noncontrollinginterests(ACTUAL) -3 -7 -10 -10 -10 -10 -10 -10 -10

InterestRevolver 0.5% 0.5% 0.5% 0.5% 0.5% 0.5%Current Portion of Long Term Debt (Short Term Debt) 0.5% 0.5% 0.5% 0.5% 0.5% 0.5%Long Term Debt 3% 3% 3% 3% 3% 3%CASH 0.2% 0.2% 0.2% 0.2% 0.2% 0.2%Long Term DebtFloating-ratenotesdueMay20,2020Fixed-rate1.40%notesdueMay18,2018Fixed-rate2.25%notesdueMay20,2020Fixed-rate3.00%notesdueMay20,2022Fixed-rate3.45%notesdueMay20,2025Fixed-rate4.65%notesdueMay20,2035Fixed-rate4.80%notesdueMay20,2045TotalPremium

Historical Projected

Page 23: Qualcomm Equity Research Report Kashif Anwer...Qualcomm Incorporated Archetypal Graham/ Buffett Value Check for QCOM QCOM is the largest communication equipment company in the world

23

Long Equity Report- Applied Portfolio Management | Analyst: Kashif Anwer

QualcommCalculations(USDinmillions,exceptpersharedata)

RetainedEarnings 9/25/14 9/25/15 9/25/16 9/25/17 9/25/18 9/25/19 9/25/20 9/25/21OperatingWorkingCapital((CA-CASH)-(CL-STDEBT))

Marketablesecurities 12702 11242 12479 13852 15375 17067Accountsreceivable,net 2219 2292 2544 2824 3134 3479Inventories 1556 1570 1742 1934 2147 2383Defferedtaxassets 0 450 500 555 616 684Collateralheldundersecuritieslending 0 0 0 0 0 0Othercurrentassets 558 575 639 709 787 873TotalOperatingAssets 17035 16129 17903 19873 22059 24485Tradeaccountspayable 1858 1856 2060 2287 2538 2817Payrollandotherbenefitsrelatedliabilities 934 902 1001 1111 1233 1369Unearnedrevenues 509 643 714 792 879 976IncomeTaxesPayable 0 0 0 0 0 0ObligationundersecuritiesLending 0 0 0 0 0 0Liabilitiesheldforsale 0 0 0 0 0 0Othercurrentliabilities 2261 2387 2649 2941 3264 3623TotalOperatingLiabilities 5562 5787 6424 7131 7915 8786

OperatingWorkingCapital 11473 10342 11480 12742 14144 15700

ΔOperatingAsset(CashFlow) 906 (1774) (1969) (2186) (2426)ΔOperatingLiabilities(CashFlow) 225 637 707 784 871Δ OperatingWorkingCapital(CashFlow) 1131 (1138) (1263) (1402) (1556)

Historical Projected

Page 24: Qualcomm Equity Research Report Kashif Anwer...Qualcomm Incorporated Archetypal Graham/ Buffett Value Check for QCOM QCOM is the largest communication equipment company in the world

24

Long Equity Report- Applied Portfolio Management | Analyst: Kashif Anwer

QualcommDebt

9/25/14 9/25/15 9/25/16 9/25/17 9/25/18 9/25/19 9/25/20 9/25/21SHORT-TERMDEBTShort-termdebtbalance 1749 1399 1049 700 350Paydown 350 350 350 350 350Short-termdebt(Ending) 0 1000 1749 1399 1049 700 350 0

InterestRate 0.5% 0.5% 0.5% 0.5% 0.5%

AverageBalance 1574 1224 875 525 175InterestExpense 8 6 5 3 1

NEWREVOLVER 0 0 0 0 965 2826 4717 6619

InterestRate 0.5% 0.5% 0.5% 0.5% 0.5%

AverageBalanceInterestExpense 0 5 15 25 34

LONG-TERMDEBTLong-termdebt(Beginning) 10008 8006 6005 4003 2002Paydown 2002 2002 2002 2002 2002Long-termdebt(Ending) 10008 8006 6005 4003 2002 0

InterestRate 3% 3% 3% 3% 3%

AverageBalance 9007 7006 5004 3002 1001InterestExpense 252 196 140 84 28

SummarySTDebt 1399 2015 3525 5067 6619LTDebt 8006 6005 4003 2002 0TotalDebt

InterestExpenseSummarySTDebtInterest 8 11 19 27 35LTDebtInterest 252 196 140 84 28TotalInterestExpense 260 207 159 111 63

CASHRequiredCASH 7907 7560 5946 7014 7786 8642 9593 10648EXCESSCASH 835 0 0 0 0TotalCash 7907 7560 5946 7849 7786 8642 9593 10648

InterestRate 0.2% 0.2% 0.2% 0.2% 0.2%

AverageBalance 6897 7817 8214 9117 10120InterestIncome 13 15 16 17 19

InterestExpense,net 247 193 144 94 44

Historical Projected

Page 25: Qualcomm Equity Research Report Kashif Anwer...Qualcomm Incorporated Archetypal Graham/ Buffett Value Check for QCOM QCOM is the largest communication equipment company in the world

25

Long Equity Report- Applied Portfolio Management | Analyst: Kashif Anwer

QualcommCashFlowStatement(USDinmillionsexceptpersharedata)

Historical Projected9/25/14 9/25/15 9/25/16 9/25/17 9/25/18 9/25/19 9/25/20 9/25/21

CashFlowfromOperationsNetIncome $6,093 $7,080 $8,103 $9,189 $10,353Depreciation 603 623 665 726 801Amortization 764 597 467 365 285ΔinOperatingWorkingCapital 1,131 (1,138) (1,263) (1,402) (1,556)TotalCashFlowfromOperations $8,592 $7,163 $7,972 $8,878 $9,884

CashFlowfromInvestingCapitalExpenditures ($684) ($795) ($910) ($1,032) ($1,163)ΔinOthernon-currentassets (1,214) (2,102) (2,333) (2,590) (2,874)ΔinOthernon-currentliabilities 445 409 454 504 559TotalCashFlowfromInvesting ($1,453) ($2,488) ($2,789) ($3,118) ($3,478)

CashFlowfromFinancing

Short-termdebtbalance ($350) ($350) ($350) ($350) ($350)Long-termdebt (2,002) (2,002) (2,002) (2,002) (2,002)CommonStock 0 0 0 0 0Additionalpaid-incapital 0 0 0 0 0Accumulatedothercomprehensiveloss 0 0 0 0 0NoncontrollingInterests 0 0 0 0 0DividendsPaid (2,885) (3,351) (3,836) (4,350) (4,901)TotalCashFlowfromFinancing ($5,236) ($5,703) ($6,187) ($6,701) ($7,253)

NetCashFlow $1,903 ($1,028) ($1,004) ($941) ($847)

CashAnalysisBeginningCash $5,946 $7,849 $6,820 $5,817 $4,875ChangeinCashfromCFS 1,903 (1,028) (1,004) (941) (847)NetCashAvailableatendofyear $5,946 $7,849 $6,820 $5,817 $4,875 $4,029

RequiredCASH $7,014 $7,786 $8,642 $9,593 $10,648ExcessCASH/(REVOLVER) $835 ($965) ($2,826) ($4,717) ($6,619)

WACC-Qualcomm3/15/17

WACC = [(kd*(1-T)*(D/D+E))+(ke*(E/D+E))] QCOM Price $52.78

FD Shs Out 1,498.0

WACC = [(kd*(1-T)*(D/D+E))+(((Rf+B*(Rm-Rf))*(E/D+E))] Equity Value 79,064.4

kd Tax Rate Debt Equity Total Cap 10 yr T-bill Beta MRP Debt as of 12/31 Balance3.00% 16.51% 11,684.0 79,064.4 90,748.4 2.28% 1.5 3.74% Short term $1,749

Long term 9,935Debt Equity Total $11,684

Actual Capital Structure 12.9% 87.1%

Target Capital Structure 35.0% 65.0%

WACC 6.05%

Page 26: Qualcomm Equity Research Report Kashif Anwer...Qualcomm Incorporated Archetypal Graham/ Buffett Value Check for QCOM QCOM is the largest communication equipment company in the world

26

Long Equity Report- Applied Portfolio Management | Analyst: Kashif Anwer

QualcommCashFlowStatement(USDinmillionsexceptpersharedata)

Historical Projected9/25/14 9/25/15 9/25/16 9/25/17 9/25/18 9/25/19 9/25/20 9/25/21

DCFValuationEBIT $6,836 $7,886 $8,975 $10,129 $11,367

Otherincome(expense),net 521 579 642 713 791

Provisionforincometaxes 1,204 1,399 1,601 1,816 2,046

EBIAT(NOPAT) $5,111 $5,908 $6,732 $7,600 $8,530

EBIAT(NOPAT) $5,111 $5,908 $6,732 $7,600 $8,530

Depreciation 603 623 665 726 801

Amortization 764 597 467 365 285

ΔinOperatingWorkingCapital 1,131 (1,138) (1,263) (1,402) (1,556)

CapitalExpenditures (684) (795) (910) (1,032) (1,163)

ΔinOthernon-currentassets (1,214) (2,102) (2,333) (2,590) (2,874)

ΔinOthernon-currentliabilities 445 409 454 504 559

UnleveredFCFs $6,156 $3,503 $3,813 $4,172 $4,583

TerminalValueGrowthrate 1.00%

Discountrate(WACC) 6.05%

TerminalValue $91,654 TimingToday YearEnd Diff Year Factor

Discountingmodel 4/14/17 9/25/17 164 365.25 0.449Mid-yearconvention YESYearcount 0.225 1.225 2.225 3.225 4.225Discountdenominator 0.987 0.931 0.878 0.827 0.780PVofFreeCashFlow $6,076 $3,260 $3,346 $3,452 $3,576

PVofFCFs $19,708PVofTerminalValue 71,512TEV(TotalEnterpriseValue) $91,221

Short-termdebt $1,749

Long-termdebt 9,935

Totaldebt $11,684

RequiredCash $7,849

ExcessCash 0

TotalCash $7,849

Convertible/Preferred 0

MinorityInterests (10)

EquityValue $87,396DilutedSharesOutstanding 1,498

Valuepershare $58.34CurrentPrice(3/15/17) $52.78

Premium/(Discount)toIntrinsicValue (9.5%)Rating BUY

Page 27: Qualcomm Equity Research Report Kashif Anwer...Qualcomm Incorporated Archetypal Graham/ Buffett Value Check for QCOM QCOM is the largest communication equipment company in the world

27

Long Equity Report- Applied Portfolio Management | Analyst: Kashif Anwer

QualcommTradingComparables(USDinmillions,exceptpersharedata)

Ticker QCOM

Company Qualcomm

Price(asof4/14/17) $52.78

SharesOut 1,498

OptionsEx. 0

FDShsOut 1,498

FDEquityValue $79,064

TotalDebt $11,684

Cash 7,849

NetDebt $28,996

Preferreds/Convertibles 0

MinorityInterests (10)

TEV $108,050

Sales(P/S) Metric MulitpleForward $26,145 3.0x

LTM 23,554 3.4x

EBITDA(TEV/EBITDA)Forward $8,204 13.2x

LTM 7,923 13.6x

Earnings(P/E)Forward $6,093 13.0x

LTM 5,705 13.9x

FCF(P/FCF)Forward $6,156 12.8x

LTM 7,384 10.7x

Note:Pricesasofmarketclose4/14/17.FCF=EBITDA-Capex.

Source:SECFilings,Yahoo!FinanceandMergentOnline.

Page 28: Qualcomm Equity Research Report Kashif Anwer...Qualcomm Incorporated Archetypal Graham/ Buffett Value Check for QCOM QCOM is the largest communication equipment company in the world

28

Long Equity Report- Applied Portfolio Management | Analyst: Kashif Anwer

Qualcomm-AnalysisatVariousPricesQualcommPrice $52.78

AnalysisatVariousPrices-TradingComps-SalesP/S 2.9x 3.0x 3.1x 3.2x 3.3x 3.4x 3.5x 3.6x 3.7x 3.8x 3.9xQCOMLTMSales $23,554 $23,554 $23,554 $23,554 $23,554 $23,554 $23,554 $23,554 $23,554 $23,554 $23,554EquityValue $68,307 $70,662 $73,017 $75,373 $77,728 $80,084 $82,439 $84,794 $87,150 $89,505 $91,861FDShsOut 1,498 1,498 1,498 1,498 1,498 1,498 1,498 1,498 1,498 1,498 1,498Valuepershare $45.60 $47.17 $48.74 $50.32 $51.89 $53.46 $55.03 $56.61 $58.18 $59.75 $61.32

AnalysisatVariousPrices-TradingComps-EBITDATEV/EBITDA 10.0x 10.5x 11.0x 11.5x 12.0x 12.5x 13.0x 13.5x 14.0x 14.5x 15.0xQCOMLTMEBITDA $7,923 $7,923 $7,923 $7,923 $7,923 $7,923 $7,923 $7,923 $7,923 $7,923 $7,923TEV $79,230 $83,192 $87,153 $91,115 $95,076 $99,038 $102,999 $106,961 $110,922 $114,884 $118,845NetDebt $11,684 $11,684 $11,684 $11,684 $11,684 $11,684 $11,684 $11,684 $11,684 $11,684 $11,684EquityValue $67,546 $71,508 $75,469 $79,431 $83,392 $87,354 $91,315 $95,277 $99,238 $103,200 $107,161FDShsOut 1,498 1,498 1,498 1,498 1,498 1,498 1,498 1,498 1,498 1,498 1,498Valuepershare $45.09 $47.74 $50.38 $53.02 $55.67 $58.31 $60.96 $63.60 $66.25 $68.89 $71.54

AnalysisatVariousPrices-TradingComps-EarningP/E 16.00x 18.00x 20.00x 22.00x 24.00x 26.00x 28.00x 30.00x 32.00x 34.00x 36.00xQCOMLTMearnings $5,705 $5,705 $5,705 $5,705 $5,705 $5,705 $5,705 $5,705 $5,705 $5,705 $5,705EquityValue $91,280 $102,690 $114,100 $125,510 $136,920 $148,330 $159,740 $171,150 $182,560 $193,970 $205,380FDShsOut 1,498 1,498 1,498 1,498 1,498 1,498 1,498 1,498 1,498 1,498 1,498Valuepershare $60.93 $68.55 $76.17 $83.79 $91.40 $99.02 $106.64 $114.25 $121.87 $129.49 $137.10

AnalysisatVariousPrices-TradingComps-FCFP/FCF 10.00x 11.50x 13.00x 14.50x 16.00x 17.50x 19.00x 20.50x 22.00x 23.50x 25.00xQCOMLTMFCF $7,384 $7,384 $7,384 $7,384 $7,384 $7,384 $7,384 $7,384 $7,384 $7,384 $7,384EquityValue $73,840 $84,916 $95,992 $107,068 $118,144 $129,220 $140,296 $151,372 $162,448 $173,524 $184,600FDShsOut 1,498 1,498 1,498 1,498 1,498 1,498 1,498 1,498 1,498 1,498 1,498Valuepershare $49.29 $56.69 $64.08 $71.47 $78.87 $86.26 $93.66 $101.05 $108.44 $115.84 $123.23

Page 29: Qualcomm Equity Research Report Kashif Anwer...Qualcomm Incorporated Archetypal Graham/ Buffett Value Check for QCOM QCOM is the largest communication equipment company in the world

29

Long Equity Report- Applied Portfolio Management | Analyst: Kashif Anwer

Qualcomm-Summary($inmillions)

9/25/14 9/25/15 9/25/16 9/25/17 9/25/18 9/25/19 9/25/20 9/25/21

SizeSales $26,487 $25,281 $23,554 $26,145 $29,021 $32,213 $35,757 $39,690

GrossProfit 16,467 15,595 14,610 16,200 17,982 19,960 22,155 24,593

EBITDA 8,700 6,990 7,923 8,204 9,106 10,108 11,220 12,454

EBIT 7,550 5,776 6,495 6,836 7,886 8,975 10,129 11,367

OCF 6,156 3,503 3,813 4,172 4,583

Capex 1,185 994 539 684 795 910 1,032 1,163

NetIncome 7,967 5,271 5,705 6,093 7,080 8,103 9,189 10,353

Debt 0 10,969 11,757 9,406 8,019 7,528 7,069 6,619

Equity 39,166 31,414 31,768 35,120 38,848 43,115 47,954 53,406

ProfitabilitySalesgrowth (4.6%) (6.8%) 11.0% 11.0% 11.0% 11.0% 11.0%

Grossmargin 62.2% 61.7% 62.0% 62.0% 62.0% 62.0% 62.0% 62.0%

EBITDAmargin 32.8% 27.6% 33.6% 31.4% 31.4% 31.4% 31.4% 31.4%

EBITmargin 28.5% 22.8% 27.6% 26.1% 27.2% 27.9% 28.3% 28.6%

Profitmargin 10.8% 11.4% 11.8% 10.2% 10.1% 10.3% 10.4% 10.5%ROA 5.9% 5.7% 5.3% 4.9% 5.1% 5.3% 5.5% 5.6%ROE 10.6% 11.7% 11.5% 14.2% 12.8% 11.6% 10.6% 9.8%ROIC 16.1% 10.8% 12.3% 12.6% 13.8% 14.6% 15.1% 15.5%Payoutratio 33.0% 55.6% 53.4% 47.3% 47.3% 47.3% 47.3% 47.3%

LeverageDebttoTotalCapital 0.0% 25.9% 27.0% 21.1% 17.1% 14.9% 12.8% 11.0%

DebttoEBITDA 0.0x 1.6x 1.5x 1.1x 0.9x 0.7x 0.6x 0.5xFCF/Interest 10.8x 6.0x 6.1x 1.7x 1.8x 2.3x 3.1x 4.4x

WorkingCapitalCapexIntensity 4.5% 3.9% 2.3% 2.6% 2.7% 2.8% 2.9% 2.9%

DaysSalesOutstanding 33.2 28.4 34.4 32.0 32.0 32.0 32.0 32.0DaysInventoryOutstanding 53.1 56.2 63.5 57.6 57.6 57.6 57.6 57.6DaysPayablesOut 79.5 49.0 75.8 68.1 68.1 68.1 68.1 68.1CashConversion 6.8 35.6 22.1 21.5 21.5 21.5 21.5 21.5

ExpensesR&Dgrowth 10% 10% 10% 10% 10% 10% 10% 10%

SGAgrowth -9% -9% -9% -9% -9% -9% -9% -9%

capexgrowth -17% 2% -9% 10% 7% 9% 10% 11%

PerformanceratiosROA 5.9% 5.7% 5.3% 4.9% 5.1% 5.3% 5.5% 5.6%

ROE 10.6% 11.7% 11.5% 14.2% 12.8% 11.6% 10.6% 9.8%

ROIC 16.1% 10.8% 12.3% 12.6% 13.8% 14.6% 15.1% 15.5%

Historical Projected