is cml curable - cmlsociety.org 2_files/is cml curable.pdf · is cml curable? we’ve been ......
TRANSCRIPT
IsCMLCurable?We’vebeenaskedlatelyifCMLiscurable.Yes,CMLiscurableandhereiswhywethinkthisisso.
First,aLittleHistoryDidyouknowthatthefirstcaseofCMLwasfirstdiagnosedinScotlandin1845andthenasecondcasewasreportedafewweekslaterinBerlin?In1872,itwasobservedthatleukemicstemcellscomefromthebonemarrow.However,itwasinalabinPhiladelphiain1962thattworesearchersworkingtogether,LowellandHungerfordlocatedthePhiladelphiaChromosome.Thiswasaverysignificanteventasitshowedthatcancer,andCMLinthiscase,couldbetracedtoaproblemintheDNA.In1972JanetRowleyshowedthattherewasatranslocation,orexchangeofgenematerial,betweenchromosomes9and22associatedwithleukemia,andspecificallyCML.Throughthedecadesavarietyoftreatmentshavebeenhelpingmostpatientsextendtheirlives.ButitwasasignificantbreakthroughbyAlexanderLevitzkiwhoshowedthatABLinhibitorscouldbeeffectivelyusedininhibitingtyrosinekinasesandblockingcancer.TodaywehavethreeapprovedTyrosineKinaseInhibitorsandanotheronefaradvancedinclinicaltrials(M.Deininger,ASH2008,CMLEducationalSession).MostimportantthanksgotoDr.B.DrukerforhistenacitywhileworkingwithSignalTransductionsInhibitors,orSTI571,nowknownasGleevecorGlivec,thatprovedtheconceptoftargetedtherapiesandgreatlyimprovedthelivesofCMLpatients.Dr.Druker’sworkedralliedtheentireCMLcommunityofscientist,doctorsandpatientsasneverbefore.Simplyput,tyrosineKinaseinhibitorsblockthefunctionofATP,whichislikeanenergycell.BlockingthefunctionofATPinturnblocksthefunctionoftheproteingeneratedbyBCRABL,whichslowsproliferation(whichiswhatanycancerreallyis,overproliferationofcellsthatgoun‐checkedbythebody’simmunesystem)ofCML.Thisisaverysimpledescriptionofit;thereareothermoretechnicalandmuchmoreeloquentlystateddescriptions.Don’thesitatetogoogleandfindtheonethathelpsyouunderstandthebest.BeforeTyrosineKinaseInhibitorstherewasInterferon.Interferonisabiologicalimmunemodifier.InterferononitsownhadaverydifficulttimetocombatCMLandBCRABLoutsmartedandoverwhelmedit.ConsequentlymanypatientshadtotakeincrediblyhighdosesofInterferontotrytostopCMLfromprogressingtoitsmoredeadlyacceleratedphases.Ahighdoseofinterferoninducesanincredibleamountofsideeffectsthatareverydifficulttodealwithandgreatlydiminishapatient’squalityoflife.However,therewassomegoodnews;somepatients,asmallpercentage,closeto12%bysomereports,couldbesuccessfullytreatedwithinterferonandwereabletostoptakingthedrugwithoutrelapsing.Someofthesepatientshavebeentrackedformorethan20yearswithoutrelapse.Theseresultsaddedtothedataofthepatientswhorespondedtoanallogenicbonemarrowtransplant,suggesttousthatCMLiscurable.
WewereallquitefortunatewhenGleevec™,theworld’sfirstTyrosineKinaseInhibitorstartedinPhaseItrialsandsuccessfullywentontoPhaseIIandexpandedaccessprograms.Iamnotgoingtoexpoundtoomuchonthesuccessofthesedrugs,thedatashowsusthatliveshavebeenextendedandwiththenewerdrugs,qualityoflifeisimprovingaswell.Forthosewhohavethemisfortuneofdevelopingresistancetoonedrugoranother,weareluckythattherearesecond‐generationdrugssuchasSprycel™andTasigna™aswellasadditionaldrugsintrials.
Butwhataboutthecure?
AtASH2008therewasanupdateonthestudythatwasstartedbyDr.MahoneinFranceanditisquiteexciting.Therewere15patientsinFrancewhodecidedtostoptreatmentwithGleevec™foronereasonoranother,sotheopportunitywastakentoobservewhatwouldhappentothem.7ofthepatientsrelapsedwithin6months,however,8ofthepatientsinthisverysmallcohortpilotstudy,didnotrelapse.Thesepatientshavebeenfollowedformorethan37months.Interestinglyitwasnotedthatthesepatientshadbeen“pre‐treated”withinterferon.Coulditbethatpretreatmentwithinterferonconferssomeadvantage?Thatwasthehypothesis,butthehypothesiswouldneedfurthertesting,sotheyenrolledanother69patientsfrom22differentcentersinFrance.ThecriterionwasthattheyhadtohavebeeninacompletemolecularremissionandPCRundetectablefortwoyearsconsecutively,beforebeingallowedtostopGleevec™.Ofthese69patients,27patientshaverelapsed;13werepretreatedwithIFN,and14wereonlytreatedwithGleevec™.Thebignewsisthatat9monthsfollowup46%(orapproximately31)ofthesepatientsarestillinremission,ofthose46%patients,53%werepretreatedwithinterferonand39%are“denovo”patients(haveonlybeentreatedwithGleevec™).EarlierwementionedthatonInterferonalone,somesourcesreportedupto12%ofpatientscouldbetakenoffthedrug.Addedwiththisnewinformation,wecanexplorethehypothesisthattheearlyresultswithinterferonalonecouldbegreatlyimprovedwiththeadditionofatargetedtherapylikeGleevec™.TheothergoodnewsisthatmostpatientswhorelapsedafterstoppingGleevec™quicklyregainedtheirmolecularresponse:“Dr.MahonalsoemphasizedthatallofthepatientswhorelapsedweresensitivetoImatinibafteritwasrestarted.Someoftherelapsedpatientswentbackintoremissionveryquickly,butforothers,itisaslowerprocess.Althoughthefollow‐upinthisparticularstudy(69patients,22centers)isshort,patientsinthepilotstudyhavenowbeenfollowedforseveralyears.“TheresultsfrombothofthesetrialsconfirmthatcompletemolecularresponsecanbesustainedafterImatinibisdiscontinued.Thisisparticularlytrueforpatientswhohavebeenpretreatedwithinterferon,saidDr.Mahon”.ItseemspossiblethatthecombinationofbothGleevec™andotherTyrosineKinaseInhibitor’sforthatmatter,withsomethinglikeInterferoncanimprovethepotentialforpatientstoenjoyarelapsefreeanddrugfreeremission.Notsureifthatistheexactsamethingasacure,butwewouldliketoseewhatitisliketonothavetothinkaboutonedrugoranother,wouldn’tyou?Earlierinthisessay,itwasmentionedthatCMLcouldbetracedtoaproblemintheDNA.Thisisverygoodnews,becausenowweknowthatourDNAdoesn’texactly“sealourfate”asweoncethoughtitdid.Thereisnewresearchaboutepigenomes.Thereallybasictakeawayaboutepigenesisthattheycanbeswitchedoneway,andthatmeansthattheycanbeswitchedbacktoo!Readthereallycoolarticleaboutthishere:Whew!YourDNAIsn'tYourDestiny
TherearenowmorecentersparticipatinginallowingpatientstotrytostopGleevec™andwethinkthatthisisveryexciting.Importantly,thereisresearchgoingoninmanyareasthathelpsusalltolearnmoreaboutthisdisease.ThisisvitallyimportanttousasthesedrugsareveryexpensiveandarecreatingasignificantsocioeconomichardshipforCMLpatientsandtheirfamilies.ThiswasevidentwiththeresultsoftheinternationalCMLpatientssurveypresentedatasatellitesymposiumatASHinDecember2008.VisittheCMLSocietywebsiteforthevideopresentation.
SayingCMLisn’tcurablewouldbeignoringthegreatsuccesseswehavehadinhelpingpeoplewithCMLtoenjoyimprovedsurvivalrates.Sostayhealthy,continuetolearnalongwithusandimportantly,stayinformed.
IsCMLCurable?Wecancertainlysaywearecountingonit!
Disclaimers:Pleasenotetheclinicaltrialdatapresentedherewasfromarelativelysmallcohortofpatientswhoweregoodresponderstotherapy.Whiletheresultsseemquitepositive,donotattempttostopyourtherapy.Ifyouhaveanyquestionsaboutyourcurrenttreatment,pleasediscussthemwithyourdoctor.
GleevecandTasignaaretrademarksofNovartisOncologySprycelistheTrademarkofBristolMyersSquibb