technical specifications - new rochelle, ny
TRANSCRIPT
Thomas Paine Monument, New Rochelle, NY November 2020
HISTORIC MASONRY CLEANING 040310 - 1
SECTION 040310– HISTORIC MASONRY CLEANING
PART 1 - GENERAL
1.1 DESCRIPTION
A. Work of this Section consists of providing all labor, materials, equipment and services to clean
the marble monument and schist perimeter wall of the Thomas Paine Monument. Work
includes, but is not limited to:
1. Removal of atmospheric soiling, biological growth, paint, iron staining, copper staining
and other surface contaminants using chemical cleaning agents.
B. Related Sections:
1. Section 040342 Historic Marble Restoration
2. Section 040344 Historic Schist Restoration
3. Section 050387 Historic Bronze Sculpture Treatment
C. Related Documents:
1. Thomas Paine Monument Conditions Assessment and Materials Analyses, dated
November 2020 as prepared by Jablonski Building Conservation, Inc.
1.2 REFERENCES
A. Cleaning shall conform to the following publications, except where modified by this Section:
1. Secretary of the Interior, “Secretary of the Interior's Standards for Rehabilitation and
Guidelines for Rehabilitating Historic Buildings”, 1995.
2. National Park Service Technical Preservation Services Division, “Keeping it Clean:
Removing Exterior Dirt, Paint, Stains and Graffiti from Historic Masonry Buildings”,
1988.
3. Brick Industry Association, Technical Note 20, “Cleaning Brickwork”, 2018.
4. Product manufacturer’s printed recommendations
1.3 QUALITY ASSURANCE
A. Cleaning of the marble monument shall be performed by a trained Conservator specialized in
stone conservation and holding Professional Associate or Fellow membership in the American
Institute for Conservation. The Conservator shall have a minimum of ten (10) years of
experience working with historic stone and marble monuments. The Conservator must
Thomas Paine Monument, New Rochelle, NY November 2020
HISTORIC MASONRY CLEANING 040310 - 2
demonstrate three (3) projects similar in scope and type to the required work completed in the
last 5 years.
1. Conservation technicians, if used, shall be experienced with the materials and methods
specified, and are familiar with the design requirements. Technicians shall be carefully
supervised to ensure that the work is accomplished to meet or exceed the highest
standards of the trade. Conservator shall maintain a full-time Foreperson who fluently
speaks, reads, and writes English. In acceptance or rejection of the work of this Section,
no allowance will be made for lack of skill on the part of technicians.
B. Cleaning of the schist wall shall be performed by a qualified restoration Contractor with a
minimum of five (5) years of experience working with historic masonry. The Contractor must
demonstrate three (3) projects similar in scope and type to the required work involving facilities
designated as Landmarks by local governments, or buildings listed on the National or State
Register of Historic Places, and completed in the last 5 years.
1. The Contractor shall maintain a steady work crew of skilled mechanics who are
experienced with the materials and methods specified and are familiar with the design
requirements. Mechanics shall have skill and experience of sufficient level to accomplish
the work described. Workers shall be carefully supervised to ensure that the work is
accomplished to meet or exceed the highest standards of the trade. Contractor shall
maintain a full-time Foreperson who fluently speaks, reads, and writes English. In
acceptance or rejection of the work of this Section, no allowance will be made for lack of
skill on the part of mechanics.
a. Mechanics shall have received training and certification where available from the
manufacturer’s representative in the safe and proper use of the equipment
specified.
2. The Contractor shall provide one crew of mechanics for the duration of the project.
Substitutions and additions of work force shall be permitted with the Owner’s
Representative’s consent, so long as there is no adverse effect on quality or performance
of work.
C. The Conservator and Contractor shall replace at no additional cost to the Owner all materials
that are broken, lost, or damaged during the work of this Section.
D. If the Conservator or Contractor fails to follow approved procedures, work may be stopped
immediately.
1.4 SUBMITTALS
A. Qualification Data: Submit qualification data and references for firms and persons specified in
Paragraph 1.3 “Quality Assurance” to demonstrate their capabilities and experience.
B. Product Literature: Submit copies of the manufacturer’s technical data for each product,
including their recommendations for use, and Safety Data Sheets (SDS). Include test reports
and certificates that verify the products’ compliance with the requirements of this Section. One
complete set of product literature and MSDS shall be placed in a 3-ring, loose-leaf binder and
Thomas Paine Monument, New Rochelle, NY November 2020
HISTORIC MASONRY CLEANING 040310 - 3
shall be present on the job site at all times for the reference of Owner’s Representative and
Mechanics.
C. Program of Work: Submit a detailed written description of materials, methods, equipment, and
sequence of operations to be used for each phase of the cleaning work including protection of
surrounding materials and Project site.
1. If materials and methods other than those indicated are proposed for any phase of the
cleaning work, include a written description of such materials and methods, including
evidence of successful use on comparable projects, and demonstrations to show their
effectiveness for this Project and worker's ability to use such materials and methods
properly.
D. Containment Plan: Submit a written Containment Plan for the work of this Section describing
methods of protection of adjacent materials, personnel, the public, landscape, and adjacent
structures. Describe method of collection and disposal of chemical runoff in accordance with
applicable Federal, state, and local laws.
1. Provide shop drawings showing method of containment and collection of cleaning waste.
1.5 MOCKUPS
A. Prior to executing work, provide in-place mockups for the Owner’s Representative’s approval.
Resubmit panels until the Owner’s Representative is fully satisfied. Mockups shall be prepared
using the same workmen, methods, and materials that will be employed for the remainder of the
work. Approved mockups shall be retained, undisturbed and suitably marked, as the standard of
work throughout construction. Mockups may be incorporated into the finished work when so
approved by the Owner’s Representative.
B. No mockups shall be made until the methods and locations are approved by the Owner’s
Representative.
C. Owner’s Representative will be present during the creation of all mockups. Do not proceed
with the work unless the Owner’s Representative is present. Notify the Owner’s Representative
no less than forty-eight (48) hours in advance of mockup.
D. Provide protection for adjacent surfaces and collection and containment of cleaning waste
during mockups.
E. Provide the following mockups in locations selected by the Owner’s Representative:
1. For each type of masonry material and soiling present provide one (1) mockup panel
measuring no less than four (4) square feet (2’ x 2’), that is representative of the effect of
the cleaning materials and methods.
F. Evaluation of Mockups:
1. Cleaning mockups shall be evaluated no less than seven (7) days after they have been
performed in order to let the mockup fully dry and to assess any reactions that may have
occurred.
Thomas Paine Monument, New Rochelle, NY November 2020
HISTORIC MASONRY CLEANING 040310 - 4
2. Evaluation of all cleaning mockups shall include, but is not limited to, the following:
a. Cleanliness of the test area.
b. Evenness of surface appearance of cleaned area.
c. Any discoloration.
d. Alteration of masonry surface or loss of material.
1.6 DELIVERY, STORAGE AND HANDLING
A. All materials shall be delivered to the job site in original unopened containers bearing
manufacturers’ name and label. Store and handle materials in strict compliance with
manufacturer's instructions.
B. Protect materials from tampering, acts of vandalism, possible injury to workers, the general
public, intrusion of foreign materials, and moisture. All vessels shall have tight fitting covers.
At no time shall vessels containing chemicals be carried to working levels when vessels are
open.
1.7 JOB CONDITIONS
A. Cold weather protection: For any cleaning method requiring water, cleaning shall not begin
until average daily temperatures remain above 40°F (4°C), including overnight. Do not clean if
the temperature of air or masonry drops below 40°F (4°C). Do not clean within seven days of
anticipated freezing temperatures.
B. Surrounding areas shall be protected from contact with chemical cleaning agents. Surrounding
areas shall include, but shall not be limited to, adjacent surfaces and structures, private property
including automobiles, vegetation, and all other surfaces that would be adversely affected by
cleaning chemicals. Contractor vehicle parking and deliveries must be coordinated accordingly.
1. Windborne Chemicals: Protect all surrounding areas and the general public from wind-
carried water or chemical over-spray. Do not clean in winds of sufficient force to blow
cleaning agents beyond the project area.
C. Any material, including adjacent materials, damaged as a result of cleaning operations shall be
repaired or replaced at the Contractor’s expense to the satisfaction of the Owner’s
Representative.
D. The Contractor will use all necessary precautions to protect persons performing the work and
others from harmful effects of the cleaning process. Workers shall be required to wear
protective clothing, goggles, face shields, gloves, and other clothing or equipment in
compliance with SDS, governing Federal, State, and local safety codes and regulations.
E. All environmental restrictions (City, State and Federal), health, and safety code requirements
regarding items in this Section will be observed. This includes complying with all
environmental regulations (City, State and Federal) regarding VOC and waste collection and
disposal.
Thomas Paine Monument, New Rochelle, NY November 2020
HISTORIC MASONRY CLEANING 040310 - 5
1. Do not allow runoff from the cleaning process to enter storm and sanitary sewers, or to
contaminate water supplies or enter natural bodies of water.
2. Collect and dispose of cleaning waste in safe and legal way as outlined in the approved
Containment Plan.
F. The Contractor shall provide, erect, and maintain barricades, danger signals and warning signs
as needed.
1.8 COORDINATION
A. Preconstruction Conference: Prior to beginning the work of this Section, convene a meeting
with the Owner’s Representative and all relevant parties to review work requirements, locations
of required mockup areas, and all job conditions and processes. All subcontracting firms
involved with this work shall participate in this meeting.
B. Marble Consolidation as specified in Section 040342 Historic Marble Restoration shall be
completed prior to cleaning marble.
C. The work of Section 050387 Historic Bronze Sculpture Treatment shall be completed prior to
performing the work of this Section.
D. All other work of this Section shall be performed prior to any other masonry restoration work.
Where work must occur out of sequence, allow newly placed cementitious materials such as
composite patching and pointing mortar to cure for no less than twenty-eight (28) days prior to
cleaning.
PART 2 - PRODUCTS
A. The following products have been proven, through on-site comparative testing, to be safe and
effective in removing the soiling types indicated. Provide the following products.
1. Approved Equal: The Contractor may submit alternate, equivalent products for the
approval of the Owner’s Representative.
a. Alternate products must be tested prior to use to demonstrate their effectiveness
and determine whether they will etch or otherwise damage the substrate.
B. Marble - General/Atmospheric Soiling and Biological Growth Remover
1. Enviro Klean ReKlaim Cleaner and Activator, neutralized with Sure Klean Limestone
and Masonry Afterwash as manufactured by PROSOCO, Inc., 3741 Greenway Circle,
Lawrence, KS 66046, (800) 255-4255
C. Marble - Copper Stain Remover (both products may be required)
1. SB2380 Copper Stain Remover Gel, as manufactured by Shore Corporation, 2917 Spruce
Way, Pittsburgh, PA 15201, (412) 471-3330
Thomas Paine Monument, New Rochelle, NY November 2020
HISTORIC MASONRY CLEANING 040310 - 6
2. SB2382 CSR Poultice mixed with SB2381 CSR Liquid, for deep-seated stains, as
manufactured by Shore Corporation, 2917 Spruce Way, Pittsburgh, PA 15201, (412) 471-
3330
D. Marble - Paint Removers
1. Light Duty Paint Remover as manufactured by Cathedral Stone Products, Inc., 7266 Park
Circle Drive, Hanover, Maryland, 21076, (410) 782-9150
2. Peel Away 1 neutralized with and Citri-Lize as manufactured by Dumond Chemicals, 83
General Warren Blvd., Suite 190, Malvern, PA 19355, (609) 655-7700
E. Schist - General/Atmospheric Soiling and Biological Growth Remover
1. Safe n’ Easy Ultimate Restoration Cleaner as manufactured by Dumond Chemicals, Inc.,
83 General Warren Blvd., Suite 190, Malvern, PA 19355, (609) 655-7700
F. Schist - Rust Remover
1. CSP Light Duty Rust Remover as manufactured by Cathedral Stone Products, Inc., 7266
Park Circle Drive, Hanover, Maryland, 21076, (410) 782-9150
2.2 TEMPORARY PROTECTION
A. Provide the following, or approved equal, for the protection of adjacent surfaces during
cleaning:
1. Polyethylene plastic sheeting
2. Strippable latex caulking
3. Liquid Strippable Masking Agent:
a. Spray Block 40, manufactured by Edison Coatings.
b. Sure Klean Strippable Masking, manufactured by ProSoCo.
c. ABR Rubber Mask, manufactured by Bonstone Materials Corporation.
d. Or approved equal.
B. All items for temporary protection of surfaces shall be non-staining and completely removable
without damage to the masonry.
2.3 MICELLANEOUS
A. Dumond Laminated Paper as manufactured by Dumond Chemicals, Inc., 83 General Warren
Blvd., Suite 190, Malvern, PA 19355, (609) 655-7700
Thomas Paine Monument, New Rochelle, NY November 2020
HISTORIC MASONRY CLEANING 040310 - 7
B. Brushes shall be stiff natural or synthetic bristle brushes. Metallic/wire brushes shall not be
used.
C. Scrapers shall be made of plastic or wood. Metal scrapers shall not be used.
D. Spray Applicator: For chemical cleaning agents, use acid-resistant, airless, low-pressure
sprayers such as those manufactured by the H.D. Hudson Manufacturing Company, 1000
Foreman St SE, Lowell, MI 49331, (312) 644-2830.
E. Pressure Washer: Pressure washers shall be fitted with a 40° fan-shaped nozzle and an in-line
pressure gauge and pressure regulator. Operating pressure shall not exceed 500 psi, as measured
in-line, and equipment shall be capable of providing a flow rate of 5 or more gallons per minute.
1. The spray nozzle shall be kept at minimum 1 foot away from the masonry surface. If
necessary, a dowel may be taped to the wand that projects 1 foot beyond the nozzle to
ensure that the nozzle remains at minimum 1-foot way from the surface.
2. If a pressure washer with a maximum operating pressure of 500 psi cannot be obtained,
the use of a hose and high flow nozzle is acceptable. Acceptable products include:
a. Westward Fireman’s High Flow Nozzle 5” available from Grainger Inc.
www.grainger.com.
b. Nelson Water Nozzle available from Grainger Inc., www.grainger.com.
c. Or approved equal.
F. Water: Water for cleaning shall be potable and free of contaminants that may stain or otherwise
damage the masonry. Flush hydrants well before use. Provide in-line filtration as required to
meet the requirements above.
G. No metal fittings that can corrode or deposit materials on the masonry shall be used.
H. pH Measurement: Paper pH strips which show the full range of acidity/alkalinity from 1 to 14.
PART 3 - EXECUTION
3.1 INSPECTION
A. Examine substrates, supports and conditions under which this work is to be performed and
notify the Owner’s Representative, in writing, of conditions detrimental to the proper
completion of the work. Do not proceed with work until unsatisfactory conditions are
corrected. Beginning work signifies installer’s acceptance of substrates and conditions.
B. Before starting any work of this section, make a complete inspection of all surfaces to be
cleaned and identify areas that will require installation of protection or other special care.
Thomas Paine Monument, New Rochelle, NY November 2020
HISTORIC MASONRY CLEANING 040310 - 8
3.2 PREPARATION FOR CLEANING
A. Ensure that the requirements of Paragraph 1.3 Coordination are complete before proceeding
with cleaning work:
1. Marble Consolidation as specified in Section 040342 Historic Masonry Restoration shall
be completed prior to cleaning marble.
2. The work of Section 050387 Historic Bronze Sculpture Treatment shall be completed
prior to performing the work of this Section.
3. Fence removal as specified in Section 050372 Historic Iron Fence Restoration shall be
completed prior to preforming the work of this Section.
4. All other work of this Section shall be performed prior to any other masonry restoration
work.
B. Sequence:
1. General/Atmospheric Soiling and Biological Growth Removal shall be performed prior to
other cleaning work.
2. Following Paint Removal, additional General/Atmospheric Soiling and Biological
Growth Removal and/or Copper Stain removal may be required to remove soiling
concealed below paint.
C. Install protection of adjacent surfaces, property, and people in accordance with the approved
Containment Plan. Protect the restored bronze from contact with the chemical cleaners or rinse
water.
D. Install and test containment system in accordance with the approved Containment Plan.
3.3 GENERAL PROCEDURES
A. Products and procedures employed will comply with the approved mock-up panels.
B. Follow all manufacturers’ instructions regarding protection, mixing, dilution, and application of
each product. If required, dilute cleaning products with water as recommended by testing and in
accordance with the manufacturers’ written instructions.
C. Cleaning using chemical agents shall begin at the bottom of the walls and progress continuously
upward.
D. To avoid streaking, all surfaces immediately below the area being cleaned shall be kept wet and
rinsed free of dripping cleaning agents.
E. Immediately remove all spills or stains on adjacent surfaces and restore affected surfaces at no
expense to the Owner.
F. Re-application of cleaners may be required to achieve a uniform level of clean. Obtain the
approval of the Owner’s Representative prior to reapplication of chemical cleaning agents.
Thomas Paine Monument, New Rochelle, NY November 2020
HISTORIC MASONRY CLEANING 040310 - 9
G. Selective stain removal may be necessary in some locations following general soiling removal.
This shall be done with only approved cleaning agents and the approval the Owner’s
Representative.
H. Finished work shall have a uniform appearance, free of stains, streaks, etching, or discoloration,
matching the cleaning level established through mockups.
I. After rinsing and neutralization, as required, cleaned surfaces shall have a neutral pH (pH 7) or
a pH equal to that of the rinse water, as confirmed using pH strips.
1. If the Contractor fails to check the pH level of surfaces after cleaning or fails to rinse
treated surfaces until a neutral pH is reached, work will be stopped immediately.
3.4 MARBLE - GENERAL/ATMOSPHERIC SOILING AND BIOLOGICAL GROWTH
REMOVAL
A. Mix products as follows:
1. ReKlaim: For 5-gallons of prepared solution, add 3 gallons clean water to a plastic
container. Carefully add 1-gallon of ReKlaim Cleaner, followed by 1-gallon of ReKlaim
Activator. Stir thoroughly with a nonmetallic tool. Prepared solutions must be used
immediately.
2. Limestone & Masonry Afterwash: Add 1 part clean water to a plastic container. Carefully
add 1 part Limestone & Masonry Afterwash to the clean water. Never pour water into
cleaner.
B. Working from the bottom to the top, apply prepared ReKlaim solution to a dry surface using a
brush or spray applicator.
C. Gently scrub surface.
D. Leave solution on the surface for 5–20 minutes. If solution begins to dry, reapply.
E. Gently scrub heavily soiled areas.
F. Rinse thoroughly with clean water.
G. Immediately after rinsing ReKlaim from masonry surface, apply the prepared Limestone &
Masonry Afterwash to the wet surface.
H. Let the Afterwash dwell for three to five minutes.
I. Rinse from the bottom of the treated area to the top. Continue rinsing until the pH of treated
surfaces is neutral (pH 7) or equal to the pH of the rinse water.
3.5 MARBLE - COPPER STAIN REMOVAL USING SB2380 GEL
A. Apply SB2380 Gel to a dry surface using a brush.
Thomas Paine Monument, New Rochelle, NY November 2020
HISTORIC MASONRY CLEANING 040310 - 10
B. Leave cleaner on the surface for 5–15 minutes. Leaving the cleaner on the surface for more than
15 minutes may lead to difficulty in removal from the surface. In some cases, additional
brushing of the applied cleaner, after the first 5 minutes, may prove to be helpful.
C. When the applied cleaner has turned to a bright blue color, gently rinse to remove product
residue.
D. After rinsing the surface, reapply the cleaner. If the cleaner turns blue, there is additional copper
stain available for removal. Repeat the application procedure until there is no color change in
the applied cleaner.
E. If staining persists after two applications of SB2380 Gel, perform spot cleaning of deep-seated
stains using SB2382 poultice and SB2381 liquid.
F. Thoroughly rinse the treated area. Continue rinsing until the measured pH of treated surfaces is
neutral (pH 7) or equal to the pH of the rinse water.
3.6 MARBLE - COPPER STAIN REMOVAL USING SB2382 POULTICE AND SB2381 LIQUID
A. Mix SB 2382 CSR Poultice with SB 2381 CSR Liquid to a paste-like consistency that will hang
on a vertical surface.
B. Using a broad knife, trowel or other application method, apply a uniform layer of blended SB
2382 CSR Poultice to a thickness of 3/8 to 1/2 inch of product. Application method should
ensure that there are no voids that will cause stains to remain in the surface.
C. Before the poultice dries, cover the surface with a plastic sheeting. Avoid air pockets when
applying the plastic sheet. Air pockets may allow the poultice to dry prematurely.
D. Allow the poultice to remain on the surface for 12 to 48 hours. If the poultice is very damp after
removal of the plastic sheeting, allow the poultice to dry uncovered for several hours prior to
removal.
E. Remove the poultice with plastic or wood scrappers, taking care to avoid marring the surface.
F. Remove as much poultice as possible and rinse with water and scrub brushes. All poultice
residues must be removed to avoid a film appearing on the surface. Continue rinsing until the
measured pH of treated surface is neutral (pH 7) or equal to the pH of the rinse water.
G. Allow the surface to dry and repeat the application where necessary.
3.7 MARBLE - PAINT REMOVAL
A. Ensure that all surfaces to be treated are clean of surface dirt and dry.
B. Apply paint remover to dry surfaces 1/8 to 1/4 inches thick, using corrosion resistant plastic
trowels or non-metallic brushes. Work paint remover well into crevices.
D. Cover Peel Away 1 with Dumond Laminated Paper. Press paper against the paint remover so
that it adheres and air pockets are removed. Cover paper with plastic sheeting. Tape or seal the
Thomas Paine Monument, New Rochelle, NY November 2020
HISTORIC MASONRY CLEANING 040310 - 11
edges of the plastic sheeting to the stone.
E. Cover Light Duty Paint Remover with plastic sheeting. Tape or seal the edges of the plastic
sheeting to the stone.
F. Allow the paint remover to dwell for 24 hours.
G. Using a plastic scraper, carefully remove excess chemical and dissolved coatings by lifting,
making sure the substrate is not scraped or gouged.
H. Multiple applications of the paint remover may be required to remove all coatings. If coatings
remain, reapply product as specified above prior to rinsing.
I. Following coating removal, thoroughly rinse treated surfaces using water.
J. Neutralize Peel Away 1 using Citri-Lize, mixed per manufactures’ instructions, and allow to
dwell for 3 to 5 minutes. Rinse until the measured pH of treated surfaces is neutral (pH 7) or
equal to the pH of the rinse water. If pH is high (>7) following rinsing, reapply Citri-Lize and
repeat rinsing.
3.8 SCHIST - GENERAL/ATMOSPHERIC SOILING AND BIOLOGICAL GROWTH
REMOVAL
A. Apply the undiluted Ultimate Stone and Masonry Cleaner to the surface using a brush or spray
application working from the bottom of the surface up.
B. Gently scrub surface.
C. Allow cleaner to dwell for 15 minutes.
D. Gently scrub surface.
E. Rinse thoroughly working from top to bottom. Continue rinsing until the measured pH of
treated surfaces is neutral (pH 7) or equal to the pH of the rinse water.
3.9 SCHIST - RUST REMOVAL
A. Pre-wet the substrate and remove excess water from the surface.
B. Apply a thick, even layer of Light Duty Rust Remover using a brush.
C. Gently scrub surface.
D. Allow product to dwell for 20 minutes. Do not allow product to dry on surface. Reapply product
to maintain a wet surface.
E. Gently scrub surface.
Thomas Paine Monument, New Rochelle, NY November 2020
HISTORIC MASONRY CLEANING 040310 - 12
F. Rinse thoroughly with water. Continue rinsing until the measured pH of treated surfaces is
neutral (pH 7) or equal to the pH of the rinse water.
3.10 COMPLETION
A. Rinse adjacent areas and remove any debris or accumulated matter.
B. Remove and legally dispose of all cleaning refuse from the work site.
C. Protect cleaned surfaces from construction related soiling. If, after cleaning is completed, the
cleaned surface becomes dirty as a result of the Contractor's operations, it shall be re-cleaned at
the expense of the Contractor using the foregoing procedures or by using soap and water.
END OF SECTION
Thomas Paine Monument, New Rochelle, NY November 2020
HISTORIC MARBLE RESTORATION 040342 - 1
SECTION 040342 – HISTORIC MARBLE RESTORATION
PART 1 - GENERAL
1.1 DESCRIPTION
A. Work of this Section consists of providing all labor, materials, equipment and services to
complete the marble restoration of the Thomas Paine Monument. Work shall include, but is not
limited to:
1. Consolidation of weathered marble
2. Filling of cracks and losses <1/8” wide
3. Composite patching of cracks and losses >1/8” wide
4. Removal and replacement of failed patching
5. Treatment of corroded metal cramps
6. Repointing mortar joints
B. Related Sections:
1. Section 040310 Historic Stone Masonry Cleaning
2. Section 040344 Historic Schist Restoration
3. Section 050387 Historic Bronze Sculpture Treatment
C. Related Documents:
1. Thomas Paine Monument Conditions Assessment and Materials Analysis, dated
November 2020, as prepared by Jablonski Building Conservation, Inc.
1.2 REFERENCES
A. Materials and methods shall conform to the "Secretary of the Interior's Standards for
Rehabilitation and Guidelines for Rehabilitating Historic Buildings", 1995.
B. Comply with provisions of the most recent versions of the following codes and standards,
except as otherwise indicated:
1. American Society of Testing and Materials (ASTM):
a. C141 Standard Specification for Hydrated Hydraulic Lime for Structural Purposes
b. C144 Standard Specifications for Aggregate for Masonry Mortar
Thomas Paine Monument, New Rochelle, NY November 2020
HISTORIC MARBLE RESTORATION 040342 - 2
2. Manufacturer’s printed recommendations
1.3 QUALITY ASSURANCE
A. All work of this Section shall be done by a trained Conservator specialized in stone
conservation and holding Professional Associate or Fellow membership in the American
Institute for Conservation. The Conservator shall have a minimum of ten (10) years of
experience working with historic stone monuments. The Conservator must demonstrate three
(3) projects similar in scope and type to the required work completed in the last 5 years.
B. Conservation technicians, if used, shall be experienced with the materials and methods
specified, and are familiar with the design requirements. Technicians shall be carefully
supervised to ensure that the work is accomplished to meet or exceed the highest standards of
the trade. Conservator shall maintain a full-time Foreperson who fluently speaks, reads, and
writes English. In acceptance or rejection of the work of this Section, no allowance will be
made for lack of skill on the part of technicians.
C. The Conservator shall provide one crew of workers for the duration of the project. Substitutions
and additions of work force shall be permitted with the Owner’s Representative’s consent, so
long as there is no adverse effect on quality or performance of work.
D. Conservator shall replace at no additional cost to the Owner all materials that are broken, lost,
or damaged during the work of this Section.
E. If the Conservator fails to follow approved procedures, work may be stopped immediately.
F. Owner’s Representative shall be given regular access to the Conservator’s scaffolding, swing
stage, or work site so that he/she may inspect work being performed.
G. Materials shall be used only at the manufacturer’s recommended temperature tolerances.
H. Repair Appearance Standard: Repaired surfaces are to have a uniform appearance as viewed
from 10 feet away by Owner’s Representative.
1.4 SUBMITTALS
A. Conservator shall submit the following to the Owner’s Representative for approval:
1. Qualification data and references for firms and persons specified in Section 1.3 “Quality
Assurance” to demonstrate their capabilities and experience.
2. Work Plan including detailed descriptions, drawings, and diagrams of how the work of
this Section will be accomplished. Include products to be used, methods, and equipment
for masonry repair and restoration, and methods and procedures for protection of
personnel, the public, and the existing construction.
a. If materials and methods other than those indicated are proposed for any phase of
restoration work, include a written description of such materials and methods,
including evidence of successful use on comparable projects, and demonstrations
Thomas Paine Monument, New Rochelle, NY November 2020
HISTORIC MARBLE RESTORATION 040342 - 3
to show their effectiveness for this Project and worker's ability to use such
materials and methods properly.
3. Copies of the manufacturer’s technical data for each product indicated or proposed for
use, including recommendations for their application and use. Include test reports and
certificates that verify the product’s compliance with the specification’s requirements.
One complete set of product literature and SDS shall be placed in a 3-ring, loose-leaf
binder and shall be present on the job site at all times for the reference of the Owner’s
Representative.
4. Samples: Conservator shall submit three (3) the following samples to the Owner’s
Representative for approval:
a. Composite patching samples for the existing marble that match the natural color
variations of the stone. More than one mix may be necessary.
b. Pointing mortar in a1/4-inch wide plastic or aluminum channel.
B. Submittal Labels: Clearly label all samples to include the project name and contract number, the
product name, manufacturer name, and any other information relevant to identification of and
differentiation between samples including production codes, batch numbers, and color or
formula numbers.
C. If alternate methods and materials to those specified are proposed for any phase of the work,
provide written description. Provide evidence of successful use on comparable projects and
demonstrate its effectiveness for use on this project.
1.5 MOCKUPS:
A. Prior to executing work, provide in-place mockups for the Owner’s Representative’s approval.
Resubmit panels until the Owner’s Representative is fully satisfied. Mockups shall be prepared
by the Conservator using the same crew, methods, and materials that will be employed for the
remainder of the work. Approved mockups shall be retained, undisturbed and suitably marked,
as the standard of work throughout construction. Mockups may be incorporated into the finished
work when so approved by the Owner’s Representative.
B. No mockups shall be made until the methods and locations are approved by the Owner’s
Representative.
C. Owner’s Representative will be present during the creation of all mockups. Do not proceed
with the work unless the Owner’s Representative is present. Notify the Owner’s Representative
no less than forty-eight (48) hours in advance of masonry restoration mockup.
D. Provide protection for adjacent surfaces during the mockup phase.
E. Provide the following mockups in locations selected by the Owner’s Representative:
1. Filling of two (2) small cracks around the shallow spalls
2. One (1) crack repair by patching
Thomas Paine Monument, New Rochelle, NY November 2020
HISTORIC MARBLE RESTORATION 040342 - 4
3. One (1) patch repair
4. Two (2) linear feet of joint repointing.
1.6 JOB CONDITIONS
A. All repair materials shall be used only within the manufacturer’s recommended temperature
tolerances or as indicated below, whichever is more conservative.
B. Cold Weather Requirements: Work involving mortar or composite patching may only be
performed as long as the temperature remains above 40° Fahrenheit. If in any given 24 hour
period the temperature drops or is expected to drop below 40° Fahrenheit at any time, work will
not recommence until a constant temperature of 40° Fahrenheit or higher is projected for a
minimum period of 72 hours. Once stopped for reason of temperature, work will recommence
only upon approval of the Owner’s Representative.
C. Hot Weather Requirements: Protect mortar and composite patching when temperature and
humidity conditions produce excessive evaporation of water from mortar and patching
materials. Provide artificial shade and wind breaks and use cooled materials as necessary to
minimize evaporation. Mortar and composite patching work shall be protected during hot, dry
weather from premature drying or rapid curing by the use of dampened fabric coverings or
controlled misting with water as required to keep mortar moist for seventy-two (72) hours
following final tooling. Do not apply mortar or patching to substrates with temperatures of 90°
Fahrenheit and above unless otherwise indicated.
1.7 DELIVERY, STORAGE AND HANDLING
A. Deliver materials to project site in manufacturer's original and unopened containers, labeled
with manufacturer's name and type of products.
B. Store materials off the ground and in accordance with manufacturer’s instructions to prevent
contamination by foreign materials. Maintain packaged materials in a clean, dry state protected
against weather, traffic, and foreign materials.
1. Do not use cementitious materials that have become damp.
C. Protect materials from tampering, acts of vandalism, and possible injury to workers or the
general public.
1.8 COORDINATION
A. Preconstruction Conference: Prior to beginning the work of this Section, convene a meeting
with the Owner’s Representative and all relevant parties to review work requirements and all
job conditions and processes. All subcontracting firms involved with this work shall participate
in this meeting.
B. Coordinate work of all other trades related to the successful completion of this work.
Thomas Paine Monument, New Rochelle, NY November 2020
HISTORIC MARBLE RESTORATION 040342 - 5
C. Bronze Restoration (Section 050387) shall be completed prior to the work of this Section being
performed.
D. Marble Consolidation work of this Section shall be completed prior to Masonry Cleaning
(Section 040310) being performed.
E. Masonry Cleaning (Section 040310) shall be completed prior to the Crack Repair, Patching, and
Repointing work of this Section being performed.
1.9 PROTECTION AND SCAFFOLDING
A. The Conservator shall take extreme care in protecting the surrounding materials, buildings,
vehicles, and pedestrians. It is the Conservator’s responsibility to ensure that protective
measures are in place and are adequate for the work being performed.
B. Protect adjacent masonry and other work from mortar and adhesive drippings or other damage.
Immediately remove misplaced mortar or adhesive.
C. Scaffold work required to accomplish the work of this Section shall be the responsibility of the
Conservator and shall be made available to all required trades and the Owner’s Representative
without charge. All scaffolding, staging and appurtenances will be adequately and safely
maintained, and shall comply, in total, to the requirements of the Safety and Health Regulations
for Construction, and any and all other government agencies having jurisdiction. The most
stringent requirements shall govern.
1. Scaffolding shall be free standing and shall not make contact with the monument, fence,
or masonry retaining wall.
2. Any damage made to the structure by the scaffold(s) will be repaired by the Conservator
to the satisfaction of the Owner’s Representative at no cost to the Owner.
PART 2 - PRODUCTS
2.1 MARBLE CONSOLIDANT
A. Conservare HCT followed by HCT Finishing Rinse, as manufactured by PROSOCO, Inc., 3741
Greenway Circle, Lawrence, KS 66046, (800) 255-4255
B. Or approved equal.
2.2 SMALL CRACK REPAIR
A. Injection Grouts
1. Ecologic Injection Grout Type 1, as manufactured by LimeWorks.us, 3145 State Road,
Telford, PA 18969, (215) 536-6706
Thomas Paine Monument, New Rochelle, NY November 2020
HISTORIC MARBLE RESTORATION 040342 - 6
2. Heritage Dispersed Hydrated Lime – Injection Mortar, as manufactured by U.S. Heritage
Group 3516 North Kostner Chicago, IL 60641, (773) 286-2100.
3. Jahn M32 Micro Injection Grout, as manufactured by Cathedral Stone Products, Inc. 7266
Park Circle Drive, Hanover, MD 21076 (800 )684-0901.
a. Only Jahn certified installers may install Jahn materials.
4. Pump-X 53iE Injection Grout as manufactured by Edison Coatings 3 Northwest Drive
Plainville, CT 06062 (860)747-2220.
B. Fine-Textured Crack Filler
1. 400 Series PHL C70 Crack Filler, as manufactured by VoidSpan Technologies, LLC, 60
Washington St, Salem, MA 01970, (800) 966-8643.
2. Or approved equal
C. Or approved equal.
2.3 COMPOSITE PATCHING
A. Provide composite patching material that is custom color-matched to the existing marble.
Multiple colors may be required.
B. Acceptable products include:
1. St. Astier Lithomex, as manufactured by LimeWorks.us, 3145 State Road, Telford, PA
18969, (215) 536-6706.
2. Heritage MT15 Marble Travertine Mortar as manufactured by U.S. Heritage Group 3516
North Kostner Chicago, IL 60641, (773) 286-2100.
3. Jahn M120 Marble Repair Mortar as distributed by Cathedral Stone Products, Inc. 7266
Park Circle Drive, Hanover, MD 21076, (800) 684-0901.
a. Only certified installers may purchase and install Jahn Repair Mortar.
4. Custom System 45 Type GR as manufactured by Edison Coatings, 3 Northwest Drive,
Plainville, CT 06062 (800)341-6621.
5. Or approved equal.
2.4 RUST CONVERTOR
A. Apply a rust-converting coating to all abandoned anchors or other ferrous materials that are not
being removed, but which were exposed during this work.
B. Acceptable products include:
Thomas Paine Monument, New Rochelle, NY November 2020
HISTORIC MARBLE RESTORATION 040342 - 7
1. Rust-oleum Rust Reformer, as manufactured by Rust-oleum 11 Hawthorn Parkway,
Vernon Hills, IL 60061, (800) 481-4785.
2. Or approved equal.
2.5 REPOINTING MORTAR
A. The repointing mortar shall be a natural hydraulic lime and sand mortar.
B. Acceptable products include
1. Ecologic Mortar, in DGM SCG Non-pigmented, Butter Joint grade, as manufactured by
LimeWorks.us, 3145 State Road, Telford, PA 18969, (215) 536-6706
2. Or approved equal.
2.6 TOOLS
A. Chisels shall be narrower than the joints in which they are used.
B. Brushes shall be stiff natural or plastic bristle brushes. No metallic brushes shall be used.
C. Fine tools like dental picks and micro-spatulas.
2.7 OTHER MATERIALS
A. Masking Tape: Non-staining, non-absorbent material compatible with pointing mortar, joint
primers, sealants, and surface adjacent to joints that will easily come off entirely, including
adhesive.
B. Grout Injection Implements: Provide syringes or other implements to inject grout into cracks.
C. Low-pressure sprayer with corrosion resistant fittings for applying consolidation chemicals.
PART 3 - EXECUTION
3.1 INSPECTION
A. Examine substrates, supports and conditions under which this work is to be performed and
notify the Owner’s Representative, in writing, of conditions detrimental to the proper
completion of the work. Do not proceed with work until unsatisfactory conditions are
corrected. Beginning work signifies Conservator’s acceptance of substrates and conditions.
B. Review the amount and extent of work to be completed with the or Owner’s Representative
prior to the execution of the work.
Thomas Paine Monument, New Rochelle, NY November 2020
HISTORIC MARBLE RESTORATION 040342 - 8
3.2 EXPOSED FERROUS METALS
A. Apply a rust-inhibiting coating to all abandoned anchors or other ferrous materials that are not
being removed, but which were exposed during this work.
1. Remove corrosion and loose coatings and prepare metal surfaces according to coating
manufacturer’s written instructions prior to application.
2. Protect adjacent work from drips or splatter.
3.3 PRE-CONSOLIDATION
A. Consolidate marble before cleaning and the repairs are executed. The purpose of the
consolidation is to prevent excessive marble loss during the cleaning process.
B. Application Procedure:
1. Use as packaged. Do not dilute or alter. Stir or mix well before use. Following treatment,
do not return used material to its original container.
2. Using low-pressure spray equipment, apply HCT to the point of rejection.
3. Allow the treatment to be absorbed for 30 minutes or until surface is visibly dry.
4. Repeat steps 1 and 2 until three saturating applications have been completed.
5. Allow surfaces treated with HCT to dry for 30 minutes or until surface is visibly dry. If
necessary, drying time may be extended overnight without adverse effects.
6. After the treated surface is thoroughly dry, apply HCT Finishing Rinse to the point of
rejection.
7. Allow treated surfaces to dry for 24 hours before cleaning as per Specification 040310
Masonry Cleaning.
3.4 SMALL CRACK REPAIR
A. Cracks larger than hairline, but narrower than 3/16 inches shall be filled with injectable grout or
fine-textured filler designed for small cracks (VoidSpan PHLc70 Crack Filler).
B. Carefully clean the cracks of biological growth, debris, and failed patching material. The use of
power tools is not permitted for this work. Removal shall be done manually. Dental picks and
other fine tools may be necessary.
C. Flush cracks with clean water.
D. Grout Injection.
1. Preparation:
Thomas Paine Monument, New Rochelle, NY November 2020
HISTORIC MARBLE RESTORATION 040342 - 9
a. Despite what is written in the manufacturer’s instructions, do not drill ports.
Drilling ports will result in the loss of material and inscription.
b. Seal the front of the crack with removable non-staining clay, leaving small
openings to receive the grout injection needle.
2. Mixing:
a. No more material than can be used in 30 minutes shall be mixed at any one time.
Material that has exceeded its pot life shall be discarded.
b. Follow manufacturer’s specification for mix ratios and instructions. Mix for a
minimum of three (3) minutes.
3. Injection Procedure:
a. Moisten the interior of the crack immediately prior to injection by flushing with
clean water. Repeat this step if the surface becomes dry before grout is injected.
b. Inject grout into lowest opening and continue to fill until it flows freely from this
opening and other ports at the same level. Seal ports as indicated until the crack is
filled. Clean up overflow immediately.
c. The repaired crack shall be flush with the face of the masonry work. All entry
ports and crack surfaces shall be subsequently patched with approved composite
patching material to match the color, texture, profile and level of surrounding clean
masonry.
E. Fine-Textured Filler
1. Preparation
a. Immediately prior to filling, dampen contact surfaces to a completely saturated
condition but avoid leaving standing water on the adjacent surfaces and within the
crack to be filled.
2. Mixing
a. Follow manufacturer’s specification for mix ratios and instructions. Hand mix for
1 to 2 minutes, correcting with either water or powder to achieve paste
consistency. To prepare colored fillers, alkali-stable pigments may be added to the
dry powder at a maximum of 2% by weight.
b. Working Time: Up to 60 minutes; do not re-temper after 60 minutes.
3. Procedure:
a. Place the prepared material using traditional pointing methods but with small tools.
Gently push the crack filler into the crack using successive lifts.
b. Do not attempt to push the material into an overly dry crack.
Thomas Paine Monument, New Rochelle, NY November 2020
HISTORIC MARBLE RESTORATION 040342 - 10
4. Clean-up excess material and any mortar smears using a damp sponge or brushes.
3.5 COMPOSITE PATCHING
A. Repair holes, wide cracks, voids, and failed patches with new patching material colored and
tooled to match existing adjacent material.
B. Preparing Void:
1. Completely remove all unsound material and failing and inappropriate patching material.
2. Cut or chisel void to a minimum depth of 1/2 inch. Void must be prepared with squared
sides.
3. Clean all surfaces to be patched of all debris, dust, grease, or other contaminants.
C. Mix patching material per manufacturer’s written instructions.
D. Pre-dampen masonry surfaces to receive patching for a minimum of twenty (20) minutes prior
to mortar placement. Masonry surfaces should be damp but free of excess standing water at
time of mortar placement.
E. Install patching material per manufacturer’s written instructions.
1. Do not feather the edges of composite patching repairs. Maintain manufacturer’s
minimum repair depth.
2. If installation in lifts is required (e.g. to fill deep voids), mechanically remove 1/16 inch of
material from preceding lift and dampen before applying additional patching material.
3. Build up material beyond the level of the adjacent surface.
F. After achieving initial set, tool patching material until the desired profile is reached.
G. Follow patching material manufacturer’s instructions for curing.
1. Periodically mist patching repairs using clean water for at least a 72-hour period. Mist
several times a day. Hot, dry conditions may require misting every 30 to 60 minutes.
2. Plastic sheeting may be used to slow the evaporation of water or protect repairs from rain.
Use of plastic sheeting does not relieve the Conservator of following manufacturer’s
curing procedures.
H. Repaired areas shall match the color, finish, tooling and texture of the existing adjacent masonry
as closely as possible.
3.6 REPOINTING
A. Mortar Removal
Thomas Paine Monument, New Rochelle, NY November 2020
HISTORIC MARBLE RESTORATION 040342 - 11
1. Manually rake joints clean to a depth equal to two and one-half (2-1/2) times the joint
width, or to sound mortar, whichever is deeper. Please note: There may not be any
bedding mortar beyond the pointing mortar.
2. Expose masonry for contact with pointing mortars or sealant. Brush, vacuum, or flush
joints to remove all dirt and loose debris.
3. Power-operated saws and grinders will NOT be permitted for use on the joints. Only
chisels, mallets, or hand saws will be permitted. The diameter of the hand tools shall be
narrower than the original joint width.
4. Do not break or mar edges of masonry units or widen joints.
B. Mortar Mixing
1. Thoroughly mix mortar in quantities needed for immediate use. Add approximately half
the required water and mix mortar for a minimum of five (5) minutes, and then slowly add
water as needed to reach the desired working consistency.
2. Add only clean, potable water at the project site. Do not add sand, stone, cement, lime,
bonding agents, color admixtures, set accelerators, plasticizers, air entraining admixtures
or other materials unless specifically authorized in writing from the manufacturer.
3. Use mortar within 1/2-hour of mixing, after which unused mortar shall be discarded. Do
not re-temper mortars which have begun to set.
C. Pointing
1. Pre-dampen masonry surfaces to receive repointing mortar for a minimum of twenty (20)
minutes prior to mortar placement. Masonry surfaces should be damp but free of excess
standing water at time of mortar placement.
2. Fill mortar joints completely. Apply the mortar in successive lifts, compacting each layer
3. Immediately tool filled joint flush to the surface with a flat profile.
4. Remove excess mortar and smears using a stiff natural bristle brush and clean water
before it has set.
5. Wet-cure tooled joints as required by lightly misting with clean water periodically for a
minimum of three (3) days following installation. Misting should be performed every hour
or two on the first day, as required to maintain the mortar in a damp condition, and this
may be reduced to every three or four hours on subsequent days.
3.7 COMPLETION
A. Upon completion of work, clean all surfaces of any debris, mortar, adhesive, construction
materials, etc.
B. Protect new work against damage from subsequent work.
Thomas Paine Monument, New Rochelle, NY November 2020
HISTORIC MARBLE RESTORATION 040342 - 12
C. Any defective or failed work shall be repaired or replaced using approved procedures.
END OF SECTION
Thomas Paine Monument, New Rochelle, NY November 2020
HISTORIC SCHIST RESTORATION 040344 - 1
SECTION 040344 –HISTORIC SCHIST RESTORATION
PART 1 - GENERAL
1.1 DESCRIPTION
A. Work of this Section consists of providing all labor, materials, equipment and services to remove
and reset existing stone masonry wall of the Thomas Paine Monument to match the original.
Work includes, but is not limited to:
1. Removal of existing planting and excavation of soil.
2. Documentation of existing stone masonry
3. Removal of existing stone masonry
4. Storage of removed stone masonry
5. Dutchman repair of removed stone masonry
6. Resetting removed stone masonry
B. Related Sections:
1. Section 040310 Historic Stone Masonry Cleaning
2. Section 040342 Historic Marble Restoration
3. Section 050372 Historic Iron Fence Restoration
C. Related Documents:
1. Thomas Paine Conditions Assessment and Materials Analyses, dated November 2020, as
prepared by Jablonski Building Conservation, Inc.
1.2 REFERENCES
A. ASTM
1. C144 Standard Specifications for Aggregate for Masonry Mortar
2. C150 Standard Specification for Portland Cement
3. C207 Standard Specification for Hydrated Lime for Masonry Purposes
4. C270 Standard Specification for Mortar for Unit Masonry
5. C615 Standard Specification for Granite Dimension Stone
Thomas Paine Monument, New Rochelle, NY November 2020
HISTORIC SCHIST RESTORATION 040344 - 2
6. C979 Standard Specification for Pigments for Integrally Colored Concrete
B. Manufacturer’s printed recommendations
1.3 QUALITY ASSURANCE
A. Contractor: All work of this Section shall be done by a qualified restoration Contractor with a
minimum of five (5) years of experience working with historic masonry. The Contractor must
demonstrate three (3) projects similar in scope and type to the required work involving facilities
designated as Landmarks by local governments, or buildings listed on the National or State
Register of Historic Places, and completed in the last 5 years
B. Conservator: The Contractor shall retain the services of a qualified Conservator at their own
expense. The Conservator shall supervise the work of the Contractor to ensure conformance with
best practices in the conservation of historic monuments. The Conservator shall be specialized in
stone conservation, have a minimum of ten (10) years of experience working with historic stone
monuments, and hold Professional Associate or Fellow membership in the American Institute for
Conservation.
C. Mechanics: The Contractor shall maintain a steady work crew consisting of skilled mechanics
who are experienced with the materials and methods specified and are familiar with the design
requirements. Mechanics shall have skill and experience of sufficient level to accomplish the
work described. Workers shall be carefully supervised to ensure that the work is accomplished to
meet or exceed the highest standards of the trade. Contractor shall maintain a full-time
Foreperson who fluently speaks, reads, and writes English. In acceptance or rejection of the
work of this Section, no allowance will be made for lack of skill on the part of mechanics.
1. The Contractor shall provide one crew of mechanics for the duration of the project.
Substitutions and additions of work force shall be permitted with the Preservation
Consultant’s or Owner’s Representative’s consent, so long as there is no adverse effect
on quality or performance of work.
D. The Contractor shall repair or replace at no additional expense to the Owner and to the
satisfaction of the Owner or Owner’s Representative all broken, lost, or damaged materials
resulting from the work of this Section.
1.4 SUBMITTALS
A. Qualification Data: Submit qualification data and references for firms and persons specified in
Paragraph 1.3 Quality Assurance to demonstrate their capabilities and experience.
B. Product Literature: Submit copies of the manufacturer’s technical data for each product
including their recommendations for installation and use and Safety Data Sheets (SDS). Include
test reports and certificates that verify the products’ compliance with the specification’s
requirements. One complete set of product literature and SDS shall be placed in a 3-ring, loose-
leaf binder and shall be present on the job site at all times for the reference of the Owner’s
Representative and mechanics.
Thomas Paine Monument, New Rochelle, NY November 2020
HISTORIC SCHIST RESTORATION 040344 - 3
C. Program of Work: Prepare a written, detailed description of materials, methods, equipment, and
sequence of operations to be used for each phase of the work of this Section including protection
of surrounding materials and project site for the approval of the Owner’s Representative.
1. Describe the methods for documenting the original masonry layout and collecting data
points and plumb lines for re-installation of masonry. Include method for labeling the
stone and a storage plan for all stone that is to be removed and reinstalled.
2. If materials and methods other than those indicated are proposed for any phase of
restoration work, add to the Program of Work a written description of such materials and
methods, including evidence of successful use on comparable projects, and
demonstrations to show their effectiveness for this Project and worker's ability to use
such materials and methods properly.
D. Documentation: Provide copies of documentation of existing masonry showing the location of
units to be removed for reinstallation and labels assigned to each unit.
E. Samples:
1. Clearly label all samples to include the project name and contract number, the product
name, manufacturer name, and any other information relevant to identification of and
differentiation between samples including model numbers, production codes, batch
numbers, and color or formula numbers.
2. Submit three (3) sets of the following to the or Owner’s Representative for approval:
a. Cured mortar sample set in 1/2” wide aluminum or plastic channel and measuring
approximately 6 inches long. Submit with sample of mortar aggregate (not less
than 50 grams) and precise measurements of ingredients, proportions, gradations,
and sources of aggregate from which each sample was made.
b. Replacement stone sample measuring not less 36 inches square (e.g. 6 x 6 in.) at its
face and any thickness. Sample shall be representative of the color, veining,
texture, and surface finish to be supplied in completed work. Note: It may be
necessary to submit multiple samples representing the natural range of variation of
the stone.
c. Composite patching sample(s) (if required) for each variation in color.
3. Provide samples of any proposed materials not listed above at the request of the Owner’s
Representative.
1.5 MOCKUPS
A. Prior to executing work, provide in-place mockups for the Owner’s Representative’s approval.
Resubmit panels until the Owner’s Representative is fully satisfied. Mockups shall be prepared
using the same workmen, methods, and materials that will be employed for the remainder of the
work. Approved mockups shall be retained, undisturbed and suitably marked, as the standard of
work throughout construction. Mockups may be incorporated into the finished work when so
approved by the Owner’s Representative.
Thomas Paine Monument, New Rochelle, NY November 2020
HISTORIC SCHIST RESTORATION 040344 - 4
B. No mockups shall be made until the methods and locations are approved by the Owner’s
Representative.
C. Owner’s Representative will be present during the creation of all mockups. Do not proceed with
the work unless the Owner’s Representative is present. Notify the Owner’s Representative no
less than forty-eight (48) hours in advance of mockup.
D. Provide protection for adjacent surfaces during mockups.
E. Provide the following mockups in locations selected by the Owner’s Representative:
1. Masonry Removal: Remove approximately 16 square feet (4’x4’ section) of stone
masonry. Demonstrate techniques for removing the masonry without damaging the
surrounding masonry and materials scheduled to remain.
2. Masonry Resetting: Reset approximately 16 square feet (4’x4’ section) of stone masonry.
Install new accessories including pins, anchors, and flashing in a manner demonstrating
their final installation on the structure. Set masonry units in the specified mortar with
bed, cross or vertical, and collar joints completely filled. Point and clean work as required
to bring to a finished state.
3. Dutchman Installation: Install one dutchman repair. Demonstrate techniques for
removing old patches or unsound stone and installing the dutchman.
1.6 DELIVERY, STORAGE AND HANDLING
A. Materials shall be delivered to site in manufacturer’s original and unopened containers and
packaging.
B. Store materials in a clean, dry state protected against weather, traffic, and foreign materials.
C. See Paragraph 3.4 Storage for storage of removed masonry units.
1.7 JOB CONDITIONS
A. Take extreme care in protecting the adjacent monument, materials, buildings, vehicles, and
pedestrians. The Contractor is responsible for ensuring that protective measures are in place and
are adequate for the work being performed.
B. Protection: Prevent mortar from staining faces of masonry. Protect all adjacent surfaces from
mortar droppings.
C. Cold Weather Requirements: Resetting and pointing work may only be performed as long as the
temperature remains above 40° Fahrenheit. If in any given 24-hour period the temperature drops
or is expected to drop below 40° Fahrenheit at any time, work will not recommence until a
constant temperature of 40° Fahrenheit or higher is projected for a minimum period of 72 hours.
Once stopped for reason of temperature, work will recommence only upon approval of the or
Owner’s Representative.
Thomas Paine Monument, New Rochelle, NY November 2020
HISTORIC SCHIST RESTORATION 040344 - 5
D. Hot Weather Requirements: Protect setting and pointing mortar when temperature and humidity
conditions produce excessive evaporation of water from mortar. Provide artificial shade and
wind breaks and use cooled materials as required to minimize evaporation. Setting and pointing
work shall be protected during hot, dry weather from premature drying or rapid curing by using
dampened fabric coverings or controlled misting with water as required to keep mortar moist for
72 hours following final tooling. Do not apply mortar to substrates with temperatures of 90°
Fahrenheit and above unless otherwise indicated.
E. Materials shall be used only at the manufacturer’s recommended temperature tolerances.
1.8 COORDINATION
A. Preconstruction Conference: Prior to beginning the work of this Section, convene a meeting with
the Owner’s Representative and all relevant parties to review work requirements and all job
conditions and processes. All subcontracting firms involved with this work shall participate in
this meeting.
B. Coordinate work of all other trades related to the successful completion of this work.
C. Iron Fence Removal (Section 050372) shall be completed before the work of this Section is
performed. Coordinate resetting stone masonry with other trades to ensure accurate alignment of
existing fence post holes for fence re-installation.
D. Masonry Cleaning (Section 040310) shall be completed prior to the work of this Section being
performed.
PART 2 - PRODUCTS
2.1 MORTAR
A. Mortar Mix: ASTM C270, Type N
1 part Cement (ASTM C150) consisting of:
3/4 part Portland Cement, Type 1, White
1/4 part Saylor’s Cement
1 part Hydrated Lime, Type S (ASTM C207)
5 parts Aggregate (ASTM C144) consisting of:
3 parts Schofield “181”
2 parts Schofield “107”
B. The mortar mix above was developed using materials that closely approximate the appearance
and performance characteristics of the original mortar. Deviation from this mix may change the
appearance or performance of the mortar. Substitutions, if made, shall match the color of the
original mortar and color and gradation of original aggregate.
C. Mortar Materials:
Thomas Paine Monument, New Rochelle, NY November 2020
HISTORIC SCHIST RESTORATION 040344 - 6
1. Portland Cement: ASTM C150 Type I, white and Saylor’s Cement (brown). Masonry
cement shall not be used.
a. White Portland Cement available from Lehigh Cement Company, 7660 Imperial
Way, Allentown, PA 18195 (800) 638-1716, or approved equal.
b. Saylor’s Cement available from Nazareth Cement Plant and Terminal, Lehigh
Cement Company, 3938 Easton Nazareth Highway, Nazareth, PA 18064, (800)
437-7762, North Region Sr. Sales Representative: Dominic Jampo, (610) 926-
1024, cell: (484) 507-4109, or approved equal.
2. Hydrated Lime: ASTM C207, Type S, incorporated as a finely divided powder in
uniform particle size, free of lumps, flakes or other inconsistencies.
a. Available from Graymont, call for local supplier (800-537-4489, or approved
equal.
3. Mortar Aggregates: ASTM C144 natural sand blend, rounded to sub-angular in shape,
washed, screened and dried. Aggregate to be selected to match the color and texture of
the original mortar aggregates as closely as possible while remaining in compliance with
ASTM C144 grading requirements.
a. Schofield “180” and “107” available from Schofield Stone, P.O. Box 110, Bound
Brook, NJ 08805 (732) 356-0858, or approved equal.
4. Dry Pigments: Pigments, if required, shall be non-fading, UV-stable pigments, blended
with other dry components, in proportions not to exceed those specified in ASTM C979.
5. Admixtures: Admixtures, including air-entraining agents, anti-freeze additives, latex
modifiers, calcium chloride, or otherwise, shall not be used.
6. Water: Potable, free of deleterious quantities of material which may affect mortar
performance or appearance.
2.2 STONE
A. Supply new stone that matches the original schist in color, veining, texture, and surface finish.
B. Stone shall comply with ASTM C 615, “Standard Specification for Granite Dimension Stone” for
material characteristics, physical requirements, and sampling for selection of granite.
C. All schist shall be of standard architectural grade, free of cracks, seams, or starts, which may
impair its structural integrity or function. Color or other visual characteristics indigenous to the
particular material and adequately demonstrated in the samples or mockups will be accepted
provided they do not compromise the structural or durability capabilities of the material. Texture
and finish shall be within the range of samples approved by the or Owner’s Representative.
D. Acceptable suppliers include:
1. Saracino Industries Inc., Yonkers Stone Co., P.O. Box 426, Hawthorne, NY 10532, Tel:
(914) 330-7110, http://yonkersgranite.com.
Thomas Paine Monument, New Rochelle, NY November 2020
HISTORIC SCHIST RESTORATION 040344 - 7
2. Champlain Stone Ltd., 27 Elm Street, Warrensburg, NY 12885, Tel: (518) 623-2902,
http://www.champlainstone.com.
3. A. Ottavino Corporation, Stoneworks, 80-60 Pitkin Avenue Ozone Park, NY 11417, Tel:
(718) 848-9404, Fax: (718) 848-7156.
4. Or approved equal.
2.3 STONE ADHESIVE
A. Provide UV-stable, non-yellowing epoxy adhesive intended for stone-to-stone and stone-to-metal
use.
B. Acceptable products include:
1. Akepox 5010, Epoxy based stone adhesive, U.V. stable, knife grade as manufactured by
Akemi North America.
2. Clear Gel Epoxy as manufactured by Bonstone Materials Corporation.
3. Flexi-Weld 520T as manufactured by Edison Coatings, Inc.
4. Or approved equal.
C. Provide adhesive filler or pre-filled adhesive formula as recommended by manufacturer.
2.4 PINS
A. Provide stainless steel, AISI Type 302 or 304, threaded rods, 3/8” diameter, for Dutchman repairs
or re-joining fractured pieces.
2.5 COMPOSITE PATCHING (IF REQUIRED)
A. Provide custom colored patching mortars to match the existing stone. Acceptable products
include:
1. Jahn M160 Granite Patching Mortar, as manufactured by Cathedral Stone Products, Inc,
7266 Park Circle Drive, Hanover, Maryland, 21076, (410) 782-9150.
2. Custom 45, as manufactured by Edison Coatings 3 Northwest Drive Plainville, CT 06062
(860) 747-2220.
3. Thin Fill 55 Reprofiling Mortar as manufactured by Edison Coatings 3 Northwest Drive
Plainville, CT 06062 (860) 747-2220.
4. Lithomex Brick and Stone Repair Materials, as manufactured by Limeworks.us, 3145
State Road, Telford, PA 18969, 215) 536-6706.
5. Or approved qual.
Thomas Paine Monument, New Rochelle, NY November 2020
HISTORIC SCHIST RESTORATION 040344 - 8
2.6 TOOLS
A. Use of rotary grinders, power chisels, or any other power tools will be permitted only with prior
written approval of tool types, locations and mechanics by the Owner’s Representative (see 1.5
Mockups).
B. Chisels shall be narrower than the joints in which they are used.
C. Brushes for cleaning masonry shall be stiff, natural or synthetic bristle brushes. Metal brushes
shall not be used.
2.7 MICELLANEOUS
A. Setting Shims: Provide hardwood, slate, or plastic shims, non-staining to stone, sized to suit joint
thickness and bed depths.
PART 3 - EXECUTION
3.1 INSPECTION
A. Examine substrates, supports and conditions under which this work is to be performed and notify
the Owner’s Representative, in writing, of conditions detrimental to the proper completion of the
work. Do not proceed with work until unsatisfactory conditions are corrected. Beginning work
signifies Contractor’s acceptance of substrates and conditions.
B. Review the amount and extent of work to be completed with the Owner’s Representative prior to
the execution of the work. Confirm quantities and locations of work.
3.2 SITE WORK - REMOVALS
A. Prior to masonry removals, remove existing plantings located within the perimeter of the wall
and excavate soil adjacent to wall as required to permit removal and resetting of the existing
masonry. Excavation shall be performed using only hand tools. Take care not to mar or otherwise
damage masonry or the monument during excavation.
3.3 DOCUMENTATION
A. All masonry should be carefully labeled and photographed so that they can be reset in their
original locations. Establish and document masonry bond patterns, levels, and coursing before
removal. Carefully measure the dimensions and geometry of the wall prior to dismantling to
ensure an accurate reinstallation.
B. The label shall include a unique identifier for each masonry unit and shall indicate the original
orientation of the unit in the wall to ensure it is reset in its correct location.
C. The labeling system and documentation must be submitted for approval prior to removals, see
Paragraph 1.4 Submittals.
Thomas Paine Monument, New Rochelle, NY November 2020
HISTORIC SCHIST RESTORATION 040344 - 9
D. Temporarily label the front of the masonry units using tape or another approved method that can
be easily removed without disfiguring or damaging the stone. Units shall be permanently labeled
on an unexposed surface following removal.
3.4 REMOVAL
A. Protect and structurally support existing masonry to remain which surrounds or contacts removal
areas.
B. Stone masonry shall be carefully removed without damaging the removed units or adjacent work
to remain.
C. Power-operated, rotary hand-held saws and grinders will be permitted for use in cutting joints,
with the approval of the Owner’s Representative, only if the Contractor can demonstrate the
ability of the operators to use tools without damaging the masonry. If damage to the masonry is
caused by the use of power tools, only chisels and mallets will be permitted for the remainder of
the project.
1. Center-cut joints: If power operated tools are permitted by the Owner’s Representative,
these tools shall only be used to cut a single kerf in the center of the masonry joints. Hand
tools shall be used to remove the remaining mortar from sides of the joints.
2. Do not break or mar edges of masonry units or widen joints. Replace in kind all masonry
joints which have become damaged.
D. Carefully remove entire units from joint to joint in a manner that will permit replacement with
full-sized units.
E. Clean all mortar and debris from exposed surfaces of removed units using hand chisels, brushes,
and water.
F. Following cleaning, transfer the information contained in the temporary label to the side of the
masonry unit using weatherproof marking.
G. Notify the Owner’s Representative of any unforeseen detrimental conditions including voids,
cracks, bulges, and loose masonry units in existing masonry backups, rotted wood, rusted metals,
and other deteriorated items.
3.5 STORAGE
A. Following removal, masonry units shall be palletized and secured as necessary to pallets for
transportation to the designated storage location.
1. Support irregular-shaped units using softwood or rigid foam insulation.
2. Label pallets as necessary to identify original location of contents.
3. Stone shall be neatly stacked on pallets. Do not exceed the load capacity of the pallet.
Thomas Paine Monument, New Rochelle, NY November 2020
HISTORIC SCHIST RESTORATION 040344 - 10
B. Removed masonry units shall be stored in a secure location approved by the Owner’s
Representative until installation can proceed.
C. Storage location shall be adequately secured to protect the masonry from theft or damage by the
public or other trades.
D. If masonry is stored outside, protect the unit labels from weathering so that they remain legible.
3.6 RESETTING
A. In areas scheduled for resetting, reinstall masonry units removed from the area. Units shall be
reset in the same location from which they were removed. Use the documentation and labeling
system established before the removal to reset the units.
B. Mortar Mixing
1. Thoroughly blend all dry components before the addition of water.
2. Mix mortar in quantities needed for immediate use. Add approximately half the required
water and mix mortar for a minimum of five (5) minutes, and then slowly add more water
as needed to reach the desired working consistency. Mortar may be mixed by hand or by
mechanical batch-type mixer.
3. Add only clean, potable water at the project site. Do not add sand, cement, lime, bonding
agents, color admixtures, set accelerators, plasticizers, air entraining admixtures or other
materials unless specifically authorized in writing from the manufacturer.
4. Use mortar within 1/2-hour of mixing, after which unused mortar shall be discarded. Do
not re-temper mortar which has begun to set.
C. Pre-wet masonry prior to installation. Stone should be nearly saturated, but with a dry surface
when laid.
D. Masonry shall be set in a solid and evenly filled bed of mortar, with bed, head, and collar joints
filled.
1. Cover sides of unit and backfill void with sufficient mortar to ensure that there will be no
air voids when the new unit is set.
E. Stone units shall be set true and level, matching the existing bond pattern, coursing, and joint
details.
F. Deteriorated or missing units shall be replaced with new or salvaged masonry that matches the
original in type, size, texture, and finish. See 3.7 Unit Replacement.
G. Point and tool joints to match the original joint profiles after the new units have been properly
installed and adjusted.
H. Protect freshly installed masonry from weather for a minimum 48-hours after placement. In hot
or dry conditions, protect mortar from premature drying by periodic misting with a fine,
nebulized water spray or by covering with wet burlap.
Thomas Paine Monument, New Rochelle, NY November 2020
HISTORIC SCHIST RESTORATION 040344 - 11
I. Clean all exposed faces of reset masonry with non-metallic brushes and water to remove any
excess mortar before mortar has set.
3.7 UNIT REPLACEMENT
A. Masonry units with extensive damage that cannot be repaired to a satisfactory appearance, as
determined by Owner’s Representative, shall be replaced.
B. Final determination of which units require replacement shall be at the discretion of the Owner’s
Representative.
C. Units requiring replacement shall be replaced in kind. Fabricate new units to match the original
schist in shape, dimension, profile, and finish.
D. Retain original damaged units, suitably marked to identify their original location and orientation,
for reference until replacement has been fabricated and approved by the Owner’s Representative.
E. Following approval of replacement units, damaged original units may be re-used as donor
material for other smaller replacement units or Dutchman repairs.
3.8 DUTCHMAN REPAIR
A. Repair complete spalls, large penetrations, inappropriate patches, or other losses in masonry units
by piecing-in material to match adjacent work (Dutchman repair).
B. New material, where used, shall match the existing stone in color, texture, and tooling.
C. Preparation:
1. Remove damaged or defective portion of existing stone unit by making horizontal and
vertical saw cuts into the face of the unit and demolish defective material to depth
required for fitting Dutchman.
a. Remove no more than the minimum required from the host stone to make repair.
b. Make edges at void cuts smooth and square to each other and to stone surface.
Make back of void flat and parallel to the face of the unit.
c. Do not overcut at corners or intersections. Use hand tools to produce clean, sharp
corners.
d. For damage occurring at the edge of units, void may be flared to a dovetail shape
to produce a self-locking repair.
e. Do not damage existing work to remain. If damage occurs, enlarge repair area as
required to remove damage.
f. Clean void to remove all loose material, dust, and debris.
2. Cut and trim Dutchman to accurately fit the void cut in the host stone.
Thomas Paine Monument, New Rochelle, NY November 2020
HISTORIC SCHIST RESTORATION 040344 - 12
a. Joints between Dutchman and host stone shall not exceed 1/16 inches.
b. Cut and orient Dutchmen so that natural bedding planes, where applicable, are
parallel to those of the host stone.
3. Pinning: Pin large repairs, including Dutchmen greater than or equal to 2 inches thick and
4 inches in diameter, or as required to support and produce a stable and durable repair.
a. Before applying adhesive, prepare pieces for concealed mechanical anchorage
consisting of threaded stainless steel rod set in holes drilled into, but not through,
host stone and Dutchman.
b. Provide a minimum of two pins per repair.
c. Center and space pins at minimum 1 inch from any edge.
d. Drill holes to provide a minimum of 1 inch of embedment into both host and repair
stones.
e. Clean holes free of dust and debris using compressed air.
f. Holes for pins shall be completely filled with adhesive and free of voids after pin is
inserted
4. Tool Dutchman as required to match adjacent tooling in host stone. Final tooling may be
done in place.
D. Setting Dutchman:
1. Clean bonding surfaces of Dutchman and void in host stone to ensure they are dry and
free of dirt, grease, and other contaminants.
a. De-grease surfaces using acetone or another suitable solvent as recommended by
adhesive manufacturer.
2. Mask exposed faces of stone directly adjacent to repair areas using tape or strippable
masking.
3. Mix adhesive according to manufacturer’s written instructions.
4. Apply an even thickness of adhesive to both surfaces, filling all crevices and voids.
a. Adhesive must remain at minimum 1/4 inch away from the exposed edge(s) of the
repair.
5. Securely join, align, and support pieces using clamps or other devices until adhesive has
set.
6. Immediately remove excess adhesive with solvent as recommended by adhesive
manufacturer. Remove masking before adhesive has set.
Thomas Paine Monument, New Rochelle, NY November 2020
HISTORIC SCHIST RESTORATION 040344 - 13
E. If open joints or voids remain along perimeter joint of repair after adhesive has cured, fill with
custom colored composite patching as required to match adjacent stone in color, texture and
profile.
F. Allow adhesive to achieve full cure as indicated in manufacturer’s instructions before performing
any final cutting, tooling or dressing.
3.9 COMPLETION
A. After mortar has set, thoroughly clean exposed masonry surfaces of excess mortar and foreign
matter using stiff nylon or natural bristle brushes and clean water spray applied at low pressure.
1. The use of metal scrapers or brushes will not be permitted.
2. The use of acidic masonry cleaners will not be permitted.
B. Protect new work against damage from subsequent work.
C. Any defective or failed work shall be repaired or replaced using approved procedures.
D. Following inspection and acceptance of the completed masonry work, replace soil within wall
perimeter and lightly compact. Top of soil shall be no higher than the bottom of the monument’s
marble base.
END OF SECTION
Thomas Paine Monument, New Rochelle, NY November 2020
HISTORIC IRON FENCE RESTORATION 050372 - 1
SECTION 050372 – HISTORIC IRON FENCE RESTORATION
PART 1 - GENERAL
1.1 DESCRIPTION
A. The work of this Section consists of providing all labor, materials, equipment and services to
complete the restoration of iron fence around the Thomas Paine Monument. Work includes,
but is not limited to:
1. Removal of existing iron fencing for restoration in a metal shop off-site.
2. Blast cleaning existing iron fencing to remove coatings and corrosion.
3. Replacement of damaged or missing fence elements with new to match existing.
4. Shop prime and paint cleaned iron fencing.
5. Reinstallation of the iron fence.
B. Related Sections:
1. Section 040310 Historic Stone Masonry Cleaning
2. Section 040342 Historic Stone Marble Restoration
3. Section 040344 Historic Schist Restoration
C. Related Documents:
1. Thomas Paine Monument Conditions Assessment and Materials Analysis, dated
November 2020, as prepared by Jablonski Building Conservation, Inc.
1.2 REFERENCES
A. Materials and work shall conform to the latest editions of reference specifications listed below,
specified herein and to all applicable codes and requirements of local authorities having
jurisdiction, whichever is more stringent.
1. American Society for Testing and Materials (ASTM)
a. A27/A27M Standard Specification for Steel Castings, Carbon, for General
Applications
b. A48/A48M Standard Specification for Gray Iron Castings
c. A53/A53M Standard Specification for Pipe, Steel, Black and Hot-Dipped, Zinc
Coated, Welded and Seamless
Thomas Paine Monument, New Rochelle, NY November 2020
HISTORIC IRON FENCE RESTORATION 050372 - 2
d. A536 Standard Specification for Ductile Iron Castings
e. A653 Standard Specification for Steel Sheet, Zinc-Coated (Galvanized) or Zinc-
Iron Alloy-Coated (Galvannealed) by the Hot-Dip Process
f. F2329/F2329M Standard Specification for Zinc Coating, Hot-Dip, Requirements
for Application to Carbon and Alloy Steel Bolts, Screws, Washers, Nuts, and
Special Threaded Fasteners
2. American Welding Society (AWS), “D1-1: Structural Welding”
3. Industrial Fasteners Institute (IFI), “Handbook on Bolt, Nut and Rivet Standards”
4. National Association of Architectural Metal Manufacturers (NAAMM) specifications and
guidelines
5. National Park Service, Preservation Assistance Division, “Metals in America’s Historic
Buildings: Uses and Preservation Treatments”
6. Society for Protective Coatings (SSPC)
a. SSPC PC-10 Near White Blast Cleaning (for work performed in the shop)
b. PA 1 Shop, Field and Maintenance Painting, Steel Structure Painting Manual, vol.
2
7. Manufacturer’s printed instructions
B. Materials shall conform to governing regulations regarding the content of volatile organic
compounds.
1.3 QUALITY ASSURANCE
A. Contractor: All work of this Section shall be done by a qualified architectural metals restoration
Contractor with a minimum of five (5) years of experience working with materials and
assemblies similar to those required for the Project. The Contractor must demonstrate three (3)
projects similar in scope and type to the required work involving facilities designated as
Landmarks by local governments, or buildings listed on the National or State Register of
Historic Places.
B. Conservator: The Contractor shall retain the services of a qualified Conservator at their own
expense. The Conservator shall supervise the work of the Contractor to ensure conformance
with best practices in the conservation of historic monuments. The Conservator shall be
specialized in stone conservation, have a minimum of ten (10) years of experience working
with historic stone monuments, and hold Professional Associate or Fellow membership in the
American Institute for Conservation.
C. Fabricators: All fabrication work of this Section shall be done by qualified Fabricators with a
minimum of five (5) years of experience fabricating materials similar to those required for the
Thomas Paine Monument, New Rochelle, NY November 2020
HISTORIC IRON FENCE RESTORATION 050372 - 3
Project. The Fabricator must demonstrate three (3) projects similar in scope and type to the
required work involving facilities designated as Landmarks by local governments, or buildings
listed on the National or State Register of Historic Places.
D. Mechanics: The Contractor shall maintain a steady work crew consisting of skilled mechanics
who are experienced with the materials and methods specified and are familiar with the design
requirements. Mechanics shall have skill and experience of sufficient level to accomplish the
work described. Workers shall be carefully supervised to ensure that the work is accomplished
to meet or exceed the highest standards of the trade. Contractor shall maintain a full-time
Foreperson who fluently speaks, reads, and writes English. In acceptance or rejection of the
work of this Section, no allowance will be made for lack of skill on the part of mechanics.
1. The Contractor shall provide one crew of mechanics for the duration of the project.
Substitutions and additions of work force shall be permitted with the Engineer’s consent,
so long as there is no adverse effect on quality or performance of work.
E. Source Limitations: Obtain products from a single source for each type of material required to
ensure a match in quality, color, texture, and pattern.
F. Damage: The Contractor shall repair or replace at no additional expense to the Owner and to
the satisfaction of the Owner’s Representative all broken, lost, or damaged materials resulting
from the work of this Section.
G. Owner’s Representative shall be given regular access to the Contractor’s scaffolding, swing
stage, or work site so that he/she may inspect work being performed.
H. Owner’s Representative shall be given regular access to the Fabricator’s studio or work site, so
that he/she may inspect the work being performed.
1.4 SUBMITTALS
A. Qualification data and references for firms and persons specified in Paragraph 1.3 “Quality
Assurance” to demonstrate their capabilities and experience.
B. Product Literature: Submit copies of the manufacturer’s technical data for each product
including their recommendations for installation and use and Safety Data Sheets (SDS).
Include test reports and certificates that verify the products’ compliance with the specification’s
requirements. One complete set of product literature and SDS shall be placed in a 3-ring, loose-
leaf binder and shall be present on the job site at all times for the reference of the Owner’s
Representative and mechanics.
C. Program of Work: Prepare a written, detailed description of materials, methods, equipment,
and sequence of operations to be used for each phase of the work of this Section including
protection of surrounding materials and project site for the approval of the Owner’s
Representative.
1. Describe the methods for documenting the original fence layout and collecting data
points and plumb lines for re-installation of the stone. Include method for labeling fence
section and a transportation plan.
Thomas Paine Monument, New Rochelle, NY November 2020
HISTORIC IRON FENCE RESTORATION 050372 - 4
2. If materials and methods other than those indicated are proposed for any phase of
restoration work, add to the Program of Work a written description of such materials and
methods, including evidence of successful use on comparable projects, and
demonstrations to show their effectiveness for this Project and worker's ability to use
such materials and methods properly.
D. Documentation: Provide copies of documentation of existing fence showing the location of
sections to be removed for reinstallation and labels assigned to each unit. Include all
measurements and locations of post holes, which will be required for the proper re-installation.
E. Containment and disposal plans for coating removal and cleaning operations in accordance with
all applicable regulations.
F. Samples: Contractor shall submit three (3) sets of the following to the Engineer for approval:
1. Samples of painted finishes for initial selection.
2. Samples of all hardware, anchors, and fasteners.
3. Samples of all castings for approval prior to full-scale production.
G. Shop Drawings: Contractor shall submit the following to the Engineer for approval:
1. Drawings for temporary shoring systems, if necessary, approved by a licensed structural
engineer.
2. Dimensions of each piece, component or ornament that requires fabrication.
a. No final sizing or finishing shall be done until the Shop Drawings for that part of
the work have been approved.
3. Conditions for installation showing layout, dimensions, and location of each component
corresponding to the sequence and procedure of installation.
H. Submittal Labels: Clearly label all samples to include the project name and contract number,
the product name, manufacturer name, and any other information relevant to identification of
and differentiation between samples including production codes, batch numbers, and color or
formula numbers.
I. Field Measurements: Fabricator and/or Contractor shall be responsible for all field
measurements. Fabricator and Contractor shall review, approve and countersign all of their
Shop Drawings prior to their submission to the Engineer for review and approval.
J. If alternate methods and materials to those specified are proposed for any phase of the work,
provide written description. Provide evidence of successful use on comparable projects and
demonstrate its effectiveness for use on this project.
Thomas Paine Monument, New Rochelle, NY November 2020
HISTORIC IRON FENCE RESTORATION 050372 - 5
1.5 MOCKUPS
A. Prior to executing work, provide in-place mockups for the Engineer’s approval. Resubmit
panels until the Engineer is fully satisfied. Mockups shall be prepared by the Contractor using
the same workmen, methods, and materials that will be employed for the remainder of the
work. Approved mockups shall be retained, undisturbed and suitably marked, as the standard
of work throughout construction. Mockups may be incorporated into the finished work when so
approved by the Owner’s Representative.
B. No mockups shall be made until the methods and locations are approved by the Owner’s
Representative.
C. Owner’s Representative will be present during the creation of all mockups. Do not proceed
with the work unless the Owner’s Representative is present. Notify the Owner’s Representative
no less than forty-eight (48) hours in advance of mockup.
D. Provide protection for adjacent surfaces during the mockup phase.
E. Provide the following mockups in locations selected by the Owner’s Representative:
1. The removal of one fence section and two posts
2. Paint removal from one section of fence. This will require a visit to the metal workshop.
3. Prime and paint one section of fence. This will require a visit to the metal workshop.
4. The installation of one fence section and two posts.
1.6 JOB CONDITIONS
A. All materials shall be used only within the manufacturer’s recommended temperature
tolerances.
B. Perform all work of this Section in accordance with all City, State and Federal regulations
regarding the transportation, storing, handling, application, removal and disposal of chemicals
and run-off.
1. Use all necessary precautions to protect persons performing the work and others from any
harmful effects of the cleaning agents. Workers shall be required to wear protective
clothing, goggles, face shields, gloves, and other clothing or equipment in compliance
with MSDS, governing Federal, State, and local safety codes and regulations.
2. Do not allow run-off from the paint removal or cleaning process to enter storm sewer
system, contaminate water supplies or to enter natural bodies of water. Dispose of
effluent in safe and legal way as outlined in the approved containment plan.
3. Provide, erect, and maintain barricades, danger signals and warning signs as needed.
Thomas Paine Monument, New Rochelle, NY November 2020
HISTORIC IRON FENCE RESTORATION 050372 - 6
1.7 LEAD-CONTAINING PAINT
A. Work that disturbs lead-containing paint shall be done in accordance with all federal, state and
local regulations and all applicable OSHA regulations, Title 29, Section 1929.62, Code of
Federal Regulations, OSHA, US Department of Labor.
B. Dispose of lead-containing paint chips as hazardous waste according to federal, state, and local
regulations: New York State Department of Environmental Conservation (NYSDEC), Title 6,
Part 364 and Parts 370-374; and US Department of Transportation, 49CFR Parts 173, 178, and
179.
C. Comply with all applicable regulations for the containerization, transportation and disposal of
hazardous waste.
1.8 DELIVERY, STORAGE AND HANDLING
A. Packing and Loading: Metal components shall be carefully packed and loaded for shipment
using all reasonable and customary precautions against damage in transit. No material which
may cause staining or discoloration shall be used for blocking or packing.
B. Deliver materials to site in manufacturer’s original and unopened containers and packaging,
bearing labels as to type and name of product and manufacturer.
C. Store materials off the ground and in accordance with manufacturer’s instructions to prevent
contamination by foreign materials. Maintain packaged materials in a clean, dry state protected
against weather, traffic, and foreign materials. Salt shall not be used for removing ice on or
near finished metals under any circumstances.
D. Protect materials from theft, tampering, acts of vandalism, or possible injury to workers and the
general public.
1.9 COORDINATION
A. Preconstruction Conference: Prior to beginning the work of this Section, convene a meeting
with the Owner’s Representative and all relevant parties to review the requirements of the
Quality Control Plan, installation procedures, locations of required mockup areas, and all job
conditions and processes. All subcontracting firms involved with this work shall participate in
this meeting.
B. Coordinate work of all other trades related to the successful completion of this work.
C. The removal of the fence shall be completed before the work of Section 040344 Historic Schist
Restoration.
Thomas Paine Monument, New Rochelle, NY November 2020
HISTORIC IRON FENCE RESTORATION 050372 - 7
PART 2 - PRODUCTS
2.1 WROUGHT IRON
A. Provide new wrought fence details and brackets to match existing.
1. Metals:
a. Ductile Iron: 65-45-12, ASTM A536
2. Dimensions: Match existing
3. Color: Match existing
2.2 PAINT MATERIALS
A. Primer for blast cleaned elements: A high performance zinc rich primer such as “Series 90-98
Tnemec-Zinc," manufactured by Tnemec Company, Inc., or approved equal. Apply 2 coats.
Provide minimum 5 mil dry film thickness.
B. Second and Finish Coats: "Series 113 “H.B. Tnemec-Tufcoat” manufactured by Tnemec
Company, Inc. or approved equal. Provide 4 - 9 mil dry film thickness.
C. Colors: Finish Coat paint color to be Tnemec “Black” 35GR in a semi-gloss finish. Prime
coats and undercoats shall each have a slight variation of color to distinguish them from the
preceding coat.
2.3 MISCELLANEOUS
A. Welding Rods:
1. Type and alloy of filler metal and electrodes as recommended by the manufacturer of
metal to be welded, and as required for color match, strength and compatibility in the
fabricated items.
2. Weld rods and Electrodes to conform to ASME SFA-5.15 “Specifications for Welding
Electrodes and Rods for Cast Iron.”
B. Anchoring
1. Lead for Setting Cast-iron: molten lead is to be used in the setting of the cast-iron
elements, in accordance with accepted industry standards and practices. Antimonial lead.
2. Bolts for anchoring shall be wrought iron, cast iron, low alloy steel or carbon steel anchor
bolt system, as approved by the Resident Engineer, based on site conditions.
a. Carbon steel to be Grade A according to ASTM A 307 “Standard Specifications for
Carbon Steel Bolts, Screws and Studs.” Alloy steel to conform to ASTM A354
Thomas Paine Monument, New Rochelle, NY November 2020
HISTORIC IRON FENCE RESTORATION 050372 - 8
“Standard Specification for Quenched and Tempered Alloy Steel Bolts, Studs and
other Externally Threaded Fasteners.” For components of mating fasteners (bolts,
nuts, washers) use carbon or alloy steel according to ASTM A563 “Standard
Specifications for Carbon and Alloy Steel Nuts.”
C. Protection for adjacent surfaces such as plastic sheeting or liquid strippable masking agent
PART 3 - EXECUTION
3.1 INSPECTION
A. Examine the areas and conditions under which work of this Section will be performed. Correct
conditions detrimental to timely and proper completion of the work, such as metal fasteners,
wires and cables, loose masonry, etc. Do not proceed until unsatisfactory conditions are
corrected.
3.2 DOCUMENTATION
A. All fence sections and posts should be carefully labeled and photographed so that they can be
reset in their original locations. Key the labels to photographs, sketches, or plans for
reinstallation.
1. The label shall include a unique identifier for each fence section and post and shall
indicate the original orientation wall to ensure it is reset in its correct location.
2. The labelling system and documentation must be submitted for approval prior to
removals, see Paragraph 1.4 Submittals.
3. Labels shall consist of stamped metal tags attached with wire that can withstand
sandblasting and repainting so that they can remain on the sections throughout the
restoration process.
B. Carefully measure the dimensions and geometry of the wall prior to dismantling to ensure an
accurate reinstallation. Produce templates of the post hole locations in the coping stones to
facilitate reinstallation on the original
3.3 REMOVAL
A. Dismantling of the fence is to be done only in the presence of the Architectural Conservator
who is experienced with historic metalwork.
B. Carefully remove the wrought iron fence from the perimeter wall. If the bolts can be loosened,
brackets between fence post sections may be mechanically separated. If the bolts cannot be
loosened, or the connection is a welded connection, the fence can be cut at these locations.
Thomas Paine Monument, New Rochelle, NY November 2020
HISTORIC IRON FENCE RESTORATION 050372 - 9
1. Cut metal by sawing, shearing, or blanking. Flame cutting will not be permitted. Make
cuts accurate, clean, sharp and fee of burrs without deforming adjacent surfaces or
metals.
C. Gently warm the posts near their settings in the stone to soften the lead. Carefully shake the
posts to loosen and remove them. Legs are not to be cut
D. Support each item as it becomes loosened to prevent stress and damage to the historic fabric.
E. Package the fence sections and elements for transport to the metal workshop. Prevent metal
elements from getting broken or bent in transit.
F. Color photographs are to be taken during the dismantling process to document the removal, the
components and the connections. These photographs can be used to assist in the reinstallation
of the units after restoration.
3.4 CLEANING
A. Painted coating and rust are to be removed from the surface of the cast iron using abrasive
methods performed in accordance with the requirements of SSPC PC-10 Near White Blast
Cleaning.
B. The end condition of the cleaned surface, when viewed without magnification, is to be free of
all visible oil, grease, dust, dirt, mill scale, rust, coating, oxides, corrosion products and other
foreign matter.
C. Some fastener holes may need to be re-drilled to remove any accumulated corrosion. All metal
newly exposed by this method will need to be immediately primed.
D. Be aware that lead paint may be present. Follow all local, state, and federal regulations for
handling and disposal of lead-based paint.
3.5 METALS FABRICATION
A. Replace all missing, broken, or deteriorated pieces with new units matching the existing or
adjacent in size, profile, and conformation.
B. Take field measurements prior to preparation of shop drawings and fabrication.
C. All materials, accessories, and other related parts shall be new and free from defects which in
any manner may impair their character, appearance, strength, durability or function.
D. Except as otherwise shown on the approved Shop Drawings, use materials of size, thickness
and type required to produce reasonable strength and durability in executing the work of this
Section.
E. Provide materials that have been selected for their surface flatness, smoothness and freedom
from surface blemishes where exposed to view in the finished unit. Exposed-to-view surfaces,
Thomas Paine Monument, New Rochelle, NY November 2020
HISTORIC IRON FENCE RESTORATION 050372 - 10
which exhibit pitting, seam marks, roller marks, stains, discolorations or other imperfections on
the finished units will not be acceptable.
F. Components shall be designed and fabricated to allow for expansion and contraction for a
minimum ambient temperature range of 120° F., without causing buckling, excessive opening
of joints, or overstressing of welds and fasteners or anchors.
G. Fabricate with accurate angles and surfaces which are true to the required lines and levels,
grinding exposed welds smooth and flush, forming exposed connections with hairline joints,
and using concealed fasteners wherever possible.
H. All removable members shall be carefully machined and fitted and shall be secured by bolts of
proper size and approved spacing.
I. Drill or cleanly punch holes; do not burn.
J. Provide all hardware required for installation.
K. Connections:
1. Mill joints to a tight, hairline fit. Form joints exposed to weather to exclude water
penetration. Dress surfaces smooth and free from mill marks or imperfections.
2. Bolts and screws: Make threaded connections tight with threads entirely concealed. Use
lock washers and nuts. Screw heads exposed to view shall be flat and counter-sunk
unless otherwise noted. Cut off projecting ends of exposed bolts and screws flush with
nuts or adjacent metal.
3. Welding shall be in accordance with “Standard Code for Welding in Building
Construction” of the American Welding Society (AWS) and shall be done with electrodes
and methods as recommended by the manufacturers of the metals being welded. Weld
shall be continuous, except where spot welding is specifically permitted. Welds exposed
to view shall be ground flush and dressed smooth and to match profile of adjoining
surfaces. Undercut metal edges behind surfaces which will be exposed to view so as to
prevent distortion of finished surface. Remove weld splatter and welding oxides from all
welded surfaces.
3.6 SHOP FINISHING
A. Shop coat all ferrous metal surfaces using specified primer paint and two coats of the specified
finish paint according to the Steel Structures Painting Manual Vol. 2, SSPC PA-1, “Paint
Application Specification No. 1, Shop, Field and Maintenance Painting.”
B. Paint shall be delivered in the original containers of the approved manufacturer
C. Painting shall be done in dry weather or under cover, and iron surfaces shall be free of moisture
or frost. No materials shall be delivered until the shop coat has dried.
D. Coats shall follow the specified thicknesses as specified in Section 2.2.
Thomas Paine Monument, New Rochelle, NY November 2020
HISTORIC IRON FENCE RESTORATION 050372 - 11
E. Surfaces concealed from view in the finished construction work and which will not be
accessible shall receive an additional shop coat of paint. Touch-up marred and abraded
surfaces with the specified paint after erection in the field.
3.7 INSTALLATION AND REASSEMBLY
A. All ironwork shall be installed in strict accordance with plans and specifications in a
workmanlike manor.
B. Re-installation of the fence is not to begin until the paint has fully dried.
C. All components shall be laid out and pre-assembled to ensure proper alignment and fit.
D. Re-install the fence in the order it was originally constructed, recreating its original appearance.
E. Reassemble iron fence so that it is plumb, level and secure.
F. Components shall be reassembled to allow for expansion and contraction for a minimum
ambient temperature range of 120° F., without causing buckling, excessive opening of joints or
overstressing of welds and fasteners or anchors.
G. Replace all existing fasteners with wrought-iron or carbon-steel bolts, nuts, screws or other
fasteners.
H. Fence posts shall be set in molten lead. Be sure the masonry is completely dry prior to pouring
the lead. Any moisture in the stone will turn to steam and potentially spall the stone.
I. Fence sections shall be attached to the fence posts using new brackets that are bolted or welded
to the posts. The fence sections shall be attached to the brackets using bolts.
J. Do not cut or abrade finishes which cannot be completely restored in the field. Return items
with such finishes to the shop for required alteration, followed by complete refinishing, or
provide new units at Contractor’s option.
K. Immediately after assembly, clean all bolted connections and all filled and abraded areas.
L. Field Welding:
1. Comply with AWS Code for the procedures of manual shield metal-arc welding, the
appearance and quality of the welds made, and the methods used in correcting welding
work.
2. Any field welding required shall be concealed and not visible in the finished work.
3. Grind all welds smooth.
M. Field prime and paint all fasteners, welds, or metal surfaces that have become damaged during
installation. Protect all adjacent masonry from paint drips or overpainting.
Thomas Paine Monument, New Rochelle, NY November 2020
HISTORIC IRON FENCE RESTORATION 050372 - 12
3.8 SITE CLEAN-UP
A. Keep the site clean and remove all debris at the end of each work day.
END OF SECTION
Thomas Paine Monument, New Rochelle, NY November 2020
HISTORIC BRONZE SCULPTURE TREATMENT 050387 - 1
SECTION 050387 – HISTORIC BRONZE SCULPTURE TREATMENT
PART 1 - GENERAL
1.1 DESCRIPTION
A. Work of this Section consists of providing all labor, materials, equipment and services to treat
the bronze bust at the top of the Thomas Paine Monument. Work includes, but is not limited to:
1. Cleaning to remove general soiling and reduce water streaks.
2. Application of protective wax coating.
B. Related Sections:
1. Section 040310 Historic Masonry Cleaning
2. Section 040342 Historic Marble Restoration
C. Related Documents:
1. Thomas Paine Monument Conditions Assessment and Materials Analyses, dated
November 2020, as prepared by Jablonski Building Conservation, Inc.
1.2 REFERENCES
A. Manufacturer’s printed recommendations
1.3 QUALITY ASSURANCE
A. All work of this Section shall be done by a trained Conservator specialized in metal/bronze
conservation and holding Professional Associate or Fellow membership in the American
Institute for Conservation. The Conservator shall have a minimum of ten (10) years of
experience working with historic metal. The Conservator must demonstrate three (3) projects
similar in scope and type to the required work completed in the last 5 years.
B. Conservation technicians, if used, shall be experienced with the materials and methods
specified, and are familiar with the design requirements. Technicians shall be carefully
supervised to ensure that the work is accomplished to meet or exceed the highest standards of
the trade. Conservator shall maintain a full-time Foreperson who fluently speaks, reads, and
writes English. In acceptance or rejection of the work of this Section, no allowance will be
made for lack of skill on the part of technicians.
C. The Conservator shall provide one crew of workers for the duration of the project. Substitutions
and additions of work force shall be permitted with the Owner’s Representative’s consent, so
long as there is no adverse effect on quality or performance of work.
Thomas Paine Monument, New Rochelle, NY November 2020
HISTORIC BRONZE SCULPTURE TREATMENT 050387 - 2
D. Conservator shall replace at no additional cost to the Owner all materials that are broken, lost,
or damaged during the work of this Section.
E. If the Conservator fails to follow approved procedures, work may be stopped immediately.
1.4 SUBMITTALS
A. Qualification Data: Submit qualification data and references for firms and persons specified in
Paragraph 1.3 “Quality Assurance” to demonstrate their capabilities and experience.
B. Product Literature: Submit copies of the manufacturer’s technical data for each product,
including their recommendations for use, and Safety Data Sheets (SDS). Include test reports
and certificates that verify the products’ compliance with the requirements of this Section. One
complete set of product literature and MSDS shall be placed in a 3-ring, loose-leaf binder and
shall be present on the job site at all times for the reference of the Owner’s Representative and
Mechanics.
C. Program of Work: Submit a detailed written description of materials, methods, equipment, and
sequence of operations to be used for each phase of the cleaning work including protection of
surrounding materials and Project site.
1. If materials and methods other than those indicated are proposed for any phase of the
cleaning work, include a written description of such materials and methods, including
evidence of successful use on comparable projects, and demonstrations to show their
effectiveness for this Project and worker's ability to use such materials and methods
properly.
1.5 MOCKUPS
A. Not used.
1.6 DELIVERY, STORAGE AND HANDLING
A. All materials shall be delivered to the job site in original unopened containers bearing
manufacturers’ name and label. Store and handle materials in strict compliance with
manufacturer's instructions.
B. Protect materials from tampering, acts of vandalism, possible injury to workers, the general
public, intrusion of foreign materials, and moisture. All vessels shall have tight fitting covers.
At no time shall vessels containing chemicals be carried to working levels when vessels are
open.
1.7 JOB CONDITIONS
A. Cold weather protection: For any cleaning method requiring water, cleaning shall not begin
until average daily temperatures remain above 40°F (4°C), including overnight. Do not clean if
Thomas Paine Monument, New Rochelle, NY November 2020
HISTORIC BRONZE SCULPTURE TREATMENT 050387 - 3
the temperature of air or masonry drops below 40°F (4°C). Do not clean within seven days of
anticipated freezing temperatures.
B. Any material, including adjacent materials, damaged as a result of the work of this Section shall
be repaired or replaced at the Conservator’s expense to the satisfaction of the Owner’s
Representative.
C. The Conservator will use all necessary precautions to protect persons performing the work and
others. Workers shall be required to wear protective clothing, goggles, face shields, gloves, and
other clothing or equipment in compliance with SDS, governing Federal, State, and local safety
codes and regulations.
D. The Conservator shall provide, erect, and maintain barricades, danger signals and warning signs
as needed.
1.8 COORDINATION
A. Preconstruction Conference: Prior to beginning the work of this Section, convene a meeting
with the Owner’s Representative and all relevant parties to review work requirements and all
job conditions and processes. All subcontracting firms involved with this work shall participate
in this meeting.
B. The work of this Section shall be completed prior to performing the work specified in Section
040310 Historic Masonry Cleaning
1.9 SCAFFOLDING
A. Scaffold work required to accomplish the work of this Section shall be the responsibility of the
Conservator and shall be made available to all required trades and the Owner’s Representative
without charge. All scaffolding, staging and appurtenances will be adequately and safely
maintained, and shall comply, in total, to the requirements of the Safety and Health Regulations
for Construction, and any and all other government agencies having jurisdiction. The most
stringent requirements shall govern.
1. Scaffolding shall be free standing and shall not make contact with the monument, fence,
or masonry retaining wall.
2. Any damage made to the structure by the scaffold(s) will be repaired by the Conservator
to the satisfaction of the Owner’s Representative at no cost to the Owner.
PART 2 - PRODUCTS
2.1 MICROCRYSTALLINE WAX
A. Renaissance Wax as manufactured by Picreator Enterprises Ltd. and distributed by Dennis
Blaine – Cutlery Specialties, 6819 S.E. Sleepy Hollow Lane, Stuart, FL 34997, (772) 219-0436
Thomas Paine Monument, New Rochelle, NY November 2020
HISTORIC BRONZE SCULPTURE TREATMENT 050387 - 4
B. Or approved equal.
2.2 ABRASIVE HAND PADS
A. Scotch-Brite Ultra Fine Non-woven Silicon Carbide Hand Pads #7445 or #7448 as
manufactured by 3M, 3M Center, Building 220-12E-04, St. Paul, MN 55144, (800) 698-4595
B. Or approved equal.
2.3 TEMPORARY PROTECTION
A. Provide the following, or approved equal, for the protection of adjacent surfaces during
cleaning:
1. Polyethylene plastic sheeting
2. Strippable latex caulking
3. Liquid Strippable Masking Agent:
a. Spray Block 40, manufactured by Edison Coatings.
b. Sure Klean Strippable Masking, manufactured by ProSoCo.
c. ABR Rubber Mask, manufactured by Bonstone Materials Corporation.
d. Or approved equal.
B. Heat-resistant fiberglass blankets to protect stone during hot wax application.
C. All items for temporary protection of surfaces shall be non-staining and completely removable
without damage to the bronze or masonry.
2.4 MICELLANEOUS
A. Propane torch or other heating device suitable for hot waxing sculpture.
B. Brushes for cleaning shall be stiff natural or synthetic bristle brushes. Metallic/wire brushes
shall not be used.
C. Soft natural bristle brushes and soft cloths for buffing.
D. Pressure Washer: Pressure washers shall be fitted with a 40° fan-shaped nozzle and an in-line
pressure gauge and pressure regulator. Operating pressure shall not exceed 3000 psi, as
measured in-line, and equipment shall be capable of providing a flow rate of 5 or more gallons
per minute.
Thomas Paine Monument, New Rochelle, NY November 2020
HISTORIC BRONZE SCULPTURE TREATMENT 050387 - 5
E. Water: Water for cleaning shall be potable and free of contaminants that may stain or otherwise
damage the bronze or masonry. Flush hydrants well before use. Provide in-line filtration as
required to meet the requirements above.
F. No metal fittings that can corrode or deposit materials on the bronze or masonry shall be used.
PART 3 - EXECUTION
3.1 INSPECTION
A. Examine substrates, supports and conditions under which this work is to be performed and
notify the Owner’s Representative, in writing, of conditions detrimental to the proper
completion of the work. Do not proceed with work until unsatisfactory conditions are
corrected. Beginning work signifies Conservator’s acceptance of substrates and conditions.
B. Before starting any work of this section, make a complete inspection of all surfaces to be treated
and identify areas that will require installation of protection or other special care.
3.2 PREPARATION
A. Install protection of adjacent surfaces, property, and people in accordance with the approved
Program of Work.
3.3 GENERAL PROCEDURES
A. Pressure wash sculpture to remove active corrosion
B. Gently scrub water run-off streaks with abrasive hand pads to reduce appearance. Do not
remove oxidation patina.
C. Install heat resistant blankets to protect adjacent stone. Ensure that adjacent stonework is
completely dry prior to heating sculpture. Saturated stone may spall if heated.
D. Carefully and evenly heat sculpture using torch or other device.
E. Apply an even coat of microcrystalline wax to the warm surface, ensuring even application into
recesses.
F. Allow sculpture to cool before buffing surface to remove excess wax.
G. Apply a second coat of wax to the cold surface and buff to remove excess.
H. Immediately remove all spills or stains on adjacent surfaces and restore affected surfaces at no
expense to the Owner.
I. Finished work shall have a uniform appearance.
Thomas Paine Monument, New Rochelle, NY November 2020
HISTORIC BRONZE SCULPTURE TREATMENT 050387 - 6
3.4 COMPLETION
A. Rinse adjacent areas and remove any debris or accumulated matter.
B. Remove and legally dispose of all refuse from the work site.
C. Protect treated surfaces from construction related soiling. If, after treatment is completed, the
surface becomes dirty or wax coating is disturbed as a result of the Conservator's operations, it
shall be re-treated at the expense of the Conservator using the foregoing procedures.
END OF SECTION
JBC matched the appearance of the mortars with modern materials. The recommendations below
represent an effort to approximate the properties of the historic mortar using modern materials.
Consideration was given to matching the color, texture, and strength of the sample. The
replication mortars were matched to freshly broken samples.
As with the pointing of masonry in any historic structure, the original joint profiles and widths
should be documented before joints are raked and replicated during pointing.
It is our recommendation that the replication mix of the Schist Mortar be an ASTM Standard
Type N (ASTM C-270 by proportion) mortar. The Brick Industry Association describes a Type
N mortar as a general all-purpose mortar with good bonding capabilities and workability.
It is our recommendation that the replication mix of the Marble Mortar be a natural hydraulic
lime 3.5 mortar. A soft mortar is recommended for the marble as the marble is sugaring and
deteriorated. A harder mortar may cause additional spalls and chips at the edges of the joints.
All mortar joints should be fully raked to a depth of 2.5 times the width of the joint or to sound
mortar, whichever is deeper, and the units should be pointed to the same depth.
Schist Mortar Mix
1 part Cement (ASTM C150) to be composed of:
3/4 part White Portland Cement, Type I
1/4 part Sailors Cement
2 parts Hydrated Lime, Type S (ASTM C207)
5 parts aggregate to be composed of:
3 parts Schofield “181” (aggregate must pass through #8 sieve)
2 parts Schofield “107”
Marble Mortar Mix
EcoLogic Natural Hydraulic Lime Mortar, type 3.5 in “DGM SCG (F) Non-Pigmented”,
manufactured by LimeWorks.us.
NOTE: All parts should be measured by volume (not by weight). Dry ingredients should be
well blended before the addition of water. When newly installed, the mortar will appear lighter
as laitance (milky film caused by the mortar paste) will be covering the mortar and sand grains.
However, the laitance will naturally wear away over time.
Mortar Replication Recommendations
MR-1
Recommended Materials and Suppliers
As accurate replication mixes are difficult to formulate, the type and quantity of materials used
are essential to ensure on-site reproduction. Materials recommended in this report or their equal
may be used. If materials are substituted, the resulting appearance of the mortar may vary.
Recommended Cement
White Portland Cement, Type I
Available from:
Lehigh Cement Co.,
7660 Imperial Way Allentown, PA 18195
(800) 638-1716
Saylor’s Cement, Type I
Available from:
Nazareth Cement Plant and Terminal
Lehigh Cement Company
3938 Easton Nazareth Highway
Nazareth, PA 18064
(800) 437-7762
Sr. Sales Representative: Dominic Jampo, 610-926-1024, cell: 484-507-4109
Recommended Lime
Hydrated Lime, Type S
Available from:
Graymont, call for local supplier (800) 537-4489
Recommended Sand
As the selection of an appropriate aggregate is critical to the formulation of any replication mortar, the sand fraction isolated during analysis was compared to a library of sands
commercially available in the greater New York area. Aggregate samples have been enclosed to
facilitate substitutions with locally available sands.
Schofield “181” – described as a predominantly fine to coarse sized natural white concrete sand,
with the addition of light-colored pebbles up to 10mm in size.
Schofield “107” – described as a yellowish tan sand, ranging in size from fine to coarse grains.
Available from
George Schofield Co., Inc.
P.O. Box 110
Bound Brook, NJ 08805
(732) 356-0858
MR-2
Recommended Natural Hydraulic Lime Mortar
EcoLogic Natural Hydraulic Lime Mortar 3.5
Available from:
LimeWorks.us
3145 State Road,
Telford, PA 18969
(215) 536-6706,
http://www.limeworks.us/
MR-3