ban: dhaka environmentally sustainable water supply project

Semi-Annual Social Monitoring Report Project number: 42173-013 Period: January – June 2018 Submission Date: March 2019

BAN: Dhaka Environmentally Sustainable Water Supply Project

This report was prepared by Dhaka Water Supply and Sewerage Authority, Ministry of Local Government and Rural Development and Cooperatives, Government of Bangladesh for the Asian Development Bank. This document is made publicly available in accordance with ADB’s Access to Information Policy and does not necessarily reflect the views of ADB. This social monitoring report is a document of the borrower. The views expressed herein do not necessarily represent those of ADB's Board of Directors, Management, or staff, and may be preliminary in nature. Your attention is directed to the “terms of use” section of this website.

In preparing any country program or strategy, financing any project, or by making any designation of or reference to a particular territory or geographic area in this document, the Asian Development Bank does not intend to make any judgments as to the legal or other status of any territory or area.

Semi-Annual Social Safeguard Monitoring Report

BAN: Dhaka Environmentally Sustainable Water Supply Project (DESWSP) January-June 2018

31 August 2018

MMD-346152-RS-RP-PX-XX-041 Mott MacDonald

Mott MacDonald Plot 77, Level 6 Block-M Road 11 Banani Dhaka Dhaka 1213 Bangladesh T +880 (2) 986 1194 F +880 (2) 986 0319 mottmac.com/international-development

Semi-Annual Social Safeguard Monitoring Report

BAN: Dhaka Environmentally Sustainable Water Supply Project (DESWSP) January-June 2018

31 August 2018

Euroconsult Mott MacDonald bv is a member of the Mott MacDonald Group. Registered in The Netherlands no. 09038921

Mott MacDonald | Semi-Annual Social Safeguard Monitoring Report BAN: Dhaka Environmentally Sustainable Water Supply Project (DESWSP) January-June 2018

MMD-346152-RS-RP-PX-XX-041 | 31 August 2018

Issue and Revision Record

Revision Date Originator Checker Approver Description

A 31.08.18 Dr. Rafeza Akter

Nigel Osmaston

6th Social Safeguard Monitoring Report

B 11.02.18 Dr. Rafeza Akter

Nigel Osmaston

Revised

Document reference: MMD-346152-RS-RP-PX-XX-041

Information class: Standard

This document is issued for the party which commissioned it and for specific purposes connected with the above-

captioned project only. It should not be relied upon by any other party or used for any other purpose.

We accept no responsibility for the consequences of this document being relied upon by any other party, or being used

for any other purpose, or containing any error or omission which is due to an error or omission in data supplied to us by

other parties.

This document contains confidential information and proprietary intellectual property. It should not be shown to other

parties without consent from us and from the party which commissioned it.

This report has been pr epared sol el y for use by the party which commissi oned it (the ‘Client’) i n connecti on with the capti oned proj ect. It should not be used for any other purpose. N o person other than the Client or any party who has expressl y agreed ter ms of r eliance with us (the ‘Reci pient(s)’) may rel y on the content, i nformati on or any vi ews expressed i n the repor t. We accept no duty of care, responsi bility or liability to any other r eci pient of thi s document. This r eport is confi denti al and contains pr opri etar y intell ectual property.

ient (‘D ata’). We have not i ndependentl y verified such D ata and have assumed it to be accurate, complete, reli abl e and curren



Contents

Abbreviations 1

Executive summary 3

1 Background of the Monitoring Report 6

1.1 Project Description 6

1.2 Purpose of the Report 6

1.3 Category of RP 6

1.4 RP Update and Public Consultation 7

2 Scope of Impacts 8

3 Status of RP Implementation 10

3.1 Update of the RPs 10

3.2 Disclosure and Public Consultation 23

3.3 Payment of CCL and other Resettlement Benefits 24

3.4 Grievance Redress Mechanism (GRM) 25

4 Institutional Arrangement 26

5 Summary Monitoring Results and Key Findings 27

6 Compliance Status 30

7 Follow up Actions and Recommendation 31

Appendices 34

A. List of CCL Recipients APs 35

A.1 Mouza wise CCL Recipient AP List (Section 1) 35

A.2 Mouza Wise CCL Recipient AP list (Section 2) 48

B. Summary of the Consultation Meetings 70

C. Sample Notice for taking Photograph 80

D. AP ID Number Format 81



E. AP ID Card 83

F. List of Dead APs in WTP 85

G. Meeting Minutes 87

H. Field Visit Report 114

I. Leaflet for RP Sections 129

I.1 Leaflet for RP Sections for 1, 2, 3, 4 & 5 129

I.2 Leaflet for RP Sections for 6 131

J. Translated GRC Application Form 133

K. Compensation Claiming Form for Titled Aps 134

L. Compensation Claiming Form for Non-Titled Aps 137

M. Compensation Receipt Declaration Form 138

N. ADB Comments-Responses Matrix 141

Mott MacDonald | Semi-Annual Social Safeguard Monitoring Report 1 BAN: Dhaka Environmentally Sustainable Water Supply Project (DESWSP) January-June 2018


Abbreviations

Abbreviation Description

ADB Asian Development Bank

AP Affected Person

BDT Bangladeshi Taka

DBO Design-Build-Operate or Design-Build-Operation

Dec Decimal

DORP Development Organization for the Rural Poor

DDR Detailed Design Reports

DED Detailed Engineering Designs

DESWSP Dhaka Environmentally Sustainable Water Supply Project

DP Displaced Persons

DWASA Dhaka Water Supply and Sewerage Authority

EA Executing Agency

EIA Environmental Impact Assessment

GEM General Entitlement Matrix

FGD Focus Group Discussion

GRC Grievance Redresses Committee

JVC Joint Verification Committee

LGRD&C Local Government Rural Development & Cooperatives

MDSC Management, Design and Supervision Consultant

MLD Millions of Liters Per Day

MML Mott MacDonald Limited

MODS Maintenance Operations and Distribution Services

PD Project Director

PMC Project Management Consultant

PPMS Project Performance Management System

PMU Project Management Unit

PVAC Property Valuation Advisory Committee



Abbreviation Description

QA Quality Assurance

RAC Resettlement Advisory Committee

RWP Raw Water Pipeline

SIU Safeguard Implementation Unit

SPS Safeguard Policy Statement

TA Technical Assistance

TOR Terms of Reference

WIA Water Intake Area

WTP Water Treatment Plant



Executive Summary

The objective of Dhaka Environmentally Sustainable Water Supply Project (DESWSP) is to

provide a reliable water supply for the Dhaka city by developing a surface water treatment plant

and distribution network to improve quality water supply, water pressure in the pipelines, cost

recovery, reduce water loss and gradual ground water depleting in Dhaka city.

The DESWSP is to be delivered through several contract packages by several consultants,

contractors and NGOs under DWASA’s Project Management Unit (PMU). Mott MacDonald is

responsible for the three main construction contracts through their Management, Design and

Supervision Consultancy (MDSC) contract. Under MDSC, Mott MacDonald is acting as the

Employer’s designer for Packages 2 and 3 and as the supervision consultant for Packages 1, 2

and 3. Package 1 is to be let as a Design, Build & Operate (DBO) contract. Package 2 (P2)

comprises of 14 km. Treated Water Pipeline from Water Treatment Plant to Madani Avenue.

Packages 3 (P3) includes Distribution Reinforce Pipeline in North Dhaka City.

The total length of the alignment is approximately 36 kilometres. This starts from the Meghna

River and passes through Ariahazar and Rupganj upazilaand reaches Madani Avenue in Dhaka

after crossing Sitalakhya and Balu rivers. This project will use 294 acres of land of which Dhaka

WASA owns 82 acres (in Gandhabpur) and Bangladesh Water Development Board (BWDB)

with Roads and Highways own another 24 acres. The rest of the land (188 acres) is privately

owned.

Issues of involuntary resettlement are addressed according to National (Government of

Bangladesh) Legislation [Acquisition and Requisition of immovable Property Ordinance

(ARIPO), 1982 and Acquisition and Requisition of immovable Property Act (ARIPA), 2017 and

ADB Safeguard Policy Statement (SPS), 2009, and DWASA Policy. A Resettlement Framework

(RF) was developed for DESWSP to provide the mechanism through which the Executing

Agency (EA) is updating Resettlement Plans (RP) for each of the sections of the project.

Scope of land acquisition and resettlement impacts has already been identified based on the

preliminary design. The project will impact private and government land of different

organizations also structures, assets, crops and trees. As per preliminary design, a total area of

188 acres of private land needs to be acquired for the construction of the water pump at the

intake and for the required pipelines.

DWASA is the EA, through the PMU will establish a monitoring system involving the Supervising

Officer (SO), Safeguard Implementation Unit (SIU) and NGO. Evaluation of the resettlement

activities will be undertaken during and after implementation of the RP. An independent monitor

(External Monitoring Agency) has been engaged as third-party monitor for RP implementation.

PMU of DESWS Project has established its own SIU on 10.10.2017 to assist the PMU for

managing social and resettlement issues.

In September 2017 DWASA with the support of MDSC National Resettlement Expert (NRE)

has organized a two days training program for SIU and other relevant staff of PMU on

Management of Land Acquisition and Resettlement.

To carry out the resettlement activities, PMU has contracted a local NGO called DORP that

mobilized in February 2015. From that date the DORP has started/completed surveys and

information campaign to update a resettlement plans for some sections.With the view of

convenient implementation project area has been divided into 6 sections for Resettlement Plan



(RP). Draft RP for Section 1, 2 and 4 have been prepared and submitted to ADB for their

approval. The RPs for other sections would be submitted to ADB by September 2018. The

alignment for RP Section 5 and 6 has been finalized by December 2017.

The socioeconomic survey (SES) has been completed in Section 3. It has also been completed

for Section 5 except three mouzas namely Naora, Harina and Rupganj because people of these

areas do not cooperate in giving data as no legal notice for land acquisition has been served

yet. This survey for Section 6 would be carried out on July 2018. It is worth mentioning that in

these no legal notice for land acquisition has been served for RP Section 3, Section 5 and

Section 6 areas. So, DORP is facing problem in collecting data.

Four committees namely Joint Verification Committee (JVC), Property Valuation Advisory

Committee (PVAC), Grievance Redress Committee (GRC) and Resettlement Advisory

Committee (RAC) have been formulated by the PMU for each section of RPs. The GRC is

responsible to assist the Affected Persons (APs) in case of complains at project level. GRC

committee has been revised and approved by the ministry on 27 November 2017.But yet to

declare its members’ names and contact number to the APs.

During this quarter DORP has submitted RP of Section 1four times, Section 2 once and Section

4twice to ADB through PMU. DORP has improved required RPsto comply with the ADB’s comments that they have given four times. Their last submission date of updated RPs for

Section 1, 2 and 4 was21st May 2018. DORP promised to submit Draft RPs for Section 3 and 5

by July 2018. It can be mentioned here that RP for Section 5 will be submitted as per ADB

safeguard official’s advice though SES of three mouzascould not be completed which is

mentioned above. SES for RP Section 6 area is being conducted.

Procedural delays with regard to Land Acquisition (LA) process have also hindered progress of

RP implementation. At present Cash Compensation under Law (CCL) is being paid by the DC

office in RP Section 1 and Section 2 area. Though updated RPs are yet to be approved by ADB

and ministry of LGRD&C.

Total nos. of CCL recipient APs are 183 and 315 in RP Section 1 and Section 2 respectively.



Figure1: DESWSP Resettlement Plan

Click here to enter text.



1 Background of the Monitoring Report

1.1 Project Description

This is a Semi-annual Resettlement Monitoring Report prepared for the PMU for onward

submission to ADB. The “Dhaka Environmentally Sustainable Water Supply Project” comprises of Water Intake, Gandharbpur Water Treatment Plant, and Raw & Treated Water Mains.

Dhaka Environmentally Sustainable Water Supply Project (DESWSP) is to provide a reliable

water supply for the Dhaka city by developing a surface water treatment and distribution

network. (See detailed map of the full project given above) The total length of the alignment is

approximately 36 kilometres. This starts from the Meghna River and passes through Ariahazar

and Rupganj upazilla and reaches Madani Avenue in Dhaka after crossing Sitalakhya and Balu

River. This part of the project is called P1 and P2. This project will require 294 acres of land of

which Dhaka WASA owns 82 acres in Gandharbpur and Bangladesh Water Development Board

(BWDB) and Roads and Highways Department (RHD) owns another 24 acres. The rest188

acres are privately owned that will need to be acquired.

A Resettlement Framework (RF) was developed for DESWSP to provide the mechanism

through which the DWASA will prepare Resettlement Plans (RP) for each section of the project.

Issues of involuntary resettlement will be addressed based on DWASA Policy (Resettlement

Policy Framework, 2013) following National Legislation (Government of Bangladesh Acquisition

of immovable Property Ordinance, 1982), and the ADB Safeguard Policy Statement (SPS),

2009. It is worth mentioning that meanwhile Bangladesh government has enacted new laws

from September 2017, namely Acquisition and requisition of Immovable Property Act (ARIPA),

2017. This will be applicable for updating RPs for Section 3, Section 5 and Section 6.

Necessary Inputs to prepare the report (Semi-annual Social Safeguard Monitoring Report) were

provided by the DORP, the NGO responsible for implementation of the Resettlement Plans. The

report covers the progress made during the 1st half of the year 2018 and is presented according

to the format provided in the resettlement framework.

1.2 Purpose of the Report

Clause no. 18 (iii) of the Terms of Reference (ToR) of MDSC requires submission of Semi-

annual Social Safeguard Implementation Monitoring Report. Moreover, Appendix C of the

Resettlement Framework of the DESWSP mentioned, ‘Following requirements of the ADB Safeguard Policy Statement (2009) and the Operations Manual section on Safeguard Policy

(OM F1), borrowers/clients are required to establish and maintain procedures to monitor the

status of implementation of safeguard plans and ensure progress is made toward the desired

outcomes for projects categorized as A or B in Involuntary Resettlement and/or Indigenous

People. The borrowers/clients are required to submit semi-annual monitoring reports for ADB

review.’ To comply with the requirement on behalf of the borrower (the DWASA), the MDSC is hereby submitting the Semi-annual Social Safeguard Monitoring Report (SSSMR). This is

the6thSSSMRof the project RP implementation.

1.3 Category of RP

Considering the extent of significance of impacts, ADB has classified projects into four

categories; A, B, C and FI. The involuntary resettlement impacts of an ADB-supported project

are considered significant if 200 or more persons will be physically displaced from home or lose



10% or more of their productive or income-generating assets. The project, which has significant

involuntary resettlement impacts, falls under category A. Thus, the DESWSP is classified as

Category A. No indigenous household has been found during the surveys; therefore, the project

falls under category C as regard to indigenous people categorization.

1.4 RP Update and Public Consultation

The NGO contracted named DORP is assisting DWASA in updating the RPs and

implementation of the resettlement activities. The DORP has so far prepared four Draft RPs for

Section-1 and Section-2, Section-3 and Section-4. They prepared a zero draft for RP for

Section-5 and submitted to MDSC on April 2018 which has been sent back by the MDSC as it

was not acceptable for review due to lack of proper data. They have submitted their second

draft to MDSC on 25thJune 2018. DORP is now conducting field census /survey in section 6 to

assess and verify the impacts on APs for the RP updates as well as its implementation.

Regular consultations with the affected persons (APs) and other stakeholders are being

conducted by the DORP to ensure that they are fully aware of the project interventions and

about their entitlements in case of involuntary land acquisition and resettlement benefits for APs

(titled or non-titled holders). The format to report on the consultation carried out need to be

reviewed to emphasis more on the remarks made by the participants.



2 Scope of Impacts

The initial Resettlement Plan for the project was prepared in 2013 and it indicated major impacts

on private land, scope of land acquisition and resettlement impacts has already been identified

based on the preliminary design. The project will impact private and government land of

different organizations and also structures, assets, businesses and livelihood, crops and trees.

Based on given alignment, a total area of187.94acres of private land would have needed

acquisition for the construction of the intake area and the pipeline construction for package 1

and 2. However, section wise required quantity of land to be acquired is presentedin Table 1.

See map above.

The project area under Package 1 and 2 has been divided into six sections to update the RPs

conveniently. The sections are named as follows;

Section-1: Water Intake Area

Section-2: Water Intake to Baliapara (End of Araihazar)

Section-3: Darikhandi Chak (start of Rupganj) to Murapara via Gandharbpur WTP

Section-4: Water Treatment Plant Gandharbpur Area

Section-5: Rupganj (West bank of Sitalakhya River) to Balu River (East bank)

Section-6: Balu River (West bank) to Vatara along Madani Avenue up to Baridhara

RP Section 1 and 2 requires both private and government (govt.) land. No land acquisition is

required for the construction of the Water Treatment Plant as DWASA acquired a total of 82

acres of land in Gandharbpur area in 1982-83. Besides, Dhaka WASA has signed a

Memorandum of Understanding (MoU) to receive back 2.83 ha of land from the Bangladesh

Water Development Board (BWDB) by DWASA for excavation of a canal for irrigation purpose.

This arrangement has been done under a MoU signed between DWASA and BWDB mentioned

in the RP.

The Table 1 below presents the summary of the land requirements with areas and type of

impacts identified so far.

Table 1: Land Acquisition and Resettlement Impacts

Section of RPs

Locations Land Requirement (in acre)

Structure and other impacts

Comments / Status

Nos. Total Govt. Owned

Privately owned

1 Water Intake Area (WIA)

21.37 18.85 2.52 Agriculture In total 183 nos. (85%). of affected persons (AP) hav got CCL. The remaining are awaiting to receive.

2 Intake to Balia Para

110.2 4.1 106.1 Agriculture, livelihood, and structure

Notice under section 7 has been served to all of the affected households (1178). Out of them, 315nos. (26.7%) of APs got CCL up to June 2018. Though DC office claimed that about 60% APs



Section of RPs

Locations Land Requirement (in acre)

Structure and other impacts

Comments / Status

have received CCL but NGO could manage recipients list for 315 APs only. (List given in Appendix A)

3 Darikhandi Chak (start of Rupganj) to Murapara via Gandharbpur WTP

60.06 22.82 37.24 Agriculture,

structure and livelihood

Process of land acquisition is underway by the DC office. For land acquisition no notice has been issued so far. However, SES has been completed and RP update is on-going. A social cut-off-date has been declared in April 2018.

4 Water Treatment Plant (WTP)

82 DWASA land

No private land

Structure and agriculture

Land acquired in 1985 by DWASA. RP has been updated and submitted to ADB for approval.

5 Rupganj (West bank of Sitalakhya river) to Balu river (East bank)

22.18 0.97 21.22 Structure, pond and agriculture

Same as section 3. SES data has been collected except three mouzas. Draft RP preparation is on-going.

6 Balu river to Bhatara

6.96 6.5 km within RAJUK road alignment. In addition, 2.43 acresof public land will be needed to be acquired

4.53 Permanent and Temporary business structures

Total length of this section is 7 km of which 6.5 owned by the RAJUK. RAJUK provided permission to use but MoU to be finalized.

Source: DWASA and DORP



3 Status of RP Updating and

Implementation

3.1 Update of the RPs

DORP, as INGO has been appointed in February 2015. First Draft RP for WTP was submitted

to DWASA in January 2016. The draft has since been resubmitted several times; the version of

December 2017 awaiting ADB’s approval. Subsequently, after various rounds of discussions

with ADB and clarifications on interpretation of the entitlement matrix, the required revisions

were made. Each time MDSC provided necessary feedback and detailed comments and

advised them in providing full details of the impacts, improve the accuracy of the data

presentation, prepare budget based on approved entitlement matrix and do proper editing of the

document. In December 2016, the DORP conducted a resurvey in WTP area because MDSC

found out some discrepancies during field monitoring.

DORP has submitted updated RPs several times for section-1; first draft in November

2016, second version in May 2017, third version in August 2018, fourth version in

December 2017, 5th one in 1 January 2018, 6th one in19 January 2018, 7th version in

February 2018 and 8th and another version in May 2018 which has been submitted to ADB

for their approval. ADB provided their observations on the RPs for WTP and WIA. ADB

Safeguards Specialist advised that the entitlement matrix could not be downgraded and

that the original entitlement matrix should be followed.

The RP for Section 1 had to be revised several times due to various reasons, including

clarity on interpretation of the entitlement matrix, required document structure and quality to

reflect the ground reality while meeting ADB’s standards. Field visits during an ADB

Mission revealed that the need to address the issue of compensation to people affected by

river erosion, leading to the need for further consultations and revision of the RP.

DORP had submitted a preliminary draft RP for Section-2 in March to MDSC for review..

Accordingly they submitted 2nd draft on May 2017 and MDSC reviewed and sent it back for

updating. They submitted Draft RP to ADB through PMU three times; first one in October

2017, second one in December 2017 and then on 21stMay 2018. which is under ADB’s review. .

After review 1st Draft of RP for Section 3 [Darikhandi Chak (start of Rupganj) to Murapara via

Gandharbpur WTP] on April 2018by the MDSC, DORP has submitted 2nd Draft of RP to MDSC

on 25June2018. This is under review.

DORP had prepared a zero draft for RP Section 5 [Rupganj (West bank of Sitalakhya River) to

Balu River (East bank)] which needed to be revised as the data given in the report was not

sufficent. DORP could not collect data from the villages namely Harina, Naora and Rupganj as

the local people were unwilling and DC office was yet to serve land acquisition (LA) notice.

No progress has been made yet by DORP for updating the RP Section 6 [Balu River (West

bank) to Vatara along Madani Avenue up to Baridhara].

Land acquisition work is in progress for Section-1(Water Intake area) and Section-2 (Intake to

Baliapara). Notice under section 7 has been served from the DC office to all entitled persons of

total 87 households in Section-1 and of 1178 households in Section 2 area for paying

compensation money or CCL. Out of them 183 APs inSection 1 and 315APs in Section 2 area



received CCL. On land acquisition matters DWASA has been following up with the DC office

regularly with regard to expedite CCL payment in Araihazar Upazila of Narayanganj District.

DWASA has been keeping all communications with the Ministry of Land (MoL)regarding

progress on land acquisition. A small part of RP Section 5 lies under military lead housing

authority namely Jalshiri Abasan. Meetings were held with PMU, MDSC team and Jalshiri

Abasan Authority along with PD and DPD with regard to finalization of draft Land Acquisition

MOU between DWASA and Jalshiri Abasan Authority.

The Table 2 below provides in a nutshell the progress achieved about land acquisition and RP

preparation section wise. It shows updates on RP preparation stage, including progress on land

acquisition, data collection and planned date for submission of RPs.

Table 2: Status of Progress about Land Acquisition and RP Update

Sections Project Locations Land acquisition status Status of RP Updates

Section -1 Water Intake area According LA law DC has initiated compensation. He has served notice under section 7 for claiming compensation with all legal papers to all APs and thus compensation payment is on-going. Out of them 183 APs have received CCL.

As per ADB SPS 2009, additional payment as resettlement assistance will be paid to the entitled APs after RP approval by ADB and concerned ministry.

Latest RP has been submitted to ADB on 21st May 2018 based on comments givenby the ADB on January 2018. PMU has complied with them. River eroded land APs’ budget and vulnerability grant budget has been revised according to ADB definition. DORP has complied and prepared comments-responses matrix and sent to ADB accordingly. They are now waiting for approval of RP from ADB.

Section -2 Intake to Baliapara (End of Araihajar)

Following LA law DC has served notice under Section 7 to all APs. Out of them 315 APs have received CCL. The rest will get soon.

As per ADB SPS 2009, additional payment as resettlement assistance will be paid to the entitled APs after RP approval by ADB and concerned ministry.

Same as RP Section-1.

Section-3 Darikhandi Chak (start of Rupganj) to Murapara via Gandharbpur WTP

LA plan has been submitted to the Ministry of Land (MoL). DC office hasconductedfeasibility Study (FS) for Rupganj in April 2018. DC has sent the reportto theCentral Land Acquisition Committee (CLAC) under MoL.Expected date of CLAC approval is July 2018 and DC office will serve the notice under section 4(according to newly enacted Acquisition and Requisition of Immovable Property Act 2017) by the end of August 2018.

Tentative date of first Draft RP submission is 20 July 2018.

Section -4 Water Treatment Plant DWASA owned land. Following ADB SPS 2009, resettlement assistance will be paid to the entitled APs after RP approval by ADB and concerned ministry.


Section -5 Rupganj (West bank of Sitalakhya River) to Balu River (East bank)

CLAC should be held soon after DC’s approval. Tentative date of DC office’s FS is lastweek of July 2018.




Sections Project Locations Land acquisition status Status of RP Updates

Section-6 Balu River to Vatara Baridhara.

This section is along the RAJUK Road. Survey is being conducted.

First RP to be prepared and submitted by the end of September 2018 (from DORP to PMU).

Source: DORP and DWASA

MDSC resettlement consultants reviewed DORP’s work plan and provided feedback advising them to make it more realistic. For upgrading DORP’s capacity a 3-days training on

Resettlement Implementation Activities to DORP’s all field staffs have been imparted in May

2018. The progress achieved so far is presented in the Progress Reports prepared by the

DORP on monthly and quarterly basis. The Monthly Progress Report covered the progress of

the DORP activities for the respective month. Quarterly reports were a cumulative reporting on

three months progress. In this phase MDSC had reviewed six (6) Monthly Progress Reports and

two (2) Quarterly Progress Report is received in this period (January to June 2018) and MDSC

provided feedback with specific comments to DORP for improving their quality of documentation and

other works to focus on the critical issues. With reference to those reports, the progress made so far

by the DORP up to June2018 is presented in the Table 3 as follows:



Table 3: Cumulative Progress up to 30June 2018

Tasks as per Work Plan Section 1

Intake

Section 2 Section 3 Section 4 Section 5 Section 6

No. % Total % Total % Total % Total % Total %

Resettlement Plan Updating

Conducted SES data collection from Affected Household Heads

87 100 1178 100 367 100 232 100 100 50%

(Approximate

)

11 10%

Conducted Consultation meeting with AHs

6 100 12 100 7 100 8 100 4 50% 7 100%

Implementation of RP

Personal contact established with AHs and other Stakeholders

907 - 2980 - 2641 - 905 100% 985 80% 521 90%

Community meetings held with AHs and other Stakeholders

49 - 79 - 124 - 48 - 34 - 17 -

Distributed Leaflets to AHs and other Stakeholders

1,000 100 2000 100 531 - 345 - 262 - 279 -

Distributed Booklets to AHs and other Stakeholders

300 100 700 100 - - 251 - - - - -

Joint verification completed by DWASA /DC assisted by DORP

21.37 acre 100 110.2 acre 100 Notice under section-4 not

yet serve

- 2 meetings held at

DWASA

- Notice under section-4 not

yet serve

- Notice under section-4 not

yet serve

-

Video Filming done 21.37 Acre 100 110.2

acre

100 do - 81.53

acre

- do - do -

Assisted DC office to disburse the Notice under section 3 to Affected Persons (APs) members

260 100 2660 100 do - Not applicable

(WASA land)

- do - do -

Distributed the Notice under section 6 to AHs members

180 100 2985 100 do - do - do - do -

Distributed the Notice under section 7 to Entitled Persons (EPs) members

87 100 1933 100 do do do do

AP received CCL 183 85 315 27 do - Payment will be made by

- do - do -



Tasks as per Work Plan Section 1

Intake

Section 2 Section 3 Section 4 Section 5 Section 6

DWASA

CCL Statement Preparation 103 56% of CCL

receipt

241 76% of

CCL receipt

- - - -

Conducted Focus Group Discussion with eligible AHs to develop livelihood plan

6 100 13 100 6 - 9 100 3 50%

(Approximate

)

1 50%

Database

Developed software for data entry – This software to be updated to accommodate supplementary

1 100 1 100 1 100 1 100 1 100 1 100%

Completed data entry using in “excel” sheet

87 100 1178 100 367 100 232 100 100 50% 136 100%

Submitted Draft ID card to PMU, DESWSP for approval

1

(Approved)

100 1

(Approved)

100 1

(Approved)

100 1

(Approved)

100 1

(Approved)

100 1

(Approved)

100%

Submitted Draft Payment Voucher to PMU, DESWSP for approval

1

(Approved)

100 1

(Approved)

100 1

(Approved)

100 1

(Approved)

100 1

(Approved)

100 1

(Approved)

100%

Payment Voucher to PMU, DESWSP for approval

1

(Approved)

100 1

(Approved)

100 1

(Approved)

100 1

(Approved)

100 1

(Approved)

100 1

(Approved)

100%

Source: <Insert Notes or Source>



It may be summarized here that LA process of Package 1 (RP Section 1, 2 and 4) is in progress

because RP Section 4 is under DWASA’s own land and CCL payment by the DC is going on for RP Section 1 and 2. However, no additional payment (top up and other resettlement benefits) could be

made since RPs are yet to be approved by the ADB and GoB. At present approval of the RP is

necessary for the project for handing over the stipulated acquired land to the DBO contractor for

construction commencement.There has been marginal progress with regard to LA process for RP

Section 3, 5 and 6. As mentioned earlier that land of these three areas will be acquired following

new law (ARIPA, 2017) enacted by the GoB has in September 2017. Rate of compensation has

been made double under this new act. It is already known that lands in RP section 1 & 2 area are

being acquired following ARIPO, 1982. The overall status of the land acquisition process of six

sections are presented in two separate tables below; Table 4for RP section 1, 2 and 4and Table 5for

RP section 3, 5 and 6. Following Figure 2 and Figure 3also follow the same sequence.

Table4:Land Acquisition Progress of RP Sections 1, 2 and 4

Jun-18

Task Complete for RP Sections

Action by Remarks RP Sections: 1 2 4

Araihazar

1 Submission of LA Proposal to Deputy Commissioner (DC) Time needed:

6 months

1 Obtaining administrative approval

from the concerned ministry (LGD) 100 100 NA [1] DWASA responsible Done

2

Layout Plan, LA Plan including plot

schedule, Cadastral Maps and

Khatiyans

100 100 NA DWASA responsible Done

3 Maximum Land Requirement

Certificate from LGD 100 100 NA DWASA responsible Done

4 Fund Allocation Assurance 100 100 NA DWASA responsible Done

2 Administrative Approval from LGD Ministry (It took 6 months for RP Section 1 and 2)

1

Feasibility Study done by DC + given

to District Land Allocation

Committee (DLAC)/Central Land

Allocation Committee (CLAC)

100% 100% NA

DC responsible (after

receipt of proposal

fromDWASA/MoL,

DC has max 21 day)

Actual time

taken:4

months

2

After approval by the DLA, the DC

starts LA case and issues notice

under section 3 of the LA Ordinance

to acquire the property

Jan-Mar

2017

100 %

Jan-Mar

2017

100 %

NA DC responsible

Actual time

taken:3

months

3

Joint verification by DC and DWASA

should be 3 days after issuance of

notice under section 4

Jan-Mar

2017

100 %

Jan-Mar

2017

100 %

NA DC (Legal time: 3

days)

Actual time

taken:3

months

4

Objection (u/s 5) against acquisition

proposal may be made by Affected

Persons (APs) within 15 days after

Section 4 Notice

Jan-May

2017

100 %

Jan-May

2017

100 %

NA Affected Persons

Actual time

taken:5

months

5 Hearing of Objection by DC and

preparing report

May

2017

100 %

May

2017

100 %

NA

DC responsible (After

expiry of objection

period within 30

days)

Actual time

taken: 1 day



6

Approval by DC if quantity of land

below 7 ha and if no objection. If

there is objection, DC sends record

with report to the Govt. or to

Divisional Commissioner (DvC)

NA NA NA

DC/DvC responsible

(if land quantity is

less than 7 ha should

take 10 days. If more

land, can take 30

days after objection

period)

No objection

7 Return the proposal to DC with

decision of the MOL. NA NA NA

DC/DvC (from

submission of the

report by DC. Time

limit: 15 days and 90

days respectively)

No hearing

3 Notice served and invite claim from

persons interested under section 7 NA NA NA

DC responsible [After

approval by

DC/DvC/MoL)]

No claim

received

1 Hearing on claims (if there is) NA NA NA

DC responsible (Legal

time: 15 days after

notice u/s 7)

No hearing

4 Collection of rates/price of assets to be acquired from different agencies

1 Sub-Registrar's Office for Land

Jan-Feb

2017

100%

Jan-Feb

2017

100%

NA

DC responsible

(Legal time: 2

months)

Actual time

needed: 1

month

2 Public Works Department for

Structure

May

2017

100%

May

2017

100%

100% DC responsible (Legal

time: 1 month)

Actual time

needed: 1

month

3 Department of Forest for Trees

May

2017

100%

May

2017

100%


time: 1 month)

Actual time

needed: 1

month

4 Dep Agriculture + Marketing for

Crops

May

2017

100%

May

2017

100%


time: 1 month)

Actual time

needed: 1

month

5 Department of Fisheries for Fish

Stock

May

2017

100%

May

2017

100%


time: 1 month)

Actual time

needed: 1

month

5

Make award and estimate for

compensation by DC. Claim fund from

DWASA

100% 100% NA

DC responsibleafter

notice u/s 7

Legal Time limit: 30

days

Actual time

needed: 7

days

6 Deposit of compensation money to DC

by DWASA 100% 100% NA

DWASA responsible

(From date of

estimate from DC.

Legal Time limit: 120

days)

Actual time:

10 days

7

Notice to persons interested (u/s 7) for

updating Record of Rights and receiving

cash compensation (CCL)

100% 100% NA

DC responsible (From

date of award of

compensation. Legal

Time: 7 days)

Actual time: 1

month

8 Payment of compensation (CCL) (u/s 10) by Treasury cheque

DC: From deposit of

compensation money

by DWASA Time limit:

60 days



1 Affected Persons (AP) receive CCL

Start Jul

2017

85%

Start

Jun

2017

27%

NA

Entitled Persons

responsible to

receive (Legal Time:

Max 15 days after

issue of notice under

section 7)

On going

9 Compensation deemed to have been

paid 85% 27% 0

DC responsible (After

expiry of above 60

days u/s 10)

Paid

10

Application to Arbitrator (u/s) 28

AP/DC/DvC: From

date of serving notice

of award.; Legal Time

limit: 45 days

1 Complain to the DC Yes Yes NA

DCcan add 10% of

entitled CCL after

positive verdict.

Settled by DC

office

2 If unsatisfactory verdict, arbitration

to DvC Yes Yes NA

DvC can add another

10%

Settled by DC

office

11 Copies of CCL Document Submitted to

INGO

6/1/201

7

(docum

ent

received

183 )

6/1/201

7

(docum

ent

receive

d 315.)

NA DORP/DWASA

responsible

DC office

representative

claimed that

they have

paid CCL to

more APs but

here is only

mentioned

numbers

based on

documents

receipt

12

Additional Payment/Top up pay as per PVAC recommendations; DWASA/INGO

afterResettlement plan (RP) Approval

(Time needed: 2 months after RP approval)

1 CCL Statement Prepared by INGO

100% of

docume

nts

received

100% of

docume

nts

receive

d

NA

(a) Out of 183 APs,

document received

103.

(b) Out of 315 APs,

document received

241.

More

documents to

be collected

2 Prepare ID Card with Photo 43% 87% 0 DORP: after Copies of

CCL Cheque received

on-going but

needed to be

expedite

3 Prepare AP file and EC 0 0 0 DORP responsible

Needs RPs

approval to

prepare those

4 Prepare Indent subject to RP

Approval 0 0 0

DORP responsible

(Will be done after

RP Approval by ADB+

LGD ministry)

RPs are yet to

be approved

5

Prepare necessary papers and

documents by INGO and Submit to

DWASA for payment

0 0 0 DORP responsible RPs are yet to

be approved



6 Other Resettlement Benefits as per

RP Policy 0 0 0

DWASA/DORP: RPs

are yet to be

approved

RPs are yet to

be approved

7 Payment of all grants 0 0 0 DWASA/ DORP

responsible

RPs are yet to

be approved

13 Compensation/Benefits/Grants as per GRC Decision

DWASA/DORP/GRC

responsible upon RP

approval

RPs are yet to

be approved

by ADB

1 Propose + Approve GRC 100% 100% 100% DWASA + LGD

responsible

GRC has been

approved by

LGD.

2 GRC is functioning Y or N ? N N N DWASA responsible

GRC needs to

be declared

by its

members

name and

contact

numbers but

not done yet.

[1] Section 4 is WTP. DWASA’s Land

* Section #1 = Intake, #2 = RW pipeline in Araihazar, #4

=WTP,

KEY: Action required



Table5:Land Acquisition Progress of RP Sections 3, 5 and 6

Jun-18

Task Complete for RP

Sections Action by Remarks

RP Sections: 3 5 6

Rupganj

1 Submission of LA Proposal to Deputy Commissioner (DC) by DWASA It took 6 months

1 Obtaining administrative approval from

the concerned ministry (LGD) 100 100 100 DWASA Done

2 Layout Plan, LA Plan including plot

schedule, Cadastral Maps and Khatiyans 100 100 100 DWASA Done

3 Maximum Land Requirement Certificate

from LGD 100 100 100 DWASA Done

4 Fund Allocation Assurance 100 100 100 DWASA Done

2 Administrative Approval from LGD Ministry (It took 6 months for RP Section 1 and 2)

1

Feasibility Study done by DC + given to

District Land Allocation Committee

(DLAC)/Central Land Allocation

Committee (CLAC)

100% 100% 0

DC (afterreceipt of

proposal

fromDWASA/ Mo

Land) Legal

Time:21 days

Actual time

needed: 4 months

2

After approval by the DLA, the DC starts

LA case and issues notice under section 4

of the LA Ordinance to acquire the

property

0 0 0 DC Actual time

needed: 3 months

3

Joint verification by DC and DWASA

should be 3 days after issuance of notice

under section 4

0 0 0 DC, Legal time: 3

days

Actual time

needed: 4 months

4

Objection (u/s 5) against acquisition

proposal may be made by Affected

Persons (AP) within 15 days after Section

4 Notice

0 0 0 Entitled Persons,

Legal time: 15 days

No LA notice has

been served

5 Hearing of Objection by DC and

preparing report 0 0 0

DC: After expiry of

objection period

within 30 days

No LA notice has

been served

6

Approval by DC if quantity of land below

7 ha and if no objection. If there is

objection, DC sends record with report

to the Govt. or to Divisional

Commissioner (DvC)

0 0 0

DC/DvC: if land

quantity is less

than 7 ha should

take 10 days. If

more land, can

take 30 days after

objection period

No LA notice has

been served

7 Return the proposal to DC with decision

of the MOLand. 0 0 0

DC/DvC: from

submission of the

report by DC. Time

limit: 15 days and

90 days

respectively; (No

hearing)

No LA notice has

been served



3 Notice served and invite claim from persons

interested under section 8 0 0 0

DC: After approval

by DC/DvC/MoL;

(No claim received)

No LA notice has

been served

1 Hearing on claims (if there is) 0 0 0

DC: 15 days after

notice u/s 7/8; (No

hearing)

No LA notice has

been served

4 Collection of rates/price of assets to be acquired from different agencies No LA notice has

been served

1 Sub-Registrar's Office for Land 0 0 0 DC, Legal Time: 2

months

No LA notice has

been served

2 Public Works Department for Structure 0 0 0 DC, Legal Time: 1

month

No LA notice has

been served

3 Department of Forest for Trees 0 0 0 DC, Legal Time: 1

month

No LA notice has

been served

4 Dep Agriculture + Marketing for Crops 0 0 0 DC, Legal Time: 1

month

No LA notice has

been served

5 Department of Fisheries for Fish Stock 0 0 0 DC, Legal Time: 1

month

No LA notice has

been served

5

Make award and estimate for

compensation by DC. Claim fund from

DWASA

0 0 0

DC: After notice

u/s 8.; Legal Time:

30 days

No LA notice has

been served

6 Deposit of compensation money to DC

byDWASA 50% 0 0

DWASA: From date

of estimate from

DC. Legal Time

limit: 120 days

(Actual time

needed: 10 days

7

Notice to persons interested (u/s 8) for

updating Record of Rights and receiving

cash compensation (CCL)

0 0 0

DC: From date of

award of

compensation.;

Legal Time limit: 7

days

No LA notice has

been served

8 Payment of compensation (CCL) (u/s 10) by Treasury cheque

DC: From deposit

of compensation

money by DWASA

Time limit: 60 days

No LA notice has

been served

1 Entitled Persons receive CCL 0 0 0

Entitled Persons:

Max 15 days after

issue of notice

under section 4

No LA notice has

been served

9 Compensation deemed to have been paid 0 0 0

DC: After expiry of

above 60 days u/s

10.

No LA notice has

been served

##

Application to Arbitrator (u/s) 28

AP/DC/DvC: From

date of serving

notice of award.;

Time limit: 45 days

No LA notice has

been served

1 Complain to the DC 0 0 0

DC: can add 10% of

entitled CCL after

positive verdict.

No LA notice has

been served

2 If unsatisfactory verdict, arbitration to

DvC 0 0 0

DvC: can add

another 10%

Settled by DC

office

No LA notice has

been served



## Copies of CCL Document Submitted to INGO 0 0 0 DC No LA notice has

been served

##

Additional Payment/Top up pay as per PVAC recommendations; DWASA/INGO after

Resettlement plan (RP) Approval

(Time needed: 2 months after RP approval)

1 CCL Statement Prepared by INGO 0 0 0 DORP No LA notice has

been served

2 Prepare ID Card with Photo 0 0 0

DORP: after Copies

of CCL Cheque

received

No LA notice has

been served

3 Prepare AP file and EC 0 0 0 DORP No LA notice has

been served

4 Prepare Indent subject to RP Approval 0 0 0

DORP: after RP

Approval by ADB+

LGD ministry

No LA notice has

been served

5

Prepare necessary papers and

documents by INGO and Submit to

DWASA for payment

0 0 0 DWASA/DORP No LA notice has

been served

6 Other Resettlement Benefits as per RP

Policy 0 0 0 DWASA/DORP

No LA notice has

been served

7 Payment of all grants 0 0 0 DWASA/ DORP No LA notice has

been served

## Compensation/Benefits/Grants as per GRC Decision DWASA/DORP/GRC No LA notice has

been served

1 Propose + Approve GRC. 100% 100% 100%

DWASA + LGD: GRC

has been approved

by LGD.

No LA notice has

been served

2 GRC is functioning Y or N? N N N

GRC cannot

function until RP

approved by ADB +

LGD.

No LA notice has

been served

[1] Section 4 is WTP. DWASA’s Land

* Section #3 = RW pipeline in Rupganj, #5 = TW transmission to Dhaka, #6 = TW pipelines inside

Dhaka.

KEY: Action required

Mott M

acD

onald

| Sem

i-Ann

ual S

ocia

l Safe

gua

rd M

onito

ring R

epo

rt B

AN

: Dhaka E

nviro

nm

en

tally

Susta

ina

ble

Wate

r Su

pply

Pro

ject (D

ES

WS

P)

Jan

uary

-June

2018

M

MD

-346

152

-RS

-RP

-PX

-XX

-04

1 | 3

1 A

ugust 2

01

8

Fig

ure

2:L

an

d A

cq

uis

ition

Pro

gre

ss

for R

P S

ectio

n 1

, 2 a

nd

4

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100

LA Proposal to DC

Approval from Ministry

Notice served u/s 3

Rate Collection for Compensation

Award and estimate for compensation

Deposit of compensation money to DC

Notice served u/s 7 for CCL Payment

EP Recieves CCL

Copies of CCL Document Submitted to INGO

RP Approval

Additional Payment/Top up payment

Compensation/Benefits/Grants as per GRCDecision

Payment of all grants

La

nd

Acq

uis

ition

Pro

ce

ss (C

om

ple

te fo

r RP

Se

ctio

ns)

Se

ctio

n 1

Se

ctio

n 2

Se

ctio

n 4



Figure3:Land Acquisition Progress for RP Section 3, 5 and 6

3.2 Disclosure and Public Consultation

DORP has conducted three hundred and ninety-five (395) consultation meetings including

community meetings with affected households and other stakeholders (351) and FGDs with the

eligible AHs (38) to develop livelihood plan up to June 2018 in the Section 1, 2, 3, 4, 5 and 6. Total

5053 participants (3788 male and 1265 female) were present at the meeting. A total of eleven (11)

DORP staffs were present at the meeting. The summary minutes of the meetings is provided in

Appendix B. Main discussion issues were: Objectives and activities of the project, opinion of the

participants about impact of the project and mitigation procedure, entitlements/compensation (CCL

and other resettlement benefits) payment procedure, livelihood activities in the locality, impact on

livelihood-based activities due to project intervention, livelihood and Income Restoration Program

(LIRP), numbers of cropping/yielding season in the RP area, Grievance Redress Mechanism (GRM),

relocation of APs, preparation of AP file, collection of relevant papers for resettlement

benefits/additional payment, rapid awareness building amongst the affected people on some basic

points, etc. andspecial agenda for river eroded affected HHs in section 1. Key findings are noted

below:

● APs and community people appreciated the project importance and requirements

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100LA

Pro

posal to

DC

Appro

val fr

om

Min

istr

y

Notice s

erv

edu/s

4

Rate

Colle

ctio

n for

Com

pensatio

Aw

ard

and e

stim

ate

for

com

pensatio

n

Deposit o

f com

pensatio

n m

oney to D

C

Notice s

erv

ed u

/s 8

for

CC

L P

aym

ent

EP

Recie

ves C

CL

Copie

s o

f C

CL

Docum

ent

Subm

itte

d to IN

GO

RP

Appro

val

Ad

ditio

nal P

aym

ent/T

op u

p p

aym

ent

Com

pensation/B

enefits

/Gra

nts

as p

er

GR

CD

ecis

ion

Pa

ym

ent of all

gra

nts

Land Acquisition Process (Complete for RP Sections)

Section 3 Section 5 Section 6



● APs were upset about losing their ancestral property; but they will have no grievance if they

receive adequate compensation to buy another land with the compensation money.

● APs expressed their urge to co-operate the JVC team in verifying the affected persons list and

their losses and PVAC team in determining of lost assets value.

● Agriculture-based employment will be affected due to implementation of the project. Three

season crops are grown in the area. Crops compensation should be paid.

● Fair compensation will be paid and the Project Authority will ensure all payments are made

directly to the affected persons (APs).from the project authority.

● River eroded land claimant APs are advised to submit their necessary legal papers in proving

their ownership. These claimant APs expected PMU’s interruption in resolving the issue with the DC.

● Suitable livelihood opportunities for the affected people should be offered and restoration of their

business should be ensured.

● DWASA committed to pay fair compensation and resettlements for lost assets and livelihood.

● APs have been informed that INGO will help them in opening bank accounts, collection of

citizenship certificates, tax certificates including submission of the required paper to the DWASA

to get resettlement benefits, etc.

● APs have been informed with regard to GRM process including GRC and its functionalities.

● APs are advised to take photographs and submit national ID card in the preparation of AP Identity (ID) card for getting resettlement benfits.

● APs are willing to be self-relocated subject to all types of payment receipt from the DC and

DWASA.

In addition to the consultation meeting that carried out during the preparation of the RPs, the

approved Entitlement Matrixwill be disclosed before the APs before implementation which will start

for WIA and WTP approximately by October 2018.

3.3 Payment of CCL and other Resettlement Benefits

Table 2, indicates CCL payment has been going on in the RP Section 1 and 2 areas. In total 498

APs received CCL in these areas. The rest of them have got notice under section 7 for CCL

payment. DORP is assisting affected persons in receiving CCL by preparing legal papers,

introducing them to the DC office, DORP has prepared 344 CCL statements (which defines AP’s cash payment) of RP Section 1 and 2 against 498 CCL recipients. They are collecting CCL papers

from the DC office with the help of PMU and directly from the recipient APs as well. In section 1 thise

who are yet to get the CCL have problems with legal papers. The others have delayed submission of

legal documents since some of them have river eroded land and conflict with the co-owners, etc.

Respective Union Parishad (UP) member will provide support to those APs who have conflict to

resolve. Three separate meetings have been held in three consecutive months during January,

February and March 2018with claimant APs, who have lost land due to river erosionand with DC

office following suggestion given by the ADB Safeguard Officer. The meetings were conducted by

the PMU in presence with MDSC National Resettlement Expert headed by the PD. Most of them

produce porcha and tax payment receipt. DC office asked them to submit their legal papers. DC

instructed ADC (Revenue) to arrange a hearing for both parties. DC has promised to repay the

compensation to the respective entitled persons if claimants’ submitted papers are proven as legal.

DORP has prepared a list of claimant APs and called them with their supporting paper on behalf of

their claims as well as to submit those to the DC office. List is provided with the meeting minutes.

Though last meeting held at DC office on 8th April 2018 and DORP disseminated the information to

the APs on the very next day but the APs have not submitted their papers to the DC office yet.

DWASA has added a different section with regard to river-eroded land issue and keep sufficient



budget for them in the entitlement matrix. DWASA is ready to pay them if they are proven as entitled.

In RP Section 2 area DC office is paying CCL gradually.

Property Valuation Advisory Committee (PVAC) has decided for additional compensation for

ensuring current market value of lost assets under RP Section 1, 2 and 4 areas. This top up payment

and other resettlement benefits will be paid upon approval of RPs by the ADB and the concerned

Ministry of Bangladesh government. It needs mentioning that no RP has been approved yet by the

ADB.

Photograph taking is going on in RP Section 1 & 2 areas for the preparation of AP Identity (ID) Card

for payment of resettlement benefits. It has been finished in WTP area. It is to be mentioned here

that 24 APs declined to take photograph as they are not interested to get compensation. Prior notice

(copy of notice is appended as Appendix C had been given to each APs describing dates and

venue of the photograph taking. However, three APs declined to take the photograph. AP ID card

preparation is going on for RP Section 1, 2 and 4.PMU has approved formula of creating AP ID

Number, attached as Appendix D Copy of AP ID Card is presented as Appendix E.

It is worth mentioning that eleven (11) old aged APs have died in this section; list is provided in

Appendix F Their legal successors will be eligible for compensation payment.

According to project requirement, the DBO contractor has to be handed the DWASA has to

handover them free acquired land with full compensation paid to all APs. DBO contract has been

signedon 16 May 2018 and they need land soon to start their construction in Package 1 area where

RP Section 1, 2, part of Section 3 and 4 are situated. Therefore, these RPs need to be approved by

the ADB and the Ministry on urgent basis.

3.4 Grievance Redress Mechanism (GRM)

Grievance Redress Committees (GRCs) are not declared yet. The PD has been reminded to declare

it in the project level. The PMU should name GRC members along with their contact numbers and

declare at each union. This is urgent and important because APs need GRC who can assist them in

notifying the project authority if they have any grievances. The GRC will exclusively work for

redressing grievance of the APs. The GRC will receive, evaluate, and facilitates the resolution of

APs concerns, complaints and grievances about the social safeguard issues linked to payment of fair

compensation as per the Entitlement Matrix.

The ministry of LGDR&C has approved the proposal for the formation of four committees for smooth

implementation of RPs; these are Joint Verification Committee (JVC), Property Valuation Advisory

Committee (PVAC), Grievance Redress Committee (GRC) and Resettlement Advisory Committee

(RAC). These committees have been formed for each sections of RPs. Considering present situation

PMU has revised these committees (except GRC) and their Terms of References (ToR) and got

them approved by the ministry in June 2017. However, GRC has been reviewed by the PMU and got

approval by the ministry in November 2017.

List of Committees and their respective Terms of References (ToR) had been attached in the 3rd

SSSMR.



4 Institutional Arrangement

DWASA is the Implementation Agency (IA) of the project. A PMU has been established with a SIU

with a staff of Resettlement, Safeguard Officer (Social and Gender) and Safeguard Officer

(Environment). DWASA has established its own SIU to assist PMU for managing social and

resettlement issues. Safeguard Officer (Social and Gender) of the SIU assisted by the Resettlement

Expert and Social Development and Gender Specialist of MDSC will oversee the implementation of

involuntary resettlement safeguard work under the project with support of the resettlement

implementingNGO DORP. The other staffs responsible for looking the safeguard issue of the

project include: one Executive Engineer, two Assistant Engineers. The Project Director and two

Deputy Project Directors and one Senior Water Supply Engineer administer the overall activities.

DESWSP is to be delivered through several contract packages by several consultants, contractors

and NGOs under DWASA’s PMU. Mott MacDonald is responsible for the three main construction contracts, through their Management, Design and Supervision Consultancy (MDSC) contract. Under

MDSC, Mott MacDonald is acting as the Employer’s designer for Packages 2 and 3 andwill act as the supervision consultant for Packages 1, 2 and 3.

MDSC is being led by the Mott MacDonald Limited (UK) in association with Fichtner GmbH & Co.

KG (GER), Euroconsult Mott MacDonald (Netherland) & Yooshin Engineering Corporation (KOR),

BCL Associates Limited (Bangladesh), SARM Associates Limited (Bangladesh), Associates for

Development Services Limited (Bangladesh). The goal of MDSC is to provide all necessary

consulting services requirements to implement the DESWSP.MDSC resettlement consultants is

specifically monitoring the RP implementation program. International and National Resettlement

Experts have been assigned to review and assist RP implementation process.

DWASA and the INGO namely DORP signed an agreement on February 2015 to update and

implement RPs with the support of DWASA. DORP is working in close coordination with DWASA

PMU. The major tasks of DORP are: updating RP, Institutional development, skill training,

consultation and distribute ID cards to each AP DORP is responsible to assess impacts, market

price of the loss of the property and all field activities such as 100% census and survey, public

consultation and FGD with the APs and communities.



5 Summary Monitoring Results and Key

Findings

As like as previous SSSMR, three RPs for Section 1, 2 and 4 have been resubmitted to ADB for their

approval within June 2018. As per these RPsin total 1497 AHs will have impacts on their livelihood,

agricultural production, small businesses, and structures (both dwellings and businesses). Summary

of project’s impacts on APs in RP Section 1 (WIA), 2 (Intake to Baliapara) and 4 (WTP) is given in Table 6 below:

Table6:Summary of Project Impacts for RP Section 1, 2 and 4

Sl. No.

Impacts/Types of losses Total (Nos./quantity)

Section-1 Section-2 Section-4

A Total Land required 8.65 ha. 44.60 ha. 33.20 ha.

i. Private Land to be acquired 7.63 ha. 42.95 ha. No private land required

ii. Government Land to be acquired

1.02 ha. 1.65 ha. 30.35 ha DWASA owned land and the rest 2.85 ha.

owned by BWDB

iii. Total affected households 87 1178 232

B Total affected population 535 5683 1148

C Total vulnerable Households (C1+C2)

51 384 104

C1 Female headed AHs (income below poverty line)

9 60 2

C2 Male headed AHs (income below poverty line)

42 324 102

D Total affected primary and secondary Structures (D1+D2)

- 534 52

D1 Affected primary structures (i+ii+iii) - 398 43

i: Affected residential Structures - 242 12

ii: Affected business structures - 20 30

iii. Affected residential-cum-business structure

- 136 01

D2 Affected secondary structures (i+ii) - 136 9

Total nos. of Sanitary Latrine

affected - 45 6

Tube wells, Deep Tub Wells and

Water Pump affected - 91 3

E Affected business persons - 12 31

F Wage Laborers in business houses

- 87 12

G Affected CPR (Graveyard and Mosque)

- - 2

H Numbers of affected trees (including banana and bamboo)

09 6352 561

Source: RPsof Section 1 (WIA), Section 2 (Intake to Baliapara Raw Water Pipeline) and Section 4 (WTP)



MDSC is monitoring the activities of the INGO, DORP. In this regard carried out field visits and

regular meetings between PMU and DORP to share the progress. Minutes of the meeting and field

visit report are attached herewith under AppendixGandAppendixHrespectively. Objectives of those

were i) to oversee the DORP’s activities in the field and their interactions with the affected persons’, ii) to ensure that the APs are informed and aware of their entitlement and compensation rights, iii)to

know the status of CCL payments and finding out the reasonsfor not getting CCL yet, iv) to know the

status of having legal papers of ownership by the APs who claimed the river-eroded lands under

Meghna.

Discussions were conducted with field staff and APs to get their feedback and suggestions on RP

implementation and bottlenecks if any. Key findings are as follow:

● CCL payment is going on in RP Section 1 and 2. MDSC monitored DORP’s activities and reviewed the status of CCLpayment receipt to find out reasons why some APs are yet to receive.

Reasons revealed that APs have problems in legal papers, conflict with co-owners, made delay in

the submission of legal documents to DC office, etc. In Section 1, it was seen that some APs

have conflict with the DC in determining ownership of the river eroded land. In RP Section 2 area

DC office is paying CCL gradually.

● In presence of MDSC consultant PMU held meeting with claimants APs who have lost land due to

river erosion which suggested by ADB Safeguard Officer. DORP has prepared a list of claimant

land owners and called themwith their supporting paper on behalf of their claims. Most of them

produce porcha and tax payment receipt. River eroded land owner have been suggested by the

PMU to file mis-case against government to regain the ownership from the government.

● MDSC consultant were present in the meeting whichPMU held with the DC to resolve the river-

eroded land issue. DC suggested claimant APs to submit legal papers to the DC. ADC

(Revenue) will check those through a hearing process with the APs. If they are proven as legal,

DC will repay his compensation to the legal owners. DORP was instructed to disseminate

information and help them to submit papers. They conducted meeting in this regard and regularly

following up the issue.

● ADB Safeguards Specialist suggested that the owners of the river eroded land be paid

compensation prescribed by the Property Valuation Advisory Committee to expedite the process.

(Ref. Skype meeting held on February 25, 2018)

● DORP has finalized leaflet with the review of MDSC for RP section 3, 5 and 6. Two separate kind

of leaflet has been published; one for RP section 3 & 5 and another for section 6 since this

section is different than other sections. Copiesare attached herewith as Appendix I.1 and I.2.

● GRC application form has been translated in Bangla following resettlement framework, which is

given as Appendix J

● Titled and non-titled AP’s application forms for claiming additional compensation and declaration form of compensation receipt have been developed are attached as Appendix K, Appendix

Land Appendix M respectively.

● JVC meeting has been held and decided to conduct Joint Verification Survey for RP Section 4 for

3 business affected APs whose income needs to be verified for ensuring proper compensation

payment.

● PMU has arranged collection of copies of CCL payment documents from the DC office. APs are

also advised to cooperate the INGO.

● Participation of female APs in the consultation process is not yet up to the expected level of ADB.

However, it has been increasing day by day. DORP field staff had arranged meeting exclusively

with the female folks. It is 25% for overall progress while this quarter made it 34%. MDSC

SD&GS is regularly following up this issue and will be guiding DORP to increase female

participation.



● Some of the APs faces problem in determining ownership right in case of joint ownership. MDSC

consultants provided them with advice and suggested DORP personnel to maintain regular

contact with them with adequate assistance.

● Rupganj INGO staffs are busy with conducting socio-economic survey in RP Section-3 and 5.

● MDSC NRE is supervising DORPs activities and will continue guiding them to improve the quality

of survey, reporting and monitoring.

● It was found that daily activities reports are prepared by the Area Managers and submitted

regularly to the DORP head office copied to MDSC NRE. MDSC NRE suggested to add daily

achievement of communication with APs such as personal contacts, FGDS, consultation

meetings. Also instructed to attach photographs of meetings, etc. In most cases, Rupganj

complied but Araihazar is expected to be improved. Even, daily progress report was not received

regularly from Araihazar Area Manager. Team Leader, DORP has been notified by the MDSC

time and again to ensure daily reporting.

● Regular assistance has been provided by the MDSC to develop the MIS database and a draft

database has been prepared. Final database presentation will be held on September 2018.

● One meeting was held with ADB Safeguard Specialist with regard to vulnerability criteria. ADB

Safeguard Specialist instructed to follow vulnerability criteria in all RPs as given in Safeguard

Policy Statement (SPS) 2009 and Resettlement Framework of this project. MDSC NRE shared

that some of the women and elderly headed households have substantial incomes much above

the poverty line income who would not be considered as vulnerable households.In the given

socio-cultural context of Bangladesh, they may feel embarrassed if offered a grant for the

vulnerable. However, in order to avoid subjectivity/judgemental errors in identification of the

vulnerable found in a few other projects in the past, ADB Safeguards Specialist opined that APs

meeting any of the vulnerability criteria must be made aware of the vulnerability benefits. Should

they choose to decline the vulnerability benefits, it needs to be documented as per due

procedure..



6 Compliance Status

The loan covenants related to land acquisition and resettlement activities are being complied. The

status of progress and compliance including all covenants are provided in the Monitoring and

Evaluation section of the Project’s Quarterly Progress Report and will not be repeated here.

ADB has given comments on various resettlement plans and also the 6th SSSMR and MDSC

complied with those. A comments-responses matrix has been given as Appendix N.



7 Follow up Actions and Recommendation

DC office has been paying CCL in Section 1 and 2 areas. Three RPs (Section 1, 2 and 4) have been

updated so far and two are being updated. SES has been completed for RP Section 3 and 5 (except

three mouzas). Information campaign, consultation meetings, community meetings, etc. have been

conducted as well side by side.

During the Feasibility Study conducted by the DC it was observed that APs of the RP Section 3

areas are confused about the project alignment route and activities of the project. PD has notified

MDSC that local people should be provided with the correct information in this regard so as to they

could know who will actually be affected in terms of losing their livelihood and assets (land, structure,

trees, etc.) and to what extent. So, DORP should be briefed from the PMU with actual map of project

alignment and activities to be done in this area. DORP has been instructed to disseminate accurate

information to those APs with regard to land acquisition and resettlement so that the affected

persons do not get confused what is going to happen.

Alignment video filming has been done and social cut-off-date has been declared in RP Section 3, 5

and 6 on 10th ,16th and 11th April 2018 respectively.

MDSC has arranged 3-days training on Resettlement Implementation Activities including Gender

Action Plan (GAP) for INGO field officials in May 2018. In addition, 2-days refresher’s training on Resettlement Implementation Activities for PMU officials also imparted on April 2018.

The Resettlement Experts of MDSC held several meetings with DORP to expedite their progress

and finalization of RPs.

Progress of work carried out by the DORP so far is improving with regard toquality and progress.

Several meetings were held with DORP and PMU from time to time where this was discussed.

Considering their progress following actions are recommended:

● DORP should disseminate accurate information to the APs with regard to LA including Right of

Way (RoW).

● DORP needs to assist APs more in processing legal papers for getting CCL. In addition, with the

assistance of Respective Union Parishad (UP) representative they will provide support to those

APs who have conflicts to resolve.

● No mentionable progress was found in LA/resettlement due to delays in Resettlement Plan (RP)

approval as well as some pending bureaucratic process of the government. PMU must instruct

DORP to update quality RPs. The PMU should also request ADB for quicker review of RPs and

approval. They need to look after the LA issue with the DC office to make it quicker. They may

push the DC office to make progress in land acquisition for RP Section 3, 5 and 6.

● River eroded land ownership issue and APs’ entitlement in RP Section 1 is yet to be decided.

DORP and the PMU should address these issues as early as possible since ADB is highly

concerned about them.

● DORP should be more proactive in RP preparation and incorporation of all comments made by

the ADB.

● DORP field officials should ensure more participation of the female in the consultation meeting

with proper documentation.

● DORP management should visit the field more often to ensure regular monitoring of the field

activities during implementation of land acquisition and resettlement.

Below is the monitoring format for activities to be done during implementation of the land acquisition

and resettlement as provided in the resettlement framework.



Table7:Monitoring of Activities during Implementation

Sl. No. Resettlement Plan Activities Completed Y/N

Remarks

A. Pre-Construction Activities and Resettlement Plan Activities

1 Approval of Final Resettlement Plan by ADB prior to contract award

N

2 Disclosure of Final Resettlement Plan on ADB and Executive Agency (EA) websites

N

3 Circulation of Summary RP in two languages i.e., English and Bangla to all stakeholders

N

4 Establishment of GRC and other committees for the RP finalization/ implementation

Y

5 Recruitment/Appointment of External Monitoring Agency

Y

B. Resettlement Plan Implementation

1 Grievance Redress Committee and telephone hotlines established

N

2 Entitlements and grievance redress procedure disclosed

N

3 Finalization of list of APs, vulnerable APs and compensation/ assistance/ allowances

Y For 3 sections of RP of the Project

4 Finalization of list of affected common facilities and roads for closure; mitigation measures

proposed

Y Ditto

5 Affected persons received entitlements as per amounts and program specified in RP

Y

6 Payment of compensation, allowances and assistance (No. of APs)

Y CCL paid to 498 APs in RP Section 1 and 2. Other allowances are not paid due to non-approval of RPs by ADB.

7 Additional assistance for vulnerable households given (No. of vulnerable APs)

N RPs are not approved.

8 Livelihood arrangements provided to vulnerable APs

N Ditto

9 Reinstallation of affected common facilities N Ditto

10 Grievances

No. of grievances registered N GRC not declared

No. of grievances redressed N Ditto

Outstanding complaints N Ditto

Disclosure of grievance redress statistics N Ditto

11 Consultation, participation and disclosure as per RP

Y On-going

12 Livelihood and Income Restoration activities:

Nos. of AHs resettled N RPs are not approved.

Nos. of AHs attend the retraining program N Ditto

Nos. of AHs replaced their agricultural land N Ditto

Nos. of AHs join the micro finance program N Ditto

Nos. of AHs reconstruct the loss business N Ditto

C. Monitoring

1 Survey on socio-economic status of APs (including vulnerable APs) completed and

compared with baseline survey results

Y Census on socioeconomic status done but not compared with baseline survey.

2 Survey on satisfaction levels of APs with RP implementation completed

Y

D. Labor

1 Implementation of all statutory provisions on labor like health, safety, welfare, sanitation,

N Not applicable. Construction not started



Sl. No. Resettlement Plan Activities Completed Y/N

Remarks

and working conditions by Contractors

2 Equal pay for equal work for men and women N Ditto



Appendices

A. List of CCL Recipients APs 35

B. Summary of the Consultation Meetings 70

C. Sample Notice for taking Photograph 80

D. AP ID Number Format 81

E. AP ID Card 83

F. List of Dead APs in WTP 85

G. Meeting Minutes 87

H. Field Visit Report 114

I. Leaflet for RP Sections 129

J. Translated GRC Application Form 133

K. Compensation Claiming Form for Titled Aps 134

L. Compensation Claiming Form for Non-Titled Aps 137

M. Compensation Receipt Declaration Form 138

N. ADB Comments-Responses Matrix 141



A. List of CCL Recipients APs

Development Organization of the Rural Poor

Dhaka Environmentally Sustainable Water Supply project

A.1 Mouza wise CCL Recipient AP List (Section1)

A.1.1 Mouza Name: Shomvupura& Tatia

Sl.

No.

Name of APs

Husband /Father

Name

Mouza

Plot

No.

Type of

Loss

Quantity

Land

(Decimal)

Cheque

No.

CCl

Amount

Remarks

1 Abdul Baten Late Abdul Korim Shomvupura 82 chala 8 0119336 516471.12

,, ,, Shomvupura 83 chala 10 645588.9

,, ,, Shomvupura 84 chala 9 581030.01

,, ,, Shomvupura 135 chala 17 0119053 1097501.13

2 Abdul Hasem Late Abdul Korim Shomvupura 97 chala 12 0119055 619761.78

,, ,, Shomvupura 122 chala 16 0119302 1032942.24

3 Md. Shiraz miah Late Lokkindur Shomvupura 105 Nall 10 0119025 516486.15

4 Md. Alabox ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, Same cheque

5 Md. Hassan Ali Late Mizanur

Rahman

Shomvupura 90 Nall 5 0119128 258234.08

6 Md.Hossan Ali ,, Shomvupura 93 Nall 5 ,, 258234.07 Same

cheque

7 Md. Alamin ,, Shomvupura 128 chala 30 ,, 1936766.7 Same

cheque

8 Md. Hassan Ali Late Mizanur Rahman Shomvupura 93 Nall 15 0119026 774702.22

9 Shab miah Late Mozaffur ali Shomvupura 9 Nall 1 0119106 51646.81



Sl.

No.

Name of APs

Husband /Father

Name

Mouza

Plot

No.

Type of

Loss

Quantity

Land

(Decimal)

Cheque

No.

CCl

Amount

Remarks

10 Md. Mostufa ,, Shomvupura 10 Nall 4 ,, 206587.26 Same

cheque

Sl.

No.

Name of APs

Husband /Father Name

Mouza

Plot

No.

Type of

Loss

Quantity

Land

(Decimal

)

Cheque No

CCL

Amount

Remarks

11 Hoque sub Late Oyaz Uddin Shomvupura 134 Chala 5.41 0119029 349263.59

12 Mozirun ,, Shomvupura 136 Chala 5.04 ,, 325376.81 Same

cheque

13 Ommay Begum ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,,

14 Fulesa Begum Late Husband. Oyaz Uddin

Shomvupura ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,,

15 Hoque Shab Late Oyaz Uddin Shomvupura 134 Chala 18.75 0119027 1210479.19 ,, ,, Shomvupura 136 Chala 8.66 ,, 559079.99

16 Abdur Rahman Late Kalai Miah Shomvupura 125 Chala 38 0199020 2453237

17 Abdur Rohim ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, Same cheque

18 Masum ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,,

19 Babul Late Abdul Korim ,, , , ,, ,, ,, ,, ,,

20 Md. Kawsar ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,,

21 Fuzlul Huque Late Jinnot Ali Shomvupura 72 Chala 16 0119018 968383.35

22 Samsul Huque ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, Same cheque

23 Fuzllol Huque Late Jinnot Ali Shomvupura 68 Chala 13 0119305 839265.57 ,, ,, Shomvupura 66 Chala 1.25 0119502 80698.61



Sl.

No.

Name of APs


Mouza

Plot

No.

Type of

Loss

Quantity

Land

(Decimal

)

Cheque No

CCL

Amount

Remarks

,, ,, Shomvupura 70 Chala 12 774706.68 ,, ,, Shomvupura 129 Chala 27 0119019 1743090.03

24 Sultan (Oayz Uddin)

Late Oayz Uddin Shomvupura 134 Chala 18.75 0119031 1210479.19

,, ,, Shomvupura 136 Chala 12 ,, 774706.68 Same cheque

25 Nubi Hossain Late Lokkindur ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,,

26 Anwara Husband Late. Misir Ali

,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,,

27 Sarjahan Begum Late Sukkor Ali Shomvupura 136 Chala 7 0119314 451912.23

28 Shamsunnahar Begum

,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, Same cheque

29 Piara Begum Husband. Late Sukkor Ali

,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,,

Sl.

No.

Name of APs


Mouza

Plot

No

Type of

Loss

Quantity

Land

(Decimal)

Cheque

No

CCL

Amount

Remarks

30 Jobad Ali Late korom Ali Shomvupura

140 Chala 7.5 0119310 484191.67

,, ,, Shomvupura

141 Nall 4.5 232410.67

31 Alak Miah Abdul Jolil Shomvupura

140 chala 17 0119309 1097501.13

32 Poreban Late Misir Ali Shomvupur 141 chala 11 ,, 710147.79 Same



Sl.

No.

Name of APs


Mouza

Plot

No

Type of

Loss

Quantity

Land

(Decimal)

Cheque

No

CCL

Amount

Remarks

a cheque

33 Shamsunnahar ( Shama) ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,,

34 Rohimun Nasha Late Nawsar Ali Shomvupura

140 Chala 3.5 0119163 225956.11

,, ,, Shomvupura

141 Chala 17 ,, 361527.7

35 Md. Sahazahan Bayan Late Morarok Hossin Shomvupura

77 Chala 31.09 0119041 2007135.89

36 Md.Moktar Hossin ,, Shomvupura

78 Chala 15 ,, 96838.35 Same

cheque

37 Abdul Aziz Late Abdul Ohab Shomvupura

106 Nall 20 0119052 1032936.3

,, ,, Shomvupura

129 Chala 1

,, 64558.89 Same

cheque

38 Shaiz Uddin Late Abdul Ohab Shomvupura

106 Nall 4 0119132 1032936.3

,, ,, Shomvupura

129 Chala 28 ,, 1807648.92 Same

cheque

39 shamsu Uddin Late Abdul korim Shomvupura

119 Chala 14.6 0119099 942559.79

40 Abdul Alim Late Nawaz Ali Bapary Shomvupura

85 Chala 20 0119311 1291177.8

41 Md.Mostufa ,, Shomvupura

86 Chala 1.5 ,, 96838.34 Same

cheque

42 Md. Kolilur Rhaman ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,,

43 Sak- Shadi ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,,

44 Joynal Abedin Late Boshor Uddin Shomvupura

69 Chala 13 0119301 839265.57



Sl.

No.

Name of APs


Mouza

Plot

No

Type of

Loss

Quantity

Land

(Decimal)

Cheque

No

CCL

Amount

Remarks

45 Muno Miah ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,,

46 Syad Ahamad Late Moktar ali Shomvupura

137 Chala 7 0119102 451912.23

,, ,, Shomvupura

138 Chala 12 ,, 774706.68 Same

cheque

47 Sundor Ali Late Hafiz Uddin Shomvupura

9 Nall 1.75 0119144 103293.63

Sl.

No.

Name of APs


Mouza

Plot

No

Type of

Loss

Quantity

Land

(Decimal)

Cheque

No

CCL

Amount

Remarks

,, ,, Shomvupura 10 Nall 1.75 51646.81

49 Kulsum Begum Husband. Robiwl Shomvupura 97 Nall 8 0119372 413174.52

50 Md. Shorif Late Robiwl tatia 746 river 17 0119563 1811605.47

51 Salam ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, Same cheque

52 Rasma ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,,

53 Mst. Minu Akter ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,,

54 Joj Miah Late Ali hossin Shomvupura 99 Nall 4 0119034 206587.26

55 Gulam Mostufa ,, Shomvupura 117 Nall 2 ,, 103293.63 Same

cheque

56 Nurunnahar ,, ,, ,, ;; ,, ,, ,, ,,

57 Sufiy Katon ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,,

58 Supon Miah Late Siraz Miah ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,,

59 Md.Alomgir Late Rofikul Islam ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,,



Sl.

No.

Name of APs


Mouza

Plot

No

Type of

Loss

Quantity

Land

(Decimal)

Cheque

No

CCL

Amount

Remarks

60 Md. Kamal Hossin Mohiz Uddin ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,,

61 Jaman Mohiz Uddin ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,,

62 Khokon ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,,

63 Fatama Akter Late Ali hossin kondokar ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,,

64 Monoara Late Abdul jolil Shomvupura 107 Nall 4 0119348 929642.67

65 Saharun ,, Shomvupura 118 Nall 14 ,, ,, Same cheque

66 Taslima Husband Abdul Aziz ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,,

67 Alak Miah Late Abdul Jolil Shomvupura 107 Nall 13 0119346 671408.6

,, ,, Shomvupura 117 Nall 7 ,, 361527.7 Same

Cheque

,, ,, Shomvupura 118 Nall 10 ,, 516468.15 ,,

68 Amin Uddin Late Abdul Mannan Shomvupura 109 Nall 8 0119313 413174.52

69 Alamin ,, Shomvupura 116 Nall 13 ,, 671408.6 Same

Cheque

Sl.

No.

Name of APs


Mouza

Plot

No

Type of

Loss

Quantity

Land

(Decimal)

Cheque

No

CCl

Amount

Remarks

70 Fatama Husband ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, Same Cheque

71 Aliza Husband Alabox Shomvupura

110 Nall 11 0119199 568114.97

,, Shomvupura

115 Nall 11 568114.97



Sl.

No.

Name of APs


Mouza

Plot

No

Type of

Loss

Quantity

Land

(Decimal)

Cheque

No

CCl

Amount

Remarks

,, Shomvupura

116 Nall 20 103293.63

72 Monwara Late Abdul Jolil Miah Shomvupura

118 Nall 14 0119348 723055.41

73 Sharun bibi ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, Same cheque

74 Taslima Late Abudl Aziz ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,,

75 Koddus ali Late Abdul Korim Shomvupura

119 Chala 15 0119135 968383.35

76 Mst. Malaka Begum Husband Ismail Shomvupura

118 Chala 7.4 0211192 472957.99

77 Abdul Ba rak Late Soruz Miah Shomvupura

121 Chala 15 0119307 968383.35

78 Abdul Motin ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, Same cheque

79 Siddikur Rohman Late Abdul Korim Shomvupura

123 Chala 18 0119117 1162060.02

80 Aman Ullah Late Badsha Miah Shomvupura

126 Chala 27 0119118 1743090.03

81 Abdul Gaffar Late Nurjaman ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, Same cheque

82 Jahanara Husband. ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,,

83 Md. Billal Hossin Late Shaiz Uddin Shomvupura

132 Nall 7 0119820 451912.23

84 Anjot Ali ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, Same cheque

85 Rofikul Islam Late Karamot Ali Tetia 745 Nall 9 0119316 959032.31

86 Rowson Ara Husband Md: Israil Shomvupura

104 Nall 3.5 0111561 180763.85

87 Monoara Begum Husband Ahsanul kobir 112 Nall 9 ,, 464821.33 Same

Cheque



Sl.

No.

Name of APs


Mouza

Plot

No

Type of

Loss

Quantity

Land

(Decimal)

Cheque

No

CCl

Amount

Remarks

88 Sanjida Husband Md. Borhan uddin ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,,

89 Minara Husband Late Tazul Tslam ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,,

90 Tanbir Ahmed Late tazul islam ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,,

91 Dolon Akter Late tazul islam ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,,

Sl.

No.

Name of APs


Mouza

Plot

No

Type of

Loss

Quantity

Land

(Decimal)

Cheque

No

CCl

Amount

Remarks

92 Sumaia Akter Late tazul islam ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, Same cheque

93 Sahaz uddin Late Asmot Ali Tetia 745 Nall 9 0119981 959032.3

94 Anowara Khatun Late Afaz uddin ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, Same cheque

95 Lakiba Husband Sufikul Islam ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,,

96 Sahin Ahmmed Abdul Baten Tetia 752 Nall 16 0119070 1704946.32

97 Siraz Miah Late Shamsu Miah Tetia 745 Nall 3.15 0119511 335661.31

,, ,, Tetia 747 Nall 12.23 ,, 1303218.35 Same

cheque

98 mostufa kamal Late Abdul Rajak Shomvupura 7 Nall 3 0119818 154940.45

99 safia khatun Husband Abdul Ba rak ,, 8 Nall 2 ,, 103293.63 Same cheque

100 khodaja Husband Hossin ,, 67 Chala 5 ,, 3.22794.45 Same cheque

101 Muno Miah Late Bosur uddin Shomvupura 67 Chala 8 0119819 516471.12

102 Eleas ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, Same cheque

103 johor Ali Late Hafij uddin Shomvupura 11 Nall 4 0119821 206587.26

104 Sofor Ali ,, Shomvupura 12 Nall 3 ,, 154940.45 Same



Sl.

No.

Name of APs


Mouza

Plot

No

Type of

Loss

Quantity

Land

(Decimal)

Cheque

No

CCl

Amount

Remarks

cheque

105 md: Jabed Ali Late korom Ali Shomvupura 140 Chala 7.5 0119310 484191.67

,, ,, 141 Nall 4.5 232410.67 Same

cheque

106

Ahsia Katun

Husband Md. Habibur

rahman

Shomvupura

114

Nall

10

0119564

516468.35

107 Abdul korim Hozrot Ali Shomvupura 71 Chala 11 0125011 710147.79

,, ,, 72 Chala 2 129117.78 Same

cheque

,, ,, 76 Chala 5.56 3589147.43 ,,

108 Sufia Khatun Husband Late Joj Miah Shomvupura 98 Nall 23 0119600 1187876.74

109 Dulal Hossin Late Joj miah 99 Nall 2.5 ,, 129117.04 Same

cheque

110 Shamsul Hoq (Sokkur Ali) ,, 108 Nall 7.5 ,, 387351.11 Same

cheque

111 Mst. Safaly Akter ,, 112 Nall 7.75 ,, 400262.82 Same

cheque

Sl.

No.

Name of APs


Mouza

Plot

No

Type of

Loss

Quantity

Land

(Decimal)

Cheque

No

CCL

Amount

Remarks

112 Mst. Silpe ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, Same cheque

113

Md: Shogir Ahmmad

Mollah

Md: Momtaz Uddin Mollah

Shomvupura

137

Chala

7

0119101

451912.23



Sl.

No.

Name of APs


Mouza

Plot

No

Type of

Loss

Quantity

Land

(Decimal)

Cheque

No

CCL

Amount

Remarks

114 Alomgir Late Rofikul Islam ,, ,, , ,, ,, ,, Same cheque

115 Nurjahan Begum ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,,

116 Kamal Hossin Mohiz Uddin Shomvupura 99 Nall 4 0119035 206587.26

117 Jamal Hossin ,, Shomvupura 117 Nall 2 ,, 103293.63

118 Khokon ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, Same cheque

119 Fatama Akter LateAliHossinKhodokar Shomvupura 104 Nall 3.5 0119568 180763.85

120 Md: sahaz Uddin Md: Ashmot Ali Shomvupura 132 Chala 3.28 0119172 205297.27

121 Anowara Khatun Husband Afaz Uddin ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, Same cheque

122 Lokiba Husband Shofikul Islam ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,,

123 Ahsan Miah Late Abdul Malak ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,,

124 Halima ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,,

125 Rahima Begum ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,,

126 Rahena Akter ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,,

127 Rup Miah Late Chan Miah Shomvupura 89 Nall 17 0119351 877995.86

128 Abdul Shamad Late Korom Ali Shomvupura 141 Chala 5 0119308 322794.45

129 Mst. Hasimun Husband Shamad Miah 141 Nall 6.5 ,, 335704.3 Same

cheque

130 Sukkur Mahmud Late Muktob ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,,

131 Joj Miah Late Abdul Malak Shomvupura 132 Chala 3.82 0119200 246614.96

132 MD. Fuzlul Hoque ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, Same cheque

133 Sahin Ahmmed (Redui) Abdul Baten Shomvupura 94 Nall 18 0119398 3357042.98

,, ,, 95 Nall 22

,, ,, 96 Nall 25



Sl.

No.

Name of APs


Mouza

Plot

No

Type of

Loss

Quantity

Land

(Decimal)

Quantity

Tree

(Nos.)

Cheque

No

CCl

Amount

Remarks

134 Shiraz Miah Late Shamsu Miah Tatia 745 Nall 3.15 0119519 335661.31

747 Nall 12.23 1303218.35

135 Md. Jomir Ali Mokrum Ali Shomvupura 105 Nall 10 0119887 516468.15

,, ,, 113 Nall 7 361527.71

,, ,, 519 Nall 6 309880.89

136 Abdur Razzak Late Didar hazi Shomvupura 80 Chala 19 0119330 1226618.91

137 Amana Khatun ,, 79 Chala 30 ,, 1936766.7 Same

cheque

138 Md: Motaleb Late Esmael ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,,

139 Jahanara Begum ,, ,,

140 Sabana Begum ,, ,,

141 Rog Mala Husband ,, ,,

142 Fotik Chondro Dash Dinbundho Dash Shomvupura 15 Nall 3 0119517 154940.44 Same

cheque

143 Delip Chondro Dash ,, 16 Nall 2 ,, 103293.63 ,,

144 Prodip Chondro Dash ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,,

145 Loknath Chondro Dash ,, ,,

146 Nemol Chondro Dash ,, ,,

147 Shre Sonjoy Chondro Dash ,, ,,

148 Ojid Chondro Dash Nikonjo Chondro Dash ,,

149

Shre Guraggo Chondro

Dash

Hiron Chondro Dash

,,

150

Shre Gorinthro Chondro

Dash

,,

,,

151 Bolai Chondro Das ,, ,,



152 Nur Jaman Late Haraz Ali Shomvupura 76 Chala 3.12 0125068 201423.74

153 Md.Samad Ali Late Chan Miah Shomvupura 76 Chala 8.55 0125061 551978.51

Sl.

No.

Name of APs


Mouza

Plot

No

Type of

Loss

Quantity

Land

(Decimal)

Quantity

Tree

(Nos.)

Cheque

No

CCL

Amount

Remarks

154 Abu Hanifa ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, Same cheque

155 Nasir Uddin ,, ,,

156 Aiyob Ali ,, ,,

157 Md.Nayeb Ali ,, ,,

158 Chan Miah Late Abdul Kalak Shomvupura 124 Chala 17 0125051 1097501.13

159 Banu Miah ,, Same cheque

160 Amina Husband Abdul Khalek Same cheque

161 Momita Begum Husband Abdul Mannan Same cheque

162 Hawoa Khatun Husband Shiraz Miah Same cheque

163 Ayasa Khatun Husband Amir Ali Same cheque

164 Jahanara Begum Husband Jamal Uddin Shomvupura 136 Nall 4.8 0119314 309882.67

165 Md.jongshor Ali Late Abdur Rohman Shomvupura 120 Nall 12 0119518 774706.68

166 Md showkot ali "

167 Rowshon Ali "

168 shetara begum "

169 sumsunnahar "

170 Fatema akter "

171 Nafiza Akter "

172 Johirul islam Renu Mia Shomvupura 13, Nall 1.25 0111381 782965.72

173 Shima akter " ,, 14 Nall 4 ,, ,, ,, Same cheque

174 Shima akter " ,, 14 Nall 4 ,, ,, ,,



Sl.

No.

Name of APs


Mouza

Plot

No

Type of

Loss

Quantity

Land

(Decimal)

Quantity

Tree

(Nos.)

Cheque

No

CCL

Amount

Remarks

175 Taslima Akter " ,, 15 Nall 1.66 ,, ,, ,,

176 Ruma Akter " ,, 16 Nall 0.01 ,, ,, ,,

177 Mahela khatun Husband Renu Mia ,, 17 Nall 4 ,, ,, ,,

,, 18 Nall 1.5 ,, ,,

Sl.

No.

Name of APs


Mouza

Plot

No.

Type of

Loss

Quantity

Land

(Decimal)

Quantity

Tree

(Nos.)

Cheque

No.

CCL

Amount

Remarks

shomvupura 19 Nall 0.005 ,, ,,

,, 20 Nall 15.16 ,, ,,

178 Hossan Late Lohindor shomvupura 134

136

Chala

Chala

6

7

0119314 839447.57

179 Anowara Husband Late Misir

Ali

180 Joma gazi Late Sukkur Ali Same cheque

181 Sharzahan Begum ,, Same cheque

182 Shamsunnahar ,, Same cheque

183 Peara Begum ,, Same cheque

Development Organization of the Rural Poor

Dhaka Environmentally Sustainable Water Supply project



A.2 Mouza Wise CCL Recipient AP list(Section 2)

A.2.1 Mouza Name: Aguandi

Sl.

No

Name of AP

Husband / Father Name

Plot No

Type of

Loss

Quantity of Loss in Dc./

trees

Cheque No. CCl Amount

Remarks

1 Md.Nobi Hossin late Abu Kalam 258 Nall, bita 2.25 0119167 213098.24

2 Md Mozibur Rahman late Abdul Ba rak 258 Nall 9.5 0119167 622902.55

3 Arju Miah late Suna miah 139

153

Nall Nall 15 4.5

0119001 1278589.46

4 Shorif late Halal uddin Same cheque

5 Rashida late Manik miah Same cheque

6 Manik miah late Abdul Gofur Same cheque

Sl.

No

Name of AP

Husband / Father

Name

Plot No

Type of

Loss

Quantity of loss in Dc./ trees

Cheque No. CCL Amount

Remarks

7 ABAMHannanRomizi

lateRomozUddinBoyean

153 Nall 4.5 0119081 1868707.65

156 Nall 13.5

223 Nall 10.5

224 Nall 0.0025

8 Rowson Miah late Asmot Ali 201 Nall 6 0119012 393412.14

9 Md.Suroz Miah late Eykob Ali 233 Nall 34.5 0119033 2239498.61

10 Monir Hossin late Hozrut Ali 201 Nall 6.82 0119171 447178.47

11 MD. Babul Hossin ,,

12 Hafaza begum Husband,late Hozrut

Ali

13 Md.Fozlul Hoque

late Sayad Ali 273 Bari 5-/trees- 0119160 3749951.7

280 Nall 14



Sl.

No

Name of AP

Husband / Father

Name

Plot No

Type of

Loss

Quantity of loss in Dc./ trees


Remarks

281 Nall 25.5

14 Md.Jaman miah late Abul Hasam 200 Nall 6 002199 389478.01

15 Md. Kawsar ,, Same cheque

16 Monoara begum ,, ,,

17 MD Josim Uddin

Bhuya

late Abdur Ruf 254 Nall 5 0119161 327843.45

196 Nall 20 0119162 2294904.15

222 Nall 15

18 Md. Rofik Bhuya late Dr. Mofiz Uddin 199 Nall 14.5 0119195 950746.01

19 ABAMMannanRonozi

lateRomozUddinBhuya

153 Nall 4.5 0119168 1852315.48

156 Nall 13.5

223 Nall 10.25

20 Sumbo Kantho

Dash

late Borda Kantho

Dash

359 Bari 51.25 0119320 235659.87

21 Binod kumar Dash ,, 360 Bari 18.75 Same cheque

22 Modon Kumar

Dash

,, 361 Bita 2.5 ,,

23 Sumbo Kantho

Dash

late Borda Kantho

Dash

359 Structure 0 0119383 14496409.62

Sl.

No

Name of AP


Plot No

Type of Loss Quantity of

Loss in

Dc./ trees

Cheque

No.

CCL Amount

Remarks

24 Mostufa Miah late Jobad ali 191 Nall 10 0119175 655686.9

25 Md. Alomgir late Solaman 192 Nall 6 0119376 393412.14

26 Abul Hossin late Hozrut Ali 201 Nall 2.9 0119378 192116.26



Sl.

No

Name of AP


Plot No

Type of Loss Quantity of

Loss in

Dc./ trees

Cheque

No.

CCL Amount

Remarks

3

27 Abdul Baten late Abbas Ali 354 Bari,

Structure

1.5 0119388 643471.28

28 MD. Babul Hossin late Abdul Malak 354 Bari,

Structure

3-/trees- 0119177 1511600.31

29 Abdur Rohoman late Abdur hakim 188 Nall 7 0119515 590118.21

30 Momotaz Husband Abdur Rohman 189 Nall 2 Same cheque

31 Mahamod late Malak 192 Nall 6 0119516 393412.14

32 MD.habesol Hoque LateKomorUddinBuyan 159 Nall 2.8 0119525 183592.33

33 Md. Ba rak Miah ,, Same cheque

34 Md. Kaiwom Miah ,, ,,

35 Md.Kobir Hossin ,, ,,

36 Sabikurnahar Tufazzul Hossin 159

222

Nall 7

11

0119524 767163.67

37 Farhana Akter ,, Same cheque

38 Tahmina Akter Husband. ,,

39 Rubina Akter late Jamal Uddin 154 Nall 5 0119333 327843.45 Same cheque

40 Md. Jakir Hossin ,, ,,

41 Md. Anowar Hossin ,, ,,

42 Tahmina Akter ,, ,,

43 Rafia Begum Husband. ,, ,,

44 Fojlul Hoque late Kofil Uddin 188 Nall 7.75 0119059 1296290.66

45

46

Monir Hossin ,, 354 Bari 2.75 ,, ,, Same cheque

Anowar

Fojila

late Taiz uddin 199 Nall 14.5 0119331 1225096.79

47 ,, 273 Bari 2 Same cheque

48 Anower late Ismail 254 Nall 33.

75

0119544 221294.32



Sl.

No

Name of AP


Plot No.

Type of Loss


trees

Cheque No. CCL

Amount

Remarks

49 MD. Shohidullah late Hozrut Ali 152 Nall 3.5 0119504 229490.41

50 Md. Aman Ullah ,, Same cheque

51 Abaidullah ,, Same cheque

52 Mofijul ,, Same cheque

53 Asadullah ,, Same cheque

54 Hasnara Akter Husband. Robi Awoal Same cheque

55 Eyasmin late Abdul Awoal 281 Nall 11.25 0111505 737647.76

56 Roksana Husband. Kamal Same cheque

57 Nojrul late Abdul Awoal Same cheque

58 Hosnaara Husband Emdadul hoque Same cheque

59

Safia

Husband late Abdul

Awoal

Same cheque

60 Peyara Begum late Alim Uddin 354 Bari,Structure 1.5 0119090 643760.87

61 Tania ,, Same cheque

62 Eyasmin ,, Same cheque

63 Anifa Akter Husband.late Alim Uddin Same cheque

64 Sahabuddin late Ahammud Ali 254 Nall 33.75 0119543 221294.32

65 Abdul Khalak late Abbas Ali 354 Bari,Structure 2.75 0119825 909031.6

66 Abdul malak Abdul malak ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, Same cheque

67 Anowara Begum Husband ,, Same cheque

68 Fatema

Husband Lokman

bapary

Same cheque

69 Kuddus Ali late Rohim Uddin 354 Structure 2.5 0119565 912192.42

70 Eddres Ali ,, Same cheque



Sl.

No

Name of AP


Plot No.

Type of Loss


trees

Cheque No. CCL

Amount

Remarks

71 Mst. Minara Begum ,, Same cheque

Sl.

No

Name of AP


Plot No.

Type of

Loss


trees

Cheque

No.

CCL Amount

Remarks

72 Parben ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, Same cheque

73 Abeda Khatun Husband ,, Same cheque

74 Kawsar Azgur Ali Same cheque

75 Abdul Aowal late Abdul Lotif 355 Structure 0 0119809 468420.97

76 Md. Nuzrul Islam late Abdul Lotif 278 trees+Str

ucture

1.5 0111532 3323592.62

77 Abdul Aowal ,, 153 ,, 4 Same cheque

78 Md.Anarul Hoqe ,, 354 ,, 7.5 Same cheque

79 Abdul Motin ,, 355 ,, 4 Same cheque

80 Munoara late Abdul Khalak 190 Nall 2.85 0119542 186870.76

81 Abul Kashem Abdul Aowal

A.2.2 Mouza Name: Atadi

Si No

Name of AP


Plot No.

Type of Loss


trees

Cheque No

CCL Amount

Remarks



Si No

Name of AP


Plot No.

Type of Loss


trees

Cheque No

CCL Amount

Remarks

1 Md.Joinal Late Mobarok 614 Nall 1.66 0119332 2066294.18

2 Mst.Asma begum ,, 615 Nall 6.33

3 Mst.Firoza begum ,, 616 Nall 1.41 Same cheque

4 Mst. Tamanna Begum ,, 425 Nall 1.83

423 Nall 5

Sl No

Name of AP

Husband / Father

Name

Plot No.

Type of Loss


trees

Cheque No.

CCL Amount

Remarks

418 Nall 13.5 ,, ,, Same cheque

5 Abul Hasam late Nowab Ali 501 Nall 10.5 0119361 781106.29

6 Marjia Begum late Jayd Ali 565 Nall 15 0119164 1115866.13

7 Hasan Ali late Sarak Ali 630 Nall 10 0119501 743910.76

8 Jakir Hossin late Abdur Ba rak 603 Nall 3.25 0119514 246465.46

605 Nall 0.0025

9 Mohosin Miah late Abdur Sobhan 600 Nall 7 0119510 1815981.25

602 Nall 13

10 Mikael late Solayman 2566 Nall 4.7 0119830 349638.05

11 Parben Husband.Sahadat Hossin 564 Nall 15 0119165 1115866.12

12 Abul Kalam late Nowab Ali 501 Nall 10.5 0119325 929888.44

602 Nall 2

13 Abdul Halim late Abdul guffor 417 Nall 1 0119512 334759.84

415 Nall 3.5

14 Akteruzzaman(gong

) late Askor Ali 390 Nall 22 0119511 1636603.65



Sl No

Name of AP

Husband / Father

Name

Plot No.

Type of Loss


trees

Cheque No.

CCL Amount

Remarks

15 Md.shamsul hoque ,,

16 Md.kamal late Akteruzzaman

17 Abul Hasam late Nowab Ali 34 Nall 9.5 0119354 353209.48

18

Md.Joynal Abadin Mollah

late Johirol Hoque Mollah

93

Nall

8

0119124

595128.6

19 Gulbahar Begum ,, Same cheque

20 Nilofa ,, ,,

21 Md.kawsar Uddin ,, ,,

Si No

Name of AP

Husband/FatherName

Plot No.

Type of Loss

Quantity of Loss in

Dc./ trees

Cheque

No.

CCL

Amount

Remarks

22 Kalada begum ,, 93 Nall 8 ,, ,, Same cheque

23 Bilkis akter ,, 93 Nall 8 ,, ,, ,,

24 Rajia Akter Husband. ,, ,,

25 Shirajul Hoque late Mutiwol Islam 607 Nall 17.75 0125037 1320441.47

26 Shamsul Hoque ,, Same cheque

27 Md. Amdadul Hoque ,, ,,

28

Muzammal Bhuya

late Shamsul Hoque

Bhuya

420

Nall

3.5

0119807

1004279.51

424 Nall 10

617 Nall 2.75 0125125 204575.45

29 Abdul Motin Md. Mohiz Uddin 607 Bari 3 0125073 363813.12

30 Esrael late Sulayman 566 Nall 4.7 0119828 349638.05

31 Abul Hossin late Rojob Ali 13 Nall 8 0119585 312081.66



Si No

Name of AP

Husband/FatherName

Plot No.

Type of Loss

Quantity of Loss in

Dc./ trees

Cheque

No.

CCL

Amount

Remarks

32 Monir Hossin ,, 17 Nall 4 Same cheque

33 Ibrahim late Motalib 600 601

Nall Bari 4.5 1.5

0119805 540106.38

34 Jahaggir Hossin late Abdul Motalib Same cheque

35 Halima Begum Husband Hoque Shab ,,

36

Mst. Salma

Husband Md. Aman

Ullah

,,

A.2.3 Mouza Name: Bazinabond

Sl

No

.

Name of AP


Plot No.

Type of Loss

Quantity of Loss in Dc./ trees

Cheque No.

CCL Amount

Remarks

1 Md.Sahzahan Miah Late Norul Islam 45 Nall 15.5 0021951 403105.48

2

Md. Habbur Rohman Bhuya

Late Nubi Hossin Bhuya

46

Nall

6.25

0119105

162542.53

3 Md. Hanifa Hafaz Shamsul Hoque 21 Nall 2 0119518 403105.48

22 Nall 13.5

4 Eddris Ali Mohammud Ali 10 Nall 19.5 0119353 507132.72

5 Anowar ,, Same cheque

6 Abul Hossin ,, ,,

7 Md.Nouman Md.Moslah Uddin 10 Nall 6 0119597 156040.63

8 Md. Shiddikur Rahman late Nayeb Ali Master 16 Nall 7 0119595 182047.64

9 Md. Nouman Md.Moslah Uddin 18 Nall 10 0119836 160068.05

10 Asya ,, Same cheque

11 Mst.Fujila Begum Husbnad. Md. Israfil ,,



A.2.4 Mouza Name: Baliapara

Sl No

Name of AP


Plot No. Type of Loss


Cheque

No

CCL Amount

Remarks

1 Md.Aowlad Hossin Late Sahab Uddin Miah 617 1.5 Nall 0119529 361627.94

2 Md.Khorsad Alom Bhuya Late Monir Uddin Bhuya 617 6.6 Nall 0119530 1211237.73

Sl No

Name of AP




trees

Cheque No.

CCL Amount

Remarks

3 Arif Hossin Bhuya ,, 617 2.4 Vita 0119530 ,, Same cheque

4 Rubi Akter ,, ,,

5 Mst. Farjana naznin ,, ,,

6 Nadia Afruz ,, ,,

7 Rabea Sultana ,, ,,

8 Razia Begum Husband. ,, ,,

9 Samim Mollah late Shohidllah Mollah 578 13 Nall 0119528 1758762.72

10 Tota amiah late Abdur Razzak 41 16 Nall 0119526 1300337.28

11 Monir Hossin late Ahmmud Ali 1580 9.5 Nall 0119531 1028196.98

12 Md Sahin Bhuya late Epas Uddn 1568 2 Nall 0119556 243520.7

1 Doba



A.2.5 Mouza Name: Bijoynogor

Sl. No. Name of AP


Plot No.

Type of

Loss

QuantityofLossinDc./tre

es


Remarks

1 Sukan Chondro kur Late Sudas Chondro Kur 59 Bari 1.13 0119896 95888.81

59 Structure 0 0119335 563939.14

60 Structure 0 3989846.02

60 Bari,Gortho 7.73+1 0119134 666345.32

2 Sorafut Ali late Jobad Ali 55 Nall 8 0119048 332746.92

Sl. No Name of AP


Plot No.

Type of Loss

QuantityofLossinDc./trees


Remarks

3 Madobi Rani Kur Husband. Osid Chondo Kur 60 Bari, Gorto 7.77+1 0119103 669739.61

59 Bari 0.0087 73825.89

4

Prodip Kumar Mithro

late Gojandro Mohon Mithro

55 62 62

Nall, Bari Nall

Structure+trees

42.5

7 0

0119047 0119808 0119531

2107691.03 594001.48 878095.35

Same cheque

5 Roton Kumar Mithro ,, ,,

6 Ronojit Kumar Mithro ,, ,,

7 Khokon kumar Mithro ,, ,,

8 MD.Elias late Samad 650 Nall 10.5 0119179 436730.33

9 Billal Hossin ,,

10 Md.Sana Ullah late Hafaz Uddin 771 Nall 27.5 0021970 1143817.54

11 Md. Mozib uddin ,, Same cheque

12 Numan ullah ,, ,,

13 Ommy Kulsom Husband. Ali Asraf 615 Nall 3 0119198 165974

14 Md. Akter Hossin late Sultan Miah 716 Nall 14 0119375 582307.11



Sl. No Name of AP


Plot No.

Type of Loss



Remarks

15 Ruma Akter late AL-haz Suroz Miah 736 Nall 17.5 0119187 727883.89

16 Abu Shai Bhuya late AL-haz Suroz Miah 651 Nall 11.5 0119188 478323.72

17 Rubi Begum Husband.Shaiful Islam 736 Nall 17.5 0119189 727883.89

18 Dilip Komar dah lateDinas Chondo 3 ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,,

Nall ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,,

18 ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,, ,,

0119520 1527432.39

19 Dullal chondro dah ,, Same cheque

20 Sudir Chondro dah late Gulap Chondo dah Same cheque

21 Manik chondro dah ,, Same cheque

22 Ripon dah Sobol dah Same cheque

23 Bishsojit Chondro dah late Subas chondo dah Same cheque

24 Endrojit chondro dah late Subol chondo dah Same cheque

25 Omol chondro dah late Sorot chondo dah Same cheque

Sl.

No

Name of AP


Plot No.

Type of

Loss


Cheque No.

CCL Amount

Remarks

26

Khokon chondro

late Deranthro chondro

dah

,,

,,

,,

,,

,,

Same cheque

27 Sojon chondro dah late Biranthro chondro dah Same cheque

28 Sujib Kumar dah late Sopon chondro dah Same cheque

29 Tusar chondro dah late Kalai chondro dah Same cheque

30 kisno chondro dah ,, Same cheque

31 Eddis Ali late Rohom Ali 614 Chala 33 0119120 2443592.75

615 Chala 14

32 Abdur Rob Momotaz Uddin 600

3

Bari Structure+tre

2 0

0119895 0125034

169714.71 841891.1

33 Shomir kanto Dah late Suraz Kanto Dah



Sl.

No

Name of AP


Plot No.

Type of

Loss


Cheque No.

CCL Amount

Remarks

34 Modu Sudon Dash Kamon Chondro Dash es Same cheque

35 Bishsojit Chondro

dah

late Subas chondo dah Same cheque

36 Omol chondro dah late Sorot chondo dah Same cheque

A.2.6 Mouza Name: Choitoncanda

Sl. No

Name of AP

Husband / Father

Name

Plot

No.

Type of

Loss


Cheque No CCL Amount

Remarks

1 Md. Sohidullah Late Rojob Ali 2991 Chala 8/trees- 0111312 802416.78

2

3

Hobe Miah

Moina begum

Late Amir Ali

,,

2995 Nall 2.58 0119396 2867088.83

2994 Nall 3.8 ,, Same cheque

Sl. No

Name of AP

Husband / Father Name Plot

No

Type of

Loss

QuantityofLossinDc./t

rees


Remarks

4 Majada begum ,, 3547 Nall 0.0025 ,, ,, Same cheque

5

6

Sajada begum

Fiara begum

,,

,,

2783 Nall 1.5 ,, ,, ,,

2810 Nall 1.58 ,,

2809 Nall 1.67 ,,

2808 Nall 2 ,,

2811 Nall 1.62 ,,

2992 Nall 0.0083 ,,



Sl. No

Name of AP


No

Type of

Loss

QuantityofLossinDc./t

rees


Remarks

2996 Nall 20 ,,

7

8

9

10

11

Sofor Ali

Johor Ali

Sahar Ali

Sundor Ali

Rowson Ali

late Hafiz Uddin

,,

,,

,,

,,

2995 Nall 12.92 0119397 6535170.11

2994 Nall 18.95 Same cheque

3547 Nall 1.25 ,,

2783 Nall 7.5 ,,

2810 Nall 7.92 ,,

2809 Nall 8.33 ,,

2808 Nall 10 ,,

2811 Nall 8.13 ,,

2892 Nall 4.17 ,,

3545 Nall 2.5 ,,

12 Siddikur Rahman late Abdul korim 2786 Nall 14 0119116 1120269.15

13 Motalib late Mollhaz 1791 Nall 0.005 012506 400091.61

14 Abdur Rohoman late Sobir Ali 2560 Nall 6.5 0021993 1120269.14

15 MD. Sahar Ali late Hafiz Uddin 2592 Nall 26.75 0119103 2140514.27

16 Md. Johor Ali late Hafiz Uddin 2778 Nall 23.5 0119083 1880451.78

17 Anowar Hossin late Abdul ohab 2560 Nall 9.5 0119104 1520365.26

2561 Nall 9.5

Sl. No

Name of AP

Husband/FatherName Plot

No.

Type of

Loss



Remarks

18 Rob Miah

MD. Mainuddin

late Mortob Ali

,,

2597 Nall 21 0119980 1680403.72

19

20 Dula Miah late Sofir Udin 2812 Nall 7 0119176 560134.58



Sl. No

Name of AP

Husband/FatherName Plot

No.

Type of

Loss



Remarks

21 Md. Main Uddin Aahman lateOsmangoniSorkar 2588 Nall 5.5 0119028 480115.35

2589 Nall 0.005

22 Md.Haronur Roshid late Abdul lotif 2785 Nall 15.5 0119084 1620389.3

2819 Nall 4.75

23

Shri- GoragguChondo

Dash

Shri-GorinthroChondo

Dash

late Hiron Chondo Dash

,,

3548

Nall

14.5

0119127

3807427.88

24

3549

Bari

16

0111312

25

Ojid mohon Dash

late.Nikondo Chondo

Dash

2990

Nall

0.005

0119396

7360715.09

3548 Nall 16

3549 Bari 22

3550 Chala 24

26 Samsu Uddin Miah late.Abdul korim 2786 Nall 14 0119100 1120269.15

27 Abdur rosid mollah late.Chan Miah 25566 Nall 9.25 0119054 740177.83

28 Md. Sohidullah ,, Same cheque

29 Rokea ,, Same cheque

30

31

Rohima bibi ,, Same cheque

Fulasa bagum Husband. ,, Same cheque

32 Samsu Uddin Miah late.Abdul korim 2787 Nall 6.5 0119098 1480355.66

2788 Nall 12

33 Md. Jakir hossin late.Abdul lotif 2785 Nall 15.5 0119119 1620389.3

2819 Nall 4.5



Sl. No

Name of AP

Husband / Father

Name

PlotNo. Type of Loss



Remarks

34 Md. Hasan Ali late.saiz Uddin mollah 2567 Nall 1 0119130 1489957.97

35 Md.kamal mollah ,, 2598 Nall 17.62 Same cheque

36 Md.babul mollah ,, ,,

37 Md. Billal hossin ,, ,,

38 All- kaiwom supon ,, ,,

39 Md. Monir hossin late. Saju miah 2590 Nall 19 0021991 3120749.7

2591 Nall 20

40 Islam Miah late.Nur mohammud 2558

2559

Nall Nall

1.75 11.75

0119126 1080259.54

41 Mozibor rohoman ,, Same cheque

42 Sab miah ,, Same cheque

43 Dalim Miah ,, Same cheque

44 Samsunnahar ,, Same cheque

45 Soria bagum ,, Same cheque

46 Anowara bagum ,, Same cheque

47 Jahanara bagum Same cheque

48 Abdul Baten late.Chan Miah 3543

2993

Nall,Structure

Nall

12-/trees- 9

0119505 4239465.62

49 Md.Mozo miah ,, Same cheque

50

firoza Bagum

Husband.Abdur

Rohoman

Same cheque

51 Md. Hossin Ali late. Mizanur rohoman Same cheque

52

53

Md.hasan Ali ,, Same cheque

Hasan Ali late.Rub Miah 2784 Nall 4.5 0119145 360086.51

54 Md. Harunur Rohid late.Abdul Lotif 2785 Nall 15.5 0119084 1620389.3

2819 Nall 4.75

Fozlul Hoq late.Jinnut Ali 2780 Nall 8 0119325 640153.8



Sl. No

Name of AP

Husband / Father

Name

PlotNo. Type of Loss



Remarks

55

Sl. No

Name of AP





Remarks

56 Huqe Shab late Neyaz Uddin 2991 Nall 14 0119182 1120269.15

57 Ummay Bagum Husband. Shan Miah Same cheque

58 Morjina Bagum Husband. Jaker Hossin Same cheque

59 Folasha Bagum Husband.late Eyaz Uddin Same cheque

A.2.7 Mouza Name: Cirpothi

Sl. No Name of AP

Husband / Father Name Plot No.

Type of Loss

QuantityofLossinDc./trees Cheque No

CCl Amount

Remarks

1 Md. Abad Ali Late Abdur Rohman 25 Nall 15 0119350 111375

A.2.8 Mouza Name: Edbardi

SL. No

Name of AP


Plot No Type of Loss Quantity of LossinDc./trees

Cheque No

CCl Amount

Remarks



SL. No

Name of AP


Plot No Type of Loss Quantity of LossinDc./trees

Cheque No

CCl Amount

Remarks

1 Md.Halim surkar Late Gias Uddin Surkar 490 3.5 Nall 0119504 2316225.78

2 parul Begum ,, 519 19 Nall Same cheque

3 Eyasmin ,, 520 6 Nall Same cheque

SL.

No

Name of AP


No.

Type of

Loss

Quantity

of

LossinDc

./trees

Cheque No

CCL

Amount

Remarks

4 parben ,, Same cheque

5 Halana Begum Husband. ,, Same cheque

6 Md.mozammal Late Nurul Islam 38 11.25 Nall 0119533 914299.65

7 Sahalom ,, Same cheque

8 Obaidol hoque ,, Same cheque

9 Mst.Rabia Akter ,, Same cheque

10 Mst.Afia ,, Same cheque

11 Safia Begum ,, Same cheque

12 Ayasa ,, Same cheque

13 Md Sahin Bhuya Late Epsz Uddin 518 3.4 Nall 0119555 276321.67

14 Nuzrul Islam Late Tomiz Uddin 470 2 Nall 0119715 1462879.44

486 11 Nall

513 5 Nall

15 Kazi Harun Or

Rashid

Late Mohrum Kazi 1157 13 Nall 0119732 1056524.0

4

16 Tota Miah Late Abdur Razzak 41 16 Nall 0119526 1300337.2

8

17 Hasem Prodan Late Shofur Uddin 76 5.5 Nall 0119764 446990.94



SL.

No

Name of AP


No.

Type of

Loss

Quantity

of

LossinDc

./trees

Cheque No

CCL

Amount

Remarks

18 pear Ali Late Kasham Ali 66 12 Nall 0119572 976252.96

19 Mina Haque Shopor Ali 1157 8.5 Nall 0111733 690804.18

20 Shapar Ali late Shaiz Uddin 66 18 Bari 0119538 3645098.8

2

21 Misir Ali ,, 66 3 Dova ,, ,, Same cheque

22 Jaher Ali ,, ,, ,, Structure 0119731 2462514.1

7

Trees 94594.5

A.2.9 Mouza Name: Kadirdia

Sl.

No

Name of AP


Plot No. Type of

Loss


Cheque No.

CCl Amount

Remarks

1 Md. Rofikul Islam Abdul Batan 324 Nall 18 0021975 799755.72

2 kobir Hossin Late komor uddin buyan 321 Nall 4.5 0119522 201958.51

3 Md. Ba rak Miah ,, Same cheque

4 Abul baten Bhuya Late Billoti Ali 315 Nall 15 0119508 673195.05

5 Sabikurnahar Sima Late Tufazzul Hossin 321 Nall 4.5 0119523 201958.51

6 Farhana Akter ,, Same cheque

7 Tahmina Akter Husband. ,, Same cheque

8 Md.Abul Hossin Late Abdul Malek 305 Nall 7 0111055 314157.69

9 Md. Hanifa Late Abdul Mannan 10 Nall 4.5 0119550 117030.6

2



A.2.10 Mouza Name: Kamaldi

Sl.

No

Name of AP


No

Type of Loss

Quantity of

LossinDc./tr

ees

Cheque

No

CCl Amount

Remarks

1 Renu Akter Late Fazlul Hoque 2051 Null 7.00 0119874 320,706.54

2 Md Abul Hossain Md. Taleb Ali 2060 Null 8.00 0119989 366,521.76

Sl. No Name of AP


Plot No Type of Loss

Quantity of LossinDc./trees


Remarks

3

Md. Sirajul islam

Late Hasen Ali

2060 Null 13.00 0119985

1,201,399.40

2291 Null 6.50

2291 Pond Par&Tree

4.50

2056 Null 1.00 0119840 366,522.76

2160 Null 7.00

4 Nargis Begum Hus. Abu Taher Mullah 2132 Null 28.50 0119891 1,305,733.77

5 Parvin Begum Hus.Babul Hosan Mullah 2040 Null 11.50 0119846 526,875.03

6 Mst Salina Begum Hus. M A Hannan 2162 Null 2.50 0119839 114,538.05

7 Md Al Amin Abdul Baten 2289 Null 4.50 0119872 280,174.95

2289 Viti 4.00

8 Mst Salaha Begum Hus. Md.Sirajul Islam 2162 Null 6.00 0119847 274,891.32

9 Golam Mostafa Hus. Late Riaj Uddin Mullah 2292 Bari & Tress 6.40 0119937 1,383,611.33

10 A.N.M Shifullah Khalid A.N.M Sowkotol Islam 2047 Null 12.50 0119812 572,690.25

11 Md Nobi Hossan Late Mohammad 2211 Null 15.50 0119841 710,135.91

12 Mst Mhamuda Begum Hus. Md. Nobi Hossan 2211 Same cheque



Sl. No Name of AP


Plot No Type of Loss

Quantity of LossinDc./trees


Remarks

13 Md Faruque Hossain Late Anower Hossan Mullah 2132 Null 9.00 0119843 412,336.98

14 Md. Kamal Hossain Late Noumuddin 2211 Null 7.50 0119849 343,614.15

15 Masuda Begum Hus.Nurul Hoque 2283 Chala 5.00 0119858 286,345.12

16 Md. Alauddin Late Kasem Ali 2038 Null 14.00 0119986 641,413.08

17 Md.Humayunkabir sadek Mullah 2064 Pond 16.50 0119995 313,704.27

18 Msuda Hus. Gaffar 2050 Null 16.00 0119958 733,043.52

A.2.11 Mouza Name: laxmipur

Sl.

No

Name of AP Husband / Father Name

Plot No

Type of Loss

QuantityofLossinDc./tree

s

Cheque No

CCl Amount

Remarks

1 Md: Misir ali Late Amin uddin Sorkar 13 Nall 5 0911191 318458.25

2 Na Mouza sir Late Chan Miah 13 Nall 10 0111194 636916.5

3 Md.Abul Kalam Md.Taijuddin 45 Nall 6 0119323 382149.9

4 Md. Sabar ullah Late Ahbad Sorkar 17 Nall 9.25 0111178 589147.76

5 Md. Nuzrul Islam Late Habiz uddin 22

23

Nall Nall

12 6.5

0111125 1178295.52

6 Md.Tajul Islam ,,

7 Md.Rasal ,,

8 M A Ba rak Late Subad Ali 14 Nall 12.25 0111304 780222.71

9 Md.Ismail ,, Same cheque

10 Md.Hozrot Ali ,, Same cheque

11 Md.Ali Azgur ,, Same cheque

12 Mst.Salaha Akter ,, Same cheque



13 Mst.Morowm

Sultana

,, Same cheque

14 Mst Sofura katun ,, Same cheque

15 Mst .Arjuda Akter ,, Same cheque

16 Md. Jounal ,, Same cheque

17 Abdur Rosid MD. Saiad Ali 41 Nall 10 0111166 636916.5

18 Nur Mohammud Late Abdur Rohman 42 Nall 9 0119367 57322485

19 Md: Abu Hanif Md. Omor Ali 29 Nall 5 0119509 318458.25

A.2.12 Mouza Name: Tilchandi

Sl. No

Name of AP


Plot No.

Type of

Loss

Quantity of

Loss in

Dc./trees

Cheque No.

CCl Amount

Remarks

01 Md Jashim Uddin Bhuiyan Late Rohim Uddin Bhuiyan 329 6.5 Nall 0119833 922914.14

02 Rob Miah Shazot Ali 318 12.88 Nall 0119916 1852927.6

305 0.17 Nall

03 Mst. Jahanara Husband-Md Sahabuddin 302 1.25 Nall 0119884 177483.49

04 Md Omar Chan Late Abdur Rahman 327 14 Nall 0119950 1987815.05

05 Md Masum Md Abdul Jolir 316 10.25 Nall 0119856 1455364.6

06 Haffj Md. Abu Said Late Kare Abu Malak 304

3 Nall 0119893 425960.37

07 Ayesa Begum Husband ,, Same cheque

08 Khokan Bhuiyan Late Oyaz Uddin Bhuiyan 301 7.5 Nall 0119900 1384371.2

324 0.0025 Nall

326 2 Nall

09 Md Chan mia Late Sonaly Mia 276 7 Nall 0119984 993907.53



2037 14 Nall 0119988 641413.08

10 Md Ratan Bhuyan Late Oyaz Uddin Bhuiyan 301 6.5 Nall 0119953 1242384.41

324 0.0025 Nall

326 2 Nall

70


B. Summary of the Consultation Meetings

71


Summary of the Consultation Meetings

Dhaka Environmentally Sustainable Water Supply Project (DESWSP) Conducted by DORP

Key Issues of Discussion Participants Responses Project Response

Section-1

▪ Opinion of the participants about impact of the project

▪ Compensation payment procedure

▪ Livelihood activities in the locality

▪ Visible object/things in the locality

▪ Impact on livelihood-based activities due to project intervention

▪ Number of cropping/yielding season in a year in the WIA area

▪ Entitlement for the river eroded affected people

▪ Grievance Redress Mechanism (GRM)

▪ Relocation of APs ▪ Preparation of affected

person (AP) file ▪ Collection of relevant

papers for Additional payment

▪ Special agenda for river eroded affected HHs in section 1.

▪ Rapid awareness build up among the affected people on some basic points

Consultation meetings were held in a cordial atmosphere and each participant took part in discussion spontaneously. Through the consultation process, it was transpired that most of the affected persons were found worried about losing of their land and agriculture-based livelihoods. Affected persons said that they have no sufficiently other land except this one. They said that they would not be able to purchase or replace lost land and properties They also said that the land they lost for the project intervention, they are using it from generation to generation as their only livelihood base. They said, compensation for lost properties must be made to the genuine owners. The Project authority should ensure compensation is paid directly to the affected persons. They informed that current market price of land (per decimal) is very high. Regarding income and livelihood activities affected persons said that agriculture, cattle rearing, poultry rearing fishing, handloom, vocational, day labor and small business are the livelihood activities and opportunities in their locality. Greenery crops are in an abound, the vegetables gardening and cultivation in the homestead and field, the mighty river Meghna and the sight of fishermen fishing and the incessant blowing gentle breeze at the river bank are the main visible and feeling object/things in the WIA. They said, agriculture-based employment will seriously be affected due to implementation of the project. They also said that they cultivate crops three times in a year. The main crops are: Paddy, Jute, Potato, Vegetables, Green-Chili and Tomato etc are grown in their land. However, they have shown positive attitudes

towards project.

Recently during January to June 2018 the following issues were discussedthrough public and consultation meetings:-

• In connection to the entitlement for the river eroded affected HHs several number of meetings were arranged with the affected HHs by PD of the project and by the DORP. In this regard they were advised to submit their papers to DC office for compensation.

• PreparationofAPIDcard: It is to be prepared as soon as possible. In this regard APs are advised to take photographs and submit national ID

The project (Section-01) will take

necessary mitigation measures to

compensate their lost assets in accordance

with ADB’s social safeguard policy. All

kind of technical and administrative support

will be provided to get compensation from

DC office as well as to get resettlement

benefits from DWASA.

As per guidelines of ADB, the DWASA

prepared resettlement plan to restore

livelihood and income of affected persons. All AHs will be compensated for their lost

properties at current market value. The

project will bring more income and

employment opportunity. Affected Persons

will get priority to get employment in project

construction works based on experience

and skill.

DORP will assist APs in lodging complaints

to GRC.

It was clearly discussed with the affected

persons that the project has no provision

for land for land, so, they have to be self-

relocated, and the EA will arrange full

compensation at the current market value

for their lost assets.

For receiving additional payment DWASA

will provide full support with a condition to

submit required documents to DORP

(INGO).

River eroded 19 HHs were advised to submit necessary papers in support of their ownership to DC office for receiving CCL In this regard several public meetings and meetings with DC Narayanganj were arranged by PD of the project. DORP is following up of the matters regularly.

Although PD has advised to keep budget for them in the RP of WIA. Accordingly, budget provision has been kept in the RP section-1 (WIA).

72


card.

• OpeningBankaccount: This is also importanttoreceiveCCLandadditionalPayment.So,APswereadvisedtoopenBankaccount.

• TakingphotographsforIDcard:APswereadvised/informedtocometotheselectiveplacefortakingphotographandDORPwilltakephotographattheirowninitiativeandcost.

• CollectionofcitizenshipcertificatefromUnion/Pouroshavachairman:Itwasdiscussedinthemeetingthatcollectionofcitizenshipcertificateisinevitablleforreceivingadditionalpayment.

• Taxcertificate: Those have taxable income they must collect tax certificate from local tax office. This is also necessary for receiving additional payment.

• Submissionofnecessarypapers: This is strict instruction of PMU that those are eligible for additional payment must produce and submission to DORP (INGO) for additional payment

• GRM:The participants were informed in the meeting about GRM that if they have any complaints regarding compensation, delayed payment and ownership claim they can lodge their complaints to the members of the GRC or to the INGO..

• Self-relocation: The participants opined and expressed their interest that they will be self-relocated with the payment they received..

Section-2

• Project Objectives;

• Resettlement Benefits;

• Compensation (CCL and other, Resettlement Benefits);

• Project Opportunity;

• Relocation and Resettlement etc.

• Grievance Redress Mechanism

• Relocation of APs

• Preparation of affected person (AP) file

• Collection of relevant papers for Additional payment.

• Rapid awareness build up among the affected people on some basic points

Participants expressed their views regarding

project, land acquisition and compensation

etc. They expressed that those, who is going

to lose their lands due to project intervention

would never be able to buy again this kind of

land because the land price is becoming

higher day by day. They are very willing to

give their land subject to proper and fairly

payment of compensation as it is the priority of

the government. Compensation rate is very

much lower than actual market price as they

claim. With this compensation they won’t be able to repurchase their land. They expressed

that they are very worried about their

next/future generations who are losing their

culture & community. They were also, worried

about dropping out their land which is their

livelihood production base. They sought

DORP’s assistance in getting necessary

documents ready for CCL from DC office.

They also drew authority’s attention in preventing broker and middlemen’s intrusion

The affected persons were informed that

the project has already undertaken

necessary mitigating measure to

compensate their lost assets in accordance

with ARIPO 1982 and in compliance with

ADB’s Social Safeguard Policy Statement

2009. The project has designed a livelihood

restoration program to resettle and re-

establish the lives of the affected persons

at least at the pre-project level All kinds of

technical and administrative supports will

be provided to the APs. They will also

provide supports in. getting compensation

from DC office as well as to get other

resettlement benefits from DWASA.


to GRC.

It was clearly discussed with the affected

persons that the project has no provision

for land for land, so, they have to be self-

relocated, and the EA will arrange full

73


into the process of CCL payment and

resettlement Benefits. However, most of the

participants expressed their views in favour of

the project.




will provide full support with condition to

submit required documents.

Section-3

• Project impact (negative and positive);

• Mitigation procedure;

• Goal and objective of the project;

• Livelihood and Income Restoration Program (LIRP);

• Environmental impact

• Entitlements



In the meeting different group/strata of people in the community were present.

The resources and speakers of the meetings expressed detail on project description and its objectives in the way that in mega city of Dhaka, here lives an uncounted number of populations, in order to meet up with the present insufficient water supply and increasing demand for it, the DWASA through the DESWSP has been taken to provide treated water to Dhaka city dwellers through DWASA distribution system.

It was discussed about negative and positive side of the implementation of the project. Ensuring pure drinking water for the city dwellers will ensure in protecting water borne diseases.

Those who are residing in Dhaka, in some way they are the relatives of ours. So, it is our moral obligation to support them in ensuring pure drinking water for them.

The project will extract surface water from the River Meghna at Shomvupura Mouza of Arihazar Upazila where a reservoir will be constructed. This surface water will be delivered through 22 km pipeline to the Water Treatment Plant at Gandharbpur in Rupganj Upazila. The treated water will then be delivered through 13 km pipeline to the distribution network of Dhaka city near US Embassy in Baridhara. This project aims to reduce abstraction of ground water by 150 million liter per day (MLD).

It was added in the meeting that due to implementation of the project the affected persons will be entitled to receive compensation for their losses. In addition, the affected persons will be provided income generating training and will be involved with the income generating activities, so the standard of their lives does not deteriorate from the pre project level.

In 1980, population of Dhaka city was quite a few in numbers, and now the numbers increased incredibly at an enormous size. With the increase of number of population in Dhaka city the demand of pure drinking water has been increased accordingly. He added that ensuring pure drinking water for the city dwellers will ensure in protecting water borne

Due to implementation of the project the

affected persons will be entitled to receive

compensation for their losses. In addition,

the affected persons will be provided

income generating training and will be

involved with the income generating

activities, so that the standard of their lives

does not deteriorate from the pre-project

level.

It was mentioned in the meetings that the

affected persons will be compensated fairly

whatever they lost. According to ADB Safe

Guard Policy Statement (SPS) 2009 All

types of affected persons (irrespective titled

or non-titled) will receive resettlement

benefits for loss assets such as: land,

trees, residential structures, business

structures etc. MDSC will guide and DORP

will assist them in all respects for easy and

tranquil payment for the APs. It was also

assured the PAPs in most of the meetings

that they will get fair resettlement benefits.

The business man, employees of the

business will receive benefit of income loss

from business and employees/workers will

receive grant for wage loss. Tenant, will

receive their due resettlement benefits. In

addition of the above benefits vulnerable

HHs and HHs those fully loss of

agriculture-based livelihoods will be entitled

to receive some other grants like for

vulnerable HHs they will receive

subsistence allowance and one-time

training grant. The vulnerable HHs and

HHs fully loss of their agriculture-based

livelihoods will be resettled by involving

them in income generating activities.

In this regard DORP and MDSC will assist

them. These are the project’s commitment to the PAPs. It was also discussed in the

meeting that by no means the life standard

of the affected persons, especially of the

poor (as they maintained before the pre-

project time) would not be aggravated,

rather it will be tried to enhance their socio-

74


diseases.

The following issues were elaborately discussed in the meeting 1) objective of the project, 2) Resettlement Activities 3) Implementation of Resettlement Activities. It is our moral obligation to support them in ensuring pure drinking water for them. In the meeting it was mentioned that the affected persons will be compensated fairly whatever they lost according to ADB Safeguard Policy Statement (SPS) 2009 All types of affected persons (irrespective of titled or non-titled) will receive resettlement benefits for lost assets such as: land, trees, residential structures, business structures etc. DORP and MDSC will assist/guide them in all respect for easy and tranquil payment for the APs. The participants were assured that the affected persons will get fair resettlement benefits, the business man, employees of the business will receive benefit of income loss from business and employees/workers will receive grant for wage loss. Tenant, will receive their due resettlement benefits. In addition to the above benefits vulnerable HHs and HHs with full loss of agriculture based livelihoods will be entitled to receive some other grants like for vulnerable HHs they will receive subsistence allowance and one time training grant. They also will be resettled through involving them in income generating activities. She added that in this regard DORP and MDSC will assist them by linking with DC office and DWASA for ensuring their rights in receiving all sorts of eligible benefits. The participants were urged to co-operate the JVC team in verifying the affected persons list and their losses and PVAC team in determining of lost assets value. It was mentioned in the meeting that by no means, the life standard of the affected persons, especially for the poor (as they maintained before the pre project time) would not be aggravated, rather it will be tried to enhance their socio economic condition at a better of condition. It was also discussed about GRM in the meeting that if they have any complaints regarding compensation, delay payment and ownership claim, construction work, Job placement especially for the vulnerable they can lodge their complaints to the members of the GRC or to the INGO. The participants opined and expressed their firm confident that they will be self-relocated with cash compensation they received.

DuringtheperiodofJanuarytoJune 2018 itwasdiscussedthefollowingissuesthroughpublicandconsultationmeetings:-

• PreparationofAPIDcard: It is to be prepared as soon as possible. In this regard APs are advised to take

economic condition at a better of condition.

The executing authority is committed to the

community on the issue of environmental

degradation, the community people as well

as WASA and DORP will be vigilance to

protect in any kind of mishaps and

mischievous on environment, especially

during construction work, he uttered it will

be not permitted in any way depletion or

cause any bad effect on trees and

biodiversity.


to GRC.

As the project has no provision for land for

land for the APs, so, they have to be self-

relocated with the compensation they

receive. The EA will ensure for the APs full




will provide full support subject to

submission of required documents to

DORP without fail.

75


photographs and submit national ID card.

• OpeningBankaccount: This is also important to receive CCL and additional Payment. So, APs were advised to open Bankaccount.

• Taking photographsforID card: Aps were advised/informed to come to the selectiveplacefortakingphotographandDORPwilltakephotographattheirowninitiativeandcost.



• Submissionofnecessarypapers: This is strict instruction of PMU that those are eligible for additional payment must produce and submission to DORP (INGO) for additional payment

• GRM:The participants were informed in the meeting about GRM that if they have any complaints regarding compensation, delay payment and ownership claim they can lodge their complaints to the members of the GRC or to the INGO.

• Self-relocation: The participants opined and expressed their interest that they will be self-relocated

Section-4

• Project impact;

• Compensation;

• LIRP;

• Additional benefits.



• Preparation of affected person (AP) file

• Collection of relevant papers for Additional payment.

• Rapid awareness build up among the affected persons on some basic points

The stakeholders told in the meeting that they are concerned about their business. Beside the agricultural work, most of the people of the area are businessmen, and they are afraid of losing their income from business due to WTP. So, they requested the project authority to provide sufficient compensation to mainstream their livelihood and skill development training, so that they could start alternative livelihood activities. The participants wanted to know about the compensation procedure clearly from the respective authority. They demanded that the concerned authority should provide suitable livelihood opportunities for the affected people and ensure the restoration of their business. They also expected adequate compensation for loss of income and business prior to construction work. It was observed in our consultation that there are two groups of affected people. One group is the businessmen and the other group is cultivating crops in the WTP land without any valid documents. It is revealed that both groups

Due compensation will be paid at the present market price as per ADB safeguard policy. Business owners will receive due compensation for business loss. DWASA made provision for Livelihood and Income Restoration Program in Resettlement Plan to rehabilitate their business. Due compensation will be paid to the temporary job losers.

Most of the AHs will likely to be self-located

within the vicinity where similar

trade/business/agriculture exists. If

compensation payments are below the

market price additional payment will be

made by DWASA.


to GRC.


land, so, they have to be self- relocated

with compensation they receive. The EA

76


demanded compensation as per present law and ADB safeguard policy. However, their attitude towards the project is positive.

From January to June 2018 the following issues were discussed through public and consultationmeetings:-

• PreparationofAPIDcard: It is to be prepared as soon as possible. In this regard APs are advised to take photographs and submit national ID card.

• OpeningBankaccount: This is also important to receive CCL and additional Payment. So, APs were advised to open Bank account.


• CollectionofcitizenshipcertificatefromUnion/Pouroshavachairman:Itwasdiscussedinthemeetingthatcollectioncitizenshipcertificateisinevitablleforreceivingadditionalpayment.

• Taxcertificate: Those, who have taxable income they must collect tax certificate from local tax office. This is also necessary for receiving additional payment.

• Submissionofnecessarypapers: This is strict instruction from PMU that those are eligible for additional payment they must produce and submit to DORP (INGO) for additional payment

• GRM:The participants were informed in the meeting about GRM that if they have any complaints regarding compensation, delay payment and ownership claim they can lodge their complaints to the members of the GRC or to the INGO..


will arrange full compensation at the

current market value for their lost assets.


will provide full support with condition to

submit required documents.

Section-5




• LIRP;



In the meeting it was expressed in detail the project description and its objectives in the way that in mega city of Dhaka, in order to meet up with the present insufficient water supply and increasing demand for it, the DWASA through the DESWSP has been taken to provide treated water to Dhaka city dwellers through DWASA distribution system. The project will extract surface water from the River Meghna at Shomvupura Mouza of Arihazar Upazila where a reservoir will be constructed. This surface water will be delivered through 22 km pipeline to the Water Treatment Plant at Gandharbpur in Rupganj Upazila. The treated water will then be delivered through 13 km pipeline to the









level.



whatever they lost. According to ADB Safe

Guard Policy Statement (SPS) 2009 All

77


distribution network of Dhaka city near US Embassy in Baridhara. This project aims to reduce abstraction of ground water by 150 million liter per day (MLD).

In the meeting it was discussed negative and positive side of the implementation of the project. In the meeting it was briefed that due to implementation of the project the affected persons will be entitled to receive compensation for their losses. In addition, the affected persons will be provided income generating training and will be involved with the income generating activities, so the standard of their lives does not deteriorated from the pre project level.

Discussing about GRC the participants were informed that if they have any complaint regarding payment system, delay payment, regarding survey and Entitlements they can lodge complaint to GRC members and or to the INGO.

It was further added that ensuring pure drinking water for the city dwellers will ensure in protecting water borne diseases. Due to implementation of the project the affected persons will be entitled to receive compensation for their losses. In the meeting the participants expressed their interest that they will be self- relocated with the compensated money The issue of GRM was discussed in almost in all of the consultation meetings.

FromJanuarytoJune 2018 thefollowingissueswerediscussedthroughpublicandconsultationmeetings:-

• PreparationofAPIDcard: It is to be prepared as soon as possible. In this regard APs are advised to take photographs and submit national ID card.

• OpeningBankaccount: This is also important to receive CCL and additional Payment. So, APs were advised to open Bank account.




• Submissionofnecessarypapers: This

types of affected persons (irrespective titled

or non-titled) will receive resettlement



structures etc. For easy and tranquil

payment for the APs DORP and MDSC will

assist them in all respect. It was also


that the affected persons will get fair

resettlement benefits, the business man,

employees of the business will receive

benefit of income loss from business and

employees/workers will receive grant for

wage loss. Tenant, will receive their due

resettlement benefits. In addition of the

above benefits vulnerable HHs and HHs

those fully loss of agriculture-based

livelihoods will be entitled to receive some

other grants like for vulnerable HHs they

will receive subsistence allowance and

one-time training grant. The vulnerable

HHs and HHs fully loss of their agriculture-

based livelihoods will be resettled through

involving them in income generating

activities.










to GRC.


land for the APs, so, they have to be self-

relocated with the compensation they

receive. The EA will ensure for the APs full




will provide full support subject to

submission of required documents to

DORP

.

78


is strict instruction from PMU that those are eligible for additional payment they must produce and submit to DORP (INGO) for additional payment



Section-6




• LIRP;



A total of four (4) consultations meetings held

in the project area.

In commencing of all of the meetings

participants were briefed about negative and

positive side of the implementation of the

project. A brief project description that

ensuring pure drinking water for the city

dwellers will ensure in protecting water borne

diseases. Due to implementation of the project

the affected persons will be entitled to receive

compensation for their losses. DORP will

assist PAPs (titled or non-titled) to collect their

compensation according to Resettlement Law.

A road will be constructed with pipelines which

will facilitate the communication with Dhaka.

The participants were informed in the meeting

about GRM that if they have any complaints

regarding compensation, delay payment and

ownership claim they can lodge their

complaints to the members of the GRC or to

the INGO.

The participants opined and expressed their

interest that they will be self-relocated with the

money compensated.

The vulnerable and HHs fully loss of

agriculture based livelihood will be provided


involved with the income generating activities,

so the standard of their lives does not

deteriorated from the pre project level.

Due to implementation of the project the affected persons will be entitled to receive compensation for their losses. In addition, the vulnerable and HHs with fully loss of agriculture base livelihood affected persons will be provided income generating training and will be involved with the income generating activities, so the standard of their lives does not deteriorated from the pre









level.



whatever they lost. According to ADB

Safeguard Policy Statement (SPS) 2009 All

types of affected persons (irrespective of

titled or non-titled) will receive resettlement



structures etc. For easy and tranquil

payment for the APs DORP and MDSC will

assist them in all respect. It was also


that the affected persons will get fair

resettlement benefits, the business man,

employees of the business will receive

benefit of income loss from business and

employees/workers will receive grant for

wage loss. Tenant, will receive their due

resettlement benefits. In addition of the

above benefits vulnerable HHs and HHs

those fully loss of agriculture-based

livelihoods will be entitled to receive some

other grants like for vulnerable HHs they

will receive subsistence allowance and

one-time training grant. They will also be

resettled by involving them in income

generating activities.





79


project level.

FromJanuarytoJune 2018 thefollowingissueswerediscussedthroughpublicandconsultationmeetings:-








to GRC.


land, so, they have to be self- relocated,

The EA will arrange full compensation at

the current market value for their lost

assets.

The affected persons expressed their

opinion and interest that they will

spontaneously relocated at their own

management.

For receiving additional payment DWASA will provide full support with condition to submit required documents to DORP (INGO).

80


C. Sample Notice for taking Photograph

81


D. AP ID Number Format



DHAKA WATER SUPPLY AND SWERAGE AUTHORITY

Dhaka Environmentally Sustainable Water Supply Project (DESWSP)

Development Organization of the Rural Poor (DORP) 36/2 East Shewrapara, Mirpur, Dhaka-1216

AP ID Card Create Number Formula

District Code Upazila/Thana Code Area Code Section Code Gender Code Loss Category Code # Serial No. (4 Digit)

Cod e

Name of District

Code Name of Upazila

Code Name of

Area Code Section

Cod e

Gender Cod

e Loss Category

1

Narayanganj

1

Araihazar

1 Araihazar

Area

1 Section - 1 1 Male 1 Titled (Land)

#

1

2

3

4

2 Section - 2 2 Female 2 (Uthuli)

2

Rupganj

2

Rupganj Area

3 Section - 3 3 Transgender 3 CPR

4 Section - 4 4 Squatter

5 Section - 5 5 Tenant

2

Dhaka

3

Vatara

6 Section - 6 6 Wage Labor

7 Lease

8 Share Cropper



E. AP ID Card



F. List of Dead APs in WTP

List of dead amongst affected persons

For section 4

Sl No.

Annex Sl. No

Reference No Name of APs Father's /Husband Name Mother's Name Main Occupation Mobile Number

1 14 5112440015 MD. NIZAM UDDIN LATE. SOMSER ALI LATE. AMIRUN NESSA Fisherman 1913795325

2 16 5112440017 ABDUL BAREK LATE. TAIJUDDIN LATE. CHOITUN Business/Contractor 1923836388

3 32 5112440034 MD. RAHAT ALI LATE TARIF ULLAH LATE JITU BIBI House worker/Retired 1755515919

4 58 5112440064 TANSEN LATE. SHOFIULLAH MST. SALMA Service(non-Gob) 1916941986

5 63 5112440069 ABDUR RASHID LATE. RAHMOT ULLAH LATE. MST. SOBIRUN NESA House worker/Retired 1946132380

6 136 5112440149 ABUL HOSSAIN LATE. MD. YEAD ALI LATE RAFJAN BEGUM Agricultural work 1945329479

7 141 5112440154 NASIR UDDIN LATE. OWAJ UDDIN BEPARY KHUDEJA BEGUM Business/contractor 1818472689

8 187 5112440222 NURU MIA LATE PANDAB ALI LATE MOMTAZ BEGUM Pan/Cigarette shop

9 208 5112440252 MD. BOJLUR RAHAMAN LATE. ABDUL AZIZ MOWAJJAM LATE. BANESA BEGUM Electrician 1950553567

10 18 5112440019 ZAMAN PRODHAN LATE. AMIN UDDIN PRODHAN NOJUMUN NEAS Agricultural work 1622351400

11 151 5112440178 SIRAZUL ISLAM LATE. MD. AZIM KHODEJA BEGUM Vegetable shop 1953995407

86


87

G. Meeting Minutes

Projecttitle Dhaka Environmentally Sustainable Water Supply Project (DESWSP) under Dhaka Water Supply and

Sewerage Authority (DWASA)

Subject VisitingDeputyCommissioner’sOfficewithregardtoDecisionregardingRiver-eroded LandOwnership

Location Narayanganj DC Office Date/timeof meeting 08.04.2018 – 3:00 pm to 5:00 pm Projectnumber

346152

Attendees

Name Initials Company/unit/division Initials

Md. Mahmudul Islam MMI PMU, DESWSP, Project Director (PD) Md. Mahmudul Islam

Dr. Rafeza Akter DRA MM MDSC, DESWSP, National Resettlement Expert (NRE)

Dr. Rafeza Akter

Md. Badiul Alam MBA PMU, DESWSP, Assistant Engineer (AE) Md. Badiul Alam

Rabbi Miah RM Narayanganj District, Deputy Commissioner (DC)

Rabbi Miah

Jashim Uddin Haider JUH Narayanganj DC Office, Additional Deputy Commissioner (ADC) (Revenue)

Jashim Uddin Haider

Recorded by Dr. Rafeza Akter, MM MDSC, DESWSP, NRE

Distribution AllAttendees

Team Leader, Deputy Team Leader, International Resettlement Expert and SDGS, MM MDSC, DESWSP

Item Discussion Action

1. The meeting had been scheduled at 3 o’clock but due to DC’s another engagement meeting started late.

-

2. The PD gave a brief description of the project to the DC and ADC (Revenue) alongwithshowingalignmentmapforRPSection1.Hestatedsameasbefore that some affected persons (APs) claimed that they have ownership against fewriver-erodedlandswhichhasbeenrecordedafterDC’snameduringJoint Verification Survey (JVS). As a result, these APs became non-titled for the CCL(CashCompensationunderLaw).According to JVS,alistofriver-eroded claimant land owners has been presented before the DC and ADC as well which had been updated from a consultation meeting that held on 24th March, 2018inWaterIntakeArea.Resolutionofthatmeetingthatpreparedbythe DORP is attached herewith.

-

3. The DC and ADC (Revenue) reviewed the list. They went through that many of claimant affected persons (APs) have porchas and tax payment receipts. Considering all, he suggested DWASA to inform these claimant APs for applying to the DC along with all legal papers they have in favour of their claims. The ADC revenue will conduct a hearing upon their claims. The ADC (revenue) stated that DWASA may represent in the hearing process. If their submitted papers proven as legal, then the DC will repay the CCL to the legal APswhichhehadreceivedasperlandacquisitionnoticeunder7onbehalfof the government owned land.

DWASA, DORP, Claimant APs, DC

Office;

Date not mentioned but as early as

possible

4. After giving decision, the DC concluded the meeting. -

END OFMEETING

88

Date: 09.04.2018

Time:11:00PM

Development Organization of the Rural Poor (DORP)

DhakaEnvironmentallySustainableWaterSupplyProject AreaOffice,Araihajar,Narayanganj

Community Meeting

Name of the Chairperson: Abdul Baten

Place of Meeting: Judge Miah’s Residence, Shomvupura

Subject:

● Discussion on submission of relevant documents to DC office in support of the ownership of the land of river eroded

affected people

● Discussion about Cash Compensation under Law (CCL)

● Discussion about AP ID card and Photograph

● Discussion about the documents of CCL’s photocopy

● Other issues.

1. The meeting was held on 9 April 2018 (Monday) at about 11.00 am.The community meeting was held in Shomvupura

Intake Area organized by Araihajar DORP Area Office.The meeting was chaired by Abdul Baten, the most honorable

person by the community.With the consent of the Chairperson, Area Manager Ms. Nurunnahar Begum gave thanks to

all of the participants in the meeting.The Area Manager said that those who have not yet received the compensation

due to river erosion and due to record their land in the name of Peoples Republic of Bangladesh,they have to submit

all of the papers they belonged in support of their ownership to the DC office (land acquisition section) within three

days. Zoynal Member said that they have been asked to submit the papers within three days but in previous meeting PD

sir mentioned that they have to be submitted miscellaneous case. In reply Ms.Nurunnahar informed that the decision has

been changed.DCoffice wants to verify the papers through arranging hearing,after verifying the papers they will suggest

what do by the river eroded APs. For this reason they have to submit the papers in support of their land ownership

claim to the land acquisition section. DeputyTeam Leader of DESWSP project Jesmin Shahana informed that at present

there is no need to file any miscellaneous case. A hearing will be held to determine the actual owner of the land.After

scrutiny if their ownership is determined they will get the compensation for land.Zoynal member said that if they do not

receive the proper market price of the land,they will not give their land for the project.Abdur Rahman member said that

the market price of the nalll and of Tetia Mouza is assessed asTk.1,07,635 per decimal.But if you giveTk.26,000 per

decimal it will not be acceptable.To acquire the land,actual market price must be paid.Shahin member also mentioned

that,the market price of the nall land of Somvupura Mouzais Tk.5,21,268 per decimal.If any it is paid less amount

than the current market price,then the rate will be not fair and it wil limpact on them negatively.

2.

3. Nurunnahar Begum said that whoever received CCL,they must submit the photocopy of CCLand others paper to

Araihazar DORP Area office.Sothat DORP can process their case for Additional payment.Area manager also

declared in the meeting that tomorrow their photograph will be taken for preparing AP ID card in Shahin member’s

residence.She requests everyone to attend tomorrow at the stipulated venue for photograph taking.

4.

5. The chair listened to all the discussions of the meeting very carefully and expressed his satisfaction for sharing their

opinions to DORP personnel.As there were no other discussions the chair closed the meeting with thanks to everybody

who attended the meeting.

89

Dhaka Environmentally Sustainable Water Supply Project (DESWSP) Dhaka Water Supply and Sewerage Authority (DWASA)

Development Organization of the Rural Poor(DORP)

Meeting minutes on Database Presentation

Subject Meeting Minutes on database presentation and direction on ensuing important activities to be done by DORP,

especially RPfinalization.

Location DESWSP, Conference Room,DWASA

Date 12.04.2018

Time of

meeting 2:00 pm to 5:30 pm

Sl. No

Agenda and discussions Responsibleperson/org

1

Meeting was chaired by the Project Director of DESWSP. In the beginning of the meeting PD thanks to the members of the meeting and begged pardon for being late for an unavoidable issue that had to deal with High Court of Bangladesh. After coming back from the court, he commenced the meeting, he created a nice environment by telling some humorous joke to the audience what he naturally practiced almost in all of the meetings so far held with us. He was actually indicating and remindingtheDORPsomeurgentactivitieswhichtobedoneinanurgent basis.Firstofall,heaskedDORPtofinalizetheRPofsection1,2and 4 as early as possible. For this reason, necessary amendment and incorporation in the RP to be made.

DORP in a short possible time.

2 Then comes the issue of DBO contact in the month of May 2018, before the contact all RP should be prepared and draft to be submitted toPMU. Although,bythistimeDORPhassubmittedfirstDraftRPofsection3and 5 to PMU for comments. It is to be mentioned here that Jean Louise Leterme (International Resettlement Expert of MDSC) has made his comments on RP section 3. Regarding preparation of RP of section 6,in this regard PD advised DORP to construct a frame for section 6 and he gave his commitment to DORP to provide necessary documents (BS AlignmentMap,PlotScheduleetc.)relatedtosection6,possiblythevery meeting date.

Draft of RP section 6 by April 2018 by DORP

and related papers(BS Alignment Map, Plot Schedule etc.) to be provided by PMU on the very meeting date,

3

The Construction work is supposed to be started by October- November 2018, so, before starting construction work in the project area by the contractors, it needs to clear up all types of payment to the APs at least onemonthbeforeconstruction.Inthisregard.PDemphasizedongetting the RP concurrent from ADB, at least of 3 RPs by May 2018. For accelerating the payment. DORP will ensure that necessary papers have been submitted to DC office by the APs. PMU will keepclose connection with LA section of DC office for expedite the payment. DORP staff will make a list of APs received CCL, and HHs, yet to submit papers to DC officeandthenumberoftheaffectedHHsareinpipelinetoreceiveCCL, their status should be updated at daily basis and report to Team Leader DORP. In addition, DORP will complete all process to open Affected Persons (AP) filesand Entitlement Card (EC) for Additional payment by DWASA.

DORP will complete the AP files and EC at priority basis.

90

Sl. No


4

The PD cited an exciting example of a meeting in the Ministry, he said that irrespective of all of the present members including senior most officers of the ministry applauded highly of the DESWSP Project unanimously, every one of the members irrespective positions narrated the high necessity of the project and already they all are well acquainted with the project, so everybody will provide necessary support for the project.

PMU will make the opportunity in real effect.

5 PD reminded DORP to incorporate budget for the river eroded affected people as usual.

DORP will make it effective by coming week.

6

A JVC meeting is needed to organize immediately for approval of the list of affected persons and loss of assets of section-4 (WTA). PDInstructed DORP to request PD to arrange a meeting on next Wednesday (18-04- 2018) at WASABhaban.

DORP will prepare and issue the mail by Monday 16 April2018.

7

PD expressed his dissatisfaction regarding market survey of Araihazar area, He suggested to complete the market survey form in regards to putting signature of the concerned respondent and revised the current market rate of losses in line with the rate determined by PVAC.

DORP by 20 April 2018.

8

PD advised DORP in regards to preserving CCL related papers for easy identification. He pointed out that papers to be preserved mentioningthe Mouza, LA case and DESWSP top of each and every bundle ofpapers.

DORP will maintain accordingly

9

PDadvisedDORPtoprepareandsubmitatimeextensionprayertoPMU with the help of Financial Analyst DORP and Abdus Salam Executive Engineer of Dhaka WASA. The prayer will contain time up to August 2019, with tentative necessary budget andresources.

DORP within this month.

10 He also advised DORP to prepare a work schedule up to December 2018.

DORP by 26 April 2018

11

After discussion on working progress of DORP he requested DORP to presentdatabaseactivitiesofDESWSP,ShimulandRakibjointlypresent the output of the data base system on DESWSP. With some feedback from PMU and MDSC the participants expressed their satisfaction on overall progress of the data basesystem. Ms.RuksanaBegum,Social Development & Gender Specialist of MDSC reminding the missing points that was came in the previouspresentation meeting which to beincorporated.

DORP will incorporate those missing points. It was taken into note in the meeting

12

PD specially pointed out that the database presentation to be presented before the personnel of MLGRDC for their easy understanding how the differentbudgetshasbeendeveloped.Forthisreason,DORPmaygofor givingfewpriorpresentationsbeforegoingtofinalpresentation beforethe personnel of MLGRDC.

DORP will take necessary preparation for dummy and final presentation and let the PMU informed.

91

List of the Participants of the Meeting

Sl. Name Designation/Organization Signature

1. Md. Mahmudul Islam Project Director, DESWSP, DWASA

2. Bahrul Islam Deputy Project Director, DESWSP, DWASA

3. Md Mostafizur Rahman Executive Engineer, DESWSP, DWASA

4. Dr. Rafeza Akter National Resettlement Expert, MM MDSC

5. Ruksana Begum Social Development and Gender Specialist, MM MDSC

6. Jean Louise Leterme International Resettlement Expert, MM MDSC

7. Md. Bodiul Alam Sub-Assistant Engineer,DESWSP, DWASA

8. SM Alamgir Hossain Team Leader, DESWSP, DORP

9. Hemayetuddin Chowdhury IT Consultant, DORP

10. Jesmin Shahana Deputy Team Leader, DESWSP, DORP

11. Md. Rakibul Islam Data Manger, DESWSP, DORP,

92

Record of meeting/discussion

Projecttitle Management Design and Supervision Consultants (MDSC), Dhaka Environmentally Sustainable Water

Supply Project (DESWSP)under Dhaka Water Supply and Sewerage Authority (DWASA)

Subject DiscussiononFinalizingEPIDCardforWTP.

Location MDSC ConferenceRoom

Date 03.02.2018

Timeofmeeting 2:45pmto3:30pm

Projectnumber 346152

Attendees

Name Initials Company/unit/division

All participants of Resettlement Refreshers’ Training (List is attached herewith).

Recorded by Dr. Rafeza Akter, MM MDSC, DESWSP,NRE

Distribution Project Director, Deputy Project Director, DESWSP, DWASA

Team Leader, Deputy Team Leader, International Resettlement Expert and SDGS, MM MDSC, DESWSP

Text Action on

1 In the midst of the training session the PD had discussion with Mr. Alamgir, Team Leader, DORP with regard to AP ID card issue and requested Dr. Rafeza to make a minute of it.

-

2 PDinstructedMr.AlamgirtofinalizeputtingAPIDnumberwiththeendorsementof him. He added that ID Card needs to belaminated.

DORP, by 4.02.2018

3 AfterthatDORPwillservenoticetoAPstodeclaredateoftakingphotographwhich will be produced to PD byMonday.

DORP, by 5.02.2018

4 PD also instructed DORP, Team Leader and Area Manager, Rupganj to take photographinWTPsitebynextSaturday(10thFebruary,2018).Everyday50APs will be called for photographs. By 15th February 2018 photograph taking must be completed. Photograph should be taken in a specific location which would be selected by the DORP. It would be as like as government agency who takes photographs for making National IDCard.

DORP, by 10.02.2018 to 15.02.2018

Attachment: List of Participants

96

Dhaka Environmentally Sustainable Water Supply (DESWSP) Dhaka Water Supply and Sewerage Authority (DWASA)

Development Organization the Rural Poor (DORP)

Meeting minutes on JVC

Subject JVC Meeting on RP Section-4 (WTP) related to the issue of Affected Persons and their los of Assets

listfinalization.

Location DESWSP, Conference Room, DWASA

Date 06.02.2018

Time of meeting 10:00 am to 2:30 pm

Sl. No


1

PD Instructed Team Leader, DESWSP DORP to prepare and finalize the list of affected persons and loss of assets for section- 4 (WTP) to submit to JVC committee for approval.

DORP by 10 February 2018

2

Before submission of affected persons and their loss list to the JVC committee the following files must be submitted to Mr. Zunayed Abu Yasir (Executive Engineer) DESWS Project: -

a. List of affected persons and theirlosses

b. Database ofsection-4

c. Budget ofsection-4


3

In compliance to the decisions made in 3 February 2018 by the PD in the midst of the training. DORP prepared a draft AP ID number and gave it to PD, he made some corrections on it for finalizing and instructed to get the number approved by him.

DORP by 12 February2018

4

Also, in compliance with the decision for serving notice to APs to declaredateoftakingphotographs.InthisregardDORPprepared adraftnoticeinBengaliandsubmittedthattothePDinthe meeting. But Mr. Bahrul Islam, DPD is supposed to give his comments on it for finalization.


of

Record of meeting/discussion 97

Projecttitle Management Design and Supervision Consultants (MDSC), Dhaka Environmentally Sustainable Water Supply

Project (DESWSP)under Dhaka Water Supply and Sewerage Authority (DWASA)

Subject Discussion on Resolving few issues with regard to Vulnerability Criteria, Comments on RP, and Entitlement for

River eroded Land Owners.

Location Project Director’s Room, Project Management Unit (PMU), DESWSP

Date 15.02.2018

Timeofmeeting 3:00 pm to 4:00 pm


Attendees


Saswati G.Belliappa SGB ADB Safeguards Specialist

Dr.Rafeza Akter DRA MM MDSC, DESWSP, National Resettlement Expert (NRE) Md. TofazzalHossain MTH PMU, DESWSP, Safeguard Officer (Social andGender) S M Alamgir Hossain SMAH DESWSP, DORP, TeamLeader

Md.Rakibul Islam MRI DESWSP, DORP, DatabaseManager



Team Leader, Deputy Team Leader, International Resettlement Expert and M&E Expert, MM MDSC, DESWSP

Text Action on

1 Following three issues were discussed with ADB Safeguard Specialist through Skype:

• Vulnerabilitycriteria

• Comments on submitted RP Section1

• Entitlement to the river eroded landowners

• Draft questionnaire for temporaryresettlement

-

of


1.1 It has been decided in the meeting held on 24th January, 2018 that vulnerability criteria will be fixed following Safeguard Policy Statement (SPS) 2009 which has been followed by the Resettlement Framework of this project as well. According to that vulnerable groups include those households are: (i) headed by single man or woman with dependents with low incomes; (ii) headed by old/disabled people without means of livelihood support; (iii) households that fall on or below the poverty line; (iv) households of indigenous population or ethnic minority;(v)persons without title to land with low income; and (v) households of socially marginalized group or caste. However, it was found and shared with her before that some of the women and elderly headed households have substantial incomes much above thepoverty line income who would not be considered as vulnerable households. In the given socio-cultural context of Bangladesh, they may feel embarrassed if offered a grant for the vulnerable. However, in order to avoid subjectivity/judgemental errors in identification of the vulnerable found in a few other projects in the past, ADB Safeguards Specialist opined that APs meeting any of the vulnerability criteria must be made aware of the vulnerability benefits. Should they choose to decline the vulnerability benefits, it needs to be documented as per due procedure..

DORP and PMU during RP finalization as well as

implementation

of


Text Action on

1.2 Dr. Rafeza wanted ADB Safeguard specialist to make comments on RP section 1 and 4 that submitted by the PMU on 12th February 2018 so as to DORP can improve RP for Section 1 accordingly. But Stated that ADB Safeguards Specialist will take time to review the RPs since these fall under category A. ADB Safeguards Specialist also suggested to submit RP section 2 by next week.

DORP by 25th February, 2018

1.3 ADB Safeguards Specialist suggested that the owners of the river eroded land be paid compensation prescribed by the Property Valuation Advisory Committee to expedite the process.

DORP, DWASA

1.4 During previous meeting mentioned above ADB Safeguard specialist wanted to share a draft questionnaire for socioeconomic survey for the temporary resettlement.

ADB Safeguards specialist by 15th

February, 2018

of


Projecttitle Management Design and Supervision Consultants (MDSC), Dhaka Environmentally Sustainable Water Supply Project

(DESWSP)under Dhaka Water Supply and Sewerage Authority(DWASA)

Subject Visiting Deputy Commissioner’sOffice

Location Narayanganj

Date 25.02.2018



Attendees


Md.MahmudulIslam MMI PMU, DESWSP, Project Director(PD)

Dr.RafezaAkter DRA MM MDSC, DESWSP, National Resettlement Expert (NRE)

Md.BadiulAlam MBA PMU, DESWSP, Assistant Engineer(AE)

Ms.SarwatMehjabin MSM Land Acquisition (LA) Section, Office of the Deputy Commissioner, Land Acquisition Officer(LAO)

MohammadBelian MB DC Land Acquisition (LA) Section,Surveyor



Team Leader, Deputy Team Leader, International Resettlement Expert and M&E Expert, MM MDSC, DESWSP

Text Action on

1 The PD met Surveyor (Mr. Belian) with regard to Feasibility Study (FS) of the RP (ResettlementPlan)Section3,5and6.BelianinformedPDthatFSisnotpossible now because PMU provided on-paper alignment did not match with tracing cloth alignment. He requested the PD to submit further the right one. Afterwards he will conduct FS and will submit to Central Land Allocation Committee (CLAC) for their endorsement.

PMU by 4th March 2018

2 We met LAO as a courtesy meeting since she joined newly. During this meeting we sought solution to a specific problem raised in the field with regard to river- eroded land ownership. We mentioned that few of the affected persons (APs) inWater Intake Area claimed that they have lands under river which have been eroded a long before. They have legal ownership documents. But according to national law river eroded lands belong to the DC and individual ownership becomesineffective. InthatcasenoonebutDCcouldbeconsideredasAPdespitepreviousAPs’claims. SheaddedthatiftheclaimantAPscouldproducetaxpaymentreceipt(khajna)then she/he will be eligible for gettingCCL.

DORP will disseminate information to the claimant APs as early as possible.

of


Projecttitle Management Design and Supervision Consultants (MDSC), Dhaka Environmentally Sustainable

WaterSupplyProject(DESWSP)underDhakaWaterSupplyandSewerageAuthority(DWASA)

Subject MeetingregardingLandAcquisitionandotherTechnicalIssues.

Location ConferenceRoom,MDSC,DESWSP

Date 04.01.2018

Timeofmeeting 11:30amto1:15pm


Attendees


Md,MahmudulIslam MMI DWASA, DESWSP, Project Director(PD)

Md.BahrulIslam MBI DWASA, DESWSP, Deputy Project Director (DPD)

Md.QuaisarulIslam MQI MM MDSC, DESWSP, Deputy Team Leader(DTL)


RuksanaBegum RB MM MDSC, DESWSP, Social Development and Gender Specialist (SDGS)

ImtiazulHaque IH MM MDSC, DESWSP, Civil Engineer (CE)

Md.HarunurRashid MHR MM MDSC, DESWSP, Civil Engineer (CE)

Md.ZakirHossain MZH MM MDSC, DESWSP, Pipeline Engineer(PE)

Md.AbdusSalam MAS MM MDSC, DESWSP, Financial Management Specialist (FMS)

DipankarBasak DB MM MDSC, DESWSP, Cheif Design Engineer(CDE)



Team Leader, International Resettlement Expert, and Monitoring & Evaluation Expert, MM MDSC, DESWSP

Text Action on

1 PD started meeting emphasizing that ADB review mission would visit on March 2018. PD stressed that some tasks will need to be completed before mission. These are asfollows:

-

1.1 Final RP for Section 2 and 4 must be submitted by Thursday, January 11, 2018.

DORP

1.2 Draft RP for Section 3 will be submitted by 30th January, 2018 DORP

1.3 Draft RP for Section 5 will be submitted by the end of March, 2018 DORP

1.4 Data collection for Section 6 should be started immediately from Monday (9.01.1018) and Draft RP will be submitted by February 28, 2018.

DORP

of


2 ItisdecidedbythePDthatspecialleafletwillbepreparedforMadaniAvenue with clear instruction of not constructing any structure on the land to be acquired.

DORP; as early as possible during January 2018

3 RB informed PD that some of the APs have already received CCL but DORP is yet to conduct any meeting with them to know their planning to investment

DORP; Meeting should be started by

next week.

of 2


Text Action on

for livelihood. PD suggested that DORP should be more active in conducting more meetings with the CCL recipient APs.

4 PD stated that he received the draft AP ID card from the DORP and he has already given one comment. He added that he will inform DORP soon if he has more comments.

PD; as early as possible

5 National Resetlement Expert MDSC informed that DORP’s field staff are procedural lacking behind their expected performance with regard to collect CCL payment data, livelihood investment data, supporting APs in legal documents preparation, etc. Area Manager Arihazer requested PD toensureexternalmonitoringagency(EMA)’sinvolvementbyappointingnew Team Leader for EMA. Natinal Resetlement Expert MDSC also requested PD that EMA should submit QuarterlyReportinsteadofSemi-annualReportsincemonthlyreportingisnot possible as per their terms and conditions. The PD agreed to make itsure.

PD; as early as possible during January 2018

6 PD instructed MQI and RB to submit hard copy of Quarterly Progress Report (QPR) of Gender Action Plan (GAP) to PMU with their initials.

MQI and RB; during submission GAP QPR

7 PD concluded meeting with resettlement team and started meeting with technical team.

-

of



Project (DESWSP) under Dhaka Water Supply and Sewerage Authority (DWASA)

Subject Discussion on Resolving few issues of general Entitlement Matrix in presence of ADB Mission, PD,DESWSP,

MDSCand DORP.

Location Chamber of Akira Matsunaga, ADB, Bangladesh Resident Mission(BRM)

Date 24.01.2018



Attendees


Md. MahmudulIslam MMI PMU, DESWSP, Project Director(PD)

AkiraMatsunaga AM ADB, Urban Development and Water Division, Economist

SaswatiG.Belliappa SGB ADB, Safeguard Specialist

JeanLouisLeterme JLL MM MDSC, DESWSP, International Resettlement Expert (IRE)

Dr.RafezaAkter DRA MM MDSC, DESWSP, National Resettlement Expert(NRE)

S MAlamgirHossain SMAH DESWSP, DORP, TeamLeader

Md.SharifulIslam MSI DESWSP, DORP, ComputerOperator



Team Leader, Deputy Team Leader and M&E Expert, MM MDSC, DESWSP

Text Action on

1 ADB Team Leader welcomed the team. -

2 Three issues mainly have been discussed in this meeting: relocation section of general entitlement matrix, clarification of vulnerable criteria, making decision with regard to vulnerable grant recipient i.e., who will be eligible for getting vulnerable grant; either affected persons (APs) or affected households (AHs).

-

3 ADB Safeguards Specialist stated that original entitlement should be followed in all sections of RPs.

DORP

4 ADB Safeguarda Specialist explained that allowance for relocation will be applicable only for those APs who will be fully displaced physically.

DWASA

5 ADB Safeguards Specialistal told that vulnerable criteria would be considered following SPS which has been done in Resettlement Framework (RF). ADB Social

Safeguard Specialistal suggested to follow the vulnerable criteria that mentioned in the RF.

DORP, DWASA

of


6 At the meeting, held on 3rdDecember,2017,one issue was pending to be resolved - that who will be entitled for getting vulnerable grant either the APs or AHs. ADB

Safeguards Specialist took time to study and explain the entitlement matrix provision to be followed. .

DWASA

of


Text Action on

7 TL DORP asked ADB Safeguards Specialist regarding use of the word ‘AP’. It was explained that the RP should not use this term in short form, it should be in full form like affected persons.

DORP will take care during RP preparation

8 ADB Social Safeguard Specialist suggested SMAH to add an annex for listing co-owners of the lost assets of the households after CCL payment done.

DORP as soon as CCL payment done

9 The Mission leader wanted to know about the status of Draft RP submission for Section 3, 5 and 6 because it is necessary to provide the bidders with the draft RP during bidding documents circulation. ADB Safeguards Specialist stated that if socioeconomic survey (SES) is not completed yet, DORP may submit draft RP with 20% SES completed. She also suggested that the area which are yet to be surveyed, estimate of the number of vulnerable will be prepared by projection on the basis of existing data. SMAH informed ADB Safeguards Specialist that DORP completed 100% SES for section 3 and 95% for the rest sections. In that case, TL , DORP will be able to submit these Draft RPs by the end of March 2018.

DORP by end of March 2018

10 Draft RP for package 3.1 and 3.2 by the Project Management Unit (PMU). For temporary resettlement, The ADB safeguard specialist agreed to share the draft questionnaire .

ADB Social Safeguard

Specialist by next week

11 AM instructed the DORP Team Leader to submit RP for Section 2 and 4 by 15th

and 4th February 2018 respectively. DORP by 4th and 15th

February 2018.

12 ADB Safeguard Specialist appreciated the resettlement progress of the project. ADB

Social Safeguard Specialist reteirated that compared to other ADB funded projects, this project is doing very well in terms of resettlement activities, and thanked PD.

-

13 AM concluded the meeting with giving thanks to the team. -

of


Subject DiscussiononDORP’sProgresswithregardtoRPImplementation

Location ConferenceRoom,ProjectManagementUnit(PMU),DESWSP

Date 07.03.2018



Attendees



BaharulIslam BI PMU, DESWSP, Deputy Project Director (DPD)-1

Md. ShafiqurRahman MSR PMU, DESWSP, Deputy Project Director (DPD)-2

Md. zunayed AbuYasir Zunayed PMU, DESWSP, Executive Engineer(XEN)

Md.MustafizurRahman MMR PMU, DESWSP, Executive Engineer (XEN)


Md.QuaisarulIslam MQI MM MDSC, DESWSP, Deputy Team Leader (DTL)


Md.TofazzalHossen MTH PMU, DESWSP, Safeguard Officer (Social andGender)

A H MNouman AHMN DORP, Chief Execuitve Officer (CEO)

S MAlamgirHossain SMAH DESWSP, DORP, TeamLeader

Ms.Shahana MS DORP

Md.IqbalHossain MIH DESWSP, DORP, Area Manager, Rupganj

Ms.NurunnaharBegum MNB DESWSP, DORP, Area Manager, Araihazar

Md.RakibulIslam MRI DESWSP, DORP, DataManager



Team Leader, International Resettlement Expert, Social Development and Gender Specialist and M&E Expert, MM MDSC, DESWSP

Text Action on

1 The PD welcomed the meeting participants. -

2 At the inception the PD, DPD, and XEN wanted to know about the current progress DORP will submit 4 RPs as of DORP and how many months they have remaining. TL DORP stated that they follows: have already submitted two Resettlement Plans (Section 1 and 4) to ADB through Section 2&3 by 15 March PMU. RP Section 2 is ready, only location map with structures’ photos will be added 2018 and will be submitted to PMU by next week. Preliminary draft for RP Section 3 is Section 5 by 31 March 2018 being written. He promised to submit that by 15th March 2018. About 95% socio- Section 6 by 15 April 2018 economic survey has been completed for RP section 5. PD stated that alignment of

RP section 5 and 6 will be changed slightly. However, DORP will submit RP section

5 by the end of March 2018.

of


Text Action on

3 Dr. Rafeza wanted to know about the status of following issues:

• new leaflet preparation anddistribution

• photograph taking for AP ID cardpreparation

• CCL statementpreparation

• preparation of application form for lodging complaints to the Grievance Redress Committee (GRC) for theirgrievances

• structures’ photograph taking in RP Section 2area

• MIS databasepresentation

Mr. Alamgir stated that as decided before two types of leaflets will be prepared; one for section 1 to 5 and another for section 6. Photograph taking has been started in WTP and Intake area. It will be finished in WTP area by 14th March 2018. But in Intake area it will be dependent on disbursing CCL cheques to the APs. With regard to CCL statement he added that up to February 2018 in RP section 1 and 2 areas 86 and 229 APs has received CCL respectively. But NGO could only collect required papers from 13 APs (7 in section 1 and 6 in section 2). So, they are very much lacking behind in making CCL statement. Ms. Nurunnahar told that they are facing problem to collect CCL papers because she heard that Mr. Badiul Alam told the APs that the INGO (DORP) has limited role in implementing RP including additional payment. That’s why APs are seemed to be very much non-cooperative withDORP.InthatcaseDr.RafezasuggestedthatMs.Nurunnaharshouldconduct communitymeetingineachmouzasaccompaniedbyMr.BodiulAlam toclarifytheir role in assisting PMU in RP implementation. The PD agreed with theadvice. Mr. Alamgir told that he will submit application form for GRC in English and Bangla by next week. Photographs taking of structures of RP section 2 have been completed on5th March 2018. DORP will present MIS database before PMU with original data on 27th March 2018.

DORP; leaflet preparation by 18th March 2018

DORP, community meeting as early as possible.

DORP; application form by 15th March 2018

DORP; MIS database presentation on 27th March 2018.

4 The PD asked Mr. Nouman that why he replaced their experienced team staffs of DESWSPforanotherproject.MD DORP Mr Nouman did not agree with tha tstatement.Hetold that he did not take anyone from this project unless PD instructs. PD told him not replace any staff from now on for the months how much remains. Mr. Nouman agreed with him. Dr. Rafeza told Mr. Nouman that if he could promise that in future he would not replace staffs then MDSC could give training to the field staff. Mr. Nouman assured that he would not replacefurther.

MDSC will impart training to DORP field staff on Resettlement by April 2018.

5 The PD concluded the meeting -

of 1




Subject Discussion on Possible Compensation Payment that could be made to the River-eroded Land Owners within the

purview of ARIPO,1982 and Resettlement Plan (RP).

Location Conference Room, Project Management Unit (PMU), DESWSP.

Date 19.03.2018

Timeofmeeting 10:00 am to1:00 pm


Attendees



Md.BadiulAlam MBA PMU, DESWSP, Sub-Assistant Engineer (SAE)

Md.QuaisarulIslam MQI MM MDSC, DESWSP, Deputy Team Leader(DTL)


S MAlamgirHossain SMAH DESWSP, DORP, Team Leader (TL)



Team Leader, International Resettlement Expert, Social Development and Gender Specialist and M&E Expert, MM MDSC, DESWSP

Text Action on

1 The PD welcomed the meeting participants. -

2 AreaManager,Araihazar,DORPpreparedalistofaffectedpersons(APs),whohave river-eroded lands She prepared the list following award book and joint verification survey (JVS) data that provided by the DC office. The PD and Mr. Badiul Alam checked with the land acquisition (LA map) and opined that list isvalid.

-

3 It is discussed in the meeting that according to award book the plots belong to DC but during field visit of ADB mission it was claimed by the APs that they have ownership right since they have legal papers against those. In this circumstances ADB suggested to include a resolution in the RP with regard to them. They

requested to provide specific information including the details of resolution either through DC or the Property Valuation Advisory Committee (PVAC) should be added to the RP.To ensure their suggestions it is decided to have a consultation meeting with those APs to find out a solution to their problems.

DORP will arrange meeting with the APs on 24.03.2018.

of 1


4 To verify the ownership, the Area Manager has been requested by the PD over phone to inform the APs to bring their legal papers with one set of photocopies as evidence of ownership.

APs during meeting on 24.03.2018 to submit to PD office.

5 In addition to land issue,Dr.Rafeza informed the PD that DORP’s field officials under DESWSP need to be imparted training with regard to resettlement and gender issues. The PD agreed with her proposal and asked to arrange training on the first week of April2018.

MDSC, first week of April 2018.

5 The PD concluded the meeting -

of 1




Subject Visiting Deputy Commissioner’s Office with regard to Decision regarding River-eroded Land Ownership

Location Narayanganj DCOffice

Date 25.03.2018



Attendees


Md.MahmudulIslam MMI PMU, DESWSP, Project Director(PD)



RabbiMiah RM Narayanganj District, Deputy Commissioner(DC)

MohammadBelian MB Narayanganj DC Office, Land Acquisition (LA) Section,Surveyor



Team Leader, Deputy Team Leader, and International Resettlement Expert MM MDSC, DESWSP

Text Action on

1 The PD met Surveyor (Mr. Belian) with regard to Feasibility Study (FS) of the RP (ResettlementPlan) Section3,5and6. Mr BelianinformedPDthatheistryingtofixthedatefor FS on Thursday (29.03.2018) if possible. Then PD asked Mr. Belian to provide with the photocopiesofpaidCCLchequesandotherlegalpaperstomakeCCLstatement.Heagreed to assistPD.

PMU will collect CCL documents by next week.

2 Then we went for meeting Land Acquisition Officer(LAO) to update her regarding river-eroded land issue as she stated during last meeting on 26th February 2018 that if the APs of Water IntakeArea(whoclaimedthattheyarethelegalownersoftheland)havetaxpaymentreceipt againstsuchlandsDCofficewillconsiderCCLpaymenttothem.Withregardtothisameeting had been arranged with those APs and found that most of those APs have such receipts as well as porcha but according to Joint Verification Survey (JVS) those lands belong to the government of Bangladesh through Deputy Commissioner (DC). As a result, those APs did not receive DC’s land acquisition notice under section 7 for compensation. Under this circumstance the project executing authority gets stuck to further progress of acquisition processbecauseADBisverymuchconcernedregardingsolutiontothoseclaimants.Butshe (LAO) was absent due to attending mobilecourt.

-

of 1


3 In absence of LAO, we met Deputy Commissioner (DC) though it was unscheduled he gave us time and listen to our issues regarding ownership dispute between government and the APs. The DC stated that he needed to discuss his officers before making any decision and needed to review existing law as well. He suggested us to make an appointment and sit with them in view of sorting out the problems.

PMU will set meeting withDC

as early as possible.

114

H. Field Visit Report

Field Visit Report

To The Team Leader,MDSC

From Dr.RafezaAkter,NationalResettlementExpertMDSC

Subject ToattendconsultationmeetingwithEntitledPersons(EPs)ofRPSection-1

atAraihazarunderLACase3.

Date 20th January,2018

● We attended meeting in the courtyard of Mr.Shaheen Member of Shamvupura village,

Shamvupuramouza,Bishnondiunion,Araihazar upazila under RP section-1.This meeting has been conducted

exclusively with the affected persons(APs)who are yet to receive the CCL (Cash Compensation under

Law).There 13nos.of APsattended the meeting.The Project Director (PD) was present as well to hear them.

● Objectives of the visit were to know the reason from the APs for not getting CCLpayments.

● It came to light from the discussion that about 65% APs of the RP Section 1 have already received

CCL.There13 APs were consulted during this visit.Details are given in the matrix below:

Sl. No .

EP Name Father/Husband’s Name

RS Plot No.

Quantity of Acquired Land (in decimal)

Type of Acqui red Land

Reason for not receiving CCL Payment

1 Zameer Ali Late Mokarom 113 7 Nall Now submitted required Ali legal papers for getting CCL. The land has been distributed amongst inheritors verbally and he has been occupying possession of the land though he did not prepare legal document of ownership. That’s why DC office issued CCL notice including his previousco- owners. But in the meantime, he madelegal paper ready and submitted all required legal documents to the DC office. But co-owners filed objection to the DC office and payment is delayed accordingly. Shaheen Member took the responsibility to solve the problem socially by discussing his co-owners.

2 Billal Late Saju Miah 132 14 Nall His brother, co-owner of the Hossain land lives in abroad. Though he authorized Billal to withdraw the CCL but its taking time. Mr. Bodiul on behalf of DWASA will take care this issue soon.

115

3 Chan Miah Late Abdul Khalek

743 2 Nall Formalities done, will get CCL by next week.

116

4 Zobed Ali Late Korom Ali 748 19 River Due to river erosion, type of land and ownership has been changed as per govt. rule. But the previous owner claims the land as well. They havebeen suggested by the PD to file mis-case.

749 19 River

5 Sufiya Khatun

Late Joj Miah 99 10.50 Nall Submitted legal papers through his brother and hoping for getting soon. 104 7 Nall

6 Shahidullah Late Rajab Ali 136 11 Chala Formalities done, will get CCL by next week

7 Moksed Ali Late Daroga Ali 127 26 Chala He took lot of time to process his required papers ready for CCL. However, submitted already and waitingfor cheque.

8 Shohor Ali Late Abdul Majid

108 28 Nall Submitted required legal documents to the DC office but co-owners filed objection to the DC office and payment is delayed accordingly.

Abdul Mannan

9 Kulsum H. Rabiullah - 17 nall Formalities done, will get CCL by next week.

9 Mizan Late Saher Ali 750 34 river Duetorivererosion,typeof land and ownership has been changed as per govt. rule. But the previous owner claims the land as well. They have been suggested to filemis-case by the PD.

10 Md. Joj Miah Late Abdul Malek

748 19 river Ditto

11 Amanullah Late Badshah Miah

751 70 river Ditto

12 Hafizuddin Mafizuddin

13 Mia Hossain Late Shaher Ali 750 34 river Ditto

●

● Mr.Jean Louis found that during the meeting the role played or assistance by the DORP was found very limited

as they did not assist any of the APs to explain their difficulties in getting payment.

● The representative from the UP have most of the detailed information of the APs and very much involved in

assisting APs in getting CCL.

Recommendations:

● Area Manager, Araihazar has been instructed to visit each AP’s household and give them support in getting

CCL.

Attachments

1. Photos of the meeting with Affected Persons (APs)

117

Photos of Consultation Meeting with APs

118

Field Visit Report

To The Team Leader,MDSC

From Dr.RafezaAkter,NationalResettlementExpertMDSC

Subject ToattendconsultationmeetingwithClaimantEntitledPersons(EPs)of River-

erodedlandsunderRPSection-1atAraihazarunderLACase3.

Date 24th March,2018

● We attended meeting in the courtyard of Ms.Sufiyan of Shamvupura village,Shamvupura

mouza,Bishnondiunion,Araihazar upazila under RP section-1.This meeting has been conducted exclusively

with the affected persons(APs) who claimed that they have the legal ownership of the river-eroded lands under

Meghna River.Numbers of the AP participants in the meeting were30.

● Objectives of the visit were to know the status of having legal papers of ownership of the river- eroded lands

under Meghna.It was found out during field visit in January that few of the entitled persons (EPs) in Water

Intake Area claimed that they have lands under river which have been eroded a long before. They have

legal ownership documents. But according to national law river eroded lands belong to the DC and

individual ownership becomes ineffective. In that case no one but DC could be considered as AP despite

previous APs’claims.She added that if the claimant APs could produce tax payment receipt (khajna) then

she/ he will be eligible for getting CCL. With regard to this a meeting had been arranged to verify the reality

of ownership.

Findings of the meetings are summarized below:

1.NameoftheChairperson

presideoverthemeeting

Md.MahmudulIslam,ProjectDirector(PD),Dhaka

EnvironmentallySustainableWaterSupplyProject, DWASA

2. Greeting speech was Today,on24March2018(Saturday)atabout9.30ama

meetingwasheldatShamvupuraWaterIntakeArea(in

Section-1).Inthemeetingthereprimarystakeholders

(theClaimantriver-erodedlandowners),andsecondary

stakeholders,personnelfromDWASA,ThePD(DESWSP)

himself,ExecutiveEngineer,ZunayedAbuYasir,Sub-Assistant

Engineer, Mr. Badiul Alam, National Resettlement Expert

(MDSC), personnel from DORP (INGO), Elites and local

community people were present. The meeting was

coordinated by Nurun Nahar, Area Manager DORP,

Araihazar.The meeting was chaired by Md.

Mahmudul Islam.The chair of the meeting expressed

his gratitude to

participants for being present in the meeting.

made by Md. Mahmudul

Islam, PD, Dhaka

Environmentally

Sustainable Water Supply

Project (DESWSP), WASA

Mainly he shared the

benefits entitled for the

river eroded affected

people and checked their

papers in support of

ownership claim.

3. Following agenda was In a befitting manner PD asked the river eroded affected

discussedinthemeeting:- Persons to submit their necessary papers in support of

a. Discussion and checking Their ownership claims.It was observed in the meeting

on ownership papers; That very few could submit full set of papers in support of

b. Updated land tax Their ownershipclaim. Most of them could not submit

receipt; Current land tax receipt and land record documents in

119

c.landownershipasperRS favour of their ownership.Very few have RS record from

record; Local land office.Unfortunately,few have no papers at all.

120

d. Filing Miscellaneous Against their claim.But the affected people assured PD

case to AC land office in that with the help of UP members they will be able to

establishing land submit the required documents within very short time.

Ownership They also mentioned that the river eroded land is still

e.Additionalbenefitsfrom under their custody and use.In narrating the use pattern

DWASA of the land, they expressed in the meeting that they cultivate some lands,especially in the dry season and grow crops there,inspite of it,mostly they used the

land under water under their catchment in under special arrangement(settingkathha)for their livelihoods.From listening to them carefully and patiently, the PD

assured Them that he would visit DC office for discussing the

issue With DCNarayangnj as well as with land

acquisition(LA) Section what PMU could do for them.He mentioned

that none of us have right to go beyond the existing govt.

law, if law permit he will do everything at the best of their effort as admissible by the law. PD forecasted that as the land has been recorded in

the Name of Bangladesh govt.and DC Narayanganj is

the custodian of the land,moreover,notice under section-

7 Has been issued in the name of Bangladesh govt.and

has been classified as river eroded,possibility of receiving compensation from Dc office in fact will be difficult.In This situation additional payment can be made to

them on ground of tilling for crops and fish

cultivation/catching.In regards to DC’s compensation they may file miscellaneous case to AC land office. A list of claimant river-eroded landowners with the

name of their submitted legal papers is attached herewith.

4. Summing up the She reiterated the things discussed by the PD and

findings, question-answer committedtotherivererodedlandaffectedpeoplethat

and reminding role of WASA,DORPandMDSCisandwillbealwayswiththem

NGO’s in resettlement tosupportandassistthemtoreceiveadditionalpayment fromDWASA.TogetherwithPDshealsocheckedand collectednecessarypapersfromtherivererodedaffected people. She mentioned and addressed the meeting

participantswerepresentinthemeetingthatobviously

WASA cannot go beyond the existing govt. law and entitlement matrix, Shahin Member asked her regarding

121

thepriceofcropsperdecimaltobepaidbyDWASA.In reply to his question Dr. Rafeza told that the priceof crops/decimalisBDT650.ShahinMemberreactedand toldthatthepriceofstandingcropsisverylowthanthe actualcurrentmarketprice.Dr.Rafezaalsorequestedthe river eroded land affected people as well as to the

communitypeopletocooperateDORPinanymatters arisesoutinimplementationofresettlementplan.She

122

told the participants that DORP has been engaged and

assigned to support the APs.

5.Concludingremarksin

themeeting

PD,the chair of the meeting listened to all the discussions related to river eroded affected people very carefully and expressed his satisfaction for sharing their opinions and expectations to WASA and DORP.He requested them to cooperate DORP in all respects, because as they knew that DORP has been assigned to assist them in regardsto implementation of resettlement plan smoothly.If theydo not cooperate DORP, it will be difficult for DWASAto make arrangements in receiving additional grant by DWASAtothem.He strongly urged them to provide the necessary documents of those already CCL has been given with a view to open AP files. Unless they provide the documents immediately their next step i.e. payment will be delayed. On this point he is hopeful and positive that the affected people will cooperate spontaneously. As there were no other discussions, the chair closed the meeting with thanks to everybody who attended in themeeting.

Status of Ownership and Legal PapersShown in the Meeting by

the APs*

Refere

nce

Numb

er

List of

River

erode

d

Affect

ed

Perso

ns

accor

ding to JVC

Fathe

r’s/ husba

nd’s name

accor

ding

to JVC

Occup

ation

Name

of

Mouza

RS

Kha

tian

Nu

mbe

r

RS

Plot

Nu

mbe

r

Tot

al

Lan

d in

the

plot

Am

oun

t of

acq

uire

d

land

Class

ificat

ion

of

land

acco

rding

to

land

recor d

Pres

ent

land

statu

s

accor

ding

to

JVC

Owner

ship

accordi

ng to

Award

book

Date

of

river

erosio

n

Remark/P

apers had

by the

Claimants

41110

10024

Shadi

ullah

and

other

s

Late,

Afilud

din

Agricul

ture

based

activiti

es

Shamv

upura

36 528 0.2

300

0.23

00

Nall River Deputy

Commis

sioner

Naraya

nganj

on

behalf

of the

Banglad

esh Govt.

Gradu

ally

from

July

2001

Now

under

cultivatio

n.

RS

Porcha.

No tax

receipt

41110 Abul Late, Cloth Shamv 36 543 0.2 0.20 Nall River Do Do Bed

1002 Hase Abdul Busine upura 200 00 raised.

m and Karim ss

other

s Claimant

but no

legal

documen

123

ts could

produce.

41110

10064

Zamir

Ali

and

other s

Late,

Sham

serAli

Agricul

ture

based

activiti es

Shamv

upura

36 530 0.1

000

0.10

00

Nall River Do Do RS

Porcha.

No tax

receipt

-- No

name

in JVC list

No

name

inJVC list

- Shamv

upura

58 531 0.1

300

0.13

00

Sand

y

River Do Do

41110 Minn Late, Agricul Shamv 36 529 0.0 0.09 Nall River Do Do RS

10053 at Ali Sham ture upura 36 542 900 00 Nall River Porcha.

and ser Ali based 36 544 0.1 0.12 Nall River

other

s activiti

es

36 545 200

0.1

000

00

0.05

00

Nall River Notax receipt

0.1 0.02

100 00

41110

10004

Md

Abdur

Rahm

an

Late,

Kalai

Busine

ss

Shamv

upura

58

141

128

140

141

532

552

553

554

535

0.4

400

0.0

800

0.2

700

0.2

900

0.1 400

0.44

00

0.08

00

0.25

00

0.04

00

0.14 00

Sand

y

Nall

Nall

Nall

Nall

River

River

River

River

River

Do

Do

RS Porcha

+ tax

receipt

-- No

name

inJVC list

No

name

inJVC list

- Shamv

upura

1 533 0.7

200

0.62

00

Sand

y

River Do Do Tax

receipt

41110

10003

Md

Hosse

n

Miah

and

other s

Late,

Mizan

ur

Rahm

an

Cloth

busine

ss

Shamv

upura

133 534 0.4

800

0.48

00

Nall River Do Do Tax

receipt

41110 Seraz Abdul Agricul Shamv 36 536 0.0 0.09 Nall River Do Do RS

10052 Miah lah ture upura 900 00 Porcha. based

activiti No tax es receipt

41110 Amir Late, Agricul Shamv 36 537 0.0 0.09 Nall River Do Do RS

10059 Ali Sham ture upura 900 00 Porcha. and ser Ali based

other activiti No tax s es receipt

41110 Raha Late, Agricul Shamv 129 538 0.1 0.16 Nall River Do Do SA

10055 m Ali Yasin ture upura 129 536 600 00 Nall River Porcha.

41110 Chan Ali Do 129 540 0.1 0.12 Nall River

10074 41110

10015

Miah Yousu

f Ali

Do Do

Do

Do

DO

129 541 200 0.2

900

00 0.29

00

Nall River Notax receipt

41110 Abdul Late 0.1 0.11

10070 Kader Raha 100 00

Dulan m Ali

uddin

124

-- No

name

inJVC list

No

name

inJVC list

Shamv

upura

1 569 0.7

200

0.04

00

Nall River Do Do -

41110

10080

Md

Zabed

Ali

and

other s

Late,

Kara

mAli

Agri

Labor

Tetia 85 748

749

0.1

900

0.1

900

0.19

00

0.19

00

Nall

Nall

River

River

Do Do RS Porcha

+ tax

receipt

41110

50081

Miazu

ddin

and

other s

Late,

Saheb

Ali

Agricul

ture

work

Tetia 276 750 0.6

300

0.34

00

Sand

y

River Do Do Tax receipt

41110

10006

Abdul

Baten

and

other s

Late,

Abdul

Karim

Weavi

ng

Tetia 235 751 1.1

100

0.70

00

Sand

y

River Do Do Tax

receipt

All total 11 26 7.3 1

5.31

*Table prepared by Ms. Nurunnahar Begum, Area Manager, Araihazar,DORP

Attachments

1. List of meetingparticipants

2. Photos of themeeting

125

List of Meeting Participants

Sl. Name Organization/Father’s Name Signatur

1. Md. Mahmudul Islam Project Director, DESWSP, DWASA

2. Zunayed Abu Yasir Executive Engineer, DWASA

3. Dr.Rafeza Akter MDSC, NRE

4. Md. Bodiul Alam S. AE/PMU/D-WASA

5. SM Alamgir Hossain Team Leader, DESWSP, DORP

6. Jesmin Shahana DeputyTeamLeader,DESWSP,DORP

7. Md. Rakibul Islam DORP-DM

8. Abdul Baten Late Abdul Karim

9. Abdur Rahman Late Kalai Mia

10 Miaz Uddin Late Shaheb Ali

11 Shahidullah Late Afil Uddin

12 Abdul Kader Late Yasin

13 Monu Mia Late Dolon Uddin

14 Kamal Late Yusuf Ali

15 Rezia Late Chan Mia

16 Abdul Khalek Abdul Kader

17 Joynal Abedin Member Hasan Ali Mollah

18 Hashem Late Abdul Karim

19 Minnat Ali Late Shomsher Ali

20 Shahin Ahmed Abdul Baten

21 Hassan Ali Member Late Mizanur Rahman

22 Md. Ayen Ali Fozar Ali

23 Md. Swapon Mia Hazi Abdur Rahman

24 Abdur Rahim Late Kalai Mia

25 Ahmad Ali Late Mohiuddin

26 Md. Nazmul Late Abdus Sattar

27 Zabed Ali Late Korom Ali

28 Hafiz Uddin Late Mofiz Uddin

29 Shohel Mia Late Abdul Barek

30 Fazol Abdul Kader

128

Photos of the meeting

129

I. Leaflet for RP Sections

I.1 Leaflet for RP Sections for 1, 2, 3, 4 & 5

131

I.2 Leaflet for RP Sections for 6

133

J. Translated GRC Application Form

134

K. Compensation Claim Form for Titleholder

APs

137

L. Compensation Claiming Form for Non-

Titleholder APs

138

M. Compensation Receipt Declaration Form

141

N. ADB Comments-Response Matrix

Sections Project

Locations

Land

acquisition

status

Status of RP

Updates

ADB Comments

(17 December

2018)

MDSC Responses

Section -

1

Water

Intake area

Notice for

payment of

compensatio

n under

section 7

served to all

APs. Out of

the total, 183

APs (or

85%) have

received

CCL.

ADB awaiting

responses to

the comments

provided on

the draft RP

for Section 1.

Any updates on

the status of RP

finalization be

reported in the

next SSMR.

The list of CCL

recipients/EPs

should be revised

to include lacking

information on the

column for cheque

nos. and the

column for CCL

amounts. The

main body of the

report

mentions 183 APs

being

mentioned have

been paid.

However, only 78

cheque

numbers are

reflected.

Required

action: Please

complete these

required cheque

numbers in the

table.

Updates on RP

finalization will be

given in the next

SSSMR as required.

Nos. of cheques are

less because many

co-sharer APs

received their CCL in

one cheque by giving

power of authority to

one of their relatives.

Table edited with

reason explanation is

attached as

Appendix A.

Section -

2

Intake to

Baliapara

(End of

Araihajar)

Notice for

payment of

compensatio

n under

Section 7

served to all

APs. Out of

the 1,178

ADB awaiting

responses to

the comments

provided on

the draft RP

for Section 1.

Any updates on

the status of RP

finalization be

reported in the

next SSMR.

The list of CCL

recipients/EPs

Updates on RP

finalization will be

given in the next

SSSMR as required.

142

Sections Project

Locations

Land

acquisition

status

Status of RP

Updates

ADB Comments

(17 December

2018)

MDSC Responses

affected

households,

315 (or

26.7%) APs

have

received

CCL.

should be revised

to include lacking

information on the

column for cheque

nos. and column

for CCL amounts.

The main body of

the report

mentions that 315

APs have

been paid.

However, only 167

cheque numbers

are reflected.

Required

action: Please

complete these

required cheque

numbers in the

table.

Nos. of cheques are

less because many

co-sharer APs

received their CCL in

one cheque by giving

power of authority to

one of their relatives.

Table edited with

reason explanation is

attached as

Appendix A.

Section 3 Darikhandi

Chak (start

of

Rupganj)

to

Murapara

via

Gandharbp

ur WTP

LA plan has

been

submitted to

the Ministry

of Land

(MoL). DC

office will

conduct field

survey (FS)

for Rupganj.

So, it is yet

to send to

the MoL

Central Land

Acquisition

Committee

(CLAC).

Approval

from CLAC

is yet to be

secured, and

only then

that DC

Likely date of

RP submission

is 1 March

2019.

Noted. To be

followed up in the

next reporting

periods.

Noted for next

reporting period.

143

Sections Project

Locations

Land

acquisition

status

Status of RP

Updates

ADB Comments

(17 December

2018)

MDSC Responses

office will be

able to serve

the notice

under

section 4

(according to

newly

enacted

Acquisition

and

Requisition

of

Immovable

Property Act

2017).

Section 4 Water

Treatment

Plant

DWASA

owned land

ADB

comments to

draft RP

provided to

PMU. PMU to

revise the RP

based on

comments and

submit to ADB

for approval.

Noted. To be

followed up in the

next reporting

period.

Noted for next

reporting period.

Section 5 Rupganj

(West

bank of

Sitalakhya

River) to

Balu River

(East

bank)

LA is yet to

be approved

by CLAC.

Census and

socio-

economic

survey are yet

to be

done. Likely

date of RP

submission is

1st week of

February

2019.

Noted. To be

followed up in the

next reporting

period.

Noted for next

reporting period.

Section 6 Balu River

to Vatara

Baridhara.

LA is yet to

be approved

by CLAC.

Census and

socio-

economic

survey is

ongoing. Likely

date of RP

submission is

1st week of

February

2019.

Noted. To be

followed up in the

next reporting

period.

Noted for next

reporting period.

With regard to Field Monitoring and Site Visit

ADB Comments Responses

It is also noted that Section 3 and Section 5 discuss the field During Jan-Jun 2018, six (6)

144

Sections Project

Locations

Land

acquisition

status

Status of RP

Updates

ADB Comments

(17 December

2018)

MDSC Responses

activities of DORP and status of RP preparation and

implementation. However, no discussion on field monitoring and

site visits undertaken by MDSC and/or PMU during the reporting

period is included.

Required action: Please revise Section 3 and Section 5 to include

discussions and summary of filed monitoring and site visits

undertaken by MDSC and/or PMU during the reporting period.

field visits have been carried

out in RP section 1, 2, 3, 4, 5

and 6 during last 6 months on

DORP’s progress in resettlement activities, to know

CCL payment status, to get

information on river-eroded

land issue, geo-technic

investigation, consultation with

regard to environment and

resettlement), accompanying

ADB mission representatives,

etc. Dates of visits were 13th

and 25th January 2018 (RP

Section 1, 2 and 4), 13th

February 2018 (RP Section 3

and 4), 25th March 2018 (RP

Section 1) and 1st April and 23rd

April 2018 (RP Section 3 and

5). Summary has been given in

the mentioned sections.

With regard to meeting minutes: It is suggested that the minutes of meetings be revised to use the titles or designations of ADB officials, instead of names or initials.



mottmac.com/international-development

ban: dhaka environmentally sustainable water supply project

Documents