disec-migration-needs un details
DESCRIPTION
Historical Roots of Current Migration Trends ................................................................................... 5 Causes and Types of Migration ............................................................................................................ 7 Current Status ...............................................................................................................................22TRANSCRIPT
Introduction ___________________________________________________________________1
Background ___________________________________________________________________2Historical Roots of Current Migration Trends ___________________________________________3
Causes and Types of Migration ________________________________________________________4Economic and Labor Migration _______________________________________________________________4Refugees _________________________________________________________________________________6Forced Migrations ________________________________________________________________________10
Effects of Migration on the Security of Host States ______________________________________12Economic Impact _________________________________________________________________________13Terrorism and Crime ______________________________________________________________________14Perception of a Culture Besieged _____________________________________________________________17
Current Status ________________________________________________________________18Souring Immigration Attitudes and Policy in EU and Australia ____________________________18
The United States, Foreign Policy Shifts, and Migration __________________________________20
Refugee Issues in LDCs _____________________________________________________________21
Bloc Positions _________________________________________________________________23Regional Positions __________________________________________________________________23
Developed States _________________________________________________________________________23Developing States _________________________________________________________________________25
Non-Governmental Organizations ____________________________________________________26
Media Positions ____________________________________________________________________28
Business Positions __________________________________________________________________28
Summary ____________________________________________________________________30
Discussion Questions ___________________________________________________________32
Works Cited __________________________________________________________________33
Works Referenced ____________________________________________________________37
0
Introduction
Migration, the flow of peoples from one state to another, has occurred at unprecedented rates in the 20th Ccentury. . There are currently 170 millionAs of a 2005 United Nations study, there were 191 million international migrants, people that live in a state other than their birthplace, in the world.,1
That total is double what it was in 1970.a number that is believed to have doubled since 1970 . The Second World War and the
subsequent end of colonial rule from Western European imperial powers created a
situation in the world that was conducive to migration. The rich states of Western Europe
had labor shortages that they sought to fill by appealing to citizens of their former
colonies. The main cCauses for migration in the second half of the twentieth c20th
Century, and still today, were economic migrants and refugees seeking asylum in other
statesare often economic, as people leave their homes to seek out economic opportunity. .
Refugee flows are caused by a variety of reasonscan also be involuntary, resulting from
persecution to environmental disasters, and . They tend to occur spontaneously, due to
the unpredictability of natural disasters or political crises. . While states saw potential
security threats caused by migration mainly in the form of economic downturn or
financial crisis, terrorist attacks carried out by migrants in the beginning of the 21st
century Century have put national security at the forefront of migration policy. .
As voluntary migration most often related to economic opportunity, it is not
surprising that people typically move from developing to developed states. When jobs
are not available in least developed states (LDCs), people are often forced to travel to
neighboring or even distant states in search of work. States fall into one of two
categories: the most developed countries (MDCs) and the least developed countries
1 “International Migration and Development,” United Nations. http://www.un.org/esa/population/hldmigration/Text/Migration_factsheet.pdf. Accessed 15 July 2006.
1
(LDCs). While this seems a natural progression of markets – labor supply moving to
locations in which there is ample demand, the process Migration poses many risks to
security for each of these groups. . MDCs Developed countries realize the value of
migrants to increase employment and productionas a cheap supply of labor, offering an
opportunity to bolster an economy dependent upon unskilled workers, which then bolster
the economy. . This economic growth does not come without costs, however, as a
significant influx of people from a given region or ethnic group can considerably alter the
makeup of communities and entire regions. At the same time, however, there is a
growing sense among the general public of these states that migrants pose a risk to their
culture. Migrants are viewed as outsiders, people who possess foreign ideas that do not
coincide with the identity of citizens of a particular state. . National security is also in
dangerput at risk in the contemporary world, where terrorism and battles with non-state
actors have surpassed conventional warfare between states as the primary threat. . In the
past five years, attacks carried out in MDCs developed were done so by terrorists who
migrated to the state for that purpose under the guise of economic or political refugees. .
The natural reaction is to crack down on migration in order to prevent enemies from
entering the country, but economic interests must also be balanced. .
LDCs face challenges due to migration in two different ways, depending upon if
populations are leaving or are
arriving. In cases where people are
emigrating from developing
countries, economies can face a
significant shock as surplus labor
becomes scarce. Economic downturn can lead to internal strife, often resulting in the
instability of the ruling government. Moreover, these states can face a “brain drain,” in
which most of the skilled laborers, those expected to drive a developing economy,
relocate to another state, thereby depriving the state of origin from its economic potential.
There are similar concerns when a significant population of migrants arrives in a
developing country, since there is now an economically depressed population seeking to
Least Developed Countries:A term which refers to the 48 countries and territories which are recognized by the United Nations General Assembly as being among the least developed countries and which are accorded special priority for the purpose of granting assistance.
Source: www.itu.int/osg/spu/intset/whatare/glossary.html
2
supplant traditional workers and to take available jobs at lower wages. The primary issue
LDCs face is the ability to deal with refugee flows. Sudden influxes of refugees mean
tThe state must cope with an increased burden on local economies and government
finances. . Failure to do so can result in resentment and threats to the security and
stability of the state from both the new arrivals and the existing population.
Preventing migration to avoid the potential security risks that accompany the
movement of people is can be an impossible task, both logistically and legallywhen
logistical and legal concerns are considered. . Advances in transportation, media, and the
continued existence of a wealth gap
between states encourage people to
relocate in search of better opportunities. .
Also, oOppressive regimes and warfare
across the planetthroughout the world
force innocent victims to seek refuge in nearby states to avoid persecution or death. .
Legally speaking, the United Nations (UN) does not possess the power to directly change
individual states’ policy on migration, as the organization was founded on the principles
of sovereignty. . Yet while the UN cannot impose policy change on states to better
handle the issue of migration, the issue itself will not disappearit does have the ability to
offer incentives and to work towards developing circumstances in which these population
flows are orderly and safe for both the migrants and the host states. LDCs rely on the UN,
in addition to other states and non-governmental organizations (NGOs), for the aid
necessary to properly handle and care for waves of refugees
.
Migration’s impactThe impact of migration on international security is felt in a
multitude of ways, including the national and economic security of the state. . The policy
dilemma facing the international community is how to effectively protect states from the
potentially harmful effects of migration while simultaneously helping the migrants
themselves, who in many cases are just searching for a better life. . Transforming states
Sovereignty:The principle that the state exercises absolute power over its territory, system of government, and population. Accordingly, the internal authority of the state supersedes that of all other bodies.
Source: www.afsc.org/trade-matters/learn-about/glossary.htm
Guest Worker:A foreign worker who is permitted to enter a country temporarily in order to take a job for which there is shortage of domestic labor.
Source: www-personal.umich.edu/~alandear/glossary/g.html
3
into fortresses closed societies that do not allow for immigration is not feasible, because
migration provides economic benefits to many states. . The humanitarian aspect of
migration, particularly refugee flows, must also be taken into consideration when
contemplating new migration policies. . Refugees move to other states because there is a
better chance of survival. . Yet, at the same time, migrants even political refugees may
pose threats to the national security of the states they enter. . Finding a solution that takes
into account all aspects of migration and strikes an appropriate balance between differing
types of security is the ultimate goalnecessary for the safety and security of states
throughout the world.
Background
Historical Roots of Current Migration Trends
The Second World War devastated Europe and undermined the global economy; .
by By 1945, its the European
population and infrastructure lay in
shambles, resulting . As a result,
there were extremein severe
shortages in labor necessary to
begin the rebuilding process, at a time when there was a surplus of work necessary to
rebuild states throughout the continent. . Simultaneously, Western European states began
the process of decolonizationThe war also resulted in a significant period of
decolonization, as the funding and manpower was no longer available to properly control
territorial possessions, coupled with a push for self-determination. . Citizens of these
former colonies in Africa and Asia moved en masse to the European continentEurope
seeking the vast opportunities offered by their former imperial masters. . Business
interests in Western European states actively recruited this inexpensive,
disposablereplaceable, and vast labor force.2 International migration into Europe after the
war was highly liberalized, emphasized by the recruiting of guest workers. . Problems 2 Goran Rystad, “Immigration History and the Future of International Migration” International Migration Review, Vol. 26, No. 4 (1992): 1171
4
today, however, are rooted in the idea European idea that the migration of foreign
workers would serve as a temporary solutionfact that this labor force was considered to
be temporary in nature, and was expected ultimately to return to its country of origin.. .It
was believed that, once the job of rebuilding these states was accomplished, the migrants
would return home. .When it became clear that migrants intended to stay and settle in
these West European states, segments of the public became xenophobic and racial
tensions grew, culminating in changes to immigration policy reflective of public opinion.
.
Decolonization itself also had major impactsan important impact on migration. .
Colonial powers, when dividing up the continent of Africaestablishing national
boundaries for their former possessions, often disregarded the natural divisions among
the differing peoples of the continentregion. . The political boundaries established when
colonies were being granted independence after the Second World War often cut across
cultural lines and sometimes forced numerous ethnicities to cohabitate within the borders
of a single state.3 Colonial powers sought to abandon these possessions sometimes as
quickly and easily as possible, resulting in a process that seldom took cultural and
regional differences into account. Some states, such as the Ivory CoastCote d’Ivoire,
Tanzania, Zambia and Kenya, benefited from the dissolution of cultural borderswere able
to prosper despite the fact that the newly independent states were made up of diverse
populations.. These states succeeded by emphasizing cooperation among ethnic
communities, and by promoting nationalism over cultural identity, and by defining
oneself by their nationality rather than by their culture.. In other newly born states, such
as Rwanda, Sudan, Angola or Uganda, instead of fostering cooperation, the political
boundaries produced struggles for powerfcaused a power vacuum between among ethnic
groups, and there was no longer a government of authority to maintain the peace.4 The
3 Constance G. Anthony, “Africa’s Refugee Crisis: State Building in Historical Perspective” International Migration Review, Vol. 25, No. 3 (1991): 5874 Ibid 587
5
social inequity and political infighting in these states has been a major notable cause of
the refugee problem in Africa, both past and present. .
Causes and Types of Migration
Economic and Labor Migration
One of the chief primary reasons people decide to leave one state in favor of
another is financial opportunity. . The wealth gapdisparity in wealth between the rich and
the poor creates causes a gap in economic opportunities amongst statespopulations. .
This The resulting migration flow normally occurs from LDCs to MDCsdeveloping to
developed states, as the latter generally offer increased economic opportunity. . Migrants
who move to seek employment fall into one of two categories: the unskilled laborers or
the professionalsand skilled. . The uUnskilled laborers constitute the majority of
emigrants, and new . eEmployment opportunities that typically pay far more than the
migrants would otherwise earn in their homeland await these laborers in the states to
which they migrate, however the decision to move can be expensive. . These
employment opportunities are not without costs or risks, however, The costs of migration
includeincluding travel expenses, administrative costs (ie: passports), and the price of
basic necessities of life such as securing shelter, food, and clothing.5
Most Many migrants of this ilk variety do not carefully weigh the costs and
benefits of such a move, as they see the opportunity for employment in the host country
as far outweighing the economic costs of the journey.; however, there is a basic
underlying expectation in the decision making.6 The ultimate motivator is the potential
for profit in the host country. Migrants expect to find employment, wages that exceed
that which they received in their home state, and an overall higher standard of living. .
One specific case study, done by Russell King and Melanie Knights, examined the
migrant community of Bangladeshis living in Rome, Italy (an MDC).. In their host
countryRome, Bangladeshi immigrants working in the service sector (restaurants & 5 Solomon Barkin, “The Economic Costs and Benefits of International Migration” The Journal of Human Resources, Vol. 2, No. 4. (1967): 503.6 Ibid
6
hotels), an area where many unskilled laborers find employment in developed nations,
were making about approximately USD $12,000 United States dollars (USD) per
monthyear. . Comparatively, Bangladesh is a LDC,is home to one of the world’s lowest
per capitaaverage incomes, as the average citizen earns a mere USD $210 USD per year.7
Even the jobs considered undesirable by the indigenous people of Italy, because of their
miniscule low earnings, pay wages that greatly trump the opportunities available to
migrants in their home state of Bangladesh.
7 Russell King & Melanie Knights, “Bangladeshis in Rome: Migratory Opportunities” in Population Migration and the Changing World Order, ed. W.T.S. Gould and A.M. Findlay, 139-140 (New York: John Wiley & Sons, 1994)
7
For the poor, the
desirability potential of for
migration has increased in
the past couplerecent
decades due to the
continuously widening
income and employment gap
between LDCs and MDCsdeveloping and developed states. . In 1950, the average per
capita income gross domestic product (GDP) (PCI) of low-income countries was USD
$164 per year, and the average for high-income countries was some 23 times higher, ator
USD $3,841.8 More recently, in 2004, the average PCI per capita GDP among low-
income countries was USD $510, while it was a staggering 63 times higher in high-
income countries, at USD $32,040.9
The gap has widened considerably in
the past 50 years, with the poor
remaining poor whilst the rich
became far richer. . Further
increasing the potential for migration
is the wealth of knowledge that mass
media has provided the world. .
Citizens of LDCs are, more than ever
before, aware of the economic
disparities between their home and the developed world.10
8 Lucie Cheng & Philip Q. Yang, “Global Interaction, Global Inequality, and Migration of the Highly Trained to the United States” International Migration Review, Vol. 32, No. 3 (1998): 6349 World Bank, “Key Development Data & Statistics”, The World Bank Group, http://web.worldbank.org/WBSITE/EXTERNAL/DATASTATISTICS/0,,contentMDK:20535285~menuPK:1192694~pagePK:64133150~piPK:64133175~theSitePK:239419,00.html (accessed February 1st 2006)10 W.T.S. Gould and A.M. Findlay, Population Migration and the Changing World Order, (New York: John Wiley & Sons, 1994), 117
Per Capita GDP in Selected Regions Relative to that of the Developed World, 1950-2001
Source: http://www.un.org/esa/policy/wess/index.html
Gross Domestic Product (GDP):Total value of a country's output, income or expenditure produced within the country's physical borders.
Source: www.gftforex.com/resources/glossary.asp
Per capita GDP:a value of how much a person produces in a year. It is calculated by dividing the Gross Domestic Product for a country by the number of people who live there.
Source: www.angliacampus.com/public/sec/geog/gn009/glossary.htm
8
In addition to the economic migrant majority of unskilled laborers and the
unemployed, there is a growing group of professionals moving from LDCs to
MDCsseeking jobs in developed states. . This also includes an increase in students who
look abroad when selecting a university for post-secondary education. . Observed
mMotivations to migrate for professionals are not entirely dissimilar from that of the
unskilled laborers. : Tthey seek better wages, improved living conditions, and similar
monetary goals ; however, these goals are in addition to career opportunities. . Differing
from the typical laborer, professionals seek
opportunities to better their current position or
advance their careers, whether it is via through
promotions, raises, or access to superior
equipment.11 While an obvious boon to the host,
the state sending their professionals abroad
experiences what is termed as a “brain drain.”12 Migration of professionals results in a
loss of very valuable human capital.
Refugees
Migration also occurs in the form of refugees: people escaping persecution and
oppression, fleeing from international or internal wars and conflict, environmental
disasters and degradation, or economic peril. . Refugee movements, or flows, are often
sudden, . potentiallySuch a situation
may catching receiving states off-
guard and unprepared to deal with the
influx of people. . Refugee flows are
typically large in number, further exacerbating the problems caused by lack of
preparation. . This is especially troubling considering where most refugee flows occur.
Contrary to popular belief, the vast majority of refugees do not seek asylum in 11 Lucie Cheng & Philip Q. Yang, “Global Interaction, Global Inequality, and Migration of the Highly Trained to the United States” International Migration Review, Vol. 32, No. 3 (1998): 63512 Ibid
Brain Drain:The emigration of a significant proportion of a country's highly skilled, highly educated professional population, usually to other countries offering better economic and social opportunity (for example, physicians leaving a developing country to practice medicine in a developed country).
Source: www.planetwire.org/glossarylist.php
Refugee:a person who has been forced to leave his/her home and has crossed an international border.
Source: www.doctorswithoutborders.org/education/bol/Glossary.htm
Origins of Major Refugee Populations in 2004Country of Origin1 Countries of Asylum Total
Afghanistan2 Pakistan, Iran, Germany,Netherlands, U.K.
2,084,900
The Sudan Chad, Uganda, Ethiopia, Kenya, DR Congo, Central African Republic
730,600
Burundi Tanzania, DR Congo, Rwanda, South Africa,Canada
485,800
Democratic Republic of Congo
Tanzania, Zambia, Republic of Congo, Burundi, Rwanda
462,200
Somalia Kenya, Yemen, U.K., USA, Djibouti
389,300
Palestine3 Saudi Arabia, Egypt, Iraq, Libya, Algeria
350,600
Vietnam China, Germany, USA, France, Switzerland
349,800
Liberia Guinea, Cote d’Ivoire, Sierra Leone, Ghana, USA
335,500
Iraq Iran, Germany, Netherlands, U.K., Sweden
311,800
Azerbaijan Armenia, Germany, USA, Netherlands
250,500
1. . This table includes UNHCR estimates for nationalities in industrialized countries on the basis of recent refugee arrivals and asylum seeker recognition.2. . This is a UNHCR estimate. . Despite major returns in 2004, the figure for Iran has been revised upwards in the light of a comprehensive registration exercise. . The figure for Pakistan only includes Afghans living in camps, and does not include some 1.9 million Afghans living elsewhere in the country, some of whom may be refugees, who were counted for the first time in a census in early 2005.3. . This figure excludes some 4 million Palestinians who are covered by a separate mandate of the U.N. . Relief and Works Agency for Palestine Refugees in the Near East (UNRWA).
Source: United Nations High Commission on Refugees, “Refugees by Numbers (2005 edition)”, UN, http://www.unhcr.ch/cgi-bin/texis/vtx/basics/opendoc.htm?
9
MDCsdeveloped states, they leave an area of impending danger and travel to neighboring
states for safety. . There were 9.2 million registered refugees still living in other nations
in 2004, however the number of new applicants seeking asylum was only 839,200,
representing a 16 year low.13 The majority of refugee movement in the world occurs
among developing nations, in areas such as Africa, South Asia, and more recently, the
Middle East (see Figures 1.1 and 1.2). . Examples of current recent events causing
refugee flows include armed conflicts in states such as Angola, Burundi, the Sudan, and
Colombia, recent wars in Iraq and Afghanistan; , and natural disasters in South Asia,
specifically the Pakistani
earthquakes and the tsunami
of December 2004.14
Environmental reasons
for migration are not new, but
the severity of the problem has
increased in both number of
people affected and size of the
natural disasters. . Natural
disasters in South Asia,
including the 2004 tsunami in
Southeast Asia and the
earthquakes in Pakistan in
2005, are affecting more
people than ever before
because the region has both a
high population and high
population growth rate. .
13 United Nations High Commission on Refugees, “Refugees by Numbers (2005 edition)”, UN, http://www.unhcr.ch/cgi-bin/texis/vtx/basics/opendoc.htm?tbl=BASICS&id=3b028097c#Refugees14 Council on Foreign Relations, “Global Conflicts Map”, CNN, http://www.cnn.com/interactive/maps/world/fullpage.global.conflict/world.index.html
10
Increased population growth not only creates results in a larger amount of people that
would be displaced by a natural disaster, but also contributes to the degradation of the
environment, as a disorderly flow is taxing a region unprepared for the population
inflow.. .
The larger populations impact the environment because of the increased strain on
the output capability of the land. . Due to these strainseffects, plus along with poor
agricultural and business practices, 11 per cent of Africa’s total land area has been
affected by human-induced soil degradation. , resulting inThe loss of useable soil has, in
turn, impacted the economics of regions throughout Africa. There has been a 25 per cent
drop in the productivity of cropland , due to the soil degradationthroughout much of
Africa.15 Population growth, however, is not the only reason for environmental
degradation. . Environmental degradationThis process normally occurs in LDCs, where
there is less funding to practice environmentally sustainable programs, and less
government ability to enforce regulations that restrict pollution. .
While most environmental factors cause internal displacement internally, there is
a growing sense that international migration is being seen by refugees as a solution to
environmental degradation. . The idea follows the simple logic that if a region has
deteriorated to the point where it cannot
sustain the population inhabiting it, then
the people should relocate and settle into a
new area. . This plan is flawed in the
long-term, however, because refugee flows
are sudden in timing and vast in numbers. .
Makeshift settlements are often established
to provide emergency shelter for the
refugees. . The very creation of large
settlements in other countries, quite
15 “Fact Sheet Desertification: Africa” GTZ CCD Project, http://lada.virtualcentre.org/eims/download.asp?pub_id=93546&v=5
Major Refugee Arrivals in 2004Origin Countries of
AsylumTotal
Sudan Chad , , Uganda , , Kenya
146,900
D.R. Congo Burundi , , Rwanda , , Zambia , , Uganda
38,100
Somalia Yemen , , Kenya 19,100 Iraq Syria 12,000 Côte d'Ivoire Liberia , , Mali 5,900 Burundi Rwanda , ,
Tanzania 4,200
Liberia Sierra Leone , , Côte d'Ivoire , , Guinea
3,700
Central African Republic
Chad 500
Rwanda Malawi , , D.R. Congo
500
11
possibly experiencing environmental problems themselves, will lead to environmental
degradation in the area to which refugees migrated.16 Additionally, migration due to
environmental degradation can also be related to economic issues, as . uUnemployment,
poverty, and increased pressure on available resources tend to be an underlying factor.
.The environmental disruption proves to be the deciding factor when choosing whether to
migrate.17
The primary cause of refugee movements in recent times, though, is armed
conflict. . There are multiple types of such conflict, but two are prominent in today’s
world: inter-state wars and intra-state ethnic conflict. . Inter-state warfare is warfare in
the traditional sense, wherethat in which two states and their respective armies meet in
battle. . In centuries past, armies would meet on a battlefield away from the centers of
population to fight. . The lives of civilians, while affected, were not disrupted in ways
that are comparable to modern times. . Modern warfare, and its highly advanced and
destructive weaponry results in the death of civilians and devastation of the infrastructure
needed for the survival of other civiliansotherwise innocent bystanders, resulting . inThis
is the root of refugee flows. . Afghanistan serves as a prime contemporaryrecent example
of what inter-state warfare can cause, as they have experienced two major wars in the
past 25 yearssince the 1980s. . The first war was the Soviet Union’s invasion in 1979,
and the second the United States’ military action to remove the Taliban in 2001. .
According to the Human Rights Watch, 3.7 million Afghan refugees fled the country to
escape these conflicts in the past 25 years.18 Similarly, refugee flows have stemmed from
the two wars fought in the Persian Gulf, in 1991 and in 2003. . The Persian Gulf War in
of 1991 resulted in the uprooting of between 4 million and 5 million people in the Middle
East in a span of just 12 months.19
16 Graeme Hugo, “Environmental Concerns and International Migration” International Migration Review, Vol. 30, No. 1(1996): 12317 Ibid 11818 Human Rights Watch, “Safe Refuge for Afghan Refugees”, Human Rights Watch. http://www.hrw.org/campaigns/afghanistan/refugees-facts.htm19 Sharon Stanton Russell, “International Migration and Political Turmoil in the Middle East” Population and Development Review, Vol. 18, No. 4 (1992): 721
12
Ethnic conflicts, on the other hand, are fought between internal forces. . Ethnic
conflicts are defined as groups of people of differing religions, ethnicities, languages,
cultures, or tribes waging war on one another
or against the state within the borders of the
country.20 Problems stem from the
government being unable to properly mediate
and manage populations that are divided
deeply along ethnic lines. . In cases where the government is actively agitating the
situation by persecuting a minority group, ethnic violence can break out between the
majority and minority. . For example, in 1983, the Sudanese government instituted
Shari’a law throughout the country. . Shari’a law is the law of Islam, which meant tThe
government was imposing Islamic law onto minority groups that were of other religions. .
Non-Arab Sudanese felt their rights were being threatened by the state and, as a result,
the Second Sudanese Civil War broke out. .
A highly publicized conflict of this type occurred in the past decade, when the
Hutu majority in Rwanda began a campaign of genocide to rid the country of the Tutsi
minority in 1994. . The former colonial ruler of Rwanda was Belgium, and they strongly
supported the superiority of the Tutsi, the minority, over the Hutu, the majority.21 In
1990, President Juvenal Habyarimana and the Hutu-dominated government of Rwanda
utilized existing ethnic tensions to shore upconsolidate support for his regime, which was
in dire straits due tosuffering from a severe economic recession. . Four years later, iIn
1994, the killing began, when President Habyarimana was assassinated upon his plane
was shot down. . His death was blamed on Tutsi rebels, and all Tutsi members of this
tribe were declared enemies of the state. . The former colonial ruler of Rwanda, Belgium
strongly supported the superiority of the Tutsi, the minority, over the Hutu, the majority.22
20 Ibid 10021 Helen M. Hintjens, “Explaining the 1994 Genocide in Rwanda” The Journal of Modern African Studies, Vol. 37, No. 2 (1999): 25022 Helen M. Hintjens, “Explaining the 1994 Genocide in Rwanda” The Journal of Modern African Studies, Vol. 37, No. 2 (1999): 250
Shari’a Law:the code of law derived from the Koran and from the teachings and example of Mohammed; "sharia is only applicable to Muslims"; "under Islamic law there is no separation of church and state"
Source: wordnet.princeton.edu/perl/webwn
13
Between April and May 1994, between 5 per cent to and 10 per cent of Rwanda’s
population was killed, and over more than two million Rwandans fled the country.23
Armed conflict within a state is not always fought because of ethnic tensions. .
Two warring political factions in Colombia, the left-wing Revolutionary Armed Forces of
Colombia (FARC) and the right-wing Auto-Defense Forces of Colombia, have been
waging a bloody battle for control of the government for 41 yearsmore than four decades.
. Colombians have had to abandon their homes to escape the conflict, for each
organization has been targeting civilians believed to be aiding the enemy their opposition.
. Some 250,000 Colombians currently reside in Ecuador, and the number of displaced
Colombians seeking refuge in other states is increasing each year.24
Forced Migrations
Refugee flows are often caused by the government of a state taking an active role
in the removal of its “undesired” citizens, usually ethnic minorities or political dissidents
or opposition. . The policies implemented to force migrations migratory movements
range from merely pressuring groups to leave, to creating conditions that make continued
residence unbearable. . While the former can compel people to leave of their own accord,
the latter often entails the idea of forcible expulsion. . An example of a state
implementing an expulsion policy towards a group of people occurred during the Persian
Gulf War. . The government of Saudi Arabia supported the fight against Iraq, and
expelled one million Yemini Yemeni migrants living in Saudi Arabia, because their home
state supported Iraq in the war.25
The extreme forms of this non-voluntary migration are violence, ethnic conflicts
and, worst of all, genocide. The Tutsis fled Rwanda not because they were living in
conditions that did not afford them equality, but rather because the Hutus undertook a
campaign of mass murder to drive the Tutsis out. Ethnic Albanians in the Kosovo region 23 Ibid 241, 24224 “UN Refugee Agency Official Spotlights Plight of Displaced Colombians”, States News Service, February 3rd, 2006, final edition. Lexis-Nexis.
25 Jeremy Hein, “Refugees, Immigrants, and the State” Annual Review of Sociology, Vol. 19 (1993): 48
14
of Serbia were exposed to the horrors of genocide when President Slobodan Milosevic
undertook the program of “ethnically cleansing” the area of undesirables.
More commonly, though, governments put forth antagonistic policies with the
purpose of threatening minorities and stripping them of their rights, . This is a coercive
way to remove people. . Discriminatory laws can attack a minority’s religion, language,
culture, political viewpoint, restrict free speech and other individual rights, and
essentially regulate relegate them to the status of second-class citizens.26 The goal of
these policies is to create establish an environment of fear and persecution conducive to
driving out a particular group. .
While the goal is to get a minority group out of the country, that is not the
whole story. Removing a minority achieves a cultural uniformity that, in turn, also can
achieves another crucial goal: national security. . Governments feel threatened by
political opposition, no matter the level of strength that the opposition group possesses. .
Fidel Castro, shortly after establishing a new Communist communist regime in Cuba,
ordered the exile of a half million more than 500,000 members of the Cuban middle
class, because middle and upper social classes are seen as enemies of socialism, and are
likely to support ongoing efforts to remove a socialist regime.27 In doing so, Castro
believed he made the environment more secure as revolts would be less likely to happen
when a half million perceived “threats” were removed.. Similarly, the current genocide
in the Darfur region of the Sudan began due to insurgencies insurgents carrying out
attacks on the Sudanese government. . The government, seeing threats to its power,
responded by trying to remove the non-Arabs in Darfur. .
Effects of Migration on the Security of Host States
Security, and threats to it, can take on different forms depending on the area of a
state that is perceived to be at risk. . The conventional definition of security is national
26 Myron Weiner, “Security, Stability, and International Security” International Migration Review, Vol. 17, No.3 (1992): 10027 Ibid 99
15
security. . This type of security can be broken down into three parts. . The first
component of national security, the traditional view, is the ability of the state to militarily
defend itself from external attack.28 The second component is defense against internal
threats, such as ethnic conflicts. . Lastly, national security also encompasses balancing
the demand for resources by the population and with the supply availability of such
resources. .29 A breakdown in the balance, where the population’s demands exceed the
available supplies, can threaten the structural integrity of a government.30
Security is not merely limited to literal physical attacks on the state. . In addition
to national security, there is economic security and cultural securityare concerns over
economic and social concerns. . Protecting the economic security of a state and its
citizens is just as important as shielding them it from acts of war. . The security of
economics is a concern of the state on both the state level and the individual level . : On
on the state level, the extra costs that migration
can bring may place a strain on the
government’s funds and hurt overall economic
performance, whereas . onEqually important is the individual level, where the citizens of
a state can have their economic status threatened by the loss of employment to incoming
foreigners. . Thirdly is the idea of cCultural security, which can greatly influences a
state’s immigration policy and increases the tension between the public existing
populations and the new immigrants. . Xenophobia, the fear of foreign persons or ideas,
can have a profound impact on the way security is seenenvisioned. . The iIndigenous
people of a statepopulations may fear their culture or their identity will slowly disappear
with the infusion of undesired persons and ideas.31 If anti-immigrant attitudes become
28 Karen Jacobsen, “Factors Influencing the Policy Responses of Host Governments to Mass Refugee Influxes” International Migration Review, Vol. 30, No. 3 (1996): 67229 National security concerns have recently been used to support claims that resources such as oil are of significant national concern. States have declared that protection of a free flow of oil represent important national security objectives, as a disruption in supply could cause significant economic damage.30 Ibid31 Ibid 110
Xenophobia:an irrational fear of foreigners or strangers
Source: wordnet.princeton.edu/perl/webwn
16
popular with the public, it can result in violence that would, in turn, threaten national
securityensuing violence can pose a threat to national security. .
Economic Impact
Host states, or states that are on the receiving end of migration, experience both
economic benefits and costs from migrants. . Some of the rewards to the receiving states
are obvious. . For one, the host is on the receiving end of the “brain drain.”; the term for
the migration of professionals and other skilled people from LDCs to MDCs. This then
process adds an educated, skilled group of workers into the state’s economy, and is. This
is beneficial because it is more difficult to fill jobs requiring a higher skill setskilled
workers have a more positive impact on the economy than those with limited abilities. .
In terms of the uUnskilled laborers that migrate, it provides a larger workforce to fulfill
various jobs for which it can be difficult to find employees because the native considers
such positions undesirable populacejobs that are often low-paying, and unattractive to
existing populations. . Another benefit to the host is that the government receiving
receives more revenue in from taxationes. .Additionally, shareholders of companies,
receive larger returns on their capital investments since more workers render the
company more productive,.32
While the advantages are many, migration does not come without costs, The costs
to the host state are numerous both in perception and in realityboth perceived and real. .
Any belief of the existence of threats can cause change in public policy towards
immigration, regardless of whether that threat is real or imaginedrealisitic. . Arguments
put forth about the economic costs of migration include: the belief that unskilled laborers
put unnecessary burdens on the state, the straining of government resources to cope with
refugees, and the fear that acceptance of refugees (or migrants looking for work) will lead
to more asylum applicants, thus thereby aggravating the problem.33
32 Mark Kleinman, “The Economic Impact of Labour Migration” in The Politics of Migration, edited by Sarah Spencer, 61. Oxford: Blackwell Publishing, 2003.33 Myron Weiner, “Security, Stability, and International Security” International Migration Review, Vol. 17, No.3 (1992): 116
17
A popular belief, especially in Western Europe, is that the unskilled, and thereby
undesired, migrants prove to be much too costly to justify their entrance into the state. .
The distinction between skilled and unskilled migrants here is important. . The public
sees the skilled migrant who is working higher-level jobs as a benefit to the economy,
and not a burden, whereas the unskilled migrant is looked down upon as dead weight for
the government. is seen as someone who will require more assistance from the
government than he is able to provide for the economy. The types of costs that unskilled
migrants put on the economy are numerous: , including costs borne by administrative
agencies, investments in infrastructure and housing for immigrants, job training, and
welfare agencies providing assistance to the poor.34 These costs are potentially more
perception than reality; in truth, migrant contributions to the economy through
employment can counteract many of the costs placed on the government. .
The economic impact of refugees is an entirely different problem. . The bulk of
the economic problems stemming from refugee flows occur in LDCsleast developed
countries, with an estimated 80 per cent of people who flee their homes seeking refuge in
other LDCs, similarly economically challenged states.35 Economic capacity is the ability
of the host state to absorb refugees into their country, and it is determined by factors such
as availability of land, employment opportunities, current infrastructure in placeal
limitations, and the land’s capacity to hold peoplesupport additional populations36. . In
LDCs, areas in which refugees tend to settle are already heavily populated and cannot
withstand a large influx of refugees, and the unpopulated areas of LDCs are normally so
because the land is unsuitable for settlement. . Refugees also place strains on medical
and educational services, transportation, infrastructure, available housing and available
jobs. . These stresses can potentially cause strife within the local community.37 On top
ofBeyond the costs to local economies, the government itself often has to provide shelter,
34 Goran Rystad, “Immigration History and the Future of International Migration” International Migration Review, Vol. 26, No. 4 (1992): 118335 William B. Wood, “Forced Migration: Local Conflicts and International Dilemmas” Annals of the Association of American Geographers, Vol. 84, No. 4 (1994): 6236 Karen Jacobsen, “Factors Influencing the Policy Responses of Host Governments to Mass Refugee Influxes” International Migration Review, Vol. 30, No. 3 (1996): 66737 Ibid
18
food, and other supplies for the new arrivals. . Further consider that mMany of the
governments called upon to provide assistance to new arrivals are quite poor and the dire
economic situations prior to the refugee flow become much worse.
Terrorism and Crime
Not all immigrants enter a country to escape poverty, oppression, or environmental
degradation. . As evidenced by recent attacks against the United States, Spain, and
Britainthe United Kingdom, migration has become a means for terrorists and other
transnational criminals to achieve their nefarious goals. . Transnational crime is carried
out by organizations spread across the globe, not individuals acting alone. . Terrorism
involving international migration is also seldom ever one individual acting alone, but
rather organized networks that carefully plan attacks.
Highly organized criminale networks pose multiple threats to international
security. . The ability to bribe, coerce, or use other illegal means to influence public
officials undermines the credibility and legitimacy of a state, in turn . This in turn could
leading to the destabilizing of a country. . If large enough, criminal organizations can
threaten order on an international level. . The worst threat posed to international security
comes about when organized crime takes uses its this ability to use money to influence
the government to the extreme:by funding revolutionary movements to overthrow the
government, thus gaining influence over the entire government if the revolt is
successful.38 With these organizations operating in many states across the world, the
movement of people and goods is necessary. , So so if a state that was deemed important
to these dark organizations was not cooperating, the organization would take steps to
undermine the state’s government in order to gain influence and improve its situation. .
Dark networkThese organizations groups are involved in the trafficking of many
illegal goods across national boundaries, such asincluding weaponry weapons and
humans (for prostitution or illegal migration). . The largest international crime trade,
however, is in drugs. . Production of illegal drugsnarcotics, like cocaine and heroin, is 38 Alan Dupont, “Transnational Crime and Security in East Asia” Asian Survey, Vol. 39., No. 3 (1999): 436
19
focused mainly primarily in East Asia and Latin America. . Drug The drug trade in East
Asia consists of products grown in one nation, such as Burma, manufactured in another,
like the Philippines, and then shipped off to their final destination state for sale,
frequently the United States. . The crossing of multiple national borders has produced
security problems that result from organized crimefor entire regions, and is often difficult
to interrupt. . By gaining more power and money, these illegal traffickers can
“purchase”bribe government officials to allow for easier trade. . For example,
Vietnamese border patrols, responsible for guarding the Vietnam-Laos border, were
arrested when it was that discovered they were working with Laos drug dealers to
facilitate narcotics smuggling across the border.39 The Philippines are is especially
troubled by the influence of organized crime. . In 1997, Philippine Senator Ernesto
Herrera described the current state of Philippine politics: “Drug money is corrupting and
co-opting elements in immigration, customs, the police, and the military. . It has even
penetrated the ranks of court officers and some well-placed officials.”40 The corruption
of state officials by organized crime, through the purchasing of government influence to
facilitate illegal activities, subverts the legitimacy of the government.
Recently, migration has spawned terrorism as a new threat to the security of states.
. The 11 September 11, 2001 terrorist attacks againstin the United States have illustrated
the possibility that international migration can pose a significant military threat. . These
attacks of September 11th were carried out by 19 men, all of whom were foreigners that
had migrated to the United States. . Subsequent attacks in Bali, Indonesia, Madrid, Spain
and London, England have further demonstrated the severe security risks that can stem
from migration. . All These three attacks involved terrorists who where migrants to the
targeted country. .Three of the five men detained in a failed follow-up attack in London
on July 21, 2005 were not born in Britain.41 Links to the terrorist organization al-Qaeda
were found in all of the attacks, meaning the preparation and organization behind
39 Ibid 44740 Ibid41 BBC, “The Suspects”, http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/shared/spl/hi/uk/05/london_blasts/investigation/html/suspects.stm, (accessed February 26th, 2006)
20
terrorism is found across many state lines. .Many charged with involvement in the
bombings in Bali appeared to first organize at a Muslim school in Malaysia, not
Indonesia.42
Compounding the problem in the modern world is the existence of weapons of
mass destruction. While the level of destruction is enormous, the size of the weapon itself
is not necessarily proportionate. If these weapons can be sufficiently concealed,
migration provides an easy, inexpensive way to carry out attacks.43 With modern warfare
being fought not between states and their respective armies, but between states and non-
state actors, terrorism is a prime concern for states.
Perception of a Culture Besieged
The possible dilution or erosion of culture The third majoris a threat to a host
state’s security is muchand is sometimes more perception than reality. . This believed
threat is the possible dilution or erosion of culture. The extreme form of this is known as
xXenophobia, which is defined as the fear of foreign people or ideas. Sometimes called
neo-racism, or differentialist racism, this new breed of discrimination does not
discriminate based on the idea of racial superiority, but . iInstead this bias is “predicated
on the imperative of preserving the group’s identity, whose purity it sanctifies.”44 The
belief is that those who are different and unwanted must be kept out in order to maintain
the purity of the culture. . The culminating theory of this neo-racism is a term French
social scientists coined “seuil de tolerance,” which translates into “the threshold of
tolerance.”45 European states have rejected the integration of migrants into society by
issuing temporary worker permits, rather than citizenship, hoping that migrants will
return to their native homes. . These anti-migrant actions were taken in an attempt to
42 BBC, “The Bali Bombers’ Network of Terror”, http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/asia-pacific/2499193.stm (accessed February 26th, 2006)43 Christopher Rudolph, “Globalization and Security: Migration and Evolving Conceptions of Security in Statecraft and Scholarship” (2002). Columbia International Affairs Online. 44 Roxanne Lynn Doty, “Anti-Immigrantism in Western Democracies” (New York: Taylor & Francis, 2003) 1945 Ibid 66
21
avoid passing crossing the perceived “seuil de tolerance,” after which the integrity of the
culture at large is at risk.
This public belief that their culture is under siege, or that the state’s sovereignty is
in jeopardy, puts pressure on the government to react in accordance to popular opinion. .
As evidenced in the Western states, such as France or the Netherlands, reactionary right-
wing parties can gain popularity and strength on the basis of anti-immigrant platforms. .
These parties provide a threat to the state’s power and national security where
governments are weak, such as in LDCs, and could potentially topple regimes in some
areas. . States often shift their public policy to more restrictive, anti-immigration stances
to avoid the potential problems that could arise if the reactionary right-wing parties gain
more power. . Discriminatory policies towards immigrants are partly to blame for the
riots in Paris, France and Sydney, Australia. . Also, the riots in the Middle East, caused
by outrage over inflammatory political cartoons published by a Danish newspaper, have
roots in the deep anti-immigrant sentiment among the public. . National security is
threatened if the public becomes too entrenched in the idea of protecting cultural security.
. The importance of this third “threat” to security is that, despite its basis being derived
from beliefs rather than factual evidence, it still impacts a government’s policy towards
migration.
Current Status
Souring Immigration Attitudes and Policy in EU and Australia
European politics have shown the effects of the public perception in recent years. .
Using nationalism, populist groups have stirred up anti-immigrant sentiments and gained
a strong following. . In 2002, Jean-Marie Le Pen of the National Front, a reactionary
right-wing party that proposes to send immigrants home and close the borders, took
France by complete surprise. When He he won 17 per cent of the national vote in the
first round of presidential voting, which placed him in the second and final run-off. .
Even more telling about this political shock was from where Le Pen received the majority
of his support: most of his votes were received in communities that had large immigrant
22
populations.46 Also during that year, in the Netherlands, thought to be one of the most
tolerant and inviting countries in Europe, the Pim Fortuyn’s List (PFL) won the second
most seats in the Dutch parliament. . The PFL is a Dutch version of the National Front,
advocating closing the borders because the Netherlands is “full.”47
Further fueling public opinion of immigration in Europe are four events of security
significance: the terrorist attacks of 11 September 11th 2001 in the United States, the
Madrid bombing on 11 March 11th, 2004, the London subway bombings on 7 July 7th,
2005, and most recently, the Parisian riots, which began on 27 October 27th, 2005 and
lasted 18 daysfor nearly three weeks. . The first three were terrorist attacks, carried out
by immigrants following a militant brand of Islam, who were able to migrate into the
various states in order to attack. . In light of these acts of terror, governments in Europe
became more concerned with the security threat posed by relaxed migration laws.
The Parisian riots, on the other hand, served to both demonstrate the results of
migrant suffering in Europe and stoke the flames of public resentment to foreigners. .
The vast majority of youths involved in the rioting were of immigrant descent, living in
ghettos outside of Paris. . These ghettos, or the suburbs as they are rosily referred to in
France,areas were built outside of major French cities during the wave of immigration
from former colonies – mainly primarily Muslims from North African colonies – during
the 1960s.48 These people moved to France in search of a better life, attempting to escape
poverty in their homeland to attain a better life for themselves and their children in the
affluent West. . Today, unemployment is 40 per cent in many of these ghettos, and the
youths living there feel trapped, as if they have no possibilities of moving upward in
French society.49 The people in these ghettos complain of racial discrimination in
education, employment, and treatment by police. .
46 Ibid 7047 Shamit Saggar, “Immigration and the Politics of Popular Opinion” in The Politics of Migration, ed. Sarah Spencer, 190 (Oxford: Blackwell Publishing, 2003)48 BBC, “Ghettos shackle French Muslims”, http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/europe/4375910.stm (accessed February 2nd, 2006)49 Ibid
23
At the same time, attitudes towards immigrants in France have become even
worsemore combative, and . tThe National Front has gained support in the wake of these
riots. . Recent surveys showed that 25 per cent of French support Jean-Marie Le Pen’s
ideas on immigration, including the removal of immigrants from French suburbs.50 With
prejudice against immigrants increasing after the riots, and the riots occurring because of
socio-economic conditions created by racism, the situation has no foreseeable solution.
Down under, Australia is coping with the same tension between migrants and the
native population. . The beaches of Sydney erupted in riots on 11 December 11th, 2005
after two Anglo-Australians were attacked by a group of Lebanese-Australians. .
Violence escalated as the “Aussies”Australians retaliated when 5,000 young men
descended on the beaches and began attacking anyone who looked Middle Eastern.51 In
response, the “Lebs”Lebanese immigrants roamed the streets near the beaches and
destroyed storefronts. . The causes of the tension between Lebanese Muslims and
Australians are the same as those in France. : Tthe Lebanese live in communities with
“disproportionately high unemployment and poverty rates,” causing the youth of these
communities to feel trapped in these conditions because of their race.52 In recent years,
Australian attitudes towards promoting immigration have sharply declined. . As a result,
the government policy has shifted to restrict migration. . Yet, while public attitudes may
be against migration, the economic future of Australia cries out for more able
bodiesdepends on workers able to fill the jobs being left open by an aging population.
European and Australian immigration policy is currently caught at a crossroads. .
The population of both continents is aging, and migration provides a possible solution to
the employment issue in the coming years. . Terrorism is a very real security threat, with
two major terrorist attacks occurring in Europe in the past two years. . Both Europe and
Australia also face the prospect of future riots and conflict between the native population
and the migrant population. . The general public’s anti-immigration view sentiment is
50 Emma-Kate Symons, “Mood Turns Darkly Towards the Right”, The Weekend Australian, December 17th, 2005, Lexis-Nexis 51 Yvonne Abraham, “On the Beach: Why the Recent Riots in Australia Should Surprise No One”, The Boston Globe, December 25th, 2005, Lexis-Nexis.52 Ibid
24
not only creating tension between the public and immigrants, something that can create
potentially volatile situations, they empower reactionary right-wing groups to the point
where some fear their views are becoming a part of the political mainstream.
The United States, Foreign Policy Shifts, and Migration
The events of 11 September 11th, 2001 marked a turning point in the history of the
United States. . Foreign policy in America shifted dramatically, thrusting the fight
against terrorism into the spotlight as its prime objective. . With the focus on terrorism
also came an analysis of the US’sAmerican immigration policy. . The US has a well-
documented history of being a haven for immigration, openly accepting waves of
immigrants from all parts of Europe at the beginning of the 20 th centuryCentury, and most
recently immigrants from Latin America and Asia. , That was before the security threat
that migration poses was so gruesomely exposed. . A new wrinkle development in US
immigration policy is the profiling of males from Arab and Muslim countries, the states
from where the 19 hijackers originated. . Legal immigrants saw their rights further
diminished restricted by the USA Patriot Act, which was passed with the hope of
preventing future terrorist attacks.53
The international effects of the United States’ reaction to the attacks of 11
September 11th 2001 are felt in the War on Terrorthroughout the world as a result of its
Global War on Terror. . The United States took a proactive approach to preventing
terrorism. : Wwith a mission statement of finding terrorists and bringing them to justice
to ensure the peace and security of the world, the United States began a campaign
scouring the globe to hunt down terrorists. . Wars were fought begun in Afghanistan, in
2001, and Iraq, in 2003. . International security was the primary reason these wars were
fought, but while threats were removed, overlooked in these conflicts are the refugee
flows stemming from them: 200,000 Afghans fled their country in 2001 after the war
began, 500,000 left Iraq for Syria, and an additional one million Iraqis sought refuge in
53 Susan Martin, “The Politics of US Immigration Reform” in The Politics of Migration, ed. Sarah Spencer, 139 (Oxford: Blackwell Publishing, 2003)
25
Jordan.54 While the United States maintains that these conflicts are vital to the security of
the international community, Pakistan and Syria are bearing the brunt of the challenge
posed by migration away from the war zones, and are at risk of internal unrest due in
large part to these migratory flows. .
Refugee Issues in LDCPopulations in Least Developed Countriess
There are multiple refugee crises around the world. . The earthquake in Pakistan
resulted in the deaths of 87,000 people and the displacement of 3.5 million more.55 The
majority of those now taking refuge in emergency camps do not want to return to their
poverty-stricken regions of Kashmir or the Pakistani-Afghanistan border. . The tsunami
of December 2004 resulted in over more than 200,000 deaths and hundreds of thousands
left homeless. . For LDCsLeast Developed Countries, foreign aid is critical to the
mission of providing for these refugees. .
Refugees can pose a threat to the stability or existence of the government in their
host state. . Threats Potential for violence arises because refugee flows can provide
newly created internal threats to the government or place significant strain on the
government’s ability to properly supply its population with food, water, and shelter.56
Since the governments of some LDCs are weak, the inability to provide its people with
basic necessities of life can cause protests and rioting. . In November 2005, 500 refugees
from various African states at the Krisan Refugee Camp in Ghana escaped and relocated
themselvesintegrated into the broader Ghanaian population. . The cited reasons for
leaving the refugee camp included “poor accommodation and feeding … health and
sanitation problems and lack of education scholarships.”57 With a refugee population of
54 UN High Commission on Refugees, “2001 Global Refugee Statistics”, UNHCR. http://www.unhcr.org/cgi-bin/texis/vtx/news/opendoc.htm?tbl=NEWS&id=3d0f66ef2 (accessed February 3rd, 2006)55 Hans Greimel, “Pakistan braces for next quake challenge: sending survivors home” The Associated Press, January 29, 2006, Lexis-Nexis56 Karen Jacobsen, “Factors Influencing the Policy Responses of Host Governments to Mass Refugee Influxes” International Migration Review, Vol. 30, No. 3 (1996): 67257 The Analyst, “500 Refugees on Rampage in Ghana” Africa News, November 11th 2005, Lexis-Nexis
26
64,000, Ghana faces serious problems if the actions of the 500 inspire other refugees to
protest the government over their deplorable living conditions. .
The influx of refugees also produces new internal enemies. . Refugee camps often
house guerillas, which results in serious security implications for both the host state and
the refugees themselves.58 In some cases, the sending state may launch raids into the host
state to attack refugee settlements. . In the 1980s, refugees fled South Africa to
neighboring states only to be hunted down by the South African military.59 South Africa
justified its actions by claiming that the refugee camps were home to armed insurgents
that threatened its national security. . The host state feels threatened by armed enemies of
the state residing in its borders and, to remove the threat, may attack refugee camps. .
This, in turn, endangers the lives of people living in the camps, the vast majority of
whom may be innocent. . Furthermore, future policy towards refugees is likely to take a
more restrictive turn if security issues arise because of the admittance of these
individuals. . Neighboring states began to ask refugees to seek asylum elsewhere after
the South African military attacked the settlements, in order to avoid further conflict,
whether internal or external.60
The situation in the Darfur of the Sudan is particularly alarming for security in
Africa. . The genocide in Sudan is causing an exodus of non-Arabs from Sudan seeking
to escape the conflict. . Armed militias known as the The Janjaweed militias are killing
non-Arab Sudanese in the Darfur region causing the death of 200,000 civilians and
leading 200,000 Sudanese to flee across the border to Chad in search of safety. .
Unfortunately, a region of barren desert awaits these refugees.61 Living conditions are
dire. There is a camp in the town of Kolloye, Chad where “10,000 refugees live in
roofless grass shelters that give little protection from the frigid night air and no shelter
58 Karen Jacobsen, “Factors Influencing the Policy Responses of Host Governments to Mass Refugee Influxes” International Migration Review, Vol. 30, No. 3 (1996): 67259 Ibid60 Ibid 67361 UN High Commission on Refugees, “Chad/Darfur Emergency”, UNHCR. http://www.unhcr.org/cgi-bin/texis/vtx/chad?page=intro (accessed February 3rd, 2006)
27
from the punishing sun.” 62 Moreover, basic necessities of life like water and food are
scarce at best. These difficult living conditions can cause unrest and frustration among a
population of already unsettled people.
Recently, the Janjaweed started to attack refugee settlements established in Chad. ,
not only These attacks not only causeing the displacement and death of Sudanese
refugees, but so farmore than 20,000 Chadians citizens from Chad have been driven from
their homes and had their property destroyed.63 Beginning in December 2005, militias
based in the Sudan and armed by the Sudanese government joined with existing Chadian
rebels groups in Chad to attack and eventually topple the government of Chadthe host
country. . General Abakar Youssouf Mahamit Itno, the man in charge of border security,
believes that “Sudan wants to export the war in Darfur to us here … they want to use the
Janjaweed they armed to terrorize Darfur, to terrorize our population.”64 Not only are the
Janjaweed, a Sudanese militia, terrorizing people within Chad’s borders, but now
Chadian rebels from Chad are establishing bases in Sudan to rest and gather supplies for
further attacks on the government of Chad. . The refugee flow from the Darfur crisis now
directly threatens the national security of Chad.
Bloc Positions
Regional Positions
Developed States
Developed nations view migration with extreme caution. . On the one hand,
immigrants help with employment issueseconomic growth by adding to the labor supply.
. Still, migration poses serious risks to national security in the form of crime and
terrorism. . The immigration of skilled or professional peoples to MDCs developed states
is viewed as not only as a benefit, but something that policy must further facilitate. . The
European Union is working towards easing restrictions on labor migration to fill what it 62 Lydia Polgreen, “Refugee Crisis Grows as Darfur War Crosses a Border: 20,000 in Chad are Uprooted by Attacks.” New York Times, February 28th, 2006.63 Ibid64 Ibid
28
perceives as a “growing skills gap,” but this is aimed at attracting the skilled workers of
LDCs, not unskilled laborers.65 Its goal is a policy of “targeted migration,” which allows
migrants to bolster employment in sectors experiencing labor shortages, and but limiting
limits migration to only those sectorsother.66 Targeted migration means taking an active
role in determining what type of migrant is desirable for the economy, and keeping those
not desired outrefusing entry to others. . Restrictive immigration policies towards
unskilled laborers play a significant role in the increaseding amount of illegal
immigration, another problem facing MDCs developed states.
The European Union and the United States have place a majorput significant
emphasis on cracking down on illegal immigration. . On 28 February 28, 2002, the EU
laid out plans to fight illegal immigration, including the creation establishment of a
European border patrol and the toughening of laws to prosecute those who promote
illegal immigration.67 The United States faces similar problems. , as Aan estimated eight
million illegal immigrants currently reside in the US.68 Part of the problem is that the
US-Mexican border is easily crossed illegallyporous, due to the sheer size of the land
border. . Potential ways MDCs developed states can hslow downinder illegal
immigration include positive solutions, such as investment in LDCs to promote economic
growth and “bring work to the workers rather than workers to the work,” or bolstering
security via through methods such as increased patrolmenpatrols, walls, or fences.69
While most MDCs developed states have a somewhat restrictive stance on
migration, Japan’s policy is incredibly rigid. . At the forefront of the reasons Japan
enforces such a strict entrance and integration policy is the goal of preserving ethnic
homogeneity, the same concept that is gaining popularity in the European Union. . Both
65 Claude Moraes, “The Politics of European Union Migration Policy” in The Politics of Migration, ed. Sarah Spencer, 125 (Oxford: Blackwell Publishing, 2003)66 “The US National Intelligence Council on Growing Global Migration” Population and Development Review, Vol. 27 No. 4, 2001: 81867 “Combating Illegal Immigration at EU Level”, European Commission. http://europa.eu.int/comm/justice_home/fsj/immigration/illegal/fsj_immigration_illegal_en.htm (accessed February 3rd, 2006)68 W.T.S. Gould and A.M. Findlay, Population Migration and the Changing World Order, (New York: John Wiley & Sons, 1994), 12169 Ibid 119
29
Japan and the European Union are staring down a potential economic crisis in coming
yearsforesee a looming economic upheaval in coming years, due to an increasingly aging
population not being able to produce a sufficient labor force. . This cautious, “wait and
see” approach to migration is only sustainable if Japan does is able to recover
economically, and to retrofit its economy to accommodate the realities of an older
workforce. . If they do, increased demand for labor will result in shortages across the
country, and may require the loosening of immigration regulations.70
Falling under the umbrella of illegal migration is crime and terrorism. The early
stages of the drug trade, such as growth and manufacturing, may be done in LDCs, but
the ultimate market for cocaine and heroin are in MDCs. Similarly, terrorist organizing,
planning, and training may be devised in a multitude of states, but the end goal is to carry
out attacks in major cities of their enemies. The most pressing issue to national security
for the West, as evidenced by recent attacks, is terrorism. Tougher migration laws or
strengthening border security to combat terrorism or narcotics trade may possibly achieve
the goals of national security, but there are trade offs on the economic end of restrictive
migration policies.
Developing States
The primary concernss for developing states are are the ability to cope with
influxes of refugees and attempting to combat transnational crime. . Some 70 per cent of
the world’s refugees are located in Africa or Asia, regions predominantly comprised of
LDCs.71 Refugees face many tasks challenges in establishing new settlements (temporary
or permanent), including procuring enough food, the availability of safe drinking water,
and accumulating wood materials with which to build shelters. . As a result,
environmental degradation is a strong possibilitysignificant concern in any new area in
which refugees settle.72 AlsoAdditionally, the receiving state in a refugee flow may not
70 “The US National Intelligence Council on Growing Global Migration” Population and Development Review, Vol. 27 No. 4, 2001: 81971 United Nations High Commission on Refugees, “Refugees by Numbers (2005 edition)”, UN, http://www.unhcr.ch/cgi-bin/texis/vtx/basics/opendoc.htm?tbl=BASICS&id=3b028097c#Refugees (accessed February 4th 2006)72 United Nations High Commission on Refugees, “Environmental Concerns During Refugee Operations”, UN, http://www.unhcr.org/cgi-bin/texis/vtx/protect/opendoc.htm?
30
possess the funding funds necessary to properly care for the new arrivals, which causes
problems. . These states could look to foreign aid, from either MDCs developed states or
Non-Governmental Organizations (NGOs), to assist in funding the programs needed to
sustain the new addition to the populationarrivals. . The governments of LDCs
sometimes seek other routes, because the acceptance of foreign aid can mean allowing
outsiders to influence your decision makingpublic policy initiatives, thus sacrificing some
degree of national sovereignty.73
National security is also at risk if refugee flows disturb the stability of ethnic,
racial, or religious groups in the state. . Many states in Africa are already coping with
deep divisions among their populations based on the grounds of ethnicity, race, or
religion. . A sudden influx of refugees can further aggravate the existing tensions. . The
possibility of this is greater if incoming refugees have a connection to a group already
there.74
LDCs also have the fear of their state being weakened, directly or indirectly.
Guerillas or insurgencies, fleeing the law of their former home and seeking to establish
new bases of operations, pose direct military threats to the security of state. Indirect
threats can result from transnational organized crime influencing members of the
government. Most recently, in South Asia, a new threat to socio-economic security has
emerged. The region has seen a dramatic shift in its narcotics problem. Instead of serving
merely a haven for the growing and manufacturing of heroin and cocaine, the region is
rapidly growing into a large base of users. Thailand, for example, has more heroin users
per capita than the United States.75 Long-term costs of health care and social services can
inhibit the government’s ability to fund development projects.
Non-Governmental Organizations(NGOs)
tbl=PROTECTION&id=3b03b6f44 (accessed February 4th 2006)73 Karen Jacobsen, “Factors Influencing the Policy Responses of Host Governments to Mass Refugee Influxes” International Migration Review, Vol. 30, No. 3 (1996): 66374 Gil Loescher & Alan Dowty, “Refugee Flows as Grounds for International Action” International Security, Vol. 21, No. 1 (1996): 4875 Alan Dupont, “Transnational Crime and Security in East Asia” Asian Survey, Vol. 39., No. 3 (1999): 452
31
Non-Governmental Organizations, or NGOs, play a vital role in assisting states
with the financial burden of supporting and supplying refugees. . Refugee flows strain
local infrastructure and resources, meaning even the most basic of necessities, like food
and clean water, become scarce. . NGOs help alleviate the situation by providing
additional funding or supplies that the government cannot produce on its own. . Africare,
the leading NGO in African charitable work, claims suggests it has been heavily involved
in “virtually every humanitarian emergency in Africa since the 1970s.” This association
includes the Somalian refugee crisis of the 1980s, and crises created by armed conflict in
countries such as Burundi, Rwanda, Sierra Leone, and Angola in the 1990s.76 Africare is
among the myriad NGOs who that specialize in the delivery of aid to areas in dire need. .
Africare is but one of many NGOs, including the International Red Cross and Oxfam
International, that specializes in distributing legal aid to migrants and refugees.
Other NGOs, such as the Human Rights Watch (HRW) or Amnesty International,
are advocacy groups that focus on the discriminatory aspects of migration. . HRW
recently addressed the International Organization of Migration to voice their its
displeasure at the inadequate measures taken to protect the basic rights of migrants. .
Additionally, in a piece drawn up by the HRW, International Catholic Migration
Committee, and numerous other NGOs, a declaration was made on the basic human
rights that refugees possess that must not be violated by the receiving state.77 While not
doling out humanitarian aid like Africare and other similar NGOs of that nature do,
NGOs like the HRW seek to assist migrants by ensuring their rights as humans are
protected regardless of where they move or what the reasons for moving aretheir
motivations for migration..
NGOs may be acting with the best of intentions, but their actions often have
unforeseen consequences. . Many refugee aid NGOs have administrators who see
76 Africare, “About Africare”, Africare. http://africare.org/about/history/history.html (accessed February 6th, 2006)77 HRW, “NGO Background paper on the Refugee and Migration Interface”, Human Rights Watch. http://www.hrw.org/campaigns/refugees/ngo-document/ngo_refugee.pdf (accessed February 6th, 2006)
32
government officials in LDCs as “inefficient, indifferent, corrupt and inadequate.”78 This
condescending view toward the very governments these relief organizations are supposed
to be assisting often results in friction between the government and the organization,
which in turn limits the efficiency the aid distribution process. . The conflict between
NGO and state can become so severe that the state actually takes an obstructionist stance
to hinder the relief effort. . Sudanese government officials in the 1980s refused to issue
work permits or visas to volunteers as retaliation to the critical stance taken by the
NGOvarious aid groups.79 In the end, these feuds only hurt the refugees. .
Media Positions
Media reactions are partly to blame for the hostile attitudes toward immigration in
MDCdeveloped states. . In 2006, The the Danish newspaper Jyllands-Posten printed
twelve political cartoons in 2006 that depicted the Prophet Mohammed as, among other
things, a terrorist or a terrorist sympathizer.80 The Danish people’s negative attitude of
much of the Danish population towards Muslim immigrants is similar to those that of the
French and Dutch, and these feelings were put into print in these cartoons. . Reaction
across the Islamic world was swift and the outrage unanticipatedintense. . Islam forbids
the depiction of the Prophet Mohammed, therefore any illustration, let alone a politically
charged cartoon, is offensive. . Large Violent riots broke out in many Middle Eastern
states, where over 11 people diedresulting in the deaths of several bystanders, the
boycotts of Danish goods were boycotted, and Danish property destroyeduction of
Danish property.81 Newspapers in various states across Europe reprinted the cartoons, in
a sign of solidarity of with the Danish paper.. Similar anti-immigrant sentiments can be
found in Japan, as editorials support a Japanese bill in parliament that would require the
fingerprinting of all visitors to the island nation.82
78 Karen Jacobsen, “Factors Influencing the Policy Responses of Host Governments to Mass Refugee Influxes” International Migration Review, Vol. 30, No. 3 (1996): 66379 Ibid80 Dan Bilefsky, “Danish Cartoon Editor on Indefinite Leave.” New York Times, February 11th, 2006.81 Ibid82 “Fingerprinting Visitors Common, Necessary” The Daily Yomiuri, April 17th, 2006, final edition. Lexis-Nexis.
33
Business Positions
Businesses in the developed world depend and thrive upon the influx of migrants
into a state. . Unskilled immigrants are able to find a variety of minimum-wage jobs
available in most developed states, and . the The wages are considerably higher than the
immigrants would receive in their state of origin, so it is a beneficial arrangement for the
worker. . Business, too, benefits from unskilled labor. Many of the jobs, such as the
service sector jobs that Bangladeshis are working in Rome, Italy, are difficult to fill
because citizens see the jobs as lowly and the wages miniscule. When businesses perform
well, it translates into economic growth, but using immigrants to fill jobs causes issues
with the publicdifficulties in public perception, such as in can particularly be seen in the
United States. . Over seven millionSome eight million illegal immigrants work in the
United States, or translating to 1 in 20 members of the American work force.83 Their
status as illegal immigrants fuels public criticism not only of the government for not
securing the borders, (for not securing the border) but also of businesses for hiring them. .
Yet, wWhile business comes under fire for employing illegal immigrants, it is often only
these immigrants that are willing to work the menial jobs that need to be performed.
83 Hanah Cho, “Demand and Supply; American Businesses Offer Jobs, and Illegal Immigrants Come” The Baltimore Sun, April 2nd, 2006, final edition. Lexis-Nexis.
34
Summary
Migration is an issue that affects all states of the world, in varying forms and with
varying results. . As long as there are natural disasters or battles foughtcountries resort to
war, there will be humans fleeing the effected affected areas in seek of refuge. .
Similarly, the difference in wealth between states will continue to motivate some to
migrate in search of better opportunities for themselves and their families. . The growing
interconnectedness of the world facilitates migration, with better transportation and
information access encouraging people to move from one state to another. .
Acknowledging migration as a cause for concern is the first step.
States face real andor perceived threats to their national, economic, and cultural
security from migration. . At the same time, however, migration provides benefits to the
state. . The MDCsDeveloped states of the world have to properly balance the benefits
and drawbacks of migration. . The fears of their people that their culture is fading
awayeroding and the increased threat to national security that transnational crime and
terrorism pose place pressure on the governments of MDCs these states to restrict
migration. . On the other handDespite these reservations, the economic problems of
unemployment and declining productivity can sometimes be solved by increased
migration. . The LDCs of the world are particularly vulnerable to internal threats to
national security from migration. . Ways to appropriately and effectively fund aid for
refugees that enter into states must be found, or else the government may find itself
governing over an angered group of refugees or an upset indigenous population. .
Refugee flows can also destabilize local economies from significant increases in demand
for food, water, shelter, and employment. .
Migration is not an occurrence that can be stopped. . Whether done legally or
illegally, for any of a multitude of reasons, people will find ways to move across borders.
. Policy addressing migration will only be successful if this is taken into account. . For
economic migrants, the key is in finding a balance between the threats to national
security that migration creates causes and the economic benefits of migrationthat it
35
achieves. . To appropriately handle a refugee flow, states cannot put up the figurative
walls to keep refugees out. Support systems of international aid must be in place to assist
states in helping meet the needs of refugees, or else national security could be
jeopardized. .
36
Discussion Questions
Does a state have the right to deny entry of an economic refugee? Can it ethically deny a political or religious refugee? What body should have the right to determine the immigration policy of a given state?
What security risks posed by migration are the most significant in today’s world?
Are restricted migration policies feasible in today’s world of globalization?
Is the concept of “targeted migration” for economic migrants fair? Should MDCs developed states be picking the best candidates from LDCs to enter their country? Does this further fuel the brain drain?What affect does this selective process have on the host country? The country of origin?
In regards to refugees, what ways can the situation be handled better to keep stability within the stateHow can refugee populations be effectively controlled to ensure that national security interests are maintained?
To what extent should the root of migration be looked atexamined? Economic migrants relocate because their home states are impoverished and cannot offer opportunities to better their lives. Refugees often seek asylum in other states to escape persecution and violence. Should the focus be on migration itself, or the causes of migration?
Hostile populations in host states can lead to violence (see: Paris, France). . How can these racist attitudes among the public of host states be properly dealt withmanaged to avoid national security issuesinternal security concerns?
How can the international community better assist LDCs in coping with refugee issuesflows? Should refugees be denied entrance into a state if the state deems them a security risk?
Developed nations and developing nations are impacted differently by migration. , yYet in some areas, such as international crime and terrorism, there are common problems. . In what ways can different states work together to deal with migration?
What realistic steps can the UN take towards resolving some of the ongoing problems migration is causing today?
37
Works Cited
Abraham, Yvonne. . “On the Beach: Why the Recent Riots in Australia Should Surprise No One”, The Boston Globe, December 25th, 2005, final edition. . Lexis-Nexis.
Africare, “About Africare: History”, Africare. . http://africare.org/about/history/history.html (accessed February 6th, 2006)
Anthony, Constance G. . “Africa’s Refugee Crisis: State Building in Historical Perspective” International Migration Review, Vol. . 25, No. . 3 (1991): 574-591
Barkin, Solomon. . “The Economic Costs and Benefits of International Migration” The Journal of Human Resources, Vol. . 2, No. . 4 (1967): 495-516
BBC News, “Ghettos shackle French Muslims”, BBC http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/europe/4375910.stm (accessed February 2, 2006)
BBC News, “The Bali Bombers’ Network of Terror”, BBC http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/asia-pacific/2499193.stm (accessed February 26th, 2006)
BBC News, “The Suspects”, BBC http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/shared/spl/hi/uk/05/london_blasts/investigation/html/suspects.stm, (accessed February 26th, 2006)
Bilefsky, Dan. . “Danish Cartoon Editor on Indefinite Leave.” New York Times, February 11th, 2006, final edition. . Lexis-Nexis.
Cheng, Lucie and Philip Q. . Yang. . “Global Interaction, Global Inequality, and Migration of the Highly Trained to the United States” International Migration Review, Vol. . 32, No. . 3 (1998): 626-653
38
Cho, Hanah. . “Demand and Supply; American Businesses Offer Jobs, and Illegal Immigrants Come” The Baltimore Sun, April 2nd, 2006, final edition. . Lexis-Nexis.
“Combating Illegal Immigration at EU Level”, European Commission. . http://europa.eu.int/comm/justice_home/fsj/immigration/illegal/fsj_immigration_illegal_en.htm (accessed February 3rd, 2006)
Council on Foreign Relations, “Global Conflicts Map”, CNN, http://www.cnn.com/interactive/maps/world/fullpage.global.conflict/world.index.html (accessed February 22nd, 2006)
Doty, Roxanne Lynn. . Anti-Immigrantism in Western Democracies, New York: Taylor & Francis, 2003. .
Dupont, Alan. . “Transnational Crime and Security in East Asia” Asian Survery, Vol. . 39, No. . 3 (1999): 433-455
“Fact Sheet Desertification: Africa” GTZ CCD Project, http://lada.virtualcentre.org/eims/download.asp?pub_id=93546&v=5 (accessed February 23rd, 2006)
Fingerprinting Visitors Common, Necessary” The Daily Yomiuri, April 17th, 2006, final edition. . Lexis-Nexis.
Gould, W.T.S. . and A.M. . Findlay. . Population Migration and the Changing World Order. . New York: John Wiley & Sons, 1994.
Greimel, Hans. . “Pakistan braces for next quake challenge: sending survivors home” The Associated Press, January 29, 2006, final edition. . Lexis-Nexis.
Hein, Jeremy. . “Refugees, Immigrants, and the State” Annual Review of Sociology, Vol. . 19 (1993): 43-59
Hintjens, Helen M. . “Explaining the 1994 Genocide in Rwanda” The Journal of Modern African Studies, Vol. . 37, No. . 2 (1999): 241-286
HRW, “NGO Background paper on the Refugee and Migration Interface”, Human Rights Watch. . http://www.hrw.org/campaigns/refugees/ngo-document/ngo_refugee.pdf (accessed February 6th, 2006)
Hugo, Graeme “Environmental Concerns and International Migration” International Migration Review, Vol. . 30, No. . 1 (1996): 105-131
39
Human Rights Watch, “Safe Refuge for Afghan Refugees”, Human Rights Watch. . http://www.hrw.org/campaigns/afghanistan/refugees-facts.htm (accessed February 1, 2006)
Jacobsen, Karen. . “Factors Influencing the Policy Responses of Host Governments to Mass Refugee Influxes” International Migration Review, Vol. . 30, No. . 3 (1996): 655-678
Kleinman, Mark. . “The Economic Impact of Labour Migration” in The Politics of Migration, edited by Sarah Spencer, 59-74. . Oxford: Blackwell Publishing, 2003.
King, Russell & Melanie Knights. . “Bangladeshis in Rome: Migratory Opportunities” in Population Migration and the Changing World Order, edited by W.T.S. . Gould and A.M. . Findlay, 127-144. . New York: John Wiley & Sons, 1994.
Loescher, Gil & Alan Dowty. . “Refugee Flows as Grounds for International Action” International Security, Vol. . 21, No. . 1 (1996): 43-71
Martin, Susan. . “The Politics of US Immigration Reform” in The Politics of Migration, edited by Sarah Spencer, 116-131. . Oxford: Blackwell Publishing, 2003.
Moraes, Claude. . “The Politics of European Union Migration Policy” in The Politics of Migration, edited by Sarah Spencer, 132-149. . Oxford: Blackwell Publishing, 2003.
Polgreen, Lydia. . “Refugee Crisis Grows as Darfur War Crosses a Border: 20,000 in Chad are Uprooted by Attacks.” New York Times, February 28th, 2006.
Rudolph, Christopher. . “Globalization and Security: Migration and Evolving Conceptions of Security in Statecraft and Scholarship” (2002). . Columbia International Affairs Online.
Russell, Sharon Stanton. . “International Migration and Political Turmoil in the Middle East” Population and Development Review, Vol. . 18, No. . 4 (1992): 719-727
Rystad, Goran. . “Immigration History and the Future of International Migration” International Migration Review, Vol. . 26, No. . 4 (1992): 1168-1199
Saggar, Shamit. . “Immigration and the Politics of Popular Opinion” in The Politics of Migration, edited by Sarah Spencer, 178-194. . Oxford: Blackwell Publishing, 2003.
40
Symons, Emma-Kate. . “Mood Turns Darkly Towards the Right”, The Weekend Australian, December 17th, 2005, final edition. . Lexis-Nexis.
“The US National Intelligence Council on Growing Global Migration” Population and Development Review, Vol. . 27 No. . 4, (2001): 817-819
The Analyst. . “500 Refugees on Rampage in Ghana”, Africa News, November 11th 2005, final edition. . Lexis-Nexis
United Nations High Commission on Refugees, “2001 Global Refugee Statistics”, UNHCR. . http://www.unhcr.org/cgi-bin/texis/vtx/news/opendoc.htm?tbl=NEWS&id=3d0f66ef2 (accessed February 3rd, 2006)
United Nations High Commission on Refugees, “Chad/Darfur Emergency”, UNHCR. . http://www.unhcr.org/cgi-bin/texis/vtx/chad?page=intro (accessed February 3rd, 2006)
United Nations High Commission on Refugees, “Environmental Concerns During Refugee Operations”, UN, http://www.unhcr.org/cgi-bin/texis/vtx/protect/opendoc.htm?tbl=PROTECTION&id=3b03b6f44 (accessed February 4th 2006)
United Nations High Commission on Refugees, “Refugees by Numbers (2005 edition)”, UN, http://www.unhcr.ch/cgi-bin/texis/vtx/basics/opendoc.htm?tbl=BASICS&id=3b028097c#Refugees (accessed February 4th 2006)
“UN Refugee Agency Official Spotlights Plight of Displaced Colombians”, States News Service, February 3rd, 2006, final edition. . Lexis-Nexis.
Weiner, Myron. . “Security, Stability, and International Security” International Migration Review, Vol. . 17, No.3 (1992): 91-126
Wood, William B. . “Forced Migration: Local Conflicts and International Dilemmas” Annals of the Association of American Geographers, Vol. . 84, No. . 4 (1994): 607-634
World Bank, “Key Development Data & Statistics”, The World Bank Group, http://web.worldbank.org/WBSITE/EXTERNAL/DATASTATISTICS/0,,contentMDK:20535285~menuPK:1192694~pagePK:64133150~piPK:64133175~theSitePK:239419,00.html (accessed February 1st 2006)
42
Works Referenced
BBC News, “Bali Terror Attack”, BBC http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/in_depth/asia_pacific/2002/bali/default.stm (accessed February 26th, 2006)
BBC News, “The London Attacks”, BBC http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/in_depth/uk/2005/london_explosions/default.stm (accessed February 26th, 2006)
Borjas, George J. . “The Economics of Immigration” Journal of Economic Literature, Vol. . 32, No. . 4 (1994): 1667-1717
Brubaker, Rogers. . “Migrations of Ethnic Un-mixing in the New Europe” International Migration Review, Vol. . 32, No. . 4 (1998): 1047-1065
“Humanitarian Crisis Reported on Colombian-Ecuador Border”, States News Service, November 17th, 2005, final edition. . Lexis-Nexis.
Keely, Charles B. . “How Nation-States Create and Respond to Refugee Flows” International Migration Review, Vol. . 30, No. . 4 (1996): 1046-1066
Kubat, Daniel. . The Politics of Migration Policies. . New York: Center for Migration Studies, 1993.
McNeill, William H. . and Ruth S. . Adams. . Human Migration: Patterns and Policies. . Bloomington: Indiana University Press, 1978.
Ongley, Patrick and David Pearson. . “Post-1945 International Migration: New Zealand, Canada, and Australia Compared” International Migration Review, Vol. . 29, No. . 3 (1995): 765-793
Schreuder, Yda. . “Report of the Salzburg Seminar Session, ‘Involuntary Migration’, Held in Salzburg, Austria, July 8-15, 1995” International Migration Review, Vol. . 30, No. . 3 (1996): 803-808
Spencer, Steven A. . “Illegal Migrant Laborers in Japan” International Migration Review, Vol. . 26, No. . 3 (1992): 754-786
43
Stolnitz, George J. . “International Migration Policies: Some Demographic and Economic Contexts” in Human Migration: Patterns and Policies, edited by William H. . McNeill and Ruth S. . Adams, 241-286. . Bloomington: Indiana University Press, 1978.
“The United Nations on Levels and Trends of International Migration and Related Policies” Population and Development Review, Vol. . 29, No. . 2 (2003): 335-340
Weiner, Myron. . “Ethics, National Sovereignty, and the Control of Immigration” International Migration Review, Vol. . 30, No. . 1 (1996): 171-197
Winchie, Diana B. . and David W. . Carment. . “Migration and Motivation: The Migrant’s Perspective” International Migration Review, Vol. . 23, No. . 1 (1989): 96-104
Zlotnik, Hania. . “International Migration 1965-96: An Overview” Population and Development Review, Vol. . 24, No. . 3 (1998): 429-468