the michigan primary care transformation (mipct) project all-partner launch event march 13, 2012 1
TRANSCRIPT
The Michigan Primary Care Transformation (MiPCT) Project
All-Partner Launch Event March 13, 2012
1
Agenda•U.S. Health Care Trends (the burning platform)•The Michigan Primary Care Transformation Project
▫CMS MAPCP Background Information ▫MiPCT Vision▫Participants▫Financial Model▫Clinical Model▫Resources Available▫How Will We Define Success?
•Summary•Questions and Discussion
2
U.S. Health Care Trends
3
Page 4
0
1000
2000
3000
4000
5000
6000
7000 United StatesGermanyCanadaFranceAustraliaUnited Kingdom
Average Health Spending Per Capita ($US): The ubiquitous and non-sustainable cost curve
K. Davis et al. Slowing the Growth of U.S. Health Care Expenditures: What Are the Options?, The Commonwealth Fund, January 2007, updated with 2007 OECD data
Where is the silver lining?
•Accountable Care Organizations?
•Patient Centered Medical Homes?
•Health Care Reform?
•All/None of the above?
5
PCMH as the Foundation for ACO Population Management
6Source: Premier Healthcare Alliance
The goal of Accountable Care Organizations should be to reduce, or at least control the growth of, healthcare costs while maintaining or improving the quality of care patients receive (in terms of both clinical quality, patient experience and satisfaction). - Harold Miller
CMS Multi-Payer Advanced Primary Care Practice (MAPCP) Demonstration Project
7
CMS Multi-Payer Advanced Primary Care Practice (MAPCP) Demonstration
•Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services is exploring the role of the PCMH in improving US health care▫ Participating in state-based PCMH demonstrations
•CMS Demo Stipulations▫Must include Commercial, Medicaid, Medicare patients▫Must be budget neutral over 3 years of project▫Must improve cost, quality, and patient experience
•8 states selected for participation, including Michigan•Michigan start date: January 1, 2012
8
MAPCP Demo: Participating States
•Maine 22 practices 42 (year 3)•Michigan 410 practices•Minnesota 159 practices 340 (year 3)•New York 35 practices•North Carolina 54 practices•Pennsylvania 78 practices•Rhode Island 13 practices•Vermont 110 practices 220 (year 3)_____________________________________________•TOTAL 881 practices 1,192 (year 3)
9
Michigan: Some fun facts
•Total population (2010 census): 9,883,640•11th largest state in the United States •Home to more than 11,000 lakes•The longest freshwater shoreline in the world•The largest State Forest system in the nation•Favorite vacation spot of Ernest Hemingway•Birthplace of Charles Lindbergh, Henry Ford, Stevie
Wonder, Gilda Radner, Madonna, “Magic” Johnson and (who can forget...) Alice Cooper
And, last but not least…
• Although Michigan is called the "Wolverine State" there are no longer any wolverines in Michigan
Michigan: Selected health statistics
•45th (of 50 states) in coronary heart disease deaths•41rd in percent of obese adults•34th in infant mortality rate•34th in percent of adults who smoke•34th in overall cancer death rate•20th in percent of adults who exercise regularly•12th in adults receiving colon cancer screening•5th in childhood immunization rate
Source: Comparison of Michigan Critical Health Indicators and Healthy People 2010 Targets, Michigan Department of Community Health, May 2011
The Michigan Primary Care Transformation (MiPCT) Model
The Vision for a Multi-Payer Model• Use the CMS Multi-Payer Advanced Primary Care
Practice demo as a catalyst to redesign MI primary care▫ Multiple payers will fund a common clinical model▫ Allows global primary care transformation efforts▫ Support development of evidence-based care models
• Create a model that can be broadly disseminated▫ Facilitate measurable, significant improvements in
population health for our Michigan residents▫ Bend the current (non-sustainable) cost curve▫ Contribute to national models for primary care redesign
• Form a strong foundation for successful ACO models
14
Guiding Principle: The “Triple Aim”
15
MiPCT Participants
16
Practice Participation Criteria
•PCMH-designated in 2010, and maintain PGIP or NCQA designation over the 3-year demonstration
•Part of a participating PO/PHO/IPA•Agree to work on the four selected focus initiatives:oCare Managemento Self-Management SupportoCare Coordinationo Linkage to Community Services
17
Participating Provider and Payer PartnersAs of April 2012
18
# Practices* # POs # Physicians # Payers
410 Practices 36 POs Over 1700 Physicians
4 (Medicaid, Medicare, BCBSM,
BCN)
*Choice of a January 1 or April 1 start date; no additional practice or PO starting date opportunities post 4/1/12
MiPCT Financial Model
19
MiPCT Funding Model
$0.26 pmpm Administrative Expenses$3.00 pmpm*, ** Care Management Support$1.50 pmpm*, ** Practice Transformation Reward$3.00 pmpm*, ** Performance Improvement$7.76 pmpm Total Payment by non-Medicare
Payers***
* Or equivalent** Plans with existing payments toward MiPCT components may
apply for and receive credits through review process*** Medicare will pay additional $2.00 PMPM to cover additional services for the aging population
20
MiPCT Clinical Model:Optimizing Patient Engagement, Improving Population Health
21
Developing a Framework to assist POs/PHOs/Practices with
MiPCT Population Management
•Build on the great work you’ve already done!
•Develop working definitions for MiPCT focus areas•Define evidence-based interventions and metrics for
each focus area, categorized by risk status and population tier
•Develop resources and training models to meet PO/PHO/practice needs
IV. Most complex
(e.g., Homeless,Schizophrenia)
III. ComplexComplex illness
Multiple Chronic DiseaseOther issues (cognitive, frail
elderly, social, financial)
II. Mild-moderate illnessWell-compensated multiple diseases
Single disease
I. Healthy Population
<1% of population Caseload 15-40
3-5% of population Caseload 50-200
50% of populationCaseload~1000
Managing Populations: Stratified approach to patient care and
care management
24
Health IT- Registry / EHR registry functionality * - Care management documentation *- E-prescribing (optional)- Patient portal (advanced/optional)- Community portal/HIE (adv/optional)- Home monitoring (advanced/optional)
Patient Access- 24/7 access to decision-maker * - 30% open access slots *- Extended hours *- Group visits (advanced/optional)- Electronic visits (advanced/optional)
Infrastructure Support- PO/PHO and practice determine
optimal balance of shared support - Patient risk assessment - Population stratification - Clinical metrics reporting
*denotes requirement by end of year 1
PCMH Services PCMH Infrastructure
Complex CareManagementFunctional Tier 4
All Tier 1-2-3 services plus: Home care team Comprehensive care plan Palliative and end-of life care
Care Management
Functional Tier 3
All Tier 1-2 services plus: Planned visits to optimize
chronic conditions Self-management support Patient education Advance directives
Transition Care
Functional Tier 2
All Tier 1 services plus: Notification of admit/discharge PCP and/or specialist follow-up Medication reconciliation
Navigating the Medical Neighborhood
Functional Tier 1
Optimize relationships withspecialists and hospitals
Coordinate referrals and tests Link to community resources
Prepared Proactive Healthcare TeamEngaging, Informing and Activating Patients
Michigan Primary Care Transformation Project Advancing Population Management
P O P U L A T I O N M A N A G E M E N T
MiPCT PO/Practice Expectations
•Care management▫Performed for appropriate high and moderate risk
individuals •Population management
▫Registry functionality by end of year 1▫Proactive patient outreach ▫Point of care alerts for services due
•Access improvement▫24/7 access to clinician▫30% same-day access▫Extended hours
25
MIPCT Joint PO/PHO and Practice Implementation Plan
•Overview of PO/PHO Role in MiPCT implementation
•High-level, jointly-developed Implementation Plan (one per practice)▫ Current and planned division of care management
responsibilities between Practice and PO▫ Care Management Staffing Plans▫ Practice Information (EHR, Registry, Key Contacts)
•Description of the planned distribution of care coordination and incentive payments between PO and practice
26
What can MiPCT practices expect?
•Additional resources available to help support team-based approach to care▫Develop a model that suits the unique
circumstances of each practice while maintaining consistency across state
▫Preserve local autonomy• Information for population management
▫Multi-payer claims based database▫Provide risk stratification, utilization reports
•Goal: To support Michigan primary care
27
Resources Available
28
29
www.mipctdemo.org
Care Management Resources
•Care Management Resource Center▫UMHS/BCBSM collaboration▫Web-based resource for templates, tools, evidence-based
information, care manager job descriptions, etc.▫Free care management consultation service▫Care management implementation guide
•Care Manager Training and Support▫National and local evidence-based models▫Also allow credit for existing PO/PHO training models
Team Development Resources
•Goal: Build on PCMH team-based capabilities▫Using team members to the maximum capability of
their roles and licenses▫Clearly define roles for physicians, nurses, medical
assistants, front office staff, and all other team members (social workers, pharmacists, dieticians, etc.)
•Facilitated learning opportunities for practice teams▫Examples: Learning Collaboratives, Lean workshops,
Practice Coaching, webinars and seminars▫Training contracts awarded to state resources
MDC – the Michigan Data Collaborative
32
The Michigan Data Collaborative (MDC) is a data collection and provisioning group at the University of Michigan.
•Collect claims data from Medicare, Medicaid, BCBSM, and BCN
•Collect other data such as registry, immunization, self-reported data, and others
•Build “multi-payer claims database”
•Create reports
•Provide reports and data to POs
Multi-Payer Claims Database
33
• Collect data from multiple Payers (insurance carriers) and aggregate it together in one database
Creates a more complete picture of a patient’s information when they:• Receive benefits from multiple insurance carriers
• Visit physicians from different Practices or Physician Organizations
Collects more complete information on a patient’s:• Procedures
• Diagnosis
• Visits
• Tests
• Test Results (if results are collected)
• Prescriptions (if Rx data are collected)
Multi-Payer Claims Database
Medicare
Medicaid BCN
BCBSM
MiPCT
Reporting
34
• Summary level and PO-specific
• Delivered to POs POs will distribute to Practices
PO
Multi-Payer Claims Database
datasets
reports
Practice Practice
Practice
Practice
Practice
Practice
Practice
datasets
reports
datasets
reports
PO PO
Retrospective Reports Quality and Utilization performance
metrics chosen for the project
Only claims-based metrics for Year 1• Requires 2-3 month run-out to ensure
availability of complete data
Prospective Reports Timely feedback about attributed
population for use in care management
• Providers are not being measured/scored
Incentive Payments Reports Incentive scores and payments
How Will We Define Success?
35
8
Source: Health2 Resources 9.30.08
MiPCT Builds Patient-Centered Medical Home Capacity in Michigan
Care Coordinatio
n
• Specialist care is coordinated, and systems are in place to prevent errors that occur when multiple physicians are involved.
• Follow-up and support is provided.
PatientFeedback
and Reporting Metrics
Team Care
• Integrated and coordinated team care depends on a free flow of communication among physicians, nurses, care managers, and other health professionals (including behavioral health professionals)
• Duplication of tests and procedures is avoided
• Patients are surveyed to assess their experience
• Performance on operational metrics is assessed regularly via a performance dashboard to ensure program integrity and inform improvement opportunities and budget neutrality
36
Success = Improvements in Population Health + Cost + Patient Experience
37
Reduction in Unnecessary and Non-Value-Added Costs
38
38
The tie to budget neutrality and ROI
Budget Neutrality and ROI
• Budget Neutrality ▫ The minimum required▫ Amount expended in additional payments to providers (practices
and POs) plus administrative costs must be equal to or less than the amount saved by avoiding unnecessary services (e.g., ambulatory care-sensitive ED visits and inpatient stays, redundant testing, etc.)
▫ Must trend toward budget neutrality at the end of Year Two (2013)
• ROI▫ The GOAL▫ “Return on Investment”▫ Saving more in avoidable costs than is spent on additional
payments to providers and administrative costs
39
Strategies for achieving…SHORT TERM SAVINGS
• High-risk patient intensive care management
• 24/7 clinical decision maker access to prevent unnecessary ED utilization and inpatient admissions
• Baseline data analysis for utilization outliers and focused root cause analysis
• Educate on evidence-based approaches to care (e.g., low back pain management)
LONG TERM SAVINGS• Focus on all “tiers” of patient
population
• Recognize and reward performance on intermediate markers of chronic conditions to prevent long-term complications (BP in diabetes, etc.)
• Focus on primary prevention/screening
• Work to build self-sustaining healthy communities
40
MiPCT Evaluation - Overview•Unprecedented opportunity to measure the
outcomes of investing in primary care across a diverse state
1. Quality, cost, efficiency2. Experience of care3. Population health
It’s about the relationship between the changes you make in the clinic and patient outcomes
What does this involve?•Statistical analysis of the effect of your work
(care management, care transitions, community linkages, IT, patient access) on quantifiable outcomes, using: ▫Claims data▫Clinical quality indicators▫Patient survey on experience of care▫Provider/clinic staff survey on work life satisfaction
•Key interviews and feedback gathering from practice and PO representatives
Summary
43
Key Dates
44
• Webinar Schedule (Select Thursdays, 3-5pm)• March 22 – Financial Reporting and Templates• Recommend your topics! We want to be helpful!
• CCM Rollout Training – 2 Q 2012
• Quarterly Report and Financial Templates• Quarter 1 (Due May 1, 2012): Brief interim reports• Quarter 2 (Due August 1, 2012): Documentation for the 6 month
performance incentive metrics• Quarter 3 (Due November 1, 2012): Brief interim reports• Quarter 4 (Due February 1, 2013): Updated Implementation Plans
• Incentive Metrics• Six month metrics (Jan-June 2012)• Twelve month metrics (August – December 2012)
•No magic bullet - the key to better health care delivery at lower cost will involve multiple solutions
•The Patient Centered Medical Home, as a foundation for the ACO/OSC model, offers one promising solution
•The Michigan Primary Care Transformation Project will help shape the future of primary care in our state
•TOGETHER, WE CAN MAKE A DIFFERENCE FOR MICHIGAN!!
45
MiPCT Contacts• MiPCT Demo Mailbox: [email protected]
• Carol Callaghan (Co-Chair) [email protected]
• Jean Malouin, MD MPH (Co-Chair, Medical Director) [email protected]
• Sue Moran (Co-Chair) [email protected]
• Diane Bechel Marriott, DrPH (Project Manager) [email protected]
46
Questions and Discussion
47