souk el khodra_sow223
TRANSCRIPT
-
8/2/2019 Souk El Khodra_SoW223
1/23
1
Community organizing:
Souk El Khodra of BeirutBy Ayman Knaifati
Haigazian University
SOW 223
Email:[email protected]
This report is bidirectional where it is used for two purposes. The first is to observe the
community under study Souk El Khodra, with an identified method for information
gathering of social, economic, and residential conditions. The second is to identify the
problems of the Souk and give valuable solutions for organizing and developing the Souk.
N.B: The file is attached with an illustrated map of the Souk and live Photographs.
mailto:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected] -
8/2/2019 Souk El Khodra_SoW223
2/23
2
Contents
Contents. 2
Preface.3
Introducing Souk El Khodra4
The Method used for gathering information6
The Observation..8
Defining the problems.11
Problems illustration and solutions suggested.12
Conclusion and Suggestions.16
Photography.17
-
8/2/2019 Souk El Khodra_SoW223
3/23
3
Preface
The first step one has to take in establishing a community profile is that of proceeding much
like a good journalist; walking through the area one is surveying and looking at it as though
through the lenses of a sensitive camera ( Allan Twelvetrees). Souk El Khorda of Beiruti
is the
community I have chosen to build my report on. Thus, and for the sake of a good information
gathering, I had to undergo certain procedures. First, I needed a new identity to enter the Souk
as an undercover reporter. Second, I had to learn about the Souks big vendors (the most
powerful and the oldest venders) so I would get significant and reliable information from them.
Third, I needed to find a perfect time where the Souk is not crowded in-order to take pictures
and be free to eye every corner in the Souk.
This report will focus on organizing, and widening the issue of Souk El Khodra, and to label its
problems and find the necessary solutions.
-
8/2/2019 Souk El Khodra_SoW223
4/23
4
Introducing Souk El Khodra
Souk El Khodra of Beirut is located near Madina Reyadiya near Hafez Al Assad high way (fig.
1)ii. Souk El Khodra is one of the oldest Souks in Beirut; it was established in 1948 that is 5
years after the declaration of the Lebanese independence 1943. As it is costumed in Arabic and
Islamic countries, the Souks are located near the big Mosques or by the big gates of a city. In
1894, Beirut Souks were named after the merchandises they display, for example; Souk El
Hariri (The Silk Market), Souk el Khodar (The vegetable Market), Souk El Sagha (The Jewelry
Market) or by the name of the craft, for example; Souk El Najjareen (The Carpenters Market),
Souk El Haddadeen (The Blacksmiths Market), or according to family names for example;
Souk Edrees, Souk El Twaini, Souk El Itani. Unfortunately, most of these Souks no longer exist
due to urbanization. On the other hand, new Souks has emerged which are more developed and
evolved such as, Souk Verdun street, Souk Hamra street, and Souk Mar Elyas Street.
Souk El Khodra is a public institution run by the Union of Fruits and Vegetables Vendors (fig.
2), which is run by a committee chair member Mohammad El Kaysi. The Souk is a market for
all kind of fruits and vegetables, not only Lebanese products but imports from broad countries
as well; Syria, Jordon, Egypt, Saudi Arabia. The most dominating vegetable is the Egyptian and
the Lebanese potato, the Lebanese Tomato comes next with the slight domination of Lebanese
Onion.
The Souk opens daily from 1:00 am and closes at 6 pm, with the exception of Saturday noon
where it closes and reopen again Monday morning 10:00 am. The Souk is well known with its
wide variety of fruits and vegetables; each vendor has his own store where he displays his
merchandise. Further illustration about the Souk is mentioned in the observation section.
-
8/2/2019 Souk El Khodra_SoW223
5/23
5
-
8/2/2019 Souk El Khodra_SoW223
6/23
6
The Method used for gathering information
It is somehow impossible to enter the Souk as a reporter and obtain the information you want, hence, the
vendors will not give you any information for they would think that you are from a government agency.
Their worst fear is the Ministry of Finance, and the Ministry of Health. Thus and by all means, I had to
go undercover as a worker who unloads the vegetables from the pickup trucks int o the stores attal.
Fortunately, I had a confederate who helped through introducing me to the store owners and vendors with
an undercover identity name as Mortada. Mohammad El Hammoud, my confederate and my first
connection into the Souk is a pickup truck owner; his job is to transport fruits and vegetables from one
place to another according to the buyer.
My first step was to be part of this community and to socialize with the vendors, the store owners, the
workers and most importantly the Union members. My first job was to unload a truck full of tomato into
the store of Walid Amairat (fig. 3); Walid Amairat is one of the oldest vendors in the Souk his expertise
are in Tomato, Potato and Onions.
The second step was to locate the significant observation points where I can take pictures, notes and
report the residential, economic, social condition of the Souk. (Further illustration is in the Observation).
Third step, is to find the specific time, by which I can walk and move freely in the Souk without drawing
any attention, after the deep research I find out that Friday 11:30 am is the perfect time to start my
observation hence most the Souks vendors would be at the Mosque; Fridays Prayer.
-
8/2/2019 Souk El Khodra_SoW223
7/23
7
1
During my undercover mission, I had to unload a pickup truck full of tomato in Malek
Omairats store. We were three workers unloading the truck; Mohammad Hammoud my
confederate who helped me get the job, myself and a 15 years old child! I was barely able to lift
two boxes of tomato, where my partner Ahmad (15 years old) was lifting 3 to 4 boxes of tomato.
Note that the box of tomato is about 15 kilos, as a result a 15 years old was lifting about 45 kilos
in every round. I tried to have a conversation with Ahmad, and I knew that he is a 15 years old
school dropout from a village in Syria who came to Lebanon to get money for his family. Note
that for every truck Ahmad (the workers) unload will get them 5000 L.L
1 (Fig. 3) My first job to be familiarize with the Souks Vendors for later observation plan
-
8/2/2019 Souk El Khodra_SoW223
8/23
8
The Observation [Friday, 11:30 pm]
(Attached map of the Souk at the end of the file)
Souk El Khodra has 4 gates, one on each corner, one main gate (fig. 4) and three other
peripherals. When you enter the gate you will be annoyed with the awful smell of vegetables
and fruit waste that are found everywhere in the Souk (fig.5). Beside the main gate, there is the
first parking lot (fig. 6), where it is used in an unorganized fashion by the store owners and
vendors cars. On the left you will notice a small timeworn building used as a police station.
There are only 3 police members currently organizing the Souk, the chief of policeAbu Hassan
is always present at the main gate sitting down inefficiently drinking his coffee and smoking his
cigarettes, while the other two would be roaming around the Souk. After the first parking lot,
you will not miss the awful smell of urine and dump in the little cabinet that is called a
bathroom (fig.7). The bathroom has 3 small cabinets, there is a man sitting beside the bathroom
that get paid 500 L.L for every person who wants to use the bathroom. Thus, the Souk workers
do not use the given bathroom so they wont pay 500 L.L; they go to the walls and dumpsters of
the Souk and use it as a free bathroom. The second parking lot is located beside the dumpster
and it used by the Transporting Trucks, their job is to transport fruits and vegetables from one
place to another according to the buyer. All of the roads are in an awful condition, an average of
30 cm holes in the ground full of dirty water, vegetable and fruit wastes. The cars and pickups
barley can move through it (fig. 8).
The Souk is divided into Easter and Western Rows, both rows contain the stores that display the
fruits and vegetables. Between the rows comes an alley (fig.9), a very tight terrible condition
road (cant fit a car); they use it to dump their waste from the both side stores, or to display their
merchandise. The alleys are very dangerous for strangers, thus it is full with drug dealers and
-
8/2/2019 Souk El Khodra_SoW223
9/23
9
prisons breakers. You will notice at the corner of the alley, a 14 years old Syrian child
delivering coffee and tea to the vendors (fig.10). What makes the peripheral roads and the alleys
even close-fitted is the door steps of the stores that are being illegally rented to Syrian vendors
to display their merchandises. Referring to my confederateMohammad Hammoud, who has
been working in the Souk for 3 years; the store owners rent their doorsteps for 100 to 150 $ per
week. According toMohammad Hammoudthe venders are demographically divided as:
Majority Kurdish( Sunni) store owners/ old Vendors.
Minority Shiaworkers and few store owners
Different nationalities and ethnicity Mostly Syrian and Palestinians
Between the alleys there is a main road that is used by the pickup trucks to unload the fruits and
vegetables into the stores. According toAli Barakat, a store owner on the second Easter row,
the road is tight and in a very bad condition that can only let one pickup to pass, thus it makes a
terrible traffic, where the costumers and pickup trucks have to wait till the pickup unloads its
boxes (fig. 11).
On the left side of the Souk, there is a parking lot used by costumers and pickup owners. The
condition of this parking lot is somehow acceptable, no dumpsters are found, and the road is in
a fine condition in comparison to the other roads, according to my confederate that is because
this parking lot is rarely used since it is located away from the stores. Other than costumers
cars and pickups, there are two bulldozers and one pickup that are used to clean the dumpster in
the Souk. The Bulldozers are in a bad condition, one bulldozer is mechanically worn out, and
the second does the job for the two. (Fig. 12)
-
8/2/2019 Souk El Khodra_SoW223
10/23
10
The Union of Fruit and Vegetable Vendors is located outside the Souk; it is an old worn-out
empty building. The chair personMohammad El kaysi comes to check on the Souk every
Monday, where he supposed to stay in his daily job in the Union building. My confederate
Mohammad Hammoud states that, the dumpster pickup trucks and bulldozers who are
supposed to be on the work daily, do not work but on Monday when the chairperson of the
union visit. In addition, the two officers who are supposed to organize the traffic do not take
their jobs seriously until the appearance of Mr. Kaysi.
-
8/2/2019 Souk El Khodra_SoW223
11/23
11
Defining the problems
A. Unorganized Parking lotB. Lack of members and organization in the Police stationC. Health problems and waste in the BathroomsD. Roads are in a very bad conditionsE. Illegal door step rental in alleysF. The Eastern alley is very tight due of dumpster and doorstep rentalsG. Unorganized, unhealthy dumpsters (fig.13)H. Traffic problems due to road bad conditionI. Lack of tools and facilities.J. Child labor
Note: as it is noticed, the problems are the cause and effect of each others. i.e.: if problem F
was solved problem G will be consequently out of the picture etc.
-
8/2/2019 Souk El Khodra_SoW223
12/23
12
Problems illustration and solutions suggested
Significant questions are asked; what seem to be visible problems or issues in the Souk? Is it a
stable area? Is the area in transition, improving, deteriorating? What areas of community
capacity need to be developed so that these problems or issues can be dealt with?
These questions can be answered after identifying the visible problems of the Souk and working
out a solution with an organized developmental plan.
A. Unorganized parking lots:There are four parking lots areas in the Souk; the store owners cars area, the transporting trucks
area, the pickup trucks area, and the area used for costumers. The problem with in these lots, is
not because they do not have enough area, however, the problem lies in the unorganized area.
There is enough parking lot area in the Souk and maybe it is more than enough. In an interview
with 3 pickup owners and 2 costumers, they assert that the problem is in the way the pickups
park. After reviewing the map of the souk, a solution was on hand; the four parking lot space
could be joined into two big parking lots; one for the costumers and one for the trucks. A
solution we discussed is to be organized as follows:
The Main gate parking lot used by the Vendor and store owners should be canceled, thus is it
the main problem of traffic. The Vendors can park their cars in the pickup truck area where
there is enough space for them. On the other hand, the parking lot of the costumers should
remain in tacked.
B. Lack of members and organization in the Police station:Organizing a police station would be somehow impossible because of the political division in
the station where; the chief of PoliceAbu Hassan is supported by Tayyar El Mustaqbal and the
-
8/2/2019 Souk El Khodra_SoW223
13/23
13
two other officers are fromHaraket Aamal. However, a simple solution I suggested, where we
mention this problem to the Unions chair-personMohammad El Kaysi, who is supported by
Tayyar El Mustaqbal as well, who can talk to the chief of police and let him organize his station
and no political sensitive issue would occur hence both are from the same party. As the political
sensitivity is out of our way, we can start organizing the station by getting new officer members
to the Souk; two members fromHaraket Amal and two from Tayar El Mustaqbal.
C. Health problems and waste in the bathroomThe smell of the bathrooms is intolerable, waste is every, the cabinets are in awful condition. A
health inspector is needed. A petition should be claimed to the Ministry of Health to take upon
this issue. Meanwhile, the main problem of the bathrooms is their 500 L.L entrance; most
workers do not want to pay to go the bathroom, so they go to the alleys and the walls of the
Souk, which creates another health problem. A police officer should be on guard for such
situation.
D. Roads are in a very bad conditions:If problem A is fixed, which is organizing the parking lots, problem D would be the next step
for development. Thus, with the help of the Works Ministry, the roads can be fixed easily if
there were serious complaints from the Souk members and costumers. Therefore, a program of
awareness should be initiated to let the Souk vendors be aware of the major problems they have.
If the roads were fixed, the pickups will easily unload its merchandises, and that will financially
turn to the store owners who by that time can unload several trucks in one day.
-
8/2/2019 Souk El Khodra_SoW223
14/23
14
E. Illegal door-steps rental in the alleys:According to eye witnesses, the municipality does not know about this illegal renting, and if
they do they are being bribe to stay silent. Thus, the Finance Ministry should be aware of the
problem where by their own means they can work it out with the municipality.
F. The Eastern alley is very tight due of dumpster and doorstep rentalsThe alley has become a dumpster for the store owners, although there is a dumpster in the Souk
behind the pickup trucks parking lot. It is obvious that the Souk dumpster does not fit the waste
from the Souk. Therefore, a Sukleen shifts should accommodate the Souk daily to clean away
the main dumpster. On the other hand, the vendors should be alerted that dumping their wastes
in the alleys will negatively turn upon their business, and if they could dump into the dumpster
instead of the alley they would have enough and clean healthy place to display their fruits and
vegetables.
G. Unorganized and unhealthy dumpsterH. Traffic problems due to road bad condition
If problem F is solves, then there would be no problem in G, consequently; if problem D was
fixed, there wouldnt be traffic problems.
I. Lack of tools and facilities:It is shown in the observation that there are only two bulldozers and one pickup truck for the
dumpster. One of the bulldozers is mechanically worn-out. At least two brand new bulldozers
and two new pickup trucks should be provided to the Souk in order to keep it clean. In addition,
a water tank should be provided to clean up the streets of the Souk daily at 6 pm.
-
8/2/2019 Souk El Khodra_SoW223
15/23
15
J. Child laborThe United Nations and the International Labor Organization consider child labor exploitative
with the UN stipulating, in article 32 of the Convention on the Rights of the Child that:
..States Parties recognize the right of the child to be protected from economic exploitation and
from performing any work that is likely to be hazardous or to interfere with the child's
education, or to be harmful to the child's health or physical, mental, spiritual, moral or social
development. Although globally there is an estimated 250 million children working
Thus and by all means, the Ministry of Social affairs should visit the Souk and see not only
child labor, but also the dangerous situations the child is working at (fig.10).
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_Nationshttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/International_Labor_Organizationhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Convention_on_the_Rights_of_the_Childhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Convention_on_the_Rights_of_the_Childhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/International_Labor_Organizationhttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_Nations -
8/2/2019 Souk El Khodra_SoW223
16/23
16
Conclusion and suggestions
After the observation, identifying the problems and giving solutions, there is ought to be a
suggestion given;
Regardless of the 9 main problems the Souk has, one problem remains. One problem which is
one of the most significant problems occur in all community development; Organization.
Organization is the main problem of the Souk, with good organizing and planning the Souk will
overcome its current problems. Organizing a certain community should be upon certain rules: iii
1. There should be an individual effort and will to organize and develop the Souk2. If the organization doesnt grow it will die.3. The most important victory is the Souk itself.4. If youre not fighting for what you want, you dont want enough
Suggestion
Reorganize the Union of Fruits and Vegetables, make up a meeting with the members,( I advise
to advocate new members) let there be daily shifts in the Union. Let the people be motivated by
their self-interests. Let there be awareness campaigns to all members, thus it's important that, at
an early stage of the development of any group, they learn to deal with conflict and
confrontation.
-
8/2/2019 Souk El Khodra_SoW223
17/23
17
iv
v
-
8/2/2019 Souk El Khodra_SoW223
18/23
18
vi
vii
-
8/2/2019 Souk El Khodra_SoW223
19/23
19
viii
ix
-
8/2/2019 Souk El Khodra_SoW223
20/23
20
x
-
8/2/2019 Souk El Khodra_SoW223
21/23
21
xi
xii
-
8/2/2019 Souk El Khodra_SoW223
22/23
22
xiii
-
8/2/2019 Souk El Khodra_SoW223
23/23
i Souk El Khodra : is an Arabic Term for a Vegetable and Fruit Market, where all vendors accumulate in one place
to sell their fruits and vegetables.ii A Satellite image by Google Maps locating Souk El Khodra.
iiiCommunity Organizing: http://comm-org.wisc.edu/papers97/beckwith.htm
iv (fig. 4) The Main Gate of the Soukv (fig.5) The Fruits and Vegetable waste you find on the groundvi (fig.6) The unorganized Parking Lotvii (fig.7) Bathroomsviii (fig.8) the holes in the ground shows the condition of the roads in the Soukix (fig.9) The Alley of the Souk
x ( fig. 10) a 14 years old working in the worse awful conditions.xi (fig.11) the main road Traffic problemxii (fig.12) Two bulldozers and one pickup truck used to clean the dumpster. One bulldozer is in an awful condition.
xiii (fig. 13) unorganized, unhealthy dumpster.
http://comm-org.wisc.edu/papers97/beckwith.htmhttp://comm-org.wisc.edu/papers97/beckwith.htm