selling your project to the board

93
SELLING A PROJECT TO YOUR COUNCIL OR BOARD Brian Gongol DJ Gongol & Associates, Inc. August 27, 2014 Iowa AWWA Short Course

Upload: brian-gongol

Post on 25-Jun-2015

7.962 views

Category:

Engineering


2 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Selling your project to the board

SELLING A PROJECT TOYOUR COUNCIL OR BOARD

Brian GongolDJ Gongol & Associates, Inc.

August 27, 2014

Iowa AWWA Short Course

Page 2: Selling your project to the board

A preview

Funding considerations Getting the board...on board Helping the board win over the public Funding strategies Funding sources

Page 3: Selling your project to the board

FUNDING CONSIDERATIONS

Page 4: Selling your project to the board

Three elements of financial success

Recognize value Think long-term Recognize what's extraordinary about your own times

Page 5: Selling your project to the board

Today's interest rates are at long-term lows

Page 6: Selling your project to the board

Costs after inflation

Page 7: Selling your project to the board

Borrowing for 30 years around 1975

Page 8: Selling your project to the board

QE/tapering -- what it all means

Page 9: Selling your project to the board

Setting your rates for water services

Page 10: Selling your project to the board

Slow, predictable increases

Page 11: Selling your project to the board

Not big jumps every 5-10 years

Page 12: Selling your project to the board

Buy right, not just cheap

Page 13: Selling your project to the board

Borrow when you don't need the money

Page 14: Selling your project to the board

Match costs and payments to the life cycle

Page 15: Selling your project to the board

How to get what you really need

Sometimes there's an "or equal"...sometimes there's not

Page 16: Selling your project to the board

Continuous improvement

Lean operations Life-cycle costs

Page 17: Selling your project to the board

GETTING THE BOARD ON BOARD

Page 18: Selling your project to the board

Show how your problem is their problem

Or how they have a problemand you can help them steer clear

Page 19: Selling your project to the board

The illusion of choice: Two options

Page 20: Selling your project to the board

The illusion of choice: Three options

Page 21: Selling your project to the board

What's the worst that could happen?

Page 22: Selling your project to the board

Make them feel the real hazards of inaction

Page 23: Selling your project to the board

Actual liability

Page 24: Selling your project to the board

Insurance costs

Page 25: Selling your project to the board

Headline risk

Page 26: Selling your project to the board

Help them take credit for successes

Page 27: Selling your project to the board

Demonstrate payoffs

Page 28: Selling your project to the board

Nothing works as well as hands-on exposure

Page 29: Selling your project to the board

Host a lunch or a party

Page 30: Selling your project to the board

If there's resistance, ask why

Make them prove your point:Do they think your workplace is unpleasant?

If so, all the more reason to fix it.

Page 31: Selling your project to the board

A challenge to us all

Brightwater WWTF (King County, Washington)hosts parties and wedding receptions

Page 32: Selling your project to the board

Small commitments: Get them in the door

Page 33: Selling your project to the board

Why car dealers offer test drives

A trial implies commitment, andcommitment cries out for consistency

Page 34: Selling your project to the board

Everyone falls for "multiplier effects"

Since 1997, the average NFL stadiumhas been 56% public-funded

Page 35: Selling your project to the board

Skip the word "environment"

Talk about public health

Page 36: Selling your project to the board

Open with a big request

No exaggeration required Then retreat to what's really necessary

Page 37: Selling your project to the board

Acknowledge real limitations they face

Page 38: Selling your project to the board

Cultivate a fiduciary mentality

Page 39: Selling your project to the board

Benchmark against your neighbors

Peer groups of comparable communities

Page 40: Selling your project to the board

TO THE PUBLIC AT LARGE

Page 41: Selling your project to the board

Tailor your message to community values

Page 42: Selling your project to the board

Iowa City and Grinnell

Environment Climate change Ecosystems

Page 43: Selling your project to the board

Council Bluffs, Des Moines, Cedar Rapids

Levees Recovery Backups Urban improvement Tax base

Page 44: Selling your project to the board

Northwest Iowa

Heritage of service Obligations Independence

Page 45: Selling your project to the board

Put spending in context

How many dollars is a 10% increase, really?

Page 46: Selling your project to the board

Be sensitive to fixed-income households

Page 47: Selling your project to the board

Don't let a "water is free" mentality take root

Page 48: Selling your project to the board

The default opt-in trick

Look carefully at your next hotel bill

Page 49: Selling your project to the board

Context, context, context

"Be fearful when others are greedy,and greedy when others are fearful."

- Warren Buffett

Page 50: Selling your project to the board

Water vs. other costs per gallon

Page 51: Selling your project to the board

Water towers vs. cost of fire protection

Page 52: Selling your project to the board

Sewers vs. time cost of septic systems

Page 53: Selling your project to the board

How old is it?

Are your pumps from the Cold War?

Page 54: Selling your project to the board

How old is it?

Are your valves as old as disco?

Page 55: Selling your project to the board

How old is it?

Are your mains from before WWII?

Page 56: Selling your project to the board

Visibility

Any idiot can recognize a broken bridge

Page 57: Selling your project to the board

Visibility

Any dunce can seeand feel a pothole

Page 58: Selling your project to the board

Visibility

But by design, nobody sees underground utilities

Page 59: Selling your project to the board

People don't vote for water

Don't ask people to vote for water Ask them to vote for fire protection, public health, and jobs

Page 60: Selling your project to the board

Cultivate a sense of ownership

Page 61: Selling your project to the board

FUNDING STRATEGIES

Page 62: Selling your project to the board

Buy from cash

Page 63: Selling your project to the board

Buy with debt

Page 64: Selling your project to the board

Buy with grants

Page 65: Selling your project to the board

Rent (short-term)

Page 66: Selling your project to the board

Lease (long-term)

Page 67: Selling your project to the board

Don't fear the leaser (er...lessor)

A third of all airliners are leased worldwide Railroad cars are also heavily leased Most office space is leased

Page 68: Selling your project to the board

Leasing algebra

Cost of management/depreciation/upkeep + profit<

Customer's cost to learn and do same

Page 69: Selling your project to the board

Lease to own

Page 70: Selling your project to the board

Shared ownership / buying clubs

Page 71: Selling your project to the board

28E

The purpose of this chapter is to permitstate and local governments in Iowa

to make efficient use of their powers byenabling them to provide joint services and facilities

with other agencies and to cooperatein other ways of mutual advantage.

This chapter shall be liberally construed to that end.

Page 72: Selling your project to the board

Privatization

Page 73: Selling your project to the board

FUNDING SOURCES

Page 74: Selling your project to the board

For each source, consider your constraints

Page 75: Selling your project to the board

Maximum amount available

Page 76: Selling your project to the board

Minimum commitment required

Page 77: Selling your project to the board

Time horizon

Page 78: Selling your project to the board

Looking for money in all the right places

Page 79: Selling your project to the board

Debt

Page 80: Selling your project to the board

Grants

Page 81: Selling your project to the board

Green funding

Page 82: Selling your project to the board

Emergency/disaster-preparedness funding

Page 83: Selling your project to the board

SRF

Page 84: Selling your project to the board

USDA

Page 85: Selling your project to the board

CDBG

Page 86: Selling your project to the board

WIFIA

Page 87: Selling your project to the board

Rainy-day fund

Page 88: Selling your project to the board

Capital improvements fund

Page 89: Selling your project to the board

Municipal bonds

Page 90: Selling your project to the board

To recap

Know what's extraordinary about your times Think ahead and make it easy to agree with you Get people on board as automatically as possible Consider all of your available strategies Consider all potential funding sources

Page 91: Selling your project to the board

Questions?

Thank you for coming!

Page 92: Selling your project to the board

Thank you for your attention!

Contact us anytime with questions

Brian Gongol DJ Gongol & Associates 515-223-4144 [email protected]

Page 93: Selling your project to the board

References:

Municipal bonds http://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/graph/?g=IpZ

http://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/graph/?g=Iq3

Money velocity http://research.stlouisfed.org/fred2/graph/?g=Iq5

WWTF as wedding venue http://www.kirotv.com/news/news/sewage-treatment-plant-advertises-wedding-venue/nfW7K/

http://www.kingcounty.gov/environment/wtd/Construction/North/Brightwater.aspx

Airliner leases: http://www.economist.com/node/21543195

Public financing of stadiums: http://cbsminnesota.files.wordpress.com/2011/12/nfl-funding-summary-12-2-11.pdf

Jimmy Carter photograph: http://www.loc.gov/pictures/item/96522672/

Harry Truman photograph: http://www.trumanlibrary.org/photographs/view.php?id=2267

Margaret Thatcher photograph: http://www.loc.gov/pictures/item/2005696424/

Bill Gates photograph: http://www.microsoft.com/en-us/news/exec/billg/images.aspx

All other photos are original work by and copyright reserved to Brian Gongol