results of bacteriological and cytological examinations of ... · examinations of the endometrium...

2
Results of bacteriological and cytological examinations of the endometrium of mares in a practice in Denmark and in Central Kentucky, USA. Ansager Dyrehospital (Ansager Large Animal Hospital), Gartnerhaven 5, DK-6823 Ansager,cvDenmark. 2 Maxwell H. Gluck Equine Research Center, Department of Veterinary Science, University of Kentucky, Lexington, KY 404435-0099, USA. Hagyard Equine Medical Institute, 4250 Iron Woks Pike, Lexington, Kentucky 40511- 8412, USA. Since endometrial cytology was first described as a diagnostic aid in evaluating potential endometrial inflammation 1 , it has become a routine tool in clinical equine reproduction. The presence of polymorph nucleated leucocytes (PMNs), indicating uterine inflammation, can be identified by light microscopy and decisions in regards to the reproductive management of the mare can be made instantly, without having to wait for culture results. The objective of this study was to compare results of endometrial cytology and bacteriology from samples obtained at two practices, in Kentucky, USA and in Denmark. Samples from the endometrium were obtained by endometrial swabs in the Kentucky practice (n=550 samples), and by endometrial biopsy in the Danish practice (n=352). Results of bacteriological and cytological examination from the two practices were compared. A higher proportion of culture negative, but cytology positive samples were found in the practice using endometrial swabs (26%) versus biopsies (3 %), (P<0.0001). In both practices, when EColi was isolated, a positive cytology sample was less likely to be identified, than if other bacterial species were isolated. This observation was statistically significant in samples obtained both in Kentucky (P<0,05) and in Denmark (P<0.0001). The significant higher number of culture negative, but cytology positive samples found using endometrial swabs compared to biopsies could not be explained by a difference in the standards between the two laboratories in diagnosing a positive sample. A more plausible explanation for the observed difference is a higher sensitivity in detecting bacteria from endometrial biopsies compared to swabs samples. This has previously been described. 2 . When bacteria other than E Coli were cultured, it was often paralleled by a positive cytology. It could be speculated, if different species of bacteria are causing different inflammatory response in the endometrium of the mare. This observation is supported by a recent work by Bindslev et a/ 3 who documented that it was less likely to find PMN's in a cytology sample, when E Coli was cultured, compared toif Strep Equi spp. Zooepidemicus was cultured.

Upload: others

Post on 18-Aug-2020

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Results of bacteriological and cytological examinations of ... · examinations of the endometrium of mares in a practice in Denmark and in Central Kentucky, USA. Ansager Dyrehospital

Results of bacteriological and cytologicalexaminations of the endometrium of mares in apractice in Denmark and in Central Kentucky,USA.

Ansager Dyrehospital (Ansager Large Animal Hospital), Gartnerhaven 5, DK-6823Ansager,cvDenmark.

2 Maxwell H. Gluck Equine Research Center, Department of Veterinary Science,University of Kentucky, Lexington, KY 404435-0099, USA.Hagyard Equine Medical Institute, 4250 Iron Woks Pike, Lexington, Kentucky 40511-8412, USA.

Since endometrial cytology was first described as a diagnostic aid in evaluatingpotential endometrial inflammation 1

, it has become a routine tool in clinical equinereproduction. The presence of polymorph nucleated leucocytes (PMNs), indicatinguterine inflammation, can be identified by light microscopy and decisions in regards tothe reproductive management of the mare can be made instantly, without having to waitfor culture results.

The objective of this study was to compare results of endometrial cytology andbacteriology from samples obtained at two practices, in Kentucky, USA and in Denmark.Samples from the endometrium were obtained by endometrial swabs in the Kentuckypractice (n=550 samples), and by endometrial biopsy in the Danish practice (n=352).Results of bacteriological and cytological examination from the two practices werecompared.

A higher proportion of culture negative, but cytology positive samples were found in thepractice using endometrial swabs (26%) versus biopsies (3 %), (P<0.0001). In bothpractices, when EColi was isolated, a positive cytology sample was less likely to beidentified, than if other bacterial species were isolated. This observation was statisticallysignificant in samples obtained both in Kentucky (P<0,05) and in Denmark (P<0.0001).The significant higher number of culture negative, but cytology positive samples foundusing endometrial swabs compared to biopsies could not be explained by a difference inthe standards between the two laboratories in diagnosing a positive sample. A moreplausible explanation for the observed difference is a higher sensitivity in detectingbacteria from endometrial biopsies compared to swabs samples. This has previouslybeen described.2.

When bacteria other than E Coli were cultured, it was often paralleled by a positivecytology. It could be speculated, if different species of bacteria are causing differentinflammatory response in the endometrium of the mare. This observation is supportedby a recent work by Bindslev et a/3 who documented that it was less likely to findPMN's in a cytology sample, when E Coli was cultured, compared to if Strep Equi spp.Zooepidemicus was cultured.

Page 2: Results of bacteriological and cytological examinations of ... · examinations of the endometrium of mares in a practice in Denmark and in Central Kentucky, USA. Ansager Dyrehospital

but gram negatives with more tenacious secretions. Extracellular products of somebacteria may thus alter the rheological properties of mucus, rendering cilia unable topropel uterine exudate.