newsletters newsletters unleash the power of your donor newsletter... and raise lots of money! by...
TRANSCRIPT
NewslettersNewslettersUnleash the power of your donor newsletter ...
and raise lots of money!
by Tom Ahern
1© 2011 Tom Ahern | www.aherncomm.com
Retention stinks
2© 2011 Tom Ahern | www.aherncomm.com
© 2011 Tom Ahern | www.aherncomm.com 3
>> 72% of newly acquired donors disappear after year 1; by year 2, the # of departed has risen to 94%
REAL & recent retention numbers for a respected agency that serves the poor and desperate effectively in NC...
© 2011 Tom Ahern | www.aherncomm.com 4
Cost to acquire a new donor:
$52Average new gift:
$25
© 2011 Tom Ahern | www.aherncomm.com 5
Need a tattoo?Every donor who does
not make a 2nd gift costs your org. $27.
Improved retention is a mathematical imperative.
6© 2011 Tom Ahern | www.aherncomm.com
You acquire 100 new donors...
1st year average gift of $25 = $2,5002nd year (28% remain) = $7003rd year (6% remain) = $150
You spent $5,200 to gain $3,350 over 3 years. Improved retention is your best source of new income ... not acquisition.
7
A 10% improvement in your donor retention improves your revenue 50% immediately.
And that’s just the beginning....
8© 2011 Tom Ahern | www.aherncomm.com
Source: Adrian Sargeant, 2010
Purpose of a donor newsletter
Job #1: Retain more donors
Job #2: Make more money
Don’t reverse the order.
© 2011 Tom Ahern | www.aherncomm.com 9
Purpose: To praise donors
Not the purpose: To sell
Not the purpose: To “educate”
Not the purpose: To brag
© 2011 Tom Ahern | www.aherncomm.com 10
11
Donors want just a few things from you
They want to feel good.They want to feel loved.They want to feel smart.
They want to feel needed.They want to feel important.
They want to belong.They want to be remembered.
12
Appeals, thanks, & newsletters work together.
You ask. You thank. You report.You ask. You thank. You report.You ask. You thank. You report.
13
The virtuous circle...
Actually...
You ask (and flatter).You thank (and flatter).You report (and flatter).
You cannot flatter too much.
14
© 2011 Tom Ahern | www.aherncomm.com 15
“Even when people perceive that flattery is insincere, that flattery can still leave a lasting and positive impression of the flatterer.”
16
Source: Neuromarketing blog
17
What does raising $500,000/yr
from 10,000 readers
look like?
Paper or electrons? (Both.)
Reviewing information on paper produces more emotional processing than viewing the same information on screen.
And emotional processing is critical to giving.
18
Source: Neuroscience blog; 2011 via Joyaux Associates newsletter
© 2011 Tom Ahern | www.aherncomm.com
“People use the Web. They read paper.”
19© 2011 Tom Ahern | www.aherncomm.com
Source: TJ Larkin, via Ann Wylie
20
21
22
23
Before
After
Domain’s proven formula:
• 11x17 format, folding to 4 8.5x11 pages• 6 pages is OK, 2 pages is not, 8 pages is not• one-color, two-color, full-color• NOT a self-mailer• mail in a #10 envelope: “Your newsletterenclosed.”• send exclusively to current donors• include a reply envelope and reply device• mail as often as possible• use the newsletter for “impact reporting”
24
25© 2011 Tom Ahern | www.aherncomm.com
26
Most important secret to success EVER!!!!!
Your newsletter is NOT about how wonderful your organization is.
Your newsletter IS about how wonderful your donors are.
27
28
29
30
31
32
© 2011 Tom Ahern | www.aherncomm.com 33
Most important secret to success EVER!!!!!
Your newsletter is NOT about how wonderful your organization is.
Your newsletter IS about how wonderful your donors are.
34
“Do they know that the success of our
mission depends on their donations?”
© 2011 Tom Ahern | www.aherncomm.com
Or are you sending exactly the wrong message...
© 2011 Tom Ahern | www.aherncomm.com 35
Readers read at 100 mph. The big check says, “Problem solved!”
36© 2011 Tom Ahern | www.aherncomm.com
37
Anatomy of a failed front page...
© 2011 Tom Ahern | www.aherncomm.com
38
30 people felt good
about this page, if
they saw it
The magic word “you” appears nowhere
Excludes everyone but attendees© 2011 Tom Ahern | www.aherncomm.com
© 2011 Tom Ahern | www.aherncomm.com 39
“Case closed” headline
© 2011 Tom Ahern | www.aherncomm.com 40
...and a good time was had by all...
• A personal sense of satisfaction.• The ability to tell others about what I’ve done.• The knowledge that I am helping people, advancing a
cause or making a difference.• The opportunity to find out more about an
organization or cause (and engage more deeply).• The opportunity to do it all again.
41
Elements of a good donor experience
Source: Chuck English, via The Agitator
42
E-newsletters
E-newsletters are action-oriented
• Adopt an urgent theme. NOT “the July newsletter.” INSTEAD: the “Surge newsletter,” “Food shortage newsletter,” “Back to school newsletter.”
• Give your readers 3-5 actions related to the topic, for instance: Find out more. | Donate now. | Buy something like a backpack. | Browse current needs. | Watch a video online.
Source: Jeff Brooks’ Power Blog July 2009
43© 2011 Tom Ahern | www.aherncomm.com
© 2011 Tom Ahern | www.aherncomm.com 44
Bad e-news:
Little to click, lots to read
© 2011 Tom Ahern | www.aherncomm.com 45
“Sent to 1,871 addresses, 21% opening rate, ZERO gifts. Why?!?”
• Subject line: “We’re great.”• Wrong SMIT. Right SMIT?
“You, the donor, are a wonderful human being.”
• Unsure what it is: newsletter, appeal?
• Dense paragraphs defeat skimming.
• 1st 3 paragraphs are about the org., not the donor.
• Built for readers, not clickers.
• Not donor-centred.
© 2011 Tom Ahern | www.aherncomm.com 46
47
Source: Kathy Swayze, CFRE; Impact Communications
48© 2011 Tom Ahern | www.aherncomm.com
49© 2011 Tom Ahern | www.aherncomm.com
Source: Jeff Brooks blog
ContentContent
51© 2011 Tom Ahern | www.aherncomm.com
52
It is not pure reporting.
It’s reporting crossed with a birthday card to your mom.
© 2011 Tom Ahern | www.aherncomm.com
© 2011 Tom Ahern | www.aherncomm.com 53
Thought for today....
Write drunk.Edit sober.
(Psssst)
Almost no one reads the articles.
54© 2011 Tom Ahern | www.aherncomm.com
55
What do “readers” really see• Artwork: 80 percent
• Photos: 75 percent
• Headlines: 56 percent
• Briefs: 31 percent
• Captions: 29 percent
• Text: 25 percent*
*This number is abnormally high, according to Poynter Institute researchers. They tested prototypes rather than actual publications. Prototypes invariably produce higher, more positive numbers than real publications. Source: Ann Wylie
Vögele’s eye motion study
56
© 2011 Tom Ahern | www.aherncomm.com 57
Almost everyone
looks at this
About a third read
this
Almost no one reads much of
this
© 2011 Tom Ahern | www.aherncomm.com 58
The fatal flaw in most donor newsletters are the headlines.
They’re self-serving, fake, weak, or non-existent.
59
This is big type. It is not a headline.
© 2011 Tom Ahern | www.aherncomm.com 60
Not a headline
61
Not a headline
Not a headline
62
Great photo…great recognition…but what’s the story?
63
Headline source: Newsweek
Is Your Baby Racist?Exploring the Roots of Discrimination
© 2011 Tom Ahern | www.aherncomm.com
© 2011 Tom Ahern | www.aherncomm.com 64
Editor: Jeff Hall
65
Before
After© 2011 Tom Ahern | www.aherncomm.com
66
Before
After© 2011 Tom Ahern |
www.aherncomm.com
After: Income doubled immediately
© 2011 Tom Ahern | www.aherncomm.com 67
A good donor headline:
(1) captures the gist of the story
(2) has a hook
(3) applauds the donor
I want to feel good I want to feel good about giving.about giving.
Source: Key donor desires, from Ken Burnett’s The Zen of Fundraising
68© 2011 Tom Ahern | www.aherncomm.com
69© 2011 Tom Ahern | www.aherncomm.com
70© 2011 Tom Ahern | www.aherncomm.com
Instant headlines: Just fill in the blanks
• The Secret of [blank]
• Get Rid of [problem] Once and For All
• [Do something] like [world-class example]
• Have a [or] Build a [blank] You Can Be Proud Of
• The Lazy [blank's] Way to [blank]
• Do You Recognize the [number] Early Warning Signs of [blank]?
• You Don't Have to Be [something challenging] to be [desired result].
Source: Kivi Leroux Miller, from Copyblogger
71© 2011 Tom Ahern | www.aherncomm.com
Kivi’s favorite instant newsletter articles
• How-to article
• List (e.g. Top Ten)
• Fact Versus Fiction (or True or False)
• Advice (usually in response to a question)
• Roundup (group several smaller items together under a common theme)
Source: Kivi Leroux Miller
72© 2011 Tom Ahern | www.aherncomm.com
73
Tell me something I don’t know ... and I’ll tell others.
© 2011 Tom Ahern | www.aherncomm.com
74
offers accomplishments(i.e., how donors changed the world)
trust tribe
© 2011 Tom Ahern | www.aherncomm.com
#1 reason people don’t make a charitable bequest?
“It never occurred to me.”
75
76
Eglantyne Jebb wants you! ... in her Society You are hereby cordially, delightedly, enthusiastically invited to join our Eglantyne Jebb Society.
What is it? The Society is a special group of compassionate souls who have taken one extraordinary step: they've added a gift in their wills to benefit Save the Children.
The Society isn't an especially large group. Most Americans don't leave gifts to charity, studies show. And you don't even get great perks (a bookmark, name recognition, and the occasional special report). But your legacy and others helps ensure that Save the Children remains a strong force for good in countries around the globe, no matter what the future brings. To join the Eglantyne Jebb Society, simply make your charitable bequest and let us know. We do not ask the size of your gift. >> Contact Diana Bogue via email at [email protected] or phone her at 203-221-3717.
© 2011 Tom Ahern | www.aherncomm.com
77© 2011 Tom Ahern | www.aherncomm.com
78
Offer
Offer
© 2011 Tom Ahern | www.aherncomm.com
79© 2011 Tom Ahern | www.aherncomm.com
Offer
80
Absolutely wrong
Much righter
© 2011 Tom Ahern | www.aherncomm.com
81
“Am I taking the donor on a journey?”
© 2011 Tom Ahern | www.aherncomm.com
82© 2011 Tom Ahern | www.aherncomm.com
83
The reason so many nonprofit newsletters are just big money-sinks is this: Their purpose is to educate their donors about how effective the organization is. The money-making donor-focused newsletter has a different purpose: To remind the donor what an incredible difference she makes.
84
Source: Jeff Brooks, Future Fundraising Now
Donor newsletter that increased giving 521%
Write to the Donor, For the Donor, About the Donor.Ensure a High "You" Quotient.Touch the Heart with Strong Emotion.Surprise and Delight!Appreciate the Donor.Design for Readability.Motivate Another Gift.Make it Convenient to Give.Appeal to the Most Basic Donor Benefit.Refresh and Reengage.
85
Source: Bob Ball, via Jeff Brooks, Future Fundraising Now
86
The “Extreme Donor-Focused Newsletter”
• 419% lift in response• 19.5% life in average gift• 521% lift in revenue
Source: Bob Ball, Masterworks
© 2011 Tom Ahern | www.aherncomm.com 87
Myfreehow-toe-newsletter…www.aherncomm.com