mental chronometry and the unification of differential psychology arthur r. jensen yi. sangyoon
TRANSCRIPT
Mental Chronometry and the Unification of Differential Psychology
Arthur R. Jensen
Yi. Sangyoon
Mental Chronometry
• Measurement of cognitive speed
• Individual’s response time(RT)
• Inspection Time(IT)
• Major aspect of general intelligence - Sir Francis Galton(1822-1911), et, al.
• Sensitive measure of individual difference
History of RT
• First appeared in astronomy Journals– Astronomers showed individual differences in
RT to the star’s transit across the hair line– Astronomer Royal at the Greenwich Observatory
• Tested simple RT on thousands of people– (Galton)
• Related to the nature of intelligence– (Vernon, 1987)
• Conventional Psychometric Measurement
• Mental Chronometry
• Advantages of Chronometry
• Advancement of Differential Psychology
Conventional Psychometric Measurement
• Ordinal Scales– Composed of a number of separate items
on which the subject’s responses are scored either R/W or P/F – Ordinal scales
– Ranking, percentile raks, standardized scores(z, T, IQ), normalized scores …
– norm referenced– Do any kind of transformation of the raw
scores’ rank order represents a true interval scale or a ratio scale??• It’s depends on ASSUMPTION.• Transformed test scores contain no new
information.
Conventional Psychometric Measurement
• Ordinal Scales– Ordinal scales have many shortcomings.– Cannot make really meaningful
statements about many things we want to know in differential and developmental psychology.
X Y
Conventional Psychometric Measurement
• Absence of ratio scales in differential psychology is most unfortunate.
• Reductionist research necessarily be focused on discovering functional relationships
• How one measured variable is related to some other measured variable
• Time MC
Advantages of MC
• Reliability
• Repeatability
• Range of Equivalency
• Sensitivity of Measurement
The Psychometric Misconception of Mental Speed• Speeded tests in given limit time– Score is the number of identifying items
completed within a time– This results have as rather small factor value– Is it minor factor ???
• This kinds of tests are different from the Chronometric methods used to measure RT and IT
• We should realize that distinction between speed and power.
Standardizing Chronometric Methods
• The units of time have been standardized throughout the history of MC ms
• But, testing conditions are not well standardized…– a severe hindrance to differential psychology
• Within vs Between(*)
• standardization is Essential for science field
Chronometry as a Primary Tool for Research on Intelligence
• “Almost entire psychometric literature shows that they are best represented by a hierarchical factor structure.”
– John B. Carroll (1993)– Three-stratum model
The most general component of the common factor variance
Chronometry as a Primary Tool for Research on Intelligence
• g– Cannot be characterized in therms of the information
content of mental test or in terms of any observable types of behavior.
– g is known not by its nature but by the variation in its loadings on a wide variety of mental tests• (Charles Spearman)
– An aspect of individual differences that causes positive correlations between virtually all measurable cognitive abilities
Chronometry as a Primary Tool for Research on Intelligence
• Chronometric and psychometric tests have much the same general factor in common– RT and IT are related to g
• It is not the main purpose of mental chronometry.
• It is a general tool for measuring all aspects of cognition.
Fundamental Findings in the Relationship of Chronometric
to Psychometric g
• The Problematic Meaning of Inter-Trial Variability
Fundamental Findings in the Relationship of Chronometric
to Psychometric g
• The “Worst Performance Rule”