manuela goretti and marcos souto imf...

20
Manuela Goretti and Marcos Souto IMF WP/13/154 Copyright rests with the author. All rights reserved

Upload: others

Post on 24-Sep-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Manuela Goretti and Marcos Souto IMF WP/13/154ec.europa.eu/economy_finance/events/2015/20151202... · High corporate indebtedness implications Drag on companies profitability, investment

Manuela Goretti and Marcos Souto

IMF WP/13/154

Copyright rests with the author. All rights reserved

Page 2: Manuela Goretti and Marcos Souto IMF WP/13/154ec.europa.eu/economy_finance/events/2015/20151202... · High corporate indebtedness implications Drag on companies profitability, investment

Outline High corporate indebtedness implications

Summary of main results summary

What led to indebtedness?

Empirical methodology, data and results

Corporate (de)leveraging

Policy implication and concluding remarks

Goretti and Souto (2013) 2

Page 3: Manuela Goretti and Marcos Souto IMF WP/13/154ec.europa.eu/economy_finance/events/2015/20151202... · High corporate indebtedness implications Drag on companies profitability, investment

High corporate indebtedness implications

Drag on companies profitability, investment and Growth (Fazzari et al. (1988), Bernanke et al. (1999), Vermeulen (2000), Farinha (1995) and Barbosa et al. (2007))

Increased credit risk -> NPL↑ -> potential fiscal implications and on-> sovereign credit risk ↑.

Goretti and Souto (2013) 3

Page 4: Manuela Goretti and Marcos Souto IMF WP/13/154ec.europa.eu/economy_finance/events/2015/20151202... · High corporate indebtedness implications Drag on companies profitability, investment

Summary of main results We find a negative relationship between corporate

investment and indebtedness.

Significant asymmetric effect beyond certain threshold levels of indebtedness.

Goretti and Souto (2013) 4

Page 5: Manuela Goretti and Marcos Souto IMF WP/13/154ec.europa.eu/economy_finance/events/2015/20151202... · High corporate indebtedness implications Drag on companies profitability, investment

What led to indebtedness?

Goretti and Souto (2013) 5

Page 6: Manuela Goretti and Marcos Souto IMF WP/13/154ec.europa.eu/economy_finance/events/2015/20151202... · High corporate indebtedness implications Drag on companies profitability, investment

Hypothesis 1: Investment affected by indebtedness? Vermeulen (2000) – Panel Approach:

Ikit: investment-to-capital ratio of firm i at time t

D: debt-to-equity or interest coverage ratio (ICR)

SK: lagged sales-to-capital ratio SK to control for standard sales-accelerator effects

Δ sensitivity of the investment rate to indebtedness

BACH, 21 sectors, Austria, Belgium, France, Germany, Italy, Netherlands, Portugal and Spain

Goretti and Souto (2013) 6

Page 7: Manuela Goretti and Marcos Souto IMF WP/13/154ec.europa.eu/economy_finance/events/2015/20151202... · High corporate indebtedness implications Drag on companies profitability, investment

Hypothesis 2: threshold effect?

Literature: Jaeger (2003), IMF (2004), Coricelli et al. (2010) and Cecchetti et al. (2010).

We estimate:

Threshold: debt-to-equity above 25th percentile of the representative Euro area firms in the sample.

Goretti and Souto (2013) 7

Page 8: Manuela Goretti and Marcos Souto IMF WP/13/154ec.europa.eu/economy_finance/events/2015/20151202... · High corporate indebtedness implications Drag on companies profitability, investment

Goretti and Souto (2013) 8

Page 9: Manuela Goretti and Marcos Souto IMF WP/13/154ec.europa.eu/economy_finance/events/2015/20151202... · High corporate indebtedness implications Drag on companies profitability, investment

Results

Goretti and Souto (2013) 9

Page 10: Manuela Goretti and Marcos Souto IMF WP/13/154ec.europa.eu/economy_finance/events/2015/20151202... · High corporate indebtedness implications Drag on companies profitability, investment

Corporate (de)leveraging EA periphery versus past crises

Goretti and Souto (2013) 10

Page 11: Manuela Goretti and Marcos Souto IMF WP/13/154ec.europa.eu/economy_finance/events/2015/20151202... · High corporate indebtedness implications Drag on companies profitability, investment

Past crises, NPLs and fiscal costs

Goretti and Souto (2013) 11

Page 12: Manuela Goretti and Marcos Souto IMF WP/13/154ec.europa.eu/economy_finance/events/2015/20151202... · High corporate indebtedness implications Drag on companies profitability, investment

Increased sovereign indebtedness

Goretti and Souto (2013) 12

Page 13: Manuela Goretti and Marcos Souto IMF WP/13/154ec.europa.eu/economy_finance/events/2015/20151202... · High corporate indebtedness implications Drag on companies profitability, investment

Policy implications and concluding remarks Corporate debt restructuring

Finding alternative funding

Banks properly recognize expected losses and provision accordingly

Promoting transparency and information sharing

Targeted fiscal incentives

Goretti and Souto (2013) 13

Page 14: Manuela Goretti and Marcos Souto IMF WP/13/154ec.europa.eu/economy_finance/events/2015/20151202... · High corporate indebtedness implications Drag on companies profitability, investment
Page 15: Manuela Goretti and Marcos Souto IMF WP/13/154ec.europa.eu/economy_finance/events/2015/20151202... · High corporate indebtedness implications Drag on companies profitability, investment

Goretti and Souto (2013) 15

Page 16: Manuela Goretti and Marcos Souto IMF WP/13/154ec.europa.eu/economy_finance/events/2015/20151202... · High corporate indebtedness implications Drag on companies profitability, investment

Goretti and Souto (2013) 16

Page 17: Manuela Goretti and Marcos Souto IMF WP/13/154ec.europa.eu/economy_finance/events/2015/20151202... · High corporate indebtedness implications Drag on companies profitability, investment

Goretti and Souto (2013) 17

Page 18: Manuela Goretti and Marcos Souto IMF WP/13/154ec.europa.eu/economy_finance/events/2015/20151202... · High corporate indebtedness implications Drag on companies profitability, investment

Goretti and Souto (2013) 18

Page 19: Manuela Goretti and Marcos Souto IMF WP/13/154ec.europa.eu/economy_finance/events/2015/20151202... · High corporate indebtedness implications Drag on companies profitability, investment

Goretti and Souto (2013) 19

Page 20: Manuela Goretti and Marcos Souto IMF WP/13/154ec.europa.eu/economy_finance/events/2015/20151202... · High corporate indebtedness implications Drag on companies profitability, investment

Goretti and Souto (2013) 20