historic descent or global civilization? expert group meeting un headquarters november 19, 2007...
TRANSCRIPT
Historic Descent or Global Civilization?
Expert Group MeetingUN Headquarters
November 19, 2007
Climate, Development, and Planetary Transition
Time
Indicators of development
Stabilization
Take-off
Acceleration
Phases of Transition
Historical Transitions
Early Civilization c. 10,000 years
20,000 10,000 0 Years Before Present
Planetary Phasec. 100 years ?
Modern Erac. 1,000 years
Stone Age c. 100,000 yearsC
ompl
exit
y
Accelerated Transitions
105 104 103 102
Years Before Present
Stone Age
Early Civilization
Modern Era
Planetary Phase
105 104 103 102
Years Before Present
Tribe
City-state
Nation
Planet
Social Organization
105 104 103 102
Years Before Present
Hunting & gathering
Settled agriculture
Industrial capitalism
Economic Basis
Globalization
105 104 103 102
Years Before Present
Language
Writing
Printing
Internet
Communication
Glo
bal C
onne
ctiv
ity
1950 2000 2050
Take-off 1980-
Planetary Transition
Global environmental changeInformation technologyCollapse of USSR, hegemony of capitalismWTO, multinationals, “Davos Man” Earth Summit, NGOs, “Seattle Woman”
Branch PointsBranch Points
SCENARIOS
Sources of Uncertainty
•Ignorance
•Surprise
•Volition
An Integrated View
Conventional Worlds
Barbarization Great Transitions
Global Scenarios
policy reform
market forces
breakdown
fortress world
new sustainability
eco-communalism
Risky Bequest
Barbarization
Environment
Inequity
Resentment
Conflict
Xenophobia
Bending the CurvePeace
2060
Majo
r C
onflic
ts
1980
30
2020
Freedom
2060
Soci
al Equit
y
1980
1
2020
Development
20601980
1 billion
2020
Hunger
20601980
CO
2(p
pm
)
550
2020
300
2060
4.5 billion
20201980
Fore
sts
(ha)
320601980
5 billion
2020People
in s
tress
Climate Ecosystems Water
Limits of the Reform PathPolicy Reform is feasible, in principle – the necessary technologies and policies are available
But daunting, in practice – gradually bending highly unsustainable trends imposes immense challenges
The critical uncertainty – where would the political will come from?
Reform may not be enough…..
New Sustainability Paradigm
•Quality of life
•Human solidarity
•Ecological sensibility
A values-led scenario
A pluralistic scenario
Proximate and Ultimate Drivers
Ultimate Drivers
Knowledge and Understanding
Power Structure
CultureValues and Needs
Proximate Drivers
Population Economy Technology Governance
Tools for Transitions
Market Forces
Policy Reform
Great Transition
well-beingconsumption
throughput
dematerialization wedge
dematerialization wedge
lifestyle wedge
rich
poor
poverty spring
equity magnet
Dimensions of Transition
ValuesKnowledge
Demographic
Social
Economic
Governance
Technology
Change Agents
Intergovernmental
organizations
Transnational corporationsCivil society
An aware and engaged public
The future is always present, as a promise and a lure. Karl Popper
Which worlddo we want?