healing societal traumas and transforming collective consciousness
TRANSCRIPT
-
8/9/2019 Healing Societal Traumas and Transforming Collective Consciousness
1/98
Healing Societal Traumas and TransformingCollective Consciousness: A Path to a Culture of
Healing
M.A. Thesis
Submitted by:
Kristin Famula, USA
To the European University Center for Peace Studies
Stadtschlaining/Burg, Austria
In partial fulfillment of the requirements for a Master of Arts Degree in
Peace and Conflict Studies
Word Count: 21,402
February 2007
Thesis adviser: Dr. H.B. Danesh
-
8/9/2019 Healing Societal Traumas and Transforming Collective Consciousness
2/98
2
Acknowledgements
Many important people have contributed directly and indirectly to this final project.
Very special thanks to my thesis advisor, Dr. Hossain B. Danesh who has spent many
hours talking, meeting, and emailing about various aspects of this paper—always
encouraging me and helping me to find new ways of looking at the ideas.
Thank you also to the European University Center for Peace Studies (EPU) and Dietrich
Fischer who helped me find a unique and wonderful support-group of dedicated peace
workers.
And lastly, deep thanks and love to my parents, Roberta and John Famula, my sister Jamie and my partner, Jason Adams for their continuous support, love and faith in my
path towards peace work. Even while I have questioned my own choices in what will
promise to be a difficult career, they have been a pedestal of never-ending
encouragement.
-
8/9/2019 Healing Societal Traumas and Transforming Collective Consciousness
3/98
3
Abstract
Traumatic events leave long-lasting, detrimental consequences on the individuals
affected. Societal traumas, such as terrorist attacks, war, and natural disasters, which
impact entire populations, similarly inflict enduring pain and suffering. These traumas
have damaging effects that are not recognized by the wounded culture. The negative
results of which are incorporated into the collective consciousness of the culture; making
ideas and actions, based on the traumatic event, seem inherent and natural. Traumatic
events occur cyclically; re-occurring if the effects are never fully healed.
Two methods for healing will be examined in this paper: healing from Posttraumatic
Stress Disorder and lessons learned from numerous Truth and Reconciliation
Commissions with the hopes of finding a new approach to healing entire societies fromthe harmful effects of trauma. Finally, the Greensboro Truth and Reconciliation
Commission (GTRC) and Education for Peace (EFP) will be considered as new
frameworks for cultural healing.
-
8/9/2019 Healing Societal Traumas and Transforming Collective Consciousness
4/98
4
Table of Contents
Chapter 1: Introduction 5
Chapter 2: Trauma and the Effects of a Traumatic Event 11
1. How We Respond to Trauma—The Need to Heal 16
2. Societal Trauma and Healing 18
Chapter 3: Trauma—Worldview – Collective Consciousness 26
1. Worldview 27
2. Collective Consciousness 293. Consciousness Upheld 304. Memory 32
5. Impact of Trauma on the Collective Consciousness 34
6. Collective Consciousness Transformation through Trauma Healing 39
Chapter 4: Healing from Trauma—Posttraumatic Stress Disorder 41
1. Treatment for PTSD 432. Difficulties with PTSD treatment 44
Chapter 5: Healing from Trauma—Truth and Reconciliation Commissions 47
1. Treatment through TRCs 50
2. Difficulties with TRCs 53
a. Truth 54
b. Justice 55c. Granting Amnesty 56d. Top-Down Approaches 56
e. Time and Resources 57
f. Long-term Healing 57
Chapter 6: A Case Study—The Greensboro Truth and Reconciliation Commission 59
1. Background 59
2. The Observable Impact on the Unhealed Community 613. The GTRC Mandate 62
4. Process for Healing 63
5. Transforming the Collective Consciousness 65
6. Previous Trauma in Greensboro’s History 66
7. Lessons Learned 68
-
8/9/2019 Healing Societal Traumas and Transforming Collective Consciousness
5/98
5
Chapter 7: Culture of Healing 71
1. Culture of Healing as Implemented in Education for Peace (EFP) 76
2. Relevance of EFP’s Culture of Healing to other Communities 78
a. Societal Trauma has a long-lasting impact 79
b. Acknowledging Past Trauma 79
c. Understanding Collective Consciousness and its Impact on Individuals 82i. Building Non-Violent Relations & Reframing Identity 84
Chapter 8: Conclusion 86
Appendix I: Mandate for the Greensboro Truth and Reconciliation Commission 89
Appendix II: Prerequisites and components of an effective program of Peace 92Education
References 93
-
8/9/2019 Healing Societal Traumas and Transforming Collective Consciousness
6/98
6
Healing Societal Traumas and Transforming Collective
Consciousness: A Path to a Culture of Healing
Traumatic events are widespread and the effects of these shocking incidents permeate
through the lives of individuals world-wide. Tragedies such as car accidents, natural
disasters, marital or parental aggression, and even rape and murder occur every day in
every part of the world. Responses and reactions to these traumatic events vary from
person to person, but most individuals will, at some point in their lives, be affected by
trauma. While many individuals are able to heal from their experiences, is it possible that
some symptoms still linger? Most psychologists and mental health workers would
answer that question in the affirmative. It is not uncommon for individuals who have
experienced trauma, to change their attitudes or behaviors. In fact, these deeply
disturbing experiences often live with people for the rest of their lives.
In 2005, after Hurricane Katrina swept through the Gulf Coast of the United States,
wiping out most of the homes and businesses in New Orleans, Louisiana, survivors dealt
with many problems in addition to the loss of loved ones and displacement. Examples of
ongoing problems included sleep deprivation, depression, and “re-living” the event. In
particular, the first anniversary of Hurricane Katrina, triggered many vivid memories and
emotional pain.
-
8/9/2019 Healing Societal Traumas and Transforming Collective Consciousness
7/98
7
Similar to those of the hurricane survivors, most traumatic events leave the impacted
individuals with emotional and psychological pain. After some time, victims of trauma
may feel as if they have moved on from the incident, but sometimes the effects are even
deeper than realized and can result in more severe and long-term, painful consequences.
Dr. Kendall Johnson, a crisis-management consultant for several school districts in
California, has observed many of these trauma side-effects during his work as a marriage
and family therapist. Some of these long-term results include anger at oneself and others,
perpetual pessimism and physical problems associated with the stress of trauma,
including stomach and head aches, weight loss or gain, and even increased likelihood for
illnesses (Johnson, 2006, 66). With the frequency of traumatic events and the severe
impact and lingering effects of trauma so often going unrealized, trauma itself becomes a
larger reason for concern.
While resultant effects are most often observed and researched in individual survivors,
trauma can also be shared across a larger population, affecting not only individuals, but
entire societies. Since the individual impact of traumatic events can be so severe and
long-lasting, it is necessary to also examine the effect on a societal level. Societal or
cultural traumas, such as those inflicted by the subjugation of native peoples, are
common as nations fight for sovereignty, populations work towards equality, or
civilizations strive for power. Societal leaders, often promise that similar traumas will
never happen again, while at the same time stressing the necessity of forgetting or
forgiving these traumas as unfortunate parts of a cultures’ history. Riane Eisler observes
in her historical account of Goddess-Worshiping societies, “[i]t is a widespread
-
8/9/2019 Healing Societal Traumas and Transforming Collective Consciousness
8/98
8
assumption that however bloody things have been since the days of the Sumerians and
Assyrians this was just the unfortunate prerequisite for technological and cultural
advance” (Eisler, 1987, 66). As a consequence of unintentionally defending or
rationalizing the actions of those committing atrocities, the healing process can be
delayed or negated altogether. Social scientist and trauma and healing researcher, Duane
Elgin suggests that some of the traumas following this pattern include, “genocide,
slavery, religious persecution, colonialism, and gender oppression” (Elgin, October 1997,
26). The subsequent effects of particular traumas on societies are ignored or not
understood, but as with individual victims, the resultant symptoms and effects still exist
whether acknowledged or not. Over time, the product of these neglected traumas is an
unhealed society with negative consequences woven into the fabric of the culture.
These unresolved, cultural traumas have a pervasive, long-lasting, negative grasp on the
identity of each culture. Individual views of the world are influenced by each trauma.
This tendency is very similar to that of a child learning a lesson. If she paints on the
walls, and is yelled at by her parents afterwards, chances are, she will think differently
about painting on the walls in the future. While this seems an insignificant example
when compared to the challenges that are created by traumatic events, it helps illustrate
how an event can change the way a person thinks. After a car accident, survivors are
often extremely cautious while driving, and may even become angry or afraid of other
drivers without reason. On a larger scale, imagine what might happen to an individual’s
perception of the world if they are violently attacked and their family members are killed
by a stranger. The person’s view of the world around him will change drastically.
-
8/9/2019 Healing Societal Traumas and Transforming Collective Consciousness
9/98
9
Possibly he will be afraid of total strangers; or he will have thoughts of revenge against
people of the same description as his attacker; either way, he will begin to think
differently and subsequently act differently after the traumatic event. Indeed thoughts,
actions and even ideas about what is inherent and natural behavior is shaped in part by
the process of healing, or not healing, from these traumas. Thus, entire cultures affected
by a common traumatic event develop a similar worldview - a collective consciousness -
which determines how they heal from these traumas, and subsequently how they
approach future conflicts.
Many psychologists and trauma professionals have realized that traumatic events often
generate future traumatic events. This occurs because the collective consciousness of the
traumatized population has transformed to incorporate trauma as natural behavior.
Adults who were abused as children often re-enact the same violence on others (if they
have not been able to heal from the trauma). Similarly, populations impacted by trauma
will often react violently, inflicting similar violence upon others. Medical biophysicist
and psychologist, Peter Levine, who developed a new method for healing from trauma
called “Somatic Experiencing”, agrees that experiencing traumatic events greatly
increases the likelihood for future violence. While violence is only one outcome of
unresolved trauma, it is certainly an important effect to examine (Levine, 1997, 225).
The potential for violent tendencies would not be so much of a worry, if they were not so
increasingly prevalent, but recent studies show the magnitude and severity of violence.
In 2002, the United Nations and World Health Organization released a report on violence
and health world-wide. In the report, they describe violence as “a global public health
-
8/9/2019 Healing Societal Traumas and Transforming Collective Consciousness
10/98
-
8/9/2019 Healing Societal Traumas and Transforming Collective Consciousness
11/98
11
disorders from a trauma, the traumatic event itself will produce deep-rooted, damaging,
results if not fully healed.
Acknowledging and healing from these traumas will open an outlet for creative
alternatives to transforming future challenges nonviolently. There are no easy solutions
for healing from deep traumas, especially those that have occurred decades ago and have
been clouded over by time, but Elgin explains, “it may seem unwise to bring the dark side
of humanity’s past into the light of day, but, unless we do, this unresolved pain will
forever pull at the underside of our consciousness and diminish our future potentials”
(Elgin, October 1997, 27).
This paper will examine different methods of healing in an effort to find a technique for
healing entire societies; for cultural healing. Two current methods for healing trauma
victims will be examined: the positive and negative aspects of methods used for healing
from Posttraumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD); and the lessons learned from numerous
Truth and Reconciliation Commissions (TRCs). These two processes, PTSD treatment
and TRCs, were selected because they have been both examined as successful methods
for healing and scrutinized for their possible failures. Both techniques treat trauma
healing as a necessary and unrealized obligation for individuals in the world today. This
paper will also examine the effects of unresolved traumas on the collective consciousness
and worldview. From there, two current cultural healing methods will examined: The
Greensboro Truth and Reconciliation Commission (GTRC), which has prioritized a need
for transforming the collective consciousness in their community; and Education for
-
8/9/2019 Healing Societal Traumas and Transforming Collective Consciousness
12/98
12
Peace (EFP), which has seen much success in developing a Culture of Healing after Civil
War in Bosnia and Herzegovina. Finally, a definition and process will be developed for a
Culture of Healing—and an examination of how a Culture of Healing may replace the
dependence on violence, and replace it with a new outlet for creative, nonviolent
solutions.
-
8/9/2019 Healing Societal Traumas and Transforming Collective Consciousness
13/98
13
Trauma and the Effects of a Traumatic Event
“Trauma” is most commonly defined as any injury both of body or mind caused by
outside means (Judith Herman, as cited in Rosenbloom and Williams, 1999, 17). Trauma
occurs when “an event creates an unresolved impact on an organism” (Levine, 1997,
129). Trauma, which is prevalent worldwide, includes all individual traumatic events
that affect a person’s normal way of living: childhood abuse, incest, rape, car accidents,
job loss, and family problems; and those traumas that occur on a larger scale such as
genocide, war, and natural disasters. A traumatic event can be caused by many types of
physical or emotional pain; even feared death or a perceived pain can cause such a
reaction. More recently, the definition of trauma has expanded to also include and
acknowledge the recurring reactions to previous trauma that one may have experienced
at an earlier age.
Traumatic events occur every day and practically every person at one point in his or her
life will be subjected to a trauma that will affect him or her in some way. Peter Levine, a
psychologist and researcher notes that, “trauma has become so commonplace that most
people don’t even recognize its presence . . . each of us has had a traumatic experience at
some time in our lives, regardless of whether it left us with an obvious case of post-
traumatic stress” (Levine, 1997, 41).
Many individuals have healthy ways of dealing with their symptoms of trauma; these
tactics sometimes include family support, journal-writing, or other coping techniques.
-
8/9/2019 Healing Societal Traumas and Transforming Collective Consciousness
14/98
14
However, as Levine notes, even if a person is able to cope with their traumatic event in a
healthy way, effects linger for some time. The difficulty is that most of these effects are
not obvious to the traumatized person, and thus psychological symptoms are not
recognized. Additionally, many people do not ever fully heal from trauma. The event
affects them for the rest of their lives whether they realize it consciously or not.
Individuals will have varying reactions to similar traumatic events, and as such, the
effects of such an event will have different outcomes for each person. Trauma can come
in all shapes and sizes and the effects will often change throughout ones life. What may
simply be an uncomfortable occurrence to one, will be traumatic and unremitting for
another, depending on the person’s history, coping abilities and other outside events in
his or her life.
The way a traumatic event affects a person depends as much on how one experiences the
event as the actual trauma itself. Individuals can experience the same incident, but
handle it differently, and therefore heal from it differently. Despite this, in all cases,
trauma has lasting effects that are not always obvious and may linger for long periods of
time. For instance, rape victims often express fear, or the inability to have intimate
relations with others after his or her trauma. It frequently requires years of therapy and
healing to deal with the emotions associated with the trauma, and subsequently, the
reactions that the person has towards other people and relationships.
-
8/9/2019 Healing Societal Traumas and Transforming Collective Consciousness
15/98
15
Human beings are designed for survival. If placed in a situation that is dangerous,
individuals often react instinctively without reflection or evaluation. A traumatic event
immediately triggers a series of reactions in an individual’s body, often called a fight-or-
flight response. This type of response is usually discussed in relation to traumatic events
that cause individuals to exhibit extreme, unexplainable strength. Human beings have
these responses as a defense mechanism against pain from trauma. These instantaneous
reactions are one of the body’s methods for survival. The body prepares a person by
sending a flood of chemicals that hasten the reaction of the body and focus attention to
the crisis. Individuals react immediately in ways that are sometimes extremely surprising
or confusing. These reactions can be categorized into four groups: physical, mental,
emotional and behavioral, and they include responses such as the momentary extreme
strength mentioned above, and quick-thinking (Rosenbloom and Williams, 1999, 20).
Many physical reactions such as rapid heartbeat, nervousness, and dizziness are simply
these immediate reactions to the trauma. In healthy bodies, these reactions will diminish
fairly quickly. Other common symptoms of trauma linger for longer, but will also
diminish within a short period of time. These can include: depression, anxiety and stress,
anger, sadness, fear, difficulty relating to loved ones, or even immediate reactions as
severe as suicide attempts. Furthermore, although an individual’s immediate responses to
trauma are not usually conscious, they differ broadly from person to person.
Most reactions fall into two “acute stress responses”; individuals either “explode into
extreme emotional action or collapse into psychological shock” (Johnson, 2006, 75).
-
8/9/2019 Healing Societal Traumas and Transforming Collective Consciousness
16/98
16
Both reactions can have dangerous results in addition to the ultimate shock or pain from
the actual traumatic injury. The second of the two responses, a state of stagnant shock, is
common but less obvious, and is often more dangerous to the trauma victim. This state
frequently leaves the person “psychologically wounded without anyone being aware of
it” (Johnson, 2006, 75). This type of response often results in future delayed stress
symptoms, including individuals that thought they were not negatively influenced by the
event. These differing reactions to trauma can be observed in a myriad of normal, every-
day experiences. When a parent dies, one child may cry profusely and be depressed for
weeks; while the other child may seem removed from the heartbreak, but may suddenly
begin having difficulties in school. Similarly, differing responses can be seen in other
traumatic circumstances.
Many of the abovementioned psychological or bodily effects of trauma will fade away
shortly after the event. Other responses to trauma or tragedy are more complicated and
also differ from person to person. Long-term effects include loss of memory (or the
inability to take in more information), long-term depression, and physical ailments such
as a weakened immune system (leading to likely increases in infections to the body or
even increased risks for diseases like cancer) (Bremner, 2005, 268). There are many
more possible long-term effects, which cause damage to the mind, brain and body.
In addition to the more common short and long-term effects, one trauma survivor,
Matthew Sanford notes, “how we carry trauma forward throughout out lives can be the
real injury” (Hart, 48). Some trauma survivors see the world as being completely
-
8/9/2019 Healing Societal Traumas and Transforming Collective Consciousness
17/98
17
different than it was before the event, and consequently the survivors’ perception of his
or her association with the world around them changes. Family and work-related
relationships as well as connections to strangers are often strained or damaged with no
clear understanding why (Hart, 48). Some experts refer to this long-term process as the
“recovery” phase of healing from trauma. The U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs
defines this phase as the “prolonged period of adjustment or return to equilibrium that the
community and individuals must go through”
(http://www.ncptsd.va.gov/facts/disasters/fs_phases_disaster.html). This phase moves
past the basic survival techniques for healing from the trauma, and begins the process of
returning to a normal state of living. For some, especially those that experienced the
traumatic event first-hand, this progression never leads to full healing and many
individuals may develop Posttraumatic Stress Disorder, which will be discussed later.
Traumatic Stress, defined as “leftover reactions (lasting emotional scars) from
overwhelming events” continues long after the actual event; some people may experience
traumatic stress reactions for their entire lives (Johnson, 2006, 70).
The long-term results of trauma can be confusing and frightening, mostly because an
individual does not usually associate the symptoms with the trauma experienced.
Because a traumatic event can have ramifications for the rest of a person’s life, it is
common for individuals to be experiencing problems that are complicating their lives
without any explanation of from where these problems are coming. These difficulties can
include anxiety, panic, disorientation or overwhelming impulses to do things that are
completely out of character such as drinking excessively (Johnson, 2006, 59). Johnson
-
8/9/2019 Healing Societal Traumas and Transforming Collective Consciousness
18/98
18
notes, “Nothing occurs in a vacuum”; the troublesome events that are occurring in one’s
community, in one’s family, and in the world, can affect the way someone handles the
problems in their life, and can release feelings and emotions that are caused by previous
experiences (Johnson, 2006, 59).
Responses to Trauma—The Need to Heal
Much of a person’s reaction to trauma depends predominantly on the way he or she
processes the situation. Although traumatic events will almost always have difficult side-
effects on an individual, outside factors in the person’s background will determine the
overall effects of trauma and will influence the severity and duration of problems. An
individual’s response depends on family experiences, age, relationships, and even
“previous coping strategies” (Rosenbloom and Williams, 1999, 18). Even things like
religious beliefs and cultural background and perspectives will affect if and how an
individual or group will heal. The “meaning” of a traumatic event will be shaped by an
individual’s history and background (Rosenbloom and Williams, 1999, 18). Their
understanding of what occurred will depend on their previous experiences.
As previously mentioned, trauma can change the way people think about themselves and
the world around them. Many factors are taken into account when determining how to
help an individual heal from a particular trauma including what a person “sees, hears,
smells, and feels during a traumatic event; how this information travels through the
system of perceptions and is modified by prior memories, emotions, and beliefs; how it is
-
8/9/2019 Healing Societal Traumas and Transforming Collective Consciousness
19/98
19
processed by the nervous system; and how it is ultimately translated into a neurological
response and a new set of memories and cognitions” (Bremner, 2005, 272). The ways in
which societies are taught to deal with trauma is an important part of the ultimate healing
process.
Continuous research has been conducted on Posttraumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD)—a
mental illness that affects many people around the world, but is most commonly
recognized in war veterans. PTSD is the result of massive trauma that is not fully dealt
with at an individual level. The methods for healing from PTSD will be examined later
in this paper, as an example of healing from long-term effects of trauma. What is clear
from research done with trauma survivors, who differed in scope of trauma and in
cultural background, is that the impact inflicted by a traumatic event can leave negative
consequences for decades (Hamber, 2003, 79). Many researchers note, as might seem
obvious, that multiple traumas, or traumatic events that occur for an extended period of
time, will have severe outcomes, especially if the sufferer has not learned how to heal
from them. This occurrence, called Complex Trauma is a “layering of traumatic events”
(Johnson, 2006, 70). Some individual responses to complex trauma are:
• Deep questioning about your character and your adequacy
• Distrust of yourself and your intentions
• Unnecessary skepticism toward the motives of others
• Deep and abiding distrust of the world in which you live (Johnson, 2006, 102).
-
8/9/2019 Healing Societal Traumas and Transforming Collective Consciousness
20/98
20
Many of the above effects of traumatic events are also observed at a collective level from
traumas that affect an entire society.
Societal Trauma and Healing
Traumatic events significantly impact individuals and it is necessary for each person to
heal fully to avoid negative long-term effects from trauma, but trauma does not only
occur at an individual level. Entire populations or cultures can also experience a
collective trauma that will impact them in much the same way as individual traumatic
experiences. One example would be the attacks on the World Trade Center and Pentagon
in the United States on September 11, 2001. This event traumatized much of the U.S.
population in many obvious ways, and also in many undetermined and less apparent
ways. As one observer notes, after September 11, 2001, “our collective trust in the world
and the security of the nation got shattered” (Sanford, 49). As news reports around the
five-year anniversary of this traumatic event report, “9-11” was not just an event; it is an
ongoing process of healing.
Although it is difficult to find scientific research that proves a link between past societal
traumas and problems that exist today, Bremner acknowledges that many different types
of “stressors” whether extreme or not, can “have effects on our minds, brains, and bodies
in ways that we don’t yet fully understand” (Bremner, 2005, 145). He further recognizes
that “scientists are just beginning to understand how extreme stress can have lasting
effects on one’s mind, brain, and physical health” (Bremner, 2005, 144). Many studies
-
8/9/2019 Healing Societal Traumas and Transforming Collective Consciousness
21/98
21
have been conducted, analyzing the long-term psychological effects of natural disasters,
mass violence, war and other traumatic events that affect entire populations. Much of the
research looks at individual psychological responses to the trauma, and methods for how
those individuals healed (or did not heal) from it. Much less research has been done on
the overall effect to entire populations, but many psychologists and counselors have
noted the link between large-scale traumatic events, and a culture’s negative change in
health and identity (Johnson, 2006, 59). As will be seen in the next section, the overall
impact on the identity of a traumatized culture can be much larger than typical
psychological effects on individuals because the pain will linger in the consciousness of
the culture. These trauma symptoms become integrated into the collective worldview of
the traumatized society, changing the identity of the culture. These new opinions and
beliefs are supported and reinforced by the changed identity, making the new behaviors
seem normal and inherent.
In 2005 a report was released by Research Education Disaster Mental Health (REDMH),
an organization co-sponsored by Dartmouth College and the National Center for
Posttraumatic Stress Disorder. The senior project director of REDMH and author of this
report, Dr. Fran Norris, examined disaster survivors from 34 countries. Catastrophes
studied included natural disasters, transportation accidents, nuclear and industrial
accidents, and war and peace-time terrorist attacks. The study examined previous
research and compiled the data from outcomes of 132 different disasters. One finding of
the report was that the “severity of exposure [to a particular disaster] also predicted
declines in social relations and increased conflicts with family members” (Norris, 2005,
-
8/9/2019 Healing Societal Traumas and Transforming Collective Consciousness
22/98
22
10). This response is typical in individual trauma survivors; however, when entire
populations are affected by a large-scale trauma, these reactions become a societal
dilemma that is sometimes not an obvious effect.
Since entire populations of people are often affected in similar ways from the same
trauma, collective ideas are developed about the trauma. Memories of the event are
shaped by other individual’s memories; responses to the trauma are shaped by others
responses, or by how other survivors responded; and a collective healing process is
consciously or subconsciously begun. Shared concepts such as these are normal and
ideas and perceptions of the world constantly change. Rarely, however, is full healing
from the trauma collectively achieved. Thus the event leaves the same common side-
effects as individual trauma, and lends to a collective consciousness negatively affected
by the unhealed trauma. It becomes important to recognize the pain and subsequent
collective consequences of societal traumas, and to consciously work towards healing
from them.
The need for cultural healing has been recognized in many places. One example
concerning the United States and Europe, was in an editorial in the Wall Street Journal—
Europe on May 3rd, 2006 by Shelby Steele. It was entitled, “White Guilt and the
Western Past”. The article concluded that the West has yet to come to terms with, and
move on from, it’s “past sins” and that this “white guilt” is now causing even more
problems:
-
8/9/2019 Healing Societal Traumas and Transforming Collective Consciousness
23/98
23
Today, the white west—like Germany after the Nazi defeat—livesin a kind of secular penitence in which the slightest echo of past
sins brings down withering condemnation . . . people stigmatizedwith moral crimes—here racism and imperialism—lack moral
authority and so . . . struggle, above all else, to dissociate
themselves from the past sins they are stigmatized with (Steele,
2006, 13).
Steele’s prognosis, however, diverged here from realizing the entire problem. He
resolved that the United States fear of stigmatization causes a retreat into
“minimalization” and thus never fully deals with the country’s problems (i.e. not using
full military capabilities to defeat the insurgency in the 2003 ongoing Iraq war). Whereas
Steele’s statement that the “white guilt” which “imposes so much minimalism and
restraint that America’s [the United States’] worst problems tend to linger and deepen” is
correct, his conclusion that “moral transformation” has already been made and must
simply be incorporated into the “public life” in the United States is misleading.
The “white guilt” as Steele calls it, has very deep roots that have not been fully faced.
The United States, as is the case for many other countries around the world, has many
traumatic experiences in its history. These cultural traumas are deeply embedded in the
historical construction and fabric of the country, but have not, on a societal level, been
healed. Some of these very significant traumas include the violence against and
subjugation of the original inhabitants of the United States, the Native Americans; the
violence committed in the structures of Slavery; the violence exacted upon the citizens of
Japan; the severe losses in the Vietnam War; or, as mentioned before, the shocking events
on September 11, 2001, all of which have traumatized U.S. citizens in a way that is not
fully acknowledged and from which it has certainly not fully healed.
-
8/9/2019 Healing Societal Traumas and Transforming Collective Consciousness
24/98
24
The United States is not the only country that suffers from these symptoms; many nations
across the globe are dealing with serious outcomes from societal traumas. One somber
realization is that these unhealed traumatic societal events lead directly back into a cycle
of violence. As Levine explains,
When people are traumatized, our internal systems remain aroused. We
become hypervigilant but are unable to locate the source of this pervasive
threat. This situation causes fear and reactivity to escalate, amplifying theneed to identify the source of the threat. The result: we become likely
candidates for re-enactment—in search of an enemy (Levine, 1997, 226).
This need for an adversary is just one of the many dangerous problems. Other common
long-term side-effects of such unhealed traumas are phobias, racism, prejudice, violence,
and a “legacy of fear” (Levine, 1997, 225). Acknowledging and healing from past
traumas will help end the need for violence as well as the other negative effects of
unresolved trauma. Levine says there will be serious consequences if the cycle of
violence is not broken, “lasting peace among warring peoples cannot be accomplished
without first healing the traumas of previous terrorism, violence, and horror on a mass
scale” (Levine, 1997, 222).
Some psychologists even suggest that collective structures are damaged by trauma
(Hamber, 2003, 77). The city of Greensboro, North Carolina was impacted by a protest
and march that resulted in citizen deaths. Greensboro is working towards healing from
this collective trauma in its recent past and notes, “The passage of time alone cannot
bring closure, nor resolve feelings of guilt and lingering trauma” (GTRC, 2006, 17). The
-
8/9/2019 Healing Societal Traumas and Transforming Collective Consciousness
25/98
25
entire culture and identity of a population affected by a traumatic event can be negatively
changed if there is not a conscious effort to heal from it. Psychologist Duane Elgin
proposes, “If we can bear witness to the reservoir of unresolved pain that has
accumulated through history, we will release an enormous store of pent-up creativity and
energy” (Elgin, October 1997, 28).
Interestingly, recent research has been done on individuals with “chronic fear”, a state
where a person is in a constant state of anxiety. Chronic fear is one of the many results of
trauma; a case where the survivor is unable to turn off the responses to danger, keeping
the body in a “constant state of arousal” (Johnson, 2006, 76). This type of trauma
response can lead to many problems such as high blood pressure, stomach ulcers and
impaired memory, while at the same time diminishing an individual’s capacity to respond
safely to traumatic events in the future (Johnson, 2006, 76). Crisis-Management
Consultant, Kendall Johnson, describes the consequences of chronic fear, “When you are
constantly on guard, you easily blow things out of proportion. Relatively minor incidents
can trigger full-blown acute stress responses. These episodes of acute stress reaction can
undermine your life” (Johnson, 2006, 77).
Ironically, after September 11, 2001, citizens in the United States were in a constant state
of fear of future terrorist attacks (partially in part from the immediate anthrax “attack”
following 9-11). The U.S. government helped to supplement the fear by raising terrorist
threat warnings while the media continuously reported the supposed threat, enhancing the
fear of many U.S. citizens. It is, of course, not precisely known whether this “chronic
-
8/9/2019 Healing Societal Traumas and Transforming Collective Consciousness
26/98
26
fear” after the 9-11 attacks resulted in a societal deterioration for future trauma-handling;
however, the similarities to individual traumatic responses is uncanny. Accordingly, it
would seem necessary to incorporate a healthy way of healing from “chronic fear” as part
of a regimen for healing from societal traumas.
This paper is not about the effects of large-scale trauma (i.e. war) on individuals
(although that is part of it), rather, it is about how these traumas affect the collective
identity of the culture that was traumatized. Certainly large-scale trauma affects
individual people, but of equal importance is the change in the collective consciousness
of the traumatized society as a whole, since this new consciousness will ultimately
influence individual reactions to future trauma. It is necessary to heal the entire affected
society and to teach that collective how to heal so that individuals within that culture can
learn to heal in a healthy manner. Equally important is learning to recognize how
societies are affected so that individual’s negative responses will be mitigated. As has
been observed, “much of our normal response to specific crisis is charged with deeper
meaning because of social and global events that are unfolding around us” (Johnson,
2006, 37). It is for this very reason that individuals must learn as a collective how to
heal from the traumas with which they are affected.
Nations have not yet determined a healthy way for dealing with and healing from societal
traumas that occur. This lack of healing in the immediate wake of the attacks on
September 11, 2001 led the United States once again to hostile and aggressive means; the
governments’ solution was to violently attack the aggressors. Not surprisingly, a recent
-
8/9/2019 Healing Societal Traumas and Transforming Collective Consciousness
27/98
27
2006 report1 released by the United States Intelligence Agency, suggests that this
resolution acted as an instigator for even more violence and terrorism. The United
States’ reaction to 9-11, its traumatic event, was not surprising in light of the realization
that trauma such as this is the result of past unhealed traumas, in this case the attackers,
and, as was shown in the Intelligence Report, will spawn future violence and trauma, the
obvious example being the war in Iraq and Afghanistan. The U.S. response to its
collective trauma, and the subsequent upshot from the violent reactions was significant in
creating a global realization that a violent reaction was probably not the best solution, and
that a more structured healing process may have had more positive results. Regardless of
whether or not fighting a war was the right “solution” after September 11th
2001; it serves
as a painful example of the nature of trauma, which if not healed, reproduces itself in a
cyclical fashion. It is necessary to develop new healing tactics for moving individuals
and nations away from this cycle of trauma and violence and helping societies fully heal
from the pain of these events.
1 Declassified Key Judgments of the National Intelligence Estimate “Trends in Global Terrorism:
Implications for the United States” from April 2006 can be found at:
http://www.dni.gov/press_releases/Declassified_NIE_Key_Judgments.pdf
-
8/9/2019 Healing Societal Traumas and Transforming Collective Consciousness
28/98
28
Trauma—Worldview – Collective Consciousness
The feelings associated with violence, whether a one-time trauma or
continuous violence, often “become the status quo and any lasting change
can only follow a transformation of the various dynamics underlying that
status quo. . . ‘victimhood’ becomes a fundamental aspect of the identity of
affected societies, such as “Catholics in Northern Ireland, Anatolian
Armenenians, European Jews during World War II, Palestinian Arabs
after 1948, Poles and Ukrainians” (Montville as cited in Lerche, 2000, 2).
This section will focus on the idea of collective consciousness, or group awareness. It
will examine how collective consciousness is formed and what the impact of collective
consciousness is on individuals. Finally, it will examine how trauma influences the
collective consciousness. The following two definitions, of “collective” and
“consciousness” are from T.R. Burns, in his Journal article, “The Social Construction of
Consciousness”. T.R. Burns, professor at the Centre for International Environment and
Development Studies, NLU in Norway, has written extensively on socio-cognitive and
consciousness studies. These two definitions will help to develop a preliminary idea of
collective consciousness:
Collective— “a collective is understood as a group or population of individuals (or
collective agents as members) that possesses or develops collective representations of
itself: its values and goals, its structure and modes of operating, its strategies,
developments, strengths and weaknesses, etc” (Burns, 1998, 67).
Consciousness—“ a type of reflective activity: observing, monitoring, judging and re-
orienting and re-organizing self; considering what characterizes the self, what self
perceives, judges, could do, should do (or should not do)” (Burns, 1998, 67).
“Consciousness” is the manifestation of ones worldview. It is shaped by the way an
individual looks at the world around them, and thus influences the way a person acts and
-
8/9/2019 Healing Societal Traumas and Transforming Collective Consciousness
29/98
29
reacts to the world around them. Consciousness is often studied at an individual level,
but individual consciousness is simply a reflection of the collective consciousness of a
particular culture:
all consciousness is basically ‘group consciousness’. An individual’s
awareness, attention, memory, etc. is socially constructed. Without groupinteraction, an individual would never achieve ‘identification’ with anyone
or anything. From this viewpoint, ‘group consciousness’ is the
fundamental matrix from which ‘individual consciousness’ emerges
(Stanley Krippner as cited in Elgin, October 1997, 4).
Since a culture’s collective consciousness is socially constructed, it ensues that societal
trauma would help create the consciousness of the effected society. The normal,
commonly negative, effects of trauma are manifested in the consciousness of the
collective that was traumatized, whether consciously or not. Before it is possible to
understand the impact that trauma has on the collective consciousness of a society, it is
necessary to understand the meaning of consciousness and worldview, and how both are
influenced and transformed.
Worldview
How could a traumatic event possibly have such a long-lasting, insidious effect on entire
societies? Many factors contribute to the makeup of a cultures worldview. One’s
worldview is, simply put, the way an individual or society looks at the world. It is the
pedestal supporting every culture, a “subconscious expression or “framework for all our
life processes—our thoughts, feelings, choices and actions” (Danesh, 64). The
composition of that worldview is complicated and constantly changing—determined by
-
8/9/2019 Healing Societal Traumas and Transforming Collective Consciousness
30/98
30
many different factors such as spiritual, philosophical, and political beliefs, historical
background, and “particular life experiences and environmental characteristics” (Danesh,
2006, 65). All of these pieces construct a common worldview in each particular society;
shaping the way individuals think, believe, understand and react to situations around
them.
Societies are constantly changing their worldviews as part of the normal changes in each
culture. “Culture” is defined by the Oxford English Dictionary as:
1 the arts and other manifestations of human intellectual achievementregarded collectively. 2 a refined understanding or appreciation of this. 3
the customs, institutions, and achievements of a particular nation, people,
or group.
The Latin origin of “culture” is cultura, meaning “growing, cultivation” (AskOxford,
2006). Thus, culture is, by definition, a continuous, collective progression. Cultivation
implies a nurturing and fostering of certain ideas, theories, and ideals, literally grown
from stimuli such as language, music, religion, and even architecture. Culture is not a
stagnant phenomenon that is evident from the initial, founding of a nation. Culture is
built, fostered and encouraged. This means that the subsequent worldview of a society is
also constantly changing and being influenced by outside factors.
-
8/9/2019 Healing Societal Traumas and Transforming Collective Consciousness
31/98
31
Collective Consciousness
The possibly dangerous aspects of any culture lie below the superficial identity, existing
at a deep-rooted level where some characteristics of the culture are hidden. Aspects of a
culture’s worldview are institutionalized and become ingrained in each individual’s
identity as normal and accepted: so called “human nature”. These “natural”
characteristics are converted into the culture’s collective consciousness and are reflected
in all that we say and do.
Consciousness has been described as the ability to “know that we know”; “mindfulness”;
and the capacity for awareness of self and others, reflection and reaction (Elgin, October
1997, 4, 12). Consciousness “subsumes all categories of experience, including
perception, cognition, intuition, instinct, will and emotion, at all levels” (Jonas, 1). It is a
phenomenon that is created, cultivated and changed, often completely subconsciously.
This collective identity is “defined and constituted in terms of core symbols, organizing
principles, norms, etc. Some core principles are understood and relied on as ‘natural’, as
if they were not really social products or human constructions” (Burns, 1998, 76).
Consciousness determines what is right and wrong, how one should behave in any given
situation, and what consequences will ensue from respective actions. Collective
consciousness is often institutionalized, encouraging (and enforcing) its seemingly
inherent nature, “the ‘binding’ quality of values and their symbols – truth, beauty and
goodness – comes from the power of collective consciousness” (Wiley, as cited in Burns,
1998, 69). The cyclical quality of collective consciousness, develops a seemingly
-
8/9/2019 Healing Societal Traumas and Transforming Collective Consciousness
32/98
32
obligatory sense of what is intrinsic in a particular culture. Each society develops its own
particular collective consciousness which is also reinforced by other cultures.
“Awareness”, which can be defined as “focusing on or attention to . . . the state or
situation of one’s own group,” while only a small aspect of consciousness, plays a large
role in raising collective consciousness (Burns, 1998, 69). This transformation of
worldview is key to the overall maturation of a society—which is ultimately imperative
for the health and longevity of a culture. As Dr. David Hawkins, a psychiatrist and
expert on consciousness, observes, “consciousness is gullible; it believes everything it
hears. Consciousness is like hardware that will play back any software that’s put into it”
(Hawkins, 2002, 247). Hence consciousness can be changed or even improved. As a
fundamentally reflective action, consciousness can be transformed on a regular basis
through observation, monitoring and judging (Burns, 1998, 68).
Consciousness Upheld
Collective consciousness is not only created and formed through past traumas and
historical events; it is supported and maintained through many different methods.
Religion, food, architecture, language, monuments, and sports all advocate a particular
identity. Governments, the media and individuals consciously and subconsciously
sustain the identity and worldview of a culture through repeated messages and
reinforcement of power.
-
8/9/2019 Healing Societal Traumas and Transforming Collective Consciousness
33/98
33
Ones collective consciousness teaches an individual how to deal with the troubles or
pleasures that he or she may encounter. It creates a basis for right and wrong behavior
and helps implement actions that are seemingly inherent. It also teaches individuals how
to psychologically handle the stress of everyday life. The process that societies embark
upon to handle the stress of a societal trauma is shaped by the collective consciousness of
the traumatized culture. The ensuing process of healing or not healing is a manifestation
of the way the society thinks it is supposed to heal.
Memory
Memory, a very important aspect of consciousness, can be defined as “the process of
storing past experience and using it to understand present events” (Johnson, 2006, 79).
Ones memory helps him or her to comprehend how to react in a certain situation and to
have a clear understanding of how to react in similar circumstances in the future. An
individual’s memory helps her to make good choices. For instance, if a person grabs a
pan out of a hot oven without using something to protect her hand, the pain that she feels
will help her brain remember that situation in the future, so that she is protected from the
heat. Sometimes an individual’s reaction to a situation can be confusing, because the
person is not conscious of the memory that is causing her to act in a certain way. Many
trauma survivors react strangely to seemingly harmless things, without remembering the
event that may have triggered the reaction.
-
8/9/2019 Healing Societal Traumas and Transforming Collective Consciousness
34/98
-
8/9/2019 Healing Societal Traumas and Transforming Collective Consciousness
35/98
35
the victim of a similar crisis, and the subsequent view of this occurrence had been shaped
by the other accident.
Kendall Johnson, an expert on crisis management, explains, that the human brain must
store many pieces of information, some important and some less so. Consequently, the
brain categorizes the intake of information in a way that it can handle. However, in a
traumatic experience, there is an excess of information that is received quickly, and the
human body has to react quickly. An individual’s past memories help him or her to react
in the best perceived way possible. At the same time, the information received does not
always get incorporated into ones memory in a logical way (Johnson, 2006, 81). In a
normal situation, “sights, sounds, and touches are . . . taken in, mixed with thoughts,
feelings, and reflections, and combined into a sensible order” (Johnson, 2006, 81). These
events are incorporated into the map of memories in ones brain; most of which are repeat
occurrences that take their natural place in ones memory. Events during a traumatic
event are incorporated in a different way because they occur too quickly to be
immediately understood. An individual’s future memories may be just snapshots of what
actually happened, or may occur out of sequence.
These traumatic memories often prompt confusing reaction or feelings that cannot be
explained. Sometimes, this is because an individual’s brain has not processed the
disturbing images that it encountered during a traumatic event, causing the person to react
in similar ways to completely unrelated future events. Thus, any sort of reminder will
trigger the same response.
-
8/9/2019 Healing Societal Traumas and Transforming Collective Consciousness
36/98
36
Impact of Trauma on the Collective Consciousness
The impact of trauma on a population, as previously discussed, can have detrimental
results that then become entrenched in the deep culture and collective consciousness.
There is a circular relationship between individual and collective trauma. Thus the
collective identity of traumatized cultures reflects the individual consciousness of
affected individuals. What is deemed accepted and natural behavior is in part, molded by
the effects of trauma. The traumatic event creates, enforces and manipulates the
collective consciousness that determines how a person will heal from these traumas, and
subsequently how he or she will approach future conflicts.
Couple a traumatic national event with a collective memory about the event, and the
consciousness of the society begins to function within the framework of a particular
worldview. Bremner notes that these traumas change “the way we view the world,
ourselves, and our place in the world. The events surrounding a traumatic stress become
strongly engraved in memory, and sometimes certain details seem to become shrouded in
fog.” (Bremner, 2005, 141). Trauma that has never been fully healed, results in
collective conflict-based thoughts, beliefs, and actions that seem inherent to a particular
culture. Roger Walsh say that “the state of the world reflects our state of mind; our
collective crises mirror our collective consciousness” (Walsh, as cited in Elgin, October
1997, 3). Violent behavior is just one of the consequences of an unhealed, traumatized
culture, whose consciousness is deeply impacted by the effects of the trauma, and is
-
8/9/2019 Healing Societal Traumas and Transforming Collective Consciousness
37/98
37
reacting accordingly. The alleged need for violence could be reduced by alleviating the
symptoms of trauma.
Trauma has a ripple effect. The immediate victims, those that are directly affected, bring
their stress responses home to their families. The media constantly reminds the survivors
and their families, and then the communities of the trauma, and so on and so on. It
moves quickly and silently so that generations after the traumatic event, the aftershocks
are still being felt in ways that are not obvious or conscious. At a societal level, a culture
is negatively impacted by a certain traumatic event. One important and often detrimental
influence after a trauma is the pressure put on the family. Psychotherapist Kendall
Johnson notes that after September 11th
2001, his total number of clients rose
considerably, but surprisingly the majority was not individuals affected directly by the
trauma, but families that were experiencing new problems or old problems that could not
be reconciled (Johnson, 2006, 47). He suggests that this “new age of anxiety” puts even
more pressure on the already difficult tasks of living. After 9-11-2001, families simply
could not handle, or did not know how to handle, this added anxiety, and did not
recognize the new problems as reactions to the stress of the trauma.
The effects that a societal trauma has on the global family are similar. In the same way
that families in the United States felt the need for help and advice during the turmoil
following 9-11, the “global family” must find ways for healing from the collective
traumas. Certainly the nearly 3,000 individuals that were killed on September 11th
2001,
had children, husbands and wives, and parents that were immediately impacted by the
-
8/9/2019 Healing Societal Traumas and Transforming Collective Consciousness
38/98
38
death of their loved one. The emergency personnel that arrived on the scene, even those
that were not physically hurt by the trauma, will have long-lasting memories of the
episode; they will bring these memories back to their families. Every citizen in the
United States will remember where they were when they found out about the attack.
They will tell their children and grandchildren the stories. Surely others around the world
will remember the event—and undoubtedly the citizens in Afghanistan and Iraq will
remember the consequences for their own countries. These memories and stories are
forever imbedded in the fabric of the global consciousness.
The collective identity of impacted countries is changed by the traumatic event. But this
changed identity is not stagnant. Collective identity is changed throughout history, and
will continue to be shaped by future events. Consciousness is continuously growing to
include the events that have been built into the collective memory. Consciousness
development can be described as, “our responses to the current global uncertainty, to
threats to the safety of our loved ones, and to changes in our world [that] are colored by
our learned response to threat” (Johnson, 2006, 99). The significant word in that
description is “learned”. Every worldview is the compilation of learned beliefs and
attitudes and “if difficult experiences form toxic beliefs and attitudes”, then, “the result
will be a perpetuation of difficult experiences” (Johnson, 2006, 109). Thus the collective
consciousness that arises from unhealed traumatic events in any culture is generally
reflected in the actions that the traumatized society feels are natural and inherent. It is a
cycle of learning from past experiences and regurgitating the responses that seem
acceptable and normal. Teilhard de Chardin describes this evolution of collective
-
8/9/2019 Healing Societal Traumas and Transforming Collective Consciousness
39/98
39
consciousness, which he calls the “noosphere” as being “inherited by each succeeding
generation of conscious individuals, and to which each generation adds something”
(Chardin, as cited in Elgin, October 1997, 6).
It is vital to the maturation of a society that it is able to transform its collective
consciousness. Many researchers have warned that if humankind does not manage to
advance the collective consciousness, the result will be a never-ending cycle of violence;
a “race between collective awakening and global catastrophe” (Elgin, October 1997, 3).
Many cultures advance the notion of individual learning and improvement, but most
ignore the important role of functioning at a societal level. Duane Elgin notes, “By
focusing primarily on the individual, East and West have neglected the integral role that
the awakening of the collective plays in both personal and cultural evolution” (Elgin,
October 1997, 5). Throughout history societies have gone through a collective process of
maturing and evolving into different levels of consciousness. The process is normal and
natural. No stage in the process of evolution is better than another; each are simply states
through which the human mind naturally progresses; all are essential for providing “more
depth and a broader scope of experience” (Elgin, October 1997, 15). Each stage is a
necessary progression in the overall consciousness; however, each has its limitations and
as a result, the society usually manages to progress to a new level of understanding.
Elgin believes that none of the first three stages of consciousness evolution can allow for
a “form of social organization adequate to provide a framework for the future”, because
the less developed worldviews put an emphasis on violence (Elgin, October 1997, 15).
-
8/9/2019 Healing Societal Traumas and Transforming Collective Consciousness
40/98
40
It becomes dangerous when a culture is unable to evolve in a positive way. There are
different theories about the outcome of a society that is unable to raise its collective
consciousness, but in all scenarios, the consequence is catastrophe. Alternatively, if a
culture is able to mature in a healthy, positive way, the result is unity and nonviolence.
Unity is “the purposeful integration of two or more unique entities in a state of harmony
and cooperation, resulting in the creation of a new, evolving entity, usually of a higher
nature” (Clarke-Habibi and Danesh as cited in Makortoff, 2006). Unity is one of the
prerequisites for a mature collective consciousness. The creation of consciousness is
continuous and can be influenced by many positive and negative factors. It is necessary
to help the collective consciousness of a society evolve in a way that will include the
principle of unity in order to transform the negative consequences of an un-evolved
culture.
Collective Consciousness Transformation through Trauma Healing
Traumatic societal events leave a negative impression on the collective consciousness
and identity of the impacted culture. Since it is important for any society to mature into a
new, constructive stage of collective consciousness, it is necessary for cultural healing to
take place after any traumatic event. If healing does not occur, the responses and results
of the trauma will feed back into the violent cycle, stalling the chances for maturation of
the consciousness. Larry Dossey explains, “[w]e have for so long defined ourselves as
separate personalities that we have fallen into the hypnotic spell of believing that
-
8/9/2019 Healing Societal Traumas and Transforming Collective Consciousness
41/98
41
separation, not unity, is the underlying reality” (Dossey as cited in Elgin, October 1997,
6).
Elgin suggests that as a species, the consciousness of humankind has evolved several
times in the past, so it is not implausible to think that humans are again in the process of a
change. He acknowledges however, that “when our capacity for collective consciousness
first awakens, what will probably emerge will be the deep psychic wounds that have
festered through humanity’s history—the voices that have been unacknowledged and the
pain that has been unexpressed” (Elgin, October 1997, 27, 12). It is necessary for human
beings to learn how to heal from the many collective traumas that are inevitable in each
society. If humankind cannot heal from these traumas, it will be in danger of continuing
in a never-ending cycle of violence. Human beings have the ability to create identities,
memories and worldviews, and must be conscious of the damage that traumatic events
have on the collective consciousness. With newfound knowledge of the negative
consequences of unhealed trauma on societies, a solution can be found. Elgin cautions,
“Humanity’s evolutionary success depends not only on awakening our collective
consciousness but also on promoting its health and healing” (Elgin, October 1997, 4).
-
8/9/2019 Healing Societal Traumas and Transforming Collective Consciousness
42/98
42
Healing from Trauma—Posttraumatic Stress Disorder
There are many different methods for healing from trauma. By understanding unique
approaches for healing from traumatic events, techniques can be gained for healing entire
societies, and for creating a collective consciousness that incorporates healthy processes
for healing. One method that has been well researched and examined at many levels is
Posttraumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD). Posttraumatic Stress Disorder has been
researched for many years, but the term PTSD was not coined by the American
Psychiatric Association (APA) until 1980 (Johnson, 2006, 92). The disorder had a long
history of misunderstanding and was diagnosed as many other disorders and problems
before finally qualifying as PTSD. The APA discloses that approximately 10 percent of
the U.S. population has at some point been diagnosed with PTSD, while many others
have exhibited similar symptoms without being diagnosed
(http://www.psych.org/disasterpsych/fs/ptsd.cfm). Additionally, cases of individuals
diagnosed with PTSD seems to be increasing due possibly in part to new common-
knowledge of the disorder, or to a new wave of individuals inflicted with post 9-11
trauma symptoms (Continuing Medical Education, 2002, 1). Finally acknowledging
PTSD as a disease that affects hundreds of people world-wide helped show the
connection between the suffering and problems that people were having and the event in
their past that was triggering these responses.
PTSD, most commonly associated with war veterans, and known as “Da Costa’s
Syndrome” during the Civil War, is now understood to be a disorder that affects both
-
8/9/2019 Healing Societal Traumas and Transforming Collective Consciousness
43/98
43
men and women whether or not they were involved with war-trauma
(http://www.ncptsd.va.gov/facts/general/fs_what_is_ptsd.html). The effects of trauma
are often similar to those experienced by other trauma victims but are distinguished by
the fact that all of the symptoms are felt by individuals experiencing PTSD. The term
Posttraumatic Stress Disorder is used to define the collection of symptoms of trauma.
Symptoms of PTSD are grouped into three categories: avoidance (of friends, family and
colleagues), hyperarousal (a constant fear or belief that “danger is near”) and intrusion (or
intrusive flashbacks) (www.psych.org/disasterpsych/fs/ptsd.cfm).
The characteristic that defines these symptoms as PTSD is that all three of these
indicators occur together and interact with each other. Additionally, certain reactions that
are common with PTSD patients and will help distinguish PTSD from other results of
trauma are that:
[T]he traumatic event must be seen as life threatening [to oneself or to
others] and overwhelming; the person must experience the event; the
reexperiencing of the event must cause symptoms of withdrawal or
avoidance; reexperience must also cause overarousal symptoms (Johnson,
2006, 94-96).
In order to be diagnosed with PTSD, these symptoms must continue for at least one
month, however, in all patients with PTSD, these times vary greatly, and for some, the
symptoms will not arise for six months or more, making it very difficult for individuals to
connect their current troubles with the past traumatic event.
For most victims of PTSD, memories of their trauma strike without warning. Many of
the same feelings and emotions experienced during the traumatic event accompany the
-
8/9/2019 Healing Societal Traumas and Transforming Collective Consciousness
44/98
44
“flashbacks” unpredictably—sometimes as extreme as feeling as though the actual
trauma was occurring again. Other symptoms can include nightmares, difficulty
sleeping, and feelings of estrangement which have severe effects on the person’s entire
life (www.ncptsd.va.gov/facts/general/fs_what_is_ptsd.html). Some of these symptoms
may seem unconnected to the previous trauma, including, fear, nightmares, feelings of
helplessness, depression, relationship troubles, difficulty relating in social settings,
anxiety and alcoholism or drug abuse. A diagnosis for PTSD helps many individuals
understand that there is a reason for these seemingly strange and uncharacteristic attitudes
and actions.
Treatment for PTSD
Although trauma healing is often a complicated and protracted process, it is possible to
heal the symptoms of trauma. Now that PTSD is more often recognized as a real and
serious disorder, research has been conducted on treatment and healing. Many different
procedures have been developed and have been largely successful at treating PTSD. Five
different practices are identified by the APA: Behavior therapy, psychodynamic
psychotherapy, family therapy, discussion groups, and medication. These treatments
cover a variety of different practices for healing all aspects of the traumatic experience,
from “correcting the painful and intrusive patterns of behavior and thought” to examining
personal values and how the experience of the event changed them. These healing
techniques involve relaxation and re-examining assumptions about the facts of the
trauma. Work is also done with family members and group counseling to help each
person realize that similar reactions during trauma are common and understandable.
-
8/9/2019 Healing Societal Traumas and Transforming Collective Consciousness
45/98
45
Medication, including antidepressants, is also used to help control the negative effects
(www.psych.org/disasterpsych/fs/ptsd.cfm).
The objective for PTSD treatment has expanded beyond helping a survivor to forget the
trauma, but rather to “facilitate re-processing and integration of the traumatic memory,
into the larger fabric of the person’s emotional and psychological life” (Continuing
Medical Education, 2002, 1). Another treatment not identified by the APA, but used by
some psychiatrists for anxiety disorders and panic attacks called, “exposure therapy”,
engages survivors in repeated reliving of the traumatic event “under controlled conditions
to help him or her work through the trauma”
(http://www.ncptsd.va.gov/facts/general/fs_what_is_ptsd.html).
In addition to both the common and more unusual methods for treating PTSD, Douglas
Bremner, a psychiatrist and researcher suggests that simply educating a victim of trauma
of the strange but normal ways that an individual’s mind and body react to traumatic
events, and helping him to realize that his reactions are simply part of the process, helps
the ultimate healing progression. Bremner notes that he has “found that education is
what helps trauma survivors and PTSD patients the most. You have to take responsibility
for teaching yourself as much as possible about stress and stress responses. Education
actually helps in the recovery process” (Bremner, 2005, xv).
Difficulties with PTSD Treatment
-
8/9/2019 Healing Societal Traumas and Transforming Collective Consciousness
46/98
-
8/9/2019 Healing Societal Traumas and Transforming Collective Consciousness
47/98
47
Lastly, but potentially most importantly, PTSD treatment does little to help distinguish
the societal effects on healing from trauma. “Healing” as defined by the World Health
Organization (WHO) is “not merely the absence of disease and infirmity but a positive
state of physical, emotional and social well-being” (as cited in Hamber, 2003, 77).
Because of the interconnectedness and complexity of the various effects of a traumatic
event, the healing process is difficult and lengthy. As discussed in the previous section,
the worry with all healing, and particularly with PTSD, is that simply concentrating on
symptoms of trauma is not enough to fully heal. In addition to dealing with the outcome
of trauma, “the origins of violence and its meaning to those involved, as well as the social
and cultural context” must be understood and addressed (Hamber, 2003, 79). Too often,
treatment for individuals affected by trauma focuses on the immediate and obvious
symptoms of the trauma but ignores other issues within the person’s life that may create
difficulties during the healing process. It also ignores the possibly detrimental healing
methods used by the society itself. What is necessary is “deal[ing] with the causes of the
distress and the symptoms…what needs to be ‘healed’ is the multitude of individual,
political, social and cultural responses to a traumatic situation and its aftermath”
(Hamber, 2003, 78). Many times the problems associated with individual trauma
survivors are, in actuality, problems created in the larger society that have not been fully
resolved (Hamber, 2003, 87).
Although the methods for PTSD treatment are continuously being examined and
perfected, ultimately the healing process must begin at a societal level, with the entire
population working towards incorporating methods for positive cultural healing into the
-
8/9/2019 Healing Societal Traumas and Transforming Collective Consciousness
48/98
48
collective consciousness, so that healing is seen as a necessary and normal aspect of
dealing with life’s events.
-
8/9/2019 Healing Societal Traumas and Transforming Collective Consciousness
49/98
49
Healing from Trauma—Truth and Reconciliation Commissions
Many researchers and practitioners have recognized the vital necessity of developing a
method for healing from the adverse effects of traumatic experiences. A great deal of
work has been done in countries around the world to find and cultivate these methods.
This paper has already looked at techniques that are used for healing individuals with
PTSD. This is a fairly widespread and increasingly well-known disorder and
subsequently, treatment for the disorder is progressing continuously. However, as has
been shown, the work that is being done to heal individuals with PTSD is not fully
appropriate for all traumatic situations and individuals.
Another process for healing from traumatic experiences that has undergone much
scrutiny is the South African Truth and Reconciliation Commission, and other less
commonly known Truth and Reconciliation Commissions. The most celebrated TRC
occurred in South Africa immediately following the Apartheid Era. Most people are less
familiar with the fact that between 20 and 402 Truth Commissions in different forms have
been conducted since 1974 (the South African TRC was appointed in 1995, although they
attempted other Truth Commissions in 1992 and ’93) (Avruch and Vejarano, 2001, 37;
GTRC, 2006, 9). Although the dozens of past commissions varied in many ways, they
held in common a belief that “shared truth was essential for social reconciliation”
(Lerche, 2000, 1). The following is an alphabetical list of Truth Commissions identified
2 Different sources define Truth Commissions differently and thus do not qualify some of the past
commissions as TRCs or Truth Commissions.
-
8/9/2019 Healing Societal Traumas and Transforming Collective Consciousness
50/98
50
since 1974 by Avruch and Vejarano, with additions from the United States Institute for
Peace:
Argentina (1983-1984), Bolivia (1982-1984), Brazil (1986), Chad (1991-
1992), Chile (1990-1991), East Timor (1999-2000), El Salvador (1992-
1993), Ethiopia (1993-2000), Germany (1992-1994), Ghana (2001—
ongoing), Guatemala (1997-1999), Haiti (1995-1996), Honduras (1993),Nepal (1991), Nigeria (1999), Panama (2001), Paraguay (1976), Peru
(2000), Philippines (1986), Rwanda (1993), Serbia and Montenegro
(2001), Sierra Leone (1999-ongoing), South Africa (1992 and 1993; TRC
in 1995), South Korea (2000), Uganda (1974 and 1986-1995), Uruguay
(1985), Zimbabwe (1985) (Avruch and Vejarano, 2001, 37; USIP,http://www.usip.org/library/truth.html).
Truth-seeking Commissions have also previously been attempted in the United States
after comparable community traumas, examining the events in Rosewood, Florida, in
1923, the Tulsa Race Riot of 1921, and the Wilmington Race Riot in 1898. Similar
efforts have also been made at a national level, investigating Japanese American
imprisonment during World War II and an apology and reparations were given by
President Clinton to the Tuskegee syphilis experiments victims after a period of research
and a final report (GTRC, 2006, 13). Additionally, later in this paper, a large-scale Truth
and Reconciliation Commission in Greensboro, North Carolina, will be examined as a
model for healing following the death and wounding of several protestors.
The premise behind many Truth Commissions is that in order to heal from mass trauma,
it is necessary to come to terms with the actual events as they took place. Generally, past
Truth Commissions have developed after a large trauma has affected a state. A body of
individuals is appointed to research the facts of the designated time period. Truth
-
8/9/2019 Healing Societal Traumas and Transforming Collective Consciousness
51/98
51
Commissions allow perpetrators, victims, families and others to give accounts of the
events that took place. The theory is that shared truth-telling and understanding will help
the affected population understand the trauma that happened in an unbiased and factual
way. The South African TRC, in particular, aimed at helping to “ventilate the evidence,
establish the truth and bring about reconciliation” (Lerche, 2000, 8).
It is commonly thought that the TRC process would stand “to reestablish a baseline of
right and wrong, to humanize the perpetrators and to obtain and disclose previously
hidden information about what happened, who gave orders, [and] where missing persons
ended up” (Minow, 1998, 338). Ultimately, the theory behind Truth Commissions is that
the shared acknowledgement of past wrongs and a common understanding of the way
forward will heal the country better than past methods for simply dealing with the
problem, commonly through a form of retributive justice. Truth Commissions attempt to
allow victims to share their pain, perpetrators to explain their view of the facts and for the
affected population as a whole to collectively heal from the deep impact of trauma.
Earlier, this paper discussed the effects that trauma can have on the consciousness of
individuals and how memories can actually encompass “facts” that did not really occur
during the event. The pieces of the trauma are compiled in the victim’s brain in
sometimes haphazard ways. The same is observably true in entire societies affected by a
common trauma. Thus Truth Commissions can exist as an opportunity to find clarity and
ultimately to help the population heal and move on. Martha Minow, a Harvard Law
-
8/9/2019 Healing Societal Traumas and Transforming Collective Consciousness
52/98
52
professor, explains that Truth Commissions can, “cut through myths, rumors, and false
pictures about the past” (Minow, 1998, 337).
Many TRC mandates also require the commissions to write a report or other written
document that will be used to verify the findings. This is often a crucial aspect of the
groups’ work, since historical evidence of the trauma will then be clarified for future
generations (USIP, http://www.usip.org/library/truth.html).
Truth and Reconciliation Commissions, though differing greatly in scale, resources, time-
frame and level of trauma, all seek the same thing: the truth about their shared past,
reconciliation in the community, and an opportunity to move into the future with an
increased level of unity.
Treatment through TRCs
Truth Commissions differ considerably in their approach. They have been established by
international organizations (such as the United Nations), and nongovernmental
organizations, but the majority have been initiated by the national governments in the
countries where the trauma occurred (Avruch and Vejarano, 2001, 37). Although the
trauma differs in every situation, most commissions have revolved around an issue of
severe human rights abuses.
-
8/9/2019 Healing Societal Traumas and Transforming Collective Consciousness
53/98
53
The South African Truth and Reconciliation Commission’s mandate, following the
period of Apartheid, looked for accounts of the many abuses, identification of
perpetrators, and even reasons why such violence and mistreatment was allowed to
happen. The South African TRC was started by the “Promotion of National Unity and
Reconciliation Act” of 1995, which was approved by former president Nelson Mandela.
It specifically allowed for the creation of a Truth and Reconciliation Commission through
three committees: Committee on Human Rights Violations, Committee on Amnesty, and
a Committee on Reparation and Rehabilitation. The act expressly called on the TRC to
accomplish the following:
the investigation and the establishment of as complete a picture as possible
of the nature, causes and extent of gross violations of human rights
committed…the granting of amnesty to persons who make full disclosure
of all the relevant facts relating to acts associated with a political
objective…affording victims an opportunity to relate the violations they
suffered; the taking of measures aimed at the granting of reparation to, andthe rehabilitation restoration of the human and civil dignity of, victims of
violations of human rights . . . the making of recommendations aimed at
the prevention of the commission of gross violations of human rights
(Federation of American Scientists,
http://www.fas.org/irp/world/rsa/act95_034.htm).
Most truth commissions, like the South African TRC, have a specific time period for the
research to be conducted and also stipulate the exact time frame that will be examined.
The commission works to heal the traumatized nation by compiling an accurate account
of the events that took place, and suggesting or enforcing methods to address the abuses
that occurred, thus moving forward and healing from the pain inflicted on all individuals.
It is understood that until there is “public acknowledgement of what has happened”, no
healing process will be able to have long-term positive results (Avruch and Vejerano,
-
8/9/2019 Healing Societal Traumas and Transforming Collective Consciousness
54/98
54
2001, 41). Truth and Reconciliation Commissions are able to help raise the awareness of
such atrocities.
Many methods are used to understand the truth about the past trauma. Two aspects seem
to be shared by most of the previous Truth and Reconciliation Commissions: public
testimony and g