use of role plays to enhace english speaking skills
TRANSCRIPT
Running head: USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 1
The use of role plays to enhance English speaking communicative ability in an adult EFL
learners' group from the Business Management program at Universidad de la Amazonia
Blanca A. Góngora and Hader Manjarrez
Universidad de la Amazonia
Author Note
Blanca A. Góngora and Hader Manjarrez, Education Sciences Faculty, English Language
Teaching Program, Universidad de la Amazonia.
This research was supported by Business Management Program, Universidad de la Amazonia
Correspondence concerning this paper should be addressed to Jader Manjarrez,
English Language Teaching Program, Universidad de la Amazonia, E-mail:
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 2
ACCEPTATION NOTE
The present final document to the Bachelor in English has been reviewed and scored with the
note of Approved
(Art 40 from the agreement 05 of April 29, 2005, from C.S.U)
__________________________
Juror 1
__________________________
Juror 2
“The Universidad de la Amazonia is not responsible for the concepts emitted by the students who work on this research project. The ideas expressed within this document are the sole
responsibility of the authors”
“El Director y el Jurado del presente Trabajo, no son responsables de las ideas y conclusiones expuestas en éste; ellas son exclusividad de sus autores”
Florencia, November, 2014
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 3
DEDICATION
To my Parents, Blanca Nora Mendoza and Ramiro Góngora, for being always by my side with
their lovely and wonderful kindness, devotion, tireless and endless support. And to my professors
who in any way influenced on my process of academic formation.
Blanca Aleyda Góngora Mendoza
Firstly, to God for guiding me in every step of my life, to my mother Olga, who always
supported me in this process, my siblings Medwin, Dayhana and Anderson, who encourage me
to do my best and finally, to my professors who I learnt from.
Hader Manjarrez Morales
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 4
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
To the professor SILVIA LUCIA MOLINA HIGUERA, director of our degree project who gave us her full support and knowledge to develop this research project.
To the professor JULIAN MEJIA, juror of our degree project who disposed his precious time to guide us so that we could carry out this research project.
To the professor WILLINGTON, juror of our degree project, who supported and guided us with his knowledge and experience in order for us to develop this research project as it is required.
To the specialist CARLOS ALBERTO GOMES, for his collaboration, time, accompaniment and space offered to develop the research project.
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 5
Content
INTRODUCTION…………………………………………………………..................……..5
1. RESEARCH PROBLEM…..……………………………………………...………..…….16
1.1. Description of the problem…………….………..………………………….....….….16
1.2. Problematic question…………………………….………………………..…………18
1.3. Justification……………………………………………………..……………………19
1.4. Context description…………………………………………………………………..20
1.4.1. Spatial delimitation……………………………………………………………20
1.4.2. Temporal delimitation…………………………………………………………22
1.4.3. Historical review……………………………………………………………….22
1.4.4. Situational analysis ………………………..…………………………………..26
2. OBJECTIVES…………………………………………………………………………….. 27
2.1. General objective…………………………..……………………………………...….27
2.2. Specific objective……………………………………………………………………..27
3. LITERATURE REVIEW ………………………………….…………..……….................28
3.1. State of the art ………………………………….………………….…….……………28
3.2. Conceptual framework…………………………..…………………...………….…....31
3.2.1. Speaking……………………………….…………………………….................31
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 6
3.2.1.1. Speaking concept………………..……...……………………..…...32
3.2.1.2. Teaching speaking ………….……..……………………..…..…....33
3.2.1.1. Guidance for teaching speaking ……………………………...…...34
3.2.2. Role play………………………………………………………….………....35
3.2.2.1. Role play concept………………………………………….............35
3.2.3. Communicative competence……………………………………..……….... 37
3.2.4. Teacher and learners’ roles in role playing as a teaching technique………..38
3.2.4.1. Teacher’s role……….. ……………. ……………….………........38
3.2.4.2. Learners’ role……….. ………………….. ……………….….......38
3.2.4. Adult EFL learner…………….. ……………. ……………..……….……..39
3.2.5. Syllabus……………………...………………………….…………..…........41
3.2.6. Evaluation ……………………………………………….……………..…..42
3.2.7. Activities to be applied within Role playing..………………..……………..44
3.3. Normativity……………………………………………….……….………………45
4. METHODOLOGY……………………………………………………………………...47
4.1. Type of research methodology……….…………………..………………………..47
4.1.1 Action Research…………………….……………………..…….…………..47
4.2. Design research methodology………………………………………………..……49
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 7
4.2.1. Population………………………………………………………………… …49
4.2.2. Data collection tools …………………….……….…..……………...…... .....49
4.2.3. Steps of the research study ……………….……….…..………………....…..50
4.2.3.1. Phase 1.… ……..…………..….…….……………..………………………..51
4.2.3.2. Phase 2..………..……….…...…………….…..…………………….…........52
4.2.3.3. Phase 3..………….………………..………………………………...............52
5. OUTCOMES AND DISCUSSION………………………………………………………54
5.1. Characterization of the focused group………………………………………….54
5.2. Description and analysis of the phases………………………………………….55
5.3. Limitations………………………………………………………………………77
6. CONCLUSIONS………………………………………………………………………….79
7. .RECOMMENDATIONS…………………………………………………………………81
8. REFERENCES ………………………………………..………………………………….83
9. ANNEXES…………………………….…………………………………...….………….88
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 8
List of tables Table 1: Chronogram of activities.
Table 2: Summary of the research techniques applied.
Table 3: Description of the respondents.
Table 4: Table of analysis of structured questionnaire.
Table 5: Table of analysis of the interviews conducted to the focused group.
Table 6: Focused group of study
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 9
List of figures
Figure 1: Location of Florencia in Caquetá department.
Figure 2: Location of Universidad de la Amazonia.
Figure 3: Participants’ ages
Figure 4: Participants’ semester
Figure 5: Analysis of questionnaire, question 1
Figure 6: Analysis of questionnaire, question 2
Figure 7: Grammar and vocabulary
Figure 8: Reading skills section
Figure 9: writing skill section
Figure 10: Speaking skill section
Figure 11: Analysis of Grammar and Vocabulary section
Figure 12: Analysis of reading skill section
Figure 13: Analysis of writing skill section
Figure 14: Analysis of speaking skill section
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 10
List of annexes
Annex 1: Analysis of the data gathered from the interview.
Annex 2: Syllabus
Annex 3: Basics of PAP Style Tutorial
Annex 4: Format of questionnaire
Annex 5: Format of interview
Annex 6: Interviews
Annex 7: Format of pre-test
Annex 8: Format of expectation survey
Annex 9: Photographs
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 11
Abstract
Much has been investigated about the methodological strategies for learning English
language in an effective manner, where students can effectively develop the English Speaking
communicative skill. Undoubtedly teachers focused on such a field await that language learners,
at the end of the learning process, have the ability to establish real communication in a foreign
language, in this case English.
To achieve this general objective, it was adopted the use of role plays in students from VI
and IX semesters of Business Management Program from the Universidad de la Amazonia. This
Teaching Technique was applied in order to provide some tools to the students so that they can
cope and thrive in the English language, reduce their affective filters and start speaking English
confidently.
The application of the Role Playing Teaching Technique was momentous in students
because this research was focused on enhancing the English speaking ability of the participants,
intending they acquired language in such a way that they communicate and interact with others,
simulating real-life situations. Additionally, the implementation of this technique encouraged
students to create and think in real situations, while practicing the English language. It also
encouraged them to participate actively and confidently in different situations presented during
the development of the course.
KEY WORDS: Speaking, Real communication, Confidently, Role Play, real-life
situations.
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 12
Resumen
Mucho se ha investigado acerca de las estrategias metodológicas para el aprendizaje de
idioma Inglés de una manera eficaz, donde los estudiantes puedan desarrollar efectivamente las
habilidades comunicativas del idioma inglés. Sin lugar a dudas, los profesores se centraron en
éste campo esperando que los estudiantes de una lengua extranjera, al final del proceso de
aprendizaje tengan la capacidad de establecer una verdadera comunicación en un idioma
extranjero, en este caso Inglés.
Para lograr este objetivo general, se adoptó el uso de juegos de roles en los estudiantes de
los semestres VI a IX del Programa de Administración de Empresas de la Universidad de la
Amazonia. Esta técnica de enseñanza se aplicó con el fin de proporcionar algunas herramientas a
los estudiantes para que puedan enfrentar y progresar en el idioma Inglés, reducir sus filtros
afectivos y empezar a hablar inglés con seguridad.
La aplicación de la Técnica de Enseñanza de Juegos de Roles fue trascendental en los
estudiantes, porque esta investigación se centró en mejorar la capacidad de habla en Inglés de los
participantes. Con la intención que adquirieran el lenguaje de tal manera que se comuniquen e
interactúen con otros, simulando situaciones de la vida real. Adicionalmente, la aplicación de
ésta técnica animó a los estudiantes a crear y pensar en situaciones reales, en la práctica del
idioma Inglés, también les animó a participar activamente y con seguridad en las diferentes
situaciones que se presentaron durante el desarrollo del curso.
PALABRAS CLAVE: Habla, comunicación real, confianza, juego de roles, situaciones
de la vida real.
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 13
Introduction
In this paper, it is presented an Action Research study, born with the purpose of
improving the English teaching and learning process carried out in the Business Management
program at Universidad de la Amazonia. The study was based on the use of Role Plays to
enhance the speaking communicative abilities of a selected adult EFL learners' group (from sixth
to tenth semester) of Business Management Program at Universidad de la Amazonia.
The Role playing Teaching Technique was chosen to develop this research study due to
the significant learning that it offers to foreign language learners. This technique allowed
students to develop the ability to engage in contextualized and real communication in English. It
stimulated self-confidence through different real life situations presented throughout the course.
This technique, applied in this Action Research, ensured the language to be acquired and used
for the accomplishment of the actual function of language, encouraging students to learn and
practice the English Language while simulating real life situations. Role plays teaching
technique stimulated learners’ creativity and thinking due to permitting students to learn and
practice new language, creating necessary motivation and participation for enabling learning to
occur. Moreover, Role plays were effective as it helped participants improve not only English
speaking communicative skills, but also listening, reading and writing, indirectly.
During the development of this research a pre-test was applied and a survey about course
expectations. Once gathered, this information was adapted and a syllabus was implemented
according to the proficiency level that students had shown in the pre-test. At the end of the
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 14
course, the collection of data through different tools (diaries, observation, interviews and
questionnaires) was carried out and finally, a final/ post-test was applied that would allow us to
value and measure the progress of the target group.
All phases were developed according to the proposed schedule, design, implementation
and evaluation of lessons, data collection and finally the analysis of information obtained. In this
report there are exposed nine sections. First, the problem and description of the problem. Second,
objective of this research. Third, the literature review. Fourth, methodology. Fifth, results. Sixth,
seventh, eighth and ninth, display conclusions, recommendations, references and annexes
respectively, which describe in detail what was conducted.
The first section contains a description of the problem found and why this research was
carried out, a brief description of the context in which it was carried out. An analysis and
description of the spatial location of population was also performed.
The second section presents the aims and objectives of this research.
The third section contains the literature review and state of the art, a thorough description
of the Role Play Teaching Technique, the abilities this technique works with, English
communicative skills, the role of teachers and students.
The fourth section presents the methodology used in this action research, the data
collection tools, and steps for the development of it.
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 15
The fifth section presents the results of the research conducted, the description of each
phase and the description of focused group, limitations and drawbacks presented during the
investigation. Finally, it is included conclusions, recommendations, references and annexes,
where all the information collected during the development of this project is located.
This project wants to emphasize that results obtained by this research were satisfactory
because the students who formed the focused group, could establish a basic communication in
English and also showed improvement in other skills worked, as writing, grammar and reading.
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 16
1. Research Problem
1.1. Description of the problem
Evidently, nowadays the ability to speak in just one language is not enough in this
interconnected world. The capacity to be bilingual or multilingual is every time more
indispensable to study, work, interact with others and learn about different cultures. The Ministry
of Education (MEN, 2005) states that being bilingual is essential in a globalized world because it
allows better communication, opens boundaries, comprehends other contexts; it contributes
directly to the development of the country to have more knowledge and opportunities, so as to be
more competent and competitive. It makes possible an individual growth, which can definitely
help in the country growth as well.
Also, students from different educational levels are evaluated by the ICFES enterprise
through diverse types of tests in which their English language level and proficiency is tested.
Therefore, the Universidad de la Amazonia; following the Colombian Policies, established two
English courses in the curriculum of some careers (as a subject of their first and second
semester), within those careers, it is found the Business Management degree program, which has
as occupational profile features of any Business Management’s student, the following ones in
their original language “willingness always open to innovation and continuous improvement.
Respect for ideas, needs, expectations and other rights. Objectivity and reliability in their
judgments, commitments and approaches. Adaptability and simplicity in interpersonal
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 17
relationships "(UDLA, 2013) and" Skill in directing and organizing staff according to
productivity and quality goals. Talent to negotiate at different levels and situations. Ability to
stay updated and informed on all business aspects” (UDLA, 2013). This means that each and
every Business Management graduated student from Universidad de la Amazonia should present
a wide disposition to lead, organize, innovate and carry out a steady improvement, as well as
keeping updated around the aspects concerning the business field having adaptability in the
interpersonal relations. Undoubtedly, this demands the English language use, if it is wanted, to
have real and wider relations and opportunities in the professional aspect taking into account
others’ ideas, expectations and rights, including the English language proficiency, and fluency
for success and advancement in their field as employees and employers.
Nevertheless, after listening to one of the researchers´ relatives, who expressed her
unconformity about not gaining much speaking skills in her English classes, as a student of
Business Management program. Researchers, who were students from the English Program,
decided to interview some students from the Business Management Program. As a result, some
stand-alone interviews posed in an informal environment were done. Some answers showed that
English skills they developed during their English classes were not enough as they expected.
Analyzing the data, it was noticed that most students agreed on saying that their English classes
did not increase their motivation to learn the language because Professors most of the time used
“a school methodology” (Traditional one), which they defined as: just photocopies with images.
Hence, the contents taught during the English courses, along with the teaching methodology
implemented, did not provide a strong enough basis for the acquisition of communicative skills
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 18
that enabled them to communicate in English with their classmates or other people (see Annex
1).
As a consequence, there was marked the necessity of the promotion of new teaching
techniques in Business Management program at Universidad de la Amazonia. For that reason,
this research study took place. The study consisted of the implementation of role plays to
enhance the English speaking skill of a selected group of Business Management’s students (from
third and tenth semester). For doing this, the participants attended deliberately an additional
English course. The course did not make part of the unique two courses included in their
curriculum (in first and second semesters). All this, bearing in mind that Role Plays (as Teaching
Technique) was an excellent alternative that could bring positive and expected outcomes in the
improvement of English speaking proficiency of the selected group.
1.2. Problematic question
¿To what extend does role playing improve the English speaking communicative ability in
adult EFL students from the Business Management program at Universidad de la Amazonia?
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 19
1.3. Justification
Nowadays it is fundamental to communicate in the English language. Every day it is used all
around this globalized world by people from different nations who are demanded to use it due to
reasons such as job, travel or academy. That is why it is important for Business Management
program’s adult students to manage the English Language as students and professionals. Hence,
this research project highlighted to expose Business Management’s students to Role Playing
Teaching Technique that permitted them to increase their English speaking ability for
communication.
This research project sought out to change the non-efficient teaching methodology applied to
Business Management’s students for the use of role plays, with the intention of promoting the
students’ motivation toward the English language, as well as developing speaking
communicative skills (while listening, reading and writing are developed indirectly). And so,
provide insights for EFL teaching. Consequently, its development looked to guide and support
mainly to the university, but also any person interested in the Teaching English as a foreign
language to adults field. Hence, this research carried out while teaching through role plays could
certainly help determine to what extent it is applicable for developing speaking skills in adult
EFL learners of a career different from one directly related to the English Language.
The findings obtained can influence the adoption of Role plays as an appropriate Foreign
Language Teaching technique implemented at Universidad de la Amazonia, so as to help
enhance the students’ level of language performance and promote a change in teaching
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 20
methodology used by teachers. All this, headed to enhance daily and contribute to the
development and progress of the education quality of the Universidad de la Amazonia and the
country. Likewise, while the Business Management’s students were positively affected, the
whole academic community of the Universidad de la Amazonia was also.
The English program, as well as people from other cities and countries interested in the issue
worked on in this research study, can also obtain great benefits from the information obtained as
the findings can suggest and give recommendations for future studies. Furthermore, the
knowledge gained by researching in the EFL field (in this case teaching English through
Roleplaying Teaching Technique) definitely gave some input to Foreign Language Learning and
education in general.
1.4. Context description
In this section, some general aspects are presented concerning the Universidad de la
Amazonia and the Business Management program; the place where the research study was
carried out.
1.4.1. Spatial delimitation
The research study was developed at the Universidad de la Amazonia, located in Florencia,
Caquetá, which is situated in southeast Colombia. (See figures Nº 1)
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 21
The main headquarter of the Universidad de la Amazonia is located in the 17th street, 17th
diagonal with Kr 3F, Porvenir neighborhood of Florencia – Caquetá, Colombia. To the
northwest, its limits find the avenue that leads to the Rincon de la Estrella neighborhood, to the
Northeast it is found the Abbas Turbay neighborhood, to the southeast, the Pablo VI urbanization
and to the southwest, the Porvenir and the circumambulate avenue are found. (See Figure Nº 2)
Figure 1: Location of Florencia in Caquetá department.
Figure 2: Location of Universidad de la Amazonia.
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 22
1.4.2 Temporal delimitation
The research study, as an option of graduation, was carried out during the months:
September, October and November of 2014 with an intensity of six hours per week.
1.4.3 Historical review
According to the history found on the web page: www.udla.edu.co, the Universidad de la
Amazonia had its beginnings at the Instituto Tecnológico Universidad Surcolombiana
(ITUSCO), which had the principal headquarter in Neiva, Huila, Colombia.
As a branch in Florencia, Caquetá, it began operating in 1971 by offering four programs in
Technology, Social Science, Mathematics, Accounting and Topography. With the Law 13 of
1976, ITUSCO was transformed into the Universidad Surcolombiana. Consequently, ITUSCO-
Florencia became its branch, whose activities were oriented from three faculties: Education
Sciences, Agricultural Sciences and Accounting and Economics Sciences.
In 1982, through Law 60 of December 30; sanctioned by the President of the Republic of
that time, Doctor Belisario Betancur Cuartas, the branch of the University Surcolombiana was
transformed into the University of Amazonia.
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 23
The Universidad de la Amazonia is official. The national level and its mission, vision,
objectives, functions and policies are aimed at contributing to the sustainable development of the
Amazon region. The challenges and commitments are fully known, not only the ones derived
from the current statutes related to the development of programs suited to the peculiarities of the
region, with the qualification of human talent through the dissemination of scientific and
technological knowledge, and with research in the Amazon, but those that have imposed the
World Declaration on Higher Education for the Twenty-first Century: Vision and Action,
adopted by UNESCO in October 1998. The statement expands the horizon and the work of the
Higher Education for the Next Millennium, in aspects such as accreditation, coverage, access to
college, internationalization, new educational technologies, etc.
Within the University history, it is found specifically the history of each and every program
the University offers. In this research study, it will be highlighted just the Business Management
program.
In 1991, the Universidad de la Amazonia submitted to the Ministry of Education, the project
for the creation of the Business Management Program. Through the Supreme Council’s
agreement 18 of 1993, the Business Management program at the Universidad de la Amazonia
was created. Thereafter, with the agreement 20 of 1994 of the Academic Council, the curriculum
was approved and with the agreement 26 of 1997, the curriculum was adopted.
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 24
The Business Management program was extended to other departments in this way: In
1996, started in Leticia, Amazonas; in both day and night shifts; in 1997 it extended to Mocoa,
Putumayo with just night shift and San Vicente del Caguán, in the department of Caquetá,
initiated in 1998, on the day shift only.
With the agreement 35 of 1998, the Superior Council of the Universidad de la Amazonia,
using its statutory powers, renews the approval of Business Management program from January
1st, 1999 until December 31, 2003. In the national system Information handled by ICFES, the
Business Management Program was given a registration number No. 111546580001800111200,
that allows to operate at the headquarter of Florencia, Caquetá, with the presential modality. As a
result of the self-assessment process, in 2004, a redesign curricular draft was submitted to the
Ministry of National Education (MEN) and the qualified register was obtained through resolution
1630 of April 17, 2006, valid for seven years, and with the identification code SNIES 791.
In 2007, the process of curriculum redesign, which modifies the curriculum with the credits
system, was carried out. It was based on the appropriate authorities and it was approved by the
agreement of 23 of the Academic Council, incorporating a total of 160 academic credits.
Moreover, two deeper areas were regulated: Organization Management, Entrepreneurship and
creation of organizations, according to the training needs of the context and the level of
professional performance.
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 25
The Business Management program is set to the current regulations and the existence. The
degrees awarded are justified by the needs of the country and the region where the current status
of training in the knowledge area makes it apart from other programs. The Business Management
program is framed on the Mission and Institutional Education Project (IEP). Within the
expectations of the program, it is highlighted the Mission and Vision, which reflects what is
expected and wanted from this.
Mission
It is an accredited higher education program that offers integral formation in the Amazon
region. It promotes ethics and responsibility for sustainable business development through
teaching and competency-based learning. We have a team of teachers with pedagogical and
disciplinary capabilities that supported by adequate infrastructure allows us to meet the
expectations of survival, growth, profitability, and regional equity.
Vision
It will be a professional formation of competencies program, in steady accreditation
oriented toward the business development whose education promotes the culture of
entrepreneurship, innovation, ethics, social responsibility, research and social projection in the
Amazon region.
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 26
1.4.4 Situational analysis.
The students who attended the English course were coursing sixth and ninth semester of
Business Management at Universidad de la Amazonia. They were adult people interested in
developing speaking skills to get to communicate with others in the English language. The
participants recognized that the technique applied in the study was a teaching exercise conceived
as an appropriate strategy to address concerns of pedagogical order related to the lack of their
English speaking skills development. Thus, the study contributes when it comes to their job
profile in terms of its social responsibility in a globalized world, which requires some English
language use as it is the universal language. So it may expand learners’ career opportunities.
The participants have already attended the English classes offered by the University during
their 1st and 2nd semesters. They have different characteristics related to the ages and
knowledge about the target language. The participants were taught in a room called:
Cananguchal room. It was the classroom where the lessons took place. It is one of the specialized
rooms the university has. It counts on a lot of space, acrylic board, air conditioning, television
and comfortable chairs. This research study was carried out from September 9th to November
13th, 2014.
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 27
2. Objectives
2.1. General objective
To enhance English speaking communicative skill through Role plays in a group of adult EFL
students from the Business Management program at Universidad de la Amazonia.
2. 2. Specific objectives
✓ To organize and develop a pre-test to establish students´ English level in order to identify
students’ initial proficiency.
✓ To apply an expectation survey to students to identify their point of view and likes toward
the English Language Learning.
✓ To adapt and apply a situational and task based syllabus to promote the speaking skill
through the use of Role Plays.
✓ To gather data through diaries, observation, interviews and questionnaires in order to
value the application of the Role Play as a technique to enhance speaking abilities.
✓ To measure students speaking abilities through a post-test in order to assess the impact of
the Role Play technique proposed
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 28
3. Literature review
"Learning to communicate is recognized as a principal goal of language learning and at the same time, by communicating, students learn the language"
(Ballman, Liskin-Gasparro & Mandell, 2001).
3.1. State of the art.
Various research studies have been done around the use and impact of the Role plays for
teaching English to EFL learners, as the ones presented below.
PRISCILLA ISLAM & TAZRIA ISLAM searched on the Effectiveness of role play in
enhancing the speaking skills of the learners in a large classroom: An investigation of tertiary
level students. They looked to enhance speaking skills by using role play in a large classroom.
Through qualitative data collection tools (questionnaires, group interviews, classroom
observation, and students’ performance evaluation result) it was concluded that the role play
technique had a positive impact in improving learners’ speaking skills as it gave students a
chance to explore different situations of real life and enabled them to speak accurately and
confidently in that situation in the target language. However, during role play activities in such a
large classroom the situation got chaotic, students forgot their dialogues; causing embarrassment.
Eventually the problem went away due to the positive feedback given by the teacher, and the
environment was comfortable. Students’ speaking abilities were getting better as the classes went
by and they felt more confident to speak. Nevertheless, the context in which their research took
place was much different from the context where this research study is intended to be applied.
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 29
Their study was done during four months in a large group of about one hundred and twenty
students (and five teachers took part of the investigation) of the Department of English of
Stamford University Bangladesh; a group that already had a good level in English. On the other
hand, our setting was a low-level adult EFL learners’ target group from the Business
Management program at Universidad de la Amazonia; a group of 25 adult participants who were
involved in the course six hours per week during three months.
Yuli rachmawati, Mukhlisatun Muayanah, & Endah Alamsari, (2013) researched on
“TEACHING SPEAKING BY USING ROLE PLAY OF THE FIFTH GRADE STUDENTS OF
MINU KH. MUKMIN SIDOARJO”. This study was led to describe the use of role play to teach
speaking and to describe students’ responses toward the technique. The object of the study was a
group of students at fifth grade of MINU KH MUKMIN SIDOARJO. The data was collected
through observation and questionnaires, having as findings and conclusions that the activities of
role playing involved teacher, students practiced and did performances. The technique was good
as students responded, students enjoyed the classes, felt happy, and found self-confidence when
speaking. On the contrary, the study applied in this research differs from the above just exposed
due to the object of this study was not young participants, but adult ones who made part of the
Business Management program at Universidad de la Amazonia.
Ramin Rahimy & Samaneh Safarpour (2012) THE EFFECT OF USING ROLE-PLAY ON
IRANIAN EFL LEARNERS’ SPEAKING ABILITY. They researched the effect of role-play as a
classroom activity aiming to determine how effective role playing could be when enhancing a
more acceptable speaking skill in Iranian EFL learners (60 intermediate in Shokouh Language
Institute in Bandar Anzali). The object of the experimental study was separated into experimental
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 30
and control groups, both were applied an oral pre-test. The Experimental group was taught
English through role-play activity while the control one was taught to speak through other
existent methods. After some sessions; conducting role plays, it was administered a post-test of
speaking and once again learners from both groups were asked to answer the post-test. Research
findings showed the great significant difference between the experimental and control group;
experimental one with more improvement.
Ayu Diyah Harni Susanti, (2007). USING ROLE PLAY IN TEACHING SPEAKING, carried
out a Pre-Experimental Study at Islamic Junior High School Soebono Mantofani Jombang-
Ciputat and the analysis of the findings concluded that students were taught speaking abilities by
the implementation of role play seemed so motivated, willing to participate deliberately and
showed better outcomes, which means it is quite effective.
Much has been written and investigated about which technique is appropriate for teaching
English as a foreign language. In fact, many of the Teaching techniques bring positive aspects
when planning a class. However, at the time of selecting the most suitable one, it must be kept in
mind all the factors surrounding the processes of teaching; the target group; its background, its
environment, their needs, the age, the goals, expectations, among other aspects are fundamental
when choosing a teaching technique.
Role Play teaching technique was selected for being applied in this research study, as it can
help enhance English Speaking communicative abilities of the target group, or in its absence,
help learners gain self – confidence in their capacities, and so acquire the basic elements of
effective communication in the Foreign Language. Similarly, it contributes to EFL teachers;
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 31
becoming conscious of the great importance of a good teaching technique selection for the
improvement of speaking skill in EFL contexts.
3.2. Conceptual framework
For the development of this research, it was necessary to support and find bases of some
important authors and sources that have had a huge impact on teaching technique and education.
3.2.1. Speaking
When people learn a language, they need to develop four language skills required for
complete communication; listening, reading, speaking and writing. The first two provide input
or reception of the language codes, and the last two provide production. Achieving
communication across the four skills is desired by any learner since all such skills fulfill an
essential function for communication.
Speaking is the productive skill in the oral form. This skill, developed along listening, is
more complex than it seems, since it involves more than just pronouncing words ( Rahelcynthia,
2013). All language skills are important for effective communication. However, speaking is
considered to be one of the most useful and essential language skills for communication. People
communicate with others to express ideas, thoughts and to know others’ ideas as well.
Communication occurs where there is speech. Without speech, we cannot communicate with
one another. Hence, the importance of speaking skills is enormous. Without speech, language is
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 32
minimized to a simple script. The use of language is an activity that takes place within the
community in a variety of situations.
3.2.1.1 Speaking concept
According to Merriam-Webster Dictionary (2014), speaking is defined as: “to say words in
order to express your thoughts, feelings, opinions, etc., to someone: to talk to someone, to talk
about a particular subject or person, to say words to express yourself in a particular way”
Speaking is also defined as “The process of building and sharing meaning through the use of
verbal and non-verbal symbols, in a variety of contexts” (Chaney cited in Kayi 2006)
Theodore Huebner (1960) by his side, says that “Language is essentially speech, and speech
is basically communication by sounds” Therefore, speaking is an ability used by someone in
daily life communication. It consists of competence in sending and receiving messages. The skill
is acquired by much repetition; it is chiefly a neuromuscular, but not an intellectual process
(Theodore Huebner, 1960).
Speaking is an interactive process of constructing meaning that involves
producing and receiving and processing information (Brown, 1994; Burns & Joyce, 1997). The
form and meaning of speaking depends on the context in which it takes place, the purposes for
speaking, the participants involved and the physical environment. Additionally, it is frequently
unpredictable, open-ended, and evolving. However, speech is not always spontaneous and
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 33
improvised; there exist some language functions that tend to recur in certain discourse situations
(e.g., requesting time off from work, giving condolences, etc.), can be predictable. (Burns
&Joyce, 1997).
Bearing in mind the above definitions, it can be simplified that speaking consists of
expressing opinions, ideas, or feelings to others through words or sounds in order to inform, tell,
persuade and entertain, and this can be learned by using some teaching techniques.
3.2.1.2 Teaching speaking
Speaking is an essential part of foreign language learning and teaching. Even though teaching
speaking is important, it has been underestimated for several years and many English language
teachers think they teach speaking when making students repeat drills and memorize dialogues,
and it is not so. Nonetheless, today's world needs that teaching speaking aims to improve
students' communicative skills so that they can express themselves in different situations and
developing appropriately in each communicative circumstance (Hayriye Kayi, 2006).
Different learning styles, motivation level, expectations, varied abilities among others, are
issues teachers need to keep in mind when teaching because they are part of a mixed class as
well. Thus, it is very necessary to apply a variety of activities and offer students up many
opportunities as possible to make the whole class find something to hold on, expand and grow.
Good and accurate teacher’s pronunciation is quite essential since the beginning. It is too hard to
change later on what has been learned at an early stage. There is one rule that we can put on
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 34
function in order to improve students speaking abilities: slowly and steadily through continual
revision, feedback and recycling (Natasa Intihar Klancar, 2006).
3.2.1.3. Guidance for Teaching Speaking
● Offer numerous opportunities to learners to speak the target language by providing an
environment that comprises authentic materials and tasks, collaborative work, and shared
knowledge.
● Try to include each and every student in all speaking activity; the teacher needs to reduce
time speaking, but encouraging learners to do it.
● Prompt students to speak more by eliciting questions
● Give written feedback like "You did a great presentation. I truly appreciate your efforts
in ….."
● When students speak, do not correct their pronunciation mistakes frequently.
● Monitor their work by walking around the classroom to see if they need help while they
work in pairs or group.
● Provide the vocabulary beforehand that students need in speaking activities.
● Provide more chances to practice the spoken language to those students who have
difficulty in expressing themselves in the target language (Natasa Intihar Klancar, 2006).
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 35
3.2.2. Role play
3.2.2.1. Role play concept
When defining the concept of role play there is not found much agreement among the terms
given in the role playing literature. According to their perspective, diverse authors have come up
with different definitions of role play (Littlewood, 1981). However, readers can get a general
idea of the concept when looking at different resources. Role play is a technique connected to
the Communicative approach as role plays focus on communication and making and negotiating
meaning through spoken language. This technique is a “way of bringing situations from real life
to the classroom” (Doff, 1990). Also, Role play is viewed as a good manner to develop
interaction skills in students, which allow learners to engage in real communication and
motivate them to share information through the target language not only in, but outside the
classroom (Richards and Rodgers, 1992).
Ments (1999) states that the concept of role acts as “a short hand way of identifying and
labeling a set of appearances and behaviors on the assumption that these appearances and
behaviors are characteristic of a particular person and predictable within a given situation”. He
claims that “The most obvious uses of role-play are in those areas which deal primarily with
aspects of communication” as it allows learners to practice with others, interacting and
distributing certain roles with certain purposes and functions. “Their aim is to feel, react and
behave as closely as possible to the way someone placed in that particular situation would do” or
would be in real life. Ments says that role playing “expresses hidden feelings, students can
discuss private issues and problems, enables students to empathize with others and understand
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 36
their motivation” “motivational and effective because it involves activity” and upon this, Role
plays are highly motivating due to, they provide something different to what students are used
to.
Generally, Role-plays can be easy or difficult, short or long, but it can be adjusted to the
students’ needs and aims of the lesson. Role Play “involves simulating processes in real
language use, particularly in transferring information and decision making” (Johnson, 1996, p.
173). This occurs because the various situations given to the learners are meant to practice
speaking in the target language and they are required to communicate while doing a task. So as
Crookes and Gass (1993) declare, that role plays are undoubtedly an appropriate way to get EFL
learners to speak and interact. Scarcella and Crookall (1990) observed that role playing helps
second/foreign language acquisition because participants are exposed to large quantities of
comprehensible input, are actively involved in the acquisition of speaking/listening and it
promotes positive effects which include desires, feelings and attitudes.
As Business Management students complained at not developing speaking skills in their
previous English classes because they were taught under a traditional methodology based on
grammar structured and gap filling. It was noticeable the large importance of role plays
implementation. This technique, as expressed above, could definitely help improve speaking
skills (as well as listening, writing and reading) of the target group, and allowed participants to
gain confidence when speaking.
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 37
3.2.3. Communicative competence.
Communicative competence defined initially by Dell Hymes (1972) as the social and
functional aspects of our ability to express and understand messages and to negotiate meanings
interpersonally within a specific context, in which the focus is not only put on developing the
grammatical knowledge of language, but also to know when, where and to whom to use suitable
language in a communicative event (Richards, 2003).
The communicative competence is made up of four areas: linguistic, socio-linguistic,
discourse and strategy. Linguistic competence is concerned with understanding and using
vocabulary, grammar, spelling, punctuation, and syntax (e.g. Sentence structure). Socio-
linguistic Competence has to do with having some awareness of how to use and respond to
language correctly, giving the setting, culture, topic, and acknowledging the relationships among
the people communicating. Discourse Competence is concerned with understanding how ideas
are connected through patterns of organization, cohesive and transitional devices. Strategic
Competence focuses on using techniques to overcome language gaps, plan and assess the
efficiency of communication and adapt text according to the audience and purpose.
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 38
3.2.4. Teacher and learners’ roles in role playing as a teaching technique.
3.2.4.1. Teacher’s role
The teacher "…becomes the Controller, and controls the event in the same way as a traffic
controller, helping the flow of traffic and avoiding bottlenecks, but not telling individuals which
way to go" (Jones, 1982). The teacher organizes the role play structure, but usually does not
actively participate in it, but of course, the teacher may play a role in the activity. Although the
teacher is a monitor, he is not the center of the class, he keeps a low profile so that students feel
free to interact with one another, which reduces student anxiety, fear and facilitates learning. The
teacher is a motivator who stimulates students’ curiosity and keeps the material useful and
interesting (Burns and Gentry, 1998).
3.2.4.2. Learners’ role
According to role playing, Learners’ role should be active and have considerable control over
their own learning. The participants should help select tasks, themes, situations and make
available teachers with details of their learning process (Scarcella and Oxford's, 1992).
Additionally, "In order for a simulation to occur the participants must accept the duties and
responsibilities of their roles and functions, and do the best they can in the situation in which
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 39
they find themselves" (Jones, 1982). Learners may also solve problems, develop tasks, assume
roles, explore creativity and determine their actions.
3.2.5. Adult EFL learners.
Malcolm Knowles (1984) pioneered the field of adult learning with principles applicable to
adult language learning and teaching instruction. Among those principles, Knowles states that:
● Adults tend to be more self-directed and autonomous in their learning. Also, Meaningful
learning can occur in adult learners if teachers actively engage and involve them in the
learning process by planning and selecting topics, materials, tasks and language (Lieb, 1991).
● Meaningful learning takes place when learners are responsible and are able to participate
and work on activities related to their interests. (Lieb, 1991).
● Teachers must take advantage of the experiences learners bring to the classroom so as to
connect learning, motivate them and make it useful and relevant as "they may not be
interested in knowledge for its own sake". (Lieb, 1991) Adult learners will sometimes look for
learning experiences so as to deal with specific life-changing events or situations of the real
life, for example, a job interview, shopping, etc.
● Adults are inclined to be goal-oriented. Teachers begin with an evaluation of learners'
needs as "Needs assessment assures learners a voice in their instruction and keeps content
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 40
relevant to their lives and goals" (Brod, 1999; Shank & Terrill, 1997, as cited in Flores, Terril.
2003). Also, teachers get an idea of the knowledge students bring to class.
Theories across the Acquisition of a Target Language expose the number of factors that
influence on the process. Cognitive, affective and linguistic issues (Florez& Burt, 2001). Other
researchers study show how the non-linguistic factors such as age, anxiety, and motivation affect
in the acquisition of a target language (Moss & Ross-Feldman, 2003). Unluckily, there has not
been conducted much research on Language Acquisition with English language in adult learners,
but "evidence shows that learning a second language, especially as an adult, is not the same as
learning one's first language" (NCLE, 2001). Teaching to adult EFL learners is challenging.
Adults bring various weaknesses and strengths to the classroom. "Teachers need to provide
instruction that acknowledges and addresses these strengths and needs, engages learners in
challenging and relevant topics, and provides them with tools they can use to meet their
responsibilities and goals" (Florez& Terrill, 2003).
Vygotsky’s (1978) theory focuses on social constructivism and the dynamic interaction
among learners, teacher, tasks, and learning context on young learners, but according to
Williams & Burden, 1997, Vygotsky’s attention put on the importance of a secure social context
is also pertinent for adult learners. Consequently, teachers should develop or make use of
materials that meet the adult language learners’ specific needs in their particular contexts. These
materials can also involve learners and the teacher in negotiating aspects of the class.
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 41
3.2.6. Syllabus.
When defining and elaborating a syllabus, many challenges are found due to different authors
give a different concept from their perspective. For instance Wilkins' (1981) states that
syllabuses are "specifications of the content of language teaching which have been submitted to
some degree of structuring or ordering with the aim of making teaching and learning a more
effective process". Breen, (1984a) defines it as "a plan of what is to be achieved through our
teaching and our students' learning". And Candlin (1984) suggests an interesting perspective
inferring that syllabuses are "social constructions, produced interdependently in classrooms by
teachers and learners…They are concerned with the specification and planning of what is to be
learned, frequently set down in some written form as prescriptions for action by teachers and
learners."
Nunan, 1988 & Richards, 2001 state that each syllabus type has drawbacks and advantages.
Nonetheless, for the application of role playing technique in our target group, it will be used a
hybrid syllabus integrated of two types of syllabuses; situational and functional syllabuses since
an independent type does not fulfill our requirements.
Task-based syllabus: consists of activities and tasks that stimulate learning as they get
engaged in the class; motivating learners to use the target language to communicate and solve
the task. Tasks will be related to real world language learners’ needs since they are needed to be
meaningful enough to be performed by students step-by-step until culminating it and so,
enhance learning (Wilkins, 1976).
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 42
Situational Syllabus: learner-centered Syllabus, it highlights that language must be put into a
specific context so as to be related to real life. Those situations will be chosen predicting real and
imaginary situations which reflect the way language and behavior are used daily, for instance: a
job interview, seeing the doctor, going to the cinema, and meeting a customer, etc
(Wilkins.1976).
Those Syllabuses; integrated and connected each other, made up a suitable hybrid syllabus
needed for the classes based on Role playing. Tasks were assigned around specific situations
(since learning is influenced by the situation, function and context in which it occurs) that require
constant communication and production. (See Annex 2)
3.2.7. Evaluation.
Evaluation is a systematic and objective assessment of an on-going or completed process,
project, its designed, implementation and results. The aim of the evaluation is to determine the
relevance and fulfillment of objectives, effectiveness, usefulness, impact and sustainability of the
process carried out.
The evaluation is an important process to the accomplishment of the learning process and
development. Evaluation comprises an organized collection of information, which is valid and
reliable, effective and appropriate analysis of the degree of this information to set standards for
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 43
the goals set in advance to take proper decisions subsequently. (Al-Azzeh F.M. & A.A. Yahya,
2011)
According to P.D Laforucade, evaluation is "The stage of the educational process that aims to
systematically check, to what extent they have achieved the goals set in advance. Understanding
education as a systemic process, designed to achieve lasting and positive changes in the behavior
of subjects, integrated into it, based on goals set in concrete, accurate, socially and individually
acceptable ".
Macario B, claims that "Evaluation is the act that is to express a value judgment, based on a
set of information on developments or results of a student, in order to make a decision”. And A.
Stack Teleña states that "Evaluation is a systematic operation, integrated in the educational
activity in order to achieve its continuous improvement, through knowledge as accurate as
possible to the student in all aspects of his personality, providing an accurate information about
the process itself and on all personal and environmental factors in this incident”. As noted in the
educational process that achieves its main objectives and confronts the set with those actually
achieved.
For this research study the evaluation was carried out to measure the teaching technique
impacts and to provide evidence whether the technique applied worked or not. For this, it used
both summative and formative evaluation. The first one was developed at the end of the process
to demonstrate which of the expected outcomes or goals were met or not; indicating final
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 44
outcomes. On the other hand, formative evaluation was done as a continuous process led to
correct mistakes and improve continuously.
3.2.8. Activities to be applied within Role Playing.
The activities in a Role play class do not focus on language structure itself, but on the goals
and activities defined by the teacher according to learners’ needs. The activities used in the Role
playing technique will be:
Task-Based Activities: Learning by doing. They are communicative activities that make
students negotiate meaning (Ballman, Liskin-Gasparro, & Mandell, 2001), allowing students to
communicate for genuine purposes in different situations. Task based activities are helpful in
Foreign Language study since they “teach students how to ask questions, negotiate meaning,
sharing personal experience, and interact in groups” (Scarcella & Oxford, 1992).
Real world situation activities: Promote self-learning and interaction in real world situations
likely to be found in everyday real life or events that require communication.
Pair and group work activities: “When pair/group work entails discussion and negotiation of
meaning, students perform a greater number of content clarifications, confirmation checks, and
comprehension checks” (Shrum & Glisan, 2010, p. 117). Examples of activities that involve pair
and group work are simulation and role playing activities, games; interviews, discussions that
require participants to simulate being other person and being in specific situations using
language for a function. As well the role plays subtypes stated by Bygate (1997):
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 45
•Role play controlled through cued dialogues
• Role play controlled through cues and information
• Role play controlled through situation and goals, scripted dramatizations
• Role play through debate and discussion
• Large scale simulation activities
• Improvisation, unscripted dramatizations
3.3. Normativity
Article 21 of the General Law of Education Act (Act 115 of 1994) provides that the
educational establishments have to offer to their students the learning of a foreign language from
the basic level. At the end of 2004 the Ministry of Education believed the need for a common
frame of reference for the learning, teaching and assessment of languages; adopting the
Common European Framework of Reference for its applicability to the educational fields.
Law 1651 of 2013, which modifies literally the article 20, 21 and 22 of the law 115 of 1994,
having as a result: “The development of the abilities for conversation, reading and writing at
least in a foreign language”.
The decree 1781 of 2003 regulated and defined for the first time the state exams of quality in
higher education (ECAES); currently Saber-Pro; as "formal academic evidence, that takes part
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 46
with other processes and actions, of a set of instruments that the national government evaluates
the quality of public education services".
About English, the test evaluates the competence to communicate effectively in English. The
test is designed and applied taking into account the common European framework; a document
developed by the European counselor in which it is describes the classification of the four
performance levels A1, A2, B1 and B2 that students acquire as their knowledge increases. All
this aims for learning, teaching and assessment.
Agreement 21 of 2009. "Whereby it is regulated the degree options for undergraduates
from the Universidad de la Amazonia " through this agreement it is regimented that
undergraduate students can access to any of the following degree options in order to obtain their
professional title.
1. Internship or community service.
2. Participation in relevant research projects or management.
3. Degree Paper.
4. Monograph.
5. Judiciary.
6. Preparatory Examinations.
7. Deepening Seminar.
8. Publication of an article in indexed journal.
9. Advanced Semester
10. Best results on the test ECAES
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 47
4. Methodology
4.1. Type of research
The type of research for this proposal was Action research.
4.1.1. Action Research.
Action research approach seeks out the improvement and problem solving by doing “a change
essential for sustained pedagogical development" (Gibbs, 1995); actively participating in a
change situation as an attempt to do things better to impact and contribute positively to students’
learning. Also, it can empower teachers; allowing them to judge their own efforts and evaluate
the outcomes of their practices and processes where they and their students are part of them.
The Action Research term comes by the social psychologist and educator: Kurt Lewin
(1994), defining it as “a comparative research on the conditions and effects of various forms of
social action and research leading to social action” that uses “a spiral of steps, each of which is
composed of a circle of planning, action and fact-finding about the result of the action”. Lewin is
credited with coining the term ‘action research’ to describe work that did not separate the
investigation from the action needed to solve the problem” (McFarland & Stansell, 1993, p. 14).
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 48
The action research is an initiated process with the purpose of solving a particular problem
and producing guidelines for best practice This research is conducted by teachers (a single
teacher, a group of educators or a team of teachers working in the same problem), who examine
critically and carefully their own classroom practices, and depending on those examinations,
changes are made; based on research findings. This research is developed around educational
matters and within the teacher’s surroundings (with students and a place where the teacher
works). Action research is geared toward the solution of concrete problems where the researcher
is compromised with a particular social group since the beginning of the research.
Ferrance (2000) sums up five main steps in an action research process. Firstly, the
problematic situation and question to be investigated must be identified. Secondly, data to help
answer the problematic question must be collected in many ways (Interviews, surveys, videos,
diaries, questionnaires, etc.). Thirdly, the data gathered is examined and interpreted critically;
identifying the major themes. Fourthly, the researcher must act from evidence found in data
order to improve the problem. Fifthly, results are evaluated, and reflection is done, particularly,
examining whether the research question has been answered or not. And finally, every step starts
once more time.
For the development of the investigation, the researchers were demanded to use some
techniques of research. The techniques and methods for data collection used in this research will
be: semi structure interviews, diaries, observations, tests and structured questionnaires; where it
will be specified qualitative and quantitative data.
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 49
4.2. Design research Methodology
4.2.1. Population
This research study was developed in an adult EFL learners from Business Management students
from the Universidad de la Amazonia. The participants had already attended the two English
courses included in their curriculum. More Description of the focused group can be found in the
point: 5.1. Characterization of the focused group.
.
4.2.2. Data collection tools
The instruments and tools implemented for gathering the data needed were the followings:
Diaries: Diaries are a great data collection, they are self-reporting methods. Users record
mainly in a written manner what it is observed, perceived, felt, experienced, interpreted, etc.,;
after the event (after every class); giving lots of useful details and information (McDonough,
1994).
Observation: it is a technique for gathering data, which involves selecting, watching and
recording the behavior and characteristics of certain people or a group of people (objects of
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 50
study). The observer can use different tools when observing, such as recording, taking
photographs, videotaping, etc.
Structured questionnaire: This type of question counts on closed-ended questions pre-
designed by the researcher. The advantages of structured questions is that they are easy for both
the student (to answer as they have the options to choose, so it generally leads to advanced
responses and more accurate data) and the researcher (This is of great importance to code and
analyze data.)
Tests: Process validity, are reliable and objective. Tests are one of the most useful tools of
Educational research, they measure aspects of human knowledge and behavior. A pre-test and a
Post- achievement test will be applied. (Godfred Annum of KUNST Gh, 2014).
Semi-structured interviews: Semi-structured interviews are useful to gather a deep
understanding of perceptions, opinions and reactions to a range of experiences or events by
involving inquiries with the purpose of getting further explanatory information concerning the
questions (Godfred Annum of KUNST Gh, 2014).
4.2.3. Steps of the research study
According to the chronogram proposed (See table 1), the following activities were carried out.
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 51
Table 1: Chronogram of activities
4.2.3.1. Phase 1: Introduction, diagnostic and expectations
In this phase, researchers shared with the participants some information related to the research
project; the technique implemented, the compromised required by the students, etc. Also, during
this stage, the researchers designed and applied a short pre-test, which included macro skills such
as reading, writing and speaking. It also incorporated some micro skills such as grammar and
vocabulary. All this was taken into account to identify the students’ general English level. (See
Annex 7)
Activities Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec
1 2 3 4
1 2 3 4
1 2 3 4
1 2 3 4
1 2 3 4
To design and apply a pre-test
X X X
X
X X X
X X X X X X X
X
X X
X X
Apply an expectation survey
To plan, design and apply a situational and task based syllabus
To gather data
Apply the post-test
Data Analysis
Final report
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 52
Similarly, the investigators arranged and applied an expectation survey to the student with the
purpose of identifying the students´ point of view and likes toward the English Language
Learning, as well as their disposition and attitude for learning. (See Annex 8)
4.2.3.2. Phase 2: Execution of the classes and data collection tools
In this phase, researchers took into account students’ needs, wants, expectations to adapt and
then apply a situational and task based syllabus, (see Annex 2) in which the teaching technique
implemented during the classes would be Role Plays in order to promote the speaking skill.
Moreover, during this stage it was carried a progressive identification of the students’ progress;
through observation and video recording. Besides, the researchers collected important data about
the application of the Role Play as a technique to enhance speaking abilities. The data was
gathered through a diary, in which the investigator wrote down what they perceived during every
single class, observation, structures questionnaires and semi-structured interviews (See annex 4
and annex 5) applied to the target group in order to determine how well the classes taught
through the implementation of role plays work.
4.2.3.3. Phase 3: Analysis and Report
In the final phase of this research project, the students were assessed through a post-test
which indicated the speaking advances the participants acquired during the process. Also, the
data collected (during Phase 2) was analyzed in order to assess the impact of the technique
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 53
applied to enhance speaking abilities of the target group. And finally, the researchers did
everything regarding to the analysis of the results and preparation of the final report.
Each phase was conducted within the schedule of activities established at the beginning of
the investigation. Thus, the research process was developed successfully in the stipulated time.
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 54
5. Outcomes and discussion
5.1. Characterization of the focused group
Initially, the target group consisted of twenty five adult EFL learners; eleven men and
seventeen women, from the Business Management program at Universidad de la Amazonia. The
Students were above 20 years old, but under 29 years old. All the participants had already
received the two English courses included in their curriculum; they were up to the sixth semester
of their career. Therefore, they were supposed to attend the course deliberately; the classes taught
were not the ones comprised in their curriculum. However, by the third week, just 12 or 10
participants were attending the lessons, and just four students attended constantly to almost every
class. Hence, the focus group was made up by four women. They were in the sixth and ninth
semester of their career. (See figure 4) And their ages oscillated between 20 and 23 years old.
(See figure3) One of the participants was a complete beginner, she knew a few words, but
nothing more. The other three participants counted on a Basic English level.
Figure 3: Participants’ ages
25%
50%
25% 0%
21 years old 22 years old 23 years old
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 55
Figure 4: Participants’ semester
5.2. Description and analysis of the phases
The three different phases that this research study comprises were developed and
culminated, according to the chronogram proposed (table 1). In each one of the phases, it was
carried out a range of data collection tools for this research, which are exposed, as a summary, in
the following table of analysis.
Table 2. Summary of the research techniques applied.
Technique Tool Section Participants Observation
Test Photocopies 1 19
Each student was given the test so that they could answer the questions according to their previous knowledge.
6th semester
25%
9th semester
75%
0%
0%
PARTICIPATS' SEMESTER 6th semester 9th semester
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 56
Survey Photocopies 1 19 Participants were asked to answer honestly an expectation survey.
Diary Notebook 20 Researchers Description and observation of each class.
Questionnaire Photocopies 1 4 Each one of the four students who made part of the focused group were given a questionnaire
Interview Recorder 1 4 Every participant of the focused group was interviewed
Test Photocopies 1 4 The focused group’s participants solved the post test.
The teaching process based on the implementation of role plays to enhance speaking skills
to Business Management Students at Universidad de la Amazonia started on September 9th of
2014.
Phase 1: Introduction, diagnostic and expectations
It began with the course introduction and application of the pre-test. In the course
introduction, the researchers explained to the participants that the English course was going to be
based on the implementation of role plays. The definition of this technique was given, the
Roleplaying teaching technique was assumed as a Teaching Technique applied into the
classroom in order to develop speaking abilities. And students were asked nicely to attend the
course seriously as their presence was essential.
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 57
Then, students were given a pre-test, which comprised reading, writing and speaking
macro- skills, but also grammar and vocabulary micro skills in order to identify the students’
general English level. Participants answered the test, some quicker than others, but all 19
students solved it the best as they could. After this, the researchers applied an expectation survey,
which student had to answer subjectively to determine how they expected the course to be and
their likes and preferences for learning English. Additionally, the researchers asked students to
speak out their expectations about the course and they were asked if they liked the role playing
technique just explained or if they were wanting a different kind of course.
EXPECTATION SURVEY
In the expectations survey, two questions were asked, the first one was:
1. Do you enjoy learning English through :
a. Music b. Games c. Writing d. Reading
e. Listening to the teacher f. Speaking g. Other
The purpose of this question was to know through which method or technique, students
liked learning English. In this question, learners could choose which they liked more, 13 of
the 18 students surveyed chose option b (See Figure 5); games, this was interpreted that
students enjoy learning English through games, opening a door we were taking the proper
technique for learning; the rest of the learners chose between a and f choice between
speaking and through music.
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 58
Figure 5: Do you enjoy learning through
Second question:
2. What are your expectations from this course:
a. Meet people
b. Be able to communicate with other in English
c. Practice and reinforce
d. Another? Which one?
To this question, students should choose just one answer, 15 of the 18 students surveyed
marked the option b (See figure 6). To be able to communicate with others in English, this
answer indicated that students of Business Management program, were enrolled in the course,
because their general aim was to establish a communication in a foreign language, the rest of the
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
Do you enjoy learning English through:
Figure 5.
Music
Games
Writing
Reading
Listening
Speaking
Other
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 59
students surveyed chose between practice and reinforce what they already knew, and another
option was to have the basic level to present the ECAES exam.
Figure 6: What are your expectations from this course
PRE TEST
Pre-test: Grammar and vocabulary section (See figure 7)
Figure 7: Grammar and vocabulary section.
02468
10121416
What are your expectations from this course:
Figure 6
Meet people
Be able to communicate withother in English
Practice and reinforce
Another
67%
28%
5%
Figure 7
less than 3
Among 3 and 4.5
5
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 60
According to the results obtained by the students who took the pre -test, 67% of students
scored below three of five possible points, in grammar and vocabulary, questions were designed
to measure the basic level of a student of English. This result certainly reflected the lack of
English proficiency among students of Business Management Program
The second part of the pre-test was to assess Learners’ reading skill, in this case, a short
story was set, and according to the reading 4 questions were performed, grades obtained by
students are shown below (See Figure 8)
Figure 8: Reading skills section
In reading skills, was evident that students have higher strengths, as only 41% of students did not
pass this test.
12%
47%
41%
Figure 8
5
3.75
Less than 3
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 61
The third part of the pre-test was to measure the writing skills, for doing it learners were
asked to write a paragraph of three lines, about the life of each. Though it was free writing, text
production was scored. The results obtained are shown below. (See Figure 9)
Figure 9: Writing skills section
For writing skill, the pre- test showed that students have lacked the tools to create a short
text, 14 learners (78%) had a score below 3. Within the focused group, it was demonstrated the
following progress, each student was identified with a letter.
Finally, the fourth part of the pre-test, was to measure speaking skills. For doing it,
students were asked themselves and a classmate to the rest of the class. The results obtained are
shown below (See figure 10)
5%
17%
78%
0%
Figure 9
5
More than 3 lessthan 5
less than 3
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 62
Figure 10: Speaking skill section
For this section, results obtained by students showed that learner cannot establish a real
communication in English, besides learners were not able to use language properly. 89% of
learners do not know how to speak English, even when teacher showed how to do it.
Phase 2: Execution of the classes and data collection tools
In the phase of the executions classes and data collection tools, it was edited the syllabus;
according to students' level, preferences and likes, the syllabus was brought into play (based on
the Roleplaying teaching technique to improve speaking skills) and data was gathered. The
classes took place from September 9, 2014 until November 13, 2014. The classes were led to the
accomplishment of the syllabus content. In each class, was performed different role playing
activities regarding to real life situations so that students could learn English within a specific
context and could get some basic tools for facing and coping with those kind of situations. All
0%
11%
89%
Figure 10
5
More than 3 lessthan 5
less than 3
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 63
the new situations had in many ways something to do with the previous situation seen in class so
that students could go over the previous topic and relate it to the new one.
For each situation, first teachers (researchers) taught the vocabulary related to the situation
they were going to be developing. The strategies for teaching vocabulary were absolutely varied;
slides, realia, mimic, flashcards, etc.; then, for practicing the vocabulary in a specific context and
situation, participants had to participate actively in the role playing games and activities that
required to solve a task. And finally students did performances, showing what they had learned
through the class.
Sometimes, Participants were given the option to make up their own conversation, other
times they were given an already structured dialog, they could also edit a dialog guide they were
given. Furthermore, participants were asked in different occasions to record a short video about
the situation that had worked. Moreover, students were given the enough material needed for
each topic. For instance, when the bank situation came up, students were given fake money and
documents so that they could do all the process of withdrawing cash, paying bills, etc. The
researchers planned different and varied role playing and simulation activities for the students so
that they got engaged and motivated.
On November 11, 2014, the questionnaire was conducted for the four participants (focused
group) who were attending the course continuously. They solved it quickly as it was a structured
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 64
questionnaire, which consisted of 5 questions related the English course based on the
implementation of role plays to enhance speaking skills in an adult EFL learners' group from
Business Management Program at Universidad de la Amazonia. (See Annex 4: format of
questionnaire) That same day, students were asked to answer honestly some questions through a
semi-structured interview. The interview entailed four simple questions that students should
answer subjectively. (See annex 5 and 6) In addition, in this research study, the entire teaching
process was monitored during all the classes by the researchers, who not only felt satisfied by
observing, but also recorded classes and wrote in a diary after every lesson was completed.
Questionnaires applied to the students
Once there was just one class missing, the students who compounded the focused group,
(four students) were asked to solve a short structured questionnaire made up by five questions.
(See Annex 5, questionnaire format) The questionnaire aimed to obtain general information
about the Role plays as a Teaching Technique in order to improve speaking abilities.
Likewise, and more specifically, it was led to meet the subjective points of view that the
participants had over Role plays as a Technique for enhancing oral production skills for
communication. The number of questionnaires applied were four, as this was the number of
students who really showed seriousness when attending classes and doing what was asked to do
from the beginning to the end of the course (focused group). (See table 3) It is necessary to say
that the total number of students who were supposed to attend the English course were 25, but
some of them attended at the beginning and then they did not come back anymore, others
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 65
attended sporadically and with intermittence, which will be explained widely in the section of
LIMITATIONS of the present report.
Table 3: Description of the respondents.
Semester Total student Focused group Questionnaires applied %
IV-IX 25 4 4 16%
Analysis and interpretation of questionnaires
The questionnaires carried out were vital to get to know the students’ vision toward the role
playing technique and its functionality, obtaining great acceptance and usefulness.
The questionnaire included 5 questions with four structured answers, each one so that the
respondents had the easy task to choose the one that fit them more. (See Annex 4, questionnaire
format) In the following table and figure it is analyzed each and every question. (See table 4 and
figure 11)
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 66
Figure 11: Analysis and interpretation of the structure questionnaire
Table 4: Table of analysis of structured questionnaire.
Answers
Questions A B C D TOTAL
Question 1 1 3 4
Question 2 2 2 4
Question 3 4 4
Question 4 1 1 2 4
Question 5 1 2 1 4
Question 1 Question 2 Question 3 Question 4 Question 5
Num
ber o
f peo
ple
1
2
3
4
QUESTIONNAIRE
A B C D
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 67
Questionnaire, translated into English
Question 1: How do you consider there have been the English classes based on Role plays
application?
A) Very nice B) Dynamic C) Boring D) Varied
As it is shown in the above table, three of four students answered B that corresponded to
dynamic, and the other one answered A, the classes were very nice. This is an evidence of their
imminent satisfaction toward the classes based on the implementation of role plays as the ones
carried out in this research study.
Question 2: Do you believe that the English course based on role plays implementation to
improve speaking skills has:
A: Influenced positively on their English language oral production
B: Helped gain self-confidence in their capacities at the moment of getting to
communicate with others in English.
C) Contributed significantly in learning the English language, especially in oral
production.
D) It did not fulfill the expectations.
In this question, two of four students answered A, and the other two answered C, which
means that the participants considered that the English course based on role plays
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 68
implementation to improve speaking skills has had positive effects on building English language
abilities than allows oral production to occur.
Question 3: Do you think the situations represented through role plays:
A) Were very appropriate and carried out dynamically and within context.
B) Were presented through activities that did not allowed learning
C) Situations there were not represented
D) They were out of context
In this question, all four participants agreed with one another when choosing the option A.
This answer determines that the real life situations used for roleplaying were well developed,
contextualized and presented creatively.
Question 4: Do you think that the role plays technique used in the English classes:
A) Ensures learning English because students gain self-confidence and believe in their potentialities
B) Not very effective since much time is wasted
C) It is good because oral production is practiced constantly, enabling good communication.
D) It is not only good for developing the ability to speak, but also write, read and listen.
One participant responded A, another C and the other two answered D. Those responses
expressed that students gained self-confidence by attending the course and they experience the
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 69
opportunity to interact and practice with their classmates and teacher too, while simulating real
life situations, which permits communication to take place. But above the other positive aspects
related to the Role Plays technique that students highlight, participants also considered that Role
Plays do not only develops speaking skills, but also listening, reading and writing.
Question 2: Do you consider that after attending the English course based on the application of
role plays, you have:
A) Learned to communicate orally everyday situations in English Language.
B) Acquired some knowledge regarding to the vocabulary seen in class situations.
C) Developed Speaking skills, but also listening, writing and reading
D) Not learned anything.
In this question, one of four students answered A, two other students answered B, and the
other responded C. This means that by attending the English coursed based on Roleplaying,
participants: 1) learned vocabulary seen in real life situations worked on the lessons, 2)
developed not only speaking skills, but also listening, writing and reading and 3) got some tools
to communicate in English with others in daily life situations.
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 70
Interviews
On November 11, 2014, an interview was done to each of the four students who
compounded the focused group. The interview applied to one by one took place in the classroom
in order to know participants’ opinion about the roleplaying teaching technique. The interviews
consisted of four simple questions. (See Annex 5: Format of the Interview)
The complete transcription of the interviews is found in Annex 6 and its photograph in the annex
9 (photograph 1)
The following table corresponds to the analysis of such interviews.
Table 5. Table of analysis of the interviews conducted to the focused group.
Questions
Interviewee
Comments toward the
English coursed based on role-
plays
Reasons why students did not
come to the course anymore.
Effectiveness of role playing
teaching technique
Effects role plays have over nerves
and insecurity when speaking in
English
Ana Milena Lopez
It was good as it does not teach grammar, but uses didactics that help students learn and interact with others.
It can be many reasons such as not real interest in the course and the schedule of the course.
Well, with role plays we experienced real life situations, which give us tools to face those situations in real life.
Emm, With the basis, one feels more secure or confident of ones’ abilities that help us communicate.
Erica Melo
It was nice, ludic full of interaction with the classmates and teacher; something different to the
Maybe, the Schedule; I talk by myself. Sometimes the schedule didn’t to our free time or perhaps they
Yes, it worked so well for me. Before I was afraid to make mistakes, but now I know that if I make a
No, because if I make mistakes, I know I can improve. Moreover, now I
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 71
English courses we see in I and II semester.
were not really interested in attending the course.
mistake I will learn.
have more basis.
Monica Cuellar
So good because the role plays used in the classroom were so interesting.
Perhaps because of many commitments related to their academic career, and they gave more significance to that than to the English course.
Yes, a lot.
Maybe a little bit. I’ve lost a lot insecurity and fear when talking in English. However, there continues existing some nerves when talking and making mistakes.
Lina Maria Jaramillo
It was good, new and nice, as I thought it was going to be boring and grammar based course I’m used to, but it was dynamic and full of activities based on interaction.
Perhaps because the course is free and does not demand a score on the curriculum
Yes, a lot
A little bit, but less than before.
Through the interviews conducted face to face at the participants, it is evidenced the
usefulness of Role plays to enhance speaking skills, since it allows students to experience more
interaction with their classmates and teacher while simulating real life situations, helps them
overcome fear, believe in their capacities and gain self-confidence when speaking.
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 72
Phase 3: Analysis and Report
The last phase of analysis and final report was done once the classes had culminated. In this
phase, the post-test, as a data collection tool was applied. Once having all this, the researchers
focused on analyzing the results of questionnaires, interviews, pre-tests, Post-tests, diary and
videos recorded during the classes and also on the drafting and organization of this research final
report.
FOCUSED GROUP OF STUDY
After the course finished, November 13, 2014, students were asked to solve a post-test;
which was the same one applied as pre-test. (See annex 7) Within the focused group, it was
demonstrated the progress obtained not only in speaking, but also in the other skills. Each
student was identified with a letter. (See table 6)
Table 6: Focused group of study
Learner’s name Letter
Erika Paola Melo Collazos A
Monica Muñoz Figueroa B
Lina Maria Urquina Jaramillo C
Ana Milena Lopez D
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 73
Grammar and vocabulary (See Figure 11)
Figure 11: Analysis of Grammar and vocabulary section
This figure shows the progress achieved by learners during the development of this
research, concerning to grammar and vocabulary. It shows significant progress in the acquisition
of new words and structures, although it was a research project focused on improving the ability
to speak, it shows how it can improve indirectly other skills.
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
Learner A Learner B Learner C Learner D
Figure 11
Pre Test Final Test
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 74
Reading comprehension (See figure 12)
Figure 12: Analysis of Reading comprehension section
Although the initial performance in reading skills was not so low (as it is shown in the
results of the pre-test applied) as the other skills, learners obtained an increase in their scores.
This means that there was some noticeable progress in this skill where the students are now able
to interpret a text in English. It happens due to the different role plays activities where students
had to interpret situations in English presented by the teacher.
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
Learner A Learner B Learner C Learner D
Figure 12
Pre Test Final Test
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 75
Writing skill (see figure 13)
Figure 13: Analysis of writing skill section
In the writing skill section, it was tested the ability of students to create a short and
coherent text about the life of each. Through this section, it was evidenced that learners, at the
end of the course, had the basic tools needed to write a short text of four lines at least.
Undoubtedly, learners can now produce short dialogues and situations, which help them develop
writing skills in English. The figure shows how the focused group improved on it.
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
Learner A Learner B Learner C Learner D
Figure 13
Pre Test Final Test
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 76
Speaking skill (See figure 14)
Figure 14: Analysis of speaking skill section
Speaking was the ability this research focused on, improve the English speaking skill in
learners of the focused group. The graphic clearly shows how three of the students, showed a
significant progress in the development of this ability. It shows clearly that students at the end of
the course, could establish a clear and simple communication in English in areas related to their
profession. It also shows that students lost their fear about speaking in a foreign language, which
is one of the main difficulty presented by learners. Although one learner (Learner A) showed no
breakthrough, it did not decrease in this ability either. Taking into account the initial and final
test results, it was observed that the speaking skill displayed the largest percentage of
improvement, because it was the main skill intended to be developed throughout the process.
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
Learner A Learner B Learner C Learner D
Figure 14
Pre Test Final Test
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 77
Analysis of diaries
Diaries were adopted as a data collection tool; it included all the information gathered during
classes as well as a detailed description of the classes carried out, such as number of participants,
attitude toward classes, students’ performance, participation and also, diaries contributed to
identify possible class enhancements. Diaries also allowed researchers to evaluate every class if
methodology adopted was filling expectation and achieving objectives proposed
The diary of class number one (see example below), shows clearly how class was
developed, what researchers found in the first class, how students behave, what were students’
feelings toward class, what kind of activities were developed, what were main problems found
in students related to communicate in English;
Research diary
Class number one (09-09-14)
Today was a day full of expectations fulfilled. Seventeen students attended the class, and even
nervous, they tried to participate in every activity we prepared for them. Some of them evidently
have a really low level while others have a better one, but not so high. However, in spite of their
low level, at the end of the class when we played Chinese whisper, they could understand and
write on the board almost all what we whisper to the first in the row. I consider that the interview
your partner activity helped so much today, as students had to know about each classmate by
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 78
asking some basic questions and simulating they were getting to know each other. This gave
them much more confidence. At the beginning of the activity they felt insecure and had to look at
the blackboard to remember what they had to ask and the possible answer, but then they knew
what they had to ask.
Today, students seemed to have enjoyed the activities and learned to introduce themselves.
Although full of fear and non-self-confidence when speaking, they did what was asked and we
consider they learned through the activities of interact in with other.
Class number two (11-09-14)
Today only 11 students attended the course as the others were at a congress. With those few
students we worked well. We continued working what had previously worked the previous class.
Students were asked to develop some tasks so that eventually they could write their own
conversation so that they could perform it then.
Students did all the process, but when role playing, the majority were so shy and felt they didn’t
want to do it because they didn’t feel seft confident. Nevertheless, they did it and try to do their
best. It is the beginning and we expect that at the end of this process they can do it without fears
and with much more level.
Class number three (16/09/14)
In today’s class, students worked on making up a script of a conversation in which one of the
three participants had to introduce other. For this, students were exposed to watch short videos in
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 79
which people introduce themselves and others. So students were supposed to simulate what they
watched, and for this, teachers gave to the students a guide worksheet.
Participants created their conversations and at the end of the class they presented their work.
Showing progress. It is noticeable how they progress and go losing their fear when speaking up
in front of others. Similarly, they are developing macro (reading, writing, listening and of course
speaking) and micro skills; vocabulary, pronunciation. We have realized that when improving
speaking other areas are developed too, perhaps not with the same intensity, but intrinsically
other skills are improved. Undoubtedly, our interest in to improve speaking, and I feel glad
students are improving significantly as the classes go by.
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 80
5.3 Limitations
The research process was affected by a main factor that although it did not impact
negatively the results, it did influence in terms of the number of physical referents or participants
involved in the study.
To begin with, it must be remembered three main aspects: first, the students enrolled in
the English coursed based on the implementation of Role plays to enhance speaking skills, were
students from VI to X semester of Business Management program, who had already coursed I
and II English levels. Third, student class attendance was not mandatory; students enrolled
deliberately, without any kind of academic pressure as the classes taught were not the ones
included in their curriculum. And third, this action research was conducted according to the
schedule established from the beginning, a total of twenty sessions were carried out, in which
different topics proposed in the syllabus were developed.
Since the beginning, learners were motivated toward the course, and had the expectation
of gaining some meaningful learning. However, over the different classes, the number of
students diminished considerably, and although we contacted each of them, to reiterate the
invitation and the commitment from the beginning of the course, most of them said the lack of
time enough to continue with the course. They emphasized the high academic workload had
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 81
along the way, and because the course did not generate any academic responsibility within their
curriculum, which brought not real compromise and responsibility toward classes.
Therefore, the process could not be completed chronologically and satisfyingly with the
majority of participants. Only four students attended the course continuously from the first to the
last class. So, with those participants or focused group the research was conducted.
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 82
6. Conclusions
*The Roleplaying is a Teaching Technique is effective when implemented in a low –level
adult EFL learners group to improve their speaking communicative ability, as students get to feel
much more self-confident when saying something, negotiating meaning with others, etc. This is
absolutely positive because when students feel confident they continue and continue practicing,
which ensures progress and improvement.
*The Roleplaying Teaching Technique fits really well within a situational syllabus, as
students simulate diverse real- life situations and take different roles according to the situation.
With this, students learn much better as every piece of language is presented contextualized so
that students can relate everything more easily.
*The Role plays allow students to lose fear, anxiety and embarrassment when speaking up
in front of others, but they can also help develop all four macro skills (reading, writing, listening
and of course speaking) and micro skills; vocabulary, pronunciation. It was noticed that while
intending to enhance speaking, other areas are developed too. Perhaps not with the same
intensity, but intrinsically, other skills are improved. This takes place since students involved in
role plays are asked to solve tasks. They are asked to read and write dialogues, conversations,
etc,; and they are exposed to listen to what their classmates and teacher speak.
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 83
*Implementing new teaching techniques, (as Role plays) in the teaching and learning
process of English learners, encourages these students to learn, achieve, explore their creativity,
imagination, personal likes, etc.
*Students who enroll in free courses like the carried out to conduct this research study, tend
not to assist constantly to it, as it does not require any type of economic nor academic pressure.
*Doing research is absolutely fundamental for all students involved in the teaching
process. Investigating helps researchers Increase knowledge by reading and writing. Researching
helps draw conclusions and make decisions about how to intervene to improve a specific
situation or problem. Researching in the educational field, contributes in improving educational
practices; learning, teaching, the dynamics of interaction in classrooms, in schools or other
institutions.
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 84
7. Recommendations
➢ It is important that English teachers use new teaching techniques and strategies to
develop meaningful and contextualized learning in students, so that they feel motivated
toward their own learning. As the technique of role plays helps improve significantly the
ability to speak and helps reduce fear to talk to others in a foreign language.
➢ To allow, encourage and support Bachelor of English students, to continue
conducting research activities that allow students from other programs at the Universidad
de la Amazonia to get involved in these processes; helping students acquire a foreign
language, which certainly helps increase the quality of education and achieve the goals
set by the National Plan of Bilingualism.
➢ Motivate students and raise awareness of the different programs from the
Universidad de la Amazonia, about the importance of managing English language, as
future professionals.
➢ To encourage students from last semester of the different programs of the
Universidad de la Amazonia, to choose Thesis as degree option, since research is
essential in the Educational field.
➢ Foment opportunities for learning English; allowing students from different
programs at Universidad de la Amazonia to learn a foreign language. This, through new,
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 85
didactic, dynamic strategies and techniques, taking into account students’ context,
preferences, likes and needs so that they get motivated to get involved in this kind of
activity
➢ Promote the addition of role plays in syllabuses designed by teachers at the English
language program for Universidad de la Amazonia. Also, future English teachers should
be informed about the effectiveness that role plays bring into the classrooms so that they
implement it in the different educational institutions where they will work.
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 86
8. References
Al-Azzeh F.M. and A.A. Yahya, (2011).Quality criteria's of computing disciplines. Eur. J. Sci. Res., 48: 352-360,http://www.eurojournals.com/EJSR_48_3_02.pdf
Andrewes, S. (2005). The CLT Police: Questioning the communicative approach. Modern English Teacher.Vol 14. No 2.
American Psychological Association. (n.d.) Basics of APA style tutorial. Retrieved from: http://www.apastyle.org/
Arkoudis, S.,Baik,C., & Richardson, S. (2012). English Language Standards in Higher Education:
From entry to exit, a new book from ACER Press Ayu, D., & Harni, S. (2007).Using role play in teaching speaking.
Retrieved from: https://saidnazulfiqar.files.wordpress.com/2011/10/skripsi-using-role-play-in-teaching-speaking.pdf
Ballman, T.L., Liskin-Gasparro, J.E., &Mandell, P.B. (2001). The communicative classroom.
Boston, MA: Heinle. Breen, M.P. (1984a). Process Syllabuses for the Language Classroom. In Brumfit, CJ. (ed.) General
English Syllabus Design Pergamon Press Ltd. and the British Council.
Breen, M. P., and Candlin, C. (1980).The essentials of a communicative curriculum in language teaching. Applied Linguistics, 1(2), 89-112
Brown, H.D. (1994). Teaching by principles: an interactive approach to language pedagogy. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall Regents.
Burns, A., & Joyce, H. (1997). Focus on speaking. Sydney: National Center for English Language Teaching and Research.
Burns, A. C., & Gentry, J. W. (1998). Motivating students to engage in experiential learning: a
tension-to-learn theory. Simulation and Gaming, 29, 133-151
Bygates (1997) Speaking. Retrieved from: http://www.cambridge.org/servlet/file/9780521805162c02_p14-20.pdf?ITEM_ENT_ID=5744725
Candlin, C.N.(1984). Applying a System Approach to Curriculum Innovation in the Public Sector.
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 87
In Read, J.A.S. (ed.) Trends in Language Syllabus Design. Singapore: SEAMEO Regional Language Centre.
Crookes, G. & Gass, S.M. (Eds.). (1993a). Tasks and Language Learning. Cleveland, UK: Multilingual Matters.
Doff, A. Teach English: A Training Course for Teachers. Cambridge: Cambridge Univer- sity Press in Association with the British Council, 1990.
FERRANCE, Eileen. THEMES IN EDUCATION: ACTION RESEARCH. Brown University. U.S: 2000, p. 9. In http://www.lab.brown.edu/pubs/themes_ed/act_research.pdf
Florez, M. C., &T~rrill, L. (2003, July).Working with literacy-level adult Englishlanguage learners. Gibbs, G. (1995). The society for research into higher education and Open University press. Celtic
Court: Buckingham.
Godfred Annum of KUNST Gh, (2014). Research Instrument for Data Collection. Retrieved from: http://campus.educadium.com/newmediart/file.php/1/giilmadstore/UgradResearch/ThesisWrit4all/files/notes/resInstr.pdf
Hayriye Kayi, Teaching Speaking: Activities to Promote Speaking in a Second Language, The Internet TESL Journal, Vol. XII, No. 11, November 2006. http://iteslj.org/Articles/Kayi-Teaching Speaking.html. p. 1 - 2
Hymes, D. (1972). On Communicative Competence. In J.B. Pride & J. Holmes (Eds.), Sociolinguistics (pp. 269-93). Harmondsworth: Penguin.
ICFES. Saber Pro results. Retrieved from:
www.icfesinteractivo.gov.co/result_ecaes/info/snee_eca_inf_ctr.jsp. www.icfesinteractivo.gov.co/result_ecaes/sniee_ins_ref.htm
Jones, K. (1982). Simulations in language teaching. Cambridge: Cambridge U. Press Kayi, H. (2006) Teaching Speaking: Activities to Promote Speaking in a Second
Language. The Internet TESL Journal, 11. Retrieved from: http://iteslj.org/Techniques/Kayi-TeachingSpeaking.html
Kizlik, B., 2014. Measurement, assessment, and evaluation in Education. Retrieved from:
www.adprima.com/measurement.htm.
Lieb, S. (1991).Principles of adult learning. Retrieved from http://hono lulu.hawaii.edulintranetlcommitteeslFacDevComlguidebk/teachtip/ adu lts-2.htm
Littlewood, W. (1981).Communicative Language Teaching. New York:Cambridge
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 88
University Press. Lowe, Mark (2005) The Shibboleths of TEFL: Straightening out our thinking Modern English
Teacher Vol 14, No 1. McDonough, Jo. (1994). A teacher looks at teacher’s diaries. ELT Journal, 42(1), 14-20. McFarland, K.P., &Stansell, J.C. (1993).Historical perspectives. In L. Patterson, C.M. Santa, C.G.
Short, & K. Smith (Eds.), Teachers are researchers: Reflection and action. Newark, DE: International Reading Association.
Ments, V. M. (1999). The effective use of role-play: practical techniques for improving learning (2nd
ed.). Retrieved May 12, 2012, from http://books.google.com.bd/books/about/The_Effective_Use_of_Role_Play
Merriam-webster dictionary (2014) retrieved from:http://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/speak Ministerio de EducaciónNacional.Altablero. Taken from:
http://www.mineducacion.gov.co/1621/article-97498.html
Moss, D. & Ross-Feldman, L. (2003, December) Second language acquisition in adults: From research to practice.Retrieved from: http://www.cal.orglnc1e/digests/SLA.htm
Natasa Intihar Klancar, Developing Speaking Skills in the Young Learners Classroom, Internet TESL Journal, Vol. XII, No. 11, November 2006. http://iteslj.org/Techniques/Klancar-Speaking Skills.html. p. 1
Nunan, D. (1988) Syllabus Design. Oxford: Oxford University Press. Nunan, D. (2005) Important Tasks of English Education: Asia-wide and Beyond. The Asian EFL Journal
Vol 7 (3)
Rahelcynthia, 2013. Four skills in the English Language. Retrieved from: http://rahelcynthia.wordpress.com/2013/06/28/four-skills-in-the-english-language/
Ramin Rahimy & Samaneh Safarpour (2012) THE EFFECT OF USING ROLE-PLAY ON IRANIAN EFL LEARNERS’ SPEAKING ABILITY. Department of English Language, Islamic Azad University, I RAN. Retrieved from: http://www.ajssh.leena-luna.co.jp/AJSSHPDFs/Vol.1(3)/AJSSH2012(1.3-06).pdf
Richards, J. (2001). Curriculum Development in Language Teaching. Cambridge: Cambridge University
Press.
Richard, J.C (2001). Communicative Language Teaching Today. Cambridge, New York:
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 89
Cambridge University Press 2006 Richards, J. C. Rodgers, T. S. (1992). Approaches and Methods in Language Teaching. New
York: Cambridge University Press. Richard, J.C and Rodgers T.s (2001).Approaches and Methods in Language Teaching. (2nd
Ed). Cambridge: cambridge University Press Priscilla Islam, Tazria Islam, (2012). Effectiveness of role play in enhancing the speaking skills
of the learners in a large classroomStamford Journal of English; Volume 7; Page 218-233. Retrieved from: http://www.banglajol.info/index.php/SJE/article/view/14475
Savignon, S. J. and Chaochang, W. (2003).Learner attitudes and perceptions. EBSCO publishing. Scarcella, R. & Oxford, R. L. (1992). The tapestry of language learning. Boston: Heinle and
Heinle.
Scarcella, R. & Crookall, D. (1990). Simulation/gaming and language acquisition. In D. Crookall & R. L. Oxford (Eds.), Simulation, gaming, and language learning (pp. 223-230). New York: Newbury House.
Shrum, J.L., &Glisan, E.W. (2010).Teacher's handbook contextualized language instruction (4th ed.).
Boston, MA: Heinle
The Internet TESL Journal, Vol. XIII, No. 2, February 2007. Taken form:
http://iteslj.org/Articles/Belchamber-CLT.html
The Measurement Group: Evaluation/Research Tools. Online: http://www.themeasurementgroup.com/evalbttn.htm
Theodore Huebner, Audio Visual Technique in Teaching Foreign Language, (New York: Cambridge University Press, 1960)
Universidad de la Amazonia. Administración de empresas,(2013). retrieved from: http://www.udla.edu.co/v10/index.php/programas/profesionales/administracion-de-empresas.html
UNIVERSIDAD DE LA AMAZONIA. Academic counsil. Agreement 21 de 2009 “Por el cual se reglamentan las Opciones de Grado de los estudiantes de pregrado de la Universidad de la Amazonia”. Florencia: La Universidad, 2009. Retrived From: http://apps.udla.edu.co/documentos/docs/Consejo%20Academico/Acuerdos/2009/Acuerdo%2021. pdf>.
White, R. W. (1988). The ELT curriculum. Oxford, Basil Blackwell.
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 90
Willis, D., & Willis, J. (2007).Doing task based teaching. Oxford, UK: Oxford University Press. Wilkins, D. A. (1972).The linguistics and situational content of the common core in aunit/credit system. MS. Strasbourg: Council of Europe.
Wilkins, D.A. (1976). Notional Syllabuses. London: Oxford University Press.
Williams, M. and Burden, R., 1997. Psychology for language teachers, a social constructivist approach. UK: Cambridge University Press.
Yuli rachmawati, Mukhlisatun Muayanah, & Endah Alamsari, (2013). TEACHING SPEAKING BY USING ROLE PLAY OF THE FIFTH GRADE STUDENTS OF MINU KH. MUKMIN SIDOARJO. Jurnal Pendidikan Bahasa Inggris STKIP PGRI Sidoarjo Vol. 1, No. 1, April 2013 ISSN: 2337-9278
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 91
9. Annexes
Annex 1
Analysis of the data gathered from the interview.
Questions asked to the interviewees from Business Management Program:
1: ¿Desde su subjetividad, cómo considera fueron los dos cursos/niveles de Inglés que la
Universidad de la Amazonia proporciona a sus estudiantes de carreras externas a la licenciatura
en Inglés?
2: ¿Fue apropiada la metodología del docente para facilitar un rápido y ameno aprendizaje?
3: ¿Los contenidos vistos durante los cursos de Inglés I y II, sirvieron como bases fuertes para la
adquisición de habilidades comunicativas en la lengua extranjera que le permitiera comunicarse
con sus compañeros u otras personas; ya fuese por medio escrito u oral?
4. ¿Fueron los cursos lo bastante útiles como para asegurar resultados positivos en exámenes
donde se mide el nivel de Inglés de los estudiantes; como el ECAES?
5. ¿Qué recomendaciones o sugerencias daría usted para que los cursos próximos de Inglés sean
mejores?
Once made the interview, the information was transcribed and analyzed. Based on the
interviewee’s answers, it was determined that
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 92
In question N° 1: Most of the interviewee agreed in saying that the courses given to them
were not effective, appropriate or significant, but boring and without relevance due to the little
motivation toward the English Language Learning; the teacher did not encourage them to learn
and participate in the class.
In question N° 2: Students claimed that the teacher methodology was not the best one since
she applied “a school methodology” full of a bunch of photocopies with images and the teacher
did not know how to explain a topic.
In Question N °3: The majority of the interviewed students said they cannot communicate in
the English Language. Some of them can pronounce some words, but they do not really know
what they are pronouncing (what the words mean).
In question N°4: They answered that even though they were taught some things, they did not
improve significantly in their English learning as an answer of the non-appropriate methodology
used by their teacher. Consequently, they did not achieve good scores in texts in which their
language proficiency is assessed.
In question N° 5: Among the aspects student suggested are: the use of the TICS, more
interesting and nice classes, planned and well organized classes, more hours per week, writing
practice, exercises within contexts and topics and activities related to our field.
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 93
Annex 2
Syllabus
1. IDENTIFICACIÓN
Nombre de la Asignatura IDIOMA EXTRANJERO
(INVESTIGACION)
Código
Área SOCIOHUMANISTICO
Naturaleza
Teórico- Práctico No de Créditos
1.5
TP Trabajo
Presencial 31
TD Trabajo Dirigido
31
TI Trabajo Independiente
10
Semestre Duración 72 h Habilitable
Homologable
Validable
PRE-REQUISITO: Ninguno.
2. JUSTIFICACIÓN
El aprendizaje del inglés constituye una herramienta fundamental para la comunicación en el mundo
entero, teniendo en cuenta está necesidad básica de comunicarse y pensando en las competencias laborales
de los profesionales de la universidad de la Amazonia, se ofrece a los estudiantes de pregrado los
elementos básicos de la lengua inglesa a través de la práctica de la habilidad comunicativa oral de la
lengua, mejorando su competencia comunicativa en contextos específicos propios de su disciplina.
3. COMPETENCIAS
3.1 Competencias Generales
Utilizo el nuevo lenguaje en la identificación, interpretación, comprensión de textos y conversaciones que
me permitan llevar a cabo tareas y desenvolverme en situaciones cotidianas donde se requiera el idioma.
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 94
3.2 Competencias Especificas
Creo diálogos de acuerdo a mis intereses. Simulo situaciones de la vida diaria Identifico conversaciones en inglés de diversas situaciones y las interpreto. Respondo preguntas sobre temas específicos. Realizo tareas que requieren el uso del idioma extranjero
5. CONTENIDO TEMÁTICO Y ANÁLISIS DE CRÉDITOS
UNIT 1. MEETING NEW PEOPLE - Greetings - Introducing people and myself - Giving information - Asking for information
UNIT 2. DESCRIBING PLACES
- At the bank - At the supermarket - At the travel Agency - At the restaurant - At the hotel - At the mall
UNIT 3. WORK ENVIRONMENT - Interviewing people - Sending an e-mail - At the office - Talking to the boss - Asking for permission -
UNIT 4. DESCRIBING PEOPLE - Telling my friends about my family
UNIT 5. MY DAILY LIFE - Talking with a friend about daily routine
UNIT 6. TALKING ABOUT MY LIFE Telling your family about your vacations
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 95
TEMAS TRABAJO PRESENCIAL
TRABAJO DIRIGIDO
TRABAJO INDEPENDIENTE
UNIT 1. Meeting new people 4 H 2 H 1 H UNIT 2. Describing places 5 H 3 H 1 H UNIT 3. Work environment 6 H 7 H 2 H UNIT 4. Describing people 4 H 6 H 2 H UNIT 5. My daily routine 6 H 7 H 2 H UNIT 6. Talking about my life 6 H 6 H 2 H TOTAL DE HORAS DEL
31 31 10
TOTAL CRÉDITOS 1.5
6. Estrategias Metodológicas
Trabajo presencial:
Role plays, uso de TICS, videos guías, y actividades relacionadas con simulación de diferentes situaciones y juegos de roles.
Trabajo dirigido:
Actividades comunicativas juegos de roles.
Trabajo independiente:
Creación de videos
7. RECURSOS.
Para la orientación del curso se utilizará diccionarios, videos, salas especializadas, posters, fotocopias y video beam, speakers y todo el material didáctico que se requiera durante el desarrollo de las clases.
8. EVALUACIÓN
(20%), General Works in class, homework and quizzes (10%), Participación en Clase (20%), Oral presentations (20%), video (15%), Final Test (15%)
9. BIBLIOGRAFÍA - Drama in the classroom: http://esldrama.weebly.com/resources--links.html -Role plays in the classroom: http://www.learnenglish.de/Teachers/roleplays.html -Fresh role plays ideas for English: http://busyteacher.org/7371-10-roleplay-ideas-for-general-english.html
Libros y revistas
Lanternfish. Retrieved from: http://bogglesworldesl.com/ David Seymour & Maria Popova, (2003). 700 classroom activities. Ashford colour press Ltd, UK. Jeffrey Walter. Games for the Elementary EFL Classroom. Korea National University of Education. JeanneMcCarten (2007), teaching vocabulary. Cambridge University press.
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 97
Annex 4
Format of Questionnaire Role Plays as a Teaching Technique
Questionnaire November 11, 2014
Marque con una “X” la opción que más corresponda de acuerdo a su punto de vista.
1. Cómo considera que han sido las clases de Inglés basadas en la aplicación de los Roleplays? A) Muy chéveres B) Dinámicas C) Aburridas D) variadas
2. Cree usted que el curso basado en la aplicación de los Roleplays para mejorar las habilidades de Speaking (habla) ha: A) Influido positivamente en su producción oral en el idioma Inglés B) ayudado a adquirir confianza en sus capacidades al momento de comunicarse con otros en Inglés. C) Contribuido significativamente en el aprendizaje del Idioma Inglés, especialmente en la producción oral D) No cumplió con las expectativas.
3. Cree usted que las situaciones representadas a través de los juegos de roles: A) Fueron muy pertinentes y se llevaban a cabo de manera dinámica y contextualizada. B) Se presentaban a través de actividades que no permitían el aprendizaje C) No se representaron situaciones D) Estaban fuera de contexto
4. Considera usted que la técnica de Roleplays usada en las clases de Inglés: A) Asegura el aprendizaje del idioma Inglés debido a que los estudiantes adquieren confianza en si mismo y sus potencialidades B) No es muy eficaz ya que se pierde mucho tiempo
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 98
C) Es buena porque se practica la producción oral constantemente que permite la comunicación. D) Es buena porque desarrolla no sólo la habilidad de habla sino también de escritura, lectura y escucha.
5. Opina usted que al recibir el curso de Inglés basado en la aplicación de Roleplays ha: A) Aprendido a comunicarse oralmente en el Idioma Inglés en situaciones de la vida diaria B) Adquirido algunos conocimientos referentes a vocabulario de situaciones vistas en la clase C) Desarrollado la habilidad de Speaking (habla), pero también de escucha, escritura y lectura D) No ha aprendido nada
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 99
Annex 5 Format of Interview
Role Plays as a Teaching Technique Interview
November 11, 2014
Interviewed: Lina Maria Urquina Jaramillo, Monica del Pilar Osorio Cuellar, Erica Paola Melo, Ana Milena Lopez Charge: participants Questions:
1.En pocas palabras, ¿cómo le pareció el curso de Inglés basado en roleplays?
2.Muchos de sus compañeros no volvieron a clase, o volvían con intermitencia, ¿por qué cree que ocurría?
3. ¿Considera usted que la técnica de roleplays dentro del salón de clases le contribuyó a adquirir confianza en su comunicación oral en el idioma Inglés?
4. ¿Después de las clases vistas, siente usted nervios o se siente insegura al momento de hacer una presentación oral en Inglés?
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 100
Annex 6
Interviews
Role Plays as a Teaching Technique November 11, 2014
Interviewed: Lina Maria Urquina Jaramillo Charge: Student Questions:
1) En pocas palabras, ¿cómo le pareció el curso de Inglés basado en roleplays?
“Pues… fue bueno porque yo pensé que iba a ser como normalmente uno recibe clases de inglés, o sea, como sin actividades. Pero en éste, la interacción que tuvimos con los demás compañeros hizo que fuese como algo nuevo y fue chévere, fue algo fuera de lo común o como había pensado que iba a ser.”
2) Muchos de sus compañeros no volvieron a clase, o volvían con intermitencia, ¿por qué cree
que ocurría?
“Umm, la verdad no sé. Creo que…. porque el curso es gratis, entonces uno no se preocupa por ir, o porque no requiere nota o algo. Yo creo que ése es el soporte o algo para no venir.”
3. ¿Considera usted que la técnica de roleplays dentro del salón de clases le contribuyó a adquirir confianza en su comunicación oral en el idioma Inglés?
“si, mucho”
4. ¿Después de las clases vistas, siente usted nervios o se siente insegura al momento de hacer una presentación oral en Inglés?
“un poquito, pero menos que antes”
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 101
Interview Role Plays as a Teaching Technique
November 11, 2014
Interviewed: Ana Milena Lopez Charge: Student Questions:
1.En pocas palabras, cómo le pareció el curso de Inglés basado en roleplays?
“Bueno, pues fue como una técnica que es básicamente como que no le enseñen a uno la gramática, sino de una manera más didáctica de alguna manera de aprender e interactuar con los compañeros que hace que se facilite más la comunicación.”
2.Muchos de sus compañeros no volvieron a clase, o volvían con intermitencia, ¿por qué cree que ocurría?
“ Pueden ser muchas cosas, una puede ser que realmente no estaban interesados, se inscribieron pero no se… Tal vez también puede ser por el horario: 2:00 pm,,no se mucho calor a ésa hora, de pronto otro horario hubiese sido más…. Pueden ser éstas algunas de muchas razones.”
3.¿Considera usted que la técnica de roleplays dentro del salón de clases le contribuyó a adquirir confianza en su comunicación oral en el idioma Inglés?
“Pues si, en los roleplays vivimos situaciones en el salón de clases que pueden presentarse en nuestra vida diaria. Entonces eso hace que uno, en el momento de pronto de hablar en ésas situaciones ya tenga como unas bases más solidas”
4.¿Después de las clases vistas, siente usted nervios o se siente insegura al momento de hacer una presentación oral en Inglés?
“Emm, pues con ésas bases uno se siente más seguro, al menos en pronunciación. Muchas palabras las podía saber uno, pero la pronunciación era fatal, entonces ya con esto uno.., o sea no será el experto pero pues ya se defiende más.”
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 102
Interview
Role Plays as a Teaching Technique November 11, 2014
Interviewed: Erica Paola Melo. Charge: Student Questions:
1.En pocas palabras, ¿cómo le pareció el curso de Inglés basado en roleplays?
“Pues fue muy chévere, muy lúdico. Pues ya.., aunque nosotros vimos al principio de la carrera, Inglés, no fue tan…, no tuvimos como tanta lúdica, pero en éste si interactuamos más en Inglés con los docentes y entre nosotros los compañeros.”
2.Muchos de sus compañeros no volvieron a clase, o volvían con intermitencia, ¿por qué cree que ocurría?
“Pues…, de pronto que ya finalizando el semestre, tenían.., pues lo digo por mí, se nos cruzaba el horario tanto en el estudio como en la clase. Y pues también de pronto no creían en esto como una clase para aprender sino por venir.. ”
3. ¿Considera usted que la técnica de role plays dentro del salón de clases le contribuyó a adquirir confianza en su comunicación oral en el idioma Inglés?
“si, si me sirvió de mucho pues antes de pronto no hablaba que porque de pronto me daba pena de equivocarme, y pues aquí uno se equivoca y aprende más. Entonces sí creo que contribuyó mucho en mi aprendizaje”
4. ¿Después de las clases vistas, siente usted nervios o se siente insegura al momento de hacer una presentación oral en Inglés?
“no porque si me equivoco sé que puedo mejorar y.. y.., qué.. Y además pues ya tengo un poquito más de bases para defenderme.”
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 103
Interview Role Plays as a Teaching Technique
November 11, 2014
Interviewed: Monica del Pilar Osorio Cuellar. Charge: Student Questions:
1.En pocas palabras, ¿cómo le pareció el curso de Inglés basado en roleplays?
“Muy bueno ya que los role plays, es decir los juegos de roles que utilizaron para darnos a entender el Inglés como para que entendiéramos fue muy interesante. En si me pareció muy bueno.
2. Muchos de sus compañeros no volvieron a clase, o volvían con intermitencia, ¿por qué cree que ocurría?
“De pronto por muchas ocupaciones en el estudio, estábamos en cierre del 70% y entonces… de pronto les importó un poquito más la parte académica en lo que tiene que ver con el programa y descuidaron el curso”
3. ¿Considera usted que la técnica de role plays dentro del salón de clases le contribuyó a adquirir confianza en su comunicación oral en el idioma Inglés?
“si, bastante”
4. ¿Después de las clases vistas, siente usted nervios o se siente insegura al momento de hacer una presentación oral en Inglés?
“De pronto un poquito, ya he perdido mucho lo que es la inseguridad y el miedo, pero si sigue estando ahí un poquito de nervios ante hablar y equivocarme muchas veces de no pronunciar bien las palabras, pero en sí sirvió mucho”
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 104
Annex 7
Format of Pre-Test Role Plays as a Teaching Technique
Pre-Test November 11, 2014
Name:_______________________________________________________ Date:________
Grammar and vocabulary (20)
Choose the correct option (escoge la opción correcta)
1. A: Is this Ann’s briefcase? B: Yes, it _________.
A: aren´t B: are C: isn´t D: is E: I don´t know 2. They _______ teachers. They’re students.
A: aren´t B: no C: not D: are no E: I don´t know
3. A: Does she watch TV? B: Yes. She ________ about two hours a day.
A: watching B: watch C: are watch D: watches E: I don´t know 4. _______ he like Rock music?
A: do B: does C: have D: has E: I don´t know 5. _______ Peter here last week?
A: are B: is C: was D: were E: I don´t know 6. What are you doing now?
1. A: I study B: I be studying C: I studies D: I'm studying E: I don´t know 7. A: Where did they go? B: I think they ______ to the mall.
A: go B: goes C: went D: did go E: I don´t know
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 105
8. Paula is my mother’s sister. Paula is my ________.
A: uncle B: cousin C: aunt D: niece E: I don´t know 9. We have a big ________ in our kitchen. A: garden B: bathtub C: refrigerator D: bed E: mirror 10. When it rains, you should use an ________.
A: boots B: sandals C: umbrella D: sneakers E: sun glasses
Reading (20)
Blanca is 21 years old. She lives in Bolivar’s neighborhood. She has four brothers and a sister. She teaches English at the Universidad de la Amazonia. Blanca likes to read and listen to music. She loves animals. Her favorite food is Chicken and rice. Blanca is going to travel to The United States next year and she is happy about it.
Answer the following questions with the above information (respond alas preguntas con la informaciòn de arriba)
1) How old is Blanca? __________________________________________________________ 2) How many brothers does Blanca have?__________________________________________ 3) What does Blanca like?_______________________________________________________ 4) Why is Blanca happy?_____________________________________________________________
Writing (20)
2: Write what you want about yourself. Your name, age, likes, hobbies, etc. (escribe lo que quieras sobre ti: tu nombre, edad, ocupación, gustos, etc)
____________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
ORAL PART (40)
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 106
Annex 8
Format of Expectation Survey Role Plays as a Teaching Technique
Expectation Survey September 9, 2014
EXPECTATIVAS PERSONALES
Seleccione las que considere aplican con total sinceridad a su punto de vista.
1. Disfruta aprender Inglés por medio de:
1) Música 2) Juegos 3) Escribiendo 4) Leyendo 5) Escuchando al profesor 6) hablando Otra/s: ___________________________________________________________________________
2. Cuáles son sus expectativas para éste curso?
1) Conocer gente 2) Poder comunicarse con otros en inglés 3) Practicar y reforzar lo que ya sé 4) Otra(s):________________________________________________________________________
__________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 107
Annex 9
Photographs
Photo 1
First induction class to motivate students through the activity Simon says, where students perform movements according to the teacher's instructions, these activities were performed before starting classes.
Photo 2
In photo 2, learners introduce classmates
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 108
Photo 3
Learners speak out about their own life
Photo 4
Bank role playing, learners perform about a real situation in a bank.
USE OF ROLE PLAYS TO ENHANCE ENGLISH SPEAKING ABILITY 109
Photo 6
Learners represent how to open a bank account using realia as shown in the pictures, they
use ID card and printed money.
Photo 7
Going shopping, students perform how to buy things in a supermarket