om final project
TRANSCRIPT
RUNNER: Nissan Case Study: Final Analysis Page | 1
Nissan Case Study: Final Analysis
James O’Brien
Southern New Hampshire University
Nissan Case Study: Final Analysis Page | 2
Outline
Part 1. Generating Value:
1. Evaluate how the company in the case study uses operations management functions to
provide products and generate value for its customers
2. Assess how this company achieves a competitive advantage using operations
management.
3. Compare and contrast service operations and manufacturing operations at the company in
the case study. How are they the same? How do they differ? How does each of these
operations provide value for their customers?
Part 2. Theories and Techniques:
4. How are gross-to-net calculations processed for material requirements planning (MRP)?
a. What specific input files would Nissan need to include in this process?
b. How would you use the MRP information to improve the operations as the
manager of Nissan?
5. Compare and contrast the critical path method (CPM) and the program evaluation and
review technique (PERT). What types of projects at this company would favor PETT
over CPM? Why? What types of projects at this company would favor CPM over PERT?
Why?
6. Explain the four primary priority rules for job sequencing.
a. In what instances at the company might each rule be most advantageous?
b. When would each rule be most disadvantageous?
7. Explain the five steps of the Theory of Constraints (TOC)
a. Explanation of the Theory
Nissan Case Study: Final Analysis Page | 3
b. Step 1: Identify
i. Step 2: Exploit
ii. Step 3: Subordinate
iii. Step 4: Elevate
iv. Step 5: Repeat
8. Explain the steps used to develop a forecasting system. How would these steps be
specifically utilizes by this company? What do you predict would be the result of
implementing a forecasting system for the top--selling product line at this company?
9. List the major categories of supply chain risk and associated risk reduction tactics. How
could the company mitigate exposure to supply chain disruptions caused by natural
disasters? For example, consider the 2011 earthquake and tsunami that devastated parts
of Japan.
10. Theories: discuss the following and describe the advantages and disadvantages of each,
and how they are related.
a. Just in Time (JIT)
b. Toyota Production System (TPS)
c. Lean
11. Describe how Total Quality Management (TQM) principles and tools can be used to
improve quality in the latest line of products.
Part 3. Data Analysis
12. How as an Operations Manager will you use the time-function map to keep the assembly
process flowing
Nissan Case Study: Final Analysis Page | 4
13. Assess why some of the company’s supply chain partners might have struggled to
implement some of the company’s newly developed materials. Utilize Cause and Effect
Diagram
14. Utilizing the data, determine where the company should locate its new manufacturing
plant. Why would this be the favorable location?
15. Develop an ABC classification system
a. What do you recommend for improving inventory management
Part 4. Sustainability:
16. How can the Triple bottom line be used to enhance operations management at Nissan?
17. How does Nissan integrate ISO 14000 standards in its manufacturing plants?
18. Describe ways that Nissan can integrate corporate responsibility principles into their
operations.
19. Conclusion
20. Appendix
21. References
Nissan Case Study: Final Analysis Page | 5
The following is an analysis of the Nissan Motor Company. In this analysis we will look
at a variety of operational management functions and theories that could help bring Nissan into
the future. We will also look at some of the operational management functions and reports that
they utilize in their day to day data analysis. We will finally finish the analysis with how Nissan
is contributing to the sustainability efforts.
I have broken this analysis up into three parts. In part one we will look into how Nissan
is generating value using competitive advantage and the usage of operational management
functions. In part two we will take a look at the management theories and techniques that have
been put in place at Nissan to bring them into the future. Theories like total quality management,
forecasting, as well as different systems that are in place to ensure proper functionality at the
manufacturing plants. In part three we will take a look at some raw data and run some analysis
to see if Nissan is operating at functioning levels. Part four will take a look at some of the way
in which Nissan is responding to the need for being corporately sustainable. I hope you enjoy
and can learn a few things about Nissan and how they function as a company on an operational
level.
Part 1: Generating Value
During and after the tragic events of March 11, 2011, Nissan put their risk management
guidelines into effect. Nissan had been prepared for situations like these so that in the event of a
natural disaster they would be able to utilize their remaining functioning plants around the world
to continue to manufacture their products so the consumers would not be affected. Their
operational management team created a Global Disaster Headquarters which was in charge of
gathering and distributing information concerning employee safety, facility damages, and
Nissan Case Study: Final Analysis Page | 6
business continuity planning for Nissan’s operations and those of its suppliers. (William
Schmidt, 2013) The results of Nissan having this continuity plan in place is the reason why
Nissan had one of the shortest down times from this event.
To achieve competitive advantage, managers need to make effective decisions in good
and service design, process, capacity design, location, process technology and control. These
decisions are the support that operations management can make in order to support the
company’s mission and therefore its business strategy. One way that Nissan is able to offer a
competitive advantage is by use of just-in-time technology. With this technology specific
vehicles and their components are produced just-in-time to meet the demand for them. What this
does in turn is allow for a lower inventory level which then keeps overall costs down due to not
having to find place to store all of the extra inventory. (Kyratzoglou, 2013) Another advantage
that Nissan brings is by their use of capacity. Nissan’s capacity affects a large portion of the
fixed cost and it also determines if demand will be met or if facilities will be unused. For
example, if the facility is too large, portions of it will be still and will add cost to existing
production or clients. On the other hand, if the facility is too small customers and perhaps
markets will be lost. Therefore determining the capacity is a crucial step to help the achievement
of the company’s strategies. (Manufacturing, N.D.)
Nissan has two major components in their business, service operations and manufacturing
operations. Although you would think that these processes would always go hand in hand, there
are differences in which you can still run a business even if one of these is not in a working
order. The main comparison between these two operations is that without the service operations
there would be no need for the manufacturing operation. You need to have clients in order to
sell your product and you need the money from these clients to manufacture the product.
Nissan Case Study: Final Analysis Page | 7
However, if for some reason like the earthquake of 2011 the manufacturing plants suffer heave
damage and cannot produce vehicles at the present time the service operations team can still
work with the existing inventory to continue to make sales for the company. Each of these
operations provide value to their customer as the organizations overall objective is customer
satisfaction. Service operations work directly with the customer in regards to specification’s that
are wanted and quantities, color, accessories etc. Manufacturing operations takes the
information that is given to the Service operations department and puts these specifications into
the vehicle that the customer is looking for.
Part 2: Theories and Techniques
Material requirements planning or (MRP) is a computer-based inventory management
system designed to assist production managers in scheduling and placing orders for items of
dependent demand. Dependent demand refers to items that are components of finished goods
such as raw materials or component parts. (MRP, N.D.) Nissan would utilize this program by
imputing information such as a billing of all materials needed, the master scheduling files and
inventory records files. What the MRP does is utilizes the bill of materials to determine the
quantity of each component that is needed to produce a certain number of finished products.
From this quantity, the system subtracts the quantity of that item already in inventory to
determine order requirements which goes along with the primary rules of job sequencing which
we will touch on later.
As with any program the MRP system does have its pros and cons. Some of the potential
benefits that Nissan could look forward to when using this system would be helping production
managers to minimize inventory levels and the associated costs, track material requirements,
determine the most economical lot sizes for orders, compute quantities needed as safety stock
Nissan Case Study: Final Analysis Page | 8
and this list could go on. (MRP, N.D.) Some of the drawback that Nissan could face when
utilizing this system could be inaccurate inventory levels if the records were not up to date prior
to installation, all bills of materials are not current. The results of these inaccuracies could be
missing parts and excessive order quantities to schedule delays and missed delivery dates. These
are some drawbacks that could really hurt the company’s customer service reputation. (MRP,
N.D.)
The critical path method (CPM) and the program evaluation and review technique
(PERT) are two ways that project management teams can utilize in order to prioritize their target
goals. These are basically diagrams that companies utilize to find the best way to get to from the
starting point of a project to the end result. In the case of Nissan, the CPM is a method that
would work when planning out their Global Disaster Headquarter contingency plans. This CPM
is a way to compute one way to arrive to the overall goal of this project. The PERT method is a
method that uses three estimates in order to reach a final destination in the planning process.
This method would generally be used when trying to come up with a plan to get one of their
vehicle lines out of production and onto the showroom floor. With this type of project there are
many factors that need to be included into the equation such as labor, materials, equipment,
maintenance, down time and more. The PERT method can take all of these factors into
consideration when plotting the overall ending date to the project at hand.
Once work has been loaded into the work center, managers decide the sequence in which
each job is to be completed. Sequencing also known as dispatching is done by specifying
priority rules as to which jobs get released for production first. (Render, 2014) There are 5
major priority sequencing rules that a company can choose to utilize for their productions. These
five sequencing rules are: 1. First come, first served (FCFS), 2. Earliest due date (EDD), 3.
Nissan Case Study: Final Analysis Page | 9
Shortest processing time (SPT), 4. Longest processing time (LPT) and 5. Critical ratio (CR).
(Hartman, N.D.)
First Come, first served is where jobs are sequenced in the order in which they arrive at
the work station. Earliest due date jobs are sequenced in the order in which they are due for
delivery. Shortest processing time jobs are sequenced in order of the processing time required at
the work station, with the job requiting the least processing time at the work station scheduled
first. Longest processing time are jobs that are sequenced in order of the processing time
required at the work stations with the job requiring the longest processing time at the work
station scheduled first. The last rule are the critical ratios. These are jobs that are sequenced in
order of increasing critical ratio (the ration of time required by work left to be done to time left to
do the work. (Hartman, N.D.)
The theory of constraints or (TOC) is a methodology for identifying the most important
limiting factor that stands in the way of achieving a goal and then systematically improving that
constraint until it is no longer the limiting factor. In manufacturing, such as with the Nissan
Company the constraint is often referred to as a bottleneck. (Constraints, N.D.) What the TOC
does is takes a scientific approach to improvements. It hypothesizes that every complex system,
including manufacturing processes, consists of multiple linked activities, in which one of these
acts as a constraint upon the entire system. (Constraints, N.D.) The TOC comprises of five steps
in which we will take a closer look at next. These steps are: Identifying the constraint, Exploit
the constraint, Subordinate and synchronize to the constraint, Elevate performance of the
constraint and finally repeat the process. (Render, 2014)
In step one, identifying the constraint is where the operations manager needs to figure out
which part of the process is limiting the rate by which the goal can be achieved. (Constraints,
Nissan Case Study: Final Analysis Page | 10
N.D.) An example of this would be if the plant manager for Nissan notices that they are running
out of a particular part for a vehicle which puts the assembly process at a halt. Step two,
exploiting the constraint is where you would need to make quick improvements to the throughput
of the constraint using existing resources. (Constraints, N.D.) This would be where a manager
would go through the entire inventory to make sure how much of the part they have on hand to
make sure that they can continue producing for as long as possible. In Step three which requires
the managers to subordinate and synchronize to the constraint, involves reviewing all other
activities in the process to ensure that they are aligned with and truly support the needs of the
constraint. (Constraints, N.D.) An example of this would be to make sure that all possibilities to
work through this problem have been resolved and that there are no other possibilities to fix the
issue sooner.
Step 4 is where you elevate the performance of the constraint. This involves making
sure that the constraint still exists after following the first three steps and if it does then one must
consider what further actions can be taken to eliminate it from being the constraint. (Constraints,
N.D.) Generally, this step is continued until the constraint is eliminated. This would be where
the manager would probably be calling to all of their suppliers and sister plants to see if any of
these parts can be expedited to the facility so that the assembly process can resume. The final
step to this process is to repeat. What this means is that the steps are an ongoing processes in the
continuous improvement cycle. Once the constraint has been fixed the next one should be
addressed immediately. (Constraints, N.D.)
Forecasting is an integral part of any company’s strategy. By utilizing forecasting tools a
company can predict what products or in Nissan’s case vehicle models will be in higher demand
so that way Nissan can make sure that they have enough inventory to meet the demands of their
Nissan Case Study: Final Analysis Page | 11
customers. In order to create a successful forecasting system there are generally five steps that
need to be taken, these steps are defining the problem, gathering information, preliminary
analysis, choosing and fitting models and using and evaluating a forecasting model.
In step 1 defining the problem, this is often one of the most difficult parts, you need to
carefully understand the way that the forecast will be used and who will be requiring the
forecasts. In this step there is a lot of data that will need to be gathered, inputting the data into a
database and setting up for the forecasting. In step 2 gathering information there are usually at
least two kinds of data that will need to be acquired, statistical data and the accumulated
expertise of the people who collect the data and use the forecasts. Step 3 is where you start
getting your preliminary analysis. The best way of sorting this information is usually by
graphing the data and looking for consistent patterns. You are also looking for trends,
seasonality, and evidence of business cycles. Step 4 is started by choosing and fitting models.
Each model is an artificial construct that is based on a set of assumptions and usually involves
one or more parameters which must be fitted using know historical data. Step 5 consists of using
and evaluating the forecasting model. Once a model has been selected and its parameters
estimated, the model is used to make forecasts. The performance of the model can only be
properly evaluated after the data for the forecast period has become available. (Forecasting,
N.D.)
In the case of Nissan, these forecasting models can be extremely helpful when trying to
figure out if any new concept vehicles would have a customer base. For instance, if Nissan were
to send out a survey to existing customers and asked for information regarding their favorite
features of the existing models and were to transpose these features into a new model the
forecasts could show how this new vehicle could fare on the showroom floor. In the automotive
Nissan Case Study: Final Analysis Page | 12
industry customer trends alone with the demographics of where they are planning to sell the
product could have weighing factors in the production of newer vehicles.
Nissan has identified seven factors that enable stronger capabilities in both supply chain
management and risk management. By matching their practices against these seven enablers,
they can assess how mature or immature their capabilities are. Below are the seven factors and
how they can enable the maturity or immaturity of the company.
1. Risk governance—the presence of appropriate risk management structures, processes, and culture.2. Flexibility and redundancy in product, network, and process architectures—having the right levels of
flexibility and redundancy across the value chain to be able to absorb disruptions and adapt to change.
3. Alignment between partners in the supply chain—strategic alignment on key value dimensions, identification of emerging patterns, and advancement toward higher value propositions.
4. Upstream and downstream supply chain integration—information sharing, visibility, and collaboration with upstream and downstream supply chain partners.
5. Alignment between internal business functions—alignment and the integration of activities between company value chain functions on a strategic, tactical, and operational level.
6. Complexity management/rationalization—ability to standardize and simplify networks and processes, interfaces, product architectures, and product portfolios and operating models.
7. Data, models, and analytics—development and use of intelligence and analytical capabilities to support supply chain and risk management functions. (Kyratzoglou, 2013)
With Nissan’s Global disaster Headquarters put in place prior to the earthquake of 2011,
Nissan was ahead of the game when the disaster struck. They already had plans in place to deal
with shortages and supply chain issues. When the disaster struck Nissan utilized its
manufacturing plants around the world to ensure that all needed supplies and parts were sent to
the areas that were affected in order to minimize downed time on the production lines. Nissan’s
preparedness for catastrophic events allow them to still maintain a positive output within six
months of the disaster while other car manufacturers in Japan were still struggling to pull
themselves back into production.
Nissan Case Study: Final Analysis Page | 13
Of the many theories out there we will take a look at a few of the main ones that the
Nissan Company use in order to continuously improve company standards as working towards
complete sustainability. The first theory that we will look at is the Just-in Time theory. What
the Just-in-Time (JIT) theory is, is a continuous and forces problem solving via a focus on
throughput and reduced inventory. (Render, 2014) With this theory materials arrive where they
are needed but only when they are needed. This allows for less inventory problems as Nissan
would make sure that they had the right amount of inventory on hand to complete the job.
Having no excess inventory allows for less storage space and can help reduce costs. The JIT
theory can also be broken down into five segments as well these would be the JIT Partnerships,
the JIT Layout, JIT Inventory, JIT Scheduling, and JIT Quality.
JIT partnerships exist when a supplier and a purchaser work together with open
communication and a goal of removing waste and driving down costs. This process usually has
specific goals but there could also be concerns by the suppliers. Some of the goals would be the
removal of unnecessary activities, removal of in-plant inventory, removal of in-transit inventory
or obtaining improved quality and reliability through long-term commitments, communication
and cooperation. (Render, 2014) Some of the concerns that this brings by the suppliers are
diversification, scheduling, and lead time, quality, and lot sizes. All of these concerns are viable
concerns for suppliers and they need to be worked out before the JIT process can be validated.
The JIT layout is a process that is designed to reduce movement. The movement of
material of the factory floor does not add value. Consequently, the managers want flexible
layouts that reduce the movement of both people and material. JIT layouts place material
directly in the location where needed. (Render, 2014) For Nissan, their assembly line should be
designed with delivery points next to the line so material can be delivered right to the point
Nissan Case Study: Final Analysis Page | 14
where it will be needed and not to a receiving facility and then needing to be moved again to the
staging area where it will be used on the assembly line. With JIT layouts time and movement
can be reduced allowing for increased flexibility as well as reduced space and inventory.
JIT inventory are inventories in production and distribution systems that often exist “just
in case” something goes wrong. These are utilized in case there is some kind of variation from
the production plans. JIT inventory is the minimum inventory necessary to keep a perfect system
running. With the JIT system the right amount of goods arrive at the plant just at the moment
that it is needed. The two main things that JIT inventory allows for is a reduced inventory and
reduced lot sizes, all of which is a time and cost saver for the company.
JIT Scheduling is where effective schedules are communicated both within the
organization and to outside suppliers. With better scheduling you can also improve the ability to
meet customer orders, drive down inventory and reduce work in process. (Render, 2014) JIT and
Quality can be related in three ways. First, JIT cuts the cost of obtaining good quality because
they care able to save because of scrap, rework, inventory investment, and damage costs. These
costs are hidden within the inventory and the JIT forces down the inventory so therefore fewer
bad units are produced and fewer units need to be redone. The second similarity is that of
quality. JIT creates an early warning system for quality problems so that fewer bad products are
produced and feedback is immediate. The third similarity is that when consistent quality exists
the JIT allows companies to reduce all costs associated with inventories. By being able to utilize
these methods Nissan would be able to completely overhaul their processes and work to create a
JIT environment to utilize all methods and start saving a tremendous amount of overhead and
expenditures.
Nissan Case Study: Final Analysis Page | 15
Of course as with any theory there comes advantages and disadvantages. A couple of
the advantages of the JIT system are customer needs, and Inventory costs. (Kokemuller, N.D.)
The main advantage with customer needs is that with the JIT system automated and efficient
inventory replenishment systems can quickly respond to reduced inventory levels. This allows
for less disruption time for the customers to receive their product from the Nissan. Nissan also
could utilize the JIT system to reduce the amount of holding space and staff required to maintain
it. Nissan could utilize the savings and invest it into business growth and other opportunities.
One disadvantage of the JIT system is coordination. The reason for this being that managing the
JIT inventory system requires significant coordination between retailers and suppliers in the
distribution channel. Retailers often put major trust in suppliers by syncing their computer
systems with suppliers so they can more directly monitor inventory levels so that they can
respond quicker to low inventory levels. (Kokemuller, N.D.)
The next theory that we will look at is the Toyota Production System (TPS). The TPS is
a theory that focuses on continuous improvement in respect for people and standard work
practices. (Render, 2014) This theory was created by Eiji Toyoda and Taiichi Ohno from Toyota
Motors. This system has three core components which are continuous improvement, respect for
people and standard work practice. The first component which is continuous improvement
means to build an organizational culture and instill it in its people a value system stressing that
processes can be improved. In order to do this Toyota begins instilling this component at the
recruiting stage and continues it with continuous extensive training. Instilling this value in their
employees leads into the next component of TPS which is respect for people.
The second component of the TPS theory is respect for people. TPS engages the mental
as well as physical capacities of employees in the challenging task of improving operations. This
Nissan Case Study: Final Analysis Page | 16
function allows for the employee to be empowered to make decisions necessary to the functions
of the business. (Render, 2014) In the case of Nissan the employees would be allowed to stop
the production process if they noticed that there was a problem with a process in the assembly of
the product. What Toyota did with this process is recognize that their employees know more
about their particular jobs than anyone else so therefore they utilize the TPS method because it
gives the employees the opportunity to not only enrich themselves but also the job at hand.
The last component of TPS is having standard work practices. Toyota has a set of
principles when outlying this component. What they expect is that work is completely specified
as to content, sequence, timing and outcome of the process. They also make sure that internal
and external customer-supplier connections are direct, specifying personnel, methods, timing and
quantity. The product and service flows are to be simple and direct. The goods and services are
directed to a specific person or machine. When improvements in the system must be made they
must be done in accordance to the scientific method at the lowers possible level in the
organization. (Render, 2014) All of these components make up a method of work flow practices
that can enhance a company’s social responsibilities with their clients and suppliers not to
mention the impact that they can have on the environment.
As we said before there are advantages and disadvantages to everything and the TPS
system is no different. Some of the advantages of the TPS include reducing the waste as much
as possible, less movement of the producing labor, leads to less time in producing JIT, Every
step of the production can be checked, go smoothly and without any mistakes due to jidoka (the
Japanese name for stopping production when a defect occurs) (Render, 2014) (TPS, N.D.) A
couple of the disadvantages of this system include it high cost to implement, dismantling
previous systems and training employees on how to use it, utilizes suppliers that can handle
Nissan Case Study: Final Analysis Page | 17
small amounts of on hand inventory. (TPS, N.D.) If Nissan were to utilize this method they
would need to be sure that the cost benefits of this would be the best option. There are potential
issues that could affect Nissan with the usage of this method including the lack of required
inventory but the “trusted” suppliers.
That last theory that we will be addressing here is the Lean operations theory. What lean
operations does is eliminates waste through continuous improvement and focuses on exactly
what the customer wants. This operation can be thought of as the end result of a well-run
operations management function, which understands what the customer wants and ensures
customer input and feedback. (Render, 2014) What this function does is analyzes the activities
needed to produce the product by optimizing the process from the customers perspective. Lean
operations utilize some of the same qualities as JIT and TPS. The methods used all work with
sections of the business such as suppliers, layouts, inventory, scheduling and more. Some of the
advantages and disadvantages of this method include waste reduction, worker satisfaction,
competitive advantage, new inefficiencies, worker frustration, and problems with JIT systems.
(Shpak, N.D.)
The purpose of utilizing these methods is not only to create cost effective practices but to
also create a sense of sustainability within the organization. Companies such as Nissan utilize
what is called the triple bottom line. The phrase “the triple bottom line” was first coined in 1994
by John Elkington, the founder of a British consultancy called SustainAbility. His argument was
that companies should be preparing three different (and quite separate) bottom lines. One is the
traditional measure of corporate profit—the “bottom line” of the profit and loss account. The
second is the bottom line of a company's “people account”—a measure in some shape or form of
how socially responsible an organization has been throughout its operations. The third is the
Nissan Case Study: Final Analysis Page | 18
bottom line of the company's “planet” account—a measure of how environmentally responsible
it has been. The triple bottom line (TBL) thus consists of three Ps: profit, people and planet. It
aims to measure the financial, social and environmental performance of the corporation over a
period of time. Only a company that produces a TBL is taking account of the full cost involved
in doing business. (Line, 2009)
With all operations management there are certain subject matter and statistical analysis
that all managers need to be aware of and how to utilize in order to run their business. The two
main functions that we will be looking at here are theory of constraints (TOC) and total quality
management (TQM). We will also be looking at some of the statistical graphs that Operations
managers utilize constantly to ensure that day to day functions as well as special projects are
met.
The next processes that Operations Managers utilize on a daily basis is total quality
management or (TQM). TQM is the management of an entire organization so that it excels in all
aspects of products and services that are important to the customer. (William Schmidt, 2013)
Quality expert W. Edwards Deming came up with 14 points to indicate how he implemented
TQM which were then broken down into seven concepts to utilize an effective TQM program.
These concepts are: Continuous improvement, Six Sigma, employee empowerment,
benchmarking, just-in-time, Taguchi concepts, and knowledge of TQM tools. (William Schmidt,
2013)
There are many tools available today to assist operations managers with TQM in there
day to day routines. Some of these tools are Pie charts and bar graphs, Histograms, Run charts,
Force field analysis, focus groups, brainstorming and affinity diagrams, tree diagrams,
Flowcharts and modeling diagrams, scatter diagrams, relations diagrams and PDCA which
Nissan Case Study: Final Analysis Page | 19
stands for Plan-Do-Check-Act. (Tools, N.D.) All of these tools have different uses for the
operations managers. Each one of these graphs and charts can depict a different aspect of their
jobs or projects. Knowing how to utilize each of these tools can help to set your company aside
from the rest of the field. For example operations managers for the Nissan Company can utilize
Run charts to follow the process of vehicle assembly over a specific time frame and look for
accuracy rates and track the high and low points in the process to see where improvements can
be made. Automobile manufactures also utilize focus groups to see what their customers are
looking for and then take that information and create brainstorming ideas and create Affinity
diagrams.
Part 3: Data Analysis
Cause-and-Effect Diagrams are another tool that operations managers utilize in order to
identify quality issues and inspection points. A Cause-and effect diagram is a schematic
technique used to discover possible locations of quality problems. (Render, 2014) In the case of
Nissan Company utilizing six different factors that could potentially hurt the production or
transportation of parts or goods to and from the manufacturing plant the diagram could
potentially look like the one provided in figure 1(please see appendix A). In this figure you can
see the factors listed in the boxes followed by different causes that could attribute to delays in
reaching their ultimate goal.
Another resource that can allow operations managers to make sure that they are
continuously on track with time demands would be the utilization of a time-function map. A
time-function map is a tool that shows the managers a time line of how long a process should
take and guidelines of where the process should be at any given time. In figure 2 you will see a
basic time function map for the production of the new Nissan NV Passenger van that has recently
Nissan Case Study: Final Analysis Page | 20
hit the showroom floors. This map will give a basic time from when the concept comes down
from R&D to the time the full product comes off of the assembly line and out to the dealerships.
Figure 2: Time-Function Mapping Nissan NV Passenger van
Now let’s say that Nissan is looking for a new location for a manufacturing plant. Nissan’s real
estate team can utilize different forms of charts and graphs to weigh out the potential pros and cons of
particular site interests. Now utilizing the same factors as shown in figure 1 we have created a Pivot
chart to weigh the pros and cons between putting a plant in either Mexico City or Columbia, SC. . Now
using the weight values listed below you can see how Nissan Company feels that these factors could
help to assist in the decision of where to build the plant.
Row LabelsSum of Weight
Sum of Mexico City
Sum of Columbia, SC
Labor Costs 0.10 80 50Labor Productivity 0.20 85 75Political Risk 0.25 70 80Rental Costs 0.15 90 55Taxes 0.10 90 50Transportation Costs 0.20 40 90Grand Total 1 455 400
Nissan Case Study: Final Analysis Page | 21
By utilizing the previous information and putting the data into a chart (figure 3) to compare the two
potential cities, one would see that Mexico City would probably be the best choice for Nissan based on
the weighted values of what they were looking for.
Figure 3: Pivot Chart for deciding what city to choose for a new Manufacturing Plant.
Labor Costs
Labor Producti
vity
Politica
l Risk
Rental Costs
Taxes
Transporta
tion Costs0.00
10.0020.0030.0040.0050.0060.0070.0080.0090.00
100.00
Sum of WeightSum of Mexico CitySum of Columbia, SC
As you can see from the information in the chart with Political risk, Transportation costs and
Labor productivity weighted the highest you can tell that there is less political risk in Mexico City, the
transportation costs are a fraction of the cost than it would be in Columbia, and the labor productivity is
higher in Mexico City. With these three factors weighing in for over half of the factors weights the
obvious choice for Nissan would be Mexico City.
One way that Nissan could help with inefficiencies with their inventory management systems
would be the usage of a chart called the ABC classification system. This system is a ranking system used
for identifying and grouping items in terms of how useful they are for achieving business goals. (Rouse,
N.D.) In figures 4 and 5 you will see a sample of data from Nissan and then you will see that data in an
ABC classification chart. This information will be helpful for Nissan to see what items are costing more
on an annual basis. With that data they can then see if they can find a different supplier that may have
the same parts for cheaper to save money on parts that they use more often.
Nissan Case Study: Final Analysis Page | 22
Figure 4: Data Sample for parts and costs (Manufacturing, N.D.)
Item Annual Demand Cost/Unit Dollar value % Dollar ValueA2 3000 50.00 150000 13.79%B8 4000 12.00 48000 4.41%C7 1500 45.00 67500 6.21%D1 6000 10.00 60000 5.52%E9 1000 20.00 20000 1.84%F3 500 500.00 250000 22.99%G2 300 1500.00 450000 41.38%H2 600 20.00 12000 1.10%I5 1750 10.00 17500 1.61%J8 2500 5.00 12500 1.15%
Figure 5: Data sample in Graph to show costs and dollar values of parts
A2 B8 C7 D1 E9 F3 G2 H2 I5 J80
50000100000150000200000250000300000350000400000450000500000
Nissan ABC Analysis
Annual Demand Cost/Unit Dollar value % Dollar Value
As you can see from this data parts G2, F3, and A2 have the largest percent of dollar
value and have the highest cost per Unit. You can also see from this data that parts G2 and F3 do
not have a high annual demand so I would definitely try to find another supplier for these items
so we can keep our costs under control.
Part 4: Sustainability
Nissan Case Study: Final Analysis Page | 23
Nissan is currently fostering eight sustainability strategies. The three strategies of
environment, safety and philanthropy represent actions that they are uniquely positioned to
pursue as a leading auto maker. While helping to find solutions to issues involving automobiles
and contribute to the realization of a truly sustainable mobility society. Nissan aims to be an
engine for CSR activities across the entire corporate sector. Their other five strategies include
quality, value chain, employees, economic contribution and corporate governance and internal
control. In the appendix B you will see what Nissan is working on for sustainability practices.
As you can see from this figure all three portions of the triple bottom line are being integrated
into Nissan’s CSR. In a meeting held in February 2014 by the executive committee, Nissan is
closely linking CSR actions and business operations to pursue corporate management that
consistently aligns the twin goals of sustainable profit and growth for the company and
sustainable development for society. (Report, 2014)
ISO 14000 standards are another way that Nissan is working towards increases CSR. In
December 2006, Nissan set objectives to bolster its environmental management through Nissan
Green Program 2010, the company's mid-term environmental action plan. Having already
previously obtained the certification for its five production plants, Nissan Zama Operation
Center, Nissan Technical Center (NTC), Nissan Advanced Technology Center (NATC), Nissan
Research Center and its product/development processes, the company has now achieved a
consistent environmental management, as additional certification was obtained at its new Global
Headquarters, Honmoku Wharf, Customer Service Centers, Global Information System Center,
Sagamihara Parts Center, Nissan Education Center and Hokkaido Rikubetsu Proving Ground.
This integrated environmental management has also been applied to Nissan Forklift Corporation
and Automotive Energy Supply Corporation, which are affiliates or partner companies of Nissan.
Nissan Case Study: Final Analysis Page | 24
As a result, a combined workforce of over 30,000 people, is working on environmental activities
with a higher consciousness. (14001, 2011)
In particular, the Global Headquarters (opened in August 2009), has already obtained the
Comprehensive Assessment System for Built Environment Efficiency (CASBEE)'s highest
ranking (Class S) in October 2009, in addition to proactively promoting the efficient utilization
of natural energy. In January 2011 Nissan announced that it had received integrated ISO 14001
certification. This is an international standard for environmental management systems. Their
announcement proves that the Global Headquarters achieved the establishment of environmental
management in all domains-buildings, working processes and business activities in roughly just
one year. (14001, 2011)
Nissan will continue activities to strengthen its environmental management, as well as
providing models to the market with high environmental performance, "Zero Emission" with its
focus on 100% electric vehicles and "PURE DRIVE" that are designed to achieve class-leading
fuel economy with next-generation eco-technologies. (14001, 2011) The usage of the ISO 14001
proves that Nissan is utilizing all methods possible to integrate CSR into their daily production
as well as limiting waste which could affect the environment as well as social stature.
There are many ways in which Nissan Motors Company can incorporate CSR principles
into their Operations. By utilizing methods such as JIT, TPS and Lean operations Nissan is
cutting down on more than just waste. By using the JIT method, the company is cutting down on
storage space needed as well as cutting down on fuel costs to transport supplies and parts from
location to location. By cutting down on storage space it helps the environment due to that fact
that there will be enough empty buildings that another supplier or manufacturer can occupy so
Nissan Case Study: Final Analysis Page | 25
therefore there will be less land clearing for the use of a new building. Of all of the methods that
have been discussed thus far I would have to say that the JIT method would be the easiest
method for Nissan to integrate into their corporate responsibility strategies. With the utilization
of the JIT partnerships suppliers and vendors can work together with open communication and a
goal of removing waste and drive down costs. (Render, 2014) Such activities will only
strengthen the CSR of Nissan and their sister companies.
In conclusion, Nissan has done a tremendous job utilizing all of the functionalities if the
values and theories and technologies in their day to day business activities. By utilizing these
functions of operational management they are setting themselves up for the future. All of the
theories and techniques that were mentioned in this analysis are tools that any company can
utilize. Just always remember there can be drawbacks for every one so be careful about
implementing too many processes at once. From the looks of all of the data and information that
were mentioned I feel that Nissan Motor Company is headed in the right direction. With these
processes and procedures that they have at their disposal they are setting themselves up nicely to
trek on into future endeavors.
Nissan Case Study: Final Analysis Page | 26
Appendix A:
Figure 1: Cause and effect chart for Nissan Production and Transportation costs
Political Risk Transportation Costs
Labor Productivity
Rental Costs Labor Costs Taxes
Trade Embargos
Rising Fuel Costs
Export/Import Fees
Usage of Transport Ship
Low Morale
Shipment Deadlines
Hour Reductions
Storage Fees
Import/Export Taxes
Overtime Due to Deadlines
Bring in extra employees to make deadlines
Nissan Case Study: Final Analysis Page | 28
14001, I. (2011, January - March). Nissan obtains integrated ISO 14001 Certification for all amin facilities in Japan. Retrieved from Nissan Motor Corporation: http://www.nissan-global.com/EN/NEWS/2011/_STORY/110120-02-e.html
Constraints, T. o. (N.D.). Theory of Constraints. Retrieved 04 04, 2015, from Lean Production.com: http://www.leanproduction.com/theory-of-constraints.html
Forecasting. (N.D.). The basic steps in a forecasting task. Retrieved 03 21, 2015, from Otexts: https://www.otexts.org/fpp/1/6
Kokemuller, N. (N.D.). Advantages & Disadvantages of Just-in Time Inventory. Retrieved 04 11, 2015, from Chron: http://smallbusiness.chron.com/advantages-disadvantages-justintime-inventory-21407.html
Kyratzoglou, I. (2013, 10 03). Making the right decisions to strengthen operations performance. Retrieved 03 19, 2015, from MIT system design and management: https://sdm.mit.edu/news/news_articles/kyratzoglou-supply-chain-risk-management/kyratzoglou-supply-chain-risk-management.html
Line, T. B. (2009, 11 17). Triple Bottom Line. Retrieved 04 09, 2015, from The Economist: http://www.economist.com/node/14301663
Manufacturing, N. M. (N.D.). Case study of Nissan Motor Manufacturing UK Limited. Retrieved from UKessays: http://www.ukessays.com/essays/business/case-study-of-nissan-motor-manufacturing-uk-limited-business-essay.php
Render, J. H. (2014). Operations Management (11th ed.). (D. Battista, Ed.) Pearson Education, Inc.
Report, S. (2014). Nissan Motor Corporation Sustainability Report 2014. Retrieved 04 11, 2015, from Nissan Motor Corporation: http://www.nissan-global.com/EN/DOCUMENT/PDF/SR/2014/SR14_E_P005.pdf
Rouse, M. (N.D.). ABC Classification systems. Retrieved from TechTarget: http://searchmanufacturingerp.techtarget.com/definition/ABC-classification
Shpak, S. (N.D.). Advantages & disadvantages of Lean Production. Retrieved 04 11, 2015, from Chron: http://smallbusiness.chron.com/advantages-amp-disadvantages-lean-production-46696.html
Strategies. (N.D.). Blue Citizenship: NIssan's CSR. Retrieved from Nissan Motor Corporation: http://www.nissan-global.com/EN/CSR/STRATEGY/
SWOT. (N.D.). SWOT analysis of Nissan. Retrieved 03 19, 2015, from Strategic Management Insight: http://www.strategicmanagementinsight.com/swot-analyses/nissan-swot-analysis.html
Tools, T. (N.D.). Total Quality Management Tools. Retrieved 04 04, 2015, from Total Quality Management: http://totalqualitymanagement.weebly.com/tqm-tools.html
TPS. (N.D.). Adavantages & disadvantages of Toyota Information Systems. Retrieved 04 11, 2015, from Toyota: http://toyotaprojectteam.blogspot.com/p/advantages-disadvantages-of-toyota.html
Nissan Case Study: Final Analysis Page | 29
William Schmidt, D. S.-L. (2013). Nissan Motor Company Ltd.: Building Operational Resiliency. MIT Sloan Management. Retrieved 03 14, 2015, from https://mitsloan.mit.edu/LearningEdge/CaseDocs/13-149%20Nissan.Simchi-Levi.pdf