capital flows, competitiveness and economic growth in latvia
DESCRIPTION
Presentation by Karsten Staehr (Tallinn University of Technology) at Country workshop: "EU Balance-of-Payments assistance for Latvia: Foundations of Success" organized by the European Commission, Directorate General for Economic and Financial Affairs, and the Bank of Latvia. Brussels, March 1, 2012TRANSCRIPT
12ttu/12Latvia-show1a_EC.ppt 1
Latvia Country Seminar ‘EU balance-of-payments assistance for Latvia: Foundations of success’
European Commission, Brussels, 1 March 2012
Capital Flows, Competitivenessand Economic Growth in Latvia
Karsten StaehrTallinn University of Technology
All viewpoints personal!
12ttu/12Latvia-show1a_EC.ppt 2
12ttu/12Latvia-show1a_EC.ppt 3
Next 14½
minutes 1)
Economic growth in Latvia
2)
Capital flows and economic growth 3)
Panel data estimations
4)
Contributions to economic growth in Latvia 5)
Some policy conclusions
12ttu/12Latvia-show1a_EC.ppt 4
1) Economic growth in Latvia A roller coaster– From ‘Baltic Tiger’– … to basket case– … to ?
Parallel to other Baltic States – and several other CEE countries– But volatility in Baltics extreme
12ttu/12Latvia-show1a_EC.ppt 5
-20
-15
-10
-5
0
5
10
15
96 97 98 99 00 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10 11*-20
-15
-10
-5
0
5
10
15
Figure 1: GDP growth in Latvia and the Czech Republic, %, annual data 1996-2011*
Latvia
Czech Republic
12ttu/12Latvia-show1a_EC.ppt 6
-20
-15
-10
-5
0
5
10
15
-25 -20 -15 -10 -5 0 5 10Current account balance, percent of GDP
Econ
omic
gro
wth
, per
cent
per
yea
r
-20
-15
-10
-5
0
5
10
15
Figure 2: Current account balance and economic growth, Latvia, annual data 1995-2011*
12ttu/12Latvia-show1a_EC.ppt 7
-20
-15
-10
-5
0
5
10
15
-25 -20 -15 -10 -5 0 5 10Current account balance, percent of GDP
Econ
omic
gro
wth
, per
cent
per
yea
r
-20
-15
-10
-5
0
5
10
15
Figure 3: Current account balance and economic growth, CEE countries, annual data 1995-2011*
12ttu/12Latvia-show1a_EC.ppt 8
6
8
10
12
14
0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10Current account balance, percent of GDP
Econ
omic
gro
wth
, per
cent
per
yea
r
6
8
10
12
14
Figure 4: Current account balance and economic growth, China, annual data 1995-2011
12ttu/12Latvia-show1a_EC.ppt 9
QuestionsHow does short-term economic growth depend on international capital flows (current account)?How much of changes in economic growth in Latvia can be explained by capital flows?
12ttu/12Latvia-show1a_EC.ppt 10
2) Capital flows and economic growth Capital inflow (current account deficit)
Access to extra resources from abroadPossibility to build up production capacity ⇒ production ↑ in longer term ‘Neo-classical growth model’Increase in demand in short term non-traded production ↑demand-driven economic boom– Relaxation of ‘balance of payments constraint’
Capital outflow (capital account surplus)‘Sudden stop’ demand-driven recession
12ttu/12Latvia-show1a_EC.ppt 11
3) Panel data estimationsUse statistics to ‘draw lines’
to find relationships
Data10 CEE countries 1995 to 2010
Explain year-to-year economic growth Explain by:
Current account balance (percent of GDP)Growth in unit labour cost relative to euro area (percent) Other variables (control variables) economic growth in Europe, crisis indicators, income level, etc.
12ttu/12Latvia-show1a_EC.ppt 12
Panel data estimationsFixed effects remove long-term, structural growth differences‘Instrumentation’ only effect from current account to growthMany robustness checks
ResultsCapital inflows (current account deficits) ⇒ contemporaneous growth ↑– Estimate depends on whether crisis is included or not– Current account balance ↓
10%-points ⇒ growth ↑
2-5%-points
Growth in relative unit labour cost ⇒ growth ↓– Lag of two years
(j-curve effect)
– Growth in unit labour cost ↑
10%-points ⇒ growth ↓
1-2%-points two years later
12ttu/12Latvia-show1a_EC.ppt 13
4) Contributions to economic growth in Latvia Simulate the contributions to changes in economic
growth in Latvia of:External capital flows (current account)International competitiveness (changes in relative unit labour cost)
12ttu/12Latvia-show1a_EC.ppt 14
Figure 5: Growth in relative unit labour cost, %; current account balance, % of GDP; economic growth, %; Latvia, 1996-2011*
-25
-20
-15
-10
-5
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
96 97 98 99 00 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10 11*-25
-20
-15
-10
-5
0
5
10
15
20
25
30Growth in relative unit labour costCurrent accout balanceEconomic growth
12ttu/12Latvia-show1a_EC.ppt 15
Contributions relative to baseline ‘normal’
values ‘Normal’ value of current account balance (external capital flows) = –4 percent of GDP‘Normal’ value of growth in relative unit labour cost (international competitiveness) = 3 percent
12ttu/12Latvia-show1a_EC.ppt 16
Figure 6: Simulation of contributions
to changes in economic growth; growth in relative unit labour cost and current account balance,
%-point
-10
-8
-6
-4
-2
0
2
4
6
8
10
98 99 00 01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10 11*-10
-8
-6
-4
-2
0
2
4
6
8
10
Current account balanceGrowth in relative unit labour costs (2 years before)Total
Early EU boom
Late EU boom
‘Double whammy’
Renewed competitiveness
12ttu/12Latvia-show1a_EC.ppt 17
ConclusionsA large part of changes in Latvian economic growth, can be explained by changes in international capital flowsGrowth driven by demand from capital inflows ‘mistaken’ for long-term growth, hiding other weaknesses– EU membership as confidence shock two phases
2004-05 external capital ↑ and competitiveness ↑☺2006-07 external capital ↑↑ and competitiveness ↓☺☺
Sudden stops in capital inflow– 2009-10 external capital ↓↓ and competitiveness ↓
12ttu/12Latvia-show1a_EC.ppt 18
5) Some policy conclusionsEconomic growth in Latvia
Wild roller-coaster ride External capital flows of great importance… often ‘drowning’ other effects, including competitiveness Effects after EU membership quite predictable – As other emerging-market economies after ‘confidence
shock’
Latin American ‘boom-recession cycle’
Upshot‘Neo-classical model of growth’ relying on capital import
handle with care!
12ttu/12Latvia-show1a_EC.ppt 19
Latvian governmentsLittle appetite for contractionary policies during boom – Capital flows and credit expansion– Supplementary budgets to make sure budget never in
surplus…
EU / European CommissionBefore entry prepare countries better on effects of European integration – Free capital flows + “confidence shock”
[Baltics, Slovenia]
– Migration
12ttu/12Latvia-show1a_EC.ppt 20
Improve welfare through counter-cyclical policiesCapital controls (e.g. Israel) not possible due to Internal Market Credit volumes – Affect supply capital requirements, reserve ratios,
‘coordination’, consumer protection regulation, etc.– Affect demand stamp duties, down payment rules, loan-
length requirements, credit card limits, tax deduction, ‘financial education’, etc.
Fiscal policy – Traditional counter-cyclical policy– ‘Forced saving’, release of private pension funds, taxes on
consumption typically financed by borrowing (cars, boats, travel, summer houses)
– Accumulation of reserves cf. China and Estonia ☺
12ttu/12Latvia-show1a_EC.ppt 21
Creating sustainable
long-term growthInfrastructure roads, public transportation in citiesEducation tertiary level (‘clear convergence goals’)‘Inclusive society’ activation of marginalised groups (discouraged, disabled, addicts, elderly)Make it pay for low income earners to participate in registered economy redistribute tax burdenReduce licensing requirements, red tape Serious fight against tax evasion Combat influence peddling, corruption
12ttu/12Latvia-show1a_EC.ppt 22
Overall conclusionInternational capital flows as fire – Warms nice, can get you burned
Latvia was careless during the EU boom Latvian bail-out ☺ illiquidity crisis Renewed competitiveness after ‘internal devaluation’breathing spaceTime for structural reforms to lay foundation for sustainable long-term growth – … and reduce reliance on fickle international capital flows