braskem’s project and portfolio management contini, tiagos3.amazonaws.com/zanran_storage/ · in...
TRANSCRIPT
Braskem’s Project and Portfolio Management
Contini, Tiago
Speaker Bio
Tiago is Telecom Engineer and Certified Associate
in Project Management (CAPM) with over 5 years of
experience in IT Project Management and 4 years
of experience in PMO
In his current role as PMO Member at Braskem,
Tiago is responsible for CA Clarity™ PPM
administration and for the Process of Portfolio
Management
Before joining Braskem, Tiago worked several
years, managing IT support teams
Summary
About Braskem
Scenario before CA Clarity PPM
Braskem’s processes and requirements
Idea Management Processes
Project Management Processes
Portfolio Management Process
Scenario with CA Clarity PPM
Brazilian Petrochemical Company
3rd generationExtraction 1st generation 2nd generation1st generation 2nd generationExtraction 3rd generation
Competitive Integration
Added Value
Competitiveness
#1 Petrochemical company of Latin
America
MarketLeadership
Scale Integration
Cost Competitiveness
Know-How
Technological Autonomy
Naphtha
Condensate
Thermoplastic Resins Plastic ConvertersRaw Materials Basic Petrochemicals
18 Industrial Units
São Paulo
PVCSpecialties
Alagoas
Chlorine / Soda PVC
Triunfo
Bahia
HDPE / LLDPE HDPE/UHMWPE
Chlorine/Soda
PVCBasic Products
HDPEHDPE
PolypropylenesBasic Products
LLDPELDPE
LDPE / EVA
LDPE / EVA
Polypropylenes
HDPE/LDPE/LLDPE
Polypropylenes
Economic – Financial Performance
Source: Braskem
Gross Revenue
R$ 23,0 bi
Net Revenue
R$ 18,0 bi
EBITDA
R$ 2,4 bi
Exports
US$ 2,2 bi
Innovation and Technology
R$ 70 million in innovation projects in 2008
Over US$ 330 million in assets
169 researchers
219 patents filled
8 pilot plants
17% of the revenue obtained in 2008 by resin sales is due to products launched in the market in the last 3 years.
1st company in the world to certify a 100% renewable polymer
Innovation and TechnologyGreen Polymers
POLYPROPYLENEPOLYETHYLENE
Awards
High Level of Corporate Governance
Level 1 of Corporate Governance at BOVESPA
100% tag-along for shareholders
Compliance with SOX
Code of Practice: Establishes values, principles and practices that regulate the company’s actions
Ethics Committee
Internal Audit
Pre-established corporate policiesNegotiation of estate valuesFinancial ManagementInsurance and GuaranteesHealth, Safety and EnvironmentSocial Responsibility
CommitteesFiscal CouncilFinances & InvestmentPeople & OrganizationStrategy & Communication
Incentive Plan, allowing to align interests with value generation
Four independent members in the Council
Information system for the Administration Council and the Fiscal Council
New ProjectsGreen Polyethylene
Ethylene-alcohol: Commitment to Sustainability
Construction start / Cornerstone: April 2009Pilot Plant Production: ~ 12 mt/yearOperation start: 2011Investment: R$ 488 millionPlant of ethylene from 200 Kt ethanolEstimated demand: ~ 500 KtEthanol consumption: 460 million litersTarget markets: United States, Europe and JapanIndustries: Auto parts and consumables
100% renewableraw material:
Sugar cane ethanol
Partnerships withnational and multinational
Food, auto parts and cosmetic sectors
1,200 kton PEVenezuela
300 kton PPCamaçari450 kton PP
Venezuela
350 kton PPPaulínia
200 kton PVCAlagoas
200 kton Green PERS
130 kton Special SolventsCamaçari
Camaçari30 kton HC Resinas
Source: Braskem
Projects in evaluation:
• Peru – PE/ Ethylene cracker
• Bolivia – PE/ Ethylene cracker
• Brazil – PE- PP/ Heavy oil cracker
GrowthInvestments
Braskem
Vision: evidence in the global scenario:Presence among top 10
2012
2002
20062007
2005 2008
Source: Braskem
Trikem
PolialdenPoliteno
Ipiranga /Copesul
Paulínia
Become leader inthermoplastic resins
in Latin America
Be among the top 10petrochemical companies
in the world inmarket value
Revision of2012 Strategy
Revision of2020 Strategy
2009
Petrochemical Triunfo
Sumary
About Braskem
Scenario before CA Clarity PPM
Braskem’s processes and requirements
Idea Management Processes
Project Management Processes
Portfolio Management Process
Scenario with CA Clarity PPM
Scenario before CA Clarity PPM
Well defined processes: ideas, project and portfolio management;
40 portfolio evaluation variables;
Excel basis tool;
The Challenge
Find a software that meets all Braskem’s requirements and needs.
Five small portfolios (by business unity) and one big portfolio (all Braskem);
To much time from portfolio inventory to portfolio approval;
Decentralized Management over all the portfolio process (inventory, approval and
following);
Low control over Project Management (cost, time, scope changes, etc.);
Summary
About Braskem
Scenario before CA Clarity PPM
Braskem’s processes and requirements
Idea Management Processes
Project Management Processes
Portfolio Management Process
Scenario with CA Clarity PPM
Braskem’s Processes and Requirements
ProjectManagement
FEL 1Business
Assessment
FEL 2Conceptual Engineering
FEL 3Basic
Engineering
ExecutionDetailed Construction
Engineering
OperationPerformance Evaluation
EA
DR1
EA
DR2 DR3
ExA
DR4 DR5
Engineering Approval Capital Approval
Braskem´sRequirements
• Support all Processes (workflow approbations);• Centralized Management to all Processes;• Centralized and secure Data Base;• Easy to use;• Information on demand (correct and fast);
• Graphical Analysis;• Multi-user operability and Web based application;• All world support;• Over 600 projects a year (over MMU$ 670);• According to PMI Process;
PortfolioManagement
InventoryCategorization
Small (BU)Portfolio
Evaluation and
Balancing
Braskem’s Portfolio
Evaluation and
Balancing
Braskem’s Portfolio
Authorization
Braskem’s Portfolio
Reevaluation
IdeaManagement
InventoryIndividual
Approval
Ideas
Portfolio
Approval
Project Management
Sumary
About Braskem
Scenario before CA Clarity PPM
Braskem’s processes and requirements
Idea Management Processes
Project Management Processes
Portfolio Management Process
Scenario with CA Clarity PPM
Idea Score
Inventory
CA Clarity PPMIdea Portfolio Management
Individual Approval
(Workflow at Clarity)
Idea Portfolio Approval
(Graphical Analysis)
CA Clarity PPMIdea Portfolio Management
ProjectManagement
CA Clarity PPMProject Management - Centralized Data Base
Project Charter
Project Name;
Project Number;
Project Scope;
Project Objectives;
Project Category;
Project Start and End Date;
Braskem Project Unit;
Project Manager;
CA Clarity PPMProject Management – Project Life Cycle
All phases (FEL1, FEL2, FEL3, EXECUTION, OPERATION) and gates (DR1, DR2, DR3, DR4, DR5)
using Clarity action items and Workflow.
CA Clarity PPMProject Management – Engineering Approval
Electronic Approval using Clarity forms, action items and workflows.
CA Clarity PPMProject Management – Document Management
CA Clarity PPMProject Management – Project Team
CA Clarity PPMProject Management – Scope Changes Control
Registry
Change Aprovation
(Clarity Workflow)
CA Clarity PPMProject Management – Capital Approval
Electronic Approval using Clarity forms, action items and workflows.
CA Clarity PPMProject Management – Time Management
CA Clarity PPMProject Management – Cost Management
CA Clarity PPMProject Management – Cost Management
Budgeting and forecasting by WBS
Responsabilities
BU CorporativeAreas
Project Categorization
Small PortfolioAnalysis
Braskem’sPortfolioAnalysis
Braskem’sportfolioapproval
ProcessReview
Project SponsorProject
Identification
BU Portfolio Manager Validatinginformation
PortfolioAnalysis
Business UnitsComitee
PortfolioApproval
PMOProcess
Revision (ifnecessary)
Braskem’s PortfolioAnalysisBU support
PMO PortfolioManagement Business Unit Support
ExComiteeStrategicPlanningDefinition
Braskem’s PortfolioApproval
Definition of Budget Restrictions
Portfólio Day
PMO Follow-UP
PortfolioBalancing
Process Steps
Portfolio Management Process Overview
Bucket 1 - Projects which primary motivation is to increase profitability or competitiveness of Braskem.
Increase Profitability / Competitiveness
Risk Mitigation /Operational
Continuity
Infrastructure and Support
Strategics
Special
Bucket 2 - Projects which main motivation is to reduce risk and operational
continuity.
Bucket 3 - Projects which main motivation is infra-structure
Bucket 4 - Projects to create new levels of cash flow.
Bucket 5 - Investment needed to develop basic engineering.
Braskem Methodology has five types of Buckets to evaluate different as well:
Portfolio ManagementBuckets
Portfolio ManagementCharacterization
The systematic prioritization has two main elements:
Buckets - Grouped projects with similar characteristics;
Dimensions – Forms the basis of comparison between projects;
Description Motivation Content
Elements of comparison
projects
Allow investments to be compared in many aspects
Criteria and parametersDimensions
Sets of comparable projects Difficulty of comparing ProjectBuckets
Portfolio ManagementScoring
Dimensions
Project Basic Information
Project Brief Description
Project Team
Timing
Strategic Leverage Score
Keep?
Market Attractiveness
Marketing Feasibility
Technology Attractiveness
Technical Feasibility
Financial
Dimensions Keep?
Balance
…
…
…
…
…
Are there any dimensions,other than what was in theportfolio tool, that should
be considered?
List of Dimensions
…
Project Basic Information
…
…
…
…
…
N/AProject Status
N/AProject Stage
N/AProgram Type
N/AProcess
N/AProject Name
ImportanceRisk?Criteria: Project Basic Information
N/AProject Status
N/AProject Stage
N/AProgram Type
N/AProcess
N/AProject Name
ImportanceRisk?Criteria: Project Basic Information
Is the criteria used in theStrategic Portfolio Management
tool relevant and calibrated?
Risk Importance RangeYes No Low (L), Medium (M), High (H)
Strategic Leverage Score Parameters
1. Congruence
3. Proprietary Position
4. Durability
5. Synergy with other operations within the corporation
2. Impact
Only peripheral fit with business
strategies
Modest fit, but not with a key element
of strategy
Good fit with key elements of
strategy
Strong fit with several key elements of
strategy
Easily copied Protected, but not a deterrent
Solidly protected with trade secrets, patents, serves
captive customers
Position protected through a
combination of patents, trade secrets, raw
materials access and so on
No distinctive advantage, quickly
“leap-frogged”May get a good few
years Moderate life cycle Long life cycle
Limited to single application
Could be applied to another application
Could be adopted or have impact among several
areas
Could be applied outside the BU
Minimal harm, no noticeable impact if program dropped
Moderate competitive and financial impact
Significant impact, difficult to recover if
program is unsuccessful or
dropped
Business unit future depends on this
program
Crit
eria
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
?
XX%
XX%
XX%
XX%
XX%
Weight
Dimensions
Criterial
Parameters
Portfolio ManagementParameter Evaluation
Alinhamento EstratégicoStrategic
AlignmentVerificar a aderência do projeto a estratégia corporativa da Braskem, considerando elementos como alinhamento às diretrizes estratégicas, desenvolvimento de competências, sinergias internas e externas, e impacto positivo geral
Verificar a aderência do projeto a estratégia corporativa da Braskem, considerando elementos como alinhamento às diretrizes estratégicas, desenvolvimento de competências, sinergias internas e externas, e impacto positivo geral
20%Desenvolvimento de Competências Diferenciadoras
20%Sinergias
20%
Impacto Geral (meio-ambiente, segurança, imagem da Braskem,
responsabilidade social)
40%
Alinhamento com as Diretrizes da
Estratégiaa- Excelência operacionalb- Matéria-prima competitivac- Aumento de rentabilidade em mercados em que já atuamosd- Desenvolvimento de novos mercados
ParâmetrosParâmetrosPesoPesoCritérioCritério
20%Desenvolvimento de Competências Diferenciadoras
20%Sinergias
20%
Impacto Geral (meio-ambiente, segurança, imagem da Braskem,
responsabilidade social)
40%
Alinhamento com as Diretrizes da
Estratégiaa- Excelência operacionalb- Matéria-prima competitivac- Aumento de rentabilidade em mercados em que já atuamosd- Desenvolvimento de novos mercados
ParâmetrosParâmetrosPesoPesoCritérioCritério
Não traz competência diferenciadora
Possui forte alinhamento com diretrizes estratégicas da Braskem
Possui alinhamento com diretrizes estratégicas da Braskem
Possui alinhamento indireto às diretrizes estratégicas da Braskem
Traz nova competência diferenciadora
Fortalece suas competências diferenciadoras atuais / traz nova competência que competidores já possuem
Traz ganhos de sinergias internas e externas
Traz ganhos de sinergias externas (fornecedores, competidores, clientes)
Traz ganhos de sinergias internas (entre UNs)
Não traz ganhos de sinergia
0 50 100
0 60 100
30 55 100
Traz perdas
100
Causa impactos positivos
Não causa impacto positivo
Provoca perdas Causa grandes impactos positivos
0 20 60 100
• Bucket selection by project Sponsor:
Portfolio ManagementBucket Selection
Complexity
Strategic Alignment
Context
Attractiveness
Tecnichal Attractiveness
Quantitative Benefits
CA Clarity PPMPortfolio Management - Project Characterization
Dimensions
CA Clarity PPMPortfolio Management - Project Characterization
Criterial
Strategic Alignment
Parameters
CA Clarity PPMPortfolio Management - Scorecard
Ex: Best Choice(Score x Budget)
CA Clarity PPMPortfolio ManagementEvaluation Tool - Efficient Frontier
CA Clarity PPMPortfolio ManagementEvaluation Tool – Graphical Analysis
Bucket 1 - Bubble GraphNPV x Strategic Alignment x Cost x Risk
NP
V
Strategic Alignment
CA Clarity PPMProject and Portfolio ManagementDashboard
Actual Scenario
Be among the top 10petrochemical companies
in the world inmarket value
Since Jan/2006;
All Braskem's Processes (Idea, Project and Portfolio) running in Clarity;
Over 600 users;
Over 7000 projects (700 actives);
More than 18 Industrial Units over 4 different states;
One Click information for all management levels;
VP approbation level;
Centralized data base and information;
Centralized Portfolio Management (PMO at Camaçari, Bahia);
All World support;
Fast portfolio scenarios;
Questions?
Please complete a session evaluation form
• The number for this session is PP409SN• After completing your session evaluation form,
place it in the basket at the back of the room
44 May 16-20, 2010 Copyright © 2010 CA. All rights reserved.