automatic forecast verification in wsfs juha markkula, bertel vehviläinen syke 12.11.2015

21
Automatic Forecast Verification in WSFS Juha Markkula, Bertel Vehviläinen SYKE 27.06.22

Upload: gillian-floyd

Post on 04-Jan-2016

215 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Automatic Forecast Verification in WSFS Juha Markkula, Bertel Vehviläinen SYKE 12.11.2015

Automatic Forecast Verification in WSFS

Juha Markkula, Bertel Vehviläinen

SYKE

20.04.23

Page 2: Automatic Forecast Verification in WSFS Juha Markkula, Bertel Vehviläinen SYKE 12.11.2015

Automatic Forecast Verification in WSFSWatershed Simulation and Forecasting

System (WSFS) has a separate subsystem to automatically calculate verification graphs and scores for operational forecasts.

This subsystem is called Forecast Accuracy Follow-up System (FAFS)

Page 3: Automatic Forecast Verification in WSFS Juha Markkula, Bertel Vehviläinen SYKE 12.11.2015

Forecast Accuracy Follow-up System (FAFS) Verification is based on released operational

forecasts, not on hindcasting FAFS has a web interface where

hydrologists can go back to previous incidents and see how the forecasts succeeded.

Page 4: Automatic Forecast Verification in WSFS Juha Markkula, Bertel Vehviläinen SYKE 12.11.2015

FAFS web interface

Lake inflowRiver peak flowAnd less important ones

• Groundwater level• Lake inflow in test model based on monthly/seasonal

weather forecast• Short meteorological temperature forecast

Page 5: Automatic Forecast Verification in WSFS Juha Markkula, Bertel Vehviläinen SYKE 12.11.2015

Lake inflow

Page 6: Automatic Forecast Verification in WSFS Juha Markkula, Bertel Vehviläinen SYKE 12.11.2015

Lake inflow

Page 7: Automatic Forecast Verification in WSFS Juha Markkula, Bertel Vehviläinen SYKE 12.11.2015

Lake inflow

Page 8: Automatic Forecast Verification in WSFS Juha Markkula, Bertel Vehviläinen SYKE 12.11.2015

Lake inflow

Page 9: Automatic Forecast Verification in WSFS Juha Markkula, Bertel Vehviläinen SYKE 12.11.2015

Lake inflow

Page 10: Automatic Forecast Verification in WSFS Juha Markkula, Bertel Vehviläinen SYKE 12.11.2015

Lake inflow

Page 11: Automatic Forecast Verification in WSFS Juha Markkula, Bertel Vehviläinen SYKE 12.11.2015

Lake inflowMost important forecast verification criteria

Mean absolute error:

Relative error:Mean absolute error divided by range of observations

Nash – Sutcliffe:

Page 12: Automatic Forecast Verification in WSFS Juha Markkula, Bertel Vehviläinen SYKE 12.11.2015

River peak flow

Page 13: Automatic Forecast Verification in WSFS Juha Markkula, Bertel Vehviläinen SYKE 12.11.2015

River peak flow

Page 14: Automatic Forecast Verification in WSFS Juha Markkula, Bertel Vehviläinen SYKE 12.11.2015

River peak flow

Page 15: Automatic Forecast Verification in WSFS Juha Markkula, Bertel Vehviläinen SYKE 12.11.2015

River peak flow

Page 16: Automatic Forecast Verification in WSFS Juha Markkula, Bertel Vehviläinen SYKE 12.11.2015

River peak flow

Page 17: Automatic Forecast Verification in WSFS Juha Markkula, Bertel Vehviläinen SYKE 12.11.2015

River peak flow

Page 18: Automatic Forecast Verification in WSFS Juha Markkula, Bertel Vehviläinen SYKE 12.11.2015

River peak flow

Page 19: Automatic Forecast Verification in WSFS Juha Markkula, Bertel Vehviläinen SYKE 12.11.2015

River peak flowDischarge forecast: 7 day lead time,intended to display peak timing error.

Page 20: Automatic Forecast Verification in WSFS Juha Markkula, Bertel Vehviläinen SYKE 12.11.2015

River peak flowDischarge forecast: 7 day maximum discharge,intended to display error in peak discharge.

Page 21: Automatic Forecast Verification in WSFS Juha Markkula, Bertel Vehviläinen SYKE 12.11.2015

River peak flow

Most important forecast verification criteria

Peak timing error:Mean absolute error in peak timing.

Peak discharge error:Mean absolute error in maximum discharge.