antti zhang greg bruno presented 4-7-2011. oligopoly the general economy drives the sales, out of...

29
Antti Zhang Greg Bruno Presented 4-7-2011

Upload: shauna-porter

Post on 25-Dec-2015

219 views

Category:

Documents


2 download

TRANSCRIPT

Antti ZhangGreg BrunoPresented 4-7-2011

Oligopoly The general economy drives the sales, out

of company’s control High Fixed COGS Consumer Discretionary: Cyclical Industry Qualities of a Good Company:

◦ Follow the market shift◦ Control Fix cost◦ Steal the market

Market Shift◦ Shift from Truck to Cars◦ Shift from Large to Small◦ Shift from US, Europe to Asia and South America◦ Gas to Hybrid

Over capacity◦ Over capacity 21M in 5 years ◦ US: 96%, Europe 37%

Source: CSMauto.com

Threat to New Entry (Very Low)◦ Require large amount of investment◦ Brand Effect◦ Economic of scale

Threat of Substitute (Low)◦ Mass Transit Service◦ Car Sharing

Competitive Rivalry (High)◦ Some level of product differential◦ Relative easy to switch

The Bargaining power of Supplies (Very Low)◦ Many companies in this industry have their own

factory to produce the components for assembling◦ The raw material is 2nd tier commoditized (Steel,

Tires, Glass, etc)

The Bargaining power of Customers (High)◦ Lots of similar car to choose (GMC vs F150)◦ Not a kind of necessarily goods

Ford is struggling to retain dominance◦ Consumer preferences shifting due to fuel prices◦ High legacy (employee) costs◦ Entrenched management

Bonds downgraded to Junk (2005)◦ Eroding market share◦ Declining margins◦ Reliance on financing for profit

Ford announces restructuring plan in 2006◦ Titled “The Way Forward”

Main Focus◦ Reduce fixed capital costs◦ Special focus on cars & crossover vehicles◦ Profitability across product lines

Reducing Fixed costs◦ Multiple Divestitures◦ Planned closings of 14 plants, 7 which make cars

Reduced Ford’s capacity by 26% by 2008 Eliminates up to 30,000 factory jobs by 2012

Focus on cars & crossover◦ New Product offering of high mileage cars

B-Class subcompact auto platform Crossover vehicles built on Fusion platform Return of the Taurus!

Profitability across product lines◦ Global Product Development system

Reduces cycle times to compete w/ Japanese New vehicle R&D costs reduced by 60% (2005-2008)

Source: Ford 2005 Annual report

Ford (wholly owned)◦ Flagship brand

Lincoln (wholly owned)◦ Luxury Brand; focus of revitalization

Mazda (minority stake)◦ Current ownership of 3.5% stake in Mazda◦ Reduction from 33.4% stake as of 2008

Aston Martin (minority stake)◦ Sold in 2007 at a $925 MM valuation with Ford retaining a $77 MM (8.3%) investment

Jaguar & Land Rover (no stake)◦ Sold to Indian company Tata motors in 2008 for $2.3 Billion (about half of purchase price)

Volvo (no stake)◦ Sold to Geely Auto in 2010 for $1.8 Billion

Mercury (no stake)◦ Discontinued in late 2010

Chairman Bill Ford◦ Commissioned the writing of a restructuring plan◦ Steps down as President and CEO

Alan Mulally◦ Former VP of Boeing and CEO of Boeing

Commercial◦ Engineer credited with BCAs revival in early 2000’s◦ Mortgaged company in 2006 for $23.6 Billion◦ Successful negotiations with UAW

Reduced Labor cost per hour by ~ 28%

“Alan was the right choice, and it gets more right every day.”-William Clay Ford, Chairman

http://cache.gawkerassets.com/assets/images/12/2009/12/alan_mulally_ford.jpg

Source: Capital IQ

Ford Toyota GM Honda Nissan

Revenue Growth (LTM)

10.9% 14.1% 29.6% 11.4% 20.0%

EBITDA Margin

11.2% 9.0% 9.2% 10.9% 13.5%

EBITDA Margin Growth (LTM)

170.0% 120.1% N/A 118.8% 152.3%

Total Debt / EBITDA

7.2x 6.9x 0.9x 4.1x 3.3x

ROA 3.1% 1.1% 2.6% 3.4% 3.3%

First positive value since 2005Source: Capital IQ

Ford Toyota GM Honda Nissan

P/E 9.49x 20.69 11.37 9.33 10.67

TEV / EBITDA

9.57x 9.79 3.44 7.29 5.36

Mkt Cap / Revenue

0.46x 0.52 0.38 0.58 0.35

P/E TEV/EBITDA P/S

Max 20.69 9.79 0.58

Mean 13.01 6.47 0.46

Min 9.33 3.44 0.35

Source: Capital IQ

Total Liabilities / Total Assets = 100.6%

Quick Ratio = 1.5x◦ (Cash + Receivables + Securities) / Current

Liabilities

EBIT / Interest Expense = 4.9x

Source: Capital IQ

Breakdown of Debt

Source: Ford 10k

Debt Repayment Schedule

Source: Ford 10k

Potential Market Movers◦ Return to Investment grade debt status◦ Resumption of dividend

Increasing Nationalism◦ Ford is linked to national psyche◦ Highest brand loyalty in the United States

No Bailout◦ Increases goodwill with investors & consumers◦ Proven (or lucky) financiers

Short-Term◦ Supply Chain disrupts production at two plants

Mustang, Super Duty F-Series, Expedition / Navigator Increased costs due to search for new suppliers

Long-Term◦ Provides opportunity to gain and hold market

share in the small car market◦ Loss of sales by competitors could force industry

capacity shrinkage Average car price increases, margins improve

2005 2006 2007 2008 2009US 17.5 17.1 16.5 13.5 10.6Europe 17.6 17.8 18.0 16.6 15.8South America

2.7 3.2 4.1 4.3 4.2

Asia 17.3 18.6 20.4 20.9 24.5

40. 00%

42. 00%

44. 00%

46. 00%

48. 00%

50. 00%

52. 00%

54. 00%

56. 00%

2005 2006 2007 2008 2009

CarTruck

Source: Ford’s 10K

Industry Sales Volume

US: 15.3% Europe: 10.4% South America: Approximately 15% Asia Pacific: 2%

◦ Emphasis of expansion efforts

Source: Ford’s 10K

Source: Ford’s 10K

0%10%20%30%40%50%60%70%80%90%

100%

2005 2006 2007 2008 2009

OthersNissanHondaToyotaChryslerGMFord

Source: Ford’s 10K, BNP CIB Report

0%10%20%30%40%50%60%70%80%90%

100%

2005 2006 2007 2008 2009

OthersNissanHondaToyotaChryslerGMFord

Source: Ford’s 10K, BNP CIB Report

3 Parts

1 Long Term Debt: YTM on current issued note

2 Short Term Debt: Revolving loan rate

3 Cost of Equity: CAPM using both raw beta and industry’s beta

Place order for 300 shares at $14.95◦ Limit, good through 5-3-2011