an evaluation of the utility of crowd sourcing in species biodiversity management

Upload: jonathan-mclatchie

Post on 04-Apr-2018

217 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

  • 7/31/2019 An Evaluation of the Utility of Crowd Sourcing in Species Biodiversity Management

    1/57

    Bfoazmao LcHazcmek

    1

    Ao K~ah{azefo fn zmk [zehezu fn Ctfyj Sf{tceoi eo Spkceks

    Defje~ktsezu Laoaiklkoz

    Bfoazmao LcHazcmek -D/Sc( L/Tks%

    Fczfdkt( 4014

  • 7/31/2019 An Evaluation of the Utility of Crowd Sourcing in Species Biodiversity Management

    2/57

    Bfoazmao LcHazcmek

    4

    Adsztacz

    Eo heimz fn itfyeoi zmtkazs zf spkceks je~ktsezu ntfl ca{sks s{cm as chelazk cmaoik aoj madezaz

    jkszt{czefo du m{laos( ez mas dkcflk eoctkaseoihu elpftzaoz zf ma~k tkajehu acckssedhk

    eonftlazefo fo spkceks je~ktsezu aoj defikfitapmecah jeszted{zefo/ Zmk Ihfdah Defje~ktsezuEonftlazefo Nacehezu -IDEN% es ao foheok jazadask fn eonftlazefo fo ihfdah spkceks jeszted{zefo(

    ptelatehu jkte~kj ntfl l{sk{l jaza cfhhkczefos/ Zmk aik fn jeiezah pmfzfitapmu mas dtf{imz

    yezm ez zmk adehezu zf ikf,zai elaik hfcazefos nft pmfzfitapms zagko fn yehjhenk/ Ctfyj sf{tceoi

    mas dkcflk a zfpecah ess{k eo tkckoz ukats( aoj mas dkko elphklkozkj s{cckssn{hhu eo fzmkt

    jescepheoks zf fdzaeo ~ah{adhk eonftlazefo -Kedko kz ah/( 40147 Tajjecgkz ah/( 4010%/ [seoi

    F~kthap( a cflp{zkt sctepz ytezzko nft zmk p{tpfsk fn jkzktleoeoi zmk jkitkk fn f~kthap

    dkzykko defje~ktsezu jaza cfozaeokj fo IDEN aoj Nhecgt( zmk ptkskoz papkt azzklpzs zf jkzktleok

    zmk pfzkozeah {zehezu fn foheok elaik smateoi nacehezeks s{cm as Nhecgt nft elptf~eoi f{t gofyhkjik

    fn defje~ktsezu aoj spkceks jeszted{zefos/ Zykozu fn zmk yfthjs lfsz kojaoiktkj spkceks atk

    skhkczkj nft aoahuses( aoj pfzkozeah jtaydacgs fn {seoi s{cm nacehezeks atk cfosejktkj/ Zf

    jkzktleok zmk k}zkoz zf ymecm zmk ptkskock fn aoelahs eo yehjhenk patgs aoj rffs es tkspfosedhk

    nft eocfoit{ezu dkzykko IDEN aoj Nhecgt( aoj zmk ptkskock fn aoelahs ykhh f{zsejk zmket oaz{tah

    madezazs( zmk aoahuses yas tkpkazkj nft khk~ko hkss eozktkszeoi ftiaoesls eoch{jeoi spkceks fn

    n{oie( eoskczs aoj ctads/ Zf k~ah{azk zmk pfzkozeah deas aiaeosz spkceks ymecm he~k eo {ojk~khfpkj

    tkiefos fn zmk yfthj -ymktk jeiezah pmfzfitapmu es hkss cfllfo%( a mkaz lap fn ikf,zaiieoi

    acze~ezu actfss zmk ihfdk yas ptfj{ckj/ Tks{hzs eojecazk zmk okkj nft lkas{tks zf helez zmk eop{z

    fn kttft aoj nft ejkozenueoi aoj cfttkczeoi kttfokf{s tkcftjs/

  • 7/31/2019 An Evaluation of the Utility of Crowd Sourcing in Species Biodiversity Management

    3/57

  • 7/31/2019 An Evaluation of the Utility of Crowd Sourcing in Species Biodiversity Management

    4/57

    Bfoazmao LcHazcmek

    :

    1/ Eoztfj{czefo

    Eo ftjkt nft kcfsuszkls zf laeozaeo zmk ptf~esefo fn s{szaeoadhk henk,s{ppftz skt~ecks -s{cm as

    acckss zf chkao yazkt( nffj skc{tezu( aoj tksehekock zf oaz{tah jesaszkts%( ez es elpftzaoz zmaz zmk

    spkceks spkcenec zf jennktkoz kcfsuszkls( aoj zmk ad{ojaock fn kacm spkceks( atk gofyo/ M{laoacze~ezu es ptkskozhu fok fn zmk ptelatu zmtkazs zf defje~ktsezu fo a ihfdah scahk/ Nft p{tpfsks fn

    kcfsuszkl lfoezfteoi aoj tesg assksslkoz( zmktk es zm{s a okkj nft jaza cfhhkczefo aoj ezs tkaju

    acckssedehezu eo a ihfdahhu,a~aehadhk aoj eozkitazkj eontaszt{cz{tk/ Zmes mas hkj zf a yejksptkaj

    knnftz zf kos{tk zmk jeiezesazefo fn l{sk{l aoj mktdate{l defje~ktsezu jaza -Smannkt kz ah( 155=%/

    1/1 Zmk Elpftzaock fn L{sk{l Cfhhkczefos

    L{sk{ls aoj acajklec eoszez{zefos atk mflk zf k}zkose~k cfhhkczefos fn defhfiecah salphks(

    fnzko spaooeoi ntfl ptkmeszftec zelks zf zmk ptkskoz jau/ S{cm jaza cfhhkczefo cfozted{zks zf

    scekozenec nekhjs s{cm as cfoskt~azefo defhfiu aoj suszklazecs( eo ajjezefo zf skc{teoi aitec{hz{tah

    aoj oaz{tah tksf{tcks/ Nft a za}foflec tk~esefo( zmk szaojatj ptaczeck nft laou phaoz aoj aoelah

    itf{ps es zf {zeherk l{sk{l spkcelkos ntfl zmk yfthjs oaz{tah meszftu cfhhkczefos/ Za}fofleszs

    tf{zeokhu tkcftj zmk jaza fo spkcelko hadkhs nft p{tpfsks fn ptfj{ceoi jeszted{zefo laps aoj

    hfcahezu heszs/

    Zmk okkj zf laeozaeo k}zkose~k cfhhkczefos mas tkckozhu dkcflk lftk {tikoz zmao k~kt dknftk(

    aoj l{sk{l salphk cfhhkczefos ma~k ptf~ejkj ct{ceah eonftlazefo( aoj eonftlkj ptkjeczefos

    adf{z zmk n{z{tk( tkhazeoi zf zmk elpacz fn madezaz hfss aoj ihfdah chelazk cmaoik fo spkceks

    defje~ktsezu/ Nft k}alphk( eo zmk lej,ykszkto [oezkj Szazks( salphks ntfl 1= jennktkoz l{sk{ls

    yktk {skj zf jklfosztazk zmaz zmk cfoskq{kock fn ptaetek madezaz hfss yas a jkcheok fn slahh

    lallahs zmaz jkpkoj fo zmes madezaz nft zmket s{t~e~ah -Pktials aoj Oudkti( 4001%/

    Zmk szftaik aoj laeozkoaock fn l{sk{l cfhhkczefos cfonkt kcfoflec dkoknezs eoasl{cm as zmku

    ptf~ejk ckoztaherkj aoj tkajehu acckssedhk eonftlazefo szftaik/

    Zmk laeozkoaock fn p{dhec mkahzm aoj sankzu es aofzmkt labft dkoknez fn s{cm defje~ktsezu jaza(

    lfsz ofzadhu eo zmfsk casks ymktk klktieoi pazmfiko sztaeos atk cflpatkj yezm salphks fn

    gofyo daczktea aoj ~et{sks/ L{sk{l jaza mas dkko {skj eo kh{cejazeoi pazmfiko jeszted{zefos

  • 7/31/2019 An Evaluation of the Utility of Crowd Sourcing in Species Biodiversity Management

    5/57

  • 7/31/2019 An Evaluation of the Utility of Crowd Sourcing in Species Biodiversity Management

    6/57

    Bfoazmao LcHazcmek

    >

    jeszeoi{esmeoi nkaz{tk heks az zmk koj fn zmk adjflko ymecm es ofz ahyaus chkathu ~esedhk( es ofz

    ahyaus pfssedhk/

    1/3 Ikf,zaiieoi

    Ikf,zaiieoi ahhfys ikfitapmecah ejkozenecazefo lkzajaza( {s{ahhu eo zmk nftl fn hazez{jk aoj

    hfoiez{jk cfftjeoazks( zf dk assfceazkj yezm a pmfzfitapm/ IPS eonftlazefo lau dk capz{tkj az

    zmk zelk fn zageoi zmk pmfzf( {seoi a jeiezah calkta( ft zmk hfcazefo eonftlazefo lau dk appkojkj

    zf zmk pecz{tk anzkt ez mas dkko zagko/

    1/: Zmk Ihfdah Defje~ktsezu Eonftlazefo Nacehezu -IDEN%

    Zmk Ihfdah Defje~ktsezu Eonftlazefo Nacehezu -IDEN% es ptkskozhu zmk hatiksz jaza pftzah nft

    eonftlazefo fo ihfdah spkceks defje~ktsezu/ Seock 400:( zmk eozktif~ktolkozah ftiaoesazefo IDEN

    mas fnnktkj tkaju acckss zf a cflptkmkose~k cflpehazefo fn eonftlazefo ntfl jazadasks fn

    l{sk{l cfhhkczefos aoj defhfiecah s{t~kus/ Zmket szazkj lessefo es zf ptf~ejk ao eozktokz

    acckssedhk( eozktfpktadhk okzyftg fn defje~ktsezu jazadasks aoj eonftlazefo zkcmofhfiu zffhs

    aoj zf lagk zmk yfthjs defje~ktsezu jaza ntkkhu aoj {oe~ktsahhu a~aehadhk ~ea zmk Eozktokz/

    C{ttkozhu( IDEN fdzaeos jaza ntfl 395 p{dhesmkts zmaz ptf~ejk lftk zmao 341 lehhefo tkcftjs

    -mzzp2&&yyy/iden/fti& accksskj 1:zm Lau 4014%/ Sflk fn zmk za}a tkpftzkj fo du IDEN kobfu a

    yejk cf~ktaik( ymktkas fzmkts atk lftk pffthu cf~ktkj ft atk cflphkzkhu adskoz ahzfikzmkt/ Nft

    k}alphk( IDEN cflphkzkhu hacgs defikfitapmecah eonftlazefo fo zmk jeszted{zefo fn [ocea {oceah

    -sofy hkfpatj% aoj Iftehha dkteoike dkteoike -Lf{ozaeo Iftehha% ymktkas zmk jeszted{zefo fn

    Dahakofpzkta l{sc{h{s -Dh{k Ymahk% aoj [ts{s latezel{s -Pfhat Dkat% es l{cm lftk

    k}zkose~khu cazahfi{kj/

    Yezm zmk eoctkaseoi okkj nft tkaju acckss zf tfd{sz defje~ktsezu jaza ez mas dkcflk lftk aoj

    lftk okckssatu zf kos{tk zmk spazeah acc{tacu fn zmk cfhhkczefo tkcftjs szftkj eo IDEN aoj

    ymkzmkt zmku tkheadhu tknhkcz zmk acz{ah za}a jeszted{zefo/ Fn ofzk( ez es fn eozktksz zf jkzktleok

    ymkzmkt za}a zmaz atk tkptkskozkj du fohu a slahh o{ldkt fn tkcftjs atk( eo nacz( ihfdahhu

    yejksptkaj d{z tatk ft atk ikfitapmecahhu tkszteczkj/ Ao k~ah{azefo fn zmk tfd{szokss aoj

    acc{tacu fn defje~ktsezu jaza yehh dk ct{ceah zf f{t adehezu zf {zehesk zmes eonftlazefo zf eonftl

    cfoskt~azefo phaooeoi/

  • 7/31/2019 An Evaluation of the Utility of Crowd Sourcing in Species Biodiversity Management

    7/57

    Bfoazmao LcHazcmek

    9

    Ptk~ef{s yftg mas sf{imz zf kh{cejazk zmk ikfitapmecah pha{sedehezu fn zmk ihfdah pfeoz jaza

    ptf~ejkj du IDEN -Ukssfo kz ah/( 4009%( eo ajjezefo zf zmk ikfitapmecah deasks eomktkoz eo zmk

    jaza aoj zmk k}zkoz zf ymecm ez es nkasedhk zf oflkochaz{tahhu ~ahejazk zmksk jaza du {zeheseoi zmk

    Eozktoazefoah Hki{lk Jazadask . Eonftlazefo Skt~eck -EHJES%( a jazadask zmaz ptf~ejks

    jeszted{zefo jaza nft zmk zykozu zmf{saoj spkceks fn zmk nhfykteoi phaoz nalehu Hki{leofsak/ Zmk

    sz{ju cfoch{jkj zmaz IDEN yas ikoktahhu acc{tazk( yezm =:+ fn zmk jaza lkkzeoi zmket ctezktea/

    L{sk{l spkcelko jaza mas ahsf dkko {skj zf ctkazk kcfhfiecah oecmk lfjkhs aoj zm{s lagk

    ptkjeczefos tkiatjeoi zmk jeszted{zefo fn tfjkoz pksz spkceks( smfyeoi zmaz ctfp jalaik es

    tkhazkj seioenecaozhu zf zmk ptkjeczkj ptkskock fn tfjkoz spkceks nft sk~ko fn oeok ctfps(

    -Saocmkr,Cftjktf aoj Latzeokr,Lkukt( 4000%/

    1/; Zmk Pfzkozeah [zehezu fn Ctfyj Sf{tceoi

    Alfoi zmk smftzcfleois fn IDEN atk ezs {ok~ko cf~ktaik aoj ezs tkheaock {pfo l{sk{l

    cfhhkczefos nft acq{esezefo fn jaza/ Ctfyj sf{tceoi mas dkko {skj s{cckssn{hhu eo sk~ktah

    scekozenec jescepheoks( s{cm as Iaha}u Rff -Tajjecgkz ah/(4010% aoj NfhjEz -Kedko kz ah/(

    4014%/ Aj~aozaiks fn ctfyj,sf{tceoi eoch{jk zmk nacz zmaz ez jfksoz cfsz lfoku zmaz yf{ hj dk

    spkoz fo paej hadf{t du ptfnkssefoah klphfukks/ Ctfyj sf{tceoi ahsf mas zmk pfzkozeah zf taesk

    eozktksz eo defje~ktsezu ess{ks/

    Pmfzfitapms fn yehjhenk( capz{tkj yezm IPS,koadhkj calktas( atk pfszkj du zmk p{dhec fo

    eozktokz sfceah okzyftgeoi sezks aoj dhfis/ P{dhecahhu acckssedhk elaiks atk a~aehadhk zmtf{im

    s{cm sezks o{ldkteoi hezktahhu eo zmk dehhefos/ Zmksk elaiks atk fnzko aoofzazkj yezm eonftlazefo

    s{cm as ikfhfcazefo aoj spkceks oalk/

    Ptk~ef{s yftg mas jk~khfpkj lkzmfjs fn ejkozenueoi zmk hfcazefo az ymecm a pmfzf yas capz{tkj

    daskj fo ezs cfozkoz -Maus aoj Kntfs( 400=%/ Zmes yas zagko n{tzmkt eo a s{dskq{koz sz{ju ymecm

    skz f{z zf {sk hfcazefo kszelazefo as ao k}pktelkozah patajeil nft eo~kszeiazeoi q{kszefos adf{z

    zmk tkhaze~k ~ah{k fn elaik nkaz{tks aoj zk}z zais eo kszelazeoi hfcazefo( -Ctaojahh kz ah/( 4005%/

    Zmktk mas ahsf dkko tkckoz yftg jfok fo skatcmeoi a cfhhkczefo fn haojlatg elaiks( {seoi

    nkaz{tks s{cm as ikfhfcazefo( elaik cfozkoz aoj zk}z zais -Gkookju aoj Oaalao( 400=%/ Zmes

  • 7/31/2019 An Evaluation of the Utility of Crowd Sourcing in Species Biodiversity Management

    8/57

    Bfoazmao LcHazcmek

    =

    sz{ju eoztfj{ckj lkzmfjfhfieks nft zmk aoahuses fn a ihfdah cfhhkczefo fn ikf,zaiikj pmfzfs(

    eoch{jeoi zkcmoeq{ks nft ptkjeczeoi hfcazefos fn zmksk pmfzfs/ Zmksk oky lkzmfjs yktk k~ah{azkj

    fo apptf}elazkhu 3; lehhefo Nhecgt pmfzfs/ Ez es s{iikszkj zmaz zmksk ikf,chassenecazefo

    zkcmoeq{ks cf{hj ahhfy pmfzf laoaiklkoz suszkls hegk Nhecgt zf a{zflazecahhu s{iiksz ikf,

    zais( seioenecaozhu tkj{ceoi zmk hadf{t eo~fh~kj eo ajjeoi ikfhfcazefo aoofzazefos/

    Seock IPS,koadhkj ikf,zaiieoi ahhfys pecz{tks zf dk assfceazkj yezm ikfitapmecah eonftlazefo(

    zmk pfzkozeah fn zmes tksf{tck zf ptf~ejk jaza fo spkceks jeszted{zefos es seioenecaoz/ Eojkkj( zmk

    pmfzf smateoi sezk Nhecgtymecm es mflk zf zmf{saojs fn yehjhenk pecz{tks capz{tkj aoj ikf,

    zaiikj fo IPS,koadhkj calktasmas tkckozhu dkko fn ~ah{k eo zmk ejkozenecazefo fn a oky

    spkceks/ Eo Lau 4011( kozflfhfieszs Sma{o Yeozktzfo -fn zmk Cahenftoea Szazk Cfhhkczefo fn

    Atzmtfpfjs az zmk Cahenftoea Jkpatzlkoz fn Nffj% aoj Sma{o Aitec{hz{tk ejkozenekj a ptk~ef{shu

    {ogofyo spkceks( hazkt oalkj Sklacmtusa bajk( ymehk dtfyseoi zmk eozktokz-Yeozktzfo kz ah/(

    4014%/ Zmes eocejkoz ehh{sztazks zmk pfykt fn elaik ctfyj sf{tceoi/ Ahzmf{im zmk elaik yas

    zagko du a pmfzfitapmkt eo jeszaoz Lahausea ymf jej ofz ma~k zmk k}pktzesk zf ejkozenu ez as a oky

    spkceks( Yeozktzfo( daskj eo Cahenftoea( maj zmk okckssatu gofyhkjik aoj adehezu/

    Zmktk es eoctkaseoihu ao fppftz{oezu nft zmk ikoktah p{dhec( yezm eozktkszs eo zmk oaz{tah scekocks(

    kezmkt gofyeoihu ft {ogofyeoihu( zf yftg zfikzmkt yezm ptfnkssefoah za}fofleszs/ Zmk tapej

    aj~aocks aoj jk~khfplkoz fn jeiezah pmfzfitapmec zkcmofhfiu( yehh koadhk ptfnkssefoah aoj

    alazk{t pmfzfitapmkts zf jk~khfp aoj eonftlahhu jfc{lkoz oky spkceks/ Ymktk zmk spkcelko es

    ofz cfhhkczkj( zmk ~f{cmkteoi fn zmk jescf~ktu ayaezs a spkcelko zf koadhk zmk nftlah jksctepze~k

    ptfckss aoj zupk jkseioazefo/

    1/> Aels aoj Fdbkcze~ks

    Zmk p{tpfsk fn zmk ptkskoz papkt es zf cflpatk zmk pmuhfikfitapmec sptkaj fn defje~ktsezu jaza

    accftjeoi zf IDEN aoj Nhecgt {seoi cflp{zkt sfnzyatk/ Eo sf jfeoi( zmk {zehezu fn Nhecgt eo

    s{pphklkozeoi jeszted{zefoah jaza cao dk assksskj/ Pfssedhk tkasfos nft eocfoit{ezu fn zmk jaza

    tkcftjkj du zmfsk zyf suszkls atk jesc{sskj/ Zmk sz{ju skkgs zf zmktkdu q{aozezaze~khu k~ah{azk

    zmk acc{tacu fn f{t gofyhkjik fn spkceks jeszted{zefos aoj zmk {zehezu fn Nhecgt eo s{pphklkozeoi

    jeszted{zefoah jaza/

  • 7/31/2019 An Evaluation of the Utility of Crowd Sourcing in Species Biodiversity Management

    9/57

    Bfoazmao LcHazcmek

    5

    4/ Lazkteahs . Lkzmfjs

    4/1 Nhecgt

    Nhecgt es skhn,jkneokj as ao foheok elaik smateoi cfll{oezu( aoj yas fteieoahhu ha{ocmkj duSzkyatz D{zzktnekhj as a s{ppftz nacehezu nft foheok ialeoi/

    Nhecgt nacehezazks zmk szftaik fn ikf,zaiieoi jaza( ymecm es oftlahhu capz{tkj a{zflazecahhu yezm

    IPS,koadhkj jeiezah calktas/ Nhecgt {skts atk adhk zf asseio zais zf elaiks fn zmket fyo aoj

    fzmkt pkfphk nft kask fn ftiaoesazefo aoj tkztek~ah/ Zmes nacehezu mas dkko a~aehadhk seock 400>/

    Ikf,zaiikj elaiks cao s{dskq{kozhu dk jfyohfajkj eo glh nftlaz cflpazedhk yezm Iffihk

    Katzm( lageoi ez a ~ah{adhk tksf{tck nft iazmkteoi defje~ktsezu jaza/

    4/4 F~kthap

    F~kthap -mzzp2&&yyy/epmuhf/fti&tpaik&pmuhfeonftlazecs&f~kthap&% es a cflp{zkt sctepz( ytezzko

    du Tfjktec Paik nft zmk p{tpfsk fn cflpateoi zmk defje~ktsezu eonftlazefo tkcftjkj eo IDEN

    yezm zmaz ikoktazkj du pmfzfitapmu szftkj fo Nhecgt/ F~kthap cahhs ykd skt~ecks ptf~ejkj du

    Nhecgt aoj IDEN/ Zmk {skt ie~ks zmksk skt~ecks zmk oalk fn ao ftiaoesl aoj zmk skt~ecks tkz{to

    eonftlazefo fo zmk ikfitapmecah jeszted{zefo fn zmaz ftiaoesl/ F~kthap ptfj{cks a tkpftz fo zmk

    jkitkk fn ikfitapmecah f~kthap dkzykko IDEN aoj Nhecgt nft a spkcenekj za}fo( ikoktazeoi zyf

    laps( tkptkskozeoi zmk defikfitapmec sptkaj accftjeoi zf IDEN aoj Nhecgt tkspkcze~khu/ Zf

    lagk zmes cflpatesfo( f~kthap cfo~ktzs zmk pfeoz hfcahezeks eozf sq{atks aoj jkzktleoks zmk

    o{ldkt fn sq{atks -csq{atks% zmaz atk cfllfo zf zmk zyf skzs fn jaza/ Zmk csq{atk serk cao dk

    ajb{szkj zf elptf~k zmk acc{tacu fn zmk f~kthap tkpftz/

    4/3 Ptfckj{tk

    Seock a tfd{sz gofyhkjik fn za}fo jeszted{zefos es fn meimksz elpftzaock eo zmk cask fn

    kojaoiktkj spkceks( zmes sz{ju skz f{z zf k~ah{azk IDENs jaza fo spkceks jeszted{zefos nft 40 fn

    zmk lfsz kojaoiktkj za}a ihfdahhu/ Skhkczkj za}a eoch{jkj zmk dhacg tmeofcktfs -Jecktfs

    decftoes%( sofy hkfpatj -[ocea {ocea%( ~aq{eza -Pmfcfkoa seo{s%( zeikt -Paozmkta zeites%( ieaoz

    paoja -Aeh{tfpfja lkhaofhk{ca%( imateah -Ia~eahes iaoikzec{s%( Aseao yehj jfi -C{fo ahpeoks%(

    itkko,cmkkgkj pattfz -Alarfoa ~etejeikoahes%( dh{k ymahk -Dahakofpzkta l{sc{h{s%( lf{ozaeo

  • 7/31/2019 An Evaluation of the Utility of Crowd Sourcing in Species Biodiversity Management

    10/57

    Bfoazmao LcHazcmek

    10

    iftehha -Iftehha dkteoike dkteoike%( ymezk tmeofcktfs -Cktazfzmkte{l sel{l%( lf{ozaeo iarkhhk

    -Iarkhha iarkhhk%( gflfjf jtaifo -^atao{s gflfjfkoses%( Lahauao zapet -Zapet{s Eojec{s%(

    Antecao nftksz z{tzhk -Mkfsklus jkptkssa%( pfhat dkat -[ts{s latezel{s%( Antecao yehj jfi

    -Hucafo pecz{s%( Cahenftoea cfojft -Iulofiups cahenftoeao{s%( dfofdf -Pao paoesc{s% aoj

    ctkszkj edes -Oeppfoea Oeppfo%/

    Spkceks oalks yktk kozktkj eozf F~kthap -csq{atk serk 1010% zf ikoktazk jeszted{zefo laps

    nft dfzm IDEN aoj Nhecgt( as ykhh as ao f~kthap tkpftz/ Zmk o{ldkt fn IDEN 1010 sq{atks

    yezm tkcftjs( zmk o{ldkt fn ikf,zaiikj pmfzfs fo Nhecgt( zmk o{ldkt fn csq{atks cf~ktkj du

    IDEN aoj Nhecgt( aoj zmk jkitkk fn f~kthap yktk ofzkj/

    Zmtkk pfzkozeah smftzcfleois fn Nhecgt as a sf{tck fn eonftlazefo fo spkceks jeszted{zefos atk -1%

    zmk pfssedhk deas aiaeosz spkceks ymecm he~k eo {ojk~khfpkj tkiefos fn zmk yfthj ymktk jeiezah

    pmfzfitapmu es seioenecaozhu hkss ntkq{koz7 -4% zmk pfssedhk deas aiaeosz spkceks ymecm atk ptkskoz

    eo tkiefos yezm hfykt hk~khs fn zf{tesz eozktksz7 aoj -3% zmk ptkskock fn aoelahs eo yehjhenk patgs

    aoj rffs( lkaoeoi zmaz laou fn zmk pmfzfs fo Nhecgt tkptkskoz ftiaoesls zmaz atk f{zsejk fn zmket

    oaz{tah taoik/ Eo ftjkt zf jkzktleok zmk seioenecaock fn zmk netsz smftzcfleoi( a cflp{zkt sctepz(

    ytezzko du Tfjktec Paik( yas {skj zf k}ztacz lkzajaza nft pecz{tks ntfl zmk Kocuchfpakjea fn

    Henks Nhecgt pffh -mzzp2&&yyy/nhecgt/cfl&itf{ps&kocuchfpkjeaVfnVhenk&pffh&% aoj( daskj fo zmk

    hazez{jeoah aoj hfoiez{jeoah cf,ftjeoazks( ctkazk a lap jesphaueoi zmk hfcazefos fn ikf,zaiikj

    pmfzfs/ Zmk sctepz aiitkiazkj zmk jaza pfeozs eozf 11 sq{atks aoj ikoktazkj a IDEN,szuhk

    lap/ Zmk PMP cfjk nft tkztek~eoi zmk pecz{tk jaza aoj ikoktazeoi zmk lap es acckssedhk ~ea

    iezm{d -mzzps2&&iezm{d/cfl&tjlpaik&nhecgtkfhlap%/

    Zf jkzktleok zmk k}zkoz zf ymecm zmktk k}eszs a deas aiaeosz spkceks ymecm k}esz eo tkiefos yezm

    hfy zf{tesz eozktksz( a ihfdah zf{tesl mkaz lap yas fdzaeokj ntfl zmk ykd eo zmk nftl fn a glh

    nehk nft ~ekyeoi fo Iffihk Katzm -mzzp2&&yyy/dh{klffo/kk&amze&zf{teszeokss,lap&%/ Zmk sctepz

    {skj zf ikoktazk zmes mkaz lap-mzzp2&&yyy/dh{klffo/kk&amze&zf{teszeokss,lap&d{ehjVlap/pu %

    es daskj fo aoahuses fn elaiks fo Paoftalef -mzzp2&&yyy/paoftalef/cfl&%/

    http://www.flickr.com/groups/encyclopedia_of_life/pool/http://www.flickr.com/groups/encyclopedia_of_life/pool/http://www.flickr.com/groups/encyclopedia_of_life/pool/https://github.com/rdmpage/flickreolmaphttps://github.com/rdmpage/flickreolmaphttps://github.com/rdmpage/flickreolmaphttp://www.bluemoon.ee/~ahti/touristiness-map/http://www.bluemoon.ee/~ahti/touristiness-map/http://www.bluemoon.ee/~ahti/touristiness-map/http://www.bluemoon.ee/~ahti/touristiness-map/build_map.pyhttp://www.bluemoon.ee/~ahti/touristiness-map/build_map.pyhttp://www.bluemoon.ee/~ahti/touristiness-map/build_map.pyhttp://www.panoramio.com/http://www.panoramio.com/http://www.panoramio.com/http://www.panoramio.com/http://www.bluemoon.ee/~ahti/touristiness-map/build_map.pyhttp://www.bluemoon.ee/~ahti/touristiness-map/https://github.com/rdmpage/flickreolmaphttp://www.flickr.com/groups/encyclopedia_of_life/pool/
  • 7/31/2019 An Evaluation of the Utility of Crowd Sourcing in Species Biodiversity Management

    11/57

    Bfoazmao LcHazcmek

    11

    Zf zksz zmk seioenecaock fn zmk zmetj smftzcfleoi( zmk ptfckj{tk yas tkpkazkj nft spkceks itf{ps

    ymecm atk {ohegkhu zf dk nf{oj eo rffs aoj yehjhenk patgs/ Zmksk itf{ps eoch{jk meimkt ftjkt

    aoelahs s{cm as nf}ks( as ykhh as spkceks fn eoskczs( ctads aoj n{oie/ Zmk spkceks eo~fh~kj yktk

    zmk ctad,kazeoi nf} -Cktjfcufo zmf{s%( zmk K{tfpkao taddez -Ftuczfhai{s c{oec{h{s%( cfllfo

    lftkh n{oie -Lftcmkhha ksc{hkoza%( smaiiu eog cap n{oie -Cfpteo{s cflaz{s%( slffzm eog cap

    n{oie -Cfpteo{s aztalkozate{s%( smftk ctad -Catceo{s lakoas%( kjedhk ctad -Caockt pai{t{s%(

    cfllfo spejkt ctad -Laba sq{eoajf%( lfsq{ezf -Aofpmkhks q{ajtelac{haz{s%( cfllfo mf{sk

    spejkt -Acmakataoka zkpejateft{l% aoj zmk klpktft jtaifonhu -Aoa} elpktazft%/

  • 7/31/2019 An Evaluation of the Utility of Crowd Sourcing in Species Biodiversity Management

    12/57

    Bfoazmao LcHazcmek

    14

    3/ Tks{hzs

    3/1 F~kthap laps nft 40 lfsz kojaoiktkj spkceks

    A

    D

    Nei{tk 12 F~kthap laps smfyeoi jeszted{zefo fnJecktfs decftoes -dhacgtmeofcktfs% spkceks nft IDEN -A% aoj Nhecgt -D%/ IDEN mas tkcftjs ntfl 19

    csq{atks7 Nhecgt mas tkcftjs ntfl = csq{atks/ F~kthap dkzykko IDEN aoj Nhecgt

    A

    D

    Nei{tk ;2 F~kthap laps smfyeoi jeszted{zefo fnAeh{tfpfja lkhaofhk{ca -IeaozPaoja% spkceks nft IDEN -A% aoj Nhecgt -D%/ IDEN mas tkcftjs ntfl : csq{atks7

    Nhecgt mas tkcftjs ntfl > csq{atks/ F~kthap dkzykko IDEN aoj Nhecgt < 1/

  • 7/31/2019 An Evaluation of the Utility of Crowd Sourcing in Species Biodiversity Management

    17/57

    Bfoazmao LcHazcmek

    19

    A

    D

    Nei{tk >2 F~kthap laps smfyeoi jeszted{zefo fnIa~eahes iaoikzec{s -Imateah%

    spkceks nft IDEN -A% aoj Nhecgt -D%/ IDEN mas tkcftjs ntfl 1 csq{atk7 Nhecgt mas

    tkcftjs ntfl ; csq{atks/ F~kthap dkzykko IDEN aoj Nhecgt < 1/

  • 7/31/2019 An Evaluation of the Utility of Crowd Sourcing in Species Biodiversity Management

    18/57

    Bfoazmao LcHazcmek

    1=

    A

    D

    Nei{tk 92 F~kthap laps smfyeoi jeszted{zefo fnC{fo ahpeo{s -Aseao Yehj Jfi%

    spkceks nft IDEN -A% aoj Nhecgt -D%/ IDEN mas tkcftjs ntfl 13 csq{atks7 Nhecgt mas

    tkcftjs ntfl 10 csq{atks/ F~kthap dkzykko IDEN aoj Nhecgt < :/

  • 7/31/2019 An Evaluation of the Utility of Crowd Sourcing in Species Biodiversity Management

    19/57

    Bfoazmao LcHazcmek

    15

    A

    D

    Nei{tk =2 F~kthap laps smfyeoi jeszted{zefo fnAlarfoa ~etejeikoahes -Itkko,Cmkkgkj

    Pattfz% spkceks nft IDEN -A% aoj Nhecgt -D%/ IDEN mas tkcftjs ntfl 10 csq{atks7 Nhecgt

    mas tkcftjs ntfl : csq{atks/ F~kthap dkzykko IDEN aoj Nhecgt < 4/

  • 7/31/2019 An Evaluation of the Utility of Crowd Sourcing in Species Biodiversity Management

    20/57

    Bfoazmao LcHazcmek

    40

    A

    D

    Nei{tk 52 F~kthap laps smfyeoi jeszted{zefo fnDahakofpzkta l{sc{h{s -Dh{k Ymahk%

    spkceks nft IDEN -A% aoj Nhecgt -D%/ IDEN mas tkcftjs ntfl =3 csq{atks7 Nhecgt mas

    tkcftjs ntfl > csq{atks/ F~kthap dkzykko IDEN aoj Nhecgt < :/

  • 7/31/2019 An Evaluation of the Utility of Crowd Sourcing in Species Biodiversity Management

    21/57

    Bfoazmao LcHazcmek

    41

    A

    D

    Nei{tk 102 F~kthap laps smfyeoi jeszted{zefo fnIftehha dkteoike dkteoike -Lf{ozaeoIftehha% spkceks nft IDEN -A% aoj Nhecgt -D%/ IDEN mas tkcftjs ntfl 0 csq{atks7 Nhecgt

    mas tkcftjs ntfl 1 csq{atk/ F~kthap dkzykko IDEN aoj Nhecgt < 0/

  • 7/31/2019 An Evaluation of the Utility of Crowd Sourcing in Species Biodiversity Management

    22/57

    Bfoazmao LcHazcmek

    44

    A

    D

    Nei{tk 112 F~kthap laps smfyeoi jeszted{zefo fnCktazfzmkte{l sel{l -Ymezk

    Tmeofcktfs%spkceks nft IDEN -A% aoj Nhecgt -D%/ IDEN mas tkcftjs ntfl 1; csq{atks7

    Nhecgt mas tkcftjs ntfl 9 csq{atks/ F~kthap dkzykko IDEN aoj Nhecgt < 3/

  • 7/31/2019 An Evaluation of the Utility of Crowd Sourcing in Species Biodiversity Management

    23/57

    Bfoazmao LcHazcmek

    43

    A

    D

    Nei{tk 142 F~kthap laps smfyeoi jeszted{zefo fnIarkhha iarkhha -Lf{ozaeo Iarkhhk%

    spkceks nft IDEN -A% aoj Nhecgt -D%/ IDEN mas tkcftjs ntfl = csq{atks7 Nhecgt mas

    tkcftjs ntfl 3 csq{atks/ F~kthap dkzykko IDEN aoj Nhecgt < 4/

  • 7/31/2019 An Evaluation of the Utility of Crowd Sourcing in Species Biodiversity Management

    24/57

    Bfoazmao LcHazcmek

    4:

    A

    D

    Nei{tk 132 F~kthap laps smfyeoi jeszted{zefo fn^atao{s gflfjfkoses -Gflfjf

    jtaifo% spkceks nft IDEN -A% aoj Nhecgt -D%/ IDEN mas tkcftjs ntfl 1 csq{atk7 Nhecgt

    mas tkcftjs ntfl 9 csq{atks/ F~kthap dkzykko IDEN aoj Nhecgt < 1/

  • 7/31/2019 An Evaluation of the Utility of Crowd Sourcing in Species Biodiversity Management

    25/57

    Bfoazmao LcHazcmek

    4;

    A

    D

    Nei{tk 1:2 F~kthap laps smfyeoi jeszted{zefo fnZapet{s Eojec{s -Lahauao Zapet%spkceks nft IDEN -A% aoj Nhecgt -D%/ IDEN mas tkcftjs ntfl ; csq{atks7 Nhecgt mas

    tkcftjs ntfl = csq{atks/ F~kthap dkzykko IDEN aoj Nhecgt < 0/

  • 7/31/2019 An Evaluation of the Utility of Crowd Sourcing in Species Biodiversity Management

    26/57

    Bfoazmao LcHazcmek

    4>

    A

    D

    Nei{tk 1;2 F~kthap laps smfyeoi jeszted{zefo fnMkfsklus jkptkssa -Atagao Nftksz

    Z{tzhk%spkceks nft IDEN -A% aoj Nhecgt -D%/ IDEN mas tkcftjs ntfl 0 csq{atks7 Nhecgt

    mas tkcftjs ntfl 1 csq{atk/ F~kthap dkzykko IDEN aoj Nhecgt < 0/

  • 7/31/2019 An Evaluation of the Utility of Crowd Sourcing in Species Biodiversity Management

    27/57

    Bfoazmao LcHazcmek

    49

    A

    D

    Nei{tk 1>2 F~kthap laps smfyeoi jeszted{zefo fn[ts{s latezel{s -Pfhat Dkat% spkceksnft IDEN -A% aoj Nhecgt -D%/ IDEN mas tkcftjs ntfl :; csq{atks7 Nhecgt mas tkcftjs

    ntfl ; csq{atks/ F~kthap dkzykko IDEN aoj Nhecgt < :/

  • 7/31/2019 An Evaluation of the Utility of Crowd Sourcing in Species Biodiversity Management

    28/57

  • 7/31/2019 An Evaluation of the Utility of Crowd Sourcing in Species Biodiversity Management

    29/57

    Bfoazmao LcHazcmek

    45

    A

    D

    Nei{tk 1=2 F~kthap laps smfyeoi jeszted{zefo fnIulofiups cahenftoeao{s -Cahenftoea

    Cfojft% spkceks nft IDEN -A% aoj Nhecgt -D%/ IDEN mas tkcftjs ntfl 3 csq{atks7 Nhecgtmas tkcftjs ntfl 4 csq{atks/ F~kthap dkzykko IDEN aoj Nhecgt < 4/

  • 7/31/2019 An Evaluation of the Utility of Crowd Sourcing in Species Biodiversity Management

    30/57

    Bfoazmao LcHazcmek

    30

    A

    D

    Nei{tk 152 F~kthap laps smfyeoi jeszted{zefo fnPao paoesc{s -Dfofdf% spkceks nftIDEN -A% aoj Nhecgt -D%/ IDEN mas tkcftjs ntfl 4 csq{atks7 Nhecgt mas tkcftjs ntfl ;

    csq{atks/ F~kthap dkzykko IDEN aoj Nhecgt < 1/

  • 7/31/2019 An Evaluation of the Utility of Crowd Sourcing in Species Biodiversity Management

    31/57

    Bfoazmao LcHazcmek

    31

    A

    D

    Nei{tk 402 F~kthap laps smfyeoi jeszted{zefo fnOeppfoea Oeppfo -Ctkszkj Edes%

    spkceks nft IDEN -A% aoj Nhecgt -D%/ IDEN mas tkcftjs ntfl 4 csq{atks7 Nhecgt mas

    tkcftjs ntfl 1 csq{atks/ F~kthap dkzykko IDEN aoj Nhecgt < 0/

  • 7/31/2019 An Evaluation of the Utility of Crowd Sourcing in Species Biodiversity Management

    32/57

    Bfoazmao LcHazcmek

    34

    Zadhk 12 Cflpatesfo fn Defje~ktsezu Jaza ntfl IDEN aoj Nhecgt

    Za}a O{ldkt fn IDEN

    1010 Sq{atks

    yezm Tkcftjs

    O{ldkt fn Ikf,

    zaiikj Pmfzfs fo

    Nhecgt

    O{ldkt fn

    csq{atks

    cf~ktkj

    -IDEN%

    O{ldkt fn

    csq{atks

    cf~ktkj

    -Nhecgt%

    F~kthap Pktckozaik fn Nhec

    csq{atks zmaz f~kt

    yezm IDEN csq{at

    Jecktfs decftoes

    -Dhacg Tmeofcktfs%

    ;; 40 19 = 3 39/;+

    [ocea {oceah-Sofy

    Hkfpatj%

    0 4 0 1 0 0+

    Pmfcfkoa seo{s

    -^aq{eza%

    : 0 1 0 0 0+

    Paozmkta zeites

    -Zeikt%

    45 40 40 5 1 11/1+

    Aeh{tfpfja

    lkhaofhk{ca -Ieaoz

    Paoja%

    = 40 : > 1 1>/9+

    Ia~eahes iaoikzec{s-Imateah%

    1 40 1 ; 1 40+

    C{fo ahpeo{s -Aseao

    Yehj Jfi%

    40 40 13 10 : :0+

    Alarfoa

    ~etejeikoahes -Itkko,Cmkkgkj Pattfz%

    := 40 10 : 4 ;0+

    Dahakofpzkta

    l{sc{h{s -Dh{k

    Ymahk%

    :50 40 =3 > : >>/9+

    Iftehha dkteoike

    dkteoike -Lf{ozaeo

    Iftehha%

    0 40 0 1 0 0+

    Cktazfzmkte{l

    sel{l -Ymezk

    Tmeofcktfs%

    :0 40 1; 9 3 :4/5+

    Iarkhha iarkhha-Lf{ozaeo Iarkhhk%

    15 1: = 3 4 >>/9+

    ^atao{sgflfjfkoses

    -Gflfjf Jtaifo%

    1 40 1 9 1 1:/4+

    Zapet{s Eojec{s

    -Lahauao Zapet%

    9 40 ; = 0 0+

    Mkfsklus jkptkssa

    -Atagao Nftksz

    Z{tzhk%

    0 1 0 1 0 0+

    [ts{s latezel{s

    -Pfhat Dkat%

    1:> 40 :; ; : =0+

    Hucafo pecz{s

    -Antecao Yehj Jfi%

    30 40 5 ; 1 40+

    Iulofiups

    cahenftoeao{s

    -Cahenftoea Cfojft%

    30 40 3 4 4 100+

    Pao paoesc{s

    -Dfofdf%

    4 40 4 ; 1 40+

    Oeppfoea Oeppfo

    -Ctkszkj Edes%

    4 1 4 1 0 0+

  • 7/31/2019 An Evaluation of the Utility of Crowd Sourcing in Species Biodiversity Management

    33/57

    Bfoazmao LcHazcmek

    33

    Zadhk 42 Cflpatesfo fn spkceks oaz{tah madezazs yezm fdskt~kj jeszted{zefos

    Spkceks Oaz{tah Madezaz Fdskt~kj Jeszted{zefo -IDEN% Fdskt~kj Jeszted{zefos

    -Nhecgt%

    Jecktfs decftoes -Dhacg

    Tmeofcktfs%

    Sf{zm( Kasz aoj Yksz Anteca Cfozeokozah K{tfpk( Asea . NatKasz/

    Oftzm Alkteca( CfozeokozahK{tfpk( Eojea aoj Nat Kasz/

    [ocea {oceah-Sofy

    Hkfpatj%

    Animaoeszao( Dm{zao( Zedkz(

    Eojea( Garagmszao(Gutiurszao( Lfoifhea(Okpah( Pageszao( Zabegeszao([rdkgeszao/

    Ofok Kaszkto cfasz fn [SA/

    Pmfcfkoa seo{s -^aq{eza% I{hn fn Cahenftoea I{hn fn Cahenftoea Ofok

    Paozmkta zeites -Zeikt% Ntfl Eojea zf Cmeoa aojSf{zmkasz Asea

    Ahasga( Oftzm Alkteca( Asea .Nat Kasz/

    Oftzm Alkteca( K{tfpk( LejjKasz aoj Eojea/

    Aeh{tfpfja lkhaofhk{ca-Ieaoz Paoja%

    Ckoztah,ykszkto aoj sf{zm,ykszkto Cmeoa

    Cmeoa Oftzm Alkteca( YkszktoK{tfpk( Cmeoa . A{sztahea/

    Ia~eahes iaoikzec{s -Imateah% Eojea aoj Okpah D{tla/ Cateddkao( Cfozeokozah K{tfpEojea( Okpah . D{tla/

    C{fo ahpeo{s -Aseao YehjJfi%

    Eojea Cfozeokozah K{tfpk( Eojea(Cmeoa. Asea/

    [SA( K{tfpk( Lftfccf( EojeaPageszao . Bapao/

    Alarfoa ~etejeikoahes-Itkko,Cmkkgkj Pattfz%

    Actfss zmk hfyhaojs fn

    oftzmkaszkto Lk}ecf

    Oftzm Alkteca( Ckoztah Alkteca

    aoj Oftzm Pacenec Eshaojs

    Oftzm Alkteca( Ckoztah

    Alkteca/

    Dahakofpzkta l{sc{h{s -Dh{kYmahk%

    Oftzm Pacenec( OftzmAzhaozec

    Cfaszah atkas eo Oftzm Alkteca(Sf{zm Alkteca( Atczec(Aozatczeca( A{sztahea( Sf{zmAnteca( Lejjhk Kasz aoj Bapao/

    Kasz Cfasz fn [SA( ItkkohaojOftzm K{tfpk( Eojea aoj Bapao

    Iftehha dkteoike dkteoike-Lf{ozaeo Iftehha%

    Ckoztah Anteca( sf{zmyksz[iaoja( oftzm,ykszTyaoja( kaszkto tkp{dhec fnCfoif

    Ofok Ckoztah Anteca

    Cktazfzmkte{l sel{l -YmezkTmeofcktfs%

    Sf{zm Anteca Oftzmkto Anteca( Kaszkto Anteca(Sf{zm Anteca . Ckoztah Alktecas

    Ckoztah Alkteca( YkszktoK{tfpk( Kaszkto aoj Sf{zmkto

    Anteca/

    Iarkhha iarkhha -Lf{ozaeo

    Iarkhhk%

    Atadeao Pkoeos{ha Ofok/ Lejjhk Kasz/

    ^atao{s gflfjfkoses-Gflfjf jtaifo%

    Eojfokseao Eshaojs Ofok Ckoztah Alkteca( Ykszkto

    K{tfpk( Eojfoksea .Pmeheppeoks

    Zapet{s Eojec{s -Lahauao

    Zapet%

    Kasz Eojeks Ckoztah Alkteca( Atikozeoa(

    Eojfoksea aoj Pmeheppeoks

    Ckoztah Alkteca( Ykszkto

    K{tfpk aoj Sf{zm A{sztahea/

    Mkfsklus jkptkssa -AtagaoNftksz Z{tzhk%

    Atgao mehhs fn ykszktoLuaolat

    Ofok/ [SA

    [ts{s latezel{s -PfhatDkat%

    Atczec Cetchk Atczec Cetchk( Ahasga( K{tfpk aoj

    Eojeao Fckao/

    Oftzm Alkteca . Ykszkto

    K{tfpk/

    Hucafo pecz{s -Antecao YehjJfi%

    Anteca [SA( Kaszkto aoj Sf{zmktoAnteca/

    Ykszkto K{tfpk . Sf{zm KaszAnteca/

    Iulofiups cahenftoeao{s

    -Cahenftoea Cfojft%

    Oftzmkto Aterfoa aoj

    sf{zmkto [zam( cfaszahlf{ozaeos fn ckoztah aojsf{zmkto Cahenftoea aojoftzmkto Daba Cahenftoea/

    Yksz Cfasz fn [SA/ Yksz Cfasz fn [SA/

    Pao paoesc{s -Dfofdf% Cfoif eo ckoztah Anteca [SA . Ckoztah Anteca/ [SA aoj Ykszkto K{tfpk/

    Oeppfoea Oeppfo -CtkszkjEdes%

    Smaao}e ptf~eock fn Cmeoa Cmeoa . Gftka Bapao

  • 7/31/2019 An Evaluation of the Utility of Crowd Sourcing in Species Biodiversity Management

    34/57

    Bfoazmao LcHazcmek

    3:

    3/4 F~kthap laps nft hkss eozktkszeoi spkceks

    A

    D

    Nei{tk 412 F~kthap laps smfyeoi jeszted{zefo fnCktjfcufo zmf{s -ctad,kazeoi nf}%

    spkceks nft IDEN -A% aoj Nhecgt -D%/ IDEN mas tkcftjs ntfl 1> csq{atks7 Nhecgt mas

    tkcftjs ntfl > csq{atks/ F~kthap dkzykko IDEN aoj Nhecgt < ;/

  • 7/31/2019 An Evaluation of the Utility of Crowd Sourcing in Species Biodiversity Management

    35/57

    Bfoazmao LcHazcmek

    3;

    A

    D

    Nei{tk 442 F~kthap laps smfyeoi jeszted{zefo fnFtuczfhai{s c{oec{h{s -K{tfpkaotaddez% spkceks nft IDEN -A% aoj Nhecgt -D%/ IDEN mas tkcftjs ntfl ;3 csq{atks7 Nhecgt

    mas tkcftjs ntfl : csq{atks/ F~kthap dkzykko IDEN aoj Nhecgt < :/

  • 7/31/2019 An Evaluation of the Utility of Crowd Sourcing in Species Biodiversity Management

    36/57

    Bfoazmao LcHazcmek

    3>

    A

    D

    Nei{tk 432 F~kthap laps smfyeoi jeszted{zefo fnLftcmkhha ksc{hkoza -cfllfo lftkhn{oie% spkceks nft IDEN -A% aoj Nhecgt -D%/ IDEN mas tkcftjs ntfl 49 csq{atks7 Nhecgt

    mas tkcftjs ntfl = csq{atks/ F~kthap dkzykko IDEN aoj Nhecgt < >/

  • 7/31/2019 An Evaluation of the Utility of Crowd Sourcing in Species Biodiversity Management

    37/57

    Bfoazmao LcHazcmek

    39

    A

    D

    Nei{tk 4:2 F~kthap laps smfyeoi jeszted{zefo fnCfpteo{s cflaz{s -Smaiiu eog,cap

    n{oie% spkceks nft IDEN -A% aoj Nhecgt -D%/ IDEN mas tkcftjs ntfl 49 csq{atks7 Nhecgt

    mas tkcftjs ntfl > csq{atks/ F~kthap dkzykko IDEN aoj Nhecgt < ;/

  • 7/31/2019 An Evaluation of the Utility of Crowd Sourcing in Species Biodiversity Management

    38/57

    Bfoazmao LcHazcmek

    3=

    A

    D

    Nei{tk 4;2 F~kthap laps smfyeoi jeszted{zefo fnCfpteo{s aztalkozate{s -slffzm eog,cap n{oie% spkceks nft IDEN -A% aoj Nhecgt -D%/ IDEN mas tkcftjs ntfl 43 csq{atks7

    Nhecgt mas tkcftjs ntfl > csq{atks/ F~kthap dkzykko IDEN aoj Nhecgt < 3/

  • 7/31/2019 An Evaluation of the Utility of Crowd Sourcing in Species Biodiversity Management

    39/57

    Bfoazmao LcHazcmek

    35

    A

    D

    Nei{tk 4>2 F~kthap laps smfyeoi jeszted{zefo fnCatceo{s lakoas -smftk ctad%spkceksnft IDEN -A% aoj Nhecgt -D%/ IDEN mas tkcftjs ntfl 31 csq{atks7 Nhecgt mas tkcftjs

    ntfl > csq{atks/ F~kthap dkzykko IDEN aoj Nhecgt < ;/

  • 7/31/2019 An Evaluation of the Utility of Crowd Sourcing in Species Biodiversity Management

    40/57

    Bfoazmao LcHazcmek

    :0

    A

    D

    Nei{tk 492 F~kthap laps smfyeoi jeszted{zefo fnCaockt pai{t{s -kjedhk ctad%spkceks

    nft IDEN -A% aoj Nhecgt -D%/ IDEN mas tkcftjs ntfl 1: csq{atks7 Nhecgt mas tkcftjs

    ntfl ; csq{atks/ F~kthap dkzykko IDEN aoj Nhecgt < ;/

  • 7/31/2019 An Evaluation of the Utility of Crowd Sourcing in Species Biodiversity Management

    41/57

    Bfoazmao LcHazcmek

    :1

    A

    D

    Nei{tk 4=2 F~kthap laps smfyeoi jeszted{zefo fnLaba sq{eoajf -cfllfo spejkt ctad%spkceks nft IDEN -A% aoj Nhecgt -D%/ IDEN mas tkcftjs ntfl 1: csq{atks7 Nhecgt mas

    tkcftjs ntfl : csq{atks/ F~kthap dkzykko IDEN aoj Nhecgt < :/

  • 7/31/2019 An Evaluation of the Utility of Crowd Sourcing in Species Biodiversity Management

    42/57

    Bfoazmao LcHazcmek

    :4

    A

    D

    Nei{tk 452 F~kthap laps smfyeoi jeszted{zefo fnAofpmkhks q{ajtelac{haz{s-lfsq{ezf% spkceks nft IDEN -A% aoj Nhecgt -D%/ IDEN mas tkcftjs ntfl 5 csq{atks7

    Nhecgt mas tkcftjs ntfl 1 csq{atks/ F~kthap dkzykko IDEN aoj Nhecgt < 1/

  • 7/31/2019 An Evaluation of the Utility of Crowd Sourcing in Species Biodiversity Management

    43/57

    Bfoazmao LcHazcmek

    :3

    A

    D

    Nei{tk 302 F~kthap laps smfyeoi jeszted{zefo fnAcmakataoka zkpejateft{l -cfllfomf{sk spejkt% spkceks nft IDEN -A% aoj Nhecgt -D%/ IDEN mas tkcftjs ntfl 13 csq{atks7

    Nhecgt mas tkcftjs ntfl > csq{atks/ F~kthap dkzykko IDEN aoj Nhecgt < 4/

  • 7/31/2019 An Evaluation of the Utility of Crowd Sourcing in Species Biodiversity Management

    44/57

    Bfoazmao LcHazcmek

    ::

    A

    D

    Nei{tk 312 F~kthap laps smfyeoi jeszted{zefo fnAoa} elpktazft -klpktft jtaifonhu%spkceks nft IDEN -A% aoj Nhecgt -D%/ IDEN mas tkcftjs ntfl 41 csq{atks7 Nhecgt mas

    tkcftjs ntfl > csq{atks/ F~kthap dkzykko IDEN aoj Nhecgt < >/

  • 7/31/2019 An Evaluation of the Utility of Crowd Sourcing in Species Biodiversity Management

    45/57

    Bfoazmao LcHazcmek

    :;

    Zadhk 32 Cflpatesfo fn Defje~ktsezu Jaza ntfl IDEN aoj Nhecgt

    Za}a O{ldkt fn IDEN

    1010 Sq{atks

    yezm Tkcftjs

    O{ldkt fn Ikf,

    zaiikj Pmfzfs fo

    Nhecgt

    O{ldkt fn

    csq{atks

    cf~ktkj -IDEN%

    O{ldkt fn

    csq{atks

    cf~ktkj

    -Nhecgt%

    F~kthap Pktckozaik fn

    Nhecgt csq{atk

    zmaz f~kthap y

    IDEN csq{atk

    Cktjfcufo zmf{s

    -ctad,kazeoi nf}%

    10> 13 1> > ; =3/3+

    Ftuczfhai{sc{oec{h{s-K{tfpkao taddez%

    >59 40 ;3 : : 100+

    Lftcmkhha ksc{hkoza

    -cfllfo lftkh

    n{oie%

    115 40 49 = > 9;+

    Cfpteo{s cflaz{s

    -smaiiu eog,cap

    n{oie%

    40> 40 49 > ; =3/3+

    Cfpteo{s

    aztalkozate{s

    -slffzm eog,cap

    n{oie%

    10; 40 43 > 3 ;0+

    Catceo{s lakoas

    -smftk ctad%

    405 40 31 > ; =3/3+

    Caockt pai{t{s

    -kjedhk ctad%

    1:> 40 1: ; ; 100+

    Laba sq{eoajf

    -cfllfo spejktctad%

    =0 > 1: : : 100+

    Aofpmkhks

    q{ajtelac{haz{s-lfsq{ezf%

    1= 1 5 1 1 100+

    Acmakataoka

    zkpejateft{l

    -cfllfo mf{sk

    spejkt%

    :0 40 13 > 4 33/3+

    Aoa} elpktazft

    -klpktft

    jtaifonhu%

    1>1 40 41 > > 100+

  • 7/31/2019 An Evaluation of the Utility of Crowd Sourcing in Species Biodiversity Management

    46/57

    Bfoazmao LcHazcmek

    :>

    Zadhk :2 Cflpatesfo fn spkceks oaz{tah madezazs yezm fdskt~kj jeszted{zefos

    Spkceks Oaz{tah Madezaz Fdskt~kj Jeszted{zefo -IDEN% Fdskt~kj Jeszted{zefos

    -Nhecgt%

    Cktjfcufo zmf{s -ctad,

    kazeoi nf}%

    Cfhfldea aoj sf{zmkto^kokr{kha( Patai{au([t{i{au aoj Oftzmkto

    Atikozeoa/

    Cfhfldea aoj sf{zmkto^kokr{kha(Patai{au( [t{i{au aojOftzmkto Atikozeoa aoj Oftzm

    Alkteca -yksz cfasz%

    Cfhfldea aoj sf{zmkto^kokr{kha(Patai{au( [t{i{auaoj Oftzmkto Atikozeoa aoj

    Oftzm Alkteca -sf{zm,yksz cfaFtuczfhai{s c{oec{h{s-K{tfpkao taddez%

    Sf{zm yksz K{tfpk -Spaeoaoj Pftz{iah% aoj oftzm ykszAnteca -Lftfccf aojAhiktea%/

    Ahh K{tfpk( A{sztahea( Sf{zm

    Alkteca( [SA( Ahasga aoj

    Pacenec Eshaojs

    Sf{zm yksz K{tfpk -Spaeo aojPftz{iah% aoj oftzm yksz Anteca-Lftfccf aoj Ahiktea%/

    Lftcmkhha ksc{hkoza

    -cfllfo lftkh n{oie%

    Oftzm Alkteca

    -patzec{hathu cfllfo eo

    kaszkto Oftzm Alkteca .

    Lejyksz%( Caoaja( Dtareh/

    Ahh K{tfpk( Ykszkto A{sztahea(

    Bapao( Oftzm Alkteca aoj

    Ckoztah Alkteca( Oky Rkahaoj/

    Ykszkto K{tfpk aoj Kaszkto

    [SA/

    Cfpteo{s cflaz{s -smaiiueog,cap n{oie%

    K{tfpk( Oftzm Alkteca(A{sztahea( Oky Rkahaoj aojEckhaoj

    K{tfpk( Oftzm Alkteca( CkoztahAlkteca( A{sztahea( Oky Rkahaojaoj Sf{zm Alkteca

    Ykszkto K{tfpk aoj Kaszkto

    A{sztahea/

    Cfpteo{s aztalkozate{s-slffzm eog,cap n{oie%

    K{tfpk( Oftzm Alkteca aojAsea

    K{tfpk( Oftzm Alkteca(Eckhaoj( Ckoztah Alkteca( Sf{zm

    Alkteca( A{sztahea( OkyRkahaoj aoj Bapao/

    K{tfpk( Scaojeoa~ea aojT{ssea/

    Catceo{s lakoas -smftk

    ctad%

    Oftzm,kasz Azhaozec Fckao(

    Dahzec Ska( A{sztahea(

    Sf{zm Anteca( Sf{zm

    Alkteca aoj dfzm Azhaozec

    aoj Pacenec cfaszs fn

    Oftzm Alkteca/

    Oftzm,kasz Azhaozec Fckao(

    Dahzec Ska( A{sztahea( lej,

    Pacenec( Tkj Ska atka( Sf{zm

    Anteca( Sf{zm Alkteca aoj dfzm

    Azhaozec aoj Pacenec cfaszs fn

    Oftzm Alkteca/ Oftzm

    Alktecao laeohaoj/

    Oftzm Yksz aoj Oftzm Kasz

    Azhaozec( Dahzec aoj Eojeao

    Fckao/

    Caockt pai{t{s -kjedhk

    ctad%

    Oftzm Ska( Oftzm Azhaozec

    Fckao aoj LkjezkttaokaoSka

    Oftzm Ska( Oftzm Azhaozec

    Fckao( Lkjezkttaokao Ska aojT{ssea/

    Oftzm Ska( Oftzm Azhaozec

    Fckao aoj Lkjezkttaokao Sk

    Laba sq{eoajf -cfllfospejkt ctad%

    Oftzm,kasz Azhaozec aojzmk Lkjezkttaokao Ska

    Oftzm,kasz Azhaozec( KaszAzhaozec aoj zmk Lkjezkttaokao

    Ska

    Oftzm,kasz Azhaozec aoj zmkLkjezkttaokao Ska

    Aofpmkhks q{ajtelac{haz{s

    -lfsq{ezf%

    Kaszkto Oftzm Alkteca/ Kaszkto Oftzm Alkteca(

    Ykszkto Oftzm Alkteca(

    Ckoztah Alkteca

    Kaszkto Oftzm Alkteca/

    Acmakataoka zkpejateft{l

    -cfllfo mf{sk spejkt%

    Alktecas( Luaolat aoj

    Pageszao

    Sf{zm Alkteca( K{tfpk( Nat

    Kasz aoj Kaszkto A{sztahea/

    Oftzm Alkteca aoj

    Cfozeokozah K{tfpk/

    Aoa} elpktazft -klpktft

    jtaifonhu%

    Sf{zmkto K{tfpk( oftzm

    Anteca aoj Asea

    Ahh K{tfpk( Ykszkto Anteca(

    Oftzmkto Anteca aoj Sf{zmkto

    Anteca/

    Ahh K{tfpk aoj Oftzmkto

    Anteca/

  • 7/31/2019 An Evaluation of the Utility of Crowd Sourcing in Species Biodiversity Management

    47/57

    Bfoazmao LcHazcmek

    :9

    3/3 Ihfdah ikf,zaiieoi acze~ezu

    3/: Zf{tesl Mkaz Laps

    Nei{tk 342 Ihfdah mkaz,lap fn ikf,zaiieoi acze~ezu/ Zmk lap tk~kahs a meim jkitkk fn

    ikf,zaiieoi acze~ezu eo Oftzm Alkteca( K{tfpk aoj A{sztahasea d{z a l{cm hfykt

    ntkq{kocu eo fzmkt patzs fn zmk ihfdk/

    Nei{tk 332 Mkaz,lap fn zf{tesl eo K{tfpk aoj Anteca/ Ukhhfy eojecazks a meim hk~kh fn

    zf{tesl/ Tkj eojecazks a lfjktazk hk~kh fn zf{tesl/ Dh{k tkptkskozs a hfy hk~kh fn

    zf{tesl/ Zmk sctepz {skj zf ikoktazk zmes lap es daskj fo aoahuses fn elaiks {phfajkj zf

    Paoftalea -mzzp2&&yyy/paoftalef/cfl&% aoj zagks eozf accf{oz zmk o{ldkt fn pmfzfs

    aoj a{zmfts zmktk atk eo kacm tkspkcze~k tkiefo/

    http://www.panoramio.com/http://www.panoramio.com/http://www.panoramio.com/http://www.panoramio.com/
  • 7/31/2019 An Evaluation of the Utility of Crowd Sourcing in Species Biodiversity Management

    48/57

    Bfoazmao LcHazcmek

    :=

    Nei{tk 3:2 Mkaz,lap fn zf{tesl eo Oftzm Alkteca/ Ukhhfy eojecazks a meim hk~kh fnzf{tesl/ Tkj eojecazks a lfjktazk hk~kh fn zf{tesl/ Dh{k tkptkskozs a hfy hk~kh fn

    zf{tesl/ Zmk sctepz {skj zf ikoktazk zmes lap es daskj fo aoahuses fn elaiks {phfajkj zf

    Paoftalea -mzzp2&&yyy/paoftalef/cfl&% aoj zagks eozf accf{oz zmk o{ldkt fn pmfzfs

    aoj a{zmfts zmktk atk eo kacm tkspkcze~k tkiefo/

    Nei{tk 3;2 Mkaz,lap fn zf{tesl eo Itkkohaoj/ Ukhhfy eojecazks a meim hk~kh fn zf{tesl/

    Tkj eojecazks a lfjktazk hk~kh fn zf{tesl/ Dh{k tkptkskozs a hfy hk~kh fn zf{tesl/ Zmk

    sctepz {skj zf ikoktazk zmes lap es daskj fo aoahuses fn elaiks {phfajkj zf Paoftalea-mzzp2&&yyy/paoftalef/cfl&% aoj zagks eozf accf{oz zmk o{ldkt fn pmfzfs aoj a{zmfts

    zmktk atk eo kacm tkspkcze~k tkiefo/

    http://www.panoramio.com/http://www.panoramio.com/http://www.panoramio.com/http://www.panoramio.com/http://www.panoramio.com/http://www.panoramio.com/http://www.panoramio.com/http://www.panoramio.com/
  • 7/31/2019 An Evaluation of the Utility of Crowd Sourcing in Species Biodiversity Management

    49/57

  • 7/31/2019 An Evaluation of the Utility of Crowd Sourcing in Species Biodiversity Management

    50/57

    Bfoazmao LcHazcmek

    ;0

    Paojas ma~k ahsf dkko capz{tkj az zmk Oazefoah Patg eo Yasmeoizfo( [SA/ Imateahs ma~k dkko

    pmfzfitapmkj eo a rff eo Ntaock/ Aseao yehj jfis ma~k dkko pmfzfitapmkj eo rffs eo Zftfozf

    -Caoaja% aoj Iktlaou aoj eo zmk [oezkj Geoijfl/ Itkko,cmkkgkj pattfzs ma~k dkko

    pmfzfitapmkj eo a rff eo Ehheofes -[SA%/

    Ao ajjezefoah ptfdhkl pktzaeos zf zmk nacz zmaz sflk fn zmk elaiks fo Nhecgt tkptkskoz atzeszec

    jesphaus ft l{sk{l k}medezs/ Nft k}alphk( fok pmfzf fo Nhecgt jesphaus a lf{ozkj zeikt mkaj eo

    zmk Oaz{tah Scekock Tkskatcm Hadftazftu az zmk L{sk{l fn Zk}as Zkcm [oe~ktsezu/ Zmktk es ahsf

    a pmfzf fn a sz{nnkj zeikt az zmk Dtejpftz L{sk{l fo Sf{zm Sztkkz eo Dtejpftz( Koihaoj/

    Selehathu( pmfzfs fn aImateah sg{hh ma~k dkko pmfzfitapmkj az zmk Slezmsfoeao l{sk{l fn

    oaz{tah meszftu eo Yasmeoizfo J/C/

    A n{tzmkt ptfdhkl tkhazks zf casks ymktk zmk salk aoelah mas dkko pmfzfitapmkj lftk zmao

    fock( ahzmf{im ntkq{kocu fn fcc{ttkock hegkhu cfttkhazks yezm zmk ntkq{kocu fn ao ftiaoesl dkeoi

    pmfzfitapmkj/ Zmes ptfdhkl patzec{hathu pktzaeos( mfyk~kt( zf zmfsk eoszaocks ymktk aoelahs atk

    ptkskoz eo rffs/ Eonftlazefo ntfl Nhecgt( zmktknftk( smf{hj dk {skj fohu zf kh{cejazk

    defikfitapmecah sptkaj fn a ie~ko za}a( d{z lau ofz dk kozetkhu tkheadhk yezm tkspkcz zf

    jkzktleoeoi zmk ntkq{kocu fn a spkceks eo a ie~ko madezaz/ Lftkf~kt( ofz ahh fn zmk pmfzfs fo

    Nhecgt ma~k dkko apptfpteazkhu ikf,zaiikj s{cm zmaz zmket hfcazefo cao dk tkajehu ejkozenekj/

    Aofzmkt smftzcfleoi es zmk fccasefoah fcc{ttkock fn les,kozktkj jaza/ Spkhheoi leszagks eo

    spkceks oalks ahsf fcc{t fo Nhecgt/ Lftkf~kt( zmk cfllfo oalks fn spkceks atk lftk hegkhu zf

    dk gofyo zmao zmket scekozenec oalks( aoj zmes hkajs zf sflk fn zmk jaza dkeoi flezzkj ntfl zmk

    jeszted{zefo laps/ Ptk~ef{s tkskatcm mas tkpftzkj zmaz 90+ fn ahh ikftknktkockj elaiks

    aoahurkj eoch{jk spkcenec phack oalk zais( -Mfhhkoszkeo aoj P{t~ks( 4010%/ Zmk naeh{tk zf ikf,

    zai elaiks {phfajkj zf Nhecgt es aofzmkt naczft zmaz tks{hzs eo zmk flessefo fn jaza ntfl

    jeszted{zefo laps/

    Kttfts cao ahsf fcc{t ymko hfoiez{jk aoj hazez{jk cf,ftjeoazks atk tk~ktskj( ft ymko a hfoiez{jk

    es kttfokf{shu tkcftjkj as dkeoi ntfl zmk Ykszkto( tazmkt zmao zmk Kaszkto( Mklespmktk -ft ~eck

    ~ktsa%/ Zmes appkats zf dk a ptfdhkl ofz fohu nft Nhecgt d{z ahsf nft IDEN/ Nft k}alphk( zmk

  • 7/31/2019 An Evaluation of the Utility of Crowd Sourcing in Species Biodiversity Management

    51/57

    Bfoazmao LcHazcmek

    ;1

    pmuhfikfitapmec lap ptfj{ckj nft IDEN smfys zmk {ohegkhu ptkskock fn pfhat dkats eo

    La{teze{s/ Zmes appkats zf tks{hz ntfl a syezcmeoi fn zmk IPS cf,ftjeoazks/ Zmk cf,ftjeoazks

    ie~ko du IDEN

    -mzzp2&&jaza/iden/fti&fcc{ttkocks&skatcmYezmZadhk/mzl6cW0\/s435:16szatz

  • 7/31/2019 An Evaluation of the Utility of Crowd Sourcing in Species Biodiversity Management

    52/57

    Bfoazmao LcHazcmek

    ;4

    :/3 Es Zmktk a Deas Aiaeosz Tkiefos yezm Hfy Zf{tesz Eozktksz6

    Zmk zf{tesl mkaz laps tk~kah selehat pazzktos zf zmk ikf,zaiieoi mkaz lap/ Zmes taesks zmk

    q{kszefo fn ymkzmkt pmfzfitapms fo Nhecgt atk zagko pteocepahhu du zf{teszs as fppfskj zf

    tksejkozs( zm{s taeseoi zmk pfssedehezu fn ukz a n{tzmkt pfzkozeah salpheoi deas/ Fok yau fn zkszeoi

    zmes es zf k}aleok pmfzfs zmaz ma~k dkko zagko eo a tkiefo yezm a meim hk~kh fn ikf,zaiieoi

    acze~ezu tkhaze~k zf zmk s{ttf{ojeoi ~eceoezus{cm as Gkoua/ Nft Nhecgt {skts ymf ma~k

    cfozted{zkj zf zmk Kocuchfpakjea fn Henk -KFH% itf{p( Nhecgt ptfj{cks a lap eojecazeoi ymktk

    eo zmk yfthj zmku ma~k zagko pmfzfs/ Zmes cao dk {skj zf lagk eonktkocks adf{z zmk {skts hegkhu

    phack fn tksejkock/ Pktnftleoi zmes aoahuses tk~kahs zmaz ahh fn zmk Nhecgt {skts ymf ma~k zagko

    pmfzfs eo Gkoua aoj ymf ma~k cfozted{zkj zf zmk KFH itf{p( nft ymecm ez es pfssedhk du zmes

    lkzmfj zf jesckto a hegkhu hfcazefo fn tksejkock( jf ofz he~k eo Gkoua/ [skt Ja~ej jF

    -mzzp2&&yyy/nhecgt/cfl&pmfzfs&ja~ejVf&lap&accksskj 04&0=&4014% es hegkhu tksejkoz eo zmk

    Okzmkthaojs7 Sata.Bfacmel -mzzp2&&yyy/nhecgt/cfl&pmfzfs&sataVbfacmel&lap&accksskj

    04&0=&4014% eo Sf{zm Anteca7 Ged{u{ -mzzp2&&yyy/nhecgt/cfl&pmfzfs&ja~ejduifzz&lap&

    accksskj 04&0=&4014% eo Aterfoa( [SA7 Seyehj

    -mzzp2&&yyy/nhecgt/cfl&pmfzfs&slezmsfoeaoyehj&lap&accksskj 04&0=&4014% eo Paoala( [SA7

    H{jf~ec Methelaoo -mzzp2&&yyy/nhecgt/cfl&pmfzfs&hmethelaoo&lap&accksskj 04&0=&4014% eo

    Iktlaou7 aoj Ajaj{ezfgha -mzzp2&&yyy/nhecgt/cfl&pmfzfs&ajaj{ezfgha&lap&accksskj

    04&0=&4014% eo Lahausea/

    Lftkf~kt( seock jaza atk cfhhkczkj fppftz{oeszecahhu -Yehheals kz ah/( 4004%( ez es pfssedhk zmaz

    zmktk lau dk seioenecaoz spazeah deas( nft eoszaock eo na~f{t fn atkas eo chfsk ptf}elezu zf te~kt

    aoj tfaj okzyftgs -Cmaplao( 400;a%/ Zmktk es( lftkf~kt( a tkhazkj spazeah deas aiaeosz hkss

    pfp{hazkj tkiefos fn zmk yfthj/ Nft k}alphk( nei{tk 34 tk~kahs zmk fcc{ttkock fn ikf,zaiieoi

    acze~ezu eo Dtareh d{z ezs adskock eo zmk Alarfo B{oihk/ Zmes lagks zmk {sk fn Nhecgt sflkymaz

    hkss {skn{h eo zktls fn ejkozenueoi of~kh spkceks zmaz ma~k mezmktzf tklaeokj {ojfc{lkozkj/

    :/: Zmk Yau Nftyatj

    Kttft ptk~kozefo es l{cm cmkapkt aoj lftk knnecekoz zmao kttft cfttkczefo aoj chkaoeoi

    -Cmaplao( 400;d%/ Ofokzmkhkss( lkas{tks smf{hj dk jk~khfpkj zf kos{tk ptfpkt jaza ~ahejazefo

    aoj cfttkczefo nft elaiks {phfajkj zf Nhecgt aoj selehat elaik,smateoi nacehezeks/ Acmek~eoi zmes

    http://www.flickr.com/photos/david_o/map/http://www.flickr.com/photos/david_o/map/http://www.flickr.com/photos/david_o/map/http://www.flickr.com/photos/sara_joachim/map/http://www.flickr.com/photos/sara_joachim/map/http://www.flickr.com/photos/sara_joachim/map/http://www.flickr.com/photos/davidbygott/map/http://www.flickr.com/photos/davidbygott/map/http://www.flickr.com/photos/davidbygott/map/http://www.flickr.com/photos/smithsonianwild/map/http://www.flickr.com/photos/smithsonianwild/map/http://www.flickr.com/photos/smithsonianwild/map/http://www.flickr.com/photos/lhirlimann/map/http://www.flickr.com/photos/lhirlimann/map/http://www.flickr.com/photos/lhirlimann/map/http://www.flickr.com/photos/adaduitokla/map/http://www.flickr.com/photos/adaduitokla/map/http://www.flickr.com/photos/adaduitokla/map/http://www.flickr.com/photos/adaduitokla/map/http://www.flickr.com/photos/lhirlimann/map/http://www.flickr.com/photos/smithsonianwild/map/http://www.flickr.com/photos/davidbygott/map/http://www.flickr.com/photos/sara_joachim/map/http://www.flickr.com/photos/david_o/map/
  • 7/31/2019 An Evaluation of the Utility of Crowd Sourcing in Species Biodiversity Management

    53/57

    Bfoazmao LcHazcmek

    ;3

    ifah tkq{etks zmk ejkozenecazefo fn cfllfo ca{sks fn kttft aoj {zehereoi zmes gofyhkjik zf lfjenu

    aoj elptf~k zmk ptfckj{tk fn jaza koztu -Cmaplao( 400;a%( eo ajjezefo zf ejkozenueoi eoszaocks

    fn kttft nft jaza ahtkaju kozktkj aoj cfttkczeoi zmfsk ejkozenekj kttfts -Lahkczec aoj Latc{s(

    4000%/ Ez mas dkko s{iikszkj zmaz( {ohkss ajkq{azk ptk~kozefo lkas{tks ma~k dkko zagko( ao kttft

    tazk fn 1,;+ es k}pkczkj -Tkjlao( 155>%/ Neojeoi aoj cfttkczeoi kttfokf{s tkcftjs cao dk

    zkjef{s aoj zelk cfos{leoi -Yehheals kz ah/( 4004% d{z ez es a zasg fn itkaz elpftzaock/ Zmk

    tks{hzs fn zmes papkt eojecazk zmaz elptfpkt koztu fn spazeah pfsezefo jaza aoj za}a ejkozenecazefo

    atk alfoi zmk sf{tcks fn kttft eo koztu fn spkceks,fcc{ttkock jaza/ Zmk hazzkt cazkiftu fn kttft

    cf{hj dk seioenecaozhu tkj{ckj en zffhs( s{cm as khkcztfoec za}a gkus( yktk jk~khfpkj zf aej za}a

    ejkozenecazefo/ Heszs fn spkceks oalks nft jennktkoz za}foflec cazkifteks aoj ikfitapmecah tkiefos

    ma~k ahtkaju dkko jk~khfpkj( aoj knnftzs ma~k dkko lajk zf cazahfi{k zmksk eozf a ihfdah eojk}

    -Ntfksk aoj Desdu( 4014%/

    Nft appatkoz spazeah kttfts ateseoi ntfl les,kozktkj hfoiez{jeoah aoj hazez{jeoah cf,ftjeoazks(

    cfttkczefo lau dk pfssedhk du lkaos fn ahzkteoi zmk seio -e/k/ oftzmkto ~s/ sf{zmkto mklespmktk%

    ft du syezcmeoi hfoiez{jeoah aoj hazez{jeoah cf,ftjeoazks/

    :/; Cfoch{sefos2 Zmk ^ah{k fn Ctfyj Sf{tceoi as a Sf{tck fn Defje~ktsezu Eonftlazefo

    Zkcmofhfiu aj~aocks ma~k dkko ejkozenekj as fok fn zmk labft tkasfo nft chelazk cmaoik/

    Etfoecahhu( as es meimheimzkj eo zmes papkt( ptfpkthu matoksskj zkcmofhfiu annftjs a labft

    fppftz{oezu zf assesz eo cazahfieoi aoj lfoezfteoi zmk knnkczs fo spkceks/ Ie~ko zmk scahk aoj

    spkkj fn cmaoik zf zmk ihfdah ko~etfolkoz( zmk elpftzaock fn {zehereoi zmksk tksf{tcks es fn

    labft seioenecaock/

    Zmk laeo cmahhkoiks eo {zehereoi zmk ctfyj sf{tceoi atk7

    a/ Zkcmofhfiu es oky aoj kathu itklheos ma~k zf dk ejkozenekj aoj ne}kj/ d/ IPS koadhkj calktas kzc/ atk ptkjfleoazkhu annftjkj du eoje~ej{ahs eo ykahzmekt patzs fn

    zmk yfthjzmk jklfitapmec fn Nhecgt {skts es cktzaeohu ofz tkptkskozaze~k fn zmk ihfdah

    sez{azefo/ Ez es fd~ef{s ntfl nei{tk 34 zmaz zmk ntkq{kocu fn {sk eo lasse~k haoj lassks

    s{cm as zmk Alarfo b{oihk atk cfosejktadhu hkss zmao eo {tdao atkas -ukz zmk taeonftksz

    atkas atk zmk lfsz kojaoiktkj aoj ahsf cfozaeo zmk meimksz ~atekzu fn ejkozenekj aoj

  • 7/31/2019 An Evaluation of the Utility of Crowd Sourcing in Species Biodiversity Management

    54/57

    Bfoazmao LcHazcmek

    ;:

    {oejkozenekj spkceks/ Zmes cfeocejks yezm a ykagokss eo IDEN eoasl{cm as s{cm

    elpftzaoz cf{ozteks s{cm as Dtareh aoj Dfhe~ea atk ofz patzecepazeoi cf{ozteks/

    c/ Ez es ofz ukz az a szaik ymktk hadkheoi cao jesckto ymkzmkt zmk spkceks es eo ezs oaz{tahmadezaz( eo a rff ft jesphaukj du a za}ejktlesz/ Zmes lau dk elptf~kj du nehzkteoi f{z

    ctkaz{tks mkhj eo rff aoj l{sk{l hfcazefos/ Zmktk atk ahsf ejkozenecazefo ess{ks s{cm as

    zmaz meimheimzkj adf~k( aoj jfc{lkozkj du Szannftj kz ah/( -4010% tkiatjeoi spkceks fn

    d{ldhk dkks/

    j/ Zmk pfssedhk salpheoi deas ca{skj du zmk ptfpkosezu nft pmfzfitapms fo Nhecgt zf dkzagko hatikhu du zf{teszs tazmkt zmao tksejkozs/

    k/ Zmk f~kthap dkzykko IDEN aoj Nhecgt es jeszftzkj nft kojaoiktkj spkceks/ Zmes es j{k zfzmk ckhkdtezu szaz{s accftjkj zf s{cm ctkaz{tks s{cm as Ieaoz Paojas ymktkas zmk zadhks

    smfy seioenecaozhu itkazkt f~kthap nft ctkaz{tks zmaz atk fn hfykt p{dhec eozktksz/

    Seioenecaoz aj~aozaiks fn ctfyj sf{tceoi atk ahsf ejkozenekj du zmes papkt2

    a/ Ez es jklfctazec eo zmaz ez koiaiks lehhefos fn pkfphk zmtf{imf{z zmk yfthj/ Zmes esknnkcze~khu ntkk tkskatcm zf zmk scekozenec cfll{oezu/ Zmk lfze~azefo fn zaiieoi es

    cfosejktkj zf dk zyf,nfhj -e% nft zmk pktsfoah ftiaoesazefo fn zmk pmfzfitapmkt aoj -ee% as

    a sfceah cfozted{zefo nft zmk {sk fn zmk yejkt cfll{oezu -Alks aoj Oaalao( 4009%/

    d/ Ez eoszaozhu {phfajs zmk eonftlazefo aoj tkcftjs zmk zeleoi fn zmk tkcftj/ Zmes es aoelpftzaoz nkaz{tk eo cfleoi zf ao {ojktszaojeoi fn leitazefo aoj ko~etfolkozah elpacz/

    c/ Ez es ikoktahhu meim q{ahezu eo zktls fn ptkskozazefo aoj ymko cazahfieoi es acc{tazk( ez eskasehu nehkj aoj tkskatcmkj/

    Zmk nfhhfyeoi komaocklkozs aoj nehzkteoi lkas{tks cf{hj elptf~k zmk sez{azefo2

    1/ Nehzkteoi f{z ctkaz{tks aoj spkceks mkhj eo rffs( dfzaoec iatjkos( l{sk{ls -k/i/ sz{nnkjaoelahs% aoj tkskatcm kszadhesmlkozs/

    4/ Jeahfi{k yezm IPS aoj Nhecgt zkcmoeceaos yezm a ~eky zf kheleoazeoi zmksk gofyoptfdhkls/

    3/ As d{jikzs pktlez( jeszted{zefo fn IPS koadhkj calktas zf tksejkozs fn atkas fn patzec{hatd{z {ocf~ktkj atkas s{cm as b{oihk( jksktz ft atczec tkiefos/

  • 7/31/2019 An Evaluation of the Utility of Crowd Sourcing in Species Biodiversity Management

    55/57

    Bfoazmao LcHazcmek

    ;;

    :/ Taeseoi p{dhec ayatkokss fn zmk cfozted{zefo ptf~ejkj du pmfzfitapmkts {phfajeoi aojikf,zaiieoi elaiks/

    K~ejkozhu( yk atk fo a hkatoeoi c{t~k eo tkspkcz fn zmk apphecazefo fn aj~aockj zkcmofhfiu/ Ez es

    ahsf chkat zmaz zmktk es a pfzkozeah nft jeszftzefo fn tkcftjs aoj zmk hfoikt zmes ifks {ocmkcgkj( zmk

    matjkt ez yehh dk zf {ota~kh zmk klktieoi les{ojktszaojeois/ En ptfpkthu matoksskj yezm azzkozefo

    paej zf jkzaeh( zmes cao lagk a m{ik eojkoz zf zmk cazahfi{eoi( lfoezfteoi aoj {hzelazkhu zmk

    ptfzkczefo fn spkceks/ Ez yehh zagk a cfocktzkj knnftz fn zmk scekozenec( zkcmofhfiecah aoj pktmaps

    lftk elpftzaozhu( p{dhec cfll{oezeks zf aj~aock f{t ~ezah cflptkmkosefo fn defje~ktsezu/

    Hezktaz{tk Cezkj

    Alks( L/( . Oaalao( L/ -4009%/ Ymu Yk Zai2 Lfze~azefos nft Aoofzazefo eo Lfdehk aoj

    Foheok Lkjea/ CME 092 Ptfc/ SEICME cfonktkock fo M{lao Naczfts eo Cflp{zeoiSuszkls( pp/ 5915=0/

    Desdu( N/ A/ -4014%/ Zmk Q{ekz Tk~fh{zefo2 Defje~ktsezu Eonftlazecs aoj zmk Eozktokz/ Scekock(

    4305-4000%/

    Cmaplao( A/ J/ -400;a%/ Pteocephks aoj Lkzmfjs fn Jaza Chkaoeoi Ptelatu Spkceks aojSpkceks,Fcc{ttkock Jaza/Tkpftz nft zmk Ihfdah Defje~ktsezu Eonftlazefo Nacehezu(

    Cfpkomaiko/

    Cmaplao( A/ J/ -400;d%/ Pteocephks fn Jaza Q{ahezu/ Tkpftz nft zmk Ihfdah Defje~ktsezu

    Eonftlazefo Nacehezu( Cfpkomaiko/

    Cfhykhh( T/ G/( . Cfjjeoizfo( B/ A/ -155:%/ Kszelazeoi zkttkszteah defje~ktsezu zmtf{imk}ztapfhazefo/ Pmehfsfpmecah Ztaosaczefos -Tfuah Sfcekzu fn Hfojfo%( 3:;( 101,11=/

    Ctaojahh( J/( Dacgsztfl( H/( M{zzkohfcmkt( J/( . Ghkeodkti( B/ -4005%/ Lappeoi zmk Yfthjs

    Pmfzfs/ YYY/

    Ja~eks( O/( ^ehhadhaoca( N/ ]/( . Tfjktecg( I/ G/ -1555%/ Defeo~asefos fn zmk Lkjnhu Cktazezescapezaza2 Sf{tck Kszelazefo [seoi JOA Skq{kocks az L{hzephk Eoztfo Hfce/ Szazeszecs( 1;3(3;1,3>0/

    Kjyatjs( B/ H/ -4014%/ Eozktfpktadehezu fn Defje~ktsezu Jazadasks 2 Defje~ktsezu Eonftlazefo foK~ktu Jksgzfp/ Sfcekzu( 4314-4000%( 4314,431:/

  • 7/31/2019 An Evaluation of the Utility of Crowd Sourcing in Species Biodiversity Management

    56/57

    Bfoazmao LcHazcmek

    ;>

    Kedko( C/ D/( Sekikh( B/ D/( Dahk( B/ D/( Cffpkt( S/( Gmazed( N/( Smko( D/ Y/( Phaukts( N/( kz ah/-4014%/ Eoctkaskj Jekhs,Ahjktask acze~ezu zmtf{im dacgdfok tklfjkheoi i{ejkj du Nfhjez

    phaukts/Oaz{tk Defzkcmofhfiu( 30-4%( 150,154/ Oaz{tk P{dhesmeoi Itf{p/

    Nfoskca( J/ L/( Calpdkhh( S/( Ctaos( Y/ B/( Lfie( L/( Leuaie( E/( Zfla( Z/( D{hheaos( L/( kz ah/

    -1555%/ Akjks -Neohaua% bapfoec{s -Jepzkta2 C{hecejak%( a Okyhu Tkcfioerkj Lfsq{ezf eozmk [oezkj Szazks2 Aoahusks fn Ikokzec ^ateazefo eo zmk [oezkj Szazks aoj P{zaze~k Sf{tckPfp{hazefos/Bf{toah fn Lkjecah Kozflfhfiu( 3=-B{hu 155=%( 13;,1:>/

    Ntfksk( T/( . Desdu( N/ A/ -4014%/ Cazahfi{k fn Henk 4014/ Tkztek~kj ntfl

    mzzp2&&yyy/cazahfi{kfnhenk/fti&aoo{ah,cmkcghesz&

    Maus( B/( . Kntfs( A/ A/ -400=%/ EL4IPS2 kszelazeoi ikfitapmec eonftlazefo ntfl a seoihk

    elaik/ C^PT/

    Mfhhkoszkeo( H/( . P{t~ks( T/ S/ -4010%/ K}phfteoi phack zmtf{im {skt,ikoktazkj cfozkoz2 [seoi

    Nhecgt zais zf jksctedk cezu cftks/ Bf{toah fn Spazeah Eonftlazefo Scekock( 1( 41,:=/

    Gkookju( H/ -400=%/ Ikoktazeoi Je~ktsk aoj Tkptkskozaze~k Elaik Skatcm Tks{hzs nft

    Haojlatgs/ YYY/

    Lahkzec( B/ E/( . Latc{s( A/ -4000%/ Jaza Chkaoseoi2 Dkufoj Eozkitezu Aoahuses/ Ptfckkjeois fn

    zmk Cfonktkock fo Eonftlazefo Q{ahezu -EQ4000%( 400,405/

    Okhsfo( D/ Y/( Nkttketa( C/ A/ C/( Seh~a( L/ N/ ja( . Gayasge( L/ H/ -1550%/ Kojklesl ckoztks(tkn{iea aoj dfzaoecah cfhhkczefo jkosezu eo Dtareheao Alarfoea/Oaz{tk( 3:;( 91:,91>/

    Oudkti( F/ T/( . Oudkti( J/ -4001%/ L{sk{l cfhhkczefos fn lallahs cfttfdftazk zmkk}ckpzefoah jkcheok fn ptaetek madezaz eo zmk Cmecaif tkiefo/ Bf{toah fn Lallahfiu( =4-:%(5=:,554/

    Tajjecg( L/ B/( Iau( P/ H/( Heozfzz( C/ B/( Ma~ko( O/( . Srahau( A/ S/ -4010%/ Iaha}u Rff2K}phfteoi zmk Lfze~azefos fn Cezerko Scekock ^fh{ozkkts/ Asztfoflu Kj{cazefo Tk~eky(

    5-1%/

    Tkjlao( Z/ C/ -155>%/Jaza Q{ahezu nft zmk Eonftlazefo Aik/ Atzkcm Mf{sk Eoc/

    Saocmkr,Cftjktf( ^/( . Latzeokr,Lkukt( K/ -4000%/ L{sk{l spkcelko jaza ptkjecz ctfp

    jalaik du ztfpecah tfjkozs/ POAS( 59-13%( 909:,9099/

    Smannkt( M/ D/( Nesmkt( T/ O/( . Ja~ejsfo( C/ -155=%/ Zmk tfhk fn oaz{tah meszftu cfhhkczefos eojfc{lkozeoi spkceks jkcheoks/ Pfp{hazefo -Koihesm Kjezefo%( ;3:9-59%( 49,30/

    S{atkr( A/ ^/( Mfhyau( J/ A/( . Cask( Z/ B/ -4001%/ Pazzktos fn sptkaj eo defhfiecah eo~asefos

    jfleoazkj du hfoi,jeszaock b{lp jespktsah2 Eoseimzs ntfl Atikozeok aozs/ Ptfckkjeois fnzmk Oazefoah Acajklu fn Scekocks( 5=-3%( 14,1:/

  • 7/31/2019 An Evaluation of the Utility of Crowd Sourcing in Species Biodiversity Management

    57/57

    Bfoazmao LcHazcmek

    Szannftj( T/( Matz( A/ I/( Cfhheos( H/( Getgmfpk( C/ H/( Yehheals( T/ H/( Tkks( S/ I/( Hhfuj( B/ T/(kz ah/ -4010%/ K{,Sfceah Scekock2 Zmk Tfhk fn Eozktokz Sfceah Okzyftgs eo zmk Cfhhkczefo fn

    Dkk Defje~ktsezu Jaza/ Sfceah Okzyftgs( ;-14%/ jfe210/1391&bf{toah/pfok/001:3=1

    Yehheals( P/ M/( Lati{hks( C/ T/( . Mehdktz( J/ Y/ -4004%/ Jaza tkq{etklkozs aoj jaza sf{tcks

    nft defje~ktsezu pteftezu atka skhkczefo/ B/ Defsc/( 49-:%( 349,33=/

    Yeozktzfo( S/ H/( I{kg( M/ P/( . Dtffgs( S/ B/ -4014%/ A cmateslazec oky spkceks fn itkko

    hackyeoi jescf~ktkj eo Lahausea - Ok{tfpzkta ( Cmtusfpejak %2 zmk cfonh{kock fn cezerkoscekozesz ( foheok elaik jazadask aoj cudktza}foflu/ RffGkus( 41:( 1,11/

    Ukssfo( C/( Dtkykt( P/ Y/( S{zzfo( Z/( Caezmokss( O/( Pamya( B/ S/( D{tikss( L/( Itau( Y/ A/( kz

    ah/ -4009%/ Mfy Ihfdah Es zmk Ihfdah Defje~ktsezu Eonftlazefo Nacehezu6 IhfdahDefje~ktsezu( -11%/