What influences English and Mathematics attainment at age 11?Evidence from the EPPSE project

What is EPPSE?

EPPSE is the Effective Pre-School, Primary and Secondary Education Project.

It is a longitudinal study that has followed 2,500 children from the age of 3 through pre-school, primary and secondary school. It examines how pre-school, primary school and home background relate to children’s achievements and behaviour. EPPSE children were in primary schools from 1999-2007 (from age 3+ to age 11).

The children were regularly assessed on their development from the age of 3. There have been interviews with staff in pre-school and school, and assessments of the quality of pre-school and school environments.

There are five key influences on child development at age 11– Child characteristics e.g.

gender or birth weight.

– Family characteristics, e.g. parents education, home language.

– Learning opportunities in the home.

– Pre-school attendance and experience.

– Primary school experience.

Mathematics and English attainment at KS2

FamilyFactors

Learning at home

Primary School

Pre-School

Child Factors

Children’s characteristics and their family background predict their outcomes At age 11 girls did significantly better than boys in English, but boys did

somewhat better in mathematics.

Children with very low birth weight or early health problems did less well in English and mathematics than other children.

Mother’s education (especially a degree) had a strong positive effect on outcomes in English and mathematics, more so than family income or social class.

What children learn at home is crucial A good environment for learning at home (in the early years), compared to a

poor one, had a similar positive effect for children as having a mother with a degree. Learning at home was particularly important for English.

Parents who provided a good environment for learning at home taught their children specific skills e.g. letter-sound relationships and improved language and vocabulary.

– It included activities such as being read to; painting and drawing; going to the library; playing with letters/numbers and learning activities with songs, poems and nursery rhymes.

Parents tended to treat girls and boys differently. Overall girls had a better home learning environment.

Good pre-school experience makes a difference to children’s attainmentGood pre-school/nursery

– provided an initial boost to pre-reading and early number skills and also helped children progress when at primary school (possibly through developing children’s motivation and capacity to learn);

– pre-schools that helped children to understand early number concepts led to better outcomes in mathematics at 11.

Quality is important– going to any pre-school had benefits for children when they started primary

school, however, only higher quality pre-schools still had an impact on children’s attainment at age 11;

– higher quality pre-schools benefitted all children in primary school and gave a greater boost to development for the most disadvantaged.

Effective primary schools help to counter disadvantaged backgrounds Primary schools varied in the progress pupils made from KS1-KS2

– EPPSE pupils made better progress in English and mathematics in more academically effective1 primary schools;.

– children from highly disadvantaged backgrounds benefited most from attending an academically effective primary school – more so than their more advantaged peers.

The influence of primary school was more important for attainment and progress in mathematics than in English.

Good pre-school experiences offered some protection against poor educational experiences later.

– Attending a high quality pre-school offered some protection for children who went on to attend less academically effective primary school.

1 - A school’s academic effectiveness was measured through analysis of KS1 and 2 results for all schools in England taking account of background characteristics.

See related EPPSE Research Bite “Effective Teaching Methods in 82 Primary Schools” which examines the impact of teaching quality on pupils’ achievement and the teaching behaviours which have an impact on pupil outcomes.

English – the key factors influencing pupils’ attainment

Influences on KS2 English

0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

0.8

Mot

hers

edu

catio

n

Early

home l

earnin

g

Birth w

eight

Fathe

rs e

duca

tion

Family

socio

-eco

nom

ic sta

tus

Gende

r

Family

inco

me

Pre-s

choo

l qua

lity

Primar

y sch

ool e

ffect

ivene

ss

Early

developm

enta

l pro

blems

Home learn

ing d

uring

Prim

ary

Eff

ect

Siz

e

Child, family, and home background are more important in predicting differences in overall pupil’s attainment in English than in mathematics

Pre-school has a significant influence.

The effectiveness of the primary schools a child attends is also important. Pupils who have a combination of good quality pre-school and then attend a more effective primary school have better outcomes.

Effect size is a statistical concept that shows the strength of the relationship between an outcome such as National Assessment scores and another variable such as Mothers’ qualifications, while controlling for other factors. An effect size of 0.1 is relatively weak, one of 0.35 moderately strong, one of 0.7 strong.

Mathematics – the key factors influencing pupils’ attainment

Mothers’ education was still important but other home and family characteristics less so.

The quality of the pre-school and the effectiveness of the primary school a child attends are also both important for attainment in mathematics. They have  stronger effects than either gender or family socio-economic status. 

Effect size is a statistical concept that shows the strength of the relationship between an outcome such as National Assessment scores and another variable such as Mothers’ qualifications, while controlling for other factors. An effect size of 0.1 is relatively weak, one of 0.35 moderately strong, one of 0.7 strong.

Influences on KS2 Mathematics

0

0.1

0.2

0.3

0.4

0.5

0.6

0.7

0.8

Mot

hers

edu

catio

n

Birth w

eight

Early

home l

earnin

g

Pre-s

choo

l varia

tion

Primar

y Sch

ool v

ariatio

n

Family

socio

-eco

nonic

statu

s

Fathe

rs e

duca

tion

Family

inco

me

Gende

r

Home learn

ing d

uring

Prim

ary

Early

developm

enta

l pro

blems

Eff

ect

size

How can you use the evidence in this study?

How do you support the learning of children who don’t receive much support for learning at home ?

How could you influence the experiences of children before they come to primary school?

– Can you work with your local pre schools that feed your primary (either based at school or elsewhere)?

How can you encourage more involvement of parents in children’s learning?– In the early years, and throughout primary school?

Authors and Further Reading Principal Investigators for the EPPSE project are: Kathy Sylva

(Oxford), Edward Melhuish (Birkbeck), Pam Sammons (Oxford), Iram Siraj-Blatchford & Brenda Taggart (IoE).

This Research Bite draws on the EPPSE report:

Influences on Children’s Attainment and Progress in Key Stage 2: Cognitive Outcomes in Year 6

A short summary (Research Brief) which covers both cognitive and social/behavioural outcomes can be downloaded from the Department for Education website:

http://www.education.gov.uk/publications/eOrderingDownload/DCSF-RB048-049.pdf

The full report is also available:

https://www.education.gov.uk/publications/RSG/publicationDetail/Page1/DCSF-RR048

Further Information

EPPSE Website:

http://eppe.ioe.ac.uk

Or contactBrenda Taggart

Principal Investigator and Research Co-ordinator00 44 (0) 207 612 6219b.taggart@ioe.ac.uk