thinkoutsideyourself.weebly.comthinkoutsideyourself.weebly.com/uploads/3/7/3/1/37318033/scan_… ·...
TRANSCRIPT
1
Executive SummaryThere is a common problem of confusing shopping lists, causing family
members to buy unnecessary grocery products, wasting money and eventually
throwing out food. Scan & Plan is a physical scanner and connected app that gives a
family the value of complete control of their dietary intake, spending analysis,
simultaneously minimizing their shopping time. The Scan & Plan is for busy health
conscious families with several children. Compared to the solutions on the market,
Scan & Plan fills the market gap with its convenience, family integration, nutritional
and financial breakdown.
The Scan & Plan’s scanner consists of a custom wireless Bluetooth scanner, an
LED light and suction cups. The Scan & Plan App is compatible with all of the family’s
smart devices. It includes the family’s shopping list and the dietary and spending
analysis from the past time period. Additional App functions are the manual item
insert, individual nutritional breakdown.
Distribution channels for the Scan & Plan include the stores Williams-Sonoma,
Kitchen Kapers, Bed Bath & Beyond, as well as the company's website. Promotion for
the product will include print advertisements, social media, trade shows and store
tours.
The initial investment for the 90-day trial period of Scan & Plan would require
$42,000, which would allow the company to evaluate the market response to the
product. Sales of the Scan & Plan will begin in the second quarter, with a quarterly
growth rate of 10% for the first year. The company will break-even in the second
quarter, after producing 2,730 total units. The initial investment required for launching
the product is $190,000 and after a full year of operation the company will reach
positive cash flow of $250,000.
2
Table of Contents
Topic Page Number
Executive Summary...............................................................................................2
List of Figures........................................................................................................5
List of Tables.........................................................................................................6
Acknowledgements...............................................................................................7
Introduction............................................................................................................8
Project Team Description & Individual Pictures..........................................8
Company & Industry Background.............................................................10
Mission Statement....................................................................................11
Business Goals and Objectives................................................................11
Positioning Statement...............................................................................11
Research.............................................................................................................12
Competitive Benchmarking.......................................................................12
Customer Needs.......................................................................................14
Description of Design Concepts..........................................................................17
Scanner Concept......................................................................................17
App Concept.............................................................................................17
Technical Feasibility............................................................................................18
Scanner Solution and Descriptions...........................................................18
Scanner Features.....................................................................................20
App Solution.............................................................................................21
Technology Background...........................................................................21
App Functions Description........................................................................22
Bill of Materials.........................................................................................24
Financial Feasibility.............................................................................................26
Marketing Phase 1 & 2 Plan.....................................................................26
Distribution & Sales..................................................................................27
Scan & Plan Pricing Strategy....................................................................28
Sales Projections & Financial Assumptions..............................................29
3
Financial Phase 1 Plan.............................................................................30
Financial Phase 2 Plan.............................................................................31
Cash Flow Analysis..................................................................................32
Potential Funding Sources........................................................................32
Conclusions and Recommendations...................................................................33
Summary Description...............................................................................33
Future Work..............................................................................................34
4
List of Figures
Figure Number Title Page Number
1 Current Solution - list...........................................................12
2 Current Solution – Out of Milk.............................................12
3 Amazon Dash......................................................................13
4 Market Survey.....................................................................16
5 Market Survey ....................................................................16
6 Market Survey.....................................................................16
7 CAD Potential Scanner.......................................................18
8 Reverse Engineering...........................................................19
9 Barcode Example................................................................21
10 Scan & Plan App.................................................................22
11 Nutrition Label.....................................................................22
12 Scan & Plan Website...........................................................26
13 Health Magazine.................................................................27
14 Best Buy Logo.....................................................................27
15 Cash Flow Analysis.............................................................32
5
List of Tables
Table Number Title Page Number
Table 1 Conceptual Map………………………………………………..14
Table 2 Bill of Materials....................................................................25
Acknowledgements
6
• Pat J. Costa , Professor
• Nigel Corea, TA
• Other TAs
- Rachael Freedman- Alex Frankel- Emily Furiga- Stacy Sawin- Jason Kravec- Michael Meehan- Kyle Ferdinando- Stephanie Porter- Paul Miyashita- Piotr Wojnarowski- Trevor Verdonik
• Professor Huang, CSE Department
• Professor Dong, Marketing Department
• Professor Ehrig, Management Department
• Professor Dimitrova, Marketing Department
• Ann Padjen, Lawyer
• Matt S., Sales Associate at Barcode Inc.
• Adam B., Salesperson at Bed Bath & Beyond
• Tony Sanna, Salesperson at H.H. Gregg
• Anthony, Salesperson at BestBuy
• Brian, Salesperson at Amazon
• Kathryn Bisson, Representative from Zco Corporation
7
Company & Industry Background
Scan & Plan was designed by five undergraduate students enrolled in the
Integrated Business and Engineering Program at Lehigh University. The main focus of
Scan and Plan is to provide a more convenient, family integrated, and nutritionally and
financially beneficial solution for grocery shopping. No solution on the market right now
offers families the health and financial benefits or convenience that Scan and Plan
offers. Most competitors offer apps that create shopping lists, however, by using the
scanner on your phone, their solutions are time consuming and not convenient. Our
closest competitor utilizes a physical scanner with an app, however it doesn’t offer
nutritional or financial benefits. We are mindful of the difficulties incurred when a family
member shops for groceries. We understand the miscommunication and disorganization
brought by grocery shopping and we want to help alleviate the problems families
experience because of grocery shopping. We are also fully aware of the growing familial
concerns for nutrition and budgeting.
The Scan & Plan targets busy families who are nutritionally and financially
conscious. Through extensive research, we concluded that the market for Scan and
Plan spans to 12 million households in the country, which consists of parents ages 25-
55 with 2-3 children ages 6-17. Out of the 170 people in our target market who were
surveyed, 76% of them said that an app would be useful for shopping. Also, from
interviewing several parents, we learned that parents would want a solution that can
connect their family while tracking their nutrition and financial spending. From our entire
market research, we decided to create a product with a physical barcode scanner,
located in the kitchen, that would connect to an app that the entire family would have
that would track the family’s nutrition and grocery spending.
8
Mission Statement
“To help the busy family maintain a healthier lifestyle, save time and money while
shopping, and seamlessly fit into the everyday kitchen routine.”
Business Goals and Objectives
To offer a simple way for families observe dietary habits and grocery spending
To simplify the grocery shopping experience
To eliminate misunderstanding and confusion with grocery shopping
To integrate with the busy family’s lifestyle
Positioning Statement
Our goal as a company is to better the lives of our customers. We strive to push
the busy health conscious family with several children to a healthy lifestyle. We want
to simplify the process of tracking dietary intake, creating a spending analysis and
minimizing the amount of time families spend shopping. Our solution easily and
conveniently fits into any kitchen and connects with any smart device, giving families
the benefit of value of complete control of their shopping and related financial and
dietary information.
9
Research and Specifications
Competitive Benchmarking
The status quo is that families use the pencil
and paper solution to create their shopping list. When
someone in the family wants something from the
grocery store or when the family runs out of a product,
that person will add it to the shopping list. Whoever
goes grocery shopping will then take the list when
he/she goes shopping for the family. However, this
solution comes with many problems. First, everyone in
the house will have different handwritings so whoever
goes shopping may not be able to read the list.
Furthermore, each family member doesn’t always have the list. For example, if the
dad is out shopping and the mother writes down something on the list, the dad doesn’t
have the new list so he can’t buy that grocery item. Additionally, the items on the list
are not organized by food category, making shopping more time consuming.
After figuring out the target market and the customer
needs that our solution would have to address, we looked at
the current solutions that are on the market. We realized that
there were countless apps that are currently out there that try to
make grocery shopping a better process. However, we wanted
to look at the apps that were the most similar to our product.
The first solution that we looked at was the “Out of Milk” app. This app, which is
a free app, is for Android and IOS devices. It uses the scanner on the smartphone to
identify products and create a shopping list. The app also uses cloud based
10
Figure 2
Figure 1
technology to share information between smartphones in the same household. The
strengths of the app is that it’s family integrated because it lets family members all see
the same shopping list on every smart device in the family. It also estimates the costs
of goods, so it’s financially beneficial, and it lets the user manually add products onto
the list in case an item doesn’t have a barcode. The app, though, is not convenient
being that in order to use it, you always have to have your phone on you. If you want
to add an item to your shopping list, you have to first take out your phone then open
the app then scan the product. Besides this being a long process, your hands may be
dirty when you’re in the kitchen and you may not want to touch your phone. The app
also doesn’t offer any nutritional benefits.
The second solution that we researched was the “Grocery IQ” app. It’s also a
free app for Android and IOS devices that uses cloud based technology that allows
families to have the same information on each of their smart devices. Like the Out of
Milk app, it also utilizes the smart device scanner technology to create shopping lists.
Moreover, Grocery IQ uses your location services to find out which grocery stores are
near you and offer you coupons and promotions to these stores. The app is family
oriented because it lets everyone in your household view the same shopping list and
add items to the list. Just like the Out of Milk app, Grocery IQ is not convenient. The
app also doesn’t track your spending or your nutritional intake.
We also looked at the product,
“Amazon Dash.” This is a physical
scanner that connects to your “Amazon
Fresh” account. Once you scan an item
that you are out of, the dash puts that item on your Amazon Fresh shopping list.
Amazon then delivers all the items on the shopping list to your house. This costs $299
11
Figure 3
a year to be a member of and currently only exists in a few parts of California. This is
convenient because it is a physical scanner that can be used easily at any time. This
product is also family oriented because anyone in the family can sign into the family’s
Amazon Fresh account on any device to view the shopping list. However, the Dash
doesn’t analyze your family’s spending or nutritional intake. Another downside of the
Dash is that the items that Amazon Fresh delivers to your house are 14% more
expensive than those same items would be in the average grocery store.
By looking at all
of the products out
there that attempt to
solve the grocery
shopping problems that
families deal with, we
realized that there is a
gap in the market. No
one solution in the market right now is convenient, family integrated, financially
beneficial, and nutritionally beneficial. This allows us to capitalize on the current
market gap as shown in the conceptual map.
Customer Needs
After extensive research through surveys, interviews, and visiting stores like
Best Buy, HH Gregg, Bed Bath & Beyond, and the Architectural Digest Home Design
Show, we were able to figure out that our solution would have to address the following
customer needs:
12
Table 1 : Conceptual Map
Family Integrated
Nutritionally Beneficial
Financially Beneficial
Convenient
When we visited HH Gregg, we spoke to Tony Sanna, who told us, “People like
their home products to be technologically integrated.” When we were speaking to him,
he told us that the market for technologically integrated home appliances is increasing
rapidly. He said that people now want smart fridges and smart washers/dryers
because they connect to a family’s smart devices. We learned from this that families
want their home appliances to be conveniently integrated with their family members
and with their smart devices.
We also interviewed several parents. Bruce Altmark, for example, said, “My family
would really benefit from something that can help us observe our grocery spending.”
Another father, Stanley Weber, said, “I want something that can connect my family
and track our nutritional habits together.” From speaking to these parents, we
realized that our solution would also have to be financially and nutritionally beneficial.
Stanley in particular helped us realize the importance of our solution being family
integrated. If a family is going to become healthier, they will need to do so together.
Stanley said that in the past it was hard for him to be the only one dieting because his
family would eat dinners that are unhealthy, making him eat separately.
13
We also conducted a survey on SurveyMonkey. Of the 170 responses we
received, 76% of the people said that an app would be useful for their shopping, as
shown in Figure 6. 98% of the people also said that they would forget to buy an item
while shopping, as shown in Figure 7. Furthermore, Figure 8 shows that 92% of
people went grocery shopping at least once a week. Being that these people shop so
often, and 98% of them forget items while shopping, we saw that grocery shopping is
a large issue for many households.
14
Figures 4, 5, 6
Description of Design Concepts
Scanner Concept
A home bar code scanner connected to an app that remained in the kitchen
would provide the most convenience for our target market. Busy families found
scanning based apps like the Out of Milk to be inconvenient to take their phone out
every time they wanted to scan an item. Furthermore, the research at Architectural
Digest Home Design Show in New York City identified the wide range of kitchen styles
and the appliances in the kitchen. The design show made it clear that the scanner
had to be small to prevent additional clutter and to easily find its “place” in every
kitchen style. Next, the daily kitchen routine is busy and can lead to the scanner being
dropped, bumped, water damaged, or food damaged. The scanner must be durable
enough to sustain any kind of fall from kitchen counters and other kitchen hazards.
Lastly, the scanner had to be compatible with all smart devices. The coding language
behind iOS systems, android systems, tablets, and computers can vary. The
information the scanner reads needs to be processed by the wide range of devices so
the target market isn’t limited to people with specific smart devices.
App Concept
An app that processed and compiled the received information from the scanner
would provide our target market with easy and convenient access to their grocery
information. The app should be shared amongst all family members to prevent the
occurrence of multiple shopping lists. In addition, from the market research, families
expressed a need to track nutrition and grocery spending. Parents have a lot of
responsibilities like working, driving their children around, cooking, cleaning, and many
more, which limits the time they have to monitor their family’s diets and spending. The
app should help families track their health and spending on grocery items in a 15
convenient way that does not require a significant time requirement or input from the
families.
Solution Scanner
The team proposed a bar code
scanner designed similar to Figure 7.
The dimensions are similar to that of an
iPhone being five inches in length by two
and half inches in height by half inch in
width. The front screen in Figure 7 is the compartment for the lasers required for the
device to scan bar codes with dimensions of about two and half inches in length by
one and half inches in height. The large surface area for the laser enables the bar
code to be read in a variety of orientations as advised by Tech Experts of Barcode
Inc., a manufacturer of bar code scanners. The alternative method for reading the bar
code would have been photo recognition software which is what competitors like Out
of Milk and Grocery IQ use. Although a camera would require a smaller surface area
than lasers, the recognition speed is slower and orienting the products correctly in
front of the camera would be difficult without a display. In addition, the scanner would
require a stronger processor to process the pictures causing the need for a larger
power supply and for the dimensions to increase. Thus a laser scanner was chosen
to keep the design small and easy for consumers to use.
To avoid cluttering the kitchen and fitting into the variety of kitchen layouts, the
team decided that suctions cups on the back would enable consumers to decide
where the scanner best fit into their kitchen. The conclusion was drawn from reverse
engineering the Mighty Mug and the Architectural Digest Home Design Show in New
York City. The Mighty Mug is a mug that never falls over when bumped or pushed.
16
Figure 7
Since the scanner would be within a busy kitchen environment, it would be prone to
similar forces. The team reversed engineered the Mighty Mug to find a suction cup
resisted the applied forces. The team also discovered the suction cup enabled the
mug to be placed on a 90 degree plane as seen in Figure 8. However due to
modification done on the suction cup, the mug was unable to be placed on a plane
greater than 90 degrees. The ability to be placed on different angled planes became
a desired quality after the Architecture
Digest Home Design Show in New
York City. The show taught the team
that kitchen lay outs vary extremely,
thus making one universal location for
the scanner impossible. Therefore, the
suction cups ability to be placed on
different angled planes enables consumers the ability to choose the location for the
scanner. The refrigerator, flat counters, and trash cans were identified as sufficient
surfaces for suction that were common amongst all kitchens giving consumers a
variety of locations to choose from. As a result, the team concluded suction cups
provided the scanner the ability to be located in a wide range of locations within the
varying kitchen layouts and prevent the scanner from falling accidentally.
To make the scanner convenient for consumers, the information is wireless
sent to the Scan & Plan App to be processed and analyze. The team recognized the
issue with the Out of Milk app is the scanning and processing was done all on one
device such as an iPhone which is also used for several other tasks. The device to
scan products is not readily available making it inconvenient for consumers to use.
With the two separate and wirelessly connected, the scanner can remain in the
kitchen at all times ready to go with the information available on the Scan & Plan app
17
Figure 8
for customers to view. By also being wireless, the additional clutter and limitation of
location that would result from having a wire is eliminated.
Scanner Features
The team realized part of the scanning process is knowing when items are
successfully scanned. Typical retail store bar code scanners beep and display the
products name that was scanned. The team originally considered a similar alert
system, but a sales associate at Best Buy informed the team that customers are
irritated by their home making increasingly more noises. Thus, a display alert system
would be used. The team decided a green LED would blink twice when a product was
scanned successfully. A LED is small enough not affect the design of the scanner and
efficient enough to alert the customer the product was scanned without irritating them.
Another key component of the scanner was battery life. Since the scanner was
to remain in the kitchen ready to go at all times and connected to Wi-Fi, the scanner
would be constantly consuming power. The team talked to a sales associate at Best
Buy about wireless connectivity learning Wi-Fi adapters were relatively small designs,
but were always connected to a larger power source. Devices such as iPhones,
though, are connected to a small power source that is recharged every few days. The
team also compared battery life to a wireless scanner with Bluetooth produced by
Coshine Group Corporation. The scanner was powered by four double A batteries
and had a battery life of 300 hours, but was only in use when users pressed the button
to activate the scanner. The team determined a sleep mode feature for the scanner
would save the necessary power to keep its small design, the scanner wireless, and
connected to Wi-Fi. The sleep mode feature would control when the scanner was on
and off through an inactive time log and a motion sensor. After a certain amount of
time of nothing being scanned, the scanner will switch into sleep mode. The green
18
LED on the front of the scanner will switch to blue so users know the device is in sleep
mode. To reactivate the scanner, a motion sensor will be on the front of the scanner.
When a user attempts to scan the barcode on a product, the motion sensor will pick
up the motion and turn the scanner back on, switching the blue LED to green. Further
tests would have to be conducted though to determine the optimal time of inactivity
until switching into sleep mode.
App Solution
An app is the best solution for displaying the data received from the scanner.
Consumers today are constantly connected through smartphones, tablets, and
computers allowing the app to be easily accessed. Based on the needs from our
target market, the team determined the app would focus on Shopping, Health, and
Budgeting.
Technology Background
Laser scanners read barcodes by emitting light at a certain frequency across
the barcode. The black bars absorb all light, while the white separation between black
bars is reflected back at the scanner. A photo diode receives the light bounced back
and from that is able to detect the separation and width of the black bars. Based on
the distances and width, a specific string of numbers called a Universal Product Code
(UPC), is created. Every product has a specific UPC associated with it, which
sometimes is located underneath the barcode as seen in Figure 9. For example, the
UPC for a Nature Valley Honey n’ Oats bar is
01600264694. Once the UPC is known the
scanner sends that number to the app to be
used to gather other product information.
19Figure 9
Shopping Section
The UPC is inputted in an online database like
UPCDatabase.com to produce a product description, in this case
Nature Valley 100% Natural Crunchy Granola Bars – Oats ‘N Honey.
With the description the app links to another database to determine
the food group it belongs to such as fruits, snacks, meats; etc. The
Nature Valley bar would be categorized as a snack. With the
description and category the app produces a simple list of product
names split into sections based on the food groups (Figure 10). The list is then
shared amongst family members to eliminate the use the creation of more than one
shopping list. When a user wishes to mark an item off the list, they touch the box
located next to the name and a check mark will be appear indicating the item is no
longer needed or wanted. For items without a barcode, users can manually input the
products name and category to add to the list. Lastly, to eliminate miscommunication
between family members, an “Out Shopping” button enables users to send a message
to everyone in their family notifying them that they are shopping. Family members can
go into the app and add desired items to the list allowing the person out shopping to
have a current list if everything their family needs.
Nutrition Section
The team found two different ways to retrieve the
nutrition facts of specific products. The first is using the
UPC in another online database like Scandit.com. The
second is using the description in a different online database
like platform.fatsecret.com. Both methods produce a
nutrition facts label like the one in Figure 11. The only
20
Figure 10
Figure 11
differences is the Application Programming Interface costs that each may require.
Further analysis by a software team would be required to determine effectiveness and
speed of both methods to make a decision. The nutrition facts label would be used to
categories foods into food groups such as fruits, grains, vegetables; etc and to create
an organized chart of a family’s consumption of each food group. The chart will
display percentages of each food group for users to read more easily. Each food
group can be selected to view the specific products that lie under the category. For
individual users that desire to monitor their own health, specific products can be
moved over into an individual section for users to see their own health.
Budgeting Section
To estimate the price of a product the UPC can be used to search another
online database like Scandit.com. Once the price is retrieved the data can be
organized into charts or graphs of spending per week, bi-weekly, monthly, and
annually. The information can be viewed on the app. When talking to families, it was
determined that most financials were reviewed at home at a computer. A connected
website to the app of the spending reports would be more convenient for the
consumers.
With the data of products users consume, the team determined the data could
be sold to a third party companies to enable companies to market directly towards
individuals with coupons for certain products. The coupons would help users save
while bringing in additional revenue for Scan & Plan. Coupons would be scan able
directly from the user’s phone or printable. The potential revenue was not accounted
for though in the financials because it was dependent on creating a user database
first.
21
Recommended Process Used
The team determined the most efficient way for consumers to use Scan & Plan is
to scan food products right before disposing or consuming them. By doing so, the app
compiles the information of products that are disposed creating a list of products that
need to be re-purchased and percentages of how healthy users have been. By
scanning the product before consumption, disposal, or products with no intention of
using the information provided in the shopping list and health section will be
inaccurate. Inaccurate information may lead to buying products that users already
possess, or invalid consumption information of food groups and or products. Products
should be scanned before consumption or disposal only if intended to consume or
dispose of the product within twenty four
Bill of Materials
The team called Coshine Group Co., Ltd, a bar code scanner manufacture to talk
about modifying the CT-20 Mini Portable Wireless Bluetooth Barcode Scanner. The
modifications included moving the lasers to the side, using Wi-Fi instead of Bluetooth,
removing buttons and installing a motion sensor. The company confirmed the feasibility
and gave the team a quote of $48.67. The team received an additional quote of $0.14
and $0.20 for implementing the suctions cups and LED in the scanner. The team also
called PAC Worldwide to discuss packaging costs for the specific dimensions of the
prototype scanner. The cost of packaging the scanner which was five inches in length
by two and half inches in height by half inch in width would be $2.46 through PAC
Worldwide. The total cost per unit is $51.48.
22
Component Material Company Price per unit
Wireless Bluetooth Barcode Scanner
Plastic Coshine Group Co., Ltd.
$48.67
Suction cup (x2) Plastic Coshine Group Co., Ltd.
$0.14
Green LED light Plastic Coshine Group Co., Ltd.
$0.20
Packaging Cardboard PAC Worldwide $2.46
Software Development
The team talked to Zco Corporation, a software development company, to
receive a quote on app development costs. The app would require access to several
databases meaning an Application Program Interfaces (API), a type of terms of use
contract, would be implemented with the database providers. The software for the app
would also have to be compatible with several types of smart devices. For the
proposed database API’s and app development, the team received a quote of $45,000
from Zco Corporations.
23
Table 2 : Bill of Materials
Financial Feasibility
Target Audience
Our target audience we found to be parents ages 25-55 with children ages 6-17.
To find this, we conducted research on Survey Money as well as real world eyeball to
eyeball communication. People in this demographic are busy, suffer from the problem
addressed, and are willing to spend money on a technologically advanced solution. In
order to first present the value of Scan & Plan to the market, we first had to organize
our strategy based on financials.
Marketing Phase 1
Scan & Plan costs around $51 to produce
resulting in a $112 wholesale price, $225
retail price, and $61 profit. To maintain this
cost we first wanted to run a 90 day “Phase
One Trial Period” to get Scan & Plan up and
running. In an effort to gain publicity in a cost
effective way, social media is the main focus. Twitter, Google AdWords, and
Facebook allows us to control our own media at around $450 for the first phase. A
website of our own (costing around $2,000 to start, $18,000 to update in the future,
and $7,000 to maintain) is the home of phase one sales. Another crucial component
of the first phase is a store tour. Our team would travel to 15 stores in 90 days and
put a face to our product at live demonstrations and launch parties. Bed Bath and
Beyond, Kitchen Kapers, and Williams-Sonoma would host us for a fee of $150/4hr
demo and we would give each store 100 units under consignment. At the end of the
trial period, the stores could give us feedback on how quickly the product moved off
24
Figure 12
the shelves allowing for adjustments in distribution. Along with
these sales, we predict 20 online sales through our website. Going
out into the stores where busy parents shop, we could communicate
with them in person and quickly make adjustments both to our engineering and
business plans.
Marketing Phase 2
The second phase of marketing promotion is under the assumption that the first 90
days was successful. We hope to invest a lot of time and money into “upping” our
current strategy and spreading Scan & Plan nationwide. Along with the continuation
of social media and store tours, we would visit two trade stores, each appealing to our
target market. The NBC Health and Wellness Expo in Washington DC is a two day
expo featuring the latest in heath related technology and products. The Dauphin
County Women’s Expo held locally in Hershey, PA appeals to everyday moms in our
target age range who would benefit from the value of Scan & Plan. Each show would
cost $6,000 to attend.
Magazines are the most costly and effective way to promote our product directly to
the client. Parenting, Health, and Working Mom are three magazines which we found
to be appropriate to advertise in. Reaching over 4.5 million readers every month, one
full page ad in each on a three month rotation would cost us $50,000 annually.
Distribution and Sales
Once proven successful, we wanted to imagine what a
successful year could look like. Revisiting the three stores
where demonstrations and consignment were held (Bed Bath
25
Figure 13
Figure 14
and Beyond, Kitchen Kapers, and Williams Sonoma) our distribution would first
prioritize with them. Next, we would add more technology based retailers such as
Best Buy, Sky Mall, and H.H. Gregg. We wanted to keep our numbers within reason
as not to get ahead of ourselves. Through financial analysis, we predict 108 units to
be sold per store (over 300 locations) starting in Q2. Website sales are also predicted
to increase to 650 in Q2 with an increase of 10% each quarter. These numbers
provide great confidence in our product and we believe that our marketing strategy will
enable sales to reach their full potential.
Business Model Overview
The business model created for Scan & Plan is divided into two parts: phase 1
and phase 2. Phase 1 is also known as a test run. This period is the first 90 days of
business operations for Scan & Plan. During this time, the product and app are still
being developed and only very low production occurs. Phase 2 follows directly after
Phase 1. This is what the first year of operations could look like for Scan & Plan,
given a successful Phase 1. Phase 1 is the most important period of this business
model because without success during this time, the company cannot continue
production.
Scan & Plan Pricing Strategy
The cost of goods sold, including materials, manufacturing, and shipping is $51.47
per unit. We will be selling the Scan & Plan at a wholesale price of $112.50 to
retailers. We made the assumptions that retailers will mark up 100% leading to a final
retail price of $225.00 per unit. Scan & Plan will also be sold online on the company
website at the same price that the Scan & Plan is sold at retail locations for $225.
This results in a gross profit of $61.03 per unit sold. On our website, we will profit
26
$173.53 because there will be no retail commission. We could not base our price on
current solutions on the market because none of our competition sells a physical
product as we do. However, we settled on this price because we wanted to keep our
product affordable, but also profit off of the value that we provide our customers. Scan
& Plan is a one-time buy for our customers and life-changing product. After some
surveying, we found that families were willing to pay at least $225 for more order and
piece-of-mind in their lives.
Sales Projections and Assumptions
There were multiple assumptions that the team had to make when determining the
financial model for Scan & Plan. The first assumption was that retail stores will end up
marking the product up 100% from the wholesale price. Also we believe that in the
first quarter of sales following our trial period we can reach only .005% of our
extremely large target market of 12 million households for retails sales. This results in
the sale of approximately 650 units.
Another assumption we made is that the three retailers, Bed Bath & Beyond,
Williams Sonoma and Kitchen Kapers, will agree to consignment. We believed it to be
very likely that these stores would agree to consignment because of the success that
Coffee Joulies had with consignment with Kitchen Kapers. The next financial
assumption the team made was that our Phase 1 would be successful and the
retailers with which we have consignment with in those first 90 days will begin selling
our product directly following this period.
The team also assumed that an additional 50% of retail sales would also be
sold on the company’s website. The use of magazine ads, social media and pamphlet
27
ads will heavily promote the team's website, resulting in a large amount of purchases
online. The community we are selling to consists of families and mothers who will
most likely try to persuade their friends to purchase our once they discover its
usefulness. This type of advertising and our presence in only three retailers will lead
to higher website sales than normal; 50% of sales was estimated to reflect that. This
adds a total of 650 additional units to our sales estimates in the second quarter
bringing the total units sold to 1,300.
Phase 1 Plan
Phase 1 is the first 90 days of operation for Scan & Plan. It is also known as the
“proof of concept” period because it is when we our first able to place our product out
in the market and see the response. During this time, we will have consignment with
three stores: Bed Bath & Beyond, Williams Sonoma and Kitchen Kapers. We will
place some of our products on their shelves at no cost to them at various locations
and as our product sells we will continue to replace them in stores. Consignment
means that retailers will display our product at no risk to them. Once the retailer
makes a sale, they will pay as back the wholesale selling price of $112.50 and we will
profit $61.03. We expect to sell a total of 300 units, 100 at each of three stores,
through consignment. Also during this period we will sell 20 units through our website.
The costs for the first 90 days are broken down into development, production,
marketing & support and ramp up. 48% of the Phase 1 costs are development costs
with most of this going towards designing and launching the Scan & Plan smartphone
app. The production, marketing & support and ramp-up costs make up 39%, 8% and
5%, respectively, of the Phase 1 costs. The required initial investment for operations
28
in the first 90 days is $42,000. The cost to acquire a customer in Phase 1 is $10 and
from each of these customers we gain $68.
Phase 2 Plan
In Phase 2 of our plan, we will see what the first year could look like. This phase
assumes a successful Phase 1 and large production and distribution through the
website and retail will occur. The first quarter of normal sales will begin in the second
quarter of the first year. One half of the sales will occur through retail and the other on
our website. The sales in the second quarter will be 1,300 units, reaching .01% of our
target audience, and this will grow at a rate of 10% per quarter. Therefore, sales in
Q3 will be 1,430 and 1,570 in Q4 of year one. The cost breakdown for Phase 2 is
40% development costs, 36% ramp up costs and 24% marketing & support costs. An
important development cost to note is $25,000 for app development, in addition to the
$20,000 originally put towards the app in Phase 1. For ramp up costs, $45,000 will be
invested in market introduction, or store demonstrations/displays, at Bed Bath &
Beyond, Williams Sonoma and Kitchen Kapers. In terms of important yearly support
costs, $9,000 will go towards app maintenance and $7,000 for website maintenance.
The cost to acquire a customer in Phase 2 is still $10, but the value we gain from each
customer jumps to $117.
29
Cash Flow Analysis and Required Initial Investment
Given the year described in Phase 2, the cash flow will mirror the graph
pictured below. The required initial is $190,000 and we will break even in the third
quarter or operations.
Potential Funding Sources
The team requires an initial investment of $190,000 for a realistic first year of
operations as described in Phase 2. However, to get Scan & Plan developed and out
on the market during Phase 1, $42,000 is required. This $42,000 is very important
because without a strong first 90 days of proving our concept success in the future will
be highly unlikely. The team will focus mainly on raising money through private
investment. It is very likely for us to receive private funding because our initial
investment is relatively conservative. However, if the initial investment cannot be
reached only through these means the team will turn to loans from a local bank.
30
Figure 15
Conclusion and Recommendations
Summary Description
After thorough market research, including surveys and one-on one
conversations with families we found a large market gap for a product that would help
simplify the regular shopping experience, eliminating confusion, disorganization and
misunderstanding. We then identified the four core customer needs: convenience and
family integration within the solution as well as a spending analysis and nutrition
breakdown. With those requirements in mind, we created Scan & Plan, a physical
scanner and smartphone App that gives its users an easy way to create a grocery list
s hop with it and track the related financial and dietary intake.
The main component of the Scan & Plan’s scanner is custom wireless
Bluetooth scanner, which allows for its compatibility with all of the family’s smart
devices. The changing LED light lets the user see when the scanner is ON or in sleep
mode. Suction cups are used to mount the scanner to any surface in a family’s
kitchen, allowing our product to seamlessly fit into any household. The App includes
the family’s shopping list and the dietary and spending analysis from the past time
period. To further simplify the shopping process there are functions such as the
manual item insert button, individual nutritional breakdown and an optional notification
sent to the family, when someone is shopping, in the case that there is a last minute
addition to the list.
The team plans to reach our target audience through means of promotion such
as social media, including Twitter, a Facebook page and Google Adwords, as well as
print advertisements in magazine like Working Mom, Parenting and Health.
Additionally, we will be present at trade shows and provide store tours to spread the
word about our product. The team will be selling the Scan & Plan through Williams-
31
Sonoma, Kitchen Kapers, Bed Bath & Beyond, Best Buy, SkyMall and H.H.Gregg for a
price of $225.00. We will also sell it directly on the Scan & Plan online website
The initial investment for the 90-day trial period of Scan & Plan would require
$42,000, which would allow the company to evaluate the market response to the
product. Sales of the Scan & Plan will begin in the second quarter, with a quarterly
growth rate of 10% for the first year. The company will break-even in the second
quarter, after producing 2,730 total units. The initial investment required for launching
the product is $190,000 and after a full year of operation the company will reach
positive cash flow of $250,000.
Future Work
Once the company receives its initial investment it can start the production for
the test trail, which would include 300 units for consignment in Bed Bath & Beyond,
Kitchen Kapers and Williams-Sonoma, as well as 20 for the Scan & Plan website.
Social media promotion would take into effect right away, as well as customer
surveying and independent validation on means of improving the product.
Once production and sales have begun, the team can look at way of expanding
the distribution and presence of the product, as well as making modifications based on
feedback. The target market can be broadened to all families that are health and
financially conscious, or for individuals that already lead specific diets, for example
gluten free or vegetarian. In order to best reach these new customers, Scan & Plan
would expand to stores such Whole Foods Market, and require advertisements in new
magazines, that were not included in the original plan.
32