trilemma challenges for the people's republic of china
TRANSCRIPT
-
8/9/2019 Trilemma Challenges for the People's Republic of China
1/41
@HNO Ybreodi Z`pgr Vgrogs
Xrocgkk` Fl`ccgdigs abr tlgZgbpcg‟s ^gpuncof ba Flod`
K`s`lorb E`w`o `dhCo-I`di Cou
Db. 706Agnru`ry >:07
@so`d Hgvgcbpkgdt N`de
-
8/9/2019 Trilemma Challenges for the People's Republic of China
2/41
Xlg Ybreodi Z`pgr sgrogs os ` fbdtodu`tobd ba tlg abrkgrcy d`kgh Hosfussobd Z`pgr sgrogs5tlg dukngrodi ba tlg p`pgrs fbdtodugh wotlbut odtgrruptobd br fl`dig. @HNO‟s wbreodip`pgrs rgacgft odoto`c ohg`s bd ` tbpof `dh `rg pbstgh bdcodg abr hosfussobd. @HNO gdfbur`igs
rg`hgrs tb pbst tlgor fbkkgdts bd tlg k`od p`ig abr g`fl wbreodi p`pgr (iovgd od tlgfot`tobd ngcbw). Vbkg wbreodi p`pgrs k`y hgvgcbp odtb btlgr abrks ba puncof`tobd.
Vuiigstgh fot`tobd=
E`w`o, K., `dh C.-I. Cou. >:07. Xrocgkk` Fl`ccgdigs abr tlg Zgbpcg‟s ^gpuncof ba Flod`. @HNO Ybreodi Z`pgr 706. Xbeyb= @so`d Hgvgcbpkgdt N`de Odstotutg. @v`oc`ncg=lttp=//www.`hno.bri/wbreodi-p`pgr/>:07/:>/0:/1766.trocgkk`.fl`ccgdigs.prf/
Zcg`sg fbdt`ft tlg `utlbrs abr odabrk`tobd `nbut tlos p`pgr.
Gk`oc= ke`w`oJpp.u-tbeyb.`f.mp, coi`di.couJ`dz.fbk
K`s`lorb E`w`o os Zrbagssbr, Ir`hu`tg Vflbbc ba Zuncof Zbcofy, Wdovgrsoty ba Xbeyb.
Co-I`di Cou os Floga Gfbdbkost, Irg`tgr Flod`, @D] ^gsg`rfl, @ustr`co` `dh Dgw]g`c`dh N`deodi Irbup.
Xlg vogws gxprgssgh od tlos p`pgr `rg tlg vogws ba tlg `utlbrs `dh hb dbt dgfgss`rocy
rgacgft tlg vogws br pbcofogs ba @HNO, @HN, ots Nb`rh ba Horgftbrs, br tlg ibvgrdkgdts tlgyrgprgsgdt. @HNO hbgs dbt iu`r`dtgg tlg `ffur`fy ba tlg h`t` odfcuhgh od tlos p`pgr `dh`ffgpts db rgspbdsonocoty abr `dy fbdsgqugdfgs ba tlgor usg. Xgrkodbcbiy usgh k`y dbtdgfgss`rocy ng fbdsostgdt wotl @HN baaofo`c tgrks.
Ybreodi p`pgrs `rg sunmgft tb abrk`c rgvosobd `dh fbrrgftobd ngabrg tlgy `rg aod`cozgh `dhfbdsohgrgh puncoslgh.
@so`d Hgvgcbpkgdt N`de OdstotutgE`sukoi`sgeo Nuochodi -7 E`sukoi`sgeo, Floybh`-euXbeyb 0::-1::
-
8/9/2019 Trilemma Challenges for the People's Republic of China
3/41
@HNO Ybreodi Z`pgr 706 E`w`o `dh Cou
@nstr`ft
Xlos p`pgr aorst rgvogws rgfgdt hgvgcbpkgdts od gxfl`dig r`tg rgiokgs, f`pot`c `ffbudtcongr`coz`tobd, odtgrgst r`tg congr`coz`tobd, `dh kbdgt`ry pbcofyk`eodi od tlg Zgbpcg‟s ^gpuncofba Flod` (Z^F). Ot tlgd bnsgrvgs tl`t tlg Z^F‟s kbdgt`ry pbcofy `utbdbky k`y l`vg nggdrghufgh wotl a`ccodi f`pot`c fbdtrbc gaagftovgdgss `dh ` roioh gxfl`dig rgiokg tl`t os stocc
toiltcy k`d`igh `i`odst tlg Wdotgh Vt`tgs (WV) hbcc`r. Xlos lypbtlgsos os odvgstoi`tghgkporof`ccy usodi nbtl tlg X`ycbr rucg `dh tlg KfF`ccuk-coeg rucg tb tgst wlgtlgr tlg Z^F‟skbdgy k`regt odtgrgst r`tg `dh/br qu`dtoty ba kbdgy suppcy `rg ngodi odfrg`sodicyodacugdfgh ny tlg WV odtgrgst r`tg br rgsgrvg `ffukuc`tobd. Xlg p`pgr fbdfcuhgs tl`t tlgrgos fbdsohgr`ncg gvohgdfg suiigstodi hokodoslodi kbdgt`ry pbcofy `utbdbky od tlg Z^F. Xbrgi`od pbcofy `utbdbky, tlg kbdgt`ry `utlbroty dgghs tb sunst`dto`ccy odfrg`sg gxfl`digr`tg acgxonocoty ba tlg rgdkodno `s cbdi `s ot fbdtodugs tb pursug f`pot`c `ffbudt bpgdodi.
MGC Fc`ssoaof`tobd= G7>, G7
-
8/9/2019 Trilemma Challenges for the People's Republic of China
4/41
@HNO Ybreodi Z`pgr 706 E`w`o `dh Cou
Fbdtgdts
0. Odtrbhuftobd ................................................................................................................ 6
>.
Xlg Xrocgkk` Lypbtlgsos od Odtgrd`tobd`c Aod`dfg .................................................... 8
6.
Gxfl`dig ^`tg Zbcofy `dh ^`tg Acgxonocoty ................................................................. 1
6.0 ^gdkodno Gxfl`dig ^`tg Ngl`vobr sodfg >::7 ............................................. 1 6.>
Gxfl`dig ^`tg Zbcofy `atgr tlg >::7 Hg-pgiiodi .......................................... <
8.
Gaagftovgdgss ba F`pot`c Fbdtrbcs ............................................................................. 00
8.0 ^gdkodno Odtgrd`tobd`coz`tobd `dh ^osodi @rnotr`ig Bppbrtudotogs ................ 00 8.>
Kg`surodi F`pot`c Fbdtrbc Gaagftovgdgss ...................................................... 06
8.6
Hgfcododi F`pot`c Fbdtrbc Gaagftovgdgss ........................................................ 01
7. Kbdgt`ry Zbcofy Fl`ccgdigs od tlg Zgbpcg‟s ^gpuncof ba Flod` ................................ 0
Vprg`h ba Vl`hbw N`deodi @ftovotogs ........................................................... >:
7.6
^osodi Voids ba Zbcofy Odgaagftovgdgss .......................................................... >0
1.
Gkporof`c Gvohgdfg bd Hokodoslodi Kbdgt`ry Zbcofy @utbdbky od tlg Zgbpcg‟s^gpuncof ba Flod` .................................................................................................... >6
1.0
Kbdgt`ry Zbcofy Ar`kgwbre ba tlg Zgbpcg‟s ^gpuncof ba Flod`.................... >8
1.>
Gkporof`c Kbhgcs abr Xgstodi Kbdgt`ry Zbcofy @utbdbky ............................. >7
1.6
Xgstodi Kbdgt`ry Zbcofy @utbdbky wotl tlg Odtgrgst ^`tg `s ` ZbcofyOdstrukgdt .................................................................................................... >9
1.8
Xgstodi Zbcofy @utbdbky wotl Kbdgt`ry @iirgi`tgs `s ` Zbcofy Odstrukgdt 6:
9.
Zbcofy Okpcof`tobds ................................................................................................... 66
9.0
Irg`tgr Gxfl`dig ^`tg Acgxonocoty ................................................................ 68
9.>
@ Vlbrt-tgrk Zbcofy Odtgrgst ^`tg abr tlg Zgbpcg‟s ^gpuncof ba Flod`........... 68
9.6
K`regt Odar`strufturgs .................................................................................. 67
-
8/9/2019 Trilemma Challenges for the People's Republic of China
5/41
@HNO Ybreodi Z`pgr 706 E`w`o `dh Cou
0. ODX^BHWFXOBD
Xlg Zgbpcg‟s ^gpuncof ba Flod` (Z^F) os a`fodi trocgkk` fl`ccgdigs `s ot fbdtodugs tbcongr`cozg ots f`pot`c `ffbudt. Xlg trocgkk` lypbtlgsos fc`oks tl`t ` fbudtry‟s kbdgt`ry`utlbroty f`ddbt `flogvg gxfl`dig r`tg st`nocoty, aod`dfo`c k`regt (br f`pot`c `ffbudt)bpgddgss, `dh kbdgt`ry pbcofy `utbdbky `t tlg s`kg tokg. 0 Xlus, `s aod`dfo`c k`regtbpgddgss l`s odfrg`sgh bvgr tokg od tlg Z^F, ots kbdgt`ry `utlbroty kust flbbsgirg`tgr gxfl`dig r`tg acgxonocoty tb rgt`od ` loil hgirgg ba kbdgt`ry pbcofy `utbdbky.
Xlg Z^F l`s nggd pursuodi ` pbcofy ba ir`hu`ccy bpgdodi ots aod`dfo`c k`regts. Vodfgtlg 0?::7. Ot ngi`d tb gdiodggr furrgdfy `pprgfo`tobd `i`odst tlg WV hbcc`r ny sloatoditb ` fr`wcodi-pgi rgiokg, tlus `ccbwodi ` fgrt`od hgirgg ba gxfl`dig r`tg acgxonocoty. @ctlbuil tlg `utlbroty tgkpbr`rocy rgstbrgh ` hbcc`r-pgi rgiokg od @uiust >:::0:, ot bdfg `i`od `hbptgh ` fr`wcodi-pgi-coeg rgiokg od Mudg >:0:. Od igdgr`c, tlghgirgg ba gxfl`dig r`tg acgxonocoty l`s ir`hu`ccy odfrg`sgh bvgr tokg nut rgk`ods loilcy
cokotgh.Xlos p`pgr `riugs tl`t wlocg tlg Z^F‟s aod`dfo`c k`regts l`vg ngfbkg odfrg`sodicyodtgir`tgh wotl gxtgrd`c k`regts, p`rtofuc`rcy tlbsg od Lbdi Ebdi, Flod`, tlg hgirgg ba^KN gxfl`dig r`tg acgxonocoty l`s dbt rosgd kufl, `dh tlg fbknod`tobd ba irg`tgrbpgddgss ba ots aod`dfo`c k`regts `dh c`fe ba suaaofogdt gxfl`dig r`tg acgxonocoty l`sfbdstr`odgh tlg `nocoty ba tlg kbdgt`ry `utlbroty tb pursug `utbdbkbus kbdgt`rypbcofy.
Xlg bri`doz`tobd ba tlg p`pgr os `s abccbws. Vgftobd > rgvogws tlg trocgkk` lypbtlgsosod odtgrd`tobd`c aod`dfg, wlofl prbvohgs tlg tlgbrgtof`c abudh`tobd abr tlg `d`cysos ba tlgp`pgr. Vgftobd 6 hosfussgs tlg gvbcutobd ba tlg Z^F‟s gxfl`dig r`tg rgiokg `dh tlghgirgg ba ^KN gxfl`dig r`tg acgxonocoty. Vgftobd 8 gx`kodgs tlg p`fg `dh gxtgdt ba
aod`dfo`c k`regt bpgdodi (br f`pot`c `ffbudt congr`coz`tobd) od tlg Z^F `dh `riugs tl`tots aod`dfo`c k`regts l`vg nggd odfrg`sodicy odtgir`tgh wotl tlg Lbdi Ebdi, Flod`k`regts hgspotg tlg gxostodi f`pot`c fbdtrbcs. Vgftobd 7 prbvohgs n`feirbudhodabrk`tobd bd tlg hosfussobd ba kbdgt`ry pbcofy gaagftovgdgss. Vgftobd 1 fbdhuftsgfbdbkgtrof `d`cysos tb ohgdtoay tlg kbdgt`ry `utlbroty‟s pbcofy rucg `dh ots fl`digsbvgr tokg `dh aodhs tl`t tlg Z^F `utlbroty‟s `nocoty tb sgt ots `utbdbkbus kbdgt`ry
0 Od tlg Z^F, kbdgt`ry pbcofy os c`rigcy hgfohgh ny tlg ibvgrdkgdt (tlg Vt`tg Fbudfoc `dh tlg gxgfutovg
nr`dfl), wlocg ots fgdtr`c n`de‘tlg Zgbpcg's N`de ba Flod` (ZNbF)‘sgrvgs `s ` pbcofy okpcgkgdt`tobd`igdfy r`tlgr tl`d ` k`od pbcofy hgfosobd k`egr. Xb rgacgft tlos rg`coty, tlos p`pgr usgs tlg tgrk–kbdgt`ry `utlbroty‛ tb rgagr tb ` k`od kbdgt`ry pbcofy hgfosobd k`egr. Xlg p`pgr `csb usgs tlg tgrk
kbdgt`ry pbcofy –`utbdbky‛ r`tlgr tl`d –odhgpgdhgdfg‛ tb `vboh pbssoncg fbdausobd wotl tlg ossug bapbcotof`c `dh/br bpgr`tobd`c odhgpgdhgdfg ba ` fgdtr`c n`de.
6
-
8/9/2019 Trilemma Challenges for the People's Republic of China
6/41
@HNO Ybreodi Z`pgr 706 E`w`o `dh Cou
pbcofy l`s nggd l`kpgrgh sodfg tlg butnrg`e ba tlg IAF. Vgftobd 9 baagrs sbkg pbcofyokpcof`tobds. Vgftobd < fbdfcuhgs tlg p`pgr.
>. XLG X^OCGKK@ L_ZBXLGVOV OD ODXG^D@XOBD@CAOD@DFG
@flogvodi dbdodac`tobd`ry, st`ncg gfbdbkof irbwtl os bdg ba tlg kbst okpbrt`dt pbcofybnmgftovgs abr kbdgt`ry `utlbrotogs, p`rtofuc`rcy fgdtr`c n`des, od tlg wbrch. K`dy`utlbrotogs aodh ot hgsor`ncg tb l`vg st`ncg br gvgd aoxgh gxfl`dig r`tgs, `s furrgdfyst`nocoty f`d lgcp `flogvg profg st`nocoty ny gst`ncoslodi odac`tobd `dflbrs `dh/brrghufodi k`frbgfbdbkof `dh aod`dfo`c vbc`tocoty. Gxfl`dig r`tg st`nocoty f`d `csb abstgrodtgrd`tobd`c tr`hg `dh odvgstkgdt ny cbwgrodi gxfl`dig r`tg udfgrt`odty `dh furrgdfyrose prgkouks.
K`dy `utlbrotogs `csb aodh ot usgauc tb l`vg bpgd aod`dfo`c k`regts `s tlgy `ccbwfbudtrogs tb hovgrsoay gfbdbkof `dh aod`dfo`c roses `dh skbbtl fbdsukptobd,odvgstkgdt, `dh/br butput bvgr tokg. Aod`dfo`c k`regt bpgddgss gdl`dfgs tlggaaofogdfy ba aod`dfo`c odtgrkgho`tobd `dh s`vodi `dh odvgstkgdt hgfosobds balbusglbchs `dh fbrpbr`tobds.
Aod`ccy, k`dy `utlbrotogs aodh ot loilcy `ttr`ftovg tb rgt`od kbdgt`ry pbcofy `utbdbky,tl`t os, tlg `nocoty tb sgt `dh okpcgkgdt kbdgt`ry pbcofy tb baasgt btlgr fbudtrogs‟kbdgt`ry slbfes `dh kbdgt`ry pbcofy fl`digs wotlbut ngodi fbdstr`odgh ny tlgorflbofg ba gxfl`dig r`tg rgiokg. Kbdgt`ry pbcofy `utbdbky soidoaof`dtcy lgcpsfbdtronutg tb gfbdbkof st`nocoz`tobd od tlg sgdsg ba `flogvodi cbw odac`tobd `dh st`ncggfbdbkof irbwtl.
Fbdfgptu`ccy, loilgr cgvgcs ba gxfl`dig r`tg st`nocoty, aod`dfo`c k`regt bpgddgss, `dh
kbdgt`ry pbcofy `utbdbky wbuch `cc ng usgauc `dh `ttr`ftovg abr `dy kbdgt`ry `utlbroty.Nut db `utlbroty f`d rgt`od `cc tlrgg `t `dy bdg tokg. Xlos os tlg audh`kgdt`clypbtlgsos‘tlg –okpbssoncg trodoty‛ br tlg –trocgkk`‛‘tl`t hbkod`tgs kbdgt`rypbcofyk`eodi od `dy bpgd gfbdbky (Kudhgcc 0?16). Xlg Z^F os db gxfgptobd.
Xlg trocgkk` os batgd occustr`tgh usodi ` tro`dicg `s slbwd od Aoiurg 0, wotl tlg tlrggsohgs rgprgsgdtodi tlg tlrgg hgsor`ncg prbpgrtogs= gxfl`dig r`tg st`nocoty, aod`dfo`ck`regt bpgddgss, `dh kbdgt`ry pbcofy `utbdbky (Otb `dh E`w`o >:08). Ylocg ot ospbssoncg tb `flogvg hgsorgh cgvgcs ba twb but ba tlg tlrgg `ttronutgs, ot os okpbssoncg tb`flogvg hgsorgh cgvgcs ba `cc tlrgg. Abr gx`kpcg, ` fbudtry‟s `utlbroty k`y flbbsg tbst`dh `t bdg ba tlg tlrgg fbrdgrs od tlg tro`dicg, nut ot os okpbssoncg tb `flogvg `cc tlrggsokuct`dgbuscy. @s bdcy twb but ba tlrgg f`d ng `flogvgh tb tlgor aucc gxtgdt (br `dygxtgdt), wg batgd bnsgrvg tlrgg hostodftovg pbcofy fbknod`tobds= (o) ` aoxgh gxfl`digr`tg rgiokg `dh aucc kbdgt`ry pbcofy `utbdbky (wotl fcbsgh aod`dfo`c k`regts, `s od tlgf`sg ba tlg cbwgr cgat-l`dh fbrdgr‘rgprgsgdtodi, abr gx`kpcg, tlg Nrgttbd Ybbhssystgk `dh tlg Z^F od tlg prg-0??:s)5 (oo) ` aoxgh gxfl`dig r`tg rgiokg `dh auccy bpgdaod`dfo`c k`regts (wlocg iovodi up kbdgt`ry pbcofy `utbdbky, `s od tlg f`sg ba tlgcbwgr roilt-l`dh fbrdgr‘rgprgsgdtodi, abr gx`kpcg, tlg ibch st`dh`rh systgk, `furrgdfy nb`rh systgk sokoc`r tb Lbdi Ebdi, Flod` `dh sk`cc gurbzbdg fbudtrogs)5`dh (ooo) auccy bpgd aod`dfo`c k`regts `dh aucc kbdgt`ry pbcofy `utbdbky (wlocg `hbptodi` arggcy acgxoncg gxfl`dig r`tg rgiokg `s od tlg f`sg ba tlg tbp fbrdgr‘rgprgsgdtodi abrgx`kpcg, @ustr`co`, F`d`h`, M`p`d, `dh tlg Wdotgh Eodihbk).
8
-
8/9/2019 Trilemma Challenges for the People's Republic of China
7/41
@HNO Ybreodi Z`pgr 706 E`w`o `dh Cou
Aoiurg 0= Xlg Xrocgkk` Xro`dicg
Z^F ; Zgbpcg‟s ̂ gpuncof ba Flod`.
Vburfg= Otb `dh E`w`o (>:08).
Ylocg lostbry os aucc ba gposbhgs ba systgks tl`t rgprgsgdt sufl –fbrdgr sbcutobds,‛
kbdgt`ry `utlbrotogs f`d `csb `hbpt `d odtgrkgho`tg fbknod`tobd ba tlg tlrggprbpgrtogs, tl`t os, ` –hbt‛ odsohg tlg tro`dicg. Xlgrg `rg `d odaodotg dukngr ba suflfbknod`tobds. Xlg rg`sbd ` kbdgt`ry `utlbroty k`y sgcgft sufl ` hbt os tl`t ot k`ywosl tb fbkprbkosg od sgcgftodi tlg cgvgc ba `tt`odkgdt ba g`fl ba tlg tlrgg prbpgrtogs.Abr gx`kpcg, ` kbdgt`ry `utlbroty k`y wosl tb l`vg sbkg gxfl`dig r`tg st`nocoty,sbkg aod`dfo`c k`regt bpgddgss, `dh sbkg kbdgt`ry pbcofy `utbdbky. Br, oa `kbdgt`ry `utlbroty woslgs tb rgt`od aucc kbdgt`ry pbcofy `utbdbky, ot dgghs tb stroeg `ibbh n`c`dfg ngtwggd sbkg gxfl`dig r`tg st`nocoty (br acgxonocoty) `dh sbkg aod`dfo`ck`regt bpgddgss (br sbkg f`pot`c fbdtrbcs). Od k`dy hgvgcbpodi fbudtrogs, kbdgt`ry`utlbrotogs batgd cokot aod`dfo`c k`regt bpgddgss `s ot wbuch k`eg tlg gfbdbkyvucdgr`ncg tb gxtgrd`c aod`dfo`c slbfes `dh f`pot`c acbw vbc`tocoty, frg`todi nbbk `dhnust fyfcgs `dh, pbtgdto`ccy, aod`dfo`c frosgs.
Xlg Z^F‟s kbdgt`ry `utlbroty usgh tb pgi tlg ^KN gxfl`dig r`tg tb tlg WV hbcc`rwlocg k`odt`ododi toilt f`pot`c fbdtrbcs (tlg cgat fbrdgr ba tlg tro`dicg od Aoiurg 0). Xlosgd`ncgh tlg `utlbroty tb rgt`od kbdgt`ry pbcofy `utbdbky. Lbwgvgr, `s ot ngi`d tbir`hu`ccy bpgd ots aod`dfo`c k`regts bvgr tokg, ots pbsotobd od tlg tro`dicg ba Aoiurg 0st`rtgh tb sloat arbk tlg cgat fbrdgr tbw`rh tlg sohg ba aod`dfo`c k`regt bpgddgss. Oa tlg`utlbroty fbdtodugs tb k`odt`od gxfl`dig r`tg st`nocoty, tlos sloat wocc t`eg pc`fglbrozbdt`ccy `cbdi tlg nbttbk ba tlg tro`dicg, tlus fbkprbkosodi kbdgt`ry pbcofy`utbdbky. Bd tlg btlgr l`dh, oa tlg Z^F `utlbroty woslgs tb k`odt`od kbdgt`ry pbcofy`utbdbky, tlg sloat wocc t`eg pc`fg upw`rh `cbdi tlg cgat sohg, tlus `ccbwodi irg`tgrgxfl`dig r`tg acgxonocoty.
Xlg flbofg ba gxfl`dig r`tg rgiokg tlgrgabrg kust ng k`hg od tlg fbdtgxt ba tlgtrocgkk` lypbtlgsos, tl`t os, od fbdmudftobd wotl tlg flbofgs bd kbdgt`ry pbcofy
Gxfl`dig r`tg st`nocoty
Arggcy acgxoncg gxfl`dig r`tgwotl auccy bpgd aod`dfo`c k`regts
(@ustr`co`, F`d`h`, M`p`d, Wdotgh Eodihbk, gtf)
Aoxgh gxfl`dig r`tgwotl auccy bpgd aod`dfo`c k`regts
(ibch st`dh`rh5 Lbdi Ebdi,Flod`5 sk`cc gurbzbdg
gfbdbkogs, gtf)
Aoxgh gxfl`dig r`tgwotl auccy fcbsgh aod`dfo`c k`regts
(Nrgttbd Ybbhs, tlg Z^F od tlgprg-0??:s, gtf)
7
-
8/9/2019 Trilemma Challenges for the People's Republic of China
8/41
@HNO Ybreodi Z`pgr 706 E`w`o `dh Cou
`utbdbky `dh aod`dfo`c k`regt bpgddgss. Abr ` c`rig gfbdbky coeg tlg Z^F,k`odt`ododi kbdgt`ry pbcofy `utbdbky os `d okpbrt`dt rgquorgkgdt abr gaagftovgk`frbgfbdbkof k`d`igkgdt. Vb, `s aod`dfo`c k`regt (br f`pot`c `ffbudt) bpgddgssodfrg`sgs bvgr tokg, tlg `utlbroty dgghs tb flbbsg irg`tgr gxfl`dig r`tg acgxonocoty tbrgt`od ` suaaofogdtcy loil hgirgg ba kbdgt`ry pbcofy `utbdbky.
6. G\FL@DIG ^@XG ZBCOF_ @DH ^@XG ACG\ONOCOX_
6.0 ^gdkodno Gxfl`dig ^`tg Ngl`vobr sodfg >::7
Bd >0 Mucy >::7, tlg Z^F `utlbroty hg-pgiigh `dh rgv`cugh tlg ^KN gxfl`dig r`tg`i`odst tlg WV hbcc`r ny >.0%, arbk FD_< tb FD_
Xlg dgw ^KN gxfl`dig r`tg rgiokg i`vg tlg `utlbroty ` dgw pbcofy tbbc tb k`d`ig otsgfbdbky. Xlg `utlbroty `ddbudfgh ` h`ocy rgagrgdfg tr`hodi spbt r`tg, f`ccgh tlgfgdtr`c p`roty r`tg (FZ^), abr tlg ^KN tb tr`hg `i`odst tlg WV hbcc`r. Xlg Z^Fc`udflgh ` stg`hy `pprgfo`tobd okkgho`tgcy abccbwodi tlg ^KN rgv`cu`tobd od Mucy>::7. Wdtoc M`du`ry >::1, tlg `utlbroty wbuch sgt tlg FZ^ abr tlg dgxt tr`hodi h`y `ttlg prgvobus tr`hodi h`y‟s k`regt fcbsg. Od M`du`ry >::1, ` dgw profodi kgfl`doskw`s odtrbhufgh tb sgt tlg FZ^ usodi ` wgoiltgh `vgr`ig sflgkg.6 Furrgdfy wgoiltswgrg hgtgrkodgh ny tlg Flod` Abrgoid Gxfl`dig Xr`hodi Vystgk `ffbrhodi tb tlgprgvobus h`y‟s tr`ds`ftobd vbcukgs ba odhovohu`c k`regt p`rtofop`dts. Od `hhotobd, btlgr
odhof`tbrs sufl `s qubtgh profgs arbk tlg `utbk`tof profg k`tflodi systgk fbuch ngusgh od prodfopcg `s ` rgagrgdfg. Lbwgvgr, sufl odabrk`tobd w`s batgd dbt `v`oc`ncg odrg`c tokg. Xlus, ot w`s hoaaofuct abr tlg k`regt tb hgtgrkodg lbw ` h`ocy FZ^ w`s sgt`dh wlgtlgr ot wbuch ng sunmgft tb v`robus gxtgrd`c pbcotof`c prgssurgs `dh odtgrd`cgfbdbkof bnmgftovgs (Cou `dh Z`uwgcs >:0>).
Xlg stg`hy `pprgfo`tobd ba tlg ^KN `i`odst tlg WV hbcc`r w`s tgkpbr`rocy l`ctghtbw`rh tlg gdh ba Mucy >::< wotl tlg gruptobd ba tlg IAF. Xlg pgi c`stgh abr `ckbst >yg`rs udtoc Mudg >:0: `t ` r`tg ba FD_1.:0>, ^KN horgft tr`hodi l`snggd `ccbwgh abr tlg ygd, @ustr`co`d hbcc`r, Dgw ]g`c`dh hbcc`r, pbudh stgrcodi, gurb,`dh Ebrg`d wbd. @s ` rgsuct, Vl`dil`o k`regt coquohoty abr tlgsg furrgdfogs l`s
> Od M`du`ry 0??8, tlg ^KN w`s hgv`cugh arbk FD_7.67 tb FD_< pgr WV hbcc`r, `atgr wlofl tlg r`tg
st`ygh `t tlg s`kg cgvgc abr kbrg tl`d 0: yg`rs.6 Xlg dgw FZ^ l`h tlrgg hostodft ag`turgs= (o) bvgr-tlg-fbudtgr (BXF) tr`hodi w`s odtrbhufgh `s tlg k`od
abrk ba furrgdfy tr`hodi5 (oo) kbrg FZ^ p`ors ba tlg ^KN `i`odst tlg WV hbcc`r, tlg gurb, tlg ygd, `dh
tlg Lbdi Ebdi hbcc`r wgrg `ddbudfgh `t ?=07 `.k. Ngomodi tokg ba g`fl nusodgss h`y5 `dh (ooo) tlg FZ^w`s f`cfuc`tgh usodi ` wgoiltgh `vgr`ig n`sgh bd tr`hodi vbcukg.
1
-
8/9/2019 Trilemma Challenges for the People's Republic of China
9/41
@HNO Ybreodi Z`pgr 706 E`w`o `dh Cou
ngfbkg ` a`ftbr `aagftodi tlgsg furrgdfogs‟ bdslbrg r`tgs `i`odst tlg ^KN, od `hhotobdtb tlgor k`regt frbss r`tgs f`cfuc`tgh `i`odst tlg WV hbcc`r.
Xlg ^KN tr`hodi n`dh vos-ê-vos tlg WV hbcc`r w`s odoto`ccy sgt `t ` toiltcy fbdtrbccghr`dig ba °:.6%, wlofl w`s c`tgr wohgdgh tb °:.7% od K`y >::9, °0% od @proc >:0>,
`dh tlgd tb °>% od K`rfl >:08. Odhggh, tlg ^KN‟s gxfl`dig r`tg acgxonocoty l`sodfrg`sgh prbirgssovgcy wotl `d gdc`righ tr`hodi n`dh bvgr tokg (Aoiurg >).
Aoiurg >= Xlg ^gdkodno Gxfl`dig ^`tg wotl ` Yohgdodi N`dh
Vburfg= Ncbbkngri.
@ctlbuil tlg ^KN gxfl`dig r`tg n`dh l`s nggd wohgdgh bvgr tokg, ^KN vbc`tocoty l`s
nggd cokotgh od fbkp`rosbd tb tlg vbc`tocoty ba btlgr arggcy acb`todi furrgdfogs sufl `stlg gurb, ygd, `dh @ustr`co`d hbcc`r. Wsodi `d bptobd-n`sgh furrgdfy vbc`tocoty kg`surg,Aoiurg 6 slbws tl`t 0-kbdtl `t-tlg-kbdgy okpcogh vbc`tocoty ba tlg gurb, ygd, @ustr`co`dhbcc`r, `dh Dgw ]g`c`dh hbcc`r acuftu`tgh `t `d `vgr`ig ba 0:%‖>:% hurodi tlg IAFpgrobh ba Vgptgkngr >:::0:. @atgrw`rh, tlg `vgr`ig vbc`tocoty ba tlgsgfurrgdfogs stocc acuftu`tgh `t `rbudh 0:%. Od fbdtr`st, tlg bptobd profg okpcogh vbc`tocotyba tlg ^KN rg`flgh bdcy 7% wotl tlg gruptobd ba tlg IAF `dh l`s sodfg sgttcgh hbwdtb cgss tl`d >%. Xlus, ^KN gxfl`dig r`tg vbc`tocoty l`s rgk`odgh cokotgh.
->.7
->.:
-0.7
-0.:
-:.7
:.:
:.7
0.:
0.7
>.:
>.7
>::7 >::1 >::9 >::< >::? >:0: >:00 >:0> >:06 >:08
% h
g v o ` t o b d
a r b k a
o x o d i
Yg`e sohg
Vtrbdi sohg
9
-
8/9/2019 Trilemma Challenges for the People's Republic of China
10/41
@HNO Ybreodi Z`pgr 706 E`w`o `dh Cou
Aoiurg 6= Bptobd Zrofg Okpcogh Qbc`tocoty ba K`mbr Furrgdfogs `dh tlg ^gdkodno
(%)
@WH ; @ustr`co`d hbcc`r, FD_ ; rgdkodno, GW^ ; gurb, MZ_ ; ygd, D]H ; Dgw ]g`c`dh hbcc`r, WVH ; WVhbcc`r.
Dbtg= Xlg fl`rt hospc`ys tlg 0-kbdtl ̀ t-tlg-kbdgy okpcogh vbc`tocoty ba tlg v`robus furrgdfogs.
Vburfg= Ncbbkngri.
6.> Gxfl`dig ^`tg Zbcofy `atgr tlg >::7 Hg-pgiiodi
@atgr tlg ^KN‟s gxot arbk tlg hbcc`r pgi, ots gxfl`dig r`tg w`s suppbsgh tb rgagrgdfg` n`segt ba furrgdfogs, wotl ots gxfl`dig r`tg rgabrk str`tgiy ngodi tb t`eg `d`pprb`fl k`regh ny –sgca-odoto`tovg, fbdtrbcc`nocoty, `dh ir`hu`cosk‛ tb okprbvg tlg ^KNgxfl`dig r`tg abrk`tobd kgfl`dosk (ZNbF >::?).
Ylgtlgr tlg ^KN l`s `ftu`ccy nggd rgagrgdfgh tb ` n`segt ba furrgdfogs f`d nggx`kodgh gkporof`ccy usodi twb `pprb`flgs. Bdg os tb fbdstruft ` furrgdfy n`segt tl`trgacgfts gdbuil ba tlg Z^F‟s tr`hg wotl tlg rgst ba tlg wbrch `dh sgg wlgtlgr tlg ^KNgxfl`dig r`tg l`s `ftu`ccy abccbwgh tlg v`cu`tobd hgrovgh arbk tlos n`segt bafurrgdfogs. Xlg btlgr `pprb`fl os tb usg tlg Ar`degc `dh Ygo (0??8) kbhgc tbgfbdbkgtrof`ccy ohgdtoay k`mbr odtgrd`tobd`c furrgdfogs `dh gstok`tg tlgor wgoilts od `d^KN furrgdfy n`segt.
N`segt ba ` c`rig dukngr ba furrgdfogs2Aorst, usodi 00 furrgdfogs tl`t k`eg up 9:% ba tlg Z^F‟s tr`hg wotl tlg rgst ba tlgwbrch, wg fbdstruftgh ` furrgdfy n`segt a br tlg ^KN `dh gxprgssgh ot `s `d okpcogh^KN gxfl`dig r`tg `i`odst tlg WV hbcc`r.8 Xlg n`segt-n`sgh ^KN r`tg os hgpoftgh odAoiurg 8 tbigtlgr wotl tlg k`regt ^KN spbt r`tg `i`odst tlg WV hbcc`r.
8 Xlg kgtlbhbcbiy fcbsgcy abccbws tlg usu`c f`cfuc`tobd ba ` dbkod`c gaagftovg gxfl`dig r`tg (DGG^)‘tl`t
os, fbdstruftodi ` igbkgtrof `vgr`ig ba tlg 00 furrgdfogs‟ gxfl`dig r`tgs `i`odst tlg WV hbcc`r `dhtlgd gxprgssodi tlg v`cug ba tlos furrgdfy n`segt `s `d gxfl`dig r`tg `i`odst tlg WV hbcc`r r`tlgr tl`d`s `d odhgx. Xlg furrgdfy n`segt `ssoids c`rig wgoilts tb tlg WV hbcc`r (68.>%), gurb (>>.7%),M`p`dgsg ygd (08.?%), `dh Ebrg`d wbd (0:.>%), abccbwgh ny tlg Vodi`pbrg hbcc`r, pbudh stgrcodi,
K`c`yso`d rodiiot, @ustr`co`d hbcc`r, Xl`o n`lt, F`d`ho`d hbcc`r, `dh ^usso`d Aghgr`tobd runcg, wotl tlgorwgoilts r`diodi arbk >% tb 6%.
:
7
0:
07
>:
>7
6:
67
8:
87
>::7 >::1 >::9 >::< >::? >:0: >:00 >:0> >:06 >:08
GW^ FD_ MZ_ @WH D]H
Vl`hgh `rg`s hgdbtg tlgpgrobhs ba ` FD_/WVH pgi
-
8/9/2019 Trilemma Challenges for the People's Republic of China
11/41
-
8/9/2019 Trilemma Challenges for the People's Republic of China
12/41
@HNO Ybreodi Z`pgr 706 E`w`o `dh Cou
X`ncg 0= Fl`digs od Bnsgrvgh Gxfl`dig ^`tg ^giokgs abr tlg ^gdkodno
Gstok`tobd Zgrobh WV Hbcc`r Gurb _gd Zbudh Vtgrcodi ^-squ`rgh
Zbst-@AF pgrobh(6 M`du`ry >:::‖6: Mudg >::7)
:.???***(:.:::)
:.:::(:.:::)
:.:::(:.:::)
-:.:::(:.:::)
:.???
Zrg-Cglk`d pgrobh(>0 Mucy >::7‖>0 Mucy >:::::0:)
:.?9:***(:.::1)
:.:>6***(:.:::0:‖60 K`rfl >:08)
:.?8:***(:.::(:.::::7 ^KN gxfl`dig r`tg rgiokg l`s dbt trucy rgagrgdfgh ` n`segt ba `wohg r`dig ba furrgdfogs od sgttodi tlg v`cug ba tlg ^KN gxfl`dig r`tg. Xlg ^KN
gxfl`dig r`tg l`s rgcogh `dh fbdtodugs tb rgcy lg`vocy bd tlg WV hbcc`r `s ots `dflbrfurrgdfy, wotl cokotgh gxfl`dig r`tg vbc`tocoty.
@ffukuc`tobd ba abrgoid gxfl`dig rgsgrvgs
Cokotgh gxfl`dig r`tg vbc`tocoty, tbigtlgr wotl ` prgv`ocodi bdg-w`y ngt bd tlg ^KN‟sfbdtodugh `pprgfo`tobd `i`odst tlg WV hbcc`r, cgh tb soidoaof`dt f`pot`c odacbws odtb tlgZ^F, wlofl rgquorgh tlg Z^F‟s kbdgt`ry `utlbroty tb gdi`ig od k`ssovg furrgdfyk`regt odtgrvgdtobds. Aoiurg 7 slbws tl`t tlg p`fg ba abrgoid gxfl`dig rgsgrvg`ffukuc`tobd l`h nggd r`poh udtoc tlg butnrg`e ba tlg IAF. @atgr tlg frosos, tlg r`tg bairbwtl hgfgcgr`tgh, wotl rgsgrvgs l`rhcy irbwodi hurodi P> >:00‖P8 >:0>. Nut tlgrgsgrvgs ngi`d tb rosg bdfg `i`od od >:06, `cngot `t ` cgssgr p`fg tl`d od tlg prg-frosospgrobh.
@s ` sl`rg ba irbss hbkgstof prbhuft (IHZ), abrgoid gxfl`dig rgsgrvgs odfrg`sgharbk 08% od >::: tb 8::?‖>:0:, `dh tlgd hgfcodgh sbkgwl`t tb 8:% od>:06. @s tlg Z^F‟s furrgdt `ffbudt surpcus `s ` r`tob ba IHZ hgfcodgh sl`rpcy `atgrtlg IAF arbk ots pg`e `t 0:% od >::9 tb bdcy >% od >:08, tlg p`fg ba rgsgrvg`ffukuc`tobd d`tur`ccy scbwgh hbwd. @s wocc ng slbwd c`tgr, rgsgrvg `ffukuc`tobd l`snggd `ffbkp`dogh ny ` r`poh odfrg`sg od tlg Z^F‟s kbdgt`ry n`sg. Xlos suiigsts tl`ttlg Z^F‟s kbdgt`ry pbcofy l`s nggd odfrg`sodicy odacugdfgh ny gxtgrd`c fbdhotobds.
0:
-
8/9/2019 Trilemma Challenges for the People's Republic of China
13/41
-
8/9/2019 Trilemma Challenges for the People's Republic of China
14/41
@HNO Ybreodi Z`pgr 706 E`w`o `dh Cou
g`sogr. Xlg codeodi ba tlg Vl`dil`o `dh Lbdi Ebdi, Flod` stbfe k`regts, c`udflgh odc`tg >:08, l`s `ccbwgh odvgstbrs od nbtl k`regts tb nuy g`fl btlgr‟s costgh sl`rgs `dhos `dbtlgr stgp tbw`rh ` kbrg bpgd f`pot`c `ffbudt.
Xlg r`poh ^KN odtgrd`tobd`coz`tobd prbfgss `csb kg`ds tl`t tlg Z^F‟s f`pot`c `ffbudt
os bpgdodi `t ` a`stgr p`fg, `ccbwodi k`regt p`rtofop`dts tb `rnotr`ig `w`y gxfl`digr`tg `dh odtgrgst r`tg hoaagrgdto`cs ngtwggd k`regts od Lbdi Ebdi, Flod` `dh tlg Z^F.Xlgrgabrg, ot os d`tur`c tb `ssukg tl`t tlg gxostodi f`pot`c fbdtrbc kg`surgs wocc ngfbkgcgss gaagftovg.
Lbwgvgr, f`su`c bnsgrv`tobds suiigst tl`t ^KN `ssgts ba tlg s`kg k`turoty od nbtlbdslbrg `dh baaslbrg k`regts stocc gdmby c`rig yogch hoaagrgdto`cs. Abr gx`kpcg, 6-kbdtl^KN s`vodis hgpbsots bdslbrg bnt`od ` rgturd ba >.1% pgr `dduk, wlocg 6-kbdtl tokghgpbsots od Lbdi Ebdi, Flod` bdcy baagr ` rgturd ba `rbudh :.7% (sgg Aoiurg 1@).Kg`dwlocg, 6-kbdtl Kodostry ba Aod`dfg nbdhs arbk tlg Z^F ossugh od Vl`dil`o `dhLbdi Ebdi, Flod` stocc l`vg yogch hoaagrgdto`cs, wotl tlg slbrtgr-h`tgh nbdhs l`vodic`rigr yogch hoaagrgdto`cs (Aoiurg 1N).
Aoiurg 1= Bdslbrg `dh Baaslbrg ^gdkodno Odtgrgst ^`tg Hoaagrgdto`cs(%)
@. 6-kbdtl hgpbsot r`tgs N. Ibvgrdkgdt nbdh yogch furvgs
Z^F ; Zgbpcg‟s ̂ gpuncof ba Flod`.
Dbtg= Baaslbrg rgagrs tb Lbdi Ebdi, Flod`.
Vburfgs= Ncbbkngri5 FGOF.
Xlgsg bnsgrv`tobds `ppg`r tb suiigst tl`t tlg Z^F‟s f`pot`c fbdtrbcs `rg stocc gaagftovgbr nodhodi. Ot os tlgsg fbdtrbc kg`surgs tl`t hrovg ` wghig ngtwggd bdslbrg `dhbaaslbrg yogchs ny cokotodi `rnotr`ig `ftovotogs od tlg abrk ba f`pot`c acbws. Xlgsgstr`oiltabrw`rh yogch fbkp`rosbds fbuch ng koscg`hodi, lbwgvgr, `s tlgy hb dbt t`egodtb `ffbudt a`ftbrs sufl `s odtgrgst r`tg fbdtrbcs, tr`ds`ftobds fbsts, `dh tlg rose ba`rnotr`ig hug tb f`pot`c fbdtrbcs.
Bdg soid ba tlos os tlg a`ft tl`t tlg Z^F‟s ud`ffbudtgh f`pot`c acbws l`vg st`rtgh tbirbw bvgr tokg. Aoiurg 9 slbws tl`t udtoc >::: noccobd, kbstcy od tlg abrk ba
:.:
:.7
0.:
0.7
>.:
>.7
6.:
6.7
K ` r - : 8
V g p - : 8
K ` r - : 7
V g p - : 7
K ` r - : 1
V g p - : 1
K ` r - : 9
V g p - : 9
K ` r - : <
V g p - : <
K ` r - : ?
V g p - : ?
K ` r - 0 :
V g p - 0 :
K ` r - 0 0
V g p - 0 0
K ` r - 0 >
V g p - 0 >
K ` r - 0 6
V g p - 0 6
K ` r - 0 8
Bdslbrg 6-kbdtl s`vodi hgpbsot r`tg
Baaslbrg 6-kbdtl tokg hgpbsot r`tg
>.7
6.:
6.7
8.:
8.7
7.:
: 7 0: 07 >: >7 6:
_g`r ba k`turoty
Bdslbrg ibvgrdkgdt nbdh yogch arbk tlg Z^F
Baaslbrg ibvgrdkgdt nbdh yogch arbk tlg Z^F
0>
-
8/9/2019 Trilemma Challenges for the People's Republic of China
15/41
@HNO Ybreodi Z`pgr 706 E`w`o `dh Cou
ud`ffbudtgh odacbws, fbodfohodi wotl tlg gxpgft`tobd ba ^KN `pprgfo`tobd. Vodfg >::?,grrbrs `dh bkossobds l`vg ngfbkg c`rig butacbws, `t `d `vgr`ig ba fcbsg tb $77 noccobd.Grrbrs `dh bkossobds dukngrs ngf`kg gvgd c`rigr od >:0>‖>:06 tb `rbudh $ noccobd,suiigstodi tl`t tlg cg`e`ig arbk f`pot`c fbdtrbcs l`s ngfbkg c`rigr bvgr tokg, gvgdwlgd tlg ^KN gxfl`dig r`tg l`s nggd bd ` stg`hy `pprgfo`tobd.
Aoiurg 9= Grrbrs `dh Bkossobds od tlg N`c`dfg ba Z`ykgdts ba tlg Zgbpcg‟s^gpuncof ba Flod` `dh tlg ^`tg ba ^gdkodno @pprgfo`tobd
NBZ ; n`c`dfg ba p`ykgdts, ^KN ; rgdkodno.
Vburfg= OKA, Odtgrd`tobd`c Aod`dfo`c Vt`tostofs.
8.> Kg`surodi F`pot`c Fbdtrbc Gaagftovgdgss
@ usgauc ngdflk`re abr fbkp`rodi yogch hoaagrgdto`cs od twb k`regts os tb rgcy bd tlgfbvgrgh br udfbvgrgh odtgrgst r`tg p`roty (O^Z) fbdhotobds br sbkg kbhoaogh O^Zfbdhotobds tl`t f`d f`pturg hostbrtobds f`usgh ny f`pot`c fbdtrbcs. Wdhgr argg f`pot`ckbnocoty, tlg O^Z fbdhotobd st`tgs tl`t odvgstbrs slbuch ng odhoaagrgdt tb dbkod`c odtgrgstr`tg hoaagrgdto`cs od twb fbudtrogs ngf`usg tlg gxfl`dig r`tg ngtwggd tlg twbfurrgdfogs os gxpgftgh tb `hmust od ` w`y tl`t baasgts dbkod`c odtgrgst r`tg hoaagrgdto`cs,
tlus rgkbvodi `dy `rnotr`ig bppbrtudotogs.Wsodi tlg O^Z `pprb`fl, K` `dh KfF`ucgy (>::9) abudh tl`t tlg Z^F‟s f`pot`cfbdtrbcs rgk`odgh gaagftovg od hrovodi ` wghig ngtwggd bdslbrg `dh baaslbrg odtgrgstr`tgs ba tlg s`kg typg ba `ssgts, abr tlg pgrobh ngabrg tlg ^KN‟s forfuc`tobd baaslbrg. @kbrg `pprbpro`tg `pprb`fl tb odvgstoi`tg tlg Z^F‟s f`pot`c fbdtrbc gaagftovgdgss wbuchng tb abccbw ` sgkod`c stuhy ny Bt`do `dh Xow`ro (0?
:
>
8
1
<
0:
-0::
-:
:
>:
8:
>::0 >::6 >::7 >::9 >::? >:00 >:06
%
$
n o c c o b d
NBZ dgt grrbrs `dh bkossobds, $ noccobd (cgat-`xos)
^KN `ddu`c `vgr`ig r`tg ba `pprgfo`tobd, % (roilt-`xos)
06
-
8/9/2019 Trilemma Challenges for the People's Republic of China
16/41
@HNO Ybreodi Z`pgr 706 E`w`o `dh Cou
bdslbrg ^KN (FD_) `dh baaslbrg FDL tr`ds`ftobds. Xlg hoaagrgdfg ngtwggd tlg twbhgvo`tobds f`d ng vogwgh `s ` f`pot`c fbdtrbc gaagftovgdgss kg`surg tl`t `hhrgssgstr`ds`ftobds fbsts `dh btlgr hostbrtobds od nbtl k`regts.7
Xlg hgvo`tobd arbk tlg O^Z fbdhotobd od tlg Lbdi Ebdi, Flod` FDL k`regt f`d ng
hgaodgh `s abccbws=
( )( )
00
00 R ∞
+
+;
FDL WVH
FDL FDL FDL
A r
V r Hgvo`tobd , (0)
wlgrg r FDL os tlg 6-kbdtl baaslbrg ^KN (FDL) odtgrn`de odtgrgst r`tg5 r WVH os tlg 6-kbdtl WV hbcc`r odtgrn`de r`tg od Lbdi Ebdi, Flod`5 VFDL os tlg FDL spbt r`tg `i`odsttlg WV hbcc`r5 `dh A FDL os tlg FDL hgcovgr`ncg abrw`rh r`tg. Vodfg wg usg tlg 6-kbdtlodtgrgst r`tgs, tlg `ddu`cozgh odtgrgst r`tg os hovohgh ny ` a`ftbr ba 8 `dh tlg rgsuctsslbuch ng odtgrprgtgh `s pgrfgdt`ig pbodts.
Vokoc`rcy, tlg hgvo`tobd arbk tlg O^Z fbdhotobd od frbss-nbrhgr odvgstkgdt f`d nggxprgssgh `s abccbws=
( )( )
00
00 R ∞
+
+;
FDL WVH
FD_ FD_
FD_ A r
V r Hgvo`tobd , (>)
wlgrg r FD_ os tlg 6-kbdtl bdslbrg ^KN (FD_) odtgrn`de odtgrgst r`tg5 r WVH os tlg 6-kbdtl WV hbcc`r odtgrn`de r`tg od Lbdi Ebdi, Flod`5 VFD_ os tlg bdslbrg ^KN (FD_)spbt r`tg `i`odst tlg WV hbcc`r5 `dh A FDL os tlg FDL hgcovgr`ncg abrw`rh r`tg. Dbtg tl`ttlos O^Z fbdhotobd usgs tlg Lbdi Ebdi, Flod` FDL abrw`rh r`tg, r`tlgr tl`d tlgbdslbrg ^KN (FD_) abrw`rh r`tg, wlofl l`s dbt nggd auccy hgvgcbpgh od tgrks ba hgptl
`dh coquohoty.
@ctgrd`tovgcy, odvgstbrs k`y usg tlg baaslbrg dbd-hgcovgr`ncg abrw`rh (DHA) r`tg `csbqubtgh od Lbdi Ebdi, Flod`, A DHA , r`tlgr tl`d A FDL , `s tlg ^KN DHA k`regt od LbdiEbdi, Flod` os c`rigr `dh kbrg coquoh `t tlos st`ig. K`dy odvgstbrs stocc usg tlos k`regttb lghig tlgor bdslbrg ^KN gxpbsurgs. Xlgrgabrg, tlg `nbvg gxprgssobd f`d ngfl`digh tb=
( )( )
00
0> R ∞
+
+;
DHA WVH
FDL FDL
FDL
A r
V r Hgvo`tobd (0)'
( )( )
000
> R ∞+
+;
DHA WVH
FD_ FD_
FD_
A r
V r Hgvo`tobd (>)'
7 Hgt`ocgh tgfldof`c hgrov`tobds ba tlgsg gqu`tobds f`d ng abudh od Bt`do `dh Xow`ro (0?
-
8/9/2019 Trilemma Challenges for the People's Republic of China
17/41
@HNO Ybreodi Z`pgr 706 E`w`o `dh Cou
Aod`ccy, f`pot`c fbdtrbc gaagftovgdgss (FFG) kg`surgs f`d ng hgrovgh ny fbkp`rodigqu`tobds (0) `dh (>) `dh gqu`tobds (0)' `dh (>)'. Xlg hoaagrgdfg ngtwggd bdslbrg `dhbaaslbrg hgvo`tobds arbk O^Z kg`ds tl`t `atgr `hmustodi abr odtgrgst r`tg hoaagrgdto`cs`dh abrw`rh prgkouks, tlg hostbrtobd rgk`ododi f`d ng `ttronutgh tb f`pot`c fbdtrbcs.Vpgfoaof`ccy, tlg FFG kg`surgs f`d ng gxprgssgh `s=
FFG0 ; | Hgvo`tobdFD_R0 - Hgvo`tobdFDLR0 | (6)
FFG> ; | Hgvo`tobdFD_R> - Hgvo`tobdFDLR> | (6)'
Wsodi h`t` arbk >::? tb tlg prgsgdt, wg f`d f`cfuc`tg tlg hgvo`tobds arbk O^Z abrgqu`tobds (0) `dh (>), `dh gqu`tobds (0)' `dh (>)'. Aoiurg :0>, tlg hgvo`tobds l`vg ngfbkg bd `vgr`ig dgicoioncg (wotlod °0%) `dh
`rg dbt a`r arbk p`roty. Xlos kg`ds tl`t tlg Lbdi Ebdi, Flod` FDL k`regt l`s quofecyngfbkg `d gaaofogdt k`regt, wotl cokotgh `rnotr`ig bppbrtudotogs ngtwggd baaslbrgtr`ds`ftobds od WV hbcc`rs `dh FDL.
Lbwgvgr, tlos os dbt tlg f`sg abr frbss-nbrhgr odvgstkgdt odvbcvodi bdslbrg ^KN (FD_)`s wg hb bnsgrvg c`rig hgvo`tobds od gqu`tobd (>). Aoiurg :00.Xlos kg`ds tl`t oa tlg s`kg `kbudt ba ^KN wgrg tb l`vg nggd sloatgh arbk baaslbrg tbbdslbrg k`regts, tlg `rnotr`ig rgturds wbuch l`vg nggd 1%‖9%. Arbk Dbvgkngr>:00 tb Vgptgkngr >:08, wg bnsgrvg ` a`cc od `rnotr`ig bppbrtudotogs ba `d `vgr`ig ba0%‖6%. Xlbuil tlos os ` sl`rp rghuftobd arbk tlg prg-Vgptgkngr >:00 pgrobh,hgvo`tobds arbk O^Z abr frbss-nbrhgr odvgstkgdt odvbcvodi bdslbrg ^KN (FD_) l`vgrgk`odgh kufl c`rigr tl`d tlbsg od tlg Lbdi Ebdi, Flod` FDL k`regt.
Aoiurg
-
8/9/2019 Trilemma Challenges for the People's Republic of China
18/41
@HNO Ybreodi Z`pgr 706 E`w`o `dh Cou
8.6 Hgfcododi F`pot`c Fbdtrbc Gaagftovgdgss
Xlg twb fl`rts od Aoiurg ? `rg fbdstruftgh usodi gqu`tobds (6) `dh (6)' `dh prbvohg twbFFG kg`surgs, bdg n`sgh bd tlg FDL abrw`rh r`tg `dh tlg btlgr tlg DHA r`tg. Bvgr
tlg pgrobh >:0:‖>:08, ot `ppg`rs tl`t tlg Z^F‟s f`pot`c fbdtrbc rgiokg od igdgr`crgk`odgh gaagftovg hgspotg tlg r`poh ^KN odtgrd`tobd`coz`tobd prbfgss `dh tlg`ffgcgr`tgh p`fg ba f`pot`c `ffbudt bpgdodi.
Gx`kododi tlg f`cfuc`tobds kbrg f`rgauccy, wg bnsgrvg tl`t FFG l`s nggd hgfcododisodfg Vgptgkngr >:00, wlgd tlg FDL k`regt od Lbdi Ebdi, Flod` ngi`d tb irbwc`rigr, ngfbkg kbrg coquoh, `dh ng ngttgr rgiuc`tgh. Ylocg tlos struftur`c nrg`e l`s ygttb ng tgstgh st`tostof`ccy, tlg hgfcodg l`s nggd sozg`ncg. Yg aodh tl`t tlgrg os dbsoidoaof`dt hoaagrgdfg ngtwggd FFG0 (Lbdi Ebdi, Flod` FDL odvgstkgdt usodi tlgFDL abrw`rh r`tg) `dh FFG> (bdslbrg ^KN UFD_[ odvgstkgdt usodi tlg DHA r`tg).Nbtl kg`surgs hgfcodgh arbk `d `vgr`ig ba 7.>% od tlg pgrobh ngabrg Vgptgkngr >:00tb `d `vgr`ig ba >.7% od tlg pgrobh `atgr Vgptgkngr >:00. 1
Aoiurg ?= F`pot`c Fbdtrbc Gaagftovgdgss Kg`surgs(%)
@. N`sgh bd tlg FDL abrw`rh r`tg N. N`sgh bd tlg dbd-hgcovgr`ncg abrw`rh r`tg
FDL ; rgdkodno k`regt ba Lbdi Ebdi, Flod`.
Vburfg= @utlbrs' fbkput`tobds usodi h`t` arbk FGOF `dh Ncbbkngri.
Xlos aodhodi suiigsts tl`t tlg hg murg f`pot`c fbdtrbcs `hbptgh ny tlg Z^F `utlbrotyk`y db cbdigr ng suffgssauc od prgvgdtodi prbaot-hrovgd f`pot`c acbws ngtwggd LbdiEbdi, Flod` `dh tlg Z^F. Xlg c`rig `dh irbwodi tr`hg odtgir`tobd ba tlg Z^F wotlLbdi Ebdi, Flod` k`y l`vg fbdtronutgh tb tlg hg a`ftb aod`dfo`c odtgir`tobd ba tlgZ^F wotl Lbdi Ebdi, Flod` bvgr tokg, abr ` iovgd hgirgg ba hg murg f`pot`c fbdtrbcs,
1 Ot k`y ng dbtgh tl`t, wlocg tlg FFG kg`surgs s`w sl`rp hgfcodgs od >:0>, tlgy st`rtgh tb rosg od tlg
sgfbdh l`ca ba >:06, rg`flodi `s loil `s 7.?% od Agnru`ry >:08, ngabrg a`ccodi `i`od n`fe tb tlg r`digba :%‖>% od tlg sgfbdh l`ca ba >:08. Xlg rosg ba tlg FFG od tlg aorst l`ca ba >:08 fbuch ng c`rigcy`ttronutgh tb rosodi gxfl`dig r`tg vbc`tocoty `s wgcc `s ` sl`rp gxfl`dig r`tg hgprgfo`tobd gdiodggrgh ny
tlg Z^F‟s kbdgt`ry `utlbroty. Bdfg tlg ^KN rgturdgh tb ` bdg-w`y ngt abr `pprgfo`tobd wotl cottcgvbc`tocoty od tlg sgfbdh l`ca ba >:08, tlg FFG kg`surgs hrbppgh `i`od.
:
0
>
6
8
7
1
9
<
?
0:
00
0>
06
@ u i - 0 :
D b v - 0 :
A g n - 0 0
K ` y - 0 0
@ u i - 0 0
D b v - 0 0
A g n - 0 >
K ` y - 0 >
@ u i - 0 >
D b v - 0 >
A g n - 0 6
K ` y - 0 6
@ u i - 0 6
D b v - 0 6
A g n - 0 8
K ` y - 0 8
@ u i - 0 8
:
0
>
6
8
7
1
9
<
?
0:
00
0>
06
@ u i - 0 :
D b v - 0 :
A g n - 0 0
K ` y - 0 0
@ u i - 0 0
D b v - 0 0
A g n - 0 >
K ` y - 0 >
@ u i - 0 >
D b v - 0 >
A g n - 0 6
K ` y - 0 6
@ u i - 0 6
D b v - 0 6
A g n - 0 8
K ` y - 0 8
@ u i - 0 8
01
-
8/9/2019 Trilemma Challenges for the People's Republic of China
19/41
@HNO Ybreodi Z`pgr 706 E`w`o `dh Cou
tlrbuil `d gxp`dhgh usg ba tlg furrgdt `ffbudt abr f`pot`c `ffbudt purpbsgs sufl `str`hg kos-odvbofodi.
Odhggh, tlg ^KN‟s rbcg `s ` tr`hg sgttcgkgdt furrgdfy l`s a`focot`tgh hg a`ftb f`pot`cacbws tlrbuil tr`hg tr`ds`ftobds. Abr gx`kpcg, tlg Z^F‟s gxpbrt aoiurg od P0 >:06 w`s
`ndbrk`ccy c`rig. Xlg `dbk`cy fbuch ng gxpc`odgh ny tlg rbudh-troppodi ba ibbhsngtwggd Vlgdzlgd `dh Lbdi Ebdi, Flod`, `d odtgrd`tobd`c gdtrgpøt, `s wgcc `s tlgbvgr-odvbofodi ba gxpbrts arbk Vlgdzlgd.
Xlgsg tr`hg `ftovotogs odtgdh tb sgge aod`dfo`c i`ods bd c`rig bdslbrg `dh baaslbrgodtgrgst r`tg hoaagrgdto`cs (sgg Aoiurg 0:), cg`hodi tb c`rig f`pot`c odacbws, wlofl pbsgfl`ccgdigs tb tlg Z^F‟s kbdgt`ry pbcofy wlocg `hhodi `pprgfo`tobd prgssurgs tb tlg^KN gxfl`dig r`tg. Xlg `utlbrotogs l`vg l`h tb gdi`ig od pgrobhof fr`fehbwds `dhsuhhgd abrgoid gxfl`dig k`regt odtgrvgdtobds tb scbw sufl `ftovotogs.
Aoiurg 0:= Xlrgg-kbdtl VLONB^, FDL LONB^, `dh CONB^(%)
LONB^ ; Lbdi Ebdi, Flod` Odtgrn`de Baagrgh ^`tg (abr baaslbrg rgdkodno UFDL[), CONB^ ; Cbdhbd Odtgrn`deBaagrgh ^`tg (abr tlg WV hbcc`r), VLONB^ ; Vl`dil`o Odtgrn`de Baagrgh ^`tg (abr bdslbrg rgdkodno UFD_[),
Vburfg= Ncbbkngri.
^gfgdt pbcofy hgvgcbpkgdts `ccbwodi aorks cbf`tgh od tlg Vl`dil`o Argg Xr`hg ]bdg tbgxpgrokgdt wotl aurtlgr f`pot`c `ffbudt congr`coz`tobd ny t`ppodi odtb baaslbrg k`regtsabr audhodi wocc k`eg tlg gxostodi f`pot`c fbdtrbc kg`surgs gvgd cgss gaagftovg. Oa tlgfurrgdt trgdh ba hg a`ftb aod`dfo`c k`regt bpgdodi fbdtodugs, tlg Z^F‟s hg murg f`pot`cfbdtrbcs wocc cbsg gaagftovgdgss a`stgr tl`d gxpgftgh. Xlos wocc `csb kg`d tl`t ots f`pot`c`ffbudt fbuch ngfbkg kbrg bpgd (hg a`ftb) kufl a`stgr tl`d os furrgdtcy gxpgftgh ny>:>:.
:
0
>
6
8
7
1
9
M ` d - : 9
M u d - : 9
D b v - : 9
@ p r - : <
V g p - : <
A g n - : ?
M u c - : ?
H g f - : ?
K ` y - 0 :
B f t - 0 :
K ` r - 0 0
@ u i - 0 0
M ` d - 0 >
M u d - 0 >
D b v - 0 >
@ p r - 0 6
V g p - 0 6
A g n - 0 8
M u c - 0 8
6-kbdtl VLONB^ 6-kbdtl FDL LONB^ 6-kbdtl CONB^
09
-
8/9/2019 Trilemma Challenges for the People's Republic of China
20/41
@HNO Ybreodi Z`pgr 706 E`w`o `dh Cou
7. KBDGX@^_ ZBCOF_ FL@CCGDIGV OD XLGZGBZCG‟V ^GZWNCOF BA FLOD@
Xlg Z^F `utlbroty os a`fodi soidoaof`dt fl`ccgdigs od ots pursuot ba kbdgt`ry pbcofy. Xlossgftobd hosfussgs tlg okp`ft ba odfbkpcgtg odtgrgst r`tg rgabrk, tlg sprg`h ba sl`hbwn`deodi, `dh rosodi soids ba kbdgt`ry pbcofy odgaagftovgdgss.
7.0 Odtgrgst ^`tg ^gabrk
Xlg Z^F l`s usgh aod`dfo`c rgprgssobd od tlg abrk ba fbdtrbccgh odtgrgst r`tgs `dhfrghot `ccbf`tobd wotl `d `ok tb suppbrt odvgstkgdt `dh gfbdbkof irbwtl. Odtgrgst r`tgfbdtrbcs `dh btlgr aod`dfo`c rgprgssobd kg`surgs l`vg `csb cgh tb tlgudhgrhgvgcbpkgdt ba tlg aod`dfo`c sgftbr, odgaaofogdt `ccbf`tobd ba s`vodis, gxfgssovgodvgstkgdt, `dh bvgrf`p`foty od fgrt`od sgftbrs ba tlg gfbdbky.
Od 0??1, tlg Z^F gkn`regh bd odtgrgst r`tg rgabrk ny ir`hu`ccy congr`cozodi odtgrn`de
cgdhodi r`tgs. Vodfg tlgd, v`robus rgabrk kg`surgs l`vg nggd fbkpcgtgh, odfcuhodi tlg`nbcoslkgdt ba tlg uppgr cokot bd odtgrn`de cgdhodi r`tgs od 0??1, tlg congr`coz`tobd baabrgoid furrgdfy cgdhodi r`tgs od >:::, tlg rgkbv`c ba cgdhodi r`tg fgocodis abr kbstaod`dfo`c odstotutobds od >::8, tlg c`udfl ba tlg Vl`dil`o Odtgrn`de Baagrgh ^`tg(VLONB^) od >::9, tlg `nbcoslkgdt ba tlg cgdhodi r`tg acbbr, `dh tlg c`udfl baodtgrn`de dgibto`ncg fgrtoaof`tgs ba hgpbsot (DFHs) od >:06, `s slbwd od Aoiurg 00.
Aoiurg 00= Xokgcodg ba tlg Zgbpcg‟s ^gpuncof ba Flod`‟s Odtgrgst ^`tgCongr`coz`tobd
F@H ; F`d`ho`d hbcc`r, FLA ; Vwoss ar`df, INZ ; pbudh stgrcodi, ^KN ; rgdkodno.
Vburfg= Zgbpcg‟s N`de ba Flod`.
@kbdi tlg rgfgdt pbcofy fl`digs, bdg ba tlg kbst soidoaof`dt w`s tlg rgkbv`c ba tlgn`de cgdhodi r`tg acbbr od Mucy >:06, wlofl `ccbwgh n`des tb arggcy sgt tlgor bwd cgdhodir`tgs. Ylocg tlos w`s ` noi stgp od odtgrgst r`tg rgabrk, tlg `ftu`c okp`ft bd tlg rg`cgfbdbky l`s nggd quotg cokotgh. Ngabrg tlg rgabrk, `ctlbuil fbkkgrfo`c n`des l`hnggd `ccbwgh tb baagr ` hosfbudt ba up tb 6:% ba tlg ngdflk`re cgdhodi r`tg, n`des od
^`osgh cgdhodir`tg fgocodi abrsk`cc gdtgrprosgs`dh rur`c frghotudobds
0??1 0??9 0??< 0??? >::: >::0 >::> >::6 >::8 >::7 >::1 >::9 >::< >::? >:0: >:00 >:0> >:06
@nbcoslgh uppgrcokot bd odtgrn`decgdhodi r`tgs
Bpgdgh upodtgrn`de rgpbk`regts
@ccbwgh sbkg odstotutobdstb dgibto`tg r`tgs bdhgpbsots bvgr FD_6:
kocc obd `dh `nbvg 7 yg`rs
Congr`cozgh abrgoidfurrgdfy cgdhodi r`tgs `dhabrgoid furrgdfy hgpbsotr t̀gs abr hgpbsots bvgr $6koccobd
Congr`cozgh INZ,FLA, F@H hgpbsotr`tgs
^gkbvgh cgdhodi r t̀gfgocodi abr `cc aod`dfo`c
odstotutobds (gxfc. urn`d`dh rur`c frghot udobds)`dh c̀cbwgh ^KN hgpbsothosfbudt
C`udflghVl`dil ò Odtgrn`deBaagrgh ^ t̀g(VLONB^)
Cbwgrgh cgdhodi r t̀gacbbr tb :.9x `dhr`osgh hgpbsot r`tgfgocodi tb 0.0x
@nbcoslgh cgdhodi r`tg acbbr.Congr`cozgh hosfbudt r`tg.^gkbvgh cgdhodi r t̀g fgocodiabr rur c̀ frghot udobds
C`udflgh odtgrn`dedgibto`ncgfgrtoaof`tgs ba hgpbsot
>:08
^`osgh hgpbsotr`tg fgocodi tb0.6x
0
-
8/9/2019 Trilemma Challenges for the People's Republic of China
21/41
@HNO Ybreodi Z`pgr 706 E`w`o `dh Cou
pr`ftofg l`h r`rgcy hbdg sb. 9 Bdcy `nbut 00% ba cb`ds wgrg baagrgh ngcbw tlgngdflk`re r`tg tlrbuil kbst ba >:06. Xlg `vgr`ig wgoiltgh 0-yg`r cgdhodi r`tg`ftu`ccy odfrg`sgh arbk 1.9% od K`rfl tb 9.>% ny tlg gdh ba >:06.
@atgr tlg rgkbv`c ba tlg cgdhodi r`tg acbbr, tlg kbdgt`ry `utlbroty c`udflgh ` systgk
abr ` prokg cb`d r`tg (ZC^) od Bftbngr >:06. Xlos os `d odhof`tovg odtgrgst r`tg `t wloflfbkkgrfo`c n`des cgdh tb tlgor prokg fustbkgrs. Xlg ZC^ os f`cfuc`tgh `s tlgwgoiltgh `vgr`ig ba ` p`dgc ba n`des‟ cgdhodi r`tgs tl`t tlgy fl`rig tlgor ngst fcogdts.Xlos w`s `csb sggd `s ` stgp tbw`rh aurtlgr odtgrgst r`tg congr`coz`tobd, `s tlg ZC^fbuch rgpc`fg tlg furrgdt ngdflk`re pbcofy cgdhodi r`tg `dh ng ir`hu`ccy usgh `s `dgw k`regt-hrovgd ngdflk`re abr cgdhodi r`tgs.
Xlg Z^F‟s hgpbsot r`tg rgk`ods fbdtrbccgh. Xb `hh sbkg acgxonocoty tb tlg fbdtrbccghhgpbsot fgocodi r`tg, tlg `utlbroty l`s nggd t`eodi ` ir`hu`c `pprb`fl tb congr`cozodin`de hgpbsot r`tgs. Fbkkgrfo`c n`des wgrg `ccbwgh tb fl`rig ` hgpbsot r`tg prgkouk,odfrg`sodi tlg r`tg ny up tb 0:% arbk tlg ngdflk`re hgpbsot r`tg od >:0>, `dh up tb6:% od Dbvgkngr >:08.:06, wlofl wgrg profgh wotl rgagrgdfg tb tlg VLONB^. Xlos rgacgftstlg `ftu`c suppcy `dh hgk`dh fbdhotobds ba tlg odtgrn`de k`regt, sodfg odtgrn`deDFHs `rg tr`h`ncg. Xlos kg`ds tl`t c`rig hgpbsots `rg dbw profgh `ffbrhodi tb k`regthgk`dh `dh suppcy. Xlgsg pbcofy kg`surgs l`vg k`hg hgpbsot r`tgs cgss nodhodi bvgrtokg.
Od `hhotobd, fbkkgrfo`c n`des l`vg usgh baa-n`c`dfg-slggt `ftovotogs tb gv`hg tlgfbdtrbccgh hgpbsot fgocodi r`tg vo` wg`ctl k`d`igkgdt prbhufts (YKZs). Fcbsg tb87,::: YKZs wgrg ossugh od >:06 `kbudtodi tb FD_0: troccobd, `rbudh 0:% ba tlgZ^F‟s tbt`c hgpbsots. Bd `vgr`ig, YKZs baagr ` r`tg ba rgturd ba `rbudh 7.7%, wlofl oskufl loilgr tl`d tr`hotobd`c hgpbsot r`tgs (Aoiurg 0>). Aod`dfo`c oddbv`tobds sufl `sodtgrdgt-n`sgh aod`dfo`c prbhufts l`vg nggd fbkpgtodi wotl tlg n`deodi systgk abr
hgpbsots, tlus puttodi aurtlgr prgssurg bd n`des tb baagr loilgr hgpbsot r`tgs `dh kbrg`ttr`ftovg YKZ yogchs tb fbkpgtg abr n`de audhodi.
9 Yotl tlg cb`d r`tg hosfbudt, tlg kodokuk cb`d r`tg n`des fbuch fl`rig bd 0-yg`r cb`ds ngf`kg 8.>%
wlgd tlg 0-yg`r ngdflk`re cb`d r`tg w`s 1%.<
Yotl tlg hgpbsot r`tg prgkouk, tlg k`xokuk hgpbsot r`tg n`des fbuch baagr bd 0-yg`r hgpbsots ngf`kg6.?% `s tlg 0-yg`r ngdflk`re hgpbsot r`tg w`s 6%.
0?
-
8/9/2019 Trilemma Challenges for the People's Republic of China
22/41
@HNO Ybreodi Z`pgr 706 E`w`o `dh Cou
Aoiurg 0>= Hgpbsot Odtgrgst ^`tg, Yg`ctl K`d`igkgdt Zrbhuft ^`tg ba ^gturd,`dh Fbdsukgr Zrofg Odhgx Odac`tobd ^`tg (yg`r-bd-yg r̀, %)
FZO ; fbdsukgr profg odhgx, YKZ ; wg`ctl k`d`igkgdt prbhuft.
Vburfgs= FGOF5 YODH.
7.> Vprg`h ba Vl`hbw N`deodi @ftovotogs
Vl`hbw n`deodi rgagrs tb frghot odtgrkgho`tobd odvbcvodi gdtotogs br `ftovotogs ny dbd-
n`des, p`rtofuc`rcy aod`dfo`c odtgrkgho`tobd butsohg tlg rgiuc`tgh n`deodi systgk (OKA>:08`). Xb `ppcy tlos fbdfgpt tb tlg Z^F, ots sl`hbw n`deodi fbdsosts ba aod`dfo`codstotutobd nusodgss (baa-n`c`dfg-slggt `ssgts ny n`des dbt sunmgft tb rgiuc`tobd), trustprbhufts, `dh udhgrirbudh n`deodi. Yg gstok`tg tl`t tlg sl`hbw n`deodi `ftovotogs odtlg Z^F fbuch ng `t cg`st FD_6: troccobd, gquov`cgdt tb 7>% ba IHZ od >:06 br 0?% batbt`c n`de `ssgts od tlg Z^F.
Fbkkgrfo`c n`des `rg sunmgft tb toilt rgiuc`tobds, sufl `s ` cokot bd tlg hgpbsot r`tgfgocodi, tlg 97% cb`d-tb-hgpbsot r`tob rgquorgkgdt, `dh tlg f`pot`c `hgqu`fyrgquorgkgdt. Iovgd tlg rosodi hgk`dh abr frghot, fbkkgrfo`c n`des od tlg Z^F ngi`dtb gv`hg sufl toilt rgiuc`tobds tlrbuil v`robus kg`surgs. Xlgsg odfcuhg= (o) aod`dfo`codstotutobd nusodgss, o.g., fl`ddgcodi c`rig `kbudts ba hgpbsots tb btlgr aod`dfo`codstotutobds (nbtl n`des `dh dbd-n`de aod`dfo`c odstotutobds) wlofl, udcoeg fbrpbr`tgcgdhodi nusodgss, os dbt sunmgft tb tlg 97% cb`d-tb-hgpbsot r`tob rgquorgkgdt br tlg loilf`pot`c rgquorgkgdt5 (oo) trust prbhufts, o.g., fbccgftodi qu`so-hgpbsots (trust audhs, YKZs,gtf.) arbk tlg puncof tb aod`dfg baa-n`c`dfg-slggt `ftovotogs5 `dh (ooo) udhgrirbudhn`deodi, o.g., udhgrt`eodi odabrk`c n`deodi od tlg abrk ba horgftcy odtgrkgho`todi prov`tgaudhs `kbdi gdtgrprosgs `dh odhovohu`cs, wlofl os dbt sunmgft tb tlg dbrk`c rgiuc`tobdsba tlg abrk`c n`deodi systgk.?
? Yotl rgi`rh tb qu`so-hgpbsots, od `hhotobd tb nbrrbwodi `kbdi tlgksgcvgs, n`des dbrk`ccy ossug YKZs
tb aod`dfg baa-n`c`dfg-slggt prbhufts. Bvgr`cc, aoxgh-r`tg YKZs prbvohg kufl loilgr yogchs tl`drgiuc`tgh hgpbsots. Xypof`ccy, fbkkgrfo`c n`des sgt up ` –f`pot`c pbbc‛ wlofl fbdsosts ba nbdhs, trust
prbhufts, cb`d-coeg fc`oks, `dh odtgr-n`de cb`ds. N`sgh bd tlos pbbc, fbkkgrfo`c n`des ossug slbrt-tgdbrYKZs tb k`tfl cbdi-tgrk `ssgts, kufl coeg wl`t `d `ssgt k`d`igkgdt fbkp`dy (wotlod ` n`de) hbgs.
0
>
6
8
7
1
9
@ u i - 0 :
B f t - 0 :
H g f - 0 :
A g n - 0 0
@ p r - 0 0
M u d - 0 0
@ u i - 0 0
B f t - 0 0
H g f - 0 0
A g n - 0 >
@ p r - 0 >
M u d - 0 >
@ u i - 0 >
B f t - 0 >
H g f - 0 >
A g n - 0 6
@ p r - 0 6
M u d - 0 6
@ u i - 0 6
B f t - 0 6
H g f - 0 6
A g n - 0 8
@ p r - 0 8
M u d - 0 8
@ u i - 0 8
Hgpbsot r`tg YKZ r`tg ba rgturd FZO odac`tobd r`tg (y-b-y)
>:
-
8/9/2019 Trilemma Challenges for the People's Republic of China
23/41
@HNO Ybreodi Z`pgr 706 E`w`o `dh Cou
Odtgrdgt aod`dfo`c prbhufts `dh kbdgy k`regt audhs l`vg `csb hgvgcbpgh r`pohcy tbgv`hg abrk`c n`deodi rgiuc`tobds. _u‟g N`b, tlg noiigst odtgrdgt aod`dfo`c prbhuft, os `dodvgstkgdt prbhuft baagrgh ny @cop`y, usgrs ba wlofl f`d put tlgor kbdgy odtb tlgprbhuft wotl db kodokuk `kbudt rgquorgkgdt `dh wotlhr`w tlgor f`sl `dytokg, `eod tb`d bpgd-gdh kbdgy k`regt audh. Kbdgy k`regt audhs put kbrg tl`d ?:% ba tlgorkbdgy `s aod`dfo`c odstotutobd hgpbsots od fbkkgrfo`c n`des. Aod`dfo`c odstotutobdhgpbsot r`tgs `rg dgibto`ncg, `dh dbt sunmgft tb tlg n`des‟ rgsgrvg rgquorgkgdts.
Xlg sl`hbw n`deodi systgk l`s pbsgh rgiuc`tbry fl`ccgdigs tb tlg Z^F‟s aod`dfo`cst`nocoty. Aorst, ots r`poh hgvgcbpkgdt fbuch abrfg tlg rgiuc`tgh n`deodi sgftbr tb gxp`dhots baa-n`c`dfg-slggt `ftovotogs od brhgr tb fbkpgtg wotl dbd-n`de aod`dfo`c odstotutobdsabr hgpbsots, odtgrdgt aod`dfo`c prbhufts, gtf. C`rig baa-n`c`dfg `ftovotogs fbuch k`egfbkkgrfo`c n`de hgpbsots kbrg slbrt tgrk, tlus gx`fgrn`todi k`turoty kosk`tflgs`dh hgst`nocozodi tlg bvgr`cc n`deodi systgk. Vgfbdh, fgrt`od aod`dfo`c odstotutobds `rgdbt sunmgft tb tlg s`kg pruhgdto`c rgiuc`tobds `s hgpbsot-t`eodi odstotutobds. @s ` rgsuct,tlgy fbuch odfrg`sg tlgor aod`dfo`c cgvgr`ig, k`idoayodi nbtl prbaots hurodi ` nbbk yg`r`dh cbssgs hurodi ` hbwdturd. Xlorh, tlg abrk`c n`deodi sgftbr l`s tlg odfgdtovg tb
prbvohg cb`ds tb dbd-n`de aod`dfo`c odstotutobds ngf`usg sufl cb`ds `rg sunmgft tb bdcy` qu`rtgr ba rgiuc`tbry f`pot`c rgquorgkgdt. Xlos wbuch odfrg`sg aod`dfo`c codes ngtwggdn`des `dh dbd-n`de aod`dfo`c odstotutobds. Xlus tlg gxp`dsobd ba sl`hbw n`deodi fbuchpbsg aod`dfo`c roses tb tlg abrk`c n`deodi sgftbr ngf`usg ba ots rosodiodtgrfbddgftghdgss wotl pbtgdto`ccy udst`ncg sl`hbw n`deodi `ftovotogs.
7.6 ^osodi Voids ba Zbcofy Odgaagftovgdgss
Vodfg tlg gruptobd ba tlg IAF, tlg Z^F‟s kbdgt`ry `utlbroty l`s `hmustgh ots kbdgt`rypbcofy st`dfg od rgspbdsg tb fl`diodi prbspgfts ba IHZ irbwtl `dh fbdsukgr profgodhgx (FZO) odac`tobd. A`fodi tlg IAF od tlg aod`c qu`rtgr ba >:::0:‖>:00, tlg kbdgt`ry `utlbroty sloatghots kbdgt`ry st`dfg arbk aoiltodi `i`odst tlg frosos tb fbkn`todi odac`tobd ny r`osodi tlgngdflk`re hgpbsot `dh cb`d r`tgs `dh tlg rgsgrvg rgquorgkgdt r`tob. Xlg rgsgrvgrgquorgkgdt r`tob w`s r`osgh 0> tokgs, wlocg tlg odtgrgst r`tg w`s `hmustgh 7 tokgshurodi tlos pgrobh. Ylgd tlg Gurbpg`d aod`dfo`c frosos hggpgdgh od tlg sgfbdh l`ca ba>:00 `dh >:0>, tlg kbdgt`ry `utlbroty ir`hu`ccy g`sgh ots pbcofy.
Arbk –f`sl frudflgs‛ tb –qu`dtoty swodis‛
Arbk K`y >:0>, tlg kbdgt`ry `utlbroty sggkgh tb l`vg `vbohgh tlg usg ba ots
tr`hotobd`c pbcofy tbbceot, sufl `s `hmustodi tlg rgsgrvg rgquorgkgdt r`tob `dh tlgngdflk`re odtgrgst r`tg tb fbdhuft kbdgt`ry pbcofy. Odstg`h, ot ngi`d tb rgcy bd bpgdk`regt bpgr`tobds odtgdsovgcy vo` rgpbs `dh rgvgrsg rgpbs tb odmgft `dh wotlhr`wcoquohoty arbk tlg n`deodi systgk. @s ` rgsuct, c`rig swodis ba odtgrgst r`tgs `dh cb`dqu`dtotogs wgrg bnsgrvgh hurodi Mudg‖Mucy >:06.
Od koh-Mudg >:06, ` suhhgd rg-profodi ba fbudtgr-p`rty rose nrbuilt `nbut ` surig odtlg slbrt-tgrk odtgrgst r`tg `dh tlgrg`atgr, soidoaof`dt vbc`tocoty od tlg kbdgy k`regt.Xlg 9-h`y rgpb r`tg, ` rgco`ncg odhof`tbr kg`surodi k`regt coquohoty fbdhotobds, surightb `ckbst 0>% arbk cgss tl`d 8% od ` h`y, wotl tlg loil r`tg c`stodi abr > wgges. Xlgk`regt p`dof frg`tgh –f`sl frudflgs‛ od tlg Z^F‟s odtgrn`de k`regts. Xlg `utlbrotyaod`ccy odmgftgh coquohoty odtb tlg n`deodi systgk > wgges c`tgr vo` tlg slbrt-tgrk cgdhodi
a`focoty (VCA), wlofl g`sgh k`regt coquohoty fbdhotobds od Mucy >:06. Xlg 9-h`y rgpbsrgk`odgh quotg vbc`tocg udtoc M`du`ry >:08 `atgr tlg `utlbroty gdi`igh od –hbuncg
>0
-
8/9/2019 Trilemma Challenges for the People's Republic of China
24/41
@HNO Ybreodi Z`pgr 706 E`w`o `dh Cou
odtgrvgdtobds,‛ o.g., odtgrvgdtobds od nbtl tlg abrgoid gxfl`dig `dh kbdgy k`regts vo`udstgrocozgh odtgrvgdtobds, cg`hodi tb ^KN hgprgfo`tobd `dh kbdgy k`regt r`tghgfcodgs.
Vodfg tlg Mudg >:06 –f`sl frudflgs,‛ tlg `utlbroty `ppg`rs tb l`vg ngfbkg kbrg
prb`ftovg od k`d`iodi kbdgy k`regt coquohoty fbdhotobds. Lbwgvgr, tlg qu`dtoty bacb`ds prbvohgh l`s ngfbkg cgss st`ncg tl`d ngabrg. Xlg Z^F‟s dgw ^KN cb`ds wgrgbdcy FD_6:08, kufl cbwgr tl`d tlg k`regt fbdsgdsus ba FD_9::< Cglk`d fbcc`psg.0:
Vufl c`rig swodis, od tgrks ba kbdgy k`regt r`tgs br cb`d qu`dtotogs, fbuch frg`tgsoidoaof`dt slbfes tb tlg aod`dfo`c systgk `dh r`osg rose prgkouks sl`rpcy, tlgrgnyf`usodi c`rig swodis od rg`c IHZ irbwtl.
Fl`diodi kbdgt`ry pbcofy gdvorbdkgdts
Ylocg tlg kbdgt`ry `utlbroty l`s dbt `hmustgh ots pbcofy st`dfg od ` soidoaof`dt w`ysodfg Mucy >:0>, tlg icbn`c aod`dfo`c gdvorbdkgdt `dh hbkgstof gfbdbkof fbdhotobdsl`vg fl`digh. Hbkgstof`ccy, tlg Z^F‟s irbwtl l`s kbhgr`tgh arbk `rbudh ?% tb9.7%. @s tlg butput i`p d`rrbwgh sl`rpcy, tlg rose ba hgac`tobd l`s rosgd. Xlg Z^F‟sprbhufgr profg odhgx (ZZO) l`s gxpgrogdfgh pgrsostgdt hgac`tobd sodfg K`rfl >:0>.Gxtgrd`ccy, tlg WV Aghgr`c ^gsgrvg Vystgk (Agh) gxp`dhgh `ssgt purfl`sgs (`hbptobdba PG6), gdhgh PG, `dh os dbw lg`hodi tbw`rh kbdgt`ry pbcofy dbrk`coz`tobd5 tlgGurbpg`d Fgdtr`c N`de (GFN) fut odtgrgst r`tgs tlrofg5 `dh tlg N`de ba M`p`d ngi`d`d `iirgssovg qu`dtot`tovg `dh qu`cot`tovg g`sodi prbir`k udhgr tlg n`ddgr ba @ngdbkofs.
Vbkg egy fgdtr`c n`des od @so` `dh Bfg`do` (tlg ^gsgrvg N`de ba @ustr`co`, tlg N`deba Ebrg`, `dh tlg N`de ba Xl`oc`dh) l`vg fut tlgor bwd pbcofy r`tgs od brhgr tb rghufgodtgrgst r`tg hoaagrgdto`cs od `d `ttgkpt tb prgvgdt bvgr-v`cugh furrgdfogs abrfbkpgtotovgdgss rg`sbds. Xlg Z^F‟s `utlbroty, bd tlg btlgr l`dh, rgar`odgh arbk usodiots tr`hotobd`c pbcofy tbbceots sufl `s fl`digs od tlg ngdflk`re odtgrgst r`tg `dh tlgrgsgrvg rgquorgkgdt r`tob ngf`usg ba tlg dggh tb durturg ` pbcofy t`rigt odtgrgst r`tg.Odstg`h, ot l`s rgcogh bd bpgd k`regt bpgr`tobds tb k`d`ig coquohoty fbdhotobds. @sslbwd od tlg prgvobus sgftobd, tlg c`rig odtgrgst r`tg hoaagrgdto`c ngtwggd bdslbrg `dhbaaslbrg k`regts wotl cottcg gxfl`dig r`tg vbc`tocoty cgh tb c`rig f`pot`c odacbws (Aoiurg 9).Od >:06 `cbdg, dgt f`pot`c odacbws odtb tlg Z^F wgrg fcbsg tb $7:: noccobd. Abr tlg aorst >qu`rtgrs ba >:08, dgt f`pot`c odacbw w`s kbrg tl`d $>:: noccobd.
Ylocg tlg Z^F l`s t`egd orrgvgrsoncg stgps tb prbirgssovgcy bpgdodi tlg f`pot`c`ffbudt, ots gxfl`dig r`tg pbcofy l`s rgk`odgh roioh, stg`hocy `pprgfo`todi `i`odst tlg
WV hbcc`r. Xlos fbdhotobd l`s hr`wd c`rig f`pot`c odacbws bd soz`ncg odtgrgst r`tghoaagrgdto`cs `dh gxpgft`tobds ba ^KN `pprgfo`tobd, tlus cokotodi kbdgt`ry pbcofygaagftovgdgss `dh `utbdbky.
^osodi soids ba `ssgt profg nunncgs
Fbrpbr`tg cb`ds `s ` pgrfgdt`ig ba tlg Z^F‟s `iirgi`tg aod`dfodi l`vg fbdtodugh tbhgfcodg `dh ZZO odac`tobd l`s rgk`odgh dgi`tovg abr dg`rcy > yg`rs, suiigstodi tl`thgk`dh abr frghot arbk tlg rg`c sgftbr l`s rgk`odgh wg`e. Kg`dwlocg, n`des‟ rgsgrvg
0: Wdhosfbudtgh n`de noccs hgfcodgh ny FD_801 noccobd od Mucy >:08, abccbwodi ` FD_088 noccobd odfrg`sg odtlg prgvobus kbdtl, c`rigcy bwodi tb tlg fr`fehbwd bd fbkkbhoty aod`dfodi abccbwodi tlg Podih`b pbrt
ar`uh f`sg. Xrust `dh gdtrustgh cb`d irbwtl `csb sbatgdgh, odhof`todi tl`t sl`hbw n`deodi `ftovotogsl`vg scbwgh hbwd sl`rpcy, wotl aurtlgr dgi`tovg okpcof`tobds abr tlg prbpgrty sgftbr.
>>
-
8/9/2019 Trilemma Challenges for the People's Republic of China
25/41
@HNO Ybreodi Z`pgr 706 E`w`o `dh Cou
kbdgy l`s rosgd bd c`rig f`pot`c odacbws tl`t l`vg cgh tb ` r`poh `ffukuc`tobd baabrgoid gxfl`dig rgsgrvgs (Aoiurg 06). Xb kggt tlgor prbaot irbwtl t`rigt, fbkkgrfo`cn`des l`vg frg`tgh dgw aod`dfo`c vglofcgs tb gxp`dh tlgor n`c`dfg slggts abr aod`dfo`c`ftovotogs. Vufl `ftovotogs l`vg rgsuctgh od ` surig od kbdgy suppcy wotlbut soidoaof`dtaod`dfo`c odtgrkgho`tobd tb tlg rg`c sgftbr.
Aoiurg 06= Kbdgt`ry N`sg `dh Dgt Abrgoid @ssgts Zurfl`sgh ny tlg Zgbpcg‟sN`de ba Flod` (FD_ troccobd)
FD_ ; rgdkodno, ZNbF ; Zgbpcg‟s N`de ba Flod`.
Vburfg= YODH.
Kbdgy l`s nyp`ssgh tlg rg`c sgftbr `dh nggd fl`ddgcgh odtb loil-rgturd, loil-rosesgftbrs sufl `s tlg prbpgrty k`regt. Od >:06, tlg Z^F‟s prbpgrty profgs sb`rgh `i`od,cgh ny aorst-togr fotogs. Ylocg tlg stbfe k`regt l`s rgk`odgh hgprgssgh, btlgr `ssgtk`regts sufl `s abr `rt fbccgftobds `dh plysof`c ibch odvgstkgdts l`vg ngfbkgnuby`dt, rgacgftodi ` sokkgrodi `ssgt profg nunncg.
1. GKZO^OF@C GQOHGDFG BD HOKODOVLODI KBDGX@^_ZBCOF_ @WXBDBK_ OD XLG ZGBZCG‟V ^GZWNCOFBA FLOD@
Xlg prgvobus sgftobd fbdsohgrgh tlg v`robus fl`ccgdigs a`fodi tlg Z^F‟s kbdgt`rypbcofy. Kufl hbfukgdtgh h`t` suiigst tl`t kbdgt`ry pbcofy gaagftovgdgss l`s hgfcodghod tlg Z^F `dh ots pbcofy `utbdbky l`s grbhgh wotl r`poh ^KN odtgrd`tobd`coz`tobd `dh` cokotgh ygt odfrg`sodicy bpgd f`pot`c `ffbudt. Xlg prbncgk sggks tb stgk arbk tlga`ft tl`t tlg Z^F‟s f`pot`c fbdtrbcs l`vg ngfbkg cgss gaagftovg bvgr tokg wlocg otsgxfl`dig r`tg rgiokg l`s rgk`odgh roioh hgspotg rgfgdt gaabrts tb k`eg ot kbrg acgxoncg.Od tlos sgftobd, wg gx`kodg tlg Z^F‟s kbdgt`ry pbcofy gaagftovgdgss `dh `utbdbkyusodi ` sgt ba gfbdbkgtrof `d`cysgs.
:
7
0:
07
>:
>7
6:
M ` d - : :
M u c - : :
M ` d - : 0
M u c - : 0
M ` d - : >
M u c - : >
M ` d - : 6
M u c - : 6
M ` d - : 8
M u c - : 8
M ` d - : 7
M u c - : 7
M ` d - : 1
M u c - : 1
M ` d - : 9
M u c - : 9
M ` d - : <
M u c - : <
M ` d - : ?
M u c - : ?
M ` d - 0 :
M u c - 0 :
M ` d - 0 0
M u c - 0 0
M ` d - 0 >
M u c - 0 >
M ` d - 0 6
M u c - 0 6
M ` d - 0 8
Kbdgt`ry n`sg Dgt abrgoid ̀ ssgts lgch ny ZNbF
>6
-
8/9/2019 Trilemma Challenges for the People's Republic of China
26/41
@HNO Ybreodi Z`pgr 706 E`w`o `dh Cou
1.0 Kbdgt`ry Zbcofy Ar`kgwbre ba tlg Zgbpcg‟s ^gpuncof baFlod`
Xlg bnmgftovg ba tlg Z^F‟s kbdgt`ry pbcofy os tb k`odt`od profg st`nocoty sb `s tb
prbkbtg gfbdbkof irbwtl udhgr tlg k`dh`tg ba tlg c`w ba tlg Zgbpcg‟s N`de ba Flod`(ZNbF). Xb `flogvg tlgsg hu`c pbcofy bnmgftovgs, tlg kbdgt`ry `utlbroty k`y usgv`robus pbcofy odstrukgdts sufl `s rgsgrvg rgquorgkgdt r`tobs, fgdtr`c n`de ngdflk`recgdhodi `dh hgpbsot odtgrgst r`tgs, rg-hosfbudtodi, fgdtr`c n`de cgdhodi, bpgd k`regtbpgr`tobds, `dh btlgr `hkodostr`tovg br wodhbw iuoh`dfg kg`surgs. Ylgd pursuodipbcofy k`dh`tgs, tlg kbdgt`ry `utlbroty gdfbudtgrs sbkg pr`ftof`c fbdstr`odts. Iovgdtlg cgss hgvgcbpgh aod`dfo`c k`regts, ot `csb l`s tlg rgspbdsonocoty tb prbkbtg aod`dfo`ck`regt congr`coz`tobd `dh rgabrks.
Ot k`y ng `riugh tl`t tlg Z^F‟s `utlbroty `ppcogs nbtl qu`dtoty `dh profg odstrukgdtstb fbdhuft kbdgt`ry pbcofy wlocg ngodi fbdstr`odgh ny tlg cgss gaaofogdt aod`dfo`csystgk. C`urgds `dh K`odb (>::9) hgsfrong tlg prbfgss ba sgttodi tlg kbdgt`ry pbcofy
ar`kgwbre od tlg Z^F od tlg abccbwodi w`y= tlg kbdgt`ry `utlbroty aorst sgts dukgrof`ct`rigts abr tlg qu`dtoty ba kbdgy suppcy `dh frghot irbwtl `s ots odtgrkgho`tg qu`dtotyt`rigts `t tlg ngioddodi ba g`fl yg`r, `dh tlgd kbdotbrs tlgsg odtgrkgho`tg t`rigtsfcbsgcy hurodi tlg fbursg ba tlg yg`r `dh aodg-tudgs hgvo`tobds arbk tlgsg t`rigts ny `dukngr ba pbcofy odstrukgdts sufl `s rgsgrvg rgquorgkgdts, bpgd k`regt bpgr`tobds,pbcofy odtgrgst r`tgs, `dh wodhbw iuoh`dfg kg`surgs. Cou `dh ]l`di (>:0:) `riughtl`t tlg usg ba slbrt-tgrk odtgrgst r`tgs `cbdg wbuch ng od`hgqu`tg od tlg Z^F, hug tbtlg wg`e odtgrgst-r`tg tr`dskossobd fl`ddgc, p`rtcy rgacgftodi tlg hbkod`dfg ba st`tg-bwdgh fbkkgrfo`c n`des wotl ` pgdfl`dt tb cgdh tb st`tg-bwdgh gdtgrprosgs (VBGs).Xlgy `csb hgkbdstr`tgh tl`t dgotlgr ` st`dh`rh X`ycbr rucg (X`ycbr 0??6) dbr ` qu`dtotyba kbdgy rucg od tlg sporot ba KfF`ccuk (0? irbwtl wgcc. Ew`d (>:06) gstok`tgh tlg X`ycbr rucg abr tlg Z^F hurodi tlg pbst-
Cglk`d pgrobh `dh abudh tl`t tlg odtgrgst r`tg pbcofy hoh dbt pc`y ` rbcg od st`nocozoditlg Z^F's k`frb gfbdbky. Bd tlg btlgr l`dh, A`d, _u, `dh ]l`di (>:00) abudh tl`ttlg KfF`ccuk rucg w`s `ncg tb gxpc`od tlg kbvgkgdt ba rg`c kbdgy suppcy wgcc.
Od tlos sgftobd, wg `ttgkpt tb ohgdtoay tlg Z^F‟s kbdgt`ry pbcofy rucg `dh gx`kodgwlgtlgr tlg rucg tl`t usgh tb wbre wgcc udhgr tlg roioh f`pot`c fbdtrbc systgk l`sngfbkg cbbsg `dh odfrg`sodicy fbdstr`odgh ny ots bwd gxfl`dig r`tg rgiokg `dh/brgxtgrd`c kbdgt`ry hgvgcbpkgdts.00 Oa wg aodh tl`t ` k`mbr kbdgt`ry pbcofy odstrukgdt,sufl `s tlg pbcofy odtgrgst r`tg `dh irbwtl ba kbdgt`ry `iirgi`tgs, w`s usghsuffgssauccy tb `flogvg hbkgstof pbcofy bnmgftovgs (profg st`nocoty `dh gfbdbkof irbwtl)wotlbut ngodi soidoaof`dtcy fbdstr`odgh ny abrgoid kbdgt`ry pbcofy fl`digs br ots bwdgxfl`dig r`tg rgiokg, tlgd wg f`d fbdfcuhg tl`t tlg Z^F `utlbroty rgt`ods kbdgt`ry
pbcofy `utbdbky. @dh oa tlg pbcofy odstrukgdt os odacugdfgh ny tlg abrgoid odtgrgst r`tg(od tlg f`sg ba tlg pbcofy odtgrgst r`tg `s ` pbcofy odstrukgdt) br ny tlg p`fg ba abrgoidgxfl`dig rgsgrvg `ffukuc`tobd (od tlg f`sg ba tlg irbwtl ba kbdgt`ry `iirgi`tgs `s `pbcofy odstrukgdt) r`tlgr tl`d ny tlg fbdsohgr`tobd ba hbkgstof gfbdbkof st`nocoz`tobd,wg f`d fbdfcuhg tl`t tlg Z^F `utlbroty hbgs dbt l`vg pbcofy `utbdbky.
00 Yg hb tlos hgspotg tlg fc`ok k`hg ny tlg ZNbF tl`t tlg kbdgt`ry `utlbroty l`s kuctopcg pbcofy t`rigts
(sufl `s gkpcbykgdt, profg st`nocoty, n`c`dfg ba p`ykgdts, `dh prbkbtodi aod`dfo`c rgabrk) `dh tl`tdgotlgr profg-n`sgh (odtgrgst r`tg) rucg dbr qu`dtoty-n`sgh (kbdgy suppcy) rucg os suot`ncg tb tlg Z^F.
>8
-
8/9/2019 Trilemma Challenges for the People's Republic of China
27/41
@HNO Ybreodi Z`pgr 706 E`w`o `dh Cou
1.> Gkporof`c Kbhgcs abr Xgstodi Kbdgt`ry Zbcofy @utbdbky
Vlbrt-tgrk odtgrgst r`tg `s ` pbcofy odstrukgdt
Aorst, abccbwodi Otb `dh E`w`o (>:08), wg prbpbsg usodi tlg abccbwodi gqu`tobds tb tgst
tlg Z^F‟s kbdgt`ry pbcofy `utbdbky=
t t t uoo ++; *
:: ξ ΰ (8)
t t t yt v yo +++; ϊ ρ ρ ρ ϊ ~~
::: (7)
,~~ 00*
00 t t t yt t w yoo ++++; ϊ ρ ρ ξ ΰ ϊ (1)
wlgrg t o os tlg pbcofy odtgrgst r`tg tlg Z^F `utlbroty sgts `dh*
t o os tlg WV hbcc`r
Cbdhbd Odtgrn`de Baagrgh ^`tg (CONB^).0> Od tlg X`ycbr rucg ba gqu`tobd (7),t y
~ os tlg
irbwtl r`tg ba odhustro`c prbhuftobd `dht ϊ
~ os tlg odac`tobd i`p, o.g., tlg hoaagrgdfg
ngtwggd tlg `ftu`c `dh t`rigt odac`tobd r`tgs.06
Gqu`tobd (1) os ` fbknod`tobd bagqu`tobds (8) `dh (7).
Otb `dh E`w`o (>:08) tlgd usg tlg bvgr`cc gstok`tobd pgrabrk`dfg ba gqu`tobds (8), (7),`dh (1) tb muhig tlg hgirgg ba kbdgt`ry pbcofy `utbdbky. Oa tlg Z^F‟s kbdgt`ry pbcofy
fcbsgcy abccbws tlg kbdgt`ry pbcofy ba tlg n`sg fbudtry, tlg fbgaaofogdt : ξ os
soidoaof`dtcy pbsotovg `dh fcbsg tb udoty `dh tlg ibbhdgss ba aot ba gqu`tobd (8) os loil. Odtlos f`sg, tlg Z^F l`s db kbdgt`ry pbcofy `utbdbky. Oa tlg Z^F `utlbroty abccbws tlg
X`ycbr rucg tb `flogvg hbkgstof bnmgftovgs, tlgd :: ≧ yρ , :: ≧ϊ ρ , `dh tlg ibbhdgss ba
aot ba gqu`tobd (7) os loil. Od tlos f`sg tlg Z^F `utlbroty l`s aucc kbdgt`ry pbcofy`utbdbky. Ylgd tlg `utlbroty abccbws nbtl tlg abrgoid odtgrgst r`tg `dh hbkgstof
bnmgftovgs, tlgd :0 ≧
ξ , :0 ≧ yρ , :0
≧ϊ ρ , `dh tlg ibbhdgss ba aot ba gqu`tobd (1) os loil.
Od tlos f`sg, tlg Z^F `utlbroty l`s sbkg, nut dbt aucc, kbdgt`ry pbcofy `utbdbky. Ygdggh tb p`y `ttgdtobd tb tlg soids `dh st`tostof`c soidoaof`dfg ba tlg gstok`tghfbgaaofogdts `s wgcc `s tlg sozg ba tlg `hmustgh ^-squ`rgh od muhiodi tlg hgirgg bakbdgt`ry pbcofy `utbdbky.
0> Otb `dh E`w`o (>:08) usg
*
t o abr tlg sydtlgtof abrgoid odtgrgst r`tg arbk tlg pbodt ba vogw ba ` fbudtry,
wlofl os tlg wgoiltgh `vgr`ig ba tlg abrgoid odtgrgst r`tgs, wotl tlg wgoilts ngodi gstok`tgh arbk tlgAr`degc `dh Ygo (0??8) kbhgc. Iovgd tl`t tlg ^KN gxfl`dig r`tg l`s `ssoidgh ` wgoilt ba bvgr ?8%tb tlg WV hbcc`r, wg usg tlg WV hbcc`r CONB^ `s tlg abrgoid odtgrgst r`tg.
06 Xlg X`ycbr gqu`tobd typof`ccy odfcuhgs tlg IHZ i`p, o.g., tlg hoaagrgdfg ngtwggd `ftu`c IHZ `dhpbtgdto`c IHZ `s wgcc `s tlg odac`tobd r`tg i`p bd tlg roilt-l`dh sohg ba gqu`tobd (7). Bdg koilt `riugtl`t tlg roilt-l`dh sohg ba tlg gqu`tobd slbuch `csb odfcuhg tlg gxfl`dig r`tg i`p, od tlg f`sg ba tlgZ^F, `s tlg fbudtry l`s nggd st`nocozodi tlg gxfl`dig r`tg. Yg sokpcoay bur `d`cysos ny oidbrodi tlospbssonocoty. @s IHZ h`t` `rg `v`oc`ncg `t kbst bd ` qu`rtgrcy n`sos, ots usg wbuch cokot tlg dukngr babnsgrv`tobds od bur s`kpcg. Xlus, wg l`vg hgfohgh tb usg tlg kbdtlcy irbwtl r`tg ba odhustro`c
prbhuftobd od gstok`todi gqu`tobds (7) `dh (1) `s tlos wbuch `ccbw us tb l`vg ` c`rigr dukngr babnsgrv`tobds.
>7
-
8/9/2019 Trilemma Challenges for the People's Republic of China
28/41
@HNO Ybreodi Z`pgr 706 E`w`o `dh Cou
Kbdgt`ry `iirgi`tgs `s ` pbcofy odstrukgdt
Yg dgxt fbdsohgr tlg pbssonocoty tl`t kbdgt`ry `iirgi`tgs, r`diodi arbk d`rr bw tbnrb`h hgaodotobds ba tlg kbdgy suppcy (K:, K0, `dh K>), `rg usgh `s pbcofy tbbcs. 08 Abrtlos purpbsg, wg fbdsohgr tlg abccbwodi tlrgg gqu`tobds=
t t t A\^ A\^ K K η ζ · +∁+;∁ // :: (9)
t t t yt y K K λ ϊ μ μ μ ϊ +++;∁ ~~/ :::
(, `dh hgpbsots ba tlg Lbusodi ZrbvohgdtAudh K`d`igkgdt Fgdtgr, `dh hgpbsots ba dbd-hgpbsot`ry aod`dfo`c odstotutobds od hgpbsotbry aod`dfo`codstotutobds od Bftbngr >:00. Ot os dbtgh tl`t K: os ` d`rrbwgr fbdfgpt ba kbdgy suppcy tl`d tlgkbdgt`ry n`sg.
07 Od los abrkuc`tobd, KfF`ccuk (0?1
-
8/9/2019 Trilemma Challenges for the People's Republic of China
29/41
@HNO Ybreodi Z`pgr 706 E`w`o `dh Cou
odstrukgdt. Oa wg aodh gvohgdfg tl`t tlg Z^F‟s kbdgt`ry pbcofy abccbwgh tlg X`ycbr rucgod g`rcogr yg`rs nut dbt `s fcbsgcy od c`tgr yg`rs, wg k`y fbdfcuhg tl`t kbdgt`ry pbcofy`utbdbky l`s hokodoslgh. Dgxt, wg tgst kbdgt`ry pbcofy `utbdbky ny gx`kododigqu`tobds (9), (:::00, >:0>, `dh>:06 bd udgxpgftgh sloats od tlg tokg sgrogs, abr wlofl tlg A-st`tostofs `rg c`rigr tl`dtlg frotof`c v`cugs. Hukky v`ro`ncgs wgrg `hhgh tb tlg aorst hoaagrgdfg vgrsobd bagqu`tobd (8) tb t`eg odtb `ffbudt tl`t k`mbr gvgdts k`y l`vg f`usgh struftur`c nrg`es`dh `aagftgh tlg odtgrgst r`tg pbcofy flbofgs.01 Lbwgvgr, tlg rgsucts l`vg dbt odhof`tghkufl hoaagrgdfg.
Xlg rgirgssobd rgsucts ba tlg aorst-hoaagrgdfg vgrsobd ba gqu`tobd (8) abr tlg twb slbrt-
tgrk odtgrgst r`tgs (9-h`y rgpb `dh 9-h`y FLONB^) `rg sukk`rozgh od X`ncg >. Ygsgp`r`tg tlg s`kpcg (Bftbngr >::8‖Bftbngr >:08 od tlg f`sg ba tlg 9-h`y rgpb, `dhVgptgkngr >::0‖Vgptgkngr >:08 od tlg f`sg ba tlg 9-h`y FLONB^) odtb twbsunpgrobhs‘tl`t os, tlg pgrobh ngabrg tlg IAF `dh tlg pgrobh `atgr‘tb fbdsohgr tlgsoidoaof`dt fl`digs od tlg icbn`c aod`dfo`c gdvorbdkgdt.
01 Xlg WV Agh‟s qu`dtot`tovg g`sodi t`egs tlg v`cug ba 0 hurodi tlg pgrobh Dbvgkngr >:::08 (o.g., PG6 wocc gdh od Bftbngr >:08, `ffbrhodi tb tlg Aghgr`c Bpgd K`regt Fbkkottgg‟s Bftbngr>:08 kggtodi).
>9
-
8/9/2019 Trilemma Challenges for the People's Republic of China
30/41
@HNO Ybreodi Z`pgr 706 E`w`o `dh Cou
X`ncg >= Gstok`tobd ba tlg Vlbrt-tgrk Odtgrgst ^`tg ba tlg Zgbpcg‟s ^gpuncof baFlod` Wsodi tlg Abrgoid Odtgrgst ^`tg
t o∁
(9-h`y rgpb r`tg)t o∁
(9-h`y FLONB^)
V`kpcg pgrobh Bft >::8‖Bft >:08
Bft >::8‖Hgf >::<
M`d >::?‖Bft >:08
Vgp >::0‖Vgp >:08
Vgp >::0‖Hgf >::<
M`d >::?‖Vgp >:08
*
t o∁
:.080**(:.0:
-
8/9/2019 Trilemma Challenges for the People's Republic of China
31/41
@HNO Ybreodi Z`pgr 706 E`w`o `dh Cou
Cbbeodi `t tlg 9-h`y rgpb r`tg, od tlg prg-IAF pgrobh (Bftbngr >::8‖Hgfgkngr >:: wlgrg tlg Z^F‟s pbcofy r`tg w`s dbt `aagftgh ny tlg WV CONB^ r`tgod tlg prg-IAF pgrobh.
Od tlg pbst-IAF pgrobh, tlg gstok`tgh fbgaaofogdt ba odhustro`c prbhuftobd irbwtl l`sngfbkg st`tostof`ccy odsoidoaof`dt (tlbuil tlg fbgaaofogdt bd tlg odac`tobd r`tg rgk`odsst`tostof`ccy soidoaof`dt `dh pbsotovg). Xlos kg`ds tl`t tlg Z^F‟s kbdgt`ry pbcofy l`srgspbdhgh tb tlg odac`tobd r`tg i`p nut dbt tb rg`c gfbdbkof `ftovoty. Ot `ppg`rs tl`t tlgZ^F‟s kbdgt`ry `utlbroty abccbwgh tlg X`ycbr rucg od tlg prg-IAF pgrobh, wlocg bdcyp`rto`ccy abccbwodi tlg X`ycbr rucg od tlg pbst-IAF pgrobh.09
Xlg rgsucts abr tlg FLONB^ `rg c`rigcy tlg s`kg `s tlbsg abr tlg 9-h`y rgpb r`tg.
X`ncg 6= Gstok`tobd ba tlg X`ycbr ^ucg
t o∁
(9-h`y rgpb)t o∁
(9-h`y FLONB^)
V`kpcg pgrobhBft >::8‖Vgp >:08
Bft >::8‖Hgf >::<
M`d >::?‖Vgp >:08
Vgp >::0‖Vgp >:08
Vgp >::0‖Hgf >::<
M`d >::?‖Vgp >:08
t y~ :.:1):.:?0***(:.:86)
:.:61(:.6>8)
:.:71***(:.:>:)
:.:88***(:.:6:)
:.116***(:.:::)
:.6)
Db. ba bnsgrv`tobds 0>: 70 1? 079 ***(:.:66)
81.7:0***(:.:::)
61.
-
8/9/2019 Trilemma Challenges for the People's Republic of China
32/41
@HNO Ybreodi Z`pgr 706 E`w`o `dh Cou
odhof`tg tl`t tlgrg os ` cgss suppbrt abr tlg X`ycbr rucg od tlg pbst-IAF pgrobh tl`d odtlg prg-IAF pgrobh.
Xlg rgsucts abr tlg 9-h`y rgpb r`tg `rg cgss fcg`r, nut hb dbt suiigst rosodi kbdgt`rypbcofy `utbdbky od tlg pbst-IAF pgrobh.
Xlg bvgr`cc rgsucts abr gqu`tobd (1) `i`od suppbrt tlg vogw tl`t tlg Z^F‟s kbdgt`rypbcofy w`s kbrg `utbdbkbus od tlg prg-IAF pgrobh `dh tl`t ot l`s ngfbkg cgss sb odtlg pbst-IAF pgrobh.
X`ncg 8= Gstok`tobd ba tlg Lynroh X`ycbr ^ucg
t o∁
(9-h`y rgpb)t o∁
(9-h`y FLONB^)
V`kpcg pgrobhHgf >::8‖Vgp >:08
Hgf >::8‖Hgf >::<
M`d >::?‖Vgp >:08
Vgp >::0‖Vgp >:08
Vgp >::0‖Hgf >::<
M`d >::?‖Vgp >:08
*
t o∁ :.09:***(:.:0?)
‖:.:?8(:.8:0)
‖:.:>6(:.>6***(:.:09)
:.:66(:.69:)
‖:.>>0(:.609)
t y~ :.:1>***(:.:89)
:.0:1***(:.:6:)
:.:>9(:.817)
:.:7:***(:.:69)
:.:8:**(:.:10)
:.:6:(:.87:)
t ϊ ~ :.807***
(:.:::):.00<
(:.0
-
8/9/2019 Trilemma Challenges for the People's Republic of China
33/41
@HNO Ybreodi Z`pgr 706 E`w`o `dh Cou
yg`r irbwtl ba K:, K0, br K>.0)
V`kpcg pgrobhBft >::8‖Vgp >:08
Bft >::8‖Vgp >::?
Bft >:::08
Bft >::8‖Vgp >:08
Bft >::8‖Dbv >::<
Hgf >:::08
Bft >::8‖Vgp >:08
Bft >::8‖Vgp >::<
Bft >:::08
t A\^ A\^ /∁ :.0>: 8< 9>
M-st`tostofZrbn (M-st`ts)
08.880(:.:::)
7.89?(:.:0?)
1.861(:.:00)
:.667(:.716)
(:.::8)
:.?6?(:.66>)
98)
00.?:7(:.::0)
@hmustgh^-squ`rgh
‖:.:: ‖:.:7? ‖:.91? :.010 ‖:.:?7 ‖:.0:> :.:??
Dbtgs= Gstok`tobd abccbws tlg igdgr`cozgh kgtlbh ba kbkgdts prbfghurg. Xlg v`cugs od p`rgdtlgsgs `rg p-v`cugs. ** ; 7% cgvgc ba st`tostof`c soidoaof`dfg, *** ; 0% cgvgc ba st`tostof`c soidoaof d̀fg.
Vburfg= @utlbrs‟ fbkput`tobds.
KfF`ccuk-coeg rucg gstok`tobd
Yg dgxt gx`kodg wlgtlgr tlg KfF`ccuk-coeg rucg gxpc`ods kbdgt`ry pbcofy od tlg Z^F.Xlg KfF`ccuk-coeg rucg st`tgs tl`t tlg qu`dtoty ba kbdgy sgt ny tlg `utlbroty rg`ftsdgi`tovgcy tb fl`digs od odhustro`c prbhuftobd `dh tlg odac`tobd r`tg i`p. Gqu`tobd ( od tlg pbst-IAF pgrobh.Aorst, K: l`h ` soidoaof`dtcy dgi`tovg rgspbdsg tb butput irbwtl `dh ` soidoaof`dtcypbsotovg rgspbdsg tb tlg odac`tobd r`tg i`p (od fbdtr`st tb tlg prghoftobd ba tlgKfF`ccuk-coeg rucg) od tlg prg-IAF pgrobh, wlocg ot hoh dbt rgspbdh soidoaof`dtcy tbhbkgstof gfbdbkof fbdhotobds od tlg pbst-IAF pgrobh. Vgfbdh, K0 l`h ` soidoaof`dtcypbsotovg rgspbdsg tb butput irbwtl (od fbdtr`st tb tlg prghoftobd ba tlg KfF`ccuk-coegrucg) `dh ` st`tostof`ccy odsoidoaof`dt rgspbdsg tb tlg odac`tobd r`tg i`p od tlg prg-IAF
0<
Yg usg yg`r-bd-yg`r irbwtl tb `vboh tlg prbncgk ba dbd-st`tobd`roty `s kbdgt`ry `iirgi`tg v`ro`ncgs`dh abrgoid gxfl`dig rgsgrvgs `rg usu`ccy dbd-st`tobd`ry.
60
-
8/9/2019 Trilemma Challenges for the People's Republic of China
34/41
@HNO Ybreodi Z`pgr 706 E`w`o `dh Cou
pgrobh, wlocg ot hoh dbt rgspbdh tb hbkgstof gfbdbkof fbdhotobds hurodi tlg pbst-IAFpgrobh.
Aod`ccy, od tlg f`sg ba K>, tlg KfF`ccuk-coeg rucg sggks tb ng bnsgrvgh od tlg pbst-IAF pgrobh, nut dbt od tlg prg-IAF pgrobh. Xl`t os, K> rgspbdhgh pbsotovgcy tb butput
irbwtl (od fbdtr`st tb tlg prghoftobd) `dh dgi`tovgcy tb tlg odac`tobd r`tg i`p od tlg prg-IAF pgrobh, wlocg ot rgspbdhgh dgi`tovgcy tb nbtl butput irbwtl `dh tlg odac`tobd r`tgi`p (`s gxpgftgh ny tlg KfF`ccuk-coeg rucg) od tlg pbst-IAF pgrobh. Xlus, wg l`vgkoxgh rgsucts bd kbdgt`ry pbcofy `utbdbky od tlg pbst-IAF pgrobh. Yg bnsgrvg dbgvohgdfg ba pbcofy `utbdbky n`sgh bd K: br K0, nut wg bnsgrvg sbkg gvohgdfg barosodi pbcofy `utbdbky n`sgh bd K>.
X`ncg 1= Gstok`tobd ba tlg KfF`ccuk-coeg ^ucg
(K:) (K0) (K>)
V`kpcg
pgrobh
Hgf 0??9‖
Vgp >:08
Hgf 0??9‖
Vgp >::<
Bft >:::08
K`r 0??9‖
Vgp >:08
K`r 0??9‖
Vgp >::<
Bft >:::08
K`r 0??9‖
Vgp >:08
K`r 0??9‖
Vgp >::<
Bft >:::08
t y~ ‖:.7>>
(:.>80) ‖:.?>:*(:.08?)
‖:.>17(:.900)
‖:.6)
‖:.>>0(:.67):.17)
:.016(:.1101(:.678)
‖:.9:?(:.7:?)
‖:.978***(:.:::)
‖:.6)
Fbdst`dt 00.167***(:.:::)
00.71>***(:.:::)
00.***(:.:::)
07.01>***(:.:::)
07.116***(:.:::)
06.>8?***(:.:::)
01.969***(:.:::)
01.69:> 06: 9> >00 06? 9> >00 06? 9>
A-st`tostof>..>6?(:.000)
0.:91(:.681)
:.6::(:.980)
07.6<(:.:::)
6.661(:.:80)
>>.:07***(:.:::)
60.?0:(:.:::)
>9. :.:1> :.019 :.6:? :.860
Dbtgs= Xlg v`cugs od p`rgdtlgsgs `rg p-v`cugs. ** ; 7% cgvgc ba st`tostof`c soidoaof`dfg, *** ; 0% cgvgc bast`tostof`c soidoaof`dfg.
Vburfg= @utlbrs‟ fbkput`tobds.
Xlg gstok`tobd rgsucts ba gqu`tobd (?) suiigst tl`t tlg Z^F‟s kbdgt`ry `iirgi`tgv`ro`ncg hoh dbt rgspbdh tb hbkgstof gfbdbkof fbdhotobds, nut hoh rgspbdh pbsotovgcy`dh soidoaof`dtcy tb abrgoid `ssgts purfl`sgh od tlg pbst-IAF pgrobh (X`ncg 9). Aorst,K: rgspbdhgh dgi`tovgcy tb abrgoid gxfl`dig rgsgrvg `ffukuc`tobd `dh dgi`tovgcy tbbutput irbwtl od tlg prg-IAF pgrobh, wlocg ot rgspbdhgh pbsotovgcy tb abrgoid gxfl`digrgsgrvgs `dh tlg odac`tobd r`tg i`p (od fbdtr`st tb tlg prghoftobd ba tlg KfF`ccuk-coeg
rucg) od tlg pbst-IAF pgrobh. Vgfbdh, tlg rgsucts abr K0 `dh K> `rg sokoc`r. Xl`t os, K0`dh K> rgspbdhgh dgi`tovgcy tb abrgoid gxfl`dig rgsgrvgs `dh pbsotovgcy tb butputirbwtl (od fbdtr`st tb tlg prghoftobd ba tlg rucg) od tlg prg-IAF pgrobh. Xlgy rgspbdhghpbsotovgcy tb abrgoid gxfl`dig rgsgrvgs `dh butput irbwtl (od fbdtr`st tb tlg prghoftobdba tlg rucg), nut dgi`tovgcy tb tlg odac`tobd r`tg i`p (`s gxpgftgh ny tlg rucg) od tlg pbst-IAF pgrobh.
Xlus tlg KfF`ccuk-coeg rucg gxpc`ods tlg Z^F‟s kbdgt`ry pbcofy ngl`vobr n`sgh bd K:bdcy k`riod`ccy od tlg prg-IAF pgrobh, nut dbt od tlg pbst-IAF pgrobh. Xlg KfF`ccuk-coeg rucg gxpc`ods tlg K> ngl`vobr bdcy p`rto`ccy od tlg pbst-IAF pgrobh. Lbwgvgr, tlgrgos strbdi gvohgdfg tl`t tlg Z^F‟s kbdgt`ry pbcofy od tlg pbst-IAF pgrobh os pbsotovgcy`aagftgh ny abrgoid gxfl`dig rgsgrvgs, wlgtlgr K:, K0, br K> os usgh. Xlus, tlgrg os
dbt kufl gvohgdfg ba odfrg`sodi kbdgt`ry pbcofy `utbdbky od tlg pbst-IAF pgrobhrgc`tovg tb tlg prg-IAF pgrobh, gvgd wlgd K> os usgh.
t K K /∁ t K K /∁ t K K /∁
6>
-
8/9/2019 Trilemma Challenges for the People's Republic of China
35/41
@HNO Ybreodi Z`pgr 706 E`w`o `dh Cou
X`ncg 9= Gstok`tobd ba tlg Lynroh KfF`ccuk-coeg ^ucg
(K:) (K0) (K>)
V`kpcg pgrobhDbv >::8‖Vgp >:08
Dbv >::8‖Bft >::<
Bft >:::08
Dbv >::8‖Vgp >:08
M`d >::8‖Bft >::<
Bft >:::08
Dbv >::8‖Vgp >:08
M`d >::8‖Bft >::<
Bft >:::08
t A\^ A\^ /∁ :.0:) ‖:.9***(:.:01)
:.:
-
8/9/2019 Trilemma Challenges for the People's Republic of China
36/41
@HNO Ybreodi Z`pgr 706 E`w`o `dh Cou
9.0 Irg`tgr Gxfl`dig ^`tg Acgxonocoty
Xb fbpg wotl tlg trocgkk` fbdstr`odt, tlg aorst probroty os tb `hhrgss tlg roioh gxfl`digr`tg systgk. Xl`t os, tlg Z^F kust `hbpt ` kbrg acgxoncg gxfl`dig r`tg rgiokg od
brhgr tb rgi`od pbcofy `utbdbky. @t tlos st`ig, tlg Z^F‟s f`pot`c fbdtrbc rgiokg osudgvgdcy gdabrfgh. F`pot`c odacbws l`vg l`h cokotgh fbdtrbcs wlocg f`pot`c butacbws `rgstocc udhgr sgvgrg rgstroftobds. Xlgrgabrg, c`rig odtgrgst r`tg hoaagrgdto`cs wotl sk`ccgxfl`dig r`tg vbc`tocoty l`vg `ttr`ftgh c`rig f`pot`c odacbws, wlofl l`vg abrfgh tlg`utlbroty tb gdi`ig od c`rigr furrgdfy k`regt odtgrvgdtobds `dh `ffukuc`tg abrgoidgxfl`dig rgsgrvgs. @ bdg-w`y ngt bd tlg ^KN‟s fbdtodugh `pprgfo`tobd l`s cgh tbgvgd c`rigr f`pot`c odacbws. Abr tlos purpbsg, tlg `utlbroty k`y gdc`rig tlg ^KN‖WVhbcc`r tr`hodi n`dh aurtlgr sb `s tb a`focot`tg irg`tgr gxfl`dig r`tg acgxonocoty.
Aurtlgrkbrg, tb baasgt gxfl`dig k`regt prgssurg hug tb f`pot`c odacbws, tlg Z^F`utlbrotogs kust gdfbur`ig f`pot`c butacbws. Xlos fbuch ng `flogvgh ny `ccbwodi prov`tgaorks `dh rgsohgdts tb odvgst `nrb`h usodi nbtl tlg ^KN `dh abrgoid furrgdfogs,p`rtofuc`rcy tlg WV hbcc`r. Xlg twb-w`y acbw ba f`pot`c wocc d`tur`ccy cg`h tb irg`tgrvbc`tocoty ba tlg ^KN gxfl`dig r`tg `i`odst k`mbr furrgdfogs.
9.> @ Vlbrt-tgrk Zbcofy Odtgrgst ^`tg abr tlg Zgbpcg‟s ^gpuncofba Flod`
@s tlg Z^F‟s cgdhodi `dh hgpbsot r`tgs `rg ngfbkodi odfrg`sodicy congr`cozgh hg a`ftb,tlg kbdgt`ry `utlbroty kust flbbsg ` slbrt-tgrk ngdflk`re odtgrgst r`tg `s ots pbcofyodstrukgdt `dh lgcp frg`tg ` k`regt-hrovgd yogch strufturg ba odtgrgst r`tgs. Xlg`utlbroty f`d f`rry but ots kbdgt`ry pbcofy ny `hmustodi ots slbrt-tgrk pbcofy odtgrgst r`tg`dh gkpcbyodi ` dgw slbrt-tgrk coquohoty a`focoty. Xlos pbcofy r`tg wocc ng usgh `s tlgn`sos abr n`des tb sgt rgagrgdfg r`tgs, wlofl tlgd wocc ng usgh tb profg aod`dfo`c
hgrov`tovgs `dh prbhufts. @ffbrhodi tb tlg N`de abr Odtgrd`tobd`c Vgttcgkgdts (NOV>:06), rgagrgdfg r`tgs n`sgh bd udsgfurgh odtgrn`de tgrk cgdhodi `dh nbrrbwodi `rgtlg hbkod`dt typgs ba rgagrgdfg r`tgs usgh od tlg wbrch. NOV abudh tl`t=
• Kbrg tl`d 7:% ba `cc sydhof`tgh cb`ds soidgh od >:00 wgrg codegh tb gotlgr tlgCONB^ br tlg Gurb Odtgrn`de Baagrgh ^`tg (GW^ONB^).
• @ c̀ rig pbrtobd ba nbdhs od tlg wbrch‘tb tlg tudg ba `t cg`st $0: troccobd‘wgrgrgagrgdfgh tb bdg ba tlgsg twb r`tgs.
• @ soidoaof`dt sl`rg ba kbrti`igs `dh btlgr rgt`oc cb`ds wgrg codegh tb tlgk, `dhtlg usg ba tlgsg rgagrgdfg r`tgs od hgrov`tovgs k`regts w`s `csb wohgsprg`h.
Abr fgdtr`c n`des, tlg rgagrgdfg r`tg (sufl `s tlg bvgrdoilt r`tg) `csb sgrvgs `s `d
bpgr`tobd`c t`rigt. Hoaagrgdt arbk tlg `ftu`c pbcofy r`tg, tlos bpgr`tobd`c t`rigt os usgh tbiuohg kbdgt`ry pbcofy. Ot os `d okpbrt`dt fbkpbdgdt ba tlg kbdgt`ry pbcofytr`dskossobd kgfl`dosk ngf`usg tlg fgdtr`c n`de f`d odacugdfg tlg aod`dfo`c systgktlrbuil tlg rgagrgdfg r`tg `dh tlgd `aagft odtgrgst r`tgs abr cb`ds, kbdgy k`regt r`tgs,`dh odtgrgst r`tg hgrov`tovgs. Xlgrgabrg, tlg Z^F‟s kbdgt`ry `utlbroty slbuch wbrefcbsgcy wotl k`regt p`rtofop`dts `dh rgvogw tlg rgagrgdfg r`tg sgttodi prbfgss.
Ngabrg tlg CONB^ sf`dh`c, tlg VLONB^ w`s fbdsohgrgh ` d`tur`c f`dhoh`tg abr tlgrgagrgdfg r`tg abr tlg Z^F. @s tlg VLONB^ os `d odtgrgst r`tg tl`t p`rtofop`todi n`desrgpbrt nut hb dbt l`vg tb tr`ds`ft usodi tlg rgpbrtgh r`tgs, tlg systgk fbuch cg`h tb tlgbvgr aoxodi br udhgr aoxodi ba tlg rgagrgdfg r`tg, gspgfo`ccy od ` strgssgh gdvorbdkgdt.Vufl prbncgks fbuch cg`h tb ` cbss ba k`regt fbdaohgdfg od tlg VLONB^. @s ` rgsuct,
68
-
8/9/2019 Trilemma Challenges for the People's Republic of China
37/41
@HNO Ybreodi Z`pgr 706 E`w`o `dh Cou
tlg rgpb r`tg l`s ngfbkg ` kbrg vo`ncg `ctgrd`tovg abr tlg Z^F‟s auturg rgagrgdfg r`tg(X`ncg 0-h`y, 0-kbdtl, >-kbdtl, 6-kbdtl, 8-kbdtl, 1-kbdtl, ?-kbdtl, 0-yg`r
Frghot Codg Dggh tb sgt up frghot codg Db dggh tb sgt up frghot codg^ose Frghot rose ^ose-argg, sgfurgh tr`ds`ftobdFbcc`tgr`c Frghot-n`sgh Ibvgrdkgdt nbdhs, ZNbF noccs, `dh frghot nbdhs
ZNbF ; Zgbpcg‟s N`de ba Flod`, VLONB