the tertiary orogenic belt of west spitsbergen: seismic ... · the tertiary orogenic belt of west...

3
Rep/y The Tertiary orogenic belt of West Spitsbergen: Seismic expressions of the off shore sedimentary basins. A reply OLA EIKEN & ATLE AUSTEGARD Eiken, O. & Austegard, A.: The Tertiary orogenic belt of West Spitsbergen: Seismic expressions of the ohore sedimentary basins. A reply. Nok Geologk Tiskriſt, Vol. @, pp. 137-139. Oslo 1989. ISSN "1`X. The grabens on the inner shelf of West Spitsbergen are discussed and arguments for a Tertiary age of the graben infill are ven. Ola Eiken• & Atle Agard, Semologica/ Observato, Universi of Bergen, Aegt. 41, N-57 Bergen, Norway. • Prent address: B.G.R. Stieweg 2, 30 Hannover 51, F.R.G. We thank Townsend & Mann (this vol.) for com- ments on our interpretations (Eiken & Austegard 1987), and certainly we agree that one should be cautious about postulating ages of the graben infill before the basins have been drilled. Nevertheless, we still consider an early Teiary age of the basins to be most likely. First, we are not confident about the sig- nificance of the grab-sampling results of Dibner (1978). We admit that the absence of Tertiary samples is a little suspicious, particularly for the presumably broad basin west of the Nordenskiold Coast. But Dibner (1978) found upper Triassic and upper Permian samples even at the outer shelf and at the continental slope west of Spits- bergen, in contradiction to the Neogene age sug- gested in several papers (e.g. Myhre & Eldholm 1988), based on ties to the DSDP drillhole site 344 (Talwani et al. 1976). Secondly, we see no inconsistency between Ter- tiary basins offshore and outcrops of older sedi- ments onshore. In fact, Tertiary outcrops are present several places landwards of the coastline: in the Forlandsundet area, at Renarodden and at Øyrlandet. Furthermore, the offshore area is doser to the zone of separation between Svalbard and Greenland in Tertiary time and therefore more likely to have experienced extension. The West Sørkapp Land basin may extend offshore, but in our opinion the 20 km gap between Hornsundneset and the eastern end of line UB 381 is too large to justi a straightforward extrapolation. Thirdly, we stress that seismic velocities of about 2.2-3.5 km/s observed in the basin sedi- ments are much lower than in sediments of Car- boniferous to Triassic age in the Central Spits- bergen basin (Eiken 1985) and in the Sørkapp area (Grønlie 1978). To our knowledge no velocity, density or porosity observations om the West Sørkapp Land Basin are available to determine if the diagenesis of the sediments there is much different from the area further east. In 1987 a seismic line, SVA-3, which fills the gap between the West Sørkapp Land Basin and the offshore basin, was shot during the Mobil Search programme for Norwegian Universities as a two-ship wide-aperture profile (Fig. la). A velocity section and a coarsely processed reflec- tion section are shown in Fig. le and lb. We observe that the offshore basin is bounded to the east (or northeast); landward of s.p. 600 is an area with distinctly higher velocities and with no visible reflections. In our opinion this shows that the discussed graben is not the offshore portion of the West �ørkapp Land Basin. We agree, however, that the small basin at the mouth of Isfjorden, where we have poor veloty control, might contain pre-Teiary sediments only. Manuscript received November 1988

Upload: vannhan

Post on 20-Mar-2019

213 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: The Tertiary orogenic belt of West Spitsbergen: Seismic ... · The Tertiary orogenic belt of West Spitsbergen: Seismic expressions of the offshore ... We admit that the ... Seismic

Rep/y

The Tertiary orogenic belt of West Spitsbergen: Seismic expressions of the offshore sedimentary basins. A reply

OLA EIKEN & ATLE AUSTEGARD

Eiken, O. & Austegard, A.: The Tertiary orogenic belt of West Spitsbergen: Seismic expressions of the offshore sedimentary basins. A reply. Norsk Geologisk Tidsskrift, Vol. @, pp. 137-139. Oslo 1989. ISSN 0029-196X.

The grabens on the inner shelf of West Spitsbergen are discussed and arguments for a Tertiary age of the graben infill are given.

Ola Eiken• & Atle Austegard, Seismologica/ Observatory, University of Bergen, A/legt. 41, N-5007 Bergen, Norway. • Present address: B.G.R. Stilleweg 2, D-3000 Hannover 51, F.R.G.

We thank Townsend & Mann (this vol. ) for com­ments on our interpretations (Eiken & Austegard 1987), and certainly we agree that one should be cautious about postulating ages of the gra ben infill before the basins have been drilled. Nevertheless, we still consider an earl y Tertiary age of the basins to be most likely.

First, we are not confident about the sig­nificance of the grab-sampling results of Dibner (1978). We admit that the absence of Tertiary samples is a little suspicious, particularly for the presumably broad basin west of the Nordenskiold Coast. But Dibner (1978) found upper Triassic and upper Permian samples even at the outer shelf and at the continental slope west of Spits­bergen, in contradiction to the Neogene age sug­gested in several papers (e.g. Myhre & Eldholm 1988), based on ties to the DSDP drillhole site 344 (Talwani et al. 1976).

Secondly, we see no inconsistency between Ter­tiary basins offshore and outcrops of older sedi­ments onshore. In fact, Tertiary outcrops are present several places landwards of the coastline: in the Forlandsundet area, at Renarodden and at Øyrlandet. Furthermore, the offshore area is doser to the zone of separation between Svalbard and Greenland in Tertiary time and therefore more likely to have experienced extension. The West Sørkapp Land basin may extend offshore, but in our opinion the 20 km gap between Hornsundneset and the eastern end of line UB

38-81 is too large to justify a straightforward extrapolation.

Thirdly, we stress that seismic velocities of about 2.2-3.5 km/s observed in the basin sedi­ments are much lower than in sediments of Car­boniferous to Triassic age in the Central Spits­bergen basin (Eiken 1985) and in the Sørkapp area (Grønlie 1978). To our knowledge no velocity, density or porosity observations from the West Sørkapp Land Basin are available to determine if the diagenesis of the sediments there is much different from the area further east.

In 1987 a seismic line, SVA-3, which fills the gap between the West Sørkapp Land Basin and the offshore basin, was shot during the Mobil Search programme for Norwegian Universities as a two-ship wide-aperture profile (Fig. la). A velocity section and a coarsely processed reflec­tion section are shown in Fig. le and lb. We observe that the offshore basin is bounded to the east (or northeast); landward of s.p. 600 is an area with distinctly higher velocities and with no visible reflections. In our opinion this shows that the discussed graben is not the offshore portion of the West �ørkapp Land Basin.

We agree, however, that the small basin at the mouth of Isfjorden, where we have poor velocity control, might contain pre-Tertiary sediments only.

Manuscript received November 1988

Page 2: The Tertiary orogenic belt of West Spitsbergen: Seismic ... · The Tertiary orogenic belt of West Spitsbergen: Seismic expressions of the offshore ... We admit that the ... Seismic

138 O. Eiken & A. Austegard

a

l Tertiary

Mesozo1c - Late Paleozoic

Devon1an

Hecla Hoek

the toast 1o•

BELLSUND­\ \

NORSK GEOLOGISK TIDSSKRIFT 69 (1989)

!67 m B7t B1J m m m 6Jt 5BJ 535 487 m J9t Hl 195 147 t9! t5t tBJ

w SHOTPOINTS

1000 900 800 700 600 500

c 10km

400

VELDCITIES (km/s)

rzzJ < 2.0

CZJ 2.0. 3.0

IÆEJ 3.0 . 3.8 �>3.8

300 200

E

100

o m " ... :I:

1

Fig. l. Reftection profile (b) and velocity section (c) from the seismic profile SVA-3 west of Hornsund. The position is indicated by a thick line on the map (a).

Page 3: The Tertiary orogenic belt of West Spitsbergen: Seismic ... · The Tertiary orogenic belt of West Spitsbergen: Seismic expressions of the offshore ... We admit that the ... Seismic

NORSK GEOLOGISK TIDSSKRIFf 69 (1989)

References

Dibner, V. D. 1978: The morphostructure of the Barents Sea

Shelf. Trudy NIIGA 185, Leningrad, Nedra. 211 pp.

Eiken, O. 1985: Seismic mapping of the post-Caledonian strata

in Svalbard. Polar Research 3, 167-176. Eiken, O. & Austegard, A. 1987: The Tertiary orogenic belt

of West Spitsbergen: Seismic expressions of the offshore

sedimentary basins. Norsk Geologisk Tidsskrift 67, 383-394. Grølie, G. 1978: Preliminary results of seismic velocity measure­

ments in Spitsbergen in 1977. Norsk Polarinstitutt Årbok 1977, 229-236.

West Spitsbergen: offshore sedimentary basins 139

Myhre, A. M. & Eldholm, O. 1988: The western Svalbard

margin (74°-BO"N). Marine and Petroleum Geology 5, 134-156.

Talwani, M., Udintsev, G. et al. 1976: Initial reports of the

Deep Sea Drilling Project, 38, Washington (U.S. Govern­ment Printing Office), 1256 pp.

Townsend, C. & Mann, A. 1989: The Tertiary orogenic belt

of West Spitsbergen: Seismic expressions of the offshore

sedimentary basins. A comment. Norsk Geologisk Tidsskrift 69, 135-136.