the seven hats of visualisation design: a 2017 reboot
TRANSCRIPT
2
Why a ‘2017 Reboot’?
http://www.visualisingdata.com/book/
3
“There is not one project I have been involved in that I would execute exactly the same way second time around. I could conceivably pick any of them – and probably the thing they
could all benefit most from? More inter-disciplinary expertise”
Alan Smith OBE, Data Visualisation Editor, Financial Times
A truly inter-disciplinary subject
4
A sometimes overwhelming subject
Images from http://images.wikia.com/marvel_dc/images/9/93/Adventures_of_Superman_424.jpg and http://www.adobenido.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2012/01/wonder_woman.jpg
5
A sometimes overwhelming subject
Talented superstars
Everyday practitioners
What capabilities do these people have…
that these people should strive to attain?
6
“Invariably, people who are new to visualization want to know where to begin, and, frankly, it’s understandably
overwhelming. Don’t worry if you feel you don’t have skills yet; just start from where you are…”
Scott Murray
A sometimes overwhelming subject
7
Lancaster University | 1995 to 1999UG Degree in Operational Research (OR)+ Year in Industry 1997/98
Cooperative Insurance Society (CIS) | 1999 to 2001Business Analyst
West Yorkshire Police | 2001 to 2007Performance Analyst > Information Manager
University of Leeds | 2007 to 2012Information Manager
University of Leeds | 2007 to 2009Masters Degree (Research) in Data Visualisation
Visualising Data Ltd | Part-time 2010, Full-time 2012 –Freelance Data Visualisation Specialist
My thinking is shaped by OR
8
Roles & Mindsets: Edward de Bono’s 6 Thinking Hats
Reference from http://www.debonogroup.com/six_thinking_hats.php
9
Roles & Mindsets: Mr Benn’s many magical costumes
Image from http://realtimeshortstories.files.wordpress.com/2011/10/mr_benn.jpg | Video from http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FMSJNrzQ3PM
Mr. Benn, a man wearing a black suit and bowler hat, leaves his house at 52 Festive Road and visits a fancy-dress costume shop where he is invited by the mustachioed, fez-wearing
shopkeeper to try on a particular outfit. He leaves the shop through a magic door at the back of the changing room and enters a world appropriate to his costume, where he has an
adventure (which usually contains a moral) before the shopkeeper reappears to lead him back to the changing room, and the story comes to an end. Mr. Benn returns to his normal
life, but is left with a small souvenir of his magical adventure.
10
Which capabilities do you already possess?Which capabilities do you not yet possess?
Which capabilities will you likely never possess?
We ALL start from somewhere: Where are you now?
DIRECTOR
12
Bringing order to the chaos: Where to begin? What path to take?
Image from http://www.mattneuman.com/maze.gif
13
Managing the decision-making process
Stage 1Formulating
your brief
Stage 2Working with data
Stage 3Establishing your editorial
thinking
Stage 4Developing your design solution
14
“… in order to design a tool, we must make our best efforts to understand the larger social and physical context within
which it is intended to function.”
Bill Buxton
Understanding and defining the context
Quote from “Sketching User Experiences” http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/0123740371/
15
Understanding and defining the context
16
Understanding and defining the context
17
Defining the project’s vision
18
The coordinator – oversees the projectInitiates and leads on formulating the project brief
Identifies and establishes the project’s key circumstancesDefines the vision for the project depending on desired outcomeManages progress through the workflow and keeps it cohesive
Has a ‘thick skin’: needs patience and empathyGets things done: checks, tests, finishes tasks
Pays strong attention to detail
DIRECTOR
COMMUNICATOR
20
Understands the need to be “audience-centred”
Perceiving Interpreting Comprehending
What does it mean?Is it good or bad?
Meaningful or insignificant?Unusual or expected?
What does it show?Where is big, medium, small?
How do things compare?What relationships exist?
What does it mean to me?What are the main messages?
What have I learnt?Any actions to take?
SUBJECT KNOWLEDGEFORM OF COMMUNICATION AUDIENCE RECEPTIVENESS
21
What do you want to tell them? What do you think
they need to know? What do you know they
need to know? If you were them what would you find relevant? How
much do they know about a subject?
Understands the need to be “audience-centred”
Image from http://zeldalily.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/11/guess-who.jpg
22
Understands the communication setting
23
(RIP Hans Rosling, the best of the best communicators)Even when he had his back to you!
Image taken from https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=usdJgEwMinM
25
Cares about the right functional and subject accessibility
Visualisation from Corriere della Serra http://www.corriere.it/cultura/17_marzo_31/premi-malofiej-vince-la-lettura-56ea698a-163a-11e7-b176-94ba31b8546a.shtml?refresh_ce-cp
26
Cares about the right functional and subject accessibility
Visualisation by Bloomberg http://www.bloomberg.com/infographics/2014-01-16/tracking-super-bowl-ticket-prices.html
27
Recognises the importance of good annotation
“The annotation layer is the most important thing we do... otherwise it’s a case of ‘here it is, you go figure it out’.”
Amanda Cox, New York Times
Quote from http://eyeofestival.com/speaker/amanda-cox/
28
Recognises the importance of good annotation
29
Recognises the importance of good annotation
Visualisation by Financial Times https://www.ft.com/content/b2eced58-a6cc-11e6-8898-79a99e2a4de6
30
The broker – manages the human dynamicsHelps to gather and understand requirements
Manages expectations and presents possibilitiesHelps to define the perspective of the audience
A good listener with a willingness to learn from domain expertsA confident communicator with laypeople and non-specialists
Possesses strong copy-editing abilitiesLaunches and promotes the final solution
COMMUNICATOR
JOURNALIST
32
Curiosity: ‘An eagerness to know or learn something’
Possesses and shapes the critical curiosity
33
“What is the pattern of success or failure in the movie careers of a range of notable actors?”
Possesses and shapes the critical curiosity
34
Potent instincts for pattern-matching & sniffing out the story
Image from http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/August_Landmesser
35
Potent instincts for pattern-matching & sniffing out the story
Visualisation by Bloomberg http://www.bloomberg.com/billionaires/latest
36
Potent instincts for pattern-matching & sniffing out the story
Visualisation by New York Times http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2016/05/22/world/europe/europe-right-wing-austria-hungary.html
37
“A photo is never an objective reflection, but always an interpretation of reality. I see data visualization as sort of a
new photojournalism – a highly editorial activity.”
Moritz Stefaner
Makes the critical editorial judgments: What’s our point?
Quote from http://well-formed-data.net/archives/1027/worlds-not-stories
38
Makes the critical editorial judgments: What’s our point?
Photos from http://neilleifer.com/portfolio/
39
Makes the critical editorial judgments: What’s our point?
Image from http://kottke.org/06/07/independent-infographic
40
The reporter – pursues the scent of an enquiryDefines the trigger curiosity and purpose of the project
Has an instinct to research, learn and discoverDriven by a desire to help others understand
Possesses or is able to acquire salient domain knowledgeUnderstands the essence of the subject’s data
Has empathy for the interests and needs of an audienceDefines the editorial angle, framing and focus
JOURNALIST
DATA ANALYST
42
Responsible for the collection of data
Sourcing data to support the enquiry…“What does the rhythm & architecture of Seinfeld look like?”
43
Responsible for the examining and familiarising with the data
44
Responsible for the transformation of data
45
Responsible for undertaking exploratory data analysis
46
Responsible for undertaking exploratory data analysis
Visualisation by New York Times http://www.nytimes.com/2014/04/23/upshot/what-good-marathons-and-bad-investments-have-in-common.html
47
Responsible for undertaking exploratory data analysis
48
The wrangler – handles all the data workHas strong data and statistical literacy
Has the technical skills to acquire data from multiple sourcesExamines the physical properties of the data
Undertakes initial descriptive analysisTransforms and prepares the data for its purpose
Undertakes exploratory data analysisHas database and data modelling experience
DATA ANALYST
SCIENTIST
50
Concerned by the importance of trustworthiness & integrity
Visualisation from New York Times http://www.nytimes.com/elections/results/president
51
Concerned by the importance of trustworthiness & integrity
Images from https://www.washingtonpost.com/graphics/politics/2016-election/trump-charts/
52
Concerned by the importance of trustworthiness & integrity
Visualisation by LA Times Graphics http://graphics.latimes.com/kobe-every-shot-ever/
53
Fundamental knowledge of visual perception
Images from http://yusylvia.files.wordpress.com/2010/03/gestalt_illustration-01.jpg?w=604&h=251&h=251 & http://psychology.about.com/od/sensationandperception/ss/gestaltlaws.html
54
Fundamental knowledge of visual perception
Taken from http://www.scribblelive.com/blog/2011/12/13/2ds-company-3ds-a-crowd/
55
Fundamental knowledge of visual perception
Image from http://eagereyes.org/basics/rainbow-color-map | Photo from https://twitter.com/espurrkawa/status/829238117848739841
56
Fundamental knowledge of visual perception
Visualisation by Stamen http://stamen.com/work/who-immunization/
57
Fundamental knowledge of visual perception
colorbrewer2.org
58
Fundamental knowledge of visual perception
Map images from https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/f/f4/Mercator_projection_SW.jpg and http://www.vox.com/world/2016/12/2/13817712/map-projection-mercator-globe
59
The thinker – provides scientific rigourBrings a strong research mindset to the process
Understands the science of visual perceptionUnderstands visualisation, statistical and data ethics
Understands the influence of human factorsVerifies/validates the integrity of all data and design decisionsDemonstrates “system’s thinking” approach to problem solving
Undertakes reflective evaluation and critique
SCIENTIST
DESIGNER
61
To make the best decisions you need to be familiar with all your options and aware of the things that will influence your choices.
Responsible for the critical design-related decision-making
THINGS YOU COULD DO
THINGS YOU WILL DO
62
Responsible for the critical design-related decision-making
“Finish”Start Decisions
63
Responsible for the critical design-related decision-making
64
Responsible for the critical design-related decision-making
http://www.myfonts.com/WhatTheFont/
65
Balances creative flair with discerning judgment
Visualisation by Washington Post https://www.washingtonpost.com/national/people-shot-to-death-by-police-and-how-they-were-allegedly-armed/2015/05/30/57a514aa-0715-11e5-bc72-f3e16bf50bb6_graphic.html
66
Balances creative flair with discerning judgment
Visualisation by Reuters http://graphics.thomsonreuters.com/14/wine/index.htmlVisualisation by WSJ http://www.wsj.com/articles/asia-loses-its-sweet-tooth-for-chocolate-1431281818
67
Balances creative flair with discerning judgment
68
“Good design is thorough down to the last detail...Nothing must be arbitrary or left to chance.”
from Dieter Rams’ ‘10 principles of good design’
A commitment to thoroughness
Quote from https://www.vitsoe.com/gb/about/good-design
69
A commitment to thoroughness
70
The conceiver – provides creative directionEstablishes the initial creative pathway through a ‘purpose map’
Forms the initial mental visualisation: ideas and inspirationHas strong creative, graphic and illustration skills
Understands the principles of user interface designIs fluent with the full array of possible design options
Unifies the decision-making across the design anatomyHas a relentless creative drive to keep innovating
DESIGNER
TECHNOLOGIST
72
Possess the critical technical abilities
http://www.visualisingdata.com/resources/
73
Balances technical flair with discerning judgment
Visualisation by Cameron Beccario https://earth.nullschool.net/
74
Balances technical flair with discerning judgment
Visualisation by Guardian http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/interactive/2012/nov/05/you-decide-the-presidential-election-interactive
75
Balances technical flair with discerning judgment
76
Balances technical flair with discerning judgment
77
Balances technical flair with discerning judgment
From Archie Tse’s talk https://github.com/archietse/malofiej-2016/blob/master/tse-malofiej-2016-slides.pdf
78
Balances technical flair with discerning judgment
From Gregor Aisch https://www.vis4.net/blog/posts/in-defense-of-interactive-graphics/
79
Pragmatist finding the means necessary to meet the ends…
80
Pragmatist finding the means necessary to meet the ends…
81
Pragmatist finding the means necessary to meet the ends…
82
The developer – constructs the solutionPossesses a repertoire of software and programming capabilities
Has an appetite to acquire new technical solutionsPossesses strong mathematical knowledge
Can automate otherwise manually intensive processesHas the discipline to avoid feature creep
Works on the prototyping and development of the solutionUndertakes pre- and post-launch testing, evaluation and support
TECHNOLOGIST
83
IN SUMMARY
84
Director Journalist Data Analyst DesignerTechnologist
Communicator Scientist
The ‘7 hats’ aren’t entirely exclusive
85
JOURNALIST = NOSE
DATA ANALYST = BACK
COMMUNICATOR = EARS/MOUTHSCIENTIST
= MIND
DIRECTOR = LEGS
DESIGNER = EYE
TECHNOLOGIST= HANDS
Alternative: The ‘Anatomy of the Visualiser’?
86
Addressing your shortcomings
Some require fresh thinkingSome require new attitudes/better discipline
Some require more knowledgeSome require more skills
Some require latent talent (technical, creative)Some can be compromised on
Some can be gained by collaboratingMost requires further experience/practice
87
“Chefs are able to more clearly discern what they taste because through constant exposure they have developed
improved senses as well as vocabulary to express and discuss their impressions.”
Oliver Reichenstein
Addressing your shortcomings: Learn, apply, reflect and repeat
Paraphrased from: http://ia.net/blog/learning-to-see/
89
Developing effectiveness and efficiency in your data visualisation work will take time:
It is a journey that never stops because data visualisation is a subject that has no ending.
