the power of market internals - better system...

10
THE POWER OF MARKET INTERNALS 3 cases studies to demonstrate the application of Market Internals in trading systems. CASE STUDY 1: SWING BOSS system As the first example I will show you one of my oldest trading systems (which you can download from my website for free) called TOM’s BOSS ATS. This case is a slightly modified SWING variant that doesn't close all positions at the end of the day (EOD exit), but it holds positions opened even for several days. Besides this small difference I haven’t changed the system in any other way. For this example I’ve chosen the ES market, but I have this system finalized for other index markets too, and the target was pretty clear - to improve the net profit to max. drawdown ratio, improve the overall performance of the system, decrease the drawdown and smoothen the equity curve. Here you can see the original equity, compiled from Out-Of-Sample intervals (it is 100% OOS equity, no In-Sample interval is included): I’m quite happy with this basic performance, it’s a very nice result for OOS intervals. But still, there is some room for improvement - and that is exactly the task for Market Internals. Regarding the system performance characteristics, all the important parameters are available in this table:

Upload: lammien

Post on 06-Feb-2018

220 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: THE POWER OF MARKET INTERNALS - Better System …bettersystemtrader.com/downloads/MarketInternalsCaseStudies.pdf · THE POWER OF MARKET INTERNALS 3 cases studies to demonstrate the

THE POWER OF MARKET INTERNALS 3 cases studies to demonstrate the application of Market Internals in trading systems.

CASE STUDY 1: SWING BOSS system

As the first example I will show you one of my oldest trading systems (which you can download from

my website for free) called TOM’s BOSS ATS. This case is a slightly modified SWING variant that

doesn't close all positions at the end of the day (EOD exit), but it holds positions opened even for

several days. Besides this small difference I haven’t changed the system in any other way.

For this example I’ve chosen the ES market, but I have this system finalized for other index markets

too, and the target was pretty clear - to improve the net profit to max. drawdown ratio, improve the

overall performance of the system, decrease the drawdown and smoothen the equity curve.

Here you can see the original equity, compiled from Out-Of-Sample intervals (it is 100% OOS equity,

no In-Sample interval is included):

I’m quite happy with this basic performance, it’s a very nice result for OOS intervals. But still, there is

some room for improvement - and that is exactly the task for Market Internals.

Regarding the system performance characteristics, all the important parameters are available in this

table:

Page 2: THE POWER OF MARKET INTERNALS - Better System …bettersystemtrader.com/downloads/MarketInternalsCaseStudies.pdf · THE POWER OF MARKET INTERNALS 3 cases studies to demonstrate the

http://www.tradingmarketinternals.com – Page 2 of 10

Again, we can see satisfactory parameters that theoretically don't need too much improvement -

especially in the context of my whole portfolio. However, I know what Market Internals can do and it

would be a shame not to try it at least. After a couple of test runs with my MI code, I have picked

one of my 40+ variants (i.e. one of my 40+ MI “over-filters”), which looks good on In-Sample

optimization as well as on Out-Of-Sample verification and which brings a number of improvements.

Let's take a look at the equity that, on the first sight, hasn't improved that much, but you can still see

some improvement:

Page 3: THE POWER OF MARKET INTERNALS - Better System …bettersystemtrader.com/downloads/MarketInternalsCaseStudies.pdf · THE POWER OF MARKET INTERNALS 3 cases studies to demonstrate the

http://www.tradingmarketinternals.com – Page 3 of 10

The equity is smoother and more stable, but you can see the real change when looking at the final

numbers:

Let's start with the Net Profit (NP): It’s not always bigger after an MI application (more often, the

drawdown is improved and therefore also NP/DD ratio). But in this case the NP has increased from

68 300 USD to 70 550 USD, i.e. an improvement of 3.3%. So far, nothing breathtaking, but hold on, it

will get better!

We can see a really dramatic improvement when it comes to the drawdown which has improved

from 6 137 USD to 3 525 USD, a reduction of almost half (42.6% to be exact)! Try to remember how

much effort you had to give to your systems last time you wanted to reduce the DD by at least 20%.

Here, just by using a single tool, we have reduced the drawdown by almost half!

Similar impressive improvements can be seen in the Net Profit to Drawdown ratio, which has

changed from an already satisfying 11.13 to a fantastic 20.01 – an improvement of 79.7%! And

finally, the profit factor has improved from 1.49 to 1.83 (improved by 22.8%) and WIN% from

41.47% to 50.53% (improved by 21,8%). All I had to do was to run one optimization and wait approx.

60 minutes for the computer to give me the results.

Do you know understand why I call MI an unfair (super)advantage?

For easier comparison I’ve prepared a table:

PARAMETER NP MaxDD NP/DD PF WIN% TRADES BEFORE MI 68 300 6 137 11.13 1.49 41.47 % 504 AFTER MI 70 550 3 525 20.01 1.83 50.53 % 471 IMPROVED BY +3.3 % +42.6 % +79.7 % +22.8 % +21.8 % -6.5%

Page 4: THE POWER OF MARKET INTERNALS - Better System …bettersystemtrader.com/downloads/MarketInternalsCaseStudies.pdf · THE POWER OF MARKET INTERNALS 3 cases studies to demonstrate the

http://www.tradingmarketinternals.com – Page 4 of 10

CASE STUDY 2: BNR system

Ok, let's move to another example. What I’ve already shown you was just a warm-up, because the

options you have when using Market Internals are much bigger! In the second example, I will show

you one of the extreme applications of MI.

In 2011 I created a system I called BNR. I’ve never run it live because it failed my robustness tests,

and it was a good decision - the system stopped working shortly after and had a drawdown of over

10 000 USD. After all, see for yourself:

And the overall statistics were not so great either:

Page 5: THE POWER OF MARKET INTERNALS - Better System …bettersystemtrader.com/downloads/MarketInternalsCaseStudies.pdf · THE POWER OF MARKET INTERNALS 3 cases studies to demonstrate the

http://www.tradingmarketinternals.com – Page 5 of 10

However, what impressed me was how the system managed to get from the (quite large) drawdown

back to the new equity high and start making profits again. That made me curious and I started

wondering if MI could improve the system performance. At least, it was a good idea to test how

powerful MI can be, to see if it can help in such an extreme situation and turn a bad system into a

good one.

In this case, the testing was a little bit more difficult as most of my Market Internals conditions didn't

provide an improvement. It turned out that such an extreme situation requires an extreme solution

and I had to implement an MI condition that lets the BNR strategy open the trade only when the

situation is really, really strong for either buying or selling.

This is a really significant filter that eliminates lots of trades as it waits only for the best (and also

most extreme) possible situations - and therefore it also dramatically reduces the number of trades.

Here you can see the results and the new equity of the BNR system after 60 minutes of “work”:

Page 6: THE POWER OF MARKET INTERNALS - Better System …bettersystemtrader.com/downloads/MarketInternalsCaseStudies.pdf · THE POWER OF MARKET INTERNALS 3 cases studies to demonstrate the

http://www.tradingmarketinternals.com – Page 6 of 10

On the first sight you can see that the equity has changed dramatically and the numbers can only

confirm our assumption:

Page 7: THE POWER OF MARKET INTERNALS - Better System …bettersystemtrader.com/downloads/MarketInternalsCaseStudies.pdf · THE POWER OF MARKET INTERNALS 3 cases studies to demonstrate the

http://www.tradingmarketinternals.com – Page 7 of 10

The net profit has decreased from 57 660 USD to 29 990 USD, i.e. reduced by 48%. You can expect

that when making such a dramatic reduction, however the rest of the numbers are really quite

impressive.

The drawdown has been reduced from 11 340 to 3510, i.e. almost 70%! This has also led to a Net

Profit to Drawdown ratio improvement from a totally unacceptable 5.1 to an almost acceptable 8.5 –

an improvement of almost 70%.

Even the profit factor has improved by 33% and WIN% by 6.5%. Here is the overview table:

PARAMETER NP MaxDD NP/DD

PF WIN% TRADES

BEFORE MI 57 660 11 340 5.1 1.41 57.65 % 562 AFTER MI 29 990 3 510 8.5 1.88 61.41 % 184 IMPROVED BY -48 % +69 % +67 % +33 % +6.5 % -67%

The most important aspect of this case study is the fact that Market Internals can improve a

potentially bad system into a tradeable system! All you need is the knowledge and a couple of

minutes of computer time.

CASE STUDY 3: CORRECTOR-1 system Now let's do something quite different - a very specific task for Market Internals.

In 2011 I created a totally atypical system that doesn't have any optimization parameters. The

system is based on one very strong observation and doesn't use any indicators or variables or

anything that could be optimized.

This has led to a very interesting situation. On one side I’ve managed to create a breakout system

that is very robust and doesn't use any optimization, but on the other side the system has such a low

average trade value that it is practically untradeable - and it is not possible to increase the average

profit by optimization - as there is nothing to be optimized!

Most traders would be helpless and have to throw this great opportunity away. But not me - I have

my unfair advantage, so let's get to it.

First, let's take a look at the equity. On first sight it doesn't look like anything special, but don't forget

- it is a unique system that doesn't use any indicators or optimization parameters:

Page 8: THE POWER OF MARKET INTERNALS - Better System …bettersystemtrader.com/downloads/MarketInternalsCaseStudies.pdf · THE POWER OF MARKET INTERNALS 3 cases studies to demonstrate the

http://www.tradingmarketinternals.com – Page 8 of 10

Some of the parameters in the table below don't look too tempting either, but then again, it is a

totally unique system and all I need to improve is the average trade profit:

So, what can the targeted implementation of Market Internals provide us this time?

Page 9: THE POWER OF MARKET INTERNALS - Better System …bettersystemtrader.com/downloads/MarketInternalsCaseStudies.pdf · THE POWER OF MARKET INTERNALS 3 cases studies to demonstrate the

http://www.tradingmarketinternals.com – Page 9 of 10

Let's start, for a change, with an overview of all performance results for the new version, after the

Market Internals filter application (and 60 minutes of computer time):

With MI we’ve managed to improve the average trade profit from an untradeable 68.56 USD to

79.21 USD (an increase of 16%). My limit for tradability of a system in the emini Russell 2000 market

is about 80 USD per trade, so in this case we have managed to get to this level and once again we

have modified an untradeable system into a tradeable one!

The rest of the parameters have improved just slightly, but there was an overall improvement. The

equity curve has some periods of stagnation but it hasn’t changed too much overall:

Page 10: THE POWER OF MARKET INTERNALS - Better System …bettersystemtrader.com/downloads/MarketInternalsCaseStudies.pdf · THE POWER OF MARKET INTERNALS 3 cases studies to demonstrate the

http://www.tradingmarketinternals.com – Page 10 of 10

After several years I was able to add this system to my portfolio - for its uniqueness I want this

system to be a part of it. This was possible only after I had discovered the world of Market Internals.

WANT MORE?

I hope these case studies have shown you the huge potential of market internals. It can be a very

powerful tool if you know how to apply it correctly.

Keep an eye out for the Trading Market Internals launch, we’re going to show you exactly how you

can leverage the power of Market Internals in your own trading, and reap the rewards of this unfair

advantage.

Trade well!

The Trading Market Internals team.