the district level environment impact assessment … · nagpur, have applied for environmental...
TRANSCRIPT
PRE FEASIBILITY REPORT (As per EIA Notification 2006)
& Ministry of Environment ,Forest & Climate Change (MoEF & CC) Notification No 141 (E)
dated 15th January 2016
For
OBTAINING ENVIRONMENT CLEARANCE
Of
SAND MINING (MINOR MINERAL)
For
PANMARA RIVER BED SAND MINE
Adjacent Kh. No.230
Area 4.87 Ha
Situated at MOUZA- PANMARA, TAHSIL- MAUDA, DISTRICT-NAGPUR, STATE- MAHARASHTRA STATE, INDIA
Submitted to
THE DISTRICT LEVEL ENVIRONMENT IMPACT ASSESSMENT AUTHORITY
District Nagpur
Applicant/Project Proponent
TAHSILDAR Collector office, Nagpur
District: Nagpur Prepared By
MANTRAS GREEN RESOURCES LTD
QCI-NABET ACCREDITED EIA CONSULTANT,
Hall No.1, First Floor, NICE Sankul, MIDC
Satpur, Nashik, Maharashtra
Email : [email protected],
Accredited by NABET: No NABET/EIA/1619/RA0060/ June 29, 2017)
March - 2018
1. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY This Pre Feasibility Report has been prepared for the Proposed sand ghat over the area of 4.87
Ha at River Kanhan adjoining Kh. No.230, Mouza: Panmara,Tahsil: Mauda, District:
Nagpur, Maharashtra in accordance with the Notification of MoEF S.O. 1533 dated 14th
September 2006. The Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change amended Principal
Notification vide 141 (E) dated 15th January 2016 and included Minor Minerals from 0 Ha to 50
Ha in the Principal Notification S.O. 1533 (E) dated 14.09.2006. Central Government made
further amendments to the notification vide S.O. 2269 (E) dated 01.07.2016. In obedience all
relevant notifications to the principal Notification dated 14th September 2006, application for the
excavation of sand ghat from proposed sand ghat is being submitted to DEIAA, Nagpur.
Though any development activity like industry or minor mineral excavation may cause
temporary damage to land, forest and induce changes in the quality of air, water, flora and
fauna of the area, it has favorable effect of industrialization on social development and progress
of the nation. For overall gain, it is necessary to strike a balance between the two aspects of
economy and ecology and ensure that impacts on the environment are minimized with
improvement in socio-economic conditions. This is better achieved through a well-planned
approach of EMP relevant to the area under consideration.
Sand is used for a wide variety of purposes. It is most commonly used as an aggregate in
construction projects. Sand is required for road base, concrete aggregate, asphalt pavement
aggregate, and many other purposes. The selected area has exposures of sand which is useful
for the various purposes mentioned above.
The mining for this sand ghat excavation is proposed to be carried out manually with opencast
method of mining engaging labours with help of crow bars, hand shovel, pick axes and baskets.
Loading will be carried out manually and transportation of mineral from the sand ghat to the
depot by tractor with tipper arrangement. As the mineral is soft & loose in nature, no drilling and
blasting are required. The proposed sand ghat area is located at Survey of India Toposheet No:
55 O/8 and falls between the Latitude 21⁰ 05' 39.23"N - 21⁰ 05' 36.13"N and Longitude 79⁰ 28'
02.53" E - 79 28' 17.94"E. The lease area is not an agricultural land and the area is classified as
River. Maximum production capacity is 17226 Brass.
In order to obtain environmental clearance as per the EIA Notification 2006 the Prefeasibility
Report (PFR) is submitted along with the application Form I M for the project under
consideration. The project is categorized as Category B2 vide Notification 141 (E) dated 15th
January 2016.
2.0 INTRODUCTION
1.1 PROJECT PROPONENT
The possession of the land under consideration lies with State Government (As per the 20 (1)
Chapter III of THE Maharashtra Land Revenue Code 1966) hence application is made through
the legal representative as a Project Proponent. Accordingly, Tahsildar, Nagpur Collectorate,
Nagpur, have applied for environmental clearance of proposed sand ghat. After obtaining the
environmental clearance this sand ghat will be auctioned as per the Notification Goukhani-
10/0615/pr. Kr.289/Kh dated 03.01.2018. Communication details of the project proponent are as
under;
Tahsildar, Nagpur Collectorate,
Civil lines, Nagpur 440001
1.2 BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF NATURE OF THE PROJECT
The selected area has exposures of sand which is useful for the various purposes mentioned
above. It is proposed to excavate sand from this area by manual opencast method without using
any excavation machinery. Transport of the excavated sand will be carried out using tractor with
trolly arrangement from sand ghat to depot and by truck/tipper/dumper onwards to the desired
destination. The excavated sand will be sold in the market. The present Pre Feasibility Report
has been prepared for Proposed sand ghat area of 4.87 Ha at River Kanhan adjoining Kh.
No.230, Mouza: Panmara,Tahsil: Mauda, District: Nagpur, Maharashtra. The project is for
excavation of sand (minor mineral) categorized as Category B2 vide Notification 141 (E)
dated 15th January 2016.
1.3 NEED FOR THE PROJECT AND ITS IMPORTANCE TO THE COUNTRY AND OR REGION.
Road/building material sand, is an essential requirement as one of the minor mineral deposits
occurring in the majority portion of Maharashtra. It has played a great role in development of
civilization and industrialization. The occurrence of sand in the proposed area is proved by the
way of exposures and its production has important role in the local infrastructural development.
The sediment in the form of river bed material (RBM) deposited every year during monsoon
season at many locations of the Kanhan River. Removal of the sand from the proposed location
is unlikely to damage the riparian system if the excavation and transport is carried out in
systematic manner proposed in the approved Mining Plan. This project operation will provide
employment directly and indirectly to the people residing in vicinity, thus improving the Socio-
economic status of the area.
1.4 DEMAND SUPPLY GAP.
Sand is an essential constituent infrastructural development projects like road, dams, bridges
and building. The demand for sand/gravel is ever growing with the growth of the infrastructure
sector in our country. The requirement for the mineral is always high in the nearby cities and
towns. Therefore there is always a good demand of the mineral in the domestic market. Its
demand in industrial area of Nagpur and nearby areas is increasing very fast. Sand mining not
only narrows the gap between the demand and supply if building material but also enhances
employment opportunities and economic growth of the region. Besides, the production will also
benefit the State in the form of revenue generation. Apart from this, the project will generate
direct and indirect employment opportunities from the nearby villages.
1.5 IMPORTS VS. INDIGENOUS PRODUCTION.
Mining of sand is required for various projects within the state of Maharashtra and other states.
Tahsildar, Collector Office, Nagpurwill explore the Sand as ROM (Run of Mines) in various sizes
i.e. fine to coarse grain which will be supply to the consumer site in outside lease area as per
their demand in nearby Cities and Villages. The excavated Sand (ROM) will be used for: To
produce Manually Mixed Concrete or Ready Mix Concrete for Construction of Roads, Bridges,
Buildings, Dams, Canals and other infrastructure development.
1.6 EXPORT POSSIBILITY.
Not explored
1.7 DOMESTIC / EXPORT MARKETS.
There is always an ever increasing demand of these minerals in the domestic market.
1.8 EMPLOYMENT GENERATION (DIRECT AND INDIRECT) DUE TO THE PROJECT.
The Statutory manpower requirement is a part of total manpower which includes Mine mate.
Apart from the Mine Mate, skilled and unskilled laborers will be required for doing Sand Mining
and transportation etc. Following will be the manpower requirements:
Grade of staff Designation Nos.
Supervisory and Technical staff Mine mate / Mine Supervisor 01
Clerical staff Clerk/ Time keeper 01
Safety/Security Officer Security Guard 02
Skilled workers Tractor Trolley Driver 16
Skilled workers Tractor trolley Helper 07
Semiskilled workers Labours Supervisor (Mukadam) 01
Unskilled workers Labours 40
Total Manpower 68
3.0 PROJECT DESCRIPTION i) Type of project including interlinked and Interdependent project, if any. As per Gazette Notification of Ministry of Environment, Forest and Climate Change (MoEF&CC)
dated 15th January 2016, New Delhi all projects (minor mineral) less than 25 hectare falls in
category “B-2”. As the lease area of the proposed project is area of 4.87 Ha at River Kanhan
adjoining Kh. No.230, Mouza: Panmara,Tahsil: Mauda, District: Nagpur, Maharashtra, it falls in
“B-2” category and will be appraised by State level authority. The entire mined out mineral will
be completely transported to the market /and there is no interlinked project.
ii) Location (map showing general location, specific location, and project boundary & project site layout) with coordinate The land is government Waste land. The area is a plain terrain. The location of proposed site
is shown in the Figure-1. The proposed area is covered in parts of Survey of India Toposheet
no. 55 P within latitude 21⁰ 05' 39.23"N and longitude 79⁰ 28' 02.53"E. (Refer Figure 2).
FIGURE-1 : LOCATION OF PROPOSED SAND GHAT
FIGURE-2 : SPECIFIC LOCATION OF PROPOSED SAND GHAT
The proposed sand mining ghat was demarcated on the ground by revenue department with
reference to adjacent survey numbers of concerned village map. The exploration/assessment of
sand Ghats has been carried out by GSDA using probing rods for delineating the total depth of
sand and depth of mineable sand with quantity.
Accordingly, reports submitted with mineable reserves of sand in particular location. On the
basis of this report State Govt. will auction the sand Ghats for excavation of sand for specific
mineable quantity.
The proposed sand ghat has sufficient reserves of sand to excavate 17226 Brass. for the period
of current financial year. This is a temporary type of lease for the limited mentioned period i. e.
up to September 2018.
LOCATIONAL DETAILS IN SUMMARIZED FORM
Sr. No. Details of the area Particulars
1 Name of Sand Ghat and River Panmara River Bed Sand Mine at
Kanhan River
2 Village Panmara
3 Taluka Mauda
4 District Nagpur
5 Adjoining Khasra No./Survey No. Adjacent Kh. No.: 230
6 Lease Area (Ha.) 4.87
7 Ownership/Occupancy of the Lease area Government Land
8 Existence of public road/railway line if any
nearby and approximate distance
Nagpur-MaudaHighway (NH-6)
Warathi, 18.19 km away towards NE
from ML.
9 Nearest Village and its distance
from lease area
Marodi ( 7 KM ) , Rajola ( 8 KM ) ,
Lapka ( 9 KM ) , Khobna ( 9 KM ) ,
Bhamewada ( 9 KM )
10 Toposheet No. and RL of the Lease area 55 P
11 Latitude & Longitude of Lease area
boundary points
(Coordinates of the boundary points taken
as per the area shown by revenue
authority Patwari/Talathi)
21⁰ 05' 39.23" N - 79⁰ 28' 02.53" E
21⁰ 05' 36.13"N-79⁰ 28' 17.94"E
iii) Details of alternate sites considered and the basis of selecting the proposed site, particularly the environmental consideration gone into should be highlighted.
Rivers and streams by far have been the most lucrative and attractive source for extracting
large volume of building materials such as boulders, stone, pebbles, sand and gravel for a
variety of construction activities. In plain reaches, where the bed slope is gentle, the river bed is
overlaid with matrix mainly comprising of sand of different gradation along with silt and clay. Due
to river dynamics, the sediments which get generated from bed load and wash load move with
river and do not settle uniformly over the entire bed. It rather settles at certain places only
(aggradations) and must be removed from time to time to avoid flash floods due to reduction in
channel width. The Government has identified such locations for sand removal and the present
location is one of them. The project is a site specific and has to be undertaken at the place of
the occurrence of the mineral and hence no alternative sites explored.
The environmental advantages of using river sediments are that the Sediments can easily be
collected / extracted by digging less deep pits in active channel or dry river beds of upper
terraces. The sand extracted from the identified stretch is free from weak materials and
interstitial loose / fine material. No requirement of processing for the sand excavated from the
river and it can be directly used without any beneficiation. The natural replenishment takes
place annually due to transportation of sediments from upper course/reaches during high stage
of river, which is achieved a number of times during monsoon. Environment Management Plan
to mitigate the activities due to the proposed sand ghat excavation is enclosed at Annexure 1.
iv) Size or magnitude of operation.
The proposed sand ghat mining having an area of 4.87 Ha will be developed as opencast for
the excavation of sand/gravel with production capacity of 17226 Brass .The excavation will be
carried out from the demarcated area which is dry. Excavation will be carried out in non
monsoon season on or before 30th September 2018.
v) Project description with process details (a schematic diagram/ flow chart showing the
project layout, components of the project etc. should be given).
The mining will be carried out manually with opencast method of mining by engaging labours
with help of crow bars, hand shovel, pick axes and baskets. Loading is proposed to be carried
out manually and transportation of mineral from the mine to the depot is proposed through
tractor with trolley arrangement. As the mineral is dry, loose in nature, no drilling and blasting
are required and hence not proposed. Sand excavated manually will be loaded directly into
vehicles. Once a pre-determined area has been exhausted of the sand, it shall be replenished
by sand during monsoon period leveled it & maintained to its maximum original topography.
There will be no OB or waste generation as the sand is directly exposed in the river bed without
any soil or silt cover or any other material which can be categorized as overburden material.
Workings will be restricted within the applied area as per the approved Mining Plan. Mining
activities will be carried out in a manner so that there is no obstruction to the movement of water
flow. No processing of sand required.
Restriction on mining:
Mining shall not be carried out within 600 m of any bridge (railway or road) .
Mining shall not be carried out within 100 m from any pumping station, water intake.
The quarrying of sand will be proposed after leaving a safety distance of 600 meter from
bridge falling under NH/SH from both side of the bank, & leaving a safety distance of 100
meter from any bridge.
Mining shall not be carried out within 3 m from the river bank It will be done leaving a
safety zone of total of 1/5th of the width of the river from the banks for bank protection.
During the entire lease period, the deposit will be worked from the top surface to 3 m bgl
or above ground water level, whichever comes first. This will also help in avoiding
ponding effect.
The workability is suggested by keeping in the mind possible effect on the meandering of
River. The mining on the concave bank is most suitable than convex bank. Hence,
mining is proposed during non monsoon period in a way that is will get replenishment
during monsoon.
Mining will be carried out only during the day time. Excavation of river bed material will
be completely stopped during the monsoon season.
No ore dressing/ handling/ processing plant shall be attached with the mine. The whole
area demarcated for the purpose of mining as per the approved mining plan shall be
mined out so as to maximize the sand production or extraction.
Systematic plantation will be made in the area outside the river bank to protect the
banks from erosion in monsoon.
In the applied area the velocity & river water flow being less the sediment load get
deposited in to the pit During Monsoon season the area get replenished with sediments
to be lifted in subsequent years. Excavated area will be replenished naturally due to
sediment inflow from the catchment area Therefore, Environment and Ecology of the
area remains undisturbed.
Sequence of mining operation is given below.
vi) Raw material along with estimated quantity, likely source marketing area of final
products, mode of transport of raw material and Finished product.
There is no requirement of any Raw Material in this project. Mode of transport of extracted sand
is surface transport by existing roads.
vii) Resource optimization / recycling and reuse envisaged in the project, if any, should be
briefly outlined.
There is no waste material generation. No recycling and reuse of material is envisaged as entire
excavated material will be transported. Minerals are generally depleting asset once mined; but
minerals like sand will be replenished naturally. Thus a scientific approach will be taken up for
excavation of mineral with systematic method.
viii) Availability of water its source, Energy / power requirement and source should be given
a) Water Requirement: Thus total water requirement will be 5.125 KLD. This water will be
supplied from the bore well from nearby villages through tankers as well as from surface
water sources for dust suppression. Dust suppression and green belt water will be utilized from water tanks. Electricity is not required as the working is only during day time which does not demand for artificial lighting.
Sr.
No.
Purpose Water Requirement
(KLPD)
1 Dust Suppression and green belt 4.00
2 Domestic (Considering 45 Litres per
person per day for 25 persons)
1.125
Total 5.125
ix) Quantity of waste to be generated (liquid and solid) and scheme for their Management / disposal. Solid Waste: There is no solid waste generation during sand excavation.
Liquid Effluent: The sand excavation from the proposed site does not intercept the water table
and the area is dry having no impoundment of water. Thus, there is no generation of effluent
envisaged. Small amount of domestic waste will be generated by the workers at the site, which
will be disposed-off through proper municipal way. No other waste generation is expected.
x) Schematic representation of the feasibility drawing which give information of EIA purpose. The proposed sand ghat project is for excavation of sand which is categorized as minor mineral
vide Notification No. S. O. 423 (E) dated 10.02.2015 issued by Ministry of Mines. The minor
mineral project such as sand excavation requires environmental clearance as per the procedure
defined by Ministry of Environment, Forest & Climate Change (MoEF & CC) Notification No.141
(E) dated 15th January 2016. EIA for the minor mineral projects >5 Ha is not required as per
this Notification. As per the Appendix XI of this Notification, approved Mining Plan, Form I and
Prefeasibility Report are required for appraisal of the environmental clearance by DEAC/DEIAA.
Accordingly, necessary compliance of the directed procedure is made by the applicant. The
Notification issued by the Revenue Department of Government of Maharashtra No. Goukhani-
10/0615/pr. Kr.289/Kh dated 03.01.2018 and Sustainable Sand Mining Management Guidelines
2016 have also been referred and the directives provided in these Notification/Guidelines have
been used for preparation of these documents.
4.0 SITE ANALYSIS The suitability for extraction was done taking into consideration general profile river stream,
annual deposition factor, and replenishment. The project site is located at a plain topography
and within the mature stage of a river. The river bed sand replenished every year with the sand
carried out with flow of water in monsoon and there is no such control of mineralization as it
depends on the nature of flow of river water.
i) Connectivity
Sr.
No. Particulars Details
1 Road Connectivity The area is approachable from Nagpur-Mauda Highway
(NH-6)
2 Nearest Highway Nagpur-Mauda Highway (NH-6)
3 Nearest Airport Nagpur, 40.00 km away towards W from ML.
4 Nearest Railway Station Nagpur, 40.00 km away towards W from ML.
ii) Land form, land use and Land ownership.
There is no village or human settlement in the lease area. There is no reserves forest or
protected forest land within the mining area. The area has Flat topography. The lease area
forms a part of Survey of India toposheet no. 55 P The landuse details for the proposed sand
ghat area are as under:-
Adjoining Khasra No. of Village / Taluka
/District/ State
Area Type of land
At River Kanhan adjoining Kh. No.230, Mouza:
Panmara,Tahsil: Mauda, District: Nagpur,
Maharashtra
4.87 Ha Government Notified Land
iii) Topography (along with map).
Survey of the proposed lease area conducted by using a Leica Total Station and surface plan is
prepared. Latitude and Longitude readings have taken by using G.P.S. instrument. All the levels
have taken with respect to Mean Sea Level.It is flat in nature. ML area is 48700 m². Temporary
Bench Mark is on Survey Station No. 1, which is 255.00 MRL.
iv) Existing land use pattern (agriculture, non-agriculture, forest, water bodies (including area
under CRZ), shortest distances from the periphery of the project to periphery of the forest,
national park, wild life sanctuary, eco sensitive areas, water bodies (distance from the HFL of
the river), CRZ. In case of notified industrial area, a copy of the Gazette notification should be
given.
Significant features with their aerial distance of the project are tabulated below;
Sr. No. FEATURES DETAILS DISTANCE 1 Village (Nearest) Marodi
Rajola , Lapka,
Khobna , Bhamewada
( 7 KM ) , ( 8 KM) ( 9 KM ) ( 9 KM ) ( 9 KM )
2 Land use Agriculture 0 km
3 Water bodies Kanhan River 1 km
4 Reserved Forest None 0 km
5 National Park None 0 km
6 Wildlife Sanctuary None 0 km
7 Eco Sensitive Area None 0 km
8 Coastal Regulation Zone None 0 km
9 Archeological Monument Near Mansar 20 km (N)
10 Industries Kamptee 5 km (W)
11 Mines Sand ghat 1 km
v) Existing Infrastructure.
There is well established road connection from the quarry to the State Highway /village road.
Other facilities like market, school, hospital (PHC), drinking water facility, electric,
telecommunication etc. are available in nearby villages.
vi) Soil classification.
There is no top soil. The river bed only consists of sand/ gravel.
vii) Climatic data from secondary sources.
Sub–tropical climatic condition prevails in the area. Maximum temperature recorded during
summer is 470C and the minimum temperature recorded during winter is 100C. The region
receives a average rainfall of around 1100 mm with an annual variation of 100 mm although
wider variation have also been noticed in the past. About 80% - 85% of rainfall precipitates from
June to September.
viii) Social Infrastructure available.
Areas occupied by sensitive man-made land uses (hospitals, schools, places of worship,
community facilities) are found within a distance of 10 km of the proposed sand ghat area.
4.0 PLANNING BRIEF i) Planning Concept (type of Industries, facilities, transportation etc) Town and country planning/ Development authority Classification.
The mine will be worked by opencast manual method. Mining will be done up to a depth of 3m
bgl or above the water level whichever is comes first. The sand will be collected in its existing
form. No drilling /blasting are required as the material is loose in nature. There will be no OB or
waste generation as the sand is exposed in the river bed. It will be done leaving a safety zone
from bank for bank protection. Mining will be carried out only during the day time. Excavation of
river bed material will be completely stopped during the monsoon season. Roads in the Applied
Area for the movement of loaded trippers/ trucks will not have slopes more than 1 in 20.
However, movement of trucks after mineral loading will be towards both sides through approach
roads connecting to tar roads. No processing of excavated sand will be done. Workings will be
restricted within the lease area/ khasra as per the description report given by Mining
Department. Mining activities will be carried out in a manner so that there is no obstruction to
the movement of water flow as the proposed area for the sand ghat is dry. Mining operation will
not be carried out during monsoon season. On view monitoring of mining activity technical staff,
skilled and non-skilled labours are employed and thus State/Central Govt. and Village
Panchayat will get royalty. Workers will get direct employment and equal number or more will
get indirect employment.
ii) Population Projection. The project will employ most of the workers from nearby villages. Thus there will be no increase
in population due to the project. However, few people from other area may migrate in this area
for business opportunities. The manpower required for the project shall be engaged from the
nearby village(s) and hence influx of population to the area is not anticipated.
iii) Landuse Planning (breakup along with green belt etc.)
The sand from the entire allocated area will be excavated as per the approved mining plan.
Local species of selected trees will be planted along the river bank and also on the approach
road to depot. If permitted by the local authorities, plantation will be carried out In school, gram
panchayat, PHC or anaganwadi premises. It is proposed to have plantation along the road sides
on both sides to provide cover against dust dissemination and also to act as noise absorber.
Approximately 300 trees will be planted with various types of species. Native plants like Teak
Neem, Arjun, Jamun Peepal, Bamboo, Shisham Gulmohar, Mahua, Tut, Kadamb and other
local species will selected in suitable combination, so that can grow fast and also have good leaf
cover.
iv) Assessment of Infrastructure Demand (physical & social)
The project requires roads for the transport of the produced material which is adequate, besides
it requires manpower to operate the quarry and is available locally.
v) Amenities/Facilities.
Temporary rest shelters, portable toilets, drinking water and first-aid will be made available to
the workers.
6.0 . PROPOSED INFRASTRUCTURE No infrastructure erection is proposed in the mine lease area
i) Industrial area (processing area).- No processing or benefication is required hence
not proposed.
ii) Residential Area (Non processing Area) - None.
iii) Green Belt.
The entire mining area falls within river course and gets flooded during monsoons; therefore, no
plantation is possible within this area. Plantation will mainly be done along the kuchha road and
along the length of the river bank or approach road to depot or places as recommended by
Gram Panchayat. Approximately 300 trees will be planted with various types of species.
species. Native plants like Teak Neem, Arjun, Jamun Peepal, Bamboo, Shisham Gulmohar,
Mahua, Tut, Kadamb and other local species will selected in suitable combination, so that can
grow fast and also have good leaf cover.
iv) Social Infrastructure.
This Project will provide employment to local people directly and indirectly. Indirect employment
will be in the form of shopkeepers, mechanic, drivers, transporters etc. The lessee will be
responsible for providing better social infrastructure benefits such as drinking water, health care
measures, educational facilities, promotion of culture and religious activities in surroundings as
part of their CSR activities.
v) Connectivity (Traffic and Transportation Road/Rail/Metro/Water ways
The area is approachable from Nagpur-Mauda Highway (NH-6) There are metalled roads and
unmetalled road up to the mine site.
vi) Drinking Water management (Source & Supply of water)
Water will be supplied from nearby villages for drinking purposes through tankers with NOC
from Gram Panchayat.
vii) Sewerage System.
Not required. Temporary toilet facilities will be provided by the proponent at the river banks.
viii) Industrial Waste Management.
Not required
ix) Solid Waste Management.
There is no Solid waste generation during sand mining. The entire excavated sand is
useable.
x) Power Requirement & Supply / Source.
Diesel will be used as motive source of primary energy for tractors/ truck arranged by the
buyers. Diesel will be outsourced from nearby diesel pumps directly by buyers. Mining
method is manual and working hour will be for 12 hours during the day time, so there is no
such power requirement.
7.0 REHABILITATION AND RESETTLEMENT (R & R ) PLAN i) Policy to be adopted (central/state) in respect of the project affected person
including home oustees, land oustees and landless laborers (a brief outline to be
given.)
The lease area does not cover any habitation. Hence the mining activity does not involve any
displacement of human settlement. No public buildings, places, monuments etc exist within the
lease area or in the vicinity of the mine lease area. The mining operation will not disturb/relocate
any village or need resettlement. Thus no adverse impact is anticipated.
8.0 PROJECT SCHEDULE & COST ESTIMATES
i) Likely date of start of construction and likely date of completion (Time schedule for the project to be given.)
The operations shall be carried out after obtaining all statutory permissions as per the statutory
guidelines. Adequate reserves are available from the proposed sand ghat area. Reclamation
and Rehabilitation plan will be prepared for sustainable development and minimized
environmental damage. This is a temporary type of lease for the limited mentioned period i. e.
up to September 2018.
ii) Estimated project cost along with analysis in terms of economic viability of the project.
The sand ghat proposed by the Project Proponent will be auctioned online as per the procedure
in vogue. Hence, project cost cannot be estimated at this stage.
9.0 ANALYSIS OF PROPOSAL FINAL RECOMMENDATIONS) i) Financial and social benefits with special emphasis on the benefit to the local
people including tribal population, if any, in the area.
The project involves collection of river bed material. This is very essential in order to prevent
widening of the riverbeds and to prevent flooding off and damage to the adjoining areas. This
can only be achieved by maintaining the existing course of the river.
The river banks, on both sides are covered by vegetation and human habitats. Widening of river
banks results in excessive erosion; resulting in damage to flora, agricultural land and
settlements which are situated at very close proximity. It is proposed to employ the local
population wherever possible in the proposed project activities directly or indirectly. It provides
employment to the people residing in vicinity directly or indirectly by the project. The sand
extracted from this area is in high demand in the local market.
There will be no environmental impact from the project since the scale of operation is very less
and the method of mining by manual. This operation doesn’t need relocation manage of any
habitants. The plantation of sufficient number of trees along the village roads is proposed which
will control the dispersion of dust during transportation as well as will be helpful in controlling
noise for propagation.
Annexure 1
ENVIRONMENT MANAGEMENT PLAN
The proposed mining method is of manual nature and the lease area is not so big. The
proposed project is River Bed Sand Mining Project of Area 4.87 Ha on Kanhan River at Mouza-
Panmara, Tahsil- Mauda, District- Nagpur, State- Maharashtra. It has been proposed to collect
approximately 17226 Brass /Annum (up to 30.09.2018) of Sand.
1.1 Land Environment
The type of mining and the characteristics of the particular mineral deposit both affect the degree
to which mining disturbs the landscape. Sand Mining and allied activities will be done in the
fluvial plain formed by river meandering. Mining of sand may cause a few environmental
degradations.
A. ANTICIPATED IMPACTS:
i) Damage of river bank due to access ramps to river bed, may cause soil erosion.
ii) Destruction of river bank hinterland and ecological due to extraction of sand by probability
of damage to the flood control bunds (built along the river side) due to heavy movements of
vehicles over the bund to approach the mine are and further during transportation for sand
from the mine area.
iii) Disposal of packing material, carried by the workers, would not be allowed. This packing
material would include used sachet/gutka/pan masala pouches.
iv) Movement of heavy vehicles sometimes cause problems to agricultural land, human
habitations, borehole users due to dust, noise and it also causes traffic hazards.
v) Surface degradation due to road network.
M. MITIGATION MEASURES:
Safety distance of 3 meter or 1/10th of the width of the river whichever is more will be left
from both the bank of the river (as per “Sustainable sand mining guidelines”).
No foreign material like polythene bag, jute bag and useless articles should be allowed
to remain/spill in river bed and catchment area, or no pits/pockets will be allowed to be
filled with such material.
Minimum number of access roads to river bed for which cutting of river banks will be
avoided and ramps are to be maintained.
Care will be taken to ensure that ponding is not formed in the river bed.
Mining will not exceeds beyond the allowed extraction capacity.
Green belt will be developed along the haul road and the bank of rivers of mine premises
and near the sand mining site. While selecting the plant species, preference will be given
for planting native species of the area.
Monuments : There are no public buildings or monuments of any important in the nearby which might be affected due during sand extraction
1.2 Water Environment
A. ANTICIPATED IMPACTS:
As the project activity is carried out in the dry part of river bed, none of the project activities will
affect the water environment or riverbank habitats. Project activities will not have any adverse
effect on the physical components of the environment and therefore may not have any effect on
the recharge of ground waters or affect the water quality. Monitoring of water quality will be
checked yearly.
M. MITIGATION MEASURES:
i) Mining is avoided during the monsoon season and at the time of floods. This will help in
replenishment of sand in the river bed.
ii) Mining below subterranean water level will be avoided as safe guard against
environmental contamination and over exploitation of resources.
iii) River stream will not be diverted to form in active channels.
iv) Utmost care will be taken to minimize or control leakage vehicles to be used for sand
transportation.
v) The washing of tractor trolleys in the river will be avoided.
vi) The contractor will follow all guidelines and rules for proper and scientific method of
mining during the period of extracting the sand.
Since there is no disturbance to the surface water or ground water, the quality of water due to
proposed sand extraction by manual method is unlikely to create any impact on quality of water.
1.3 Air Environment:
A. ANTICIPATED IMPACTS:
a) Due to Haul Road/ Access Road:
Plying of tractor trolleys from public road to river sand collection points needs access roads.
Majority of such access roads are the same existing roads/tracks being used by
pedestrians/cart owners. Movement of heavy vehicles sometimes causes problems to cattle,
agriculture land, and human habitations due to dust, noise and movement of public. These
environmental problems are felt more as the area is rural in nature.
b) Due to Mining process:
Air pollution is likely to be caused at various stages of sand mining operations such as
excavation, loading & transportation of material. Most of the dust will be generated from
loading& transportation. This dust becomes air borne and gets carried away to surrounding
areas. The impact on air is mainly localized in nature as the dust particles are not carried to
longer distances and the effect is felt within the core zone of the project involving active Sand
mining operations.
M. MITIGATION MEASURES:
a) Mitigation of Impacts on Access Roads:
Movement of the vehicles on the road will be increased; however, unmetalled road in the mining
area will be sprinkled with water at regular intervals. In addition to prevent spillage by tractor
trolleys over loading should be controlled along with speed limit (1Brass /tractor trolley).
Maintenance of haul road will be done on regular basis.
b) For Fugitive Dust Emission:
i) To avoid fugitive dust emissions at the time of excavation, regular sprinkling of water
will be done on regular basis.
ii) Sand is transported to the sites by road through tractor trolleys. The sand carrying
vehicles shall be covered by tarpaulin sheets.
iii) The Green Belt development will be prepared along the haul roads, which will act as a
pollution sink.
iv) To minimize the vehicular pollution from the sand transporting vehicles, the following
conditions will insist to permit the vehicles of the transporters.
• The vehicles should be (Bharat-IV stage) compliant and should have pollution
control certificate (PUC) issued by appropriate authorities.
• Regular maintenance of transport vehicles and monitoring of vehicular emission
levels at periodical intervals.
1.4 Noise
A. ANTICIPATED IMPACTS:
Noise environment in this project will be affected only by the equipment at the site and
vehicular transportation. Since, slight increase in noise levels can be expected.
M. MITIGATION MEASURES:
Minimum use of Horns at the village area.
Timely maintenance of vehicles and their silencers to minimize vibration and Sound.
Phasing out of old and worn out tractor trolleys.
Provision of green belts along the road networks.
Care will be taken to produce minimum sound during sand loading.
Use of Backhoe and ear plugs may be provided to protect the labors working at the site.
2.4 Socio-Economic Environment
This project operation will provide livelihood to the poorest section of the society. Approximately
25 people shall work at mine site.
A. ANTICIPATED IMPACTS AND EVALUATION:
The project activities shall not have any adverse impacts on any of the common property
resources of the village communities, as the sand mine lease area is not being used for any
purpose by any section of the society in this region. There is no R & R involvement in this
project. There is no land acquisition in this project.
The results of the field survey conducted to understand the knowledge and perception of the
people living around the project area gives a clear idea about the need for the project. A major
portion of the houses in the study area are semi- pucca type structures. The water source to
these areas is from the municipal connection and private bore wells and wells. The awareness
level regarding the proposed mining activity is very high.
The proposed mining activity is expected to provide stimulus to socio-economic activities in the
region and thereby accelerate further development processes.
i) Social and Demographic Profile:
The workers are from local villages. These people have been provided all welfare from a lessee
like medical benefits, insurance, fees for children’s education etc. They have some land and
cattle for their daily earnings. Additional income earned from the Sand Mining work will improve
their living standard. The group of quarries in and around will help to have infrastructure facilities
like roads, schools, shops etc. This will improve their social life.
ii) Occupational Health And Safety:
This is River Bed Sand Mine. So the mining activities are comparatively less because the
production is not on large scale. Workers do not come across any extreme condition like
excessive heat; moisture etc. Workers working around it may come across this dusty
environment. But the impact on health will be within limit.
iii) Human Settlement:
There are no houses in and around lease area. Blasting is only activity, which may affect the
settlement, but settlement is at distance of more than 1.0 Km from the Sand Mining. All the due
precautions will be taken during mining. Transport of finished products is through the villages.
There will be psychological impact of the traffic on the local people. However, the intensity of
traffic is less.
iv) Health and Hygiene:
In general, the health of villagers is moderately good. In the rainy season, the atmospheric
condition is unhygienic due to lack of proper drainage and sanitation in the village habitation.
Villagers are working in agricultural fields and work as laborers.
v) Education:
Mostly education is up to middle standard. Economic condition is in general moderate. So
after this project the standard of education will be increase.
vi) Socio Economic Benefits Arising Out Of Mining:
Generation of employment in the rural area.
Improvement in the living standards of the rural people.
Creating of infrastructural facilities like roads, electricity, shops, school etc.
Helping to improve literacy in the area
Exploiting natural mineral so generation of revenue
Helping to sustain construction activity
Improving the greenery of the area, this is otherwise very poor. 1.6 LIQUID EFFLUENT:
Not applicable because small mine and impacts are negligible
1.7 SOLID WASTE:
Not applicable because small mine and impacts are negligible.
2.0 IMPLEMENTATION OF EMP:
Environmental Management Plan serves no purpose if it is not implemented with true spirit.
Some loopholes in the EMP can also be detected afterwards when it is implanted and
monitored. Thus, an implementation and monitoring programmed has to be prepared.
Implementation of proposed control measures and monitoring programmed has an implication
on the surrounding area as well as for the region. Therefore, sand mining management should
be strengthen the existing control measures as elaborated earlier in this report and monitor the
efficacy of the control measures implemented within the sand mining area relating to the
following specific areas:
Coordinate with environment monitoring laboratory for collecting and analyzing air,
water, soil & noise quality of the area.
Implementing the control and protective measures.
Co-coordinating the environment related activities within the project as well as with
outside agencies.
Separate Budget has been allocated for the EMP.
Collecting statistics of health of workers and population of surrounding villages.
Monitoring the progress of implementation of environmental management program
2.1 GREENBELT DEVELOPMENT:
The implementation for development of green belt will be of paramount importance as it
will not only add up as an aesthetic feature, but also act as a pollution sink.
The species to be grown in the area should be dust tolerant and fast growing species so
that permanent green belt is created.
To stabilize the river bank erosion the plantation of native species of that area along the
river bank.
Apart from the green belt and aesthetic plantation for elimination fugitive of emission and
noise control, all other plantation efforts shall be decided and executed with the
assistance and co-operation of the local community.
Proposed Program for Plantation For Green Belt Development:
Afforestation will be carried out to increase the green cover and create harmony with nature.
The area will be afforested with variety of local sapling. This will help to have polyculture. The
details of a forestation program are given below. This will be done on the statutory barrier to be
left and on the general surface of the lease. along the access road at sand mining site.(List of
trees is given):
S.N. Scientific Name Hindi Name Number
1 Azadirachta indica Nim 30
2 Tectona grandis Teak 30
3 Terminalia arjuna Arjun 30
4 Tuti Tut 30
5 Syzygium cumini Jamun 30
6 Ficus religiosaa Pipal 30
7 Bambusa vulgaris Bamboo 30
8 Neolamarckia cadamba Kadamb 30
9 Dalbergia sissoo Shisham 30
10 Madhuca longifolia Mahua 30
Total 300
Cost of Environment Management Cost:
S.N. Description Cost Rs. (in thousands)
1 Dust suppression 20,000
2 Haul road maintenance 30,000
3 Green belt & Maintenance 15,000
4 Monitoring cost 25,000
2.2 TRANSPORT SYSTEM:
1. Proper parking places should be provided for the tractor trolleys and other vehicles by
the Mine Owner to avoid any congestion or blocking of roads.
2. Spillage of sand on roads may lead to accidents. Proper road safety signs both inside
and outside the mine should be displayed for avoiding road accidents.
2.2 MONITORING SCHEDULE AND PARAMETERS
2.2.1 MONITORING OF AMBIENT AIR, WATER, and NOISE:
To evaluate the effectiveness of environmental management program regular monitoring of the
important environmental parameters to be monitored are shown in following Table:
Monitoring Parameters Frequency of
Monitoring
Ambient Air: (Ambient Air Quality at appropriate location
for PM, SO2, NO2) :In the vicinity of the mine area &Near
Access road.
Half-yearly
Water: Two Surface (up-stream & Down Stream) & One
Ground Water Samples nearby the project site Yearly
Noise: Day & Night level Noise Monitoring at mining site Half-yearly
For air, water and noise pollution control measures, it has been suggested that samples would
be collected and tested all-round the year with appropriate frequency at strategic places by
suitable agencies. In case, it is found that any of the control parameters exceed the tolerance
limit as fixed by the State/Central Pollution Control Board, preventive measures will be taken
and if required expert opinion will be sought for proper remedial measures.
2.2.2 DISASTER PLANNING
Proper disaster planning should be done to meet any emergency situation arising due to fire,
explosion, sudden leakage of gas etc. Firefighting equipment and other safety appliances
should be kept ready for use during disaster/emergency situation including natural calamities
like earthquake/flood.
2.2. ENVIRONMENT MANAGEMENT CELL:
Each mine or group of mine should identify within its setup a Department/Section/Cell with
trained personnel to take up the model responsibility of environmental management as required
for planning and implementation of the projects
3.0 CONCEPTUAL MINING PLAN
This stage not applicable because the Conceptual plan of the proposed lease area at the end of
lease period is prepared.
3.1 Ultimate depth, size & shape of the pit:
The Lease will be for 1 year. Therefore, it is very premature to decide the conceptual plan for
the Sand Mine. However, based on the available geological information requirement or purpose
of mining the shape and size of Sand has been defined and shown as the Ultimate Pit Limits by
colored lines in the Geological plan, the Production &Development plan, and the Conceptual
plan. Ultimate pit size will be 480.00 m x 60 m x 0.50 m. The Conceptual plan and
Environmental Management Plan are shown in Plate No.-VII
3.2. Ultimate Capacity of Dump: No surface dump is proposed at the conceptual stage.
3.3. Land use pattern:
The anticipated land use pattern as envisaged after five years and at the end of conceptual period would be as tabulated below:-
S. N.
Particulars As on Today in Ha
After 1 Years in Ha
1) Area of top soil spread for a forestation - -
2) Storage for top soil - -
3) Green Belt 0.000 0.000
4) Over burden Dump - -
5) Mineral Storage - -
6) Infrastructure (Workshop, Admin. Building etc.)
0.000 0.000
7) Mine road in Mine lease area 0.000 0.000
8) Utilized area for Sand Mining 0.000 4.870
9) Virgin lease area for Sand Mine & Other Uses 4.870 0.000
10) Road - -
4.0 COMPLIANCE OF SAFETY RULES AND REGULATIONS
Whether there are any serious violation of safety rules and regulation which may jeopardize
human health and safety. If so, give details of violations and state the steps proposed to be
taken with the time scheduled to rectify the violations:
No, there are not any serious violation of safety rules and regulation, which may jeopardize
human health and safety. The applicant has given a commitment in this effect and undertaking
also given to follow and implement, as specified in the mining plan. The applicant is undertake
to abide and implement any special conditions imposed by various authorities and also to
complete formalities under provision of the Mines & Mineral (Development & Regulation) Act,
1957 and the Bombay Minor Mineral rules, the Mineral Conservation and Development Rules,
1988 as amended, the Maharashtra Minor Minerals Extraction (Development and Regulation)
Rule 2013, MoEF & CC Notification S.O. 141 (E) dated 15th January 2016, and MoEF & CC
Sustainable Sand Mining Management Guidelines 2016.
5.0 ANY OTHER INFORMATION
Stringent stipulations have been laid out while issuing EC. This includes regular monitoring of
environmental parameters and carrying out various mitigates measures to protect the
environment. These things will be religiously followed and its report will be periodically
submitted to the concerned authority. All Notices, Letters received from Government and all
communication with Government (Court, NGT, DGMS, Directorate of Geology and Mining,
District Mining Officer, Collector, Tehsildar, Grampanchayat, Talathi, Pollution Control Board,
Forest department, Environment department, Irrigation department, Public Works Departments,
Controller of Explosive, Labour Commissioner, Sale tax etc.) regarding Mine Lease and Mining
will be strictly followed by Mine Owner. Mine Owner must follow all provisions of the
Maharashtra Minor Minerals Extraction (Development and Regulation) Rule-2013, MoEF & CC
Notification S.O. 141 (E) dated 15th January 2016, and MoEF & CC Sustainable Sand Mining
Management Guidelines 2016, the Environment (Protection) Act 1986 and Rules made there
under, the Water (Prevention and Control of Pollution) Act 1974, the Air (Prevention and Control
of Pollution) Act 1981, the Hazardous Wastes (Management and Handling) Rules 1989, the
Wildlife (Protection) Act 1972, the Forest Conservation Act-1980, the Forest Conservation Rule-
2003, the Mineral Conservation and Development Rule-1988, the Mineral Concession Rules-
1960, the Mines and Minerals (Development and Regulation) Act-1957, the Mines Act, the
11) Railway - -
12) Tailing Pond - -
13) Effluent Treatment Plant - -
14) Mineral separation plant - -
15) Township Area - -
16) Others to specify - -
17) Ownership Government River
Government River
Total 4.870 4.870
Mines Rule, the Mines Regulations, the public Liability Insurance Act 1991 and its amendments,
Orders and Bye Laws made there under and any laws or guidelines that may be applicable to
mine / area from time to time whether made by Central or State Government or any other
authority. Wherever specific permissions are required, the applicant will approach the
Directorate General of Mines Safety, Indian Bureau of Mines and Directorate of Geology and
Mining. Mine Owner should obtained relevant clearances as per Environment Protection Act-
1986 and EIA notification dated 21.01.1994 and 04.09.2006.