the control of helicity correlated beam asymmetries for...
TRANSCRIPT
![Page 1: The Control of Helicity Correlated Beam Asymmetries for ...people.virginia.edu/~kdp2c/pubpage/talkarchive/Paschke_HCBA_APS2016.pdf · The Control of Helicity Correlated Beam Asymmetries](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022042006/5e6fec4ffbee2d4c5719168b/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
TheControlofHelicityCorrelatedBeamAsymmetriesforParity-Viola9on
Experiments
KentPaschkeUniversityofVirginia
![Page 2: The Control of Helicity Correlated Beam Asymmetries for ...people.virginia.edu/~kdp2c/pubpage/talkarchive/Paschke_HCBA_APS2016.pdf · The Control of Helicity Correlated Beam Asymmetries](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022042006/5e6fec4ffbee2d4c5719168b/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
KentPaschkeAPS’16,SaltLakeCity
Parity-Viola9ngElectronScaHering
2
Forelectronssca,eringoffnucleiornucleons:Zcouplingsprovideaccesstodifferentlinearcombina9onof
underlyingquarksubstructure
ForverylowQ2,ore-/e-sca,ering:comparisontoStandardModelcouplingsprovidesaccessto
possibleeffectsfrom“new”physics
HAPPEX,G0,A4,PREX,SoLID
E122,E158,Qweak,MOLLER,P2SoLID
⇥�10�5 � 10�4
⇥Q2
APV =⌅L � ⌅R
⌅L + ⌅R⇥ MZ
M�⇥ GF Q2
4 ⇤ �
�ge
AgTV + ⇥ge
V gTA
⇥
� = |M� + MZ |2
![Page 3: The Control of Helicity Correlated Beam Asymmetries for ...people.virginia.edu/~kdp2c/pubpage/talkarchive/Paschke_HCBA_APS2016.pdf · The Control of Helicity Correlated Beam Asymmetries](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022042006/5e6fec4ffbee2d4c5719168b/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
KentPaschkeAPS’16,SaltLakeCity
PrecisionofPVeSExperiments
3
-810 -710 -610 -510 -410 -310-1010
-910
-810
-710
-610
-510
-410
100%
10%
1%
0.1%G0
G0
E122
Mainz-Be
MIT-12C
SAMPLE H-I
A4A4
A4
H-IIH-He
E158
H-III
PVDIS-6
PREX-I
PREX-II
CREX
Qweak
SOLID
MOLLER
MESA-P2
MESA-12C
Generation IGeneration IIGeneration IIIGeneration IV
PVA
)PV
(Aδ
![Page 4: The Control of Helicity Correlated Beam Asymmetries for ...people.virginia.edu/~kdp2c/pubpage/talkarchive/Paschke_HCBA_APS2016.pdf · The Control of Helicity Correlated Beam Asymmetries](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022042006/5e6fec4ffbee2d4c5719168b/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
KentPaschkeAPS’16,SaltLakeCity
BeamAsymmetries=FalseAsymmetries
4
QWeak: 7o, ~100 micron beam spot.
Posi9onDifference
SpotSize
�R =d
d✓
✓d�
d✓
◆
✓0
�x
D
dR
R� (0.5 ppm)
�⇥x
⇥x
IntensityAsymmetry�R =
✓d�
d✓
◆
✓0
�I
![Page 5: The Control of Helicity Correlated Beam Asymmetries for ...people.virginia.edu/~kdp2c/pubpage/talkarchive/Paschke_HCBA_APS2016.pdf · The Control of Helicity Correlated Beam Asymmetries](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022042006/5e6fec4ffbee2d4c5719168b/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
KentPaschkeAPS’16,SaltLakeCity
FutureRequirementsforHCBA
5
Experiment Beam Energy (GeV)
Beam Current (μA)
Charge Asymmetry
(ppb)
Position Difference
(nm)
Angle Difference
(nrad)
Size Asymmetry
(ppm)
HAPPEX-I 3.3 40 200 12 3 -HAPPEX-2 3.0 55 400 2 1 -
PREX-I 1.1 70 85 4 1 <100Qweak 1.1 180 ~20 3 0.1 <100PREX-II 1.0 70 <500 <2 <0.6 <100
MOLLER 11.0 85 <10 <1 <0.1 <10
achieved
future
HCBAhavenot(yet)provedtobethelimi9ngsystema9cerrorforanymeasurement.Butthedegreeofdifficulty(MOLLER,P2)
goesupinthefuture.
![Page 6: The Control of Helicity Correlated Beam Asymmetries for ...people.virginia.edu/~kdp2c/pubpage/talkarchive/Paschke_HCBA_APS2016.pdf · The Control of Helicity Correlated Beam Asymmetries](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022042006/5e6fec4ffbee2d4c5719168b/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
KentPaschkeAPS’16,SaltLakeCity
ThePolarizede-SourcePhotoemission
HVExtrac9onandInjec9on
…fromstrainedGaAscathodeproduceshighly-polarizede-beam.
PockelsCell:Allowsrapidhelicityflip
whichiskeytothemeasurements
HCbeamasymmetriesaregeneratedbydifferencesinprepara9onofcircularlypolarizedlaserlight.
Prepara9onofCircularly-polarizedLight
DevelopedandfirstusedforSLACE122
6
![Page 7: The Control of Helicity Correlated Beam Asymmetries for ...people.virginia.edu/~kdp2c/pubpage/talkarchive/Paschke_HCBA_APS2016.pdf · The Control of Helicity Correlated Beam Asymmetries](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022042006/5e6fec4ffbee2d4c5719168b/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
KentPaschkeAPS’16,SaltLakeCity
� =⇥
2� = �⇥
2
HelicityFlip
7
Toavoidslow-dri9s(calibra<ons,targetdensity,etc),usearapidhelicityfliptomeasuretheasymmetryat5Hz-1kHz
HAPPEX-II±λ/4retarda<onproduces±circular
polariza<on
![Page 8: The Control of Helicity Correlated Beam Asymmetries for ...people.virginia.edu/~kdp2c/pubpage/talkarchive/Paschke_HCBA_APS2016.pdf · The Control of Helicity Correlated Beam Asymmetries](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022042006/5e6fec4ffbee2d4c5719168b/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
KentPaschkeAPS’16,SaltLakeCity
� =⇥
2� = �⇥
2
HelicityFlip
7
Toavoidslow-dri9s(calibra<ons,targetdensity,etc),usearapidhelicityfliptomeasuretheasymmetryat5Hz-1kHz
HAPPEX-II±λ/4retarda<onproduces±circular
polariza<on
Asy
mmet
ry (pp
m)
Slug
SlowReversal:Inser<ngHalf-waveplateflipsini<allinearpolariza<on,andthefinalcircularpolariza<on
![Page 9: The Control of Helicity Correlated Beam Asymmetries for ...people.virginia.edu/~kdp2c/pubpage/talkarchive/Paschke_HCBA_APS2016.pdf · The Control of Helicity Correlated Beam Asymmetries](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022042006/5e6fec4ffbee2d4c5719168b/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
KentPaschkeAPS’16,SaltLakeCity
ConsequencesofImperfectCircularPolariza9on
8
Perfect±λ/4retarda<onleadstoperfectD.o.C.P.
ThisiscalledtheΔphase
Acommonretarda<onoffsetcreatestoomuchphase-shi9inonestate,
tooliWleintheother
(theotherdegreeoffreedom,theasymmetricphaseshik,cancelsintheasymmetry)
![Page 10: The Control of Helicity Correlated Beam Asymmetries for ...people.virginia.edu/~kdp2c/pubpage/talkarchive/Paschke_HCBA_APS2016.pdf · The Control of Helicity Correlated Beam Asymmetries](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022042006/5e6fec4ffbee2d4c5719168b/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
KentPaschkeAPS’16,SaltLakeCity
ConsequencesofImperfectCircularPolariza9on
8
Perfect±λ/4retarda<onleadstoperfectD.o.C.P.
ThisiscalledtheΔphase
Acommonretarda<onoffsetcreatestoomuchphase-shi9inonestate,
tooliWleintheother
(theotherdegreeoffreedom,theasymmetricphaseshik,cancelsintheasymmetry)
(Historically called “PITA” effect)
SignificantDoLPwithsmallchangeinDoCP
(DoLP)2=1-(DoCP)2
Δphaseleadstoresiduallinearpolariza<on,withtheoppositesignintheL/Rstates
Inthephotocathode,thereisapreferredaxis:QuantumEfficiencyishigherforlightthatis
polarizedalongthataxis
QEanisotropycouplestoresidual“Δ”linearpolariza<ontoproduce
anintensityasymmetryAQ.
![Page 11: The Control of Helicity Correlated Beam Asymmetries for ...people.virginia.edu/~kdp2c/pubpage/talkarchive/Paschke_HCBA_APS2016.pdf · The Control of Helicity Correlated Beam Asymmetries](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022042006/5e6fec4ffbee2d4c5719168b/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
KentPaschkeAPS’16,SaltLakeCity
ConsequencesofImperfectCircularPolariza9on
8
Perfect±λ/4retarda<onleadstoperfectD.o.C.P.
ThisiscalledtheΔphase
Acommonretarda<onoffsetcreatestoomuchphase-shi9inonestate,
tooliWleintheother
(theotherdegreeoffreedom,theasymmetricphaseshik,cancelsintheasymmetry)
(Historically called “PITA” effect)
SignificantDoLPwithsmallchangeinDoCP
(DoLP)2=1-(DoCP)2
Δphaseleadstoresiduallinearpolariza<on,withtheoppositesignintheL/Rstates
Inthephotocathode,thereisapreferredaxis:QuantumEfficiencyishigherforlightthatis
polarizedalongthataxis
QEanisotropycouplestoresidual“Δ”linearpolariza<ontoproduce
anintensityasymmetryAQ.
Intensity
Asymmetry(p
pm)
PockelscellvoltageΔoffset(V)
PerfectDoCP
ScanningthePockelsCellvoltage=scanningtheretarda<onphase=scanningresidualDoLP
![Page 12: The Control of Helicity Correlated Beam Asymmetries for ...people.virginia.edu/~kdp2c/pubpage/talkarchive/Paschke_HCBA_APS2016.pdf · The Control of Helicity Correlated Beam Asymmetries](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022042006/5e6fec4ffbee2d4c5719168b/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
KentPaschkeAPS’16,SaltLakeCity
ConsequencesofPhaseGradients
9
Aspa<algradientinthephaseshi9resultsinarela<velinearpolariza<ongradientacrossthebeamspot.
Gradientinchargeasymmetrycreatesahelicity-dependent
beamprofilecentroid.
Spa<alnon-uniformityinΔphaseshi9alsocreateshighermoments(i.e.spotsizeorshape
asymmetries)
No charge asymmetry
Large Δ
Δ=0
Large -Δ
Big charge asymmetry
Big negative charge asymmetry
![Page 13: The Control of Helicity Correlated Beam Asymmetries for ...people.virginia.edu/~kdp2c/pubpage/talkarchive/Paschke_HCBA_APS2016.pdf · The Control of Helicity Correlated Beam Asymmetries](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022042006/5e6fec4ffbee2d4c5719168b/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
KentPaschkeAPS’16,SaltLakeCity
6.3 Formalism 123
Pockels Cell Horizontal Translation (mm)-4 -2 0 2 4
Asy
mm
etry
(ppm
)
-12000
-10000
-8000
-6000
-4000
-2000
0
Pockels Cell Horizontal Translation (mm)-4 -2 0 2 4
m)
µPo
sitio
n D
iffer
ence
(-0.5
0
0.5
1
1.5
Pockels Cell Horizontal Translation (mm)-4 -2 0 2 4
m)
µSp
ot S
ize
Diff
eren
ce (
-0.3
-0.2
-0.1
0
0.1
0.2
Figure 6.3.7: The data acquired by scanning the PC across the face of the beamis presented above, to illustrate the relationship between di↵erent moments of theHC e↵ects. This data was acquired with the LAPD detector oriented vertically, andthe analyzer present in the laser’s path in Figure 6.2.1. The top plot represents thezero-moment e↵ect: helicity-correlated beam asymmetry (HCBA), Aq. The secondplot represents the first-moment e↵ect along x: helicity-correlated (HC) position dif-ference, Dx. The third plot represents the second-moment e↵ect along the same axis:HC beam spot-size and shape di↵erences, Drms. Dx tracks with the first-derivativeof Aq and Drms with the first-derivative of Dx (or equivalently, second-derivative ofAq). Dx (Drms) is zero at the extrema of the Aq (Dx) curve, and the extrema inDx (Drms) correspond to the maximum slopes in the Aq (Dx) curve.
6.3.4 HCBA dependence on PC angular misalignment
The formalism presented so far assumes that the laser light is incident on the PC
parallel to the symmetry axis (optic axis) of PC. However, the laser light is usually
incident at an angle to the PC symmetry axis resulting in phase gradients. In fact,
PockelsCellHorizontalTransla9on(mm)
SpotSize
(micron)Posi9on
Differen
ce(m
icron)ChargeAsym
metry(p
pm)
Phasegradientsandtheireffects
10
Intensityasymmetryispropor9onaltothephaseΔ.
Posi<ondifferenceisroughlypropor9onaltothederiva9veoftheintensityasymmetry.
Spotsizedifferenceisroughlypropor9onaltothederiva9veof
theposi9ondifference.
Op9cs-tabledatalookingatasymmetrieswhiletransla9ngPockelscell(seesmalleffectswithrapid-flipasymmetryDAQ,100%analyzer)
Datafrom:RupeshSilwal,Ph.D.Thesis,2012
![Page 14: The Control of Helicity Correlated Beam Asymmetries for ...people.virginia.edu/~kdp2c/pubpage/talkarchive/Paschke_HCBA_APS2016.pdf · The Control of Helicity Correlated Beam Asymmetries](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022042006/5e6fec4ffbee2d4c5719168b/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
KentPaschkeAPS’16,SaltLakeCity
6.3 Formalism 123
Pockels Cell Horizontal Translation (mm)-4 -2 0 2 4
Asy
mm
etry
(ppm
)
-12000
-10000
-8000
-6000
-4000
-2000
0
Pockels Cell Horizontal Translation (mm)-4 -2 0 2 4
m)
µPo
sitio
n D
iffer
ence
(-0.5
0
0.5
1
1.5
Pockels Cell Horizontal Translation (mm)-4 -2 0 2 4
m)
µSp
ot S
ize
Diff
eren
ce (
-0.3
-0.2
-0.1
0
0.1
0.2
Figure 6.3.7: The data acquired by scanning the PC across the face of the beamis presented above, to illustrate the relationship between di↵erent moments of theHC e↵ects. This data was acquired with the LAPD detector oriented vertically, andthe analyzer present in the laser’s path in Figure 6.2.1. The top plot represents thezero-moment e↵ect: helicity-correlated beam asymmetry (HCBA), Aq. The secondplot represents the first-moment e↵ect along x: helicity-correlated (HC) position dif-ference, Dx. The third plot represents the second-moment e↵ect along the same axis:HC beam spot-size and shape di↵erences, Drms. Dx tracks with the first-derivativeof Aq and Drms with the first-derivative of Dx (or equivalently, second-derivative ofAq). Dx (Drms) is zero at the extrema of the Aq (Dx) curve, and the extrema inDx (Drms) correspond to the maximum slopes in the Aq (Dx) curve.
6.3.4 HCBA dependence on PC angular misalignment
The formalism presented so far assumes that the laser light is incident on the PC
parallel to the symmetry axis (optic axis) of PC. However, the laser light is usually
incident at an angle to the PC symmetry axis resulting in phase gradients. In fact,
PockelsCellHorizontalTransla9on(mm)
SpotSize
(micron)Posi9on
Differen
ce(m
icron)ChargeAsym
metry(p
pm)
Phasegradientsandtheireffects
10
Intensityasymmetryispropor9onaltothephaseΔ.
Posi<ondifferenceisroughlypropor9onaltothederiva9veoftheintensityasymmetry.
Spotsizedifferenceisroughlypropor9onaltothederiva9veof
theposi9ondifference.
Op9cs-tabledatalookingatasymmetrieswhiletransla9ngPockelscell(seesmalleffectswithrapid-flipasymmetryDAQ,100%analyzer)
Datafrom:RupeshSilwal,Ph.D.Thesis,2012
![Page 15: The Control of Helicity Correlated Beam Asymmetries for ...people.virginia.edu/~kdp2c/pubpage/talkarchive/Paschke_HCBA_APS2016.pdf · The Control of Helicity Correlated Beam Asymmetries](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022042006/5e6fec4ffbee2d4c5719168b/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
KentPaschkeAPS’16,SaltLakeCity
6.3 Formalism 123
Pockels Cell Horizontal Translation (mm)-4 -2 0 2 4
Asy
mm
etry
(ppm
)
-12000
-10000
-8000
-6000
-4000
-2000
0
Pockels Cell Horizontal Translation (mm)-4 -2 0 2 4
m)
µPo
sitio
n D
iffer
ence
(-0.5
0
0.5
1
1.5
Pockels Cell Horizontal Translation (mm)-4 -2 0 2 4
m)
µSp
ot S
ize
Diff
eren
ce (
-0.3
-0.2
-0.1
0
0.1
0.2
Figure 6.3.7: The data acquired by scanning the PC across the face of the beamis presented above, to illustrate the relationship between di↵erent moments of theHC e↵ects. This data was acquired with the LAPD detector oriented vertically, andthe analyzer present in the laser’s path in Figure 6.2.1. The top plot represents thezero-moment e↵ect: helicity-correlated beam asymmetry (HCBA), Aq. The secondplot represents the first-moment e↵ect along x: helicity-correlated (HC) position dif-ference, Dx. The third plot represents the second-moment e↵ect along the same axis:HC beam spot-size and shape di↵erences, Drms. Dx tracks with the first-derivativeof Aq and Drms with the first-derivative of Dx (or equivalently, second-derivative ofAq). Dx (Drms) is zero at the extrema of the Aq (Dx) curve, and the extrema inDx (Drms) correspond to the maximum slopes in the Aq (Dx) curve.
6.3.4 HCBA dependence on PC angular misalignment
The formalism presented so far assumes that the laser light is incident on the PC
parallel to the symmetry axis (optic axis) of PC. However, the laser light is usually
incident at an angle to the PC symmetry axis resulting in phase gradients. In fact,
PockelsCellHorizontalTransla9on(mm)
SpotSize
(micron)Posi9on
Differen
ce(m
icron)ChargeAsym
metry(p
pm)
Phasegradientsandtheireffects
10
Intensityasymmetryispropor9onaltothephaseΔ.
Posi<ondifferenceisroughlypropor9onaltothederiva9veoftheintensityasymmetry.
Spotsizedifferenceisroughlypropor9onaltothederiva9veof
theposi9ondifference.
Op9cs-tabledatalookingatasymmetrieswhiletransla9ngPockelscell(seesmalleffectswithrapid-flipasymmetryDAQ,100%analyzer)
Datafrom:RupeshSilwal,Ph.D.Thesis,2012
![Page 16: The Control of Helicity Correlated Beam Asymmetries for ...people.virginia.edu/~kdp2c/pubpage/talkarchive/Paschke_HCBA_APS2016.pdf · The Control of Helicity Correlated Beam Asymmetries](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022042006/5e6fec4ffbee2d4c5719168b/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
KentPaschkeAPS’16,SaltLakeCity
Arotatableλ/2waveplatedownstreamoftheP.C.allowsarbitraryorienta<onofresidual
linearpolariza<on
maximumanalyzingpower
minimumanalyzingpower
IntensityAsymmetryusingRHWP
11
A+Bsin(2θ)+Csin(4θ)
sin(2θ)term:imperfec<onsinRHWP
sin(4θ)term:analyzingpower*DoLP
Electron
beamintensity
asym
metry(p
pm)
Rota<ngwaveplateangle
![Page 17: The Control of Helicity Correlated Beam Asymmetries for ...people.virginia.edu/~kdp2c/pubpage/talkarchive/Paschke_HCBA_APS2016.pdf · The Control of Helicity Correlated Beam Asymmetries](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022042006/5e6fec4ffbee2d4c5719168b/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
KentPaschkeAPS’16,SaltLakeCity
Cathodeproper9esalsomaHerElectron
beamposi<on
diffe
rence(m
icron)
Rota<ngwaveplateangle
AQandposi<ondifferencesbothfollow“sin(2θ)+sin(4θ)”fit.
LargeDoLP=largeposi<ondifference
->Gradientincathodeanalyzingpower
Electron
beamposi<on
diffe
rence(m
icron)
WithLargeΔvoltageoffset
Rota<ngwaveplateangle
4θtermmeasures:analyzingpower*(gradientinDoLP)
+(gradientinanalyzingpower)*DoLP
12
![Page 18: The Control of Helicity Correlated Beam Asymmetries for ...people.virginia.edu/~kdp2c/pubpage/talkarchive/Paschke_HCBA_APS2016.pdf · The Control of Helicity Correlated Beam Asymmetries](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022042006/5e6fec4ffbee2d4c5719168b/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
KentPaschkeAPS’16,SaltLakeCity
Laserspotcentroiddifference,a9erlinearpolarizer(maximum“analyzingpower”)
Ver<calposi<on
differen
ce(μ
m)
YawAngle(mrad)
IHWPOUT
IHWPINSimultaneouszeroposi9ondifferencesforpitchandyawangles(sameforboth
waveplatestates)canbefound,represen9ngbestaveragealignment
alongop9caxis.
•Off-axisbeammixesindexofrefrac<onbetweenop<candextraordinaryaxes
•DivergentbeamcouplesΔ-phaseshi9toangle
•Anglecouplestoposi<onResult:aposi<on-sensi<veΔ-phase
Spatial distribution of Δ phase associated with Pockels cell
Pockels Cell
Untilted.
non-zerosize
differences
Pockels Cell Tilted.
non-zeroposition
differences.
BeamDivergenceandCellAlignment
13
![Page 19: The Control of Helicity Correlated Beam Asymmetries for ...people.virginia.edu/~kdp2c/pubpage/talkarchive/Paschke_HCBA_APS2016.pdf · The Control of Helicity Correlated Beam Asymmetries](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022042006/5e6fec4ffbee2d4c5719168b/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
BeamDivergenceandCellAlignment
6.4 Controlling Helicity-Correlated (HC) E↵ects 130
Pockels Cell Rotation (mrad)-8 -6 -4 -2 0 2 4 6 8
Asy
mm
etry
(ppm
)
-80000
-60000
-40000
-20000
0
20000
40000
60000
Pockels Cell Rotation (mrad)-8 -6 -4 -2 0 2 4 6 8
m)
µPo
sitio
n D
iffer
ence
(
-2
-1
0
1
2
Pockels Cell Rotation (mrad)-8 -6 -4 -2 0 2 4 6 8
m)
µSp
ot S
ize
Diff
eren
ce (
-1.4
-1.2
-1
-0.8
-0.6
-0.4
-0.2
-0
Figure 6.3.10: The Pockels Cell (PC) misalignment in angle relative to the beampropagation direction results in large HC e↵ects, as is evident in these plots. Thesee↵ects are contained in HCBA of Eq. 6.3.25. The plots presented above refer to dataacquired with the PC rotated in the range of ± 8 mrad in the xz-plane about itscenter. These data were acquired with the LAPD detector oriented at 45� to thehorizontal, and with the analyzer present in the laser’s path in a setup similar to thatof Figure 6.2.1. The top plot presents the HCBA as a function of the PC rotationangle. The middle and bottom plots present the HC position di↵erence, and HC spot-size and shape di↵erences measured along one of the PC birefringence axis (which isat 45� from the horizontal) as a function of the PC rotation angle.
respectively. Considering broadly, there are two ways to suppress Aq:
• Use a photocathode with no analyzing power ( ✏T = 0): When HAPPEX-III
and PREX ran, ✏T = 0 was only achievable with a photocathode that yielded
electrons with a substantially reduced beam polarization of ⇠ 35%. The very
SpotSize
(micron)Posi9on
Differen
ce(m
icron)ChargeAsym
metry(p
pm)
PockelsCellTiltAngleScan(mrad)
Spatial distribution of Δ phase associated with Pockels cell
Pockels Cell
Untilted.
non-zerosize
differences
Pockels Cell Tilted.
non-zeroposition
differences.
Higherorder:evenwhenaligned,thiseffectwillleadto“quadrupole”breathingmode
ofbeamspot.
14
![Page 20: The Control of Helicity Correlated Beam Asymmetries for ...people.virginia.edu/~kdp2c/pubpage/talkarchive/Paschke_HCBA_APS2016.pdf · The Control of Helicity Correlated Beam Asymmetries](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022042006/5e6fec4ffbee2d4c5719168b/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
KentPaschkeAPS’16,SaltLakeCity
SpecializedTechniquesforSourceLaserOp9cs
Strainedvacuumwindowisbirefringent.DoLP=0doesn’tmeanthespa<alvaria<onofLPiszero
15
•Measurephasegradients(1stand2ndmoments)•Enhancedby100%polarizer.•Requireintegra9ngDAQ,segmentedphotodiodes•Characteriza9onofop9cs.Carefulalignment.• Ingeneral,moreproblemsthanknobs
Testsonlasertable
Testsonelectronbeam•Vacuumwindow,cathodeprovidetheirownfeatures•Precisionisharder,3%analyzingpower
NextChallenges:•RapidFlip•BeamHalo•Laserinterference
TakeadvantageofwaystosuppressHCBAinthebeam
![Page 21: The Control of Helicity Correlated Beam Asymmetries for ...people.virginia.edu/~kdp2c/pubpage/talkarchive/Paschke_HCBA_APS2016.pdf · The Control of Helicity Correlated Beam Asymmetries](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022042006/5e6fec4ffbee2d4c5719168b/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
KentPaschkeAPS’16,SaltLakeCity
Feedback
16
AdjustPC“delta”phasetokeepDoLPminimized
Simplealgorithmdrivesconvergenceofthemean
as1/N
IntensityFeedback
Posi<onFeedback•Laserposi9onfeedbackcouplestotoomanyotherproblems•Magnetsinlow-energyinjector•Unlikeintensityasymmetryfeedback,thistreatssymptomsbutnotcause
![Page 22: The Control of Helicity Correlated Beam Asymmetries for ...people.virginia.edu/~kdp2c/pubpage/talkarchive/Paschke_HCBA_APS2016.pdf · The Control of Helicity Correlated Beam Asymmetries](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022042006/5e6fec4ffbee2d4c5719168b/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
Adiaba9cDampingAreaofbeamdistribu<oninthephasespace
(emiWence)isinverselypropor<onaltomomentum.
Forexample:from100keVinjec9onenergyto
3GeVattarget:
Ifbeamop<csdeviatefromdesign,significantcorrela<onscandevelop
1C-Line
before matching
matched
![Page 23: The Control of Helicity Correlated Beam Asymmetries for ...people.virginia.edu/~kdp2c/pubpage/talkarchive/Paschke_HCBA_APS2016.pdf · The Control of Helicity Correlated Beam Asymmetries](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022042006/5e6fec4ffbee2d4c5719168b/html5/thumbnails/23.jpg)
KentPaschkeAPS’16,SaltLakeCity
Adiaba9cDamping
18
JLabexperimentshaveseensuppressionfactorsat5-30x
![Page 24: The Control of Helicity Correlated Beam Asymmetries for ...people.virginia.edu/~kdp2c/pubpage/talkarchive/Paschke_HCBA_APS2016.pdf · The Control of Helicity Correlated Beam Asymmetries](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022042006/5e6fec4ffbee2d4c5719168b/html5/thumbnails/24.jpg)
KentPaschkeAPS’16,SaltLakeCity
Adiaba9cDamping
18
JLabexperimentshaveseensuppressionfactorsat5-30x
Noteveryexperimenttookthesebenefits(PREX-I,Qweak)
QweakInjector~150nmattarget
![Page 25: The Control of Helicity Correlated Beam Asymmetries for ...people.virginia.edu/~kdp2c/pubpage/talkarchive/Paschke_HCBA_APS2016.pdf · The Control of Helicity Correlated Beam Asymmetries](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022042006/5e6fec4ffbee2d4c5719168b/html5/thumbnails/25.jpg)
SlowHelicityReversals
Effec9venessreliesonflippinghelicitywithoutchangingsystema9ceffect...youneedtherightflipforthespecific
possiblesystema9ceffect
“slow” helicity reversals are an important component of a comprehensive strategy to
control HCBANot all HCBA are measured: spot size/shape, phase
space correlations, halo…
OneExample:IHWPFlipssignofcircularpolariza9on,butalsoofthecathodeanalyzingpowerwithrespecttothePockels
cellvoltagesomostlaserop9csasymmetriesdon’tcancel
SLACE158
InjectorSpinManipula<on
g-2Precession
•Solenoids+2Wienrota9ons•Ideallykeepsenvelopethesame•Robustopera9onessen9al
forhighbeamenergies(11GeV),smallfrac9onalchangeinenergyprovidesπrota9on
![Page 26: The Control of Helicity Correlated Beam Asymmetries for ...people.virginia.edu/~kdp2c/pubpage/talkarchive/Paschke_HCBA_APS2016.pdf · The Control of Helicity Correlated Beam Asymmetries](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022042006/5e6fec4ffbee2d4c5719168b/html5/thumbnails/26.jpg)
KentPaschkeAPS’16,SaltLakeCity
SuccessfulControlofPosi9onDifferences
20
!"#$%&$'()*'%+&"#%,-..$/001%
2%#"3*4%&(35#$%1%%&-36"#%789$&%
6"#83-*$'%%
."'85"3%:%;3#%
-3<)$%:%=>;?%3&-6%
!"#$%&$'()*'%+&"#%,-..$/001%
2%#"3*4%&(35#$%1%%&-36"#%789$&%
6"#83-*$'%%
."'85"3%:%;3#%
-3<)$%:%=>;?%3&-6%
Performance during HAPPEX-II proton run
Position differences < 2 nm
Angle differences < 2.5 μRad
• Achieve position differences in 100 KeV injector of ≈50 nm using HAPPEX-II protocols.
• Rely on adiabatic damping reduction of ~100 (half the theoretical maximum).• Should lead to 0.5 nm goal. Be prepared to use feedback (might be
necessary simply because of measurement resolution and random jitter).
Plans for 12 GeV Moller:
Widths dominated by jitter(not measurement resolution).
HAPPEX-II(2005)RunAveraged:
Energy:-0.25ppbXTarget:1nm
XAngle:0.3nradYTarget:2nm
YAngle:<0.3nrad
![Page 27: The Control of Helicity Correlated Beam Asymmetries for ...people.virginia.edu/~kdp2c/pubpage/talkarchive/Paschke_HCBA_APS2016.pdf · The Control of Helicity Correlated Beam Asymmetries](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022042006/5e6fec4ffbee2d4c5719168b/html5/thumbnails/27.jpg)
FastHelicityFlip-RTPWhy are we trying to use RTP?
KD*P Cell
Piezoelectric Ringing � At 2kHz helicity switching,
100μs deadtime
is 20% loss of data
RTP Cell
Observe
� Virtually no ringing (<0.2%)
� Faster transition 12μs
� At 2kHz switching, deadtime reduced by ~10x
MOLLERwillrequire2kHzfliprateKD*PPockelscellcan’tkeepup
Qweakmanaged~70μs=7%dead9me
Why are we trying to use RTP?
KD*P Cell
Piezoelectric Ringing � At 2kHz helicity switching,
100μs deadtime
is 20% loss of data
RTP Cell
Observe
� Virtually no ringing (<0.2%)
� Faster transition 12μs
� At 2kHz switching, deadtime reduced by ~10x
RTPisnotpiezo-electric
transversedesign,newchallengeslongitudinaldesign• EachcrystalisO(1000)waveplate• reflec9on,analyzingpower• uniformity• compensa9ngdesigneliminates“breathingmode”
![Page 28: The Control of Helicity Correlated Beam Asymmetries for ...people.virginia.edu/~kdp2c/pubpage/talkarchive/Paschke_HCBA_APS2016.pdf · The Control of Helicity Correlated Beam Asymmetries](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022042006/5e6fec4ffbee2d4c5719168b/html5/thumbnails/28.jpg)
KentPaschkeAPS’16,SaltLakeCity
RTP-newtechnology,newchallenges
22
Commercialcellwasnotsuitable
Mount Redesigned
TestmountofRTPcrystals
• LargephaseshikinS2,notcorrectablewithHVoralignment
• Largergradients(10xoverKD*P)
UsedunmountedRTPcellsforstudies• rela9vealignmentiscrucial• Gradientsreduced(s9lllargerthanKD*P)• Significantanalyzingpowerateachsurface• etalon-unstablepowerandasymmetryDespitechallenges,s<llthe
mostpromisingavenue
Otherop9ons:KerrCell• Largegeometry,notsymmetric• Selffocusing• Ioncontamina9on-volumecharge
![Page 29: The Control of Helicity Correlated Beam Asymmetries for ...people.virginia.edu/~kdp2c/pubpage/talkarchive/Paschke_HCBA_APS2016.pdf · The Control of Helicity Correlated Beam Asymmetries](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022042006/5e6fec4ffbee2d4c5719168b/html5/thumbnails/29.jpg)
HaloAsymmetryQweak:AsymmetryinsmallanglescaWered-beam
monitorsindicatedasymmetryhalo
• canbe>10ppm(requires104suppression)• Correlatedtomaindetector• showntobescaHeredfrombeamline• sensi9vetobeamop9cs,RFphase
![Page 30: The Control of Helicity Correlated Beam Asymmetries for ...people.virginia.edu/~kdp2c/pubpage/talkarchive/Paschke_HCBA_APS2016.pdf · The Control of Helicity Correlated Beam Asymmetries](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022042006/5e6fec4ffbee2d4c5719168b/html5/thumbnails/30.jpg)
KentPaschkeAPS’16,SaltLakeCity
AsymmetricHalo
24
AsymmetryvariesacrosseachRFbunch
UpstreamofChopper
DownstreamofChopper
Intensity
Intensity Asymmetry
Asymmetry
![Page 31: The Control of Helicity Correlated Beam Asymmetries for ...people.virginia.edu/~kdp2c/pubpage/talkarchive/Paschke_HCBA_APS2016.pdf · The Control of Helicity Correlated Beam Asymmetries](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022042006/5e6fec4ffbee2d4c5719168b/html5/thumbnails/31.jpg)
KentPaschkeAPS’16,SaltLakeCity
SourcesofHalo
25
àHelicity correlated movement of centroid is 1µm.
KurtAulenbacher,studyreportedatPAVI‘06
Onepossiblesource:fringesoflaserspot
Largeenhancementoftheintensityasymmetryispossibleforfringes.Noteasytocontrolinthepolarizedsourceconfigura9on.
![Page 32: The Control of Helicity Correlated Beam Asymmetries for ...people.virginia.edu/~kdp2c/pubpage/talkarchive/Paschke_HCBA_APS2016.pdf · The Control of Helicity Correlated Beam Asymmetries](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022042006/5e6fec4ffbee2d4c5719168b/html5/thumbnails/32.jpg)
KentPaschkeAPS’16,SaltLakeCity
Recordofachievements,butnewchallenges
26
Significantprogresshasbeenmadebythoroughlyunderstandingtheoriginsoftheeffects,withnanometerlevelofposi<ondifferencecontrol.
•Rapidhelicityflipwithhigh-precisiontechnology•Robustlimitsonspotsizeasymmetry•Halocrea9on,monitoring
Thenextgenera<onexperiments(MOLLER,P2)willpresentnewchallenges
State-of-the-artissufficientforPREX-IIandCREXgoals
![Page 33: The Control of Helicity Correlated Beam Asymmetries for ...people.virginia.edu/~kdp2c/pubpage/talkarchive/Paschke_HCBA_APS2016.pdf · The Control of Helicity Correlated Beam Asymmetries](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022042006/5e6fec4ffbee2d4c5719168b/html5/thumbnails/33.jpg)
KentPaschkeAPS’16,SaltLakeCity
Backup
27
![Page 34: The Control of Helicity Correlated Beam Asymmetries for ...people.virginia.edu/~kdp2c/pubpage/talkarchive/Paschke_HCBA_APS2016.pdf · The Control of Helicity Correlated Beam Asymmetries](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022042006/5e6fec4ffbee2d4c5719168b/html5/thumbnails/34.jpg)
KentPaschkeAPS’16,SaltLakeCity28
ThepiezoelectricPockelsCellactsas“ac9ve”lens
Transla9on(inches)
Xpo
si<o
ndiff.(u
m)
Ypo
si<o
ndiff.(u
m)
Red, IHWP OutBlue, IHWP IN
Signatureofsteering:•scaleswithleverarm•notrelatedtobeampolariza9on•doescancelonslowreversal
HCBAExample:PiezoelectricSteering
![Page 35: The Control of Helicity Correlated Beam Asymmetries for ...people.virginia.edu/~kdp2c/pubpage/talkarchive/Paschke_HCBA_APS2016.pdf · The Control of Helicity Correlated Beam Asymmetries](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022042006/5e6fec4ffbee2d4c5719168b/html5/thumbnails/35.jpg)
KentPaschkeAPS’16,SaltLakeCity
BeamPosi9onDifferences,Helium2005
29
HCbeamasymmetriescorrespondtodifferencesinprepara<onofcircularly
polarizedlaserlight*.*unlessyoudecidetoaddhelicityinforma9ontotheelectronbeamakeritisgeneratedfromthe
cathode
Problem:Helicitysignaldeflec<ngthebeamthroughelectronics“pickup”Largebeamdeflec<onsevenwhenPockelscellisoff
Helicitysignaltodriverreversed
Helicitysignaltodriverremoved
•Problemclearlyiden9fiedasbeamsteeringfromelectroniccross-talk
•Testsverifynohelicity-correlatedelectronicsnoiseinHallDAQatsubppblevel
•Largeposi9ondifferencesmostlycancelinaverageoverbothdetectors,cancelswellwithslowreversal
XAngleBPM
micron
RawALLAsymetry
ppm
AT3GeV!
![Page 36: The Control of Helicity Correlated Beam Asymmetries for ...people.virginia.edu/~kdp2c/pubpage/talkarchive/Paschke_HCBA_APS2016.pdf · The Control of Helicity Correlated Beam Asymmetries](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022042006/5e6fec4ffbee2d4c5719168b/html5/thumbnails/36.jpg)
KentPaschkeAPS’16,SaltLakeCity
BeamIntensityMonitor
30
9/10/2014' MOLLER'Science'Review' 25'
Random'Beam'FluctuaBons'and'Beamline'InstrumentaBon'Use'Qweak'experience'(@'1'kHz'data'rate)'→'Assess'MOLLER'specifica4ons'(@'2'kHz'data'rate)'for'beam'fluctua4ons/monitoring'
Monitor'type' MOLLER'spec.' Qweak'observed'
Beam'charge' 10'ppm' 65'ppm'
Beam'posi4on' 3'µm' 6'µm'
Beam''property' MOLLER'spec.' Qweak'observed'Intensity' <'1000'ppm' 500'ppm'Energy' <'108'ppm' 6.5'ppm'Posi4on' <'47'µm' 48'µm'Angle' <'4.7'µrad' 1.4'µrad'
Random'beam'fluctua4ons'(“jiver”)'@2'kHz:'''If'12'GeV'machine'is'as'“quiet”'as'6'GeV'machine,'these'will'be'easily'sa4sfied!'
Beamline'monitor'precision'@2'kHz:'''• Posi4on'nearly'sa4sfied'• Charge'monitoring'will'require'
further'developments'
JLab:1497MHzresonantcavity
Futurerequiresimprovedprecision
shownhere:“triplet”forx,y,Imonitoring
Tomeetprecisiongoal(randomnoise)10ppmprecisionat2kHz
•IntrinsiccavityS/Nsufficient,requiresimprovedsignalprocessing
•Measuredbycomparingdifferen9almeasurementsbetweentwomonitors
•Poten9alfornoisecommontosignalprocessing-checkvs.independentsignals,derivefromhigh-precisionscaHeringmeasurements
![Page 37: The Control of Helicity Correlated Beam Asymmetries for ...people.virginia.edu/~kdp2c/pubpage/talkarchive/Paschke_HCBA_APS2016.pdf · The Control of Helicity Correlated Beam Asymmetries](https://reader033.vdocuments.mx/reader033/viewer/2022042006/5e6fec4ffbee2d4c5719168b/html5/thumbnails/37.jpg)
KentPaschkeAPS’16,SaltLakeCity
Posi9ondifferences,EndofHAPPEX-2005
31