the 2012 texas ballot challenge

7/31/2019 The 2012 Texas Ballot Challenge

1/79

Pfa4234 Pavc Dcnnhp Ofcnnamla

Rtaampa`dz

Eannz Ocmhm&jm ohnncdhtcpjhm |jpf kdk`*

4234 kdk` cm` ekocmhm


2/79

Ayam daihta pfa Rtajàmpjcn rtjgctz

achm jm 4226. ghp hi q cntac`z ema|;

ph da Ohmpjpqpjhmcnnz anjljdna ihtRtajàmp &ht Yjoa Rtajàmp*

3- zhq fcya ph da c Mcpqtcn Dhtm Ojpj{am4- zhq fcya ph da ?1 zact hn`

?- zhq fcya ph njya jm pfa Q-_- iht 30 zact


3/79

Dqp. iht pfa ijtp pjga. gjnnjhm hi q dalcm|hm`atjml fh|ph `apatgjma pfa ocm`j`cpa

cpjija` pfcp anjljdjnjpz-

&Cm` |fcp `has Mcpqtcn Dhtm Ojpj{am gacm.

cmz|cz8*


4/79

\fz pfj q``am ajgjo fjip ithg ojyjoohgrncoamoz. ph ohmoatm8&Jm hpfat |ht`. |fcp lhp hqt cppampjhm-*

Tqght fc` rthqpa` pfcp Dctcoe Hdcgc.pfam @aghotcpjo Rtaj`ampjcn mhgjmaa

|cmmcda. |c mhp c Mcpqtcn Dhtm Ojpj{am-


5/79

Gt- Hdcgcs ocgrcjlm c``taa` pfaatqght dz rhpjml pfj mh| icgjnjct |ad jpa

hm Kqma 34. 4226-


6/79

_otaamsfhp hi pfa Ijlfp pfa _gacts |adsjpa. 4226 &phr fcni*


7/79

_otaamsfhp hi pfa Ijlfp pfa _gacts |adsjpa. 4226 &dhpphg fcni*


8/79

Mhpa; pfjs yatsjhm hi Ijlfp pfa _gacts |cs

àjlma` ph da qa` cipatpfa Rtajàmpjcnmhgjmcpjml ohmyampjhm dqp daihtapfa lamatcn

anaopjhm-

Fh| `h J emh|8

Daocqa pfa ncmlqcla jm pfa ihhpat ofcmla.àram`jml hm pfa rfca hi pfa ocgrcjlm-


9/79

Fh|ayat. |fjna pfa Hdcgc ocgrcjlm ncqmofa`

pfa Ijlfp pfa _gacts |ad sjpa jm Kqma 42265pfaz icdtjocpa` cm` ohrztjlfpa` jp

dcoe jm 422


10/79


11/79

Pfa Hdcgc ocgrcjlm fcta` pfajt rth`qopjhm|jpf hpfat yamqa. jmonq`jml NC Pjga. @cjnzEh. cm` Cmmamdatl Rhnjpjocn IcopOfaoe. cnn

hi |fhg qdasqampnz tarhtpa` pfaz ohqn`ohmijtg pfa jgclas cqpfampjojpz- Fh|8

Daocqa pfaz lhp jp `jtaopnz ithg pfa Hdcgcocgrcjlm-


12/79

Gjnnjhm hi q |fh fc` sqapjhma` |fapfatpfa mhgjmaa |cmmcda |c anjljdna ph da

Rtasj`amp mh| sc| Ijlfp pfa _gacts- Hqt

tacopjhm8

\a dalcm cmcnz{jml rjvan hm pfaohgrqpat otaam ptzjml ph rthya |fapfat

pfa jgcla |cs tacn-


14/79

Qm`at pfa fac`jml.Pfa Ptqpf Cdhqp Dctcoes Djtpf Oatpjijocpa.

pfata |c pfj;

_gacts oncjgjml Dctcoe Hdcgc `hasmp

fcya c djtpf oatpjijocpa ctamp copqcnnz cdhqp

pfcp rjaoa hi rcratpfazta cdhqp

gcmjrqncpjml rahrna jmph pfjmejml Dctcoe jsmpcm Cgatjocm ojpj{am-


15/79

Cm` pfj-

Pfa ptqpf j. Dctcoe |c dhtm jm 3:93 jm pfa

pcpa hi Fc|cjj. c mcpjya ojpj{am hi pfa Qmjpa`_pcpa hi Cgatjoc-


16/79

Cm` pfj-

Mavp pjga shgahma pcnes cdhqp Dctcoesdjtpf oatpjijocpa. gcea qta pfaz &jo* aa pfjrcla-


17/79

Pfa njma. Dctcoe Hdcgcs Hiijojcn Djtpf

Oatpjijocpa crracta` `jtaopnz cdhya c

icojgjna hi cm hiijojcn'nhhejml `hoqgamp. jmltaam. ampjpna`. Oatpjijocpjhm hi Njya Djtpf.

|fjof jm`jocpa` fa |c dhtm jm Fc|cjj-


18/79

Pfa cpptjdqpjhm jm pfa ihhpat cp pfa dhpphg hipfa rcla onactnz spcpa`; Rcj` iht dz Dctcoe

Hdcgc-


19/79

\fcp |c fattacopjhm ph

Ijlfp pfa _gacts8


20/79

_CZ. \FCP8

&Copqcnnz. fa cj` hgapfjml ana. dqp faonacma` qr pfa ncmlqcla iht pfj

rtaampcpjhm-*


21/79

Eaar jm gjm` pfcp c hi Kqma 34. 4226. kdk`.

njea ghp hi q. ema| mhpfjml cdhqp pfa nc|lhyatmjml pfa jàmpjijocpjhm hi iqm`jml cm`

cqpfhtj{jml hqtoa iht rhnjpjocnavram`jpqta5 ht njgjpjml c dhmc ijà

jàmpjijocpjhm `hoqgamp ph hma lamatcpa`

dz pfa jssqjml cqpfhtjpz-


22/79

_fa ohqn`mp `jspjmlqjsf dap|aam c djtpf

oatpjijocpa cm` c oatpjijocpjhm-


23/79

_fa fc` mh j`ac pfa `jiiatamoa dap|aam cmcpjya ojpj{am yatsqs hma |fh |cs mcpqtcndhtm- &_fa `j`mp emh| |fcp mcpqtcn dhtm

gacmp. cmz|cz-*


24/79

Dqp fa ohqn` tac`pfa jgrtjmpa` |ht` jm pfa

fac`jml hi pfa ihtg hm pfa otaam |coatpjijocpjhm. mhp oatpjijocpa-


25/79

Cm` sfa |cs oatpcjm mcpqtcn dhtm. mhp

mcpjya. |cs pfa ncmlqcla jm pfaOhmpjpqpjhm-


26/79

Ohgghm amaphn` fat. `hqdp ayatzpfjmlscj` jm Ijlfp pfa _gacts. |fjof |cs

dhqlfp cm` rcj` iht dz pfa Rtasj`ampjcn

ocm`j`cpa |fh jmjpa` fa |cOhmpjpqpjhmcnnz anjljdna iht hiijoa5 iht pfac`gjppa` rqtrha hi `jrannjml tqght. fa

fc` nja`#


28/79

anaopthmjo jgclas yjsjdna hmnz

|jpf pfa cj` hi c ohgrqpat otaamohmpjpqpa ayj`amoahi cdhnqpanz

mhpfjml&nap cnhma rthyapfcp c Rtaj`ampjcn ocm`j`cpa

j Ohmpjpqpjhmcnnz anjljdna iht pfa khd*-


29/79

Ratfcr ghta jgrhtpcmpnz5 kdk` ema| pfcp pfa

nc|zat |htejml hm pfa Hdcgc ocgrcjlmoatpcjmnz ema| Ijlfp pfa _gacts gacmp

mhpfjml. phh-


30/79

Mh|. gjta` qr ph fata |jpf ptzjml ph rtayamp

Hdcgc ithg pacnjml Onjmphms mhgjmcpjhm5iht pfa ijtp pjga. kdk` dalcm ph qraop fa

gjlfp mhp da Ohmpjpqpjhmcnnz anjljdna iht pfakhd-


31/79

Dqp. qmnjea pfha hi q |fh |ata ihoqjml

hm fh|ph aspcdnjsf fa fcsmp scpjsija`Ohmpjpqpjhmcn anjljdjnjpz5 kdk` dalcm cejml|fhj tarhmjdna iht `apatgjmjml fa fc8


32/79

_h dalcm fat ihtcz jmph Rtajàmpjcn anjljdjnjpz-Cm`. jm mh pjga cp cnn. fa |c khnpa` hqp hiàocà hi ojyjo malnaop- Daocqa c fa

`johyata`5 |fjna pfa Ohmpjpqpjhm rann hqp

pfa rtatasqjjpa ph Rtajàmpjcn anjljdjnjpz.ojpj{am fcya amcopa` mh nc| |fjof tasqjtacmz pcpa copht. pfcp j. c lhyatmgamp hiijojcn.

ph ofaoe-

Cm`. asqcnnz fhoejml. j pfj;


33/79

PFATA J_ MH NALCNNZ DJM@JML @AIJMJPJHM

HI PFA PATG. MCPQTCN DHTM OJPJ[AM.CMZ\CZ#

Mh gcppat fh| hipam ht fh| ptamqhqnz

rahrna taracp pfa oncjg pfcp pfa àijmjpjhm jijva` dz taiatamoa ph cmz hpfat |tjppam |hte-

Daocqa. c pfa Ohmpjpqpjhm jmptqop.àijmjml jp patg icnn qmàt pfa kqtj`jopjhmhi pfa kqpjoa hi pfa iaàtcn crranncpa ohqtp.

cm` mhp jm`jyj`qcn ojpj{am- &Pfa Q-_- _qrtagaOhqtp j dhpf cm crranncpa ohqtp cm` c ohqtp hi

htjljmcn kqtj`jopjhm-*


34/79

PFATA J_ MH NALCNNZ DJM@JML @AIJMJPJHMHI PFA PATG. MCPQTCN DHTM OJPJ[AM-

\fcps ghta. pfata |jnn hmnz da c nalcnnz

djm`jml `aijmjpjhm hi mcpqtcn dhtm ojpj{am |famc ia`atcn crranncpa ohqtp jqa c tqnjml jm c

oca `jtaopnz hm rhjmp- Iqtpfatghta. mh gcppatfh| hipam ht fh| ptamqhqnz rahrna taracp

pfa oncjg pfcp pfa ohqtp fc cntac`z jqa`qof c tqnjml5 jp fc mhp-


35/79

PFAM. \FCP @J@ PFA @TCIPAT_ GACM DZMCPQTCN DHTM OJPJ[AM8

J `hmp emh|5 zhqt lqass cs lhh` cs gjma-

Fh|ayat


36/79

PFATA J_ C NALCNNZ DJM@JML @AIJMJPJHMHI OJPJ[AM-

Pfj gacm. jm ht`at ph da anjljdna ph daRtaj`amp. pfa ocm`j`cpa fc ph cp nacpda c

ojpj{am. |fapfat mcpqtcn dhtm


37/79

cm`. ljyam pfa sfamcmjlcms kdk` hdatya`hm Ijlfp pfa _gacts. sfa mh| `hqdpa`

|fapfat cmz `hoqgampctz ayj`amoa cycjncdnajm pfa rqdnjo taoht` ohqn` apcdnjf Gt-

Hdcgc |c ayam pfcp#

_fa `apatgjma` ph ijlqta hqp |fh|ccqpfhtj{a` ph oatpjiz pfa ocm`j`cpas

Ohmpjpqpjhmcn anjljdjnjpz-


38/79

kdk` pq`ja` pfa rthyjjhm jm pfa Ohmpjpqpjhm

|jpf taraop ph anaopjhm5 cm`. tayja|aànaopa` pcpa anaopjhm ohà- Cnghp

jgga`jcpanz. fa tacnj{a`

3- Mh nc| tasqjta pcpa Anaopht ph hmnz anaopc Rtajàmp |fh j Ohmpjpqpjhmcnnz anjljdna

iht pfa khd-&Hm pfa hpfat fcm`5 yhpat jm ayatcn pcpafcya rca` nc| tasqjtjml Anaopht ph ocp

yhpa iht pfa mhgjmaa hi pfajt rhnjpjocnrctpz#*


39/79

4- Ohmlta j hmnz tasqjta` ph Oatpjiz pfayhpa hi pfa Anaopht iht Rtaj`amp c ph

rthoa`qta. mhp Ohmpjpqpjhmcn anjljdjnjpz- &Pfa

Ohmspjpqpjhm `hasmp qa pfa patg AnaophtcnOhnnala-*

?- Pfa Ofjai Kqpjoa hi pfa Q-_- _qrtaga

Ohqtp |act jm ph hiijoa. pfa Rtaj`amp pfaAnaopht anaopa`-


40/79

Mh|. fa tacnj{a` pfa ohqmptz ohqn` am` qr|jpf c nc|iqnnz anaopa` dqp Ohmpjpqpjhmcnnz

jmanjljdna Rtaj`amp qmna Onjmphm qrrhtpatcp pfa ohmyampjhm |ata cdna ph ihtapcnnHdcgcs mhgjmcpjhm#


41/79

Dqp |fcp ji Hdcgc daocga pfa @aghotcpjoRtaj`ampjcn mhgjmaa. ayam cqgjmlfa jOhmpjpqpjhmcnnz jmanjljdna iht pfa khd- Ljyam

avjpjml nc|5 cp pfj rhjmp. ohqn` cmzpfjml da`hma ph rtayamp fj anaopjhm8

Pfa cm|at ocga ph kdk` jm pfa daljmmjml hi

Cqlqp. 4226 &cp ?;22 jm pfa ghtmjml*-


42/79

Ocm`j`cpa ocmmhp lap anaopa`qmna pfajt mcga cta hm pfa

dcnnhp-

_h. ji zhq pfjme c ocm`j`cpa j jmanjljdna ph daRtasj`amp


43/79

PFA HMNZ\CZ PH EAAR FJG

HQP HI PFA \FJPA FHQ_A J_PH EAAR FJG HII PFA

DCNNHP#


44/79

Cm`. |fjna anaopjhm cta c pcpa ciicjt5 yhpat|jnn njeanz mhp ocp pfajt yhpa iht c ocm`j`cpa

hm pfa dcnnhp jm hma pcpa. emh|jml fa |cqmsqcnjija` ph lap hm pfa dcnnhp jm cmhpfat-


45/79

kdk` `j` fat dap ph fcta pfj arjrfcmz- _fa

qtla` ojpj{am pfthqlfhqp pfa dnhlhrfata phofaoe anaopjhm nc| jm hqt pcpa-

_ayatcn |tjpat ithg Pavc aaga`

rctpjoqnctnz jtcpa cdhqp pfa anjljdjnjpz jpqcpjhm-_h kdk`. |fh j mhp ithg Pavc. nhhea` qr hqt

nc|-

_fa ptqoe hjn-


46/79

ANAOPJHM OH@APJPNA 33- RTA_J@AMPJCN ANAOPJHM_

OFCRPAT 3:4- RTA_J@AMPJCN ANAOPHT_ CM@ OCM@J@CPA_

3:4-2?3- RCTPZ OCM@J@CPA,_ AMPJPNAGAMP PH RNCOA HM DCNNHP-&c* C rhnjpjocn rctpz j ampjpna` ph fcya pfa mcga hi jp mhgjmaa ihtrtajàmp cm` yjoa'rtajàmp hi pfa Qmjpa` _pcpa rncoa` hm pfa dcnnhp jm crtajàmpjcn lamatcn anaopjhm ji;

&3* pfa mhgjmaa rha pfa sqcnjijocpjhm iht pfha hiijoa

rtaotjda` dz iaàtcn nc|5&?*pfa rctpz, pcpa ofcjt ànjyat pfa |tjppam oatpjijocpjhm ph pfa

aotapctz hi pcpadaihta pfa ncpat hi&C* 1 r-g- hi pfa


47/79


48/79

Pfata |ata nc| czjml crrnjocpjhm ph lap hmpfa rtjgctzdcnnhp fc` ph da ijna` |jpf pfa ofcjt

hi pfa pcpa rctpz5 nc| czjml pfha

crrnjocpjhm |ata rqdnjo`hoqgamp qrhmijnjml5 cm` nc| czjml ojpj{am clltjaya` pfcp

rctpz ofcjt taiqa` tasqap ph fcm` hyatpfaa `hoqgamp. ohqn` lap pfa ohqtp ph ht`at

ohgrnjcmoa &qm`at cm copjhm ocnna` Gcm`cgq*-


49/79

kdk` rhpa` pfaa Pavc anaopjhm nc| cnn hyatpfa jmpatmap cm` pfam. |jfjml q pfa dap5

taqga` fat|hte hm lappjml Onjmphm pfamhgjmcpjhm-


50/79


51/79

Dctcoe Hdcgc |c |htm jm c pfa 00pfRtaj`amp hi pfa Qmjpa` _pcpa hi Cgatjoc

hm Kcmqctz 42. 422:-


52/79


54/79

Rcj` rhnjpjocn c`yatpjagamp

hiijojcn j`ampjijocpjhm-


55/79

ZhqPqda C` iht Ijlfp pfa _gacts &cs rctp hi pfa C`s dz

Lhhlna satyjoa. 422:*


56/79


57/79

@MO Ta'anaopjhm C`. 4233 &ncqmofjml pfa jgcla Pfa Ptqpf Cdhqp Dctcoe

Hdcgcs Djtpf Oatpjijocpa*


58/79

_hqtoa oh`a iht Pfa Ptqpf Cdhqp Dctcoe Hdcgcs Djtpf Oatpjijocpa. nhc`a`

hm @MO _atyjoa Ohtrhtcpjhm |ad jpa Crtjn 4


59/79

\a emh| pfa _aotapctz hi _pcpa àpatgjma|fjof ocm`j`cpa cta iaàtcnnz sqcnjija` cm`.

pfataihta. ampjpna` ph crract hm pfa dcnnhp-

\a emh| fat pcm`ct` iht apcdnjfjml iaàtcn

sqcnjijocpjhm j ph fcya pfa ocm`j`cpa qdgjp cdcnnhp crrnjocpjhm oncjgjml Ohmpjpqpjhmcnanjljdjnjpz. coohgrcmja` dz cm hcpf qmàt pfa

rcjm cm` ramcnpja hi ratkqtz. pfj j pfa ptqpf-

Nhhe cp pfa crrnjocpjhm fa àyja` ihtJmàramàmp cm` \tjpa'jm Rtajàmpjcn cm` YjoaRtajàmpjcn ocm`j`cpa ph lap hm pfa lamatcn

anaopjhmdcnnhp-


60/79

\tjpa'Jm &ht Jm`aram`amp* Ocm`j`cpa Lamatcn Anaopjhm DcnnhpCrrnjocpjhm ph _aotapctz hi _pcpa


61/79


62/79

Pfa Tarqdnjocm Rctpz hi Pavcs &TRP*

c`hrpa` pfa _aotapctzs spcm`ct` iht

coatpcjmjml pfcp pfa ocm`j`cpa crrnzjml phpfa rtjgctzdcnnhp gap iaàtcn sqcnjijocpjhm-

Ptqa. pfa nc| hmnz pcpa zhq fcya ph daiaàtcnnz sqcnjija` ph da ampjpna` ph lap hm pfalamatcn anaopjhmdcnnhp- Fh|ayat. pfa hmnz pjga

pcpa rctpz ofcjt ocm apcdnjf pfj iaàtcn

sqcnjijocpjhm j |fam ocm`j`cpa ijnacrrnjocpjhm |jpf pfag. ph lap hm pfa rtjgctz

dcnnhp-


63/79


64/79

TRP; Ocm`j`cpa Rtjgctz Dcnnhp Crrnjocpjhm phRctpz Ofcjt


65/79

Cm`. jm Pavc. nzjml ph pfa pcpa rctpz ofcjt |jpf taraop phpfa dcnnhp j njea nzjml ph pfa _aotapctz hi _pcpa-

PAVC_ RAMCN OH@APJPNA 6- HIIAM_A_ CLCJM_P RQDNJO C@GJMJ_PTCPJHM

OFCRPAT ?


66/79

Cm` J emh| pfaa crrnjocpjhm cta cnn pfaz

qa` iht ocm`j`cpa cqpfampjocpjhm. daocqa

pfaz phn` ga h-


67/79

_otaam'ocr; TRP Tarhma ph Tasqap iht @hoqgamp


68/79

Pfa Pavcs @aghotcpjo Rctpz &P@R* cnsh qsa`

ocm`j`cpa crrnjocpjhm- Dqp c zhq |jnn aa5

pfcp |c pfa am` hi pfa taagdncmoa ph pfaihtg qa` dz dhpf pfa _aotapctz cm` pfa TRP-


69/79

P@R; Ocm`j`cpa Rtjgctz Dcnnhp Crrnjocpjhm phRctpz Ofcjt


70/79

P@R; Ocm`j`cpa Rtjgctz Dcnnhp Crrnjocpjhm phRctpz Ofcjt


71/79

Cm` J emh| pfaa crrnjocpjhm cta cnn pfazqa` iht ocm`j`cpa cqpfampjocpjhm.

daocqa pfaz phn` ga h-


72/79

_otaam'ocr; P@R Tarhma ph Tasqap iht @hoqgamp


73/79

Emh| |fcp pfj gacm8

Majpfat pfa Rtajàmpjcn mht pfa YjoaRtajàmpjcn mhgjmaa hi pfa @aghotcpjo Rctpz

|jnn da ampjpna`ph crract hm pfa Pavc lamatcnanaopjhm dcnnhp- Cm` hmnz pfa Tarqdnjocm YjoaRtajàmpjcn mhgjmaa |fh qdgjppa` c dcnnhpcrrnjocpjhm jm pfa rtjgctz fc daam iaàtcnnz

sqcnjija` iht pfa khd-


74/79

Dqp |a cnh emh| pfa _aotapctz ht`jmctjnz

`hasmp saa pfasa rctpz crrnjocpjhms


75/79

daocqsa pfasa anaopthmjo ptcmsgjssjhms cta

pfa hmnz jmihtgcpjhm fa tasqjta pfa rctpjaph qdgjp ph qrrhtp lappjml pfa mcga hi pfajt

ocm`j`cpa hm pfa rtjgctz dcnnhp-@aghotcpjo Rctpz Ocm`j`cpa;

Tarqdnjocm Rctpz Ocm`j`cpa;


76/79


78/79

_h fh| `h |a phr fat ithg `hjml pfj clcjmjm 42348

Nalcn copjhm-

Dqp |a maa` zhqt fanr-

Pfa 4234 Pavc Dcnnhp Ofcnnamla-

Cta zhq jm8


79/79

-Tac` ghta cp

fppr;((kdk`-htl

the 2012 texas ballot challenge

Documents