Slide 1

Structure and Function

Slide 2

Structure and Function in the Origin Structures developed through descent by modification modulated by natural selection. Connects structure with function through adaptation.

Slide 3

Influence of Naturphilosophie Archetype or Urplan Development of taxa within the plan Richard Owen 1804-1892, Britain

Slide 4

Following Origin Determine evolutionary history by morphology Similarities and differences between existing taxa Construct phylogenies using paleontology Thomas Henry Huxley 1825-1895, Britain

Slide 5

Ernst Heinrich Philipp August Haeckel German naturalist Expert on Radiolaria Coined many common terms including Protista, Ecology, Phylogeny, Stem Cell Developed Darwinism built on Naturphilosophie Evolutionary Morphology: search for phylogenies based on form and development within structural constraints 1834-1919, Germany

Slide 6

H.M.S Challenger Supported, in part, by The Royal Society Traveled 170,000 km samples from the surface to the bottom 1872-1876

Slide 7

Kunst-Formen der Natur Had been populizer of evolution Artist and produced 100 plates in the form of Art Nouveau Common ancestry explained repeated patterns in body plans

Slide 8

Slide 9

Slide 10

Slide 11

Slide 12

Slide 13

Slide 14

Following the rediscovery of Mendel and the discovery of mutations, structural change due to random mutation forming hopeful monsters. Structural constraints not as important.

Slide 15

Theodosius Grygorovych Dobdzansky Initially, mutationist Then, began to work on ADH in fruitflies. Enough natural variation Natural selection documented in fruitflies 1900-1975, Russian Empire and USA

Slide 16

From Michael Ruse (2003) Now understand that living things have evolved within multiple constraints (as did Darwin): Genetic constraints: Does the gene produce product(s)? Size of genome Historical or phylogenetic constraints Structural constraints: the task of putting together a functioning organism 1940-present, USA

Slide 17

Genetic Constraints Product(s) of the gene Working product(s) Pleiotropy Size of genome Related to complexity Can determine size of the cell Rudolf Raff, 1941- present, USA

Slide 18

Historical Constraints Developmental constraints; earlier molecular characters fixed in the line Need not be optimally adaptive Homologies based on past history Homeotic genes Proteins that regulate structural genes HOX genes (homologs in fruit flies, frogs, fish, mice, and humans) Relationship between bauplan (urplan) and adaptation Might be nonadaptive or maladaptive Reduce importance of function in evolution

Slide 19

Structural Constraints Many characters are left over or allometric (ex: Irish Elk). How do new characters form? Unexpected structures can be co-opted (ex: feathers).

Slide 20

DArcy Wentworth Thompson On Growth and Form (1916) Form over function Form determined by physics of the environment (ex: aquatic organisms conform to a water- drop shape) Thus, physics trumps adaptation 1860-1948, Scotland

Slide 21

Radiolarian Evolution, Form and Function Recognized as unicell with mineralized nested cytoskeleton elements 2 Major groups: SiO 2 and SrSO 4 Both have taxa that are bilaterally- or radially- symmetrical

Slide 22

Structure and Function Molecular phylogenetics Molecules have form that is related to function Confirms relationship Darwinian relationship between form and function thus connecting form to adaptation (natural selection) ML phylogeny based on SSU rRNA

Slide 23

natural selection has been invigorated and made healthier precisely because of the new emphasis on form, rather than despite it. -Michael Ruse