speciality packaging case study
TRANSCRIPT
-
8/12/2019 Speciality Packaging Case study
1/20
DEMAND FORECASTING
GROUP 9 MPE year II (2013-14 batch)
Jayant Iyer (Roll No: 16)
Mugdha Khandekar (Roll No: 22
Mrinal Singh (Roll No: 51)
Ruth Sequeira (Roll No: 45)Vinayak Srivastava (Roll No: 52)
-
8/12/2019 Speciality Packaging Case study
2/20
SPC is into the business of supply of recyclable/disposable containers for the food
industry.
Food containers manufacturing is a two-step process. First polystyrene sheet get wound
into rolls and secondly rolls are loaded into transformation process to convert into
container.
Plastic for containers are either clear or black.
Demand for containers made from clear black plastic & are seasonal in nature.
Capacity on extruders is not sufficient to cover demand for sheets during peak seasons
and therefore company need to build inventory of sheet in anticipation of future
demand.
Julie Williams is about to be assigned to a team who will be responsible for developing
the demand forecasting model.
-
8/12/2019 Speciality Packaging Case study
3/20
As demand for containers is seasonal and not linear, using the nave or
moving average methods will not be suitable for SPC. Seasonality of demand also can be noticed from following graph where it can
be seen that demand is highest in Q4 and then it goes to least in Q2. Howeverannual sales is growing year over year.
0
2000
4000
6000
8000
10000
12000
14000
0 5 10 15 20 25
Black Plastic
Black Plastic
Linear (Black Plastic)
-
8/12/2019 Speciality Packaging Case study
4/20
As demand for containers is seasonal and not linear, using the nave ormoving average methods will not be suitable for SPC.
Seasonality of demand also can be noticed from following graph where it canbe seen that demand is highest in Q2 and then it goes to least in Q4. Howeverannual sales is growing year over year so there is trend also.
0
2000
4000
6000
8000
10000
12000
14000
16000
18000
0 5 10 15 20 25
Clear Plastic
Clear Plastic
Linear (Clear Plastic)
-
8/12/2019 Speciality Packaging Case study
5/20
Looking at the demand for containers Julie Williams & team can evaluate fromthe following four methods:
Static Regression Method
Trend & Seasonality Corrected Exponential Smoothing Method Trend Corrected Exponential Smoothing Method Simple Exponential Smoothing Method
-
8/12/2019 Speciality Packaging Case study
6/20
In this first de-seasonalized demand has been computed for T3 to T18 usingfollowing formulae:
Herep is number of periods in a year which is 4 in this case.
Intercept and slope has been computed using excel formulae for deseasonalizeddemand of T3 to T18 with respect to T.
Using intercept and slope deasonalized demand has been computed for eachperiod using following formulae:
Intercept + Slope*t Seasonal factors has been computed for each period i.e. actual
demand/deseasonalized demand. Average of seasonal factors has been computed for each quarters. Forecast for each period has been computed using following formulae
Ft = (Intercept + Slope*t)*Season Factor of Quarter
MSE, MAD, MAPE & TS has been computed for forecast demand.
-
8/12/2019 Speciality Packaging Case study
7/20
Level for Period 0 has been computed by taking average of actual demand.
Level for succeeding period has been computed using following formulae:Lt= D* + (1-)*Lt-1
Forecast of each period is equal to Level of immediately preceding period.
MSE, MAD, MAPE & TS has been computed for forecast demand.
-
8/12/2019 Speciality Packaging Case study
8/20
Level for Period 0 has been computed by computing interceptof deseaonalized demandcomputed under static method. Similarly Trend for Period 0 has been computed by
computing slopeof deseasonalized demand.
For all four periods of first year seasonal factor has been taken same which was computedunder static method.
Level for succeeding period has been computed using following formulae:
Lt= D/Seasonal Factor* + (1-)*(Lt-1+TRt-1)
Trend for succeeding period has been computed using following formulae:
TRt= (Lt - Lt -1)* + (1-)*TRt-1 Seasonal factors for 2ndyear onward has been computed using following formulae:
S5= D1/Seasonal Factor of Period 1* + (1-)*Seasonal Factor of Period1 In similar way S6, S7. Can be computed by dragging the formulae up to Perio 20.
Forecast of each period will be computed by following formulae:Ft=(Lt-1+TRt-1)*St
MSE, MAD, MAPE & TS has been computed for forecast demand.
-
8/12/2019 Speciality Packaging Case study
9/20
Level for Period 0 has been computed by computing interceptof actual demand. SimilarlyTrend for Period 0 has been computed by computing slopeof actual demand.
Level for succeeding period has been computed using following formulae:Lt= D* + (1-)*Lt-1
Trend for succeeding period has been computed using following formulae:
TRt= (Lt - Lt -1)* + (1-)*TRt-1 Forecast of each period is equal to sum of Leveland Trendof immediately
preceding period.
MSE, MAD, MAPE & TS has been computed for forecast demand.
-
8/12/2019 Speciality Packaging Case study
10/20
Intercept Slope
2,592.75 226.86
Time
Period
Black
Plastic
Deseason
lized
Demand
Deseason
lized
Demand
Seasonal
FactorForecast Error Abs. Errror MSE MAD % Error MAPE TS
01 2250 2,819.60 0.80 2,535.61 285.61 285.61 81,573.45 285.61 12.69 12.69 1.00
2 1737 3,046.46 0.57 1,824.45 87.45 87.45 44,610.42 186.53 5.03 8.86 2.00
3 2412 3,575 3,273.32 0.74 2,283.37 (128.63) 128.63 35,255.80 167.23 5.33 7.69 1.46
4 7269 3,784 3,500.17 2.08 6,301.32 (967.68) 967.68 260,542.20 367.34 13.31 9.09 (1.97)
5 3514 3,965 3,727.03 0.94 3,351.64 (162.36) 162.36 213,706.06 326.35 4.62 8.20 (2.71)
6 2143 4,070 3,953.88 0.54 2,367.88 224.88 224.88 186,517.11 309.44 10.49 8.58 (2.14)
7 3459 4,119 4,180.74 0.83 2,916.36 (542.64) 542.64 201,937.57 342.75 15.69 9.60 (3.51)
8 7056 4,272 4,407.59 1.60 7,934.95 878.95 878.95 273,263.80 409.78 12.46 9.95 (0.79)
9 4120 4,237 4,634.45 0.89 4,167.66 47.66 47.66 243,153.59 369.54 1.16 8.98 (0.75)
10 2766 4,274 4,861.31 0.57 2,911.32 145.32 145.32 220,949.92 347.12 5.25 8.60 (0.38)
11 2556 4,595 5,088.16 0.50 3,549.35 993.35 993.35 290,567.48 405.87 38.86 11.36 2.12
12 8253 4,969 5,315.02 1.55 9,568.57 1,315.57 1,315.57 410,580.97 481.68 15.94 11.74 4.52
13 5491 5,390 5,541.87 0.99 4,983.69 (507.31) 507.31 398,794.86 483.65 9.24 11.55 3.45
14 4382 6,083 5,768.73 0.76 3,454.75 (927.25) 927.25 431,723.27 515.33 21.16 12.23 1.44
15 4315 6,575 5,995.59 0.72 4,182.34 (132.66) 132.66 404,114.95 489.82 3.07 11.62 1.25
16 12035 6,509 6,222.44 1.93 11,202.20 (832.80) 832.80 422,205.32 511.26 6.92 11.33 (0.44)
17 5648 6,490 6,449.30 0.88 5,799.72 151.72 151.72 398,723.75 490.11 2.69 10.82 (0.14)
18 3696 6,688 6,676.15 0.55 3,998.18 302.18 302.18 381,645.48 479.67 8.18 10.67 0.48
19 4843 6,903.01 0.70 4,815.33 (27.67) 27.67 361,599.16 455.88 0.57 10.14 0.45
20 13097 7,129.87 1.84 12,835.82 (261.18) 261.18 346,929.90 446.14 1.99 9.73 (0.13)
Seasonal Factor
QtrsSeasonal Factor(Static
Method)
Q1 0.90
Q2 0.60
Q3 0.70
Q4 1.80
-
8/12/2019 Speciality Packaging Case study
11/20
Time
Period
Black
PlasticLevel(L) Forecast Error Abs. Errror MSE MAD % Error MAPE TS
0 5,052.10
1 2250 5,049.30 5,052.10 2,802.10 2,802.10 7,851,764.41 2,802.10 124.54 124.54 1.00
2 1737 5,045.99 5,049.30 3,312.30 3,312.30 9,411,540.89 3,057.20 190.69 157.61 2.00
3 2412 5,043.35 5,045.99 2,633.99 2,633.99 8,586,987.31 2,916.13 109.20 141.48 3.00
4 7269 5,045.58 5,043.35 (2,225.65) 2,225.65 7,678,618.17 2,743.51 30.62 113.76 2.38
5 3514 5,044.05 5,045.58 1,531.58 1,531.58 6,612,040.32 2,501.12 43.59 99.73 3.22
6 2143 5,041.14 5,044.05 2,901.05 2,901.05 6,912,711.28 2,567.78 135.37 105.67 4.27
7 3459 5,039.56 5,041.14 1,582.14 1,582.14 6,282,778.48 2,426.97 45.74 97.11 5.17
8 7056 5,041.58 5,039.56 (2,016.44) 2,016.44 6,005,683.69 2,375.65 28.58 88.54 4.43
9 4120 5,040.66 5,041.58 921.58 921.58 5,432,753.03 2,214.09 22.37 81.19 5.17
10 2766 5,038.38 5,040.66 2,274.66 2,274.66 5,406,884.34 2,220.15 82.24 81.29 6.18
11 2556 5,035.90 5,038.38 2,482.38 2,482.38 5,475,551.57 2,243.99 97.12 82.73 7.22
12 8253 5,039.12 5,035.90 (3,217.10) 3,217.10 5,881,733.13 2,325.08 38.98 79.09 5.58
13 5491 5,039.57 5,039.12 (451.88) 451.88 5,444,999.65 2,180.99 8.23 73.64 5.75
14 4382 5,038.91 5,039.57 657.57 657.57 5,086,956.63 2,072.17 15.01 69.45 6.36
15 4315 5,038.19 5,038.91 723.91 723.91 4,782,762.74 1,982.29 16.78 65.94 7.02
16 12035 5,045.18 5,038.19 (6,996.81) 6,996.81 7,543,551.36 2,295.70 58.14 65.45 3.01
17 5648 5,045.79 5,045.18 (602.82) 602.82 7,121,188.71 2,196.11 10.67 62.23 2.8718 3696 5,044.44 5,045.79 1,349.79 1,349.79 6,826,785.24 2,149.10 36.52 60.80 3.57
19 4843 5,044.24 5,044.44 201.44 201.44 6,469,616.39 2,046.59 4.16 57.82 3.84
20 13097 5,052.29 5,044.24 (8,052.76) 8,052.76 9,388,485.80 2,346.90 61.49 58.00 (0.08)
-
8/12/2019 Speciality Packaging Case study
12/20
0.001 0.100
Time
Period
Black
Plastic Level(L) Trend(T) Forecast Error Abs. Errror MSE MAD % Error MAPE TS
0 2,042.74 286.61
1 2250 2,042.94 257.97 2,329.34 79.34 79.34 6,295.29 79.34 3.53 3.53 1.00
2 1737 2,042.64 232.14 2,300.91 563.91 563.91 162,145.03 321.63 32.46 18.00 2.00
3 2412 2,043.01 208.96 2,274.78 (137.22) 137.22 114,373.39 260.16 5.69 13.89 1.95
4 7269 2,048.23 188.59 2,251.97 (5,017.03) 5,017.03 6,378,428.81 1,449.38 69.02 27.67 (3.11)
5 3514 2,049.70 169.88 2,236.82 (1,277.18) 1,277.18 5,428,979.83 1,414.94 36.35 29.41 (4.09)
6 2143 2,049.79 152.90 2,219.58 76.58 76.58 4,525,127.16 1,191.88 3.57 25.10 (4.79)7 3459 2,051.20 137.75 2,202.69 (1,256.31) 1,256.31 4,104,153.82 1,201.08 36.32 26.71 (5.80)
8 7056 2,056.21 124.47 2,188.95 (4,867.05) 4,867.05 6,552,155.63 1,659.33 68.98 31.99 (7.13)
9 4120 2,058.27 112.23 2,180.68 (1,939.32) 1,939.32 6,242,022.52 1,690.44 47.07 33.67 (8.15)
10 2766 2,058.98 101.08 2,170.50 (595.50) 595.50 5,653,281.83 1,580.94 21.53 32.45 (9.09)
11 2556 2,059.48 91.02 2,160.06 (395.94) 395.94 5,153,598.87 1,473.22 15.49 30.91 (10.02)
12 8253 2,065.67 82.54 2,150.50 (6,102.50) 6,102.50 7,827,510.21 1,858.99 73.94 34.50 (11.23)
13 5491 2,069.09 74.63 2,148.21 (3,342.79) 3,342.79 8,084,952.23 1,973.13 60.88 36.53 (12.27)
14 4382 2,071.41 67.40 2,143.72 (2,238.28) 2,238.28 7,865,304.76 1,992.07 51.08 37.56 (13.28)15 4315 2,073.65 60.88 2,138.80 (2,176.20) 2,176.20 7,656,673.18 2,004.34 50.43 38.42 (14.28)
16 12035 2,083.61 55.79 2,134.53 (9,900.47) 9,900.47 13,304,335.46 2,497.85 82.26 41.16 (15.42)
17 5648 2,087.18 50.57 2,139.40 (3,508.60) 3,508.60 13,245,860.76 2,557.31 62.12 42.40 (16.44)
18 3696 2,088.79 45.67 2,137.74 (1,558.26) 1,558.26 12,644,877.65 2,501.80 42.16 42.38 (17.42)
19 4843 2,091.54 41.38 2,134.46 (2,708.54) 2,708.54 12,365,474.09 2,512.68 55.93 43.10 (18.43)
20 13097 2,102.54 38.34 2,132.92 (10,964.08) 10,964.08 17,757,754.39 2,935.25 83.71 45.13 (19.51)
-
8/12/2019 Speciality Packaging Case study
13/20
0.001 0.100 0.200
TimePeriod
BlackPlastic
Level(L) Trend(T) SeasonalFactor
Forecast Error Abs.Errror
MSE MAD % Error MAPE TS
0 2,592.75 226.86
1 2250 2,819.29 226.82 0.90 2,535.61 285.61 285.61 81,573.45 285.61 12.69 12.69 1.00
2 1737 3,045.96 226.81 0.60 1,824.24 87.24 87.24 44,592.14 186.43 5.02 8.86 2.00
3 2412 3,272.96 226.83 0.70 2,282.99 (129.01) 129.01 35,276.05 167.29 5.35 7.69 1.46
4 7269 3,500.32 226.88 1.80 6,300.63 (968.37) 968.37 260,892.21 367.56 13.32 9.10 (1.97)
5 3514 3,727.48 226.91 0.88 3,276.36 (237.64) 237.64 220,008.60 341.57 6.76 8.63 (2.82)
6 2143 3,954.04 226.87 0.59 2,345.56 202.56 202.56 190,178.59 318.40 9.45 8.77 (2.39)
7 3459 4,181.64 226.95 0.71 2,949.41 (509.59) 509.59 200,107.52 345.72 14.73 9.62 (3.67)
8 7056 4,407.98 226.89 1.86 8,180.42 1,124.42 1,124.42 333,134.23 443.05 15.94 10.41 (0.33)
9 4120 4,634.85 226.88 0.89 4,133.27 13.27 13.27 296,138.87 395.30 0.32 9.29 (0.33)
10 2766 4,861.62 226.87 0.58 2,833.99 67.99 67.99 266,987.29 362.57 2.46 8.60 (0.18)
11 2556 5,086.91 226.71 0.73 3,713.55 1,157.55 1,157.55 364,527.40 434.84 45.29 11.94 2.52
12 8253 5,312.88 226.64 1.80 9,588.96 1,335.96 1,335.96 482,881.54 509.93 16.19 12.29 4.77
13 5491 5,540.15 226.70 0.89 4,936.85 (554.15) 554.15 469,358.64 513.34 10.09 12.12 3.65
14 4382 5,768.64 226.88 0.58 3,345.48 (1,036.52) 1,036.52 512,573.56 550.71 23.65 12.95 1.52
15 4315 5,995.83 226.91 0.68 4,102.90 (212.10) 212.10 481,401.03 528.13 4.92 12.41 1.19
16 12035 6,223.38 226.98 1.75 10,916.91 (1,118.09) 1,118.09 529,446.65 565.00 9.29 12.22 (0.87)
17 5648 6,450.10 226.95 0.91 5,877.49 229.49 229.49 501,400.79 545.27 4.06 11.74 (0.48)
18 3696 6,676.37 226.88 0.62 4,113.22 417.22 417.22 483,215.96 538.15 11.29 11.71 0.29
19 4843 6,903.36 226.89 0.69 4,772.89 (70.11) 70.11 458,042.28 513.52 1.45 11.17 0.17
20 13097 7,130.44 226.91 1.79 12,764.96 (332.04) 332.04 440,652.75 504.45 2.54 10.74 (0.49)
-
8/12/2019 Speciality Packaging Case study
14/20
Seasonal Factor
Intercept Slope
3,611.98 263.94
Time
Period
Clear
Plastic
Deseason
lizedDemand
Deseason
lizedDemand
Seasonal
Factor Forecast Error Abs. Errror MSE MAD % Error MAPE TS
0
1 3200 3,875.92 0.83 2,951.64 (248.36) 248.36 61,681.69 248.36 7.76 7.76 (1.00)
2 7658 4,139.86 1.85 7,862.48 204.48 204.48 51,746.96 226.42 2.67 5.22 (0.19)
3 4420 4,472 4,403.80 1.00 4,174.99 (245.01) 245.01 54,507.91 232.62 5.54 5.32 (1.24)
4 2384 4,657 4,667.74 0.51 1,935.68 (448.32) 448.32 91,129.09 286.54 18.81 8.70 (2.57)
5 3654 4,944 4,931.68 0.74 3,755.64 101.64 101.64 74,969.38 249.56 2.78 7.51 (2.55)
6 8680 5,049 5,195.62 1.67 9,867.60 1,187.60 1,187.60 297,538.89 405.90 13.68 8.54 1.36
7 5695 5,132 5,459.56 1.04 5,175.90 (519.10) 519.10 293,528.78 422.07 9.12 8.62 0.08
8 1953 5,892 5,723.50 0.34 2,373.49 420.49 420.49 278,939.63 421.88 21.53 10.24 1.079 4742 6,634 5,987.44 0.79 4,559.64 (182.36) 182.36 251,641.49 395.26 3.85 9.53 0.69
10 13673 6,850 6,251.38 2.19 11,872.71 (1,800.29) 1,800.29 550,580.52 535.77 13.17 9.89 (2.85)
11 6640 6,791 6,515.32 1.02 6,176.80 (463.20) 463.20 520,032.40 529.17 6.98 9.63 (3.77)
12 2737 6,573 6,779.26 0.40 2,811.31 74.31 74.31 477,156.54 491.26 2.72 9.05 (3.90)
13 3486 6,363 7,043.20 0.49 5,363.63 1,877.63 1,877.63 711,645.22 597.91 53.86 12.50 (0.07)
14 13186 6,308 7,307.14 1.80 13,877.83 691.83 691.83 695,001.18 604.62 5.25 11.98 1.08
15 5448 6,932 7,571.08 0.72 7,177.71 1,729.71 1,729.71 848,127.53 679.62 31.75 13.30 3.50
16 3485 7,887 7,835.02 0.44 3,249.13 (235.87) 235.87 798,596.80 651.89 6.77 12.89 3.29
17 7728 8,662 8,098.96 0.95 6,167.63 (1,560.37) 1,560.37 894,841.13 705.33 20.19 13.32 0.83
18 16591 8,989 8,362.90 1.98 15,882.95 (708.05) 708.05 872,979.95 705.48 4.27 12.82 (0.17)
19 8236 8,626.84 0.95 8,178.62 (57.38) 57.38 827,206.94 671.37 0.70 12.18 (0.27)
20 3316 8,890.78 0.37 3,686.94 370.94 370.94 792,726.56 656.35 11.19 12.13 0.29
QtrsSeasonal Factor(Static
Method)
Q1 0.76
Q2 1.90
Q3 0.95
Q4 0.41
-
8/12/2019 Speciality Packaging Case study
15/20
-
8/12/2019 Speciality Packaging Case study
16/20
0.001 0.100
Time
Period
Clear
Plastic Level(L) Trend(T) Forecast Error Abs. Errror MSE MAD % Error MAPE TS
0 4,133.70 210.66
1 3200 4,132.77 189.50 4,344.36 1,144.36 1,144.36 1,309,553.27 1,144.36 35.76 35.76 1.00
2 7658 4,136.29 170.90 4,322.26 (3,335.74) 3,335.74 6,218,342.77 2,240.05 43.56 39.66 (0.98)
3 4420 4,136.58 153.84 4,307.19 (112.81) 112.81 4,149,803.70 1,530.97 2.55 27.29 (1.51)
4 2384 4,134.82 138.28 4,290.41 1,906.41 1,906.41 4,020,956.66 1,624.83 79.97 40.46 (0.24)
5 3654 4,134.34 124.40 4,273.10 619.10 619.10 3,293,422.93 1,423.68 16.94 35.76 0.16
6 8680 4,138.89 112.42 4,258.75 (4,421.25) 4,421.25 6,002,434.07 1,923.28 50.94 38.29 (2.18)
7 5695 4,140.44 101.33 4,251.31 (1,443.69) 1,443.69 5,442,694.03 1,854.77 25.35 36.44 (3.04)
8 1953 4,138.26 90.98 4,241.78 2,288.78 2,288.78 5,417,168.90 1,909.02 117.19 46.53 (1.76)
9 4742 4,138.86 81.94 4,229.24 (512.76) 512.76 4,844,475.34 1,753.88 10.81 42.56 (2.21)
10 13673 4,148.39 74.70 4,220.80 (9,452.20) 9,452.20 13,294,432.14 2,523.71 69.13 45.22 (5.28)
11 6640 4,150.89 67.48 4,223.10 (2,416.90) 2,416.90 12,616,886.24 2,514.00 36.40 44.42 (6.26)
12 2737 4,149.47 60.59 4,218.37 1,481.37 1,481.37 11,748,349.52 2,427.95 54.12 45.23 (5.87)
13 3486 4,148.81 54.47 4,210.06 724.06 724.06 10,884,958.56 2,296.88 20.77 43.35 (5.89)
14 13186 4,157.85 49.92 4,203.27 (8,982.73) 8,982.73 15,870,987.82 2,774.44 68.12 45.12 (8.11)
15 5448 4,159.14 45.06 4,207.77 (1,240.23) 1,240.23 14,915,466.95 2,672.16 22.76 43.63 (8.89)16 3485 4,158.46 40.49 4,204.20 719.20 719.20 14,015,577.87 2,550.10 20.64 42.19 (9.03)
17 7728 4,162.03 36.79 4,198.95 (3,529.05) 3,529.05 13,923,732.73 2,607.68 45.67 42.39 (10.19)
18 16591 4,174.46 34.36 4,198.83 (12,392.17) 12,392.17 21,681,635.82 3,151.27 74.69 44.19 (12.36)
19 8236 4,178.52 31.33 4,208.82 (4,027.18) 4,027.18 21,394,086.32 3,197.37 48.90 44.44 (13.44)
20 3316 4,177.66 28.11 4,209.85 893.85 893.85 20,364,330.38 3,082.19 26.96 43.56 (13.66)
-
8/12/2019 Speciality Packaging Case study
17/20
-
8/12/2019 Speciality Packaging Case study
18/20
Method MSE MAD MAPE
Min Max
Static Regression Method 346,929.90 446.14 9.73 (3.51) 4.52
Simple Exponential Smoothing 9,388,485.80 2,346.90 58.00 (0.08) 7.22
Trend Corrected Exponential Smoothing 17,757,754.39 2,935.25 45.13 (19.51) 2.00
Seanson and Trend Correct Exponential Smoothing 440,652.75 504.45 10.74 (3.67) 4.77
TS Range
Summary of Errors(Clear Plastic)
Method MSE MAD MAPE
Min Max
Static Regression Method 792,726.56 656.35 12.13 (3.90) 3.50
Simple Exponential Smoothing 15,835,322.56 3,162.49 65.54 (1.00) 6.00
Trend Corrected Exponential Smoothing 20,364,330.38 3,082.19 43.56 (13.66) 1.00
Seanson and Trend Correct Exponential Smoothing 994,545.40 719.72 13.20 (3.63) 4.04
TS Range
-
8/12/2019 Speciality Packaging Case study
19/20
-
8/12/2019 Speciality Packaging Case study
20/20