resilient futures: operationalising resilience for uk infrastructure and its stakeholders
DESCRIPTION
Prof Seth Bullock is a leading UK complexity science researcher at the University of Southampton. The Resilient Futures project aims to build a prototype interactive demonstrator simulation that operationalises the otherwise nebulous concept of resilience for a wide range of decision makers and stakeholders.TRANSCRIPT
Resilient Futures
Seth Bullock, Andy Dainty, Rich Dawson, Pete Fussey, Jonathan Rigg, Brooke Rogers,Beverly Searle, Jon Timmis
Operationalizing Resilience for UK Infrastructure and its Stakeholders
Institute for ComplexSystems Simulation
Origins
An EPSRC “Sandpit”: Next-Generation Resilience.Aim: generate adventurous, interdisciplinary research projects targeting infrastructure resilience.• 20+ academics from a range of disciplines• + “mentors”, “facilitators”, guest
speakers…• …and a BBC Radio 4 documentary team…• One week of presentations and
brainstormingCollaborative proposals developed and pitchedR-Futures project green lit
Future Resilience
What will our critical national infrastructure look like in 2030? In 2050? Beyond?
How resilient will it be?
Today’s decision makers will partly determine the answers.
R-Futures aim: to enable resilience considerations to inform current decision making.
What do we Mean by Resilience?
• the ability to cope with shock or stress• “bounce-back-ability”
Iain Dowie: Football manager,
rocket scientist
Adapt
Recover
Resist
Resilience of What to What?
For every sector of our national infrastructure...• transportation, ICT, energy, water, waste• health, government, emergency services
...resilience is seen as increasingly important.
This is particularly significant in the context of:• sustainability• climate change• terrorism
White-Out
Wash-Out
Knock-Out
The R-Futures Team
An interdisciplinary collaboration:- Complex Systems Modellers: Southampton, York
- Civil Engineers: Loughborough, Newcastle- Social Scientists: Durham, Essex, Kings, St Andrews
Key Challenges
• Capture the inter-dependencies between sectors
Interdependent Futures...
Attack
Every node needs at least one same type neighbour.
A complex cascade of failures...
Interdependent Networks
Green edges indicate additional inter-network mutual inter-dependencies
Coupling redundancy (K) increases resilience.
2
4
32
Network A
% Attacked0% 100%
N
0
K
Interdependent Resilience
Siz
e o
f L
arg
est
R
em
ain
ing
Con
nect
ed
C
om
pon
en
t
But network B fails less gracefullyeven with high K.
2
4
32
Network B
% Network A Attacked0% 100%
N
0
K
Interdependent Resilience
Siz
e o
f L
arg
est
R
em
ain
ing
Con
nect
ed
C
om
pon
en
t
Measuring Robustness
How should network A and B be connected and coupled in order to maximise robustness to attack?• If “robustness of Network B” = “size of the
largest post-attack connected component of B”Optimal between-network coupling = zeroOptimal within-network connectivity = maximal
• But real-world networks are coupled together because they need to be.
• What if a viable B node were one in a B fragment that remains: large enough + coupled to A enough.
Init
ial
Cou
pli
ng
Initial Connectivity
Su
rviv
ing
BS
urv
ivin
g A
Attack Size0
1
Rob
ust
ness
2440
1
0 1
Unconstrained Viability (Γ=0.0)
0
1
Init
ial
Cou
pli
ng
Initial Connectivity
Su
rviv
ing
BS
urv
ivin
g A
Attack Size0
1
Rob
ust
ness
2440
1
0 1
Constraining Coupling (Γ=0.1)
0
1
Constraining Coupling
Network B
Initial Coupling Between Network A and B
0% 100%
1
0
Rob
ust
ness
Network A
1
0100%
0%
Switching from Erdos-Reyni graphs to regular lattices radically changes the influence of coupling.
Influence of Topology
Network B
Initial Coupling Between Network A and B
0% 100%
1
0
Rob
ust
ness
Network A
1
0100%
0%
Open Questions
• Spatial embedding
• Correlated/structured interdependencies
• More than two coupled networks
• Hierarchical multi-network structures
• Dynamic processes on networks: e.g., flows
• Repair and recovery dynamics
• What do post-attack networks look like?
• How functional are they?
Key Challenges
• Capture the inter-dependencies between sectors
• Engage with the right stakeholders
Stakeholders
• Halcrow
• Costain
• Arup
• RUSI
• DfT
• BT
• Cabinet Office – Civil Contingencies Secretariat
• Fire & Rescue Service
• Institute of Civil Engineers
• Local Authorities
• National Youth Agency
• Health Protection Agency
• Community Organisations
• TFL
• CPNI
• NaCTSO
• Red Cross
Key Challenges
• Capture the inter-dependencies between sectors
• Engage with the right stakeholders
• Address the right future scenarios and hazards
R-Futures Scenarios
R-Futures Scenarios
Decentralised Centralised
New Tech
Trad Tech
High-Tech Hamlets
i-World
Local Power for Local People The Global
Village
Key Challenges
• Capture the inter-dependencies between sectors
• Engage with the right stakeholders
• Address the right future scenarios and risks
• Effectively integrate social science and modelling
Scenarios
Models
Stakeholders
Insight
Key Challenges
• Capture the inter-dependencies between sectors
• Engage with the right stakeholders
• Address the right future scenarios and risks
• Effectively integrate social science and modelling
• Make a critical impact on the key stakeholders
Beyond “one number”
• New understanding of interdependencies A demonstrator system that foregrounds resilience Transformative learning in key stakeholders
Evacuation point
Built up areas
Congestion
Flooded area
Trapped agents
What is the best new conduit for insight?
“Serious Games”
There is increasing interest and investment in interactive models for informing policy/strategy.Some key issues revolve around the question of scale:•Spatial: Regional? National? Continental? Global?•Temporal: Acute phase? Recovery? Adaptation?•Governance: Local agencies? National? Community?
Where should the boundaries be drawn for serious games? What needs to be in and what can be left out?
Key Questions for Me
• How can academic research projects align with private sector and policy making imperatives?– “Infrastructure” is an increasingly
crowded area– But academic and non-academic interests
are divergent.– Will we make a difference here and now,
or ever?• What do we want from models?
– Realistic, Accurate, Predictive– “Computational Thought Experiments”– Serious Games, Decision Theatres?
Gaihua Fu Paul Andrews
Dan SageMehdi Khoury
Duncan MortimerJulia Pearce
Kate CochraneLucy Gregson-
Green
Thank you