relativistic jets: krakow june 26- 30 2006 the interaction of jets with the interstellar medium of...

31
Relativistic Jets: Krakow June 26-30 2006 The Interaction of Jets with the Interstellar Medium of Radio Galaxies Geoff Bicknell, Ralph Sutherland, Vicky Safouris Research School of Astronomy & Astrophysics Australian National University Ravi Subrahmanyan, Lakshmi Saripalli Raman Institute, Bangalore, India

Upload: buck-stephens

Post on 18-Jan-2018

219 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

DESCRIPTION

Relativistic Jets: Krakow June Axisymmetric simulations Bow shock Jet shocks Hot spot Jets constrained to be straight

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Relativistic Jets: Krakow June 26- 30 2006 The Interaction of Jets with the Interstellar Medium of Radio Galaxies Geoff Bicknell, Ralph Sutherland, Vicky

Relativistic Jets: Krakow June 26-30 2006

The Interaction of Jets with the Interstellar

Medium of Radio Galaxies

Geoff Bicknell, Ralph Sutherland, Vicky SafourisResearch School of Astronomy & Astrophysics

Australian National University

Ravi Subrahmanyan, Lakshmi SaripalliRaman Institute, Bangalore, India

Page 2: Relativistic Jets: Krakow June 26- 30 2006 The Interaction of Jets with the Interstellar Medium of Radio Galaxies Geoff Bicknell, Ralph Sutherland, Vicky

2Relativistic Jets: Krakow June 26-30 2006

Outline

Evolution of powerful radio sources from initial stagesEffect of inhomogeneous interstellar medium – three dimensional effectsX-ray emission linking radio and optical structureSupersonic turbulent disks in radio galaxiesRestarting jets in Mpc-scale radio galaxies

Page 3: Relativistic Jets: Krakow June 26- 30 2006 The Interaction of Jets with the Interstellar Medium of Radio Galaxies Geoff Bicknell, Ralph Sutherland, Vicky

3Relativistic Jets: Krakow June 26-30 2006

Axisymmetric simulations

QuickTime™ and aPhoto - JPEG decompressor

are needed to see this picture.

Bow shock

QuickTime™ and aPhoto - JPEG decompressor

are needed to see this picture.

Jet shocks Hot spot

Jets constrained to be straight

Page 4: Relativistic Jets: Krakow June 26- 30 2006 The Interaction of Jets with the Interstellar Medium of Radio Galaxies Geoff Bicknell, Ralph Sutherland, Vicky

4Relativistic Jets: Krakow June 26-30 2006

Slab jets in clumpy medium(Saxton, Sutherland & GB)

QuickTime™ and aAnimation decompressor

are needed to see this picture.

Page 5: Relativistic Jets: Krakow June 26- 30 2006 The Interaction of Jets with the Interstellar Medium of Radio Galaxies Geoff Bicknell, Ralph Sutherland, Vicky

5Relativistic Jets: Krakow June 26-30 2006

Developments and additions

3D (with thermal cooling via MAPPINGS shock and photoionization code)Potential of luminous and dark matterHot isothermal ISM consistent with potentialClumpy ISM described by log-normal + power-law energy spectrumIn some cases the warm ISM is distributed in a turbulent equilibrium disk In other cases an adhoc distribution of warm clumpy matter is used for the initial data

Page 6: Relativistic Jets: Krakow June 26- 30 2006 The Interaction of Jets with the Interstellar Medium of Radio Galaxies Geoff Bicknell, Ralph Sutherland, Vicky

6Relativistic Jets: Krakow June 26-30 2006

Turbulent disk

Density distribution:

Near Keplerian, isothermal disk:Mean temperature Turbulent velocity

dispersion

Page 7: Relativistic Jets: Krakow June 26- 30 2006 The Interaction of Jets with the Interstellar Medium of Radio Galaxies Geoff Bicknell, Ralph Sutherland, Vicky

7Relativistic Jets: Krakow June 26-30 2006

Supersonic turbulent disks

In order to achieve a scale height of order the luminous core radius the turbulent velocity dispersion has to be supersonic.

Page 8: Relativistic Jets: Krakow June 26- 30 2006 The Interaction of Jets with the Interstellar Medium of Radio Galaxies Geoff Bicknell, Ralph Sutherland, Vicky

8Relativistic Jets: Krakow June 26-30 2006

Supersonic turbulent disks in radio galaxies

Disk in M87 (Dopita et al., 1997)

Turbulent velocity ~ 250 km/s

Shock velocity required to reproduce emission line flux = 265 km/s

Page 9: Relativistic Jets: Krakow June 26- 30 2006 The Interaction of Jets with the Interstellar Medium of Radio Galaxies Geoff Bicknell, Ralph Sutherland, Vicky

9Relativistic Jets: Krakow June 26-30 2006

NGC 7052 (van der Marel et al. 98)

B

B-I

I

H-alpha-[NII]

HST images of NGC 7052

Velocity dispersion ~ 70 - 400 km/s

Page 10: Relativistic Jets: Krakow June 26- 30 2006 The Interaction of Jets with the Interstellar Medium of Radio Galaxies Geoff Bicknell, Ralph Sutherland, Vicky

10

Relativistic Jets: Krakow June 26-30 2006

10

10

Van der Marel et al. “true colour” image of NGC 7052

Page 11: Relativistic Jets: Krakow June 26- 30 2006 The Interaction of Jets with the Interstellar Medium of Radio Galaxies Geoff Bicknell, Ralph Sutherland, Vicky

11

Relativistic Jets: Krakow June 26-30 2006

3D simulations

ppmlr - Piecewise Parabolic Method Lagrangian Remap: VH1 + local enhancements for cooling & shock stabilityNon-relativistic parameters (density, Mach no) chosen to correspond with relativistic jet with same energy fluxSynchrotron emissivity

Page 12: Relativistic Jets: Krakow June 26- 30 2006 The Interaction of Jets with the Interstellar Medium of Radio Galaxies Geoff Bicknell, Ralph Sutherland, Vicky

12

Relativistic Jets: Krakow June 26-30 2006

Double isothermal potential

Solve for dark and luminous matter self-consistently using Poisson’s equation

Parameters of distribution:

• Dark and luminous core radii

• Dark and luminous velocity dispersions

Page 13: Relativistic Jets: Krakow June 26- 30 2006 The Interaction of Jets with the Interstellar Medium of Radio Galaxies Geoff Bicknell, Ralph Sutherland, Vicky

13

Relativistic Jets: Krakow June 26-30 2006

Sample dark and luminous matter distribution

Gravitational force

Page 14: Relativistic Jets: Krakow June 26- 30 2006 The Interaction of Jets with the Interstellar Medium of Radio Galaxies Geoff Bicknell, Ralph Sutherland, Vicky

14

Relativistic Jets: Krakow June 26-30 2006

3D jet and disk simulation

QuickTime™ and aGraphics decompressor

are needed to see this picture.

512 cells = 1.024 kpc

512 cells = 1.024 kpc

Jet

Potential10 cells

Hot ISMEquivalent relativistic parameters

Warm disk

Page 15: Relativistic Jets: Krakow June 26- 30 2006 The Interaction of Jets with the Interstellar Medium of Radio Galaxies Geoff Bicknell, Ralph Sutherland, Vicky

15

Relativistic Jets: Krakow June 26-30 2006

Evolutionary phases Disk interaction

phase

Jet-driven bubble; bifurcated jet

Jet breakoutCSS => Classical radio galaxy

End of bubble phase

Page 16: Relativistic Jets: Krakow June 26- 30 2006 The Interaction of Jets with the Interstellar Medium of Radio Galaxies Geoff Bicknell, Ralph Sutherland, Vicky

16

Relativistic Jets: Krakow June 26-30 2006

Log density

z=255

x=5

QuickTime™ and aGraphics decompressor

are needed to see this picture.

QuickTime™ and aGraphics decompressor

are needed to see this picture.

Page 17: Relativistic Jets: Krakow June 26- 30 2006 The Interaction of Jets with the Interstellar Medium of Radio Galaxies Geoff Bicknell, Ralph Sutherland, Vicky

17

Relativistic Jets: Krakow June 26-30 2006

Radio and thermal surface brightness

QuickTime™ and aGraphics decompressor

are needed to see this picture.

QuickTime™ and aGraphics decompressor

are needed to see this picture.

Viewed at 30 degrees to the jet axis

Page 18: Relativistic Jets: Krakow June 26- 30 2006 The Interaction of Jets with the Interstellar Medium of Radio Galaxies Geoff Bicknell, Ralph Sutherland, Vicky

18

Relativistic Jets: Krakow June 26-30 2006

More powerful jet; more holey disk

QuickTime™ and aGraphics decompressor

are needed to see this picture.

Page 19: Relativistic Jets: Krakow June 26- 30 2006 The Interaction of Jets with the Interstellar Medium of Radio Galaxies Geoff Bicknell, Ralph Sutherland, Vicky

19

Relativistic Jets: Krakow June 26-30 2006

Cygnus A Radio - extent 60 kpc

Page 20: Relativistic Jets: Krakow June 26- 30 2006 The Interaction of Jets with the Interstellar Medium of Radio Galaxies Geoff Bicknell, Ralph Sutherland, Vicky

20

Relativistic Jets: Krakow June 26-30 2006

Cygnus A X-ray

Page 21: Relativistic Jets: Krakow June 26- 30 2006 The Interaction of Jets with the Interstellar Medium of Radio Galaxies Geoff Bicknell, Ralph Sutherland, Vicky

21

Relativistic Jets: Krakow June 26-30 2006

Evolutionary sequence

3C48

3C76

3C20 3C98

3C457

3C109Model

Model

Model

Model

YoungObjects

Intermediate Ages

Older Systems

Page 22: Relativistic Jets: Krakow June 26- 30 2006 The Interaction of Jets with the Interstellar Medium of Radio Galaxies Geoff Bicknell, Ralph Sutherland, Vicky

22

Relativistic Jets: Krakow June 26-30 2006

Extended distribution of warm clumpy matter

QuickTime™ and aGraphics decompressor

are needed to see this picture.

256 cells = 25.6 kpc

Log-normal distribution of gas withscale height 2 kpc

Page 23: Relativistic Jets: Krakow June 26- 30 2006 The Interaction of Jets with the Interstellar Medium of Radio Galaxies Geoff Bicknell, Ralph Sutherland, Vicky

23

Relativistic Jets: Krakow June 26-30 2006

Evolution of radio surface brightness

QuickTime™ and aGraphics decompressor

are needed to see this picture.

Page 24: Relativistic Jets: Krakow June 26- 30 2006 The Interaction of Jets with the Interstellar Medium of Radio Galaxies Geoff Bicknell, Ralph Sutherland, Vicky

24

Relativistic Jets: Krakow June 26-30 2006

PKS 1138-262 (De Vries, Van Breugel et al. 2005)

HST continuum

No HST Ly-alpha near AGNBright double knot where jet splitsFaint emission outside radio source

z=2.16

Page 25: Relativistic Jets: Krakow June 26- 30 2006 The Interaction of Jets with the Interstellar Medium of Radio Galaxies Geoff Bicknell, Ralph Sutherland, Vicky

25

Relativistic Jets: Krakow June 26-30 2006

Restarting jets: A different medium

PKS 1545-321

(Safouris, Subrahmanyan, Saripalli, GB, RS)

VLA + ATCA 20 cmVLA 6cm

Page 26: Relativistic Jets: Krakow June 26- 30 2006 The Interaction of Jets with the Interstellar Medium of Radio Galaxies Geoff Bicknell, Ralph Sutherland, Vicky

26

Relativistic Jets: Krakow June 26-30 2006

Previous work and ideas• Clarke & Burns 1991: Simulations of restarting jet show that new jet is overdense

• Low Mach number of the leading bow shock

• Lack of prominent hot spot

Kaiser, Schoenmakers & Rottgering 2000

• Argue for entrainment of material into the existing lobe

• Produces higher Mach number bow-shock

Page 27: Relativistic Jets: Krakow June 26- 30 2006 The Interaction of Jets with the Interstellar Medium of Radio Galaxies Geoff Bicknell, Ralph Sutherland, Vicky

27

Relativistic Jets: Krakow June 26-30 2006

Simulations of restarting jet

QuickTime™ and aGraphics decompressor

are needed to see this picture.

Equivalent rel. jet

Background medium

log(density)

Page 28: Relativistic Jets: Krakow June 26- 30 2006 The Interaction of Jets with the Interstellar Medium of Radio Galaxies Geoff Bicknell, Ralph Sutherland, Vicky

28

Relativistic Jets: Krakow June 26-30 2006

Surface brightness

QuickTime™ and aGraphics decompressor

are needed to see this picture.

Page 29: Relativistic Jets: Krakow June 26- 30 2006 The Interaction of Jets with the Interstellar Medium of Radio Galaxies Geoff Bicknell, Ralph Sutherland, Vicky

29

Relativistic Jets: Krakow June 26-30 2006

Analysis of PKS 1545-321 data

Use arm-length ratio of inner hot spots to estimate hot spot velocity

=> Density of lobe andhot spot Mach number

Page 30: Relativistic Jets: Krakow June 26- 30 2006 The Interaction of Jets with the Interstellar Medium of Radio Galaxies Geoff Bicknell, Ralph Sutherland, Vicky

30

Relativistic Jets: Krakow June 26-30 2006

Jet power Inner hot spots due to jittering jet

– consistent with energy budget of inner lobe

Page 31: Relativistic Jets: Krakow June 26- 30 2006 The Interaction of Jets with the Interstellar Medium of Radio Galaxies Geoff Bicknell, Ralph Sutherland, Vicky

31

Relativistic Jets: Krakow June 26-30 2006

SummaryA clumpy interstellar medium significantly influences the early evolution of radio galaxiesDisk + Jet => 3 phases of evolutionMemory of early phase in late-time structureMore extended clumpy medium => highly disrupted structure typical of high redshift radio galaxyThermal X-ray emission the link between radio and optical structureFeasible that inner doubles in radio galaxies are the result of jet propagation in a polluted cocoon