reclaiming public space: banker's alley

44
Reclaiming Public Space: Banker’s Alley

Upload: nashville-civic-design-center

Post on 01-Apr-2016

222 views

Category:

Documents


1 download

DESCRIPTION

The goal of revitalizing Banker’s Alley is to highlight underutilized urban spaces and routes using interventions that emphasize social interconnectedness, cultural identity, and efficient transportation, while connecting locals and tourists. Bankers Alley is currently an underutilized, widely unknown space in The District. However, it could potentially become a valuable asset in connecting the Core and enhancing commercial and recreational activity.

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Reclaiming Public Space: Banker's Alley

Reclaiming Public Space:

Banker’s Alley

Page 2: Reclaiming Public Space: Banker's Alley

This mission of the Nashville Civic Design Center is to elevate the quality of Nashville’s built environment and to promote public partnership in the creation of a more beautiful and func-tional city for all.

www.civicdesigncenter.org

Reclaiming Public Space:

Banker’s Alley

This book was written and edited by Emily Kleinfelter, Joseph Mayes, Susan Steffenhagen, and Chelsea Velaga. Ron Yearwood and Eric Hoke created additional renderings, and Chelsea Velaga designed the layout.

June 2014

Special thanks to Scott Chambers, Won Choi, Tamara Dickson, and the staff of the Nashville Civic Design Center:

Julia Fry Landstreet, Executive DirectorGary Gaston, Design DirectorRon Yearwood, Assistant Design Director Eric Hoke, Design FellowEmily Kleinfelter, InternJoseph Mayes, InternKion David Sawney, InternSusan Steffenhagen, InternChelsea Velaga, Intern

NASHVILLE CIVIC DESIGN CENTER

Page 3: Reclaiming Public Space: Banker's Alley

Contents

Introduction

Components

Case Studies

Process

Existing Conditions

Recommendations

Toolbox

Successful Alley Examples

Credits

2-3

4-7

8-21

22-23

24-25

26-33

34-37

38-39

40-41

Page 4: Reclaiming Public Space: Banker's Alley

2

Introduction

Mission Statement: The goal of revitalizing Banker’s Alley is to highlight underutilized urban spaces and routes using interventions that emphasize social interconnectedness, cultural identity, and efficient transportation, while connecting locals and tourists.

Methodology: Initially, we directed our focus towards understanding the subtleties of The District and the alleys involved. Historical and cultural contexts of the areas were highlighted for preservation. Residents in the area, as well as developers and investors, spoke to us about how increased utilization and intervention would affect the areas. The commercial and recreational potential for the area, as well as potential for livability of the neighborhoods, was central in the brainstorming stages. Enhancing the connectivity of the areas wouldnot only activate underused alleyways and routes, but also improve the aesthetic value of the spaces.

We prioritized key features for the areas, and wrote detailed case studies on the features implemented in other urban environments. Public art, lighting, sustainability, and pocket parks stood out as feasible enhancements to the areas, and are detailed later in the text.

After developing case studies, we individually sketched plans using key images of the area. After comparing the drawings, a standardized plan was drafted. Afterwards, a diverse group of downtown stakeholders helped select the most feasible and effective plans for the area.

Then, the sketches were used to create digital renderings of the plans, and detailed recommendations for the spaces involved.

Bankers Alley is currently an underutilized, widely unknown space in The District. However, it could potentially become a valuable asset in connecting the Core and enhancing commercial and recreational activity.

The area contained within The District is quickly expanding commercially, as new hotels and apartments, as well as retail stores, are popping up throughout the area. Thus, it was important to research the planned expansion of the area, and

Page 5: Reclaiming Public Space: Banker's Alley

3

Context:

Alley District (1 mile)

Connection to Watefront

Alleys

Banker’s Alley

Pedestrian Crossing

Legend

Bankers Alley is currently an underutilized, widely unknown space in The District. However, it could potentially become a valuable asset in connecting the Core and enhancing commercial and recreational activity.

Page 6: Reclaiming Public Space: Banker's Alley

4

Components

The Arcade is a historic structure located between 4th and 5th Avenues; it features art galleries on the second floor, and various eater-ies and shops on the first floor. Built in 1902, it was modeled after an arcade in Italy; thus, the entrances feature identical Palladian facades.

The busiest times for the restaurants are weekdays during lunch, and the First Saturday Art Crawl. Every first Saturday of the month, new exhibits fill the upstairs galleries, and the restaurants are open late to accommodate the huge crowds. The event attracts tourists and locals alike, and is a great snapshot of local art talent.

Banker’s Alley runs through the core of this once-booming financial center. Historically, Nashville was referred to as the ‘Wall Street of the South’. Banks, insurance, and securities companies, among other financial institutions, defined the city. Thus, located in the heart of Downtown Nashville, Banker’s Alley also inter-sects with Printer’s Alley. While this historical alley is currently underutilized, it exhibits great potential for transformation and revitalization.

Page 7: Reclaiming Public Space: Banker's Alley

5

The District is comprised of lower Broad-way, 2nd Avenue North, and Printer’s Alley. These areas contribute to some of the most vibrant nightlife in Nashville. There are many bars and clubs in this area of downtown; frequently, these bars feature live music, and contribute to Nashville’s ‘Music City’ identity.

Currently, The District is a tourist’s destination, with few locals exploring the space. Connecting the north section of 2nd Avenue and Printers’ Alley to Bankers Alley will guide tourists around The District into Banker’s Alley and The Arcade. This new route in The District provides new destinations for not only tourists, but locals as well.

Page 8: Reclaiming Public Space: Banker's Alley

6

5th Avenue attracts both music and art lovers alike. Also known as the ‘Avenue of the Arts’, 5th Avenue includes many fine art galleries. The Art Crawl, held on the first Saturday of every month, stimulates the area and helps the galleries and retail stores thrive. The streetscape improvements made to 5th Avenue in 2013 created a more attractive destination using artistic lighting and green space. Additionally, new pedestrian friendly sidewalks and crosswalks facilitate safety.

5th Avenue stretches from north of the Bicentennial Mall to south of Lafeyette Street. Our focus, however, remains in the areabetween Union Street and Broadway. Both the-historic and the new venues bring people into the area and connect the old and new attrac-tions of downtown Nashville.

Page 9: Reclaiming Public Space: Banker's Alley

7

Printer’s Alley has a rich history dating back to the early 20th Century. Throughout the early and mid 1900s, Cherry Street (now known as 4th Avenue) became the center of Nashville’s printing and publishing industry. Thirteen publishers and ten printers, as well as the city’s two largest newspapers, were based in and around Printer’s Alley at the turn of the century. While the business offices faced out onto the main streets, the ‘ink-soaked typeset-ters’ and ‘printer’s devils’ took to hanging out in the alley on their breaks. One by one, the printers moved to new locations, leaving only the alley’s name as a relic.

In the 1940s, nightclubs began to open up in the alley. Printer’s Alley soon became the center of the city’s nightlife, and increased traffic to hotels, restaurants, and saloons fronting Men’s Quarter on 4th Avenue. The alley flourished during prohibition because Mayor Hilary Howse protected its ability to illegally sell alcohol.

However, once prohibition was repealed and the sale of alcohol at restaurants was legalized, Printer’s Alley was no longer the only place in town to imbibe. This led to the downfall of Printer’s Alley’s reputation as the hub of Nash-ville’s nightlife. The alley is now home to bars, restaurants, and adult entertainment venues.

Page 10: Reclaiming Public Space: Banker's Alley

8

Case Studies

Public ArtPublic art, along with privately funded art in public places, plays a huge role in enhancing the beauty and livability of urban spaces. Unexpected artistic interventions enhance the vitality of a space, and promote social interac-tion while emphasizing public participation and cultural co-creation.

Types of public art include sculpture, mural painting, and street performance. These art forms engage the public and take aesthetic and social art practices outside of the museum context. Working as a catalyst for enhanced interaction, public art re-conceptualizes a space as singular as an alleyway, or as broad as an entire neighborhood. Additionally, these types of interventions express civic identity and sym-bolism, while articulating site-specific commu-nity participation.

Successful public art highlights the surround-ing area, and does not detract from the utility and recreational value of its environment. The dragon sculpture in Fannie Mae Dees Park, for example, is not only an aesthetically pleas-ing sculptural mosiac, but also a structure that invites children and adults alike to play and congregate.

A subtle yet powerful example of seamless inte-gration into a pre-existing environment is Sol LeWitt’s Lines in Four Directions in Flowers. For this piece, LeWitt enlisted the help of a landscape architect to plant more then 7000 flowers in strategically symmetrical rows in front of the Philadelphia Museum of Art. This piece, although massive in scale, blends into the natural environment, and juxtaposes organic materials with man-made precision and symmetry. The work is framed by the existing architecture of the space, and thus effectively enhances the outdoor space, as opposed to distracting from the main facade of the museum. Similarly, the dragon sculpture in Fannie Mae Dees Park activates the potential energy of the space yet remains integrated in the surrounding playground.

Page 11: Reclaiming Public Space: Banker's Alley

9

Public art is different than other arenas of art because it proposes its own particular model for thinking about the way all art functions—as a dynamic exchange of intervention, production, delivery, reception, and action rather than more formal characteristics. Public art can shape the collective imagination and can provide a sense of the consequences of individual desire and actions within a shared physical and cultural environment.

The dragon sculpture in Fannie Mae Dees park attracts locals and tourists alike (below). Sol Lewitt’s landscape installation infuses geometry into the natural environment (right).

Page 12: Reclaiming Public Space: Banker's Alley

10

Another successful piece, on a much smaller scale, is Nashville’s own Catfish Out of Water series. In 2003, brightly painted individualized catfish sculptures were placed throughout the city, and quickly became an attraction for tourists and locals alike. The playful and imaginative aesthetic of the piece balanced the more serious conceptual reasoning, as the work was designed to highlight environmental issues such as the massive groundwater loss occurring in Nashville and the effects of pollution on the catfish popu-lation and their natural habitat.

Additionally, the city-wide intervention joined communities across town, and promoted exploration of the city.

Similar projects have appeared in cities such as Chicago; The Cow Parade exhibit, seen below,featured colorful cow sculptures placed through-out the city that were eventually auctioned off in order to raise money for various charities.

Page 13: Reclaiming Public Space: Banker's Alley

11

A major component of public art and art in public spaces is often the site-specific nature in which it exists. The meaning and intentionality of a public installation works in dialogue with the physical site for which it was created, or has been installed.

Murals are a common form of public art, and often reflect the culture and spirit of a neigh-borhood or commercial district. Many murals utilize bold colors and strong lettering for vibrancy, such as the typographic murals shown to the right. “I Believe in Nashville” murals, created by local design shop DCXV, have been popping up in neighborhoods around town; subsequently, they have attracted tourists and locals alike, and have provided not only a great backdrop for local designers’ photo shoots, but also a splash of color to the surrounding areas.

Page 14: Reclaiming Public Space: Banker's Alley

12

Environmental Aspects

Many downtown alleys today remain under-utilized and abandoned. Standing, unsanitary water, lack of any form of light, and a lack of greenery contribute to their dismal atmospheres. These short comings can be addressed by transforming everyday alleys into Green Alleys, which incorporate Green Infrastructure (GI) elements such as permeable pavements, biore-tention, and street trees.

Chicago, Illinois has been at the forefront of this Green Alleys initiative. The Chicago Green Alley Program began in 2006, and by 2010, there were over 100 Green Alleys throughout the city. The program’s main goal is to promote more efficient practices in storm water man-agement within public alleys, address drainage issues without incurring additional expensive sewer infrastructure improvements, and introduce light.

Chicago city planners believe that permeable paving, recycled materials, reflective pavements, and energy-efficient lighting reduce the amount of runoff into the storm sewer system by up to 80%. Additionally, these changes reduce local-ized flooding of nearby properties and the urban heat island effect.

In order to achieve these results, city planners have outlined 4 pilot approaches to achieving greener alleys:

The City of Chicago and CDOT have taken additional measures to include the public in these newly established Green Alleys. For easy identification each Green Alley has the same im-age stamped on both ends of the alleyway, and are thus easily identifiable.

Additionally, they have reached out to adjacent landowners and encouraged them to implement practices that would maximize the effectiveness of the neighboring Green Alleys. These recommendations include recycling and composting, as well as planting trees, plants, and/or a rain garden. Alternate practices include barrel/cistern utilization, permeable pavement, green roofs, energy-efficient/dark sky lighting, naturalized detention, and bioswales/vegetated swales.

• Green pavement materials with conventional drainage

• Full alley Infiltration using permeable pavement

• Center alley infiltration using permeable pavement

• Green pavement materials with subsoil filtration system

Page 15: Reclaiming Public Space: Banker's Alley

13

A typical Chicago alley, accompanied by standing water and asphalt. Source: The Chicago Green Alley Handbook

The same alley as pictured above. Now, however, the permeable pavement, among other Green Alley principles, have elimi-nated standing water. Source: The Chicago Green Alley Handbook

Chicago may have one of the most established Green Alleys programs, but other cities are quickly following suit. Los Angeles is currently in the process of bringing their Green Alleys Project to the neglected alleyways of South Los Angeles.

The alleys’ new permeable paving allows rainwater to seep into the ground, preventing the accumulation of unsanitary, undesirable standing water. This same water will irrigate plants along the alleyways, fostering mini parks and mitigating storm water runoff.

However, the alleys will remain underutilized if locals and tourists alike are not encouraged to use them. Therefore, significant increases in crosswalk striping, lighting, and signage will encourage pedestrian use.

Additionally, many native and drought-tolerant plants will be planted where possible. These types of greenery can be low maintenance, and can provide beauty and shade to the alley.

Page 16: Reclaiming Public Space: Banker's Alley

14

The first Detroit Green Alley was finished in 2010. Unsightly concrete was replaced with permeable asphalt and salvaged brick pavers that maintained consistent plant growth and water absorption.

In addition to enhancing the sustainability factors of the alley, officials increased pedes-trian access and safety by erecting bollards on both ends. Low energy lights promoted safety and improved the overall atmosphere.

Aesthetically, the area was greatly improved by implementing organized gardens full of native plant species, in place of the stray weeds popping up through cracks in the asphalt.

Detroit’s first Green Alley after completion. As opposed to the same alley from years before (above), it now encompasses multiple key Green Infrastructure elements.[Source: detroit.curbed.com]

A Detroit alleyway off Second Av-enue. This alley would become the first Green Alley in Detroit.[Source: detroit.curbed.com]

Page 17: Reclaiming Public Space: Banker's Alley

15

Pocket Parks Parks and plazas play a huge role in public spaces, and allow for relaxation, nature walks, community events, and concerts; additionally, “recreation is always an important park value, … the presence of other values makes the landscape and park purposes and uses con-siderably richer.” (Rethinking Urban Parks). Proper park features enhance public participa-tion and leisure in these areas.

A park along Banker’s Alley will support many of the goals in the Nashville Open Space Plan, as well as principles in The Plan of Nashville. Increased plant growth will contribute to the tree canopy addressed in the Open Space Plan, and provide shade and natural value to the space; these changes will also encourage additional interventions in the downtown area.

A park helps “reestablish the streets as the prin-ciple public space of community and connectivity”, one of the Ten Principles in The Plan of Nashville. A park will thrive near retail establishments, and influence more tourists and locals to visit Printers Alley and surrounding attractions. Additionally, park spaces increase opportunities for public art installations, thus supporting another one of the Ten Principles.

A park would aid in connecting Banker’s Alley across 3rd and 4th Avenues. The enhanced connectivity will expose more people to Printer’s Alley and generate more traffic for future and existing retail establishments.

Located in historic downtown Lebanon, Ohio, The Lebanon Citizen National Bank Pocket Park provides a place to sit and relax in a very small area. Thus, a small, underutilized space can be transformed into an attraction for residents and tourists alike.

Page 18: Reclaiming Public Space: Banker's Alley

16

Greenacre Park in New York City, shown below, illustrates how fountains and vertical gardens can be effectively used in compact public spaces. The greenery in this small area allows users to escape the urban landscape and have a quiet lunch in a small trove of natural life. The park also features various types of seating, and can accommodate visitors based on their specific needs.

Small spaces can house elaborate attractions that pull in both tourists and local visitors. The 6th Ave NW pocket parks in Seattle (shown to the right) include interactive elements such as a giant functional chessboard and movable fur-niture. The park features a multi-use stage that draws a variety of different guests for concerts, performances, and presentations.

The park also contains a nature walk and outdoor seating, which creates a serene and peaceful getaway while remaining within the enclosed space of the park.

Page 19: Reclaiming Public Space: Banker's Alley

17

Potentially even more feasible than pocket parks are parklets, which are small urban parks capable of replacing multiple parking spaces with patios, plants, seating, and greenery. In terms of cost, parklets are less expensive to implement than pocket parks. Rather than being financed by local governments, these parklets are typically privately owned and funded public spaces.

The costs often include the design, obtaining a permit, fabrication, and installation of the parklet. Cities can also waive permitting fees, or assist applicants in locating vendors. However, once the parklet is finished, the adjacent owner is often responsible for overseeing maintenance, security, and general upkeep.

Parklets, such as the one to the left, receive revenue for upkeep and other maintenance costs through the vendors that initially established them. In other circumstances, parklet supervisors may utilize various vendors, both permanent and mobile, to generate revenue. For example, the parklet on 5th Avenue and Church Street doubles as seating for customers at Puckett’s, the adjacent restuarant. Patrons of surrounding eateries activate the parklet, while contributing revenue to the surrounding area. Parklets are often located in the public right of way; the revenue generated by food sales can compensate for the removed metered parking.

Page 20: Reclaiming Public Space: Banker's Alley

18

Lighting in Alleys

Ample lighting in alleys is imperative to main-taining safe environments. A well-lit alley discourages crime, increases livability, and encourages artful elements. Improving alley lighting is not only favored by law enforce-ment officials, but also commonly suggested by the general public. When a pedestrian passes by an alley with adequate lighting,

they are far more likely to utilize it.

The alleys shown to the right illustrate the ominous environ-ment created by poor lighting. Dim alleyways deter pedestrian use, and thus many of these alleys become neglected.

Following the direction of Seattle’s Pioneer Square Alleys, transforming Nashville alleys into pedestrian-friendly spaces takes an adapt-able, evolutionary approach to lighting.

Page 21: Reclaiming Public Space: Banker's Alley

19

Trimble Court Alley in Fort Collin, Colorado displays ample lighting within an alley, both with street lamps and Tivoli style string lighting.

The following goals detail the necessary approach:

• Emphasize the assets of an alleyway through a variety of small, low-impact lighting

• strategies that can accentuate architectural elements and highlight the uniqueness of these spaces

• Create a more human-scaled experience for pedestrians, use string lighting to trace a meandering path down the alley, inviting visi-tors to explore down the alley and creating a “ceiling” to the alley space

• Illuminate the entries to buildings• Use the lighting to make the alley feel

welcoming to new visitors

Designed by Dario Cavaliere, these large, glowing arboreal-shaped lights incorporate both artistic and illuminating elements to an alley in Rome.

Page 22: Reclaiming Public Space: Banker's Alley

20

Alleys that are paved and well lit are perceived as neater in appearance and are safer than their untidy counterparts. The expense is bal-anced interest of a city as it expands its security and nighttime appearance. Doing so instills pride in citizens and eliminates the cluttered condition of some alleys.

Lighting at night, however, is not the only important aspect of a well-lit alley. Researchsuggests that exposure to natural light is conducive to productivity, comfort, and overall happiness. Using natural sunlight to illuminate Banker’s Alley would preserve the authenticity of the site, and maintain its cultural value and historical significance.

Nashville’s Printer’s Alley

Natural lighting also brings ambiance to a space, and adding softer lights or playing with lighting temperature can bring new life and at-mosphere to an alley.

In a high-density mixed-use alley such as Banker’s Alley, an addition of lighting makes the deep alley feel brighter and more inviting.

Seattle’s historic Post Alley

Page 23: Reclaiming Public Space: Banker's Alley

21

Proposed Light Installation

The “Harmonic Fugue” tunnel on Hendrix College’s campus in Conway, Arkansas is an interactive sound and light environment designed by Christopher Janney to “make the passageway not just a transition space, but a destination place for creative play at all hours of the day and night.” As visitors wave ther hands, both an LED light and an ever-changing soundscape from the audio speakers are triggered. Also designed into the artwork is a “riddle” created by Janney, adding an additional experience for the returning participant.

Janney built this tunnel with the intention of speaking to the social interaction of public spaces. Taking note from Conway, a light installation would benefit Printer’s Alley, stretching from Commerce Street to Church Street. This provides a promising opportu-nity for private/public collaborations with CMT and the Downtown Partnership to create a more aesthetically pleasing path-way while minimizing interference with loading areas along the alleyway.

The “Harmonic Fugue” tunnel in Conway, Arkansas was designed by artist Christo-pher Janney to make an interactive space for both students of Hendrix College and local residents.

Page 24: Reclaiming Public Space: Banker's Alley

22

Process

Page 25: Reclaiming Public Space: Banker's Alley

23

Page 26: Reclaiming Public Space: Banker's Alley

24

Existing Conditions:Banker’s Alley • Underutilized, despite its proximity to

Printer’s Alley• Visually unappealing, low aesthetic energy• Flanked by unattractive parking garages• Area of high water runoff • No lighting fixtures or signage• Unappealing adjacent alleys• Lack of identity

Page 27: Reclaiming Public Space: Banker's Alley

25

Page 28: Reclaiming Public Space: Banker's Alley

26

moveable park furniture and cafe seating

retail and restaurant spaces

rotating billboard featuring advertisements, public art, and white space for video projections

green wall for irrigation and increased flora

Recommendations Concept AThe underutilized space between 3rd Avenue and Printer’s Alley could potentially house both retail and restaurant establishments capable of draw-ing locals and tourists alike to the area. High-end retailers such as Anthropologie are thriving in Nashville, and could thus draw clientele to the downtown-area. Retail spaces on the first floor of the adjacent garage, along with a rotating bill-board (suited for advertisements and public art) will bring additional revenue to the area.

Sustainability features such as a green wall, irri-gation waterfall, and permeable pavement will maintain an environmentally safe space through Banker’s Alley, as well as add greenery to the downtown area.

Movable furniture and bleachers will encourage park activity and events, while establish the area as a vibrant and bustling plaza.

Page 29: Reclaiming Public Space: Banker's Alley

27

enhancedlighting

permeable grass pavers creating a route through the district

waterfall for irrigation and aesthetic purposes

bleachers for event seating

Page 30: Reclaiming Public Space: Banker's Alley

28

Concept B

The same space between 3rd Avenue and Print-er’s Alley will contain additional housing in the form of micro units. These units provide an affordable way to move into this uniquely urban area. Retail spaces on the bottom floor of the space provide additional opportunities for commercial ventures.

A prominently featured typographic mural will reference Nashville’s letterpress history, and add aesthetic energy to the area. Enhanced lighting will create a safer environment while promoting nightlife. Similarly, new signage establishes the identity of Banker’s Alley while adding artistic elements to the area.

Page 31: Reclaiming Public Space: Banker's Alley

29

typographic mural

revamped signage

ample outdoor seating opportunities

schweiss hydraulic doors for increased visual energy and seating options

corner retail/restaurant space capable of engaging

both sides of the alley

micro units for affordable and convenient housing in

the downtown area

Page 32: Reclaiming Public Space: Banker's Alley

30

Visually striking pavement is crucial for various reasons. Firstly, the presence of a visual marker emphasizes the connectivity of the various streets and alleys. Tourists and others unfamiliar with the area can confidently explore a connected, planned section of downtown using this visual guide. Secondly, this visualization emphasizes the importance of the area as home to hotels, restaurants, and shops.

Concept C

The stretch of Banker’s Alley from 2nd to 4th is currently used almost exclusively for parking. By revamping this path with signage, lighting, and seating, as well as retail establishments, the space becomes a destination. The pathway formed by the lights guides patrons through the route while simultaneously creating a safer environment. Cafes and boutiques on the ground floors of the adjacent buildings will bring in additional activity, as well as revenue. Museum/hotel 21C is cur-rently being developed in the adjacent building, and will add to the rich art atmoshphere in the

The image below provides a view down Banker’s Alley from 3rd Ave. The image above features the area from 4th Ave to Printer’s Alley.

enhanced lighting

signage

outdoor bistro seating

cafe

Page 33: Reclaiming Public Space: Banker's Alley

31

rotating facade for art and advertisements

viewing platform and outdoor event seating

water feature for storm water mitigation

ground floor retailtraffic

bollardsgreen wall

vegetation shade

Banker’s Alley between 3rd Avenue and Print-ers’ Alley, shown to the right, is currently used for nothing more than parking. However, this space is capable of housing both a park and retail space. Elevated seating allows for views of the surrounding area, as well as additional retail or eateries. Furthermore, visitors can view murals displayed on the garage.

Concept D

Page 34: Reclaiming Public Space: Banker's Alley

32

Concept E

Beginning at 1st Avenue, Banker’s Alley can connect the waterfront to The Arcade and the Avenue of the Arts. Creating a wider sidewalk and stores that interact with passerbys activate the area and bring more people into rest of Banker’s Alley. Replacing the current parking lot with a mixed use building would also allow the current Bank Street to feel more like an alley. Using similar lighting as the rest of the alley and making a clear connection from the cobblestones between 1st and 2nd Avenues to Banker’s Alley adjacent to the future 21C will show a clear connection for pedestrians walking to and from the river.

Page 35: Reclaiming Public Space: Banker's Alley

33

consistent and appealing signage Back entrance to 21c

Retail and restaurant to activate the alley

enhanced lighting for safety and aesthetic

purposes

permeable pavement to help with storm water

irrigation

Concept F

The view from 2nd to 3rd Avenues shows string lighting that not only aesthetically improves the area, but also makes it a safer destination. The lights create a path down Banker’s Alley, and illuminate the outdoor seating. The movable fur-niture encourages people to remain in the area for longer, and enjoy the many retail and culinary opportunities nearby.

The 21c museum/hotel will feature an attrac-tive back entrance that will draw visitors into the space.

The added signage in the area will promote Banker’s Alley as a destination, and simultane-ously preserve the history of the area.

Page 36: Reclaiming Public Space: Banker's Alley

34

Toolbox The components involved in a successfully utilized alley are readily available both locally and globally. When implementing these components, preserving the character and nuances of the surrounding area is vital. Used together, these components create an inviting and appealing alley that promotes safety, sustainability, commerce, and creativity.

Consistent Signage

Increased Commercialization

Lighting

Landscaping

Page 37: Reclaiming Public Space: Banker's Alley

35

Public Art

Increased Connectivity Movable

Furniture

Sustainability

Page 38: Reclaiming Public Space: Banker's Alley

36

Features

The map to the right includes components from the toolbox, case studies, and recom-mendations. The aerial view contextualizes the intended changes, and combinesthe different elements of the report.

Arca

Riverfront Park

Proposed Building

Proposed Retail

Proposed Park

Seating for Proposed Projection

Mixed-Use Retail and Residential

Expansion of pedestrian connectivity

Permeable Pavers*

Pedestrian Crossing*

Movable Furniture*

Art Installation*

Art Installation*

Lights*

String Lights*

Banker’s Alley

* - refer to image below

Legend

pedestrian crossing permeable pavers billboard art installation

Page 39: Reclaiming Public Space: Banker's Alley

37

rcade

movable furniture lights string lights art installation

Page 40: Reclaiming Public Space: Banker's Alley

38

Agueda, Portugal

Detriot

Sydney, Australia

Detroit

Denver

Page 41: Reclaiming Public Space: Banker's Alley

39

San Francisco

Philadelphia

Sorrento, Italy

Page 42: Reclaiming Public Space: Banker's Alley

40

Photo Credits

Page Image Source

Cover Banker’s Alley Eric Hoke, NCDC

04 5th Avenue Ron Yearwood Banker’s Alley05 Map of the District www.thedistrictnashville.org

06 5th Ave of the Arts Paramore, www.paramoredigital.com 07 Printer’s Alley Detroit Duchess, www.detroitduchess.com

09 Fannie Mae Dees Park www.activerain.trulia.com Philadelphia Museum of Art www.gardenhistorygirl.blogspot.com

10 Catfish Out of Water www.nashville.about.com, www.ferrebeekeeper.wordpress.com Cows on Parade www.johntunger.com, www.artattackjim.blogspot.com

11 I Believe in Nashville Mural DCXV, www.fashionofanovice.blogspot.com Typographic Mural www.designworklife.com

15 Lebanon Park www.kleinfgers.com

16 Greenacre Park Hiroko Masuike, New York Times

17 6th Ave NW Park (2) GGLO, www.gglo.com

18 Dark Alleys Wattsgm, www.panoramio.com, Dark City Alley, www.galleryhip.com 19 Trimble Court Bradley Smith, www.azurground.com Antler Lights TrendHunter, www.trendhunter.com

20 Post Alley Chuck Pefley, www.almostoneday.blogspot.com. Tiffany M. Roberts, Printer’s Alley www.nashvilledesignhistory.wordpress.com

21 Harmonic Fugue Christopher Janney, www.janneysounds.com

24 Banker’s Alley www.googlemaps.com

25 Banker’s Alley www.googlemaps.com 26 Concept A Eric Hoke, NCDC 27 Concept A Eric Hoke, NCDC

Page 43: Reclaiming Public Space: Banker's Alley

41

Photo Credits

Page Image Source

28 Concept B Emily Kleinfelter

29 Concept B Emily Kleinfelter 30 Concept C Emily Kleinfelter

31 Concept D Ron Yearwood

32 Concept E Joseph Mayes, Emily Kleinfelter

33 Concept F Emily Kleinfelter

34 Toolbox www.flikr.com, www.pedestrianfriendly.wordpress.com, www.zeleno.com, www.eastoneccentric.blogspot.com,

35 Toolbox www.samstradwick.blogspot.com, www.generalpavingstones.com, Emily Kleinfelter, www.visionmasters.com

36 Features Joseph Mayes

37 Features Joseph Mayes

38 Successful Alley Examples www.trekearth.com, www.urbanful.com, www.detroitenv.org, www.alleyofseattle.com39 Successful Alley Examples www.lavitaguila.com, www.iputmylifeonashelf.com, www.fineartamerica.com

Page 44: Reclaiming Public Space: Banker's Alley

42