presentation stopand frisk
TRANSCRIPT
#StopandFrisk
Anna Prohl
The Data • n=5213 tweets • 97.83% in English • Collection Range: 1/14/14 – 2/25/14
Visualiza(on courtesy of www.Cartodb.com
It’s all about New York.
Visualiza
(on courtesy of w
ww.wordle.ne
t
Twitter connects people talking about stop-and-frisk
Visualiza
(on prod
uced
in Gep
hi
9$*$1-$B*DHO(%
MRKQBVLUDFXVD
����:,161HZ<RUN
SHWHUGOHGHUHU
DDOGHIQLFKRODVYFKHQ
ZLOGURVHVWURQJ
$%$HVT
<&&-0LNH+HQVH
1HZV)HHG1HZ<RUN
$%&�1<
&DXVH,P$IULFDQ
-DKB%ULP
7/B�
&HVFD���VROH[��
)HOL[B-XQLRU��
2/$$60
$&/8B1RU&DO
FDWULQDFKDRV
WKH6PLWKLDQGDQDPR
7UR\*HDU\
*ORULD-5RPHUR5.QLJKWBWZLWHPDUWL
EHHEHHWKHFDW
DKHDOWK\GHVLJQ
$&/8B6R&DO
PL$&/8
)UHGGLH)RJJ
$&/81-
QLFNLBNLQVHOO
$QWKRQ\$OIDQR
$&/8RI,/
-RR+\XQB.DQJ$)-%H%ROG
FKDQJHWKHQ\SG
EVWRXGW�
$UFXV/*%7
$)-XVWLFH
-$;QRQSURILWV
VXVDQVWHUQEHUJ
VZPVWQ�
:ULWLQJ%URDGZD\
'DUHQ$)-
5RVHQEHUJ)RXQG 'HVWL*UDFH�'LDQH6QDYHO\
EDUDFNREDPD[�
L5DWKPDQ
$,86$PHGLD
LWVPHQDQLFH
DMDP
1603KLOO\
2II3DJH3URMHFW
WKH�VW6WDUU
MXOLWR��
$-$06WUHDP
5D\QDUG)DX[
0RFKD/LVDFFLQR
HORQMDPHV/-&DUWDJHQD
UHQDLVVDQFHHDVW
�ODOD
MINHHOHU
6ORSVWHU�� 3DWWH&20
&RSZDWFK
EDVHGKDXHUZDV
0XUGHU0DQ&KULV
+DQQDK%3�FU\VWDOED\DUGVDIDQDGLUDK1<&5HWZHHW
9HUD7ULSOHWW3K'
SULQFVV�
IXOOHUBGHUHN
MRQDWKDQD\DOD
VDEDBPERXQG]D
NUVW$FOU
)ORRU&KDUWV
KRQH\ULOOD
ODWLQRMXVWLFH
%0$FKLHYHPHQW
0RUH7KDQ$4XRWDMD]PLQFKDYH]
FDLWOLQUDLQ
$:.:25'UDS
$-6WUHDP
'XVWLQ6ODXJKWHU
$OLFH2OOVWHLQ
FNDUDWQ\WVN\
%HVW2I7KH/HIW
DDURQPLJXHOB
'HHS(FRPHG\3DXO+XINHU
WKKLQW]H
0\VVW\EOXH
NRPEL]
DOOLVRQNLONHQQ\ MDVLULB[
VKRNXIH\HVLE
&KH\B0DUO\BPRP
HUDVPXVOLMQRBFBFBXBSB\
WKURXJKZDOOVQ\
<D\\HVV
NLULNRNLNXFKL
EORJGLYD
NLUDPNHFDXONWKHZDJRQ
*0DODQGUXFFR
MHUHNH\V
6DVV\6WHSK%
NLGFKDUOHV
PGHOJDGRQ\F
UXQWRGD\OLJKW
VDPHHXOODKBGU
DPQHVW\PVWIDD\GLQ
)RNNNVQRR]H
VSHDNDQRWKHUJLU
JRWZRRO
DVDGVKDED]\
FHOHVWHFRO���
$+5�$OO
VGXE��
MRKQSDVNR
MR\OODGLHEQ[6HHPH��6HHPH
\DUVYRQPDUV
NLPPL����Y'RQ4XL[RWH����
.XUW6DODPDQ
KDQGVRQ���
WU\LQJ�JHWLW
DUODQ���
MHGPRUDQ
KLVVHLQQRXUL
BJDEULHOOH
+5'RFXPHQWDWLRQ
0DVLND�
KHDG�XVP\VFUDSER[
GMVSRRN\
VKDIHHJKHDG�QHZV/RRS\BB/RRSVWHU
KDUY\NHNEUDKLPLEQL
DP\FKXD
QXDODFDEUDO
DQGHUVRQDWODUJH
�BSDWWRQ
$QRQ\B0LD
$3
OVDUVRXU
$UDE$PHULFDQ1<
:LGH$VOHHS1LPD
ODZDWPDUJLQV
&$62-,B'(6,*16
11$$&
3URI6WLII
51XQH]/DZUHQFH
5RRVHYHOW$YH&$
DUFEHQGLQJ
-++HUDOG
VVHNDUDQ
DWODQWLF
VFVM
=XVKD(OLQVRQ
DZLQVWRQ
EBKDGG\
$]L
MRVKJUHHQPDQ1DV0RKLW
3DJHRQHVL[W\VL[
P\OHVBQP
'HEEL$OPRQWDVHU
3HWHU+HOW]HO
$&/83$6$
\SSH��
OLIHZLQQLQJ
FKD\HVPDWWKHZ&KHU\O3DKDKDP+DPPHU'DLO\
5R\3DXO5HSRUWV
-DFN\-
/HIW9RLFHV
EFROE\KDPLOWRQ
MGPFOHRGMU
%HQ-HDORXV
&+DUW:LOOLDPV
.DWULQD1DWLRQ
&7SDUHQWVXQLRQ
%/LVW3XQGLW+LER5DQG
8ED7KH'LSORPDW)UDQFR,.8
QDJR\DVKL��
*XQD5RFN<D
'U+DUULV3K'
DUJ����
XQLWHKHUH
)UDQ/XNH���
ZRRGVWRFN���
DQGLHBZDOVK :DOGHQ(
UXWK����KD\PDNHUV
1RUWKTXDKRJ��
3LSVLHHH
5/6RRPGDZULWHU
HOL]DEHWKJHQR-HDQDEHOOD
SHUV�VWHQFH
VWUHHWSLUDF\
$QWRQLRB%DXPDQQQIRUHPDQEU\DQW
0DUYLQ%LQJ
%<3B���
5HY<HDUZRRG+LSKRS7&
3DPVNLG
6SLNH)LVK
&HH/RV6SHDNV
<YHV*HEKDUGW
8)7PLNHBUDELQRZLW]GLD]BVX]DQQH;
5RFN'RF,Q/9
VZDQQHZ
:DU\��
;XOWDU
&RQJUHVV�2EDPD�7HPLD%ULQVRQ/D'LYD/DWLQD0DJ
3DOV-XVWLFH
'&%&RPPV����6(,8
.DUHQ5HJLVEHWK\JRRFK
*UUDF\
5XEDLQ'RUDQF\%$.UHPS
20*0RRN3OHDVH%H\RQFH
%H\RQG%DUV
7$WUDQVLWLRQ
/XY/LWHUDF\7KH*RRG*LUO+HUH
:HE$QW2Q<7
ELEOLRWHTBWUHVV
%H+HDUGB5DGLR
%LOO%UDWWRQ
3ROLFLQJ:DWFK
%LOOGH%ODVLR
&%61HZ<RUN
ZFEV���
1LGD.KDQ1<$)DUUD\
FXQ\GVF
5HEHFFD..DW]
1<&/8
%3(ULF$GDPV
WKH&&5
-XVW$VN'RQQD
0D[6KROO
6DUDB*ODQRZVNL
'DYLG/DQH5LFH
92&$/1HZ<RUN
SKLOOLSPEDLOH\
.HHJDQ1<&
WRQ\NFKRL
$EH)URPDQ
0&-7ZHHWV
9LQFH:DUUHQ
HUEURG
'5($0HU-B'
PD\DKDUULVB
EUHDNWKURXJK
3ROLWLFV1DWLRQ
PVQEF35
SWKQ\
PRUJDQZLQQ
0V%U\Q:
%ON3ROLWLF6SRUW
VH[[\PRPPD��
OXQDWLFLDO
<YHWWH&ODUNH
ULFKDUGMPDULQL
0LFKDHO:1<&
WKHRPDUWLDO
UDPQHHWNV
6PLWKRQ3ROLWLFV
DKXMLH
'1'DLO\3ROLWLFV �SDUDJUDSKV
HOOHQWKHUH
QNR]LNRZVND
7LPRWK\03DWH
GRPLQLTXHBHB$OLFLD5LGHQRXU
WDQXNDORKD%LOO'H%ODVLR
JOHQQ(PDUWLQ
1$$&3B/')
��./5��
IURODG\
QZOF
-)5(-1<&
MSHUH]ODWLQR
/-3*DUFLD
HQOLJKWHQPHQW��MHIIWRQH�
UHDOJMRKQVRQ�
��&OHUJ\&RXQFLO%NO\Q(DJOH
7HQDFLRXVBB
,QODZV2XWODZV%OXH)LHOG+DQG
PD\OHHFKDL
0DM-DFN'RZQLQJ
PLFKDHOGELUFK
LQQHUFLW\SUHVV
%ORRPEHUJ1HZV
VSRNHQFRQVFLRXV
-RH\/RYHV0DU\
%RQJ%ODVW��
1<13B1HZV %R\V&OXE1<
NDWKOHHQKRUDQ
DYLILQN
ENO\QSLWR���
5RE+DOSHULQ
5HJLQDOG7%URZQKRPHPDGHENO\Q
2UJDQLF)DUP*X\&8))+
4XLQODQ7/%UDWWRQ
(P:LOOLDPV&&&8
IHGVHF� %UHDNLQJ1HZV
FDVWDNHQDV
'HFLGH1<&
%ULDQ/HKUHU:1<&0/1<SHWLWHPDRLVWH
EURNHQZLQGRZV
6B6B3\UUKXV
%URQ['HIHQGHUV
NUDR��GHEUDJRRG
0DU\0RULDUW\
%UXMD5HEHO
/RFD9LEHV
OJEWFLYLOULJKWV
%X]])HHG/*%7
%URZQVYLOODLQEYLOOHSDUWQHU
'DZXG:DOLG&$,51DWLRQDO
&$,5B:$
WSZDWHV&DSHKDUW-
FDSLWDOQHZ\RUN
EU\QDSL]]R
&DUH�
PDUJDULWDYLHUD
&DUORV'DQJHU1<&
+HOHQ0DQQ&%&
FEFDVLWKDSSHQV
/LOND$GD
7KRPDV)RUPDQ,,
:LOOLKRFN
0DWW+LJJLQV��
8SGDWHG,QIR�
&&5
PHWWDZRUGOLIH��
&KDQJH
'HVLV5LVLQJ8S
JRQ]DOH]SULV
6$6<287+1<&
5HEHNDK'HOVRO
VOLFNVHDQ
JDS\RXWKPHGLD
WDULTQLVDUDKPHG
SXEOLFBVFLHQFH
DOH[LVJROGVWHLQ
-HVVLH1<&
PDWDQDUREHUWV
SULVRQHUMXVWLFH
FRGHSLQNQ\F
HLQDWBPDQRII
DFWXSQ\
OLDPGQRLW
'DUE\%3332ZHQ5%URDGKXUVW
1$7$6+$1,67$
0]0DULFKDO
6XQLWD3DWHOBFFU
(&KULVWRSKHU=HQ
0XVOLP$GYRFDWHV
6XUYLYDOLVW0LQG
FKDULQJEDOO
+7KXUV&KDUWHUVFKRRO
]DQVDUL�&KULV2ZHQV�8
0HJ:LOOLDPV���
FQQEUN
&R&R6RXWK/$
B6RSKLVWL.DWHGB
&RORU2I&KDQJH
URRWEDQ[
UDVKDGURELQVRQ
&RS:DWFK1<&
&RPPLVV%UDWWRQ
3ULQFHVV'D\WXUD
FRPPRQGUHDPV
ELEDFXV
VRSKLDVJDOD[\
-RQB+D\PDQFRQVSLUDF\
6<33<287+
URZP\ERDW
&DUO1\EHUJ���
DNLURQH
.LOOHUVSLHOHU��
:HE3URVSHFWRU�
=DF%,7:NDWDOLQBSRWD
3HDFHIXO6WV1<&
'DQQ\3DQ]HOOD
5DPL6DIDGL��
%URNHQ'RFFULPFDVW
.B6UHHKDUVKD
FVEKDWQDJDU
EUDLQ\DQGEUDZQ\
FDURODPDVRQE
GDQLHOOHLDW
5+&DSS\
0DUFB1HOO
'HDQ0HPLQJHU
LQYLQFHDEHOOD
GH%ODVLR1<&
-&DUQLJ
1HZVLH5RFFR
NHQHURMU
60*HEUXKRQRUDEOHORUGN
IDEXFDW
/\QGD/RSH]�� ,]]\66:
.HVK5XH 0LFKLJDQERUQ��6LILOOB/')
NGZDOG)RJDUW\-RQHV
&WU+,9/DZ3ROLF\
,YDQ(VSLQR]D(64/$85$67</(=
PHDUOFRODFR
6DOLVEXU\EXLOW
--,QLWLDWLYH
GHPRFUDF\QRZ3UR'HPRNUDWLH
.\OH7D\ORU/XFDV
WKLVLVRXUHDUWK
/LEHUDO1&FDVVLG\BFULVS
:HQRQDK+DXWHU
�PK�UGF�U�SDVVLYHDQHUNLVW
7DPL*ROG'2&6
$%)1<&����
<RVKLR1RPXUD
1-'&��
,QGLDQD7DONV
%/$&.)/$*FKL
GMVDUWLQ
6,5)B6$&+2:6*OREDO-:03*B5DGLR
ORFDOIUHVKLHV
%HWVH\&KDFH
ND]DPDVHPL
-RHODND0D*
%LOO\*RULOOD
WKHPDULQ
JRWWBDUXQ
FJVKHOGRQ
6DQQUL
FDUPHORUXL]
OXF\ZLOOFKDQJH
KLJKTRR
1<SRHW
1RUWK6WDU)XQG
DDURQKP��
6DUDB:LW]HO
36���
IOXJHQQRFN
$QRQ)U���DOO
GUXJIUHH\RXWK;./RQGLNH���
-:D5HHV6
'U&ODUN0�GYDQSRROHQ'HQLVH0B12/$
VDODKXGGLQBNROL
P]BFKLHI
0LODWUXG��
MDPHVOLSK
3DUU\7RGG
FRJQLWLYHVODSWPWZHHW]
KDVVHONX
3LOO&OLQWRQ���
HKBPH\GO
KRWOHDGHQHPD
6WRS93'YLROHQFH
JOHQ\DULLPDJLQHVDLEDED
PXW���
2U%9,286��
0RGXODWH7KLV1DW%DWUDYLOOH
4XDNHU'LDQH
)LQGRDQ
.XKQBH\HVRSHQ,PSHULR&DOLEDQ$36RXO
MRHOQDQGHUVRQ
YDQHVVDVDGVDG
JUDKDPSHGOH\
KRZDUGVTXLUHV
5DFKHO*DUYLQ�
0V3RLQW\
$OL0DULHB��SURLQLFLR$&7B80'
%DOWR6SHFWDWRU
2FFXS\1HUGV
&UDLJV'RRUV
HO]KLBIDQ
PLDPLGHFRU
DUFKLWDWD\ORUGLEODVLR
6WHDO7KLV6LQJXO
+HOHQ5RVHQWKDO
PDJJLHSROLWLFR
3ROLWLFV,Q1<&
FHOHVWHPF
+27��
.DPLDQ���
-0LNHBWKHB-RNHU
1<'13ROLWLFV
-XQH0R��
HILW]VPLWK5HEHFFD'/\QFK
)DKLPD��
GRQOHPRQ
-RHO&6DWL
'U6PLWKHUPDQ
+LVSDQLF1HZ<RUN
HOGLDULRQ\
%RR9D\�
0LOHV+\H
5DZNX]��
7RUWXJD6NHSWLF
%ODFNQHVV79
EORRPEHUJVBVRQ7:,%,8
HDW/$8*+UHSHDW
7:L%BIP
9$/,'PDJ
WZLEGDUN7:L%QDWLRQ
7KH7:,%QHW
DP7:,%
DPHULFRQVXPHUHPLOMDQD���
RVKPDHPLO\PEDGJHU
,UHWKVXULRQ(UOLQH3
-XDQ0D%HQLWH]
(VSDLOODW1<
IDL]DBQBDOL
/LJKWIRRW���
IUDFNLQJ
IVPLWK���
JJUHHQZDOG
0LQW3UHVV1HZV
PHOLDQQRVJLOOLDQEGROO
-XVW/HDGHUV86$
-RVHSK&53URJUDP
P\LVKDFKHUU\
JLOEHUWOL]]\
03LOOLVFKHU
PRQHRUDQJHMEHUPDQ�
URELQHMHQNLQV
SLQWVL]H�B�
6KH\OD1<&
-R\)XO6SLULW���
)HDUIXOO\0DGH�
5XWK,OLDQD��
009LYHULWR
*ORULD3D]PLQR
VWURQJPDQ���
QLJKWIHYHU
+HJDUW\.DWLHJUUUOUHYROXWLRQ
*XDUGLDQ86
7LVK-DPHV
,VDLDK/&DUWHU
%.FROLQ
+RW��$P6KRZ
ROGPDQHEUR
5RPHR/ORUHQV���MRVL
+HDU+HB+RW%R\
B8PDLU.KRNKDUKHQQDFB
MBDBMBBB
KHURLQH
PDUHQWHVOXLV3DODQWH/DWLQR
KRPDJH�KXPDQLW\
6RXOHEULW\
'RPLQLFDQ'5HZ
5HDO<20
NRYLH���+RY
6RODQRB/DZ
+XIILQJWRQ3RVW.LWW\2YHUWRQ
5(&85286$
LEUDKLPGRQPH]Q\
*DU\6Q\GHU6KRZ3HSSHU/6Q\GHU
*DH0DU��(UDNLW
,QVLGH&LW\+DOO
NU\VWDOZDOOV��
LVUHYLHZ
LNHY��
XUYDVKLYDLG
$EUDVLYH$V)XFN
-$<<&$0
VLFNMHZTXHHQHVWKHU
NHHSLWULHO
MDQQDEGLDPRQG
WKHQ\ZRUOG
5RVVB�B�
-LPP\%HDU�$-DP����
MREV
8U)DY&KDULW\
MRHOPPDWKLV
XQLTXHORYHVMRHPDFDUH
N\OHXUE
VKHOE\SHDUO*%1<&KDQJH
3$3$'2&/,9(
ZDWFKWKHFRSV
DXGUHORUGH
GUDYD]HG
''6��
��%-B6(,8
7�6$��
$QWKRQ\/H7LJUHMRSUDD
-XPDDQH:LOOLDPV
6TXDUH3HJ'HP
FRROMXVWLFH
NDMRODQQ
VGL[RQ����
MDVRQHPU\VV
5KLDQQRQ.:<
BVLOYHUVPLWK
WXPPOHU��
$OLVRQ+LUVK
VWHIDQJU\
PHODFDOGHURQH
SDWNLHUQDQ
3LSHU
PHOEHOOH���
/&RPPD7KRXJKWV
UYROFKRN
7KH0DG0DQ�����
NDUHQPLOOHU���
ORVDQJHOLHV
FKDPEUG1$'LOXV
NDWKHUJD�
)RUKHF]7
FKHVWHUVRULDEHWKIHUWLJ
&RUOH\7RULDQR
NDWLHSURJUHVV
8GL$&/8
%HOORZ)HOORZ
NHUU\4XDGH
GRFURFNWH[��
6XVWDLQDEO'\ODQ$UURJDQW'HPRQ
%0/HZLV�
<DKZHK��
,P1RW6FRW:DONHU
:KHQ86HH0H6HH8
NHYLQBSRZHOO
&UD]\,GHDOLVW
<RXWK%UHDN287
7KH)LUH1H[7LPH
ODIHPDJUHV
1:DWG
,OOLQRLV/*%75&
/DPEGD/HJDO
8QLRQ)XHU]D/*%7
'DNRWD'
DZPVGUHDPV
$OIUHGD/DQRL[
-D\+DOLP
PDGGHUND
2871%&8QLYHUVDO
0DUWKD3OLPSWRQ
6WHSKDQLHB5DQG
KDQQDKNVODWHU
MIROW]YD�
0LFKDHO%RUFKHUW0UV/DXUD5RVOLQ
%LWDFRUD'6[
3'/DVVLWHU
FRXJPDPD����
-DNH51HOVRQ
7UDQV6RF:UN=DDF
KGDYLP
W\LVSUHWW\UDG
VWRSKDWH����&UHDWHG*D\
IDXVWROR]DGD
HGZDUGFRUUHD
6KDXQ$EUHX
&81<%0,
/RSHUDBHVT
WKHSHUH]QRWHV
/-VSDWULFN
[LFDQD����
(VDB&RORPELDQD
QFDPSRV��
ODWLQRUHEHOV
7RGG/X[H
$TXDULXV*LDQWV�
0U2WKH.LQJ
0UEJX\����
%RGHJD'RY-RQHVHWL
-LOO\-LOO]
:$6+5220678',26
/DYHUQHFR[
WMMRXULDQ
SDXOQRFHUD
/HDYH1R&KLOG%HKLQG
%UDHGHQ-WKH*
3$67$7(1$1
/HQHH7DL
PDVORZVQHHGV
VWUHHWJDQJV
/RV$QJHOHV3ROLFH'HSDUWPHQW
VDPPLHMRH
RVLULV���
'RYLH%ULWWQH\
6XOD\PDQ)
=HNH-RKQVRQ$L
FKULVWRFDUERQH
GRURWK\N��=DSDWLVWD+LMDEL
OVXUHYHLOOH
MORGRHVLWZHOO�
DVVWBSULQF
0DNHWKH5RDG1<JLGHRQROLYHU
1R:DOOV1R&DJHV
SRSGHPRF
FDVDHVSHUDQ]DQM3URJUHVVLYH3RUW
PDUNODELE
KDUULVO\QQ
HUJRGLFDOO\PDU\VKDZRQOLQH
6DQWR7KH:ULWHUPD[LPRVLV
PHWDTXHVW
ZLOOLDPVYHH
'-GD6DYDJH�
0D\RU'HEODVLR
NHLWKOIRUHVW
PHGLD
VDODPDQ���
PHHOHH�%
'LSORPDW(VT
PHHQDMDJ
*UDKDP5HHGHU
0LNH%ORRPEHUJ
0/.
%LJ*DWRU�PRHODQH
EDUEV��
ZROILHPRXVH
0U�WK'LVWULFW
0DOL\NDLV+HDOWK07$
0;*0&RS:DWFK/7LJDQL
0;*01DWLRQDO
1<1-5-%7.6),$&
33$VVHPEOLHV
MXVWMHVHOOH
1$$&3
QHWDBVLJQH
UFDVWOH��
$LVKD*��
'D/HIW+RRN
1LD].DVUDYL
$QLWDB6DUDK
5XWJHUV7$���,PDQL.ULVWLQD
XQLWHGRUJDQL]HG
7(/DZ2IILFH
'HEV:RUOG1<1%&1HZ<RUN
1<&�����
1HZV��%.
SDVVSRUW�KDXWH7
DZROI79
DEURQ[FKLFN1HZV��%;
QHZVRQH
R]R
1HZ<RUN2EVHUYHUFDPSXVBXSKDUVLQ
-��B5��
5HWZLWWHRVV
6(4XHHQV3UHVV4XHHQV7ULE
WXBDEUD]R
/LYLQJ%ODFN/RYH
UDQPDQ��
1<
5RODQG5HSRUWV
URODQGVPDUWLQ1LFNB:%7:
.HRQ:LOOLDPV(1<&%ODFN([SR
:�P�P�0LWFKHOO
1<&
6WRSBDQGB)ULVN
-XOLD6ZHHW7ZHHW
ZLQWHUWKXU)UHH3HOWLHU1RZ
7HQLVKD<HH=<
(PLOLRB9HUGL
UJLQRDNODQG
PON��+LQD6KDPVL
0LFKHOOH)ORUHVB
$NLGR��
-DPLHMKDJHQ
ODZ\HUZULWHUPRP
QRUWKZHVWEURQ[
$&/8$ODEDPD
%URRNH$&/8
$UWB/LYH2Q
'*B&RPSDQ\
RFHDQVKDPDQ
$VN$QJ\
1<$$)
1=)R:/
+XQWHG+RUVH
6HDWWOH3ULYDF\WRYDQJDU�
$&/8
5HDOO\3HWUROLQL
-LP&RUULJDQB0VPLQ[DORW
&UHDVH3DXO
PDQQ\O\RQ
7KH6DP*UDG\
FRSLHVRIFRSLHV
$GDSW7R5HDOLW\
GFKRSSLQ
FDWK\LVJURRY\
$&22/��
NXLQV
RSHQIO\
5D\WHUULOO
=B5LSSHU
0RUHDJD
IUHGGLH]EORJV
7KH$QGUHD*DLO
LQIRUPDWLRQULRW
FPDJLOO
'DYLG)RUEHV
IUHVKVTXHH]HG��
&ROLQ6WDUJHU
�PDUJDULWD
NPRQWHQHJUR
YLYDFLRXVYHUD
SDQW\SRSR
.DWKU\Q+XOLQJ
OVGERPE
7KH-0*��
PDVVSLUDWHV
ROGERW6HDQ&DPRQL
DUNFH\ORQ
&KD]HB*UHJRLUMDPHVYDVLOH
0(B;R3
UREHUHLG
6DUDK&DVVL
GRQWFDUH$QJHO
*DEULHO00RUJDQ5REHUW*DPPRQ
&KULV$OJRR
-RVKB6KHUP\RVWHII
HOGDQJ
VRPDOLURVHN*UDFLH1XQ\DEL]
VQJLQWKHU
BQRYHPEHU�OHYHQ
XVDQ\J
0LGGOH��%ORJ
VRFNROW
NNDSODQ
VWHSKHQ�����BBBNLWW\JOLWWHU
JLDFRPRQ\W
EUHDNHUIDOOHQ
PDJLNRUE
HULFQXOO
GDQUHOO\
6WHIDQV$57
0DULR*LDQFDUOR
1-2ZHQ]XULFKOLYH
OHVPLFNV
$%XWW����
/,9,1*QV
VGHOODGRQQDM��B�
&LDQ2&RQFXEKDLU
PDGILONHQWLVW
EMNHVVEHUVO�
VHHORZU\
$&/8B0'
MDNBGHUDLOHG
GDYLGPLQENO\Q
EODNBDGDP
1RW$IUDLG2I5XLQ
026(&21B<DQ
&HH/2P$;(/B*ULQG7LPH
DORRIOLNHDURERW
JLQVRPQLDF
%HQQQ\Y
'U*RQ]R%RFNUDWK
WDEROVWDG
%<D.���
MXMXH\HEDOO
*XULQJR��
$&/8B25
7KH:HVW,QGLDQ
SRUWDEOHBFKDYH]
OZULHPHQ
GLGJHU\����
0RUDOLW\���
VWULNHLWXS/$/$9$�
2%&ROOHFWLYHB
KHUJXHQW
-RUGDQ%URRNO\Q
/XPLQRXVB$QLPDO
PVXQLHOVHQ
:LOOVWHYHQV��
WKHVWHUHREXV
0LWUD(EDGRODKL
PPGHYDQH\
1XVUDW-DKDQ&NDUUHU��'RQ*DUGHQV
*UDKDPB%UXQHOO
'RQ-XDQ/HRQ
WUXWKJORZ
86&LWL]HQ$SSDUHJ\DWZHHWV
+DVDQ)DULG
ZRULP
DOL]DUG[+RRVLHU-DVRQ
0-6FDUIR
NKHUXD%XVHV$UH%ULGJHV
NDWK\VDPLUD
7UHNNHUB*
JFWRUUHVUDZJD\GLOIV%HVV.RQWRV
*UHHHQJX\���
%ODFN$QG3LQN%RV
OLEHUWDULDQOZ\U
$OLB1DMPL
KLVWRULDQHVV
1<RFFXS\
5HPHPEHUDQGKRSH3DWULFN&7RRPH\
&U\VWDOLQ*RGHVV.QRZ0\5LJKWV
OLEGHPZDVMDLOHG
OLEGHP�
VKDZQFDUULH
-RXUQDOLVP/LE
1<&0D\RUV2IILFH
HLQIDO
1<'DLO\1HZVEKDQQRQPDUWLQ
1HHG�.QRZ7ZHHW
1<'14XHHQV
1<'1FRODQJHOR
1<3'
&ROXPELD6SHF
Q\SG
Q\SRVW
69%KDWLD
Q\WLPHV
5LPDB5HJDV
&/RSH]$%&1HZVPLRQRYD
MXOLHPDVWULQH
JDEEXORXV�
RLOGHIRQ
RND\SOD\HU
$QGHUVRQ3XE&-
1<&%DU/HJLV1<70HWUR
Q\XODZ
2FFXS\'HPRFUDWV
3DXO$ERZG2FFXS\:DOO6W1<&
WDUVKDRUQV
0DUN6FKXPDFNHU2PDU6KDEEL
DND6DVVLQDN
%NO\QLWH*DOOHU\
FODLUHBEDUQHWWH
NHYLQUQV
'DYH.DSV
-0LNH\
.ULVWLIRUFKDQJH
2FFXS\/DV9HJDV
&KDQJH7KUX$UW
SXQNHWWH%UR]ODYB
%HU\O%RPEDRKFWVKLUWV
$YHU\(;3-DVPLQH7DJRUGD(OOHB:LQVWRQ
0RRVHB+DUULV
+DDJHOB%LWHV
2OJDB0B6HJXUD5D7+H5B8Q�4X(
RZVVSDZJ
DQJU\VRFLDOVW
3HRSOHV9RLFHB79
7XOVD3:0
3HWHU0RVNRV
8&&32:(5
SKLOO\ZKDWV3233<1
3KLOO\3ROLFH
QRWKLQJVPRQVWUG(IILQJ0DJSLH
.LPB/RHZHQ
3LWFK%ODN%UDVV
EHELUG
GUWXUQHUOHH
3ROLWLF���
UHJJLHRQHBE
-RQHVGFFDPDF���)R/����
*HRUJH-DPHVF
FDWORYHU����
UVKDED]]
7KH5HY$O
'JDU\��0\EL])ROG7HQ
7LJHUILVWV��
JKHWWRSLFNOHVK\EULGMHVXV
&RQQLH5D]]D
VHQWHQFHEHQGHU
IOX[XV[
7KH:DOO6W%XOOTXHHQVFRXULHU
UDFH
5DFLDO3URILOLQJ
ELJFLW\EDQWHU
UDFLDOSURILOLQJ
5DPDUOH\*UDKDP
,/LQ%DLOH\
KDOH\GUD]5D\6DQFKH]1<&
.D\OD(SVWHLQ
UGHYUR
UHDVRQDEOHVXVSLFLRQ
FKDUOHVPRQDFR-RQDWKDQ5RVHQ%5
'PDUWLQ63/)
MRUBHVF
6'LYHUVLGDGB360
SDVWRUPRQURVH
5HS-HIIULHV
/DZ0')
'HPRFUDWV��
7KH6ZLVV.LP
%URQ[&%�UXEHQGLD]MU
0DNHED8KXUX
5XQQ\PHGH7UXVW
0LVVRXUL*6$QHW
'DUN0DWWHU5DJH
-RH\0RJXO
),(5&(1<&
SROLWLTXHVWLRQV
7UDQV-XVWLFH)3
/DX�WXUWOH
<ZX:RPHQ/HQRUH*RUH
GLVVHQWLQJOHIW)LUH%UHDWKLQJ7*
PRQWVHUUDWOM6FRWW*UHHQILHOG
P\VRQVGDG�VHDQKDQQLW\
VWDQOH\URJRXVNL
UPHQLNRII
:KDW5DG2YHUORUG6KLW
L%ULGJHIRUWK6KLYDQD+DUULUDP
+H\6LVWDK,&8VNZLVKPHHM
&KLHI7DQLFKD6/,.1,.7+(58/(5
KROORZHDUWKVVQRRJOHV����
6SLNH/HH
65/3
VSHFWUHN\H
1XUVH0DUWD$QG\\\\(
.DMKHUR0D\D6FKHQZDU
'LUHFWRU&(/6-5
8-&6H[:RUNHUV0DVV73&
2SLQLRQB7'5
VURVHUH\QHQ
6WDWV$QG7KH&LW\
6WRSDQG)ULVN
VWRSDQGIULVN
FEO�
WKH&6,
8PLFKUDFHODZ
VKRFNWKHPRQNHH
6WRS$QG)ULVN
3;/386+(5����
2)$B-DUU\G
$QGUHX6XWWHUE\
KDQDBHOKDWWDE
&HFLO\$OH[D&DUQLOLXV5
3XEKLVWRULDQ
-HZRQHPHLQ
2PDU%DGGDU
%NO\Q'HIHQGHUV
0LVV7D\$PDUL
PDWWFXUWLVQ\F
IRQJDERR
6WRSDQGIULVN
62&,$/(%21,&6
FRUQHUSURMHFW
/DUD&UR\GRQ
MDLVDOQRRU
1D]ND]��
PHODQLHDWHQGLGRGDOODVUEDLUG
GXPLOHZLV
FXQQLQOHSUHFXQ
PLPLDEXLVQDLQHK
ODVHUODXUHQ
&KLHI(ON
IHPPHBHVTJDEE\VLODQJ
FZKDUORZ
PWQZL]DUG
ZLOOLDPFDQGHU
.LUVWHQLQ07
JZHKGRO\QGXFRUZULWHU
ODULSOH\
GRXBGF&UXWFK�
VDGLDVPXVLQJV
GMMRKQVR
GHHDZQGUXK
ORLVQDP
,W]L1DOODK
$QRQ.RSLPL6WRS$QGIULVN
$QQ1RQP
/LO\%RORXULDQ
E4Q��
SUHUQDSODO
1KRM2SHUWVHU
EL\LDW
TXL[WLF
DNRXODQGD
.ULVK.DVK��
+HUHWLF����
6&23(B/$
HOOHHVW-$17(
OXUNHULDWLSVRV
:ULWHU/DUU\
-XVWLQ3IHIIHUOH
6XSHU%RZO
FKHX\D
VDHVD�
0XQLUDK[0XQ\HFD5RKOLKODKOD
HRQPDVVRF
PRFRVDPRPHQWV
/NRQJ�
PVQ�WU
%OLQNHU0XOOLQJVFRQUD]RQ
IUDQNOXFDQ\F
7DONV2Q/DZ
6RXUFH7DUJHW
WFRW
0LOO&LW\&RPLF$QRQ$QWL3HGR'U6FRWW%RZPDQND]L��
ODFKLUOLQ\FODGXSHU
&%6$QGUHZ
PODXUDKXVV
$&/89DQLWD
MHHQDVKDKHVT
:HVW2I7UDYLVWKHWLQ\UDFFRRQ
VDUDKUNQLJKW
MXVWOHIW'U%HQ]�
NMVXQGHUOLQ
KHDWKHUEHQMDPLQ
QLOOLDVFD
1HQD'DUOLQJ
FNIRWR
UHJJLHVKXIRUG
OLEBHUWDULDQB+DZDLL)2:/
MXPSLQJPHDQ1<+DUP5HGXFWLRQ
ODXUDMUD\PRQG
FRUGHOLHUV
./:VSHDNV6WDF\1&DPPWKHQDURELQVRQ
OLVDZERUGHQ
-HVVLFDB6FKROHV
VXLJHQHULVMHQ
DB5LDV
QHWPLQQRZ
86+510U-RVHSK,Q1<&
GKDUPDULRW
NDOKDQ
GDQLHOOH����
EDUHQWURWK
QLFROHFDWD
JDZQHPDUN PDULVFDOI
&OHDQ+RXVH����WKHFULVLVPDJ
7KH'DLO\6KRZ
WKH*ULR
GD]HGVXQVKLQHWKHQDWLRQ
&56B$OH[DQGHU
7KH8JK
DPEHUJURI
WQODZJLUO%DWPDQ����
GHEVDWQDP
HOBUDWWOHVQDNHDSROORBJROGGHYH
PLVWHUVSHHGHOGHUOHDI
=DTXDQ%H\'HQYHU+DUULQJ
-'3B0$*1802386HUQHVWOHYDQV
MHQQDOHH��7KHVD0HORQD
DUVFKLFDJR
3LU�W
DSKLFNVRQ
6DQJ\H+
7KH*LQGHQEXUJWKH\RXQJLVW
BRQHFKLOOJX\
7HUHQFH���
UDXOGRXJRXMHQQEULVVHWW
HOOHQEUHQQD
4XHHULQJ-HZ
DOLFLDILDVFR
0DOFROP(VVH[%HVSRNH%XWFK
*DWR1HJUR���
EVSFRUOHWRWUXWKRXWVXUILQJ�FKDQJH
HOPH��
%OXH/DWK\UXV��
SKOX
%XGDQG5RDFK6KRZEURZQLQJV����
RULJLQDOEDPE
7KH0HQGLQJ1HZV
2QLRQOL]DUG
7XQH,Q
7:,%QDWLRQ
2]]\)RU0D\RU
1R(DV\3URSV
KHUHDQGQRZ8-&B3523
XQFRQVWLWXWLRQDO
YDOYHJD86$72'$<
'DQB(B0DU[YDSRUWUDLOHU
YHUDLQVWLWXWH
0DQGHODPHQ
$OYDUR$9HUJDUD��SHJ
QDUYLFKDV
0DUWLQ350DUNHWQEKDWLDS$EROLWLRQLVW/&
0DGG\GH/RQH
&RO0RUULV'DYLV
PDOOLNDGXWW,EUDKLP1<&
VXFKDQLFHJLUO
GXQQFODQ
KKDJDUV
1HZ(QJODQGLWH
;KDKLG.KDQ
/DXUHQ*D]]ROD
ZLOOBSRWWHU
:LOOLDP%UDWWRQ
:LOIUH\IUH\
*LUOV/RYH1HUGV:6-ODZEORJ
:6-1<
ZZZLFHJRY
LWV:DQGD
GDQFHV\RLWVGV\
$-3HDFHPDNHU
.ULVWLQD'HVLU
(VWKHU3UH]��
MESKLOLS
]LJJ\PDUOH\
DQGVKHGRQWVWRS
h@p://www.nyc.gov/html/nypd/html/home/home.shtml
The NYPD has published their stop-and-frisk data from 2003-2013 online.
85% of people frisked by the NYPD from 2003 to 2012 were Black or Hispanic.
“I think we disproportionately stop whites too much. And minorities too little.” – Former NYC Mayor Michael Bloomberg, WOR, June 28, 2013.
Where?
Visualizing Race: Brownsville vs. Manha@an
Maps generated using Social Explorer
Percentage of total popula(on that iden(fied as “Black or African American Alone” on the 2010 census.
“It’s not racially driven profiling, it’s crime driven profiling.”- Newark Police Director
Quote: http://www.theatlantic.com/features/archive/2014/03/is-stop-and-frisk-worth-it/358644/
“Stop-and-Frisk gets guns off the streets.” –Former NYC Mayor Michael Bloomberg
Conclusions
1. #Stopandfrisk pertains to NYC. 2. Twitter connects people interested in stop-and-frisk. 3. NYPD-published data contradicts the claims of stop-and-frisk advocates: the data indicates Stop-and-frisk to be driven by racial profiling.
Cita(ons NYPD Stop-‐and-‐Frisk Data h@p://www.nyc.gov/html/nypd/html/analysis_and_planning/stop_ques(on_and_frisk_report.shtml Newspaper Headlines 1. h@p://www.ny(mes.com/2014/01/31/nyregion/de-‐blasio-‐stop-‐and-‐frisk.html?_r=0 2. h@p://www.ny(mes.com/2013/08/13/nyregion/stop-‐and-‐frisk-‐prac(ce-‐violated-‐rights-‐judge-‐rules.html?pagewanted=all Images 1.Bill de Blasioh@p://www.crainsnewyork.com/apps/pbcsi.dll/storyimage/CN/20140224/BLOGS04/140229936/AR/0/Bill-‐de-‐Blasio.jpg?q=100 2.Brownsville Grafic: h@p://citynoise.org/cache/preview/49988.jpg 3. Michael Bloomberg: h@p://graphics8.ny(mes.com/images/2013/08/13/nyregion/subFRISK/subFRISK-‐ar(cleLarge.jpg