preparation of tungsten film and its tribological

8
September 30, 2014 · 84 · 1 Introduction Most sliding counterparts operate inefficiently under bound- ary lubrication condition, because aggressive wear and con- sequent seizure of mating parts would occur in these lubri- cant deficient environments, and contribute to a high friction and wear loss which is undesirable for the lubricant system [1] . The friction and wear behavior under boundary lubrica- tion is mainly determined by the property of the surfaces and the lubricants [2] . Investigation about the tribologi- cal properties and mechanisms of different surfaces and various lubricants has been conducted. They are mainly related with the Fe-based surface and different additives such as ZDDP and MoDTC [3] . However, with the rapid development of vacuum technology, many new surface treatment methods are introduced [4-7] . Coatings such as Al, W, DLC and some alloy films were produced which improved the corrosion resistance and mechanical proper- ties of the materials [8-9] . But the tribological behavior and mechanisms of these films in the boundary lubrication environment were found to be different from that on the Fe-based surfaces. Yang Dehua, et al. have investigated the tribochemical behavior of A1 ion-implanted pure iron material lubricated with ZDDP-containing base oil which Received date: 2014-03-25; Accepted date: 2014-08-05. Corresponding Author: Dr. Li Xingliang, Telephone: +86-10- 68380521; E-mail: [email protected]. China Petroleum Processing and Petrochemical Technology 2014, Vol. 16, No. 3, pp 84-91 Lubrication Research Preparation of Tungsten Film and Its Tribological Properties under Boundary Lubrication Conditions Li Xingliang 1,2 ; Yue Wen 2 ; Wang Song 2,3 ; Li Guolong 1 ; Zhao Shiqian 1 (1. Aviation Key Laboratory of Science and Technology on Precision Manufacturing Technology, Beijing Precision Engineering Institute for Aircraft Industry, Beijing 100076; 2. School of Engineering and Technology, China University of Geosciences (Beijing), Beijing 100083; 3. Xi’an Research Institute of China Coal Technology & Engineering Group Corp., Xi’an 710054) Abstract: Tungsten film (W film) is deposited by using the ion beam assisted deposition (IBAD) on the 316L substrate sur- face in this experiment. The micro structure and nano-hardness of the film are investigated by scanning electron microscopy (SEM) and nano-indentation tester. The tribological behavior of W film under lubrication by oil with ZDDP and MoDTC is evaluated by a SRV test machine. The tribo-film formed on the worn surfaces is investigated by X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) to find out the tribological mechanisms between the W film and the two additional additives. The result shows that the W film lubricated by ZDDP and MoDTC-blended base oil has synergistic effects on the friction reduction property, while the anti-wear property is mainly caused by the hard surface of W film. Key words: IBAD, W film, lubricant additive, tribological properties. showed that the wear resistance of A1 ion-implanted pure iron specimens was lower than that of the un-implanted specimen because the existence of Al element retarded the formation of tribofilm [10] . Anne Neville has made a compari- son of boundary lubrication behavior between steel and Co/Cr/Mo thermal spray coating under lubrication with ZDDP-containing base oil, which have found out that the wear film on the Co/Cr/Mo coating comprised an adherent hydrocarbon layer over a thin base layer of species derived from the additive. It effectively reduced friction at all temperatures and reduced wear at the highest temperature (100 ) [11] . M. I. de Barros’Bouchet has investigated the boundary lubrication mechanisms of carbon coatings in the presence of a lube oil containing MoDTC and ZDDP additives, and it was interesting to notice that tribochemical reactions can occur without the presence of iron catalyst element in the tribo-system [12] . Different films and different additives can give rise to different tribochemical reac- tions, which can result in different tribological behavior. Tungsten has the highest melting point, high strength and

Upload: others

Post on 09-May-2022

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Preparation of Tungsten Film and Its Tribological

September 30, 2014

· 84 ·

1 Introduction

Most sliding counterparts operate inefficiently under bound-ary lubrication condition, because aggressive wear and con-sequent seizure of mating parts would occur in these lubri-cant deficient environments, and contribute to a high friction and wear loss which is undesirable for the lubricant system[1].The friction and wear behavior under boundary lubrica-tion is mainly determined by the property of the surfaces and the lubricants[2]. Investigation about the tribologi-cal properties and mechanisms of different surfaces and various lubricants has been conducted. They are mainly related with the Fe-based surface and different additives such as ZDDP and MoDTC[3]. However, with the rapid development of vacuum technology, many new surface treatment methods are introduced[4-7]. Coatings such as Al, W, DLC and some alloy films were produced which improved the corrosion resistance and mechanical proper-ties of the materials[8-9]. But the tribological behavior and mechanisms of these films in the boundary lubrication environment were found to be different from that on the Fe-based surfaces. Yang Dehua, et al. have investigated the tribochemical behavior of A1 ion-implanted pure iron material lubricated with ZDDP-containing base oil which

Received date: 2014-03-25; Accepted date: 2014-08-05.

Corresponding Author: Dr. Li Xingliang, Telephone: +86-10-

68380521; E-mail: [email protected].

China Petroleum Processing and Petrochemical Technology 2014, Vol. 16, No. 3, pp 84-91Lubrication Research

Preparation of Tungsten Film and Its Tribological Properties under Boundary Lubrication Conditions

Li Xingliang1,2; Yue Wen 2; Wang Song2,3; Li Guolong1; Zhao Shiqian1

(1. Aviation Key Laboratory of Science and Technology on Precision Manufacturing Technology, Beijing Precision Engineering Institute for Aircraft Industry, Beijing 100076; 2. School of Engineering and

Technology, China University of Geosciences (Beijing), Beijing 100083; 3. Xi’an Research Institute of China Coal Technology & Engineering Group Corp., Xi’an 710054)

Abstract: Tungsten film (W film) is deposited by using the ion beam assisted deposition (IBAD) on the 316L substrate sur-face in this experiment. The micro structure and nano-hardness of the film are investigated by scanning electron microscopy (SEM) and nano-indentation tester. The tribological behavior of W film under lubrication by oil with ZDDP and MoDTC is evaluated by a SRV test machine. The tribo-film formed on the worn surfaces is investigated by X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) to find out the tribological mechanisms between the W film and the two additional additives. The result shows that the W film lubricated by ZDDP and MoDTC-blended base oil has synergistic effects on the friction reduction property, while the anti-wear property is mainly caused by the hard surface of W film.Key words: IBAD, W film, lubricant additive, tribological properties.

showed that the wear resistance of A1 ion-implanted pure iron specimens was lower than that of the un-implanted specimen because the existence of Al element retarded the formation of tribofilm[10]. Anne Neville has made a compari-son of boundary lubrication behavior between steel and Co/Cr/Mo thermal spray coating under lubrication with ZDDP-containing base oil, which have found out that the wear film on the Co/Cr/Mo coating comprised an adherent hydrocarbon layer over a thin base layer of species derived from the additive. It effectively reduced friction at all temperatures and reduced wear at the highest temperature (100 ℃)[11]. M. I. de Barros’Bouchet has investigated the boundary lubrication mechanisms of carbon coatings in the presence of a lube oil containing MoDTC and ZDDP additives, and it was interesting to notice that tribochemical reactions can occur without the presence of iron catalyst element in the tribo-system[12]. Different films and different additives can give rise to different tribochemical reac-tions, which can result in different tribological behavior.Tungsten has the highest melting point, high strength and

Page 2: Preparation of Tungsten Film and Its Tribological

· 85 ·

hardness and good chemical stability. It can effectively improve the anti-wear and anti-corrosive properties of the rubbing surfaces. So tungsten and tungsten-base al-loys are widely used in cutting tools, engine components, printing rollers, metal-ceramic materials and resistance heating elements. Meanwhile, ZDDP and MoDTC are two kinds of widely used lubricant additives[13-14]. But in-formation about the boundary lubrication mechanisms of W films in the presence of MoDTC and ZDDP additives is quite scarce in the literature.So, the purpose of this work is to investigate the bound-ary lubrication mechanism of tungsten film prepared via IBAD and lubricated by MoDTC and ZDDP-containing base oil. In this study, the W film was prepared on the surface of 18Cr-12Ni-2.5Mo austenitic (316L) stainless steel. The structure and mechanical behavior of the tung-sten film was studied, and the tribological behavior of the W film under oil lubrication at high temperature (100 ℃) was investigated. The tribological mechanism was ap-proached and discussed through a series of microanalyses. The results are expected to propose a high-temperature lubricant system that combine the W film with traditional lubricant additives.

2 Experimental

2.1 Experimental materials and method of preparation

The substrate material was the 316L stainless steel with a hardness of HV 153 and an elasticity modulus of 200 GPa. The chemical composition and physical property of the 316L stainless steel is shown in Table 1. The speci-mens were 3 mm in thickness and 60 mm×30 mm in dimension. The average surface roughness Ra of each specimen was 4 nm.

Table 1 Chemical composition and physical properties of the 316L stainless steel

Items Data Items DataElementsContent, %

Cr 16.0—18.5

C ≤0.08 Mo 2.0—3.0

Si ≤1.00 Tensile strength, MPa ≥310

Mn ≤2.00 Yield strength, MPa ≥310

P ≤0.035 Elongation,% 30

S ≤0.03 Contractibility rate, % 40 Ni 10.0—14.0 Density, g/cm3 8.03

The tungsten film was deposited by means of an ISB-700 multi-functional ion beam sputtering machine. The W target had a purity of 99.95%, with a dimension of 120 mm×100 mm×7 mm. The 316L stainless steel was placed on the sample holder. The temperature of the sub-strate during the deposition was about 20—85 ℃. The system base pressure prior to deposition was 2×10-4 Pa, with a high-purity Ar gas (99.999%) being used as a sput-tering gas and assisting gas. Two symmetrical sputtering sources corresponding to two symmetrical targets and one assisting source were adopted in the preparation of film deposition. The ion energy and beam current applied to the targets were 2 700 eV and 100 mA, respectively. The total time for each deposition was 3 h. Prior to deposition, a thick Cr interlayer was deposited to enhance the adhesion between the thin tungsten film and the stainless steel substrate.The lubricating oil used was a synthetic base oil—poly-α- olefin (PAO), with a kinematic viscosity of 16.68 mm2/s at 40 ℃ and a VI of 124. And the additives selected were two typical additives (ZDDP and MoDTC). The chemical composition and physical properties of base oil and addi-tives are listed in Table 2.

Table 2 Chemical composition and physical properties of base oil and additives

Substance Index

PAOTransparent liquid with a kinematic viscosity (at 40 ℃) of 16.68 mm2/s, a VI of 124, a flash point of 213 ℃, a pour point of -72 ℃, and an evaporation loss of 11.8%.

ZDDPYellow liquid, with a density of 1.13 g/cm3, a Zn content of 10%, a P content of 8%, and a S content of 16%.

MoDTCGrayish brown liquid, with a density of 1.01 g/cm3, a kinematic viscosity (at 40 ℃) of 700 mm2/s, a Mo content of 10%, and a S content of 11%.

2.2 Friction and wear test

The wear testing equipment is a sliding, reciprocating and vibrating test machine (Optimol SRV, Germany). An ISI52100 steel ball (with a diameter of 10 mm, a Ra of 25 nm and a hardness of 770 HV) was mounted in the clamper and was oscillated against the stationary plate of modified films. The tests were conducted under a load of 20 N, at an oscillating frequency of 10 Hz and an ampli-tude of 1 mm over a period of 30 min. The lambda ratio, known as the ratio of film thickness to the surface rough-

Li Xingliang, et al. Preparation of Tungsten Film and Its Tribological Properties under Boundary Lubrication Conditions

Page 3: Preparation of Tungsten Film and Its Tribological

China Petroleum Processing and Petrochemical Technology

· 86 ·

ness, can be used as a criterion for defining the lubricating condition. For this test the lambda ratio was calculated to be 0.167 and 0.291 for the 316L and W surfaces, respec-tively. Although the lambda ratios of two surfaces were not equal, they were all less than 1. So the lubrication of the two films was in the boundary regime. The lubricat-ing oil was preheated to 100 ℃ and was kept at this fixed temperature in the process of testing. The friction coef-ficients were recorded directly by the SRV tester. By us-ing a profilometer, the cross-sectional area of worn track on the three modified samples was obtained afterwards, which was used to calculate the worn volume. The testing of every sample was repeated three times.

2.3 Film characterization

A JSM-7001F field emission scanning electron micro-scope (FE-SEM) with an energy dispersive spectroscope (EDS) was utilized to observe the surface and cross-sec-tional morphologies of the films. The nano-hardness and elastic modulus were measured by a XP nano-indentation tester equipped with a three-sided pyramid diamond in-denter tip (Berkovich type). The maximum depth at which the indenter tip drove into the sample surface was less than 100 nm. The ESCALAB 250Xi X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) was utilized to identify the chemical state of the compounds formed on the worn surface. The surfaces were coated with a thickness of 5 nm via Ar+ ion sputtering before the data collection in order to reduce the influence of the surface pollutants on the results. And the peaks of C1s occurring at a binding energy of 284.5 eV was considered as the reference for charge correction.

3 Results and Discussion

3.1 Microstructure and hardness

Figure 1 shows the surface and cross-sectional morphol-ogy of the W film. It can be seen from Figure 1(a) that the surface of the W film is quite smooth with an average surface roughness (Ra) of 55 nm. The surface element contents analyzed by EDS are shown in Table 3 which shows that the deposited film has a high purity. Figure 1(b) shows the cross-sectional morphology and the EDS line scans of W film. The bright ribbon stands for the de-

posited film which is about 1.5 μm in thickness[15-16].Figure 2 shows the variation of hardness and elastic modulus with the penetration depth obtained from the nano-indentation tests performed on the W film. The data of hardness and elastic modulus are the average value of three repeated indentation tests. The average hardness and elastic modulus of the W film are equal to 19.0±5.0 GPa and 400±100 GPa, respectively.

Figure 1 SEM images of W film: (a) surface; (b) cross section

Table 3 EDS results on W film

Element Fe C W Mo

Mass fraction, % 0.37 6.42 93.21 —

Figure 2 Average nano-hardness and modulus versus the penetration depth of the W film

2014,16(3):84-91

Page 4: Preparation of Tungsten Film and Its Tribological

· 87 ·

3.2 Tribological behavior

Figure 3 shows the average friction coefficient of two ma-terials under the lubrication of PAO, PAO+1% MoDTC, and PAO+1% ZDDP, respectively. It can be seen from Figure 3 that the average friction coefficients of two ma-terial surfaces are greater than 0.1 under the lubrication of the PAO base oil. With addition of the additives, all the friction coefficients decreased as compared with that lu-bricated by the base oil. Especially under the lubrication of PAO+1% MoDTC, the average friction coefficients of the two surfaces are less than 0.07. Moreover, under the same lubrication condition, the average friction coef-ficient of the W film is smaller than that of the 316L sub-strate surface.

Figure 3 Average friction coefficient of the substrate and W film under different lubrication conditions

Figure 4 shows the worn volume of the surfaces under different lubrication conditions. It can be seen that the worn volume on the 316L surface increases under lubri-cation by PAO+MoDTC in comparison with that under

lubrication by PAO, while the lowest wear is identified under the lubrication by the base oil with ZDDP. The worn volume on the W film surface is smaller than that on the substrate surface under the same lubrication con-dition. However, the worn volumes on the W film sur-face are basically the same under the three lubrication conditions.

3.3 SEM analysis

Figure 5 shows the SEM analyses of the worn surfaces on the 316L stainless steel and W film under the lubrica-tion by base oil with addition of MoDTC and ZDDP. The worn surfaces on the 316L steel have two typical mor-phologies. One is the plastic marks which are caused by plastic deformation, another is the furrows which might be caused by the wear grains. The tungsten worn surfaces just have furrows which are slighter than those on the worn surfaces of 316L steel. These morphologies corre-spond quite well with the wear volumes.

Figure 5 SEM images of the worn surfaces

3.4 XPS analysis

In order to further understand the tribological mecha-Figure 4 Worn volumes of the surfaces under different

lubricant conditions

Li Xingliang, et al. Preparation of Tungsten Film and Its Tribological Properties under Boundary Lubrication Conditions

Page 5: Preparation of Tungsten Film and Its Tribological

China Petroleum Processing and Petrochemical Technology

· 88 ·

nism between the different surfaces under lubrication of MoDTC and ZDDP, the XPS analyses were conducted on the worn surfaces. Figure 6 shows the XPS spectra of elements on the worn 316L substrate and W surfaces under lubrication by PAO+1% MoDTC. It can be seen from Figure 6(a) that the peak of C1s occurring at 284.5 eV is ascribed to adsorptive C, and the peak at a binding en-ergy of 283.7eV is assigned to the carbide. Figure 6(b) shows that the chemical state of Fe in both reaction films is the same, and is mainly associated with Fe (at

706.7 eV), FeO (at 708 eV), Fe2O3 (at 709.8 eV) and FeS (at 711.5 eV)[17]. We can find out from Figure 6(c) that the element Mo on the two worn surfaces has two chemi-cal states. One is MoOx, the other is MoSx. The chemi-cal states of element O on the two worn surfaces shown in Figure 6(d) are also the same. They are MoO3 (at 529.7 eV), Fe2O3 (at 530.1 eV) and oxide (at 531.6 eV), which are in agreement with the chemical state of other elements. As regards the chemical states of element S on the two surfaces, we can see from Figure 6(e) that the

Figure 6 XPS spectra of elements on the worn substrate and W surfaces under lubrication of PAO+1% MoDTC

peaks of S2p occurring at 161.3 eV and 162.4 eV are FeS and MoS2 on the worn 316L substrate surface, while on the worn W surface, there are not only FeS and MoS2 but also WS2 at a binding energy of 163.3 eV. The element W on the worn W surface is also detected in the Figure 6(f), the peaks of W4f occurring at 31.4 eV, 32 eV and 36 eV are identified as W, WS2 and WO3, respectively.Figure 7 shows the XPS spectra of elements on the worn 316L substrate and W surfaces under lubrication of PAO+1% ZDDP. It can be seen from Figure 7(a) that the peaks of Fe2p3/2 occurring at 706.7 eV, 708 eV, 709.8 eV,

711.8 eV, 713.5 eV and 715.5 eV are ascribed to Fe, FeO, Fe2O3, FeOOH, FePO4 and Fe(II)sat, respectively, on the worn 316 L substrate surface, while the binding energies of 706.7 eV, 709.8 eV, 711.8 eV, 713.5 eV and 715.5 eV are ascribed to Fe, Fe2O3, FeOOH, FePO4 and Fe(II)sat, respectively, on the worn W surface. In Figure 7(b), the Ols peak is composed of oxide, BO and NBO. They are the same on the two surfaces analyzed thereby. The P2p peaks in Figure 7(c) are mainly composed of phosphates. It can be seen from Figure 7(d), that WS2 and sulfide are formed on both worn surfaces. The Zn2p peaks in the Fig-

2014,16(3):84-91

Page 6: Preparation of Tungsten Film and Its Tribological

· 89 ·

Figure 7 XPS spectra of elements on the worn substrate and W surfaces under lubrication of PAO+1% ZDDP

ure 7(e) are composed of ZnO, phosphate and ZnS at the binding energies of 1 021.7 eV, 1 022.8 eV and 1 024.7 eV, respectively, while the W4f peaks on the worn W surface in Figure 7(f) indicate to W, WS2 and WO3 with the binding energies of 31.4 eV, 32 eV and 36 eV, respectively[18-21].The element contents on the worn surfaces under lubri-cation by ZDDP and MoDTC added to the base oil are shown in Figure 8. The elements P, S and Zn are the typi-cal ones originated from ZDDP[22] that reflect the degree of ZDDP decomposition, while the elements Mo and S reflect the degree of MoDTC decomposition. It can be seen from Figure 8 that the percentage of Zn+P+S on the

W surface is just the same as those identified on the 316 L surface. While the percentage of Mo+S on the two surfac-es is equal to around 30 %, the total contents of Mo and S do not have much difference. This phenomenon implies the existence of lubricant additives on the W surfaces.

3.5 Discussion

The friction coefficients and worn volumes on W surface are lower than that on the 316L substrate under the same lubrication condition. But the friction coefficients and worn volumes on the W surface do not have significant difference under different lubrication conditions, especially in terms of the worn volumes identified under different lubri-cation conditions, showing that they are basically the same.It is interesting to recognize that hardness is not the only factor that determines the wear resistance. Coating elas-ticity and toughness can also have an important influence on the wear. Plastic deformation (which is mostly deter-mined by material elasticity) leads to large transplant of the materials on the rubbing surfaces and causes serious wear. So there are some merits to use H/E ratio for describ-ing the coating properties without using hardness alone as the only measurement criterion[23]. During this experi-ment, the W film formed via ion beam assisted deposition

Figure 8 Element contents on the worn surfaces■—S; ■—Mo; ■—P; ■—Zn; ■—W; ■—C; ■—O; ■—Fe

Li Xingliang, et al. Preparation of Tungsten Film and Its Tribological Properties under Boundary Lubrication Conditions

Page 7: Preparation of Tungsten Film and Its Tribological

China Petroleum Processing and Petrochemical Technology

· 90 ·

(IBAD) method has the advantage to produce dense struc-tural film thanks to the beam-enhanced migration. And the W film has a harder surface than the untreated surface. In addition, the hardness of W film is 19 GPa and its modu-lus of elasticity is 400 GPa, and the H/E ratio for W film is about 0.047 5. The hardness of the 316L stainless steel is about 153 HV which is converted to be 1.53 GPa and its modulus of elasticity is 200 GPa, with its H/E equat-ing to about 0.007 65, which is much smaller than that of the W film. So the W film has a superior property to resist plastic deformation and wear. And the W film has better tribological behavior than the 316L substrate under the same lubrication condition.When the additives are added to PAO, it could not be denied that there are some benefits for the formation of a sliding layer on the surface. The friction coefficients on the 316L and W surfaces are reduced consequently. But the formed compounds do not have significant effect on the wear behavior for the W film. Since the wear behavior is mainly defined by the surface hardness in this experi-ment, the hard W film has a superior tribological behavior compared to that of 316L surface under the same lubrica-tion condition. However, tungsten has little advantage in promoting the decomposition of the additives. It was reported that W content in the film could lead to the for-mation of a more stable and protective transfer film on the surface[24-27].

4 Conclusions

(1) The tungsten film was successfully prepared on the 316 L stainless steel surface via IBAD with an aver-age hardness of 19.0±5.0 GPa, an elastic modulus of 400±100 GPa, and a film thickness of about 1.5 μm.(2) Upon being lubricated by the base oil (PAO), the W film with a dense and hard surface showed smaller fric-tion coefficient and worn volume as compared with those of the stainless steel substrate.(3) When additives were added to the base oil, more easy-to-slide products were generated on the hard surface, and the friction coefficient on the W film decreased sig-nificantly as compared with the case lubricated by PAO. However, the worn volumes on the W film surface were

basically the same under three lubrication conditions.Acknowledgements: The authors would like to thank the Bei-

jing Natural Science Foundation (3132023), the National Natu-

ral Science Foundation of China (51275494 and 51005218),

the Fundamental Research Funds for the Central Universities

(2652012115 and 2652013081) and the Tribology Science Fund

of State Key Laboratory of Tribology (SKLTKF13B10) for their

financial support to this research.

Reference[1] �Hsu S M, Gates R S. Boundary lubricating films: Forma-

tion and lubrication mechanism[J]. Tribology International,

2005, 38(3): 305-312

[2] �Neville A, Morina A, Haque T, et al. Compatibility between

tribological surfaces and lubricant additives—How fric-

tion and wear reduction can be controlled by surface/lube

synergies[J]. Tribology International, 2007, 40(10/12):

1680-1695

[3] �Onodera T, Morita Y, Suzuki A, et al. A theoretical inves-

tigation on the abrasive wear prevention mechanism of

ZDDP and ZP tribofilms[J]. Applied Surface Science, 2008,

254 (23): 7976-7979

[4] �Donnet C, Erdemir A. Historical developments and new

trends in tribological and solid lubricant coatings[J]. Sur-

face and Coatings Technology, 2004, 180-181: 76-84

[5] �Holmberg K, Mathews A. Coatings tribology: A concept,

critical aspects and future directions[J]. Thin Solid Films,

1994, 253(1/2): 173-178

[6] �Pradip K S. Thermodynamics and tribology in aluminum

extrusion[J]. Wear, 1998, 218(2): 179-190

[7] �Tang J G, Liu D X, Tang C B, et al. Tribology behavior of

double-glow discharge Mo layers on titanium alloy in avia-

tion kerosene environment[J]. Transactions of Nonferrous

Metals Society of China, 2012, 22(8): 1967-1974

[8] �Vanhulsel A, Velasco F, Jacobs R, et al. DLC solid lubricant

coatings on ball bearings for space applications[J]. Tribol-

ogy International, 2007, 40(7): 1186-1194

[9] �Carr G E, Conde R H. Tribology of hard coating alloys

deposited by thermal methods: Applications to industrial

components[J]. Surface and Coatings Technology, 2008,

203(5/7): 685-690

[10] �Yang D H, Zhou J R, Xue Q J. Study of the tribochemical be-

havior of A1 ion-implanted pure iron lubricated with ZDDP[J].

Surface and Coatings Technology, 1998, 102 (3): 223-232

2014,16(3):84-91

Page 8: Preparation of Tungsten Film and Its Tribological

· 91 ·

[11] �Neville A, Kollia-Rafailidi V. A comparison of boundary

wear film formation on steel and a thermal sprayed Co/Cr/

Mo coating under sliding conditions[J]. Wear, 2002, 252

(3): 227-239

[12] �de Barros’Bouchet M I, Martin J M, Le-Mogne T, et al.

Boundary lubrication mechanisms of carbon coatings by

MoDTC and ZDDP additives[J]. Tribology International,

2005, 38(3): 257-264

[13] �Spikes H. The history and mechanisms of ZDDP[J]. Tri-

bology Letters, 2004, 17(3): 469-489

[14] �Yamamoto Y, Gondo S. Friction and wear characteris-

tics of molybdenum dithiocarbamate and molybdenum

dithiophosphate[J]. Tribology Transactions, 1989, 32(2):

251-257

[15] �Li G Y, Xu J H, Zhang L Q, et al. Growth, microstructure,

and microhardness of W/Mo nanostructured multilayers[J].

Journal of Vacuum Science & Technology B: Microelec-

tronics and Nanometer Structures, 2001, 19(1): 94-97

[16] �Li G Y, Han Z H, Tian J W, et al. A study on the interface mi-

crostructure and superhardness effect of W/Mo multilayer[J].

Raremetal Materials and Engineering, 2003, 42(6): 2-5

[17] �Wagner C D, Riggs W M, Davis L E, et al. Handbook of X-

Ray Photoelectron Spectroscopy[M]. Perkin Elmer, 1979

[18] �Martin J M. Antiwear mechanisms of zinc dithiophos-

phate: A chemical hardness approach[J]. Tribology Letters,

1999, 6(1): 1-8

[19] �Willermet P A, Dailey D P, Carter III R O, et al.

Mechanism of formation of antiwear films from zinc

dialkyldithiophosphates[J]. Tribology International, 1995,

28(3): 177-187

[20] �Yue W, Gao X C, Wang C B, et al. Synergistic effects

between plasma-nitrided AISI 52100 steel and zinc dial-

kyldithiophosphate additive under boundary lubrication[J].

Tribology Transactions, 2012, 55 (3): 278-287

[21] �Onodera T, Kuriaki T, Morita Y, et al. Influence of nano-

meter scale film structure of ZDDP tribofilm on Its me-

chanical properties: A computational chemistry study[J].

Applied Surface Science, 2009, 256 (4): 976-979

[22] �Grossiord C, Martin J M, Mogne T L, et al. In situ MoS2

formation and selective transfer from MoDPT films[J]. Sur-

face and Coatings Technology, 1998, 109 (1/3): 352-359

[23] �Leyland A, Matthews A. On the significance of the H/E ratio

in wear control: A nanocomposite coating approach to opti-

mised tribological behaviour[J]. Wear, 2000, 246 (1): 1-11

[24] �Haseeb A S M.A, Albers U, Bade K. Friction and wear

characteristics of electrodeposited nanocrystalline nickel–

tungsten alloy films[J]. Wear, 2008, 264 (1/2): 106-112

[25] �An V, Bozheyev F, Richecoeur F, et al. Synthesis and char-

acterization of nanolamellar tungsten and molybdenum

disulfides[J]. Materials Letters, 2011, 65 (15/16): 2381-2383

[26] �Zhu L N, Wang C B, Wang H D, et al. Microstructure and

tribological properties of WS2/MoS2 multilayer films[J].

Applied Surface Science, 2012, 258 (6): 1944-1948

[27] �Greenwood O D, Moulzolf S C, Blau P J. The influence

of microstructure on tribological properties of WO3 thin

films[J]. Wear, 1999, 232 (1): 84-90

Li Xingliang, et al. Preparation of Tungsten Film and Its Tribological Properties under Boundary Lubrication Conditions

Successful Commissioning of First in China Integrated Coal, Oil and Gas-based Olefins Production Project

After three years of construction all units of the integrated coal, oil and gas resources conversion project at the Yan-chang Jingbian Chemical Park, the investment of which totals 27 billion RMB, have been operating to deliver the on-spec PE and PP products, symbolizing the successful start-up of the first in the world integrated coal, oil and gas conversion project. This project is the energy chemical project, the initial investment scale of which is the largest in the Shaanxi province, and is also the first in the world giant integrated project for manufacture of olefins from coal, oil and gas

resources. The said project mainly includes an 1.8 Mt/a methanol unit, an 1.5 Mt/a unit for catalytic pyrolysis of residue, an 1.2 Mt/a polyolefins unit and other five units, among which the syn-gas compressor train of the 1.8 Mt/a methanol unit is the largest machine in the world. The methanol-to-olefins technique, the heavy oil cata-lytic pyrolysis technology, and the gasification process of water-coal slurry made from multiple feedstocks are all Chinese independent proprietary innovative tech-nologies which have assumed an internationally leading position.