planetary microct instrument for in-situ analysis of rock ... · mineral spatial distribution,...

2
PLANETARY MICROCT INSTRUMENT FOR IN-SITU ANALYSIS OF ROCK CORES. P. Sarrazin 1 , R. Obbard 1 , N. Vo 2 , K. Zacny 3 , P. Ngo 3 , N. Hinman 4 , T. Bristow 5 and D. Blake 5 , 1 SETI Institute, 189 Bernardo Ave, Mountain View CA 94043 [email protected] , 2 Diamond Light Source, Harwell Science and Innovation Campus, Didcot, Oxfordshire OX11 0DE, UK, 3 Honeeybee Robotics, 398 W Washington Blvd., Pasadena, CA 91103, 4 De- partment of Geosciences, University of Montana, Missoula MT 59812, 5 NASA Ames Research Center, MS239-4, Moffett Field CA 94036. Introduction: We present the development of a planetary X-ray computed tomography instrument for in-situ analysis of rock cores. In X-ray Computed Tomography (CT), radio- graphic images of a solid sample are collected through a range of orientations and a 3-dimensional model of its internal structure is computed. X-ray CT allows the non-destructive analysis of internal features that would otherwise only be revealed by physically sectioning the material. MicroCT is a micron-scale variant of CT that combines a microfocus X-ray source (X-ray tube or synchrotron source) with geometric magnification. MicroCT has attracted the interest of geologists as a re- sult of its ability to resolve individual grains or pores in rock samples. MicroCT has been recommended as the 1st technique to be applied to returned Mars sam- ples [1]. Risks of radiolytic damage to putative Martian organics present in the sample are being assessed [2]. We propose the deployment of microCT on the surface of a planet for remote analysis of rock samples. PIXI: We are developing a planetary instrument concept for in-situ microCT analysis for rock cores. PIXI (Planetary In-situ X-ray Imager) is based on a cone-beam geometry and simple architecture shown in Figure 1. X-ray images collected at small angular steps are downlinked for processing and 3D reconstruction. Figure 1: Notional design of the PIXI flight instrument with microfocus 50kV X-ray source, sample rotation stage and X- ray detector (CCD or CMOS with scintillator). PIXI will also provide X-ray fluorescence (XRF) data of the surface of the sample with limited spatial resolution via the the use of collimation. PIXI will enable 3D-reconstructions of rock frag- ments or rock cores, to evaluate grain size distribution, mineral spatial distribution, porosity, fragmentation etc. The study of rock microstructures will elucidate rock formation processes and reveal potential biogenic origins. Proof-of-concept: A breadboard prototype was built by combining a commercial microfocus X-ray tube (60µm spot size), a stepper-motor based sample rotation stage and an X-ray camera based on a APS-C format CMOS sensor with a CsI scintillator. Attenua- tion images were collected at steps of 0.9° over a full revolution (400 angular positions). Image preprocess- ing steps were integrated in the data analysis pipeline: zinger removal, flat-field correction, ring artifact re- moval, and beam hardening correction. A dedicated calibration method was developed to compute instru- ment geometry parameters that couldn’t be practically measured on the breadboard. 3D reconstruction soft- ware was based on a Filtered Back-Projection (FBP) method. Fig. 2 shows a single slice (among about 1000 pro- duced in a single scan) of a 3D reconstruction of an 8 mm dia. Saddleback basalt core compared with equiva- lent data collected with a laboratory instrument (Bruker Skyscan 1173). The breadboard data shows all but the very finest features found in the laboratory instrument data. A similar dataset is shown in Fig. 3 using a sandstone sample, and similar conclusion drawn on the PIXI data quality. The measured resolu- tion of the breadboard data is better than 40μm. This figure is will be improved with future generations in- struments. Figure 2. Equivalent slices of 3D reconstructions of a Sad- dleback basalt core (8mm diam) with PIXI (left) and a labo- ratory microCT Bruker Skyscan 1173 (right). Voxel size 10μm. Black areas: voids, light gray: higher absorption min- erals. 3004.pdf 51st Lunar and Planetary Science Conference (2020)

Upload: others

Post on 26-Aug-2020

1 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: PLANETARY MICROCT INSTRUMENT FOR IN-SITU ANALYSIS OF ROCK ... · mineral spatial distribution, porosity, fragmentation etc. The study of rock microstructures will elucidate rock formation

PLANETARY MICROCT INSTRUMENT FOR IN-SITU ANALYSIS OF ROCK CORES. P. Sarrazin1, R.Obbard1, N. Vo2, K. Zacny3, P. Ngo3, N. Hinman4, T. Bristow5 and D. Blake5, 1SETI Institute, 189 Bernardo Ave,Mountain View CA 94043 [email protected], 2Diamond Light Source, Harwell Science and Innovation Campus,Didcot, Oxfordshire OX11 0DE, UK, 3Honeeybee Robotics, 398 W Washington Blvd., Pasadena, CA 91103, 4De-partment of Geosciences, University of Montana, Missoula MT 59812, 5NASA Ames Research Center, MS239-4,Moffett Field CA 94036.

Introduction: We present the development of aplanetary X-ray computed tomography instrument forin-situ analysis of rock cores.

In X-ray Computed Tomography (CT), radio-graphic images of a solid sample are collected througha range of orientations and a 3-dimensional model ofits internal structure is computed. X-ray CT allows thenon-destructive analysis of internal features that wouldotherwise only be revealed by physically sectioning thematerial. MicroCT is a micron-scale variant of CT thatcombines a microfocus X-ray source (X-ray tube orsynchrotron source) with geometric magnification.MicroCT has attracted the interest of geologists as a re-sult of its ability to resolve individual grains or poresin rock samples. MicroCT has been recommended asthe 1st technique to be applied to returned Mars sam-ples [1]. Risks of radiolytic damage to putative Martianorganics present in the sample are being assessed [2].We propose the deployment of microCT on the surfaceof a planet for remote analysis of rock samples.

PIXI: We are developing a planetary instrumentconcept for in-situ microCT analysis for rock cores.PIXI (Planetary In-situ X-ray Imager) is based on acone-beam geometry and simple architecture shown inFigure 1. X-ray images collected at small angular stepsare downlinked for processing and 3D reconstruction.

Figure 1: Notional design of the PIXI flight instrument with microfocus 50kV X-ray source, sample rotation stage and X-ray detector (CCD or CMOS with scintillator).

PIXI will also provide X-ray fluorescence (XRF)data of the surface of the sample with limited spatialresolution via the the use of collimation.

PIXI will enable 3D-reconstructions of rock frag-ments or rock cores, to evaluate grain size distribution,

mineral spatial distribution, porosity, fragmentationetc. The study of rock microstructures will elucidaterock formation processes and reveal potential biogenicorigins.

Proof-of-concept: A breadboard prototype wasbuilt by combining a commercial microfocus X-raytube (60µm spot size), a stepper-motor based samplerotation stage and an X-ray camera based on a APS-Cformat CMOS sensor with a CsI scintillator. Attenua-tion images were collected at steps of 0.9° over a fullrevolution (400 angular positions). Image preprocess-ing steps were integrated in the data analysis pipeline:zinger removal, flat-field correction, ring artifact re-moval, and beam hardening correction. A dedicatedcalibration method was developed to compute instru-ment geometry parameters that couldn’t be practicallymeasured on the breadboard. 3D reconstruction soft-ware was based on a Filtered Back-Projection (FBP)method.

Fig. 2 shows a single slice (among about 1000 pro-duced in a single scan) of a 3D reconstruction of an 8mm dia. Saddleback basalt core compared with equiva-lent data collected with a laboratory instrument(Bruker Skyscan 1173). The breadboard data showsall but the very finest features found in the laboratoryinstrument data. A similar dataset is shown in Fig. 3using a sandstone sample, and similar conclusiondrawn on the PIXI data quality. The measured resolu-tion of the breadboard data is better than 40μm. Thisfigure is will be improved with future generations in-struments.

Figure 2. Equivalent slices of 3D reconstructions of a Sad-dleback basalt core (8mm diam) with PIXI (left) and a labo-ratory microCT Bruker Skyscan 1173 (right). Voxel size 10μm. Black areas: voids, light gray: higher absorption min-erals.

3004.pdf51st Lunar and Planetary Science Conference (2020)

Page 2: PLANETARY MICROCT INSTRUMENT FOR IN-SITU ANALYSIS OF ROCK ... · mineral spatial distribution, porosity, fragmentation etc. The study of rock microstructures will elucidate rock formation

Figure 3. Equivalent slices of 3D reconstruction of a 8.2 mm dia. sandstone core; left: PIXI data, 35 kV- 7 W, right: Bruker Skyscan data, 100 kV-8 W. Voxel size 10 μm. Darkerspots: voids; white and light gray spots: inclusions.

Application to Astrobiology: PIXI has been usedto collect micro-CT data from hot spring sinter sampleshaving biogenic microstructures. Martian hot springdeposits are prime targets for astrobiological explo-ration because of the likelihood that life on Earth de-veloped in hydrothermal environments, their ease ofdetection from orbit, and their high habitability andpreservation potential [3]. On Earth, hot spring micro-facies display predictable changes in population alongthermal and chemical gradients [4]. Micro-CT imagingwill enable an elucidation of the interrelated microbial,hydrodynamic, and geochemical processes responsiblefor the different microfacies, whether abiotic or bio-genic. An example of hotspring core analysis withPIXI is given in Figure 4. The sample from ExcelsiorGeyser (Yellowstone) shows biofabrics associatedCalothrix-dominated microbial mats. These fossil mi-crobial mats comprised dominantly opal-A that formsreadily on microbial surfaces upon cooling of water inthe hot spring runoff channels. Vertical fenestral fabric,also known as palisade fabric, is divided into sub-cen-timeter units that are separated by laminar sheets alsocomprising opal-A. This microstructure is clearly visi-ble in the microCT data shown here.

Figure 4: PIXI analysis of an Excelsior Geyser hotspring sample; left: photograph of a vertical section; top: render-ing of the PIXI 3D reconstruction; bottom: horizontal slices of the PIXI data show the structures of the opal-A coatings.

Radiographic analysis of cores in their coringtubes: microCT is demanding in terms of downlinkbandwidth, mechanical precision and analysis time.

Simple radiographic images can be very informativeon the internal structure of rock core. To demonstratethis, we used the PIXI breadboard without fine step ro-tations to image the content of titanium tubes repro-ducing the design of the Mars 2020 coring tubes. Ex-ample of such images are provided in Figure 5 for sev-eral type of rock cores, and a steel screw for reference.In all cases, the morphology of the core is clearly visi-ble. The core X-ray absorption properties, dimensionsand fragmentation state could be assessed through suchimages covering the full length of the coring tube, pos-sibly from several orientations.

The substantial X-ray absorption of the titanium al-loy used for Mars-2020 coring tubes is constraining theX-ray source to the highest voltage settings availablewith the PIXI breadboard (50kV) for quality images tobe collected. MicroCT analysis through the coringtube has not been demonstrated but appears feasibleand will be attempted in upcoming studies. The choiceof coring tube materials with lower X-ray absorptionfor future sampling missions would greatly improve in-situ microCT analysis capabilities, and will be the sub-ject of the future investigation.

Figure 5. Attenuation images of a Ti6Al4V tube canister with13 mm cores inserted; from left to right: sandstone, gypsum, calcite in 2 fragments, basalt, ¼” dia. steel screw for refer-ence. X-ray tube setting 50 kV 10 W, 8s integrations.

Further development: One of the technical chal-lenge foreseen toward the development of a flight PIXIis a high voltage X-ray source. While laboratory mi-croCT instruments typically use voltage >80kV, our re-sults with the PIXI breadboard and computer modelingdemonstrate that X-ray tube voltages of 35-50kV al-lows quality data from core cores. We are developingflight capable X-ray tubes for 50kV operation, and weare refining the PIXI concept with improved proto-types.

Acknowledgements: This development is fundedby a NASA SBIR 2018 to eXaminArt, LLC (Los Altos,CA).

References: [1] Kminek, G., et al. (2014) Reportof the workshop for life detection in samples fromMars. Life Sciences in Space Research, 2, 1-5. [2]Welzenbach, L.C., et al (2017), 48th Lunar and Plan-etary Science conference, 20-24, [3] Cady, S.L., Skok,J.R., Gulick, V.G., Berger, J.A. and Hinman, N.W.,(2018) From Habitability to Life on Mars (pp. 179-210), Elsevier, [4] Walter, M.R. and Des Marais, D.J.,(1993) Icarus, 101(1), pp.129-143.

3004.pdf51st Lunar and Planetary Science Conference (2020)