pink floyd's dark side of the moon: tracing alienation through musical unity

30
Emery Coxe Professor Kopper 5/19/2009 COLT 60 S09 "Got to keep the loonies on the path": Alienation through Unity in Pink Floyd's Dark Side of the Moon “B-bmp, b-bmp, b-bmp…” Slowly out of the silence of the first track, “Speak to Me”, rises the illustrious heartbeat that permeates the soundscapes of Pink Floyd’s Dark Side of the Moon, resurfacing surreptitiously and sporadically as the album progresses until its climactic finish, “Eclipse”, where, after the music culminates in both intensity and intent, the listener is left in a soundless vacuum pierced only by the rhythmic cadence of that same heartbeat, fading to oblivion. From a purely symbolic perspective, this beating heart suggests that Dark Side is more than electronic instrumentals, dubbed vocals, and experimental effects – that there is something organic, something vital, something alive about this record. Surely, when one considers the album’s structure – a singular, continuous, fluid concept rather than unrelated and unconnected tracks – Dark Side seems more an entity than a simple construct. And Dark Side’s

Upload: emery-coxe

Post on 10-Apr-2015

1.134 views

Category:

Documents


1 download

DESCRIPTION

This essay delves into Pink Floyd's Dark Side of the Moon, analyzing the band's history and development leading up to DSOTM. Then, the band's uncharacteristically efficient use of the studio is examined with respect to the final cut of DSOTM. The paper concludes with a track-by-track analysis of DSOTM, noting the particular effects/instrumentals on each song and how they augmented Roger Water's treatise on modernity.

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Pink Floyd's Dark Side of the Moon: Tracing Alienation through Musical Unity

Emery CoxeProfessor Kopper5/19/2009COLT 60 S09

"Got to keep the loonies on the path": Alienation through Unity in Pink Floyd's Dark Side of the Moon

“B-bmp, b-bmp, b-bmp…” Slowly out of the silence of the first track, “Speak to

Me”, rises the illustrious heartbeat that permeates the soundscapes of Pink Floyd’s Dark

Side of the Moon, resurfacing surreptitiously and sporadically as the album progresses

until its climactic finish, “Eclipse”, where, after the music culminates in both intensity

and intent, the listener is left in a soundless vacuum pierced only by the rhythmic cadence

of that same heartbeat, fading to oblivion. From a purely symbolic perspective, this

beating heart suggests that Dark Side is more than electronic instrumentals, dubbed

vocals, and experimental effects – that there is something organic, something vital,

something alive about this record. Surely, when one considers the album’s structure – a

singular, continuous, fluid concept rather than unrelated and unconnected tracks – Dark

Side seems more an entity than a simple construct. And Dark Side’s history corroborates

this notion: with “741 weeks on the Billboard Hot 200 chart”, over 34 million album

sales, myriad rankings among the top of Greatest Albums lists, and “8,000 new copies

sold each year…in America alone”, it is readily apparent that Dark Side has rooted itself

in our collective psyche and is relevant and alive even among today’s audience (Bailey,

xiii). What remains unclear, however, is why? Why have 42:59 minutes of progressive

rock captured the reverence and awe of untold millions, inspiring countless musings and

developing a quasi-mythic legacy? Perhaps it owes to the contents of the lyrics –

existential ethics that pertain, in particular, to the concept of alienation in modern society.

Page 2: Pink Floyd's Dark Side of the Moon: Tracing Alienation through Musical Unity

Coxe 2

Perhaps it is the ingenuity of the music. Or perhaps the answer lies elsewhere, unknown

and ineffable. While we may never succeed in answering this fundamental question, it is

still possible to shed some light on the darkness surrounding the album’s success.

Particularly, by analyzing the unity and collaboration of the band members while

recording Dark Side – resulting in one of the most cohesive albums of all time, both

musically and thematically – I posit that Pink Floyd created the ideal canvass to paint

their polemic against alienation in modern society, a concern every bit as applicable to

today’s society as that of 1973.

While the key to understanding Dark Side lies, in part, with the process of its

production, equally important is the development of Pink Floyd as a band leading up to

this musical masterpiece. By 1965, The Pink Floyd Sound – the initial incarnation of the

group, led by Syd Barrett and consisting of all other members less David Gilmour – had

played their first show in England, and by 1967, they were well known among Britain’s

Underground as pioneers of space/psychedelic rock (by now, they had dropped the

‘Sound’ from their title). However, Pink Floyd’s future as a band in 1968 rested

precariously on their ability to replace their visionary, songwriter, and primary source of

“creative input” Syd Barrett, whose mental health had deteriorated – most likely due to a

latent disorder brought out by the pressures of life as a musician and his relentless

consumption of mind-altering substances – so much that it disrupted their live

performances (often in memorable and disturbing ways) (Harris, 44). Enter David

Gilmour – an old acquaintance of the group – who was initially brought in as a second

guitarist to cover for Syd when he was not in sufficient playing condition, and soon

thereafter relieved Syd altogether. But with Syd gone, and without the source of their

Page 3: Pink Floyd's Dark Side of the Moon: Tracing Alienation through Musical Unity

Coxe 3

spacey sound, the outlook for Pink Floyd was bleak, as no other members had

demonstrated any substantial creative ability to produce songs. As their manager Peter

Jenner, who quit once Syd was gone, expressed, “For us, it was ‘What the fuck are we

going to do if Syd’s not there?’” (Harris, 55).

Yet this pessimistic prognosis was flawed: with Barrett out of the picture, the

group, led by Roger Waters, churned out a new CD, A Saucerful of Secrets, that focused

musically on “mastery of atmosphere” rather than melodic pop hooks (Harris, 58). And

while the Barrett-less group’s initial work outputs seemed “a dogged attempt to maintain

the group’s momentum, compromised by…[a] lack of any hard-and-fast ideas”, they

maintained a solid fan base, and due to the musical culture of the period, which hastened

the artistic drive of musicians due to the “sheer velocity of its schedule”, Pink Floyd

released a substantial amount of material between 1968 and 1973 – Ummagumma, Atom

Heart Mother, Meddle, and several film soundtracks (Harris, 60,62). In retrospect, these

works were stepping stones towards Dark Side, as they allowed the Floyd to experiment

with new sounds, to explore new grooves, most of all, to find their creative stride. As

Gilmour stated, “If you take A Saucerful of Secrets, the track ‘Atom Heart Mother’, then

the track ‘Echoes’ – all lead quite logically towards Dark Side of the Moon.” (Harris, 58-

9). And certainly, by 1972 Dark Side was itching to escape the creative confines of the

group member’s minds: “dying of boredom”, having already written “The Violent

Sequence” for the Zabriskie Point and “Mortality Sequence”, early manifestations of “Us

and Them” and “Great Gig in the Sky”, respectively, and having articulated the driving

theme (human empathy) behind Dark Side in ‘Echoes’ – “Strangers passing in the

Page 4: Pink Floyd's Dark Side of the Moon: Tracing Alienation through Musical Unity

Coxe 4

street/By chance two separate glances meet/And I am you and what I see is me” – Pink

Floyd had paved a solid foundation for what was to come (Harris, 72, 78).

All of this came to a head in 1972, when the band booked rehearsal studios during

tour breaks to “add new material to their live repertoire” – material that, when finished,

would comprise Dark Side of the Moon (Harris, 78). From polishing previous songs – for

example, “The Violent Sequence” – to re-writing recent material (“Breathe”) to creating

original compositions, Pink Floyd grooved through the kinks as a collective unit to create

a unique sounding body of music. As Waters expressed, “Making The Dark Side of the

Moon…was a very communal thing… ‘From each according to his ability, to each

according to his need’” (Harris, 79). After a short stint of rehearsal, Floyd hit the road,

touring to promote their album Meddle, and each show featured a performance of

Eclipse, the functioning title of what would become Dark Side. And as Floyd became

more familiar with performing Eclipse, the songs, sounds, and titles continually evolved,

refining what they had previously written and tightening their collective sound. But while

the concepts behind Dark Side had initially been conceived outside of the recording

studio, not until their sessions in Abbey Road, beginning in May 1972, where the band

benefitted from collaboration, concentration, and creativity, did the musical ingenuity

that characterizes the album truly pour forth.

In marked contrast from earlier recording sessions, by the time Pink Floyd entered

the studio to begin recording, “Dark Side of the Moon was a fait accompli...very

structured, together” (Harris, 104). Thus, the band was able to utilize the studio a much

more efficiently than in the past – to enhance and perfect their compositions, rather than

conceive them. Aided by audio engineer Alan Parsons, the group began laying their

Page 5: Pink Floyd's Dark Side of the Moon: Tracing Alienation through Musical Unity

Coxe 5

tracks onto tape, focusing on experimental effects – quadraphonic sound, multitracking,

tape loops, and analogue synthesizers – to polish and refine their songs. The initial take

of each song would generally consist of tracking each musician individually, and

significantly, many of the tracks that found their way onto the record were improvised, at

least in part – in Gilmour’s case, “The guitar solos were all improvised” (Harris, 111).

Similarly, when recording “The Great Gig in the Sky” (then known as “The Mortality

Sequence”), Rick Wright’s (keyboards) take, which he had carefully and painstakingly

pieced together over the course of several hours, was done in one recording, and

considered by band members as “one of the best things Rick ever did” (Harris, 112).

After recording the each track, the group would layer and texturize the piece using

studio effects that complemented the feel of the music and thematic content, creating lush

soundscapes that heightened the album’s atmosphere of alienation. While the studio

effects on Dark Side now seem hackneyed, it must be noted that in 1973, they were

cutting edge, and infused a new and unfamiliar aspect to Dark Side, one that profoundly

influenced the sound, concept, and reception of the piece. For example, the album’s first

musical piece “Breathe” featured double-tracking of Gilmour’s plaintive A-major

plucking and spacey steel slide guitar, with ample electronic effects to “wet” the sound of

each guitar track, creating a glacial soundscape that envelops the listener. Next, one is

catapulted across the globe in “On the Run”, a synthesized rendition of “The Travel

Sequence”, that utilized the Synthi A, an analogue synthesizer (a novel technology) as

well as multitracking of running footsteps, helicopter effects, whispered vocals, and the

sound of a microphone scraping up and down Gilmour’s guitar strings (played

backwards, for added effect). Similar experimentation with effects throughout the album

Page 6: Pink Floyd's Dark Side of the Moon: Tracing Alienation through Musical Unity

Coxe 6

contributed to the “wet” sound of the music – produced by layering electronic effects

over the tracks of each musician – leaving a body of work with a unique, distinct, and

foreign texture (that is, a texture never before experienced by listeners at the time). This

ambient use of sound pervades Dark Side, contributing to the sense of the album as a

collective whole rather than a sum of parts (Pink Floyd – Making). Surrounded by such

an outlandish musical environment, the listener is most susceptible to experiencing in

some way the alienation Water’s laments in his lyrics, for surely, the music violates

standard sounds in such a way that the listener is forced to conform to Dark Side’s

strange conventions.

Though Dark Side had, for the most part, been conceived in full once the effects

had been layered onto the recording, several last minute decisions radically polished the

album’s final cut. The addition of four background female vocalists filled out and

enhanced previously recorded material – “Time”, “Us and Them”, “Brain Damage”, and

“Eclipse” (moreover, their voices were, at times, passed through a Frequency Translator

to mesh with the wet sound of the instruments). Dick Parry provided improvised, soulful,

and breathy saxophone solos on “Us and Them” and “Money”. Clare Torry was brought

in to sing vocals on “The Great Gig in the Sky”; with little instruction from the band (she

had only been told the song was about “death”), Torry used her voice as an instrument,

orgasmically caterwauling an improvisation that, with slight splicing from her few

subsequent takes, was used on the song’s final cut (Blake, 199). And most importantly,

Waters devised a scheme of questions, which were asked to staff and occupants of Abbey

Road, that ultimately engendered thematically relevant blurbs littered throughout the

album, contributing to its mystique and sense of madness. For example, when asked

Page 7: Pink Floyd's Dark Side of the Moon: Tracing Alienation through Musical Unity

Coxe 7

about the meaning of the album’s title, Gerry O’Driscoll, a janitor at Abbey Road,

contributed the remarkable response, “There is no dark side of the moon. As a matter of

fact, it’s all dark…” (Harris, 135). Again, Pink Floyd had benefitted from the

“serendipitous magic” of improvisation; with little forethought, and little (if any)

guidance, the Floyd had uncovered all the pieces of the puzzle that is Dark Side, and soon

thereafter would paste them together properly. The rest, they say, is history.

Throughout the recording process – the stage where Dark Side truly evolved into

the masterpiece we know and love – the unity and collaboration of the band members (as

well as all involved) cannot be overemphasized: it is truly the source of Dark Side’s

allure. Once Waters had laid the thematic foundation for the work – “a series of different

lyrics that had a theme running through them”, with clear and simple words to illuminate

the message – the musical development and tracking occurred in a quite democratic

fashion (Gilmour). Though each musician was given ample creative rein with respect to

their own recordings, furthered by the freedom to improvise on their tracks at times, the

band fostered significant discussion about the layering of tracks in order to perfect parts

that sounded inadequate, and these discussions were always cooperative (if occasionally

heated). Similar debate and collaboration took place over the inclusion of particular

sound effects, the “wetness” of the sound, and the use of spoken voices throughout the

work (Alan Parsons, of course, was included). So impassioned was the discourse that

producer Chris Thomas was brought in to resolve the band’s disagreements (in particular,

Gilmour and Waters’ squabbles) – it was he who supervised the final cut, resulting in the

addition of “extra guitars to ‘Money’”, the reduction of guitar influence in “Us and

Them”, and the completion of “Speak to me”, among other minor embellishments (Blake,

Page 8: Pink Floyd's Dark Side of the Moon: Tracing Alienation through Musical Unity

Coxe 8

198). The fruit of these efforts was a tight, cohesive composition – a fusion of simple

and, on the whole, undemanding instrumentals, straightforward effects, and clear lyrics

that juxtaposed itself perfectly to create a complex, intricate, and surreal soundscape, the

ideal canvass for Water’s profound diatribe against the alienating effects of modern

society.

But how, exactly? How did the music of Dark Side generate the ideal canvass for

Water’s “expression of political, philosophical, and humanitarian empathy” (Johnston,

134)? The subsequent song-by-song analysis intends to highlight the interplay between

sound and concept, tracing the progression of the Floyd’s existential treatise by means of

each song’s components. The album’s first track, “Speak to Me”, immediately isolates

the listener through the use of white noise, broken by a crescendo amalgamation of

sounds – a beating heart, a ticking clock, a cash register – and voices – maniacal laughter,

muffled talking, frantic wailing. The resultant effect is a sensation of alienation, as

though the listener is inside the head of a lunatic and experiencing his irrational and

disconcerting thoughts (or, more disturbingly, as though the listener is himself insane).

And though none of Water’s philosophy is explicitly set forth yet, “Speak to Me”

foreshadows his ensuing discourse, hinting at the concepts of alienation, greed, time, and

madness. To put it best, the beating heart that bookends Dark Side and shatters the

silence of “Speak to Me” “alludes to the human condition and sets the mood for the

music” (Detmer, 64).

Then, after establishing an eerily serene soundscape in the introduction of

“Breathe”, Waters begins his manifesto with the lines “Breathe, breathe in the air/Don’t

be afraid to care”; these lines, complemented by the peace and calm of the music, convey

Page 9: Pink Floyd's Dark Side of the Moon: Tracing Alienation through Musical Unity

Coxe 9

Waters’ overarching motif – to live unfettered from the norms imposed by society.

Shortly thereafter, Waters firmly roots his message in the realm of existentialism,

proclaiming “All you touch and all you see/Is all your life will ever be”; clearly, what is

to follow will deal exclusively with life and its peripheries. The crux of “Breathe”,

however, lies in the song’s final two stanzas. Waters and Gilmour sing “Run rabbit

run/Dig that hole, forget the sun” while Wright’s electric piano riff – sliding stealthily

from the background to the fore – screeches an electrified glissando, as though exhorting

the listener to, in fact, run. Here, the lyrics, heightened by the tension of Wright’s keys,

examine the pressures of work and its alienating effects on the individual – the sense of

objectification and overwork at the loss of personal pursuits. Waters further reviles the

pressures of work in modern society, amplifying the sentiment of exploitation (“When at

last the work is done/Don’t sit down it’s time to dig another one”) and introducing the

concept that society forces its conventions on people (“Only if you ride the tide”); against

the backdrop of Gilmour’s serene yet plaintive chord strumming and slide guitar, these

words are poised properly to propel forth their meaning, harmoniously complementing

the wistful mood of the music. Then, as Waters’ injects his final reproach, broaching the

concept of death – “You race towards an early grave” – the lyrics mesh perfectly and

segue into “On the Run”.

“On the Run” – designed to conjure the sense of travelling, which, according to

the band, is inextricably connected with the fear of dying – features a zany 8-note

synthesizer loop, played at a tempo of 166, and a repetitive high-hat loop. Coupled with

the running footsteps that pervade the background, the sound cannot but recreate the

feeling of literally being “on the run”. Through the addition of maniacal laughter, droning

Page 10: Pink Floyd's Dark Side of the Moon: Tracing Alienation through Musical Unity

Coxe 10

voices (one, an airport announcer, and the other, stating “Live for today, gone

tomorrow…that’s me”), and alien sounds – Gilmour’s wicked guitar squeals – the Floyd

succeeds in shading a hue of terror over the base concept of travel. To cap it all off, the

song terminates with a loud crash, imbuing the literal notion of death from air travel. But

from the ensuing silence emerges Waters’ next topic of discourse: as the inexorable

ticking of clocks permeates the post-crash atmosphere, the transparency of the track’s

title – “Time” – is made evident. According to Waters, the impetus for “Time” was his

realization that “Fucking hell – this is it...I wasn’t preparing for [life] – I was right in the

middle of it, and always had been” (Harris, 82). Heightened by the metronome-like effect

throughout the introduction, as well as the sheer slowness and longevity of the song’s

first segment, the Floyd fosters a sense of leisure and idleness, as though “there is time to

kill today”. The first two stanzas of the song’s lyrics describe this same feeling with lines

such as “Ticking away the moments that make up a dull day” and “Waiting for someone

or something to show you the way”. However, his ensuing lyrics denounce this passive

attitude (“you missed the starting gun”), noting the transience of time (“The sun is the

same in a relative way but you’re older/Shorter of breath and one day closer to death”)

and its interrelation with death. Waters then sharpens his critique, wryly noting,

“Hanging on in quiet desperation is the English way” – an exhortation to seek happiness

in life at the cost of societal norms. The concluding lines, in addition to bridging into

“Breathe (Reprise)”, summarize perfectly the feeling that drove the production of “Time”

– “The time is gone, the song is over/Thought I’d something more to say”. With these

words, Waters reinforces the notion that our time on earth is limited and ephemeral.

Page 11: Pink Floyd's Dark Side of the Moon: Tracing Alienation through Musical Unity

Coxe 11

Instantly, the music smoothly slides back into the key of “Breathe”; this time,

Gilmour strums more slowly, more gently, more languidly. The resultant soundscape

hearkens back to the eerie yet peaceful texture of “Breathe”, yet induces a sense of

comfort and complacence in the listener, a perfect complement to Waters’ lines “Home,

home again/I like to be here when I can”. Though the reprise is short, it serves two

functions: first, to comment on the transitory and taxing life of a musician (and, more

universally, any person worn down from work), and second, to segue into “The Great Gig

in the Sky”. The latter is achieved simply with the concluding lyrics “To hear the softly

spoken magic spells”, which connects perfectly to the subsequent piano piece – a

mellifluous movement more fitting for a church than a rock concert. After an

instrumental introduction that establishes a placid atmosphere, broken only by whispering

voices discussing the fear of death, the stage is set for Torry’s mesmerizing vocal

performance. The sheer emotion in her screams strikes a chord among listeners, unveiling

the concept of death and the contingencies surrounding it; moreover, the seductive

quality of her voice shades on erotic quality over the notion of death (it was, after all

voted the “Best Song to Make Love To” in 1990 in Australia) (MacDonald, 217). Such

impassioned caterwauling gives way to a quieter, more pensive moaning, and fades to

silence as Wright gently caresses his final notes, leaving an ambience of blissful calm.

Once more, the silence is shattered by sound effects – in this case, a seven-beat

loop of a cash register, clinking coins, ripping cash, and more. This loop, in addition to

laying the beat for the ensuing song, “Money”, foretells the commentary on greed that

will follow. Mirrored by a saucy guitar riff (the product of Chris Thomas’s layering), a

cheeky sax solo, and a screeching guitar solo, Waters’ sardonic lyrics deride the societal

Page 12: Pink Floyd's Dark Side of the Moon: Tracing Alienation through Musical Unity

Coxe 12

obsession with money, the oil that greases the gears of the capitalistic machine. By listing

off inordinately expensive material possessions, Waters takes his first shot at greed; he

furthers this with lines such as “Money, get back” and “don’t take a slice of my pie”,

wryly noting the avaricious tendencies that money instills in people. The kernel of the

piece, however, lies in the penultimate lyrical couplet: “Money, so they say/Is the root of

all evil today”. These words comprise Waters’ message: money engenders avarice and is

one factor contributing to the alienating effect of modern society because it divides,

rather than connects, people. As the guitar riff of “Money” fades into the background, a

medley of voices, all claiming to have been “in the right”, overtakes the ambience of

sound, furthering the notion of disharmony and disunity among people and

foreshadowing the theme of “Us and Them” – the fundamental question of us versus

them. Organ and piano then silence the voices, and with the addition of guitar, drums,

and bass, a peaceful, spacious soundscape permeates the environment, characterized by,

literally, temporal space between the notes of each instrument, and in particular, Wright’s

piano and Parry’s breathy sax riffs. This use of space is mirrored in Waters and

Gilmour’s singing style, allowing ample distance between such diametric contrasts as

“Us and them”, “Me and you”, “Black and Blue”, “Up and Down”, and heightening the

effect of these juxtapositions to intensify the disparity between “us” and “them”. And

while the lyrics of “Us and Them” reflect aspects of Waters’ life (the death of his father

in WWII) and certain societal conditions of the time – Vietnam and the civil right’s

movement – the subject matter of his lyrics primarily discusses the question of human

empathy: can we resolve the mindset of us versus them, and coexist peacefully,

humanely? Clearly, Waters’ is a proponent of empathy; lines such as “who knows which

Page 13: Pink Floyd's Dark Side of the Moon: Tracing Alienation through Musical Unity

Coxe 13

is which and who is who” condemn the tendency of mankind to discriminate and split

into factions, instead suggesting that we are all one and the same – human. Finally, in the

concluding stanza, Waters interconnects the concept of human empathy with previous

theme of time:

Out of the way, it’s a busy day

I’ve got things on my mind.

For want of the price of tea and a slice

The old man died.

Here, the pressure of time (or lack thereof) is causally linked with a lack of humanity:

Waters asserts that people are so caught up with their own hectic, busy lives to empathize

with the plight of others.

As the final word of the aforementioned stanza resounds, the music immediately

segues into the screeching organs of “Any Colour You Like” – a fitting shift when one

considers that this song serves principally as a necessary transition between “Us and

Them” and “Brain Damage”. “Any Colour You Like” is an instrumental jam, featuring a

wet amalgamation of organ, synthesizer, and guitar that creates an alien ambience,

altogether funkier, faster, and less eerie than that of “Breathe”. Nevertheless, the listener

must not be fooled: this song is the second reprise of “Breathe”, glossed over with

electronic effects to create a grooved out vibe, seemingly unrelated to former without

strict scrutiny or a knack for picking out musical notes. And though there is no explicit

message set forth in the song, it follows logically that hidden somewhere obscure lies

another tenet of Waters’ philosophy; after all, each previous track was charged with

intent. This prediction is accurate: according to Waters, the title, “Any Colour You Like”,

Page 14: Pink Floyd's Dark Side of the Moon: Tracing Alienation through Musical Unity

Coxe 14

Thus, the band’s decision to reprise “Breathe” a second time in a cryptic and abstruse

way mimics the concept of a lack of true choice in society, harmonizing with the overall

treatise against the alienating tendencies of modern society – clearly, the lack of choice

implied by “Any Colour You Like” pertains to the notion that society imposes norms on

people, robbing them of self-determination and instilling within them a feeling of

isolation from others.

At the end of “Any Colour You Like”, the song serves its requisite purpose,

transitioning fluidly into “Brain Damage” – “the spark for Waters’ whole concept”. In

marked contrast from previous songs, the guitar reduces to a simple 4-note progression,

the drums drop off to closed hi-hat half notes, and the organ lays out a near-silent

background. Posed against such a simple setting, Waters’ straightforward lyrics assume

the fore – an essential for the album’s thematic core. Immediately, Waters conjures the

concept of alienation using madness as a metaphor for said sentiment – “The lunatic is on

the grass” – that is heightened by Gilmour’s howling slide guitar (and, later, maniacal

laughter), resounding whenever Waters utters a line containing “lunatic”. The remainder

of the first stanza condemns societal conventions and, moreover, societal notions of

madness, using the contrast between the first line and the last (“Got to keep the loonies

on the path”) to convey the idea that the desire to “walk on the grass” is natural and that a

society that imposes such illogical and authoritative norms is, in fact, insane. The

subsequent stanzas intensify the songs interrelation with madness – “The lunatics are in

my hall”, “The lunatic is in my head” – all the while reducing the experience of madness

from an observant to a personal perspective, allowing the singer to empathize with those

who feel the same. Waters then incriminates society for this madness (“You raise the

Page 15: Pink Floyd's Dark Side of the Moon: Tracing Alienation through Musical Unity

Coxe 15

blade/you make the change/You rearrange me ‘til I’m sane”), linking strict societal

conventions that curtail personal freedom as a cause for this lunacy. The song’s final

chorus bears the crux of the song’s message: paying homage to Syd (“If the band you’re

in starts playing different tunes”), and identifying with other “loonies” (“If the cloud

bursts, thunder in your ear/You shout and no one seems to hear”), Waters utilizes the

chorus of background singers to reinforce his message and engender a sense, not of

isolation, but of unity, singing “I’ll see you on the dark side of the moon.” With these

words, Waters connects his plea for empathy with the concept of alienation, suggesting

that one is not alone in experiencing isolation and moments of madness, and that others

too struggle with the same issues. As the singers’ final cry rings out, only instrumental

music remains – the same simple backdrop, with an electrified synthesizer that imbues a

sense of insanity into the music itself, enhanced by maniacal laughter and an uttered

voice.

Suddenly, Mason’s floor tom pierces through the synthesized ambience, counting

the band off for the album’s veritable climax, “Eclipse”. Wright’s organ dominates the

song’s bridge into the lyrics, wailing fervently as Mason accentuates the sound with

crashes and cascading drum fills, adding an epic tinge to the soundscape. After the

instrumentals set the mood, Waters launches his dialectic; each line follows the form of

its predecessor (“All that you touch/All that you see”, “All that is now/All that is gone”),

and are enhanced by drum crashes (landing on the first and last word of each line),

cascading fills (following the final word of the line), and guitar arpeggios that peak on the

final word of each line, emphasizing the content of the lyrics. Then, the background

singers once more enter the equation, filling the backdrop of the song and supporting

Page 16: Pink Floyd's Dark Side of the Moon: Tracing Alienation through Musical Unity

Coxe 16

Waters’ message by inducing a sense of unity in the music. When only the final lyrical

couplet remains unsung, Waters has already listed off a set of conditions that comprise

nearly every aspect of the human condition – to put it simply, he has described life. This

culminates as Waters belts out the last lines: “And everything under the sun is in tune/but

the sun is eclipsed by the moon.” With these words, Waters imbues a shade of hope in his

polemic on alienation; in his own words, “[it] is the idea that we all have the potential to

be in harmony…to lead happy, meaningful, and right lives,” if we can overcome that

which mires us (symbolized by the moon eclipsing the sun) (Harris, 96). As the final note

of Waters’ cry fades to silence, and as Wright’s organ dies out, the beating heart once

more pervades the atmosphere, pounding rhythmically while Gerry O’Driscoll, an

employee at Abbey Road, concludes the song’s message, stating “There is no dark side of

the moon. As a matter of fact, it’s all dark.” This utterance – augmented by the heart’s

repetitive reminder that the song concerns the human condition – offers relief to those

experiencing said alienation due to modernity, suggesting that the modern world itself,

and not the individual, is mad.

Reflecting societal woes of the era, Dark Side was a product of early adult

disenchantment that impelled Waters to speak out, to cry for harmony. And certainly, the

social and political environment of the times contributed to this cynicism, not only with

Waters but also across the modern world. The Vietnam War raged on, yielding turmoil

and discontent among the American people that was exacerbated by the publication of the

Pentagon Papers and the ensuing executive scandal – Watergate. Across the pond,

“British unemployment had reached 904,000 – the highest level since the…1930s.”

(Harris, 84). Conflict between the British army and the Irish Republicans became

Page 17: Pink Floyd's Dark Side of the Moon: Tracing Alienation through Musical Unity

Coxe 17

increasingly acrimonious: Bloody Sunday, for example, occurred in January 1972.

Reactionary campaigns endeavoring to “[roll] back the permissive attitudes of the

previous decade” threatened to retrogress certain societal conditions (Harris, 85). Most

telling, though, is a story run by The Guardian – a liberal paper from the U.K. – that

looked into work-related stress:

The numbers affected by psychosis, psycho-neurosis, as well as the less

worrying complaints of debility, nervousness, and headaches have

been soaring. According to the [governmental] report, the best way to

avoid trouble is to ensure the worker should be satisfied with his work,

and should be stretched to his limits, but not beyond them.

Clearly, modernity had struck a common chord among people of all different

backgrounds, Waters included. Yet, these societal ills are not indigenous to Dark Side’s

era; rather, they transcend generations, manifesting themselves in analogous ways. In

today’s society, war rages in Iraq; tensions run high between certain nations; and disunity

reigns across the globe. Moreover, despite the increased interconnection brought by the

Internet Age, reactionaries remain who lament the loss of true human interaction due to

digitalization. Perhaps, then, the broad and transcendent topicality of Dark Side –

relevant to modernity in any stage – thus explains the success and mystique of the album,

answering that most troublesome of questions: Why?

Page 18: Pink Floyd's Dark Side of the Moon: Tracing Alienation through Musical Unity

Coxe 18

Works Cited

"Any Colour You Like -." Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia. 19 May 2009

<http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Any_Colour_You_Like>.

Blake, Mark. Comfortably Numb. New York: Thunder's Mouth P, 2007.

Harris, John,. Dark side of the moon: the making of Pink Floyd's masterpiece.

Cambridge, MA: Da Capo P, 2005.

Macdonald, Bruno, ed. Pink Floyd Through the Eyes of-- The Band, Its Fans, Friends,

and Foes. New York: Da Capo P, 1997.

Pink Floyd-The Making of Dark Side of the Moon. Dir. Matthew Longfellow. DVD.

Eagle Rock Entertainment, 2003.

Reisch, George A. Pink Floyd and Philosophy (Popular Culture and Philosophy).

Chicago: Open Court, 2007.

Reising, Russell. Speak To Me: The Legacy Of Pink Floyd's Dark Side Of The Moon

(Ashgate Popular and Folk Music Series). Grand Rapids: Ashgate, 2006.

Works Referenced

Pink Floyd: Live at Pompeii. Dir. Adrien Maben. DVD. BR, 1973.

Pink Floyd. Dark Side of the Moon. Chris Thomas, 1973.