performance-based development and learning: closing the loop
TRANSCRIPT
The audio will automatically stream through your computer speakers.
To join the teleconference (optional), please dial:
Toll Free: 1.866.469.3239Access Code: 664 758 312 #
You will be listening to music until the webinar begins.
Performance-Based Development and Learning: Closing the Loop
#CLOwebinar
Speaker: Stephan Millard Director Product Marketing,SumTotal Systems, Inc.
Moderator: Daniel Margolis,
Managing Editor,
Chief Learning Officer Magazine
Performance-Based Development and Learning: Closing the Loop
#CLOwebinar
• Q&A
– Click on the Q&A panel (?) in the bottom right corner
– Type in your question in the space provided
– Click on “Send.”
Tools You Can Use
#CLOwebinar
• Polling
– The poll will appear on the right side of your screen
– Select the best option for each question
– Click on “Submit”
#CLOwebinar
Tools You Can Use
#CLOwebinar
Performance-Based Development and Learning: Closing the Loop
Daniel MargolisManaging EditorChief Learning Officer magazine
Stephan MillardProduct Marketing Director
SumTotal Systems, Inc
Performance-Based Development and Learning: Closing the Loop
Page 7 - April 12, 2023 – PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL
Today’s Agenda
EVOLUTION OF LEARNING, PERFORMANCE AND DEVELOPMENT
RESULTS OF SUCCESSFUL PROCESS INTEGRATION
STRATEGIES & TACTICS: HOW TO IMPLEMENT TALENT-BASED LEARNING
“CLOSING THE LOOP” TO IMPROVE DECISION MAKING
WHAT TO DO NOW?
ABOUT SUMTOTAL
Page 8 - April 12, 2023 – PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL
Evolution of Development, Performance, and Learning
Delivering Greater Value
■ Better Performance
■ Better Alignment
■ Improved Compliance
■ Measureable Results
Time & Maturity of HR Practice
Va
lue
& B
usi
ne
ss I
mp
act
Siloed HR Processes
Learning, Development and Performance are sillo’d
Complete Talent Infrastructure
Performance, Development and Learning are integrated
Loosely Connected, Little Value
May Pass One or Two Pieces of Information Across
Page 9 - April 12, 2023 – PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL
Ideal Process for Aligning Learning & Performance
Goal Alignm
ent
360 Feedba
ck
Gap Analys
is
Development Plans
Personalized
Learning
Goals cascaded
Performance goals linked to organizational goals
Competencies used for job profiles
360 feedback to highlight gaps
Skill gaps identified
Learning priorities based on performance goals & from identified skill and competency gaps
Learning includes blended solutions
Systems enable SME’s to easily contribute content
Personalized learning paths provide tailored development
Page 10 - April 12, 2023 – PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL
45%
Level 2: Standardized Talent ProcessesTalent processes are consistent and tailorable, with some integration;
several systems connected through manual processes
20%
Level 3: Integrated Talent ManagementHeavy focus on connecting systems and processes; single person / team
responsible for talent initiatives
7%Level 4: Strategic Talent Management
Fully integrated processes and systems used to makebusiness decisions; talent mgmt. is business-driven
Bersin: Talent Management Maturity Model
28%
Level1: Siloed HR ProcessesIndividual HR processes or “silos”;
may have systems in place but not connected
As companies move up the maturity ladder, they have lower turnover, greater employee engagement and greater success in nearly every talent area.
Bersin & Associates, 2010
Page 11 - April 12, 2023 – PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL
Greater Maturity = Higher Return Rate
Page 12 - April 12, 2023 – PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL
Instructional Design
Development of Rich Media (ex: audio, video, Flash, etc.)
Coaching & Feedback Skills
Performance Consulting
Project Management
Systems Thinking
Quality/Process Improvement methodologies such as Six Sigma, Lean, or TQM
Information Architecture
Knowledge Management
Business Acumen
Business Intelligence / Analytics
Marketing & Communications
4.4
3.9
4.3
4.2
4.3
4.0
3.7
3.8
3.8
4.1
4.0
4.2
3.5
2.8
3.2
3.1
3.4
2.9
2.7
2.6
2.6
3.2
2.8
3.1
New Disciplines of High-Impact Learning & Development
High Impact Learning Practices© Bersin, 2009, 1000+ respondentswww.bersin.com/hilp
Comparing the Top 10% of High-Performing L&D Organizations (n>1,000)
Modern HighPerformance
Learning Organizationsare particularly
strong in:
• Knowledge Management
• InformationArchitecture
• BusinessAnalytics
• Rich MediaNew Media
• PerformanceConsulting
#1
#2
#3
#4
#5
AllOrganizations
Top 10%in Impact
Page 13 - April 12, 2023 – PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL
How are Businesses Linking Learning to Talent Management
Many organizations are integrating talent management & learning applications
Page 14 - April 12, 2023 – PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL
How Linking Applications Gives Strategic Value
Single Record for all Learners
Integrated HRMS provides one unified record with all info, for
better reporting
Improve TalentMobility
Tie learning plans to career paths employees wish to pursue
Speed On-Boarding
Automatically push on-boarding & learning plans to new employees
Integrated Workforce Analytics
Link learning plans to development goals for employees
Link Learning to
Development
Drive Compensation Incentives for
Learning
Use learning compliance / completed courses as data points
that can drive compensation
Improve Social / Informal LearningFacilitate dialogue with
Forums for courses; use Wikis to push out pre-work;
Blogs to share info
Link learning activities to positions to
succession plans for high-value employees
Succession Based
Learning
Learning
Management
Page 15 - April 12, 2023 – PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL
POLLING SLIDE: Are you integrating learning with the other parts of HR?
■ Learning Integrated with Recruiting
■ Learning Integrated with Performance
■ Learning Integrated with Development
■ Learning Integrated with Succession
■ Learning Standalone only
*Select all that apply
Page 16 - April 12, 2023 – PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL
Technology Requirements for Talent Based Learning
Single Data SourceHR record, Talent data, Learning data, Competencies, Job profiles
Single Data SourceHR record, Talent data, Learning data, Competencies, Job profiles
Shared Core ServicesSingle user experience ,Security, User management, Workflow
Shared Core ServicesSingle user experience ,Security, User management, Workflow
Imbedded Analytics & Reporting ServiceFeature rich tool, Business-user friendly, Flexible delivery
Imbedded Analytics & Reporting ServiceFeature rich tool, Business-user friendly, Flexible delivery
Complete set of TM/LM/HR ApplicationsHRMS, Recruiting, Development, LMS, Performance, Goals,
Compensation, Succession
Complete set of TM/LM/HR ApplicationsHRMS, Recruiting, Development, LMS, Performance, Goals,
Compensation, Succession
Page 17 - April 12, 2023 – PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL
CONFIDENTIAL 17
Talent-based Learning Application Rollout
• Establish rev. related goals
• Establish key org. goals to track
• HR data
• Key org. competencies
• Job profiles
• Talent profiles
• Establish Performance
• Align individual goals
• Align individual competencies
Centralized Data
Goals / Revenue
Performance
LMS / Dev. • Align learning
to development
• Create / import content
TM Analytics• Establish
benchmarks
• Create analytics
Page 18 - April 12, 2023 – PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL
Keys to a Successful Technology Rollout
■ Executive sponsorship & Governance
■ Business-driven (but with IT’s help)
■ Well defined goals, scope, and plan
■ Focus on configuration (vs. customization)
■ Open communication
■ Training & end user adoption
■ Organizational change management
■ Vendor partnership
Page 19 - April 12, 2023 – PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL
Integrated Infrastructure
Com
plet
enes
s
Single point solutions
Course ReportsLMS Reports Integrated Learning
Analytics
AttendanceLittle / no Business Value
CourseSurveysHighly subjectiveNo direct correlations
LMS ReportsKirkpatrick ScoreCompetency Prof.
Course Results
Employee Results
Business Results
Busine
ss
Impa
ct
Effectiveness of Metrics to Measure Business Impact
IntegratedLearningTraining : PerformanceTraining : Sales
Page 20 - April 12, 2023 – PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL
Measuring Results: What are the Metrics / Analytics?
Advanced analytics
Basic analytics
Training metrics
• Kirkpatrick Level II - Scores
• Kirkpatrick Level III – Competency
Page 21 - April 12, 2023 – PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL
Analytics: What is Being Tracked Today
Recruiting tracks the largest number of metrics Today’s metrics are largely tactical Strong growth in more impactful metrics
% Growth
162%
111%
97%
76%
80%
84%
30%
40%
34%
57%
46%
22%
13%
17%
6%
Talent Metrics Tracked2010 State of Global People Management
Page 22 - April 12, 2023 – PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL
POLLING SLIDE: What is Your Organization Measuring?
■ Training Metrics Only (e.g. attendance, completion, course surveys)
■ Kirkpatrick Level Two & Three
■ Basic analytics (e.g. effect of training on performance, goal achievement to test scores)
■ Advanced analytics (e.g. Workforce productivity, return on training investment)
Page 23 - April 12, 2023 – PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL
Sales Example: Competencies vs. Sales Bookings
Page 24 - April 12, 2023 – PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL
Manufacturing Org Goal Achievement vs. Training Scores
Exceed
Met
Miss
Goa
l Ach
ieve
men
t
Avg. Test Scores
>60% 80% 100%
8
5
90%70%
Close
Goal Achievement: 20% reduction in Manufacturing error rate vs. Avg. Test Scores on 4 courses
8
8
5
1
8
15
2
2
9
5
1
55
1
94 % met or exceeded the
goal
72% did not Achieve goal
Page 25 - April 12, 2023 – PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL
Performance Based Learning: Calculating Return on Investment
Calculate Benefit Gained Reduced time to complete processImproved productivity of a better skilled workforceEquals total direct benefit
Calculate Cost of Learning ProgramDirect costs of course creation & deliveryIndirect costs of course (lost time)Equals total costs
Return On Training Investment• S
ubtract cost from benefit = Total net benefit
• Use business specific formula(s) for ROI
*Use correlation to show relationship between training and result
Page 26 - April 12, 2023 – PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL
Near Term Tactics
■ Focus: Current year business goals & group to focus on
■ Pick Competencies: What are 2-3 key competencies that can improve success at goal
■ Performance Process: Get engaged in before / after performance scores for your target audience
■ Execute: Execute your learning program(s)
■ Measure: Look at before / after measures against performance / goal attainment to see success
Don’t Boil The Ocean
Page 27 - April 12, 2023 – PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL
SumTotal – What We Offer
People:
HR Process Expertise
Product:
Complete End-to-End
HR Platform
Services:
Solution Consulting & Support
Results:
Deep Reporting
& Analytics
■ Deployed in 156 countries & 39 languages
■ 98% Customer Retention
■ 20+ years of Domain Experience
■ Rapidly Scalable Global Infrastructure
■ Profitable with Consistent Growth
■ Significant Financial Backing
■ Long-standing Global Customer Community
■ Offices in US, Europe, India, China, Japan, & Australia
■ One Partner for All of Your Talent Needs
Complete End-to-end Talent Solution
Page 28 - April 12, 2023 – PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL
Most Complete – Comprehensive & End-to-end
■ Complete End-to-end Solution
■ Broadest & Deepest Capabilities
■ Holistic Talent Management Workflows
■ Pervasive Embedded Analytics
■ Seamless User Experience
■ Proven, Scalable Architecture
■ Highly Configurable & Easy to Use
■ Talent-based system of record
Page 29 - April 12, 2023 – PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL
Most Innovative - Recognized as Leader by Analysts
Rated “Visionary” (Gartner EPM MQ)“…well-suited for global organizations seeking best-in-class…functionality”
Highest Rated Overall (AMR Strategic HCM)“...the broadest and most mature application suite in the strategic HCM specialist space”
Highest Score Among All Vendors (Forrester)Forrester Wave for Enterprise Learning Suites”
Highest Rated Overall (Bersin TM Systems) “…best-suited to support the needs of large, multinational organizations that are seeking a well-integrated and global solution”
Highest Rated Overall (Ventana Total Compensation)“The top supplier, based on the weighted factoring of the seven product and customer assurance categories…”
4+ Years in the Leader’s Quadrant (Gartner)Gartner Magic Quadrant for Corporate Learning Systems
Highest Rated in Product Offering (Forrester TM)“...among the leaders for integrated performance & compensation solutions”
Page 30 - April 12, 2023 – PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL
Summary
■ Performance based development & learning delivers measurable results
■ It is also better aligned to the overall business results
■ Start by looking at several key process integrations
■ Integrated technology is key to addressing the challenge
■ Pick metrics that show relevance to your business
■ Near term: Don’t try to boil the ocean
Page 31 - April 12, 2023 – PROPRIETARY AND CONFIDENTIAL
Questions & Answers
@SumtotalSystems
http://www.linkedin.com/groups?home=&gid=45382
http://www.facebook.com/SumTotal.Systems
Visit us at www.sumtotalsystems.com and through these social channels:
Join Our Next CLO Webinar!
Thursday, February 3, 2011
What to Consider When Designing Content for
Adaptive Learning
CLO Webinars start at 2 p.m. Eastern / 11 a.m. Pacific
Register at www.clomedia.com/events
Join the CLO Network: http://network.clomedia.com/
#CLOwebinars