overview – pacific ocean · 18 review of the state of world marine capture fisheries management:...

17
Overview – Pacific Ocean 15 R&D in the recreational fisheries, the full funding of these costs by the government tended to be equally high across the three sub-sectors (Figure 18). Monitoring and enforcement budgets reportedly increased in approximately 50 percent of the large-scale fisheries; however, budgets decreased within about one third of the large-scale fisheries. Corresponding budgets increased in fewer fisheries in the other two sub-sectors (41 and 36 percent, respectively) and, as in the large-scale fisheries, decreased in about one third of the fisheries. Wide-spread use of various monitoring and enforcement mechanisms was reported throughout the large-scale fisheries; contrasted with a dependence on inspections within the small-scale and recreational fisheries (Figure 19). This reported lack of monitoring and enforcement within the small-scale sub-sector raises the question of the effectiveness of management tools and regulations reported above. The limited use (about 50 percent) of VMS and on-board observers within the large-scale sector also points to potential weak links within fisheries management for these fisheries. FIGURE 18 Government management funding outlays 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 R&D Monitoring & enforcement Daily management % of fisheries surveyed in which government pays all costs Large-scale Small-scale Recreational FIGURE 19 Compliance and enforcement mechanisms in use in top three fisheries 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 VMS On-board observers Random dockside inspections Routine inspections at landing sites At-sea boarding and inspections % of fisheries surveyed Large-scale Small-scale Recreational

Upload: others

Post on 14-Nov-2020

4 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Overview – Pacific Ocean · 18 Review of the state of world marine capture fisheries management: Pacific Ocean Fleet capacity management within the largest fisheries It is commonly

Overview – Pacific Ocean 15

R&D in the recreational fisheries, the full funding of these costs by the government tended to be equally high across the three sub-sectors (Figure 18).

Monitoring and enforcement budgets reportedly increased in approximately 50 percent of the large-scale fisheries; however, budgets decreased within about one third of the large-scale fisheries. Corresponding budgets increased in fewer fisheries in the other two sub-sectors (41 and 36 percent, respectively) and, as in the large-scale fisheries, decreased in about one third of the fisheries. Wide-spread use of various monitoring and enforcement mechanisms was reported throughout the large-scale fisheries; contrasted with a dependence on inspections within the small-scale and recreational fisheries (Figure 19). This reported lack of monitoring and enforcement within the small-scale sub-sector raises the question of the effectiveness of management tools and regulations reported above. The limited use (about 50 percent) of VMS and on-board observers within the large-scale sector also points to potential weak links within fisheries management for these fisheries.

FIGURE 18Government management funding outlays

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100

R&D Monitoring &enforcement

Daily management

% o

f fi

sher

ies

surv

eyed

in w

hic

h g

ove

rnm

ent

pay

s al

l co

sts Large-scale

Small-scale

Recreational

FIGURE 19Compliance and enforcement mechanisms in use in top three fisheries

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100

VMS On-boardobservers

Randomdockside

inspections

Routineinspectionsat landing

sites

At-seaboarding andinspections

% o

f fi

sher

ies

surv

eyed

Large-scale

Small-scale

Recreational

Page 2: Overview – Pacific Ocean · 18 Review of the state of world marine capture fisheries management: Pacific Ocean Fleet capacity management within the largest fisheries It is commonly

Review of the state of world marine capture fisheries management: Pacific Ocean16

Fisheries management cost recovery mechanisms (Figure 20), other than license fees, were uncommon throughout thee three fisheries sub-sectors’ legislations.

Participatory mechanisms and conflict management within the largest fisheriesIncluding stakeholders into the fisheries management process is a basic tenet of the FAO Code of Conduct for Responsible Fisheries (the Code [FAO, 1995]) in part to reflect multiple objectives, to define the roles and responsibilities within each fishery and to foster compliance with any agreed upon management measures.

Although legal or formal definitions of those having an interest in the use and management of fisheries resources were not common, efforts had been made in most fisheries across the three sub-sectors to identify such stakeholders (Figure 21). In most cases, it was felt that arrangements had been made to consult these stakeholders and to work with them on the management of these fisheries; however, these sentiments were less strong within the small-scale and recreational sub-sectors than in the large-scale sub-sector.

FIGURE 20Fisheries management cost recovery sources in national legislations

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100

License fees inthe fishery

License fees inother fisheriesof subsector

License fees inother fisheries

of othersubsectors

Resource rents

% o

f fi

sher

ies

surv

eyed

Large-scale

Small-scale

Recreational

FIGURE 21Participatory mechanisms and impacts

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100

stakeholdersdefined

stakeholdersidentified

stakeholdersconsulted

helped toreduceconflict

led to volutarystewardship

managementprocess faster

stable stocklevels over the

last 5 years

% o

f fi

sher

ies

surv

eyed

Large-scale

Small-scale

Recreational

Page 3: Overview – Pacific Ocean · 18 Review of the state of world marine capture fisheries management: Pacific Ocean Fleet capacity management within the largest fisheries It is commonly

Overview – Pacific Ocean 17

If stakeholders were part of the fisheries management decision-making process, the participatory approach had led to a reduction in conflict within the fisheries and, in at least half of the fisheries, created incentives and reasons for stakeholders to voluntarily practice “responsible” fisheries stewardship. The involvement of stakeholders tended to speed up the management process within the large-scale sub-sector but not necessarily within the small-scale sector and the recreational sub-sectors and the attainment of stable stocks was not automatically associated with stakeholder involvement.

Although participatory approaches to management assisted in the reduction of conflict within and among the fisheries, there remained significant levels of conflict throughout the three sub-sectors (71, 71, and 63 percent of the fisheries, respectively). Conflict within the large- and small-scale sectors was often caused by competition between different vessels categories or with other fisheries; while conflict within the recreational sub-sector tended to arise from competition with all other uses for the same area of water (Figure 22).

Conflict resolution processes were used on average over half of the large-scale and small-scale fisheries and within a over a third of the recreational fisheries. These processes included zoning for specific users, stock enhancement, resource allocation between and among the fisheries, and educational methods to sensitize users regarding the multiple-use nature of certain resources (Figure 23). There was little variation among the large-scale and small-scale sub-sectors in their preferences of conflict resolution methods and very little use of these methods in the recreational sub-sector.

FIGURE 22Sources of conflicts

0102030405060708090

100

competitionamong the

same type ofvessels insub-sector

competitionbetween

different typesof vessels insub-sector

competitionfor the samearea of water

with otherfisheries

competitionfor the samearea of water

with otherindustries

competitionfor the samearea of water

with therecreationalsub-sector

% o

f fi

sher

ies

surv

eyed

Large-scale

Small-scale

Recreational

FIGURE 23Conflict resolution methods

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

100

zoning fordifferent users

stockenhancement

resourceallocationwithin the

fishery

resourceallocation

among sub-sectors

educationabout sharing

resources

% o

f fi

sher

ies

surv

eyed

Large-scale

Small-scale

Recreational

Page 4: Overview – Pacific Ocean · 18 Review of the state of world marine capture fisheries management: Pacific Ocean Fleet capacity management within the largest fisheries It is commonly

Review of the state of world marine capture fisheries management: Pacific Ocean18

Fleet capacity management within the largest fisheriesIt is commonly accepted that excessive fishing capacity contributes to overfishing, the degradation of marine fisheries resources, the decline of food production potential, and significant economic waste. Therefore, as part of the implementation of the Code, countries have been urged to implement the International Plan of Action (IPoA) for the Management of Fishing Capacity (FAO, 1999). The first step in managing fishing capacity is to establish the current level of fishing activity within fisheries and to analyse each fishery for signs of excessive fishing inputs and overcapitalization. The second step would entail the preparation and implementation of national plans to effectively manage fishing capacity and to establish immediate actions for fisheries requiring urgent measures.

Within the Pacific Ocean, only in the large-scale sub-sector was fleet capacity measured in more than half the fisheries (Figure 24). Capacity measurement within the small-scale and recreational sub-sectors was often not undertaken. In addition, although there was either officially or a “sense” that overcapacity existed within at least half of the large-scale and small-scale fisheries, very few capacity reduction programmes were put into place to adjust for the levels of effort in these fisheries.

When put into place, the method of preference for reducing capacity levels was the purchase of fishing licenses from the fishery followed by a less-used approach of buying out fishing vessels licensed to operate in the fisheries. It was felt that license removal was an efficient means in immediately reducing any excess fishing capacity; while vessel buyouts were considered much less effective. In addition, these initial license removals, when supported by ongoing license purchases were often felt effective for ensuring that any excess fishing capacity did not return.

Funding for such capacity reduction programmes was generally supported through government funds but several instances occurred in which such programmes were paid for by participants within the fishery itself (55 percent of large-scale and 33 percent of small-scale fisheries) or, occasionally, by participants within other fisheries.

STATUS OF STOCKS IN THE PACIFIC OCEANIn 2005, the FAO published its review of the state of the world’s marine fishery resources based on stock assessments and other complementary information available through 2004 (FAO, 2005). For the 181 stocks or species groups of the Pacific Ocean for which there was adequate information to evaluate the state of the resources, 77 percent were determined to fall within the range of moderately-fully exploited to

FIGURE 24Fishing capacity indicators

0

10

20

30

40

50

60

70

80

90

Is fleet capacity measured?

CPUE constantor decreasing?

Doesoverfishing exist

officially?

Is there a sensethat

overcapacityexists?

Have capacityreduction

programmes beenused?

% o

f fi

sher

ies

surv

eyed

Large-scale

Small-scale

Recreational

Page 5: Overview – Pacific Ocean · 18 Review of the state of world marine capture fisheries management: Pacific Ocean Fleet capacity management within the largest fisheries It is commonly

Overview – Pacific Ocean 19

overexploited/depleted (Appendix 2).11 These levels signal little room for further expansion, in addition to the possibility that some, if not most, stocks might already be overexploited. One should also note the number of stocks for which it has not been possible to determine stock status (Figures 25-30).

FIGURE 252002 Landings and stock status of 25 species landed in the Northwest Pacific

0

500

1 000

1 500

2 000

2 500

3 000

3 500

4 000

4 500

Mar

ine fi

shes

not i

dentifi

ed

Japa

nese a

nchov

y

Larg

ehea

d hair

tail

Other

Misc

ellan

eous c

ostal fi

shes

Other

Misc

ellan

eous p

elagi

c fish

es

Alaska

pollo

ck (=

Wal

leye p

oll.)

Chub m

acke

rel

Akiam

i pas

te sh

rimp

Japa

nese fl

ying sq

uid

Other

Squid

. Cuttl

efish

, octo

puses

Other

Shrim

ps, p

raw

ns, et

c.

Gazam

i cra

b

Other

misc

ellan

eous d

emer

sal fi

shes

Pacifi

c sau

ry

Yesso

scall

op

Yellow cr

oake

r

Pacifi

c her

ring

Japa

nese p

ilcha

rd

Japa

nese j

ack m

acke

rel

Chum

(=Ket

a=Dog) s

almon

Vario

us squi

ds nei

Other

Sea-

spid

ers,

crabs

, etc.

Pink

(=Hum

pbac

k) sa

lmon

Pacifi

c cod

Other

Her

rings,

sard

ines

, anch

ovie

s

Land

ings

1 0

00 t

onne

s

Under to moderately exploited

Moderately to fully exploited

Fully to overexploited

Unknown status

Source: FAO, 2005

11 Moderately exploited – exploited with a low level of fishing effort; believed to have some limited potential for expansion in total production. Fully exploited – operating at or close to an optimal yield level with no expected room for further expansion. Overexploited – exploited at above a level which is believed to be sustainable in the long term, with no potential room for further expansion and a higher risks of stock depletion/collapse.

FIGURE 262002 Landings and stock status of 21 species landed in the Northeast Pacific

0

200

400

600

800

1 000

1 200

1 400

1 600

Alask

a po

llock

(=W

alleye

pol

l.)

Pacifi

c cod

North

Pac

ific h

ake

Pink

(=Hum

pbac

k) sa

lmon

Other

Flou

nder

s, ha

libut

s, so

les

Sock

eye (=

Red)

salm

on

Yello

wfin

sole

Chum

(=Ket

a=Dog

) salm

on

Pacifi

c her

ring

Pacifi

c ha

libut

Other

her

rings

, sar

dine

s, an

chov

ies

Pacifi

c shr

imps

nei

Dunge

ness

crab

Coho

(=Sil

ver)

salm

on

Other

sea-

spid

ers,

crab

s, et

c.

Chin

ook (=

Sprin

g=Kin

g) sa

lmon

Other

Shrim

ps, p

rawns

, etc.

Chub

mac

kere

l

Pacifi

c roc

k crab

Other

cods

, hak

es, h

addo

cks,

etc.

Other

misc

ellane

ous p

elag

ic fish

es

Lan

din

gs

1 0

00

to

nn

es

Under to moderately exploited

Moderately to fully exploited

Fully to overexploited

Unknown status

Source: FAO, 2005

Page 6: Overview – Pacific Ocean · 18 Review of the state of world marine capture fisheries management: Pacific Ocean Fleet capacity management within the largest fisheries It is commonly

Review of the state of world marine capture fisheries management: Pacific Ocean20

SUMMARY AND CONCLUSIONSFisheries management within the Pacific Ocean varied from highly structured and centralized to devolved and community-based management systems and from data rich to data poor systems. The countries themselves varied to from capital intensive and developed economics to labour intensive and least developed economies. Therefore, generalized comments can be easily countered by specifics. Having said this, there

FIGURE 272002 Landings and stock status of 25 species landed in the Western Central Pacific

0

500

1 000

1 500

2 000

2 500

3 000

Skip

jack tu

na

Other

Misc

ellan

eous c

osta

l fish

es

Scad

s nei

Yello

wfin tuna

Sard

inell

as n

ei

Other

Misc

ellan

eous p

elagi

c fish

es

Other

Tunas

, bon

itos,

billfi

shes

, etc.

Indi

an m

acker

els n

ei

Natan

tian de

capo

ds n

ei

Stol

ephor

us an

chov

ies

Caran

gids n

ei

Tuna-

like fi

shes

nei

Frig

ate a

nd b

ullet

tunas

Thre

adfin b

ream

s nei

Comm

on sq

uids n

ei

Goldstr

ipe s

ardin

ella

Pony

fishes

(=Sli

pmou

ths)

nei

Indi

an sc

ad

Other

Squi

d. Cu

ttlefi

sh, o

ctopu

ses

Bigey

e sca

d

Anchovie

s, et

c. ne

i

Kawak

awa

Other

Her

rings

, sar

dines

, anc

hovie

s

Shar

ks, r

ays,

skat

es, e

tc. ne

i

Lan

din

gs

1 0

00

to

nn

es

Under to moderately exploited

Moderately to fully exploited

Fully to overexploited

Unknown status

Mar

ine fi

shes

nei

Source: FAO, 2005

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

800

Califo

rnia

pilch

ard

Yello

wfin tuna

Pacifi

c anch

ovet

a

Mar

ine fi

shes

not

iden

tified

Jum

bo fl

ying s

quid

Bigey

e tun

a

Opalesc

ent i

nshor

e squ

id

Misc

ellan

eous

costa

l fish

es

Skip

jack tu

na

Shrim

ps, p

raw

ns, e

tc.

Pacifi

c thr

ead h

errin

g

Albac

ore

Other

Tunas

, bon

itos,

billfi

shes

, etc.

Other

Misc

ellan

eous p

elagi

c fish

es

Chub m

acker

el

Califo

rnia

n anch

ovy

Other

Sea-

spid

ers,

crabs,

etc.

Other

Her

rings

, sar

dines

, anc

hovie

s

Misc

ellan

eous

dem

ersa

l fish

es

Oyste

rs

Dungen

ess c

rab

Pacifi

c jac

k mac

kere

l

Cods,

hakes

, had

docks

, etc.

Pacifi

c blu

efin t

una

Octop

uses

, etc

. nei

Lan

din

gs

1 0

00

to

nn

es

Under to moderately exploited

Moderately to fully exploited

Fully to overexploited

Unknown status

FIGURE 282002 Landings and stock status of 25 species landed in the Eastern Central Pacific

Source: FAO, 2005

Page 7: Overview – Pacific Ocean · 18 Review of the state of world marine capture fisheries management: Pacific Ocean Fleet capacity management within the largest fisheries It is commonly

Overview – Pacific Ocean 21

were several tendencies shared across many of the Pacific Ocean fisheries worthy of mentioning.

In general, there was a shift from development/production-oriented policies toward management and sustainability policies and from ad hoc planning and decision making to stated policy and management objectives supported by legal frameworks. These

0

50

100

150

200

250

Blue g

renad

ier

Wel

lingto

n flyin

g squi

d

Sout

hern

blu

e whiti

ng

Other

Misc

ellan

eous d

emer

sal fi

shes

Jack

and h

orse

mac

kerels

nei

Snoe

k

Pink

cusk

-eel

Orange

rough

y

Oreo d

ories

nei

Vario

us sq

uids n

ei

Other

Misc

ellan

eous c

osta

l fish

es

Blue m

acker

el

Sout

hern

hak

e

Other

Cod

s, hak

es, h

addo

cks,

etc.

Silve

r sea

brea

m

Green

back

hor

se m

acker

el

Mul

lets n

ei

White

trev

ally

Red co

dling

Gadifo

rmes

nei

Silve

r sca

bbar

dfish

Butte

rfish

es, p

omfre

ts ne

i

Other

Misc

ellan

eous p

elagi

c fish

es

Silve

r gem

fish

Barra

cudas

nei

Lan

din

gs

10

00

to

nn

es

Under to moderately exploited

Moderately to fully exploited

Fully to overexploited

Unknown status

FIGURE 292002 Landings and stock status of 25 species landed in the Southwest Pacific

Source: FAO, 2005

FIGURE 302002 Landings and stock status of 23 species landed in the Southeast Pacific

0

2 000

4 000

6 000

8 000

10 000

12 000

Anchove

ta(=

Peru

vian a

nchov

y)

Chilea

n jac

k m

acker

el

Chub m

acker

el

Arauca

nian h

errin

g

Jum

bo fl

ying s

quid

Sout

h Pa

cific h

ake

Pata

gonian

gre

nadi

er

Skip

jack tu

na

Yello

wfin tuna

Other

Her

rings

, sar

dines

, anc

hovie

s

Other

Misc

ellan

eous p

elagi

c fish

es

33-Misc

ellan

eous

costa

l fish

es

Bigey

e tun

a

Other

Misc

ellan

eous d

emer

sal fi

shes

Sout

h Am

erica

n pilc

hard

Other

Tunas

, bon

itos,

billfi

shes

, etc.

Other

Cod

s, hak

es, h

addo

cks,

etc.

Sout

hern

hak

e

Pacifi

c thr

ead h

errin

g

Other

Squi

d. Cu

ttlefi

sh, o

ctopu

ses

Pata

gonian

tooth

fish

Vario

us sq

uids n

ei

Easte

rn Pa

cific b

onito

Lan

din

gs

1 0

00

to

nn

es

Under to moderately exploited

Moderately to fully exploited

Fully to overexploited

Unknown status

Source: FAO, 2005

Page 8: Overview – Pacific Ocean · 18 Review of the state of world marine capture fisheries management: Pacific Ocean Fleet capacity management within the largest fisheries It is commonly

Review of the state of world marine capture fisheries management: Pacific Ocean22

legal frameworks aimed to increased transparency in planning and decision-making by defining the roles and responsibilities of the various stakeholders, structuring the planning processes, increasing stakeholder consultations, devolving responsibility for developing and implementing management measures, and requiring more integrated information for decision-making. However, the ultimate decision-making tended to remain at top levels without the assistance of transparent and well-defined decision-making rules.

Funding of management primarily came from state coffers although some countries were shifting to at least partial recovery of management costs through the collection of license fees throughout the fishing sub-sectors. Such costs had increased over the years due to increased monitoring and enforcement, modifying regulations, and stakeholder consultations. However, the impression was that there were insufficient funds to properly monitor and enforce the fisheries and, combined with low penalties, the risks of being penalized were too low to act as deterrents; pointing to a weak point in management implementation throughout the Pacific Ocean countries.

Countries were starting to expand their use of management tools, such as spatial and temporal restrictions, however, incentive adjusting or rights providing mechanisms were often limited to the issuance of fishing licences. Use of varied management tools, as well as formal management plans, were even more limited in the recreational fisheries sub-sector, although their importance (economic and biological) had been acknowledge in a growing number of countries in the region.

As mentioned above, great efforts had been made to include stakeholders in the planning and management processes, helping to reduce conflicts, increase voluntary stewardship of the resources, and accelerate management processes. However, conflict remained prevalent within and among the fisheries and other users of the aquatic resources. To assist in minimizing these conflicts, conflict resolution methods were often applied in the large-scale and small-scale fisheries and included zoning, stock enhancement, resource allocations, and sensitization methods.

Knowledge about fleet capacities and fishing efforts had increased but only in certain areas and was still sorely lacking in most small-scale and recreational fisheries. In addition, although knowledge about key target stocks had increased, there remained many gaps in knowledge, especially in the low-valued by-catch species. Contrary to a precautionary approach, and even when faced with over-capacity and over-fishing, very few capacity reduction programmes had been used.

It appears that fisheries management remained reactive for the most part - reacting to conflicts, stock/resource problems and international requirements; rather than providing a forward-looking framework for obtaining sustainable use of aquatic resources. In addition, while legal and policy frameworks had been revisited and updated, their implementation, including their monitoring and enforcement, remained inadequate.

Actions to address these issues may include:• The definition of pre-defined trigger and reference points forcing management

action, which would be guided by established decision-making rules and, thereby, increasing decision-making transparency and decreasing decision-making susceptibility to undo influences;

• The introduction of adaptive management strategies, based on strengthened management structures with well-defined, prioritized objectives;

• The strengthening of the application of ecosystem and precautionary approaches to fisheries management;

• The investigation of cost-effective data gathering methods for biological, economic, social, and environmental aspects of fisheries;

• The investigation of creative and simple “win-win” techniques to minimize harmful impacts of fisheries;

Page 9: Overview – Pacific Ocean · 18 Review of the state of world marine capture fisheries management: Pacific Ocean Fleet capacity management within the largest fisheries It is commonly

Overview – Pacific Ocean 23

• An effective enforcement of fishery laws and regulations;• A better control over growth in fishing fleet capacity;• A greater harmonization of the definition and application of laws and regulations

among and within the fishery sub-sectors; • The development and implementation of fisheries management plans with relevant

stakeholders;• The elimination of harmful subsidies;• An active participation in regional initiatives such as regional fishery bodies to

assist in the control of IUU fishing, the harmonization of fisheries laws and regulations, and of the development of consistent management measures with respect to shared and transboundary stocks; and

• Continued involvement of stakeholders in management with consideration given to co-management schemes requiring the creation or strengthening of organizations to represent fishers and other interests.

The countries of the Pacific Ocean will need to continue in their development of sustainable fisheries management frameworks; addressing both international norms and agreements as well as adapting to each country’s specific situation and needs. Although there is no panacea for managing all fisheries, countries could benefit from the experiences of other countries in the same region (many of which are presented in this report), as well as elsewhere12, and existing literature in the search for creative and cost-effective methods for managing fisheries.

In addition, regardless of the management framework chosen, if there is a lack of political will to implement the relevant laws and regulations and management measures, even perfectly designed frameworks will remain on the bookshelves.

Finally, a better understanding of the effects of implemented management measures on the fisheries (e.g. economic efficiency, social justice, and stock/ecosystem health) would greatly assist in the adaptive improvement of fisheries management.

REFERENCESBerkes, F. et al. 2001. Managing Small-Scale Fisheries Alternative Directions and Methods.

IDRC 2001 ISBN 0-88936-943-7.De Young, C (ed.). 2006. Review of the state of world marine capture fisheries management:

Indian Ocean. FAO Fisheries Technical Paper. No. 488. Rome, FAO. 2006. 458p.FAO. 1995. Code of Conduct for Responsible Fisheries. Rome, FAO. 1995. 41 p. ISBN

92-5-103834-1.FAO. 1999. International Plan of Action for reducing incidental catch of seabirds in longline

fisheries. International Plan of Action for the conservation and management of sharks. International Plan of Action for the management of fishing capacity. Rome, FAO. 1999. 26p. ISBN 92-5-104332-9

FAO. 2005. Review of the State of World Marine Fishery Resources. FAO Fisheries Technical Paper No. 457. Rome, 2005, 235 pp. ISBN 92-5-105267-0.

Hart, P. & Reynolds, J. 2002. Handbook of Fish Biology and Fisheries Volume 2 Fisheries, Blackwell Publishing.

Thompson, D. 1980. Conflict within the fishing industry. ICLARM Newsletter, 3(3), 3-4.

12 See, for example, the Review of the state of world marine capture fisheries management: Indian Ocean (De Young, 2006).

Page 10: Overview – Pacific Ocean · 18 Review of the state of world marine capture fisheries management: Pacific Ocean Fleet capacity management within the largest fisheries It is commonly

Review of the state of world marine capture fisheries management: Pacific Ocean24

APPENDIX 1 Top three fisheries in the large-scale, small-scale and recreational fisheries within the Indian Ocean countries

Large-scale (Commercial/ Industrial)

Australia (Pacific coast) Southeast Trawl East Coast Tuna and billfish Northern Prawn Trawl

Cambodia Trawl Gill Net Purse seine

Canada Hake trawl Groundfish trawl Salmon

Chile Jurel Anchoveta Caballa

China Trawlers

Colombia (Pacific coast) Tunas Small pelagics Shrimps

Costa Rica (Pacific coast) Tuna Purse Seine Vessels Long line Shrimp Trawlers

Ecuador Pelágicos Pequeños Atunes Camarón de Arrastre

El Salvador Tuna Shrimp Crawfish

Fiji Tuna longline Tuna pole and line

FSM Tuna purse seine Tuna longline Tuna pole/line

Guatemala (Pacific and Atlantic coasts) Shrimp Shark Tuna

Honduras (Pacific coast) Camarón Langosta Caracol

Indonesia (Pacific and Indian coasts) Longline Purse seine Shrimp nets

Japan purse seine Longline Trawling

Korea (Republic of) Anchovy Mackerels Squids

Malaysia (Pacific and Indian coasts) Trawl Purse Seine

Mexico (Pacific coast) Sardine Tuna Shrimp

New Zealand Hoki Squid Southern Blue Whiting

Nicaragua (Pacific coast) Finfish Shrimp

Panama Anchovies/herrings Snappers Shrimps

Peru Anchoveta Merluza Jurel-Caballa

Philippines Roundhead Indian Sardines Skipjack

Russian FederationAlaska Pollack in Sea of Okhotsk and Bering Sea Herring in Northern Sea of Okhotsk Pacific salmon in Kamchatka

Samoa Tuna longline Deepslope bottomfish

Taiwan Province of China Tuna Long Line Purse Seine for Tuna Squid Jigging

Thailand (Pacific coast) Trawl Purse Seine Gillnet

United States (Pacific coast) Pacific Whiting Pacific Sardines Squid (loligo)

Viet Nam Trawl Purse Seine Gill Net

Small-scale, artisanal, lifestyle, subsistence, indigenous, customary

Australia (Pacific coast) Saltwater prawn (shrimp) Marine bivalves Small baitfish

Cambodia Subsistence Artisanal Largest small-scale

Canada First nations

Chile Sardina comun Anchoveta Merluza comun

China Small scale gill and drifnets Set-net

Colombia (Pacific coast) Bentonics Pelagics Crustaceans

Costa Rica (Pacific coast)Coastal demersal and pelagic

EcuadorTunas and other large pelagics Demersals Sharks

El Salvador Finfish Shrimp Other crustaceans

Fiji Finfish Non-finfish Subsistence

FSM Nearshore trolling for tuna Night spearfishing for reef fish Trochus (trochus niloticus)

Guatemala (Pacific and Atlantic coasts) Shark Shrimp Mahi mahi

Honduras (Pacific coast)Corvinas, pargos y jureles, camarón Camarón, tiburones y rayas Jaiba

Indonesia (Pacific and Indian coasts) Gillnets Seine nets Trap

Japan Set net Trawling Gillnet

Korea (Republic of) n.a.

Page 11: Overview – Pacific Ocean · 18 Review of the state of world marine capture fisheries management: Pacific Ocean Fleet capacity management within the largest fisheries It is commonly

Overview – Pacific Ocean 25

Small-scale, artisanal, lifestyle, subsistence, indigenous, customary

Malaysia (Pacific and Indian coasts) Drift & gill net Hook & line Bag net

Mexico (Pacific coast) Giant squid Sharks Shrimp

New Zealand Grey mullet Kina Paua

Nicaragua (Pacific coast) Shrimp Lobster Finfish

Panama Fish Shellfish Mollusk

Peru Peces Crustaceos Moluscos

Philippines Frigate Yellowfin Sardines

Russian Federation n.a.

Samoa Diving/spearing Gillnetting Hook/line fishing

Taiwan Province of China n.a.

Thailand (Pacific coast) Small scale gillnet Trap Hook & line

United States (Pacific coast) Sea urchins Clams Sea cucumbers

Viet Nam Small gill net Shrimp trawl Small liftnet with lightNote: n/a = not applicable; n.a. = not available

Recreational fisheries, including non-consumptive use

Australia (Pacific coast) Flathead Whiting Bream

Cambodiaonly limited recreational fishing

Canada salmon (chinook and coho) salmon (sockeye, pink & chum) Rockfish

Chile Trucha Arcoiris Trucha Café Salmon

China n.a.

Colombia (Pacific coast) Sailfish Marlin Swordfish

Costa Rica (Pacific coast) Sport Pelagic and Demersal

Ecuador Pesca deportiva de altura Buceo con Arpón Pesca deportiva de playa

El Salvador Pez vela, dorado Marlin, dorado Pez Espada, dorado

FijiPrivate recreational gamefishing Commercial charterboat sportfishing

FSMPelagic recreational trolling Commercial sport fishing

Guatemala (Pacific and Atlantic coasts) Swordfish Mahi mahi Sailfish

Honduras (Pacific coast) Pez Espada Pez Vela Sábalo

Indonesia (Pacific and Indian coasts)

n.a.

Japan rod/line on-board handline on-board rod/line on beach

Korea (Republic of) n.a.

Malaysia (Pacific and Indian coasts) n.a.

Mexico (Pacific coast)Striped Marlin, Blue Marlin, Sailfish Dolphinfish Roosterfish

New Zealand Snapper Kahawai Kingfish

Nicaragua (Pacific coast) n.a.

PanamaVarious demersals and pelagics

Peru n.a.

PhilippinesVarious demersals and pelagics

Russian Federation n.a.

Samoa Recreational sport fishing Commercial sport fishing

Taiwan Province of China n.a.

Thailand (Pacific coast) n.a.

United States (Pacific coast) Flatfishes Salmon Rockfish

Viet Nam n.a. Note: n/a = not applicable; n.a. = not available

Page 12: Overview – Pacific Ocean · 18 Review of the state of world marine capture fisheries management: Pacific Ocean Fleet capacity management within the largest fisheries It is commonly

Review of the state of world marine capture fisheries management: Pacific Ocean26

APPENDIX 2State of exploitation of selected species fished in 2002

Northwest Pacific (FAO Statistical Area 61)

Stock or species groups Main fishing countries State of exploitation*

Chum(=Keta=Dog)salmon Japan, Russian Fed F

Pink(=Humpback)salmon Russian Fed, Japan F

Other Salmons, trouts, smelts, etc. F

Salmons, trouts, smelts, etc.

Alaska pollock(=Walleye poll.) Russian Fed, Japan, Korea D P Rp F

Pacific cod Russian Fed, Japan, Korea Rep F

Other Cods, hakes, haddocks, etc. F

Cods, hakes, haddocks, etc.

Yellow croaker China F

Other Miscellaneous costal fishes F

Miscellaneous costal fishes

Largehead hairtail China F-O

Other Miscellaneous demersal fishes ?

Miscellaneous demersal fishes

Japanese anchovy China, Japan, Korea Rep F

Japanese pilchard China, Japan M

Pacific herring Russian Fed, China ?

Other Herrings, sardines, anchovies ?

Herrings, sardines, anchovies

Tunas, bonitos, billfishes, etc.

Chub mackerel China, Japan, Korea Rep F

Japanese jack mackerel Japan, Korea Rep F

Pacific saury Japan, Russian Fed, China,Taiwan p. China F

Other Miscellaneous pelagic fishes F

Miscellaneous pelagic fishes

Sharks, rays, chimaeras, etc. ?

Marine fishes not identified ?

Gazami crab China, Korea Rep ?

Other Sea-spiders, crabs, etc. F

Sea-spiders, crabs, etc.

Akiami paste shrimp China ?

Other Shrimps, prawns, etc. ?

Shrimps, prawns, etc.

Yesso scallop Japan ?

Scallops, penctens, etc.

Japanese carpet shell Japan, Korea Rep ?

Other Clams, cockles, arkshells, etc. ?

Clams, cockles, arkshells, etc.

Japanese flying squid Japan, Korea Rep M (R)

Various squids nei China, Russian Fed, Japan F

Other Squid. Cuttlefish, octopuses ?

Squid. Cuttlefish, octopuses * (U) Underexploited; (M) Moderately exploited; (F) Fully exploited; (O) Overexploited; (D) Depleted; (R) Recovering.Source: FAO, 2005

Page 13: Overview – Pacific Ocean · 18 Review of the state of world marine capture fisheries management: Pacific Ocean Fleet capacity management within the largest fisheries It is commonly

Overview – Pacific Ocean 27

Northeast Pacific (FAO Statistical Area 67)

Stock or species groups Main fishing countries State of exploitation*

Chinook(=Spring=King)salmon USA, Canada F-O

Chum(=Keta=Dog)salmon USA, Canada F

Coho(=Silver)salmon USA F-O

Pink(=Humpback)salmon USA, Canada F

Sockeye(=Red)salmon USA, Canada F

Other Salmons, trouts, smelts, etc.

Salmons, trouts, smelts, etc.

Pacific halibut USA, Canada F

Yellowfin sole USA U

Other Flounders, halibuts, soles ?

Flounders, halibuts, soles

Alaska pollock(=Walleye poll.) USA F

North Pacific hake USA U-D

Pacific cod USA ?

Other Cods, hakes, haddocks, etc. ?

Cods, hakes, haddocks, etc.

Miscellaneous costal fishes

Pacific herring USA, Canada M-O

Other Herrings, sardines, anchovies ?

Herrings, sardines, anchovies

Chub mackerel USA F

Other Miscellaneous pelagic fishes ?

Miscellaneous pelagic fishes

Dungeness crab USA, Canada F

Pacific rock crab USA F

Other Sea-spiders, crabs, etc. F

Sea-spiders, crabs, etc.

Pacific shrimps nei USA ?

Other Shrimps, prawns, etc. F-O-D

Shrimps, prawns, etc. * (U) Underexploited; (M) Moderately exploited; (F) Fully exploited; (O) Overexploited; (D) Depleted; (R) Recovering.Source: FAO, 2005

Page 14: Overview – Pacific Ocean · 18 Review of the state of world marine capture fisheries management: Pacific Ocean Fleet capacity management within the largest fisheries It is commonly

Review of the state of world marine capture fisheries management: Pacific Ocean28

Western Central Pacific (FAO Statistical Area 71)

Stock or species groups Main fishing countries State of exploitation*

Chacunda gizzard shad Philippines, Malaysia ?Diadromous clupeoids nei Malaysia ?Indian pellona Malaysia, Philippines ?Toli shad Indonesia M-FShads, etc. Bigeyes nei Thailand, Indonesia ?Lizardfishes nei Thailand, Indonesia, Malaysia, Philippines M-OMullets nei Indonesia, Philippines, Thailand, Fiji Islands M-FPercoids nei Philippines ?Ponyfishes(=Slipmouths) nei Indonesia, Philippines M-OSea catfishes nei Indonesia, Malaysia, Thailand, Philippines MThreadfin breams nei Thailand, Philippines, Indonesia, Malaysia M-FOther Miscellaneous costal fishes ?

Miscellaneous costal fishes Hairtails, scabbardfishes nei Indonesia, Philippines M-FLargehead hairtail Thailand, Malaysia M-FOther Miscellaneous demersal fishes ?

Miscellaneous demersal fishes Anchovies, etc. nei Thailand FBali sardinella Indonesia FGoldstripe sardinella Indonesia M-FSardinellas nei Philippines, Thailand M-FStolephorus anchovies Indonesia, Philippines FOther Herrings, sardines, anchovies ?

Herrings, sardines, anchovies Frigate and bullet tunas Philippines, Thailand FKawakawa Malaysia, Philippines, Thailand MSkipjack tuna China,Taiwan p. China, Indonesia, Korea

Rep, JapanF

Tuna-like fishes nei Indonesia, Viet Nam MYellowfin tuna Indonesia, Philippines, China FOther Tunas, bonitos, billfishes, etc. M

Tunas, bonitos, billfishes, etc. Bigeye scad Philippines, Thailand M-FCarangids nei Indonesia, Philippines, Thailand ?Flyingfishes nei Philippines, Indonesia MIndian mackerel Philippines, Thailand ?Indian mackerels nei Indonesia, Thailand, Malaysia FIndian scad Malaysia, Thailand FScads nei Philippines, Indonesia M-FShort mackerel Philippines M-FOther Miscellaneous pelagic fishes M-F

Miscellaneous pelagic fishes Rays, stingrays, mantas nei Indonesia, Malaysia, Thailand, Philippines M-FSharks, rays, skates, etc. nei Indonesia, China,Taiwan p. China,

Malaysia, ThailandM-F

Sharks, rays, chimaeras, etc. Marine fishes nei Viet Nam, Thailand, Indonesia, Malaysia M-FMarine fishes not identified Banana prawn Indonesia, Thailand, Australia FGiant tiger prawn Indonesia, Australia F-ONatantian decapods nei Indonesia, Viet Nam, Malaysia ?Penaeus shrimps nei Thailand, Philippines, Australia M-FSergestid shrimps nei Philippines, Thailand, Malaysia M-FOther Shrimps, prawns, etc. ?

Shrimps, prawns, etc. Common squids nei Thailand, Indonesia, Philippines M-FCuttlefish,bobtail squids nei Thailand, Malaysia, Indonesia M-FOctopuses, etc. nei Thailand, Philippines, Indonesia MVarious squids nei Malaysia, Korea Rep ?Other Squid. Cuttlefish, octopuses ?

Squid. Cuttlefish, octopuses * (U) Underexploited; (M) Moderately exploited; (F) Fully exploited; (O) Overexploited; (D) Depleted; (R) Recovering.Source: FAO, 2005

Page 15: Overview – Pacific Ocean · 18 Review of the state of world marine capture fisheries management: Pacific Ocean Fleet capacity management within the largest fisheries It is commonly

Overview – Pacific Ocean 29

Eastern Central Pacific (FAO Statistical Area 77)

Stock or species groups Main fishing countries State of exploitation*

32-Cods, hakes, haddocks, etc. ?-U

33-Miscellaneous costal fishes M-O

34-Miscellaneous demersal fishes ?

California pilchard Mexico, USA M-F

Californian anchovy USA, Mexico M-F

Pacific anchoveta Panama M-F

Pacific thread herring Panama M-F

Other Herrings, sardines, anchovies ?

35-Herrings, sardines, anchovies

Albacore China,Taiwan p. China, Amer Samoa, Fr Polynesia, Samoa

?

Bigeye tuna Japan, Korea Rep, China, USA ?

Pacific bluefin tuna Mexico ?

Skipjack tuna Spain, Guatemala, Mexico, Other nei ?

Yellowfin tuna Mexico, Venezuela, Other nei ?

Other Tunas, bonitos, billfishes, etc. ?

36-Tunas, bonitos, billfishes, etc.

Chub mackerel Mexico, USA M

Pacific jack mackerel USA U

Other Miscellaneous pelagic fishes ?

37-Miscellaneous pelagic fishes

39-Marine fishes not identified ?

Dungeness crab USA ?

Other Sea-spiders, crabs, etc. ?

42-Sea-spiders, crabs, etc.

45-Shrimps, prawns, etc. F-O

53-Oysters ?

Jumbo flying squid Mexico M-F

Octopuses, etc. nei Mexico, Costa Rica ?

Opalescent inshore squid USA M-F

Various squids nei Korea Rep, Costa Rica ?

57-Squid. Cuttlefish, octopuses * (U) Underexploited; (M) Moderately exploited; (F) Fully exploited; (O) Overexploited; (D) Depleted; (R) Recovering.Source: FAO, 2005

Page 16: Overview – Pacific Ocean · 18 Review of the state of world marine capture fisheries management: Pacific Ocean Fleet capacity management within the largest fisheries It is commonly

Review of the state of world marine capture fisheries management: Pacific Ocean30

Southwest Pacific (FAO Statistical Area 81)

Stock or species groups Main fishing countries State of exploitation*

Blue grenadier New Zealand M/F

Gadiformes nei Japan, Korea Rep M

Red codling New Zealand F

Southern blue whiting New Zealand, Japan F

Southern hake New Zealand, Korea Rep F

Other Cods, hakes, haddocks, etc. F

32-Cods, hakes, haddocks, etc.

Mullets nei Australia, New Zealand ?M

Silver seabream New Zealand, Australia F

Other Miscellaneous costal fishes F

33-Miscellaneous costal fishes

Demersal percomorphs nei Japan ?

Hairtails, scabbardfishes nei Korea Rep ?

Orange roughy New Zealand F/O

Oreo dories nei New Zealand F/O

Pink cusk-eel New Zealand, Korea Rep ?

Silver gemfish New Zealand, Australia F/O

Silver scabbardfish New Zealand -

Snoek New Zealand, Ukraine M

South Pacific breams nei Ukraine F

Other Miscellaneous demersal fishes ?M

34-Miscellaneous demersal fishes

Barracudas nei Korea Rep ?M

Blue mackerel New Zealand, Ukraine ?

Butterfishes, pomfrets nei Japan M

Greenback horse mackerel Ukraine M

Jack and horse mackerels nei New Zealand M

Mackerels nei Australia ?

White trevally New Zealand, Australia M

Other Miscellaneous pelagic fishes M

37-Miscellaneous pelagic fishes

Cuttlefish,bobtail squids nei Australia ?

Octopuses, etc. nei Australia, New Zealand M

Various squids nei Korea Rep M

Wellington flying squid New Zealand, Ukraine F

57-Squid. Cuttlefish, octopuses * (U) Underexploited; (M) Moderately exploited; (F) Fully exploited; (O) Overexploited; (D) Depleted; (R) Recovering.Source: FAO, 2005

Page 17: Overview – Pacific Ocean · 18 Review of the state of world marine capture fisheries management: Pacific Ocean Fleet capacity management within the largest fisheries It is commonly

Overview – Pacific Ocean 31

Southeast Pacific (FAO Statistical Area 87)

Stock or species groups Main fishing countries State of exploitation*

Patagonian grenadier Chile F-O

South Pacific hake Chile, Peru F-O-D

Southern hake Chile F-O

Other Cods, hakes, haddocks, etc. ?

32-Cods, hakes, haddocks, etc.

33-Miscellaneous costal fishes ?

Patagonian toothfish Chile M

Other Miscellaneous demersal fishes F-O

34-Miscellaneous demersal fishes

Anchoveta(=Peruvian anchovy) Peru, Chile R-O

Araucanian herring Chile F-O

Pacific thread herring Ecuador F

South American pilchard Chile, Peru, Ecuador F-O

Other Herrings, sardines, anchovies ?

35-Herrings, sardines, anchovies

Bigeye tuna Ecuador, Japan, Other nei, Spain ?

Eastern Pacific bonito Peru D-O

Skipjack tuna Ecuador, Other nei, Spain ?

Yellowfin tuna Ecuador, Venezuela, Other nei, Colombia ?

Other Tunas, bonitos, billfishes, etc. ?

36-Tunas, bonitos, billfishes, etc.

Chilean jack mackerel Chile, Peru F-O

Chub mackerel Chile, Peru M-F

Other Miscellaneous pelagic fishes ?

37-Miscellaneous pelagic fishes

Jumbo flying squid Peru, Japan, China, Korea Rep M

Various squids nei Chile M

Other Squid. Cuttlefish, octopuses ?

57-Squid. Cuttlefish, octopuses * (U) Underexploited; (M) Moderately exploited; (F) Fully exploited; (O) Overexploited; (D) Depleted; (R) Recovering.Source: FAO, 2005