overberg asset management e...sa portfolios: performance vs. unit trusts total return (rand) % 3...

12

Upload: others

Post on 09-Jul-2020

3 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: Overberg Asset Management E...SA PORTFOLIOS: Performance vs. Unit Trusts Total Return (rand) % 3 year 5 year Average in Peer Group 36.94 68.28 Best in Peer Group 81.74 155.99 Worst
Page 2: Overberg Asset Management E...SA PORTFOLIOS: Performance vs. Unit Trusts Total Return (rand) % 3 year 5 year Average in Peer Group 36.94 68.28 Best in Peer Group 81.74 155.99 Worst

Overberg Asset Management (Overberg) specialises in the management of private share portfolios. Throughout history the most successful

companies have been single product providers. It makes sense as these companies allocate to their chosen product a greater proportion

of their resources than less focussed competitors. This singular focus enables Overberg to provide its clients with a superior wealth

creating opportunity and superior service. In the immensely competitive asset management industry the Overberg philosophy ensures

a secure long-term relationship with our valued clients, built on trust, service, value and performance. At the cutting edge of investing,

Overberg has a proven track record in global and domestic South African markets.

OUR STRATEGY

Page 3: Overberg Asset Management E...SA PORTFOLIOS: Performance vs. Unit Trusts Total Return (rand) % 3 year 5 year Average in Peer Group 36.94 68.28 Best in Peer Group 81.74 155.99 Worst

Like the chameleon, our Privately Managed Share Portfolios are optimally structured to adapt to changing market conditions and

opportunities. This allows us to keep pace with the ever changing investment environment, showing greater potential for growth and

better returns over the long-term. Our focus is on the individual with meticulous attention to detail, irrespective of portfolio needs.

Page 4: Overberg Asset Management E...SA PORTFOLIOS: Performance vs. Unit Trusts Total Return (rand) % 3 year 5 year Average in Peer Group 36.94 68.28 Best in Peer Group 81.74 155.99 Worst

There are significant differences between pooled investments such as unit trusts (UT’s) and private share portfolios (PSP’s).

PSP investing involves a bespoke investment portfolio in which shares and other securities are held in the client’s name, and are bought

and sold on behalf of the individual client by the asset manager. The asset manager will invest directly in the market and will avoid

investing through middlemen, like unit trusts. Asset allocation and share selection within the portfolio can be customised to suit the

client’s precise risk-return objectives. This may range from equity-only portfolios through to more conservative portfolios focussed

on giving investors a high income yield. A PSP can also exist within a wrapper such as a retirement annuity or preservation fund.

PRIVATE SHARE PORTFOLIOS VERSUS UNIT TRUSTS

Page 5: Overberg Asset Management E...SA PORTFOLIOS: Performance vs. Unit Trusts Total Return (rand) % 3 year 5 year Average in Peer Group 36.94 68.28 Best in Peer Group 81.74 155.99 Worst

WHAT ARE THE COSTS?

Fees are incredibly transparent in a PSP, as any change in the portfolio has to be disclosed as a line item in the monthly statements

presented to clients. On the other hand UT’s are investment vehicles in which a number of investors co-invest making the level of reporting

more complicated. While regulators have tried to standardise the measure of total UT cost to investors through a Total Expense Ratio

(TER), not all costs associated with a UT are included in the TER, and the actual cost can be higher than those advertised. Ironically, there

are many cases where a pooled investment is more expensive than a bespoke one. TER’s can be, and they often are, misleading.

SHARE SELECTION : INCREASED DIVERSIFICATION

Clients invested in a selection of UT’s will probably suffer a duplication of exposure to many of the same large-cap shares represented

in the Top-40 index. At the same time there will be limited exposure to smaller exciting companies which historically have

outperformed the All-Share index. A PSP will give more effective diversification and greater access to smaller faster growing

companies.

HOW DO YOU TRANSFER UT’s TO PSP’s

The PSP account is opened in the name of the client with a chosen custodian (Investec Securities/

Nedbank Private Wealth/ Standard Bank Group Securities and in the UK Charles Stanley Stockbrokers).

UT’s are transferred to the client’s PSP.

Capital Gains Tax (CGT) calculation is completed to optimise how and when to sell the client’s UT’s.

UT’s are sold based on research into individual UT’s, the market outlook and CGT calculation.

Cash raised is invested in new PSP.

Page 6: Overberg Asset Management E...SA PORTFOLIOS: Performance vs. Unit Trusts Total Return (rand) % 3 year 5 year Average in Peer Group 36.94 68.28 Best in Peer Group 81.74 155.99 Worst

EXIT STRATEGIES OF A PSP AND THE EFFECT OF CGT

Investors can exit at any time. There are no exit penalties, but CGT must be paid. For PSP’s the R30,000 CGT annual exclusion is used every

year. The annual exclusion cannot be rolled over to the next year - it is a “use it or lose it” benefit. Unlike a UT, there won’t be a single

massive CGT shock when you exit a PSP.

COMPARISON: PSP’s VERSUS UT’s

The table on the next page highlights some of the differences between PSP’s and UT’s. Global trends show that as investors and advisers

demand greater transparency, there is growing appetite for PSP’s as part of an overall investment solution. While UT’s have typically been

the primary investment vehicle for most investors due to their ease of access, the demand for transparent and bespoke solutions has

been increasing rapidly in a global context. Given the wider choice, flexibility on fees, enhanced agility, and greater transparency, South

African investors are increasingly following the global trend.

Page 7: Overberg Asset Management E...SA PORTFOLIOS: Performance vs. Unit Trusts Total Return (rand) % 3 year 5 year Average in Peer Group 36.94 68.28 Best in Peer Group 81.74 155.99 Worst

BESPOKEPortfolio can be tailored to individual’s unique needs and risk-returnobjectives.

ONE-SIZE-FITS-ALLEach client receives the same UT. See-through analysis and effectivediversification is difficult.

SEGREGATED, IN CLIENT’S NAMEMore meaningful exposure to less liquid smaller cap shares in a smallersegregated portfolio. Asset allocation shifts, which historically explain80% of outperformance, require agility.

POOLEDAgility is often lost to UT’s due to their larger size. UT’s can be cumbersome,the larger they become the worse they are likely to perform.

ACTIVE MANAGEMENTFunds are invested opportunistically over a period of time. If cash needsto be raised this can be done by selling the weakest holdings at the timewhich helps improve performance.

PASSIVE MANAGEMENTFunds are not invested with the individual client in mind. Funds areinvested in a single day raising the risk of poor market timing. Cash israised by selling units of the entire pooled portfolio rather than selectshares.

PERSONALISED SERVICEHigh level of engagement. Clients have direct access to the asset managerand client relationship managers. Clients can receive instant feedback.

PUBLIC COMMUNICATIONAll communication is via public media. There is no personal interactionwith the asset manager.

TRANSPARENT AND FLEXIBLE FEE STRUCTUREIncredibly transparent fees. Total fees should not exceed 1.5% per annumand are flexible for larger portfolios.

RIGID AND COMPLICATED FEE STRUCTUREThere are many middlemen all charging fees including custodial fees,audit fees, legal fees, trustee fees, distribution and marketing fees,platform fees, and performance fees. Not all costs associated with a UTare included in the Total Expense Ratio (TER).

CAPITAL GAINS TAX (CGT) PLANNINGCGT is levied every time a share is sold. Clients will pay CGT every year,making full use of their CGT annual exclusion, and locking in relativelylow CGT rates. South Africa’s CGT rate is low by international standardsand will inevitably increase over time.

NO CAPITAL GAINS TAX PLANNINGCGT is only levied when investors sell the UT which means CGT may notbe paid for a number of years. While beneficial over the short-term theCGT rate is likely to rise over time making the eventual total CGT liabilityfar greater.

PRIVATE SHARE PORTFOLIOS (PSP’s) UNIT TRUSTS (UT’s) AND OTHER POOLED INVESTMENTS

Page 8: Overberg Asset Management E...SA PORTFOLIOS: Performance vs. Unit Trusts Total Return (rand) % 3 year 5 year Average in Peer Group 36.94 68.28 Best in Peer Group 81.74 155.99 Worst

CONCLUSION

UT’s are typically big mass-market retail products. They tend to be cumbersome and expensive. In contrast, PSP’s are smaller boutique-

style wholesale products. They are agile, user-friendly and cheaper.

We are committed to providing our clients with service excellence. Being a boutique asset management company, our clients have a

unique direct and open access to our asset managers. In addition investors are continuously updated and kept informed by our highly

talented team of professional client relationship managers. Quarterly reporting to clients is extensive and comprehensive adopting

pension fund reporting standards.

Since share certificates have been dematerialised, we do not hold clients’ cash or securities. The administration, custody and safe-

keeping of all securities and cash are outsourced to the custodians of clients’ private share portfolios. The custodians include Investec

Securities, Standard Bank Group Securities, and Nedbank Private Wealth Stockbrokers in South Africa, and Charles Stanley Stockbrokers

in the United Kingdom. Stock brokerage is provided by these custodians on behalf of our clients at highly competitive institutional rates.

Clients have direct online access to their portfolios providing live valuation and complete transparency on all transactions, dividends

and interest earned.

SERVICE EXCELLENCE

Page 9: Overberg Asset Management E...SA PORTFOLIOS: Performance vs. Unit Trusts Total Return (rand) % 3 year 5 year Average in Peer Group 36.94 68.28 Best in Peer Group 81.74 155.99 Worst

The Overberg investment process starts with asset allocation. According to pension fund studies around 80% of investment

outperformance stems from correct asset allocation between currencies and the various key asset classes. These include cash,

bonds, commercial property and shares.

An even split between “value” and “growth” investments. Value investments typically trade at significant valuation discounts, with

a high margin of safety limiting the risk of steep price declines. However, while lowering the volatility of a portfolio value investments

can remain depressed for prolonged periods. The catalyst which unlocks value can be a long time coming. Equally, growth investments

which tend to trade at a significant premium to the market may enjoy a rising valuation trend for prolonged periods, but can also

suffer steep price declines in the event of disappointing results or systemic market risk. Overberg is confident that the structuring

of portfolios with a balanced exposure to value and growth investments offers the optimal investment strategy, allowing for steady

returns while sustaining only moderate volatility.

A measured allocation to small- and mid-cap shares. Although exposure is within disciplined guidelines to stem the inherently

higher risk of less established companies these shares tend to provide the best performance in clients’ portfolios. Starting from

a lower base smaller companies have greater prospects for earnings growth, benefit from a higher level of management ownership

and a more entrepreneurial culture. Surprisingly, given these advantages they often trade at a discount to the broader market as

they are not actively researched by the large institutions due to lack of liquidity.

KEY TO OUTPERFORMANCE

Page 10: Overberg Asset Management E...SA PORTFOLIOS: Performance vs. Unit Trusts Total Return (rand) % 3 year 5 year Average in Peer Group 36.94 68.28 Best in Peer Group 81.74 155.99 Worst

Retirement fund clients with living annuities, retirement annuities, provident preservation funds, pension preservation funds and

endowment funds, who previously were limited in their choice to unit trusts and other collective investment schemes can now make

use of private share portfolios. This can be done via the Sanlam Glacier Platform and Momentum Wealth Platform.

DOMESTIC PORTFOLIOS

Overberg builds global private share portfolios around investment companies. These are closed-end investment trusts (having a limited

number of shares in issue) listed on the London Stock Exchange (LSE). They are publicly quoted companies that invest their shareholders’

equity in a wide spectrum of shares, spreading risk over markets and currencies. Investment companies provide low cost access to best-

of-breed traditional and cutting edge global investment opportunities. With their low fees, trading at discounts to net asset value, and

paying attractive dividend yields, investment companies are by far the most cost-effective way of diversifying a global investment portfolio.

Investment companies are the professional investors’ best kept secret. With around 600 listed investment companies, they comprise

the largest sector of the LSE.

LSE listing provides active secondary market (immediate pricing) and regulatory comfort to alternative investment strategies such as

absolute return, private equity and commercial property. The market price of investment companies may trade below (discount) or above

the Net Asset Value depending on demand. A discount will narrow with increased demand thereby providing a “double whammy” to

investment returns. Analysis of the discount/premium cycle provides an additional opportunity for enhancing returns.

GLOBAL PORTFOLIOS

Page 11: Overberg Asset Management E...SA PORTFOLIOS: Performance vs. Unit Trusts Total Return (rand) % 3 year 5 year Average in Peer Group 36.94 68.28 Best in Peer Group 81.74 155.99 Worst

05 06 07 08 09 10 11 12 13 14 15

750

650

550

450

350

250

150

50

JSE All Share Index OAM Local Growth

03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10 11 12 13 14

1007550

15

125150175200225250275

SA PORTFOLIOS: Performance vs. Unit Trusts

Total Return (rand) % 3 year 5 year

Average in Peer Group 36.94 68.28

Best in Peer Group 81.74 155.99

Worst in Peer Group -4.78 2.01

Overberg Growth 65.83 144.87

Overberg Ranking 6/153 4/127

Number of funds 153 127

(Peer Group: SA Unit Trust sector: SA Multi-Asset Class)(Source: PSG Wealth Mega Fund Factsheet)

To end October 2015

GLOBAL PORTFOLIOS: Performance vs. Unit Trusts

Total Return (rand) % 3 year 5 year

Average in Peer Group 71.35 119.95

Best in Peer Group 88.41 154.67

Worst in Peer Group 34.2 63.88

Overberg Growth 85.32 146.23

Overberg Ranking 5/25 2/18

Number of funds 25 18

(Peer Group: SA Unit Trust sector: Global Multi-Asset Class)(Source: PSG Wealth Mega Fund Factsheet)

FTSE Global 100 Global Growth

Page 12: Overberg Asset Management E...SA PORTFOLIOS: Performance vs. Unit Trusts Total Return (rand) % 3 year 5 year Average in Peer Group 36.94 68.28 Best in Peer Group 81.74 155.99 Worst

Overberg Asset Management (PTY) Ltd.Johannesburg Office: 0861 277 387

Hermanus Office: 028 312 1783 | 9 Paterson Street, Hermanus, 7200

Somerset West Office: 021 852 6040 | 11 Myburgh Street, Somerset West, 7130

Greyton Office: 028 254 9013 | 9 DS Botha Street, Greyton, 7233

email: [email protected]

Overberg Asset Management (PTY) Ltd. Authorised Financial Services Provider: 783There is a risk associated with investing in our financial products. The value of the investments and income may rise as well as fall, and there is a risk that the client may suffer financial losses.Returns are dependent on the performance of underlying assets and other variable market factors. Past performances are not necessarily indicative of future performances.

Contacts

Nick Downing: 082 555 5334 email: [email protected]

Gielie Fourie: 073 517 0058 email: [email protected]

Brett Birkenstock: 082 303 0573 email: [email protected]

Carel La Cock: 076 703 0253 email: [email protected]

Kirk Swart: 084 261 4153 email: [email protected]