on his income in u.s. politics trumps claims ... - nytimes.com€¦ · 04/11/2016  · ton is...

1
U(DF463D)X+&!,!\!#!] BULENT KILIC/AGENCE FRANCE-PRESSE — GETTY IMAGES As Iraqis sought safety Thursday, many said that without political change, sectarian strife would recur after an ISIS defeat. Page A12. A Scramble to Flee Mosul Closure for Cubs, in a Fitting Final Catch Continued on Page B11 CLEVELAND — Anthony Rizzo was 3 years old when his father, John, first knew he might be a baseball player. “I chipped him golf balls and he’d catch everything,” John Rizzo said early Thursday morning at Progressive Field. “I was learning how to play golf. He used to get his mitt and catch the chips.” The steady right hand that snagged golf balls as a boy would one day catch The Ball, the one that deliv- ered the Chicago Cubs their first championship since 1908. With two outs in the bottom of the 10th inning in Game 7 of the World Series, Anthony Rizzo raised his glove and caught a throw from third baseman Kris Bryant, who had gathered a slow chopper from the Cleve- land Indians’ Michael Martinez. The Cubs had triumphed, 8-7, for a moment 108 years in the making. “There’s a lot of relief involved, because there’s so much stress — it just builds and builds and builds,” said Tom Ricketts, the Cubs’ chairman. “Relief, and then you start to absorb it. Honestly, I never really let myself think too hard about what happens next. So now we’ll see what it all means.” It means that baseball is different, forever. The franchise most famous for failure now sits on top. The holy grail of sports — as David Ross, the beloved retiring catcher, put it — has been found. The group that did it will be Chicago legends for life. The Curse of the Billy Goat — the ludicrous notion that an aggrieved tavern owner hexed the team for denying his goat entry to Wrigley Field for the 1945 World Series — is no more. TYLER KEPNER ON BASEBALL EZRA SHAW/GETTY IMAGES Anthony Rizzo after an R.B.I. in Game 7 of the World Series. Saturating swing states with powerful campaign surrogates and mobilizing a vast field organi- zation, Hillary Clinton on Thurs- day intensified her public attacks on Donald J. Trump as a threat to minorities in the hope of driving them to the polls in decisive num- bers. In an effort to blunt any late mo- mentum for Mr. Trump, Mrs. Clin- ton is moving to reinforce her po- sition among crucial constituen- cies, including black communities in North Carolina and Florida, and Hispanic strongholds in Nevada and Arizona, to lock down the 270 electoral votes needed to win. She and President Obama as- sailed Mr. Trump in separate cam- paign appearances on Thursday as an enemy of black voters, and warned that he could use the power of the presidency against them. Mrs. Clinton’s efforts are most intense in a few large swing states where balloting is underway. Guided by data on millions of voters around the country, the Clinton campaign has deployed her top surrogates to areas where she needs a boost: Mr. Obama fired up voters on her behalf in Jacksonville, Fla., and Miami, cit- ies where black voters have yet to turn out in sizable numbers. Seldom have Mr. Trump and Campaigns Attack Election Map In Widely Divergent Game Plans By ALEXANDER BURNS and JONATHAN MARTIN Continued on Page A16 HARARE, Zimbabwe — The time came for worshipers to sur- render their tithes on Sunday morning. But instead of dropping bills into a collection plate, the congregants at a large Pente- costal church rose and filed to- ward the deacons clutching hand- held card-reading machines. With a swipe, they were done. “Yes, it looks like shoppers in a supermarket,” said Mercy Chi- hota, 33, a member of the church, the United Family International Ministries, in Harare, Zimbabwe’s capital. “It feels good, but strange at the moment, because it’s very new.” Of all the places speeding to- ward a cashless economy, this na- tion in southern Africa may not come to mind. About 90 percent of Zimbabweans work in the infor- mal economy, where cash is usually a must. The country, de- spite the spread of cheap smart- phones in recent years, remains low-tech. Blackouts are part of ev- eryday life. But Zimbabwe is hurtling to- ward a plastic future for a simple reason: It is running out of cash, specifically the American dollars it adopted in 2009 before abandon- ing its own troubled currency. Anxious about their nation’s po- litical and economic troubles, many Zimbabweans have been hoarding dollars or taking them out of the country. Banks have slashed daily withdrawal limits. A.T.M.s now sit empty. Debit card machines are prolif- erating in Zimbabwe’s cities, not only in churches but also in super- markets, betting parlors, night- clubs, parking lots and every busi- ness happy to accept cash but un- able to dispense it. If there are no card-reading machines around, many shoppers now text pay- With Little Choice, Zimbabweans Hurtle to a Cashless Economy By JEFFREY MOYO and NORIMITSU ONISHI Continued on Page A8 LONDON — The British gov- ernment’s plan for leaving the Eu- ropean Union was thrown into un- certainty on Thursday after the High Court ruled that Parliament must give its approval before the process can begin. The court’s decision seemed likely to slow, but not halt, the British exit from the bloc, a step approved by nearly 52 percent of voters in a June referendum. Nevertheless, the court’s deci- sion was a significant blow to Prime Minister Theresa May. She had planned to begin the legal steps for leaving the European Union by the end of March, and to prepare for talks over Britain’s exit mostly behind closed doors. If the court’s ruling is upheld — the government immediately vowed to appeal — that plan would be thrown into disarray, an- alysts said. Mrs. May would be forced to work with Parliament and con- sider its competing priorities for Britain’s future. Specifically, she would have to give it a detailed strategy for negotiating the British departure, or “Brexit.” She has adamantly resisted doing so, British Court Muddles Plan To Leave E.U. By STEPHEN CASTLE and STEVEN ERLANGER Continued on Page A11 On the financial disclosure forms that Donald J. Trump has pointed to as proof of his tremen- dous success, no venture looks more gold-plated than his golf re- sort in Doral, Fla., where he re- ported revenues of $50 million in 2014. That figure accounted for the biggest share of what he de- scribed as his income for the year. But this summer, a consider- ably different picture emerged in an austere government hearing room in Miami, where Mr. Trump’s company was challeng- ing the resort’s property tax bill. Mr. Trump’s lawyer handed the magistrate an income and ex- pense statement showing that the gross revenue had indeed been $50 million. But after paying oper- ating costs, the resort had actually lost $2.4 million. Mr. Trump has repeatedly held out his financial disclosures as a justification for breaking with tra- dition and refusing to release his personal tax returns. “You don’t learn that much from tax returns,” he said in September during his first debate with Hillary Clinton. “You learn a lot from financial dis- closure. And you should go down and take a look at that.” But an examination of his tax appeals on several properties, and other documents obtained by The New York Times through Free- dom of Information requests, shows that what Mr. Trump has reported on those forms is no- where near a complete picture of his financial state. The records demonstrate that large portions of those numbers represent cash coming into his businesses before covering costs like mortgage payments, payroll and maintenance. After expenses, some of his businesses make a small fraction of what he reported on his disclosure forms, or ac- tually lose money. In fact, it is virtually impossible to determine from the forms just how much he is earning in any year. Mr. Trump appears to have Records Erode Trump’s Claims On His Income Disclosure Forms Paint Incomplete Picture By RUSS BUETTNER Continued on Page A17 An overwhelming majority of voters are disgusted by the state of American politics, and many harbor doubts that either major- party nominee can unite the coun- try after a historically ugly presi- dential campaign, according to the final pre-election New York Times/CBS News Poll. In a grim preview of the discon- tent that may cloud at least the outset of the next president’s term, Hillary Clinton and Donald J. Trump are seen by a majority of voters as unlikely to bring the country back together after this bitter election season. With more than eight in 10 voters saying the campaign has left them repulsed rather than ex- cited, the rising toxicity threatens the ultimate victor. Mrs. Clinton, the Democratic candidate, and Mr. Trump, the Republican nominee, are seen as dishonest and viewed unfavorably by a ma- jority of voters. While her advantage has nar- rowed since mid-October, Mrs. Clinton still has an edge in the sur- vey because of a commanding ad- IN POLL, VOTERS EXPRESS DISGUST IN U.S. POLITICS PREVIEW OF DISCONTENT Clinton Holds Slim Edge — Many Say Nation Can’t Be Unified This article is by Jonathan Mar- tin, Dalia Sussman and Megan Thee-Brenan. 9/9- 9/13 9/28- 10/2 10/12- 10/16 10/28- 11/1 HORSE RACE AMONG LIKELY VOTERS Source: New York Times and CBS polls Clinton 45% Trump 42% % 50 45 40 35 Continued on Page A16 ‘C’MON, MAN’ A catchphrase, born on ESPN, becomes a weapon of withering disbelief for President Obama. PAGE A19 IN THE COURTROOM A review of Hillary Clinton’s early work as a litiga- tor gives hints of what kind of politician she would become. PAGE A22 Since France dismantled a squalid migrant enclave known as the Jungle last month in the northern port city, recent arrivals from Africa and Afghanistan have been living in pup tents on the outskirts of the capital, creating a new crisis for the French. PAGE A13 INTERNATIONAL A4-13 From Calais to Paris The crypt believed to be the burial bed of Jesus Christ in Jerusalem was opened as part of the renovation of a shrine in what today is known as the Church of the Holy Sepulcher. PAGE A4 Jesus’ Tomb Is Opened Federal statistics show that it is now just as likely for children ages 10 to 14 to die from suicides as from traffic acci- dents. PAGE A3 NATIONAL A3, 14-23 Youth Suicides on the Rise Investigators are looking into whether a Russian sports agent conspired with American marathon organizers to allow athletes using banned substances to compete in their events. PAGE B9 SPORTSFRIDAY B9-14 Doping Inquiry Extends to U.S. The government is seeking to fine Penn State for failing to alert the public about campus dangers that included sexual abuse by Jerry Sandusky. PAGE B13 U.S. Seeks to Fine Penn State Mark Leckey’s retrospective, showcasing his passion for under- ground subcul- tures, is an exu- berant time cap- sule of the vital art world before the “Brexit” vote. Jason Farago reviews. PAGE C17 WEEKEND ARTS C1-30 Love Letter From Britain Suket Dhir, a 38- year-old who once sold mobile phones, has made himself into a rising fashion star in India by mixing craft tradi- tions with subtle tailoring in his designs. PAGE D11 MEN’S STYLE D1-12 From ‘Slacker’ To Fashion Star The patina of good cheer at Trader Joe’s has masked growing demoralization for workers in some stores. PAGE B1 BUSINESS DAY B1-7 Tensions for Trader Joe’s The Dalai Lama Arthur C. Brooks PAGE A27 EDITORIAL, OP-ED A26-27 VOL. CLXVI . . . No. 57,406 © 2016 The New York Times Company FRIDAY, NOVEMBER 4, 2016

Upload: others

Post on 19-Aug-2020

2 views

Category:

Documents


0 download

TRANSCRIPT

Page 1: On His Income IN U.S. POLITICS Trumps Claims ... - nytimes.com€¦ · 04/11/2016  · ton is moving to reinforce her po-sition among crucial constituen-cies, including black communities

C M Y K Yxxx,2016-11-04,A,001,Bs-4C,E2

U(DF463D)X+&!,!\!#!]

BULENT KILIC/AGENCE FRANCE-PRESSE — GETTY IMAGES

As Iraqis sought safety Thursday, many said that without political change, sectarian strife would recur after an ISIS defeat. Page A12.A Scramble to Flee Mosul

Closure for Cubs, in a Fitting Final Catch

Continued on Page B11

CLEVELAND — Anthony Rizzo was 3years old when his father, John, first knew hemight be a baseball player.

“I chipped him golf balls and he’d catcheverything,” John Rizzo said early Thursday

morning at Progressive Field. “Iwas learning how to play golf. Heused to get his mitt and catch thechips.”

The steady right hand thatsnagged golf balls as aboy would one day

catch The Ball, the one that deliv-ered the Chicago Cubs their firstchampionship since 1908. Withtwo outs in the bottom of the 10th inning in Game 7 of the World Series,Anthony Rizzo raised his glove and caught athrow from third baseman Kris Bryant, whohad gathered a slow chopper from the Cleve-land Indians’ Michael Martinez. The Cubs hadtriumphed, 8-7, for a moment 108 years in themaking.

“There’s a lot of relief involved, becausethere’s so much stress — it just builds andbuilds and builds,” said Tom Ricketts, theCubs’ chairman. “Relief, and then you start toabsorb it. Honestly, I never really let myselfthink too hard about what happens next. Sonow we’ll see what it all means.”

It means that baseball is different, forever.The franchise most famous for failure nowsits on top. The holy grail of sports — asDavid Ross, the beloved retiring catcher,put it — has been found.

The group that did it will be Chicagolegends for life. The Curse of the BillyGoat — the ludicrous notion that anaggrieved tavern owner hexed theteam for denying his goat entryto Wrigley Field for the 1945World Series — is no more.

TYLERKEPNER

ONBASEBALL

EZRA SHAW/GETTY IMAGES

Anthony Rizzo after an R.B.I. in Game 7 of the World Series.

Saturating swing states withpowerful campaign surrogatesand mobilizing a vast field organi-zation, Hillary Clinton on Thurs-day intensified her public attackson Donald J. Trump as a threat tominorities in the hope of drivingthem to the polls in decisive num-bers.

In an effort to blunt any late mo-mentum for Mr. Trump, Mrs. Clin-ton is moving to reinforce her po-sition among crucial constituen-cies, including black communitiesin North Carolina and Florida, andHispanic strongholds in Nevadaand Arizona, to lock down the 270electoral votes needed to win.

She and President Obama as-sailed Mr. Trump in separate cam-

paign appearances on Thursdayas an enemy of black voters, andwarned that he could use thepower of the presidency againstthem.

Mrs. Clinton’s efforts are mostintense in a few large swing stateswhere balloting is underway.Guided by data on millions ofvoters around the country, theClinton campaign has deployedher top surrogates to areas whereshe needs a boost: Mr. Obamafired up voters on her behalf inJacksonville, Fla., and Miami, cit-ies where black voters have yet toturn out in sizable numbers.

Seldom have Mr. Trump and

Campaigns Attack Election MapIn Widely Divergent Game Plans

By ALEXANDER BURNS and JONATHAN MARTIN

Continued on Page A16

HARARE, Zimbabwe — Thetime came for worshipers to sur-render their tithes on Sundaymorning. But instead of droppingbills into a collection plate, thecongregants at a large Pente-costal church rose and filed to-ward the deacons clutching hand-held card-reading machines. Witha swipe, they were done.

“Yes, it looks like shoppers in asupermarket,” said Mercy Chi-hota, 33, a member of the church,the United Family InternationalMinistries, in Harare, Zimbabwe’scapital. “It feels good, but strangeat the moment, because it’s verynew.”

Of all the places speeding to-ward a cashless economy, this na-tion in southern Africa may notcome to mind. About 90 percent ofZimbabweans work in the infor-mal economy, where cash is

usually a must. The country, de-spite the spread of cheap smart-phones in recent years, remainslow-tech. Blackouts are part of ev-eryday life.

But Zimbabwe is hurtling to-ward a plastic future for a simplereason: It is running out of cash,specifically the American dollarsit adopted in 2009 before abandon-ing its own troubled currency.Anxious about their nation’s po-litical and economic troubles,many Zimbabweans have been

hoarding dollars or taking themout of the country. Banks haveslashed daily withdrawal limits.A.T.M.s now sit empty.

Debit card machines are prolif-erating in Zimbabwe’s cities, notonly in churches but also in super-markets, betting parlors, night-clubs, parking lots and every busi-ness happy to accept cash but un-able to dispense it. If there are nocard-reading machines around,many shoppers now text pay-

With Little Choice, Zimbabweans Hurtle to a Cashless EconomyBy JEFFREY MOYO

and NORIMITSU ONISHI

Continued on Page A8

LONDON — The British gov-ernment’s plan for leaving the Eu-ropean Union was thrown into un-certainty on Thursday after theHigh Court ruled that Parliamentmust give its approval before theprocess can begin.

The court’s decision seemedlikely to slow, but not halt, theBritish exit from the bloc, a stepapproved by nearly 52 percent ofvoters in a June referendum.

Nevertheless, the court’s deci-sion was a significant blow toPrime Minister Theresa May. Shehad planned to begin the legalsteps for leaving the EuropeanUnion by the end of March, and toprepare for talks over Britain’sexit mostly behind closed doors.

If the court’s ruling is upheld —the government immediatelyvowed to appeal — that planwould be thrown into disarray, an-alysts said.

Mrs. May would be forced towork with Parliament and con-sider its competing priorities forBritain’s future. Specifically, shewould have to give it a detailedstrategy for negotiating theBritish departure, or “Brexit.” Shehas adamantly resisted doing so,

British CourtMuddles Plan To Leave E.U.

By STEPHEN CASTLEand STEVEN ERLANGER

Continued on Page A11

On the financial disclosureforms that Donald J. Trump haspointed to as proof of his tremen-dous success, no venture looksmore gold-plated than his golf re-sort in Doral, Fla., where he re-ported revenues of $50 million in2014. That figure accounted for thebiggest share of what he de-scribed as his income for the year.

But this summer, a consider-ably different picture emerged inan austere government hearingroom in Miami, where Mr.Trump’s company was challeng-ing the resort’s property tax bill.

Mr. Trump’s lawyer handed themagistrate an income and ex-pense statement showing that thegross revenue had indeed been$50 million. But after paying oper-ating costs, the resort had actuallylost $2.4 million.

Mr. Trump has repeatedly heldout his financial disclosures as ajustification for breaking with tra-dition and refusing to release hispersonal tax returns. “You don’tlearn that much from tax returns,”he said in September during hisfirst debate with Hillary Clinton.“You learn a lot from financial dis-closure. And you should go downand take a look at that.”

But an examination of his taxappeals on several properties, andother documents obtained by TheNew York Times through Free-dom of Information requests,shows that what Mr. Trump hasreported on those forms is no-where near a complete picture ofhis financial state.

The records demonstrate thatlarge portions of those numbersrepresent cash coming into hisbusinesses before covering costslike mortgage payments, payrolland maintenance. After expenses,some of his businesses make asmall fraction of what he reportedon his disclosure forms, or ac-tually lose money. In fact, it isvirtually impossible to determinefrom the forms just how much heis earning in any year.

Mr. Trump appears to have

Records ErodeTrump’s ClaimsOn His Income

Disclosure Forms PaintIncomplete Picture

By RUSS BUETTNER

Continued on Page A17

An overwhelming majority ofvoters are disgusted by the stateof American politics, and manyharbor doubts that either major-party nominee can unite the coun-try after a historically ugly presi-dential campaign, according tothe final pre-election New YorkTimes/CBS News Poll.

In a grim preview of the discon-tent that may cloud at least theoutset of the next president’sterm, Hillary Clinton and DonaldJ. Trump are seen by a majority ofvoters as unlikely to bring thecountry back together after thisbitter election season.

With more than eight in 10voters saying the campaign hasleft them repulsed rather than ex-cited, the rising toxicity threatensthe ultimate victor. Mrs. Clinton,the Democratic candidate, andMr. Trump, the Republicannominee, are seen as dishonestand viewed unfavorably by a ma-jority of voters.

While her advantage has nar-rowed since mid-October, Mrs.Clinton still has an edge in the sur-vey because of a commanding ad-

IN POLL, VOTERS EXPRESS DISGUST

IN U.S. POLITICS

PREVIEW OF DISCONTENT

Clinton Holds Slim Edge— Many Say Nation

Can’t Be Unified

This article is by Jonathan Mar-tin, Dalia Sussman and MeganThee-Brenan.

9/9-

9/13

9/28-

10/2

10/12-

10/16

10/28-

11/1

HORSE RACE AMONG LIKELY VOTERS

Source: New York Times and CBS polls

Clinton45%

Trump

42%

%50

45

40

35

Continued on Page A16

‘C’MON, MAN’ A catchphrase, born on ESPN, becomes a weapon ofwithering disbelief for President Obama. PAGE A19

IN THE COURTROOM A review of Hillary Clinton’s early work as a litiga-tor gives hints of what kind of politician she would become. PAGE A22

Since Francedismantled asqualid migrantenclave known asthe Jungle lastmonth in thenorthern port city,recent arrivalsfrom Africa andAfghanistan have

been living in pup tents on the outskirtsof the capital, creating a new crisis forthe French. PAGE A13

INTERNATIONAL A4-13

From Calais to Paris

The crypt believed to be the burial bedof Jesus Christ in Jerusalem wasopened as part of the renovation of ashrine in what today is known as theChurch of the Holy Sepulcher. PAGE A4

Jesus’ Tomb Is Opened

Federal statistics show that it is nowjust as likely for children ages 10 to 14 todie from suicides as from traffic acci-dents. PAGE A3

NATIONAL A3, 14-23

Youth Suicides on the Rise

Investigators are looking into whether aRussian sports agent conspired withAmerican marathon organizers to allowathletes using banned substances tocompete in their events. PAGE B9

SPORTSFRIDAY B9-14

Doping Inquiry Extends to U.S.

The government is seeking to fine PennState for failing to alert the public aboutcampus dangers that included sexualabuse by Jerry Sandusky. PAGE B13

U.S. Seeks to Fine Penn State

Mark Leckey’sretrospective,showcasing hispassion for under-ground subcul-tures, is an exu-berant time cap-sule of the vital artworld before the“Brexit” vote.Jason Faragoreviews. PAGE C17

WEEKEND ARTS C1-30

Love Letter From Britain

Suket Dhir, a 38-year-old who oncesold mobile phones,has made himselfinto a rising fashionstar in India bymixing craft tradi-tions with subtletailoring in hisdesigns. PAGE D11

MEN’S STYLE D1-12

From ‘Slacker’To Fashion Star

The patina of good cheer at Trader Joe’shas masked growing demoralization forworkers in some stores. PAGE B1

BUSINESS DAY B1-7

Tensions for Trader Joe’s

The Dalai Lama Arthur C. Brooks PAGE A27

EDITORIAL, OP-ED A26-27

VOL. CLXVI . . . No. 57,406 © 2016 The New York Times Company FRIDAY, NOVEMBER 4, 2016